Monday #576

The audiobook I’ve just finished listening to had two Enid Blyton references in it, not unusual, but the strange thing is that it’s a book I’ve read before yet I hadn’t made a note of it. I have this time, though, and it’s logged beside the other ones I’ve seen recently, waiting on just a few more before I can make a whole post out of it.

In other news we were at a wedding at the weekend and apart from a little spittering when we left the house, and a little more when we got home, it did not rain! There was even some sunshine, miracle of miracles!

Letters to Enid part 47

and

Reading the Famous Five to Brodie part 5

As it is spring (despite the weather not really cooperating) I’ve chosen Stef’s recommended Spring Reads from way back in 2013.

Stef’s spring reads

 

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Letters to Enid part 46: From volume 3 issue 8

Previous letters pages can be found here.


Letters page from Volume 3, issue 8. April 13th-26th, 1955.

OUR

LETTER PAGE

 A letter from Hugh Morris, Aylsham, Norfolk.
Dear Enid Blyton,
In the holidays and on Saturdays, I go round with the Veterinary Surgeon in his car. I have been going with him for a long time. I hand him out the different instruments, and when I am at a farm with him, I sometimes run back to his car and fetch the drugs for the animals. One night I was out till half-past twelve watching an operation on a cow, it was very interesting. I am 12 years old, and a Busy Bee.
Love from,
Hugh Morris.

(How I would have loved to do this when I was twelve, Hugh! Are you going to be a Vet. when you grow up? I shouldn’t be surprised!)

A letter from Rosalind Jackson, Tisbury, Wilts.
Dear Miss Blyton,
I should like to know what the surnames of the “Famous Five”
are. I should like you to write “Famous Five” books as long as you live, because they are jolly interesting. Our class have dictation and compositions on them.
Yours sincerely,
Rosalind Jackson.

(Rosalind, you have asked me a question that hundreds of children ask. So now I will give the answer and set everyone’s mind at rest. The surname of the four cousins; George, Julian, Dick and Anne, is KIRRIN. That’s easy to remember, isn’t it, because of Kirrin Island. Please don’t ask me what Timmy, the dog’s surname is!)

A letter from June Hatherell, Swindon, Wilts.
Dear Enid Blyton,
Our Club has a very jolly time. We call meetings, and have a password. All our Club does the “Famous Five” puzzle in the Magazine, and we all have your Magazine, and we like it very much. We have a collection and each bring a penny and when we have saved up enough, we buy things for our Club, such as sweets, biscuits, drinks and so on. That is all for now.
Yours sincerely, June Hatherell.

(I have chosen your good little letter, June, because it is typical of many excellent ones I get, giving me news of F.F. clubs. Your Club seems a very jolly one indeed.)


I normally talk about the letters in order but today I will skip to what is quite possibly the most important thing written in any of the letters pages. The surname of all (human) members of the Five is KIRRIN. Rosalind is obviously too polite to say that she (and clearly the hundreds of other children) has noticed the Kirrin/Barnard confusion and wants answers. But what a public service Rosalind has performed, getting her letter, and the answer published. I shall now be able to respond to anyone asking that question with a definitive answer, fully referenced with Blyton, E. (1955) “Our Letter Page”, Enid Blyton’s Magazine, 3(8), p. 13.

Meanwhile, Hugh’s letter gives us a brief insight into the lack of health and safety in 1955 whereby young boys were allowed to go off with the local vet and handle the scalpels and drugs and get kicked by injured horses… I’m kidding (mostly). I’m sure it was very interesting and educational for him and it would be lovely if he did become a vet.

It is nice to see a letter which talks about saving up money and spending it on the savers for once. (The generous donation letters are nice, too, of course, but this one was a pleasant surprise.) I like the sound of June’s club – hopefully the leader is less strict than Peter as it does seem to have a Secret Seven influence too.

 

 

 

Posted in Magazines | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Five Have a Puzzling Time – a joint review

As I was working both Monday and Tuesday evening this week I felt like I didn’t want to start the next Famous Five book (Finniston Farm) on Sunday evening. Instead I suggested we try a Famous Five short story so we could finish it it one night.

I have the 1996 Red Fox paperback, the first time ever that all the stories had been gathered together in one volume, and it lives on one of Brodie’s bookshelves as there is no room on mine beside the hardbacks. You can just see it on the top shelf, the last book on the right.

 

For information on where these stories were first published see my series synopses – part one and part two. I have also reviewed the audio versions of these stories but focussed mostly on the voice acting and not the plots – part one and part two.

Despite those posts I’ve not really reviewed it in full. Reading it aloud made me notice a whole lot of things which I want to write down, and of course I have Brodie’s comments too, so I’ll include those as I go along.


An immediate adventure

Being a short story there is no time to waste on preliminary scene-setting. It begins with the girl already in bed at Kirrin Cottage, and by page 2 George sees a light on her island. “The adventure is beginning already,” Brodie said excitedly.

Of course George is furious and determined to set off right away, just as she was when Anne thought that she saw a light on Kirrin Island in the middle of the night in Five Have Plenty of Fun. 

Five Have Plenty of Fun (1955)

George sat up in her chair as if she had had an electric shock. “On Kirrin Island! Whatever do you mean? Nobody’s there. Nobody’s allowed there!”

“Well—I may have been mistaken,” said Anne. “I was so very sleepy. I didn’t hear the motor-boat go away. I just went back to bed.”

“You might have waked me, if you thought you saw a light on my island,” said George. “You really might!”

“If the boat’s ready, we’ll certainly go over to Kirrin Island today,” said George. “If any trippers are there I’ll send Timmy after them!”

Five Have a Puzzling Time (1960)

‘Anne! Quick, wake up! ANNE! Come and see! There’s a light shining out on Kirrin Island, a light, I tell you! Somebody’s there—on MY island! Anne, come and see!’

Anne sat up sleepily. ‘What’s the matter, George? What did you say?’

‘I said there’s a light on Kirrin Island! Somebody must be there—without permission too! I’ll get my boat and row out right now!’

George was very angry indeed, and Timmy gave a little growl. He would most certainly deal with whoever it was on the island!


The first investigation

As George has to go to the dentist (she was awake because of toothache) she can’t go to the island that morning. By page eight, the others have decided to go by themselves and find nobody there, but one of Anne’s sandals disappears when she takes them off for a paddle.

When George returns she insists that she and Timmy go as Timmy will obviously succeed where the cousins failed.

This, unfortunately became the beginning of a lot of repetitiveness in the story. It is only 46 pages long and they spend around 19 of those pages searching the island for the maker of the mysterious light.

On the first visit they sensibly they rule out anyone’s presence as there’s no boat, but Julian, Anne and Dick have a good look around anyway.

This only lasts a few pages and yet there are at least three inconsistencies with the rest of the series. Blyton wasn’t above making mistakes across the series, like having a room whole then the roof falling in then it being whole again, but three in almost as many pages is fairly poor. Five Go to Demon’s Rocks was published the year after this story, and I don’t think it shares the same faults, so I’m not sure we can put it down to the onset of her dementia. Perhaps the short story format made her rush?

Anyway, the inconsistencies are:

The jackdaws came down from the tower, and chacked loudly round them in a very friendly manner. Some of them flew down to the children’s feet, and walked about as tame as hens in a farm yard.

The jackdaws have always been very flighty, and were a sign that anyone had walked near them if they flew into the air. They do fly into the air soon after this and Julian asks what startled them. There’s no suggestion in any other book that the jackdaws know the Five and are so tame around them.

We’ll go up the old broken-down tower steps as far as we can, shall we? We might see something there—perhaps a lantern.

But in Five on a Treasure Island it’s established that you couldn’t do any such thing.

‘Was there an upstairs to the castle, George?’

‘Of course,’ said George. ‘But the steps that led up are gone. Look! You can see part of an upstairs room there, by the jackdaw tower. You can’t get up to it, though, because I’ve tried. I nearly broke my neck trying to get up. The stones crumble away so.’

And the Anne says;

What a lovely little island this is—and how lucky George is to own it. I wish I had an island belonging to my family, that I could call my own.

Obviously quite forgetting that George has shared her island with her cousins and says it belongs to all of them now.


The mystery deepens

In the brief interlude between visits to the islands (for lunch, of course) the Kirrin Cottage cook has reverted to being Joan rather than Joanna – except for one time where George calls her Joan. Interestingly the Faded Page version has it as Joanna each time – although they often admit to making “corrections” as they digitise it.

That’s not the real mystery, though. Joan/na is demanding to know where her oranges and grapes have gone, and Timmy’s dog biscuits. Then George noticies some chocolates missing from a box.

There has been a thief at Kirrin Cottage and Timmy didn’t notice!?


Back to the island

Another search of the island and the repetition really begins.

Naturally George wants to check for a boat as well.

George circled it deftly in the boat, being anxious herself to see that no one had hidden a boat anywhere. She pointed to where a great mass of brown seaweed had piled up on the west shore.

‘See what the wind did when we had that terrific gale on Tuesday—brought in masses of seaweed again! Now we’ll have an awful smell when it dries out!

Despite having hidden their own boat with seaweed twice, none of them wonder if the trespasser has done the same, but I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt and say that perhaps the piles weren’t quite boat-sized.

The jackdaws fly off again, perhaps startled by someone, again.

In new content Anne finds some orange peel and a grape pip, asking ‘Does that ring a bell, anyone?’ Brodie, excitedly, shouted “Yes, yes it does, Joanna’s oranges and grapes!”

Julian does what I’m beginning to notice he does second best (after being bossy) which is to instantly and incorrectly dismiss the others’ ideas, this one being that someone stole fruit from Kirrin Cottage and brought it to the island.

However, the find of the dog biscuits proves Dick was right.

Timmy, sadly, is fairly useless, as he picks up several trails and loses them – the longest one ending at the seaweed. (Mind you, it makes me wonder why he didn’t find the entrance to Uncle Quentin’s workroom in Kirrin Island Again, I suppose Uncle Q might have crisscrossed the island, but his strongest scent should have led right to the fireplace!) This made the search feel rather repetitive and hopeless.

The Five sit down and the overly tame jackdaws visit them again, along with the rabbits this time. As they are distracted by a rabbit which has been pecked by a jackdaw they fail to notice their biscuits and chocolate being stolen. Apparently even Timmy didn’t hear a thing. I find that really hard to believe, that anyone could walk up right behind them and take their things without Timmy noticing. He follows the trail again, but loses it at a tree.

The next bit of poor continuity is actually in Demon’s Rocks as the Five entirely fail to remember/mention the boy with the monkey who predates Tinker and his monkey by a year! Perhaps Bobby and Chippy inspired Tinker and Mischief as she realised a monkey would be amusing alongside Timmy – though of course Miranda and Looney had already been causing hilarity for over ten years.

Thankfully there are no more trails just a monkey to follow, and he leads them to his owner and his dog who are, hardly surprising, under the seaweed.


The ending

In my opinion the ending dragged on for far too long. Given that the story is 46 pages long, and they find the culprit on around page 30, there really was no need to take 15 pages – nearly a third of the book – to round it off. It felt like the end of the final Lord of the Rings film!

Bobby has run away because his Granpop said he’d have Chummy (the dog) put down a he bit someone. They take him back to Kirrin Cottage where (after some debate) he is allowed to stay the night, and he is firmly told by the Five that he has to train Chummy properly if he cares about him. A valid point and important lesson – but it needn’t have taken 15 pages and so much talking.


Five really do have a puzzling time

Aside from the number of times ‘following the trail’ and similar variations on the phrase were used, and the dozens of times the word seaweed appeared, the Five were also extremely puzzled.

‘Well—we’ll walk round the island and examine the rocks sticking up here and there,’ said Dick, puzzled about the jackdaws, too.

‘Of course!’ said Julian. ‘This is a puzzle! What do we do next?’

Why? George was puzzled.

‘Nor did Tim—or he would have barked,’ said George, really puzzled.

Timmy was already sniffing, looking very puzzled indeed.

‘Well, let’s hunt round a bit again,’ said Julian, more puzzled than ever.

‘Of course!’ said Julian. ‘This is a puzzle! What do we do next?’

They sat sucking the barley sugars, really puzzled.

Timmy was as puzzled as the children.


Final thoughts

Brodie listened pretty intently to the adventurous parts but he definitely got a bit restless once Bobby was found and it became a bit boring. I asked him if he enjoyed it and he said no, he couldn’t bear it not having any chapters. As a single story it is probably about two or three regular chapters long, so not too bad to read in one go, assuming one third of it doesn’t drag.

I thought the basic premise wasn’t bad – but it could have been a much shorter, tighter story. We didn’t need George to have a sore tooth, and the cousins to go first, thus exploring the island twice. We didn’t need so much toing and froing with poorly excused uselessness from Timmy. Yes the seaweed smell would have made it harder for them to find the trespassers but not to the extent of the trouble they had!

Aside from that, the idea that Bobby floated to the island on an air bed with a spade for an oar, rather stretched plausibility. We are told over and over that it is very hard to land on Kirrin Island. The local fishermen can manage it, and obviously the baddies do a few times, but a young boy on an air bed? Obviously George’s pride over her special ability to be the ‘only one’ to land on her island is exaggerated by her, but come on.

Sadly the illustrations in the Red Fox edition are poor – or at least poorly printed with very dashed lines. Brodie was horrified! I explained that it was a different illustrator and he wanted to know why Enid Blyton hadn’t drawn them this time…

It wasn’t all bad, though. The characters were well written, as they always are, George was perfectly George-ish in her fury at someone being on her island, and although it was a short story there was some nice moments like below.

‘Cheer up. We’ll all go and hunt over the island again this afternoon—and I expect you’ll find a couple of pirates, two or three robbers, a shipwrecked sailor, a …’

George gave a sudden grin. ‘Shut up, you idiot. Don’t take any notice of me for a bit. I’ll be all right soon.’


 

Posted in Book reviews | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Monday #575

Apart from going to work I have barely left the house in the past weeks due to a certain spotty little boy. We did get out at the weekend for a walk in the woods, though, where we experienced sun, rain, hail, strong wind and a double rainbow. So, a typical Spring day, really.

Five Have a Puzzling Time – a joint review

and

Letters to Enid part 46

I’m a little behind but I thought it was still worth mentioning that the second new Famous Five episode is now available to watch. It sounds even less like the books than the first one did, though!

When Uncle Quentin’s life’s work is stolen from Kirrin Cottage, the Famous Five take the night train to Scotland and are drawn into a deadly game of espionage, theft and deceit.

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Rating the Famous Five titles part 2

Continuing now with the remaining half of the books. Part one can be found here.


Five Have a Wonderful Time

Again, this could literally apply to all 21 books – probably why it is one of the titles I always mix up.

You might say Hang on, George didn’t have a wonderful time when she was kidnapped two books earlier or the same about Dick three books earlier, but all Five get locked in a tower in this one and left overnight! Despite the various dangers and tough times the Five face they always have a wonderful time on their adventures.

This doesn’t give you the tiniest clue about what the book contains – but I imagine that all children needed to see was that it was a Famous Five book and that was enough to sell it to them. I wonder, though, if faced with half a dozen Fives at a bookshop or library, which titled would get picked up first? I’m betting titles like Smuggler’s Top or Treasure Island would be looked at before something as vague as Wonderful Time.

Five Go to Faynights might have been better – it’s less vague and Faynights is an interesting, attractive-sounding place.


Five Go Down to the Sea

I think that this one is reasonably descriptive. They do spent a lot of time by the sea at Kirrin, of course, but they don’t really go down there. They do go to the coast for Demon’s Rocks, but not for bathing/beaches.

My only issue is that they barely spend any time by the sea! Compared to most Kirrin adventures where their bathing suits are barely off (Adventuring Again notwithstanding for obvious reasons), in Sea they go to the beach and swim exactly one time.

Tremannon Farm is not even that close to the sea! They have to walk a long way to Yan’s Grandad’s hut to even see the Sea.

So it’s descriptive but to me, it feels like it doesn’t really accurately tell you what the book is going to be about.

Five Go to Tremannon Farm would have worked (and Finniston Farm hadn’t been written yet, so it wasn’t a case of not wanting two Farm titles) or Five and the Wrecker’s Way would have been a really appealing title.

⭐⭐


Five Go to Mystery Moor

Finally, another good one! A title can only convey so much, but while we don’t know what or where Mystery Moor is I know it’s something that sounds intriguing.

 

It’s better than Five Stay at the Stables or Five Sleep in a Quarry! But we could have had Five Get Lost in the Mist!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five Have Plenty of Fun

At the risk of sounding repetitive this could also apply to all the books. I also get muddled on this one quite often. One good way to try to remember it is to say Five have Plenny of Fun, like Berta would.

What else could we call it, though? Five and the Mistaken Identity (sounds a bit Hardy Boys, and could also apply to Get Into Trouble.), Five Meet Berta, er, Leslie, er, Jane, Five Lose George (Again)? Nothing is jumping out at me – so suggestions, please!


Five on a Secret Trail

I don’t have any issues identifying this title, though it’s not that descriptive now I think about it. The Five actually follow a lot of secret trails. But it does tell us that they go hunting for something and Secret Trail sounds mysterious and intriguing.

Other possible titles could be Five and the Mad Boy! or Five and the Stone Slab (of a Particular Size). 

⭐⭐⭐


Five Go to Billycock Hill

It’s nice and clear which book this is from the title. I’m not sure, however, how appealing this title is.

Even in the late fifties when this was published a Billycock hat (which I’ve literally just discovered is a nickname for a bowler hat, even though having Googled it before I had thought how much it looked like a bowler hat!) was a hundred years old and about twenty years out of style (unless you were a city gent, apparently). How many 7-10 year olds in 1957 knew what a Billycock hat was?

I suppose it is an interesting sounding name for a hill which might spark an interest in the book itself.

As the farm and caves are also Billycocks there’s no use switching to either of them for a title. The only other option is something like Five and the Missing Pilots which gives away perhaps a bit too much, or Five and the Run(ned) Away Pigling?

⭐⭐⭐


Five Get Into a Fix

While in reality this is another thesaurus-ed version of Five Get Into Trouble I don’t actually have any trouble identifying the book. I’m not sure why the Fix title sticks in my head but as soon as I read it I can see Eileen Soper’s Five frolicking in the snow.

In terms of appeal and descriptiveness this should really be a one star book. But as I kind of like the title I have to give it more.

Instead I suppose we could have had Five Go to Magga Glen? Or Five Go Ski-ing (hyphenated like it is in the books), though that sounds silly with the picture of them tobogganing on the cover. Perhaps Eileen Soper would have drawn them skiing, of course, had the title been different. Five Go Tobogganing is a bit of a mouthful.

In making my own version of the cover I noticed for the first time that the title letter have snow on them! How many times have I looked at it and not noticed that? I tried to replicate it the best I could in my version.

⭐⭐


Five On Finniston Farm

Surely an easy title for any reader to identify – unless they think of Tremannon Farm and get confused. While the Five must visit dozens of farms in the books – they have to get their food somewhere! – few are named, and they only stay at two.

While many of us love Blyton’s other farm stories (Willow Farm, Cherry Tree Farm, Buttercup Farm, Mistletoe Farm and so on) they are generally adventurous in a different way to the Famous Five. The fact that this is Five On makes it attractive to fans of the Famous Five, and tells us that this will be more than learning about nature and dealing with poachers. I also think that Finniston is a suitably interesting name for a farm and therefore book title.

 

What other options could we have had? The castle is not even ruined, it’s plain gone so it’s no good putting that in the title.

Five and the Obnoxious Americans? Blyton never really make it in the United States but probably not a great idea to alienate them from the title alone!

⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five Go to Demon’s Rocks

This is a thrilling title, I think. It makes it very clear which book in the series it is, and Demon’s Rocks sounds mysterious and dangerous. It might have been nice to squeeze Lighthouse into the title, but the lighthouse is on the cover and so it isn’t really needed.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five Have a Mystery to Solve

Our last extremely vague title. The Five manage to straddle the adventure/mystery genre quite successfully. Although they are not solving a crime/disappearance/strange happening in every book in the organised clue-hunting way that the Five Find-Outers or Secret Seven do, they are often trying to find out what’s going on. This means that they more or less solve a mystery in every book.

In short, this title doesn’t identify which book it is, nor does it tell us anything specific about what to expect from this book.

Five On/Go to Whispering Island would have been much better, even if it does give away the fact that they end up on the island when they didn’t plan to.


Five Are Together Again

Whilst this is fairly vague – the Five are together, again, in every book but the first! – I think as this is the last book in the series the Together Again sounds quite poignant. It’s not really a reunion, though it is a year on since the previous book, but just the Five having one last (somewhat feeble) hurrah.

Alternatives might have been Five Go to Big Hollow, Five Camp in a Field, Five and the Circus?

⭐⭐


There we are – my opinions on all the titles along with alternative titles of varying quality. Let me know your thoughts and if you have any better ideas, and I’ll compile a final list of titles in another post.

Posted in General bookishness | Tagged | 3 Comments

March 2024 round up

It feels like ages since I wrote the February round up – but we are over a week into April I suppose.


What I read

What I have read:

  • How to Date Your Dragon (Mystic Bayou #1) – Molly Harper
  • A Sister’s Wish (Yorkshire Blitz #2) – Donna Douglas
  • Studies (Maggie Adair #4) – Jenny Colgan
  • Boy of Chaotic Making (Whimbrel House #3) – Charlie N Holmberg
  • The Island of Adventure
  • And the Rest is History (Chronicles of St Mary’s #8) – Jodi Taylor
  • The Love Hypothesis – Ali Hazelwood
  • Five on a Secret Trail
  • Twenties Girl – Sophie Kinsella
  • The Briarmen – Joseph A Chadwick
  • A Daughter’s Hope (Yorkshire Blitz #3) – Donna Douglas

I ended the month still working through:

  • Pride and Prejudice – Jane Austen
  • Witches & Words (Library Witch Mystery #4) – Elle Adams
  • A Brief Atlas of the Lighthouses at the End of the World – Gonzalez Macias
  • Five Go to Billycock Hill
  • The Care and Feeding of Stray Vampires (Half Moon Hollow #4) – Molly Harper

What I watched

  • We are up to ER season 8 now, and I also went back to The Crown and watched series 6 which I’d completely forgotten about. I think it dropped in two parts and I was waiting on part 2 before I watched it – but that was in December!
  • Tuesday nights we watched The Lost City (with Sandra Bullock and Channing Tatum) and Crossroads (with Britney Spears).
  • With Brodie I think I half-watched the first Ant-Man movie, and definitely ET. (It’s really annoying that Disney+ doesn’t keep a log of what you’ve watched as if I don’t write it down I often forget!) I think Ewan and I also watched The Marvels.

What I did

  • I had a hen party where I got to make a floral wreath which now hangs on my front door.
  • I built my mother’s day Lego set – a Dobbie figure
  • We had our first (and only, so far) afternoon in the garden as it was actually warm enough to sit outside, and as it was Easter Sunday we rolled our eggs (well, we sort of lobbed them at the greeny poles, but the important thing is that they broke so we could start eating them.)
  • And lastly I failed to believe Brodie when he told me he had another gap in his teeth. In my defense it hadn’t been wobbly before this and it just disappeared! We think he swallowed it with his breakfast.

 


How was your March?

Posted in Personal Experiences | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments

Monday #574

I’m back after our few days away – where we had mixed weather. One day of clouds and intermittent rain, one day of constant rain, one day which started out sunny and warm (no coats needed!) then became windy and cold, and on our last day, snow. I kid you not.

We made the most of it anyway, despite the weather. We are in for a lot more rain the next few days but tomorrow we will be staying home anyway as Brodie has, quite inconveniently, come down with chicken pox.

March round up

and

Rating the Famous Five titles part 2

Nothing ground-breaking but there is a new article out about the filming of series 5 of Malory Towers.

The key point for me is that there’s a new matron. This could be a real shame as I love Ashley McGuire and think she’s the best ‘made up’ part of the show.

 

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Rating the Famous Five titles

A recent comment on the blog has inadvertently inspired this post. A regular reader pointed out that I had written Five Have a Wonderful Time when I actually meant Five Fall Into Adventure. It wasn’t that I had confused the plots of the two books, but I had confused the titles. Wonderful Time, Fall Into Adventure along with Plenty of Fun are particularly vague titles which give no clue as to the plot of the stories and are the three I mix up the most.

And so, while walking to work one morning after the comment politely pointing out my error I started writing (in my head) a review of all the Famous Five book titles complete with star ratings. As is always the case my written review will never match the witty brilliance of what I can come up with when I have no pen and paper, but I’ll do my best here.

I’ll also try to come up with some alternative titles – though this is very hard and I don’t think I can actually come up with anything better!


Five on a Treasure Island

I think there are a few things that are important about a book title – besides being catchy. One is that it should give prospective readers an inkling of what the book will be about, and the other is that it should be sufficiently descriptive to differentiate it from other books in a series, or from the same author.

Five on a Treasure Island does both of these things. While the children visit Kirrin island several other times in the series it is only the first book where there is treasure to be found.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five Go Adventuring Again

This is a rather vague title. Given that the Five have twenty adventures after Treasure Island, this could really apply to any of those!

I don’t have an issue remembering this one, for some reason. Perhaps as it’s only book two and I can confidently name the order of books 1-6, though the rest I wouldn’t remember in order.

Is there a better title? I’m not very good at coming up with titles but perhaps Five Have a Winter Adventure? Five Get Snowed In? Five Go Up Against a Thief? We are  a bit limited if we want to stick to the Five Go/Have/On/Get format. Otherwise how about Five and the Stolen Papers?

One thing we have to consider is that Blyton only intended the series to run for six books. Although this doesn’t help greatly with telling prospective readers what the book is about it would have helped with keeping the titles straight in our minds. Of course Blyton was such a phenomenon that by book two I’m sure children would have read Five Have a Mildly Interesting Time, Five Play Chess or Five Go to the Shops anyway.

With that in mind, Five Go Adventuring Again would score more highly had the series ended with book six. Thankfully for us it didn’t.

⭐⭐


Five Run Away Together

This is definitely less vague. Although the Five do go off all sorts of places together this is the only time they do it in secret, the only time they actually run away. (The Five all have loving parents and comfortable homes – what on earth could they be running away from? I imagine children crying on first seeing this title.)

This could have been called Five on Kirrin Island Again, really, as it is probably the book with the second-most amount of time spent on the island. However run away is more evocative of the plot.

⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five Go to Smuggler’s Top

A perfect title. Enough said?

You know I can’t miss an opportunity to expound on my favourite book from the series. It’s a simple title, telling you they go somewhere called Smuggler’s Top. This title makes it perfectly clear which plot goes with it, and the mere mention of smugglers is sure to attract readers.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five Go Off in a Caravan

Our third Go title. It’s not terribly vague – although the Five stay in caravans in (let me think for a moment…) Wonderful Time they go to the caravans, not Go Off in them.

The only issue is that there are two caravans. Five Go Off in Caravans, admittedly, doesn’t have the same ring to it, but that’s probably because I’ve been reading the real title for over 30 years. Had the book come out as In Caravans I’m sure it would sound perfectly fine to me.

⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five on Kirrin Island Again

While this doesn’t exactly describe the plot in detail, I’m struggling to think of anything else that would work. Five and the Underground Explosives? Five and the Undersea Tunnel? Five Save Kirrin Island?

As this was meant to be the final book of the series it probably worked quite well as it is – beginning with Treasure Island and ending on the island again. The Again also makes a pattern with Adventuring Again.

However, with ? more books featuring visits to Kirrin Island it isn’t the most unique title.

⭐⭐⭐⭐


Five Go Off to Camp

This one does half a good job at telling us what the book is about. The Five indeed go camping, or rather off to camp to fit in with the (varying) format of the other book titles.

However, they do camp in several books. If you’re only classifying camping as staying in tents then they do this in Get Into Trouble, Secret Trail, Billycock Hill and Together Again, though they sleep out in ruined rooms, caves, cellars, and quarries in at least four other books.

What are our other options then?

Five and the Spook Train? 

Five and the Black-Marketeers?

Five Go Off to Camp by a Haunted Railway?

I can’t think of anything that really fits the loose style for the titles (there are no Five and the Blank titles in the original run, but I’m sure there are some in the Claude Voiler continuations).

⭐⭐⭐


Five Get Into Trouble

Despite describing the plot of practically every single Famous Five book, I generally know which one this is. For some reason the cover of the Knight Paperback comes firmly into mind when I see the title and I know that the gates are at Owl’s Dene and therefore which story it is.

I suppose they didn’t want to call it Five Go to Owl’s Dene because that would give away too much as the Five work out where Dick has been taken.

Five Get Kidnapped? Short, snappy, and mostly accurate. Dick is certainly kidnapped. The others more or less do break into Owl’s Dene and are held against their will – but is that strictly kidnapping? (Research tells me that no, it is not as kidnapping involves carrying someone away – it would be false imprisonment however. But as we had Caravan and not Caravans earlier, then I’m sure the inaccuracy of kidnapping would be allowed.)

Five and the Black Bentley? KMF 102 is a fairly iconic and memorable part of the book after all. Or Five and the Escaped Prisoner? perhaps that gives too much away. I know – Five Go Off on Their Bikes! 


Five Fall Into Adventure

As I said at the top of this post, this is one of the titles I regularly mix up. The Five fall into adventure 21 times, this could be literally any book – it’s as if Blyton took the previous title and ran it through a thesaurus.

Five Tumble Into Peril
Five Plunge Into Intrigue
Five Get Into a Spot of Bother
Five Don’t Go Looking For Trouble.

You get the idea.

I try to remember that Timmy FALLS from the cliff into the sea near the end of the book, and picture the dust jacket image of that scene to help but I can’t always remember to do this.

This title neither tells you (specifically) what the book is about, nor does it really help you recall it afterwards.

So what could this one be called?

If we chose Five Get Kidnapped to replace Five Get Into Trouble, we could have Only Two of the Five Gets Kidnapped This Time?… Five Minus Two? Or perhaps Five On a Wild Goose Chase? If we didn’t have to have Five at the start we could call it Jo Saves the Day!


Five on a Hike Together

This one is just about descriptive enough. The Five do go on lots of explorations but this is their only walking holiday. It doesn’t tell you an awful lot about what to expect, but the alternatives like Five Go to Gloomy Water/Two TreesFive on a Treasure Lake, Five Search for the Saucy Jane all give away a bit too much and would spoil some of the impact of the first reading of Two Trees. Gloomy Water. Saucy Jane. And Maggie knows. 

⭐⭐⭐


Do you agree, or disagree, with any of my ratings? Do you have any better ideas for possible titles? Let me know in the comments below!

Posted in General bookishness | Tagged , | 9 Comments

Monday #572

I nearly decided to have a week off from blogging this week, as I have come down with that feels like my hundredth lurgy of 2024. (It’s probably only the fourth or fifth, but it is only March!) However I will probably be taking next week off as it’s the school holidays and we will be away for a couple of nights. I just hope we finally get some better weather.

At risk of sounding like an intrepid explorer writing a diary that will be found years later alongside my body – Temperatures are regularly below freezing. Continual rain makes the outside world a miserable, inhospitable place. Snow is forecast tonight. I have forgotten what sunshine looks like.

OK so I’m not Scott and this is not the Antarctic, so I may be exaggerating a smidge. I just really need a bit of warmth and sunshine!

Rating the titles of the Famous Five books

and

Letters to Enid part 46

A comment on an recent post suggested the Sue Welford series Adventures with George and Timmy/Just George for Brodie after we finish the Famous Five. While looking for something to highlight here I happened across this interview with none other than Sue Welford!

An interview with Sue Welford – Author of the Just George Series

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Fan fic Friday: Bill and Allie’s great adventure chapter 5

Parts one, two, three and four for anyone who needs to catch up.

Jack nudged Philip sharply in the side, careful not to let Dinah see what he was doing, then made a show of scratching the side of his neck, trying to let the other boy know that there was a whiskered nose poking out the collar of his white shirt. 

Philip hastily dislodged the mouse from his collar, feeling its little paws scrabbling down his front as it looked for another comfortable spot, giving Dinah a winning smile as she looked at him suspiciously.

“Philip… you haven’t!” she hissed.

“Haven’t what?” he asked innocently.

“Mother told you that you weren’t to bring ANY pets with you today!”

“What makes you think,” began Philip. He was ready to remind her that sometimes Kiki just remembered old phrases and it absolutely didn’t mean that she had seen a mouse, when his new companion decided to betray him completely by darting out of his cuff to grab a large bread crumb off the table. As quickly as it had appeared it disappeared back in to eat its prize, but not before Dinah had seen it. “She didn’t say I couldn’t pick up any new ones today,” he called over his shoulder as he hurried from his seat, though he had spared a second to take his plate so he could refill it at the buffet.

Dinah glared at her brother and shuddered a little as she thought about the mouse that Philip must have picked up in the hall. What a beastly thing for him to do when he knew she didn’t like mice. 

“How tiresome,” she sighed, sitting back in her seat. “I suppose we shall have another mouse running about the house for the rest of the holiday.”

“At least it’s not a snake, or some sort of bug,” Lucy-Ann said in agreement. “But I don’t mind Philip’s mice friends. They are so sweet.”

“As long as Kiki doesn’t think that they are lunch,” Jack chuckled. He stroked Kiki where she rested on his shoulder.

“Keep that bird under control,” Bill said, appearing by the children and putting his hand on Jack’s shoulder. “Are you lot having a good time? Enough to eat?”

“Philip has just gone up for another plate of food,” Jack said jovially. “It really is a marvellous spread, Bill.”

“Everything is scrumptious,” Lucy-Ann agreed. “I can’t wait for the cake! Aunt Allie is very proud of it!”

“I vote that we give Philip a slice of the top tier,” said Dinah with a suspiciously bright smile.

“Be nice,” Bill warned her with a laugh, knowing that the top tier was actually made of cardboard decorated to look like cake, rationing not allowing for more than one tier even for a wedding.

Jack looked quizzically at them. “What’s wrong with the top layer? Did Aunt Allie mess up the recipe or something? You were just saying how pleased she was with it.”

Bill and Dinah both laughed, entirely unsurprised that Jack was oblivious. It wasn’t bird-related, after all. “It’s not cake,” Bill explained.

Jack leaned back in his chair, forcing it onto two legs as he strained for a better look. “It looks like cake,” he said at last.

Philip returned with his second plate laden with food. “You’ll split your head open, Mannering,” he barked, imitating their form-master, and even going as far as using his free hand to shove the back of Jack’s chair as the master regularly did.

The front legs of Jack’s chair slammed back down on the floor, making the cups and saucers of the table rattle. A few people looked around to discover the cause of the disturbance, and one or two at the same table began mopping up spilt tea and coffee.

Bill gave Philip a stern look, one that was mirrored by Mrs Cunningham. He then winked at his new wife, a wink that said he had it all in hand, and she returned to her conversation with Aunt Polly.

“Yes, Dinah,” he said carefully. “Make sure that Philip does get a slice from the top.”

“I was wondering when we’d get cake,” Philip said obliviously, thinking that his new mouse would probably enjoy some too.

“I’d be surprised if even you had room for cake after those enormous platefuls,” said Dinah, while Lucy-Ann sat quietly, her head turning back and forth like a spectator at a tennis match.

There was no real malice in their teasing, and she knew that Dinah was just trying to needle Philip for breaking the no pets rule. She wouldn’t cause a scene by tattling on him, but she would try to get even in other ways.

Still, Lucy-Ann didn’t like any tension between them, especially on such a happy day as this. She had been overjoyed, when, a few years earlier, Aunt Allie had taken her and Jack in, giving them a warm, loving home and a mother figure. Now she was to have a father figure too, and she couldn’t be happier. Just the thought of them all living together as a family in the next school holidays was enough to make her beam. 

Bill caught sight of her smiling face and grinned back at her. He was greatly fond of all the children, but Lucy-Ann in particular.

“The top tier is nice and light,” he said airily to Dinah before he moved on to speak to Anatoly, Johns and his other work colleagues, pausing only long enough to give Lucy-Ann a gentle squeeze on her shoulder.

“We’ll go and get the cake, once it’s cut,” Dinah said sweetly. “They should be ready to do that soon.”

It wasn’t long before there came the light sound of a fork hitting a glass to attract everyone’s attention and distract Philip from his thoughts of a third plate of food.

“Ladies and gentlemen,” Bill said in a carrying tone. “Allie and I are about to cut the cake.”

Several people got to their feet and moved for a better view. “Keeping the top later for the christening?” one of Bill’s work friends called out teasingly as Allie removed it and set it to one side. 

Bill sent his colleague a glare as Allie blushed, and then quickly smiled again as Jack had raised his camera to capture the cake-cutting.

Deciding it would be too difficult to cut the cardboard layer and have it look convincing, Dinah decided to bring the whole top tier to the table. She checked first that her mother didn’t intend to use it again, then grabbed the spare knife that had been laid out.

She took the false cake, which really did look rather convincing, even up close, and put it down on the table close to Philip. “Don’t even think about cutting yourself a slice,” she said. “You’d cut massive slabs and there would be none left!” She knew that a direct order like that would be far more effective than asking her brother to do something, and so began to gather up the used plates and cutlery from the table. “Does anyone want a cup of tea with the cake?” she asked as she headed off.

Lucy-Ann had already collected four slices of cake from Mrs Cunningham and was over by the tea urn. Dinah joined her and together they watched as Philip picked up the knife and attempted to cut the cake. They saw his confusion as the top bent in a little, but did not cut. 

Anatoly watched him try again and smothered a laugh. Johns reached out and, with one large hand, lifted the cake off the plate. “Hey,” Philip objected before Johns solemnly turned it upside down and put it back, showing off the hollow interior.

Everyone began to laugh. “Dinah! Where are you, you beast!” called Philip.

“I told you not to cut the cake,” Dinah reminded him, passing him a real piece of cake as a peace offering.  

“Well it’s not cake,” Philip said, his crossness tempered by the generous slice of real cake on his plate. 

“Look, Kiki’s even more confused than you were,” Lucy-Ann said, distracting from the disagreement. They all turned to watch the parrot who had fluttered off Jack’s shoulder to examine the hollow cardboard cake, eventually pushing it off the edge of the table in disgust.

“Naughty bird,” Jack said, tapping her on the beak before picking up the decorated piece of cardboard. Kiki rustled her wings. “Poor old Kiki, poor old Kiki.”

The rest of the reception went off without a hitch, and once all the guests had left Bill drove Allie home and Anatoly brought the children. Bill had already moved most of his belongings into Allie’s house, it was larger and they didn’t want to unnecessarily disrupt the children’s lives. All that was left was some larger pieces of furniture and the few things he had needed for the morning of the wedding. 

“Now children, I don’t want to hear any arguments this evening,” Aunt Allie warned as they tumbled indoors, Anatoly following more sedately behind. He was to stay over in order to drive the children to the train station in the morning to begin their journeys back to school. Luckily the boys’ and girls’ schools resumed on the same day this term. “Everything should already be packed and all that should be left out are your wash bags and uniforms for tomorrow.” 

They all nodded tiredly. Lucy-Ann stumbled a little as she moved towards the stairs but Anatoly caught her before she could fall over. She smiled and thanked him before heading upstairs with the others to bed.

“They are going to be hard to wake in the morning I bet,” Bill said with a shake of his head.

It wasn’t the traditional sort of wedding night, not with four children, one parrot, one mouse and one junior agent/surrogate nephew clattering around the house preparing for bed, but once the children, parrot and mouse safely off to school Bill and Allie would be off to France for their honeymoon.

Allie just hoped that Bill wouldn’t drag her into another adventure this time. Getting married had been adventure enough!

The end

Posted in Fan fiction | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Reading the Famous Five to Brodie part 4

While in real-time we are on to Five on a Secret Trail, in blog-time it’s time for what Brodie said about books 6 & 7.


Five on Kirrin Island Again

We went straight onto this book the night after finishing Five Go Off in a Caravan. Gone are the days of reading anything else in between Famous Five books (which we only did once, actually, after the first one.)

My copy has the reprint dust jacket shown on the left, so unfortunately I couldn’t play ‘spot the error on the jacket’ with Brodie. Maybe someday I’ll show him a picture of it online and see what he says.

We were looking at the end papers before we started reading, and he said that the two other people must be “The Sticks, they must have escaped from prison!” The Sticks really must have made quite an impression on him!

When the Five can’t find Uncle Quentin on the island Brodie was certain that they would find him at the top of the tower. But he imagined the tower to be made of planks of wood painted green. It’s so cute how he keeps explaining to me that “I picture it when you’re reading it to me, so I see it in my head.”

The weeds around the dungeon stone took him a minute to understand, but he did get it in the end particularly that Uncle Quentin couldn’t get back out if it was shut.

His new theories became that that a) Uncle Quentin was wandering around the island the whole time and they just kept missing each other and b) that Uncle Quentin went down the well into the dungeon, and used a crane from a fishing boat to lower down his supplies.

For some reason this led us on to talking about escape rooms, which I had to explain to him. His response was “I’d get out easy. I’d just press on all the panels until I found a secret passage.” When telling this to Stef we had the brainwave that we should open an Enid Blyton themed escape room – in 2037, of course, when her copyrights expire.

Impressively he guessed that the man parachuted from a plane onto the island, and even more so he caught the mistake about the room being whole/fallen in/whole again. I feel SO vindicated in having listed my nitpicks in reviews, knowing that even a six year old (so well under the cut of of 12 that Blyton had for disregarding criticism) could spot some of them!

To balance things out he also believed that George would easily let Timmy stay with Quentin, and then that Quentin would let her stay with him. So he’s about 50/50 with his responses.

The next night he asked “When is the adventure going to begin?” Clearly this one’s more of a slow burner.

The night after that he was home late after a birthday party, and in bed late, so we skipped story time. But he woke up after half an hour having had a bad dream. So we talked about what nice dream he could have – and we settled on the Famous Five looking for treasure.

Either he just imagined a story before he fell asleep, or he really did have a Famous Five dream as he told me it all he next morning on the way to school. I did my best to accurately type it up when I got home half an hour later:

Anne and George were at the train station when Julian and Dick arrived “HI JULIAN, HI DICK!” they shouted, (and then my brain repeated that bit). They took the pony cart to Kirrin Cottage and one of them said “Maybe there’s treasure under our beds!” Aunt Fanny laughed and said “Maybe there is!”… (then there was something about going on a pirate ship to the island, but they came back), and Timmy sniffed around under the stairs and then the stairs lifted up and there was a deep, deep hole under there! Julian went down first, and there were iron staples for his feet, but then there were beams (that’s another word for staples, Mummy), and he kept going down, but then the beams ran out and he had to come up and get a rope. So we went down again but when he got near the bottom there wasn’t enough air. So they went to a scuba shop and bought… (I said “tanks of air”) Yes, tanks of air, but they sold all the swimming stuff, it was a trick you see. Then they went back to the cottage but I lost the dream and decided to dream about dragons…

The next time we read he was still annoyed by the mistake of the room with a roof. He got cross and wanted me to change what I read to a fallen-in room so it was right.

When George got into the undersea tunnel he got a bit scared and needed me to put my arm around him. And at the end of the chapter he really really begged for more because he needed to know what happened, but we’d already done four chapters so that was it.

He thought that Uncle Quentin should give the men the book to stop them from blowing up the island.

When “something” gets in through the window and comes upstairs to jump on Julian’s bed he shouted “It’s Timmy!” (Correct, one point). “He must have got in the boat and come back.” (Ummm no… no points there )

As Stef said: Timmy is good, but he’s not that good.

I later mentioned this to Ewan and his response was that maybe a dog could lean over the side and paddle with his paws – so what hope has Brodie got?

Anyway, sticking with Timmy, Brodie had to think about it for a minute but he figured Timmy was taking them to the quarry and quickly from that figured the undersea tunnel connected up to there.

He did think that two bad men were the same as from the first book though (they are pretty generic bad guys to be fair), and that the reason they didn’t come out at the quarry is that they were still trying to blow up the island.

This became his favourite book in the series (so far the most recent one has always been his favourite) and we talked about how this one was meant to be the last one but the fans begged for more. I explained that 21 was last as Blyton wasn’t so well and had trouble remembering things then.

“Like the room with a roof or no roof?”

He just couldn’t let that drop! That led to me explaining her whole “cinema screen” process for writing which he found pretty interesting.

He then said “We’ll start the next one tomorrow night… but what will we read after we’ve finished them all?” 

Around the time we were reading this we visited St Andrews and we spotted these iron staples in the wall. He pretended to be one of the Famous Five, having an adventure.

“If we lived in that house I’d pretend to be the Famous Five all the time and I’d go up and down those staples every day.”

He’d be Julian of course and he made me George (having already accused me yesterday of having a temper like George because I’d told him off for jumping on our bed) and Ewan gets to be Dick. He wasn’t bothered about not having an Anne, but he was bothered about Timmy who we decided would have to be played by a toy from home.


Five Go Off to Camp

Again we were straight on to the next book the next night. He was very excited when he realised they were going camping.

At the end of chapter two when they all fall asleep he said “I bet when they wake up in the morning they won’t remember they’re on holiday.” I love how he’s picked up on that little detail – one of them does it in practically every book!

And indeed Julian did not disappoint us:

He sat up and wondered where he was and who was calling. Of course! He was in his tent with Dick—they were camping on the moors.

While he said didn’t know what it was, he didn’t think that Anne was sitting on a volcano. After it turned out to be a train he admitted that he thought it might have been a geyser.

anne, five go off to camp

One evening he was absolutely begging and begging for more chapters because he wanted, had, to know if the boys went and if they saw a spook train. But, he added “someone must be driving it because ghosts. Aren’t. Real.”

I ran into a real Scottish problem here, as Jock had to have a Scottish accent. A) he’s called Jock and B) he has a Scottish accent on the cassette tape I had as a child. You may wonder what the problem was, as being Scottish, you’d think I could do a Scottish accent nae bathir.

That literally is the problem. I have a Scottish accent. So the Five, despite me trying to be a little less broad and a little more neutral of voice, still sound pretty Scottish. So how could I make Jock stand out as actually Scottish? By doing an extra-Scottish accent. A real och aye the noo one. Which then I had to replicate in softer tones for Mrs Andrews and harsher ones for Mr Andrews.

At one point Anne goes to check their tents are “untouched” when they get back. “I bet they’re been touched,” said Brodie. And also “I think the spook trains going to take them away and when they get off they’ll be in ghost land.” He was a bit scared when the shepherd was talking about the spook trains.

Funnily he (for a while at least) he was saying “jumping jiminies” when anything was surprising.

He suggested that the spook train had broken down the wall between the tunnels and gone in there – which is really not that far off the solution.

I had to explain how they could walk over the tunnel because he was picturing a curved tunnel above ground level – I blame the toy train sets with tunnels like that (especially because I have a hard time not picturing the same thing!)

Stef asked me if I had to explain why they could walk on the rails, to which the answer was no, he didn’t ask me about that. I did have to explain about the niches in the side for workers, though.

Other Famous Five things he said that evening:

“Mummy, do you love books or do you hate books?”

Obviously I said I love them.

“But you haven’t read all the ones on your shelves have you!?”

Before I could defend myself he started talking again.

“Do you know my favourite books?… CHAPTER BOOKS. Because I love the Famous Five… why are they called the Famous Five? Are they famous… why Five though?”

I asked how many of them were there and he ran off to get a book to count the characters. He brought through Caravan.

“Have we read this one before? Oh good, I didn’t want to spoil it for myself.” He did count the Five as being five but argued that Timmy shouldn’t count as he’s a dog…

His next story idea was that someone had “programmed the spook train with coordinates to run to the yard and back with no-one driving it.” 

He asked why Anne didn’t fall down the vent on her way back across the tunnel top – well, she stayed on the path when George had left it to investigate the lump, but it’s a good question, as George ripped up a load of heather so you’d think Anne might have at least noticed it on her way back.

Camp was then his favourite book, but very closely followed by “The one with the tower where he smashes the windows at the end.”

His favourite part was that the men were playing a trick making everyone think it was a spook train when it was just an ordinary train.

Again he asked “When we’ve finished the Famous Five what are we going to read next???” 

 

Posted in Book reviews | Tagged , , | 10 Comments

Monday #571

I briefly looked for something non-weather related to say this week but it’s difficult to find something Blytonian-related that isn’t already going into one of my upcoming posts.

So I’ll tell you that it’s actually sunny right now. Not only that but it’s above 5 degrees. I’m sure this is just a brief respite before yet more heavy rain, but I’ll take it while it lasts.

Reading the Famous Five to Brodie part 4

and

Bill and Allie’s Great Adventure part 5

The Five experience the strange wailing noise along with blue, green and white lights floating in the sky outside the old cottage.

Dick felt the roots of his hair pricking. He leapt off the heather-bed and ran to the window. ‘Quick! Come and look at this!’ he cried. ‘What is it?’

They all crowded to the window, Timmy barking now as loudly as he could. In silence the others gazed at a very strange sight.

Difficult to convey blue and green lights in black-and-white, though. I showed Brodie this before I read out the next line and he was puzzled.

“Huh?… Snow?”

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Fan fic Friday: Bill and Allie’s Great Adventure chapter 4

In case you missed them:

Chapter one
Chapter two
Chapter three

It was a short and simple ceremony, but Bill wasn’t sure he would remember all of it. His hand shook slightly as he guided the ring onto Allie’s finger, but she seemed to be in control as she pushed his ring over his knuckle. 

As the registrar wound up, saying that they were now man and wife and that Bill could now kiss the bride, Kiki joined in with “Kiss the bride. Kiss the bird. God save the King!” at the top of her lungs before Jack could stop her. 

Bill paused, raised an eyebrow and said dryly, “You know, Kiki, old girl, I will certainly agree to God Save the King, and I certainly am going to kiss the bride, but I cannot be persuaded to kiss the bird!” 

The children giggled, even Jack who was bright red at Kiki’s interruption. There were a few laughs from the congregation. Bill looked at Allie and with a smile, added, “May I now kiss the bride?”

“Only as long as you keep to kissing the bride and not the bird,” teased Allie gently as he pulled her close for a kiss. Bill chuckled and gently kissed Allie as everyone else laughed at the exchange and clapped. 

Anatoly took over the photography from this point as Philip and Jack slipped out of the room to go and decorate the car with the tin cans and the signs they had made. The guests then began to make their way out of the registry office and down to the steps to shake confetti over Bill and Allie as they made their way to the car.

“I’ll get you two for this later,” Bill called warningly to Philip and Jack who were doubled over laughing at the look on his face. 

“Anatoly was in on it as well!” Jack called back as Bill shook a menacing fist, obviously trying to spread the blame around.

“Traitor!” Anatoly said, taking the camera from around his neck and, in Jack’s opinion, swinging it far too recklessly on its strap in retaliation. 

“Oi! Be careful with that!” Jack shouted as Anatoly pretended to almost drop his precious camera. 

“You’re in enough trouble as it is without destroying our wedding photos,” Bill reminded him, eyebrows raised. 

Anatoly smoothly handed the camera to Jack and then cuffed him on the ear while the boy’s hands were busy examining it for damage. 

“Shall we go before anyone else gets into trouble?” Allie asked, smothering a laugh. 

“Girls?” Bill looked at Dinah and Lucy-Ann, who although smiling at the boys’ antics, were keeping themselves apart from any of their nonsense. “There’s nothing you’d like to tell me, is there? No surprises lurking in the car or at the reception?”

“Of course not, Bill,” they chorused, the picture of innocence. He looked at them suspiciously and then shrugged. Bill knew that whatever the girls may have planned, it would be less embarrassing than the boys’ decorating of the car. He held the passenger door open for Allie before he got in himself, turned the key in the ignition, and waved to everyone as he drove off. 

Anatoly used Allie’s car to transport the children, Kiki and Allie’s aunt and uncle to the reception in the village hall, as she had insisted she was fine to drive herself and the girls to the registry office. Bill had paid a local catering company to set up and do the food and the wedding cake. It was worth the money so that Allie hadn’t had to make it all herself with her daily help. 

As they pulled up, Bill spotted the sign that the girls must have put up on the front of the hall. It was a nice sign, if not slightly embarrassing to have their union declared to everyone in the village. The sign read “Congratulations, Bill and Allie on your wedding!”.

Allie sighed and laughed, “I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised but at least it doesn’t make a noise!” 

Bill grunted and shook his head a little, and offered up the idea, “It’s the thought that counts?” 

Allie nodded and took his hand. “Indeed, and I think it just goes to show how fond they are of both of us that they want to show off that we have gotten married,” she said softly. “And they are just excited. Let them have their moment and don’t be so grumpy,” she teased. 

Bill lifted her hand to his lips and planted a kiss on the back of it. “You’re right of course,” he agreed. “I’m just not used to having things so out in the open. Come on then Allie, let’s go and make sure everything is how we want it before the hoards arrive!” 

The catering company had done a lovely job, and so there was little for them to do in the hall, but Allie went around checking everything nonetheless. They had only had a brief head start on the other guests, and soon everyone else was arriving. Most of the guests had walked the short distance over, but Anatoly took the car back to collect Bill’s older cousin and his wife.

“Is that everyone here?” Bill asked, doing a headcount after Anatoly’s passengers were inside, everyone having congratulated him and Allie again as they arrived.

“If there was anyone else they have missed their chance,” he said with a shrug.

Bill grinned. Including he and Allie there were 21 people and one bird in the hall. A small wedding by anyone’s standards but just the right number for them. Allie’s friends had come on their own – a girl’s night out they were calling it – and his colleagues had also come alone, so the numbers were fairly even for dancing later. 

In the meantime, the food was waiting. Bill cleared his throat noisily. “Thanks for coming, everyone. I know that at least some of you came mostly on the promise of food,” here he gave a raised eyebrow in the direction of his work colleagues, “so I declare the wedding breakfast open!”

“Hooray, I’m starved,” said Philip, heading straight for the plates at the end of the table before Aunt Polly caught his arm. 

“Let the bride and groom fill their plates first,” she scolded.

Despite the delay Philip still managed to be near the start of the queue. After piling his plate high with at least two of everything on offer he joined Jack, Dinah and Lucy-Ann at the end of one of the tables which formed three sides of an open square. Bill and Allie were in the middle of the top table but had said they weren’t going to fuss about seating arrangements, leaving it a free-for-all. 

After a minute Anatoly dropped into the chair beside him, but immediately turned towards Johns. Philip rolled his eyes. Once upon a time he and the others had been quite friendly with Anatoly but, especially if anyone else was around, they were apparently beneath him now. 

“Did Bill not eat this morning, or something?” he heard Anatoly ask his colleagues. “Only it is not breakfast-time, and this,” he indicated his plate of sandwiches and sausage rolls, “is not breakfast food.”

Johns and the other agents guffawed at the question.

“Not been to many weddings?” Johns asked, trying to keep a straight face.

“What?” Anatoly demanded. “What did I say?”

“It’s always a wedding breakfast,” Bentley explained. “Even if it’s at night. That’s just what they call it. Something to do with the bride and groom fasting before the wedding once upon a time, then breaking that fast with a meal after.”

Anatoly snorted. “People should just call things what they are.”

“But where’s the fun in that?” Thompson asked with a grin. This wasn’t the first time they’d had to educate Anatoly in the English language, despite him having grown up in London.

Dinah and Lucy-Ann were talking as they ate, but the boys were listening into the conversation next to them, wondering if they could glean any information on Anatoly’s high and mighty airs and graces now he was working less and less with Bill. Kiki was on the table, taking the odd grape or piece of fruit from the children’s plates and flexing her crown occasionally when someone ate something she wanted. 

“Three blind mice,” she said conversationally.

“I thought she’d forgotten that one,” said Dinah. “I don’t think she’s said it since you had that mouse a few summers ago.”

To be continued…

Posted in Fan fiction | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Reading the Famous Five to Brodie part 3

Part one covered Five On a Treasure Island, and then part two was Five Go Adventuring Again and Five Run Away Together.


Five Go to Smuggler’s Top

This is, of course, my absolute favourite so I was really really hoping he would like it.

We began with this cracker:

“Uh oh. I don’t think Sooty should come to Kirrin cottage. He might find out their secrets, like the secret passage to Kirrin Farm!”

Then he was surprised by Soper’s illustration of Aunt Fanny (despite her being shown in at least one earlier book). He pictured her looking like Ms Frizzle from the Magic School Bus Rides Again (without the lizard, probably). It seems he’s like me, in that his brain gives him a picture of a person in a book and then he’s stuck with it. I usually get someone with the same name, he’s just got someone with the same initial.

He was tricked by George when she pretend to go off to Smuggler’s Top without Timmy, but did think George was up to something – planning to catch a smuggler not sneaking Timmy with them. He did guess he was who they were picking up when the car stopped, though. “They’ll have to hide him somewhere outside!” 

He had questions about the illustration and the strange-looking car. I had to remind him this book is very old, which somehow led to a long discussion about people getting TVs for the coronation.

Then I had to try to describe a marsh to him, because he said “I know what marsh is, it’s what you get when you burn wood…” He meant ash. I think in the end I had to look up images of marshes on my phone so he understood.

After a bit of prompting he identified the secret passage in the illustration (why did they have to put so many illustrations way ahead of the matching text? Brodie gets very annoyed by this and keeps pointing it out when he notices!)

New words were learned, namely precipice and summit.

When Sooty says “ready?” to the Five, Brodie answered with an emphatic “YES”. His solution would be keeping Timmy in the cupboard the whole time. When Sooty’s door buzzed he gasped and said “It’s the step father!!” He thought that Mr Lenoir sounded very much like Uncle Quentin.

We went over precipice, summit and catacombs again later as he had forgotten what they meant. “Why are there so many complicated words in this book?” he asked, obviously not knowing that Blyton was criticized for her simple language.

I asked him and he said he would trust Sooty and would follow him into the catacombs, the rope ladder would be fine because he can climb the ladder into the loft and that’s quite high. Thinking ahead, as soon as they climbed back into Marybelle’s room he said “What about the furniture? They’ll have to move it back!”

I regularly ask him questions to see what he’s thinking –

Who’s signalling from the tower? “It must be Block!” (He was right of course, but I’m not sure if he worked it out or it was a wild guess.)

Where did the man go in Block’s room? “Out the window! Or he’s a magician, and he disappeared in a flash. I know, maybe he’s under the bed!… Or maybe there IS a secret passage in Block’s room.” Honestly, I can’t keep up with him sometimes!

When smugglers were coming across the marsh he had this epiphany – “That’s why it’s called Smuggler’s Top! Because there are smugglers!”

One night we ended on the cliffhanger of Timmy barking while Mr Lenoir is in the school room, he was not happy. (He pretty much always begs for one more chapter but on cliffhangers it’s even more desperate.)

The next night he was full of concern that the Five would get into trouble for having Timmy there. We had a long conversation about how lying is wrong and that’s why the Five don’t say that Timmy is with Alf. He thought that Aunt Fanny and Uncle Quentin would be worrying about where Timmy was – this is a good point, I can only assume they think he is with Alf/James.

He later asked me if we could get up in the middle of the night some time and look out the window because that would be like the Famous Five. He thought we might see a robber sneaking into our garden… The only thing we’d see in our garden at night is the fox, or at least I hope so.

He found it very tense when George was in Mr Lenoir’s study, shouting “Get out! Get out! George!! Get out!!” And “I think I know what’s going on now… it’s getting to the exciting part because we’re near the end.”

Sometimes he’s astute and at other times completely incomprehensible – “I think there’s some sort of mechanism. He (Block) is a robot. There’s some sort of chain reaction going on.”

For a while he was convinced that Uncle Quentin and Sooty were inside the window box, and, touchingly, he was concerned that it was a bit small for two people. Eventually he twigged that there was a secret passage there too.

He did guess that Block was screwing the lid back down, though. He was all for them waking the whole house that evening and it took a bit of explaining about them not trusting Mr Lenoir (as always though I spend ages explaining and then two paragraphs later Julian more succinctly says the same things anyway). He then wanted them to tell Sarah and we had a discussion about Mr Lenoir being in charge of the house and his staff wouldn’t keep secrets from him.

“Maybe Mr Lenoir isn’t on the bottom of things.”

Then there was a bit of an argument because he agreed with Julian about not letting the girls go to Mr Barling’s because to have an adventure you had to be strong and stay awake all night (there were other things on that list that I’ve forgotten) and girls aren’t as strong as boys… honestly the rubbish he picks up from adverts and TV shows and kids at school it makes me furious. But he did agree that George was very brave and capable.

After we finished I asked the usual questions. It was his favourite book so far and all of it was his favourite part – except maybe the end because it wasn’t so exciting after the adventure ended.


Five Go Off in a Caravan

 

The night after we finished Smuggler’s Top he climbed up on the back of the sofa and took this one off the shelf himself, as a not so subtle hint that he wanted to start it. But then he thought he had picked the wrong one.

“No not this one, it doesn’t have a caravan on the front!”

I have the reprint dust jacket where they are underground – but it does have a bit of caravan on the spine.

He was sad that Sooty wasn’t in it because he liked Sooty. He said “Where’s Sooty?” in real surprise, and “I thought he’d be there. Who’s with them, then?”

About the elephant pulling a caravan he said “That’s not right!”

He didn’t know what a procession was – his guess was “a camping competition.”

Mrs Kirrin asking Anne if she’s been standing on her head because her hair is a mess prompted two whole minutes of hysterical laughter from him

He said he would choose the green caravan because green is his favourite colour. Which brings me to the realisation that I picture the caravans as white/cream, like today’s caravans, and not red or green.

He would also help with the chores, “I’d wash the dishes because I like getting my hands wet.” (He does actually like doing dishes, but they don’t usually get very clean, and more than just his hands get very wet.)

He thought Anne breaking the egg outside the cup was funny, that sitting outside the caravan was strange and that having to sit there guiding the horse would be boring. When George said she likes adventures he said “So do I. But I don’t know what adventurous thing they can find in the hills.”

One night  he had the book and pretended to read to me first but basically summarised what had happened earlier.

“And the caravans went away, pulled by the elephant. The boy who did cartwheels and his angry dad who said “Go and make me a coffee”.”

When Merran hills came into view he cried “Yessss! Now the adventure begins!” He thought Pongo was hilarious, wearing clothes, shaking paws, particularly with Timmy’s tail. This led to a long discussion over why you don’t see animals in circuses any more (though I just discovered that they have only just been banned in the UK in 2020).

Inspired by the Five Brodie had a camping session in the house during the school holidays. (We were under severe weather warnings so we couldn’t go anywhere!)

He packed a whole suitcase for this, and told me that I had to play “Mother” to help him.  Obviously I didn’t help enough as his case contained toothbrush, toothpaste, t-shirts, trousers, pyjamas, bottled water, marshmallows, sticks to toast them on, a toy camera and his tablet to play white noise at night. No underwear or torches though.  He then played as Anne making the food for camping.

That night he had a really quite intelligent idea –

“I know! They’re smugglers! There must be a trench under the ledge and there’s treasure they’ve smuggled there! That’s what the cart was all about!”

Then, after a pause.

“If I’m right then I’ve just spoiled the book for myself.”

I refused to tell him if he was right or not, though I did have to laugh at how serious he was about potentially spoiling the book for himself.

Further clever thinking led him to say that they shouldn’t stop and examine the treasure in the hill “because Tiger Dan and Lou the acrobat might come down behind them.” 

(Mind you, he also thought that the hollow for the caravans had stone walls and a roof so he’s not got a 100% success rate with the intelligent comments.)

He learned to say acrobat properly that night. Until then it came out as actorbat.

There was lots of laughter at Nobby saying “Yes, Ma,” to Anne, and at Pongo licking the honey from the jar. He asked “How much is he going to eat??” about the inspector with the bread and honey.

Then, after I read the last line of the book, he burst into tears because they were going home. Apparently it’s not a happy ending because they went home. But Caravan is now his favourite story, even more than Smuggler’s Top.

“How many more adventures can they have???” he asked in disbelief.

Well 16 actually…


 

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , | 5 Comments

Monday #570

Halfway between meteorological spring and astronomical spring and… it’s still cold! (Mind you, if I didn’t have the weather to complain about I’m not sure what I’d find to say every Monday.)

Things I am looking forward to in spring:

Sunshine and warmth
Wearing trainers instead of boots
Flowers/leaves/general greenery instead of bare branches

Things I am not looking forward to:
Being too hot
Getting wet feet because it still rains in spring (and summer…)
Wasps

Reading the Famous Five to Brodie part 3

and

Bill and Allie’s Great Adventure part 4

As it was Mother’s Day in the UK yesterday (I got more Lego!) I thought we should revisit my post about Blyton’s mothers. (Image is unrelated apart from the fact it mentions mother’s day!)

Blyton’s Mothers

 

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Fan fic Friday: Bill and Allie’s Great Adventure chapter 3

In case you missed them:

Chapter one
Chapter two

Soon it was time for the groom and his best man to head over to the registry office. On Bill’s request, Anatoly had borrowed a slightly more posh service car to use as the wedding vehicle. It didn’t matter that they weren’t going very far for the reception. Bill wanted everything to be as near perfect as possible for Allie. 

Away from Bill’s prying eyes Anatoly knew that Jack and Philip had a “Just Married” sign for the back window, and tins cans on string to tie to the bumper for after the ceremony. Anatoly had caught them whispering about it during the brief wedding rehearsal the week before. “I heard nothing,” he had said as they spotted him. “What you two do to get into trouble is your own problem.” However he had been grinning as he spoke.

They arrived at the registry office and Bill had a cigarette pressed onto him by Anatoly before they went in, meaning they got to see some of the guests arriving. A few of Bill’s SIS colleagues appeared and shook his hand. Bill’s only relatives, a few distant cousins, turned up and so did some of Allie’s friends, escorted on foot from the nearby station by Jack and Philip. 

Aunt Polly then appeared and shook Bill’s hand warmly. “I always hoped things would work out for you both,” she said kindly before moving on to talk to Jack and Philip. Behind her, rather bemused by everything around him, was Uncle Jocelyn. His round-shouldered, wild-haired, bespectacled stare let everyone know that he wasn’t really with them, but rather miles away with whatever he was working on and his precious papers.

Polly waited for him to catch her up and then began steering him around people and into the right room by gentle pressure on his arm. 

“I’m surprised that Aunt Polly managed to pry Uncle Jocelyn out of his study for today,” Philip said to Jack after the couple had moved out of earshot.

“She wouldn’t have, I’m sure, if they had still been at Craggy Tops,” Jack replied.

“Long way to come, too,” Philip said thoughtfully. “I don’t think that they ever travelled so far back when they lived there. I can only imagine the look on Jo-Jo’s face if he’d had to drive them all that way in the rattly old car.”

They both paused for a moment, thinking about Jo-Jo, the servant, odd-job man, driver, and secret forger who had worked for Aunt Polly at Craggy Tops. It was all well and good to joke about Jo-Jo’s temper three years after his arrest, but they still remembered all too clearly the moment he had dropped his mask of foolishness and had revealed himself to be as cold and calculating as he was clever. Having broken up the forging gang during their first summer together, none of the four children liked to think of what Jo-Jo might do to them should they cross paths again. 

“They’re much better off now, aren’t they?” Jack said finally.

“Well, Uncle Jocelyn complains constantly about having had to leave Craggy Tops, but I think Aunt Polly has a much easier time of it now, especially with her poor health. She’s got hot and cold running water, and electricity for a start.”

Jack had only spent a few weeks at Craggy Tops before the undersea explosions set off by the desperate gang had ruptured the well on the mainland and ruined the house’s only water supply. But he remembered well having to fetch water in buckets, trimming the wicks on the paraffin lamps, collecting firewood and all the other jobs which were rather laborious given the primitive conditions found in such a desolate location. It hadn’t bothered the children much at the time, but he could imagine how draining it would have been for increasingly elderly Aunt Polly year after year. 

“And your uncle can still write his book from the new house,” he said.

Philip laughed. “He’s been writing that all his life, or so it seems. I don’t know if he’ll ever finish it.”

Jack coughed and Kiki imitated him, making people close to them laugh in bemusement and awe. Jack gave Kiki a little warning tap on the beak when she flapped her wings and puffed her throat. “Steady on, old thing. You need to behave today.”

“Steady on, old thing, behave! Behave! Steady, behave!” Kiki repeated, hopping from foot to foot on Jack’s shoulder.

“Exactly,” Jack said firmly. “Behave.”

Before long they were ushered inside as the registrar’s room, and the last guests found their seats as the clock moved closer to 10.30 and Allie’s scheduled arrival.

Bill and Anatoly went to the front of the room, nodding to the registrar, before Bill turned to Anatoly and asked, “You still have the rings don’t you?” 

Anatoly looked shocked. “You never gave them to me…” he started but at the look on Bill’s face, which had suddenly drained of all blood, he hastily laughed and pulled out the box from his pocket. “I did, however, remember to pick them up!” he finished off and grinned sheepishly. 

“Don’t you start,” Bill warned him as everyone in the room heard a car pull up outside. Bill slid one finger around his suddenly tight collar, glanced warningly at Anatoly to discourage him from any further tricks as the car doors slammed outside and footsteps could be heard heading towards the room they were in. 

There was a sudden, “God save the King!” squawk from Kiki in the hallway, which was hastily silenced by Jack who was waiting outside the doors to take pictures of Allie being walked down the aisle by Philip. 

The registrar cleared his throat and the pianist in the corner started the wedding march. Jack opened the door, and hurried up the aisle as Dinah and Lucy-Ann came through the doors ahead of Philip and Allie. 

The girls looked grand in their dresses with a simple bunch of flowers each, and their hair done nicely. Bill moved forward and kissed them each on the cheek as they got to the front of the room. He straightened up and looked back down the aisle as Jack hurried half way back and started snapping pictures. One of Allie’s friends from the village pulled him out of the way as Philip and Allie approached them so Bill could see Allie for the first time. 

Bill found that his breath caught in his chest as he laid eyes on Allie. She looked divine as she walked down the aisle in her light blue dress, Philip escorting her. She smiled shyly at Bill as she drew level with him. Bill smiled widely at them both and shook Philip’s hand before Allie and Bill both turned to the registrar. 

“All be seated,” he said. “We are gathered here today to witness the marriage of William Patrick Cunningham and Alison Elizabeth Mannering…”

To be continued.

Posted in Fan fiction | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

February 2024 round up

 

What I have read

I felt like I had a slow start to reading in February – and I definitely did a lot of listening to old favourites. But then I must have read a lot as I ended on 17 books!

What I have read:

  • Five Go Down to the Sea
  • The Secret Book Club – Shauna Robinson
  • A Second Chance (Chronicles of St Mary’s #3) – Jodi Taylor
  • Tilly and the Map of Stories (Pages & Co #3) – Anna James
  • A Trail Through Time (Chronicles of St Mary’s #4) – Jodi Taylor
  • The Library Girls of the East End – Patricia McBride
  • No Time Like the Past (Chronicles of St Mary’s #5) – Jodi Taylor
  • Five Go to Mystery Moor 
  • What Could Possibly Go Wrong? (Chronicles of St Mary’s #6) – Jodi Taylor
  • Happily Ever After for the Cornish Midwife (Cornish Midwife #8)
  • The Vintage Guide to Love and Romance – Kirsty Greenwood
  • A Demon’s Guide to Wooing a Witch (Glimmer Falls #2) – Sarah Hawley
  • James Herriot’s Animal Storybook – James Herriot
  • We Are the Baby-Sitters Club: Essays and Artwork from Grown Up Readers – Marisa Crawford
  • The Nesting – C J Cooke
  • Five Have Plenty of Fun
  • Lies, Damned Lies, and History (Chronicles of St Mary’s #7) – Jodi Taylor

And I’m still working on:

  • Pride and Prejudice – Jane Austen
  • How to Date Your Dragon (Mystic Bayou #1) – Molly Harper
  • The Island of Adventure
  • Boy of Chaotic Making (Whimbrel House #3) – Charlie N Holmberg

What I have watched

  • I’ve still been watching Call the Midwife Series 13, as well as ER season 5 and 6 and I finally finished Time Traveller’s Wife. Such a shame there won’t be a series two. I might actually have to read the book now (or maybe watch the movie, to see what happened next.)
  • Tuesday nights we have still been watching season two of And Just Like That (the Sex and the City sequel) even though it’s so bad. The terrible knitwear in every episode has us shouting at the screen.
  • Stef and I watched the new Famous Five episode (reviews here and here) and then with Brodie we watched a couple of episodes of the 90s series (review to follow.) We also watched Miss Congeniality.

What I have done

  • We went to see The Rock Orchestra by Candlelight and it was amazing. They played loads of songs that we loved and they were just so good.
  • Then Stef arrived for a visit! Aside from watching the Famous Five we took Brodie to the park to make patrins, we went to Fife Zoo, and the V&A. Then we took ourselves off to St Andrews for the weekend. We had tickets for a book event at Topping and Co to see Sara Sheridan, but we also made time to get our feet wet (accidentally) in the extremely high tide as it washed over the harbour path.
  • I built another Harry Potter Hogwarts set which Brodie immediately claimed to play with – as they are modular you can mix and match the ‘rooms’ so we made quite a good set-up combining the Room of Requirement and the Battle of Hogwarts courtyard. I then bought myself a smaller set – the Polyjuice Potion bathroom and we added that in too. And then I bought the Herbology Classroom which I’ve been after for ages.
  • We went back to St Andrews again to go to the aquarium and visit the castle.
  • I helped my parents with clearing out their loft and claimed a huge box of my Babysitters Club books.

What I bought

I treated myself to another copy of Splendid Notes for Every Occasion as I found it in a charity shop for £2. I say another as I already have it, and the rest of the set. They’re too  nice to actually use however, but now I have a second set maybe I will actually use it!


How was your February?

Posted in Personal Experiences | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

Monday #569

First post of March already! So far March has remained fairly chilly, but there’s still time for it to get warmer – she says hopefully. We are in the period where it is spring but also is not spring, as it is past March 1st (meteorological spring) but we haven’t reached March 20th (astronomical spring). No wonder the weather doesn’t know what it’s doing.

February round up

and

Bill and Allie’s Great Adventure part 3

As I don’t have a product of the week (or a drink of the week) header I’m going to ask a question this week. Who has tried (or even heard of) Kirrin Island Ale?

Coming from a micro-brewery in Swanage it apparently tastes of Exotic tropical fruits, brought about by plenty of New Zealand hops, on a sweet soft golden malt. 

I won’t be trying it as no matter what flavours are promised all ales/beers taste just taste the same to me and I can’t stand them.

Posted in Blog talk | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Fan fic Friday: Bill and Allie’s Great Adventure chapter 2

Chapter one went up last week.

They had pulled together their wedding day in a few short weeks. Bill had a smart suit already and he had sent Allie into town to buy herself a new dress. Being a second wedding she had opted not to wear white but he hadn’t seen what she had picked yet.

The invites had been sent out, and the marriage licence had been obtained. The speed of things had been necessitated by the fact that the children were to return to school in September, and were absolutely refusing to miss the big day. Not that Bill or Allie would have dreamt of excluding them. Luckily the registry office had a morning slot the day before the children were due to leave for their boarding schools. 

The usually calm and cool Allie had become a little more flappable and was often heard saying things like before the wedding you must all make sure you are packed for school! and if you need anything new please tell me now so that I can go and order it!

Jack and Kiki had been severely reprimanded as the bird had been squawking Cold feet! Cold feet! Over and over and had also been caught pecking at the bag containing Allie’s new dress. 

Bill had some stern words of his own for Kiki when she had snuck into the room where he was trying to write his speech and muttering under his breath. She must have liked what she heard as she kept repeating What an ass! Such a poor Polly. What an ass!

Bill had jumped, banged his knee on the desktop, accidentally scored a line across his page, and shouted Bother you Kiki! Jack, come and get this bird RIGHT NOW!

Of course that had only led to Kiki cackling Bother you! Bless you! whenever she thought she would get away with it.

As this was Allie’s second wedding, and neither of them could be considered love’s young dream, they were keeping most things simple, much to everyone’s relief. One tradition they were sticking to was the groom not seeing the bride before the wedding.

“Is that just so you can avoid us in the morning?” Philip had asked cheekily when the plan was discussed.

“You, the chaos you will undoubtedly create, and particularly that wretched bird,” Bill had confirmed, giving Kiki a dark look. He hadn’t quite forgiven her for the What an ass debacle. Kiki had raised her crest slowly and said Cold feet in a mournful tone before adding a cough she had picked up from Uncle Geoffrey.

On the morning of the wedding Allie was being attended to by Dinah and Lucy-Ann who had both been rapturous in their delight over helping choose the dress, the flowers, the make-up and the hair. The boys meanwhile were only tasked with making themselves decent.

And Bill had Anatoly, his 20 year old surrogate nephew and best man, who didn’t particularly care for weddings (other than the free bar) even if he was pleased for him and Allie.

Anatoly was already dressed in a smart suit which complemented Bill’s when he arrived. Bill had insisted that Anatoly had his curly hair cut so that he would appear at least semi-presentable, so he was pleased to note that not only had Anatoly not managed to pick up a black eye or other obvious injuries right before the wedding, but he had also run a comb though his recently shorn curls.

“Not ready yet?” Anatoly asked, eyeing Bill’s attire, which consisted of his suit trousers and a vest.

“Top marks for observation,” Bill said with a laugh. “I’m just taking my time. No point in rushing when I don’t have to. I’ve shaved and -”

“Done your hair nicely?” Anatoly suggested, looking at Bill’s balding head from his slightly greater height; augmented by the fact he was the only one wearing shoes.

“Remind me why I didn’t choose Tim as my best man, out of gratitude for the Thamis rescue?” Bill shot back. He had invited Tim and a few of his other most trusted colleagues from his time in the SIS, but he was far closer to Anatoly whom he really saw as family despite there being no blood relationship at all. His relationship with Jack, Philip, Dinah and Lucy-Ann also went to prove that a family could be formed in many ways other than by blood.

When Anatoly just shrugged maddeningly and kept his face blank Bill gave up. “I’m going to finish getting dressed, you can pour the drinks in the meantime.”

Anatoly crossed to the drinks cabinet as Bill headed back upstairs. He was well acquainted with the contents of the cabinet so already knew exactly what he would find but he still spent a few moments lifting up the bottles to read the labels, occasionally pulling a face at some of Bill’s liquor choices. He settled on the vodka which Bill kept in for him. It wasn’t the finest stuff but it was an acceptable brand. He poured himself a generous measure (Bill was always complaining how quickly the bottle went down) and took it over to the window to sip as he looked outside.

He was just finishing it off when Bill came back downstairs, raising his eyebrows at the lack of a drink for him. Anatoly just shrugged again. “I did not know how long you would be. You like ice in your whisky and it might have melted.”

Bill fetched his own ice and poured his own drink. “As my best man you are supposed to do a little more than stand around drinking and insulting me.”

“I have to look after the rings,” Anatoly reminded him.

“You do, but only after I’ve given them to you,” Bill pointed out.

“Moral support.”

“Eh?”

Anatoly gave a long-suffering sigh that was a good imitation of the ones Bill so often gave him. “I am providing you with moral support.”

“Are you? I don’t feel particularly supported yet. Is your mere presence supposed to be helpful?”

“Are you anxious? Nervous? Panicking at all?” Anatoly asked him, grinning when Bill paused to consider. “Nyet. You are far too busy being annoyed with me to be getting your feet cold.”

Ignoring the incorrect phrasing – he suspected that Anatoly did it deliberately, at least most of the time, just because he thought it was funny – Bill had to acknowledge that Anatoly had a point. He wasn’t terribly anxious about getting married, but he did have his worries about making sure that the day went without a hitch and everyone had a good time. 

He didn’t anticipate too many threats to the smooth running of events. Jack and Kiki had been extremely well warned about Kiki’s behaviour and the bird was to be taken out at the first sign of trouble. If Jack had to miss parts of the festivities then so be it.

Micky wouldn’t be a problem as with Allie refusing to be responsible for a monkey during term time, he had recently been adopted by a local retired colonel from an Indian regiment who had long experience with exotic pets. The colonel had responded to an advert that Allie had placed in the newspaper, offering a monkey for sale, reasonable offers considered. The other people who had responded had all been circus and zoo owners, so when Micky had taken an obvious and immediate liking to the ruddy-faced colonel as he had regaled them all with the monkeys he had known in his lifetime, Philip and Allie had decided he was the best choice. When he agreed that Philip could visit Micky whenever he wanted during the holidays he had been told that he could have Micky for free, and they had shaken on the deal.

With the animal threats taken care of, there was not much else to worry about. But annoyingly Anatoly was right – his attitude was distracting Bill from repeatedly running over the day’s schedule, his vows and other details of the day.

To be continued.

Posted in Fan fiction | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

The Famous Five 2020s Style: The Curse of Kirrin Island, part 2

Last week I posted a transcript of the conversation Stef and I had as we watched this for the first time. It was pretty lengthy so I kept back Stef’s more in-depth thoughts and will post them here along with mine.


An interview with Stef

I asked Stef what she thought and had planned to just let her talk, but couldn’t help from interrupting!

Stef: are you sure that you want my honest opinion?

It had potential in the first – generously – ten minutes.

Then… it just… spiralled into this crazy utter mess that just… doesn’t match with any of the Famous Five energy. And… although it says based on, quite honestly I think Blyton would have been appalled. There were too many what-the-heck moments to really highlight what the daftest thing they did was. I’m kinda thankful we didn’t have to see them escaping through the crypt underground tunnel as that was a stretch and a half. It was all a stretch and a half.

Though, the end, on the beach, coming back to Kirrin Cottage, and agreeing to keep the secret and whatever, that ties into the rest of the Famous Five energy.

[Fiona: so basically the problem was just everything in the middle?]

Yes. [Clearly looking for something positive to say] Julian was the best cast.

[Fiona: but underutilised?]

Yes. Presumably to make way for George, as an ethnically diverse female lead to try to make it more relevant for today’s younger audience.

Dick and Anne did not live up to expectations at all. They were not in the slightest what they should have been. They tried to make Anne into Dick and Dick into a geek and a bit of Anne. I can understand why, you’ve got your fearless leader and you can also have chaps that are knowledgeable but scared and they balance each other out. But no. Just no.

They were both underutilised in the end. Had we had more of them…

[Fiona: and less of the crazy ramblings of the bad people?]

Yes. More screen time to come into their characters. Reminds me of the 7os Five who took a long time to tap into their character. In my humble opinion.

I then started talking again.

Fiona: I read criticism about Fanny being a writer, the money maker, making Quentin a useless potterer but I didn’t see that at all.

Stef: I think they got the power balance right.

Fiona: Well, they were barely in it.

Stef: She probably took up writing to get by while he tried to invent.

Fiona: Obviously she’s not making a fortune as they’re still poor.

Stef: Interesting the thing they through in about Jack being in the secret service.

Fiona: But it didn’t go anywhere

Stef: It had potential to tie in.


Potential?

I think potential is a key word here. There was a lot of potential in the ideas used but unfortunately there were perhaps too many ideas. The Five were never ones to need to travel into the big city to visit a crypt to find a clue to bring back to Kirrin – it was far too Dan Brown or Indiana Jones.

There were several plot lines that went nowhere – but perhaps these are going to be fleshed out in the next episode(s). With the baddie’s mother, for example, there seemed to be more story than what we were shown. Annie’s death – but no body being found. The body found on the beach but never mentioned again.

I agree with Stef that neither the characters or the storyline lived up to expectations. Julian was the best (isn’t he always?) while George was decent but we just didn’t see enough of what makes her George. The initial introduction to her cousins, and them making friends is very fast. Book George takes time to warm up to them, to fully trust them and to learn that sharing can be fun.

The same goes with Timmy – she finds him one minute and the next he is a fully formed member of the Five. The thing about book Timmy is that he is supremely loyal and George has trained him to follow her every command. The dog playing Timmy was obviously able to follow commands but most of the time I forgot he was there as he wasn’t spoken to, wasn’t involved in the action. In the underground scenes he stays outside of the circular room, begging the question how he joined them again later.

Actually, now I think about it, I now question how they got George’s boat back. They slide down the tunnel and are fired into the sea, then swim back. (Kirrin Island is supposed to be too far out/in too choppy water/too rocky to swim to, of course.)

I’m getting off the topic of potential now…


The cast

I think the only actor I didn’t like was Jack Gleeson, probably the biggest name in it. He was just far too pantomime and over-the-top to be taken seriously.

While I didn’t like the way Anne and Dick behaved in the episode Flora Jacoby Richardson and Kit Rakusen played their reimagined versions of the characters well.

George (Diaana Babnicova) had some nice stroppiness, and Elliott Rose was convincing as the oldest and in charge member of the Five, though he was underutilised.

Fanny (Ann Akinjirin) and Quentin (James Lance) were largely relegated to the background but we did get a sense of Quentin being impatient (if not hugely irritable) and Fanny trying to keep the peace.


Final thoughts

I will say something I often say about Blyton continuation books: If this had been an adventure film/episode about a newly invented group of children (in any era) it could have been quite enjoyable. As an entry into the Famous Five canon, it is not good.

It failed to capture much of what the Five were about as it spent too long focussing on things like Mr Wentworth and his evil machinations, the trip to London, and Anne being whiny. I mean it’s the Famous Five and the only thing they ate the entire time was some of the cake Mrs Wentworth gave them!

Besides that I wasn’t keen on the soft-focus that was used heavily throughout (not least because it made taking screen-caps so hard) or the 80s synth music which played most of the way through. However, the clothing (converse aside) and the locations were good. I particularly liked Julian’s shirt-and-braces look, while at least Dick got to rock a Paul Child worthy pullover.

 

Posted in Blyton on TV | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment