The Meaning Behind The Song: Cruel War by Peter, Paul and Mary

Table:

The song “Cruel War” by Peter, Paul and Mary was released in 1962, during a tumultuous time in American history. The Vietnam War was raging on, and this song provided a poignant reflection on the harsh realities of war and the personal sacrifices made by those who were drafted to fight.

The lyrics of the song tell the story of a young man named Johnny who is called to fight in the war. His lover, who is deeply attached to him, desperately wants to be by his side from morning till night. She asks Johnny to let her go with him, but he initially denies her request, stating “No, my love, no.”

In the second verse, we learn that Johnny will be called by his Captain on Monday, and he must obey. The woman again pleads with him to let her accompany him, but he continues to refuse. She expresses her frustration and disappointment, tying back her hair and mentioning that she would even dress as his comrade to hide her true identity. Johnny’s response remains unchanged, as he repeats, “No, my love, no.”

However, in the final verse, the tone shifts. The woman professes her deep love for Johnny, declaring that she loves him more than anyone else in the world. At this point, Johnny finally relents, saying “Yes, my love, yes.” The poignant ending suggests that love and the desire to be together can overcome even the most challenging circumstances.

Personally, this song holds a special place in my heart. Growing up, I heard it frequently as my parents were fans of Peter, Paul and Mary. The haunting melody and touching lyrics resonated with me as a young child, even though I couldn’t fully comprehend the weight of the Vietnam War at the time.

As I grew older and learned more about the history of that era, the lyrics took on a deeper meaning. They became a powerful reminder of the individual stories and sacrifices of the people who experienced the war firsthand. I was moved by the love and dedication portrayed in the song, as well as the portrayal of the pain and longing felt by those left behind.

Listening to “Cruel War” not only connects me to the past, but it also serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggles and conflicts that persist in the world today. The song speaks to the universal human longing for peace and the desire to be with loved ones during times of hardship.

In conclusion, “Cruel War” by Peter, Paul and Mary is a timeless and poignant song that captures the harsh realities of war and the strength of love. Its message remains relevant to this day, reminding us of the enduring human spirit in the face of adversity.