�ɨ�ĳ�D�G����C�� ����e

�ɨ�ĳ�D�G��C�� e

[2016.11.10] �o��

�i��M�T�j��o�F�ݴ��ΡA��C��w�ĤJ��`�ͬ��C��תŶ��L��j�A�H��q�B�h��B��s�֡A�P�u�B�͡v�զ��u�p��l�v��A�C�C��ܧڭ̱��T��覡�C��ӧڭ̦b��W��Ҩ��һD�A�Y�{�פW�Q��A�p�G�i�o��ҡA�N�|�y��ť�Ʀܷ��ݫ�Q�C��C��s��ХX�@�ӫ�˪��@�ɡH

��O��C��H

��C��(social media)�O�ѥΤ��ɫH��M�P��B��q��y��u��M��x�A�p��x�Bfacebook�BInstagram�M��P�׾µ��C��C��M��B�q��B�q�x��ǲδC��̤j��P�A�b�󤺮e�ѥΤ�D�ʵo�G�B��ܩνs��A�s�@�ΨϥΪ��e�C�A�P�n�i��s�C��C�餬�ʱj�B�Ǽ��t�ק�(�Y��)�B�[�\��s(��a��)�A�O�ӤH�B��s�H�ܾ��c��q�Ҧ��X�{�ܤơC

��ĳ

�u�H�H�s��v ��l��x

��C��P�i�H�P�H��q�A��H��E�A�H�H�s��C��䤤��j�Ƿs�D�P�Ǽ��ǰ|�б§��߮p��X�A�@��ڭ̤��|�ӳ��w�M�N��P��H��סA�]��O�r��A�ҥH�H�ɦV��F��۪񪺤H��y�A�ÿ�ܾ\Ū��A�۪񪺴C��C

�Ҥl�G��B�ʡuunfriend��v

2014�~9��z�o��B�ʡA��Hfacebook�Ȱ_�uunfriend��v�A��ĵ��٬O��ǥ͡B��u�ŵ��v�Ρu��v��S��A�F�v�߳��P�N�uunfriend�v�O�H�A��R�𪺰Q��ܱo�U�ӷU��C

��ĳ

�}�񥭥x �y�N�u��M�a�v

��d�`��j�Ǥ߲z�ǮaDavid Dunning��ĵ�i�A��p��e��O�H�ۥH��O�Ӫ��ѲW�ժ��M�a�C�L��X��H��i�b��W�o�񤣹��ơC�@�ɸg�ٽ׾�2013�~�w�g�N��q�ƽX��H��C��|�D�n�¯٤��@�C��2013�~�m�H��P��|�߲z�ǡn�@��s��i��ܡA��~�H��H��[�P�P�ƹ�t��h�A��H�ϧO�C

��ĳ

�L�o��T

��Ƿj�M��pGoogle�i�H�]�w�ӤH�Ʒj�M�A�u��ܸg�z�諸��e�C��facebook��|�ھڥΤ᪺�s��A�Ҧp�q�\�M��B�P�B�ͪ��(��g�B��ɡB�d��)�Φ��_�I�\��e�[�ݡA��ÿz��X�Τ�Q�ݪ��e�A�L�o�Τ�i�ण�P��Τ��{�P��e�A�A�e�{�b�Τ᪺�ʺA��(news feed)��W�CInstagram�ήa�l�H�ۤv�߷R��H��A�ϥθӵ{��j�h�|�ݨ�ӤH��Ӥ��P��r�A�b�u��(Explore)�v��줤��u�A�i��|��w��v��(Videos You Might Like)�v�C�Y��w�ݨ쪺�v��O�A�]�i�H��fb�@�˿�ܤ��o��v��~��X�{�C

�p��@�ӡA�Τᱵ��T�K��쭭��A�l�͡u�L�o��w��v(filter bubble effect)�M�u�^�n�Ǯ��v(echo chamber effect�A�t��Ķ�u�^��v)�{�H�A��Ǫ̼~�{�|��ê��צۥѡA�H�ܲ�ê��M��|��h��o�i�C

�L�o��w��

��|�u��e�Τ�P��쪺��A�N�i��P�Τ��[��P��T�L�o�A��O�Τ�B��P��ʰ��Ҥ��G�u�p��l�v(��w)��H��P�n�P��A��ơB�N�ѧκA�M��ܱo��@�A�u�ۤv�H�v��l��x�A�Y��C

�^�n�Ǯ��

�L�o��w��O��C��Τᱵ��H��ͳ�@�A�y��u�^�n�Ǯ��v�A�Y�H�̪��ۤv��[�۪��n��A�[�Ӥ[��|�H��o�O�D�y�N��Ψƹꪺ��A�Φ��ΰ�ť�A�v�T�P�_�O�A�u��N��ۦP�̥�y�A�L�U�Q�סC��G�O�[�j��P�s�ժ��A�ΥO�Y�@ĳ�D��N��ͦV�ⷥ�C

�Ҥl�G��`�ο��|��W��N�P�{��

2016�~��`�ο��|�A�@�M�үS�Դ��bfacebook�MTwitter��H�̡B�g�n�B��o�ƩM��׼ƶq�A��D�Ҫ��ƩԸ̡F�L��H�]��D��C��A�ר��w�oTwitter�C��v�Ǫ̾��{��A�S�Դ��|�O�w�﷥��H��ǲδC�骺��X�L�̤��۫H�a�y�ܷx�B��z�ʫ��ϷP�B��R��ѽסA�ӳo�ǫH��Q�u��^�v��ǲδC��C��x��L�̻E��A��u�a��Pı�v�C

��L�A��N��ϬM�{��A��ڤW�j��N�լd��A�S�Դ��ƩԸ̡C�Ҧp�b9��26�魺��q��G�׵��ATwitter��벼��G�O�S�Դ��H62%��29%��ӡA��CNN�e�U�ֽ׬�s��qORC�Ұ��իh�ۤϡA�ƩԸ̥H62%��27%�j�ӡC��10�멳FBI��s�լd�ƩԸ̥Ψp�H�q�l�B�z��Ȩƥ�A�S�Դ��פ~��s��q�M�m�ز��y�l��n�p�X�Ұ��D�y��դ��A�y�L�϶W�ƩԸ�1%�C��z��MIpsos��իh��ܧƩԸ̤��6�H�C

��ĳ

�j�ץθ� ��Pı��D�u

��T�L��A�ʺA��s�A��b�u�t��v�~�N�A�ëD�Ҧ��H��@�ʾ\Ū�`�J��R��u�w�v��T�C�A�|�s��j�M��Ĥ@��H�~��G�ܡH�N�ӵ��G�A�|�d�ҥt�~�@�ܨ�ӿW�ߪ��T�ӷ��A�H�d��H��u��ܡH�A�|�_�Q�ϲ��d��D�A�θرi��ꪺ��B��l�ޡH

��֬�s��ܡA�H�@��Y��[�I�A�N�|�ɤO�ư��ߪ��ݪk�A�۫H�߳��[�I��ƹ�A��|�q�@�t�C��Ҥ��A�u�D�靈�Q��׾ڤ��v��C�߲z�Ǯa�B2002�~�ը��g�پǼ��o�DDaniel Kahneman�b�ۧ@�m�֫�C�Q�n��o�ءu�{��P�v(cognitive ease)�A��H�̶ɦV�׶}�ݭn�j�q��O��ҡC

�u��u�ۡv�F�v�ɥN

�F�ȼ��H��ëD�s�{�H�A2016�~9�몺�m�g�پǤH�n�H�u��u��(post-truth)�F�v�v��D�A��Q��y�F�ɡu�j�ܺ�v��D�{�H�C�b�u��u�ۡv�ɥN��u�u�ۡv�_��n�A�H�̤��ӭ��ҩν�ìF�Ȫ��׬O�_�ݹ�A��n��O�u�Pı�v�C�F�Ȼ��O��F�f�F�A�ӬO�d�T�ؼиs��A��@��C�Ϲ��n��u�|�[�@�ħڹ�ߡA�l�ͦU�س��ѽסA�O��½�C

��]

�m�g�پǤH�n�١A�u��u�۬F�v�v��D�y�ǴC�B��^��h��ب��c��h�H��C�P��P�ɡA��_�_��A��Ǳ��Τ��ɸ�T�A�j�q��g��Ү��t��F��ɦV�N��Q�k�̵��A�O��T�ܱo��@�ʳ��C

�Ҥl1�G�S�Դ��j�ܳs�g

�S�Դ��Q��u�۬F�v��N��H��C�L�n��`�ζ��ڰ��ëD�b��X��(�ƹ�W��ڰ��b�L�¦i�X�͡A�L�¦i�O��g)�A�S��٥L�O��ݲ�´ISIS��u�п�H�v�C��򴶥߯��D�Ҭ��cPolitiFact��˵��S�Դ��סA�o�{�񤻦��ݥ��A��4%��ݹ�C��޳��u��סv�@�L�ھڡA��L�l�S�Դ��W��סA�ϳQ��ı�Q��^��h��d��ܪ��C

�Ҥl2�G�^��ڬ��Ŷ�

2016�~6��^��ڷ��e�A��ڬ��_�Ŷǭ^�ꥭ��C�g�n�V�ڷ��3.5��^��u�|�O�v�A��M�w�ҹꬰ�ؤj�ƹ�A��ڬ��~��H��ŶǡC��a��ܪ񤻦��벼�ɶɦV�ھڪ�ı�ӫD�ƹ�P�_�C

�Ҥl3�G��u4�H����J2.2�U�v��s�D

2016�~10��A��W�A�{�u4�H�a�x���J2.2�U��v�峹�A��s��k��b�䮳��u�G�L�m�U�ѥСv�A�äޥμƾڡB��W�Ӱ��k��X�ݪ��I�ϡC�峹�ߧY�ƶǡA�ިӺ��ç��a�H�u�g�o�L��v�C�g�D�ҫ�A�o�{�O�Ӧۡu��e�A��v��s�D�C��D�ʤ��٬ޱ��ұa�Ӫ��ˮ`�B��s��t��ҡA��O�@�y�u��s�D�v�K�໴��a�L�C

�Ҥl4�G��Ϭ̭]��

�@��(WHO)�έp�A�C�~�h�F200�U��300�U�H�]��ج̭]�ӧK�]�V�f��R�C��~�Ȱ_�Ϭ̭]��A��վ��c�\��(Gallup)2015�~�o��լd��ܡA54%��X�̻{��a��l�k��ج̭]�D�`��n�A��2001�~�U�^10�Ӧʤ��I�F30%��X�̺�ť�L�̭]��`�B�A��2001�~�W�[1��C�Ϭ̭]��n��̭]�ɭP�۳��g�A�S��ìF��P�ļt�ĵ��f�̭]�׮`�C�Ӭ��e�f��P�w��(CDC)�h��L�Ҿ��ܬ̭]�P�۳��g��C

��v�T

�F�v��G ��|�I�N��

��|��Ĳ�h��שM��[�A��غc��D��|��v�T�A�]�A��F�v�ƥ󪺿��B�W�[�藍�P��ץ߳��]�e�A�H�δ��ɬF�v��ѵ��C��x��@��F�άF��g�پǪ�Anthony Downs��X�A��౵��û{�Ѥ��P�F��A�@��Q�{��O��ϥ��D��@�j��n�]��F�Y�L�̦b��W�j��L�N��n��A�i��F�v�B��|�c��v�T�C

�m�g�پǤH�n(��)��u��u��(post-truth)�F�v�v��峹�١A��M��a�ۤ�A��D��a��̾a�W�ߥq�k��׵��u��ܿ��A��F�v��J��_��u��G�A�F�ȥu�۲��M�ˤj��A��F��{�u�Q�׶եI��p�A�u�|�A��ת��H�ߡA�Φ��c�ʴ`��C

��d�̨ιq�v�m�J�I�l��n��{��D��@�B�{��m�ز��y�l��n�D�s�ڭ�(Martin Baron)�A2016�~5��ͤΥ��ڵ��ۤϥ߳��ƪ��{�H�A��X�H�̻��N�D�y�ǴC�Ǽ��O�L�̷P�줣�ΪA��ƹ��@�u�ޭp�v�A�u��ܳQ��u��A��ѽצb�j�q��ڡK�K��ڭ̳s�̰򥻪��ƹ�]�L�k��@�P�ݪk�A�ڭ̦p��֦��Ī��D��סH�v�L�j�y�s�D�t��ǥ͡A�Y�ϯu�۬D�ԧA��[�I�]�n�L��F�Y�ϬO�P�A�[�I�̫n�ե_�᪺�H�A�]�в�ť�L�̪��n��C

�m��q�q�� 417��n