What To Watch If You Love 'Midnight Mass'

watchworthy
Updated May 2, 2024 45 items
Voting Rules
Vote up the films and television series that you know other fans of 'Midnight Mass' will love.

Looking for more shows like Midnight Mass? We’ve compiled this list of movies and TV shows similar to Midnight Mass, the Netflix supernatural horror drama centered on an isolated island community that experiences unexplainable events after the arrival of a mysterious priest. 

With lots of options, including The Haunting of Hill House, a scary series from Midnight Mass creator Mike Flanagan, and even movies like Oculus, a film directed by Flanagan, deciding what to watch after Midnight Mass will really just depend on your mood.

Vote up the best movies and shows like Midnight Mass so other fans know what to watch next. Thanks to streaming services like Netflix, Hulu, HBO Max, Disney Plus, and Prime Video, you can start streaming these movies and shows right now.

With more than 40 million people visiting Ranker every month, we are able to offer you data-driven recommendations based on voting across thousands of film & TV polls.

  • The Haunting of Bly Manor
    Photo: The Haunting of Bly Manor
    1
    8 votes

    The Haunting of Bly Manor

    For fans of: scary drama series from Mike Flanagan

    The Haunting of Bly Manor, a chilling exploration of love and loss, envelops viewers in an atmospheric journey through a haunted English estate. This gothic horror series, created by Mike Flanagan, has garnered critical acclaim, solidifying its place among the genre's finest offerings. With a compelling narrative that weaves together past and present, the show delves into the tragic lives of its characters, such as the enigmatic governess Dani Clayton (Victoria Pedretti) and the tormented Peter Quint (Oliver Jackson-Cohen). The Haunting of Bly Manor captivates audiences with its eerie ambiance, complex relationships, and spine-tingling mysteries, leaving an indelible mark on the landscape of supernatural storytelling.
    More The Haunting of Bly ManorRight Arrow
  • Lisey's Story
    Photo: Lisey's Story
    2
    5 votes

    Lisey's Story

    For fans of: horror drama series

    Venturing into the realm of psychological horror, Lisey's Story is a gripping tale that delves deep into the complex world of love, grief, and the intricacies of the human mind. Based on the novel by renowned author Stephen King, the show masterfully intertwines elements of suspense and emotion, earning several award nominations in the process. The plot follows the life of Lisey Landon (played by Julianne Moore) as she navigates through her late husband's dark past, unraveling chilling secrets that test the boundaries of reality. With a powerful ensemble cast and a meticulously crafted narrative, Lisey's Story is a hauntingly beautiful experience that leaves a lasting impression on its audience.
    More Lisey's StoryRight Arrow
  • The Haunting of Hill House
    Photo: The Haunting of Hill House
    3
    4 votes

    The Haunting of Hill House

    For fans of: scary drama series from Mike Flanagan

    The Haunting of Hill House, a gripping supernatural drama series, masterfully delves into the complexities of family dynamics and the chilling effects of past traumas. With its intricately woven narrative and superb acting, the show garnered numerous award nominations, including a Saturn Award for Best Streaming Horror & Thriller Series. The Crain family, led by parents Hugh (Henry Thomas) and Olivia (Victoria Pedretti), navigate the harrowing experiences that follow their stay in the notorious Hill House. As the story unfolds, viewers are treated to a rich tapestry of emotional depth and spine-tingling suspense that keeps them guessing until the very end.
  • Doctor Sleep
    Photo: Warner Bros. Pictures
    4
    4 votes

    Doctor Sleep

    For fans of: scary dramas from Mike Flanagan

    In Doctor Sleep, a horror drama directed by Mike Flanagan, Danny Torrance (Ewan McGregor) grapples with his traumatic past. His life takes an eerie turn when he encounters Abra (Kyliegh Curran), a teenager possessing a powerful psychic gift. The sinister Rose the Hat (Rebecca Ferguson) and her followers, The True Knot, threaten their survival. This movie, a sequel to The Shining, masterfully blends suspense and supernatural elements as it follows Danny's struggle against dark forces. Despite confronting his own demons, Danny must protect Abra from the looming danger that is The True Knot.
    More Doctor SleepRight Arrow
  • Gerald's Game
    Photo: Gerald's Game / Netflix
    5
    6 votes

    Gerald's Game

    For fans of: scary dramas from Mike Flanagan

    Gerald's Game is a 2017 American survival horror film directed by Mike Flanagan, based on Stephen King's novel. While trying to spice up their marriage in their remote lake house, Jessie (Carla Gugino) must fight to survive when her husband dies unexpectedly, leaving her handcuffed to their bed frame.
    More Gerald's GameRight Arrow
  • Chapelwaite
    Photo: Chapelwaite
    6
    3 votes

    Chapelwaite

    For fans of: supernatural horror series featuring vampires

    Captain Charles Boone relocates his three children to his ancestral home after his wife dies at sea.
    More ChapelwaiteRight Arrow
  • Haunted
    Photo: Haunted
    7
    3 votes

    Haunted

    For fans of: paranormal drama series

    Haunted, a chilling Netflix original series that premiered on October 19, 2018, dives into a spine-tingling format where real people sit down with friends and family to share terrifying true stories from their past, re-created through chilling re-enactments. Although there are no regular cast members or voice actors due to its anthology nature, each episode features a new set of individuals ready to divulge their encounters with the supernatural. The show delves deep into the dark and eerie themes of hauntings, demonic possessions, and other unexplained phenomena that have left a haunting impact on the lives of those who experienced them. Haunted has captured viewers' imaginations with its blend of personal storytelling and horror, garnering attention for its attempt to bring authentic and paranormal experiences to the screen.
  • A Discovery of Witches
    Photo: A Discovery of Witches
    8
    5 votes

    A Discovery of Witches

    For fans of: atmospheric horror series  

    A Discovery of Witches, based on the eponymous novel by Deborah Harkness, plunges viewers into an enchanting world where witches, vampires, and daemons coexist. The show follows the journey of historian Diana Bishop (Teresa Palmer), a reluctant witch who stumbles upon a mysterious manuscript that propels her into the heart of a centuries-old conflict. Alongside enigmatic vampire Matthew Clairmont (Matthew Goode), the duo navigates the precarious balance between supernatural factions. Garnering acclaim for its lush visuals and gripping storyline, the series has captured the imaginations of fans worldwide, earning multiple award nominations in the process.
  • Squid Game
    Photo: Netflix
    9
    5 votes

    Squid Game

    For fans of: thrilling Netflix drama series 

    In the realm of television, there occasionally emerges a show that transcends borders and becomes a global phenomenon. Squid Game is a prime example of this, with its gripping narrative centered around a deadly competition that unfolds within a dystopian society. The South Korean thriller, directed by Hwang Dong-hyuk, has captivated audiences worldwide, earning critical acclaim and several award nominations. Through its intricate storytelling and compelling character development, particularly that of Seong Gi-hun (Lee Jung-jae) and Cho Sang-woo (Park Hae-soo), Squid Game delves into themes of morality, social inequality, and survival, all while maintaining an air of suspense that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats.
    More Squid GameRight Arrow
  • Black Spot
    Photo: Black Spot / France 2
    10
    12 votes

    Black Spot

    For fans of: horror drama series

    Black Spot (France 2, 2017) a is a French-Belgian television thriller created by Mathieu Missoffe. A prosecutor comes home to learn why the town's murder rate is six times the national average.
    More Black SpotRight Arrow
  • Dracula
    Photo: Dracula
    11
    6 votes

    Dracula

    For fans of: horror series featuring vampires

    In a dark and atmospheric reinvention of Bram Stoker's classic tale, this gripping series delves into the life of the enigmatic Count Dracula (Claes Bang), as he navigates the Victorian-era London with a sinister charm. Balancing horror and drama, the show masterfully intertwines the iconic vampire's lust for blood with his yearning for human connection. The audience is drawn into the battle of wits between Dracula and the fearless vampire hunter, Van Helsing (Dolly Wells), who is determined to bring an end to his reign of terror. Garnering critical acclaim for its enthralling storytelling and remarkable performances, this adaptation has breathed new life into the legendary character and left viewers thirsty for more.
    More DraculaRight Arrow
  • Legacies
    Photo: Legacies
    12
    6 votes

    Legacies

    For fans of: supernatural horror series featuring vampires

    In a world where supernatural beings coexist, Legacies brings forth an enthralling tale of adventure, friendship, and self-discovery. As a spin-off of the critically acclaimed series, The Vampire Diaries and The Originals, this fantasy drama has earned a dedicated fan base. Centered around Hope Mikaelson (Danielle Rose Russell), the tribrid daughter of Klaus Mikaelson and Hayley Marshall, the story unfolds at the Salvatore School for the Young and Gifted. This unique institution provides a haven for young vampires, werewolves, and witches to learn control over their powers and navigate through the complexities of life. With its intriguing plotlines and dynamic character development, Legacies continues to enchant audiences as it delves into the mysteries of this supernatural universe.
    More LegaciesRight Arrow
  • Hush
    Photo: Netflix
    13
    4 votes

    Hush

    For fans of: scary dramas from Mike Flanagan

    In Hush, Maddie Young (Kate Siegel) is a deaf-mute author, living in isolation. A serene existence in the woods, punctuated by her writing and the companionship of her cat. But tranquillity shatters when a masked intruder (John Gallagher Jr.) invades her solitude. The film, directed by Mike Flanagan, is a thriller that plays on the senses. It's a nightmarish game of cat-and-mouse, where silence isn't just golden; it's survival. Hush treads the line between horror and suspense, immersing viewers into Maddie's silent world while keeping them on edge with its relentless tension.
    More HushRight Arrow
  • American Horror Story: Double Feature
    Photo: American Horror Story / FX
    14
    4 votes

    American Horror Story: Double Feature

    For fans of: atmospheric horror series featuring vampires

    A struggling writer and his family move to an isolated beach town for the winter..
  • Lovecraft Country
    Photo: Lovecraft Country
    15
    13 votes

    Lovecraft Country

    For fans of: supernatural horror drama series

    Atticus Black embarks on a road trip across 1950s Jim Crow America in search of his missing father.
    More Lovecraft CountryRight Arrow
  • Hemlock Grove
    Photo: Hemlock Grove
    16
    2 votes

    Hemlock Grove

    For fans of: horror series set in a small town

    In the mysterious town of Hemlock Grove, audiences are immersed in a web of supernatural occurrences and thrilling secrets. This horror-fantasy series, which received two Primetime Emmy nominations, skillfully balances elements of intrigue and suspense with well-developed characters. The plot revolves around the unlikely friendship between Roman Godfrey (Bill Skarsgård), a wealthy heir with a dark side, and Peter Rumancek (Landon Liboiron), a newcomer with enigmatic abilities. As they navigate their way through a series of chilling events, viewers are drawn into a world where nothing is quite as it seems, and every revelation leads to yet another twist.
    More Hemlock GroveRight Arrow
  • No One Gets Out Alive
    Photo: No One Gets Out Alive
    17
    2 votes

    No One Gets Out Alive

    For fans of: atmospheric horror features

    Desperate and without documentation, a woman from Mexico moves into a rundown Cleveland boardinghouse. Then the unsettling cries and eerie visions begin.
    More No One Gets Out AliveRight Arrow
  • 30 Days of Night
    Photo: 30 Days of Night / Sony Pictures Releasing
    18
    2 votes

    30 Days of Night

    For fans of: vampire movies set in a small town

    In the chilling horror thriller 30 Days of Night, Barrow, Alaska's northernmost town, plunges into a month-long darkness. Sheriff Eben Oleson (Josh Hartnett) and his estranged wife, Stella (Melissa George), find themselves battling a savage group of blood-thirsty vampires led by Marlow (Danny Huston). As the sun sets for an extended period, the town becomes a gruesome playground for this relentless predator. The townspeople's survival hinges on Eben and Stella's bravery and cunning. Amidst the perpetual night and Arctic cold, they wage a desperate fight against time and terror.
    More 30 Days of NightRight Arrow
  • Panic
    Photo: Panic
    19
    3 votes

    Panic

    For fans of: dark drama series

    Panic is a thrilling drama series that delves into the lives of high school graduates in the small, economically-strapped town of Carp, Texas, where a high-stakes game offers a chance for escape. Each summer, the graduating seniors risk their lives competing in a series of challenges that force them to confront their deepest fears for the opportunity to win life-changing money. As secrets start surfacing and the stakes rise, these teens must decide how much they are willing to risk to leave their hometown behind. The show stars Olivia Scott Welch, Mike Faist, and Jessica Sula, and it examines themes of desperation, camaraderie, and ambition.
    More PanicRight Arrow
  • V-Wars
    Photo: V Wars
    20
    3 votes

    V-Wars

    For fans of: horror series featuring vampires

    In a world where a mysterious virus turns humans into bloodthirsty creatures, V-Wars explores the complexities of survival, morality, and human nature. As an adaptation of Jonathan Maberry's graphic novels, this sci-fi horror series presents a gripping narrative led by Dr. Luther Swann (Ian Somerhalder) and his best friend-turned-vampire, Michael Fayne (Adrian Holmes). With its engaging storyline, the show has garnered a dedicated fan base, while also receiving critical acclaim for its fresh take on the genre. V-Wars delves into the challenges faced by its characters as they navigate a society torn apart by fear, violence, and the ever-present threat of an unstoppable pandemic.
    More V-WarsRight Arrow
  • Absentia
    Photo: Absentia / Phase 4 Films
    21
    4 votes

    Absentia

    For fans of: scary dramas from director Mike Flanagan

    Absentia is a 2011 horror film written and directed by Mike Flanagan and produced by FallBack Plan Productions. The film's principal photography phase was funded by way of the film's project page on crowd funding website Kickstarter. Courtney Bell stars as a pregnant woman whose missing husband briefly reappears after an unexplained seven year absence.
  • Evil
    Photo: Evil
    22
    4 votes

    Evil

    A psychologist joins a priest-in-training and a carpenter as they investigate unexplained mysteries.
    More EvilRight Arrow
  • Friday Night Lights
    Photo: Friday Night Lights
    23
    1 votes

    Friday Night Lights

    For fans of: series featuring Zach Gilford

    Delving into the lives of a small-town Texas community, Friday Night Lights weaves an intricate tapestry of both on-field and off-field drama. Centered around the Dillon Panthers high school football team, the show masterfully balances the intense world of competitive sports with the personal journeys of its ensemble cast. Coach Eric Taylor (Kyle Chandler) leads the team with unwavering determination, while his wife Tami (Connie Britton) provides steadfast support as the school's guidance counselor. With multiple Emmy nominations to its name, Friday Night Lights offers an authentic glimpse into the heart and soul of America's beloved pastime, capturing the passion, heartache, and triumphs that come with chasing dreams under the bright stadium lights.
    More Friday Night LightsRight Arrow
  • iZombie
    Photo: iZombie
    24
    1 votes

    iZombie

    For fans of: supernatural horror series featuring Rahul Kohli

    In a fresh twist on the zombie genre, iZombie explores the life of Liv Moore (Rose McIver), a medical resident turned undead, as she navigates her newfound hunger for brains and its unexpected side effects. With a mix of crime-solving and dark humor, this critically acclaimed series keeps viewers engaged while confronting the complexities of Liv's dual existence. Boasting a talented ensemble cast, the show has been nominated for multiple awards, including a Leo Award for Best Lead Performance by a Female in a Dramatic Series. As Liv grapples with retaining her humanity, iZombie delivers an intriguing balance of wit, emotion, and suspense.
    More iZombieRight Arrow
  • Intrusion
    Photo: Intrusion / Netflix
    25
    1 votes

    Intrusion

    For fans of: atmospheric horror series  

    When a husband and wife move to a small town, a home invasion leaves the wife traumatized and suspicious that those around her might not be who they seem.
    More IntrusionRight Arrow
  • Tell Me Your Secrets
    Photo: Tell Me Your Secrets
    26
    1 votes

    Tell Me Your Secrets

    For fans of: thrilling series featuring Hamish Linklater

    Unraveling the intricate web of deceit and secrets, this gripping psychological thriller navigates the lives of three morally ambiguous characters. Emma (Lily Rabe), a former convict, John (Hamish Linklater), a grieving therapist, and Mary (Amy Brenneman), a desperate mother, are brought together by their dark pasts as they search for redemption. The show has garnered attention for its stellar performances and well-crafted narrative arcs. While exploring the depths of human nature, it raises questions on the duality of good and evil within each individual. With unexpected twists and turns, Tell Me Your Secrets keeps viewers on the edge of their seats, leaving them eager for more.
    More Tell Me Your SecretsRight Arrow
  • Legion
    Photo: Legion
    27
    1 votes

    Legion

    For fans of: thrilling series featuring Hamish Linklater

    Legion, a marvelously crafted psychological thriller, dives deep into the complexities of the human mind while exploring the fascinating world of mutants. Garnering critical acclaim and multiple award nominations, this show masterfully weaves intricate storytelling with stunning visuals, leaving viewers on the edge of their seats. The protagonist, David Haller (Dan Stevens), grapples with his perceived mental illness only to discover that he possesses extraordinary abilities. As the narrative unfolds, an ensemble of compelling characters, each with their own unique powers, join David in a gripping journey full of unexpected twists and turns, challenging the very notion of reality itself.
    More LegionRight Arrow
  • Van Helsing
    Photo: Van Helsing
    28
    1 votes

    Van Helsing

    For fans of: supernatural horror series featuring vampires

    In a post-apocalyptic world ravaged by vampires, Van Helsing emerges as a beacon of hope and survival. This thrilling drama series follows the story of Vanessa Helsing (Kelly Overton), a descendant of the legendary vampire hunter Abraham Van Helsing. With her unique blood composition granting immunity to vampires and the ability to turn them back into humans, Vanessa becomes humanity's last chance for salvation. Throughout its five-season run, the show garnered a dedicated fanbase and praise for its gripping narrative, impressive visual effects, and stellar performances, particularly by Jonathan Scarfe as Axel Miller, a Marine with unwavering loyalty to the cause.
    More Van HelsingRight Arrow
  • Thirst
    Photo: Thirst
    29
    1 votes

    Thirst

    For fans of: atmospheric vampire movies  

    Sang-hyun (Song Kang-ho), a respected priest, volunteers for an experimental procedure that may lead to a cure for a deadly virus. He gets infected and dies, but a blood transfusion of unknown origin brings him back to life as a vampire. Now, Sang-hyun is torn between faith and bloodlust, and has a newfound desire for Tae-ju (Kim Ok-bin), the wife of his childhood friend.
    More ThirstRight Arrow
  • True Blood
    Photo: True Blood
    30
    1 votes

    True Blood

    For fans of: supernatural horror series featuring vampires

    Vampires walk the Earth using synthetic blood.
    More True BloodRight Arrow