All the 'Into the Dark' Episodes, Ranked

Updated March 26, 2021 24.0K views

Ranked By

1.8K votes

475 voters

This is a list of all the Into the Dark episodes as information about them is released. Blumhouse Television and Hulu have teamed up to terrify us all year long with Into the Dark, a horror anthology promising a new episode celebrating the darkest sides of the holidays. Over the year, a new Into the Dark episode is released monthly, themed to the major holiday for that month.

Each episode of this web television horror anthology will feature a different writer, director, and set of actors. Though some themes and narrative devices may connect them, expect a fresh set of scares on a regular basis. After a successful first season the horror anthology - which brought new feature-length episodes each month - was renewed for a second season, promising fresh freaky takes on the holidays.

Season two of Into the Dark delivers new scares for each season. Vote up your favorite episodes of Into the Dark, and vote down any bad episodes that you really didn't enjoy, despite how much you love the anthology series as a whole. It might be tough to put one Into the Dark episode over the other when there are so many that you love, which is why you can vote on however many episodes you like.

Video: YouTube
1
52 VOTES
A Nasty Piece of Work
Starring: Kyle Howard, Julian Sands, Dustin Milligan, Angela Sarafyan, Molly Hagan, Natalie Hall
Written by: Paul Soter

After an employee at a giant company learns he will not be receiving a Christmas bonus, his boss invites him to dinner to give him tips on how to angle a promotion - by defeating his competition in a violent brawl.

Holiday: Christmas

52 votes
Video: YouTube
2
85 VOTES
Culture Shock
Starring: Martha Higareda, Richard Cabral, Shawn Ashmore, Barbara Crampton, Creed Bratton
Written by: James Benson, Efren Hernandez, Gigi Saul Guerrero

A young Mexican woman in pursuit of the American Dream crosses illegally into the United States, only to find herself in an American Nightmare.

Holiday: Independence Day

85 votes
Video: YouTube
3
16 VOTES
Good Boy
Starring: Judy Greer, Steve Guttenberg, Ellen Wong, Elise Neal, Maria Conchita Alonso, McKinley Freeman, Chico the Dog
Written by: Aaron Eisenberg and Will Eisenberg

Maggie (Judy Greer) gets an emotional support dog to help with her anxiety. The dog proves to be more than effective - killing anyone who adds stress to Maggie's life.

Holiday: Pet Appreciation Week

16 votes
Video: YouTube
4
63 VOTES
School Spirit
Starring: Corey Fogelmanis, Annie Q., Jessi Case, Julian Works, Philip Labes and Hugo Armstrong
Written by: Patrick Casey, Josh Miller

Six social outcasts stuck in weekend detention are confronted by their school's legendary hauntings.

Holiday: First day of school

63 votes
Video: YouTube
5
11 VOTES
Delivered
Starring: Vito D'Ambrosio, Tina Majorino, Micah Joe Parker. Natalie Paul
Written by: Emma Tammi

A pregnant woman's life is upended by an unexpecgted threat aimed at her unborn baby.

Holiday: Mother's Day

11 votes
Video: YouTube
6
117 VOTES
I’m Just F*cking With You
Starring: Keir O'Donnell, Hayes MacArthur, Jessica McNamee
Written by: Gregg Zehentner, Scott Barkan

On the way to his ex-girlfriend's wedding, Larry (Keir O'Donnell) and his sister (Jessica McNamee) endure a night of increasingly frightening practical jokes during a one-night stay at a secluded motel.

Holiday: April Fool's Day

117 votes
Video: YouTube
7
50 VOTES
Pilgrim
Starring: Kerr Smith, Reign Edwards, Peter Giles, Courtney Henggeler, Taj Speights, Antonio Raul Corbo
Written by: Marcus Dunstan and Noah Feinberg

Anna Baker invites pilgrim re-enactors to her home on Thanksgiving, to help them remember their privilege and help them bond. When the actors continue in their character roles, the Baker family begin to regret showing them gratitude. Based on true events.

Holiday: Thanksgiving

50 votes
Video: YouTube
8
65 VOTES
All That We Destroy
Starring: Samantha Mathis, Israel Broussard, Aurora Perrineau, Dora Madison, Frank Whaley
Written by: Sean Keller, Jim Agnew

A geneticist (Samantha Mathis) fears that her son may be becoming a serial killer. She creates a group of clones so that he can allowing him to relive the slaying of his first victim, in an attempt to cure him of his psychopathic tendencies.

Holiday: Mother's Day

65 votes
Video: YouTube
9
122 VOTES
New Year, New You
Starring: Isabella Acres, Mia Ella Clyburn, Bianca Lopez
Written by: Adam Gaines, Sophia Takal

On New Year's Eve, a group of old high school friends reunite and must confront previous traumas.

Holiday: New Year

122 votes
Video: YouTube
10
132 VOTES
Flesh & Blood
Starring: Dermot Mulroney, Dana Silvers, Tembi Locke
Written by: Louis Ackerman

A year after the murder of Kimberly's (Dana Silver) mother, she still hasn't left her home but is beginning to suspect she is in danger. She is unsure if her father (Dermot Mulroney) or therapist (Tembi Locke) can be trusted.

Holiday: Thanksgiving

132 votes

Video: YouTube
11
119 VOTES
Down
Starring: Matt Lauria, Christina Leone
Written by: Kent Kubena

What could have been a meet-cute between two office workers in a trapped elevator over a long Valentine's day weekend turns troubling.

Hoiday: Valentine's Day

119 votes
Video: YouTube
12
70 VOTES
They Come Knocking
Starring: Clayne Crawford, Josephine Langsford, Robyn Lively, Lia McHugh, Dwight Hicks
Written by: Shane & Carey Van Dyke

A recent widower (Clayne Crawford) takes a road trip with his two daughters, but the family finds themselves the target of terrifying supernatural entities.

Holiday: Father's Day

70 votes
Video: YouTube
13
108 VOTES
The Body
Starring: Tom Bateman, Rebecca Rittenhouse, Aurora Perrineau, David Hull, Ray Santiago
Written by: Paul Davis, Paul Fisher

Maggie (Rebecca Rittenhouse) is intrigued and fascinated by professional hitman Wilkes (Tom Bateman), while Dorothy (Aurora Perrineau) attempts to outmaneuver him.

Holiday: Halloween

108 votes
Video: YouTube
14
42 VOTES
Pure
Starring: Jahkara Smith, McKaley Miller, Scott Porter, Annalisa Cochrane, Ciara Bravo, Jim Klock, T.C. Carter
Written by: Paul Fischer and Paul Davis (story), Hannah Macpherson (teleplay)

Several teen girls at a Purity Retreat participate in a secret ritual, and they start to see a supernatural entity. The girls need to focus on the demon they have unleashed, as well as their fathers' expectations.

Holiday: Daughter's Day

42 votes
Video: YouTube
15
12 VOTES
The Current Occupant
Starring: Barry Watson, Sonita Henry, Marvin Jones III, Lilli Birdsell, Kate Cobb, Ezra Buzzington, Joshua Burge
Written by: Alston Ramsay

A man trapped in a mysterious psychiatric ward who has no memory but comes to believe he is not only at the center of a conspiracy but is the President of the United States.

Holiday: Independence Day

12 votes
Video: YouTube
16
30 VOTES
Midnight Kiss
Starring: Augustus Prew, Scott Evans, Ayden Mayeri, Lukas Gage, Chester Lockhart, Adam Faison
Written by: Erlingur Thoroddsen

A group of gay best friends heads to a gorgeous desert home to celebrate the new year with one of their annual traditions - a game called Midnight Kiss. Already a dangerous challenge to find someone to ring in the new year with, the game becomes deadly when a sadistic killer wants to join the play.

Holiday: New Year

30 votes
Video: YouTube
17
28 VOTES
Crawlers
Starring: Jude Demorest, Pepi Sonuga, Giorgia Whigham, Olivia Liang, Cameron Fuller
Story by : Catherine Wignall
Teleplay by : Catherine Wignall and Mike Gan

During a Saint Patrick's Day night of parties and drunken revelry, three unlikely friends band together to save their college town from body-switching aliens.

Holiday: Saint Patrick's Day

28 votes
Video: YouTube
18
14 VOTES
Pooka Lives!
Starring: Felicia Day, Wil Wheaton, Malcolm Barrett, Rachel Bloom, Jonah Ray, Lyndie Greenwood, Gavin Stenhouse
Written by : Ryan Copple

A group of thirty-something friends from high-school create their own Creepypasta about Pooka for laughs, but are shocked when it becomes so viral on the Internet that it actually manifests more murderous versions of the creature.

Holiday: April Fool's Day

14 votes
Video: YouTube
19
112 VOTES
Pooka!
Starring: Nyasha Hatendi, April Campion, Dale Dickey, Gene Freeman, Cliff Weissman
Written by: Gerald Olson

Aspiring actor Wilson (Nyasha Hatendi) is a new arrival in town who can't find work. He's easily persuaded by a potential employer to dress up in a costume of a children's toy called Pooka. As he wears the suit, his connection with the world outside becomes tenuous, and he senses that something larger and more sinister is coming.

Holiday: Christmas

112 votes
Video: YouTube
20
37 VOTES
Uncanny Annie
Starring: Georgie Flores, Adelaide Kane, Paige McGhee, Jacques Colimon as Craig, Dylan Arnold, Evan Bittencourt
Written by: Alan Blake Bachelor and James Bachelor

On Halloween night a group of college students get trapped in a mysterious board game that brings their darkest secrets and fears to life, where they must play to escape…and win to survive.

Holiday: Halloween

37 votes

Video: YouTube
21
67 VOTES
Treehouse
Starring: Sophia Del Pizzo, Sutton Foster
Written by: James Roday

Celebrity Chef Peter Rake (Jimmi Simpson) retreats to his family's wooded vacation home to escape negative tabloid attention. But, once there, he realizes he's traded the tabs haunting his footsteps for the attention of his own unresolved ghosts.

Holiday: Ides of March

67 votes
Video: YouTube
22
27 VOTES
My Valentine
Starring: Britt Baron, Anna Lore, Benedict Samuel, Anna Akana, Ally Maki, Sachin Bhatt
Written by: Maggie Levin

A pop singer whose songs and artistic identity have been stolen by her ex-boyfriend/manager and shamelessly pasted onto his new girlfriend and protégé is locked in a small concert venue after hours with her ex and his new star. The three of them confront the emotional abuses of the past - until things turn violent.

Holiday: Valentine's Day

27 votes
Video: YouTube
23
9 VOTES
Blood Moon
Starring: Megalyn Echikunwoke, Yonas Kibreab, Joshua Dov, Marco Rodriguez, Gareth Williams, Jack Yang
Written by : Adam Mason & Simon Boyes

Esme (Megalyn Echikunwoke) and her 10-year-old son, Luna (Yonas Kibreab), move to a small desert town looking for a fresh start, but soon attract all the wrong kinds of attention. As the locals begin to probe, Esme must battle to protect her son, and a terrifying secret before the next full moon threatens their very existence.

Holiday: Spring Full Moon

9 votes
Video: YouTube
24
11 VOTES
Tentacles
Starring:Felicia Day, Wil Wheaton, Malcolm Barrett, Rachel Bloom, Jonah Ray, Lyndie Greenwood, Gavin Stenhouse
Story by: Alexandra Pechman & Nick Antosca
Teleplay by: Alexandra Pechman

Tara (Dana Drori) and Sam (Casey Deidrick) fall head over heels into a new romance and entwine their lives — until their intimacy transforms into something terrifying.

Holiday: Valentine's Day

11 votes