�ɨ�ĳ�D�G�O�٪��v VS. �Ч@�ۥ�

[2016.01.21] �o��

�i��M�T�jCap�ϡB��q��B½�ۨé�WYouTube�A��u�G��Ч@�v�O��֤H�ͬ��@��C�F��N�m2014�~��v(�׭q)��ү�סn��ߪk�|�GŪ�A��ܭn��n�a�O�٪��v�H�Q�q�A��ֺ��{��o�O�u�c�k�v�A�٤��u��23��v�A��ñ��ҹ�G��Ч@��ŧK�d��ӯ��B�Ǧ�a�a�Ӧh�A��߰ʻ��o�S�A�{��Ҧ��зN�B��שM��F�ۥѤ��A�n�D�F��M�^��סC

��ת��v�H�O�@��v��󭫭n�H

��v(copyright)�O��Ѳ��v(intellectual property rights)��@�ءA�ΥH�O�٧@�̪��F�ۤv��覡�C�ھڪ��Ѳ��v�p�A��v�O�۰ʽᤩ��Ч@�~�֦��H��M��v�Q�A�i�s�b��ǡB��֡B��@�B��N��@�~�A�n��B�v��B�s��B��u�Ǽ��`�ةM��ǡB��@�έ��֧@�~�w�o��ƦL�s�ơA�H�Ϊ��t�̪��t�X��C��p��ǰe��v�@�~�]��O�@�A²��p�@�V��q��ͬ��Ӥ]�i�֦��v�C

�Ч@��Y�֦��v�A�𶷵��U�]��k�߫O�@�C�@�~��@�̬O��v��Ĥ@�֦��H�F��@�~�A��D�Ҹ��t��ĳ�A�_�h��D�O��v��Ĥ@�֦��H�C��H�b��g��v��H�P�N�U��ŧ�B�ƻs�ΧQ�Ψ�@�~�A�Y�ݫI�Ǫ��v�A�η|�t�W�k�߳d��C�I�v�欰�i�ର��v��H�a�Ӹg�ٷl��A�O�@��v�O�L��к믫�A��Ч@�H��ߦ�o��^��A�๪�y��h��Ч@�~�A�P�ɥ�T�O��̦b�ۥѤ��ҤU��ӡC

��סu�G��Ч@�v�H

��צۥѡB��F�ۥѩM�Ч@�ۥѬO��䪺�֤߻��ȡA��ڭ̯�H��P�覡��F�ҫ�ҷQ�A�]�A��ɬF��N��B��F��A�_�ʹ�@�ưȤ��ġC

�G��Ч@(secondary creation��re-create)�O�Ч@�M��F�覡�@�ءA��ϥΤw�s�奻(�]�A��r�B�Ϲ��B�v��B��֩Ψ�L��N�@�~��)�A�[�J�зs��ξ�X�A�@��Ч@�A�útö�X�s��N�q�C�G��Ч@�]�A½Ķ�B��s�B��B�P�q�B�c�d�B��K�B��s�զX�B��H�ơB�ޥΨå[�H�o��Ч@�Ҧ��M��k�A�ä��O��O�H��@�~��ѷ��ۤv��F��C

��~�y��G��Ч@�A�]�A�Ψӿب�ɨơA�Q�{��O��j��o�n��~�|��@�C�G��Ч@�@��O�ɧU�j��@�諸�ƪ��A�ᤩ�s�N��A�@�w��a�X��D�A�H�F�ب�B��Ʊ��Ϫ��ĪG�C��禳�N��æ��欰�A�ΫI�`��Ъ̪��v�Q�q�A��t�k�߳d��C�o�O��v��ҭ׭q�ް_��Ϲ諸�@�j��]�A�L�̼~�{�|��͡u�H�ͮ��v�A��зN�C

��v��ҭ׭q

��䪺�m��v��ҡn��1997�~6��27��ͮīᴿ�h��׭q�A�H��p��t�o�i�A��ҥ��W�ɥN�ݭn�C�F��2011�~��X�׭q�m��v��ҡn�A�ھڰ�ڰ��k�[�j�睊�v��H��O�١A�N�W�޽d��X�j�ܩҦ��q�l�ǰe�Ҧ��A�[��W�I�v�欰�C2012�~5��p��m2011�~��v(�׭q)��ү�סn��ߪk�|�GŪ�A��ŧK��B�c�d�B��ϵ��u�G��Ч@�v�A���צۥѤΧ��зN�A�j�P�Ϲ�C�F��]��ɾ��ԥ��m�ߪk�A��s�ԸߡC

2014�~6��A�g�Ը᪺߫�m2014�~��v(�׭q)��ү�סn�Z�ˡA2015�~12�봣��ߪk�|�GŪ�A�׭q��I�O�ŧK�P�G��Ч@��j�欰�X�X��B�ب�B��y�ƽ]�B�ҥ�B��׮ɨơB�ޥΡC

�ھڪ��Ѳ��v�p�A��ׯ�O�٤T��Q�q�G

��v��H�J�s�׭q�ޤJ�u�Ǽ��v�v�A�w��j�W�Ҫ��I�v�欰�A�Ҧp�N�@��q�v��y(streaming)��[�ݡC(��J�{��Ұw��I�v�~�A��ʺަ�y�I�v�A�]�Τ�𶷤U��ɮ�)

��W�A�ȥ��x�J�N�o��k�w�u�w��v��O�١C�ҿסu�w��v�A�Y�O��p��A�Ȩ��Ӧp�ŦX�Y�z��A�]�A�o�x��A�ȥ��x�W�X�{�I�v��ʫ�Ĩ��X�z��I�A�K��ΰ����(�p�N�@�~�U�[)�A��ӥu�ݹ��I�v�欰�Ӿᦳ��k�߳d��C

��ϥΪ̡J�׭q��ү�׫�ĳ�N�u��B�ب�B��y�ƽ]�B�ҥ�B��׮ɨơB�ޥΡv�o��j�欰��ǤJ�ŧK�d��A�Y�G��Ч@�Y��W�z6�ӥت��A�p�ݡu��B�z�v�A��ȧQ�B��j�q�B��N��@�A��ƻs�B�I�ϡB��ɡB��g��W�Ϥ��Χ�ϧ�q��欰�A��o�M�Ǽ��Ҥ��|�ۭP��ƩΦD�ƪk�߳d��C��Y�u�O��o�ӤH�P��ήi�ܤ~��A�P��Q�q�L��p�A��i��ŧK�C

��B�zvs.��ϥ�

�m2014�~��v(�׭q)��ү�סn�u�έ^��u��B�z(fair dealing)�v��k�A�Y�O�M��C�X�i�ŧK�d��A�]�A��B�ب�B��y�ƽ]�B�ҥ�B��׮ɨƤΤޥε��A�ݫʳ��ŧK�A�n�B�O��޲M��C��{��ŧK�d��U��A��Ч@�A�n�D��Ĭ��[�J�}��ŧK�u��ϥ�(fair use)�v��h�A�Y�O��|�կȶ¦r�g�U�ŧK�d��A�u�C�X�@�t�C��h�A�̲ץѪk�|��h�v�@�P�_��ĳ��Ч@�O�_�I�v�C

��v��Ҫ�ĳ

��|��M�{�P�ݭn�O�@��v�A��s��欰�C��b�ϥΪ̪��׬ݡA�W�[��j�ŧK��ءA�s��׵L�ø�2011�~��׶i�B�A��u��f�v�A�n�D�F��M�^��סC��צ��áH�F��B�~�ɩM�Ǫ̵��p��^��H

1. �ŧK�d�� l�Ч@�ۥѡH

�׭q��ү��ŧK6�ئ欰�A��S�C��ŧK��W�`��I�ϡB½�ۡB�¦��s��B�ʺ��P�H�x�M��A�Y�{�u½�۩M�籡��P��P�ɬF�L��G��Ч@�A��i��Ĳ�Ǫk�ҡC��F��׭q��[�\�Ҧ��u�G��Ч@�v�欰�A�{��ثe��ŧK�d��ӯ��A�|��Ч@�C

��䪩�v�j�p��G6��ŧK�Ӽe�P

�v��B�ۤ��κ��e�ɵ�16�ӷ~�ɹ��զ��䪩�v�j�p��A��q�L��סC�j�p��B��ڼv��|�`�ȸ��Ʀ󰶶��j�աA�רҨëD�w��A�~�ɪ��u�Գ��v�O��I��´�Ǹo��ΡB��M�q�v�W��p��o�ȧQ��I�v�H�C�󰶶��{��6��ŧK�Ӽe�P�A��~�ɩ��խY��q�L��ҡA��зN��~�N��Ʀ~��Y�A�G�u�t�\��v�C

��´�G�ŧK�w�q��T

��´�u��L�Խu�v�o��H�K�|��{��A��6��ŧK�A��½�۩M��y��ŧK�A�B�ب�B�ҥ鵥�ŧK�d�򪺩w�q��T�A�̲פ@��n�b�k�x�B�z��G��Ч@��A�|��y��e�j��O�C�u��v�ΤG��Ч@��`�p��v�o��H��F�{�P�n�O�@��v�A��º��ŧ��欰�A��{��v�D�u�O�ӤH�ȿ��u��A��y�Ч@�]�O�O�@��v��䤤�@�ӥت��C

�h�Ӻ��o�_�u�Ϲ��23��p�p�v�A��X�T�j�n�D�A�䤤�@�ӬO�ޤJ�u�}��ŧK�v�A�Y�u�n�O�D�ȧQ�ΫD�ӷ~�Ч@�A�H�εL�ˮ`��@��v�Q�q�A�N��t�D�d�C�p�p�@��20�h�U�H��C

��D��G��O�@

�ߪk�|��T��ެ�ĳ��D��{��ޤJ�u��B�z�v��ŧK�d��A�O��u��O�@��a��h�F�v�A�]�˱��״��A�uĵ���F�i�d�A��d��v�C��{��ثe�̤j�¯٨ëD��H�i�A�ӬO�G��Ч@�@�~��ɳQ�n�D�U�[�A�s�ҤU�A�p�G�@�~�b�ŧK�d��A��Q�U�[�ɤϦӦh�F�ӶD��D�C

��F��G��רҤϷl�Ч@�ۥ�

�ӰȤθg�ٵo�i��Ĭ�A�ٱj�աA��Ҥ��|��צۥѩM��G��Ч@�ۥѡA�ӬO��H��ڼзǡA�O�٪��v��H�C�L��ܡA��䪺��v��Ҥw��F10�h�~�A�s��ײŦX��ڼзǡA�s�׭q��ү�׷s�W6��ŧK�A��U��̬O�̦n��šC

2. �F��|�Q�Ϊk�ҧ@�F�v��H

��߷s��v��ҷ|�ܦ��F�v��u��A�Ҧp�N�⪩�v�֦��H��Ϲ�Τ��l�s�A�F��]�|¶�L��v��H�έ�Ъ̡A��G��Ч@�H�ΫI�v�̪��X�D�ư_�D�C

��Ѳ��v�p�G��v�֦��H�l�s�~�˱�

�L�ױ��ү�׬O�_�q�L�A�F��|¶�L��v�֦��H�Ӵ��X�˱��C��ާ@�W�A�Y��k��{��@��欰��D�ƫI�v��ΦX�z�h�áA�|�ɧ��p��v��X�k�֦��H�A�F�Ѩ�O�_�Ϲ�ΰl�s�F�u��b��v�֦��H�l�s��G�U�A�~�|�Ҽ{�i�@�B��u�@�C

��j�߮v�G�F��¶�L��v�H

�k�F�׫䦨��B�j�߮v�d�v�q��X�A�D��˱��v�ѫ߬F�q�M�w�A�@��Ө��A�S��v�H��U��H��ߪ��ҨѡA�G�F��u��L��v�H�v��X�D�ư_�D�C

��v�Ǫ̡G��_�D�稬�H��~

��ꪩ�v�Ǫ̧E�a��{��A�F��M��v�֦��H�`��u�ڤ��|�i�A�v�A��{�ɤ��i�A��N��N�Ӥ��i�C��̩Ȫ��O��߮v�H�A��Υh�쥿��_�D��q�A�w��_�u��~�v�@�ΡC

�m��q�q�� 370��n