Oi ching bak min bau (2001) - Oi ching bak min bau (2001) - User Reviews - IMDb
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
A generic romantic comedy...
paul_haakonsen27 January 2016
For a romantic comedy then this 2001 Hong Kong movie wasn't particularly impressive. And how much those words weigh in the rom-com genre, well, that I will leave up to you to decide. However, I just felt that "Bakery Amour" (aka "Oi ching bak min bau") was as predictable and generic as they come.

It should be said that the storyline was essentially good enough and it did have some potential, but director Stephen Lo Kit Sing just didn't fully manage to utilize the potential and turn the script into a great movie.

The story is about Tang Dai Chi (played by Francis Ng) who moves into a new apartment with his friend Tang Chang (played by William Wing Hong So). Tang Dai Chi finds 99 unopened letters with the stamps taken off in a small box, all addressed to Lok To (played by Michelle Reis), another tenant in the building. Tang Dai Chi reads the letters and decides to help Lok To to get reunited with her long lost lover Jia Lam (played by Conroy Chi-Chung Chan) and opens up a bakery shop and employs Lok To.

Sure, the story was sweet enough in itself. However, it just wasn't outstanding compared to so many other romantic comedies. And the predictability of the movie just didn't help to promote the entertainment value one bit.

Francis Ng is usually quite a good actor, but I must say that his performance in "Bakery Amour" wasn't particularly outstanding. He seemed to be running on autopilot. I suppose it was the limitation of the script and the director. I think this is the only movie that I have seen Michelle Reis in, or at least remember seeing her in. But I will say that she did perform quite alright.

All in all, then "Bakery Amour" is a very generic and mediocre romantic comedy, one that didn't particularly leave a lasting impression and it sort of faded in comparison to many other Hong Kong movies.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
a really good romantic drama/comedy that is wonderfully unlike what we get from Hollywood
dbborroughs4 October 2008
Warning: Spoilers
(The names in the film are slightly different then in the subtitles and on the back of the VCD and the IMDb list- I'm fudging it for the purposes of illustration) Tai Chi moves in with his friend in an apartment building. The friend is friends with Lok To, a woman who is in love with Gala, who is away in Paris and who has been sending Lok To letters. Tai Chi finds 99 letters from Gala to Lok To chronicling their relationship in his friend apartment and reads them becoming well versed in the relation ship and determined to get the two lovers together. Toward that end Tai Chi helps Lok To open a bakery. However when Gala finally returns to Hong Kong he brings along another woman...also complicating matters is the fact that Tai Chi has fallen for Lok To.

Films like this are the reason I suffer the discount bins in Chinatown, they are small little surprises that I never would have stumbled upon had I not taken a chance for a buck.

This is a charming romance with real characters and nary a real villain in site. Normally in films like this you can't understand why the love interest likes the beau she will eventually leave, usually he's boorish and prigish from the start and you can't see why they ever were together in the first place, thats not the case here. You understand why Lok To loves Gala and why they still have feelings. You also understand how they drifted apart.

The characters are all real people with a genuine affection for each other. They all have their quirks (Tai Chi most of all but he is a man inside his head and his quirks are real) but nothing over powering, they are very much like the people you know. Its so nice that no one is shrill and screaming.

Its also great that the story unfolds in its own way in its own time. Nothing seemed to be to be fake or forced with nary a "cute" meet style scene anywhere to be found. (Okay the cellphone on the bridge bit kind of is but it works in context where its placed.) I like that it seems like we are watching clips from the lives of these people and not a made up romance tale.

Don't get me wrong this isn't a perfect film, it meanders a bit and some bits don't quite work as well as others, but its still a solid little film thats not your typical piece of romance (especuially if you watch Hollywood fodder). It gets points for just being itself and not a copy of a copy of a cliché.

Will I look to replace the VCD with a DVD? probably not(addendum-yes I have replaced the VCD with a DVD). To be honest I don't know if I'll watch it again. HOWEVER that doesn't mean its not going to be a movie I'll mention and recommend to anyone I think will listen or to anyone who I think will have a shot at running down a copy.

(The problem with searching out films that are off the beaten path is you very often find things that are next to impossible to share because no one can find copies for themselves)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent chick flick! William So is not only talented in singing but acting.
ktfleur13 April 2002
"Bakery Amour" is definitely up there with the list of good chick flicks to be seen when you are in the mood for some good acting from Francis Ng and William So. I must say that William So is not only a talented composer singer musician but now is showing some real skills in acting too. Yes, this is not the major lead for him. Yet his supporting role gives Francis Ng, the wit and reality checks he needs. All in all. This is a good love story with an ending that won't leave you depressed, but feeling good. Baking bread might just lead to love!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed