Nicholas Clee
Quote at Your Own Risk
Who Owns This Sentence? A History of Copyrights and Wrongs
By David Bellos & Alexandre Montagu
Mountain Leopard Press 384pp £25
Those writing in Literary Review and other journals work under the assumption that they may lift passages from the books under review to illustrate their points and give readers a flavour of the authors’ latest offerings. This, despite the forbidding notice on the book’s copyright page: ‘No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in any retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means … without the prior permission of the copyright owners and the publishers.’ The warning has the proviso ‘except as allowed by law’. We take this clause to mean that quoting a few brief passages will not violate the much-disputed concept of ‘fair use’. Our chief worry, if we do not like the book in question, is not to overtax another disputed concept, ‘fair comment’.
Academics writing about T S Eliot’s The Waste Land (itself, of course, full of borrowings from various sources) could scarcely function if they were unable to demonstrate their arguments with lines from the poem. They have been doing so, often quite liberally, for about one hundred years. How then was the late Valerie Eliot, guardian of her husband’s estate, able in the mid-1980s to prevent the biographer Peter Ackroyd from quoting more than a tiny number of examples from Eliot’s work, and nothing at all from his letters and unpublished correspondence? And how in 1990 was she also able to prevent the cartoonist Martin Rowson from using any quotes at all from The Waste Land in his comic-book adaptation of the poem?
David Bellos and Alexandre Montagu, authors of Who Owns This Sentence?, do not mention these examples, but they do cite another oddity, from the copyright page of ‘a recent novel’: ‘Excerpt from The Waste Land … Copyright the Estate of T S Eliot. Reproduced by permission of Faber and
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
When @djbduncan notices the text for a literary jigsaw puzzle had been written by a former colleague, his head spins. A wild surmise. Are jigsaws REF-able?
Dennis Duncan - The W Factor
Dennis Duncan: The W Factor
literaryreview.co.uk
In an effort to scold drinkers, Victorian temperance societies furiously marked every drinking establishment with a red X on city maps. It was a spectacular case of propaganda backfiring.
@foxtosser explores the history of drink maps
Edward Brooke-Hitching - From Beer Street to Gin Lane
Edward Brooke-Hitching: From Beer Street to Gin Lane - Drink Maps in Victorian Britain by Kris Butler
literaryreview.co.uk
How did a workers’ insurance agent who died of tuberculosis at the age of forty become a global literary icon?
@MortenHoiJensen on Kafka's metamorphosis
Morten Høi Jensen - Paranoid Humanoid
Morten Høi Jensen: Paranoid Humanoid - Metamorphoses: In Search of Franz Kafka by Karolina Watroba; Kafka: Making o...
literaryreview.co.uk