An Imperfect Murder
By Tara McNamara,
Common Sense Media Reviewer
Common Sense Media Reviewers
Self-indulgent thriller is boring; violence, drinking.
A Lot or a Little?
What you will—and won't—find in this movie.
Where to Watch
Videos and Photos
An Imperfect Murder
Community Reviews
Based on 4 parent reviews
An Imperfect Flick
The imperfect murder
What's the Story?
Actress Vera Lockman (Sienna Miller) has a nightmare that she kills her drug-dealing ex-boyfriend in self-defense. When she realizes that nightmare has come true, she's surprised by her real-life reaction. In the days following, with a detective (Alec Baldwin) sniffing around and asking lots of questions, Vera examines her role in AN IMPERFECT MURDER.
Is It Any Good?
A boring, self-important waste of time, this non-thrilling thriller was completed at the precipice of hundreds of #MeToo allegations being lodged against writer-director James Toback. But An Imperfect Murder unintentionally provides one related service: It offers a living example of what a predator looks and acts like. The film's concept feels like an inside joke for the Hollywood Good Ol' Boys club: A famous, beautiful actress believes she can get away with a murder because her acting skills are so second-nature that she can convince anyone of her innocence. This speaks volumes about the apparent disdain Toback feels for the female talent that vexes him -- which is accentuated by the fact that he actually writes himself into the piece as a "friend" who shows up, uninvited and without context, to Vera's house, saying he's worried about her. He then probes Vera with prying questions, including whether she's living a secret sexual life without telling him (again, his character appears to be a friend, not someone to whom she would owe any information about her romantic life). This longwinded psychoanalysis offers little information to help us understand Vera, but perhaps some to understand Toback -- especially when it becomes apparent that his visit was never about her but about him and what he hoped to get from her.
The massive quantities of information shared with real-life reporters about Toback's abusive behavior makes small nuances of the film even more unsettling and telling. For instance, the fact that he films Miller sleeping braless in a see-through white T-shirt: Exactly how does her nipples being in the center of the frame help viewers understand she's having a nightmare? And the film opens and closes by slowly panning over an unsettling painting of nude people that has sexual insinuations, all over an orchestral symphony, perhaps to help pretend that the art -- and this film -- has some artistic relevance? The stars all perform to expectation, with Charles Grodin in particular evoking pathos, authenticity, and understanding in his role as Vera's grandfather, who's frustrated by the dementia that's like a demon raiding his brain. His one unforgettable scene feels shoehorned into the film. It otherwise doesn't really fit, except to lay the groundwork for another bizarre moment in which billionaire Carl Icahn, playing himself, shows up at Vera's door and tells a story, doing nothing to move the plot forward. All of which is to say that An Imperfect Murder doesn't just fail as a Time's Up casualty: It fails on its own merit as a terrible, self-indulgent film.
Talk to Your Kids About ...
Families can talk about how we should examine art made by artists who have been accused of reprehensible behavior. How do we deal with new pieces of work by directors like Toback or performers like Shia LaBeouf, and how does that compare to how we consume older entertainment by entertainers like Bill Cosby, Roman Polanski, and Michael Jackson?
How is the main character made to be sympathetic? How does the filmmaker indicate to viewers through the course of the film that she may not be worthy of our sympathy?
How does the scene with Vera's grandfather evoke compassion for those suffering from dementia? How can entertainment be used to create understanding?
Is drinking glamorized? If Vera were drinking hard alcohol instead of wine, would you feel differently about her character? Do you think the frequent depiction of characters drinking wine in film and on television can impact viewers' behavior?
Movie Details
- On DVD or streaming: October 9, 2020
- Cast: Sienna Miller , Alec Baldwin , Charles Grodin
- Director: James Toback
- Inclusion Information: Female actors
- Studio: Quiver Distribution
- Genre: Thriller
- Run time: 72 minutes
- MPAA rating: R
- MPAA explanation: some language and brief drug use
- Last updated: June 20, 2023
Inclusion information powered by
Did we miss something on diversity?
Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.
Suggest an Update
Where to Watch
Our Editors Recommend
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.
See how we rate