What do you think?
Rate this book
Instant Replay: The Green Bay Diary of Jerry Kramer
In 1967, when Jerry Kramer was a thirty-one-year-old Green Bay Packers offensive lineman, in his tenth year with the team, he decided to keep a diary of the season. “Perhaps, by setting down my daily thoughts and observations,” he wrote, “I’ll be able to understand precisely what it is that draws me back to professional football.” Working with the renowned journalist Dick Schaap, Kramer recorded his day-to-day experiences as a player with perception, honesty, humor, and startling sensitivity. Little did Kramer know that the 1967 season would be one of the most remarkable in the history of pro football, culminating with the legendary championship game against Dallas now known as the “Ice Bowl,” in which Kramer would play a central role. Nor could he have anticipated that his diary would evolve into a book titled Instant Replay , first published in 1968, that would become a multimillion-copy bestseller and be celebrated by reviewers everywhere, including the Washington Post ’s Jonathan Yardley, who calls it “to this day, the best inside account of pro football, indeed the best book ever written about that sport and that league.”
This groundbreaking look inside the world of professional football is one of the first books ever to take readers into the locker room and reveal the inner workings of a professional sports franchise. From training camp, through the historic Ice Bowl, then into the locker room of Super Bowl II, Kramer provides a captivating player’s perspective on pro football when the game was all blood, grit, and tears. He also offers a rare and insightful view of the team’s storied leader, Coach Vince Lombardi.
Bringing the book back into print for the first time in more than a decade, this new edition of Instant Replay retains the classic look of the original and includes a foreword by Jonathan Yardley and additional rarely seen photos from the celebrated “Lombardi era.” As vivid and engaging as it was when it was first published, Instant Replay is an irreplaceable reminder of the glory days of pro football.
This groundbreaking look inside the world of professional football is one of the first books ever to take readers into the locker room and reveal the inner workings of a professional sports franchise. From training camp, through the historic Ice Bowl, then into the locker room of Super Bowl II, Kramer provides a captivating player’s perspective on pro football when the game was all blood, grit, and tears. He also offers a rare and insightful view of the team’s storied leader, Coach Vince Lombardi.
Bringing the book back into print for the first time in more than a decade, this new edition of Instant Replay retains the classic look of the original and includes a foreword by Jonathan Yardley and additional rarely seen photos from the celebrated “Lombardi era.” As vivid and engaging as it was when it was first published, Instant Replay is an irreplaceable reminder of the glory days of pro football.
320 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 1968
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews
August 31, 2007
In its day, this was a very popular book. This was due in large part to a masterstroke in marketing -- it was packaged with a razor and sold in every drugstore in America. And of course as a sports-crazed kid, I had to see what it was all about.
It was an interesting inside account. (In fact, when you're going for kind of thing, it doesn't get much more inside than an interior lineman's perspective.) Anyway, there were some great stories about Vince Lombardi and some of the Packers' star players. It all led well to the denouement: Kramer's key block that allowed Bart Starr to fall forward through the hole in the vaunted Cowboy defense in the last seconds of the championship game for the winning score.
It was an interesting inside account. (In fact, when you're going for kind of thing, it doesn't get much more inside than an interior lineman's perspective.) Anyway, there were some great stories about Vince Lombardi and some of the Packers' star players. It all led well to the denouement: Kramer's key block that allowed Bart Starr to fall forward through the hole in the vaunted Cowboy defense in the last seconds of the championship game for the winning score.
June 29, 2021
Instant Replay appears on nearly every list of must-read books on the NFL. Written right before Jim Bouton’s classic Ball Four, Kramer doesn’t dish on teammates or tell you much about the underbelly of the NFL. What he does tell you is how physically hard the game is and why his Green Bay coach, Vince Lombardi, gives players the inspiration and fire to go out and ruin their bodies every Sunday.
Kramer has been a Packer since 1958, the year before Lombardi became coach at Green Bay. He is 31 years-old at the start of the season and he questions why he’s still playing the game. The twice-a-day workouts are horrendous. The coach treats the veterans and rookies the same shabby way. Nothing is ever good enough for Lombardi. They are all bums in Lombardi’s eyes. Kramer is getting $28,000 for the season and he makes more money from his outside business interests. He doesn’t need football to make a living anymore. He doesn’t need the physical or verbal abuse. Probably because he knows he can quit anytime, he doesn’t fret. He just keeps pushing himself to get through one more season.
Kramer plays right guard, a physically demanding position in which you are only noticed when you fail. The left guard is Forrest Gregg who would become an NFL head coach. Paul Zimmerman taught me that Offensive Lineman are smartest players on the field. It makes sense that the articulate Kramer and future coach Gregg would be teammates on the great Lombardi teams.
It was fortuitous that Kramer’s Packers would make it to the Super Bowl, but then again Lombardi had his teams in contention for the championship every year. The thing that surprised is that Kramer and the players treat the super bowl against the Raiders as a secondary game to the NFL championship they won against the Dallas Cowboys. They just considered the AFL an inferior league. Tom Landry’s Cowboys were a real challenge.
Kramer does some reminiscing about other seasons with the Packers and goes into some details about injuries that cost him playing time through the years, but the book is really about this season and how he sees Lombardi as a guy he hates in the moment and then loves in reflection. Lombardi made them winners, but he didn’t make it easy.
Oh and Lombardi retires after this season and the Packers wait nearly 30 years before they play in another championship game.
Kramer has been a Packer since 1958, the year before Lombardi became coach at Green Bay. He is 31 years-old at the start of the season and he questions why he’s still playing the game. The twice-a-day workouts are horrendous. The coach treats the veterans and rookies the same shabby way. Nothing is ever good enough for Lombardi. They are all bums in Lombardi’s eyes. Kramer is getting $28,000 for the season and he makes more money from his outside business interests. He doesn’t need football to make a living anymore. He doesn’t need the physical or verbal abuse. Probably because he knows he can quit anytime, he doesn’t fret. He just keeps pushing himself to get through one more season.
Kramer plays right guard, a physically demanding position in which you are only noticed when you fail. The left guard is Forrest Gregg who would become an NFL head coach. Paul Zimmerman taught me that Offensive Lineman are smartest players on the field. It makes sense that the articulate Kramer and future coach Gregg would be teammates on the great Lombardi teams.
It was fortuitous that Kramer’s Packers would make it to the Super Bowl, but then again Lombardi had his teams in contention for the championship every year. The thing that surprised is that Kramer and the players treat the super bowl against the Raiders as a secondary game to the NFL championship they won against the Dallas Cowboys. They just considered the AFL an inferior league. Tom Landry’s Cowboys were a real challenge.
Kramer does some reminiscing about other seasons with the Packers and goes into some details about injuries that cost him playing time through the years, but the book is really about this season and how he sees Lombardi as a guy he hates in the moment and then loves in reflection. Lombardi made them winners, but he didn’t make it easy.
Oh and Lombardi retires after this season and the Packers wait nearly 30 years before they play in another championship game.
October 25, 2021
“When the game is over, it is really just beginning”, this quote really stuck out to me because it’s true, once the game is over we begin the next one, that’s how football is. I really liked this book because it’s very inspiring to me, there truly are difficulties in being a football player, but this book shows me to never give up on my dream and to keep pushing myself to do better. Also, this book really inspired me to keep working hard because one day i will make it and i will live my dream. Although I really loved this book but one dumb reason I didn’t like this book was because I never liked the green bay packers.
November 13, 2008
This was an amazing book. I remembered it inadvertently while walking into an elevator the other day and just had to add it. I really loved this book when I read it as a football-obsessed kid (maybe 12 or so) and I was startled by remembering how much I remembered of it and how articulate and thoughtful he really was.
I remember how he describes training camp and how Lombardi made all the tryouts get up and sing in front of everybody- to test their meddle or something, I'm not sure. But it's a brilliant move from a legendary coach, who gets his due from the inside here.
How he worked out all day running sprints in Florida for training camp and when they went to a bowling alley to unwind afterwards they drank pepsi and it was so cold and so delicious after a day spent draining themselves it was the most delicious thing in the world. I know what he means!
and how he didn't want to take his helmet off, even though he's probably always hated it, after winning the Super Bowl (I think) and how it was like a badge of honor after so much time....
Seriously great book!!!
March 19, 2017
I'm a Packer fan (shh, don't tell my dad) and I had to read this for school. My English teacher had fangirled over Jerry Kramer, sent him letters, and even got to speak with him on the phone, and she was all too proud to tell us about it. This book was an interesting recollection into the Lambeau locker room, into the Ice Bowl, and offered a very good snapshot of Lombardi himself. I really enjoyed it and I think I got rebuked for reading it too quickly because unlike the other students who read to the prescribed point, I read the whole thing in a weekend and then had to censor myself for a month to resist giving spoilers.
September 17, 2009
For as much as I love the Packers, I've avoided this book for whatever reason -- probably because books written by athletes invariably suck. I'm not sure how much of this was actually Kramer and how much was ghostwritten by Dick Schaap, but this is as good of Packers/Lombardi book as I've read. Particularly fascinating was the amount of racism present -- both implied and overt. Makes sense considering this was the late '60s, but it's something that rarely comes up when you hear about the gilded dynasty years.
July 18, 2007
This has always been one of my favorite books. It's the diary written by Jerry Kramer, an offensive lineman during the Lombardi years in Green Bay, during Lombardi's final season as coach. I still have the promotional paperback copy that was distributed with Personna razor blades and that I read as an 8-year-old in third grade. You may have to look around in a second-hand bookshop to find a copy these days but if you do find one, snap it up! It's one of the best sports books you'll ever read.
January 23, 2009
"When I look back upon the 1967 season,...
...I remember a very special spirit, a rare camaraderie, something I can't quite define, but something I've tried to capture in this diary." Jerry Kramer
Spirit - camaraderie - achievement - teamwork, this book has it all with nothing held back - a great book about the NFL for any sports fan!
p.s., will someone please look at the accomplishments of Jerry Kramer and get this guy into the NFL Hall of Fame.
...I remember a very special spirit, a rare camaraderie, something I can't quite define, but something I've tried to capture in this diary." Jerry Kramer
Spirit - camaraderie - achievement - teamwork, this book has it all with nothing held back - a great book about the NFL for any sports fan!
p.s., will someone please look at the accomplishments of Jerry Kramer and get this guy into the NFL Hall of Fame.
February 21, 2019
Even though I am a Vikings fan and only root for the Packers if they play Dallas, I enjoyed reading this timeless classic by Kramer. He chronicles the 1967 season which, to the book's benefit, includes the Ice Bowl game vs. Dallas and Kramer's block of Jethro Pugh that allowed Bart Starr to plunge into the end zone and win, sending the Pack to their second Super Bowl.
Kramer, who was inducted into the NFL Hall of Fame in 2018, showed his nervousness, dreaming and prepping for defensive stars such as Alex Karras and Alan Page. It was interesting to look back on his story of more than 50 years ago; he mentions the "new" college defensive end Bubba Smith, who went on to star for Baltimore, Oakland and Houston. He offers insights into players such as Bart Starr, Elijah Pitts, Ray Nitschke and Forrest Gregg.
And of course, Vince Lombardi and his varying demeanor during the "movies" of the previous weeks' games are featured in the book.
It is a good sports diary for its time. Two years later, though, the greatest sports diary and book of all time came out. "Ball Four," by Jim Bouton was published and set the standard for any season chronicle.
Kramer, who was inducted into the NFL Hall of Fame in 2018, showed his nervousness, dreaming and prepping for defensive stars such as Alex Karras and Alan Page. It was interesting to look back on his story of more than 50 years ago; he mentions the "new" college defensive end Bubba Smith, who went on to star for Baltimore, Oakland and Houston. He offers insights into players such as Bart Starr, Elijah Pitts, Ray Nitschke and Forrest Gregg.
And of course, Vince Lombardi and his varying demeanor during the "movies" of the previous weeks' games are featured in the book.
It is a good sports diary for its time. Two years later, though, the greatest sports diary and book of all time came out. "Ball Four," by Jim Bouton was published and set the standard for any season chronicle.
June 9, 2023
Classic!
July 19, 2021
Read this one as a young boy when I was playing Pop Warner football. It was the first behind the scenes memoir of a sports figure I ever read. Pretty tame compared to a few years later when I read Jim Bouton’s Ball Four.
October 12, 2007
"Instant Replay" is a fascinating look, in journal form, at an NFL season, through the eyes of veteran Green Bay Packer guard Jerry Kramer. Kramer had been an integral part of the great Packer championship teams of the 1960s, and as he relates the story of a disappointing season without legendary Coach Vince Lombardi (who had stepped down after the previous Super Bowl to move into the front office), it's hard not to get a bit misty- eyed at times. "Instant Replay" is a great book for a limited audience; there will be some difficulty understanding the story without at least some knowledge of the people involved. Jerry Kramer, btw, was one of the greatest offensive linemen in NFL history. It's a travesty that he isn't in the Hall of Fame.
May 10, 2020
Instant Replay: The Green Bay Diary of Jerry Kramer by Jerry Kramer (Doubleday 1968)(Biography). This is the original memoir by former NFL All-Pro offensive guard Jerry Kramer of the 1960's era Green Bay Packers. He played for legendary Coach Vince Lombardi, whose Packer teams won the first two Super Bowl games. This is the first and likely still the best football memoir by an offensive lineman. I loved this book growing up and considered the author to be one of my role models. My rating: 7.5/10, finished 1971.
December 6, 2019
One of the great sports books in that it shows not all sports books have to be shallow fluff to take advantage of a momentary market. An inside look at one of the greatest football teams ever and a time when players played hurt, fo better of worse. (I still remember the image of Jerry Kramer sitting in the locker room with a colostomy bag and telling a rookie, "It's a tough game, kid.") Kramer will be remember for more than a great, game-winning block in the "Ice Bowl."
December 30, 2010
When I played high school football, my favorite team was the Green Bay Packers. I [layed right guard and Jerry Kramer was my hero. Not some wimpy quarterback. So of course I loved this book. But, as it turns out, the book was pretty well written, and given that the Pack won the SuperBowl that year, makes for a good story.
February 4, 2014
A best-seller in the 60's, this book chronicles the day-by-day of what was Jerry Kramer's last season with the Packers, and, as it turns out, the last season coach Vince Lombardi was with the team. A fascinating inside account of a football season decades before the internet, sports radio, etc.
February 14, 2020
Tedious to a degree. Also fascinating to hear about life in the 1960s, when football players were simultaneously more childlike (curfews, etc) and less childlike (reserved, restrained) than they are today.
April 7, 2009
Loved this book. Right up there with the Jim Brown and Lombardi bios that I read around the same time.
May 5, 2009
The reason I still wear a Packers cap; also the reason I've never watched a complete NFL game since 1967 and the Ice Bowl. How do you climb higher than the top?
October 30, 2009
If you like the Packers or football you'll love this book. Tons of great stories about the Lombardi era Packers.
February 8, 2016
I'm biased. I'm a Green Bay Packers fan but I'm a football fan even more. A great book about the "world" of football. Really enjoyable. I highly recommend it if you are a football fan.
February 11, 2024
When this book was published in 1968, it read like a peek inside a mysterious world that ordinary people had never seen before. Jerry Kramer offered readers an inside view of playing in the National Football League. Specifically, he wrote about the 1967 season of his team, the Green Bay Packers. Often called the team of the '60s, the Packers were coached by Vince Lombardi, considered one of the all-time greats in NFL history. Lombardi built great teams full of skilled players who won multiple championships. In 1967, though, it all looked ready to end: Lombardi was rumored to be considering retirement, the Packers had lost some of their stalwarts to expansion teams such as the New Orleans Saints and other players were also considering hanging up their cleats. Kramer was one of them; he had had so many surgeries over his career that his nickname was "Zipper." In this book he takes readers behind the scenes as the Packers try for one more championship.
Any student of football history knows how that season went for the Packers. In spite of that, Kramer gives us a great deal of drama and suspense. The book uses his diaries from training camp to Super Bowl, showing his views of the season, his teammates and the challenges of a long season. I enjoyed his open admiration of certain opponents such as Alex Karras of the Detroit Lions and Merlin Olsen of the Los Angeles Rams. Above all is his portrait of Vince Lombardi, great coach and master manipulator, willing his team to victory by all means.
Kramer does an excellent job of showing the ordinary lives of football players. Despite that, there were certain missing elements that kept me from giving it four stars. He glosses over widespread use of pharmaceuticals that allowed players to stay on the field and even turn in superhuman performances. Also, he never mentions the gambling scandal that earned Karras and former Packer Paul Hornung one-year suspensions in 1963. No one seems to be much of a carouser or a womanizer either, which I find difficult to believe. Obviously that was not Kramer's life and he did not want to spill locker room secrets. That viewpoint is appreciated even if it feels something is missing. Three and a half stars.
Any student of football history knows how that season went for the Packers. In spite of that, Kramer gives us a great deal of drama and suspense. The book uses his diaries from training camp to Super Bowl, showing his views of the season, his teammates and the challenges of a long season. I enjoyed his open admiration of certain opponents such as Alex Karras of the Detroit Lions and Merlin Olsen of the Los Angeles Rams. Above all is his portrait of Vince Lombardi, great coach and master manipulator, willing his team to victory by all means.
Kramer does an excellent job of showing the ordinary lives of football players. Despite that, there were certain missing elements that kept me from giving it four stars. He glosses over widespread use of pharmaceuticals that allowed players to stay on the field and even turn in superhuman performances. Also, he never mentions the gambling scandal that earned Karras and former Packer Paul Hornung one-year suspensions in 1963. No one seems to be much of a carouser or a womanizer either, which I find difficult to believe. Obviously that was not Kramer's life and he did not want to spill locker room secrets. That viewpoint is appreciated even if it feels something is missing. Three and a half stars.
April 13, 2021
I read about this book in the brilliant Lombardi bio "When Pride Still Mattered" and being intrigued by it (I'm a sucker for any ghostwritten athlete "diary of a season" style books, as evidenced by my reading "Ball Four," "Pennant Season," and others). When I found a copy of it at the local Salvation Army for 49 cents (not fifty, but 49), I figured it was a heck of a deal. This is Jerry Kramer's inside account of the Green Bay Packers' championship season in 1967, when they did a three-peat of NFL championships and won their second straight Super Bowl (the NFL and AFL would merge later). It's a fun, rollicking time as Kramer describes not just the dynamics on the team but also his outside interests that, in the eyes of Lombardi, might distract Kramer and his other teammates from the ultimate purpose of football: winning. But the team manages to capture its second Super Bowl title and Lombardi would retire at the end of this season, working as general manager and then going to the Washington Football Team (known then by their very racist old name, which I will not repeat here) before his untimely death in 1970. Kramer proves to be a winning guide through the locker room and on the field, and I enjoyed this book a lot. It's not as salacious as later sports memoirs would be (and indeed, "Ball Four" reads as pretty tame today compared to its reputation upon publication as well), but it's a lot of fun and captures the moment of Green Bay's last hurrah under Lombardi, the man who would define what the Packers were for generations of even casual football fans (it doesn't hurt that it's his name on the championship trophy given out at the end of the Super Bowl). If you can find a copy of this, and you're really into football or just a casual fan, you'll like this book a lot.
July 24, 2018
A total treasure!
Given that Jerry Kramer will be inducted into the Hall of Fame this year, it just felt right to read his amazing diary that wrote during the 1967 championship season. Honestly,after reading this, I have no idea what took so long to put this player into the Hall of Fame.
The first thing you will note in this book is how football has not changed as much as we think. The camaraderie, teamwork, sacrifice, and mentality have always been part of this beautiful game. As Kramer notes it:
"Nothing irritates me more than the implication that we're some sort of subhuman beasts, trained animals clawing each other for the amusement of modern Romans"
It gives a unique insight of how players from an NFL team live their seasons. The struggle and pain are always present and even second thoughts are part of their daily routines:
"We started two-a-day workouts today, and the agony is beyond belief. Grass drills, agility drills, wind sprints, everything. You wonder why you're there, how long you're going to last. The grass drills are exquisite torture:"
Maybe the best thing hidden in this piece of history, is the way it portraits Vince Lombardi, one of the greatest coaches in history.
Kramer says about him: "He is a beautiful man, and the proof is that no one who ever played for him ever speaks of him afterward with anything but respect, admiration, and affection."
A must read and one of the best football books I've ever read.
Given that Jerry Kramer will be inducted into the Hall of Fame this year, it just felt right to read his amazing diary that wrote during the 1967 championship season. Honestly,after reading this, I have no idea what took so long to put this player into the Hall of Fame.
The first thing you will note in this book is how football has not changed as much as we think. The camaraderie, teamwork, sacrifice, and mentality have always been part of this beautiful game. As Kramer notes it:
"Nothing irritates me more than the implication that we're some sort of subhuman beasts, trained animals clawing each other for the amusement of modern Romans"
It gives a unique insight of how players from an NFL team live their seasons. The struggle and pain are always present and even second thoughts are part of their daily routines:
"We started two-a-day workouts today, and the agony is beyond belief. Grass drills, agility drills, wind sprints, everything. You wonder why you're there, how long you're going to last. The grass drills are exquisite torture:"
Maybe the best thing hidden in this piece of history, is the way it portraits Vince Lombardi, one of the greatest coaches in history.
Kramer says about him: "He is a beautiful man, and the proof is that no one who ever played for him ever speaks of him afterward with anything but respect, admiration, and affection."
A must read and one of the best football books I've ever read.
December 7, 2019
Instant Replay - in 2019, this is better than when I first read this book, probably in the early 1970’s in my preteen years. This book was for sale in a used book store, sadly going out of business, and I had a strong desire to read it again. I grew up watching a different pro football game than is played today. The Green Bay Packers, under Vince Lombardi, the greatest coach ever, set a standard for greatness. They worked hard, played the game with toughness and passion, and they were winners (not whiners). Jerry Kramer, the right guard, kept a diary during the 1967 season. I played right guard in high school, so I prefer a book written by a guard more than any other position. He is in the trenches. This story he tells is fascinating and so different than today’s game. They have unbelievably tough pre season practices. They played six pre season games, and the starters played hard in each game. Their salaries were small, especially compared with today, as Kramer made less than $30,000 a season. The quarterback, Bart Starr, called the plays. Not the coaches. They ran the ball, and the plays were simple, and still unstoppable. A full back, a half back, no man in motion, and simplicity and practice were key. I think any football fan will enjoy this book, even if they are too young to have watched the game 50 years ago.
February 29, 2024
I can see now why this book is ranked among the top twenty best sports books of all time. Jerry Kramer, who was a guard for the Green Bay Packers in the 1960s, kept a diary chronicling the historic season of 1967 where the Packers under Vince Lombardi make run for a third straight NFL championship as well as to win Super Bowl II. Kramer, with his eloquent recollection of the memories made in that 1967 season, makes you experience what he saw, how he practiced, how Lombardi acted, as well as the interactions he makes with Bart Starr, Forrest Gregg, Ray Nitschke, as well as other Hall Of Fame Packers. It gives a great glimpse of the start of the Super Bowl Era, as well as the beginning of the end of the historic NFL before the merger between the NFL and AFL. Reading through Kramer's diary showed what it was like playing under Lombardi as well as to show what the game was like before the Super Bowl Era as well as the Modern Era of the NFL. Kramer is so human in this diary, he shows his fears, his stress, his mindset, and it shows his humanity in general. As a Packers fan, who grew up and still lives in Wisconsin, this was delightful to read. Anybody, whether their Packers fan or sports fan should add this to their sports library.
September 9, 2018
This was a fun, often repetitive, diary of Jerry Kramer through the Superbowl 2 season. It's as much of an examination of Vince Lombardi as it is of Jerry Kramer.
I found the portrayal of Lombardi interesting. He has a cult-like presence with his players and constantly yells at them for not doing enough. In doing so, he's a master motivator. But he also loses control at times and doesn't know when to compliment a player or when to yell at them. It takes a certain form of psychosis to coach a team that wins 55-7 and then yell at each player for what they did wrong. There are also some fascinating stories about how dismissive Lombardi was of player's injuries. He would show up in the training room and basically tell players with broken limbs that they were fine.
Kramer is very honest about how conflicted he is about football, although this issue feels too easily resolved. He spends most of the book talking about hating football, hating being yelled at, and hating putting his body through it. Then in the epilogue he basically says that looking back after the season he loves football again and loves the teammates.
I found the portrayal of Lombardi interesting. He has a cult-like presence with his players and constantly yells at them for not doing enough. In doing so, he's a master motivator. But he also loses control at times and doesn't know when to compliment a player or when to yell at them. It takes a certain form of psychosis to coach a team that wins 55-7 and then yell at each player for what they did wrong. There are also some fascinating stories about how dismissive Lombardi was of player's injuries. He would show up in the training room and basically tell players with broken limbs that they were fine.
Kramer is very honest about how conflicted he is about football, although this issue feels too easily resolved. He spends most of the book talking about hating football, hating being yelled at, and hating putting his body through it. Then in the epilogue he basically says that looking back after the season he loves football again and loves the teammates.
October 29, 2022
Obvious bias here, I am a huge Packers fan.
Further bias, I had an amazing experience, having bought this book at a thrift book store, and brought it home to discover it being hand signed by Jerry Kraemer himself.
That said, I have read my fair share of books chronicling sports figures, teams, and events, and this may be my favorite. One of my favorite reads of the year.
This is essentially a historical document, following a Hall of Fame player during the last season of a legendary dynasty under one of the greatest, most important coaches and figures in league history. Featuring one of the most iconic plays and games ever, as well as the first and only three-peat in the NFL Playoff history.
Is that not enough? Jerry Kraemer is actually super well articulated, and does an amazing job illustrating the daily life of an NFL player as the league handled the rival AFC’s integration, boomed, and overtook the college game for hold, as well as life in the 1960’s.
Kraemer has so much humility, and you really root for him while he battles the notion of retirement, aging out of the game, and watching his friends and long time teammates struggle against Father Time. His relationship with Lombardi is also a perfect microcosm of Vince’s coaching prowess, with a love-hate dynamic that drives all his players to be their absolute best.
I don’t think I’m wrong to say this book would appeal to ALL sports fans, not just those who support the green and gold. It’s a quick read, and I may make a yearly tradition of it.
Further bias, I had an amazing experience, having bought this book at a thrift book store, and brought it home to discover it being hand signed by Jerry Kraemer himself.
That said, I have read my fair share of books chronicling sports figures, teams, and events, and this may be my favorite. One of my favorite reads of the year.
This is essentially a historical document, following a Hall of Fame player during the last season of a legendary dynasty under one of the greatest, most important coaches and figures in league history. Featuring one of the most iconic plays and games ever, as well as the first and only three-peat in the NFL Playoff history.
Is that not enough? Jerry Kraemer is actually super well articulated, and does an amazing job illustrating the daily life of an NFL player as the league handled the rival AFC’s integration, boomed, and overtook the college game for hold, as well as life in the 1960’s.
Kraemer has so much humility, and you really root for him while he battles the notion of retirement, aging out of the game, and watching his friends and long time teammates struggle against Father Time. His relationship with Lombardi is also a perfect microcosm of Vince’s coaching prowess, with a love-hate dynamic that drives all his players to be their absolute best.
I don’t think I’m wrong to say this book would appeal to ALL sports fans, not just those who support the green and gold. It’s a quick read, and I may make a yearly tradition of it.
October 10, 2019
I was really ready for this to be a dated sugar coating of a year in the life of the Packer's Hall of Fame left guard during Vince Lombardi's last year as Green Bay's head coach. In terms of the language it is a book of its time and you'd have to wonder how different a book it would have been had it been published after Jim Bouton's Ball Four or if Kramer were a little less prominent than he was. That said, concussions and pain killer abuse are every bit as much a part of this NFL as they are in today's game which I found equal parts refreshing and alarming. I also found myself drawn to the mundane elements of the story, the side hustles Kramer and other athletes have for extra income and the rituals and self deceptions players use to keep the game fresh were every bit as interesting to me as anything that happened during the ice bowl.
February 10, 2019
Lombardi thinks of himself as the patriarch of a large family, and he loves all his children, and he worries about all of them, but he demands more of his gifted children.
From the time of being a young girl who watched my big brothers play highschool football together. Johnny was a halback and Jerry was a quarterback in our small town, Greenville, Michigan. Coach Smith was their coach. Everyone loved him. He would flood the school playground every year across the street from our house. I begged him to let girls play football. My brothers taught me how to throw a spiral. Reading Instant Replay and the agony of Nutcracker drills, freezing weather, being cussed out by the coach, I know I couldn't have played football. Love, love, to be a spectator!! Great book!!!
From the time of being a young girl who watched my big brothers play highschool football together. Johnny was a halback and Jerry was a quarterback in our small town, Greenville, Michigan. Coach Smith was their coach. Everyone loved him. He would flood the school playground every year across the street from our house. I begged him to let girls play football. My brothers taught me how to throw a spiral. Reading Instant Replay and the agony of Nutcracker drills, freezing weather, being cussed out by the coach, I know I couldn't have played football. Love, love, to be a spectator!! Great book!!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews