�׼f�k�|�b�u��׷��סv��k�߿��~

http://paper.wenweipo.com [2012-03-21] �ڭn��

��j�߮v ��p�M�~�ưȩe��|�k�ߥl��H

�@�b1999�~�u�d�Ŭ®סv��A�׼f�k�|��X�A��k�|��v�h�fĳ�H�j�`�e�|��k�O�_�X�G�򥻪k�A�H�ϰ򥻪k�ɭ��k�|�i�H��w�H�j��k�L�ġC��H�j�`�e�|�b�u�d�Ŭ®סv��ߧY��k�A��k�O�w��u��D�v�]�Y��O��ä[�~��b��ҥͪ��l�k)�C�ۦ��A��׼f�k�|�b�u�d�Ŭ®סv��ӻ{�H�j�`�e�|��k�v�A��b2000�~�A�װ|�b�u��׷��סv��򥻪k��24(2)(1)�@�X�P�M�A�P�w�u��D�v�]�Y��賣��O��ä[�~��b��ҥͪ��l�k) ��~��v�C�惡�A��H�j�`�e�|�ߨ�o��n��A��װ|��P�M��ŦX1999�~��H�j��k�C��ӡu��D�v��j�q��J�A�ﭻ��]�I�a�ӨI��O�C�װ|��P�M�a�Ӫ��D�A�ް_��|�U�ɿE�P�Q�׸ѨM��k�C��߮v��ĳ�ק�򥻪k�A��H�n�D�Φ�F��I��I�A��H�n�D�H�j�A��k�C�̲צb��~��|�Q�׫�F��n�װ|�u�ۧڪȥ��v��@�ѡC

��k�ߤ�1999�~��k��e

�@�򥻪k��24(2)(1)��b��S�O��F�Ϧ��ߥH�e�ΥH��b��X�ͪ��ꤽ��ä[�~��v�A�S��X�̤ͪ@�w�Ѧ��~��v��Υ��ҥ͡C

�@�b��򥻪k��22(4)��M��24(2)(3)��P�ɡA1999�~��H�j�`�e�|�q�L��m��󭻴�򥻪k��22��4�کM��24��2�ڲ�(3)��n��X�G�u��ĩ��ߪk��N�H�έ��򥻪k��24��2�ڨ�L�U��ߪk��N�A�w��{�b1996�~8��10��H�j��S��w�e�|�q�L��m��I��򥻪k��24��2�ڪ��N��n��v�C1996�~8��10��w�e�|�q�L��m��I��򥻪k��24��2�ڪ��N��n�A��X�ӱ��Ӵڲġ]1�^��W�w��u�b��X�ͪ��ꤽ��v�A�u�O��Τ@��X�k�w�~�b��ҥͤl�k�A��]�A�D�k�J�ҡB�O��~�d�Φb��{�ɩ~�d��H�b��ҥͪ��l�k�C�v

��׷��ר쩳��˧P�H

�@�װ|�{��1999�~��k�èS��24��(2)(1)�A�{��Ӧ��k�u��F�򥻪k��22(4)��A��24(2)(3)��A�G�̬ҩM��׵L��C�ҥH1999�~��H�j��k�b��24��(2)(1)�W�èS��ʡC�]��S��ʡA�׼f�k�|�i�H�δ��q�k�h��C�b��q�k�U�A�u�@��_�w�奻�r�y�T�O�t�q�M��A�K��o�Ǧr�y��M��t�q�C�k�|��|��~�Ӹ�ƦӰ��o�Ǧr�y��M��t�q�A�ᤩ��Ҥ��]�t��N��C�v�]��A�װ|��Ӧr�q�F�Ѱ򥻪k��24��2�ڲ�1��A�ӫD�m��I��򥻪k��24��2�ڪ��N��n��Ū�C��ҭI��j�߮v�b��̾ڷ��ɡu��D�v�ϥͼƦr��h�A�O��u��D�v��|��v�T��j�A��Q�k�x��ǡA��f�P�̾ڡC

�H�j��k��

�@�]1�^�b�װ|�}�f��q�N��F��j�߮v�w�g�b��B�A�ӻ{�H�j��k�S��ʡA�u��ѦҩʡA�G�ɭP�k�|�~�H��ۥѥδ��q�k��24(2)(1)��@�X��C��j�߮v��\��O��U�k�|�P�סA�װ|��P��d��k�S�j�߮v�C

�@�]2�^��M1999�~��H�j�`�e�|��k�u�w��u�򥻪k�v��22(4)�A��24(2)(3)��A��Ӧ��k��]�t��24��媺��C��24(2)(1)��w�]�t�b1999�~�H�j�`�e�|��k��夺�A�Ӳ׼f�k�|��ӻ{��I�C

�@�]3�^�J�M�׼f�k�|�w�ӻ{��24(2)(1)��N��O�H�j��k��@��A��S��ӻ{��ʩO�H�P��èS��M��]�A��q�r�̦涡�i�H�ݥX�k�|�u��k��@�Ūk�x�P�M�C��H�j��k��@�Ūk�|��P�M�O�@�Ӯڥ��W��~�C��M�A�b��q�k��U�T�v��ߪ��a�O��|�X�{��|�N�k�ҧ@��A�]��k�v��b�k�|�C��S��P�ҥi�`�ä��N�N��װ|�i�H��H�j��k��@�Ūk�|��P�M�C�b��q�k�U��k�|�P�M�@�w�]�t�P�M�z�ѡ]ratio decidendi�^�A�禳�i��]�t��a�N��(obiter dictum�^�C��@�Ūk�|��P�M�z�ѹ�U�@�Ūk�|�O��ʪ��A��a�N��h�S��ʡC��a�N��q�`�O�b�k�x�T�w�פ��ƹ��Ϊk�ߧ@�X�P�M��A�b�P��]�@�Ǭ��Ҥl�A�N��Ҥl�@�X��R�A�û��Y�N�ӯu��Ҥl��ƹ�o�͡A�k�|��ӷ|��򵲽סC��]��H�j��k�v�N��@�Ūk�|�A�礣��k�@��q�k�k�|�P�ҬݫݡC

�@�]4�^�A�̡A�Y��k�O�Ѫk�|��158��Ѫk�|��СA�װ|��~�a�{��H�j��k�D�P�M�@�ءA��i��F��1999�~��k�O�ѬF��o�S�Ϧ�F��@�X��СA�ëD�Ѫk�|�o�S�ϥq�k��@�X��СA�װ|��~�ܱo��[��C

�@�]5�^��k�|�@�V��ǧP�M��|�c��t�᪺�ҾڡA�]��k�|�u�|�̾ڪk�ߧP�סA��|�Ҽ{�k�ߥH�~��]��C�Ҧp�b�~�ĩ~��v�סA�j�k�x��ǥ~�ĩ~��|�c��t�᪺�ҾڡC��װ|�b��פ��ǡA�íʭ��Ҿڧ@�P�M�A�꦳��зǡC

�@�`�Ө��A��T��P�M��ӬO�H�j��1999�~��k��24��Ҧ��e��ʡC�]��A�H�j�L��A��k�A�װ|��|�ɥi�H�Юֲ��ת��P�M�z�ѡA�@�X�󥿡C