Here's When Buying in Bulk is Really Worth It | My Money | US News

Here's When Buying in Bulk is Really Worth It

This is how to decide whether buying in bulk is right for you.

U.S. News & World Report

Here's When Buying in Bulk is Worth It

Interior warehouse super store with focus on empty shopping cart in store aisle.

Consider buying rice, dry beans, toiletries, canned goods, diapers and other products in bulk.(Getty Images)

Buying food and household products in bulk is one of the most commonly shared frugal strategies, and for good reason. Buying large quantities of a particular item, such as buying diapers in bulk, can save you a lot of money.

However, buying in bulk isn't always a good strategy. It can be a big money-saver in some situations, but not all, and it comes with a few additional challenges.

Read on for tips on how to buy in bulk the right way.

The Pros and Cons of Buying in Bulk

Pro: Buying in bulk is almost always cheaper per unit. This is the big advantage of buying items in bulk. When you buy an item in bulk, you're almost always saving money on each use of that product. This might be a small difference per use – perhaps only a few pennies – but if it's an item you use frequently, those pennies add up rapidly. If you save 10 cents on something you use daily, that's $36.50 in savings per year.

Con: Buying in bulk is an upfront expense. In order to take advantage of bulk buying, you have to buy it all now rather than spacing out the purchases. You might only pay $30 for $50 worth of shampoo, but it's $30 now rather than $10 spread out five times over the course of several months. For some consumers, that can present a financial difficulty.

Pro: Buying in bulk means you rarely run out of that product. This makes it less likely that you'll need to make an unexpected trip to the store, which is usually a source for additional impulse buys.

Con: If you have a large quantity of something, you're prone to overusing it. For example, if you have a lot of paper towels in the cupboard, it seems like less of a big deal to overuse those paper towels. If you have a giant jug of body wash in the shower, it's tempting to overuse that body wash. If you have a massive jar of pasta sauce, it's easy to overuse it.

Pro: Bulk buying is more environmentally friendly. Most bulk purchases have significantly less packaging per use than smaller purchases have. Jumbo packs of toilet paper, for example, are covered in one layer of plastic wrap, whereas individual smaller packs have just a few rolls covered in plastic. A jumbo jug of laundry detergent holds a lot more in a container that's made up of a bit more plastic than smaller containers.

Con: Buying in bulk requires storage space and reliable transportation. Bulk items take up more space in the closet, and if you're buying lots of products in bulk, that closet better be a big one. If you don't have storage space at home or a large car to transport the purchases, you may want to skip bulk purchasing.

Pro: Buying in bulk makes it easier to handle emergencies. Having a large quantity of basic toiletries and food items on hand means that in an emergency situation, you're prepared for the worst. Many people stock bulk supplies in their basement for preparedness reasons.

Con: Buying in bulk means less variety in the products you use. If you buy a jumbo pack of a particular food item, that food item is going to be a consistent part of your diet for a while, meaning that if you or family members don't like it, you may have a difficult time consuming all of it. Even if it is an item that everyone enjoys, it can still grow tiresome. The same is true for bulk household supplies and hygiene products. For example, having a bulk quantity of a type of shampoo that causes dandruff isn't going to be a productive purchase.

Pro: Buying in bulk means fewer trips to the store. Not only do bulk purchases mean fewer emergency trips to the store, it can mean fewer trips, period. With plenty of supplies on hand, it becomes easier to spread out visits to the store, meaning there are fewer situations to spend money on impulse buys and less fuel and mileage spent traveling.

Con: Items bought in bulk can sit around past their expiration dates. While many items have no expiration date or a very long-term date, some items you may consider buying in bulk can expire or at least go past their "best if used by" date. If you're not sure that you're going to use an item by the listed date, skip the bulk buy.

Pro: Bulk buying allows for low-cost bulk meal preparation. If you like to prepare meals in advance, bulk purchasing can make that process a lot easier and cheaper. Buying bulk quantities of pasta sauce, pasta and ricotta cheese, for example, makes it easier and more cost-efficient to prepare several pans of lasagna at once.

Con: Bulk buying for many products requires a warehouse club membership or other additional cost. While many stores offer a few items for bulk purchase, most people who dive into bulk purchasing as a significant frugal strategy end up buying a warehouse club membership, which can cut into the savings. In order to make a warehouse club membership worthwhile, you have to commit to bulk buying as well as to the other services provided, such as discounted gas.

Best Products to Buy in Bulk

Some good items to buy in bulk include:

  • Household and cleaning supplies.
  • Rice.
  • Dry beans.
  • Toiletries.
  • Canned goods.
  • Diapers.
  • Beverages safe to store at room temperature.

Products to Avoid Buying in Bulk

On the other hand, you may want to avoid buying meat in bulk and other perishable goods. Here are some products to avoid buying in bulk:

  • Milk.
  • Eggs.
  • Meat (unless you're going to freeze it).
  • Fresh produce.
  • Snack foods (you run the risk of overindulging).
  • Coffee beans.

In short, bulk buying works best for people with plenty of storage space and a good system in place for using what they've purchased at a sensible pace. For people with limited storage space, mobility or transportation concerns, and those with a very tight budget, bulk buying might not be the best idea.

Compare Offers

Compare Offers

Ad disclosure

About My Money

Expert advice on managing your money.

Get personal finance advice from the voices behind the top money blogs, including TurboTax,, BeFrugal and MagnifyMoney.

Are you a Financial Advisor?

Expand your practice with insights from U.S. News

Comparative assessments and other editorial opinions are those of U.S. News and have not been previously reviewed, approved or endorsed by any other entities, such as banks, credit card issuers or travel companies. The content on this page is accurate as of the posting date; however, some of our partner offers may have expired.

Your Money Decisions

Advice on credit, loans, budgeting, taxes, retirement and other money matters.