Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2023 | Sight (2024) | Misha Bartnovsky |
| 2021 | Crisis (2021) | Dean Geoff Talbot |
| 2020 | Misbehaviour (2020) | Bob Hope |
| 2019 | Phil (2019) | Phil |
| 2019 | Strange But True | Richard |
| 2019 | Frankie | Gary Archer |
| 2018 | Brian Banks (2019) | Justin Brooks |
| 2017 | Same Kind of Different as Me | Ron Hall |
| 2017 | Brigsby Bear | Detective Vogel |
| 2016 | Little Men | Brian Jardine |
| 2014 | Heaven Is For Real | Todd Burpo |
| 2014 | Murder of a Cat | Ford |
| 2013 | Movie 43 | Griffin Schraeder |
| 2013 | The English Teacher | Dr. Tom Sherwood |
| 2013 | Anchorman 2: The Legend Continues (2013) | Gary |
| 2012 | Stuck in Love | William Borgens |
| 2011 | I Don't Know How She Does It | Richard Reddy |
| 2011 | Salvation Boulevard | Carl |
| 2011 | Thin Ice | Mickey Prohaska |
| 2010 | Green Zone | Clark Poundstone |
| 2010 | The Last Song | Steve |
| 2008 | Baby Mama | Rob |
| 2008 | Flash of Genius | Robert Kearns |
| 2007 | Feast of Love | Bradley Thomas |
| 2006 | Invincible | Dick Vermeil |
| 2006 | Unknown (2006) | Broken Nose |
| 2006 | Little Miss Sunshine | Richard |
| 2006 | Fast Food Nation | Don Henderson |
| 2005 | The Matador (2005) | Danny Wright |
| 2005 | Bad News Bears | Roy Bullock |
| 2005 | Robots: The IMAX Experience | Ratchet |
| 2004 | Godsend | Paul Duncan |
| 2003 | Stuck on You | Walt Tenor |
| 2002 | We Were Soldiers | Maj. Bruce Crandall |
| 2002 | Auto Focus | Bob Crane |
| 2001 | Someone Like You (2001) | Ray Brown |
| 2001 | Dinner With Friends | Tom |
| 2000 | Loser | Prof. Edward Alcott |
| 2000 | What Planet Are You | Perry Gordon |
| 2000 | Nurse Betty | Dr. David Ravell/George McCord |
| 2000 | The Gift (2000) | Wayne Collins |
| 1999 | Mystery Men | Lance Hunt/Captain Amazing |
| 1998 | You've Got Mail | Frank Navasky |
| 1997 | As Good as It Gets | Simon Bishop |
| 1991 | Dillinger (1991) | Arizona Legislator |
