My top ten Buffett songs : r/jimmybuffett Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/jimmybuffett icon
r/jimmybuffett icon
Go to jimmybuffett
r/jimmybuffett
A banner for the subreddit

A place to share things related to Jimmy Buffett. Welcome Parrotheads!


Members Online

My top ten Buffett songs

I saw someone do this earlier in the week and I enjoyed reading what everyone had to say about that list so I’m intrigued to read the comments about mine. Here it is!

  1. Tin Cup Chalice

  2. Nautical Wheelers

  3. The Wino And I Know

  4. Cowboy In The Jungle

  5. School Boy Heart

  6. Trying To Reason With Hurricane Season

  7. A Pirate Looks At Forty

  8. Banana Republics

  9. Come Monday

  10. Death Of An Unpopular Poet

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options
u/Size14-OrangeDiver avatar

I agree with almost all of those. 1,2,5,6,7,8,10.

I also love:

Coast of Carolina

He Went To Paris

Bama Breeze

Changing Channels

One Particular Harbour

I’m including Floridays for my daughter, she loves that song.

Changes in Latitudes/Attitudes may always be my favorite. That time in your life when something just makes sense. Yesterdays are over my shoulder, I can’t look back for too long, there’s just too much to see, waiting in front of me, and I know that I just can’t go wrong.

But truthfully, favorite songs change over the years, and especially change with your mood. I’ve been especially enjoying the softer, slower songs these past 10 years. I guess I’m just growing older. Not up.

u/Kooky_Introduction28 avatar

Huge fan of the Floridays updated arrangement from the Hoot soundtrack.

u/Size14-OrangeDiver avatar

Sad to say I have not heard about that. And it appears to be a difficult to find album. I’ll keep trying.

first look is such a damn good song. whole LP is timeless

More replies
More replies
u/Ngata_da_Vida avatar

I feel like Havana Daydreamin’ never gets any love. It’s my favorite Buffett song.

Yes

More replies
u/angrypelican29 avatar

So close! lol. Drop 2/8/10 for changes in lattitude, incommunicado and weather is here.

u/lclassyfun avatar

This is an excellent list. Trying To Reason might be my all-time favorite but I also have a special place for Little Miss Magic, I used to play that one for my daughter when she was a toddler and it still holds a special place for both of us.

u/Ecroberts73 avatar

I'm here for every top ten. I'd say I don't always agree, but mine change so often, and I often read someone's top ten and think, "Ohhhh, that is a great song. I might have to include that in mine."

I'm not sure if I ever actually agree or disagree.

How about Live recordings vs studio? JB’s songs evolved over time. Some got longer and some disappeared. In listening to many versions over the years I believe there’s magic in both; One Particular Harbor” being a good example. But now that he’s gone, I’m enjoying the live songs again, especially “The Great Filling Station Holdup” and “This Hotel Room” Mac and Jimmy at their best imo I can’t seem to nail down a top ten just yet, maybe a little too soon. I wonder what it would have been like to see Mac and Jimmy finish up a show with an acoustic encore of “Audience of One”?

Not to imply this list isn't going to change tomorrow. There's just too many greats. Today, the rotation goes:

  1. Tin Cup Chalice

  2. Livingston Saturday Night

  3. Boat Drinks

  4. The Weather is Here, Wish You Were Beautiful

  5. One Particular Harbour

  6. Jamaica Mistaica

  7. He Went to Paris

  8. A Pirate Looks at Forty

  9. I Heard I Was in Town

  10. Someday I Will

My top ten changes every few months lmao. I just can’t make a definitive list. It’s impossible.

Some others that you didn’t mention I also love:

I’m No Russian

Bama Breeze

Margaritaville (one day I think it’s overplayed then I listen to it again and realize how great it is)

Johnny’s Rhum

Desperation Samba

Only Time will Tell

Tides

Jamaica Mistaica

Mile High in Denver

Floridays

Nothin’ but a Breeze

Life is Just a Tire Swing

Portugal or PEI

Diamond as big as the Ritz

One Particular Harbor

Still bummed out I never got to see one of his concerts live!

u/sschmeh avatar

Love this list too!!!

Good list. West Nashville Grand Ballroom Gown is in my top, along with Migration.

Depends on the day. Lone Palm is on my list