Historical Context
Before we discuss the NiceneRefers to the Trinitarian theology accepted by the Council of Nicaea in A.D. 325 that is the foundation of the “Nicene Creed” that was actually fo... more Creed we need to set the stage for the controversy leading up to the 1st Council of Nicaea that created the NiceneRefers to the Trinitarian theology accepted by the Council of Nicaea in A.D. 325 that is the foundation of the “Nicene Creed” that was actually fo... more Creed. Sadly, power-politics played a major role in the early Churcha term translated from the Greek word “Ecclesia” which means an assembly called together and is sometime translated as a congregation. A church is... more. The major metropolitan areas of Rome, ConstantinopleWas established in A.D. 324 by Emperor Constantine as the Eastern capital of the Roman Empire. The city was built over the much smaller ancient city o... more, Alexandria, and AntiochA large and important city in Syria and the meeting point of the East and West. more rivaled for supremacy. In particular, the two major schools located in Alexandria and AntiochA large and important city in Syria and the meeting point of the East and West. more engaged in sustained and intense rivalry for centuries.
The Christian school of Alexandria tapped into a long legacy of learning based in that city. During the 3rd Century B.C. its Greek Ptolemaic rulers constructed one of the largest and most important libraries in the ancient world. For centuries Alexandria functioned as a major center for philosophy and learning. The Platonist Jewish philosopher Philo(c. 20 B.C.–A.D. 50) Jewish philosopher and exegete who used an allegorical method to interpret the scriptures that was influential on ancient Chris... more of Alexandria, a contemporary of Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more, emphasized an allegoric approach to interpret scripture. This method was adopted by many early Christian fathers. Indeed, Augustine(A.D. 354-430) Bishop of Hippo in North Africa, the most influential theologian of the West, known especially for his doctrine of grace, including rel... more was converted to Christianity when AmbroseAurelius Ambrosius (c. A.D. 340–397) was Bishop of Milan, which had by then become the capital of the Western Roman Empire. He had government experi... more introduced him to this technique to help Augustine(A.D. 354-430) Bishop of Hippo in North Africa, the most influential theologian of the West, known especially for his doctrine of grace, including rel... more overcome his objections to many Old Testament stories and rituals. The Alexandrian school became the center for this Platonist perspective in Christianity, which emphasized the spiritual and downplayed the empirical. They liked to quote Paul: “the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.” (2 Cor 3:6). They accused their opponents in AntiochA large and important city in Syria and the meeting point of the East and West. more, who read the scriptures literally, of killing the true gospel message.
On the other hand, the proponents of the school in AntiochA large and important city in Syria and the meeting point of the East and West. more accused the Alexandrians of corrupting the clear literal meaning of scripture. So, the dispute carried on, each school writing polemic literature defending their approach to right-thinking and attacking the other. The Antiochians strove to separate the divine and human nature of Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more and emphasized the humanity of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more, while the Alexandrians emphasized the union of the divine and the human natures of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more with the dominance of the divine.
The dispute came to a head when the dynamic theologian Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more, who was trained in AntiochA large and important city in Syria and the meeting point of the East and West. more, moved to Alexandria and became a priest at one of the local churches. He taught that ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more was a creaturerefers to everything except God who is the Creator who created all things. more subordinate to God the Father, and that there was a time when he did not exist, because he was created by the Father. This upset a cross-town rival priest named Athanasius(c. A.D. 296–373) Athanasius was a Bishop of Alexandria and was a leading proponent of orthodox trinitarianism in opposition to Arianism. His positi... more who strongly claimed that God was one and that Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more was teaching heresyComes from a Greek term meaning “sect,” and was used by the early Church theologians to identify doctrines that they rejected as not orthodox. The... more. He complained to the local bishopA person holding the ecclesiastical office that exerciseds authority over the laity and priests in a geographical area called a “diocese” where th... more, Alexander, and the fight became very intense.
To help get a sense of what was happening, imagine a modern day setting where a charismatic fundamentalist BaptistThe first English Baptist congregation is created (A.D. 1609) out of a Puritan Separatist congregation that is meeting in exile in the Netherlands. Th... more preacher from Texas moves to Boston and becomes the priest at a local Catholic parishIs a local geographical and administrative unit in the Catholic Church overseen by a parish priest under the direction of the diocese’s bishop. Some... more. He becomes very popular teaching that infant baptismFrom a Greek word meaning “to immerse;” and is an initiatory ritual washing whereby one becomes a member of the Christian community. It involves v... more is not scriptural and it is just plain hooey. This upsets a hot-blooded Irish priest from a neighboring parishIs a local geographical and administrative unit in the Catholic Church overseen by a parish priest under the direction of the diocese’s bishop. Some... more, who cannot rest until this heresyComes from a Greek term meaning “sect,” and was used by the early Church theologians to identify doctrines that they rejected as not orthodox. The... more is stopped dead.
This dispute in Alexandria spread and involved the whole empire. Bishops as far away as Spain put in their two-cents regarding the issue. It became so hotly contested that Christians were ridiculed by their pagan neighbors. Here is how one ancient record describes the atmosphere at the time:
“Everywhere in the public squares, at the crossroads, on the streets and lanes, people would stop you and discourse at random about the trinity. If you asked something of the moneychanger, he would begin discussing the question of the Begotten and Unbegotten. If you questioned a baker about the price of bread, he would answer that the Father was greater and the Son is subordinate to him. If you went to take a bath, the Anomoean bath attendant would tell you that in his opinion the Son came from nothing.”1
Another ancient historian wrote:
“The workmen in the port, the sailor, the idle and the common people in the street knew these songs [written by Arius], and assailed the ears of the faithful of Alexandria with them. Whence endless fights… The public was interested in these questions, even the pagan public, who, be it well understood, made use of the occasion to amuse themselves at the expense of the Christians and of their beliefs. The quarrel of Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more and Alexander echoed even in the theatres.”2
The glue that ConstantineConstantine I (c. A.D. 272–337) was a Western Roman Emperor who, after a series of civil wars, became emperor of the entire Roman Empire. He strengt... more had recently chosen to hold his empire together was tearing it apart. Something had to be done, so he called a counsel of the bishops to be held in Nicaea in AD 325.
Typically, historians state that the orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more position prevailed at this council, but that is true simply because that is the position that ultimately prevailed and became the orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more position. The victors write the history. In reality, both Arius’ and Athanasius’ positions were extremes at the time. By far the dominate position was the Logos Theology (described below), which had been the orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more teaching of the Churcha term translated from the Greek word “Ecclesia” which means an assembly called together and is sometime translated as a congregation. A church is... more for two to three centuries. This teaching fell in the middle of these two extremes and was referred to as semi-Arianism. However, this position was too nebulous and subject to continued debate to satisfy the emperor’s need of a definitive conclusion in order to end the fighting. Ultimately, the Emperor chose Athanasius’ Trinitarian position at the Council of Nicaea, and most of the bishops in attendance fell in line under threat of banishment.
However, that did not end the controversy that raged on for centuries. It is much easier to tell people what to believe than to actually get people to change their opinions. Over the next 100 years the orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more of the Churcha term translated from the Greek word “Ecclesia” which means an assembly called together and is sometime translated as a congregation. A church is... more regarding the trinity swung back and forth between ArianismAn extension of Logos subordinational theology advocated by Arius, a 4th century priest in Alexandrian, which asserted that Christ was simply a creati... more and Trinitarianism depending on what the emperorRefers to the Emperor of the Roman Empire and its succeeding Byzantine Empire as well as the ruler of the Holy Roman Empire, beginning with Charlemagn... more believed at the time. Many of the same bishops would vote one way in one council and the opposite way in a later council. Most of the converts to Christianity outside of the Empire were converted to an Arian version of Christianity, complicating the matter. However, in A.D. 496, the Frankish King, ClovisClovis I (c. A.D. 466–511) was a Frankish chieftain who united the Frankish tribes under the rule of one king. He ensured his kingship descended to ... more I, under the influence of his Catholic wife, converted to Roman CatholicismThe Christian tradition that is synonymous with Western (Latin) Christianity and claims its authority back to Peter and the Apostles but was repudiate... more with its Trinitarian doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more of deity. Over the next three hundred years he and his heirs proceeded to conquer the Arian Christian kingdoms in Europe leading to the creation of the Catholic Holy Roman Empire(A.D. 962) The Holy Roman Empire emerges in the Germanic areas and Northern Italy with Otto I assuming the imperial crown descended from Charlemagne. more when the Pope crowned CharlemagneCharlemagne (c. A.D. 742–814) was the eldest son of Pepin, who became sole ruler of the Franks upon the death of his younger brother Carloman. Charl... more emperorRefers to the Emperor of the Roman Empire and its succeeding Byzantine Empire as well as the ruler of the Holy Roman Empire, beginning with Charlemagn... more on ChristmasA Christian holiday celebrating the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. The first recorded celebration of Easter occurred in Rome in A.D. 336. Why the date o... more Day, A.D. 800.
Platonic Influence
What was the big deal that they were fighting about? To us it may appear that they were quibbling over words, but such an assumption would be a mistake. To them, they were arguing over the very nature of God and their personal salvation. In order to understand why this was so important to them, we need to understand where they were coming from.
Christianity sprang from Jewish and Greco-Roman parents, and its religious and cultural DNA came from those roots. Christianity began as a Jewish sect in a Greco-Roman world, and both influences contributed to the debate regarding the nature of God leading up to the Council of Nicaea.
The Greco-Roman world held a schizophrenic view regarding divinity. On one hand, the ideas of various monotheistic philosophical schools prevailed in rational discussions, while the myths of the Pantheons of gods dominated social religious practice. Christians adopted, or at least adhered to, many of the philosophical concepts accepted by educated Romans, while they rejected wholesale the pagan gods as not only false myths but demons or stories created by the devil.
The philosophical ideas that influenced Christianity began with Heraclitus (550-480 B.C.) who introduced the idea of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more as the universal mind that permeated everything and was the source of the harmony and order of the universe. The word logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more literally means “word” but it developed a much broader meaning over the centuries leading up to the birth of Christianity. Socrates(470–399 B.C.). Socrates is credited with being the father of philosophy because he taught that the individual must begin by first examining himself... more (470-399 B.C.) believed in one god, but it was Plato(c. 427–348 B.C.) Greek philosopher, Socrates’s student, Aristotle’s teacher, and founder of the only rigorously non materialist philosophical t... more (427-347 B.C.) who later introduced the idea of eternity or a dimension beyond time to Greek philosophy. Plato(c. 427–348 B.C.) Greek philosopher, Socrates’s student, Aristotle’s teacher, and founder of the only rigorously non materialist philosophical t... more taught that this physical world was created by a transcendent eternal being, a master craftsman, who initiated time and fashioned this material universe in replica of a pre-existing eternal model. Therefore, that which is eternal–outside of time–is divine, while this material world is his creation and all humans and other living things are creatures. AristotleAristotle (384–322 B.C.) was a greek philosopher, founder of the sciences of logic, physics, and biology, whose writings were a major conceptual res... more (385-323 B.C.) believed in one god that was the “prime mover unmoved,” the first cause of all things. Plato(c. 427–348 B.C.) Greek philosopher, Socrates’s student, Aristotle’s teacher, and founder of the only rigorously non materialist philosophical t... more and AristotleAristotle (384–322 B.C.) was a greek philosopher, founder of the sciences of logic, physics, and biology, whose writings were a major conceptual res... more advocated differing versions of a similar idea that matter replicates eternal forms, which became accepted Greco-Roman doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more for millennia. In the 3rd Century B.C., Stoic philosophers adopted many of these earlier ideas and developed a more sophisticated doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more regarding the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more as a sort of divine spiritual principle. This became the basic element of most Greco-Roman philosophy at the time of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more. The logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more represented reason, intelligent discourse, eternal truth, and the universal lawIs a fundamental concept of Luthernism and is contrasted by Luther with the Gospel. For Luther, the law consists of God’s commands regarding how one... more that governs nature and human happiness, an intelligent principle that is part of the essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more of all things, the source of creation; in sum a pantheistic god.
Judaism was the first recorded monotheistic religion. Over millennia its leaders made a concerted effort to combat the polytheistic influences in the world around them. Yet, the concept of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more played a role in its theology. The Aramaic term memra, which interpreted means “the Word,” was found throughout the Targums (Rabbinical writings that interpreted the Hebrew Bible) leading up to the time of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more. This term is often used as a substitute for the name of God in scriptures dealing with the creation and the source of wisdom such as in the Book of Proverbs. The Platonist Jewish philosopher, Philo(c. 20 B.C.–A.D. 50) Jewish philosopher and exegete who used an allegorical method to interpret the scriptures that was influential on ancient Chris... more of Alexandria, used the concept of logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more extensively. He taught that the Word was a shadow of God that he used to create the world, the second most universal thing after God, and that the Word was not like the uncreatedThis is a technical theological term originating in Greek philosophy that is used to determine what is eternal and divine and what was created by the ... more God, but was also not like created humans; the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more existed in an state between both. He combined the Jewish ideas with Platonist concepts to claim that the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more was the sum total of all ideas in this intelligible world, was God’s creative word and his revelator. By the time Christianity was born, many Jews shared the Greco-Roman view that the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more, the Word of God, was a life force that enabled the creations of a monotheistic god or force to move, breathe and exist. This concept was generally accepted by the Christian community.
The Apostle John opened his gospel by drawing on this Jewish and Greco-Roman understanding of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more, the Word of God, when he wrote:
“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the beginning with God. All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made. In him was life; and the life was the light of men.”
These concepts were not new to his Jewish or Gentile audience. What was revolutionary was his assertion that: “The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us.” (John 1:14). The idea that Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more was the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more incarnate became a central Christian doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more.
Logos Theology
The earliest Christian apologist Justin Martyr(c.A.D 100–165) Born in Palestine early in the 2nd century, Justin was educated as a philosopher and converted to Christianity, retaining many of hi... more (approximately A.D. 100-165) used the familiar concept of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more to describe the divine nature of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more. According to JustinJustin Martyr (c. A.D. 100–165) Born in Palestine early in the 2nd century, Justin was educated as a philosopher and converted to Christianity, reta... more, Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more was the personification of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more and embodied a fullness of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more principles. The rest of humanity, however, had a seed of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more that ennobled their soul. This seed of truth sown in the hearts of men was the source of correct thinking and right living. It acted as the lawIs a fundamental concept of Luthernism and is contrasted by Luther with the Gospel. For Luther, the law consists of God’s commands regarding how one... more by which one will be judged. As a seed, it was capable of growing as humans embraced truth and righteousness. It functioned as a light of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more inside each personDerived from the Latin term persona and the Greek term prosopon. It is a technical term in Christian theology for the concept that the Trinity consist... more bringing life and understanding of the divine. Consequently, great moral teachers of the past, such as Heraclitus, Socrates(470–399 B.C.). Socrates is credited with being the father of philosophy because he taught that the individual must begin by first examining himself... more and Plato(c. 427–348 B.C.) Greek philosopher, Socrates’s student, Aristotle’s teacher, and founder of the only rigorously non materialist philosophical t... more, were Christian without actually realizing it.
JustinJustin Martyr (c. A.D. 100–165) Born in Palestine early in the 2nd century, Justin was educated as a philosopher and converted to Christianity, reta... more taught that God the Father was the source of the logosIs a Greek word meaning “word,” “reason.” and “logic.” It was an important concept in Greek philosophy. St. John opened his gospel identif... more and inseparable from it just as the sun is the source of its light. However, he argued that even more than the sun is distinct from the light that emanated from it ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more was a separate personDerived from the Latin term persona and the Greek term prosopon. It is a technical term in Christian theology for the concept that the Trinity consist... more from God the Father. He emphatically declared that the Son was distinct in number from the Father, and subordinate to the Father. To prove this point, he referred to passages of scripture such as where God the Father spoke with a distinct rational divine being prior to creation. (Genesis 1:26). Yet, JustinJustin Martyr (c. A.D. 100–165) Born in Palestine early in the 2nd century, Justin was educated as a philosopher and converted to Christianity, reta... more also emphasized the divinity of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more. Indeed, he asserted that ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more, not the Father, was the divine entity with whom the Old Testament prophets interacted. He taught that the Son was unified with the Father in that he was begotten from the Father just as one flame can kindle a separate fire, each in essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more being the same yet distinct.
One of the main doctrines taught by JustinJustin Martyr (c. A.D. 100–165) Born in Palestine early in the 2nd century, Justin was educated as a philosopher and converted to Christianity, reta... more that later became central to the debate leading up to the Council of Nicaea and a key component of the mystery of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more was the timing of the Son’s creation. According to JustinJustin Martyr (c. A.D. 100–165) Born in Palestine early in the 2nd century, Justin was educated as a philosopher and converted to Christianity, reta... more, God the Father, who existed outside of time, created the Son by his own will and power as the first step in the creative process. Even though the Father existed prior to the Son, the Logos (ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more) was created before the physical universe so he technically was not a creaturerefers to everything except God who is the Creator who created all things. more (as Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more later insisted). Yet ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more was subordinate to the Father in regard to the creation and as a revelatory intermediary between the Father and humans. He also taught that the Son was worshiped in second place after God the Father.
This concept of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more being subordinate to the Father, while remaining unified with Him, was a central doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more of the Christian community, and served as the framework for minor disputes that occasionally occurred leading up to the Arian controversy. Some theologians such as Origin and Tertullian(c. A.D. 160–225) North African priest and theologian, the first major Latin Christian author. Despite the large number of his writings that have su... more acknowledged the subordination of the Son while others such as Irenaeus(c. A.D. 120–200) Bishop of Lyon, the most important Christian theologian of the 2nd century; author of a large work, Against Heresies. more emphasized the unity of God. Even so, Irenaeus(c. A.D. 120–200) Bishop of Lyon, the most important Christian theologian of the 2nd century; author of a large work, Against Heresies. more recognized an intermediary role of the Word and taught, “the Word became a man, so that men may become gods.” Orthodox theology and most theologians prior to the Arian ControversyAn extension of Logos subordinational theology advocated by Arius, a 4th century priest in Alexandrian, which asserted that Christ was simply a creati... more acknowledged some level of subordination of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more in relation to the Father.3
Sabellian Heresy
A Trinitarian dispute occurred around A.D. 220 when a priest named Sabellius(c. A.D. 215) He was an early Christian theologian who taught that God is indivisible so the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are simply different manifest... more argued that the godhead did not consist of three separate persons but instead was one entity working through three different modes or aspects: creation through the Father, redemption through the Son, and sanctificationDerived from the Latin word sanctus for “holy” and literally means “becoming holy.” In most Protestant theology it refers to the process of be... more through the Holy Spirit. His teachings emphasized the unity and absolute divinity and greatness of God and held that dividing God into three separate persons diminished his greatness. His ideas at first gained favor with some theologians, including the Pope, but were soon rejected by the Pope and most Christians, who continued to hold to a belief in the distinct personhood of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. This heresyComes from a Greek term meaning “sect,” and was used by the early Church theologians to identify doctrines that they rejected as not orthodox. The... more in its general application is variously referred to as Sabellianism, Modalistic Monarchianism and Patripassianism. Asserting that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are simply different names of the same entity, or that God can appear in different forms, or even using a three leaf clover to explain the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more, in a broad sense are all examples of the Sabellian Heresy. Later, when the issue of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more came to a head in Alexandria, Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more and his followers were quick to falsely accuse his rival Athanasius(c. A.D. 296–373) Athanasius was a Bishop of Alexandria and was a leading proponent of orthodox trinitarianism in opposition to Arianism. His positi... more and those who adhered to his Trinitarian formulation, of Sabellianism.
The Arian Controversy
Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more simply took the doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more of subordination to its logical conclusion based on the accepted reasoning of his time. If the Son originated from the Father, then there was a time when the Son did not exist. Based on the accepted Platonist and Aristotelian assumption that everything divine is eternal and not created, then ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more is not wholly divine. Consequently, he is a created being, a creaturerefers to everything except God who is the Creator who created all things. more of God, who is independent from and subordinate to the Father. Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more quoted numerous scriptures to support his proposition, such as:
“for my Father is greater than I.” (John 14:28)
“The Son can do nothing of himself, but what he seeth the Father do.” (John 5:19)
“But of that day and that hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels which are in heaven, neither the Son, but the Father.” (Mark 13:32)
“Jesus increased in wisdom and stature, and in favour with God and man.” (Luke 2:52)
“this is life eternal, that they might know thee the only true God, and Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more, whom thou hast sent.”
“Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God.” (Mark 10:18)
“O my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me: nevertheless not as I will, but as thou wilt.” (Matthew 26:39)
“a bright cloud overshadowed them: and behold a voice out of the cloud, which said, This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased; hear ye him.” (Matthew 17:5)
“God also hath highly exalted him, and given him a name which is above every name.” (Philippians 2:9)
To combat their opponents claim that the Father and Son are one, they quoted John 17:21-22, “That they all may be one; as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they also may be one in us… And the glory which thou gavest me I have given them; that they may be one, even as we are one.” Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more prayed that his followers will become united with the Father in the same way that the Son and the Father are unified. So, the Son is a distinct being from the Father just like humans are, and their unity does not rise to the level of being the same personDerived from the Latin term persona and the Greek term prosopon. It is a technical term in Christian theology for the concept that the Trinity consist... more, essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more or substance.
Meanwhile, Athanasius(c. A.D. 296–373) Athanasius was a Bishop of Alexandria and was a leading proponent of orthodox trinitarianism in opposition to Arianism. His positi... more insisted on the oneness and immateriality of God as understood by the Platonist philosophy taught in the Alexandrian school of theology. He and his followers quoted scriptures to support their position, such as:
“I and my Father are one.” (John 10:30)
“the Father is in me, and I in him.” (John 10:38)
“he that hath seen me hath seen the Father.” (John 14:9)
“there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in him; and one Lord Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more, by whom are all things, and we by him.” (1 Corinthians 8:6)
First Council of Nicaea
As previously mentioned, when the controversy became so heated, public and widespread, the new Emperor ConstantineConstantine I (c. A.D. 272–337) was a Western Roman Emperor who, after a series of civil wars, became emperor of the entire Roman Empire. He strengt... more felt the need to call a council to settle the matter. ConstantineConstantine I (c. A.D. 272–337) was a Western Roman Emperor who, after a series of civil wars, became emperor of the entire Roman Empire. He strengt... more not only called the council, but also presided over its opening ceremony, participated in its discussions and ultimately had the final say over its outcome as its de facto supreme ruler. Even though ConstantineConstantine I (c. A.D. 272–337) was a Western Roman Emperor who, after a series of civil wars, became emperor of the entire Roman Empire. He strengt... more would not be baptized until on his death bed years later, which was not uncommon for believers in that day, ConstantineConstantine I (c. A.D. 272–337) was a Western Roman Emperor who, after a series of civil wars, became emperor of the entire Roman Empire. He strengt... more referred to himself as Bishop of External Affairs throughout his reign. He insisted on a solution regarding the nature of God that would be definitive enough to end the dispute so that tranquility could be restored to the Empire.
At the start of the Council of Nicaea there were basically three main divisions. The majority were moderates who represented the orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more position up to the time of the Arian controversy and were referred to as semi-Arian. They professed the divinity of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more but were hesitant to recognize his complete unity and equality with the Father. The larger of the minority views was Athanasius’ Trinitarian position of perfect equality between the Father and the Son from all eternity, followed by strict Arians who held that Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more was a creaturerefers to everything except God who is the Creator who created all things. more and not fully divine.
I will not bore you with all of the council’s internal political wrangling that took place. It ultimately culminated in the creation and adoption of a new term to describe the Christian Godhead, homoousiosThis is the Greek term invented during the first Nicene Council to describe the relation between the Father and the Son in the Trinity and is the foun... more, meaning one essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more or one substance. This new term, “the same substance,” was chosen over various rival suggestions in order to give no room for any leanings toward Arian ideas as the orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more had done prior to this controversy.
The Nicene Creed
The final formulation of the original NiceneRefers to the Trinitarian theology accepted by the Council of Nicaea in A.D. 325 that is the foundation of the “Nicene Creed” that was actually fo... more Creed created during the First Council of Nicaea(A.D. 325) The First Council of Nicaea (the first ecumenical council) condemns the teaching of Arius and approves a creed containing the homoousios cl... more that is now accepted by all traditional Christians reads as follows:
“We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and invisible.
And in one Lord Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more, the Son of God, begotten of the Father the only-begotten; that is, of the essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more of the Father, God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father;
By whom all things were made both in heaven and on earth; Who for us men, and for our salvation, came down and was incarnate and was made man; He suffered, and the third day he rose again, ascended into heaven; From thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead.
And in the Holy Ghost.”
The following addendum was attached to this creedis a Christian confession of faith that has obtained this title from the use of the Latin term credo, “I believe,” at the beginning of such f... more:
“But those who say: ‘There was a time when he was not;’ and ‘He was not before he was made;’ and ‘He was made out of nothing,’ or ‘He is of another substance’ or ‘essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more,’ or ‘The Son of God is create,’ or ‘changeable,’ or alterable’― they are condemned by the holy catholicderived from the Greek word meaning “universal,” and was originally used to identify orthodox beliefs and practices that were universally accepted... more and apostolic Churcha term translated from the Greek word “Ecclesia” which means an assembly called together and is sometime translated as a congregation. A church is... more.”
This creedis a Christian confession of faith that has obtained this title from the use of the Latin term credo, “I believe,” at the beginning of such f... more was later expanded in 381 A.D. at the First Council of Constantinople(A.D. 381) The First Council of Constantinople (the second ecumenical council) approves an expanded version of the creed of Nicaea, which is today cal... more to read as follows:
“We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven, earth, and of all things visible and invisible. and in one Lord Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more, the only-begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father before all worlds, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father; by whom all things were made; who for us men, and for our salvation, came down from heaven, and was incarnate by the Holy Ghost and of the Virgin MaryMary (born c. 18 B.C.) was a Galilean Jewish woman and mother of Jesus. Christians believe that Jesus was conceived miraculously through the Holy Spir... more, and was made man; he was crucified for us under Pontius PilatePontius Pilate (c. 20 B.C.–c. A.D. 38) was the Roman Prefect of Judea from about 26 A.D. to 36 A.D. Jesus Christ was tried by Pontius Pilate, who fo... more, and suffered, and was buried and the third day he rose again, according to the Scriptures, and ascended into heaven and sitteth on the right hand of the Father; from thence he shall come again, with glory, to judge the quick and the dead; whose kingdom shall have no end. And in the Holy Ghost, the Lord and Giver of life, who proceedeth from the Father, who with the Father and the Son together is worshiped and glorified, who spake by the prophets. In one holy catholicderived from the Greek word meaning “universal,” and was originally used to identify orthodox beliefs and practices that were universally accepted... more and apostolic Churcha term translated from the Greek word “Ecclesia” which means an assembly called together and is sometime translated as a congregation. A church is... more; we acknowledge our baptismFrom a Greek word meaning “to immerse;” and is an initiatory ritual washing whereby one becomes a member of the Christian community. It involves v... more for the remission of sins; we look for the resurrectionThe doctrine that Jesus’ spiritual essence was reunited with his physical body and that other humans will likewise live again with their spirit or s... more of the dead, and the life of the world to come. Amen.”
The Mystery of the Trinity
This formulation of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more created at the 1st Council of Nicaea resulted in the mystery of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more: that God is one indivisible substance yet three distinct persons, and that the Son was begotten by the Father yet there was never a time when the Son did not exist as a separate personDerived from the Latin term persona and the Greek term prosopon. It is a technical term in Christian theology for the concept that the Trinity consist... more from the Father. These contradictions were tolerated by the council due to its acceptance of the belief that God was incomprehensible.
As previously mentioned, this creedis a Christian confession of faith that has obtained this title from the use of the Latin term credo, “I believe,” at the beginning of such f... more and anathema did not immediately end the controversy as ConstantineConstantine I (c. A.D. 272–337) was a Western Roman Emperor who, after a series of civil wars, became emperor of the entire Roman Empire. He strengt... more had hoped, but over time it eventually became settled Christian doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more. Augustine(A.D. 354-430) Bishop of Hippo in North Africa, the most influential theologian of the West, known especially for his doctrine of grace, including rel... more tried to explain this concept of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more as follows:
“The Father is God; the Son is God, the Holy Spirit is God.
The Father is not the Son; the Son is not the Holy Spirit; the Holy Spirit is not the Father.
There is one God, and only one God.”
(Augustine(A.D. 354-430) Bishop of Hippo in North Africa, the most influential theologian of the West, known especially for his doctrine of grace, including rel... more of Hippo: On the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more)
In order to try to understand the reasoning behind this orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more concept of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more, one needs to forget to count. Instead, one needs to focus on relationships. The three separate entities are one because they are the same substance or essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more and all have the same will and the same actions. What distinguishes them is their relationship with each other. The Son originates from the Father, but the Father does not originate from the Son. Likewise, the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father, while the Father does not proceed from the Holy Spirit. Even though the Son and Holy Spirit originate and proceed from the Father there never was a time when they did not exist as separate persons from the Father.
The concept that the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more consists of three separate persons is somewhat clarified by the Latin word, hypostasisIs a Greek word for “complete individual being” as opposed to something that is a part of something else, hence a person, a plant, and a dog are e... more, translated as personDerived from the Latin term persona and the Greek term prosopon. It is a technical term in Christian theology for the concept that the Trinity consist... more, that was used in these discussions. It does not mean a separate consciousness, personality or will that we associate with the word “personDerived from the Latin term persona and the Greek term prosopon. It is a technical term in Christian theology for the concept that the Trinity consist... more.” This term actually means “mask,” referring to the dramatic charactercomes from a Latin word that basically means an “indelible mark” like a tattoo. Under Roman Catholic theology, this word is a term of art that ref... more that an actor played in the theater. So, each member of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more plays three separate roles more than they are three separate persons, as we understand the term. This sounds a lot like the Sabellian Heresy that Arius(c. 256-336) Alexandrian presbyter whose teaching on the Trinity was condemned at the Council of Nicaea A.D. 325. (See Arianism and Arian Controversy.... more accused his rivals of adopting. Regardless, to counter that allegation, orthodoxDerived from a Greek term meaning “right belief” and also “right worship.” When the term is not capitalized it typically refers to teachings i... more doctrineis derived from the Latin word for teaching, doctrina, and is an important aspect of Christianity more so than other world religions because Christian... more maintains that each member of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more is still distinct in number due to their relationships and roles even though they remain one substance. The concept of the TrinityThe Traditional Christian doctrine that God is simultaneously the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, three persons in one, and addresses the relation betwe... more as adopted by the Great Churchis the term mainstream Christianity used to describe itself in the early church as opposed to heresies. more at the First Council of Nicaea(A.D. 325) The First Council of Nicaea (the first ecumenical council) condemns the teaching of Arius and approves a creed containing the homoousios cl... more is a human attempt to explain the incomprehensible God of the creeds.
The legacy of the NiceneRefers to the Trinitarian theology accepted by the Council of Nicaea in A.D. 325 that is the foundation of the “Nicene Creed” that was actually fo... more Creed was a shift of Christianity’s focus from what Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more did to who he was. This fundamental shift is symbolized by ChristmasA Christian holiday celebrating the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. The first recorded celebration of Easter occurred in Rome in A.D. 336. Why the date o... more (celebrating the incarnation of God) supplanting Easteris the most sacred holiday of the Christian calendar and celebrates the resurrection of Jesus. There was a serious dispute between the western and eas... more (celebrating the resurrectionThe doctrine that Jesus’ spiritual essence was reunited with his physical body and that other humans will likewise live again with their spirit or s... more of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more) as the major Christian holiday or “holy day.” We will see how this shift in emphasis led to the next major controversy in the Churcha term translated from the Greek word “Ecclesia” which means an assembly called together and is sometime translated as a congregation. A church is... more: If the Father and the Son are the same essencethe English word generally used for the Greek term ousia, that is also translated as “being” or “substance” and refers to that which makes som... more, then who or what was Jesus(c. 4 B.C.–A.D. 30-33) Also known as Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ, the Messiah, and Savior of the World. He is the founding figure of Christianit... more? The Christological Controversy(c. A.D. 150–681) During the 2nd Century disputes began in the Christian Church regarding the nature of Christ and his relation to the Father and Ho... more regarding the incarnation of ChristDerived from a Greek term meaning anointed and is equivalent to the word “messiah” from Hebrew roots. The anointing references the act of installi... more soon emerged and would not be resolved until the Third Council of ConstantinopleThe First Council of Constantinople convened in AD 381 is one of the most important ecumenical councils of Christianity. It dealt with issues of the T... more in A.D. 680.
1 Gregory of Nyssa, Oration on the Divinity of the Son and the Holy Spirit, Page 46:557.
2 Histoire Ancienne de I’Eglise, Vol. II, p.137-138.
3 Irenaeus, Against Heresies, bk. 5, preface.
IMAGES:
Athena Pronaia Sanctuary at Delphi, Greece. Constructed between 380–360 B.C., De architectura Book VII.
Statue of Constantine the Great commemorating his accession as Roman Emperor in A.D. 306. Outside York Minster, York, UK.
Plato and His Disciples in the Garden of the Academy, from La Vie Des Savants Illustres.
Ancient Cryllic Bible
Fresco of Emperor Constantine at Council in Nicaea church Hospital de los Venerables Sacerdotes by Juan de Valdes Leal, Seville, Spain.
Painting of resurrected Jesus Christ with Thomas the apostle. Christ Between the Apostles by Sebastiano Santi in Chiesa dei Santi Apostoli church, Venice, Italy.
go to previous:
The Donatist Controversy (pending)
go to next:
The Incarnation Controversy