Does anyone think Michael Madsen is a decent actor? : r/moviecritic Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
Go to moviecritic
r/moviecritic

A subreddit for movie reviews and discussions


Members Online
ā€¢

Does anyone think Michael Madsen is a decent actor?

I can't think of a role I've liked him in, I've never heard anyone deliver lines as poorly as him

r/moviecritic - Does anyone think Michael Madsen is a decent actor?
Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options
u/Jj9567 avatar
ā€¢

You gonna bark all day little doggie, or you gonna bite?

I bet you're a big Lee Marvin fan? Me too.

Paint your wagon... with blood.

"Gonna paint a wagon, gonna paint it fine, gonna use oil-based paint because the wood is pine"

One of my all-time favorite Simpsons quote.

More replies
More replies

Kid Shaleen! ("Cat Ballou")

More replies
More replies
u/copperdoc avatar

Loved him in kill bill

ā€¢

reservoir dogs

u/Puzzleheaded-Plan450 avatar

Love him in hateful eight too

SHUT THE GODDAMNED DOOR!

"PUT TWO NAILS IN! ONES NOT GONNA HOLD SHIT!"

more replies More replies
more reply More replies
More replies

Donnie Brasco

Donnie Brasco is also the answer. Not every rat bastard can upstage Al Pacino. But he got really angry and mean in that movie. True stories, go figure

ā€¢ ā€¢ Edited

Sonny Black. Iirc they never recovered his head in real life šŸ˜³ Edit: the body they found didnā€™t have hands and was decomposed. Itā€™s not 100% certain that itā€™s his body either.

more replies More replies
more reply More replies
More replies
u/bulgarian_zucchini avatar

Are you gonna bark all day little doggy? Or are you gonna bite?

The Hateful Eight was great, too, as was Donnie Brasco.

Nice Guy Eddie: So nobody knows what happened to Mr. Blue?

Mr. Blonde: Either heā€™s alive, or heā€™s dead, or the cops got him, or they donā€™tā€¦.?

Hahahaha brilliant lines throughout this whole movie

Stuck in the middle with you..

More replies

This is his best one for sure. His friendly, amiable attitude at the beginning somehow fit perfectly into his switch into a cold blooded psychopath. Rewatching his first scenes is eerie, because itā€™s not like heā€™s hiding his true nature, he just thinks nothing of it.

More replies
u/copperdoc avatar

That too!

u/mrpink01 avatar
ā€¢

I'm all ears!

Are you gonna bark all day little doggy...or are you gonna bite...pretty iconic line in cinema

u/-Motor- avatar
ā€¢

Its the same character....

u/Flimsy-Technician524 avatar

He was good in Reservoir Dogs, but it was a one note role.

Torture you?

u/Vegetable_Cloud_1355 avatar

That's a good idea. . . I like that.

more reply More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
u/CameronPoe37 avatar

Love the scene where he's sat outside his trailer with Bill

"That woman.... deserves her revenge. And... we deserve to die."

I make my Madsen lookalike friend say it all the time. Pretty sure it got him laid once.

ā€¢

Iā€™m a bouncer at a titty bar bill

"....there ain't no one out there to bounce"

More replies

"But then again. So does she. So, I guess, we'll just see. Won't we?"

More replies

A week ago, I would have said reservoirs dogs as my first shout, but I literally just rewatched both kill bills the other dayā€¦ He is quite good in volume 2. A pretty cool character too.

His character seemed to know exactly who he was in Volume 2, which is a trait I find admirable in real life as well.

U hocked a Hatori Hanzo sword? It was priceless.

Lol. Not in El Paso it ain't. In El Paso, I got me $250 dollars for it.

The fact that Budd sits there and lies to Bill, stone-faced. Not too many people would do that willingly, given the way the story unfolds.

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
ā€¢

Loved his ā€œMaybe we deserve to die.ā€ monologue outside his trailer.

u/Vegetable_Cloud_1355 avatar

Word. In that movie I think he very aptly captured a certain sentiment. As much as I generally pride myself on always trying to do the right thing, there's a few times in my life that I've kinda arrived at a certain point and realized that even I am not rooting for me but for various reasons felt unable to change my role or actions. At those times I generally have gotten this sense of grim inevitability and not even tried to step out of the way of consequences - because in the world that I want to live in, FAFO always applies. I feel like he captured that vibe quite well.

More replies
u/nthensome avatar

Tarantino wrote the part of Vincent Vega in Pulp Fiction for him but he was tied up doing reshoot for another movie (Wyatt Earp, I believe) and Quentin had to go with his 2nd choice, John Travolta, instead.

Imagine the career Madsen would have had if schedules didn't conflict.

And you'd have to image that Travolta probably would be a distant 70s Barbarino memory & nothing more

He certainly wouldnā€™t own his own jumbo jet.

Madsen didn't join Scientology. So no, no jumbo jet.

More replies

Tarrantino also wanted Lawrence Fishburne to play Jules Winfield, but he couldn't make the film, so Tarrantino cast Samuel Jackson, based on his strength in the Die Hard movie.
It would have been a much different movie with Madsen and Fishburne in those roles.
And Vincent Vega seemed like Vinnie Barbarino in his 40's to me.

u/therealrexmanning avatar

so Tarrantino cast Samuel Jackson, based on his strength in the Die Hard movie.

Considering Die Hard was released a year later, I don't think that's entirely accurate.

More replies
More replies
u/Throwawaylmao2937372 avatar

Daddy Daud in Dishonored šŸ‘šŸ»

That whole cast of Kill Bill were amazing. Hottake but I reckon Daryl Hannah should have been nominated for Best Supporting Actress. And dare I say Vivica too.. despite having a very short performance.

u/copperdoc avatar

I agree. I was a Daryl Hannah fan since seeing her in Blade Runner in the theaters. I loved watching her in this role, another villain but this time an absolute psychopath

More replies
More replies

"ain't nobody badass with two tits full of rock salt!"

ā€¢

Yessir! One of my favourite lines that I use all the time in real life (mainly with my infant son after giving him a bottle) is, 'That gentled you down some, didn't it?'

"Wakey wakey...eggs and Bacey"

More replies

He killed it.

More replies

Thereā€™s his nameā€¦. Whoops, there went his nameā€¦

In the hospital, watched Kill Bill on AMC. That line "That woman Deserves her Revenge. And we deserve to die," gives me a chill every time.

Species.

Wakey Wakey! Eggs and bakey!

u/Conscious_Street9937 avatar

He's about as useless as an ass hole right here

u/NewBuddha32 avatar

Came here to say this

I watched it again the other day he had a distracting amount of makeup on for a dero living in a caravan. But good on him look good feel good.

More replies
More replies
u/IBeMeaty avatar
ā€¢

Heā€™s not exactly the best of the best, sure, but most of what Iā€™ve seen him cast in is perfect. Lack of range doesnā€™t always mean lack of ability.

Madsen is one of those actors that needs a good director. He isnā€™t gonna carry the story himself but he is the PERFECT actor with a part written for his demeanor. Probably why is best roles are Tarantino movies. Same with John Travolta.

u/IBeMeaty avatar
ā€¢

Well said. And I hope your year in the waste management sector is off to a wonderful start, Mr. Barone.

u/johnniesSac avatar

Fuckin Dick Barone

more replies More replies

I took a step back from the company after dying of Lou Gehrig's disease :/

more reply More replies
More replies
More replies
u/oldbuc avatar
ā€¢ ā€¢ Edited

That was well said

So was this

u/RondaArousedMe avatar

It was at least well spaced.

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
u/PhillyCSpires avatar
ā€¢ ā€¢ Edited

ā€Lack of range doesnā€™t always mean lack of abilityā€ will be Keanu Reeveā€™s eulogy.

And I say this as someone who worships the ground that man walks on.

More replies

That's a pretty decent way of looking at it I think

u/HurricaneAlpha avatar

Dude fits in a profile and knows it. Gotta respect that.

u/idleat1100 avatar

Yeah Iā€™d add that he has that ā€œitā€ quality. Not in droves like a marquee star, but he has some.

u/Ghosts_of_the_maze avatar

You know what they say about actors who get typecast. They pay off their mortgage

Itā€™s the reason I argue with people about Keanu. Keanu is one of the greatest action stars of all time. The physicality he has is not easy. He just has a narrow range.

u/Torgo-A-GoGo avatar

I think it's kind of a silly question to ask is he a decent actor. I agree with your assessment and think just about anybody who likes the type of movies he's in thinks he's a quite good actor.

More replies
u/Green-Instruction729 avatar

I like him. Have you seen hateful eight?

u/hjf80 avatar
ā€¢

Christmas with mother... It's a beautiful thing.

Iā€™m writing the only thing Iā€™m qualified to writeā€¦my life story.

u/Green-Instruction729 avatar

Am I in it?

You just entered.

More replies
More replies

You know, looks can be deceiving. Because I definitely am the coming-home-for-Christmas-to-spend-time-with-mother type

More replies
More replies

The most underrated Tarantino film. I loved it

More replies
More replies
u/KennyDROmega avatar
ā€¢ ā€¢ Edited

He does a certain sort of character extremely well.

You need someone to play a stoic hardass, maybe with a little empathy, maybe with a little humor, he's your man.

u/MrPlowThatsTheName avatar

I would say total lack of empathy but otherwise yes.

What about in thelma and louise? Hes great in that, and does the archetype described with lots of empathy

More replies
More replies
More replies

Clowns to left of me, jokers to the right.

Here I am stuck in the middle with you.