What do you think?
Rate this book
Rath & Rune #1
Unhallowed
Monsters. Murder. Librarians.
Librarian Sebastian Rath is the only one who believes his friend Kelly O’Neil disappeared due to foul play. But without any clues or outside assistance, there’s nothing he can do to prove it.
When bookbinder Vesper Rune is hired to fill the vacancy left by O’Neil, he receives an ominous letter warning him to leave. After he saves Sebastian from a pair of threatening men, the two decide to join forces and get to the truth about what happened to O’Neil.
But Vesper is hiding secrets of his own, ones he doesn’t dare let anyone learn. Secrets that grow ever more dangerous as his desire for Sebastian deepens.
Because Kelly O’Neil was murdered. And if Sebastian and Ves don’t act quickly enough, they’ll be the next to die.
Librarian Sebastian Rath is the only one who believes his friend Kelly O’Neil disappeared due to foul play. But without any clues or outside assistance, there’s nothing he can do to prove it.
When bookbinder Vesper Rune is hired to fill the vacancy left by O’Neil, he receives an ominous letter warning him to leave. After he saves Sebastian from a pair of threatening men, the two decide to join forces and get to the truth about what happened to O’Neil.
But Vesper is hiding secrets of his own, ones he doesn’t dare let anyone learn. Secrets that grow ever more dangerous as his desire for Sebastian deepens.
Because Kelly O’Neil was murdered. And if Sebastian and Ves don’t act quickly enough, they’ll be the next to die.
226 pages, ebook
First published July 17, 2020
About the author
Jordan L. Hawk
79 books2,512 followersJordan L. Hawk is a trans author from North Carolina. Childhood tales of mountain ghosts and mysterious creatures gave him a life-long love of things that go bump in the night. When he isn’t writing, he brews his own beer and tries to keep the cats from destroying the house. His best-selling Whyborne & Griffin series (beginning with Widdershins) can be found in print, ebook, and audiobook.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 283 reviews
Read
June 16, 2020A new Jordan L Hawk series is always a thing of joy, and this starter is pure Lovecraftian fun. Set in the Widdershins world! And, even better, among the Librarians!
This was enormously enjoyable. Vesper is a great creation (I won't spoil his identity but it's deeply satisfying) and the mystery/threat setup is genius. Adored every minute of the Librarians and the many excellent running jokes (also, big shout-out to the underwhelming fossil fish). I didn't connect quite as much to Sebastian but this is a series and we have plenty of time for him to develop. Plus his sister and family set-up absolutely rock. I wolfed this down in an evening with immense pleasure.
I had an ARC from the author.
This was enormously enjoyable. Vesper is a great creation (I won't spoil his identity but it's deeply satisfying) and the mystery/threat setup is genius. Adored every minute of the Librarians and the many excellent running jokes (also, big shout-out to the underwhelming fossil fish). I didn't connect quite as much to Sebastian but this is a series and we have plenty of time for him to develop. Plus his sister and family set-up absolutely rock. I wolfed this down in an evening with immense pleasure.
I had an ARC from the author.
November 29, 2020
3.5 Stars
Lovers of Whyborne and Griffin should have no problem with this spinoff as the atmosphere is creepy and secretive, with just that touch of surprising horror as Widdershins still has its hold on its denizens and those that it beckons into its fold.
Newcomer Vesper Rune, has a deep dark secret that has plagued him all his life and in a desperate attempt to rid a curse from himself and his beloved brother, he infiltrates the Ladysmith’s library under false pretenses. Of course, what he doesn’t expect to find is a belonging he’s never had and stirring feelings for one he should never desire. The thing is, will Vesper have the chance to fulfill such farfetched dreams with library archivist Sebastian Rath, or will a brewing nasty foe prevail instead?
What always makes a spinoff good and what made this story’s predecessor so successful was that it delivered a solid mystery, stoked an initial slow burn between the two protagonists that turned epic, and Hawk consistently plied plenty of heart behind the terror and suspense.
Here, it’s not quite there yet, but it’s only the first book and I have strong hopes and an inkling that Vesper and Sebastian (as well as the eccentric librarian cast) will more than prove their worth by employing their quirky resourceful ways. Whyborne and Griffin are in the periphery doing their own thing, hopefully enjoying some of their hard won peace but as everyone knows, evil never rests and will inevitably rear its ugly head in some form or another. There’s a new duo in town to take their turn at it, and they’re far from shabby and subpar!
Lovers of Whyborne and Griffin should have no problem with this spinoff as the atmosphere is creepy and secretive, with just that touch of surprising horror as Widdershins still has its hold on its denizens and those that it beckons into its fold.
Newcomer Vesper Rune, has a deep dark secret that has plagued him all his life and in a desperate attempt to rid a curse from himself and his beloved brother, he infiltrates the Ladysmith’s library under false pretenses. Of course, what he doesn’t expect to find is a belonging he’s never had and stirring feelings for one he should never desire. The thing is, will Vesper have the chance to fulfill such farfetched dreams with library archivist Sebastian Rath, or will a brewing nasty foe prevail instead?
What always makes a spinoff good and what made this story’s predecessor so successful was that it delivered a solid mystery, stoked an initial slow burn between the two protagonists that turned epic, and Hawk consistently plied plenty of heart behind the terror and suspense.
Here, it’s not quite there yet, but it’s only the first book and I have strong hopes and an inkling that Vesper and Sebastian (as well as the eccentric librarian cast) will more than prove their worth by employing their quirky resourceful ways. Whyborne and Griffin are in the periphery doing their own thing, hopefully enjoying some of their hard won peace but as everyone knows, evil never rests and will inevitably rear its ugly head in some form or another. There’s a new duo in town to take their turn at it, and they’re far from shabby and subpar!
September 24, 2023
My lackluster excitement for the last two books from the Whyborne and Griffin series has shown me that I either needed to move on, or the series needed to come to a close. In my defense I did make a valiant effort to explore the author's other series, but when the spin-off set in Widdershins reared its head, I could barely wait to immerse myself back into the creepy atmosphere of the world of Widdershins.
There's a whole new set of characters, which is great because they're all very interesting in their own right. Although there is some overlap with characters from the old series, for the most part it's quite clear that it can stand on its own.
I quite enjoyed smirking at Vesper's many unfounded worries, looking forward to the big reveal. On Sebastian's side of things, his naïve acceptance of the library's more outlandish security features provide quite a bit of comedic humor. All this was obviously possible, thanks to my preexisting knowledge of Widdershins' society.
For all that I've done nothing but sing its praises, the excitement factor of the Rath and Rune series doesn't quite measure up to that of the prequel. While there are a few hot-n-heavy scenes, they're much tamer compared to those from the Whyborne and Griffin series, and this in spite of the very real opportunity for things to veer into extreme hentai territory.
Score 3.3/5 stars
I loved going back to Widdershins, and navigate its weird social circles, the mysterious Ladysmith Museum, all alongside a brand new set of main characters. I'm kind of disappointed at the lack of cameos from either Whyborne or Griffin, but Mr. Quinn's antics did go some ways to appease my nostalgia.
================
Review of book 2: Unseen
Review of book 3: Unknown
There's a whole new set of characters, which is great because they're all very interesting in their own right. Although there is some overlap with characters from the old series, for the most part it's quite clear that it can stand on its own.
I quite enjoyed smirking at Vesper's many unfounded worries, looking forward to the big reveal. On Sebastian's side of things, his naïve acceptance of the library's more outlandish security features provide quite a bit of comedic humor. All this was obviously possible, thanks to my preexisting knowledge of Widdershins' society.
For all that I've done nothing but sing its praises, the excitement factor of the Rath and Rune series doesn't quite measure up to that of the prequel. While there are a few hot-n-heavy scenes, they're much tamer compared to those from the Whyborne and Griffin series, and this in spite of the very real opportunity for things to veer into extreme hentai territory.
Score 3.3/5 stars
I loved going back to Widdershins, and navigate its weird social circles, the mysterious Ladysmith Museum, all alongside a brand new set of main characters. I'm kind of disappointed at the lack of cameos from either Whyborne or Griffin, but Mr. Quinn's antics did go some ways to appease my nostalgia.
================
Review of book 2: Unseen
Review of book 3: Unknown
August 15, 2020
4 Stars
A promising new start to a brand-new historical M/M romance series set in Hawk’s illustrious home for the supernatural, Widdershins.
Although a new story in its own right, Rath and Rune is a spin-off series picking up almost a decade after the events of Hawk’s fan-favourite Whyborne and Griffin series. As such, I highly recommend new readers start there, if only to experience the epic wonder of Widdershins and its loveable characters from their very inception, but this spin-off tale, full of new characters and new supernatural myths and mysteries was easy to follow and spookily entertaining.
As far as the lead characters were concerned, I warmed quickly to enigmatic bookbinder Vesper Rune, even more so once the mystery of his otherworldliness was cracked wide open later on in the story. His counterpart, library archivist extraordinaire Sebastian Rath, was a tougher nut to crack. Sebastian, at many points throughout the story, seemed a bit uneven as a character, which I’m hoping was just a result of my own desperate efforts to narrow in on who these men where and what was driving them, even so early in the piece. I’m fairly sure, as the series progresses, that these initial feelings of uncertainty that I have towards Sebastian’s character will fade away the more I get to know him.
The mystery elements of the storytelling were strong, especially when it came to me trying to identify exactly what type of supernatural being Vesper was, and even more so when it came to the building of a larger, series defining mystery and legacy. I had a great deal of fun with this aspect of the story and how things unfolded.
As for the romance, I felt a little blindsided by how swiftly Vesper and Sebastian went from barely-tolerable new work colleagues to impassioned lovers, but insta-feelings aside, I can see a world of potential for these two, and I can’t wait to see how their relationship grows as they continue to solve bigger Widdershins mysteries together.
A promising new start to a brand-new historical M/M romance series set in Hawk’s illustrious home for the supernatural, Widdershins.
Although a new story in its own right, Rath and Rune is a spin-off series picking up almost a decade after the events of Hawk’s fan-favourite Whyborne and Griffin series. As such, I highly recommend new readers start there, if only to experience the epic wonder of Widdershins and its loveable characters from their very inception, but this spin-off tale, full of new characters and new supernatural myths and mysteries was easy to follow and spookily entertaining.
As far as the lead characters were concerned, I warmed quickly to enigmatic bookbinder Vesper Rune, even more so once the mystery of his otherworldliness was cracked wide open later on in the story. His counterpart, library archivist extraordinaire Sebastian Rath, was a tougher nut to crack. Sebastian, at many points throughout the story, seemed a bit uneven as a character, which I’m hoping was just a result of my own desperate efforts to narrow in on who these men where and what was driving them, even so early in the piece. I’m fairly sure, as the series progresses, that these initial feelings of uncertainty that I have towards Sebastian’s character will fade away the more I get to know him.
The mystery elements of the storytelling were strong, especially when it came to me trying to identify exactly what type of supernatural being Vesper was, and even more so when it came to the building of a larger, series defining mystery and legacy. I had a great deal of fun with this aspect of the story and how things unfolded.
As for the romance, I felt a little blindsided by how swiftly Vesper and Sebastian went from barely-tolerable new work colleagues to impassioned lovers, but insta-feelings aside, I can see a world of potential for these two, and I can’t wait to see how their relationship grows as they continue to solve bigger Widdershins mysteries together.
November 22, 2020
Widdershins always knows its own,
In blood and spirit, breath and bone.
It was fun to return to Widdershins and see it through the eyes of new characters. This was something of "the right book at the right time" for me -- not too demanding, revisiting a familiar world, easy to read. In theory it could be considered a standalone, but I wouldn't recommend it that way -- at least half my enjoyment came from the in-jokes and callbacks to the original series.
Sebastian Rath, librarian at the Ladysmith Museum Library, and Vesper Rune, newcomer to Widdershins, are appealing characters whose mutual attraction seems credible and unforced. Family plays a large part in the story, for both men, and while that's often a turn-off for me, here it just added to the fun.
My overall impression is that this was charming but lightweight. Despite the monsters, it wasn't particularly dark or deep. Which was part of why it appealed to me right now, honestly. Over the course of the book I occasionally wondered how in the world Hawk was going to turn what felt like a one-off into a series. Let's just say he pulled it off in a way I found intensely satisfying, with a twist that felt both shocking and organic. So I'll be back for the next installment, which, thanks to that twist, feels like it has the potential to go a little darker and a little deeper.
November 1, 2021
Once again, Widdershins doesn’t disappoint.
When I first heard about this new series, I was in equal parts excited and worried, because what were the chances that it would be as good as Whyborne & Griffin? I don’t want to jinx it, but if the first book is anything to go by, the chances are really good.
I loved being back in this unusual, crazy town, I loved all the little references to the mother series and I got the confirmation that yes, the librarians are indeed very much fun to read about, from every POV not only Whyborne’s.
All that, I pretty much expected. What I didn’t expect was this new pair of MCs, especially Ves. I don’t want to say anything about him, because finding out for myself was one of the things I enjoyed most in this book, but I loved his character, it was a wonderful surprise. Sebastian was also great and I think they complement each other pretty well, which helped me to buy how they I also appreciated that
The mystery/adventure part of the plot was pretty much business as usual for Widdershins, with arcane magic, secret cults, secrets revealed and more secrets to be revealed. And of course the most interesting museum that ever was right at the center of everything.
Add a great cast of secondary characters and the recipe for another awesome series seems to be complete. I’m very ready for the next book.
-----------------------------
Thanks to my BR companions for making this even more fun, I can't wait to read the rest of the series with all of you!
When I first heard about this new series, I was in equal parts excited and worried, because what were the chances that it would be as good as Whyborne & Griffin? I don’t want to jinx it, but if the first book is anything to go by, the chances are really good.
I loved being back in this unusual, crazy town, I loved all the little references to the mother series and I got the confirmation that yes, the librarians are indeed very much fun to read about, from every POV not only Whyborne’s.
All that, I pretty much expected. What I didn’t expect was this new pair of MCs, especially Ves. I don’t want to say anything about him, because finding out for myself was one of the things I enjoyed most in this book, but I loved his character, it was a wonderful surprise. Sebastian was also great and I think they complement each other pretty well, which helped me to buy how they I also appreciated that
The mystery/adventure part of the plot was pretty much business as usual for Widdershins, with arcane magic, secret cults, secrets revealed and more secrets to be revealed. And of course the most interesting museum that ever was right at the center of everything.
Add a great cast of secondary characters and the recipe for another awesome series seems to be complete. I’m very ready for the next book.
-----------------------------
Thanks to my BR companions for making this even more fun, I can't wait to read the rest of the series with all of you!
August 31, 2022
i have to be up at 7am tomorrow morning (um, this morning, i guess) so obviously i've stayed up until half 5 to finish this book.
and it! was! perfect!! and i need the next books N O W
and it! was! perfect!! and i need the next books N O W
November 27, 2021
4.5 Stars
Oh how wonderful it was to visit Widdershins again! I love how this new series has started and am so excited for more!
Oh how wonderful it was to visit Widdershins again! I love how this new series has started and am so excited for more!
July 21, 2020
What a lovely start to this new Widdershins series!
I think it could stand alone if necessary, but I wouldn’t recommend reading it without first having completed the other books.
If you’ve already read Widdershins and enjoyed it, you know why you should read this.
Also, tentacles can be sexy and not hentai genre; who knew?
I think it could stand alone if necessary, but I wouldn’t recommend reading it without first having completed the other books.
If you’ve already read Widdershins and enjoyed it, you know why you should read this.
Also, tentacles can be sexy and not hentai genre; who knew?
September 7, 2020
3.5 stars
This is a great start to a new series, set in the Widdershins universe that many of us will be familiar with in the Whyborne & Griffin series. Unhallowed takes place eight years after the end of Deosil, and while there are no outright spoilers, there are enough hints about what happened that I think it's definitely better to read this after finishing W&G, though it's by no means necessary. This book is written to stand on its own, and it can; those unfamiliar with W&G will simply miss all the references to that series.
Sebastian Rath and Vesper Rune are both engaging MCs. Ves in particular has a harrowed past he's trying to make amends for, but Sebastian also has things in his past that makes him feel inadequate at times. As such, they are a good balance for each other and I enjoyed seeing them thaw out toward each other and get to know each other. Still, they didn't have the immediate spark and draw for me as a reader that Whyborne and Griffin did. I know it's unfair to compare the two, but I do wish there was a bit more chemistry between the leads than what we got, especially since this is insta as hell.
The library is as quirky as ever, and we get to learn some of its secrets, in particular the history surrounding its construction. Hawk really added so many layers to that and it all fits with what came before. The new librarians are pretty tame in their personalities so far. None of them really leap off the page in the same way that Christine, Miss Parkhurst or even Bradley had, so I'm hoping they get more development in the next book. But it's good to see Mr. Quinn is still as strange and perfect as ever, lol. And of course, I love all the little references to how odd Widdershins is compared to other towns, and how oblivious its residents are to that fact.
The main plot, which I won't go into too much, is interesting enough that it kept my attention, even if I figured out at least one part of it early on. The main conflict resolution was interesting as well and leaves the door open for future developments. I'm baffled how the
There are a couple of inconsistencies in the text, but they aren't so huge they can't be overlooked, but they should have been found during editing. There was a bit too much repetition, consistently reminding the reader of the time clock and what Rune hoped to gain from this; a few of those references could have been removed, as they got annoying after a time.
So I enjoyed this and am looking forward to more. Thanks for the awesome BR with Cristina, Teal, Elena, Rosa and Gabi. Can't wait to hash this out with you all. :D
This is a great start to a new series, set in the Widdershins universe that many of us will be familiar with in the Whyborne & Griffin series. Unhallowed takes place eight years after the end of Deosil, and while there are no outright spoilers, there are enough hints about what happened that I think it's definitely better to read this after finishing W&G, though it's by no means necessary. This book is written to stand on its own, and it can; those unfamiliar with W&G will simply miss all the references to that series.
Sebastian Rath and Vesper Rune are both engaging MCs. Ves in particular has a harrowed past he's trying to make amends for, but Sebastian also has things in his past that makes him feel inadequate at times. As such, they are a good balance for each other and I enjoyed seeing them thaw out toward each other and get to know each other. Still, they didn't have the immediate spark and draw for me as a reader that Whyborne and Griffin did. I know it's unfair to compare the two, but I do wish there was a bit more chemistry between the leads than what we got, especially since this is insta as hell.
The library is as quirky as ever, and we get to learn some of its secrets, in particular the history surrounding its construction. Hawk really added so many layers to that and it all fits with what came before. The new librarians are pretty tame in their personalities so far. None of them really leap off the page in the same way that Christine, Miss Parkhurst or even Bradley had, so I'm hoping they get more development in the next book. But it's good to see Mr. Quinn is still as strange and perfect as ever, lol. And of course, I love all the little references to how odd Widdershins is compared to other towns, and how oblivious its residents are to that fact.
The main plot, which I won't go into too much, is interesting enough that it kept my attention, even if I figured out at least one part of it early on. The main conflict resolution was interesting as well and leaves the door open for future developments. I'm baffled how the
There are a couple of inconsistencies in the text, but they aren't so huge they can't be overlooked, but they should have been found during editing. There was a bit too much repetition, consistently reminding the reader of the time clock and what Rune hoped to gain from this; a few of those references could have been removed, as they got annoying after a time.
So I enjoyed this and am looking forward to more. Thanks for the awesome BR with Cristina, Teal, Elena, Rosa and Gabi. Can't wait to hash this out with you all. :D
July 28, 2023
Widdershins is back! Eight years after the not quite end of the world and show down with the Masters, we return to Ladysmith Museum, but this time we enter the sacred walls of the Library and start discovering all its secrets. Very enjoyable new angle at the shadowy monsters, power of arcane and love beyond measure. There is mystery, there is betrayal and there is redemption. I enjoyed seeing Mr. Quinn, the head librarian, in his element. I liked the internal goings on in the library and how all the librarians saw themselves as protectors.
Sebastian Rath is a likable fellow with penchant for amateur sleuthing and so much curiosity that just might get him in trouble. He is a devoted brother and a wonderful archivist. Vesper Rune despite his childhood and origins is kind and caring man. The choice that brings him to Sebastian might not have been wise but in the end it feels like Widdershins is exactly where he is meant to be. Vesper finally finds his self worth and a place in this world and Sebastian finds someone to love and cherish.
I loved secondary characters. They represented different walks of life and families of Widdershins. I liked that Endicotts seemed to have assimilated well into the town life and its inhabitants. Widdershins is a special place that keeps its secrets close to the vest and accepts those who are lost and in need of guidance. Ves and his brother Noct find what they have been looking for all their lives - family and a place to belong to. This was steadily paced, mildly steamy, angsty and medium suspenseful PNR romance full magic, high emotions and a cast of wonderful characters that I want to know all about. I enjoyed the storytelling and will definitely read the next one!
Sebastian Rath is a likable fellow with penchant for amateur sleuthing and so much curiosity that just might get him in trouble. He is a devoted brother and a wonderful archivist. Vesper Rune despite his childhood and origins is kind and caring man. The choice that brings him to Sebastian might not have been wise but in the end it feels like Widdershins is exactly where he is meant to be. Vesper finally finds his self worth and a place in this world and Sebastian finds someone to love and cherish.
I loved secondary characters. They represented different walks of life and families of Widdershins. I liked that Endicotts seemed to have assimilated well into the town life and its inhabitants. Widdershins is a special place that keeps its secrets close to the vest and accepts those who are lost and in need of guidance. Ves and his brother Noct find what they have been looking for all their lives - family and a place to belong to. This was steadily paced, mildly steamy, angsty and medium suspenseful PNR romance full magic, high emotions and a cast of wonderful characters that I want to know all about. I enjoyed the storytelling and will definitely read the next one!
March 16, 2022
A new series set in a familiar place, the uncanny un-Puritan city founded in 17th-century Massachusetts on a swirling vortex of arcane magic. Vesper Rune is, by his own definition, a monster, but he is on a mission to liberate himself and his younger brother, Nocturne, from a curse, using his skills as a bookbinder to obtain a position in the library of the venerable Ladysmith Museum in Widdershins. Sebastian Rath is the archetype of the fussy, prim librarian—archivist, to be exact. He resents Rune’s arrival, because it comes on the heels of the mysterious disappearance of a long-time colleague and family friend. Rath doesn’t see that Rune is a monster, only that he has taken a position that was held by a friend for whom Rath mourns. It’s a classic standoff until Rune unexpectedly comes to Rath’s aid in a moment of crisis, and they become inadvertent allies in something neither of them fully understand. A great start on this new series....at least for me. I understand there are now 11 more books. YEAH!
June 20, 2023
The “too lazy to write a review” review:
I liked it
I liked it
July 19, 2020
This is an interesting start to a new series, set in Widdershins, but I think quite accessible to a reader who hasn't read Whyborne and Griffin (though I'd recommend starting with them.) Sebastian Rath is the chief archivist for the Ladysmith library, a repository of books both mundane and arcane whose librarians are very serious about their sacred trust. His mother was the book binder who expected him to follow in her footsteps, and Sebastian is haunted by the fact that he declined, and then she died, with that rift and some secrets still wedged between them. Haunted worse by the fact that he saw her die and failed to save her.
So when her successor in the position mysteriously up and left in the middle of the night, Sebastian was sure foul play was at work. But he's spinning his wheels trying to prove it, until a new book binder - Vesper Rune - arrives from Boston. Little events surrounding them trigger an increasing certainty that something is truly wrong in the library. And in Ves, he hopes he's found an ally in uncovering them.
Ves is in a terrible position. He took the job in the Ladysmith library to secretly work for a man whose motives he doesn't trust, but who holds Vesper's younger brother hostage, and who offers them a promise of a better life. Ves is also hiding a deeper secret - of who and what he is. He should get in, get his boss the information he wants, and get out. Not get involved with anything or anyone else.
But despite a harsh childhood being prepared to be a cult's secret soldier, Ves has a warm nature and a fast sympathy for the underdog. And in Sebastian he's finding the first friend he's ever had. How can he abandon or betray him? And yet, how can he abandon the brother he's loved and protected all his life?
This book has a different dynamic than the first series. These two are new characters (Sebastian appeared briefly), with an interaction that is unique to them. And the town of Widdershins, having come through the climactic battle at the end of Deosil, is a different place - less dark, more aware of magic, willing to accept or at least look the other way, and slow to judge. For Ves, it's nothing like Boston, or his remote secretive upbringing.
Part of those changes make the pressures lower - less hiding from everyone, on multiple fronts. Less desperate mutual fear of judgement and rejection. Despite Ves's deep issues, the story has a lighter feel. I'm not yet fully invested in the characters or their relationship, but I'm interested and intrigued, and I fully trust this author to take me through another great adventure with this series and these two men.
So when her successor in the position mysteriously up and left in the middle of the night, Sebastian was sure foul play was at work. But he's spinning his wheels trying to prove it, until a new book binder - Vesper Rune - arrives from Boston. Little events surrounding them trigger an increasing certainty that something is truly wrong in the library. And in Ves, he hopes he's found an ally in uncovering them.
Ves is in a terrible position. He took the job in the Ladysmith library to secretly work for a man whose motives he doesn't trust, but who holds Vesper's younger brother hostage, and who offers them a promise of a better life. Ves is also hiding a deeper secret - of who and what he is. He should get in, get his boss the information he wants, and get out. Not get involved with anything or anyone else.
But despite a harsh childhood being prepared to be a cult's secret soldier, Ves has a warm nature and a fast sympathy for the underdog. And in Sebastian he's finding the first friend he's ever had. How can he abandon or betray him? And yet, how can he abandon the brother he's loved and protected all his life?
This book has a different dynamic than the first series. These two are new characters (Sebastian appeared briefly), with an interaction that is unique to them. And the town of Widdershins, having come through the climactic battle at the end of Deosil, is a different place - less dark, more aware of magic, willing to accept or at least look the other way, and slow to judge. For Ves, it's nothing like Boston, or his remote secretive upbringing.
Part of those changes make the pressures lower - less hiding from everyone, on multiple fronts. Less desperate mutual fear of judgement and rejection. Despite Ves's deep issues, the story has a lighter feel. I'm not yet fully invested in the characters or their relationship, but I'm interested and intrigued, and I fully trust this author to take me through another great adventure with this series and these two men.
June 13, 2020
Like many readers I fell deeply in love with Whyborne, Griffin and the world Jordan L. Hawk created in the Widdershins series, so I was little worried that his first entry in a spin-off series with new characters set in our favorite murder town couldn't possibly live up to its predecessor. I shouldn't have worried; Unhallowed has a few call-backs and Easter eggs for W&G fans, but it very much stands on its own, featuring two strong MCs, a cast of promising supporting characters (including an Endicott!) and an intriguing new paranormal peril.
I don't want to spoil the story, so I'll just say that if you liked the increasingly bizarre Mr. Quinn and the other librarians you'll be right at home in Unhallowed. Sebastian Rath (who played a very minor role in W&G's final book, Deosil) is the chief archivist for the Ladysmith library, and Vesper Rune is the man with a Big Secret who arrives from Boston to take a job as the new library binder/conservator. They start out as antagonists but fairly quickly become allies, and then friends working together to solve the mysterious disappearance of the man who held Ves's job before him. But Vesper can't get too close to Sebastian; not only because he can't reveal his true purpose, but also because he can't let anyone see what he really is...a monster (not a spoiler, see the book's opening sentence).
The dynamic between the two men has some superficial similarities to Whyborne's "nobody could possibly love gawky old me" and Griffin's "self-assured but hiding years of deep hurt." Ves thinks nobody will ever want or even touch him, but he has none of Whyborne's innocence or physical awkwardness. And Sebastian is pretty easy going but is living with a load of guilt about the fallout from the decision not to follow in his mother's professional footsteps. So there's still that lovely moment of amazement and relief for both MCs of "he sees me and he still wants me" but it comes from a very different angle.
I think the book can be enjoyed by Widdershins newbies, but there are numerous delightful nods to the previous series that reward loyal fans. Widdershins in 1910 is a different place than it was at the end of Deosil; sorcery is acknowledged and appreciated, and even Sebastian's sexuality doesn't seem to set off any alarm bells. Some of the funniest parts of the book are Sebastian comparing Widdershins to Boston and labeling the latter as "strange."
The book ends with a definite HFN for our MCs but lots of unanswered questions and a direct lead into the next installment. I'm so happy to be back in Widdershins, but not for the nostalgic value; this series looks like it has the promise to be just as wonderful on its own merits. W.K.I.O. indeed!
I don't want to spoil the story, so I'll just say that if you liked the increasingly bizarre Mr. Quinn and the other librarians you'll be right at home in Unhallowed. Sebastian Rath (who played a very minor role in W&G's final book, Deosil) is the chief archivist for the Ladysmith library, and Vesper Rune is the man with a Big Secret who arrives from Boston to take a job as the new library binder/conservator. They start out as antagonists but fairly quickly become allies, and then friends working together to solve the mysterious disappearance of the man who held Ves's job before him. But Vesper can't get too close to Sebastian; not only because he can't reveal his true purpose, but also because he can't let anyone see what he really is...a monster (not a spoiler, see the book's opening sentence).
The dynamic between the two men has some superficial similarities to Whyborne's "nobody could possibly love gawky old me" and Griffin's "self-assured but hiding years of deep hurt." Ves thinks nobody will ever want or even touch him, but he has none of Whyborne's innocence or physical awkwardness. And Sebastian is pretty easy going but is living with a load of guilt about the fallout from the decision not to follow in his mother's professional footsteps. So there's still that lovely moment of amazement and relief for both MCs of "he sees me and he still wants me" but it comes from a very different angle.
I think the book can be enjoyed by Widdershins newbies, but there are numerous delightful nods to the previous series that reward loyal fans. Widdershins in 1910 is a different place than it was at the end of Deosil; sorcery is acknowledged and appreciated, and even Sebastian's sexuality doesn't seem to set off any alarm bells. Some of the funniest parts of the book are Sebastian comparing Widdershins to Boston and labeling the latter as "strange."
The book ends with a definite HFN for our MCs but lots of unanswered questions and a direct lead into the next installment. I'm so happy to be back in Widdershins, but not for the nostalgic value; this series looks like it has the promise to be just as wonderful on its own merits. W.K.I.O. indeed!
August 15, 2020
What I like most about Jordan L. Hawk is the uniqueness of his stories. And this book, which is the beginning of a new series, is a great example of that. And although I admit that I like the Hexworld, Spirits and Whyborne & Griffin series more, I still think it's a great book and I absolutely recommend it.
Usually I start my reviews with a description of the main characters or the plot, but this time there is something that absolutely pushes to the fore. Tentacles! Tentacles!! Yay! I was wondering, it actually falls under the character description category, lol. I try to remember if I have ever read a book in which the main character would have tentacles. And I think I didn’t, and certainly no one was as cute as the characters in this book. You see, this is the uniqueness of Hawk's story.
But tentacles aside, characters are always a strong point in Hawk's books and here he did a good job. Sebastian and Vesper are very nice characters, even if, in my opinion, they are lacking a little bit of something I usually find in this author’s characters. This little unnamed thing that make them truly remarkable. Of the two, Vesper stands out with his tortured past. Sebastian is perhaps a little too bland compared to him. Although both are definitely likeable. And we also have some great supporting characters here. Hawk can make even the pompous Mortimer Waite have something special about him that makes me unable to dislike him.
If I missed something in this story, it was probably something unique in the plot. I mean, the plotline is really good and interesting, I didn't get stuck for a moment. We have plenty of action and twists and turns. But perhaps there is some uniqueness missing. There is probably more emphasis on the characters than on the story. The concept itself is interesting, but I was missing something.
Also, Vesper and Sebastian's romance is a little too quick and too easy for me. I can easily believe that they like each other a lot and that they care a great deal about each other, but it seems too early at this stage to make an open declaration of love, that’s what I think at least. They have just met. For me, I could wait until the next book with that.
But despite all the things I said above, it is a really good book that is very quick and easy to read. And no doubt I will also read the next book in this series. I also hope for a happy ending for Nocturn eventually.
Usually I start my reviews with a description of the main characters or the plot, but this time there is something that absolutely pushes to the fore. Tentacles! Tentacles!! Yay! I was wondering, it actually falls under the character description category, lol. I try to remember if I have ever read a book in which the main character would have tentacles. And I think I didn’t, and certainly no one was as cute as the characters in this book. You see, this is the uniqueness of Hawk's story.
But tentacles aside, characters are always a strong point in Hawk's books and here he did a good job. Sebastian and Vesper are very nice characters, even if, in my opinion, they are lacking a little bit of something I usually find in this author’s characters. This little unnamed thing that make them truly remarkable. Of the two, Vesper stands out with his tortured past. Sebastian is perhaps a little too bland compared to him. Although both are definitely likeable. And we also have some great supporting characters here. Hawk can make even the pompous Mortimer Waite have something special about him that makes me unable to dislike him.
If I missed something in this story, it was probably something unique in the plot. I mean, the plotline is really good and interesting, I didn't get stuck for a moment. We have plenty of action and twists and turns. But perhaps there is some uniqueness missing. There is probably more emphasis on the characters than on the story. The concept itself is interesting, but I was missing something.
Also, Vesper and Sebastian's romance is a little too quick and too easy for me. I can easily believe that they like each other a lot and that they care a great deal about each other, but it seems too early at this stage to make an open declaration of love, that’s what I think at least. They have just met. For me, I could wait until the next book with that.
But despite all the things I said above, it is a really good book that is very quick and easy to read. And no doubt I will also read the next book in this series. I also hope for a happy ending for Nocturn eventually.
September 7, 2020
"Widdershins knows its own"
It's been a pleasure being back in this murder town. When last year I BR Whyborne & Griffin series and discovered the awesomeness of the Ladysmith Librarians, we joked about how awesome it would be to know more about them, so when this series was announced we were truly excited, and for me, this starting point has been everything I was hoping for and more.
I loved how this new characters are introduced to us and despite suspecting who was behind the mystery, I enjoyed following the scattered clues and putting them together.
I liked Sebastian and Vesper, , and I also liked the few interactions with Irene. I think she is going to be an interesting character being an Endicott and such.
I'm looking forward to the next book in the series, this one has been really good, despite being unable to explain properly why. If you're still in the fence about reading this one, read the awesome review by Ele, she's done a better job than me at explaing why you shouldn't miss this.
It's been a pleasure being back in this murder town. When last year I BR Whyborne & Griffin series and discovered the awesomeness of the Ladysmith Librarians, we joked about how awesome it would be to know more about them, so when this series was announced we were truly excited, and for me, this starting point has been everything I was hoping for and more.
I loved how this new characters are introduced to us and despite suspecting who was behind the mystery, I enjoyed following the scattered clues and putting them together.
I liked Sebastian and Vesper, , and I also liked the few interactions with Irene. I think she is going to be an interesting character being an Endicott and such.
I'm looking forward to the next book in the series, this one has been really good, despite being unable to explain properly why. If you're still in the fence about reading this one, read the awesome review by Ele, she's done a better job than me at explaing why you shouldn't miss this.
September 10, 2020
This was such an enjoyable read!
It's always nice to have the opportunity to read a new novel by Jordan L. Hawk, especially now that the Whyborne & Griffin series is (sadly) over.
Unhallowed is the beginning of a new saga set in Widdershins and focusing on two new characters, archivist Sebastian Rath - who appeared quickly in Deosil - and bookbinder and human hybrid Vesper Rune.
The story was satisfying on so many levels - the old adage that "Widdershins knows its own" pervades the pages of the novel and gives the reader a nice - but never comfortable in Widdershins! - sense of familiarity. It felt to me like stepping back into a well-known universe, with its weird and wonderful characters, the dark alleys, the constant crossing of natural and supernatural, the shifting shadows hiding behind corners.
Sebastian and Ves are nice new characters with great potential to grow into another formidable due. I didn't feel the immediate love that I felt for Whyborne and Griffin when I read the first book in the W&G series, but I truly enjoyed Sebastian's personality and felt really sorry for Vesper's lonely upbringing and current solitude.
The secondary characters, starting with the eccentric Mr Quinn and including Sebastian's family, shows a lot of promise for the future instalments of this new series.
Really nice!
It's always nice to have the opportunity to read a new novel by Jordan L. Hawk, especially now that the Whyborne & Griffin series is (sadly) over.
Unhallowed is the beginning of a new saga set in Widdershins and focusing on two new characters, archivist Sebastian Rath - who appeared quickly in Deosil - and bookbinder and human hybrid Vesper Rune.
The story was satisfying on so many levels - the old adage that "Widdershins knows its own" pervades the pages of the novel and gives the reader a nice - but never comfortable in Widdershins! - sense of familiarity. It felt to me like stepping back into a well-known universe, with its weird and wonderful characters, the dark alleys, the constant crossing of natural and supernatural, the shifting shadows hiding behind corners.
Sebastian and Ves are nice new characters with great potential to grow into another formidable due. I didn't feel the immediate love that I felt for Whyborne and Griffin when I read the first book in the W&G series, but I truly enjoyed Sebastian's personality and felt really sorry for Vesper's lonely upbringing and current solitude.
The secondary characters, starting with the eccentric Mr Quinn and including Sebastian's family, shows a lot of promise for the future instalments of this new series.
Really nice!
July 23, 2020
Widdershins is back, babeeeeeys
(Zero objectivity in this "review", Im incapable of being anything but hype machine over Jordans books, so take this "review" for what it really is- a rambling loving mess)
Reading this book as an academic librarian was so fucking funny. God I wish I could curse asshole library patrons for not returning or damaging books. Mr. Quinn please hire me Im begging you, or at least teach me your methods.
This book was so funny! The culture shock of a regular normal librarian clashing against the bonkers Widdershiners was amazing. The culture shock of a guy who grew up in a cult fully aware magic is real going "oh, when these completely normal and regular people of Widdershins find out Im a horrible monster, they will be so disgusted and terrified :(" meanwhile the town is pulling up a sign saying "we love Whyborne, our fish king". Its amazing. Also hilarious. I love it
On a bit of a serious note, do check out TWs before reading because there is a lot of heavy subjects being dealt with. Jordan walks the tightrope between hilarity and angst masterfully, we all know this based on his previous works, but still, this book goes real dark at points, so be aware.
Basically if you like Whyborne and Griffin, or if you like queer lovecraft spookiness, OR if you like The Magnus Archives, you should read this book
(Zero objectivity in this "review", Im incapable of being anything but hype machine over Jordans books, so take this "review" for what it really is- a rambling loving mess)
Reading this book as an academic librarian was so fucking funny. God I wish I could curse asshole library patrons for not returning or damaging books. Mr. Quinn please hire me Im begging you, or at least teach me your methods.
This book was so funny! The culture shock of a regular normal librarian clashing against the bonkers Widdershiners was amazing. The culture shock of a guy who grew up in a cult fully aware magic is real going "oh, when these completely normal and regular people of Widdershins find out Im a horrible monster, they will be so disgusted and terrified :(" meanwhile the town is pulling up a sign saying "we love Whyborne, our fish king". Its amazing. Also hilarious. I love it
On a bit of a serious note, do check out TWs before reading because there is a lot of heavy subjects being dealt with. Jordan walks the tightrope between hilarity and angst masterfully, we all know this based on his previous works, but still, this book goes real dark at points, so be aware.
Basically if you like Whyborne and Griffin, or if you like queer lovecraft spookiness, OR if you like The Magnus Archives, you should read this book
July 26, 2020
3.5
So we're back in our favorite New England town of parallel history 8 years after the last visit. After the not-quite-end of the world the town is a changed one, a lighter kind of quirky, more open and accepting or a least slower to judge but still full of dark secrets. The residents are not even aware of their difference to the other parts of the US like that the books in the Boston library are not protected by curses or that other harbor towns only know the first part of the saying 'A wife in every port, a husband on every ship'. Things like that are setting a different pace to the story telling and I liked that it made the start of Rath and Rune not just a different colored Whyborne and Griffin i.e. it's not only a change of MCs but also in dynamic and atmosphere.
It's still Widdershins and it's still Hawk so the adventure and mystery is well prepared and impeccable and while there is no cliffhanger there's a lot space of foreboding and I'm really looking forward to where the author is taking that story.
I hope with the next books I also get more invested with Sebastian. He's a nice character with a lot of potential but I was not able to connect with him. We get a lot told about him but I didn't really felt what I read and I was surprised how Hawk played the insta-attraction card in his case. Ves on the other side … no complains about him and there are some great supporting characters like Ves' brother Noct of whom I'm quite sure we will see more and then also more of Irene and the already well established Bonnie and no doubt about Fagerlie and his School of Nights.
Rath and Rune is not yet on the same level as Whyborne and Griffin but that might be the curse of setting such high margins with his other books and the now equally high expectations of his readers but I'm quite sure we'll get there.
So we're back in our favorite New England town of parallel history 8 years after the last visit. After the not-quite-end of the world the town is a changed one, a lighter kind of quirky, more open and accepting or a least slower to judge but still full of dark secrets. The residents are not even aware of their difference to the other parts of the US like that the books in the Boston library are not protected by curses or that other harbor towns only know the first part of the saying 'A wife in every port, a husband on every ship'. Things like that are setting a different pace to the story telling and I liked that it made the start of Rath and Rune not just a different colored Whyborne and Griffin i.e. it's not only a change of MCs but also in dynamic and atmosphere.
It's still Widdershins and it's still Hawk so the adventure and mystery is well prepared and impeccable and while there is no cliffhanger there's a lot space of foreboding and I'm really looking forward to where the author is taking that story.
I hope with the next books I also get more invested with Sebastian. He's a nice character with a lot of potential but I was not able to connect with him. We get a lot told about him but I didn't really felt what I read and I was surprised how Hawk played the insta-attraction card in his case. Ves on the other side … no complains about him and there are some great supporting characters like Ves' brother Noct of whom I'm quite sure we will see more and then also more of Irene and the already well established Bonnie and no doubt about Fagerlie and his School of Nights.
Rath and Rune is not yet on the same level as Whyborne and Griffin but that might be the curse of setting such high margins with his other books and the now equally high expectations of his readers but I'm quite sure we'll get there.
July 19, 2020
Happy to be back in Widdershins and glad to see that Hawk is still in top peak.
Looking forward to more of these two plus the others, I got thoughts on Noct..........
Looking forward to more of these two plus the others, I got thoughts on Noct..........
Want to read
June 16, 2020
March 9, 2021
A fun mystery set in Widdershins with a new central cast, focused on the librarians, and with a promise of at least three more books in the series. What's not to like?
Since he was making a new series here, I think Hawk made a good choice in not having Whyborne show up at all (though with ). Of course, I missed the old characters, but the new ones were quite fun. I loved Bonnie, and I'm especially drawn to Nocturn -- can't wait to see more of him.
Only one critical comment, and that's that it took to a full 60% to get the details of Vesper's curse, even though it was very clear from chapter 1 that it was a physical curse and was monstrous in a Lovecraftian way. Unfortunately, he thought about the physical nature of his curse all the time, so it felt like the details were being hidden from us as readers when there was no reason that Ves wouldn't think of it more directly (as he does after the reveal). It made his POV sections feel less natural and "in character" and more written with an obvious authorial intent to obscure it from the reader (plus ) Anyway, this is going to be a non-issue in future books regardless since the secret is out -- it just stood out to me in this one.
Since he was making a new series here, I think Hawk made a good choice in not having Whyborne show up at all (though with ). Of course, I missed the old characters, but the new ones were quite fun. I loved Bonnie, and I'm especially drawn to Nocturn -- can't wait to see more of him.
Only one critical comment, and that's that it took to a full 60% to get the details of Vesper's curse, even though it was very clear from chapter 1 that it was a physical curse and was monstrous in a Lovecraftian way. Unfortunately, he thought about the physical nature of his curse all the time, so it felt like the details were being hidden from us as readers when there was no reason that Ves wouldn't think of it more directly (as he does after the reveal). It made his POV sections feel less natural and "in character" and more written with an obvious authorial intent to obscure it from the reader (plus ) Anyway, this is going to be a non-issue in future books regardless since the secret is out -- it just stood out to me in this one.
July 20, 2020
4.25 stars from me for this, the first offering in a new series, set in the Widdershins universe.
Yes, we have vague mentions of Whyborne & Griffin, Christine and Iskander, but that's your lot 🙁. This series starts in 1910, 8 years after the huge battle in Deosil when our heroes foiled the Fideles, the Masters and their servants. Up front and centre in this new series is the amazing Mr Quinn, head librarian and his merry band of associates who have to have sworn the Librarian’s Oath before they can be employed. “Widdershins knows its own, in blood and spirit, breath and bone. I swear on my life to defend the library, the town, and the maelstrom”. The oath contains words which are extremely relevant to this new series i.e. blood, spirit, breath and bone...but I'll leave you to discover HOW relevant they and Halley's Comet actually are to the storyline.
Liked our two new MC's, Vesper [who is an unusual hero] and Sebastian. One of the Endicotts is still around 🤨, and there is an absolute shedload of information to absorb in this first instalment...you'll definitely need your wits about you. I would love to find out whether Ival and Griffin and the famous lady Archeologist, her husband and their 2 children still live in Widdershins, and will make any appearances in this series at all...pretty please dear Author??
Great start to the new series Jordan L. Hawk.
Yes, we have vague mentions of Whyborne & Griffin, Christine and Iskander, but that's your lot 🙁. This series starts in 1910, 8 years after the huge battle in Deosil when our heroes foiled the Fideles, the Masters and their servants. Up front and centre in this new series is the amazing Mr Quinn, head librarian and his merry band of associates who have to have sworn the Librarian’s Oath before they can be employed. “Widdershins knows its own, in blood and spirit, breath and bone. I swear on my life to defend the library, the town, and the maelstrom”. The oath contains words which are extremely relevant to this new series i.e. blood, spirit, breath and bone...but I'll leave you to discover HOW relevant they and Halley's Comet actually are to the storyline.
Liked our two new MC's, Vesper [who is an unusual hero] and Sebastian. One of the Endicotts is still around 🤨, and there is an absolute shedload of information to absorb in this first instalment...you'll definitely need your wits about you. I would love to find out whether Ival and Griffin and the famous lady Archeologist, her husband and their 2 children still live in Widdershins, and will make any appearances in this series at all...pretty please dear Author??
Great start to the new series Jordan L. Hawk.
November 1, 2021
Unhallowed (Rath & Rune 1)
By Jordan L. Hawk
Published by the author, 2020
Five stars
Widdershins knows its own.
A brand-new series set in a familiar place, the uncanny un-Puritan city founded in 17th-century Massachusetts on a swirling vortex of arcane magic.
You know, like in the post cards.
Vesper Rune is, by his own definition, a monster. He is on a mission to liberate himself and his younger brother, Nocturne, from a curse; using his skills as a bookbinder to obtain a position in the library of the venerable Ladysmith Museum in Widdershins.
And there’s the hook. The Whyborne and Griffin books were all about the curators at the Ladysmith Museum. One remembers, however, the active role the library staff played in that great final confrontation. This time, it’s all about the library, in which, as we learn, the true secrets of the Ladysmith are hidden.
The joke (irony?) in this set up is that the self-styled monster knows nothing at all about Widdershins and its dark reputation. Vesper grew up in an isolated cult deep in the New England woods, and thus knows little of the world beyond what his abusive mother taught him. But, Vesper now only seeks a better life and freedom for the only person who has ever loved him.
Sebastian Rath is the archetype of the fussy, prim librarian—archivist, to be exact. He resents Rune’s arrival, because it comes on the heels of the mysterious disappearance of a long-time colleague and family friend. Rath doesn’t see that Rune is a monster, only that he has taken a position that was held by a friend for whom Rath mourns.
It’s a classic standoff until Rune unexpectedly comes to Rath’s aid in a moment of crisis, and they become inadvertent allies in something they don’t fully understand.
Jordan Hawk does her usual great job of establishing the characters and reminding us what a strange and interesting city Widdershins is beneath its Edwardian veneer of tired urban reality. Hawk also—to my mind, at least—turns the Ladysmith Library into a great metaphor for the power of knowledge to serve and protect civilization. I worked in a museum for 37 years, and one of my best friends there was the librarian and archivist—who knew where all the secrets were hidden. Of course I’d love this series.
By Jordan L. Hawk
Published by the author, 2020
Five stars
Widdershins knows its own.
A brand-new series set in a familiar place, the uncanny un-Puritan city founded in 17th-century Massachusetts on a swirling vortex of arcane magic.
You know, like in the post cards.
Vesper Rune is, by his own definition, a monster. He is on a mission to liberate himself and his younger brother, Nocturne, from a curse; using his skills as a bookbinder to obtain a position in the library of the venerable Ladysmith Museum in Widdershins.
And there’s the hook. The Whyborne and Griffin books were all about the curators at the Ladysmith Museum. One remembers, however, the active role the library staff played in that great final confrontation. This time, it’s all about the library, in which, as we learn, the true secrets of the Ladysmith are hidden.
The joke (irony?) in this set up is that the self-styled monster knows nothing at all about Widdershins and its dark reputation. Vesper grew up in an isolated cult deep in the New England woods, and thus knows little of the world beyond what his abusive mother taught him. But, Vesper now only seeks a better life and freedom for the only person who has ever loved him.
Sebastian Rath is the archetype of the fussy, prim librarian—archivist, to be exact. He resents Rune’s arrival, because it comes on the heels of the mysterious disappearance of a long-time colleague and family friend. Rath doesn’t see that Rune is a monster, only that he has taken a position that was held by a friend for whom Rath mourns.
It’s a classic standoff until Rune unexpectedly comes to Rath’s aid in a moment of crisis, and they become inadvertent allies in something they don’t fully understand.
Jordan Hawk does her usual great job of establishing the characters and reminding us what a strange and interesting city Widdershins is beneath its Edwardian veneer of tired urban reality. Hawk also—to my mind, at least—turns the Ladysmith Library into a great metaphor for the power of knowledge to serve and protect civilization. I worked in a museum for 37 years, and one of my best friends there was the librarian and archivist—who knew where all the secrets were hidden. Of course I’d love this series.
July 28, 2023
o7/28/2023 reread
I remembered all the things I loved about this spin off. Noct is such a sweetheart. I enjoyed it and am ready for the Unseen.
I remembered all the things I loved about this spin off. Noct is such a sweetheart. I enjoyed it and am ready for the Unseen.
March 12, 2021
4.5 stars
An enjoyable visit to Widdershins with a new group of people. More chaos and magic!
I look forward to getting to know Sebastian & Ves, Bonnie, her younglings, Noct and the rest.
An enjoyable visit to Widdershins with a new group of people. More chaos and magic!
I look forward to getting to know Sebastian & Ves, Bonnie, her younglings, Noct and the rest.
July 28, 2020
While there was a lot I really liked about this I didn't feel it as strong as the original Widdershin's series.
The setting beyond the library is harder to imagine, it seems Widdershins is now in it's own bubble outsiders talk about it and rarely stay. Life appears very progressive on all fronts. While that should be a good thing it confused the historical setting, for me making it harder to place. I don't know what the norms are to this society. But then when deciding to accept it on it's own terms there was sudden referances to real life people and that threw me off.
In the original Christine is a modern woman of fierce independance, in this spin-off her counterpart beyond some descriptions of fashion lacks fire, how/if people react to her isn't really shown.
The Library however is fantastic. It sounds incredible. I want to visit with a strong torch and trustworthy guide. I liked what we saw of librarians they make for a quirky bunch and would love to get to know the characters better.
Ves is an interesting character, Hawke does research and the excitement over book margins amused me. But Sebestain I never warmed to. It's a series and there's time for him to become better drawn but here he was weak. My first impression of his character was proved wrong and it made him harder to know, his attitudes at times somehow made things seem less.
The plot was predictable, no suprises, I guessed the villian very early on along with other mysteries. The first half of the book seemed a lot of talking in circles and nothing really happening then all the action hits in the second half. The tension was never what it could have been. Found certain things contradictory and was left with some niggles. Lovecraft's influence continues.
Hopefully with the players introduced the next book in the series will become stronger. It's a good read but there was a high standard to live up to.
The setting beyond the library is harder to imagine, it seems Widdershins is now in it's own bubble outsiders talk about it and rarely stay. Life appears very progressive on all fronts. While that should be a good thing it confused the historical setting, for me making it harder to place. I don't know what the norms are to this society. But then when deciding to accept it on it's own terms there was sudden referances to real life people and that threw me off.
In the original Christine is a modern woman of fierce independance, in this spin-off her counterpart beyond some descriptions of fashion lacks fire, how/if people react to her isn't really shown.
The Library however is fantastic. It sounds incredible. I want to visit with a strong torch and trustworthy guide. I liked what we saw of librarians they make for a quirky bunch and would love to get to know the characters better.
Ves is an interesting character, Hawke does research and the excitement over book margins amused me. But Sebestain I never warmed to. It's a series and there's time for him to become better drawn but here he was weak. My first impression of his character was proved wrong and it made him harder to know, his attitudes at times somehow made things seem less.
The plot was predictable, no suprises, I guessed the villian very early on along with other mysteries. The first half of the book seemed a lot of talking in circles and nothing really happening then all the action hits in the second half. The tension was never what it could have been. Found certain things contradictory and was left with some niggles. Lovecraft's influence continues.
Hopefully with the players introduced the next book in the series will become stronger. It's a good read but there was a high standard to live up to.
September 13, 2020
Well, this is a proper rollicking good ride through early 1900s Widdershins!
We've got the magic, and the beasties, and the Ladysmith, and our Librarians, and they're all riled up thanks to the comet soon to be whizzing by the planet.
Most in this cast of characters are new, with a few connections to our beloved origin series that centers around Whyborne and Griffin. I found myself becoming invested, both in our main duo and the supporting players. My favorite is Bonnie, she had me chuckling.
I also found myself pulling for said main duo, wanting them to be OK, to succeed, to vanquish those nasty baddies and get some happiness along the way.
The world building detail is wonderfully creative. Pulling me in, it had me imagining myself dashing through the labyrinthine aisles and hallways of our favorite supernatural library with these people.
You do not need to have read Hawk's Widdershins series in order to enjoy this. However, if you don't, I will seriously question your level of love for adventure, magic, humor, drama, and, well, love. 😂
I enjoyed the heck outta this, and I'm looking forward to the next story. There's much potential to be tapped!
We've got the magic, and the beasties, and the Ladysmith, and our Librarians, and they're all riled up thanks to the comet soon to be whizzing by the planet.
Most in this cast of characters are new, with a few connections to our beloved origin series that centers around Whyborne and Griffin. I found myself becoming invested, both in our main duo and the supporting players. My favorite is Bonnie, she had me chuckling.
I also found myself pulling for said main duo, wanting them to be OK, to succeed, to vanquish those nasty baddies and get some happiness along the way.
The world building detail is wonderfully creative. Pulling me in, it had me imagining myself dashing through the labyrinthine aisles and hallways of our favorite supernatural library with these people.
You do not need to have read Hawk's Widdershins series in order to enjoy this. However, if you don't, I will seriously question your level of love for adventure, magic, humor, drama, and, well, love. 😂
I enjoyed the heck outta this, and I'm looking forward to the next story. There's much potential to be tapped!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 283 reviews