FACULTY
OF
TOURISM
ISBN:978-605-4769-22-3
7 7 86 0 54 76 9 22 3
Internat onal Conference on Rel g ous Tour sm and Tolerance,
9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Editor
Prof. Dr. Muhsin KAR
9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Internat onal Conference on Rel g ous Tour sm and Tolerance,
9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
© Her hakkı saklıdır. Bu kitabın tamamı yada bir kısmı, yazarının izni olmaksızın,
elektronik, mekanik, fotokopi yada herhangi bir kayıt sistemi ile çoğaltılamaz,
yayınlanamaz, depolanamaz.
Bu kitaptaki bilgilerin her türlü sorumluluğu yazarlarına aiittir.
Editor
Prof. Dr. Muhsin KAR
Designer
Recep TAN
Himmet AKSOY
ISBN: 978-605-4769-22-3
Aybil Yayınevi Sertifika No : 17394
YAYINL ARI
www.aybilonline.com
KONYA - MAYIS - 2013
FOREWORD
Respected Guests and Participants!
On behalf of my University's academic team and administrative staff, I would like to welcome
and greet all of you with peace and happiness and thank all the participants who have come
from various parts of the globe to attend this International Conference on Religious Tourism
and Tolerance, organized by the Tourism Faculty of our University. Needless to say, hosting
such an important and timely academic event, in such an historically, intellectually and
spiritually affluent city as Konya, gives us great pleasure but at the same time thrusts upon us
an enormous task of making your stay enjoyable and fruitful.
This Conference, as has been well understood from its title, aims to bring to the attention of
the interested researchers, academics, students, teachers, as well as entrepreneurs and
managers, the importance of faith and religion in the context of tourism and vice-versa. As
such, it apparently involves a number of interdisciplinary and cross-cultural areas, ranging
from humanity and social sciences to management and business administration, from religion,
ethics and spirituality to international relations and tourism, etc.
Again, this International function, apart from its intrinsic value for both academics and
tourism experts, it has also paramount social significance for the citizens of the world at large,
as it deals with so many crucial and global issues concerning pluralism, multi-culturalism,
multi-religiosity, religious tolerance, faith-oriented visits, inter-religious and inter-faith
activities, as well as interactions and collaborations among diverse religious communities.
I am confident that all the participating experts in the Conference will not only share with us
their precious knowledge, wisdom and experience in their respective fields but also cast their
valuable perspectives and insights into the understanding of the various aspects and
implications of the Conference's main theme, i.e. religious-oriented tourism and tolerance.
Moreover, they will offer fresh projections for prospective studies and researches to be
conducted in the above-listed interdisciplinary subjects.
At this point, I should like to mention, again, how meaningful it is to hold such a very timely
international function in this metropolitan city of Konya. As is well known, this magnificent
town, especially when it had been serving as the capital city of the Seljukid Empire for about
two hundred years, had attracted many great scholars, thinkers and theologians from different
regions of the Islamic world. Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi and Sadr al-Din al-Qunawi, for
instance, had flourished in this fertile intellectual setting and enlightened the whole world by
leaving behind their intellectual heritage in this culturally diverse and intellectually dynamic
city. Besides, together with its surrounding environment Konya has numerous historical sites,
such as Neolithic and Chalcolithic (Catalhoyuk) settlement, and magnificent religious centers
and architectural edifices. Hence, this is the most suitable place for hosting this Conference.
In concluding, I wish to reiterate my heartfelt gratitude to all the guests and participants,
national and international alike, for being with us in this International scientific convention,
and also to the members of the Organizing Committee of the Conference who have all been
working for nearly a year, day and night, behind the scene, to make this event a huge success.
I leave you with a word of wisdom uttered by Mawlana Jalal al-Din Rumi, one of the greatest
representatives of love and tolerance in Islamic Civilization and the worldly-renowned
intellectual and spiritual master of our city.
God's Presence is full of Mercy and Generosity. Both existence and nonexistence are in love
with Him. (Mathnawi I/2445)
Prof. Dr. Muzaffer ŞEKER
Rector
PREFACE
Distinguished Guests and Dear Participants,
On behalf of the Organizing Committee for the International Conference on Religious
Tourism and Tolerance, I would like to thank you all for your positive response to our call.
Each year millions of people are travelling throughout the world for different purposes. Faith-
based visits to holy sites and sacred places are the oldest and most common type of travel in
human history and this type of tourism is increasingly finding its share in the sector.
Obviously, motivations behind religious tourism may depend on many reasons: searching for
truth and inner peace, enlightenment, developing a genuine relationship with the divine,
satisfaction of the spiritual and/or material needs. Considering the multi-religiosity in the
world and spreads of the religions, travelling to religious sites may generally require visiting
other countries. The spiritual journey may also result in a direct interaction with "the other"
and hence may change the perceptions of pilgrims, tourists and local people.
Undertaking such visits and journeys generally requires serious thinking and planning, as
well as economic means and travel arrangements. Regarding the seasonality of the religious
activities, the sustainability of this type of tourism is also very important for regional
economic development, as well as for the local people.
With the aim at discussing various aspects of the religious tourism, we have convened the
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance (RTT2013) in Konya.
Convening this conference in Konya also carries an important message, as the city hosts
Mawlana Jalāl ad-Dīn Muḥammad Rūmī, well-known in the West as Rumi, a very
prominent Sufi thinker and famous poet (d. 1273), whose teaching fosters respect among
humanity, love of God, and religious tolerance, inspiring today's multi-cultural societies.
Therefore, Konya is the best place in Turkey to host this important International
Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance: the major goal here is to interconnect
tourism with religion and other inter-disciplinary subjects.
In the Conference, we have seven keynote speakers, well-known people in the tourism,
religion and religious tourism area. We have participants from the various regions of the
world. The participants will focus their presentations on latest theoretical developments and
practical observations on tourism, religion, pilgrimage and tolerance around the world as
reflected in various civilizations. This academic gathering and professional activity is
intended to facilitate and promote the means of communications and cooperation among the
conference participants.
Thank you all for participating and sharing your knowledge with us.
By seizing upon this opportunity, I would like to thank Prof. Dr. Muzaffer ŞEKER, the Rector
of Necmettin Erbakan University for his encouragement to realize this Conference. I also
thank Tahir AKYÜREK, the Mayor of Metropolitan Municipality of Konya for his support
and collaboration to convene this Conference.
Last but not least, I also thank each member of the Organizing Committee, including the
Secretary, for their unselfish efforts and precious time for the actual realization of the
Conference.
Prof. Dr. Muhsin KAR
Chairman
COMMITTEES
Honorary Board
Aydın Nezih DOĞAN Governor of Konya
Tahir AKYÜREK Mayor of Konya Metropolitan Municipality
Prof. Dr. Mustafa ĠSEN General Secretary of the President of Turkey
Prof. Dr. Muzaffer ġEKER Rector of Necmettin Erbakan University
Chairman
Prof. Dr. Muhsin KAR Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Scientific Committee
Prof. Dr. A. Akın AKSU Akdeniz University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Abdülkerim BAHADIR Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Anna TRONO University of Salento, Italy
Prof. Dr. A.Celil ÇAKICI Mersin University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Ahmet AKTAġ Akdeniz University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Ahmet TAġĞIN Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Bilal KUġPINAR Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Birol AKGÜN Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Çağatay ÜNÜSAN KTO Karatay University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Cevdet AVCIKURT Balıkesir University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. David A.MASON Kyung Hee University, Korea
Prof. Dr. Derman KÜÇÜKALTAN Trakya University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Ercan SIRAKAYA TÜRK University of South Carolina, USA
Prof. Dr. Fevzi OKUMUġ University Of Central Florida, USA
Prof. Dr. Füsun BAYKAL Ege University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Füsun ĠSTANBULLU DĠNÇER Ġstanbul University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. G. Nilüfer TETĠK Akdeniz University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. hab. Jerzy WYRZYKOWSKI University of Business in Wroclaw, Poland
Prof. Dr. Jafar JAFARI University of Wisconsin-Stout, USA
Prof. Dr. Keith HOLLINSHEAD University of Bedfordshire, UK
Prof. Dr. Kiran A. SHINDE Bharati Vidyapeeth Deemed University, India
Prof. Dr. KurtuluĢ KARAMUSTAFA Erciyes University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Levent ALTINAY Oxford Brookes University, UK
Prof. Dr. Meryem AKOĞLAN KOZAK Anadolu University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Metin KOZAK Muğla Sıtkı Koçman University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Muhsin HALĠS Sakarya University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Muzaffer UYSAL Virginia Tech University, USA
Prof. Dr. Nazmi KOZAK Anadolu University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Necdet HACIOĞLU Balıkesir University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Nelson H.H. GRABURN University of California, Berkeley, USA
Prof. Dr. Orhan BATMAN Sakarya University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Orhan ĠÇÖZ YaĢar University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Recep ġENTÜRK Fatih Sultan Mehmet Waqf University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Suavi AHĠPAġAOĞLU Anadolu University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Yüksel EKĠNCĠ Oxford Brookes University, UK
Prof. Dr. Yüksel ÖZTÜRK Gazi University, Turkey
Prof. Dr. Zbigniew KAZMĠERCZAK University of Bialystok, Poland
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ashraf GHAREEB King Abdul Aziz University, S. Arabia
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ferhan NĠZAMLIOĞLU Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Mete SEZGĠN Selçuk University, Turkey
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nejdet GÖK Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Mustafa KOYUNCU NevĢehir University, Turkey
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Syed Farid ALATAS National University of Singapore, Singapore
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Zeynep ASLAN NevĢehir University, Turkey
Sen. Lec. Dr. Noga COLLINS-KREINER University of Haifa, Israel
Sen. Lec. Dr. Razaq RAJ Leeds Metropolitan University, UK
Assist. Prof. Dr. Abdurrahman DĠNÇ Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Assist. Prof. Dr. Hamira ZAMANĠ-FARAHANĠ Islamic Azad University, Iran
Assist. Prof. Dr. Mustafa ÇIPAN Governship of Konya, TURKEY
Assist. Prof. Dr. Özgür ÖZER Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Assist. Prof. Dr. Sebahattin KARAMAN Balıkesir University, Turkey
Assist. Prof. Dr. Yasin BĠLĠM Necmettin Erbakan University, Turkey
Dr. Ciprian I. ALECU Romanian Academy, Romania
Dr. Michael A. Di GIOVINE University of Chicago, USA
Dr. Necdect SUBAġI Directorate for Religious Affairs, Turkey
Organizing Committee
Prof. Dr. Muhsin KAR Necmettin Erbakan University (Chairman)
Prof. Dr. Bilal KUġPINAR Necmettin Erbakan University
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ahmet TAYFUN Gazi University
Assoc. Prof. Dr. ġuayip ÖZDEMĠR Afyon Kocatepe University
Assist. Prof. Dr. Ali Osman ÇIBIKDĠKEN Necmettin Erbakan University
Assist. Prof. Dr. Cengiz SARIKÜRKÇÜ Necmettin Erbakan University
Assist. Prof. Dr. Ahmet BÜYÜKġALVARCI Necmettin Erbakan University
Assist. Prof. Dr. Fatih Mehmet BERK Necmettin Erbakan University
Assist. Prof. Dr. Özgür ÖZER Necmettin Erbakan University
Conference Secretary
Assist. Prof. Dr. Abdurrahman DĠNÇ Necmettin Erbakan University
Assist. Prof. Dr. Yasin BĠLĠM Necmettin Erbakan University
Instructor Ceyhun Can ÖZCAN Necmettin Erbakan University
Instructor Murat KOÇYĠĞĠT Necmettin Erbakan University
Instructor Soner ARSLAN Necmettin Erbakan University
Res. Assist. BüĢra MADENCĠ Necmettin Erbakan University
Domestic Tourism As A Viable Option- A Sustainability Approach Discourse:
The Case Of Iran 1
Habib Alipour
Holy Sites in Neo-Liberal World:Indian-Banaras Model 31
Cemil Kutlutürk
Behavioral Differences of Muslim and Non-Muslim Visitors at Holy Sites:
Case of Mother Mary House 43
Zafer Öter
Mehmet Yavuz Çetinkaya
A Comparison of Museum Visitors’ Expectations within the
Context of Faith Tourism 57
Özgür Özer
Serhat Adem Sop
Umut Avci
A Proposal of A Route to Tours to the Ancient Age Oracle Centres of West Anatolia 67
Vedat Acar
Gül Erbay Aslitürk
Rihla: Activist Of Campus Da’wah Institute’s Lifestyle In Urban Area 85
Jhane Pebyana Wilis
Nur Aida Mardhatila
The Narrative Skills of the Tourist Guides in Faith-based Tourism: the Case of
Yılanlı Church in Göreme Open Air Museum 95
Aytuğ Arslan
Hayrullah Çetin
Sociological characteristics of religiosity of Poles 101
Beata Rafalska
Aneta Michałowska
St. Thecla: a native of iconium 109
Fatih Mehmet Berk
Mustafa Arslan
Unlocking the Potential of Religious Tourism in Manisa, Turkey 123
Burak Kartal
Mustafa Tepeci
Hakan Atlı
The Role Of Service Quality In Promoting Tourism Development In Obudu
Mountain Resort 137
O.B Enemuo
Barra Temple
Being ‘the European other’: Codification and commodification of Ottoman
Heritage in Bosnia & Herzegovina 145
Senija Causevic
Derek Bryce
Faith-Based Tourism to Turkey as Cultural Diplomacy for American Christians 155
Allison Block
Taylan Gürbüz
Role of Religious Tourism in Conflict Resolution 179
Adejoh Apeh Matthew
Alternative Tourism in Isparta City: Faith Tourism in Psidia Antiocheia Ancient City 185
İsmail Kervankıran
Hüseyin Kaya
Religious Recourses and Pilgrim tourism in Georgia 191
Marina Metreveli
The Knowledge of Students of Tourism about Sacred Monuments on the
Territory of Serbia 199
Snežana Štetić
Sanja Pavlović
Dario Šimičević
Sara Stanić
Tourism and the Transformation of Ritual Practice with Sand Pagoda 211
Ploysri Porananond
The Passengers Islamic Perspective in Airline Hospitality 227
Ehsaneh N.M. Nameghi
Mohammad Ali Shadi
Upon This Rock I Will Build My Church: Constructions of Christianity (and Their
Consequences) at American Religious Youth Music Festivals 239
Kellee Caton
Colleen Pastoor
Yaniv Belhassen
Billy Collins
Mark Wallin
Recreational and the Geotourism Value Estimated Babek Castle Using
Conditional Valuation Method 259
Fariba Ayase
Mohammad Hosein Fathi
Adel Mohammadi Far
Mina Farokhi Someh
Halal and Haram foods-drinks in the views of Rumi 267
Zabihi Robab
Zabihi Ebrahim
Raoufi Farzaneh
A socio-demographic study on Iranians Hajj-pilgrims 273
Zabihi Ebrahim
Zabihi Robab
Emrani Ali-Asghar
Raoufi Farzaneh
The Usage Of Socio-Psycho Factors As A Sustainable Competition Medium To
Develop Faith Tourism Center: The Case Of Konya 279
Ahmet Tayfun
Erkan Akgöz
Karabey Palavar
An Evaluation on the State of the Visit Sites Took Part In Holy Bible in Faith Tourism 291
Hakan Yılmaz
Feeling of Security in Iranian Pilgrims Traveling to Mashhad 301
Hamed Bakhshi
Residents attitudes toward religious tourism development in Medjugorje 307
Ivana Pavlic
Promotion of tourist destinations as ethno-brands 319
Zanina Kirovska
The role of electronic tourism industry on the interaction between Islamic Countries
(with the Emphasize on the role of Iran) 329
Mohsen Kalantari
Samira Moradi Mofrad
Akbar Hossein Zadeh
Mohammad Kazem Jamshidi
Ghamar Abasi
Analysis of Dimensions and Components of Sustainable Pilgrimage CityStudy Case's:
Mashhad 339
Mozhgan Azimi Hashemi
Evaluate of Ecological Ability of Eco-Tourism With GIS Software. Case Study:
Khorasan-E-Razavi Province, Iran 347
Mozhgan Sabet Teimouri
Churches and Synagogues in Classical Islamic Law: Debates on Construction,
Continuance and Repair 353
Necmeddin Güney
Traditional Tourism: A Tool Towards Religious Tolerance in Nigeria 361
Fabunmi Samuel Kehinde
Protection and Respect for the Places of Worship in Islam 373
Sanaullah Bhutto
Muhammad Khan Sangi
Islamic Tour Operators and Religious Tourism Markets in Syrian Shi’ite Visits 379
Shin Yasuda
Islamic Issues In The Hotel Industry: The Dilemma And Tolerance 389
Basri Rashid
The Role of Second Houses in the Development of Tourism Focusing on Investment in
Rural Areas (Case Study; Hesar Valiasr Village, Boeinzahra Township) 401
Jamshid Einali
Hosein Farahani
Ahmad Romyani
Samira Sohrabi Vafa
A Research Aimed at Determining the Mediating Effect of Leadership in the
Relationship Between Knowledge and Innovation 409
Rana Özen Kutanis
Muammer Mesci
Zeynep Mesci
Hatice Bozkurt
The Importance of the Innovation to Enhance the Competitive Power:
A Research in Hotel Managements 417
Rana Ozen Kutanis
Muammer Mesci
Zeynep Mesci
Tugba Şen
A Study on the Role of religious Tourism in Economic, Social and Cultural Development
of Rural Areas (Case Study; Fakhrabad district, Meshginshahr county, Iran) 425
Mohsen Ahadneja
Ebrahim Sadegh
Ahmad Roumiyani
Afshin Naderi
The routes of money in the routes of faith 435
Christos Desyllas
Contribution of Religious-Tourist Attractions to Social Tolerance:
The Case of Batu Caves in Malaysia 447
Saim Kayadibi
Mehmet Birekul
Ahmet Koyuncu
Place of Religious Tourism and How to Use Them to Improve On Existing
Capacity and Potential: A Case Study of Neyshabour, Iran 485
Robabeh Sadat Hosseini
Artinah Zainal
The Need for Cooperation of Peace Activists for Peacebuilding by Bottom-Up
Globalization Approach Based On Education of Universal Ethical Norms 493
Volkan Çiçek
Peacebuilding Activities of Gulen-Inspired Institutions through Education in Iraq
and the World: Educational Philosophy and Characteristics 509
Volkan Çiçek
Legal Protection of Religious Tourist Attractions 521
Akmal Ramadan
In Search of the Miracles: Pilgrimage to the Miraculous Pla 535
Darius Liutikas
The Usage Of Socio-Psycho Factors As A Sustainable Competition
Medium To Develop Faith Tourism Center: The Case Of Konya 551
Ahmet Tayfun
Erkan Akgöz
Karabey Palavar
A Research For Determination Of Travel Business Managers Profiles
Organized Religious Tourism Travels In The Aegean Region 563
Burhanettin Zengin
Gül Erkol
As a Conceptual Proposal for Spiritual Searching with Tourism Marketing Perspective:
Mawlana Camps in Konya 579
Özlem Güzel
Özgür Özer
İnanç Turizmini Yönlendiren Bir Unsur Olarak Coğrafya 587
Abdurrahman Dinç
Çevre ve İnsan Bağlamında Kur'ân'ın Turizm ve Seyahate Yüklediği Mana 599
Mustafa Kayhan
Türklerde Kutsal Sayılan Bazı Hayvanlar ve Biyolojik Özellikleri 617
Rahile Öztürk
Türkiye’de İnanç Turizmi: Bugünkü Durum, Sorunlar ve Gelecek 627
Ayşe Okuyucu
Mehmet Somuncu
Hititler Dönemi Anadolusunda Ritüel Malzemesi Olarak Ekmek 645
Tolunay Sandıkcıoğlu
İslami Otellerin Ürün Nitelikleri: Türkiye Örneği 651
Önder Met
İsmail Mert Özdemir
Burhan Aydemir
Edirne Selimiye Camii Ziyaretçilerinin Beklentilerinin Saptanmasına Yönelik
Bir Araştırma 663
İbrahim Alpay Yilmaz
Adil Oğuzhan
Derman Küçükaltan
Mevlevilik Felsefesinin Konya Mutfağı Üzerindeki Etkisi 679
Mehmet Sarıoğlan
Murat Doğdubay
Ayşe Can
Erken Hıristiyanlık Döneminin Konyalı Manevi Önderleri 687
Nermin Öztürk
Turizm Rehberliği Eğitimi Alan Öğrencilerin Mevlana ve Mevlevilik ile
İlgili Algılarının Ölçülmesine Yönelik Bir Araştırma 695
Emel Morel Gökgözoğlu
Özlem Köroğlu
Merve Kalyoncu
Hz. Pir Şeyh Şaban-I Veli ve Kastamonu Evliyaları Anma Haftası’nın Türkiye
İnanç Turizmi ve Hoşgörü Kültüründeki Yeri 707
Muharrem Avcı
Ziyaret Yerlerinin İnanç Turizmi Açısından Değerlendirilmesi: Giresun İli Örneği 717
Ünsal Bekdemir
İbrahim Sezer
Silifke İnanç Turizmi’nde Aya Tekla’nın Yeri ve Önemi 739
Nur Bakar
Özkan Demir
Kuzey Kıbrıs Türk Cumhuriyeti’nde Hoşgörü Ortamı Bağlamında Maronitler ve İnanç
Turizmine Yansımaları 747
Ulvi Keser
Hoşgörü Bağlamında KKTC’de İnanç Merkezleri ve Turizm Ekonomisine Katkıları 759
Ulvi Keser
Heybeliada Aya Triada Manastırı 771
Salih İnci
Tarsus İnanç Turizmi Potansiyeli ve Halkın İnanç Turizmine Bakışı 781
İhsan Kurar
Atilla Akbaba
Şanlıurfa Kültür ve İnanç Turizmi Potansiyelinin Değerlendirilmesi 795
Sabri Kürkçüoğlu
Gül Erkol
İnanç Turizminde Göbekli Tepe'nin Yeri ve Önemi 815
Tolga Fahri Çakmak
Dinî Yolculuğun Varoluşsal Anlam ve Önemi 835
Cenan Kuvancı
Alevilerde Yeme-İçme Adetleri ve Yasakları: Güneybatı Akdeniz ve Güneydoğu Anadolu
Bölgeleri Üzerine Karşılaştırmalı Bir İnceleme 833
Olcay Kılınç
Uğur Kılınç
İnanç Turizminin Din Eğitimi Açısından Değeri 851
Mehmet Ayas
Dünyada Yaşanan Çatışmaların Göz ardı Edilen Boyutu: Dini-Jeopolitik 865
Fatih Sezgin
Recep Bilgin
Bilal Altıner
İnanç Turizminde Belediyelerin Rolü: İstanbul İlçe Belediyelerine
Yönelik Bir Araştırma 877
İsmail Kızılırmak
Mehmet Altuğ Şahin
Çatışma Çözme, İletişim Ve Empati Kültürünün Kazanılmasında Dini
Fenomenlerin Etkisi: Sosyal Psikolojik Bir Değerlendirme 893
Kasım Tatlılıoğlu
Mehmet Karaca
Kur'ân’da Yolculuk ve Gerekleri 909
Şaban Karasakal
Sessiz ve Doğal Bir Turizm Noktasi Olarak Barla ve Said Nursi: Destinasyon Yönetimi
Bağlamli Bir Analiz Çalişmasi 921
Hulusi Doğan
İlknur Doğan
İstanbul’un İnanç Turizmi Potansiyelinin Değerlendirilmesi 935
Füsun İstanbullu Dinçer
Serol Dilmaç
Orhan Akova
Uşak’ta İki Önemli Sûfî: Hacım Sultan ve Şeyh Alâeddin Uşşâkî’nin Tarihteki
Yeri ile Sosyo-Kültürel Alandaki Önemi 965
M. Murat Öntuğ
Salih Gülerer
Zemzem Suyunun Faziletine Dair Rivayetlerin Değeri 991
Mehmet Eren
Turizmin Niş Pazarı Şırnak İlinin (Şehr-İ Nuh) İnanç Turizmi Açısından
Değerlendirilmesi: Sorunlar ve Çözüm Önerileri 1005
Nurdan Şarman
Sedat Çelik
Siirt’in İnanç Turizmi Açısından Değerlendirilmesine Yönelik Nitel Bir Araştırma 1021
Sedat Çelik
Nurdan Şarman
İnanç Turizmi Çerçevesinde Antalya Destinasyonunun İncelenmesi:
Dinler (Hoşgörü) Bahçesi Örneği 1041
Gökhan Yılmaz
Saliha Başak Erdinç
Sema Küçükali
Türkiye’nin Kutsal Yiyecekler ve İçecekler Açısından Turist Çekme Potansiyelinin
İncelenmesi 1057
Hacı Ahmet Çakır
Atila Akbaba
Kültür ve İnanç Turizmi Kapsamında Hoşgörü Kenti Hatay İlinin Değerlendirilmesi 1063
Melda Harbalıoğlu
Gamze Özel
Aziz Nikola Kilisesi ve Efes Meryem Ana Kilisesi Bağlamında İnanç Turizminin
Seküler ve Dini Boyutları Üzerine Bir Değerlendirme 1071
Ayşe Ambaroğlu
Mutlu Akıncı
Üç Büyük Dine (Hristiyanlık, İslamiyet ve Musevilik) Ev Sahipliği Yapan
Anadolu’nun İnanç Turizmi Açısından Pazarlanması 1079
Özlem Köroğlu
Veli Ulaş Asmadili
Kutsal Ateş, Ocak Pişirme ve İnanç Turizmi Açısından Yemek Sosyolojisi 1095
Halil Mutioğlu
Bütünleşik Pazarlama İletişimi Çerçevesinde Türkiye’de İnanç Turizminin
Geliştirilmesi 1103
Sadık Serçek
Gülseren Serçek
Tüketicilerin Dini Olmayan Kutsal Yerlere Gelme Nedenleri:
Şafak Koyu’nda Bir Araştırma 1133
Nilsun Sarıyer
Etnik Kültürlerin Ortak İnanç Paydası: Dünya Coğrafyasında Hıdırellez 1141
Melih Aydın
Çanakkale’de İnanç Turizminin Geliştirilmesi ve Din Görevlilerinin
İnanç Turizmine Bakışı 1147
Ersin Arıkan
Emre Çilesiz
Afyonkarahisar Sandıklı İlçesinde Turistik Ürün Çeşitlendirme Stratejisi
Kapsamında İnanç Turizminin Geliştirilmesi Üzerine Bir Araştırma 1157
Ahmet Baytok
Hasan Hüseyin Soybalı
Melek Yavuz
Ahmet Yavuz
İnanç Turizminde Kutsal Mağaralar: Türkiye’deki Ashâb-ı Kehf Mağaraları
(İzmir-Mersin-Kahramanmaraş-Diyarbakır) 1173
Bayram Çetin
Çağlar Kıvanç Kaymaz
Yalvaç’ ta İnanç Turizmi ve Sosyo-Ekonomik Etkileri 1191
Melda Harbalıoğlu
İpek Ünal
Dini Tolerans Bağlamında Endülüs Medeniyetinin Karakteristik Özellikleri 1199
Nejdet Gök
The Origins Of Religious Tourism, Important Places, Person And
Time-Frames In Terms Of Islam 1207
Mehmet Şimşir
Anadolu’da Yatır, Ziyaret ve Türbe İnanışlarının Doğa Korunması Açısından Önemi 1221
İhsan Bulut
Abdurahman Dinç
Şeb-i Arus Törenlerine Katılan Ziyaretçilerin Memnuniyet ve Sadakat Düzeyleri
Üzerine Bir Araştırma 1235
Ahmet Tayfun
Arzu Kılıçlar
Ahmet Uşaklı
Özgür Yayla
İnanç Turizmi İle İlgili Türkiye’de Yapılan Akademik Çalışmaların İncelenmesi 1245
Yalçın Arslantürk
Özlem Altunöz
Sevil Bülbül
Fulden N. Güral
Şehir Pazarlaması ve Bir Şehir Varlığı Olarak Hz. Mevlana Algısı 1255
Erkam Yarar
Ashabü’l Kehf’in Afşin’in Ticaret Hayatına Katkısı: Bir Alan Çalışması 1271
Hüseyin Ağır
Nurettin Koca
Ahmet Şahbaz
İnanç Merkezlerinin Pazarlanmasında Eleştirel Noktalar: Hatay Örneği 1281
Kazım Kocabozdoğan
Cevat Tosun
Fikret Gökçe
Yasin Bilim
Halkla İlişkiler Bağlamında Konaklama İşletmelerinin Müşterileri İle
İletişim Kurma Biçimleri: Web Siteleri Üzerinde Bir İnceleme 1291
Murat Koçyiğit
İnanç Turizminin Sosyo-Kültürel Etkilerine Yönelik Yerel Halk Algısı 1305
Mutlu Uygun
Sinan Mete
H. Bahadır Akın
Sosyal Medyanın, İnanç Turizminin Tanıtım ve Pazarlamasında Oynayabileceği Rolün
Önemi ve Ortaya Çıkabilecek Muhtemel Sorunlara Bulunabilecek Çözüm Yolları 1321
M. Murat Yeşil
Domestic Tourism As A Viable Option- A Sustainability Approach
Discourse: The Case Of Iran.
Habib Alipour
Eastern Mediterranean University
Faculty of Tourism
Gazimagusa/KKTC/TRNC
Via Mersin 10, Turkey
Habib.alipour@emu.edu.tr
Abstract
Most of the studies in the tourism literature have focused on international tourism; however,
domestic tourism in specific destinations as Iran can contribute to job creation, heritage
restoration, regional integration, cross-cultural understanding and enhancement of
environmental awareness. Market for domestic tourism in Iran, despite its potentials, has been
downplayed and the true value of this activity is underutilized. This study is an effort to
explore the problems/bottlenecks associated with the lagging domestic tourism sector which
is reinforced by public sector‘s passive role in tourism system definition. This study argues
that tourism institutions have an apathetic behavior towards such vital market in one hand and
remained complacent to the vigor of domestic tourists and their travel pattern/behavior in
another hand. Domestic tourism is emphasized not by chance; rather it is an alternative form
of tourism that can be placed in the context of ‗sustainability‘ discourse. A triangulation
method adopted towards the study that composed of three tier approach. First, survey
questionnaire was administered to the domestic travelers who frequented the travel agencies
in the capital city-Tehran. Second, the theoretical frameworks that guided this study are
based upon: I) an assertion that domestic tourism is indeed ‗poor cousins no more’
(Scheyvens, 2007); II) the culture-ideology of consumerism as the manifestation of global
tourism in conflict with ‗sustainability‘ (Higgins-Desbiolles, 2009, 2006); III) social
metabolism and sustainable de–growth in reference to our interaction with the environment
(Martinez-Alier et al, 2010a, 2010b); IV) and ‗globalization‘ approach to tourism with
emphasis on ‗ the global culture approach’ (Sklair, 2010, 1999). Third, an interview was
conducted with the officials/employees of formal institutions responsible for tourism
development and management in Iran. Study has revealed that the supply side components of
the tourism functioning system (i.e., attractions, transportation, promotion, information, and
services) (Gunn and Var, 2002; Jafari, 1982; Mill and Morrison, 1989) are devoid of rational
planning principles in the context of the multiplicity of spatial characteristics of different
tourism regions. In addition, the study revealed that sustainable tourism development through
dynamics of domestic tourism is a possibility in the case of Iran; and direct or indirect critique
of international tourism through study‘s theoretical frameworks reinforces the fact that
domestic tourism is a domestic investment (Collier, 2010) with a sustainability agenda.
Keywords: Domestic Tourism Development; Global Tourism Structure; Sustainable
Tourism.
1
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Introduction
Iran‘s tourism potentials make it one of the highly suitable candidates to focus on tourism
resources and reap the deserved share of world tourism pie. However, this sector has been
neglected for various political and social reasons, especially, during the post- Islamic
revolution of 1979. In a nutshell, the country has experienced numerous turns and twists as it
was engulfed in the upheavals of the 1970s (i.e., post-revolution) and 1980s (i.e., war with
Iraq). Obviously, both of the decades of revolutionary transition from monarchy to Islamic
Republic and subsequent war with Iraq, were not conducive to tourism development
particularly. However, with the passing of time and peace agreement between Iran and Iraq, a
gradual calm returned to the country by the late 1990s. Nonetheless, the tourism sector has
remained a low key activity in comparison to other sectors. In juxtaposing the post-
revolutionary upheavals, Iran‘s demographic structure experienced a rapid population
growth due to ‗adoption of a [pronatalist] policy and suspension of the family planning
program after the revolution; there has been a huge rise in the fertility and population growth
rates during the first decade after the revolution (1979-1989)‘ (Mehryar and Ahmad-Nia,
2004). Demographic shift accompanied higher transportation use-mainly car ownership-
which allowed a higher mobility of the population. The implications of these developments
have been an increase in both domestic and outbound tourism. In the meantime, lack of
suitable transportation system of roads, railway, and airway facilities, resulted in various
bottlenecks and increase in the rate of car accidents on the dilapidated and inadequate roads
(http://payvand.com/news/04/jan/1142.html). Not to forget that domestic tourism, as well as,
VFR tourism have been established in Iran for a long time regardless of lack of formal and
institutional approach to tourism system development, especially in the post-Islamic
revolution (O‘Gorman et al, 2007). The dominant nature of domestic tourism in Iran has been
revolving around pilgrimage to shrines of revered religious saints of Shiite sect. This by itself
results in spatial pattern of tourism which is highly concentrated in a few locations of
pilgrimage sites. The second important magnet for domestic tourism in Iran is the Caspian
Sea region, especially for the Capital city of Tehran.
In the meantime, the economy of Iran is highly dependent on the export of fossil fuels,
with unemployment running in double digits; the tourism sector has remained dormant
notwithstanding the tremendous potential for varieties of tourism resources. With the future of
nonrenewable sources of energy in doubt, due to environmental concerns and their possible
depletion (Marsh and Grossa Jr, 2005), tourism remains a prospective alternative to combat
economic and social hardships (http://travel.mapsofworld.com/iran/history.html; Karbassian,
2000).
The paper is structured as follows: section 1contextualizes the tourism industry as an
instrument to achieve economic growth; however, ‗economic growth‘ which focuses on
increase in the rate of GDP per person, may not satisfy the demands of ‗sustainable
development‘ (Kates et al, 2005; Hurka, 1992; Hosseini, 2003). Section 2 brings in theoretical
discourses emanating from the recent critique of globalization and tourism in general, as well
as, in the context of present global economic crisis
(http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/special_reports/global_economy/). Section 3 focuses on attitudes
and perception of domestic tourists in Iran. Section 4 concludes that in the context of
theoretical discourse in the literature– in respect of sustainable tourism development–
domestic tourism can offer an opportunity to initiate a process towards sustainability. In the
meantime, the present tourism policy of the public sector is a blessing in disguise as
manifested through regime‘s apathy towards a full force international tourism development.
The study aims to fill some of the existing gaps in literature in regard to domestic tourism
and its implications for a sustainable tourism specific to certain destinations. This is in line
with local tourism governance (Beaumont and Dredge, 2010) which is a characteristic of
2
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
domestic tourism –external to global tourism system (Higgins-Desbioless, 2012, 2009; Sklair,
2011; Burns, 1999). The significance of this paper is that it opens up discussion about
domestic tourism as an option in certain destinations such as of Iran. The study highlights the
advantages of domestic tourism and explores its relevance to sustainable tourism
management. The findings can inform public sector of advantages/benefits of domestic
tourism and the cost of their inaction.
Furthermore, the following questions will also guide the study process:
What is the nature of Iran‘s domestic tourism in relation to the supply side?
What is the attitude of the domestic tourists in relation to the quality of the
Supply?
What are the main deficiencies in the domestic tourism supply/development?
What are the shortfalls of the Iran‘s tourism organization regarding domestic
tourism development?
To what extent does the domestic tourism supply fulfill the desires of the
market/demand?
Theoretical backdrop: A prelude
Tourism has gone and will continue to experience metamorphosis in reaction to the
changes around us. The evolutionary process of tourism phenomenon can be witnessed
through the changes that are experienced in the supply side (destinations) , as well as, in the
demand side (the market) (Inskeep, 1999; Gunn with Var, 2002; Hall, 2009; Edgell et al,
2008; Walton, 2009; Papatheodorou, 2004; Cooper and Hall, 2008 ). The obvious
manifestation of the changes in the destinations is the shift from myopic focus on mass
tourism to so called alternative tourism e.g. specifically ecotourism which is highly
charged/framed by the sustainability and environmentalism discourse. It seems that the
survival of tourism, as a productive sector, is strongly linked to the environmental quality and
sustainable planning (ample evidence can be accessed in the journal of sustainable tourism;
journal of sustainable development and planning; journal of sustainable development, and the
Journal of American Planning Association). In the other side of the coin is the demand or
tourism market which is highly capricious and volatile with ever changing character of its
protagonists–the tourists (Cooper and Hall, 2008).
At any rate, by looking at the history of tourism one can witness how a limited business
oriented perception of tourism as an economic activity has evolved into a discipline
(composed of fields) (Tribe, 1997) that draws a pool of literature presented by sociology,
anthropology, geography, urban planning, economics, environmental sciences, law, political
science, and development discourse versus growth (GDP) with hotly debated issues or thesis
and antithesis (Walton, 2009; Tribe, 1997). No doubt we have come a long way since the
Grand Tour of 17th century which the traditional trip of Europe undertaken by mainly upper-
class European young men of means from an aristocratic rite
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Tour; Walton, 2009, p. 786). At the same time, the
extraordinary dynamism of tourism industry is planning to take us to the space unimaginable
by the early travelers (USA TODAY–
http://www.usatoday.com/travel/columnist/mcgee/2010-02-24-space-travel_N.htm).
Nevertheless, an evolutionary path of ‗tourism industry‘ should not come as a surprise as
this is the nature of constantly changing phenomenon that surrounds humanity. But what is
unique about tourism industry is its highly peculiar structure and operation. It is not
3
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
comparable to any other industry because it is not based on a simply packaged and managed
product with a clear cut process; therefore, linear and reductionist approach to its analysis is
not suffice (Farsari et al, 2011; Cole, 2009; Farrell and Twining-Ward, 2004; Zahra and Ryan,
2007; Miller et al, 2010; Tribe, 2006; Gunn with Var, 2002).
When it comes to the decision making process it poses a unique challenge as ‗Tourism
policy-making is a complex phenomenon involving various actors and institutions in the
negotiation of power distribution and organizational complexity. Moreover, the contested
political character of sustainable development with its meaning along with its ethical
considerations still being debated in policy, industry and academic circles has complex
ramifications for decision making‘ (cf. Farsari et al, 2011: 1110-1111). To clarify further, its
analysis is not also adhering to conventional models because tourism industry is ―chaotic‖ and
―industry of industries‖ that ‗is complicated by its many entities and interactions, or as an
activity critically vulnerable to irregular climatic, political, and market events; and as a global
phenomenon, is indisputably complicated, and vulnerable to unscheduled events with its
specific local manifestation‘ (Cole, 2009: 691). Therefore, it ‗may exhibit quite different
dynamics from those captured by traditional growth models or localized supply- demand
elasticity models‘ (Cole, 2009: 689).
At any rate, ‗environmental‘ concerns/problems are a hot potato now-a-days. Because the
conflict between economic development and environment can be crystalized easily as
evidences are abundant (Martines-Alier et al, 2010a; Martinez-Alier et al, 2010b; Redclift,
2007). In the meantime, ‗social and political institutions change too slowly, and are unable to
accommodate the realities of new resource pressures‘ (Redclift, 2007: 124). By borrowing
from Redclift, his expression of the conflict is enlightening as it is placed in the context of
historical process and political economy by saying:
‗To locate our conception of the ‗environment‘ within a broader historical and comparative
framework, one which distinguishes the historical role of the environment at different stages of
capitalist development. [Furthermore], to identify common elements in a political economy of the
environment in which changes in the natural environment are analytically related to ‗super-structural
factors, such as ideology and policy, and at different levels of political complexity (2010, p. 124).
However, Redclift‘s statement which is in line with Sklair‘s (2010) notion of crisis of
ecological sustainability, alerts us about the challenges of managing the contradictions
between development and the environment. The point is that ‗environmental‘ or ‗ecological‘
crisis are rather transparent and tangible entities as their decline and demise can be measured
in various forms (Marsh and grossa Jr, 2005: Warland, 2001). However, it is the concept of
‗development‘ which is highly controversial (Hosseini, 2003; Starr, 2006) and misguided. As
expressed by Wallerstein:
‗We are told that socialism is road to development. We are told that laisssez-faire is the road to
development. We are told that a break with tradition is the road to development. We are told that a
revitalized tradition is the road to development. We are told that industrialization is the road to
development. We are told that increased agricultural productivity is the road to development. We are
told that delinking is the road to development. We are told that an increased opening to the world
market (export-oriented growth) is the road to development. Above all, we are told that development
is possible, if only we do the right thing. But what is this right thing? (1994, p. 3).
And/or, we are told that ‗mass tourism‘ is the road to development. Sklair eloquently
poses a thorny dimension which has been ignored by voluminous tourism literature that are
focused on micro level studies and highly charged with neo-liberal economic perspective
(Martinez-Alier et al, 2010; Walton, 2009; Higgins-Desbiolles, 2009). Sklair‘s thorny issue,
which is not pleasant to neo-liberalists‘ ears, is at the heart of this discussion. Because, he
touches upon the most visible/tangible problem associated with global capitalism, as well as,
globalized tourism in the following terms:
4
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Capitalist globalization simultaneously enriches more people all over the world than ever before in
human history, but cannot bring the poorest out of debilitating poverty in most societies, and those in
the middle seem fated to suffer cyclical bouts of economic insecurity, and the crisis of ecological
unsustainability - capitalist globalization spreads industrial civilization all over a planet that cannot
cope (Sklair, 2010, p. 115).
Two items are worthy of attention in the statement above when it comes to tourism per se.
first, the relationship between tourism development and ecological sustainability which poses
an obvious oxymoron and are paradoxical. To clarify the issue, ‗an important distinction must
be drawn between ‗sustainable tourism‘ and ‗sustainable development in the context of
tourism‘; where the former is aimed at sustaining the tourism industry, while the latter is
geared to meeting the ‗greater good‘ or human needs through tourism‘ (cf. Higgins-
Desbiolles, 2010, p. 117). However, the devil is in the detail. Up to now, tourism‘s role in
poverty alleviation has remained skeptical in the case of the so called Third World countries
(Hall, 2007; Scheyvens, 2007, 2008; Schilcher, 2007). With a note of cautious, tourism per se
is not the culprit, rather its domination and operation by the global protagonists in the context
of ‗culture-ideology of consumerism‘ and at the mercy of Transnational Capitalist Class
(TCC) produced a distorted development as well as an unattainable sustainability in the
context of ecological crisis (Sklair, 1999, 2002). The influence of TNCs alluded to by
Harrison as he stated:
―Transnational companies operate at all levels of the industry, as travel agents, tour operators,
hoteliers and airline operators. Indeed, the industry as a whole is characterized by considerable
vertical and horizontal integration. Even in 1978, when only sixteen transnational hotel companies
were linked with international airlines, they accounted for 34 percent of all foreign hotels; on average,
nearly three quarters of the airline-associated hotels were foreign based and , of these, three firths
were in developing countries‖ ( Harrison, 1994, p. 241).
Some of the globalization scholars have taken the discussion to a higher level by referring
to ‗ecotourism‘, which supposed to be sustainable form of tourism, not necessarily sustaining
tourism but rather using the industry as a whole to fix the contradiction that are inherent in the
global capitalism which manifests in numerous crisis temporally and spatially. Therefore,
tourism in general and ecotourism in particular are instruments of ‗fixes‘ that is elaborated by
Harvey as:
‗Spatial fix‘ entails exporting excess capital to a new geographical location where it can be reinvested
in novel development. International tourism development can be viewed as an ideal means by which
this is accomplished, and ecotourism in particular, in its quest specifically for relatively undeveloped
areas, can be viewed as the epitome of this strategy. A ‗temporal fix‘, by contrast, involves displacing
excess capital into future return, either by investing in ventures that will realize profit down the road
or by reducing turnover time, that is, ‗the speed with which money outlays return profit to the
investor. In addition to helping to resolve the central capitalist contradiction, ostensibly ‗sustainable‘
forms of tourism such as ecotourism in particular may help to resolve what James O‘Connor calls
capitalism‘s ‗second contradiction‘ (cf. Fletcher, 2011, p. 450-51).
However, globalization discourse has not zoomed on tourism for nothing; in fact, the field
of tourism (i.e., not necessarily the ‗tourism discipline‘) is composed of two sub-fields that
one is focusing on ‗environmental impacts, tourism perception and social impacts‘ and the
second one is built upon tourism business studies which has strong marketing connotation
within the global market (Tribe, 1997) . In the process, it is the community that by passed
because ―disorganized capitalism and its tendency to transform itself over space and time-
particularly through the growth of individualization and privatization‖ (cf. Hall, 2004: 138).
In this context, tourism planning and policy-or simply tourism development-has become a
political battle ground by the power brokers which were also connected to the global
structure.
5
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Domestic tourism: a sustainable option?
With respect to the significant role of tourism in the global economy and the destination‘s
wellbeing, the concept of ‗tourism ‗addresses two major sectors: ‘international’ and
‘domestic’. ‗Domestic‘ tourism has been defined as being: 'In relation to a given country or a
region, it is considered a form of tourism, involving residents of the given country travelling
only within this country' (WTO, 1995: 11); and/or 'domestic tourism is the activity of people
visiting destinations within their own country's boundaries' ( Demir, 2004: 325). Although
tourism goes back to the ‗grand tour‘ of preindustrial era; however, it was not until post-
industrial revolution that a subsistence economy of the UK transformed to an urban based
manufacturing and paved the way for the growth of domestic tourism. No doubt,
technological innovation and economic growth, which finally generated a middle class eager
to travel, were main influencing factors. Eventually, by 1900, domestic tourism began to be
consolidated where factors such as limiting working hours, higher wages, weekend holidays,
annual summer holidays, the pioneering of the railway age, and affluent urban population
with the romantic movement of 19th century were highly influential (Burton, 1995). Despite
domestic tourism‘s role in socioeconomic, as well as, infrastructural development of the
destinations, it has not received sufficient attention in terms of research and analysis
(Eijgelaar et al, 2008). As Massidda and Etzo (2012: 603) noted:
‗It is common knowledge that in many countries domestic tourism is dominant with respect to
international flows in terms of both size and economic contribution. In spite of that, only recently
researchers have started to concentrate on this phenomenon and its economic impact, as well as on its
potential for reducing disparities in less developed world areas‘.
Nevertheless, UK residents alone took 76.8 million domestic holidays within the UK in
2007, spending £14 billion. England accounted for 60.9 million of these holidays and spent
£10.9 billion. In Wales the equivalent figures were 6.5 million holidays and £1.1 billion were
spent, and in Scotland, 8.7 million holidays generated £1.9 billion. Domestic tourism for the
UK registered 126.0 million trips (a rise of + 7%) for year 2009.
(billionhttp://www.britishresorts.co.uk/tourismfacts.aspx). In 2005, domestic tourism
contributed an estimated $55.5 billion to the Australian economy, more than three times the
contribution of international arrivals. Despite this, the main focus of Australian academic
tourism research has been on international tourism (Athanasopoulos and Hyndman, 2008: 19).
Domestic tourism has also made various impacts in many areas of China. ‗ It makes a
significant contribution in promoting regional economic growth, improving local economic
structures, driving the development of related industries, enhancing employment and
activating domestic demands' (Wu et al, 2000: 296). Domestic tourism in Turkey has
experienced a burgeoning growth between 1980s and 2000 where the number of travelers
within the country reached 16.4 million. The growth has been attributed to increasing income
level, improved transportation facilities/modes, cultural change, and improved
accommodation sector (Demir, 2004: 327).
‗The World Tourism Organization (WTO) predicts that during the next 20 years the
expansion of domestic tourism will be especially strong in several developing countries, most
notably China, India, Thailand, Brazil and Mexico. These are the examples of contribution of
domestic tourism which is already a growing industry in several parts of the developing
world‘ (Mazimhaka, 2007: 491).The scale of world domestic tourism, on the other hand,
exceeds world international tourism by a ratio of 10:1. For instance, in the case of India, for
every international tourist, there are 80 domestic tourists
(http://www.planningcommission.gov.in/plans/planrel/fiveyr/10th/volume2/v2_ch7_5.pdf).
Domestic tourism has been instrumental in increasing expenditure, reducing seasonality,
improving the geographic spread of tourism, as well as, alleviating regional imbalances.
These outcomes have positively affected job creation, GDP growth and transformation. For
6
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
example, in the case of South Africa, these impacts have been reflected through 49.3 million
trips with receipts valued at R 47 billion (South African Rand) in 2003
(http://www.southafrica.net/media/en/page/annual-reports). After the 9/11, In the case of
United States, international tourism experienced a set back; however, domestic tourism
thrived (WTTC, 2011).
Furthermore, this study is, to a large extent, an attempt to delve into a specific tourism
destination (i.e., Iran), where not only there is not any directed research, but tourism
development itself has not become a full force deliberate policy yet. This study, in a way,
contrary to most of the tourism studies, is focusing on an uncharted waters metaphorically
speaking. Because most of the studies have focused on areas and locations where tourism has
been developed and policies for its development, to some extent, have been formulated. As
Mason and Cheyne (2000: 392) stated:
‗There are few studies on the perceived impacts of tourism either prior to any development or when it
is not yet seen to be a significant economic area of activity for a region. The majority of research since
the mid-70s, however, has been in the form of ―snapshots'' taken at a particular time, in a particular
location, with most of the studies taking place where it was already economically important. The
perceived impacts on host communities and their attitudes to its growth were the focus of much of this
research in this period'.
In another hand, the concept of domestic tourism per se, which has been established as a
dynamic sector in different destinations to achieve various economic, social, and
environmental objectives is a dimension to reckon with (Athanasopoulos et al, 2008; Wu et al,
2000; Burton, 1995; Seckelmann, 2002). Thus, domestic tourism, has been given a lofty
attention to alleviate various economic and social ills, especially in those destinations where
the primary resource development has been in decline and environmentalism has been in rise
(Rigas, 2009). Another qualifying/ amplifying dimension of domestic tourism is its
characteristic as an alternative form of tourism which is sustainable as it remains external to
global tourism system (Higgins-Desbiolles, 2009). Furthermore, domestic tourism is in
harmony with the goals of sustainable management which is also reiterated in the Rio Earth
Summit‘s 12 key principles for sustainable development and the Agenda 21 ―to conserve
sensitive areas; balance the demands of conservation and development; stimulate community-
based economic growth; and preserve the intrinsic features of rural areas‖ (Ghaderi and
Henderson, 2012: 48). As Higgins-Desbiolles (2010, p. 126) articulated: ‗ For instance,
holidaying closer to home may provide us with greater connections to our community and its
environment, thereby combating the sense of alienation increasingly evident in our
globalizing world and fostering an appreciation of our own environment that is conducive to a
commitment to sustainability‘. Arguing for sustainability potentials of domestic tourism is
also plausible through the social dimension of sustainable development (Steward and Kuska,
2010; Baker, 2006). As articulated by the researchers:
Encouraging participation in domestic tourism by minimizing constraints to access and enjoyment
may help bridge cultural gaps and enhance respect for cultures between and within communities.
Domestic travel can raise people‘s appreciation of different cultural, linguistic and religious groups
and of common interests of the people of a country, thus helping to foster national integration.
Similarly, domestic tourism is often more concerned with nation-building (instead of looking for the
„exotic‟)‖. It can expand people‘s knowledge and understanding of their home country, with a
subsequent increase in national pride. Generally, mobility helps people to know and be reflexive
about both self and places. Tourism researchers have acknowledged the importance of putting the
social into tourism. Most social networks develop in the context of leisure. It is the social aspects of
domestic tourism that are of particular interest in the present context as domestic tourism has the
greatest potential for connecting people (cf. Moufakkir, 2010: 50).
Some went further and considered domestic tourism as an important tool in social
integration in line with Putnam‘s concept of ‗social capital‘ essential for community bonding;
7
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
social networks and trust (cf. Moufakkir, 2010). Furthermore, it is immune to problems that
associated with international mass tourism. In fact, domestic tourism tends to have a positive
impact regarding the seasonality, spending, dispersion, security, participation and solidarity.
As suggested by Mendiratta (2011: 5).
‗Domestic tourism, when developed in a meaningful, sustainable and complementary way to
international tourism, offers destinations an exceptional platform for year-round tourism economy
growth and development. And, as importantly, domestic tourism creates a destination that stands
proud as a place for both the people of the world, and those of the destination, to explore and enjoy as
their own‘.
Thus, Iran‘s domestic tourism development issue and the urgency for its research should
not come as a surprise.
The case of Iran-a critical view
Iran is an ancient civilization with land area of 1.648million Km² (terrestrial area of 1.636
million Km² and 12,000Km² of aquatic area), coastline of 2,440Km in the south and 740 Km
in the north and a population size of 78,868,711
(http://geography.about.com/library/cia/blciran.htm). (See figure 1). Iran is located on the
confluence of oriental and occidental world. Iran has ranked seventh in the world in terms of
possessing varieties of attractions (http://lcweb2.loc.gov/frd/cs/profiles/Iran.pdf). Iran with
attractive natural and historical sites is rated among the 10 most touristic countries in the
world in terms of its history. With a wealth of cultural, natural, and historical resources, it can
offer varieties of tourism activities and products. For instance, there are 131 protected areas,
including19 national parks, 91 natural reserve, 21 natural parks, 15 world heritage sites and
54 submitted sites which are on the tentative list (http://whc.unesco.org/en/statesparties/ir/).
Iran also possesses about 1000 spa and a history of medical tourism (Kazemi, 2008).
However, Iran currently ranks 68th in tourism revenues worldwide
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourism_in_Iran#cite_note-IR-1). Iran‘s market share of Middle
East total demand is 16.7%, but on the global scale it is a mere 0.35%. For instance, in
compare to Egypt, an Islamic country of relatively similar geographic size and population,
ranks sixth in the top ten most sought after destinations in the world. Such figures are very
disappointing considering Iran‘s tremendous potential (http://www1.american.edu/ted/iran-
tour.htm?iframe=true&width=100%&height=100%).
Notwithstanding the lack of attention and absence of a clear policy objective to develop
international tourism in Iran, a spontaneous surge in domestic tourism has been witnessed as
relative calm permeated in the country and the turmoil and revolutionary fervor began to
settle to some extent. This rather unplanned domestic tourism activity poses some questions
which answering and exploring them is fundamental to the future of Iran‘s tourism se Figure
1. Map of Iran
8
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Resim 8:
Source: http://www.infoplease.com/atlas/country/iran.html
Now-a-days, the political-economy of Iran along with international sanctions, which is
exacerbated by threat of war, does not make it terribly conducive to international tourism
(inbound foreign tourists). With the exception of limited religious tourism from neighboring
Islamic countries, the latest number of arrivals has remained under 3 million including Iranian
ex-patriots. As stated by Alavi & Yasin (2000: 2-3):
―While Iran has a great potential for attracting tourists due to its rich history and culture, it
dramatically lags behind in terms of achieving such potential. According to the UNSCO, Iran is
ranked as one of the top ten countries in the world in terms of its ancient and historical sites.
However, the number of tourist arrivals to Iran in 1995 was only 443 thousand, which is less than one
tenth of one percent of the total global tourism market. In the case of Iran, the gap between potential
9
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
and reality can be attributed to many factors. The most important of these are the political realities of
Iran, lack of infrastructure needed to support and facilitate tourism activities, and the absence of a
systematic tourism policy‖.
With increasing sanctions imposed against Iran because of its nuclear program, and
ongoing tensions with western powers and their regional allies (cf. Ghaderi and Henderson,
2012), a full force international mass tourism is a far-fetched-scenario. Despite the repeated
claim by Iranian officials that the nuclear program is for peaceful purpose; some of the main
tourism markets have closed their embassies in Iran (e.g., Canada, UK, and USA) (Austen,
2012). However, Iranian officials do not have to throw the baby out with the bathwater. They
can capitalize in and pave the way for domestic tourism because it ‗requires little foreign
exchange to develop, and it is not as vulnerable to fluctuations in numbers caused by
seasonality or problems arising from travel booking systems, international airline schedules,
changing international tastes, perceived security threats or world economic recession‘
(Scheyvens, 2007: 311). Furthermore, the implications of domestic tourism economically
(i.e., in terms of job creation); socially (i.e., in terms of recreation and leisure, as well as,
cohesion among numerous ethnicities); politically (i.e., in terms of placing Iran within the
global community of nations as she deserves), and environmentally (i.e., enhancing
appreciation and awareness of rare natural resources) is undisputed (McDowall and Choi,
2010; Carr, 2002). The bottom line is, if international tourism is not palatable to the public
sector in Iran, which is understandable; however, it needs not to spearhead the same attitude
towards domestic tourism. Because domestic tourism will curb the burgeoning numbers of
outbound tourists (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourism_in_Iran) that results in outflow of
hard currency during the present economic hardship as a result of economic sanctions
(http://www.mb.com.ph/articles/370870/economic-sanctions-hit-irans-merchants).
Building on these themes, it is essential to argue some of the institutional short falls
associated with the public sector‘s attitude. Of course, this is not limited to public sector in
Iran where ―…existing tourism policies in developing countries have tended to concentrate
overwhelmingly on expanding international tourist arrivals from the North and have
frequently ignored both the benefits and problems of the emerging phenomenon of mass
tourism involving domestic and regional visitors‖ (cf. Scheyvens, 2007: 1).
However, the public sector‘s suspicious attitude towards international tourism is not
without its ground as ample critique has leveled against global tourism structure /nature that
discussed in this paper. In respect of those critical views, Iran‘s policy makers‘ attitude is a
blessing in disguise and policy makers‘ ideological position towards international tourism
may not be completely irrelevant as numerous scholars have cautioned about unsustainable
nature of mass tourism in the past (Kuvan, 2010; Gössling, 2002). Therefore, the public space
in Iran is ripe for a home grown economic activity (i.e., domestic tourism), in light of
unwitting behavior of government towards mass tourism. Therefore, to argue for the option of
domestic tourism, Higgins-Desbiolles articulation is worthy of attention when she said:
‗More radically, we may see an acceptance of the need to holiday closer to home or even at home.
This may become imperative for greater numbers of people as the global financial crisis hits, the finite
energy resources we rely on become scarcer and full environmental costing of our activities makes
our old patterns prohibitively expensive or impossible. Rather than decry these developments, we
should embrace such possibilities as they invite us to think more imaginatively about the meaning,
purpose and impacts of our tourism and travel cultures. For instance, holidaying closer to home may
provide us with greater connections to our community and its environment, thereby combating the
sense of alienation increasingly evident in our globalizing world and fostering an appreciation of our
own environment that is conducive to a commitment to sustainability‘ (2009: 126).
10
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Adaptive domestic tourism model (ADTM)
An Adaptive Domestic Tourism Model (ADTM) is illustrated in Figure 2, which
contextualizes domestic tourism planning within a sustainability framework that ‗accounts for
resource-based (e.g. impacts on natural and cultural capital), activity-based (e.g. growth and
development of industry) and community-based (e.g. involvement of social capital in a local
context) traditions‘ (cf. Larson and Poudyal, 2012: 919). ADTM is adopted to fit Iran‘s case
in respect of culture, religion, geography, demography, environment and Iran‘s political-
economy. The model focuses on domestic tourism development in order to remove ambiguity
regarding the goals and strategies that needs to be clarified by the managers and planners.
Therefore, ADTM is a framework that can facilitate acquiring knowledge and know-how
towards this process. It is also essential to clarify the potentials and problems at the beginning
of the process through the feedback loop. Notwithstanding the national decision (i.e., at the
macro level), a National Tourism Organization (NTO) is a prerequisite to establish a
functional institution specifically for tourism. This will clarify and facilitate a political vision
‗that step beyond a sometimes fragmented and disorganized administrative culture‘ (Burns,
2004: 33). NTO-via domestic tourism, will have three fundamental objectives: first, it will
remedy some of the economic ills through job creation; second, it will provide an uplifting
recreational means to a population in desperate need of transition from revolution to
recreation/regeneration; third, it will facilitate a socio-cultural harmony through interaction
among ethnicities that can bring cohesion and understanding within different ethnic groups in
a multi-ethnic country (Moufakkir, 2010). NTO will approach the process within a
sustainability framework to maximize the benefits and minimize the impacts through three
traditions: resource-based, activity-based, and community-based traditions (Saarinen, 2006).
Based on such perspective (traditions), ADTM inseminates sustainability process/goals into
the political-economy of domestic tourism where power issues and decision-making processes
are established and perceived at the local levels (i.e., local, provincial/regional, and urban).
Not to forget, ADTM is a domestic project that supposed to:
‗… Address the elements of education, training, and capacity building, as is strongly indicated in pro-
poor tourism discussions, for example. There is also an urgent need to re-evaluate the perspectives
from which the industry and its sustainability are perceived and redefine the position of tourism and
scale of analysis in sustainable development discourses‘ (Saarinen, 2006: 1131).
In a way, the ‗resource-based‘ tripod lays the foundation for three levels/scales (indicated
in grey bubbles) where domestic tourism will function. The characteristics of each level are
different in terms of capacity, education, attractions and the host in general. Such scaling will
allow for better control, management action, implementation and monitoring. This is also
conducive to Iran‘s case which is challenging geographically and culturally. This is
tantamount to a decentralized approach that will emit innovative ideas based on knowledge‘s
of the community at each level. In another hand, ADTM is not a top-down planning process
but rather it is place-based model guided by local knowledge and concerns (Larson and
Poudyal, 2012). For instance, the ‗urban tourism organization‘ is identified as a separate
scale because an approach to and management of tourism in urban centers require certain
actions that are dictated by challenges specific to urban areas. Namely, environmental profile
of urban areas in terms of quality of urban fabric, infrastructure, pollution, and waste
management is not comparable to profile of rural areas. Public-private partnership takes a new
meaning when it comes to urban regeneration via tourism (Tsenkova, 2002). ADTM focuses
on market ties which in the case of domestic tourism it takes a different meaning and
morphology. Interestingly, domestic tourism market, for example, in the case of Turkey
(Özel and Kozak, 2012), showed an expanse of motivations and clusters that can easily fulfill
the suppliers expectations. In the case of Iran, which is highly multi-ethnic/culture entity, a
rich market with varieties of motivations to travel at home also is in abundance. Although, the
11
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
model (Figure 2), divides tourism to domestic and international; however, the focus is on
‗domestic‘ tourism where underpinning planning philosophy is based on governance inclusive
of public sector, private sector and universities within the community framework. Involving
universities in such partnership is not metaphorical, since in the case of Iran, ubiquitousness
of Islamic Azad University is a reality. This notion is also known as TRG-triangle (tourism,
research and governance), which ‗is a form of steering that involves the governed and other
actors necessary to provide knowledge-based management‘ (Viken, 2011: 335). The presence
of NGOs is to signify the community and its role as a formidable stakeholder in the process.
However, the decentralized nature of the model aims to facilitate the flourishing of civil
institutions which lacks in the case of Iran, as well as, in most of the developing countries
(Burns, 2004). The policy formulation, plan and implementation stage in ADTM is also an
adaptive practice. This means that shortfalls and benefits of the whole domestic tourism
project are addressed at the beginning of the process through ‗feedback loop‘. There will not
be room for surprises at the end. In a ‗bottom-up‘ approach, obstacles associated with
institutional complexity will be discussed and avoided.
12
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 2. An Adaptive Domestic Tourism Model.
DOMESTIC TOURISM
DEVELOPMENT: THE CASE OF
IRAN.
FEEDBACK
NATIONAL TOURISM ORGANIZATION (NTO)
Resource- Activity- Community-
based. based. based.
Provincial tourism
Local tourism organization. Urban tourism
organization. organization.
Focus on local Regional level approach
affairs/community Urban specific
to tourism planning
based operations.
&management. tourism.
TYPES OF TOURISM BASED ON MARKET
TIES?
Domestic International tourism (mass
tourism and not welcomed by the
(sustainable/pr public sector).
actical).
PLANNING APPROACH/DOMESTIC TOURISM PLANNING PROCESS.
FOCUSED PROPOSITION.
Public sector; private sector;
universities/NGOs (TRG triangle).
policy plan Implementatio
n.
Implementation stage will be flexible and open to a participatory decision-making in order
to acquire cooperation as well as greater logistic, financial, and technical support across
multiple scales. ADTM is not ‗one-shot, big bang’ (Burns, 2004) master plan, which are
highly technical and discrete; therefore, it is based on local values with measurable outcomes
13
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
and immediate, mid-term and long-term utility. The underpinning philosophy of ADTM is to
be implementable in a way to take full account of the local social dynamics in the context of a
platform for sustainable growth and human development.
Study method
The study has administered a multi- strategy approach, which is also known as
‗triangulation‘. It entails using more than one method of source of data in the study of social
phenomena (Bryman, 2004; Fetterman, 2010). See also figure 3. The first tier of the research
(method 1) brings in sociological theories of: ‘culture-ideology of consumerism’, ‘tragedy
of tourism resources’ (strategic game), ‘environmental economics’, ‘ecological economics’,
‘political ecology’, and ‘global tourism system’ (Higgins-Desbiolles, 2009, 2011, 2004;
Schilcher, 2007; Fletcher, 2011; Sklair, 2010, 1999; Burns & Novelli, 2007; Garrod and
Fyall, 1998). Each of these theories brings in sociological, ecological, as well as, political-
economy discourse in the context of globalizing capitalism/global economic system that
critically analyzes the paradoxes between international tourism system (mass tourism) and
sustainable development. These authors argue that sustainable tourism development is a far-
fetched goal because the tourism industry is interwoven into globalizing capitalism based on
overproduction and overconsumption that environmental and social problems are an
inevitable result. For instance, Bramwell‘s research in the case of Malta‘s tourism pictures
some of the contradictions as he noted:
14
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 3. A Triangulation research process model.
Method 1. Theoretical discourse based Method 2. Qualitative approach:
on following theories: ‘culture-ideology of unobtrusive observation /ethnography/indirect
consumerism’, ‘tragedy of tourism measure/content analysis (Fetterman, 2010;
resources’ (strategic game), ‘environmental Trokhim, 2006; Reeves et al, 2008). . Authors’
economics’, ‘ecological economics’, involvement through various research projects
‘political ecology’, and ‘global tourism in Iran, their unobtrusive observation as native
system’ (Higgins-Desbiolles, 2009, 2011, scholars highly aware of Iran’s socio-cultural
2004; Schilcher, 2008; Fletcher, 2011; Sklair, characteristics, religion, history, geography and
2010, 1999; Burns & Novelli, 2007; Garrod political-economy and environment. Knowledge
and Fyall, 1998) of Iran’s multi-ethnic character and variation.
Multiple research
method (triangulation)
applied to investigate
the conduciveness of
domestic tourism as an
option for the case of
Iran.
Method 3. Quantitative research strategy. A deductive
approach to data collection and analysis based on
descriptive statistics. Two population groups in two
different locations were targeted; non-probability
sampling was applied; self-administered survey
questionnaires were distributed; SPSS program
employed to conduct data analysis.
15
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Many residents realize that there are relatively few economic alternatives to this industry within the
global economy, and some recall the economy‘s precariousness when the country gained political
independence in 1964. But the resulting growth has exacerbated problems of economic dependency,
class inequality, low wages, summer crowding, and considerable environmental degradation. Some
Maltese are concerned that it has significantly accelerated the loss of scarce open space and has
contributed to an erosion of moral standards and family life. [Furthermore], ‗Government-related
organizations led one intervention advocating sustainable development, but actually it was much
affected by business considerations and technical rationality. A second effort by a heritage
organization emphasized environmental concerns, but this lacked power to influence official policies‘
(2006: 957).
The above statement is not irrelevant to what Milne and Ateljevic stated about hegemony,
globalization and tourism policies by saying: ―Tourism […] must be viewed as a transaction
process which is at once driven by the global priorities of multi-national corporations, geo-
political forces and broader forces of economic change, and the complexities of the local –
where residents, visitors, workers, government and entrepreneurs interact at the industry
‗coal-face‘‖ (cf. Giampiccoli, 2007: 176).Therefore, an alternative form of tourism (e.g.,
domestic tourism) may be sustainable and averse to hazards of globalizing capitalism. In the
meantime, domestic tourism is conducive to the present political economy, as well as, to the
socio-cultural characteristics of Iran as a religious nation-state where the institutions
responsible for tourism see international tourism as a global conspiracy to export western
decadency to Islamic Republic of Iran
(http://english.farsnews.com/newstext.php?nn=9007271782). Such an attitude is a ‗blessing in
disguise’ that coincidentally shares some common grounds with ‗culture-ideology of
consumerism’ perspective that recommends travel closer to home or at home as a mechanism
of sustainability (Higgins-Desbiolles, 2011).
If Iranian officials are calling international tourism as a form of cultural invasion, the pro
‗culture-ideology of consumerism‘ theorists are also wary of international tourism as means to
fix the globalizing capitalism problems by saying:
―… Researchers, however, identified a number of mechanisms by which capitalism is able to alleviate
overproduction crises through economic growth. Thus, they contend that capitalism requires continual
expansion in order to survive – what Sandler calls the GOD (‗grow or die‘) principle. Harvey, for
instance, observes that excess capital may be reabsorbed into the system by means of a variety of
different spatial and/or temporal displacements or ‗fixes‘, thereby (temporarily) forestalling an
overproduction crisis. Tourism can be seen to provide a number of such fixes. Harvey‘s ‗spatial fix‘
entails exporting excess capital to a new geographical location where it can be reinvested in novel
development. International tourism development can be viewed as an ideal means by which this is
accomplished, and ecotourism in particular, in its quest specifically for relatively undeveloped areas,
can be viewed as the epitome of this strategy‖ (cf. Fletcher, 2011: 448-49).
Thus, the notion of international mass tourism is an arrangement to fix the problems
inherent in global economic structure (Fletcher, 2011; Evans, 2008). However, scholars who
adhere to this argument do not throw the baby out with the bath water. They are calling for an
alternative globalization –alternative to generic globalization (Sklair, 2010; Evans, 2008),
which is also conducive to alternative tourism (g. e., domestic tourism). Finally, domestic
tourism can be perceived in tantamount to a means of production that ‗create opportunities for
movements to experiment with new practices prefiguring the democratic management of
collective affairs that must be central to any progressive alternative institutional architecture‘
(Evans, 2008: 276).
Second tier (method 2) focused on inductive approach based on observation, content
analysis, unstructured interviews, researcher reflexivity, and numerous visits and personal
communication (Gilgun, 2010; Watt, 2007) with officials in Iran. Participant observation and
direct observation have been significant approach that allowed us to delve into the culture and
16
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
the context. This process provided the collection and storage of data in relation to power
relations, community attitude, and conflict between and within the power bases relevant to
present political economy of Iran. Within the second tier of study method in the context of an
inductive reasoning, unstructured interviews contributed to the analysis of field data
(Trochim, 2006). For instance, collaboration in relation to tourism planning and
development in Iran is not necessarily a process of joint decision-making among key
stakeholders. Reasons are fragmented political-economy, geographic vastness of the country,
multi-ethnic/culture trait, and overall preoccupation with international conflict (Akbari, 2011;
Alamdari, 2005). With the present multiplicity of power base, a unified policy-essential for
establishment of an international mass tourism system remains to be an illusion. As Eisenstadt
(2011: 1) stated :
‗Iran‘s political system is characterized by parallel structures that are the locus of multiple power
centers. These consist of both traditional and revolutionary institutions: the President and Supreme
Leader; the Majles and Guardian Council; the Judiciary and Special Clerical Courts; and the regular
military and the Islamic Revolution Guard Corps (IRGC). Due to this organizational complexity and
the importance of informal influence networks, the functioning of the regime is often opaque—even
to many of its members‘.
One proposed solution to this, which is indicated in the ADTM (figure 2) model (i.e.,
local, regional and urban), is to apply a decentralized approach to domestic tourism system
management as each level in the system has its own so called DNA (Gunn and Var, 2002).
Gunn and Var have used the DNA metaphorically in reference to supporting resources for
tourism which signifies the uniqueness of each destination. Nevertheless, while international
mass tourism remains a far-fetched scenario; however, domestic tourism by its nature has
been less subject to contentions as it is not bounded into the global tourism structure- role of
tourism in providing capitalist fixes (Fletcher, 2011).
The third tier of research method (method 3) (Figure 3) focused on domestic travelers‘
perception to explore their views about bottlenecks associated with traveling in Iran. The
assumption is that travelers‘ perception can shed some light about the behavior of public
sector towards domestic tourism development. The approach involved an empirical study
through the administration of a survey questionnaire which had applied by Mason and Cheyne
(2000). In addition, numerous other studies have examined different destinations that
particularly targeted travelers or residents (domestic tourists) attitudes towards tourism
development (Andereck & Vogt, 2000; Andriottis, 2002 ; Ap and Pang, 2002). For this
purpose, two locations were targeted based on their ranking in terms of receiving the number
of domestic visitors.
The process of sampling and distribution of survey questionnaire were conducted in two
different locations. The first location was the city of Tehran (the capital city), and second
location was the city of Chaloos located in the north of Iran in the region of Caspian Sea.
Chaloos was selected as it is located in one of the highly popular sun, sea, and sand tourism
zone and the area is also popular for its green and lush environment. It is also playing the role
of ‗pressured area‘ –a rural region within the sphere of influence of major urban areas (i.e.,
Tehran), where the countryside is used for daytrip recreation (Burton, 1995).
A non-probability sampling was administered based on a mode of sampling known as
‗convenience‘ sampling. This mode is highly popular in studies of this nature and in social
sciences where the samples are simply available to the researcher by virtue of its accessibility
(Bryman, 2004). Out of 500 self-completion/administered questionnaires, 400 were
distributed in various travel agencies in Tehran, and the rest were filled out by the respondents
in Chaloos, where tourists were targeted in different hotels. The total of 483 survey
17
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
questionnaires were collected and analyzed, with the number of missing samples of 17. Each
questionnaire form contained a total of 42 questions composed of three sections.
The medium of language was Farsi (the official language of Iran). This was also due to the
nature of the study which focused on domestic tourists and foreign tourists were not
considered. The responses to the questionnaire were analyzed using SPSS version 13.0
(http://www-01.ibm.com/software/analytics/spss/). Data analysis also revealed the internal
reliability of the indicators that made up the scale/index is in a consistent manner, meaning,
confident interval for the Cronbach‘s Alpha value is 0.95 percent, which is a validation of
reliability coefficients. This is also obvious in relation to standard deviation where almost a
bell shape curve can be generated as the variation from the grand mean is minimal. Refer to
the appendix A for the statistical information and data tabulation.
First 33 questions designed to measure the responses based on Likert scale –essentially a
multiple indicator – on a 5-point scale referring to frequency and evaluation ranging from
‗totally agree, agree, I have no idea (neutrality), disagree, and totally disagree‘ (totally
agree=1, agree=2, I have no idea=3, disagree=4, and totally disagree=5) (See also appendix
A/table 1, 2). As shown in table 1, respondents overwhelmingly supported domestic tourism
and are aware of its economic, social and cultural impacts. They believe domestic tourism can
bring different ethnicities together and achieve cross-cultural understandings. They also
believe that domestic tourism can be instrumental in maintaining the heritage resources. They
are also in agreement with the need for recreation and leisure which domestic tourism can
fulfill these needs (consistency of standard deviation in respect of cumulative percentages of
respondents to totally agree and agree ranges (for quantitative statistics, refer to Table 1and
2/Appendix A). However, they are highly critical of public institutions for lack of attention to
this sector. They are critical of lack of adequate facilities, information, adequate
transportation, sanitations, attractive food outlet, and quality of services. The findings are in
accordance with the literature that supports domestic tourism as an option when the condition
is not suitable for mass tourism. The second section composed of 4 questions regarding
demographic information to identify age, gender, education and frequency of travel pattern
(for quantitative statistics refer to appendix A/table 3). The third part of the questionnaire
composed of 5 items to clarify the purpose of travel, seasonality, length of stay, availability of
information prior to trip, and satisfaction with the facilities (See also appendix A/table 4 for
quantitative statistics).
Discussion and Conclusion
This study has focused on domestic tourism in the context of political economy of Iran. In
this regard, Iran‘s political economy manifest in lack of cohesiveness amongst numerous
political and economic clique (i.e., formal and informal), who do not realize the advantages of
domestic tourism as a potential sustainable mode of tourism (Seckelmann, 2002; Ghaderi,
2011). The overarching problem identified in this paper is the policy makers‘ suspicious of
international tourism (i.e., to some extent understandable); however, this attitude need not to
hold domestic tourism at bay which is a significant tool to development. in fact, there are
critical views of international tourism who defend domestic tourism by saying ‗if we took
more time and resources to make ‗here‘ look more like ‗there‘ to be ‗here‘ would become
more attractive‘ (cf. Burns, 1999: 345-6). There is also a deficit in the literature which mainly
has focused on evaluation and impact assessment that generalized to other destinations. Iran‘s
case is unique and complex. One can easily witness the clashes of ideas of modernity and
traditionalism hand in hand that makes achieving a synthesis of reconciliation cumbersome
(Jahanbegloo, 2004; Arjomand, 2002). In the meantime, the dynamism of Iranian society has
enough space to pursue a rational planning process towards a formidable, as well as, a
18
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
sustainable domestic tourism system and its definition. This study has tried to fulfill the need
to theorize the nature of power, conflict, development and political agency (Theerapappisit,
2011) in the context of domestic tourism and the deficit of sustainable planning instrument.
Within such a kaleidoscope of political economy, ‗domestic tourism‘ dissected as a project
which potentially is impregnated with social, economic, environmental, and political and
sustainability connotations not as a metaphor but a plausible reality. For instance, domestic
tourism and its growth in Iran has become a challenge where citizens are demanding
recreation and leisure as their human right, while the officials perceive it as a luxurious
decadency associated with the western way of life. In this regard ‗the European Union (EU)
declared that travel and tourism is a basic human right and introduced a program whereby the
EU will subsidize vacations for youth, the elderly, the disabled and for those who are poor‘
(http://landlopers.com/2010/05/27/is-travel-a-human-right/). The study looked at anatomy of
domestic tourism project as a wakeup call to the public sector not only to fulfill the demands
of the tourism market in the country, but also a way out for the policy makers who are
suspicious of tourism and complacent to the tenacity of the Iranians to travel. Therefore,
domestic tourism project analyzed and justified on three grounds. First, domestic tourism has
been identified as an activity that can be immune to the vagaries that are laid against global
tourism structure (i.e., especially mass tourism) in the context of global economic structure.
This perspective, under the ‗culture-ideology of consumerism’, is highly critical of mass
tourism as an active dimension of global accumulation of wealth controlled by global tourism
which is motivated by profit through capitalist production of mass tourism. they argue that in
respect of production and consumption, as the key to rate of growth of profit, the global
structure of tourism contradicts the implementation of sustainability principles in relation to
ecology, society and economic (Higgins-Desbiolles, 2010; Sklair, 2002; Hall, 2009; Azarya,
2004). Therefore, sustainable tourism becomes an ultimate paradox of globalization;
furthermore, it fixates the destinations (i.e., especially in the less developed world) to the
margins of global economic structure where ‗sustainability‘ is the last thing to be concerned
with. ‗Their marginality is kept so that it can be commercialized in the context of
globalization‘ (Azarya, 2004: 964).
Secondly, domestic tourism and its system definition (Ritchie and Crouch, 2003)
interrogated in the case of Iran, was examined through an interview with the officials who
supposed to agree upon and involve in a framework to govern such system. Because without
an explicit recognition and common understanding among formal sector, it would be almost
impossible to agree on the entity for which the strategy is to be developed. The result of the
qualitative approach to this tier of research revealed that an absence of an explicit philosophy
resulted in lack of development of a coherent domestic tourism policy. Notwithstanding
religious tourism dynamism in Iran, domestic tourism system should embrace and facilitate
numerous compatible activities along the religious practices/worships without jeopardizing
the sacred traditions. In fact, some entrepreneurial developments are underway to achieve just
this (personal communication, August 15, 2012).
At the end, the governance for tourism must incorporate the present dynamism of
religious tourism with the demand of the population for a better mobility, recreation,
entertainment, art and cultural activities within a clearly defined domestic tourism system.
Such system must take under consideration several fundamental issues. First, domestic
tourism will save Iran billions of dollars which leak out through outbound tourism. This is the
case where the country is experiencing the shortage of hard currency and economic hardship
(Gladstone, 2012). ‗According to Euro monitor report (Euro monitor International ,2009)
there were 5,588.800 people traveled to other countries, among which 4,633.000 people
traveled for leisure and totally have spent 31,207.8 IRR billion and it is predicted that the
19
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
number of outbound tourists from Iran will reach 6,167.000 in 2013 and outgoing tourism
expenditure will reach 26,682.000 IRR billion‘ (Asadi and Daryaei, 2011: 780). Secondly, in
a multi-ethnic Iran with regional disparities and a gap between rural and urban areas, domestic
tourism has the potential to contribute to cross-cultural understanding and rural development
(Seckelmann, 2002; Brouder, 2012; Yang, 2011; Sheykhi, 2009) which can strengthen the
communal bonds, as well as, modify the negative stereotypes. Third, domestic tourism, if
supported and involved by the active role of public sector (i.e., political will), can be a
catalyst to lay down the supporting factors and resources essential for domestic tourism now
and international tourism in the future (Ritchie and Crouch, 2003).
Hopefully, this study gains the legitimacy and justification as it is the first study of its kind
in this location, and it is a research about tourism where tourism has not been assimilated into
the psychic of the policy makers as a means for economic growth and development (Alipour
and Heydari, 2005). Last but not least, this study explored the situation of tourism in Iran
where government‘s perspective is not conducive to embracing international tourism in one
hand, and does not have a clear policy how to cope with a spontaneous domestic tourism in
another hand. Domestic tourism can become a catalyst and a strategy to rescale the cities
which are struggling with unemployment and lack of proper services/facilities because of
rural-urban migration in a rapidly urbanizing country (71% of population reside in urban
areas) (https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/fields/2212.html).
Domestic tourism can become complementary strength to community-based strategies to
enhance social capital, increase citizen involvement and to build civic capacity (Svatch and
Kantor, 2003). Alas, despite a ready to develop potentials, public sector needs to overcome
some obvious barriers. These barriers are: lack of education about tourism impacts, lack of
vision, lack of education about development processes, insufficient infrastructure, lack of
direction and organization, lack of decentralized approach, and need for hospitality training
(Gunn and Var, 2002). The fact remains that regardless of the absence of a clear policy
guideline, spontaneous domestic tourism has been on the rise throughout the country. Such a
surge in domestic tourism in Iran attributed to various structural changes brought by the
Islamic Revolution of 1979 that accompanied by demographic change, income distribution
throughout larger population, technological revolution in communication and popularization
of travel (Ghaderi, 2011: Sheykhi, 2008).
References
Akbari, R.H. (2011). Posturing of Political Parties Indicates Fragmentation among
Conservatives. Retrieved from http://www.insideiran.org/news/posturing-of-political-parties-
indicates-fragmentation-among-conservatives/
Alamdari, K. (2005). The Power Structure of the Islamic Republic of Iran: transition from
populism to clientelism, and militarization of the government. Third World Quarterly, 26 (8),
1285 – 1301.
Alavi, J., and Yasin, M.M. (2000). Iran's Tourism Potential, and market realities: An
empirical approach to closing the gap. Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing., 9(2), 1-22.
Andereck, K., and Vogt, C. (2000). The Relationship between Residents‘ Attitudes Toward
Tourism and Tourism Development Options. Journal of Travel Research 39(1), 27–36.
Andriottis, K. (2002). Residents‘ satisfaction or dissatisfaction with public sector
Governance: The Cretan case, Tourism and Hospitality Research 4 (1), pp.53–68.
Ap, J., and Pang, D. (2002). Community Perceptions of Eco-Tourism. Retrieved form
http://fama2.us.es:8080/turismo/turismonet1/economia%20del%20turismo/turismo%20y%20
medio%20ambiente/COMMUNITY%20PERCEPTIONS%20OF%20ECOTOURISM.PDF
20
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Arjomand, S. (2002). The reform movement and the debate on modernity and tradition in
contemporary Iran. International Journal of middle East Studies, 34, 719-731.
doi:10.1017.S0020743802004063
Asadi, R. and Daryaei, M. (2011). Analysis and Prioritization of Push Factors of Iranian
Outbound Tourists. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 5(11), 780-787.
Athanasopoulos, G, and Hyndman, R. J (2008) Modeling and forecasting Australian
Domestic Tourism. Tourism Management. 19 (1), 19-31.
Austen, I. (2012, September 7). Canada Closes Tehran Embassy and Orders Iran Envoys to
Leave. The New York Times. Retrieved from
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/08/world/middleeast/canada-closes-its-embassy-in-
iran.html?_r=2
Azarya, V. (2004). Globalization and International Tourism in Developing Countries:
Marginality as a Commercial Commodity. Current Sociology, 52 (6), 949-967.
Baker, S. (2006). Sustainable Development. London: Routledge.
Beaumont, N., and Dredge, D. (2010). Local Tourism Governance: a comparison of three
network approaches. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 18 (1), 7-28.
Bramwell, B. (2006). Actors, power, and discourses of growth limits . Annals of Tourism
Research, 33, (4), 957-978.
Brouder, P. (2012). Creative Outposts: Tourism's Place in Rural Innovation. Tourism
Planning and Development, 9(4), 383-396.
Bryman, A. (2004). Social Research Methods. New York: Oxford University Press.
Burns, P. M. (1999). Paradoxes in Planning: tourism elitism or brutalism? Annals of Tourism
Research, 26(2), 329-348.
Burns, P. M. (2004). Tourism Planning: A Third Way? Annals of Tourism Research, 31 (1),
24-43.
Burns, P. M., and Noveli, M. (Eds.). (2007). Tourism and Politics: Global Frameworks and
Local Realities. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Burton, R. (1995). Travel Geography. (2nd Ed.). New York: Prentice Hall.
Carr, N. (2002). A comparative analysis of the behaviour of domestic and international young
tourists. Toursim Management, 23(3), 321-325.
Collier, P. (2010). The Plundered Planet: Why We Must-and How We Can-Manage Nature
for Global Prosperity. New York: Oxford University Press.
Cole, S. (2009). A Logistic Tourism Model: Resort Cycles, Globalization, and Chaos. Annals
of Tourism Research, 36 (4), 689-714.
Cooper, C. and Hall, C.M. (2008). Contemporary Tourism: An International Approach.
Oxford: Butterworth- Heinemann.
Demir, C. (2004). A Profile of Turkish Tourism. International Journal of Contemporary
Tourism Management, 16 (5), 325-328.
Edgell, D.L., Allen, M.D., Smith, G., and Swanson, J. (2008).Tourism Policy and Planning:
Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow. New York: Butterworth- Heinemann.
Eijgelaar, E., Peeters, P., and Piket, P. ( 2008). ―Domestic and International Tourism in a
Globalized World. Ever the twain shall meet - relating international and domestic tourism‖.
21
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
November , 24-26, Rajasthan, India RC50. International Tourism, International Sociological
Association Jaipur.
Eisenstadt, M. (2011). The Strategic Culture of the Islamic Republic of Iran: Operational and
Policy Implications. Retrieved from
http://www.washingtoninstitute.org/uploads/Documents/opeds/4e60ff471079a.pdf
Evans, P. (2008). Is an Alternative Globalization Possible? Politics & Society. 36(2), pp.
271-305.
Farrell, B.H., and Twining-Ward, L. (2004). Reconceptualizing Tourism. Annals of Tourism
Research, 31 (2), 274-295.
Farsari, I., Butler, R.W., and Szivas, E. (2011). Complexity in tourism policies: A Cognitive
mapping approach. Annals of Tourism Research, 38 (3), 1110-1134.
Fetterman, D. M. (2010). Ethnography: Step-by-Step. (3rd.Ed.). Thousand Oaks/CA: Sage
Publications, Inc.
Fletcher, R. (2011). Sustaining Tourism, Sustaining Capitalism? The Tourism Industry‘s Role
in Global Capitalist Expansion. Tourism Geographies, 13 (3), 443-461.
Garrod, B., and Fyall, A. (1998). Beyond the rhetoric of sustainable tourism? Tourism
Management, 19 (3), 199-212.
Ghaderi, Z. (2011). Domestic tourism in Iran. Anatolia-An International Journal of Tourism
and Hospitality Research, 22(2), 278-181.
Ghaderi, Z., and Henderson, J. C. (2012). Sustainable Rural Tourism in Iran: A perspective
from Hawraman Village. Tourism Management Perspectives, 2-3, 47-54.
Giampiccoli, A. (2007). Hegemony, Globalisation and Tourism Policies in Developing
Countries. In P. a. Burns (Ed.), Tourism and Politics: Global Frameworks and Local Realities
(pp. 175-192). New York: Elsevier.
Gilgun, J.F. (2010). Reflexivity and Qualitative Research. Current Issues in Qualitative
Research, 1 (2), 1-8.
Gladstone, R. (2012, October 16). Iran Sanction May cut Supply of Currency. The New York
Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/17/world/middleeast/irans-supply-
of-currency-may-be-at-risk-in-sanctions.html?_r=0
Gössling, S. (2002). Global Environmental Consequences of Tourism. Global Environmental
Change, 12(4), 283-302.
Gunn, C.A., and Var, T. (2002). Tourism Planning: Basics, Concepts, Cases. (4th.Ed).New
York: Routledge.
Hall, C.M. (2004). Reflexivity and Tourism Research: Situating myself and /with others. In J.
Phillimore and L. Goodson (Eds.), Qualitative Research in Tourism: Ontologies,
Epistemologies and Methodologies. (pp. 137-155). London: Routledge.
Hall, C.M. (Ed.). (2007). Pro-Poor Tourism: Who Benefits? Clevedon: Channelview.
Hall, C. M. (2009). Degrowing Tourism: Décroissance, Sustainable Consumption and Steady-
State Tourism. Anatolia: An International Journal of Tourism and Hospitality Research ,
20(1), 46-61.
Haque, M. S. (1999). The Fate of Sustainable Development Under Neo-Liberal Regimes in
Developing Countries. International Political Science review, 20(2), 197-218.
22
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Harrison, D. (1994). Tourism, Capitalism and Development in Less Developed Countries. In
L. Sklair (Ed.), Capitalism and Development. (pp. 232-257). New York: Routledge.
Higgins-Desbiolles, F. (2006). More than an ―industry‖: the forgotten power of tourism as a
social force. Tourism Management, 27 (6), 1192-1208.
Higgins-Desbiolles, F. (2009). The elusiveness of sustainability in tourism: The culture-
ideology of consumerism and its implications. Tourism and Hospitality Research, 10 (2), 116-
129.
Higgins-Desbiolles, F. (2008). Justice Tourism and Alternative Globalization. Journal of
Sustainable Tourism. 16(3), 345-364.
Higgins-Desbiolles, F. (2012). The Hotel Bauen‘s Challenge to Cannibalizing Capitalism.
Annals of Tourism Research, 39 (2), 620-640.
Hosseini, H. (2003). Why Development is more Complex than Growth: Clarifying some
Confusions. Review of Social Economy, 61(1), 92-110.
Hurka, T. (1992). Sustainable Development: What Do We Owe to Future Generations?
Retrieved from http://www.ethics.ubc.ca/papers/susdev.html#hurka
Inskeep, E. (1999). Tourism Planning: An Integrated and Sustainable Development
Approach. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Inc.
Jafari, J. (1982). The Tourism Market Basket of Goods and Services: the components and
nature of tourism. In T.V.Singh, J. Kaur, and D.P. Singh (Eds.), Studies in tourism, wildlife,
parks, conservation (pp.1-12). New Delhi: Metropolitan.
Karbassian, A. (2000). Islamic Revolution and the Management of the Iranian Economy.
Social Research. 67 (2), 620-40.
Kates, R.W., Pariris, T.M., and Leiserowitz, A.A.(2005). What is Sustainable Development?
Goals, Indicators, Values, and Practices. Environment, 47 (3), 10-21.
Kazemi, Z. (2008). Study of the effective factors for attracting medical tourism in Iran.
Lulea/Sweden: Lulea University of Technology. Retrieved December 26, 2012, from
http://epubl.ltu.se/1653-0187/2008/021/index-en.html
Kuvan, Y. (2010). Mass Tourism Development and Deforestation in Turkey. Anatolia: An
International Journal of Tourism and Hospitality Research, 21(1), 155-168.
Larson, L. R., and Poudyal, N.C. (2012). Developing sustainable tourism through adaptive
resource management: a case study of Machu Picchu, Peru. Journal of Sustainable Tourism,
20(7), 917-938.
Mason, p., and Cheney, j. (2000). Residents' attitudes to proposed tourism development.
Annals of Tourism Research. (27) 2. pp. 391-411.
Massidda, C. and Etzo, I. (2012). The Determinants of Italian domestic tourism: A panel data
analysis. Tourism Management, 33 (3), 603-610.
Marsh, W.M., and Grossa, Jr, J. (2005). Environmental Geography: Science, Land Use, and
Earth Systems (3rd.Ed). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Martinez-Alier, J, Pascual, U, Viven, F. D, and Zaccai, E. (2010a). Sustainable de-growth:
Mapping the context, criticisms and future prospects of and emerging paradigm. Ecological
Economics, 69 (9), 1741-1747.
23
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Martinez-Alier, J, Kallis, G, Veuthey, S, Walter, M, Temper, L. (2010b). Social Metabolism,
Ecological Distribution Conflicts, and Valuation Languages. Ecological Economics, 70 (2),
153-158.
Mazimhaka, J. (2007). Diversifying Ruanda‘s Tourism Industry: a role for domestic tourism.
Development Southern Africa, 24. (3), 491-504.
Mehryar, A.H., & Ahmad-Nia, S. (2004). Age-structural transition in Iran: short and long
term consequences of drastic fertility swings during the final decades of twentieth century.
Retrieved from
http://www.cicred.org/Eng/Seminars/Details/Seminars/Popwaves/PopwavesMehryarAhmad-
Nia.pdf
Mendiratta, A. (2011). Domestic Tourism: Home Grown-Growth. Retrieved from
http://www.cnnmediainfo.com/task/download/TASK_Compass_27.pdf
McDowall, S. and Choi, Y. (2010). A Comparative Analysis of Thailand Residents'
Perception of Tourism's Impacts. Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality & Tourism,
11(1), 36-55.
Mill, R.C., & Morrison, A. (1989). The Tourism System. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
Miller, G., Rathouse, K., Scarles, C., Holms, K., and Tribe, J. (2010). Public Understanding
of Sustainable Tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 37 (3), 627-645.
Moufakkir, O. (2010). Peace through Domestic Tourism and Tourism Rights: Inclusion of
Muslim Ethnic Minorities in the Context of Social Tourism. The Journal of Tourism and
Peace Research, 1 (1), 42-59.
O‘Gorman, K, McLellan, L.R, Baum, T. (2007). Tourism. In Iran: Central Control and
Indigeneity. In R. Butler and T.Hinch (Eds.), Tourism and Indigenous Peoples: Issues and
Implications. (pp.251-264). Burlington: Butterworth-Heinemann.
Özel, C.H., and Kozak, N. (2012). Motive Based Segmentation of the Cultural Tourism
Market: A Study of Turksih Domestic Tourists. Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality
& Tourism, 13(3), 165-186.
Papatheodorou, A. (2004). Exploring the Evolution of Tourism Resorts. Annals of Tourism
Research, 31 (1), 219-237.
Redclift, M. R. (2007). Frontiers: histories of civil society and nature. Cambridge Mass:
MIT Press.
Redclift, M.R. (2010).The transition out of carbon dependence: the crises of environment and
markets. . In M. R, Redclift and G. Woodgate (Eds.) The International Handbook of
Environmental Sociology, second edition (pp. 121-135).London: Edward Elagar Publishing
Limited.
Rigas, K. (2009). Boat or Airplane? Passenger's Perceptions of Transport Services toIslands:
The Example of the Greek Domestic Leisure Market. Journal of Transport Geography. 17
(5), 396-401.
Ritchie, J. R. (2003). The Competitive Destination: A sustainable tourism perspective.
Wallingford: CABI publishing.
Ritchie,J.R.B. and Crouch, G.I. (2003). The Competitive Destination. Wellingford: CABI
publishing.
24
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Saarinen, J. (2006). Traditions of Sustainability in Tourism Studies. Annals of Tourism
Research, 33(4), 1121-1140.
Scheyvens, R. (2007). Poor cousins no more: valuing the development potential of domestic
and diaspora tourism. Progress in development studies, 7(4), 307-325.
Scheyvens, R. (2008). Exploring the Tourism-Poverty Nexus. Current Issues in Tourism. 10
(2-3), 231-254.
Schilcher, D. (2007). Growth versus Equity: The Continuum of Pro-Poor Tourism and
Neoliberal Governance. Current Issues in Tourism, 10 (2-3), 166-193.
Seckelmann, A. (2002). Domestic tourism—a chance for regional development in Turkey?
Tourism Management, 23(1), 85-92.
Sheykhi, M. (2009). Domestic Tourism in Iran. Tourismos: an International Multidisciplinary
Journal of Tourism, 4(1), 109-123.
Sklair, L. (1999). Competing Conceptions of Globalization. Journal of World-Systems
Research, 2 (summer), 143-163.
Sklair L. (2002). Globalization, Capitalism and Its Alternatives. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Sklair, L. (2010). Iconic Architecture and the Culture-ideology of Consumerism. Theory,
Culture & Society, 27 (5), 135-159.
Sklair, L. (2011). Global Economy. In G, Ritzer and J.M, Ryan (Eds.). The Concise
Encyclopedia of Sociology, (pp. 257-258). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Inc.
Starr, M.A. (2006). Growth and conflict in the developing world: Neo-liberal narratives and
social-economy alternatives. Review of Social Economy, 64 (2), 205-224.
Steward, W.C., and Kuska, S. (2010). Developing and sustaining creative cities: a
sustainability fool for designers, planners, and public administration. International Journal of
Sustainable Development, 13 (1/3), 6-16.
Svatch, H.V. & Kantor, P. (2003). Urban Strategies for a Global Era. American Behavioral
Scientist, 46 (8), 1002–1033.
Theerapappisit, P. (2011). The Mekong Tourism Dilemma: Converging Forces, Contesting
Values. In D. Dredge & J. Jenkins (Eds.), stories of practice: tourism policy and planning.
(pp.199-226). Burlington: Ashgate Publishing Company.
Tribe, J. (1997). The Indiscipline of Tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 24 (3), 638-657.
Tribe, J. (2006). The Truth about Tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 33 (2), 360-381.
Trochim, W. M. K. (2006). Regression-discontinuity analysis. Retrieved from
http://www.socialresearchmethods.net/kb/statrd.php.
Tsenkova, S. (Ed.). (2002). Urban Regeneration: learning from British experience. Calgary:
Universtiy of Calgary.
Van Den Berg, H. (2001). Economic Growth and Development (2nd ed.). Columbus:
McGraw Hill.
Viken, A. (2011). Tourism, research, and governance on Svalbard: a symbiotic Relationship.
Polar Record, 47(243), 335-347.
Wallerstein, E. (1994). Development: Lodestar or Illusion? In L. Sklair (Ed.), Capitalism and
Development. (pp. 3-20). London: Routledge.
25
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Walton, J.K. (2009). Prospects in tourism history: Evolution, state of play and future
developments. Tourism Management, 30 (6), 783-793.
Warland, J.S. (2001). Measuring the Natural Environment [Review of the book measuring the
natural environment, by I. Strangeways]. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 108(2), 163-
164.
Watt, D. (2007). The Value of Reflexivity: On Becoming a Qualitative Researcher. The
Qualitative Report, 12 (1), pp. 82-101.
World Travel & Tourism Council. (2011). Travel and Tourism 2011. Retrieved from
http://www.wttc.org/site_media/uploads/downloads/traveltourism2011.pdf
World Tourism Organization. (1995). Collection of Domestic Tourism Statistics. Madrid:
World Tourism Organization.
Wu, B., Zhu, H., and Xu, X (2000) .Trends in China's domestic tourism development at the
turn of the century. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management. 12 (5),
296-299.
Yang, L. (2011). Ethnic tourism and cultural representation. Annals of Tourism Research,
38(2), 561-585.
Yang, L. (n.d.). Ethnic tourism and cultural representation. Annals of Tourism Research,
38(2), 561-581.
Zahra, A., and Ryan, C. (2007). From Chaos to Cohesion-Complexity in tourism structure:
An analysis of New Zealand‘s regional tourism organizations. Tourism Management, 28 (3),
854-862.
26
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
(Appendix. A.) Table 1. Descriptive statistics
Questions Totally Freque Cumulative Agree Frequency Cumulative Mean St. D.
agree ncy % (a) %
(t.a)
1 T.A 255 56.2 A 141 87.2 1.64 .888
2 T.A 268 55.7 A 190 95.2 1.51 .639
3 T.A 250 52.6 A 188 92.2 1.57 .691
4 T.A. 210 43.5 A 223 89.6 1.69 .722
5 T.A. 226 47.6 A 191 87.8 1.66 .724
6 T.A. 226 47.0 A 220 92.7 1.62 .673
7 T.A. 229 48.0 A 188 87.4 1.67 .763
8 T.A. 239 50.1 A 190 89.9 1.61 .709
9 T.A. 218 45.5 A 207 88.7 1.69 .763
10 T.A. 187 39.0 A 226 86.0 1.80 .797
11 T.A. 266 56.2 A 179 94.1 1.52 .695
12 T.A. 204 43.4 A 194 84.7 1.74 .768
13 T.A. 222 46.3 A 206 89.4 1.66 .700
14 T.A. 261 54.7 A 199 96.4 1.50 .600
15 T.A. 254 53.4 A 197 94.7 1.54 .672
16 T.A. 218 45.7 A 226 93.1 1.64 .692
17 Y.A. 242 50.6 A 208 94.1 1.58 .683
18 T.A. 253 53.4 A 192 93.9 1.54 .663
19 T.A. 222 46.0 A 221 91.7 1.65 .723
20 T.A. 267 55.4 A 185 93.8 1.53 .697
21 T.A. 278 57.8 A 183 95.8 1.49 .665
22 T.A. 283 59.2 A 169 94.6 1.49 .687
23 T.A. 208 43.3 A 239 93.1 1.66 .698
24 T.A. 190 39.8 A 207 83.2 1.80 .796
25 T.A. 233 48.4 A 195 89.0 1.67 .799
26 T.A. 184 38.3 A 249 90.0 1.73 .686
27 T.A. 147 30.7 A 242 81.2 1.94 .835
28 T.A. 198 41.9 A 232 91.1 1.68 .671
29 T.A. 194 40.7 A 245 92.0 1.70 .709
30 T.A. 186 39.1 A 240 89.5 1.74 .711
31 T.A. 186 39.2 A 236 88.8 1.74 .707
32 T.A. 184 38.6 A 185 77.4 1.95 .991
33 T.A. 222 46.4 A 199 88.1 1.69 .793
27
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
(Appendix A.)Table 2. Questions and descriptive statistics.
Descriptive Statistics
Std.
N Mean Deviation
1. The higher the quality of the services in hotels and other public accommodation, the more the number of the domestic 454 1.64 .888
tourists
2. The historical places of Iran are the main causes of attracting visitors 481 1.51 .639
3. Travelling (domestic tourism) leads to better social health 475 1.57 .691
4. Iranian domestic tourism helps in flourishing Iranian handicrafts 483 1.69 .722
5. The expansion of Iranian national tourism leads to the expansion of the international interaction of the country 475 1.66 .724
6. Domestic tourism contributes to appreciation of different cultures 481 1.62 .673
7. Domestic tourism can lead to expansion of the tourism industry 477 1.67 .763
8. Maintaining historical places result in expansion of Iranian tourism industry 477 1.61 .709
9. The quality of public facilities is a catalyst to travel. 479 1.69 .763
10. Domestic tourism is helpful in cross-cultural interaction among different ethnicities. 480 1.80 .797
11. The destruction of historical places is equal to the destruction of the national culture 473 1.52 .695
12. The inadequacy of the domestic tourism in Iran is attributed to lack of planning and management 470 1.74 .768
13. Domestic tourism can enhance growth and employment. 479 1.66 .700
14. Public sector should actively involve in focusing on positive aspects of domestic tourism 477 1.50 .600
15. Domestic tourism can help to improve the rural economy 476 1.54 .672
16. Domestic tourism will lead to future development of international tourism. 477 1.64 .692
17. Lack of Information has undermined the expansion of domestic tourism 478 1.58 .683
18. Lack of service quality is an issue that affects domestic tourism negatively 474 1.54 .663
19. Knowledgeable tour guides is a factor that can encourage domestic traveling. 483 1.65 .723
20. Quality of food, food outlets and rest- areas can encourage domestic traveling. 482 1.53 .697
21. Overall quality of sanitation can encourage domestic traveling. 481 1.49 .665
22. Lack of adequate and safe transportation system is an obstacle to domestic traveling. 478 1.49 .687
23. Domestic tourism can enhance the quality of life of citizens. 480 1.66 .698
24. Fuels subsidies can encourage domestic travelling. 477 1.80 .796
25. Social tourism should be available for low income domestic travelers. . 481 1.67 .799
26. Safety and security are important factors to enhance the number of domestic travelers. 481 1.73 .686
27. Intra-regional cooperation can boost the number of domestic travelers.
479 1.94 .835
28. Domestic traveling will result in inspiring local, regional and national pride. 472 1.68 .671
29. Air traveling as a mode of transportation is highly convenience for domestic travelers. 477 1.70 .709
30. Overall needs of domestic travelers are not met.
476 1.74 .711
31. The pilgrimage domestic tourism can be boosted by incorporation of non-pilgrimage activities.
475 1.74 .707
32. Domestic tourism is an attractive option for the case of Iran in compare to neighboring countries. 477 1.95 .991
33. Public sector‘s active role is highly needed. 478 1.69 .793
28
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
(Appendix. A.). Table 3. Demographic information.
DEMOGRAPHIC RESPONDENTS n. (%)
CHARACTERISTICS (FEMALE/MALE)
0-15 483 3%
16-30 483 21%
Age 31-40 483 33%
41-55 483 39%
Over 55 483 4%
total 100%
Gender Male 82%
Female 18%
total 100%
Secondary Education 483 29%
Education University Graduates 483 40%
No official Certificate 483 13%
Post graduate degree 483 18%
total 100%
Frequency of Once a year 483 25.4%
Travel Twice a Year 483 36.6%
pattern 3 Times a Year 483 29.60
5 times a Year 483 8.2%
10 times a Year 483 0.2%
total 100%
29
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
(Appendix. A). Table 4. Frequencies for non-likert/exploratory questions.
QUESTION ON THE PATTERN OF TRAVEL/HOW OFTEN.
Annually Frequency Cumulative %
Once a year 109 26.1
Twice a year 157 62.7
Three times a year 80 81.4
Four times a year 31 88.6
Five times a year 35 96.7
QUESTION ON RESPONDENTS’ SATISFACTION WITH THE FACILITIES THEY VISIT
Response Frequency Cumulative %
no 327 69.4
yes 144 100.0
total 471
QUESTION ON THE DURATION OF THE TRIP.
Response Frequency Cumulative %
Less than a week 107 22.5
One week 167 57.7
More than a week 127 84.4
One month 46 94.1
SEASONALITY
Response Frequency Cumulative %
spring 98 20.7
autumn 30 27.0
summer 261 82.1
winter 21 86.5
QUESTION ON AVAILABILITY OF INFORMATION PRIOR TO THE TRIP
Response Frequency Cumulative %
yes 74 15.7
no 398 100.0
30
Holy Sites in Neo-Liberal World:
Indian-Banaras Model
Cemil KUTLUTÜRK
Ankara University, Faculty of Divinity
Department of World„s Religions, Turkey
cemilkutluturk@gmail.com
Abstract
There is a great connection between religious tolerance and holy sites due to this kind of holy
places are regarded as sacred, securely and reliable by all human beings who belong to
different religions. In this context, India is one of the most pertinent samples in neo-liberal
world because of its various holy sites and different religious beliefs. Especially Banaras, the
city of India, which is regarded as religious and cultural capital of India, is the center of
religious freedom. With religious freedom comes a respect and tolerance for other religions,
which is a value held in high esteem in both India and Banaras. This paper, therefore, aims to
discuss the relationship between religious forbearance and holy sites by examining the Indian
– Banaras sample. The first section mentions about the importance of Banaras in terms of
religions and informs about holy places in this city. The second section deals with
contributions of holy sites to religious peaces and tolerance under the example of Indian –
Banaras model. Along with this, the paper has been supported by interesting photos which
have been taken in original sacred places.
Keywords: India-Banaras (Varanasi, Benares), holy places, religious tolerance
1. Introduction
The demographics of India are inclusive of the second most populous country in the
world, with over 1.21 billion people (2011 census),1 more than a sixth of the world‟s
population. A vast majority of Indians associate themselves with a religion. Hence, religion
has been a significant part of the India‟s culture and tradition, throughout its history.
Religious diversity and religious tolerance are both established in the country by custom and
law.
India is the birthplace of Hinduism, Jainism, Buddhism and Sikhism which are the four
major world religions. Besides this, India is one of the most diverse nations in terms of
religion. Even though Hindus form close to 80 percent of the population, the country also has
large Muslim, Sikh, Christian and Zoroastrian followers. Among them, Islam is the largest
minority religion in this country. According to some new data Hinduism is the majority
religion with 78.5% of the population of India. Islam (15.4%), Christianity (2.3%), Sikhism
(1.9%), Buddhism (0.8%) and Jainism (0.4%) are the other minor religions followed by the
people of India.2 This diversity of religious belief systems existing in India today is a result
of, besides existence and birth of native religions, assimilation and social integration of
religions brought to the region by traders, travelers, immigrants, and even invaders and
1
Provisional Population Totals – Census 2011, Office of the Registrar General and Census Commissioner
(Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India), http://www.censusindia.gov.in/2011-prov-
results/indiaatglance.html. [accessed 17.11.2012].
2
Justice Rajindar Sachar (Chairperson), Social, Economic and Educational Status of the Muslim Community of
India (Reported by Prime Minister‟s High Level Committee), (Cirrus Graphics Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi, 2006), p.
28.
31
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
conquerors.3 All these religious belief systems have lived harmonizingly until today without
any big problem.
2. Holy Sites of Banaras
Since Banaras is accepted a mini India and also cultural capital of India, the city was
preferred for this study, which is one of the most proper model to this field. Banaras is the
mosaic of Indian culture with respect to representing the diversity and the distinctiveness of
the regional cultures of India. People from different parts of India, speaking different
languages and carrying their own features, beliefs and customs have settled in this city. But in
this process they inwardly have protected their own culture and outwardly have become a part
of mosaic culture of the city. Banaras, therefore, is a living expression of Indian culture and
traditions in all its multi-ethnic traditions, particular relationship with life and death, ancient
educational methods and practices, multi-ethnic population architectural treasures, religious
rituals and religious beliefs.4
The word “banaras” comes from the word “bana” which means “a place where always
ready” and the word “ras” which means “juice of life”. It is the blending of these two words,
which makes up the mosaic of culture known as Banaras. The natural setting, the spirit of
place, and the continuity of cultural traditions have all blended together to create and preserve
a unique lifestyle known as Banarasi. The life style of Banaras is an art of living, both
passionate and carefree, both traditional and modern, both relaxed and concentrated, both
intense and free.5 The city of Banaras, on the other hand, has different names such as Kaşi,
Varanasi etc. The name Varanasi has its origin possibly from the names of the two rivers
Varuna and Assi for the old city lies in the north shores of the Ganges bounded by its two
tributaries, namely Varuna and Assi.6
The population of city of Varanasi is about two millions. It is unique in the architectural,
artistic and religious expressions of traditional Indian culture and is, even today, a living
sample of this style of life. The city, moreover, is an extraordinary testimony to living
traditions in religious faith, rituals and various festivals, ancient forms of worship and belief
that are still practised in the varied expressions of asceticism, spiritual and meditative
exercises, education, music, dance, handicrafts and art forms, passing from one to other
generations, from past to present.
Banaras is one of the oldest continuously inhabited cities in the world. Banaras was a
place of Aryan philosophy, religion and culture and was also a commercial and industrial
center famous for its silk fabrics, ivory works, sculpture and perfumes by the 2nd millennium
BCE. After that this historical city was the capital of the kingdom of Kashi during the time of
the Buddha, about 6th century BCE.7 The city has remained a center of religious, educational,
and artistic activities until today.
Banaras has an important universal value, because of its architectural heritage is linked
strongly, since centuries, to the living cultural and religious traditions of three of the major
3
Kenneth Pletcher, The Geography of India Sacred and Historic Places, (Britannica Educational Publishing,
New York), 2011, p. 160.
4
See in detail, Rana P.B. Singh and Dar V. (2003). Varanasi as Heritage City (India) on the scale the UNESCO
World Heritage List: From Contestation to Conservation. International Conference on Communication for
Development in the Information Age: Extending the Benefits of Technology for All, Banaras Hindu University,
Varanasi (India), 2003, pp. 4-5.
5
Rana P.B. Singh, Cultural Landscapes and Lifeworld. Literary Images of Banaras, (Indica Books, Varanasi,
2004), p. 10.
6
Ibid, p. 11.
7
S. Pravin, Banaras Region: A Spiritual and Cultural Guide, (Indica Books, Varanasi, 2002), p. 7.
32
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
religions of the world which are Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism According to their
followers the city is the most important religious pilgrimage destination. Traditional worship,
religious rituals, beliefs and festivals are still practiced in here. Banaras is also considered to
be a storehouse of religious festivals and ceremonies. The popular saying that more than ten
festivals happen in a week, express this richness.8 In this respect, there are few cities in the
world of greater antiquity and none have so uninterruptedly maintained their ancient celebrity
and distinction.
In Banaras there are not only Indian religions but also other religions and their holy sites.
It can be found over 3000 Hindu shrines and temples, about 1400 Muslim shrines and
mosques, 12 churches, 3 Jain temples, 9 Buddhist temples, 3 Sikh temples (Gurudvaras) and
several other sacred sites in this ancient city of India.9 It can be said that this is one of the rare
places in the world where such a huge number of Hindu and Muslim sacred places co-exist.
And the existence of these various holy places still until today demonstrates that religious
tolerance is the main characteristic feature of people of this city.
In India, Banaras (or Varanasi) is a holy city for Indian religions especially for Hinduism
and being one of the most sacred pilgrimage places for Hindus of all denominations. Banaras
is to Hindus what Mecca is to Muslims or Vatican to Catholics. Because the holy sites such as
River Gangas, Ghats, Kashi Vishwanath Temple and Sarnath, the place where Buddha
preached his first sermon after enlightenment, are found in this city. On the other hand, it is
one of seven Hindu holiest cities (Sapta Puri), considered the giver of liberation (moksha).10
Banaras also houses a community of more than 50,000 Brahmins who give religious services
to devout. Some of them come on a traditional pilgrimage while others come to die. Besides
these, the holy epic poem Shri Ramcharitmanas by Goswami Tulsidas was also written here.11
All this makes Banaras a significantly holy place.
The culture of Banaras is closely associated with the River Ganges and the river‟s
religious significance. It is believed that bathing in the River Ganges results in the remission
of sins and dying in this holy city (Banaras) ensures release of a person‟s soul from the cycle
of its transmigrations.12 Thus, many Hindus come here for dying. These kinds of beliefs lead
to increasing of religious tourism to Banaras from all over the India.
Banaras owes its existence to the Ganga River considered to be the most holy river for the
Hindu people and especially sacred in Banaras where its course towards the Bay of Bengal
suddenly turns north. Symbolically, the flow from south to north refers to the life cycle from
death. This unique directional change of the river course brings about the development of the
importance of the ancient city.13
The Ganges is the most sacred river to Hindus and is also a lifeline to millions of Indians
who live along its course and depend on it for their daily needs. It is worshiped as the goddess
8
Rana P.B. Singh and Dar V, Varanasi as Heritage City (India) on the scale the UNESCO World Heritage List:
From Contestation to Conservation, p. 3; B. Hans, Construction and Reconstruction of Sacred Space in
Varanasi, Numen,Vol. 43, 1996, pp. 32-55.
9
Rana P.B. Singh, Banaras (Varanasi): Cosmic Order, Sacred City, Hindu Traditions, (Tara Book Agency,
Varanasi, 1993), p. 24; Rana P.B. Singh and Dar V, op. cit., p. 5.
10
The other holy cities are 1 Ayodhyā, 2 Mathurā, 3 Gayā, 4 Kaśī, 5 Kañchi, 6 Avantikā, 7 Dwārāvatī. These
seven cities (including Banaras) should be known as the givers of liberation. See Garuḍa Purāṇa, XVI, 114.
http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/gpu/gpu18.htm. [accessed 20.11.2012].
11
Myra Shackley, Managing Sacred Sites: Service Provision and Visitor Experience. (Cengage Learning, 2001),
p. 121.
12
Wilder-Smith, E. Schwartz and M. Shaw, Travel Medicine Tales Behind the Science, (Elsevier Linacre House,
UK, 2007), p. 273.
13
B. Hans, op. cit., p. 53.
33
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Ganga in Hinduism.14 Hindus consider the waters of the Ganges to be both pure and
purifying. Nothing reclaims order from disorder more than the waters of the Ganges. Moving
water, as in a river, is considered purifying in Hindu culture because it is thought to both
absorb impurities and take them away.15
The Ganges is a sacred river along every fragment of her length. All along her course,
Hindus bathe in her waters. All along her course, they pay homage to their ancestors and to
their gods by cupping her water in their hands, lifting it and letting it fall back into her; they
offer flowers and rose petals. On the journey back home from the Ganges, they carry small
quantities of her water with them for use in rituals. When a loved one dies, they return to the
Ganges to consign the ashes to her custody. The Ganges is invoked whenever water is used in
Hindu ritual, and is therefore present in all sacred waters.16
In Banaras, several festivals and religious rituels have been hold in the name of Ganga.
For instance, Ganga Mahotsav is a five-day music festival organized by the Uttar Pradesh
Tourism Department, held in November–December culminating a day before Kartik
Poornima (Dev Deepawali). In this time the Ganges is venerated by “arti” offered by
thousands of pilgrims who also release lighted lamps to float in the river from the ghats.17
Varanasi has at least 84 ghats which are embankments made in steps of stone slabs along
the river bank where pilgrims perform ritual ablutions. Steps in the ghats lead to the banks of
River Ganges, including the Dashashwamedh Ghat, the Manikarnika Ghat, the Panchganga
Ghat and the Harishchandra Ghat where Hindus cremate their dead. Many ghats are
associated with some legends and most of them have their own features. The Dashashwamedh
Ghat is the main and probably the oldest ghat of Varansi located on the Ganges. It is believed
that the god Brahma created it to welcome Shiva and he also sacrificed ten horses during
Dasa -Ashwamedha yajna performed here.18
14
Sukumari Bhattacharji, Legends of Devi, (Orient Longman Limited, Calcutta, 1995), p. 56.
15
Diana L. Eck, Banaras, city of light, (Columbia University Press, 1982), p. 217.
16
See in detail, op. cit., p. 212-214.
17
Kisanlal Sharma, Why? Hindu Customs, Rituals and Rites, Manoj Publications, Delhi, 2010, p. 168; Rana
Singh, Water Symbolism and Sacred Landscape in Hinduism: A Study of Benares (Varanasi), Erdkunde, Vol. 48,
1994, pp. 212-214.
18
Bansal Sunita Pant, Hindu Pilgrimage: A Journey Through the Holy Places of Hindus All Over India, (Pustak
Mahal, 2008), pp. 34–35.
34
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Picture 1: People performing Hindu ceremony at Ganga River and Ghats of Varanasi
Source: Author‟s own, October-2012
Kashi Vishwanath temple is another holy place for Hindus. It is most important temple in
Varanasi and located on the outskirts of the Ganges. Kashi Vishwanath Temple dedicated to
lord Shiva. The name of Vishwanath means “Lord of the world”. Besides this temple, in
Banaras there are two other significant temples named “Durga”. The first one is Durga
Mandir which built about 500 years ago and other one is Durga Kund which built in the 18th
century. Thousands of Hindu devotees visit Durga Kund during Navratri to worship the
goddess Durga. The temple has multi-tiered spires and is stained red with ochre, representing
the red colour of Durga. The building has a rectangular tank of water called the Durga Kund.
The meaninig of "Kund" is a pond or pool. Every year on the occasion of Nag Panchami, the
act of depicting the god Vishnu reclining on the serpent Shesha is recreated in the Kund.19
19
Alexander Cunningham, Ancient Geography of India, (Munshiram Manoharlal, 2002), pp. 132-136; Rana P.B.
Singh, Banaras (Varanasi): Cosmic Order, Sacred City, Hindu Traditions, p. 53.
35
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Picture 2: Durga Kund is one of the most important Hindu temples in Varanasi
Source: Author‟s own, April-2012.
The sacred city, on the other hand, is bounded by a holy road known as Panchakosi. Every
devout Hindu wishes to walk this road, visits the city once in a lifetime and hopes to die there
in old age. All these kinds of grounds make to Banaras holy for Hindus and therefore, more
than a million pilgrims visit this sacred city each year.
Banaras is also important for Buddhism because of Sarnath where Gautama Buddha first
taught the Dharma, and where the Buddhist Sangha came into existence. Sarnath is located 13
kilometres north-east of Banaras. It is a place of Buddhist pilgrimage and the site of the deer
park where Siddhartha Gautama is said to have given his first sermon about the basic
principles of Buddhism.20
According to Buddhist tradition, after attaining enlightenment at Bodh Gaya the Buddha
went to Sarnath; and it was here that he preached his first discourse in the deer park to set in
motion the “Wheel of the Dharma”. Therefore, it is one of the most holy sites as in this place
the stream of the Buddha‟s teaching first flowed.21
A Monastic tradition flourished for over 1,500 years on the site of the deer park at
Sarnath. In the third century BC Ashoka erected a column 15.24 m in height which had four
lions as its capital which is now treasured in the archaeology museum. The lion symbolizes
both Ashoka‟s imperial rule and the kingship of the Buddha. The four-lion capital was
adopted as the emblem of the modern Indian republic. The largest monastery constructed was
Dharma-Chakar-Jina Vihar, erected by Kumardevi, who ruled over Benares during 1114 to
1154. In due course Sarnath became a forest of debris below which the historical ruins
remained buried. Of the two great stupas which adorned the city only the Dhamekha remained
which is of the 6th century.22
The Dhamekha Stupa is the most conspicuous structure at Sarnath. Dhamekha seems to be
a distorted form of Dharma Chakra which means turning the wheel of the Dharma. The
20
Shobhna Gupta, Monuments of India, (Har-Anand Publications, New Delhi, 2003), p. 11.
21
V.S. Bhaskar, Faith and Philosophy of Buddhism, Kalpaz Publications, Delhi, 2009, p.169; S. Gupta, op. Cit.,
p. 12.
22
W. Joanna, Sarnath Gupta Steles of the Buddha’s Life, Ars Orientalis, Vol. 10, 1975, p. 175.
36
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
original stupa was constructed by Ashoka. The present size of the stupa is 31.3 m high and
28.3 m in diameter. The lower portion of the stupa is covered completely with beautifully
carved stones. The Dhamekha stupa is considered to be the sacred place where the voice of
Buddhism was first heard. Most of Buddhist who are from different countries, visit this place
for circumambulation of this sacred stupa and to worship the Buddha. Some Buddhists,
especially Tibetan Buddhists repeat a mantra -Om mani padme hum- when they circle of this
structure.23
Picture 3: Dhamekha Stupa at Sarnath
Source: Author‟s own, Augus-2011.
At Sarnath, on the other hand, there are ruins of ancient Buddhist monasteries and temples
as well as temples built by the Maha Bodhi Society and by the Chinese, Burmese, and Tibetan
Buddhists.24 These kinds of places are regarded as holy by Buddhist and they come to this
place, Sarnath, from different countries for visiting the temples and worshiping to Buddha.
Banaras is also one of the most important religious centers of Jainism. Jainism is one of
the oldest religions identified today. It‟s not just a religion; it‟s thought way to live a happy
life. Its principals, way of life and philosophies emphasize the essential of self-effort to
progress the soul towards heavenly realization and freedom.
The Jain literature refers to Banaras as a Jain holy place because here were born 4 of the
Jain Tirthankaras (the ford-makers). In the 8th century BCE Parshvanatha was born around
Bhelupur in Varanasi. He was followed in the 6th century BCE by Mahavira, who also visited
Varanasi during his 42nd year of teaching. The birthplace of Suparshvanatha, the 7th
Tirthankara, is also mentioned in the Jain literature, but its location and identification have
still not been verified. It is believed that the present Jain temple in Sarnath, near the
Dhamekha Stupa, was built to commemorate the birthplace of 11th Tirthankara,
Shreyamshanatha. The birthplace of the 8th Tirthankara Chandraprabhu, is identified with
Chandravati, an ancient village lying on the Varanasi-Ghazipur road at 23 km northeast from
Banaras at the western bank of Ganga River.25
23
V.S. Bhaskar, op. cit., p. 170.
24
See in detail, W. Joanna, op. Cit., pp. 177-184.
25
Bharat S. Shah, An Introduction to Jainism, (Setubandh Publications, New York, 2002), p. 104; L. M. Singhvi,
Jain Temples in India and Around the World, (Himalayan Publishers, 2002), p. 42.
37
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
There are also different holy sites for Jains in Banaras. For instance, Bachraj Ghat also
known as Jain ghat, is located at the bank of the Ganga. Near this Ghat there are three Jain
temples located to bank of Ganges. It is believed that visiting to these temples is a lifetime
experience for Jain Pilgrim. Jain community people have a visit this place and have a dip in
the Ganga and then go for prayers one by one in all the three consecrated temples.
Banaras, therefore, is a pilgrimage site for Jains along with Hindus and Buddhists. It is
believed to be the birthplace of Suparshvanath, Shreyansanath, and Parshva, who are
respectively the seventh, eleventh, and twenty-third Jain Tirthankars. Besides this, Shree
Parshvanath Digambar Jain Tirth Kshetra (Digambar Jain Temple) is situated in Varanasi.
This temple has a great religious importance for Jain Religion as such Banaras is a holy city
for Jains.26
Picture 4: With a Jain Monk in a Jain Temple
Source: Author‟s own, September-2011.
Banaras is also an important holy place for Sikhs because it is accepted that Guru Nanak
(1469-1539), the founder of Sikhism, had been in this city. The story suggested that Nanak
visited Varanasi two times; firstly when he was on pilgrimage. Secondly he came to have
discourses with saints living in Varanasi and also to convey his messages in 1506 on the day
of the Maha Shivaratri festival and stayed in a garden at this city, which later came to known
as Guru Bagh. The Adi Granth consists of the hymns of Guru Nanak and of the first five
gurus as well as poems by great earlier saint-poets and singers such as Kabir and Raidas. the
visiting of Nanak played a large role in the founding and development of Sikhism.27
Banaras also plays host to non-Indian religions such as Christianity, Judaism and Islam.
The East India Company, which has begun a direct political control in the time of Warren
Hastings by end of the 18th century, has established a strong field for Christianity in Banaras
and this movement has encouraged the development of Christian missionaries. They have
built sacred places for their religion. Some of the important churches are St. Thomas Church
(at Godaulia), Red Church (at Nadesar), St. Paul Church (at Sigra), David‟s Church (at
26
Bharat S. Shah, An Introduction to Jainism, p. 108.
27
Surjit Singh Gandhi, History of Sikh Gurus Retold, (Atlantic Publishers and Distributors, New Delhi, 2007), p.
90; S. J. W., Charles, Guru Nanak and Origins of the Sikh Faith by Harbans Singh, Journal of the American
Oriental Society, Vol. 92, 1972, pp. 320-322.
38
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Teliabagh), St. Mary (at Cantt.), Bethlehem Gospel (at Mahmoorganj), Evangelical Church of
India (D.L.W.) and Church of Varanasi (at Sunderpur and Kakarmatta).28
Banaras, on the other hand, is an important area for Muslims and their religious traditions.
Muslims have been residing in Banaras since several generations starting from the rule of the
Delhi Sultanate. The invasions of Mahmud of Ghaznawi in 1021-1030 CE had opened the
door to Muslim settlement in Banaras. Nowadays they constitute about one fourth of the total
population of Banaras District and have earned a significant place in the traditional economy,
society, culture and trade of the city.29
In Banaras, there are a huge number of holy sites of Muslims such as Masjids (mosques),
Mazar (religious-cultural sites), Takiya (burial ground) and Idgah (place of special prayer),
since they have been living in this city for centuries. The total numbers of sacred places of
Muslims are more than one thousand in this city. Among them the Mosques have basic and
significant statuses which cater to the prayer needs of the Muslims. For Muslims, Gyanvapi
Mosque, Alamgiri Mosque, Ganj-e-Shaheedan Mosque and Chaukhamba Mosque are some of
the important sacred places in this city.30
Picture 5: Muslims performing salaah in a mosque at Varanasi
Source: Author‟s own, February-2012.
These events demonstrate that the city of Banaras does the honors several holy sites and
religious beliefs which are different from each other. People who live in this city can perform
their religious doctrines and can visit their sacred places without any oppression and invasion.
People, in general, respect to all kind of beliefs and allow living a person‟s inner life in this
city. The majority of the people in Banaras are of the Hindus, yet religious tolerance is the
norm in this city where a great deal of faiths and cults are believed in and different languages
are spoken.
28
Rana P.B. Singh and Dar V, Varanasi as Heritage City (India) on the scale the UNESCO World Heritage List:
From Contestation to Conservation, p. 5.
29
See G. Smita, The Muslims of Uttar Pradesh, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 42, 2007, pp. 2142-2146;
See in detail, Census of India-Socia-cultural aspects. Censusindia.gov.in.
http://censusindia.gov.in/Census_Data_2001/Census_Data_Online/Social_and_cultural/Religion.aspx. [accessed
02.12.2012].
30
Koenraad Elst, Ram Janmabhoomi vs. Babri Masjid, (Voice of India, New Delhi, 1990), p. 140.
39
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3. Contribution of Banaras to Religious Tolerance
The city has been famous not only as a religious sites and place of pilgrimage but also as a
center of cottage industries and textile manufacturing even in Pre-Buddhist times. Silk
weaving and sari making, metal, wood and terracotta handicrafts, toy making, particular
painting forms, etc., comprise the religious and commercial importance of Banaras. These
commercial activities range from gold and silver jewellery, saris, utensils, carpet weaving, a
variety of handicrafts, publishers and book shops, stationery articles, handmade paper,
wooden toys, bangles made of glass, ivory work, perfumes, etc.31 All these activities make the
city holy and significant and give an opportunity to observe of various religious traditions and
customs.
The cultural and religious richness of Banaras, on the other hand, leads to increasing of
religious tourism. Hence, religious tourism is a thriving business in Banaras, where thousands
of temples and sacred places represent numerous religions. Every devout Hindu hopes to visit
the city at least once in a lifetime, take a holy dip at the famous “Ghats” of the Ganga, walk
the pious Panchakosi road that bounds the city, and die here in old age. Every year around a
million pilgrims come to this city, and all of them bathe in the Ganga River, followed by
worshipping in various temple. People from all over the world visit this historical city in order
to promenade the holy places and to purchase same special goods during a year. Tourism and
related activities are major source of city‟s economy.32 However, it is more important to
maintain a sustainable tourism development that is in harmony with the existing cultural and
religious atmosphere of the city. Some efforts to this end are being taken by the concerned
authorities through specific kinds of promotion activities and organization and re-vitalization
of religious festivals.
Both Hindus and non-Hindus from around the world visit Varanasi for different reasons.
For every visitor, Varanasi has a different experience to offer. The gentle waters of the
Ganges, the boat ride at sunrise, the high banks of the ancient “Ghats”, the array of shrines,
the meandering narrow serpentine alleys of the city, the myriad temple spires, the palaces at
water's edge, the ashrams (hermitages), the pavilions, the chanting of mantras, the fragrance
of incense, the palm and cane parasols, the devotional hymns that is unique to the city of
Banaras.33 Among international tourists visiting Varanasi, more than 40% is shared by four
countries, viz. Japan, France, UK and Germany. Especially the Japanese come to the city
because of its association with the Buddha, who gave his first sermon in Sarnath.34 The
foreign tourism inflow is largely seasonal concentrating in the months of July- September and
from November to April.
By the way of religious sites and religious tourism individuals can attain a chance through
which they can observe several religious traditions. Thereby they enhance religious tolerance
to all kinds of beliefs. By means of religious tolerance a person accepts and permits religious
beliefs and practices which disagree with his own way of life. Moreover he acknowledges that
others have the right to hold and practice their beliefs.35 Another significant benefit of
religious indulgence is, within a nation or ethnic group, acceptance of the right to hold beliefs
that differ from the dominant religion, worship freely according to these beliefs and attempt to
peacefully convince others to convert to that faith.
31
Wilbert M. Gesler, Margaret Pierce, Hindu Varanasi, Geographical Review, Vol. 90, 2000, pp. 232-235; Rana
P.B. Singh, Cultural Landscapes and Lifeworld. Literary Images of Banaras, p. 17.
32
Rana P.B. Singh and Dar V, Varanasi as Heritage City (India) on the scale the UNESCO World Heritage
List: From Contestation to Conservation, pp. 9-10.
33
S. Pravin, Banaras Region: A Spiritual and Cultural Guide, p. 11.
34
Rana P.B. Singh and Dar V., op. cit., p. 9.
35
Jolie M.F. Wood, Contentious politics and civil society in Varanasi, (Anthem Press, 2011), p. 9.
40
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
4. Conclusion
The existence of temples (Mandır, Gurudwara etc.), mosques, churches and devotees of
different religions affirm that religious tolerance is the basic feature of Banaras. In this sense,
Banaras, which is called the religious capital of India, is one of the most appropriate model of
city of religious tolerance where various cultures and religious systems have been living since
centuries.
Consequently, the model of Banaras and events which are mentioned above demonstrate
to us that holy sites bring about the improving of the religious tourism. A result of religious
tourism, people attain an opportunity in the name of understanding and observing of other
person‟s sacred values. Hence, it can be put forward that the role of holy sites is very
important and essential on behalf of increasing the religious tolerance.
References
Bhaskar, V.S. (2009). Faith and Philosophy of Buddhism. New Delhi: Kalpaz Publications.
Bhattacharji S. (1995). Legends of Devi. Calcutta: Orient Longman Limited.
Charles, S. J. W. (1972). Guru Nanak and Origins of the Sikh Faith by Harbans Singh .
Journal of the American Oriental Society, 92, pp. 320-322.
Cunningham, Alexander. (2002). Ancient Geography of India. Munshiram Manoharlal.
Eck, Diana L. (1982). Banaras, city of light, Columbia University Press.
Elst, Koenraad. (1990). Ram Janmabhoomi vs. Babri Masjid. New Delhi: Voice of India
Gandhi, Surjit S. (2007). History of Sikh Gurus Retold. New Delhi: Atlantic Publishers and
Distributors.
Gupta, Shobhna (2003). Monuments of India. New Delhi: Har-Anand Publications.
Hans, B. (1996). Construction and Reconstruction of Sacred Space in Varanasī. Numen, 43,
pp. 32-55.
Joanna, W. (1975). Sarnath Gupta Steles of the Buddha‟s Life, Ars Orientalis, 10, pp. 171-
192.
Mcleod, W. H. (1989). The Sikhs History, Religion and Society. New York: Columbia
University Press.
Pletcher, Kenneth. (2011). The Geography of India Sacred and Historic Places. New York:
Britannica Educational Publishing.
Pravin S. (2002). Banaras Region: A Spiritual and Cultural Guide.Varanasi: Indica Books.
Rana, S. (1994). Water Symbolism and Sacred Landscape in Hinduism: A Study of Benares
(Varanasi). Erdkunde, 48, pp. 210-227.
Rana P.B. Singh. (1993). Banaras (Varanasi): Cosmic Order, Sacred City, Hindu Traditions.
Varanasi: Tara Book Agency.
Rana P.B. Singh and Dar V. (2003). Varanasi as Heritage City (India) on the scale the
UNESCO World Heritage List: From Contestation to Conservation. International Conference
on Communication for Development in the Information Age: Extending the Benefits of
Technology for All. Varanasi, (India): Banaras Hindu University, pp. 1-11.
41
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Sachar, J. R. (Chairperson) (2006). Social, Economic and Educational Status of the Muslim
Community of India (Reported by Prime Minister‟s High Level Committee). New Delhi:
Cirrus Graphics Pvt. Ltd.
Shackley, M. (2001). Managing Sacred Sites: Service Provision and Visitor Experience.
Cengage Learning.
Shah B. (2002). An Introduction to Jainism. New York: Setubandh Publications.
Sharma, Kisanlal. (2010).Why? Hindu Customs, Rituals and Rites. Delhi: Manoj Publications.
Singh, Rana P.B. (2004). Cultural Landscapes and Lifeworld. Literary Images of Banaras.
Varanasi: Indica Books.
Singhvi, L. M. (2002). Jain Temples in India and Around the World. Himalayan Publishers.
Smita, G. (2007). The Muslims of Uttar Pradesh. Economic and Political Weekly, 42, pp.
2142-2146.
Sunita Pant, Bansal. (2008). Hindu Pilgrimage: A Journey Through the Holy Places of
Hindus All Over India. Pustak Mahal.
Wilbert M. Gesler, Margaret P. (2000). Hindu Varanasi. Geographical Review, 90, pp. 222-
237.
Wilder-Smith, E. Schwartz and M. Shaw. (2007). Travel Medicine Tales Behind the Science.
UK: Elsevier Linacre House.
Wood, Jolie M.F. (2011). Contentious politics and civil society in Varanasi. Anthem Press.
Provisional Population Totals – Census 2011. (2011). Office of the Registrar General and
Census Commissioner (Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India), 2011,
http://www.censusindia.gov.in/2011-prov-results/indiaatglance.html. [accessed 17.11.2012].
http://censusindia.gov.in/Census_Data_2001/Census_Data_Online/Social_and_cultural/Religi
on.aspx. [accessed 02.12.2012].
http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/gpu/gpu18.htm. [accessed 20.11.2012].
42
Behavioral Differences of Muslim and Non-Muslim Visitors at Holy Sites:
Case of Mother Mary House
Zafer Öter, Mehmet Yavuz Çetinkaya
Izmir Katip Celebi University,
Department of Tourism Management & Department of Tourism Guidance
Faculty of Tourism, Cigli- Izmir, Turkey
E-mails: zafer.oter@ikc.edu.tr , mehmetyavuz.cetinkaya@ikc.edu.tr
Abstract
The global importance of tourism industry is on the rise. This fact is better understood day by
day not only by large destinations but also by remote small villages. Tourism industry creates
human mobility, generate trillions of dollars to global economy, create new jobs for young
generations, and help people to discover other cultural heritages. Tourists are getting
increasingly diversified and their expectations constantly change in time. Diversification of
the demand in tourism industry has several reasons including the participation of new
emerging nations to the consumption, rising 3rd age populations in Europe, greater levels of
access to travel by younger generations during education, diversification and accessibility of
tourism attractions by recent transportation investments. In this sense, the importance of
alternative tourism types is on the rise. Faith-based tourism is one of the alternatives for
tourists who are in search of information about the past of the beliefs, who prefer to visit
centers of divine religions in order to pray and be part of a spiritual experience. This
qualitative and exploratory study aims to find out behavioral differences between Muslim and
non-Muslim visitors during holy site visits in Turkey. Discovering these differences can help
better prepare attractions for new visitors, solve in situ problems, increase visitor satisfaction,
and protect cultural heritage area. One of the most popular faith tourism attractions, the House
of Mother Mary located near Ephesus ancient site in Selçuk-Izmir is a holy sanctuary for both
Christians and Muslims. This research tries to reflect primary data obtained through
qualitative data collection techniques (semi-structured interview) from professional tourist
guides at House of Mother Mary. Following the evaluation of findings recommendations will
be developed for tourism industry and cultural heritage managers.
Keywords: Visitor Behavior, Religious Tourism, Cultural Heritage Sites.
1. Introduction
Travel for religious reasons dates back to the Roman, Greek, Egyptian and Indus Valley
civilizations, and is perhaps the oldest and most prevalent type of travel in human history
+(Jackowski,A., Smith, A. 1992 in Rodriques, S.A.M, 2012). Every year, millions of people
are attracted to visit major religious destinations around the world (Jansen & Kühl, 2008),
both ancient and modern in origin. According to the World Religious Travel Association, over
300 million travelers undertook journeys to sacred sites in 2007, and consequently the
industry size was estimated at US$18 billion (Wright, 2007). Rundquist (2010), estimates that
approximately 300 million people motivated by religion travel across the world, despite the
fact that a majority of people actually live in a secular way (Rojo, 2007). The majority of
religious travelers emerges from the major religions, and identify themselves as Christians,
Muslims, Hindus and Buddhist (Gan, Ma & Song, 2000).
For thousands of years, people have been travelling to places considered sacred to meet or
to worship concepts around Divinity (Coleman, 2004; Tirca, Stanciulescu, Chis & Bacila,
2010). Religion is important in people‟s lives, and indeed it has been argued that human
beings have always had a need to believe in a superior entity (Timothy and Olsen, 2006).
43
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
From the beginning of creation until modern times therefore, there have been several cults and
beliefs relating to different Gods and superior forces, which were and are worshipped and
venerated through statues, representations and buildings (Rojo, 2007).
Religious tourism is defined as „that form of tourism whose participants are motivated in
part or exclusively for religion reasons‟ (Rinschede, 1992). The term religious emerges as a
result of the understanding of tourists‟ motivations. Religious tourism therefore involves
visiting local, regional, national or international pilgrimage centers, attending religious
ceremonies, conferences and celebrations, and all other religious oriented meetings that do not
take place in the home environment (Rinschede, 1992). According to Hinnells (1984), the
concept of religion revolves around a system of recognizable beliefs and practices that
acknowledge the existence of a `superhuman' power that enables people to both address and
transcend the problems of life. Religious tourism is therefore linked to this system through the
behavior and motives for visiting sites of religious significance. Religious tourism, also
commonly referred to as faith tourism, is a form of tourism, where people travel individually
or in groups for pilgrimage, missionary, or leisure (fellowship) purpose.
Most researchers identify religious tourism with the individual‟s quest for shrine sand
locales where the visitors seek to experience the sense of identity with sites of historical and
cultural meaning (Nolan and Nolan 1989). It is explained according to Al-Amin(2002), how
religious tourism is not one type of tourism, as is the case of secular tourism and describes
two different types of religious tourism, a tourism performed through a religious duty, and
tourism where the knowledge is recorded and quoted for wider dissemination. Another
definition of religious tourism is that the evaluation of touristic travels which people make
with an aim of visiting faith attraction centers, practicing religious beliefs in tourism
phenomenon out of the places of people, where they continually reside, work and meet the
regular needs can be defined as religious tourism.1
2. Religious Tourism in Turkey
Not only did the development of first civilizations in Anatolia but also the defection of
apostles in Early Christianity and Jewish people in their own countries to Anatolia as a result
of severe repression and destruction policies, played a significant role in emerging of many
synagogues and churches in Anatolia as well as the structures belonging to Islam, which is the
religion of Turkish Nation. The people living during the period of Seljuk and particularly
Ottoman period were allowed to live their own religion without any pressure, build their own
sanctuaries related their own religions and this was one of the most significant factors on this.
As a result of this, the sanctuaries and temples built in Anatolia reached today in line with
Islamic understanding of Turkish Nation with deep respect and tolerance. Turkey is an
important center for that fact that apostles and important religious saints lived in Anatolia
during the early Christianity for a long time and the spread of this religion started from
Anatolia. Not only is Turkey an important center for Christianity, but also for Islam. There are
so many mosques, shrines and sacred places belonging to people named saints with a high
spiritual identity in almost every city of Turkey as well as the religious structures constructed
during the Ottoman Empire which was a worldwide empire having the leadership of Islam for
6 centuries and the culture of Turkish-Islam which dominated these lands for more than 1000
years.2
The peninsula of Anatolia has been the cradle of many civilizations, cultures and religious
beliefs for thousands of years. Turkish Republic situated in this peninsula is now in the
position of inheritor of religious beliefs with this overall cultural heritage. Turkey houses
many monuments regarded as sacred by Muslims, Christians and Jews (Aktas & Ekin,
2007).When it comes to Christian sites, Turkey is as important as Israel or Greece for
44
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
religious tourism. For instance, St. Jean, regarded as the most important apostle in the first
years of Christianity and who played a considerable role in spreading of it, passed to Anatolia
from Jerusalem owing to the pressure of idolaters. This event is accepted as one of the turning
points of Christianity. Furthermore, also the mother of Jesus Christ, Mother Mary passed to
Anatolia under the auspices of St. Jean. A number of archaeological proofs support this
viewpoint. It is accepted by the Vatican and by a considerable number of churches.
3. Mother Mary House in Selçuk (Ephesus-Western Turkey): A Global Attraction for
Religious Visitors
The modern history of Meryem Ana begins in the first half of the 19th century on the
banks of the Rhine in Germany, in the sickbed of a peasant woman in a village near Dülmen
in Westphalia. Anna Katharina Emmerick (1774-1824) suffered from an incurable illness
which confined her to bed for 10 years. During that time she took comfort from visions which
she had concerning the lives of Jesus and Mary. These visions were extraordinarily extensive
and detailed, and they contained facts, places and people that she could not have otherwise
known (Granella, 2011). Following the visions of Anna Katharina Emmerick, a group of
Lazarist priests discovered a house, which is believed to be the place where Mother Mary
spent her last days in 1891. This discovery attracted the attention of the entire Christian world
(Selçuk Municipality, 2012). According to predominant Christian tradition, Mary was brought
to Ephesus by the Apostle John after the Resurrection of Christ and lived out her days there.
This is based mainly on the traditional belief that John came to Ephesus combined with the
biblical statement that Jesus consigned her to John's care (John 19:26-27).Mother Mary,
accompanied by Saint John, came to Ephesus at the end of her life, circa 37-45 A.D.
Renaissance church historians mentioned the trip, and it is said that local Christians venerated
a small house near Ephesus as Mary‟s. St. John, in his Gospel, tells us that Jesus, before dying
on the Cross, entrusted to him the care of his Mother when he said (saying): “Here is your
mother” and from that hour St. John took her to his own. The “Acts of the Apostles” relate
how after the death of Christ, his followers were persecuted in Jerusalem. St. Stephen was
stoned in 37 A.D. , St. James was beheaded in 42 A.D. and any further relate how they
divided the world between them for preaching the Gospel, and St. John was given Asia
Minor. Now, Mary had been given to his care and with the persecution, probably brought her
with him to Asia Minor.
There are two evidences confirming historically these facts;
1- The presence of the tomb of St. John in Ephesus,
2- The presence of the first Basilica of the world dedicated to the Blessed Virgin. In the
early days of the Church, places of worship were only dedicated to persons who had lived or
died in the locality.
45
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Picture 1 House of Mother Mary House in Selçuk İzmir
Source: http://www.sacred-destinations.com
Furthermore, the Ecumenical Council of 431 was held in Ephesus in this Basilica for the
definition of the dogma of the Divine Motherhood of Mary. There is another confirmation in
the oral tradition of the villagers of Kirkindje (Şirince). These people were the descendants of
the Christians of Ephesus. They had passed from generation to generation, the belief of the
death of Mary in this place, so they called “Panaghia Kapulu”. They have kept this tradition
alive through the annual pilgrimage of 15th of August (Şirince Houses,2012). The house
received visits from Pope Paul VI in 1967 and Pope John Paul II in 1979 who declared the
Shrine of Virgin Mary as a pilgrimage place for Christians, which strengthened the belief that
Virgin Mary lived and died in Ephesus. This site has become a frequent destination for
pilgrims, tourists and curious visitors since the image of Virgin Mary is venerated not only by
Christians but also by Muslims who recognize Mary as the mother of one of their prophets.
Every year on August 15th, a ceremony is organized to commemorate Mary's Assumption.
On November 29, 2006, Pope Benedict XVI celebrated mass here (House of Mother Mary,
2012).
The House of Mother Mary (Meryem Ana in Turkish) is located on the top of
“Nightingale” mountain is situated in a nature park between Ephesus and Seljuk and is
believed to be the last residence of the Virgin Mary, Mother of Jesus (House of Mother
Mary). The original two-stored house, which consisted of an anteroom (where today candles
are proposed), bedroom and praying room (Christian church area) and a room with fireplace
(chapel for Muslims). A front kitchen fell into ruins and has been restored in 1940's. Today,
only the central part and a room on the right of the altar are open to visitors. From there one
can understand that this building looks more like a church than a house. Another interesting
place is the "Water of Mary", a source to be found at the exit of the church area and where
rather salt water, with curative properties, can be drunk by all (Ephesus, 2012).
46
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Picture 2 House of Mother Mary in Selçuk İzmir
Source: http://www.sacred-destinations.com
Mother Mary is a mother of help and goodness. Regardless of religion, people visit the
house of Mother Mary for so many different reasons. All the people hearing that the water
coming from the source at the back of the house is a healing and treatment-giving one for all
kinds of illnesses and disorders come to visit the house of Mother Mary. Some patients claim
that they got rid of their illnesses after drinking the water and some other visitors claim that
their wishes came true after their visit. The wishes change according to the gender, age and
the economic situation of people. Any wish which may come to the mind of people is written
in the guest book of the house (Yitik, 2000 in Türkoğlu, 1986).
Today, the House of Mother Mary, which is recognized as one of the most sacred places
in the world by Vatican is, regarded one of the popular and holy places visited by Christians
coming from all over the world. Furthermore, the house of Mother Mary is also visited by
Muslims, as Mother Mary is accepted as the mother of one of the prophets, Hz. Isa (Jesus) in
Islam. The House of Mother Mary attracts nearly 1 million visitors each year (Efes Museum,
2012).
4. Mother Mary’s House and Its Muslim Visitors
There is no cult of Holy Mother Mary among Muslims like among Catholic Christians.
According to Islam, Mother Mary is not a mother giving birth to God, which is accepted as
the main sin, protected from all kinds of spiritual dirt or raised to God (Assumption)
immediately after her death. Furthermore, there is no depiction of Mother Mary carrying Jesus
(Her Son) in her arms in any Muslim shrine and none of the countries with the religion of
Islam has a city or state devoted to Mother Mary with the names such as Virginia, Santa
Maria and Mary Land. This situation should not be interpreted that Muslims ignore Mother
Mary in their beliefs and prays. Because Mother Mary is only woman who is chosen, cleaned
and made superior to all women of in the world with the verses(42-43) of Al-I Imran, I. Sura
in Quran (Yitik, 2000).
47
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
"Behold! The angels said: 'O Mary! God hath chosen thee and purified thee - chosen thee
above the women of all nations. O Mary! Worship thy Lord devoutly: Prostrate thyself, and
bow down (in prayer) with those who bow down.'" (Quran 3:42-43).
Many people may be surprised that Muslims love Mary, the mother of Jesus. In the Quran,
no woman is given more attention than Mother Mary. Mother Mary receives the most
attention of any woman mentioned in the Quran even though all the Prophets with the
exception of Adam had mothers (Jesus and Virgin Mary in Islam). Moreover, the Koran gives
Mother Mary special consideration: numerous verses and suras speak of Mary and Jesus
Christ. The Koran even contains a surah named after Mary (Surah XIX), describing her
virtues and qualities. Mary has various names and titles in the Koran, such as She who was
chosen, the greatest of Women, the Pure, The Immaculate, The Chaste, She of whom the
Hadiths Speak, Interlocutor of the Angels, She who Bows Down to Allah in Worship,
Receiver of the Good News of the Birth of Jesus. She and her son Jesus Christ are viewed as
signs demonstrating the existence of God (Granella, 2011). Mother Mary is mentioned in
different verses of Koran for 70 times and her name is repeated 34 times in total in Koran,
which makes her the 4th person mentioned in Koran after Prophet Moses (169), Prophet
Abraham (69) and Prophet Noah (43)(Smitt,1989 in Yitik,2000).
Today, the House of Mother Mary is mainly visited by Muslim visitors as Mother Mary is
regarded as the mother of one of the prophets Prophet Jesus (Isa) in Islam. As many Muslim
visitors think Mother Mary as a respectful and helpful person, they go to visit the house of
Mother Mary, pray there and ask for a help from God through Mother Mary when they have
some problems such as a crucial illness with no treatment, financial hardship, and search for
spouse or job etc. According to them, God never refuses prays and wishes of his bellowed
servants, because of this reason their prays will be accepted by God if they are done with
purity and sincerity (Yitik, 2000).
5. Mother Mary’s House and Its Non-Muslim Visitors
The Holy Bible begins in Turkey with Abraham‟s vocation in Harran (Southeast Turkey)
and it ends in Turkey with the book of Revelations (the letters to the seven churches in
Anatolia) (Granella, 2011). Not only do the Muslim visitors visit the house of Mother Mary
and ask her for help and goodness, but also the house of Mother Mary is a holy sanctuary
which is visited by Christians, Jewish, Buddhist, Shintoists and the people without any belief
in a religion. However, there is no doubt that Christian Catholics take the first place among
them, because the house of Mother Mary is not a simple usual place of visiting for them.
According to the Christian Catholics belonging to Lazarist and Capuchin traditions, the house
of Mother Mary and its surrounding is a place where Mother Mary came after the crucifixion
of her only son Jesus Christ, spent the last days of her life and probably died (Yitik, 2000). On
one hand Protestant Christians think that it is not right to accept the Mother Mary as a
mediator between God and human being, on the other hand Orthodox Christians regard
Mother Mary as a helping and healing goddess having super human characteristics and
qualifications. Furthermore, Mother Mary is accepted as a person with the characteristics such
as Teotokos, Immaculate Conception and Assumption of Mary by Catholic Christians
(Yitik,2000).
According to predominant Christian tradition, Mary was brought to Ephesus by the
Apostle John after the Resurrection of Christ and lived out her days there. This is based
mainly on the traditional belief that John came to Ephesus combined with the biblical
statement that Jesus consigned her to John's care (John 19:26-27). As the House of Mary in
Ephesus is a very tangible reminder that Mary plays an important role in Christianity, the
sanctuary was visited by three popes as pilgrims: Pope Paul VI, who stopped in Ephesus in
48
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
July 1967, Pope Jean Paul II, who came here as a pilgrim on November 30th 1979; and lastly ,
during his visit to Turkey Pope Benedict XVI also decided to come here to Ephesus as a
humble pilgrim and live this day of prayer ( he had no official appointments, just the Mass in
Sanctuary) in the memory of Mary, praying for peace in Jerusalem and all over the world in
her name (Granella, 2011).
The house of Mother Mary is therefore primarily a place of prayer, silence and reflection.
A place where groups of Christians pilgrims from all over the world celebrate Holy Mass in
memory of Mary taken up into the heaven, and where the flocks of pilgrims both Christians
and Muslims and others with another religion belief stop to say a silent prayer. The Mother
Mary grants grace to those who come with faith and a pure hearth cleansed of all sin
(Granella, 2011).
6. Visitor Behavior at Holy Sites
Visitors demonstrate changing behavioral patterns at tourism destinations. Tourist or
visitor behavior is shaped under several circumstances. The behavior of visitors might be
questioned from the perspective of space or location. Visitors of websites have certain
behavioral characteristics, but their behavior is generally analyzed during their online website
surfing. One can surf the Internet at home, at work or at other places and their behavior
regarding their website visits may differ. For instance; these behaviors can be clarified by the
timing of website visits, frequency of visits per given time (day/week/month etc.), duration of
the visit (minutes, hours etc.) per visit or per given time slice (day, week, month, year…),
choices of pages displayed, preferences of website languages, use of certain web site features
(e-mail, commenting etc.), activities realized on web site (purchase of products, music
listening, video watching, reading, listening news, watching live stream TV programs…),
preferences of explorer (Opera, Internet Explorer, Firefox, Safari, Chrome, Pardus…), web
sites visited prior and ulterior to the actual visited website and so on. Moving from this
analogy it is possible to analyze visitors of holy sites behavior at different spaces such as; at
homeland (another country and city), at the country of holy site, at transport vehicles, airports
and terminals, at other holy sites of the country visited, at accommodation units and hotel
location, and finally at the holy site itself (in situ behavior). Nearby this spatial analysis it is
possible to look at visitor behavior with temporal perspectives. Visitor behavior may differ at
different time pieces such as; before the visit of holy site, during the visit of holy site (in situ
behavior), after the visit of the holy site, and variations with change of seasons, holy time
pieces (days, weeks, months).
Visitor behavior might be affected from several factors. Traditionally, consumer behavior
theory puts forward factors such as; situational conditions, family and household, personal
characteristics, social class membership and socio-economic status, and culture. Visitors
experience psychological processes during their visits as economic or cultural (aesthetic,
recreational) consumptions. Three most known processes are; attitudinal and behavioral
changes, learning, and information processing (Engel et al., 1990). Tourist or visitor behaviors
have been widely analyzed from the economic, marketing, and consumer behavior
perspectives. Thus, their behaviors regarding the purchase decision is similar to the other
buyers in different markets. Typically, visitors‟ purchasing decisions follow stages of;
recognizing a problem/need, research on the problem, comparing alternative decisions,
decision-making for selected alternative(s), action of buying/purchase, post-purchase
evaluation and behaviors (Boone and Kurtz, 1993).
In tourism industry tourist behavior has been categorized from different angles (Hart and
Troy, 1996). From travel motivation it is possible to classify them as business, pleasure, and
personal motivation seekers. From consumption/usage rate or frequency; never users, old and
49
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
new users, first time and repeat users, regular and irregular users, heavy users and light users
are classified. Loyalty is another criteria used for grouping tourist behaviors. Some tourists
are loyal to one destination, one enterprise, one brand, some tourists are demonstrating soft
loyalty (2-3 brands), and some tourists are experience seekers and are never loyal to any
destination or enterprise.
The literature given above can partly help understand and explain visitor behavior at holy
sites. Personal characteristics of holy visitors may vary from other types of visitor/attraction
couplings. For instance, it is natural to expect Christians to visit cathedrals, churches,
Christian temples, while Muslims are expected to visit Islam‟s heritage areas. However, a
great majority of holy sites and buildings are open to visits from different faith holders.
Therefore, it is quite natural in Selçuk-Ephesus to see Muslims, Christians, and other spiritual
groups visiting House of Mother (Virgin) Mary.
7. Discovering Behavioral Aspects of Muslim and Non-Muslim Visitors: An
Application at Mother Mary’s House in Selçuk (Ephesus)
The house of Mother Mary Turkey is located in İzmir Province (ancient Smyrna). Selçuk
district where Mother Mary‟s House is actually located lies at the border of İzmir and Aydın
provinces of Aegean Region, at the Western extremity of Anatolian peninsula. The location of
the House is 7 km. from the ancient Ephesus archeological remains and modern centrum of
Selçuk. The house is found on Mt. Koressos (Bülbüldağı in Turkish literally meaning Mt.
Nightingale) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_the_Virgin_Mary ). According to
religious visions of German nun named Anna Catherina Emmerich (1774-1820), recorded and
published by C. Brendano Mother Mary lived near Ephesus for three years after her arrival
with St. John, but because she missed Jerusalem she went back with St. John and St. Peter.
During this last stay in Jerusalem she was heavily ill, and people around thought she would
die shortly. However, she recovered and felt strong enough to return to Ephesus to live her
last days at her house on Mt. Koressos, before she died at age of 64. Her coffin was put into a
cave 2 km. away from her house (http://www.kusadasi.biz/virgin-mary/ ). Most of the house
seen today dates back to 6th and 7th centuries; however its foundations back to 1st century. The
site had long served as a place of pilgrimage for Orthodox Christians of the vicinity
(http://www.sacred-destinations.com/turkey/ephesus-house-of-the-virgin ). Mother Mary‟s
house is open for visits all year. In summer, visitors are accepted from 07.00 to 17.00. In
winter period, visiting hours are from 07.30 to 17.00.
Within the scope of this research behavioral aspects of Muslim and non-Muslim visitors
will be analyzed based on the primary data obtained from professional tourist guides those
practice their profession at Mother Mary House. In order to collect primary data from tourist
guides a semi-structured interview has been prepared following the principle aims of the
research question. This research basically aims to discover behavioral characteristics of
religious (holy, sacred) site visitors from different religious convictions. By discovering these
differences holy sites like Mother Mary‟s House can be better prepared and designed for
visitors from diverse origins and religious affiliations. Understanding differences of visitors
can help to solve in situ visitor originated problems and eventually increase visitor
satisfaction. One last aim of the research is to develop suggestions for better protection and
management of holy sites as cultural heritage zones.
After an intensive literature search seven questions were developed. Table 1 depicts
questions probing the research question.
50
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Table 1 Questions Developed for Interview at Mother Mary‟s House
1. How the Holy Site of Mother Mary House can be prepared for first-time Muslim and
non-Muslim visitors for a satisfactory visit? (State of readiness to the group visits)
2. How can in situ visit experience of Muslim and Non-Muslim visitors be improved?
(What type of arrangements for physical surroundings and procedural aspects can be
developed? Please state type of problems you have discovered/observed/experienced
during tours and visits.)
3. Please develop your recommendations separately to increase visitor satisfaction for
Muslims and Non-Muslims at Mother Mary House? (What type of precautions can
increase satisfaction of Muslim and Non-Muslim visitors? Please differentiate
specifically.)
4. Please evaluate behaviors of Muslim and Non-Muslim visitors of all types (women,
men, old/young, children, different nationalities…) during their visits. Are there
differences among Muslims? How? Are there different behaviors among Non-
Muslims? How? (E.g. Catholics, Protestants…)
5. Please differentiate behaviors of Muslim/Non-Muslim visitors regarding the protection
of Mother Mary House Holy Site as a cultural heritage area? How should visitors and
Holy Site managers protect this heritage area during visits?
6. Please suggest solutions for tourism industry professionals - companies and religious
cultural heritage area managers in general?
7. Please add your comments freely regarding this research?
Note: Questions are formulated after literature search by authors.
After preparing research instrument, authors of the study have realized study trip to
Mother Mary‟s House during December 2012. Before visiting the Holy Site of Mother Mary‟s
House sufficient number of notebooks, pens and pencils, voice recording equipment with
adequate storage memory and batteries, photo camera devices have been prepared. Authors
consumed an entire day at Mother Mary‟s House and interviewed 25 persons having
experience and information about visitors of the Holy Site. Initially, these interviews were
planned to be realized only with tourist guides, however the number of tourist guides
interviewed has reached to 13 including off-site interviews with guides having experience of
Mother Mary‟ House touring. The rest of the interviews were belonging to three main groups,
namely; visitors (Muslims and non-Muslims), personnel working at Mother Mary‟s house,
salesmen employed by sub-contractors at souvenir shops of Holy Site. Interviews were male
in majority, ranging from 20 years old to 60 years old. Tourist guides‟ experience level was
moderate ranging from 5 years to 16 years. Tourist guides guided groups of mixed nature
(having members of different religious affiliations), and few tourist guides guided uniquely
for Muslim groups. Most of the guides had experience of touring with Catholic visitors at
Mother Mary‟s House. Guides were grouped into two regarding their employment status,
since majority of them had other income sources than guiding profession. Therefore, tourist
guiding is still practiced as a temporary job for many due to seasonality of the profession and
industry.
The questions are asked to participants (professional tourist guides, visitors, personnel of
Mother Mary‟s House, and salespeople employed at the Holy site) about the behavioral
differences of Muslim and Non-Muslim visitors making a visit to the house of Mother Mary
which is accepted as a holy sanctuary by Christianity and Islam as well. Within the scope of
51
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
the research data were collected through qualitative data collection techniques (semi-
structured interview).
The obtained results are followed;
Muslim Visitors:
According to the results of the research, it is found out that the number of the Muslim
visitors visiting the house of Mother Mary is less than the Non-Muslim visitors in spite of the
fact that the house of Mother Mary is accepted as a holy sanctuary by both Islam and
Christianity, and that there is an immense Muslim population close to the Holy Area. The
possible reasons of this result are followed;
o The management of the House of Mother Mary belongs to a Christian Association.
Mother Mary‟s House is associated with Christianity despite its importance and
recognition by Islam.
o There is a sign on the left side of the inner door at the entrance of Mother Mary House
indicating that “the written prayers and printed brochures belong to the religion of
Christianity", which inherently proposes that the House is primarily serving to visitors
belonging to Christianity.
o There seems limited preparation for Muslim visitors regarding their spiritual needs
such as a place of worship/pray, ablution, souvenir shop including books related with
Islam and so on in the vicinity of Mother Mary House. The possible reason that could
explain this situation is the low number of Muslim visitors.
o Muslim visitors may slightly perceive a sense of belongingness to the area while
visiting this holy sanctuary since the visual aspects offer few imaginary for Islam.
Therefore among Muslim visitors those who have deep knowledge about Mother Mary
and those who are conscious on the Mother Mary‟s religious importance can feel more
attached to the location.
o When the motivation (purpose) of Muslim visitors is compared with that of Christian
visitors, it is found out that the Muslim visitors are in general far less conscious and
informed about the history, meaning, and cultural importance of the place. Most of
Muslim visitors‟ aim seemed to be realizing a recreational/tourism focused visit
instead of a religious visit. For a large part of Muslim visitors, Mother Mary‟s House
had an image of one of the must-see attractions around İzmir.
o According to the research results, it is found out that the majority of young (less than
35 years old) Muslim visitors such as students from universities and high schools
behave in an inappropriate way during their visits. This group is not careful about
presence of other visitors and does not keep silent in conformity with area
management‟s principles.
o Another inappropriate behavior stemming from young visitors including Muslim and
Non-Muslim visitors, is speaking loudly in the holy sanctuary, disturbing other
visitors, and taking pictures in the inner part of the house even it is forbidden.
o In general young Muslim visitors (predominantly Turkish citizens in this research)
have limited or very little information and education about the Mother Mary
Phenomena. Even if they know that Jesus Christ and Mother Mary are accepted as
Holy personages by Islam, their knowledge is very superficial.
52
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
o During the access and visiting period at Mother Mary‟s House no visual clues help
Muslim visitors perceive that this area is a place of worship, and it has meaning and
importance for Islam faith nearby Christianity.
o Despite, for a small group in total Muslim visitors, religious purpose is valid and of
importance, however in general Muslim visitors seemed to visit this holy area not for
true religious purposes but only for tourism/travel purposes.
o The age of Muslim visitors is related with their behavioral characteristics. Visitors
over 35 years old are more conscious, pre-planned, and have more respect for the holy
shrine of Mother Mary. This situation can be explained by their growing interest for
meaning in life via religion and their increased maturity level.
Christian Visitors;
According to the results of the research, it is found out that the number of Christian
visitors visiting the house of Mother Mary surpass Muslim visitors and visitors of other
religious convictions. Visitors from countries having considerable Christian populations
although they may not be strictly practicing Christianity rules, behave in a more respectful an
appropriate way when compared with Muslim visitors. The possible reasons for this situation
are followed;
o Mother Mary is accepted as a holy figure in all the sects of Christianity (Catholic,
Orthodox, and Protestant). Respect for Mother Mary is generalized among Christians
during their visits.
o Among Christian visitors, behavioral differences are observed between sects.
Accordingly, Christian Catholics have deeper interest and respect and they feel much
more impressed from their visiting experience than other Christian visitors. Visits of
Popes from Vatican may support the interest of Catholic visitors.
o It is also found out that Christian visitors belonging to Orthodox and Protestant sects
make a visit to the house of Mother Mary for touristic reasons as the house is included
in their tour program rather than for religious reasons. However, it is possible to
observe passionate visitors from these groups occasionally.
o Similar to the behavioral changes by age, Non-Muslim visitors, and in particular
Christians over mid-age behave more polite, more respectful, more silent, and in a
more careful manner during their visits at Mother Mary‟s House.
8. Conclusions and Policy Implications
There should be a limit to the number of visitors as the carrying capacity exceeds during
the summer time when the high season is on its path, because the visitors complain about the
congestion in the house of Mother Mary during the visit. The high season for this holy shrine
is during July and August. Currently, there is no restriction for visit, and tourist guides
communicate among each other to plan their visiting hours and decrease level of congestion.
Tourist guides generally interchange timing of visits of Mother Mary‟s House, Ephesus
ancient Site, and/or Ephesus Museum. In future, when the number of tours and participants of
individual and group visits increase the carrying capacity will be questioned.
As the house of Mother Mary is accepted as a holy sanctuary and universal place both by
Muslims and Christians, it may be a good idea to give a brochure or a leaflet giving
information about Mother Mary and the house and how to behave in the house of Mother
Mary to the visitors at the entrance of the house in different languages such as Turkish,
English, German, French and Russian. It is urgent to prepare documents in Turkish for
53
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Turkish speaking visitors with a map, because when they arrive with school buses their visits
create congestion momentarily.
According to the results of the research, it is found out that the house of Mother Mary has
visitors from all age groups. Some visitors, especially elder ones, have a great difficulty in
reaching the mountain where the house of Mother Mary is located. This problem may be
overcome with a cable car (lift) which will be established like in Acropolis archeological site
in Pergamum. Furthermore, the establishment of this cable car will enable visitors to see the
view of the Ephesus an ancient city founded as a port city in ancient time. The civil transport
to the hill where Mother Mary‟s House is located is not well-designed. Someone who tries to
visit the House should either take a taxi from Selçuk District center or from gates of Ephesus
ancient site. This can be expensive and impossible service during peak seasons. Dolmus
(minibus for collective transport), city bus, and cable lift can be put on service for the ease of
visitor. The current road is narrow, and needs protective side-bars for pedestrians and
vehicles. There is no road section reserved for cyclists and visitors coming with motorbikes or
bikes.
The existent information signs and other warnings in the vicinity of Mother Mary House
can be reorganized. For example; warnings like; “It is not allowed to smoke here and to speak
loudly here”, “Please keep right during your walk” in different languages.
New arrangements can be done to prevent the objects destroyed in the holy structure.
Protecting the garden of Mother Mary House is also critical. For example; the food and
beverage organizations, parking area for the tour buses and other cars and entrance door can
be taken a little bit farther to prevent the noise, pictures informing visitors about the holy
sanctuary can be hung to meet the visitors coming from entrance and there may be a holy
music application informing visitors about the holy sanctuary of Mother Mary House.
Solutions are required to increase awareness level of Muslim visitors (such as seminars,
mini booklets to be distributed, large signs with explanations etc.) Especially young visitors
and students should be informed about the house of Mother Mary before their arrival to the
heritage site. The society will have more consciousness through these seminars and the level
of respect will increase in this way.
The necessary precautions that should be taken to increase the level of satisfaction of
Muslim visitors , increase the number of Muslim visitors, increase the level of their
consciousness are written below as follows;
It is thought that the increase of awareness for this heritage area among Muslim visitors
will make a contribution to the number of the Muslim visitors in a positive way. Providing
Muslim visitors with the brochures or leaflets giving information about the importance of
Mother Mary in Islam at the entrance of Mother Mary House will make a contribution in a
positive way. The existence of a small prayer place (Masjid or a Small Mosque) which will
enable Muslim visitors to pray in the holy vicinity of Mother Mary House may attract more
Muslim visitors to the area. If the Muslim visitors are provided with the chance to buy some
souvenirs related to Islam in the shops situated in the garden of Mother Mary House and use
the current currency of Turkey (Lira) as well as Euro may increase satisfaction of Turkish
Muslim visitors.
Tourism industry stakeholders should work in close coordination with the Association
responsible for management of this heritage area. Another key relationship is between
Municipality and the Association. Cultural heritage management principles should be
developed in long term for Mother Mary‟s House. Visitor management principles should be
applied in conformity with heritage management cases from all over the world.
54
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
References
Aktaş, A., Ekin, Y., (2007), Case Study 5: The Importance and the Role of Faith (Religious)
Tourism As Alternative Tourism Resources in Turkey, In, R. Raj and N. Morpeth, Religious
Tourism and Pilgrimage Festivals Management: An International Perspective, pp.170-183.
Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing.
Al-Amin, H.(2002). Religious Tourism in Islamic Heritage. Islamic Tourism – Issue 02 –
pp.32-34
Boone, L.E., Kurtz, D. L. (1993). Contemporary Business, 7th Ed., Orlando: Dryden Press.
Engel, F.J., Blackwell, D.R., Miniard, P.W. (1990). Consumer Behavior, 6th Ed., USA:
Dryden Press.
Chis, A., Bacilia, F. & Tirca,A. (2009) Priors' perceptions of Religious tourism and its
spiritual, ethical, social and economic impacts: The case of Transylvania, Proceedings of the
International Conference on Sustainable Tourism within High Risk Areas of Environmental
Crisis (81-90), Messina, Italy.
Coleman, S (2004). Framing Pilgrimages: Cultures in Motion. Routledge.
Gan, Z., Ma, Y. & Song, B. (2000). Tourism Resource of Religious Culture. In Z. Gan, Y.Ma
& B. Song (Eds.), Tourism Resource and Development (157-176). Tianjin: Nankai University
Press.
Granella,O.(2011). Meryem Ana Visitors‟ Guide to the Meryem Ana Sanctuary and the
Christian History of Ephesus. Edizioni Eteria.
Hart, C.W.L., and Troy, C.A. (1996). Strategic Hotel/Motel Marketing, Michigan-USA:
Educational Institute of AH&MA.
Hinnells, J. H. (1984). The Penguin Dictionary of Religions. London: Penguin Books Ltd.
Jackowski, A.,Smith, V.L. (1992). Polish Pilgrim-Tourists. Annals of Tourism Research,
19(1) 92-106.
Jansen, W., & Kühl, M. (2008). Shared Symbols: Muslims, Marian Pilgrimages And Gender.
European Journal of Women's Studies, 1, 295-311.
Nolan, M. 1., & Nolan, S. (1989). Christian Pilgrimage in Modern Western Europe. Chapel
Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Pres.
Rinschede, G. (1992). Forms of religious tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 19(1) 51-67.
Rodriques,S.A.M.(2012). Motivations, Experiences and Potential Impacts of Visitors to a
Monastery in New Zealand: A Case Study.The University of Waikato Department of Tourism
and Hospitality Management.
Rojo, D. M. (2007). Religious Tourism: The Way to Santiago, MA European Tourism
Management, Bournemouth University.
Smith, J.I., Haddah,Y.Y. (1989). “The Virgin Mary in Islamic Tradition and Commentary”
The Muslim World,Vol LXIIX, July October pp 161-187
Timothy, D., and Olsen, D., (2006) Tourism, Religion and Spiritual Journeys. Routledge.
Rodriques,S.A.M.(2012). Motivations, Experiences and Potential Impacts of Visitors to a
Monastery in New Zealand: A Case Study.The University of Waikato Department of Tourism
and Hospitality Management.
55
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Timothy, D. J., & Boyd, S. W. (2006). Heritage tourism in the 21st century: Valued traditions
and new perspectives. Journal of Heritage Tourism, 1(1), 1–16.
Wright, K. (2007) November, Leisure Group Travel Special Edition.(8-16). Religious
Tourism, A New Era, A Dynamic Industry.
Yitik,A.İ.(2000). İslam Kültüründe Hristiyanlığa Bakış ve Müslüman-Hristiyan
Münasebetleri. Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi.
Internet References
Selçuk Municipality.(2012) Selçuk, Ephesus, Mother Mary House
http://www.selcuk.bel.tr/tr/selcuk.php?module=9 [Accessed 15.12.2012]
Kuşadası Biz. (2022) Virgin Mary, http://www.kusadasi.biz/virgin-mary/ [Accessed
15.12.2012]
Şirince Houses.(2012) House of the Virgin Mary.
http://www.sirince-evleri.com/Default.asp?L=EN&mid=275 [Accessed 15.12.2012]
House of the Virgin Mary.(2012). Welcome to the House of the Virgin Mary in Ephesus,
Turkey.http://www.sfpnn.com/TravelbyPatty/1Patty2011/Virgin%20Mary%20House/HOUS
E%20OF%20VIRGIN%20MARY.htm [Accessed 15.12.2012]
Ephesus.(2012). House of Virgin Mary.
http://www.ephesus.us/ephesus/houseofvirginmary.htm [Accessed 15.12.2012]
Ephesus Museum.(2012). House of Mother Mary.
http://www.efesmuzesi.gov.tr/index2.php?dil=TR&sayfa=dp&pc=40 [Accessed 15.12.2012]
Onislam. (2012) Jesus Christ and Virgin Mary in Islam,
http://www.onislam.net/english/reading-islam/understanding -
islam/belief/messengers/450258-jesus-and-the-virgin-mary-in-islam.html [Accessed
15.12.2012]
Ministry of Culture and Tourism.(2012) Religious Tourism,
http://www.ktbyatirimisletmeler.gov.tr/TR,9952/inanc-turizmi.html [Accessed 15.12.2012]
Sacred Destinations. (2012) House of the Virgin, http://www.sacred-
destinations.com/turkey/ephesus-house-of-the-virgin [Accessed 15.12.2012]
Wikipedia. (2012) House of the Virgin Mary,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_the_Virgin_Mary [Accessed 15.12.2012]
56
A Comparison of Museum Visitors’ Expectations within the Context of
Faith Tourism
Özgür ÖZER
Konya Necmettin Erbakan University
Tourism Faculty
Department of Travel Guide, Turkey
E-mail: oozer@konya.edu.tr
Serhat Adem SOP
Mehmet Akif Ersoy University
School of Tourism and Hospitality Management
Department of Hospitality Management, Turkey
E-mail: serhat_adem_sop@yahoo.com
Umut AVCI
Muğla Sıtkı Koçman University
School of Tourism and Hospitality Management
Department of Hospitality Management, Turkey
E-mail: aumut@mu.edu.tr
Abstract
Due to the functional diversification of museums in recent years, it has started to arouse
interest in understanding the museum visitors‟ expectations and finding out whether their
expectations are met or not. Therefore, this study aimed to identify and compare the
expectations of domestic and foreign visitors of Mevlana Museum particularly within the
context of faith tourism in Konya, Turkey. 163 domestic and 184 foreign visitors that visited
the museum were surveyed with the questionnaire developed specifically for the research.
Then, a factor analysis was conducted to reduce data and to clarify the dimensions, and finally
five factors were obtained: attention and empathy, cultural impression, escapism,
reminiscence and value for money. According to these findings, 80 % of the visitors seemed
as having information about Mevlana while 57 % of the visitors were determined as having
information about the Mevleviyeh. The findings of this study prove that the visitors of the
museum mostly consist of informed ones. On the other hand, the expectation levels of the
domestic visitors in attention and empathy and cultural impression dimensions were found
higher while the expectations of both the domestic and the foreign visitors in terms of value
for money dimension were similar.
Keywords: Domestic and foreign visitors, expectations, faith tourism, Mevlana Museum.
1. Introduction
Since the earliest times, there have been many factors that lead people to travel. Among
these factors, especially the religious ones have been in the forefront since the middle age.
Therefore, travelling for religious purposes started to become significant among all travels.
One of the aims of religious journeys is one‟s desire to worship in these places. The other
important aim is one‟s desire to visit sacred places and holy shrines no matter which religion
he or she belongs to. In line with these aims, throughout history people have visited many
different places of religious and scientific attractiveness. Among these attractions, museums
hold an important place. In general, museums are defined as “places and buildings in which
artistic and scientific works or useful objects for art and science are preserved and available
57
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
for public viewing” (TDK, 2005: 1445). However, Yılmaz (2011) draws attention to the fact
that today the scope of the definition of “museum” has expanded in terms of tourism and has
also covered places of religious interest.
The fact that the scope of museums has expanded and they becoming important tourist
attractions have contributed to the importance of managing those areas as well as meeting the
expectations of the visitors over time. Museum administrators are obliged to ensure visitors‟
satisfaction particularly by capturing their imagination (Gartenhaus, 1997). Within this
context, while taking measures not only to improve museums but also to increase the
satisfaction level of visitors, it is of great importance to take into account of what expectations
the visitors of museums have during these visits and in which direction of their perceptions
have developed. Although museums have become complex and important tourist attractions
today, it is observed that not many studies have been conducted on the expectations and
satisfaction of the visitors. However, it is known that having little or no feedback from the
visitors will fail to guide the museum administrators. Thus, the current study aims to find out
and compare the expectations of both domestic and foreign tourists who visit Mevlâna
Museum within the context of faith tourism. It is considered that the findings of the study will
provide the museum administration with some leading insights and will guide further research
to be conducted in this field in the near future.
2. Faith Tourism and Mevlâna Museum
Faith means “heartfelt attachment to a thought” (TDK, 2005). As a requirement of their
faith, people are travelling for such spiritual purposes as "pilgrimage" and "seeing the holy
places". It is known that not only pilgrims but even other people also visit those places out of
curiosity and get involved in tour organizations for those places (Özgüç, 2003: 84). In this
sense, Mecca and Medina in Islam, Jerusalem, Rome and Ephesus in Christianity, and again
Jerusalem in Judaism are holy places of mass religious tourism. It is possible to increase the
number of such holy places when taken into consideration of many parts of the world (Sargın,
2006: 3). In terms of tourism, those activities and events carried out to visit such places are
described as “faith tourism”.
According to the definition made by the “Ministry of Culture and Tourism” of Turkey,
faith tourism is identified as “the evaluation of touristic trips in the scope of tourism
phenomenon, which are taken by people with the aims to fulfill their religious needs and see
religious attractions outside the places in which they continually reside, work, and meet their
usual needs” (Dikici and Sağır, 2012: 36). In Turkey, since the 1990s, activities to improve
faith tourism have been attached importance by the Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism,
and the inventory of the extant works of the three major religions and worship centers was
created in 1993 (Kuter, 2008: 518). For this purpose, centers which are thought religiously
important and visited mostly, are thought important in terms of the history of art, are the first
of its kind and interesting due to the architectural features, are located in an easily accessible
area and thus are included in tour programs by travel agencies have been evaluated in the
scope of faith tourism. Many important structures and places, bearing the above-mentioned
features, in Turkey have been opened to visitors within the scope of faith tourism, and it has
been aimed to turn Turkey into an important centre of these tourist activities. Mevlâna
Museum, situated in Konya, is one of these centers. Also known as a literary museum,
Mevlevi Lodge and Mausoleum were first opened to visitors under the name of Konya Asar-ı
Atika Museum in 1929 (Özkul et al., 2012). In 1954, the museum was given the name of
Mevlâna Museum. The current area of the museum (along with a rose garden) is 15,000
square meters. Mevlana Jalaluddin-i Rumi was the great Turkish thinker, Sufi, cleric and
humanity poet who lived in Konya during the thirteenth century. This museum in which his
58
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
memory is kept alive is visited by foreign visitors who pay attention to his opinions as well as
domestic visitors (Tapur, 2009: 484). Mevlâna Museum is the third-most-visited museum
placed after Hagia Sophia and Topkapi in Turkey. In 2011, a total of 1, 735,424 people visited
the museum (www.kulturvarliklari.gov.tr).
3. Museum Visitors’ Expectations
Throughout the world, there has been a significant increase in the number of museums
since the 19th century. Along with this period, the number of museum visits has increased and
museums have become important places over this time. No doubt that this situation has
played an important role in increasing interest in museums both in terms of tourism activities
and management (Uralman, 2006: 252). In addition, along with the functional diversification
of the museums (Weil, 2000), there has been an awakened interest over the issues of
identifying what expectations the museum visitors have and finding out whether these
expectations are met or not. Despite an increase in the number of studies on exploring this
interest in recent years, it is interesting that there is a limited amount of academic research
about this subject.
Museums, which play an important role because of being among tourist attractions, are
generally known to focus on education, conservation and exhibition of works. However, it is
also obvious that the visitors‟ expectations of trying such different experiences as
entertainment and internal satisfaction have shown an increase (MacDonald and Alsford,
1995; Moscardo, 1996; Kang and Gretzel, 2012).
Therefore, it has been crucial for museums to be able to understand and meet the
expectations of visitor groups who wish to have different experiences from their visits to the
museum (Moscardo, 1996; Kang and Gretzel, 2012). In this context, it is an important attempt
to involve researchers from different academic units in the management of some museums
with the purpose of understanding the expectations of people who visit the museums (Barnes
and Lynch, 2012). Another point of view on the importance of the expectations of museum
visitors has been suggested by Weil (2000). Weil (2000) stresses that being familiar with the
expectations of museum visitors and meeting these expectations will help improve their
quality of life. In the study carried out by Sheng and Chen (2012), it was also found out that
there are a lot of factors influencing the experiences of museum visitors. Among these factors,
the interaction of personal, social and environmental factors stand at the forefront.
In the literature relating tourism, there are only few studies based on the experiences of
museum visitors. In this sense, a study conducted by Yılmaz (2011) on the Goreme Open Air
Museum examined a total of 308 visitors' perceptions of service quality. In this study, their
perceptions of quality were examined under four headings as "the physical elements of the
service", "elements of exhibitions", "empathy" and "price, and other service elements". The
results of the study show that the visitors expect higher quality service from all of these
factors. In addition, it was found out that the visitors coming to the museum for the first time
had low levels of quality perceptions. In another study carried out by Sheng and Chen (2012),
the expectations of a total of 425 tourists who visited 5 different museums were evaluated
(those museums were the Taiwan Museum, the Museum of Drinking Water, the National
Museum of History, the National Taiwan Science Education Centre and the Miniatures
Museum of Taiwan). At the end of the study, it was found out that the majority of visitors had
the expectations of “comfort and entertainment".
4. Methodology
The main purpose of the study is to explore the expectations of tourists who visit Mevlâna
Museum and compare the expectations of domestic and foreign visitors. With this purpose,
59
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
data were gathered from October 1 to December 1 (2012) through a questionnaire completed
by 163 domestic and 184 foreign tourists who visited Mevlâna Museum. 37 out of the
questionnaires filled out by the domestic visitors, and 16 out of those completed by the
foreign visitors were not evaluated because they had the missing or incorrect information. The
data base of this study consisted of 347 valid questionnaires.
The questionnaire used as a data collection tool was developed by taking into account of
the studies by Barrio et al. (2009), İlhan (2009), Yılmaz (2011), Sheng and Chen (2012). The
propositions drawn from these studies were associated with religious tourism. After the
questionnaire form was constructed, a total of 68 domestic and foreign visitors were asked to
respond the questionnaire form under the plot study in order to check the reliability of the
scale. Following this pre-application, the reliability of the questionnaire was found as 0.83.
So, the questionnaire form consists of 23 items that prepared to find out the expectations of
the visitors. In addition, 6 questions to determine the participants‟ experiences of their visit to
the museum and 9 questions to identify their demographic characteristics are included to the
form.
5. Findings of the Study
The findings regarding the characteristics of the participants are presented separately for
domestic and foreign visitors as seen in Table 1. In this context, 55.3 % of the participants are
domestic and 44.7% are foreign visitors. The majority of the participants are aged between 19
and 29, and 58.5% of them are single, and most of the participants are university graduates.
Whereas 33.7% of the foreign participants have visited Mevlâna Museum with a tour group,
26.4% of the domestic participants have visited it along with their families. It has been
identified that 16.7% of the foreign participants have come from European countries while
11.8% of them have come from the Far East countries.
Table 1: Profile of the respondents
Domestic (N=163) Foreign (N=184) Total (N=347)
n % n % n %
Gender
Male 88 54 104 56.5 192 55.3
Female 74 46 80 43.5 155 44.7
Age
19-29 93 57.1 97 52.7 190 54.8
20-39 33 20.2 26 14.2 59 17
40-49 26 16 23 12.5 49 14.1
50-59 8 4.9 19 10.3 27 7.8
60 and more 3 1.8 19 10.3 22 6.3
Marital Status
Married 98 60.1 105 57.1 131 37.8
Single 60 36.8 71 38.6 204 58.5
Other 5 3.1 8 4.3 13 3.7
Education
Primary School 12 7.4 2 1.1 14 4
High School 21 12.8 21 11.4 42 12.1
University 115 70.6 104 56.5 219 63.1
Master‟s 10 6.1 45 24.5 55 15.9
PhD 5 3.1 12 6.5 17 4.9
Travelling with whom
Alone 29 17.8 37 20.1 66 19
Suppose 24 14.7 21 11.4 45 13
Family 43 26.4 42 22.8 85 24.5
Relatives 8 4.9 4 2.2 12 3.5
Travel Agency 29 17.8 62 33.7 91 26.2
60
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Other 30 18.4 18 9.8 48 13.8
Nationality
Turkey 163 100 - - 163 47
Arabian Countries - - 21 6.1 21 6.1
Middle Asian Countries - - 19 5.4 19 5.4
Far Eastern Countries - - 41 11.8 41 11.8
European Countries - - 58 16.7 58 16.7
Russian Federation - - 2 0.6 2 0.6
South American Countries - - 28 8.1 28 8.1
North American Countries - - 1 0.3 1 0.3
African Countries - - 14 4 14 4
When the participants‟ experiences of their visit are examined, it has been observed that
64.8% of them have visited the museum before (Table 2). The majority of these participants
have visited the museum one or two times. The rate of the participants who have knowledge
about Mevlâna is 80.6% whereas the visitors who have knowledge about the Mevleviyeh rates
57% of the participants. Furthermore, it can be seen that 52.1% of the visitors have gathered
information from different sources before they visited the museum, and 61.9% of them have
particularly devoted time in their holiday schedule to visit the museum.
Table 2: Visiting experiences of the respondents (N=347)
Have you ever visited Mevlana Museum before? n %
Yes 225 64.8
No 122 35.2
If yes, how many times? n %
1 94 41.7
2 69 30.6
3 34 15.1
4 16 7.2
5 and more 12 5.4
I have information about Mevlana n %
Yes 280 80.6
No 67 19.4
I have information about the Mevleviyeh n %
Yes 198 57
No 149 43
I’ve collected information from different sources before
n %
visiting Mevlana Museum
Yes 181 52.1
No 166 47.9
I’ve spared some special time for today to visit Mevlana
n %
Museum in my holiday schedule
Yes 215 61.9
No 132 38.1
23 items produced which are to be able to identify how the visitors‟ expectations of the
museum are grouped for testing the validity of the questionnaire and were analyzed through
the exploratory factor analysis. The items with factor loading < 0.40 were excluded from
evaluation. Until it reached a meaningful factor construct, the analysis was repeated in three
stages. In the fourth stage, the 17 items, as referred to in Table 3, were grouped under five
factors. In the analysis, those factors that have an eigenvalue >1 were evaluated. As a result of
the factor analysis, the KMO value of the sampling was calculated as 0.846. The result of the
Bartlett test (Sig.0.000) showed that a significant factor model can be established.
61
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Table 3: Factor analysis and reliability test results of expectation. (N= 347)
Explained Cronbach‟s
Factor
Factors and Items Variance Alfa
Loading Eigenvalue
(%)
Factor 1 – Attention and Empathy 5,360 % 31,527 0.81
Mevlana Museum is a worldwide known faith ,494
tourism center.
While visiting Mevlana Museum, I would like to ,664
see other visitors‟ interest for the museum.
I expect not be disturbed by other visitors while ,697
visiting Mevlana Museum.
Just as expected from the visitors, I also expect ,696
the museum officials to behave in a good manner
to keep silence and peace in the museum during
the tours to Mevlana Museum.
I‟d like to feel myself as one of the conscious ,506
visitors while visiting Mevlana Museum.
Factor 2 – Cultural Impression 1,688 % 9,931 0.79
While visiting Mevlana Museum, I expect the ,607
historical artifacts presented in the museum to
evoke admiration on me artistically.
I expect the historical artifacts that I see in ,730
Mevlana Museum to influence me spiritually.
While visiting Mevlana Museum, I‟d like to find ,468
out some interesting differences and changes
between that age and today.
I‟d like to relax and feel at peace while visiting ,531
Mevlana Museum.
Factor 3 – Escapism 1,422 % 8,362 0.77
I feel myself as a part of history while visiting ,462
Mevlana Museum.
While visiting Mevlana Museum, I feel as if I ,933
lived in the same age with the historical artifacts
presented in the museum.
I visualize the legendary characters or events of ,476
that age while visiting Mevlana Museum.
Factor 4 – Reminiscence 1,117 %6,568 0,74
I‟d like to buy souvenirs while visiting Mevlana ,414
Museum.
I‟d like to have good memories that will remind ,881
me the Museum after the visit.
I‟d like to feel that I‟ve gained a new aspect of ,504
future after visiting Mevlana Museum.
Factor 5 – Value for Money 1,036 %6,096 0,72
I‟d like to feel that the payment of museum ,765
entrance is worth for the visit.
After visiting Mevlana Museum, I‟d like to feel ,702
that the payment I‟ve made is worth for the
souvenirs.
1- strongly disagree ………………………………. 5- strongly agree
As the result of factor analysis, five factors were identified as “attention and empathy”,
“cultural impression”, “escapism”, “reminiscence” and “value for money”. The total variance
of these five factors is 62.4% that means they can be explained. Among these, the variance
explanation rate of the "attention and empathy" factor is 31.5%.
62
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Table 4: T-test results between domestic and foreign visitors
Levene's Test
for Equality T-test for Equality of
of Variances Means
F Sig T df Sig.
(2-uçlu)
Assumed* 1,453 ,229 8,063 345 ,000
Attention and Empathy
Not assumed** 8,114 344,908 ,000
Assumed* ,289 ,591 7,115 245 ,000
Cultural Impression
Not assumed** 7,135 343,119 ,000
Assumed* 1,500 ,222 4,581 345 ,000
Escapism
Not assumed** 4,568 335,612 ,000
Assumed* 0,339 ,561 2,181 345 ,031
Reminiscence
Not assumed** 2,174 334,415 ,030
Assumed* 3,279 ,071 1,743 345 ,082
Value for Money
Not assumed** 1,725 314,771 ,086
* Equal variances assumed ** Equal variances not assumed
An independent t-test was employed in order to compare the expectations of domestic and
foreign tourists who visited Mevlâna Museum. The result of analysis points out that the
domestic and foreign visitors do not show any differences only in their expectations of the
"value for money" factor (Table 4).
Table 5: Post-Hoc comparisons after T-test
Cumulative Std. Std. Error
N Mean Deviation Mean
Domestic Visitors 163 21,5583 3,10137 ,24292
Attention and Empathy
Foreign Visitors 184 18,7065 3,44524 ,25399
Domestic Visitors 163 17,4049 2,64724 ,20735
Cultural Impression
Foreign Visitors 184 15,3261 2,77620 ,20466
Domestic Visitors 163 11,3804 2,54153 ,19907
Escapism
Foreign Visitors 184 10,1576 2,42756 ,17896
Domestic Visitors 163 11,4601 2,47268 ,19368
Reminiscence
Foreign Visitors 184 10,8967 2,33650 ,17225
Domestic Visitors 163 7,4724 2,21196 ,17325
Value for Money
Foreign Visitors 182 7,0934 1,82283 ,13512
The responses of the domestic and foreign visitors were compared to determine the
sources of these differences in their expectations. As can be seen in Table 5, the expectation
levels of the domestic visitors are higher than those of the foreign visitors. Especially the
difference in terms of the first two factors is at a higher level.
6. Results and Discussion
In this study, the expectations of domestic and foreign visitors who visited Mevlâna
Museum were measured and compared. For this purpose, the data were collected through a
questionnaire form conducted with a total of 163 domestic and 184 foreign visitors who
visited the Mevlâna Museum. In order to evaluate the expectations for the museum in the
study, the questionnaire was developed by benefitting from the studies by Barrio et al.,
(2009), İlhan (2009), Yılmaz (2011), and Sheng and Chen (2012). Following this, a factor
analysis was conducted to determine how the items included in the questionnaire were
grouped. As a result of the factor analysis, the five factors referred as "attention and
63
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
empathy", "cultural impression", "escapism", "reminiscence" and "value for money", and 17
items were identified. The total variance of these five factors is 62.4%. The study presents
some crucial findings as to the experiences of the visitors. For example, it is pointed out that
80% of the visitors have knowledge about Mevlâna while 57% of them have information
about the Mevleviyeh. Moreover, 52 % of the visitors obtained information from different
sources before their visit to Mevlâna Museum. It can also be considered that these findings
show that the participants of this study visited the museum consciously.
The tourists‟ expectations of their visit to Mevlâna Museum vary with respect to such
dimensions as “attention and empathy”, “cultural impression”, “escapism” and
“reminiscence” in terms of domestic and foreign visitors. The domestic visitors‟ expectations
as to these four factors are at a higher level than those of the foreign visitors. In particular, the
perception levels of domestic visitors in terms of "attention and empathy" and "cultural
impression" are much higher. This point can be occurred due to the domestic visitors‟ beliefs.
Moreover, such a difference can be explained by that the domestic visitors are generally
motivated and conscious in their visits to Mevlâna Museum. Another interesting finding of
the study is that the expectations for the factor referred as “value for money” do not show any
difference in terms of domestic and foreign visitors. The cumulative arithmetic average for
this factor is low, so this can be considered as an indicator of the fact that financial
expectations are slightly significant during their visits to Mevlâna Museum (Table 5). This
finding is valid for both domestic and foreign visitors of the museum.
According to those findings, some suggestions should be made as listed here. Firstly, it is
suggested that the expectations in the context of “attention and empathy” and “cultural
impression” should be taken into consideration in museum planning. Hence, it should also be
suggested museum managers may train the staff with regard to “attention and empathy”
dimension. Because of being important from the point of the visitors, museum managers need
to ensure the continuity of cultural impression dimension which includes the artifacts and the
atmosphere itself. Finally, the academicians who are enthusiastic in this subject should make
a detailed research focusing on “attention and empathy” and “cultural impression” dimensions
and their variables.
7. References
Barrio, M.J., Herrero, L.C. & Sanz, J.A. (2009). Measuring the Efficiency of Hertage
Institutions: A Case Study of a Regional System of Museums in Spain. Journal of Cultural
Heritage, 10, pp. 258-268.
Barnes, A. & Lynch, D.R. (2012). From Classroom to the Museum: Understanding Faculty-
Designed Assignments in an Academic Museum. Museum Management and Curatorship,
27(5), pp. 487-503.
Çelebi, C. (1997). Hazret-i Mevlana. Konya: T.C. Konya İl Müdürlüğü Yayını.
Dikici, E. & Sağır, A. (2012). Antalya‟da İnanç Turizminin Sosyolojik Çözümlemesi: Demre-
Myra Örneği. KMÜ Sosyal ve Ekonomik Araştırmalar Dergisi, 14(2), pp. 35-42.
Falk, J.H. & Dierkingi L.D. (1992). The Museum Experience. Washington D.C.:Whalesback
Books.
Fletcher, A. & Lee, M.j. (2012). Current Social Media Uses and Evaluations in American
Museums. Museum Management and Curatorship, 27(5), pp. 505-521.
Gartenhaus, A.R. (1997). Minds in Motion-Using Museums to Expand Creative Thinking (3rd
Ed.). USA: Caddo Gap Press.
64
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Grasskamp, W. (1981). Museumsgrunder und Museumssturmer - zur Sozialgeschichte des
Kunstmuseums. Munchen: C.H. Beck.
İlhan, A.Ç. (2009). Educational Studies in Turkish Museums. Procedia Social and Behavioral
Sciences, 1, pp. 342-346.
Kang, M. & Gretzel, U. (2012). Perceptions of Museum Podcast Tours: Effects of Consumer
Innovativeness, Internet Familiarity and Podcasting Affinity on Performance Expectancies.
Tourism Management Perspectives, 4, pp. 155-163.
Kuter, N. (2008). İnanç Turizmi ve Isparta-Yalvaç, Pisidia Antiocheia Antik Kenti. In
Proceedings of the ‘IV. Lisansüstü Turizm Öğrencileri Araştırma Kongresi’. Antalya, pp.517-531.
MacDonald, G.F. & Alsford, S. (1995). Museums and Theme Parks: Worlds in Collision?
Museum Management and Curatorship, 14(2), pp. 129–147.
Moscardo, G. (1996). Mindful Visitors: Heritage and Tourism. Annals of Tourism Research,
23(2), pp. 376-397.
Özgüç, N. (2003). Turizm Coğrafyası. İstanbul: Çantay Kitabevi.
Özkul, E., Demirer, D. & İpar, M.S. (2012). Edebiyat‟ın Pazarlama Aracı Olarak Turizm Amaçlı
Kullanımı Üzerine Bir Araştırma. In the Proceedings of „13. Ulusal Turizm Kongresi’. Antalya,
pp. 1-22.
Özönder, H. (2005). Dünden Bugüne Konya. Konya: Konya Büyükşehir Belediyesi Kültür
Yayınları, No: 67.
Sargın, S. (2006). Yalvaç‟ta İnanç Turizmi. Fırat Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 16(2), pp.
1-18.
Sezgin, M. (2008). Konya. In Aktaş, G. (eds.) Turizm Coğrafyası. Ankara: Detay Yayıncılık,
pp. 315-333.
Sheng, W.C. & Chen, M.C. (2012). A Study of Experience Expectations of Museum Visitors.
Tourism Management, 33, pp. 53-60.
Tapur, T. (2009). Konya İlinde Kültür ve İnanç Turizmi. Uluslararası Sosyal Araştırmalar
Dergisi, 2(9), pp. 473-492.
TDK - Türk Dil Kurumu. (2005). Türkçe Sözlük. Ankara: 4. Akşam Sanat Okulu Matbaası.
Tröndle, M., Wintzerith, S., Waspe, R. & Tschacher, W. (2012). A Museum for the Twenty-
First Century: The Influence of „Sociality‟ on Art Reception in Museum Space. Museum
Management and Curatorship, 27(5), pp.461-486.
Uralman, N.H. (2006). 21. Yüzyıla Girerken Bir Bilgi Kurumu olarak Müze. Bilgi Dünyası,
7(2), pp. 250-266.
Weil, (2000). Perspectives on Outcome Based Evaluation for Libraries and Museums.
http://www.imls.gov/assets/1/AssetManager/PerspectivesOBE.pdf,
accessed: 17.101.2013.
Yılmaz, İ. (2011). Müze Ziyaretçilerinin Hizmet Kalitesi Algılamaları: Göreme Açık Hava
Müzesi Örneği. Anatolia: Turizm Araştırmaları Dergisi, 22(2), pp. 183-193.
http://www.konhaber.com/yeni/haber-82855-KULTUR-SANAT-Bayramda-Mevlana-
Muzesine-ziyaretci-akini.html accessed: 5.11.2012.
http://www.kulturvarliklari.gov.tr/TR,43336/muze-istatistikleri.html, accessed: 5.11.2012.
65
A Proposal of A Route to Tours to the Ancient Age Oracle Centres of West
Anatolia
Vedat ACAR
Adnan Menderes University
Department of Tour Guiding,
Tourism and Hotel Management, Kuşadası / AYDIN
vedat.acar@adu.edu.tr
Gül ERBAY ASLITÜRK
Adnan Menderes University
Department of Tour Guiding,
Tourism and Hotel Management, Kuşadası / AYDIN
gerbay@adu.edu.tr
Özet
Günümüz insanının bile çok ilgisini çeken geleceği bilme, gelecek hakkında bilgi edinme
isteği, antik çağda günümüzdekinden çok daha fazla önem arz etmekteydi. Kentlerin
kuruluşunda, kentlerin sorunlarının çözümlenmesinde, kentlerle ve kişilerle ilgili önemli
kararların alınmasında ve olağanüstü olayların açıklanmasında Apollon kült merkezlerine
danışılmaktaydı. Apollon kâhinleri tarafından çeşitli şekillerde yapılan yorumlar, kimi zaman
bir krallığın yıkımına, kimi zaman da bir krallığın doğuşuna neden olabilmekteydi. Apollon
kült merkezleri, bu açıdan bakıldığında insanların yaşamlarını şekillendirmekle kalmayıp,
aynı zamanda onların hayatlarına yön veren önemli bir güce sahipti. Bu araştırmanın
kapsamında, Batı Anadolu‟da antik çağın önemli kehanet merkezlerinden olan Letoon, Patara,
Hierapolis, Alabanda, Telmissos, Didyma, Klaros kentleri kehanet merkezleri olmaları
açısından değerlendirilmiştir. Bu kehanet merkezlerinin kurulmalarını sağlayan kâhinler, bu
merkezlerin seçilmesinde dikkat edilen noktalar ve dönemin insanları tarafından bu kehanet
merkezlerinin ne şekilde ziyaret edildikleri ele alınarak, günümüz insanları tarafından bir
güzergâh dâhilinde bu kehanet merkezlerinin ziyaretini olanaklı hale getirme önerisi
amaçlanmaktadır.
Anahtar Kelimeler: Kehanet, Apollon Kültü, Kehanet Turu
Abstract
Desire to know the future, to get information about the future was much more important than
it is at the present time compared with the one in the ancient age. The Apollo cult centres
were consulted on founding the cities, solving the problems of the cities, taking important
decisions about cities and habitants and clarifying the extraordinary events. Interpretations
made by the oracles of Apollon in various ways might sometimes cause a kingdom to
demolish or a kingdom to rise. When considered the matter from this point of view, Apollo
cult centers used to have a significant power not only shaping the lives of people but
dominating the lives of them as well. Within the scope of the research, the cities of Letoon,
Patara, Hierapolis, Alabanda, Telmissos, Didyma, Claros, many of which were considered to
be important cult centres of Apollo in the ancient world, were evaluated with regards to being
of Oracle centres. Bringing a proposal of a visit to those oracles centres within the compass of
a route by today‟s people was aimed at taking into consideration of the oracles who had those
centres founded, the points when those centres were chosen and in what way, they were
visited by the people in that age.
Key words: Oracle, Apollo Cult, Tour of Prophecy
67
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
1. Introduction
Prophecy may be defined as “to foretell an event that will ocur, to notice future with a
perception or intuition beyond the five senses, to foresight”. Ciccero (106-43 B.C), a well
known politician stated in his book known as “The Nature of The Gods” that prophecy is
(Akoğlu, 2006: 96):
“the power or art or ability to foretell the things which will happen in the future was given
to none of the creatures but to humans by immortal Gods. The truth is that Gods do not only
care and protect the human race as a whole but also each of individuals singly. By frequently
coming in sight in person, Gods themselves reveal the care they take of both society and each
of individuals one by one. This care is also understood from the signs, correlated with the
events to happen in the future, which are shown sometimes in their dreams and sometimes
when they are awake. Moreover, we are stimulated by a lot of other signs causing to form the
art of divinatio1by a lot of indications, by watching and using a long time of many visceral
organs of sacrifices. For this reason, there is nobody among great people who aren‟t inspired
by the divinatio somehow!”
It may be inferred from Ciccero‟s words that oracles are individuals equipped with special
abilities. We know very little knowledge about which tactics oracles used while they were
prophesying, however, there are some assertions suggested; one of those is the pareidolia
effect of the gases and the other one is the dream. It was believed that the dreams were sent
out by the Gods in the Roman Period just like in the Ancient Age (Akoğlu, 2006: 118).
Apollo, the son of Zeus and Leto, may probably have been the most significant God in the
Ancient Age Greek World and a great number of temples were built in his honor. The
officials serving in his temples had special places in the hearts of the society.
Why individuals used to consult the prophecy hoping for solutions for their problems may
be understood that the prophecy itself was a phenomenon not only correlated with the future
but also affecting the life of individuals at the present time. “Future” is one of the most
wondered matters at the present time. There are some reasons why people want to know the
things happening in the future. Desire to be prepared for disasters, desire to take advantage of
the matters the other people don‟t know how to act, desire to keep away from disappointments
and desire to know whether they will achieve their goals or not may be the reasons why
people want to get knowledge about the future. From this point of view, a question came up
as follows: “Could the curiosity of today‟s people be supported or satisfied by making an
expedition to Ancient Age Oracle Centers?” The main aim of this research is to determine the
oracles, myths and annals which occured in the light of the Oracle Centers and to make a
route appropriate for this theme in the Ancient Age West Anatolia. Within the scope of the
research, the literature of archaelogy and mythology became the starting point of the cities
related to the cult of Apollo. In the light of the data acquired, it may be said that a lot of
temples were built in honor of Apollo, that a lot of oracles‟ names were mentioned, that
Apollo played a crucial role in such important events as Trojan War, the destruction of Sardis
and establishment of Smyrna. The cities discussed are Letoon, Patara, Hierapolis, Alabanda,
Telmissos, Didyma and Claros respectively. Oracles and prophecies were mentioned by
scanning the Myths about those cities and those information were supported by archaeology.
Within this framework, it was seen that Akurgal (1988) evaluated Letoon in terms of
Archaeology whereas Grimal (2007) and Des Courtils (2003) informed about the myths about
that city. Herodotus (1920), Akurgal (1988), Grimal (2007), Gürdal (2007) and Işık (2008)
are the authors who mentioned the ancient city of Patara and myths of prophecy. Sevin
1
Prophecy
68
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
(2001), D‟Andria (2004), Negri and Leucci (2006), Gürdal (2007), Johnston (2008) are the
authors who mentioned about Hierapolis. Vitrivius (1914), Herodotus (1920), Strabo (1960)
and Bağdatlı (2006) may be considered to be the authors mentioning Alabanda in their works.
Herodotus (1920), Graves (1960), Grimal (2007) Gürdal (2007) handled the myths of
Telmissos. Fontenrose (1988), Erhat (1996), Kennedy (1998), Grimal (2007), Gürdal (2007)
and Eren (2008) are such writers who touched the prophecy of Didyma. When Claros is taken
into consideration, while Şahin (1998) studied in terms of Archaeology, Erhat (1996),
Kennedy (1998), March (2001), Strabo (1960), Schwab (2004), Grimal (2007) and Johnston
(2008) wrote about the myths of prophecy of the city.
On the other hand, although the region of Troas and Cnidos have remarkable amount of
data with respect to the myths, they have been excluded from the tour program on account of
being located in certain spots of destination halting the tour program. In the last chapter, a
three days and two nights‟ tour to Letoon, Patara, Hierapolis, Alabanda, Telmissos, Didyma
and Claros has been programmed and an available schedule has also been organized.
2. Oracles in the Ancient Age West Anatolia
A lot of oracles lived in the ancient age West Anatolia. It is possible to encounter a lot of
prophecies and oracles from the begining to the ending of the Trojan War. When the son of
Thetis was nine years old, Calchas, one of those oracles prophesied that unless the son of
Thetis was engaged in the Trojan War, the war wouldn‟t be won by Achaians and on account
of that, he advised Thetis to hide her son among the daughters of the king of Skyros. It was
also Calchas who prophesied that the wind preventing the fleet of Achaians from setting sail
for Troy was because of Agamennon who angered Artemis and the only way to soothe
Artemis was the sacrifice of Iphigenia, daughter of Agamennon to the Goddess. One of the
prophecies Calchas foretold, was that unless the daughter of Cyrises was given back to her
father, the rage of Apollo wouldn‟t cool down. Calchas also prophesied that Troy would be
captured in the tenth year of the war. The other prophecy Calchas foretold just after Achilleus
had died was that unless the arch of Herakles wasn‟t found, Troy wouldn‟t be captured and
that the only person knowing which circumstances the city would be conquered was Helenos,
one of the sons of Priam and Having dreamt, He also advised Achaians to make a wooden
horse as well (Grimal, 2007; Morford and Lenardo, 2003: 444, 453, 455; Rose, 2005: 97, 198;
Kennedy, 1998: 5, 18, 49, 61, 73, ; Berens, 2007: 61, 189, 190, 192, 198).
The other significant oracle in the Ancient Age West Anatolia was Aisakos. Aisakos
having the ability to interpret dreams was the son of Priamos and Arisbe. When Hekabe
dreamt that she bore a blazing torch, she consulted to Aisakos in order to interpret her dream.
After that, Aisakos advised them to kill the infant as soon as he was born because of the fact
that the infant would cause the city to demolish. Soon afterwards he had interpreted the dream
of Hecabe, his wife passed away on account of being bited by a snake. As soon as he saw his
wife‟s dead body, he did away with himself (Grimal, 2007: 30).
Aisakos wasn‟t the only child of Priamos having the ability to prophesy. Cassandra and
Helenos, twins of Priamos and Hecabe had the ability to soothsay as well. When they were
born, a ceremony was conducted in the Tymbra Apollo Temple. Having finished the
ceremony, the twins were forgotten in the temple. On the following day, the twins were given
the ability to prophesy. Before Paris set sail for Greece, Helenos prophesied all the disasters
that voyage would bring about. After Paris had died, Priam married Helena to Deiphobos.
Helenos went to Mount Ida on acount of his father‟s not marrying him to Helena. When
Calchas mentioned the only person knowing how to conquer Troy was Helenos, Odyseus
found Helenos and persuaded to tell how to capture the city. Helenos took his revenge on
69
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
telling Odyseus that there were three conditions to capture the city (Erhat, 1996: 133, 166,
246; Nardo, 2002: 41, 54, Rose, 2005; Coleman, 2007: 466, 825).
Besides Helenos, his sister was also an oracle. In some sources, Cassandra got the ability
to prophesy after she stayed the night in the Tymbra Apollo Temple just as her brother. But in
some sources, it is stated that Apollo gave Cassandra the ability to prophesy. According to the
first legend, Cassandra and Helenos were forgotten in the Tymbra Apollo Temple after the
ceremony had been conducted in honour of their birth. When Priam and Hecabe came to the
temple the following day, they found their infants being asleep and two snakes by the side of
them. As soon as the snakes realized the people coming in the temple, they withdrew to
sacred laurels. After the snakes had mundified the infants, they got the ability to prophesy.
According to the other legend, Apollo fell in love with the daughter of Priam, Cassandra and
wanted to lie with her. Cassandra told him that she would accept his proposal on condition
that he gave her the ability to prophesy. Apollo taught her how to prophesy completely,
however, Cassandra broke her promise and didn‟t want to lie with Apollo. On account of that,
Apollo spitted at her mouth and punished her by ordaining that she would always tell the
truthful prophecies but that nobody would believe her (Nardo, 2002: 26). It was Cassandra
who prophesied that when Paris came to Troy, he would spell troubles to the city and should
be killed immediately. When Hector was carried away by Achilleus, Priam went to the
military quarters of Achaian to get Hector back. Cassandra was the first person who foretold
that Priam would come back safe and sound. Having seen the wooden horse, she claimed that
there were Achaian soldiers inside the wooden horse and it shouldn‟t be let in the city. It was
also Cassandra given to Agamennon as a spoil of war after Troy had been occupied and
although she had foreseen both she and Agamennon would be killed by Clytaimestra and her
lover, she didn‟t clam up (Erhat, 1996; 105, 164; March, 2001: 188, 215, 769, 784).
One of the most significant oracles in The Ancient Age being the son of Eueres and
Chariclo, one of the Nympha, was Tiresias. There are different rumours about getting the
ability to prophesy. Some mention that on account of seeing Athena completely unclothed,
Tiresias was punished by being made blind by the Goddess and afterwards, she made up for
giving him the ability to prophesy (Mair and Mair 1969: 119; Grimal, 2007: 746; Coleman,
2007: 107; Daly, 2009: 141; Kennedy, 1998: 56). However, according to another legend, as
Tiresias was wandering around the Mounth of Cyllene or Mounth of Chitharion, he saw two
snakes mating. Some say that Tiresias killed the female one, on the other hand some say that
he wounded both of them.That intervention resulted in his turning into a woman. Seven years
later, while he was wandering around the same place, he saw once again two snakes mating.
He acted just as he had done seven years ago. This time he turned back into a man. What
Tiresias had come across popularized him. One day, while Zeus and Hera was argueing on
the matter which sexes enjoyed love more, Tiresias came to their minds by virtue of his
having been both a man and a woman. They asked Tiresias whether man or woman enjoyed
love more. Tiresias answered:“If the parts of love- pleasure be counted as ten, Thrice three
go to women, one only to men (Graves, 1960: 219). As soon as Hera heard what Tiresias had
said, she blinded him. To make up for that deed, Zeus gave the ability to prophesy and
bestowed favors on living an extraordinarily long life (Grimal, 2007: 747; Coleman, 2007:
471; Anonym, 2009, 918, 1077). Tiresias took part in a series of prophecies. It was Tiresias
who revealed sins of Oedipus and when Eteocles consulted him in the course of the campaign
of Seven Champions, he prophesied that Thebans would be victorious only if a prince of royal
house freely as a sacrifice to Ares and that city of Thebans would be overrun and the only one
of the Seven Champions would stay alive for that reason, they should leave the city at
a nighttime (Graves, 1960: 219, 221, 225, 261; Grimal, 2007: 746, 747). On account of the
oppression of Protesilaus to reveal them the location of Achilleus, Tiresias prophesied that
70
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Achilleus was on the island of Lycomedes, wearing women‟s clothing (Roman and Roman,
2010: 2). Just After the invasion of Theban by Epigons, Tiresias migrated from the city with
other locals. One morning, they stopped by the side of a spring water known as Telphoussa.
He passed away as soon as he drank water. According to another legend, he passed away
while he was sent to Delphi as a captive or while he was going to Colophon with his daughter,
Manto (Grimal, 2007: 747; Coleman, 2007: 995).
In the Ancient Age West Anatolia, there were prophetesses like Cassandra. Manto was
one of those prophetesses. After the invasion of Thebans by Epigons, Manto was taken
captive and dedicated to Apollo as a sacrifice in Delphi. Manto became skilled during the stay
in Delphi (March, 2001: 290, 475; Grimal, 2007: 459). After a while, Manto came to the city
situated in the Asia Minor2. She was captured by Cretans who were making war with the local
Carians and Rakius, the leader of Cretans, married Manto and she bore him a son, Mopsus
(March, 2001: 475; Grimal, 2007: 459; Coleman, 2007: 668). When Mopsus grew up, he
became the oracle of Apollo in Claros (see Claros).
The other prophetess in the Ancient Age was Herophile. Herophile one of the
prophetesses known as Sibylle were mentioned in a lot of places (Rose, 2005: 114). Herophile
was the daughter of a Nympha living in Troas3 and Theodoros, a sheepherd in the Mounth
Ida. Her first prophecy was that city of Troy would be tolled the death knell on account of
a woman coming from Spartan (March, 2001: 700; Rose, 2005: 114; Grimal, 2007: 278, 713)
and she interpretted the dream of Hecabe and advised her to kill the infant as soon as it was
born (Graves, 1960, 363). Herophile wandered around the world and came to Claros, Samos,
Delos and Delphi. When she prophesied, she stepped up onto a stone which she carried along
with her (Grimal, 2007: 278).
3. Prophecy of Apollo in the Ancient Age West Anatolia
2.1. Letoon
Letoon being a wealthy region in terms of spring waters even in ancient ages, is a a
sanctuary place situating four kilometers from Xantos and in the west coast of Xantos River
(Akurgal, 1988: 489). The name of Letoon stems from Leto, the mother of Apollo and
Artemis and the daughter of Titan Koius and Titan Phoibe. According to the legend, Having
learnt Leto‟s being pregnant, Hera did everything in order to prevent that birth. No pieces of
land accepted Leto. Leto came to Island of Delos relentlessly and had her twins there.
Afterwards, on account of being afraid of Hera, Leto came to Lykia. While she was resting
near a water spring in order to wash her twins, sheepherds prevented Leto‟s taking the water
from the spring. Losing her temper on account of the sheepherds‟ attitudes towards her, Leto
transformed them into frogs. A Cult was founded at that place where that miraculous incident
had happened (Des Courtils, 2003: 130; Grimal, 2007: 430).
Although the cult of Apollo doesn‟t predominate in the sanctuary place of Letoon, it is
important in terms of being worshipped with Leto and Artemis in the same sanctuary place.
At this place, there is just an evidence connected with Apollo is a mosaic pavement, on the
cella of one of the temples, dating back to the second century B.C. It is remarkable that there
are three figures reflecting Apollo‟s features. One of them is a motif situated on the right side
of the plaque and decorated with lyra depicting artistic aspect of Apollo. On the left side of
the plaque, arrow and quiver, being the other features of Apollo, are depicted. This brings to
mind the quality of “archer god” of Apollo. Finally, there is a motif depicting of the Sun, the
other symbol of Apollo, situated in the middle of the plaque (Des Courtils, 2003: 142, 143).
2
Anatolia
3
The whole land of Çanakkale, a region comprising Biga Peninsula
71
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
2.2. Patara
Ancient city of Patara is situated in a region, known as Gelemiş at the present time, eleven
kilometers west of Xantos. Patara was among the coastal towns of Lykia in the Ancient Age
(Akurgal, 1988: 490; Gürdal, 2007: 133). Like other cities associated with Apollo, there is a
legendary story of Patara. According to the legend, Apollo and a nympha called as Lykia had
a child known as Ikadius. The name of Lykia was given to the country where he was born.
When he grew up, he came to Patara and founded the Oracle there. Afterwards, He decided to
go to İtaly; however, his ship went down without arriving there. A dolphin brought him to
mountainside of Parnassus. When Ikadius arrived in Parnassus, he founded a city called as
Delphi in memory of the dolphin rescuing him (Grimal, 2007: 323).
Contrary to Letoon, the cult of Apollo comes into prominence in Patara. The original data
is reached from Herodotus stating that Prophetesses, associated with Apollo, were confined to
the temple during the night with the purpose of getting in contact with the God. At the same
time, Herodotus also mentioned that those Prophetesses couldn‟t be reached (Herodotus,
1920: 227). It might probably be stemmed from serving of the temple in winter months. Işık
(2008: 346) has mentioned that Kokarsu believed to heal wounds by local people and being
two kilometers away from Patara is the same water spring which healed the wounds of
Telephus in accordance with the suggestion of Oracle of Apollo. According to what Gürdal
(2007) has cited by Pausanias, Patara was also a city where Telephus gave a bronze pot made
by Hephaistus, as a gift to Apollo. Gürdal (2007) has also stated that Apollo was known as
Patroos in the region and that oracle center gained such a reputation and worthiness to
compete with Dephi and Delos in the Roman Age.
2.3. Hierapolis
According to Sevin (2001: 203), Hierapolis was founded by Seleucus and in 190 B.C. it
was captured by Eumenes the second, the king of Pergamon and ıt was named as “Hiera” or
“Hiero”, legendary founder of Pergamon. According to a research in 1960‟s, a large marble
building correlated with Apollo known as “Plutonion” which was situated on the top of
monumental stairs and near underground chasm was revealed (Negri and Leucci, 2006). On
account of an epidemic illness in the Ancient Age, there were five cities mentioned in the
sources. Those were thought to be Pergamon, Hierapolis, Caesarea Trokketa, Callipolis and
most probably Sardis. In order to tackle that epidemic, on the one hand, The God Apollo
advised Pergamon to constitute four choirs consisting of young men so as to sing hymns to
Zeus, Dionysus, Athena and Asclepius and make sacrifices. On the other hand, he said to
inhabitants of Hierapolis that the Earth was angry owing to the death of Python, and advised
them to make sacrifices to her, to Aether4 and the other gods, told them to consecrate statues
of Apollo the Archer averting plagues and to send choirs of boys and girls to sing in his
sanctuary at Claros (Johnston, 2008: 80).
According to what Gürdal (2007: 109) cited by D‟Andria (2003: 136), the Sanctuary of
Apollo is situated in the middle of Hierapolis, in other words in the heart of the city and is
surrounded by a temenos wall which was accompanied by porches built with Doric order. The
sanctuary is situated within the boundaries of Temenos5 and there are sacred cave known as
Plutonion6, building of prophecy and a monumental fountain situating on opposite side of the
temple in the sanctuary. Strabo mentioned that Plutonion as (Strabo, 1960: 187):
4
One of the Gods in the Greek Mythology, Air God of the Upper Atmosphere.
5
A sacred place surrounding the temple.
6
The caves which were believed to be the entrances to the hell in the Roman Period.
72
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
“First, near the Mesogis, opposite Laodiceia, to Hierapolis, where are the hot springs and
the Plutonium, both of which have something marvellous about them; for the water of the
springs so easily congeals and changes into stone that people conduct streams of it through
ditches and thus make stone fences consisting of single stones, while the Plutonium, below a
small brow of the mountainous country that lies above it, it is an opening of only moderate
size, large enough to admit a man, but it reaces a considerable depth, and it is enclosed by a
quadrilateral handrail, about half a plethrum7 in circumference, and this space is full of a
vapour so misty and dense that one can scarcely see the ground. Now to those who approach
the handrail anywhere round the enclosure the air is harmless, since the outside is free from
that vapour in calm weather, for the vapour then stays inside the enclosure, but any animal
that passes inside meets instant death.”
And he also mentioned (Strabo, 1960: 187):
“But the Galli8, who are eunuchs, pass inside the such impunity that they even approach
the opening, bend over it, and descend into it to a certain depth though they hold their breath
as much as they can.”
D‟Andria (2004: 149) verified those data which Strabo had mentioned in the reports of
excavation by saying that they came across small birds exposed to the gas evolution in front
of the Plutonion in some mornings. Besides D‟Andria (2004), Negri and Leucci (2006) also
stated about the Plutonion that:
“The Plutonion is a chamber wide enough for a person to enter and very deep,
broadening as one descends. There is a hole 9 m in diameter surrounded by a fence, which is
covered by a thich mist, making it impossible to see inside. The air outside the fence is quite
clear, and when no wind is blowing there is no danger in approaching it, but any living
creature that enters the whole dies instantly.”
In Hierapolis, the process of prophecy was a bit different by comparison with Didyma or
Claros. First of all, as we understand from what Gürdal (2007: 110) cited by D‟Andria (2003:
223-231) that the people wanting to consult the prophecy of Hierapolis, took 24 tickets on
which each of the letters of Greek Alphabet were written. After that, they chose one of them
and got an answer by looking the inscription on which there was a response to each one of all
the letters.
2.4. Alabanda
Alabanda, one of the cities of Caria Reigon in the Ancient Age, is situated four kilometers
away from west of river of Marsyas (Akurgal, 1988:475). Although the name of Alabanda
was sometimes mentioned in the sources dating back to the ancient ages, continuity
informations about the history of Alabanda in the sources weren‟t observed. The very first
data about Alabanda date back to the Period of Hittites. According to what Bağdatlı (2006)
has cited by the study on the historical geography of the Hittite Empire of Gargstang and
Gurney, although there hasn‟t been found prof positive, they mentioned that while launching
an expedition to a city known as Ahhiyawa, the name of one of the sites that Mursilis the
second passed, was Waliwanda and that may most probably be Alabanda. Strabo, one of the
most notable authors in the ancient age, mentioned the location of the city and how a
prosperous city it was (Strabo, 1960: 299):
“Alabanda is also situated at the foot of hills, two hills that are joined together in such a
way that they present the appearance of an ass laden with panniers. And indeed Apollonius
7
Unit of measure in Ancient Greece, a plethrum is equivalent to 30.83 meters.
8
Priests of Cybele
73
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Malacus, in ridiculing the city both in regard to this and in regard to the large number of
scorpions there, said that it was an "ass laden with panniers of scorpions." Both this city and
Mylasa are full of these creatures, and so is the whole of the mountainous country between
them. Alabanda is a city of people who live in luxury and debauchery, containing many girls
who play the harp. Alabandians worthy of mention are two orators, brothers, I mean
Menecles, whom I mentioned a little above, and Hierocles, and also Apollonius and Molon,
who changed their abode to Rodes”
The other Information about Alabanda is obtained from Herodotus. He stated that there
was Aridolis, the tyran of Alabanda, among the prisoners whom Persians had captured during
the naval warfare between Greek and Persian near Euboi in 480 B.C. (Herodotus, 7, 195)9.
On the other hand, the first information about the Temple of Apollo in Alabanda is
obtained from “The Ten Books on Architecture” which was written by Vitrivius. Vitrivius
mentioned The Temple of Apollo in Alabanda in the chapter “Classification of Temples” of
his book while he was defining the types of temples: “The pseudodipteral is so constructed
that in front and in th rear there are in each case eight columns, with fifteen on each side,
including th corner columns. The walls of teh cella in front and in the rear should be directly
over against the four middle columns. Thus there will be a space, the width of two
intercolumniations plud the thickness of the lower diameter of a column, all round between
the walls and the rows of columns on the outside. There is no example of this in Rome, but at
magneisa there is the temple of Diana by Hermogenes, and that of Apollon at Alabanda by
Mnesthes” (Vitrivius, 1914: 78).
In addition to what Vitrivius mentioned, it may be said that the excavations of Ethem Bey
at the beginning of the twentieth century, formed the basis of Isotimos Temple of Apollo in
Alabanda (Bağdatlı, 2001: 13). It has been stated that the temple, was dedicated to Apollo
Isotimos, to defied Augustus and to public as a result of the inscription, unearthed as a result
of the excavations. It is possible that the inscription is the only evidence confirming what
ancient age writers mentioned about the past of the city. According to what Bağdatlı (2006)
cited by Laumonier (1958), the name of “Ismotimos” was used in the meaning of “equality to
Zeus Khrysaoreus” (Bağdatlı, 2006).
2.5. Telmissos
Telmissos, as being one of the Lelegian cities that Mauosoles connected to Halicarnassus,
is located 10 km away from Halicarnassus (Gürdal 2007: 19). Apollon Telmissos was
considered to be the prime god of the city Telmissos. In a battle against the Persian King
Cyros, on realizing the weakness of his forces, the Lydia King Croesus took the decision to
withdraw from the region to Sardis. After having spent the winter in Sardis, he aimed at going
to war against the Persian by providing his forces with some help and support from the nearby
kingdoms (the Egyptian, the Babylonian, the Lacedaemonian) in spring again. But Croesus
never happened to think of the possibility that the Persian King Cyros might approach Sardis.
In the meantime that Croesus turned up Sardes,snakes started to raid climbing up the external
walls of the city.When the snakes appeared, horses acted as if they had been determined not to
leave the pastures that they were accustomed to and ate up all the snakes at one stretch.
Telmissos sent a group of envoys to his interpreter so that he could interprete that miracle.
The envoys were not able to convey the information that they had got from the interpreter of
Telmissos to Croesus because Croesus had already been taken prisoner before they turned up
Sardes. The Monk of Telmissos had foretold them that Croesus should be prepared for an
attack on his country and when that attack was performed, it would make all the inhabitants in
9
The History of Herodotus, parallel English/Greek, tr. G. C. Macaulay, [1890], at sacred-texts.com
74
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
the city obey and the snakes were the children of the Earth but the horses were the enemies or
foreign bodies. But when that information was about to be conveyed to Croesus, the Sardis
city had already been invaded and Croesus had been prisoned (Herodotus, 1973: 78-80).
Grimal (2007: 206) mentiones about two Hyperboreans called Galeotes and Telmessos related
to the foundation of the oracle of Telmissos. Galeotos was the son of Themista, the daughter
of the Hyperborean King Zabios and Apollon.When Galeotes and Telmessos went to the
oracle of Dodona to consult him, he advised them that one was supposed to walk towards the
East while the other one was heading for the west until an eagle appeared to snatched the
sacrifical flesh away on the course of votive offerings.And told them to found an altar at the
scene of the event. Galeotes went to Sicily and Telmessos arrived in Caria. When Midas, the
King of Phrygia trooped in the Asia Minor directed by the Brigian, Gordios the childless King
of Phrigia adopted him. One day, as he was plowing his field, he was surprised to withness
when a magnificent eagle flew down and perched on the yoke of his ox cart remaining there
all day long. Upon that, he went to Telmissos of Phrigia where a highly respected priest used
to live. When Gordios arrived at the very doorway of the city, an oracle welcomed him and
she noticed the eagle still perching on the yoke of the ox cart. There she insisted him on
sacrificing to the god Zeus immediately. She told Gordios „ Let me accompany you, the
peasant „ and warned him „ Make sure you have chosen the right sacrifice „ Then Gordios
replied her „ of course „ and asked her „You are a wise and thoughtful woman,will you marry
me?‟ „As soon as the sacrifice has been offered‟ the woman replied him. The King of Phrigia
died without any reason and an oracle called out to the Phrigian telling them that the new
king and his bride were about to approach the city on the ox cart. When Gordios arrived at the
agora of Telmissos on his ox cart, he was proclaimed king. After his death, Midas took his
position (Graves 1960: 167). In a text dated back to the end of 3 BC, it is stated that Apollon
Telmissos, the oracle and the priest founded a kind of sect called as „thiasos‟, and all the
members of the families pertained their whole power to keep the existence of that sect and for
the sake of their belief, they spent money in order to make sacrifice and buy land for the god
(Gürdal 2007: 21).
2.6. Didyma
The foundation of Apollo oracle in Didyma is connected to a legend. As Fontenrose
(1988: 118-119) narrated by Connon and Varro, a Delphi citizen whose name was Democles
had a son called Smikros. Having listened to what a soothsayer told him, he came to Miletos
with his son. After they had had their meal, he went on his destination but leaving Smikros on
the coast behind. A goatherd found the boy and took him to his father Eritharses. Eritharses
liked him as much as he liked his son. One day Smikros and Eritharses‟ son caught a swan
while they were pasturing the goats and got it to dress up. Then they began arguing about who
would give that swan to Eritharses. When they finally got tired of arguing and pulled up the
cloth off the swan and made it undressed, they noticed that they made a woman purely naked
who was the goddess of the Leukothean and then she asked them to do her the honour of
helding a competition. Then Smikros got married to a daughter of a distinguished person from
Miletos. When she became pregnant,she had a dream about the sun descenting from the
sky,visiting every corner of her body and then leaving her out through her belly.When the
soothsayers were consulted they stated that it was a blessed sign. She called the baby
Bragkhos by birth. After he had grown up, Apollo saw him one day while he was pasturing
his herd and was very much fond of him. Later on Bragkhus built an alter to Apollo and
founded a center of oracle in Didyma located in the South of Miletos (Grimal 2007: 122). Just
the opposite of Grimal (2007) and Erhat (1996), it is written in some sources that the founder
of the oracle of Apollo was Machaereus, the ancester of the Bragkhos, he who became
infamous for being the murderer of Neoptelemos (Kennedy, 1998: 197). No matter how the
75
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
legend ended ,whatever a family or a clan or an institution it was,it was known that the
Branchiadian conducted all the acts of worship in the heart of the oracle and had an effective
way of ruling as to have that holly place called by their reputation (Fontenrose, 1988; Eren,
2008). In the center of worship, certain rituels of sacrifice would be carried out and the
animals to be sacrificed were of bulls, sheepand goats. As for Seleucos Nikator and
Antiochus, in 288 BC, it was documented in the inscriptions that he had sent 1000 sheep and
12 bulls as votive offerings (Gürdal, 2007: 45 cited by Rehm, 1958). Among the things that
had been vowed most for Apollon Didymeus, there were the phiales to come across. The rich
used to offer golden phialaies. Fontenrose (1988: 66) states that there found the candles,
golden censers and cups in various types, hole digging tools, earthenware pitchers, tea pots,
baskets and golden crowns in the inscriptions. Among the people who had made those
offerings, Antiochus who had sent him 318 drahmas, a couple of palimpotas of two obels was
considered to be as one of them (Fontenrose, 1988: 66). Fontenrose (1988: 68-69) also
mentiones that a charitable called Eudemos had had a school built near the temple and
sacrificed an ox to Didymeia every four year. On those days, anyone was possible to be
positioned as a soothsayer for several times. Claudias Damas was eighty-one when he was
promoted for that mission forth he second time and probably in the 1st century, a poseidonios
man was another to be promoted for the third time. At the same time, there were no
limitations of age for being an oracle. When he was honoured with that position, Claudias
Damas was eighty-one whereas Markus Ulpius Flavianus Phileas was only twenty-three when
he undertook the position of his father as an oracle. Similar to Phileas, most of the oracles
used to be either the children or the grandchildren of the oracles. But in Miletos, the art of
prophecy was not limited to any certain families, any male citizen could be promoted to that
position. It was put forward in the inscriptions that, after 334 BC, as it happened in Dephoi, a
woman who had been inspired by Apollon conveyed his quotes to the people who would
consult (Fontenrose, 1988: 55). In Apollon Didymeus several feasts used to be celebrated,
among those the most significant ones were the Didymeia feasts. During the feasts starting
with certain rituels of sacrifice, various music contests and sports competitions used to be
organized and for those especially related to both theatre and music, the Miletos theatre was
used (Fountenrose, 1988: 71).
2.7. Claros
Sacred place of Claros is 13 km away from the southeast of Colophon/ Degirmendere and
2 km away from North of Notion (Şahin, 1998: 17). The importances of Claros may probably
resulted from having been one of the most notable oracle centers of that age. The date
correlated with the cult of Apollo goes back to the period of Mycenae 13th Century B.C. and
12th Century B.C. According to a legend, a group of Cretans came to Colophon and defeated
the local Carians and captured Colophon under the leadership of Rhacius. After a bit later of
the colonization of Mycenaean, the region confronted another flow of migrants coming from
Theban. However, Cretans didn‟t let them come in the city. Among that flow of migrants,
there was a woman known as Manto, the daughter of Tiresias and a prophetess of Apollo.
Rhacius, the leader of Cretans fell in love with Manto at first sight (Şahin, 1998: 19). That
legend was told differently in some sources. Kennedy (1998) and Grimal (2007) mentioned
that when Thebai was besieged, Tiresias prophesied that the city would be invaded, so he
advised the local Thebans to leave the city at a nighttime and that he also set off with the
other flow migrants but he died as soon as he drank some water by the side of the water
spring known as Telphoussa. They also mentioned that before they captured Thebai, Epigons
had decided to sacrifice the most beautiful woman they would take captive for this reason,
Manto, the daughter of Tiresias, was taken captive and then she was sacrificed to the God,
Apollo. On account of living in the Temple of Apollo in Delphi through long ages, Manto
76
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
became skilled in prophesying. Grimal (2007) told that Manto was sent to Anatolia by Apollo
and she got married with Rhacius, one of Cretans. According to what Şahin (1998: 20) cited
by Apollonius “Manto the daughter of Tiresias was sent to Delphi among the spoils of war in
order to sacrifice to the God. When se was getting out of the temple, she ran across Raikus,
the son of Lebes, a Mycanean. Raikus got married with Manto and he brought away her to
Colophon. When Manto came to Colophon, she broke into tears on account of losing her
motherland. She founded a temple in honour of Apollo. By virtue of the tears of Manto, a
spring water came about in Claros. As regards to Raikus, the reason why he was given that
name was that he was dressed badly and he was poor”. On the other hand, Erhat (1996: 199)
mentioned that Manto came to Claros by herself and that she was taken captive by pirates and
got married to Rhocius, the leader of them and that bore him Mopsus. In spite of the fact that
the legend was told differently, Manto came to Colophon and bore a child known as Mopsus
and founded the cult of Apollo in Claros. Mopsus, the son of Manto became a skilled oracle
in Claros.
After the army of Achaean had devastated Troy, they came together in order to set sail for
their homeland. However, what Aias the Lesser hailing from Locris had done to Cassandra,
the daughter of Priam, brought down Athena‟s vengeance. When Troy was conquered by
Achaean forces, Cassandra took refuge in the Temple of Athena. Aias dragged Cassandra
from the local altar of Athena and raped her. Achaeans wanted to lapidate him by virtue of his
insolence but he saved his life by skipping out to the Temple of Athena and taking shelter by
the atlar of Athena. Not only Aias but also all the other Achaean fleets paid the penalty for
that insolence by being exposed to storm (March, 2001: 70; Nardo, 2002: 16; Schwab, 2004:
609-610; Coleman, 2007: 41). A dispute started between Menelaus and Agamennon whether
they should set sail for their homeland or stay on the shore after they all had seen the rage of
Athena. All the fleet of Achaean were somehow exposed to the rage of Athena during their
voyages except for Amphilochus, Calchas, Leontes, Podalirius and Polypotes who left their
vessels behind on the shore of Illıum10 and came to Colophon by land. Calchas had known the
prophecy that when he came across an oracle, sager than him, he would pass away. When
they arrived at Colophon, they were hosted by Mopsus, the son of Manto, one of prophetesses
of Apollo and a debate over foretelling the future between Calchas and Mopsus began.
Apollodorus mentioned that event as follows: “A wild fig-tree grew on the spot, and when
Calchas asked, „How many figs does it bear?‟ Mopsus answered, „Ten thousand, and a
bushel, an one fig over‟ and they were found to be so. And when Mopsus asked Calchas
concerning a pregnan sow, „How many pigs has she in her womb, and when will she farrow?‟
Calchas answered, „Eight‟. But Mopsus smiled and said, „The divination of Calchas is the
reverse of exact; but I, as a son of Apollo and Manto, am extremely rich in the sharp sight
which comes of exact divination, and I divine that the number of pigs in the womb is not eight,
as Calchas says, but nine, and that they are all male and will be farrowed without fail
tomorrow at the sixth hour” When the things Mopsus had said turned out so, Calchas died of
grief and he was buried at Notium (Apollodorus, 1921: 245). Hesiod told the story a bit
different from Apollodorus. According to what Strabo cited by Hesiod (Strabo, 1960: 233-
235): “„I am amazed in my heart at all these figs on this wild fig tree, small though it is; can
you tell me the number?‟ And Calchas makes Mopsus reply: „They are ten thousand in
number, and their measure is a medimnus11; but there is one over, which you cannot put in
the measure.”
Oracle Center of Claros, played a significant role in establishment of New Symrna. When
Alexander the Great was sleeping under a tree on the Pagos Hill, he saw Nemesis in his
10
One of the names of Troy in latin
11
About a bushel and a half (About 54 kg)
77
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
dream. She told him to found the new city there and make the habitants move to there. As
soon as he woke up, he went to Claros in order to make his dream interpret. Oracle of Apollo
told him: “Habitants living in Pagos, off side of Sacred Stream of Meles would become happy
threefold or fourfold”. So, the new city was founded on Pagos Hill on account of that
prophecy (Şahin, 1998: 23).
Prophecy in Claros began right after the past sun down under the torchlights. A Ciereus12,
a prophetes13, a thespioidos14 a graphylochos15 and a kleidophoros or kleidouchos16 served in
the temple. The man carrying the key of the temple had no dealing with the prophecy and the
oracles transmitting the order of God, put into words those prophecies with hexametron
prosody17. Some officials were chosen for annually like prophetes, but some like thespiodos
took charge in the temple for lifelong. Although function of prophecy was undertaken by
mostly women, sometimes respectively by women or men in the other Oracle Centers that
function was carried out by only men in the Oracle centers of Apollo Claros, Apollo Ptoion
and Apollo Koropaios (Şahin, 1998: 26).
During the Imperial Period, people consulting the Oracle Center of Claros inscribed the
names of themselves, the cities from which they came, the dates they visited and the officials
taking care of them during their visit on the external walls, stairs and columns. From this
material, it may be said that three of the officials played important role in the process of
prophecy. First of them was the prophetes serving a year long period. The others were a priest
and a thespioidos each of whom held office for a longer period. Some scholars state that the
prophetes drank the water from the sacred spring and afterwards the thespioidos put what
prophetes said into verse. On the other hand, some suggest that the one drinking the water
from the sacred spring was the thespioidos and that the other putting into the verses was the
prophetes. Whoever it was drinking the water from the sacred spring, he was most probably
the only official admitted to the underground cave During the Imperial Period, people visiting
Claros were patients coming from the Asia Minor rather than from Hellas18(Johnston, 2008:
77-78). Prophecy in Claros began right after the past sun down under the torchlights. People
coming from all over the world in order to solve their problems could come in front room of
adyton19. The chieftains coming to consult on behalf of their homelands were called as
“theoros” or “theopropos” and they were the only ones admitted to the adyton. They sat on
sediles with the prophetes or waited standing beside the omphalos20. The graphycos
(amanuensis) wrote the questions on the plaques standing on their knees and then thespiochos
took those plaques and passed to the back room of adyton where the sacred well was situated.
After he had drunk some water, he went into trance, posed questions to the God and received
the answers. Those responses were put into verses by prophetes. Finally, they were delivered
to the people who consulted (Şahin, 1998: 27).
3. Tour Route of Prophecy
West Anatolia is one of the most important settlements in the Asia Minor hosting a lot of
legends and wars not only in the ancient ages both also at the present time. It is also important
with regards to being a territory where the cult of Apollo spreaded to the other regions and
12
Priest
13
Oracle
14
A man who interpret the prophecy, medium
15
Amanuensis, secretary
16
A man who carry the key of the temple
17
A traditional Hellene prosody. Homeros and Herodot used that prosody.
18
Greek mainland
19
The sacred room of the temple
20
A sacred Stone standing in the front room of Apollo Temples
78
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
countries. When we draw a line from the North to the South of the West Anatolia, we come
across a lot of settlements correlating with Apollo. Cnidos, Letoon, Patara, Hierapolis,
Alabanda, Telmissos, Didyma, Claros and Troas are the most important settlements in the
West Anatolia correlated with Apollo. When it is evaluated with regards to tourism, a lot of
tours are organized to the region. However, there hasn‟t been any tour under the name of
“Tour of Oracle” so this has constituted the starting point of the research. When considered
from this aspect, a tour program lasting two nights and three days can be carried out. It must
be pointed that entrances to the ruins have been arranged according to the day light saving
time. Internet Page of Maps Google has been used to determine the interzonal distances.
There are such airlines as Turkish Airlines, Pegasus, Atlasjet, Sun Express and Onur Air
shuttling from İstanbul to Dalaman. Guests coming from abroad could arrive in Dalaman by
the plane of Turkish Airlines21 making a flight from İstanbul Atatürk Airport to Dalaman
Airport at 10.45. The first day of the tour starting at 11.30 comes to an end in Hierapolis at
about 21.30 once after the visit of Letoon and Patara. Second day of the tour starts at 07.30
with the visit of Hierapolis. Right after the visit the ruins of Hierapolis, the guests depart for
Alabanda and they have lunch in Çine at 12.30. After the visit of Alabanda, the group depart
for Telmissos at 15.00 and stay overnight at a hotel in Bodrum. Third day of the tour starting
at 07.30 goes on with the visit of Didyma at 09.30. After the lunchtime at 12.30 in Selçuk,
Claros is visited and afterwards they depart for İzmir at 15.30. After the setting time for the
guests for shopping, They are transferred from İzmir to İstanbul with the flight of Turkish
Airlines at 21.00. There are some significant points to determine about this tour. One of them
is that although Smintheon in Troas is correlated with Apollo, it has been excluded. Being in a
different location of Troas is the main reason of that. Cnidos, the other settlement in Datca
Peninsula correlated with Apollo has also been excluded due to the same reason. When all of
which are evaluated, there will be a tour schedule as follows:
I. DAY:
İstanbul- Dalaman Airport (Landing at 10.45, Turkish Airlines)
11.30 Departure to Gocek
12.00 Gocek (Lunchtime) (Dalaman- Gocek 23km, 32 min.)
13.00 Departure to Letoon
14.30 Arrival to Letoon (Gocek- Letoon 88km, 1 hour and 30 min.)
15.30 Departure to Patara
16.00 Arrival to Patara (Letoon- Patara 18km, 30 min.)
17.00 Departure to Hierapolis
21.30 Arrival to the Hotel in Hierapolis (Kas- Hierapolis 296km, 4 hours and 20 min.).
II. DAY:
07.30 Departure to Hierapolis
08.00 Hierapolis
09.30 Departure to Alabanda (Hierapolis- Alabanda 158km, 3 hour and 8 min.)
12.30 Lunchtime in Cine
13.30 Departure to Alabanda (Cine- Alabanda 10,5km, 20 min.)
21
http://www.atmairport.aero/ucus_gelis_ichatlar.php ATM Dalaman Airport
79
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
13.45 Alabanda
15.00 Departure to Telmissos (Alabanda- Telmissos 111km, 2 hours)
17.00 Telmissos
18.30 Departure to the Hotel
19.00 Arrival to the Hotel in Bodrum
III. DAY:
07.30 Departure to Didyma
09.30 Didyma (Bodrum- Didyma 118km, 2 hours)
11.00 Departure to Selcuk
12.30 Lunchtime in Selcuk (Didyma- Selcuk 92km, 1 hour and 30 min.)
13.30 Departure to Claros (Selcuk- Claros 20km, 20 min.)
14.00 Claros
15.30 Departure to İzmir
16.40 İzmir, Konak (Ahmetbeyli- Konak 53km, 1 hour and 7 min.)
16.40-19.30 Setting time for the guests for shopping in Konak
19.30 Departure to Adnan Menderes Airport ( Konak- Adnan Menderes Airport 16km,
30 min.)
20.00 Adnan Menderes Airport
21.00 Flight (Turkish Airlines (From İzmir to İstanbul)
80
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Picture 1 Route of the Oracle Centers in the West Anatolia
Maps Google Web Page: https://maps.google.com/
4. Conclusions
A lot of places correlated with the cult of Apollo have been spotted in the Ancient Age
West Anatolia. Letoon, Patara, Hierapolis, Alabanda, Telmissos, Didyma and Claros may be
considered as the ones associated with the prophecy. The abundance of the oracles and myths
of prophecies about so called cities has brought to mind a suggestion for carrying out a tour
schedule. Besides these cities, Oinoanda, Sura, Philedelphia, Thyateira, Sardis, Eumeneia,
Kyzikos, Germe, Smintheon, Thymbra, Troia, Gryneion, Aigai, Magnesi ad Maendrum,
Smyrna, Erythrai, Cnidos, Caunos, Myndos, Amos, Loryma, Amyzon, Neandria and Mylasa
are also among the cities associated with the prophecy of Apollo (Gürdal, 2007: 3-4).
However, apart from Region of Troas and Cnidos, one of the reasons why the formerly
mentioned cities are excluded from the tour schedule is that the cult of Apollo wasn‟t a
dominant power in those cities. The main reason why both of the cities were excluded from
the tour schedule is that the cities are situated in different routes. Including Cnidos situated in
Datca Peninsula in the tour schedule means about a twelve hour waste. That is to say, a visit
to Cnidos will cause to overrun the time for another one more day. This tour has been
scheduled with the aim of visiting as many cities associated with the cult of Apollo as
possible in the shortest possible time. On account of this, Datca Peninsula hasn‟t been
included in the schedule. The reasons why the region of Troas hasn‟t been included in the tour
schedule are that except for Smintheon, the cult of Apollo wasn‟t dominant in the other
settlements and that the take off would have to be from İstanbul and that after the visit of
Troas, a next coming long journey would be waiting for the guests. Most probably, the main
disadvantage of the schedule is that the very day would be very tiresome because just after the
81
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
visits of Letoon and Patara, there is for about a four hour journey to Hierapolis. Another
disadvantage is that the schedule hasn‟t been carried out practically. “Maps Google” has been
used to estimate both the distances among the cities and the time in the process of scheduling
the tour.
Next researches aiming at determining the profile of tourists interested in the cult of
Apollo and prophecy, marketing of the regions correlated with the cult of Apollo, devising
projects reflecting the process of a prophecy (devising buildings showing similarities with the
temples of Apollo in the Ancient Age) and doing a cost analysis for such a tour of prophecy
may contribute to the literature.
References
Akurgal, E. (1988). Anadolu Uygarlıkları. İstanbul: Net Turistik Yayınları.
Akoğlu, S. (2006). Ciccero‟da Tanrı, İnanç ve Yazgı: Özgür İstenç‟te Assensio‟nun Yeri.
Ankara: Ankara Universitesi Latin Dili ve Edebiyatı Ana Bilim Dalı Doktora Tezi (Ankara
University Department of Latin Language and Literature, Doctoral Thesis).
Apollodorus (1921). Epitome, (Trans. J. G. Frazer). London: William Heinmann, New York:
G. P. Putnam‟s Sons.
Bağdatlı, F. (2001). Alabanda Apollon Isotımos Tapınağı. Aydın: Adnan Menderes
Universitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, (Adnan Menderes
University Institute of Social Sciences Unpublished Master‟s Thesis).
Bağdatlı, F. (2006). Alabanda Sikkelerinde Apollon İsothimos. Anadolu Arkeolojisine
Katkılar, 65. Yaşında Abdullah Yaylalı‟ya Sunulan Yazılar (Editor:T.Takaoglu), İstanbul:
Hitit Color Press, pp. 235-230.
Berens, E.M. (2007). Myths and Legends of Ancient Greece and Rome. New York: Maynard
Merrill and Co.
Coleman, J.A. (2007). The Dictionary of Mythology. London: Arcturus Publishing Limited.
Daly, K.N. (2009). Greek and Roman Mythology A to Z (revised by M. Rengel). New York:
Infobase Publishing.
D‟Andria, F. (2004). Hierapolis 2003. 26. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı II. Cilt, 24-28 Mayıs
2004, Konya: Kültür ve Turizm Bakanlığı Yayınları, pp.147-156.
Des Courtils, J. (2003) The Guide to Xanthos and Letoon, Ege Yayınları: İstanbul.
Eren, K. (2008). Didyma- Klaros Bir Karşılaştırma Denemesi. In I. Uluslar arası Antik
Dönemde Kehanet ve Apollon‟un Kültleri Sempozyum Bildirileri, 17-20 Agustos 2005. İzmir:
Ege Universitesi, Arkeoloji Dergisi (Ege University) 2008/2, pp. 69-74.
Erhat, A. (1996). Mitoloji Sözlüğü. Remzi Kitabevi: İstanbul.
Fontenrose (1988). Didyma: Apollo‟s Oracle, Cult and Companions. University of California
Press: London.
Graves, R. (1960). The Greek Myths Revised Edition),
Grimal, P. (2007). Mitoloji Sözlüğü Yunan ve Roma (Translated by S. Tamgüç), Kabalcı
Yayınevi: İstanbul.
Gürdal, T. (2007). Anadolu‟da Apollon Kültü. Ankara: Ankara Universitesi Sosyal Bilimler
Enstitüsü Doktora Tezi (Ankara University Institute of Social Sciences Doctoral Thesis).
82
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Herodotus (1920). Herodotus I, Book I-II (Translated by A.D. Godley). London: Harvard
University Press.
Herodotus (1973). Herodot Tarihi (Translated by M. Okmen), İstanbul: Remzi Kitabevi.
Işık, F. (2008). Patara 2007. 30. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı, 26-30 Mayıs 2008, Kultur ve
Turizm Bakanlığı Kultur Varlıkları ve Muzeler Genel Mudurlugu Yayınları, Vol. 4, pp. 337-
354.
Johnston, S.I. (2008). Ancient Greek Divination. United Kingdom: Wiley Blacwell Publishing
(First Edition).
Kennedy, M.D. (1998). Encyclopedia of Greco-Roman Mythology. California: Library of
Congresss Cataloging-in Publication Data.
Mair A.W. and Mair G.R. (1969) Callimachus and Lycophron Aratus (revised edition).
London: The Loeb Classical Library William Heinemann (Edited by E. Capps, T.E.Page and
W.H.D. Rouse), New York: G.P. Putnam‟s Sons.
March, J. (2001). Cassells‟ Dictionary of Classical Mythology. London: Cassell& CO.
Morford, M.P.O. and Lenardon R.J. (2003). Classical Mythology (Seventh Edition). New
York: Oxford University Press.
Nardo, D. (2002). Greek and Roman Mythology. United States of America: Greenhaven
Press, Gale Cengage Learning.
Negri, S. and Leucci, G. (2006). Geophysical investigation of the temple of Apollo
(Hierapolis, Turkey), Journal of Archaelogical Science, Vol. 33, pp. 1505-1513.
Roman, L. and Roman, M. (2010). Encyclopedia of Greek and Roman Mythology. United
States of America: Facts on File Library of Religion and Mythology.
Rose, H.J. (2005). A Handbook of Greek Mythology. London, New York: Taylor and Francis
e- Library.
Schwab, G. (2004). Klasik Yunan Mitolojisinin En Güzel Efsaneleri (Translated by D.D.
Yüzer). İzmir: İlya İzmir Yayınevi.
Sevin, V. (2001). Anadolu‟nun Tarihi Coğrafyası I. Ankara: Turk Tarih Kurumu Yayınları.
Strabo, (1960). The Geography of Strabo (Translated by H.L. Jones). Harward University
Press: Cambridge.
Şahin, N. (1998). Klaros Apollon Klarios Bilicilik Merkezi. İstanbul: Ege Yayınları.
The History of Herodotus. http://www.sacred-texts.com/cla/hh/index.htm [accessed
28.12.2012]
U X L Encyclopedia of World Mythology (2009). United States of America: Gale Cengage
Learning.
Vitrivius, (1914). The Ten Books on Architecture (Translated by M.H. Morgan). Cambridge:
Harward Universitiy Press, London: Humphrey Milford Oxford University Press.
83
Rihla: Activist Of Campus Da’wah Institute’s Lifestyle In Urban Area
Jhane Pebyana Wilis and Nur Aida Mardhatila (co-author)
Universitas Indonesia
Department of Sociology and Department of Politics Science
Faculty of Social and Politics Sciences
Indonesia
e-mail: jhanewilis@ymail.com, mardhatillanuraida@gmail.com
Abstract
It is important to know why rihla is eagerly awaited by activist of campus da’wah insitute and
it has already been a part of Islam student activist in urban area. For this case I took
Universitas Indonesia as the scope of research and Islam activists to be informant. Rihla is an
da’wah activist’s activity outside their secretariat or formal events. The main purposes are to
strengthen silahturahim and enhance the understanding of the nature (tafakur alam or natural
recognition). Also in relation to the internal strengthening a movement, rihla can be means of
strengthening the identity of member organizations. Strong solidarity can facilitate resource
mobilization da’wah activities. Commonly rihla takes place in outdoors, such as mountain,
waterfall, beach, forest, and so on. This activity is packaged in fun and informal, such as
outbound, games, or simulations of cultural agenda that must be done. It is not wrong if rihla
considers as a lifestyle. In order to postitif implications such the strengthening the
organization. Due to the impact of rihla itself on activist of Universitas Indonesia has
consolidated bonds and upheld unity. More the values which are brought are the value of
Islamic norms and thankfulness to the Creator.
Keywords: Da’wah, Activist, Rihla
1. Introduction
Islam entered Indonesia through various ways, including trading, preaching, marriage,
education, mysticism, religious congregations, as well as art. Through these channels Islam
gradually spread in Indonesia. In the 14th century until the 15th century AD, when the Hindu
Majapahit Empire had collapsed, the spread of Islam is still relatively in the port city. The
merchants and scholars with his students play an important role. Port cities, such as Pasai
(Sumatra) and Demak (Java) developed into kingdoms palace, education centers, as well as
the spread of Islam who visited students from outside the area.
Later in the Dutch colonial period around the 18th-century, colonial take over the system
of government, especially in the Islamic kingdom of Java. The scholars and students chose
exile to the countryside and some superior sending students to study religion in the Middle
East. When the students who studied in the Middle East returned to Indonesia they become
young scholars and established organizations in urban areas. Furthermore, these
organizations, such as SI, Muhammadiyah, and Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) became the base of the
Islamic youth movement against colonialism for independence.
After the proclamation of independence August 17, 1945, Indonesia was led by President
Sukarno in a period called the Old Order (1945-1966). During this period the upheaval of
thought between the nationalist, religious, and communist, especially in terms of the
formulation of the state. Indonesian Islamic group wants to be the state that based on Islamic
values. The claim is brought in the 1955 Constituent Assembly in three main reasons. First,
Islam is a concept that is whole and does not distinguish the state and society. Second, Islam
appeared in the process of state formation and nation of Indonesia. Third, the fact is
85
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
quantitatively if Muslim is majority in Indonesia (Sunanto, 2005). The suit ultimately agreed,
especially after the Islamic group (Masyumi) only received 44 percent of the vote in the 1955
election. While PNI and PKI, two other parties nationalist and communist ideology, more
agreed basing on the principle of Pancasila.
Furthermore, under the rule of President Suharto (1966-1998) Indonesia experienced
authoritarian rule. Political participation is limited in order to maintain political stability for
economic development. Learning from the Old Order where there is a conflict of ideologies,
the government was doing Fusion Party. Parties in Indonesia merged into three groups: Islam,
Nationalism, and Golongan Karya (Golkar). Golkar is an organizations such as the party of
government at that time. Golkar always gets the most votes in each of the elections. While
Islamic groups and the Nationalist limited role in terms of banning religious symbols or
criticizing government policies.
Although the participation of Islamist groups is limited in practical politics, but it is more
developed at universities. The decline of ideologies in New Order made an impact on the
younger generation to better explore Islam as the energy change in the
community. Normalisasi Kehidupan Kampus (NKK / Campus Policy Normalization) and the
Badan Koordinasi Kemahasiswaan (BKK / Student Coordinating Board) issued by the
government to restrict the activities of student organizations do not apply optimally. Heads of
various universities in major cities such as UI (Jakarta), ITB (Bandung), UGM and UII
(Yogyakarta) implicitly allow students engage in a discussion or activity other underground
organizations. The discussion was continued to the campus mosque.
After New Order cover faucet mass political Islam, on the 1998 Reform taps wide open
and gives students the opportunity to declare his organization activity. Ignas Kleiden (1999)
in writing Sudarsono (2010) tried to explain this phenomenon is due to the explosion of the
student movement ban on political activities during the New Order was more like quarantine
to protect students from germs and viruses. In the case of Muslim students, space is becoming
increasingly sterile quarantine when meeting with mosque variables are identical to sacred
space and religious nuances. Not many people suspect that the mosque became a place for
discussion and exchange students during the repressive reign until today become the base for
activist of campus da’wah institute’s.
Since the 1980's the movement of da’wah activist has built a strong network in the
basement. Until the 1990's activists have started building the pillars of da’wah as lighters
Islamic revival in Indonesia by targeting the campus and education. Campus as a center of
civilization and development need to build a generation of educated intellectual morality,
especially based on Islamic values. This is the main goal of the da’wah activist. Especially in
the period of the 2000s, when political participation and ideological currents open widely,
facing the opponent is no longer an authoritarian regime, but a war of ideas (ghazwul fikr).
The euphoria of democracy post-1998 Reforms in parallel with the introduction of liberal
thought and culture. This situation is supported by the rapid development of
globalization. Kenichi Ohmae (1992) as quoted Dr. Nayef R.F. Al-Rodhan in his book titled
Definitions of Globalization: A Comprehensive Overview and a Proposed Definitions (2006)
write the definition of globalization as "the onset of the borderless world." Limitation of the
country increasingly blurred with the phenomenon of what is becoming a trend in Western
countries can also become a trend in other countries, including lifestyle matrealisme and
pragmatism. This new ideologies that influence the shift in the thinking of the youth,
including a change in the character and contribution of young people in the democratic era
(Mardhatila in KOMAP FISIPOL GMU, 2012).
86
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Nabiel Habib bin Fuad Al-Amin Musawa in the prologue of the book titled Ijtihad
Membangun Base Gerakan (2010) writes that in the era of democracy, there are two types of
dangers faced by Muslim students. First, secularism thought. On the one hand it contains the
goodness when their purpose is to conduct scientific specialization according their respective
fields. However, it would be dangerous if the purpose is to separate religion from science
because they think science and religion are not incompatible logic. Second, the next danger of
activist is culture shock (Cylde Khuckpohn). Most of the current Muslim students lose their
identity and history as the heir of the great Islamic civilization. The material on the history
and science world dominated by Western values. It is also exacerbated by sending students
abroad without equipped with a solid base of faith.
This situation became the reason for the phenomenon of brain drain and brain
washing. Brain drain is a runaway intellectuals from Islamic countries to the developed
countries because of incentives and greater life. While brain washing phenomenon manifested
in changes in mindset and behavior of the intellectuals after returning to school from
developed countries. Negative impacts, these phenomenon conflict with the culture and values
of Islam that dominant in Indonesia.
Nabiel writing is open discourse on the da’wah activists challenge facing the movement
today. In addition to forming a professional management of da’wah and projects effectively
and efficiently, the da’wah activists need to make internal activities to strengthen the base of
the movement, the solidarity of its members. In this paper the authors raise rihla as da’wah
activist activities undertaken to strengthen the relationship between goals and organizational
members. In addition to the focus of the study, the authors take a case study at the Universitas
Indonesia (Depok Campus). Special interests rihla as reinforcement base movement is then a
background formulation of the problem:
How can rihla be an activist of campus da’wah institute’s lifestyle in urban area?
2. Conceptual Framework
2.1 Definition of Rihla
According Perwitasari (2004) rihla word implies a break. As a term, rihla aimed at
recreational activities provide a means of refreshing the mind and heart. In general, rihla done
by visiting outdoor attractions that provide a new atmosphere, in contrast to a typical
day. Perwitasari also wrote several benefits of rihla, there are: as a means of refreshing to
eliminate boredom that inhibits productivity; adds knowledge to broaden their horizons;
cultivate a sense of gratitude to God: as a means of strengthening ukhuwah; social media
mature emotional learning, particularly in interacting with people; as well as nourish the body
with a variety of activities such as sports or other physical games. Based on these
explanations can be concluded that rihla not only take a walk, sightseeing, or others benefit of
religion an education, but also it can strengthen solidarity of the organization.
2.2 Definition of Da’wah
Etymologically, da’wah comes from the Arabics, there are da'a, yad'u, da'wan, du'a are
defined as the invite, call, request, and demand. At the practical level, da’wah should be
involve and contain three elements, namely the messenger, the information submitted, and the
recipient. However, da’wah implies wider than those terms. Because the term implies da’wah
as an activity to convey the message of Islam, do good and prevent unjust deeds, and give
good tidings and warnings to humans.
According to Munir and Ilaihi (2006) based on the notion that da’wah has been collected
in their book entitled Manajemen Da’wah, the essence of da’wah can be summed up as an
87
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
attempt to change people, both individuals and the community from bad to a better
situation. Moreover, the term da’wah include, first, da’wah is an activity of a call or invite
others to practice the teachings of Islam. Second, da’wah is the delivery of Islamic teaching is
done consciously and deliberately. Third, da’wah is an activity whose implementation can be
done in various ways or methods. Fourth, the mission was planned with the aim of looking
for happiness in life on the basis of the pleasure of God. Fifth, efforts to increase
understanding of the mission is to change the religious view, mental attitude, and behavior of
people who do not conform to the teachings of Islam to suit the demands of shari'a to gain
happiness in this world and the hereafter.
2.3 Group Identity
Identity is defined as the process by which social actors recognize themselves and are
recognized by others as part of a wider grouping, and build an emotional bond with them. The
identity is not only shaped by social characteristics in common, but also a result of sharing
orientation, values, perspectives, lifestyles, and experiences (Astarini, et.al., 2012).
Identity can be exclusive where exclusion of other ideas, and to be inclusive where
individuals can engage in some kind of collectivity at the same time. The formation or
reproduction of identity is an important part of enabling individuals give meaning to their
experiences and transformation. Identity is also an important component of collective action,
through which the actors involved in the conflict are identified, build trust among members,
and connect events from different periods.
According to Porta and Diani (2006) there are two paradoxes of the concept of
identity. First, social identification can simultaneously static and dynamic. On the one hand,
identity can generate sustainability and robustness of members. On the other hand it also
allows identity to the constant redefinition, where the modification of binding limits
repeatedly. Second, is a multiple identity. Where social actors can have multiple identities at
the same time. As an activist who was also a student, children, consumers, and citizens.
Porta and Diani also wrote that the collective identification very rare a homogeneous
identity and integrated strongly. This is because identity is formed through a social process,
where the collectivity and the feeling of belonging among the groups are fluid. In reality, it is
also very rare to find the identity of the dominant actors who are able to integrate a whole. In
fact, identity tends to have a polycentric structure rather than hierarchy. This is because the
motivations and expectations of individuals participating in social movements is very diverse
and more diversified than the public image of the movements.
2.4 Resources Mobilization
Porta and Diani in their book titled Social Movements an Introduction (Second Edition,
2006) wrote about the theory of resources mobilization that needed to understand the
formation and consolidation of the beginning of a movement. The concept is based on the
question,
How can a movement attract the attention of someone that he wanted to join and be a participant of that
movement or organization?
The study of this theory begins by American sociologists in the 1970s about the study of
the formation of the organization and concluded the importance of the resource to mobilize
movements. In view of the early scientists, collective movements is a form of conventional
political participation. The actors are bounded by rational interests, such as a movement that
sponsored by a capitalist and able to contribute to the mass movement followed in large
numbers.
88
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
The movement is part of the normal political process. The existence of obstacles in the
form of provision of material resources (funds) to develop studies on the theory that the
movement or organization can also be formed by a variety of other resources. Fulfillment of
resource mobilization has an important position, because after that the movement can proceed
with the strengthening of solidarity, development strategies, concrete action, and evaluation.
Mobilization capacity of a movement or organization depends on the resource material
and non-material. Material resources such as employment or the division of labor (work),
money, concrete benefits, and services. While the non-material resources such as authority,
moral engagement, faith, and friendship are formed in a group. Resources are distributed
objectively and exchanged with each other among the members.
3. Description
3.1 Description of Interview Results
Universitas Indonesia (UI) is one of the best universities which creates many reliable
generations of the nation, determining the direction, as well as the rise and fall of the
Indonesian state. UI students known as the ranks of students continuing to think critically and
have role as a messengers of aspirations, both among students themselves and in the society.
Oftentimes UI students engage in significant momentum in Indonesia. It is a form of
actualization of the knowledge-gained and result of forging dynamically student activities
running at the university.
No doubt, too, that most of UI students are Muslim Students. Splendor of Muslim student
activities characterized by varying shades of Muslim student activities, such as day-to-day
commemoration of Islam, scientific studies theme of Islam, the development of Islamic art,
and so on. The general framework of student over the activity is to strengthen the moral life
functions and establish a climate of Islamic brotherhood among Muslims and the Muslimah
Student in UI.
The diversity of student activities nuanced Islam made organizing-process are varied. At
the faculty level bodies are relatively independent as Forum for Islamic Studies (FSI),
Mosque, Forum Brotherhood and Islamic Studies (FUKI), and the Forum Amal and Islamic
Studies (Formasi). While at the university level, the organization of the activities carried out
by Islam's Student Activity Unit (UKM) called Spirituality Nuance Students Islamic
University of Indonesia (SALAM UI), which was officially established on October 28, 1998
in Ukhuwah Islamiyah Mosques (MUI) at Universitas Indonesia, Depok, West Java,
Indonesia.
The da’wah institutions annualy work program according to the vision, mission and values
of the organization. In the swift currents of globalization, activists’ challenges of work
program are behavior and paradigm shift of Muslim students on campus. Theories and
Western Culture adopted by college, in this case the UI, has influenced the way students
toward liberal thinking and pragmatic. This phenomenon is the duty of the individual to the
da’wah activist on campus to formulate more solid base movement, including the
strengthening of identity and understanding of the members. One way to strengthen the
da’wah institution by organizing solidarity among members, called ‘rihla’.
In this study the authors conducted interviews with da’wah activists of faculty (LDF) and
on campus (LDK), including two people on board of SALAM UI, one of (Forum of Islamic
Studies of Faculty of Social and Politics Science) FSI FISIP UI board, and one of (Islamic
Studies of Faculty of Computer Science) FUKI Fasilkom UI. From interviews with Arief
Aditya (Chairman) and Syahidah Asmaamani (Head of External) which is the SALAM UI
2013 board, information of rihla that is generally understood as journey activity. The term is
89
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
derived from the Arabic and is commonly used to express the da’wah activist of campus
activities roads that have a specific purpose, kind of glue relationships between members.
Rihla essence starts from the organization atmosphere that can not be forced to do hard-work
continuously. Completion of a work program requires professional-work and is identical to
the situation serious and exhausting. Presence of rihla can be a means of refreshing and
strengthening solidarity among members, in addition to other benefits such as matural
recognition (tafakur alam) and enriching the knowledge.
Both Aditya and Asmaamani agree that rihla is not a formal activity which become
mandatory for every member of the organization. Due to rihla is cultural and not a formal
agenda although in practice a routine that is always held annually in stewardship. Therefore, if
there is a member who was unable to attend rihla may ask a permission and there is no
specific sanction for it. Although rihla is cultural and not a mandatory agenda, but importance
of rihla in every stewardship has made this activity as a lifestyle. Especially when rihla held
outside the campus, such as natural attractions or other tourist areas that require careful
planning in its realization. For da’wah activist of campus in urban that is almost hard to find a
refreshing, rihla can be a means of adding new inspiration, strengthen solidarity organizations,
and engage in natural recognition to encourage the spirit and rectify the intention of da'wah
movement.
Information about rihla not much different from two other informants that authors
obtained. According to Arif Rahman Hakim (General Secretary of FUKI Fasilkom UI 2012)
rihla has been doing by Islamic Organizations (Rohis) at secondary school level. Despite the
difference, in higher-education level, rihla done with a more mature, like a mix-match
between serious-fun agendas. Hakim agrued it is really important in organization to pack a
serious agenda in a more fun because not all members are interested in serious things, and
vice versa. It is also due to the ‘entertainment needs’ of human’s life.
The same opinion was also obtained from Risza Damayanti (Head of Muslimah
Department of FSI FISIP UI 2012). From the information gathered by the authors, adding that
rihla, Damayanti can be performed by an organization in the beginning, middle, or end of
stewardship. Both at the beginning and middle management of an organization, rihla intended
to recognize and strengthen solidarity among the members. While at the end of the
stewardship, generally rihla bring the alumni organization that later merged with the
regeneration agenda. If the informant had previously said there was no specific sanctions if
there are members who do not follow rihla, Damayanti have different answers when rihla
linked in the process of regeneration. According to Damayanti, the absence of a person in
rihla is no specific formal sanctions, but members will lose their right to vote, elected, or
participate in the process of determining the next muslim activist on board which generally
done in the form of deliberations (syuro').
Either Hakim or Damayanti agreed saying that rihla has become a lifestyle of muslim
activist on campus, especially in urban areas. It is based on the human need for entertainment
and the diversity of human character are not all members like serious agendas. The
professionalism of the organization and purpose of the movement need to be packaged in fun
activities in order to strengthen solidarity among members, and refresh the mind of every
individual. Because the organization's work situation is identical to a busy schedule and
completion targets that require workers to stay healthy both mentally and physically.
Therefore rihla is always scheduled every year until arguably the da'wah activists on campus
in urban’s lifestyle.
90
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3.2 Analysis
Rihla is a refreshing activity that deliberately scheduled the management of an
organization to raise the spirit and refresh the mind of its members. It departs from the
background situation of organizations, including da’wah institutions, which is identical with
serious agendas with a busy schedule and tiring. Situation can lead to boredom and stagnation
movement that affects disorientation and degradation of commitment. Broader negative
impact is not achieving the vision, mission, and values that have been implemented. It is
certainly not expected in an institution of da’wah campus that has a mission to strengthen the
moral of Muslim students to be able when to go into the community with values of Islam.
In this paper the author tries to analyze rihla in the socio-political context in which the
activities of student organizations are also influenced by the country's political dynamics and
the development of people's minds. It is against the backdrop of historical records that the
student has a moral force in developing politically oriented movement. Including activists of
da’wah that bases its motion on the situation in Indonesia as a Muslim majority country.
Culturally, democracy emerging post-1998 Reforms have opened up the idea of new
ideologies, especially those from the Western. In addition to the positive effects of
globalization that brings progress the flow of information, technology and communication, the
process also brings negative effects such as the spread of ideologies contrary to the domestic
values. Capitalism, individualism, pragmatism is considered contrary to the values and culture
of Indonesian people who are predominantly Muslim. Islam teaches people to always
beneficial to each other, helping each other, and live a life based on the Al-Quran and Hadith.
This situation challenges the activists of da’wah campus today. Especially in terms of
building an Islamic moral of Muslim students that began degraded by Western values. A
pattern of brain drain and brain washing that is packaged in the form of scholarships, student
exchanges, and cooperation with universities in developed countries shows that Indonesian
Muslim students who attend the program does not have the provision of Islamic morals that is
strong enough. This is certainly be a concern especially the students are the next generation
who determine the future direction of the nation.
Therefore, as a driver of change morality, student activists, particularly in this paper are
the da’wah activists, need to develop the activities of an organization that aims to strengthen
understanding and identity as Muslims who uphold the values of Islam. The strength of
identity can facilitate the resources of mobilization to the vision, mission, and values of the
institution. And in this study the authors noticed that rihla is an activity that can strengthen the
identity and facilitate mobilization.
The author’s argument is based on interviews with da’wah activists by taking a case study
in Universitas Indonesia. The results of these interviews indicate that rihla understood as
recreational activities that have an implicit agenda to strengthen solidarity between members,
as well as casual agenda to refresh the activist’s minds. Refresher required given formal
organizational activities synonymous with serious agendas which require hard work and are
exhausting. The rihla show if the serious agenda can be packaged in a form that is more
enjoyable. Besides, rihla also has religious and educational mission. Because urban activist
generally do rihla to natural attractions that have more calm and fresh atmosphere, away from
the noise and hassle of urban area. Determining of the destination of rihla is important and
meaningful because the da’wah activists can also add insight contemplation of nature and the
beauty of the panorama or the availability of new information at rihla destination.
Rihla as a reinforcement of the importance of identity members to facilitate the resources
mobilization within a movement, making this activity as a regular agenda of da’wah campus
91
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
institutions. Although based on author interviews, rihla is not a non-formal agenda with
absence of specific sanctions for members who are absent, but rihla remain on the agenda that
must exist in any programming work. It is based on the human need for entertainment. In the
context of resource mobilization theory, the needs of the entertainment is included in the non-
material resources which include moral engagement, faith, and friendship. These resources
are believed to strengthen the solidarity among members to keep running the movement
according to the vision, mission and values of the organizations.
Therefore rihla is a routine agenda and it is important, authors state that rihla can be
considered as an activist of campus da’wah institute’s lifestyle in urban area. Thesis writers
strengthened by the results of interviews with informants who are da’wah activists that say if
rihla always run every year, either at the beginning, middle, or end of stewardship. Rihla for
activists seeking not merely a means of take a walk and sightseeing. Rihla also contains the
interests of strengthening the organization, solidarity and identity of members, and rectifying
the commitment to fight for the vision, mission, and values of movement. Especially for
da’wah campus activists in urban area that gets stronger challenges than other areas. The
challenges is a war of ideas (ghazwul fikr). This is parallel with the strengthening of the
globalization that brings foreign values and ideologies. These values do not necessarily
correspond with the local culture of Indonesian society, especially the Muslim population that
dominant in this country.
4. Conclusion and Policy Implication
During the existence of da’wah campus activists remain in Indonesia, particularly
universities in urban area like Universitas Indonesia, rihla activity will always intently as their
lifestyle. Formal agenda such as consolidation, succession planning, regeneration, and others
will be much more interesting if it is packaged in a form that is more fun as rihla. Rihla
indirectly alter the perspective of organizational activities that in fact often serious and
saturate, more enjoyable. So that, the vision and mesages of the organization conveyed to the
next generation. Moreover, human nature, refers to the theory of Maslow's needs, have a need
for spiritual support towards self-actualization. Thus, rihla be the best option for the da’wah
campus activists in internalising the values and norms of the organization.
The essence of rihla is basically a trip. The linkage between rihla and organizational
agenda, particularly activist of da’wah campus very closely. With the purpose of the student
movement that took place in the sights, the government should be able to see the opportunities
that the potential for tourism in Indonesia is very large.Not only focused on the pragmatic
side, but also there is the potential for religious tourism where activists of da’wah campus can
utilize it as a place to study or discussion. No doubt, if Indonesia has the potential to be a
destination for the da’wah activists, both domestics and foreign countries, who seek solace in
the beauty of nature and to tafakur them.
References
Al-Rodhan, Nayef R.F. (2006). Definitions of Globalization: A Comprehensive Overview and
a Proposed Definitions. Jenewa: Geneva Centre for Security Policy.
Astarini, Priska Dewi, et.al. (2012). Perbandingan Antara Kelompok Feminis dan Kelompok
Islam dalam Menanggapi Rancangan Undang-Undang Keadilan dan Kesetaraan Gender.
Depok: Departemen Sosiologi, FISIP, Universitas Indonesia.
Maarif, Syafii. (1999). Upaya Membingkai Peradaban. Cirebon: Pustaka Dinamika.
Porta, Donatella Della & Diani, Mario. (2006). Social Movements an Introduction; Second
Edition. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
92
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Sudarsono, Amin. (2010). Ijtihad Membangun Basis Gerakan. Jakarta: Muda Cendekia.
Sunanto, Musyrifah. (2005). Sejarah Peradaban Islam Indonesia. Jakarta: PT RajaGrafindo
Persada.
UGM, KOMAP FISIPOL (ed.)/2012. Mahasiswa Merajut Asa: Antara Pemikiran dan Aksi.
Yogyakarta: Penerbit Bulaksumur Empat.
Internet Resources
Admin. (2012). Sejarah. http://salam.ui.ac.id/profil/sejarah [accessed 13.1.2013]
Perwitasari. (2004). Mengembangkan Diri Lewat Rihla.
http://bnurulfikri.tripod.com/BNF2004053.pdf [accessed 13.1.2013]
93
The Narrative Skills of the Tourist Guides in Faith-based Tourism: the
Case of Yılanlı Church in Göreme Open Air Museum
Aytuğ Arslan & Hayrullah Çetin
Selçuk University & Nevşehir University
Department of Tourism Guidance, Beyşehir Ali Akkanat Vocational Training School &
Ürgüp Sebahat ve Erol Toksöz Vocational Training School, Turkey
arslan_aytug@hotmail.com
Abstract
Göreme National Park which was added to the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1985
contains an open air museum of rock-cut churches in the village of Göreme, Nevşehir. The
mean annual visiting rate for Göreme Open Air Museum is 25 percent, meaning 1 in 4 tourists
in Cappadocia region visit the site. Therefore a huge number of the tourists reach the
information given by the tourist guides. This study aims at finding out the narrative skills of
the tourist guides in terms of three criteria; familiarity, accuracy and association.
Keywords: tourist guide, narrative skill, Göreme.
1. Introduction
For this study, a number of commentary questions were gathered and a survey was applied
to evaluate the narrative accuracy of the tourist guides for the frescoes of Yılanlı (snake)
Church. After creating data frames for the three criteria, a survey was carried out with the
nineteen tourist guides whose average working years in the tourism sector range from 4 to 30
years in the region of Cappadocia. While the criterion of familiarity means their awareness of
the frescoes, the accuracy is used to evaluate the accounts made by the tourist guides whether
they are faithful according to the Christian tradition or not. The last criterion is the association
with regard to establishing close links with the other myths of the different faiths.
2. The Definition of Religious Tourism and Attraction - Göreme Open Air Museum
Religious motivated tourism is probably as old as religion itself and as a consequence it is
perceived by some scholars as being the oldest form of tourism (Terzidou, 2010). However,
there is no single confirmed definition for religious tourism. There are two general views: the
first is based on the fact that religious followers conduct touristic activities for the purpose of
religion, including pilgrimage, doctrine-spreading etc.; the second focuses on the various
touristic activities performed around resources of religious tourism (Zhang et al., 2007). On
the other hand, although religious tourism, in theory, only focuses on those visitors who
belong to a certain religious group and travel primarily with the aim of furthering their
knowledge of or engagement with a specific faith, most religious sites also attract cultural
heritage tourists who may or may not have a religious affiliation (Smith et al., 2010). The
people would not generally be seen as religious tourists because their motivation for visiting a
religious site is probably more cultural. This is also underlined in the relatively short visits
paid by most cultural tourists to religious sites (Richards, 2007).
According to a recent study conducted in Göreme Open Air Museum by Yılmaz (2011)
reveals that 77 percent of the tourists visited the museum for the purpose of culture, 19
percent for the faith and 12 percent for the other reasons. These results reveal that most of the
tourists do not take part in the form of tourism with strong religious motivation, but for
sightseeing.
Cappadocia is world renowned for its exceptional natural beauties as well as its historical
and cultural heritage apart from the religious attraction of Göreme Open Air Museum. This
95
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
situation confirms Richards’ (2007) and Vukonić’s (2006) views that many of the trips
usually seen as cultural tourism often involve a visit to a religious site and the sacred sites
derive additional value from the accompanying historical and cultural attractions.
Religious sites can be classified based on the sites’ type.
Pilgrimage shrines – places that serve as the goals of religiously motivated journeys.
Religious attractions – structures or sites of religious significance with historic and
artistic importance.
Festivals with religious association (Nolan & Nolan, 1989).
Religious attractions as parts of the natural landscape are usually ecclesiastical structures
visited by secularly oriented tourists and religious groups but are not considered to be places
of pilgrimage. Such religious places attract both believers and non-believers (Terzidou, 2010).
Göreme Open Air Museum seems to be in the second category because of not being actually a
pilgrimage site but religious with its historic importance and natural feature as a part of the
natural lunar landscape including fairy chimneys, rock-cut castles and valleys.
2.1. Yılanlı Church
After Christianity was officially accepted as a religion in 313 A.D., three religious figures
known as Cappadocian Fathers; St. Gregory of Nyssa, St. Basil of the Great, and St. Gregory
of Nazianzus effectively took part in the promotion of the new religion. After succeeding in
vanquishing the Arabs towards the middle of 9th century, the Byzantine Empire established
powerful administrative control over the eastern frontiers which was to last until the third
quarter of the 11th century, during which the region enjoyed a relatively prosperous period.
Göreme National Park which was added to the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1985
contains an open air museum of rock-hewn churches in the village of Göreme, Nevşehir. The
churches in Göreme Open Air Museum are richly adorned with the frescoes dating to 10th
and 11th centuries. Among the churches, Yılanlı Church is simple barrel-vaulted church with a
long nave. It was named after the dragon Saint George slays as depicted in a fresco. The
church has also a fresco of Emperor Constantine and and his mother Saint Helena holding the
True Cross. Another fresco is the portrait of Saint Onuphrius who led hermetic life in the
Egyptian desert near Thebes.
3. The Data Frame of the three Criteria
3.1 The Familiarity
The sample of the tourist guides in this survey was supposed to be familiar with the
frescoes of St. George and the Dragon; the Emperor Constantine the Great and the Empress
Helena, known as the True Cross and St. Onuphrius (Pic. 1-3).
3.2 The Accuracy
3.2.1 The Battle of St. George and the Dragon
George, a tribune, was born in Cappadocia, but traveled to the town of Silene in Libya.
Near this place was a pond in which resided a monstrous dragon which had many times
driven back an armed host sent to destroy it. It was a terrible menace to the city, for it would
from time to time approach the walls, and with its poisonous exhalations kill all the
inhabitants who happened to be near. To pacify the monster, it was decided to supply him
each day two sheep, and he was given sheep until none were left in the neighborhood. The
hungry dragon then attacked the town. The people held a council at which they decided that
each day a man and a beast should be offered, so that they actually sacrificed their sons, and
96
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
daughters.. At last the lot fell upon the daughter of the king, princess Saba. The king dressed
her in royal robes. Then after a last embrace they parted, and she walked down to the lake.
Now it so fell out that George was passing that way, and seeing the weeping maiden, asked
the cause of her tears. She told him all; but on hearing her story, he replied “Fear nothing. In
the name of Jesus Christ I will assist you.” The dragon appeared above the surface of the
water. St. George advanced to meet it. Then with his lance he transfixed the monster to the
ground and smote off the head of the monster. Then, the king, and all his people, twenty
thousand men, without counting women and children, were baptized. After instructing the
king in the duties of his new religion, he went on his way rejoicing (Howey, 2005).
3.2.2 The Emperor Constantine the Great and the Empress Helena, the True Cross
When Helena arrived in Jerusalem she summoned the leading Jewish experts in the Law
and berated them for not accepting Jesus as the Messiah. Then one of them, Judas, told the
story of his grandfather, who told how the discovery of the True Cross would assure the
victory of the Christians. To compel him to reveal the location of the Cross, Helena threw
Judas into a well for seven days, after which time he agreed to lead her to the place where the
Cross was buried. After Judas prayed that God might reveal this place, he began to dig and
quickly found three crosses. To determine which of the three the cross of Jesus was, a corpse
was brought to the crosses; the raising of the dead man identified the True Cross. Helena put
the Cross in a silver casket and had Judas baptized. Pope Eusebius made him bishop of
Jerusalem with the new name of Cyriacus. Not content with just the cross, Helena searched
for the holy nails, with which “the Jews” had crucified Jesus. When Cyriacus prayed for their
discovery, a flash of light from heaven revealed where the holy nails were. This miracle
caused many Jews to convert to Christ (Frassetto, 2007). Helena returned to Constantinople,
apparently taking part of the True Cross to her son and leaving the rest in Jerusalem. Over the
site at which Helena, the mother of Constantine, was believed to have discovered the wood of
the True Cross in 324, a church -the Holy Sepulchre- was erected (Kroesen, 2000).
Constantinople was captured and sacked by the forth crusade in 1204. After the conquest of
the city, a part of the cross of the Lord was divided among the knights; it was donated to
churches after their return to their homelands. Not only did the kings of Jerusalem but also the
patriarchs of the Church of the Holy Sepulcher give away pieces of the Holy Cross from time
to time. It seems that being able to obtain a fragment of the True Cross was one of the aims of
European pilgrimage. The relic was believed to have powers (Schein, 2005).
3.2.3 St. Onuphrius
The story of Onuphrius, one of the Egyptian desert hermits of the fourth or fifth century,
was recounted by Paphnutius, an abbot in Egypt. He wandered in the desert for sixteen days,
meeting Onuphrius on the seventeenth day. He was startled by his appearance. His hair and
beard reached to the ground, his body was covered with hair that looked like fur, and he wore
only a loincloth of leaves. When they began to talk, he said that his name was Onuphrius and
that he had once been a monk in a large monastery in the Thebaid, but felt called to the
solitary life and had been a hermit for seventy years and a palm tree near his cave provided
him with a few dates. He took Paphnutius to his cell and they spent the night together in
prayer, but in the morning Paphnutius found that Onuphrius was dying. Onuphrius said, “Fear
not, brother Paphnutius, for the Lord in his infinite mercy has sent you here to bury me.” The
old man blessed Paphnutius and died. It was a barren and rocky place, so Paphnutius could
not dig a cave. He tore his own cloak in half to provide a shroud and left the body of the old
hermit in a cleft in the rocks, weighted down with stones to protect it from wild beasts. When
he had done this, the cave which had been Onuphrius’s cell crumbled and the date palm
drooped and died (Butler et al., 1997).
97
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3.3 The Association
The tourist guides were supposed to establish a close link with other stories such as the
battle of the Storm God and the dragon Illuyankas, Bellerophon and the Chimaera, the Battle
of Zeus and Typhon, the legend of Shahmaran or the apocryphal Acts of Philip.
4. The Evaluation of the Narrative Skills of the Tourist Guides in Yılanlı Church
The answers they gave to the open-ended questions have revealed that all of the tourist
guides are familiar with the frescoes. For the fresco of the St. George and the Dragon; fifteen
out of the nineteen tourist guides just told that “the battle was the symbol of Christianity’s
victory over paganism or victory of goodness over evil. Three of them said that the story was
told in the Bible. The dragon lived in the mountain of Erciyes, ancient Argaeos. Saint George
killed the dragon because it abducted the daughter of the king, cut the water supply off to the
villagers or attempted to carry the devil into the heaven”. Only one of them gave a full and
accurate account of the story and established a close link with other myths.
For the fresco of Emperor Constantine and Helena; it has been determined that two of the
nineteen tourist guides just recognized the scene but not the details. Fifteen out of told that
“the cross known as the True Cross was discovered in Jerusalem and brought to
Constantinople by Empress Helena. The Emperor Constantine permitted Christianity and
Christianity was promoted to the rank of a legal religion in 313 A.D. For their activity of
spreading Christianity, Emperor Constantine and Empress Helena were canonized as equal
to the apostles. The scene symbolizes the end of the paganism in the Roman Empire. However,
two of them added that the True Cross was buried under the foundations of the Church of
Hagia Sophia or the Column of Constantine (Çemberlitaş)”. Two of the tourist guides gave
different information about the scene. The former informed that “on the day before a war,
Constantine the Great saw in a dream a cross in the sky and an angel told him that he would
conquer under the sign of the cross. Therefore, this led to Constantine’s conversion to
Christianity with his soldiers’ shields and banners emblazoned with the cross”. The latter told
that “the reason of Emperor Constantine and Empress Helena to be painted in the church is
the council which was convened by the Emperor Constantine the Great to restore the
veneration of icons and put an end to the Iconoclastic debate”. Although the discovery of the
True Cross begins with the miraculous vision of the cross on the day before the important
battle on Milvian Bridge in Rome which Constantine the Great won against Maxentius and
became sole Emperor of the Roman Empire, the other information about the Iconoclasm is
false because the council was convened by the Empress Irene in Nicaea in 787. None of the
tourist guides gave a full and accurate account of the story.
For the fresco of Saint Onuphrius; the twelve of them told the story of a virtues young girl
named Onuphria after stating that he was actually an Egyptian desert hermit. In this story,
“Onuphria prayed all night to become a man in order not to marry a suitor and had her wish
miraculously granted with an along beard on her face. Therefore, he is depicted as a half-
man with a long beard and half-woman with breasts with a fig leaf”. The five of them
confused the both stories although they do not have causal relationship. When reporting him
as a hermit, they added some elements related to the story of virtuous girl and Hermaphrodite
in Greek mythology. Only two of the tourist guides opposed talking about the Saint
Onuphrius under another stories and gave a full and accurate account of his life.
5. Conclusion
It has been found at the end of the study that the entire tourist guides who participated in
this survey could describe the event and persons in the frescoes. However, most of them could
not provide detailed information. One of the a few reasons for the lack of an extensive
98
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
knowledge on the frescoes is the fact that they are not able to find reliable and comprehensive
sources for the accurate information. The great amount of their knowledge generally comes
from the explanations of the other tourist guides. On the other hand, the great number of
European tourists consist the important part of Cappadocia visitors which means that they are
not familiar with the stories originated in the Eastern world of Christianity, especially in Asia
Minor. This leads the tourist guides to be more inclined towards the distortion of the stories.
This study confirms this view that the stories of frescoes has been differentiated by adding
some irrelevant but interesting elements to make compensation for the missing information
and draw the attention of the tourists.
Plate 1
Pic. 1. St. George and the Dragon
Source: author’s own
Pic. 2. Emperor Constantine and Empress Helena Pic. 3. St. Onuphrius
Source: author’s own Source: author’s own
99
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
References
Butler, A. - Jones, K. - Burns, P. (1997). Butler's Lives of the Saints. Continuum International
Publishing Group.
Frassetto, M. (2007). Christian Attitudes toward the Jews in the Middle Ages. CRC Press.
Howey, M. O. (2005). The Encircled Serpent a Study of Serpent Symbolism in All Countries
and Ages: A Study of Serpent Symbolism in All Countries and Ages. Kessinger Publishing.
Kroesen, J. E. A. (2000). The Sepulchrum Domini through the Ages: Its Form and Function,
Peeters Publishers.
Nolan, M. - Nolan, S. (1989). Christian Pilgrimage in Modern Western Europe, Chapel Hill:
University of North Carolina Press.
Richards, G. - Fernandes, C. (2007). Religious Tourism in Northern Portugal. In Richards, G.
(ed.). Cultural Tourism: Global and Local Perspectives. The Haworth Hospitality Press, PP.
217-218.
Schein, S. (2005). Gateway to the Heavenly City: Crusader Jerusalem and the Catholic West
(1099-1187). Ashgate Publishing.
Smith, M. - Macleod, N. - Robertson, M. H. (2010). Key Concepts in Tourist Studies. Sage
Publications.
Terzidou, M. (2010). Religion as a motivation to travel: The case of Tinos Island in Greece.
In Management of International Business and Economic Systems (MIBES). Kavala: Kavala
Institute of Technology, p. 338.
Vukonić, B. (2006). Sacred Places and Tourism in the Roman Catholic Tradition. In
Timothy, D. J. et al. (eds.) Tourism, Religion & Spiritual Journey. Routledge, p. 248.
Yılmaz, İ. (2011). Müze Ziyaretçilerinin Hizmet Kalitesi Algılamaları: Göreme Açık Hava
Müzesi Örneği, Anatolia: Turizm Araştırmaları Dergisi, 22:2, pp. 183-193.
Zhang, M. - Huang, L. (2007). Religious Tourism and Cultural Pilgrimage: a Chinese
Perspective. In Raj, R. et al. (eds.) Religious Tourism and Pilgrimage Management: An
International Perspective. CABI, p. 101.
100
Sociological characteristics of religiosity of Poles
Beata Rafalska1 , Aneta Michałowska2
1
The Jerzy Kukuczka University of Physical Education in Katowice,
2
The Josef Pilsudski University of Physical Education in Warsaw
e-mail: beciulka@gazeta.pl
Abstrakt
Introduction: The aim of this study was to investigate religiosity of Poles on a basis of
religious practices and respecting the Church's social teaching in private and in everyday life.
Methods and tools: Theoretical implications. Results: Social and financial status do not lead
to deepening religiousness, however inter-Church factors provoke greater faith and religiosity
in Polish people. Religion and the Church lose their monopoly position in the life of
Christians. Every Catholic chooses and then builds their own religion. Religion and the
Church for Christians mean only fulfilling their social roles. Religious experiences, that are
available only for some people, should be institutionalized so that they are accessible for all.
Poles claim they are devout people, which is not reflected, however, in their daily life. Those
who consider themselves as practicing Catholics do not honour many dogmas of faith. Young
people understand some of the tenets as they want to, and not as they should be understood.
Conclusions: Poles declaring themselves as practicing Christians do not take part in Holy
Masses, which are one of the fundamental duties of their faith. In everyday life they do not
pay attention to the foundations of their religion and from the teachings of the Church they
choose the ones that suit them.
Keywords: Christianity, Catholic Church, Polish society
Introduction
Our experience with religion can begin at any point of our life, but perhaps the best time
to start this adventure is the childhood - by being baptized, or in our youth, whilst our
personality, system of values and our interests is beginning to take its shape. At this point we
are gaining the experiences that can strongly influence our faith, spirituality and religiousness.
Defining religion may be a difficult and complex task, depending on the intensity of its
influence on individual's life. Just to quote one of such definitions that provides a clearer
picture of how the religion can be defined:
„Religion is an organized collection of belief systems in a community that describes the
relationship between the sacred (spirituality and the divinity) and the individual. It
demonstrates through the doctrinal dimension (doctrine, belief), religious rituals (cult), social
dimension - social structure and institutions (church, religious community) and in individual's
spiritual life. The correlation between the individual and the sacred is mostly focused on the
sanctity itself, the deepest desire is to be closer to the sacred, the fear of the scared, the
worship and the distance between the individual and the sacred” (Wikipedia).
„A religion is a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, i.e., things
set apart and forbidden, beliefs and practices which unite in one single moral community
called a Church” (É. Durkheim, 1990).
According to Berger's (2005) concept, religion is a symbolic collection of meanings, with
a transcendent roots. Religion influences all aspects of our existence. Religion's main purpose
is to maintain and legitimate the social world of existence. It's important to prevent social
anomy and chaos. All becomes possible thank to tradition.
101
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
„Religion is a system of symbols which acts to establish powerful, pervasive, and long-
lasting moods and motivations formulating conceptions of a general order of existence and
clothing these conceptions with such an aura of factuality that the moods and motivations
seem uniquely realistic” (C. Geertz 2005).
Religion should be something of a great importance for each individual human being,
therefore each Christian should endeavour deepest understanding and knowledge of the
his/hers religion. The faith and belief themselves are a first step to knowing and understanding
God through the loving unity with God's Kingdom.
In a nutshell, we can say that religion is an important phenomenon and it is inseparable
from human's life. Religion is also common across all cultures and that is what makes it so
significant in individual's life.
The main purpose of this dissertation is achieving a better understanding of religious life
in Poland, religious rites and the acceptance and incorporation of Catholic Church's system of
beliefs, taking into account both public and private spheres of life.
The research is also focusing on the religiousness of Polish people, what's influencing it
the most, the percentage of Polish people declaring themselves Christian, and what has
triggered their religious choices in the first place. The study is based the following research
questions:
1. Which gender (male or female) is more religious?
2. Is there a correlation between the place of living and the religiousness?
3. What are the religious rites amongst the young people and the adults?
4. What are the most commonly received holly sacraments?
Material and methods
This study is a result of analysing a series of scientific articles and essays originating from
a Google search engine and across the board literature study, touching upon religion and the
place and role of the Church in Polish society. Only the subject articles referring to Polish
people were taken into account.
Whilst analysing the articles and publications firstly the simple method of dividing the
findings between the young people and adults was implemented. Secondly, the publication
were subcategorised based on a specific subject touched upon, also chronologically.
Diagnostic surveys method was used in the research done by the Office for
National Statistics. This is a method of collecting and gathering data based on public opinion,
common beliefs and viewpoints. The method mainly focuses on structural and functional
subjects, the dynamics of social events - their intensity and directions they may take.
Diagnostic survey is also used to research any other not institutionalized phenomena as long
as the phenomena has an educational value. A predefined target group affected by the
phenomena in question, that represents a general population, is being analyzed here.
In our research the data originating from religious organizations and churches was
analyzed. In addition, the statistical data regarding the percentage of Catholics in Polish
society from the sociological and statistical researches was taken into account.
There is a significant correlation between the level of religiousness in a society and its
demographical structure. Therefore, amongst the most religious we can list: elderly, woman
and children. Religiousness also determined by level of education, place of living, or financial
background/wealth. The most important indicator of the level of religiousness in a society is
its participation in religious rites.
102
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
When it comes to the young people attitude towards religion, this is mainly influenced by
their family home's socializing and educational patterns.
Surveys of public opinion indicate that in Polish society between 88.9% to 96%
respondents declare themselves Catholic, amongst adults the numbers vary between 79,8% to
97,1%, and amongst the young people the percentage of the declared Catholics varies from
77,5% to 95,6%.
Results
Theological concept of the everyday language comes from Suchy (2011). The concept
highlights the fact that people who in fact openly declare themselves as a church members,
have been taught this great love at their family home. Erasmus of Rotterdam said that if the
Catholics will become better human beings then the Church will be a greater place. The main
role in upbringing of the children lies with their parents. Erasmus said that parents who would
take their children to church would bring them closer to God. Saint Monica had a similar
approach towards her son. Although, his life was not an easy one, she would carry on praying
for him and never lost her fight in his religious awakening and conversion. By our
identification with the Church and its values we help to build our religious community.
The religious homelessness in people's spiritual life can be observed amongst the baptised
people. Those who choose not to nourish their faith are moving away and drifting off the
Church and God's Kingdom.
Smoła (2011) is listing the family itself as one of the reasons for the religiousness
homelessness. A family where the religious homelessness has been present for a very long
time. Individual, who's been raised in such an environment will not see his or hers home as a
family home. This may be one of the reasons why the 72 thousands of married couples
divorced one another in 2009 in Poland. This is a 1/3 of all marriages that took place in that
year. For an individual coming from such background the parish will only be an institution not
a home. This religious homelessness occurs more and more commonly.
(J. Smoła)
According to the research done by Czarnik (2011), it is the Church's responsibility to plant
and nourish the faith amongst all human beings. This enables the God's Kingdom to enrich
and evolve. Christians, by spreading good, living according to the commandments, by
cherishing and loving God and others are building the foundations of the Church.
Berger (2005) suggests, that the religiousness should be researched in the everyday life.
Religion can only be experienced by the chosen ones, and that means that the society should
institutionalize religion in order to reach out to the common people. As a result religion
becomes the main sphere and ingredient in public life.
Ciupak (1984) back in 1980 carried out a study about religiousness. In 1997 the this was a
subject of Mariański's research (1997). They both stating that this was not an easy task. First
cross national survey about religiousness in Poland took place in 1959-1960. It was the Centre
for Public Opinion Research working alongside Polish Public Radio who organized the
survey. The research would focus on young people aged 18-24. The results were in fact very
optimistic, as over 78% of the respondents stated that they are Catholics, but the definition of
Catholics varied. They would say that they are active in their religious life, but would disagree
with some of the principles of the Catholic faith.
The Centre for Public Opinion Research (part of the Polish Public Radio) would focus on
the one main indicator of the religiousness, and that would be taking an active part in
religious rites. Obviously, different religious rites represent the religiousness in a diverse
103
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
intensity. The less objective parameter is a simple declaration of one's participation in
religious rites. A vast majority of the young people taking part in the study declares
participation in religious rites, however, only the minority participates on a regular basis.
Most of them are students and therefore no longer under parents' supervision.
Whilst defining different types of religiousness we need to focus on a social-religious
bonds in a society. Rules and norms of social coexistence are defined by the coexistence of
common beliefs, religious rituals in a community, rules, allowances, disallowances.
This is an important aspect in defining young people's religiousness. Their belongingness
to the church community or lack of it. The lack or very vague bond between the young people
and the Church is visible in the way that young people view, or not, Church as an authority.
Young people do not view the Church as an important player when it comes to solving the
issues and conflicts arising in each society's everyday life. Based on a multiple studies we
know that the clergy is ranked here much lower than politicians.
If a person identifies with the spiritual life of each community he or she takes an active
part in this community and parish's life. Such activities include: common prayers,
commemorative masses/religious services, pilgrimages to holy places, one can also volunteer
work, or any other activities in the community.
The Centre for Public Opinion Research (part of the Polish Public Radio) during its study
strongly highlights the fact that the other important factor in the level of religiousness is
celebration of family and community special events (such as: weddings, baptisms, first holy
communion) in the Church. Young people aged 18-24 declare they would like to have a
church wedding, however, the result is the same for the atheists and agnostics. So it seems
that the decision about making the relationship formal is more linked to the cultural choices
rather than the religious ones. We are so strongly influenced by the society that we feel the
need for receiving the holy sacrament - in this case a church wedding. The reasons are
twofold. On one hand this is a tradition that needs to be cultivated, and on the other hand this
is strongly embedded in conformism. Most of the young people who took part in the study
declares themselves as 'believing in God', however, only few were able to explain the reasons
behind such a declaration. Young people approach religion in a very individual way. This
means that they have their own definition of the religious dogma, that differs from the proper
one advertised by the Church. Amongst people declaring themselves Catholics there were
individuals not believing in God, or the creation of the world, or in afterlife. When we look at
the subject of young people's religiousness closer, we'll see the important role of the concepts
that interest young people the most. Those would be the ethical and moral rules in a society.
That means the young people would concentrate on a humanism as such, therefore, at the
same time avoiding the religious systems and issues. If becomes clear that young people
represent a very basic theoretical knowledge of religion i.e. about its rules, rites, rituals. There
also is no urgency in young people to change this and improve the understanding of religion
amongst them. There is a possibility that this is a result of the early experiences (first holy
communion, confirmation) and seeing the theoretical knowledge as something with no use it
the real life, with no implication in real life. This is to be learnt by heart and forgotten.
Though, as we go through life we learn that Bible can provide a vital and irreplaceable advice
to our daily struggles and questions that may arise as we're getting older. However,
understanding the Bible, its arguments, is a difficult assignment and finding a parallel
between our world and Bible proves to be a complex task.
There are a several independent variables - social parameters and social events that decide
about religiousness. Amongst the fundamental ones we can list: gender, age, place of living.
We also have: psycho-sociological environment, mentality, culture of symbols and
institutions. There are two main variables here: demographical one and socio-cultural.
104
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
In studies the most analyzed is the relation between the religiousness and gender. Amongst
Catholics woman are the most orthodox it their religious believes. There are approximately
20% more orthodox Catholics among woman than there are among men. Female more often
become very strict when it comes to the subject of marriage and its sanctity. The same applies
to abortion or pre-marriage sex life. This is a result of: religion itself, but also very pragmatic
approach towards life. Men are more cautious toward the Church as an institution. One's
attitude towards religion is also a repercussion of each individual's social background. The
other important factor is the place of living. Living in a countryside will greatly influence
person's attitude towards Church. This can be easily confirmed by the fact that most of the
people who live in a countryside (villages) are mostly very faithful and rigorous Catholics.
Whilst assessing population living in cities there is a great need to take social background
into account. The general rule is the lower the social class background - the higher the level of
religiousness. Young people's attitude towards religion is majorly shaped by their family home
- the overall upbringing. We can count the traditional upbringing as the most effective method
religious wise. This means the parents remain full and close control over their children, and
they will make the decisions. The less effective is the "modern-liberal" upbringing, that
cultivates partnership in the parent-child relationship.
We cannot forget however, about the importance of the young people's peers, colleagues,
friends. Although, they would not strongly impart their beliefs on their colleagues but there is
a correlation between the behaviour of young people and their peers. Young people's beliefs,
ethics, attitude are influenced by their colleagues, this happens especially if child leaves his or
hers family home to study.
Amongst additional, but equally important, parameters that can shape and affect
religiousness are: lifestyle change, the diversity of people that may influence young person,
new opportunities to spend their free time differently, the influence that the new school may
have, and also multiculturalism characteristic of the urban lifestyle.
Mariański (1997) explains how the modern influences society and therefore Church is
losing its position as a final resort for the moral and ethical meanings.
In a modern world, so full of a socio-cultural pluralism of ideas, and the individualism, results
in "the necessity to build your own individual religious existence". Religiousness no longer
equals Church, Church that would supreme the other religious institutions. "The view that the
morality equals the religiousness is fading away. No longer we say that only the religious
people, or the ones believing in God, can be good and right." The way we define religion is
more and more problematic for the traditional institutions.
Baptism is the first act confirming one's belongingness to the Christian religion, it
introduces a new member of the Church. Mariański (2011) states that this first holy sacrament
is received by the new member of the Church via his parents, as this is the traditional way.
Nevertheless, after this single activity most parents stop their religious activities and no longer
participate in the Church's life. Seeing the Baptism as an obligation rather than choice.
Comparing the data for the new born Baptisms (under the age of 7) we learn that between
1969 and 1990 96,6% of all children were baptised. Only 3,4% new born children were not
baptised, or were baptised in a different Christian church. Hypothetically, assuming that
approximately 3% of those children were baptised in Christian church, this gives us a result of
less than 1% of new born children that are not baptised at all.
Matthes (2005) states that the Baptism itself does not define the religiousness. We can
have adults being Baptised but have no connection with any of the official churches
whatsoever. Some of the baptised switch to a different church, some will rather move toward
atheism but still feel a connection with the Catholic Church.
105
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Modern times have a negative influence on modern human's awareness and his or hers
attitude towards religion. A modern human trying constantly to catch up with the reality
becomes this individual consumer, where a religion is nothing but a product. He or she can
taste it in the same way as any other product. He or she chooses the religious event or
institution that suits him or her most, browsing the more traditional but also the modern
religious movements.
Polish society's secularisation is below 58.1%. 58.1% of all Christians believes in the
primary dogma that God was a human, and believes in the existence of hell. Only 31.9% of
young people believes in afterlife. Mariański (1991) says: „I declare that I'm a Catholic, I
believe in God no longer means that one accepts even the most basic dogma of Christian
faith”.
According to the 2006 Statistical Yearbooks (GUS)
33 921 016 of Polish people declared that they belong to the Catholic Church - to all its
varieties including Greco-Catholics, Armenian, and the Catholic East Church, to the other
religious institutions and communities total of: 842 816. Taking into account that the total
population of Poland in 2006 was: 38 125, 5 thousand, then 89,0% of all polish citizen
declared being Catholics. 2,2% declared belonging to the other religious institutions and
communities. 8,8% were not taken into account in this study (Statistical Yearbook 2007).
According to the 2008 (December 2008) statistical study by The Centre for Public
Opinion Research 92,7% of adult in Poland declared that the belong to the Catholic Church,
0,4% - Evangelic, 0,5% - Eastern Orthodox Church, 1,4% - Christian in general, 0,9% - other
faith, 2,6% - agnostics, atheists, 0,9% - not able to declare, 0,5% - no answer. Amongst all of
the respondents 11,9% declared that they are orthodox believers, 81,4% - believers, 3,9% -
rather believing and 2,8% - non- believers. The respondents were also asked about the
intensity of their religious rituals/rites (masses, religious gatherings) 7,4% would declare
taking part in such activities few times a week, 46,6% - once a week, 16,2% - once or twice a
month, 20,8% - few times a year and 9,0% - never. Those studies were repeated 2 months
later and then 94,7% of adults declared they belong to the Catholic Church, 0,4% - Evangelic,
0,4% - Eastern Orthodox Church, 0,4% - other faith, 2,1% - agnostics, atheists, 1,2% -
Christian, 0,4% - not able to declare, 0,4% - no answer.
Conclusion
There is a huge discrepancy between the declaration in the scientific studies that most of
the Poles are Catholic and deeply religious. It proves to be completely different in real life.
In this study Polish religiousness is described in a socio-cultural criteria. Being
a Catholic is a cultural imperative.
The scientific studies clearly show the correlation between the religiousness and
demographical structure of the society. Woman, children and the elderly are being described
as the most devoted and religious than men and young people aged 18-24. Also, the education
is very significant. The higher the education, the less religious the person. It varies depending
on the subject of study, we can observe more religious people amongst those studying
technical or natural sciences. Also, the economical status has an impact. The poorest find in
religion hope and a promise of a better life. People with a better socio-economical status put
less effort towards their spiritual existence.
Similarly, in big cities people are more cautious when it comes to Church, were rarely
they would take part in religious activities as masses, gatherings. Their religiousness can be
described a 'celebratory' as they would only actively engage in the Church's life during
holiday season such as Corpus Christi. Countryside/polish villages and small towns represent
106
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
just the opposite - most of the citizen would actively participate in masses, religious
gatherings - for Saint Mary, rosary masses.
To summarize, the socio-cultural factors have no influence over the religiousness of Polish
people, this rather stops them from taking active part in the religious rites such as holy mass.
References
Berger P. (2005). Sacred canopy. Elements of a sociological theory of religion. Kraków: Wyd.
Nomos.
Ciupak E. (1984). Religiousness of young Pole. Warszawa.
Czarnik J. (2011). I believe in the Church. In Siwak W. & Janiga W. (eds.) Creed
and the Ten Commandments. Catechism homily – Series „B” 2011-2012. Przemyśl:
Wyd. Archidiecezji Przemyskiej, pp. 156-160.
Durkheim E. (2005). The elementary forms of the religious life. Warszawa, pp. 31.
Geertz C. (2005). Religion as a cultural system. In: The interpretation of cultures: selected
essays Kraków, pp. 502
Kehrer G. (1996). Introduction to the sociology of religion. Kraków: Wyd. Nomos.
Kiciński K & Koseła K. & Pawlik W. (eds.) (1995). School or parish? Religious education in
school, in the light of sociological research. Kraków: Wyd. Nomos.
Mariański J. (2011). Polish Catholicism - Continuity and change. Sociological study. Kraków:
Wyd. WAM.
Mariański J. (1991). Religious and moral condition of young Poles. Kraków:
Wyd. Nomos.
Mariański J. (1997). Religion and Church between tradition and postmodernity. Sociological
study. Kraków: Wyd. Nomos.
Mariański J. (1997). Postmodern religiosity and measurements methodology. Religious
Review, nr l, pp. 35-51.
Matthes J. (2005). Das Eigene und das Fremde. Würzburg: Ergon.
Merton T. (1989). No man is an island. Kraków:
Wyd. Znak.
Murphy J. (2012). The Power of Your Subconscious Mind. Warszawa: Świat Książki.
Piwowarski W. (1996). Sociology of Religion. Lublin: RW KUL.
Rynio A (red.) Catholic pedagogics. Selected issues. Stalowa Wola: Oficyna Wydawnicza
Fundacji Uniwersyteckiej.
Statistical Yearbook of Demography. 1998-2008. Warszawa: GUS.
Smoła J. (2011). Construction of the spiritual temple or the religiousness homelessness. In
Siwak W. & Janiga W. (eds.) Creed and the Ten Commandments. Catechism homily – Series
„B” 2011-2012. Przemyśl: Wyd. Archidiecezji Przemyskiej, pp. 107-114.
Suchy Z. (2011). In the family we teach the love for the Church and the faith in its
supernatural. In Siwak W. & Janiga W. (eds.) Creed and the Ten Commandments. Catechism
homily – Series „B” 2011-2012. Przemyśl: Wyd. Archidiecezji Przemyskiej, pp. 42-47.
107
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Weber M. (1984). Sketches of the sociology of religion. Warszawa: Wyd. Książka
i Wiedza.
http://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religia, [accessed 27.12.2012].
108
St. Thecla: a native of iconium
Asst. Prof.Dr. Fatih Mehmet Berk
NE University, Tourism Faculty
fberk@konya.edu.tr.
Asst. Prof.Dr. Mustafa Arslan
Selcuk University,
Beysehir Ali Akkanat School of Tourism and Hotel Management.
Abstract
Asia Minor has been the highway of the nations crossing from East to West, and occasionally
reversing their course. This privileged position of Asia Minor provided many opportunities to
host many cultures and civilizations. The earliest traces of mankind date back to the
Paleolithic Age in Asia Minor. Then with the Neolithic centers such as Çatalhöyük, Çayönü,
Nevali Cori, Hacilar, Göbekli Tepe, we can see the the first human settlements in Asia Minor.
This cultural movement continued with the contributions of the Assyrian Trade Colonies, the
Hittites, the Phrygians, the Hellenistic, the Roman, Byzantine Kingdoms, the Seljukians and
finally the Ottoman Empire. In this line, the religion history range from the early paganism
with their god and goddess to the monotheistic religions in Asia Minor. In this context, no one
needs to argue the significance of Asia Minor for the origins of Christianity. It was home to
the first Christian communities and therefore one can easily follow the footsteps of the
Apostles who founded them, from the first saints and martyrs to the first councils and
monasteries. Here, the Aposte Paul, was born and went on much of his missionary journeys.
Antioch, Constantinople, Tarsus, Ephesus, Trapezus, Myra and many other provinces are
important sites for the Christian culture and movement. Konya, the hometown of Rumi and
the capital city of the Seljukian Empire also equipped with some Christian figures and
cultures. Iconium, the former name of Konya was mentioned many times in the New
Testament. Saint Paul, the most responsible person for the spread of Christianity, visited
Iconium and met with St. Timothy who would be one of the most beloved disciples of St.
Paul in the following years. And the other important figure in Iconium is St. Thecla. She met
with St. Paul in Iconium and converted to Christianity and became one of his first students.
So, Iconium became a main place for the events narrated in the apocryphal Acts and Paul and
Thecla. In this study, we will try to introduce St. Thecla in the context of Early Christian
movements in Iconium and underline its noteworthy contribution for the introduction of
Konya.
Key Words: Early Christianity, Iconium, St. Thecla
Introduction
The knowledge of what has been excavated in Anatolia for many years testified the old
phrase of ―Ex Oriente Lux‖1, or the view of Anatolia as the bridge between East and West.
The autochthonous character of Anatolian culture of any period needs no particular
explanation. It was favored by the geographical position of the land (Mellink, 1966: 129). The
role of the geograpy has been widely ignored while analyzing cultures and
civilizations.(Gleditsch and Ward, 2000:6). Braudel stated that the civilizations tightly
coupled to the region that designed with geography (Braudel, 1992: 104).
1
Light comes from the East.
109
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
So, while studying any age of Anatolia, we have no option to ignore the geographical and
geopolitical power of Anatolia. Ramsay, called Anatolia as one of the wealthiest country of
the ancient times and underlines that this prosperity should be created again (Ramsay, 1923:
279). While stating the influence of geography upon the people who live in it, Ramsay
empasized that no country can be compared with Asia Minor and called its situation as
peculiar and unique (Ramsay, 1902: 257). In every phase of Anatolian prehistory and history,
the cultural richness makes itself felt. It dominates one of the world's great crossroads and it
has been a battle and trading ground and a land of passage in all times (Merriam, 1926:86).
The opposing forces may be recognized as respectively Eastern and Western in every age, in
every war, in every crisis held in this geography (Ramsay, 1902: 259). In nowadays as it is
known by every one there are two common political phrase that are commonly based on
culture covering especially ―Islam and Christianity‖. ―The Clash of Civilizations2‖ and ―the
Alliance of Civilizations‖. Turkey, inherited from its rich past, now again a key country for
those two theories concepts.
Anatolia , from the beginnings of civilizations, a crossroads for numerous civilizations
and therefore, the first revolutionary steps have been observed in Anatolia in the Neolithic
Centers such as Çatalhöyük, Hacılar, Göbekli Tepe. The Neolithic Revolution seen in
Anatolia was not only a set of technological innovations associated with farming and herding.
It was also an institutional revolution that people became sedentary and social and political
life changed. Known historically as Asia Minor, Anatolia, was one of the productive and
opulent countries of which antiquity has left us (Cramer, 1832:10). Later then, this cultural
movement continued throughout the periods of the Hittites, Phrygians, Urartians, Hellenistic
settlements, the Romans, Byzantines, Seljukians and the Ottomans. King Midas, Sappho,
Xenophanes,Thales, Heredotos, Strabon, Anaximander, Heraclitus, Diogenes, Homeros, St.
Nicholas known as Santa Claus, St. Paul, St. Timothy are some of the well-known figures
born in Anatolia. These peoples left indelible marks on the face of this unique peninsula.
Anatolia is the hinge of the world especially around the three continents called Europe,
Asia and Africa. The lock over this hinge can only be unlocked by the role of Anatolia. It can
lock or unlock the north-south and east and west line. This characteristic has been continued
throughout the history (Celerier, 1985: 76).
Anatolia And Christianity
Without doubt, the central and decisive element in civilization is religion. That alone
which deals with the higher nature of man can so enter into even the life of nations as to result
in the kind of growth in which civilization consists. Inevitably, a country with rich cultures
and civilization should be filled with religious history and traces. The religion concept in
Anatolia beginning from the early paganistic religions continued to the Judaism, Christianity
and Islam. Ramsay, after observing the ancient history of Anatolia, noticed the religion
essence in the adoration of the life of Nature and described the nature as an emerging one in
new and different forms. So, the people who observing this unique beauty of Nature try to
find some ways to worship. The mystery of self reproduction, of eternal unity amid temporary
diversity is the key all the legends and ceremonies that cluster round worship (Ramsay, 1893:
565). As a key to history, religion has changed its form since its birth and but its strength
remains the same throughout the history (Baldwin,1907: 221).
The history of Judaism, Christianity and Islam is obviously mixed with the history of
Anatolia. Following the early paganistic worships, Christianity was developed away from its
2
S.P. Huntington's thesis called as ― The Clash of Civilizations‖ outlines a future where the "great divisions
among humankind and the dominating source of conflict will be cultural". Before Huntington, the theory was
introduced by Arnold J. Toynbee in 1950s.
110
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
original place and taken a new form in Asia Minor, Greece and Rome especially by the
missionary journeys of St. Paul. So many traces related with Early Christianity found in Asia
Minor. Jordan, Palestine, Israel, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Italy, Greece, Cyprus, and Turkey
also are stages upon which the biblical story was enacted. Nearly two-thirds of the New
Testament, including all the letters of Paul, most of Acts, and the book of Revelation, are set
in either Turkey or Greece (Fant and Reddish, 2003:7). Paul may be said to have forwarded
Jesus' own movement, and in how far he is to be regarded as the originator of a new
movement (McGiffert, 1909: 5). French historian Guizot has said that democracy was
introduced into Europe by a foreign missionary called Paul (Baldwin,1907: 220). If this be so,
it was a democracy whose motive and sphere were religious and related with Anatolian
geography as Paul originaly from Tarsus, a city in the southern part of Turkey. The Christian
movement then continued its existence throughtout the geography of Asia Minor. The first
seven ecumenical councils were held in Anatolia (Nicea, Constantinopole, Chalcedeaon,
Ephesus). The first Christian church in history which was built in a cave in Antioch (Antakya) and the
birth place of St Nicholas (The famous Santa Claus) is in Myra (Demre). The seven churches,
Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamum, Thyatira, Sardis, Philadelphia and Laodicea mentioned in the
opening chapters of the Book of Revelation. The existence of the Christianity continued in the
Roman, Byzantine and even in the Seljukian and Ottoman times. This cultural and religious
richness makes Anatolia unique in the world history.
Iconium and st. Thecla
There is a phrase in Turkish language: ―Şereful mekan bil mekin‖. It means ―an honor of a
city based on the people who live in it‖. Many cities obtained their familiarity from the well-
known people who are related with the history of the cities. For instance, Urfa, called as the
―City of the Prophets‖, ―Tarsus, city of St. Paul‖, ―Amasya, city of Strabon or ―city of
Şehzadeler (Princes)‖. Therefore many important figures whether as prophets, sultans, mystic
leaders or any other important figures contributed a lot to the culture of cities. Sultan
Alaeddin I., Shams-i Tabrizi, Rumi, Sadrettin Konevi are just only a few of the samples of
well-known figures that contribute to the familiarity of Konya. And as it host Rumi, Konya is
called as ―City of Rumi‖. In addition to the Muslim figures, the history of Konya related with
the Christian figures such as St. Paul, St. Barnabas, St. Timothy and St. Thecla and Helena,
mother of Byzantine Emperor Constanine.
Iconium is one of the oldest cities in Turkey. It seems to have been inhabited as far back
as the third millenium BC. During the 2nd millennium, the Hittites controlled the area. It was
anciently the provinve of Phrygia. Xenophon referred Iconium as the last city of Phrygia
(Xenophon, 1922: 1.2.19). The Lydians took control of Iconium at the beginning of the 7th
century BC, and then the following century the Persians ruled the area (Fant and Reddish,
2003: 228-229). Strabo and Cicero stated Iconium as a Lycaonion city.3 Following the defeat
of the Persians by the Alexander the Great, it became a part of Alexander‘s Empire. After
Alexander‘s death, Iconium was controlled by the Seleucids and then by the Pergamene
rulers. In 129 B.C., four years after the Pergamene kingdom was bequeathed to Rome,
Iconium was made a part of the Roman province of Asia (Fant and Reddish, 2003: 229).
Iconium in the time of St. Paul was a city of the Province called Galatia (Ramsay, 1908:
343). During the missionary activities of St. Paul in Iconium (See: Figure I) in the Jewish
synagogue, a great multitude both of the Jews and the Greeks believed Paul‘s ideas. St. Paul
and St. Barnabas had to leave Iconium after experiencing some mistreatments by the people
3
Strabon, Geographica ( XII:6); Cicero, Epistulae ad Familiares (15.4.2);
111
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
who didn‘t believe them(Acts 14:1-7).4Iconium5 was the setting for several episodes in the
Acts of Paul, a work from the latter half of the 2nd century that contains legendary stories
about the missionary activities of Paul. The episodes in Iconium involved Thecla, a young
woman from the city who was so impressed by Paul‘s preaching that she left her fiancé and
followed Paul on some of his travels. (Fant and Reddish, 2003:230). St. Timothy, a native of
Lystra one of his helpers during Paul‘s missionary travels (I Corinthians, 4: 17). 6 We learnt
the involvement of St. Timothy in the early letters of Paul, the Acts of the Apostles and the
Pastoral Epistles. St.Timothy is described in the Pastoral Epistles as exercising authority in
particular churches as Paul‘s life and ministry.
Figure I: St.Paul's First Missionary Journey
(http://www.biblestudy.org/maps/pauls-first-journey-map.html)
4
And it came to pass in Iconium, that they went both together into the synagogue of the Jews, and so spake, that
a great multitude both of the Jews and also of the Greeks believed. But the unbelieving Jews stirred up the
Gentiles, and made their minds evil affected against the brethren. Long time therefore abode they speaking
boldly in The Lord, which gave testimony unto the word of His grace, and granted signs and wonders to be done
by their hands. But the multitude of the city was divided: and part held with the Jews, and part with the apostles.
And when there was an assault made both of the Gentiles, and also of the Jews with their rulers, to use them
despitefully, and to stone them, They were ware of it, and fled unto Lystra and Derbe, cities of Lycaonia, and
unto the region that lieth round about: And there they preached the Gospel." (Acts 14:1-7)
5
Then some Jews arrived from Antioch and Iconium and won the crowds to their side. They stoned Paul and
dragged him out of town, thinking he was dead (Acts, 14:19). So they shook the dust from their feet as a sign of
rejection and went to the town of Iconium (Acts, 13:51). In Iconium Paul and Barnabus went into the Jewish
synagogue and spoke in such a way that a great number of both Jews and Greeks believed (Acts, 14:1). You also
know about the kind of persecutions and sufferings which happened to me in the cities of Antioch, Iconium, and
Lystra. I endured those persecutions, and the Lord rescued me from all of them ( II. Timothy, 3:11). The
believers in Lystra and Iconium spoke well of Timothy (Acts, 16:2).
6
For this reason I have sent to you Timothy, who is my beloved and faithful child in the Lord, and he will
remind you of my ways which are in Christ, just as I teach everywhere in every church (I Corinthians, 4: 17). 6
112
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
The position of st. Thecla in christianity
The Holiness is important concept for the Christians to spread their religion. In this
context, not only the ―holy virtues‖ but also some ― holy figures‖ such as heroic monks and
martyrs were mentioned to the people by the priests during their preaches. These holy figures
played a crucial role as healers, exorcists, patrons, counsellors, and arbiters of disaggrements.
While they were living, their personel sanctity attracted the followers of them and after death,
their life stories were retold in hagiographical narratives. Many Christians believed that they
could obtain access to the power of Christ manifest in the saints‘ lives by imitating them
(Davis, 2008: 3-4).
Devotion to the holy people has been observed in many forms such as radical acts of
asceticism and long pilgrimage journeys to more mundane activities like the decoration of a
grave, the reading of sacred texts at a local martyr shrine, or private veneration of images in
the home. All of these practices commonly called as the cult of the saints (Davis, 2008: 3-4).
St. Thecla is the person who had chosen the narrow gate and refused the easiest one that
was supported by her beauty by following the verse stating in the New testament: ―Enter
through the narrow gate; for the gate is wide and the way is broad that leads to destruction,
and there are many who enter through it. But the gate is narrow and the way is difficult that
leads to life, and there are few who find it‖ (Matthew 7: 13-14). She entered through the the
narrow gate and chose the difficult life.
The apocryphal Acts of Paul and Thecla probably originating in Asia Minor during the
latter part of the second century BC. (Elliot, 1993: 350). The emergence of the Acts of Thecla
remains as a mystery like much else in ancient literary history. The work may be classified as
a short novel or perhaps more accurately as a feuilleton (series)â episodes, possibly emanating
from the literary and religious fringe. (Petropoulos 1995,127). D. Ronald MacDonald and
Virginia Burrus have each argued that the ATh should be understood as folk tales and were
originally oral stories shared in women-centered communities that resisted the established
patriarchal order.7 The Acts of Paul and Thecla has come down to us in Greek, Coptic, Syriac,
Slavic, Arabic and four independent Latin versions. (MacDonald, 1983: 90).
The Acts of Thecla of the second century AD., which seem to have come from women‘s
oral traditions were a great source for great inspiration for women in the ancient world.
Stories on Thecla handed down from generation to generation, obtaining embellishments with
every expression and seen every where ranging from the church walls to the medallions. The
author of Thecla could have been exposed to the visual discourse directly from the
philosophical and doxographical sources or filtered through the Church Fathers. It might have
been compiled by one of the disciple of Paul in at a date about A.D. 160. Tertullian, states that
it was written in honor of Saint Paul by a presbyter of Asia (Gündüz, 2004: 28).
Early Christian preachers described her as the role model of chastity for women. St.
Ambrose, bishop of Milan (c. 330 –397), urged virgins to take Thecla as a role model second
to Mary in his book ―De Virginibus‖ (Pederson, 2006: 61). St. Methodius (early fourth
century AD), bishop of Olympus and Patara in Asia Minor, in his symposium of the ten
virgins, included Thecla among the exemplary virgins (Methodius, 1958: 104).
At the end of the second century Tertullian denounces the the Acts of Thecla as a forgery
and points out that Paul would never have permitted a woman either to teach or to baptize and
complained some stories such as that of Thecla, were used to legitimate women teaching and
baptizing (Tertullian,1908: XVII). Emmelia, mother of Gregory of Nyssa (335-395), had a
7
MacDonald The Legend and the Apostle; Virginia Burrus, Chastity as Autonomy: Women in the Stories of
Apocryphal Acts (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen, 1987).
113
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
vision of St Thecla, while she was in labor. Therefore, Emmelia named her child Macrina
after her grandmother, but gave her Thecla as a private name which may have been an
indication of her aptitude to virginity (Gregory of Nyssa,1967:164). Gregory of Nyssa states
that Thecla , having heard the words of St. Paul, destroys the outward character within herself,
renounces of the world and wipes our all her carnal thougts and desires. 8 Hippolytus, in his
work Commentary on Daniel, written about 204, refers to Paul & Thecla and the baptized lion
without hesitation as orthodox (Hippolytus, 2010: 3.29; Elliot, 1993: 351). Egeria9 (fourth-
early fifth century A.D.), traveller, devout Christian pilgrim, writer, visited the tomb of St.
Thecla in Seleucia.10 In Seleucia, Egeria met her woman friend from her days in Jerusalem,
the deaconess Marthana (Egeria, 1919: 42).
John Chrysostom (347-407), a notable Christian bishop and preacher from the fourth and
fifth centuries in Syria and Constantinople, praises Thecla as she gives away her gold jewels
to meet with St. Paul in prison. (Chrysostom,1851: 36811.The Homily Of Pseudo-Chrysostom
on St. Thecla glorifies the virginity of of Thecla and analyzes her chastity and martyrdom. In
this work, Thecla flees into the desert after escaping from her lover and disappears in a desert
leaving him alone (Pesthy, 1996: 171-173). Epiphanius of Salamis sets Thecla in row with
Elijah, John the Baptist and Mary12. St. Isidore of Pelusium (died around 435), a native of
Alexandria, stated St. Thecla as the first woman martyr (Pesthy,1996: 168) 13. Although the
Acts of Thecla even labeled as apocryphal by St. Jerome (in the fourth century), he considered
her as a saint (Petropoulos 1995,126). A homily of Severus of Antioch, a bishop of Antioch,
in 512, also described her as a person who possesses the virtues of the whole church (Pesthy,
1996: 173). Syncletica of Alexandria, a Christian saint and Desert Mother of the 4th century,
called as a ―genuine disciple of the blessed Thecla‖ as she followed her teachings. Like
Thecla, Syncletica left her house, changed her appearance, and assumed a public role as an
ascetic teacher of women (Davis, 2008: 108-111). Eugenia, the daughter of Philip (born in
183), the Eparch of all Egypt, imitated Thecla. She cuts her hair and dresses herself like a
man, a sign of her rejection of family ties and commitment to the virginal life after reading
the Acts of Paul and Thecla (Davis, 2008: 108-143).
The next source, a two volume text entitled as ―The Life and Miracles of Saint Thecla,
was attributed to the theologian Basil of Seleucia in the fifth century. ―The Life and Miracles
of Saint Thecla,‖ which reiterates the tales of the Acts of Paul and Thecla (Vol. I) and then
recounts a number of miracles attributed to Thecla by Christians throughout the area of Asia
8
Monika Pesthy cited in her paper called as ―Thecla among the Fathers,‖ in Bremmer, The Apocryphal Acts of
Paul and Thecla on page 167 referring Gregory of Nyssa, Homilies on the Song of Songs 14, in PG 44:1068.
9
Egeria (sometimes called as Etheria) was a fifth-century devout Christian pilgrim, traveler, and author of the
Itinerarium Egeriae. Clearly, Egeria traveled to Asia Minor, Palestine, and Egypt in the late fourth and early fifth
A.D. (Ligtmann et al., 2008: 111).
10
Three places are stated for the tomb of St. Thecla. Meryemlik in Seleuica (Silifke), Maalula in Syria and Rome
(Pederson, 2006: 68).
11
Hear concerning that blessed Thecla, how, that she might see Paul, she gave even her gold: and thou admirest
what she did, but dost not emulate her. Hearest thou not that Blessed are the merciful, for they shall obtain
mercy? What is the gain for your costly garments? How long shall we continue agape for this attire? Let us put
on the glory of Christ: let us array ourselves with that beauty, that both here we may praised, and there attain
unto the eternal good things, by the grace and mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ, with Whom, to the father and the
Holy Ghost together, be glory, dominion, honour, now an ever, world without end. Amen (Chrysostom,1851:
368 (Home.25).
12
Monika Pesthy stated Epiphanius of Salamis in her paper called as ―Thecla Among the Fathers of the Church,‖
in a book edited by Jan N. Bremmer ― The Apocryphal Acts of Paul and Thecla Studies on Early Christian
Apocrypha referring the work of Epiphanius called as ―Panarion‖.
13
St. Thecla was the summit of all the women‘s victories and exploits, who is renowned everywhere; she is still
the eternal pillar of chastity which in the middle of heaving passions shows us the way into the waveless harbour
(Isidore, Epistolarum I.87).
114
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Minor (Vol. II). However, this attribution proves to be false. Internal evidence shows that it
was in fact written by an anonymous fifth-century rival of Basil, probably a local rhetorician
from Seleucia. The first volume containing the life of Thecla and the second one is a series of
46 miracles of Saint Thecla (MacDonald, 1983: 92; Davis, 2008:40 ). There are many contrast
between the Acts of Thecla and The Life and Miracles of Saint Thecla. St. Thecla observed as
a silent character in the Acts of Thecla but in the work of Basil of Seleucia, she was described
as a talkative person with her long speeches.
She is a strong female character who takes on male dress and roles. So, the roles and
deeds of St. Thecla is noteworthy as an evidence for women‘s experience and position
(Welch, 1996:66). She had many awful experiences but with the blessings of God, she
overcome all of the troubles she met. After escaping the arena in Antioch, the city resounds
with the voices of women who cry out, ―One is God who has delivered Thecla‖ (Elliot, 1993:
369).14 Thecla found St. Paul in the city of Myra and after hearing her intention returning to
Iconium, St. Paul replies, ―Go and teach the word of God‖.15
In the life of St. Thecla, ―acquiring maleness‖ is observed. She obtained the ―courage and
fortitude‖ of a man and represented in a ―male‖ identity. The ―weakness‖ is an inherently
female character while ―strength‖ is attributed to men. Acquisition of masculinity in Thecla‘s
life is interpretted in many ways. It can be seen as an example of ―reversal‖ motif that is
familiar in early Christian, especially in Pauline literature: ―the last becomes the first‖, ―the
victim becomes the victor‖. The archtype of these early Christian themes based on Christ‘s
victory on the cross. Thecla becomes a ―man‖ after she overcomes in the tests of her courage,
faith and fortitude.
Martyrdom is an another sphere in which female martyrs‘s unusual strength is often
mentioned in masculine metaphors. We have also seen masculine metaphors in the
experiences of Blandina, a martyr, a female slave, in 177 in the reign of Marcus Aurelius and
Perpetua, martyr in the city of Carthage (Welch, 1996:69).
In the Acts of Thecla, maleness confers not only strength but also authority. She takes on
male roles in addition to the male appearance. Thecla obtained the privileges despite of her
female identity and also criticized by some Christian writers such as Tertullian (Welch,
1996:69). The Acts of Thecla provides an egalitarian interpretation of Paul of Galatians:
―There is no longer Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male and
female; for all of you are one in Christ Jesus‖ (Paul of Galatians, 3:28). Dennis MacDonald, a
scholar, stated that there is a contrast concerning the women position mentioned in the Acts of
Thecla& Paul of Galatians and the Pastoral Epistles. According to him, The Pastoral Epistles
were written specially to refute the women positions mentioned in the Acts of Thecla (Welch,
1996:70).
In Christian faith, Thecla‘s story can be commented as an allegory illustrating the defeat
of sexual desire. Chastity‘s enemies are classified as male in keeping with the traditional
view that the man is the active partner in sexual intercourse. So, in the role model of Thecla,
the passive female figure, overcome her attackers with the help of Jesus and resist the demons
of sexual desire. In the Pauline doctrine seen in Thecla, the marriage and family concept was
rejected. Sometimes Thecla is regarded as the female equivalent of castration after
annihilating her female identity (Welch, 1996:71-74). Another abstention example seen in the
Acts of Peter, one of the earliest of the apocryphal Acts of the Apostles. In the text Peter's
14
Acts of Paul and Thecla, 26-39; is taken in a book called as ―The Apocryphal New Testament. A Collection of
Apocryphal Christian: Literature in an English translation based on M.R. James published by Oxford University
Press.
15
Acts of Paul and Thecla, 41.
115
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
beautiful virgin daughter is paralyzed on one side after kidnapping by a rich person called as
Ptolemy. St. Peter wants to protect her from men and doesn‘t want to heal her, so her chastity
could be maintained(Welch, 1996:71).
The aim of the Acts of Thecla, in Christian theology was composed of three parts: At first,
to defend the apostle against his Ebionite traducers, with their hints of personal attachment to
his women converts; second, to inculcate the practice of virginity and celibacy; and, third, to
assert the right of women to preach and to baptize (Goodspeed, 1901: 186).
After gaining an important position as a female martyr in Christianity, huge numbers of
pilgrims flocked to churches and other shrines devoted to Thecla in Asia Minor, Syria and
Egypt in search of her divine healing. Thecla revered as a model martyr and worshipped as a
saint, in some parts of the Christian world next to the Mary, the Mother of Jesus herself, as the
most important person outside the Trinity. Although it was considered as uncanonical by
certain Church Fathers, Thecla has remained a paragon of female chastity and asceticism in
the Orthodox Church, which commemorates her on September 24th16. Her feast and cult were
officially supressed by the Roman Catholic Church in 1969, though her cult continues in
countries like Spain (Petropoulos 1995,126).
The identity of st. Thecla
St. Thecla, a well-born and a beautiful virgin, who, upon hearing Paul preach regarding
the blessedness of chastity, left her fiancé, and her family to follow the Paul and to become a
Christian martyr ( Elliott, 1993: 365).17 As she speaks little and seldom, she is referred as a
woman not of words but of deeds, she is a figure full of life, a girl of flesh and blood (Pesthy,
1996:166).
Theoclia, mother of St. Thecla and Thamyris, her fiancé, are the other main figures in her
story. While Paul was preaching in the house of Onesiphorus18 in Iconium, Thecla listened
Paul night and day. Even without seen him, Thecla is made exceedingly joyous by his
teachings. Thamyris, Thecla's fiancé, figures out the recognizable and transformative
behaviours19 of Thecla after visiting her mother, then eventually drags Paul before the
governor.The governor throws Paul into prison, where Thecla secretly goes and visits him at
16
In Bede's martyrology, Saint Thecla is celebrated on September 23, which is still her feast day in the Roman
Catholic Church.
17
And while Paul was speaking in the midst of the church in the house of Onesiphorus a certain virgin named
Thecla, the daughter of Theoclia, betrothed to a man named Thamyris, was sitting at the window close by and
listened day and night to the discourse of virginity, as proclaimed by Paul. And she did not look away from the
window, but was led on by faith, rejoicing exceedingly. And when she saw many women and virgins going in to
Paul she also had an eager desire to be deemed worthy to stand in Paul's presence and hear the word of Christ.
For she had not yet seen Paul in person, but only heard his word (Elliot, 1993: 365).
18
Onesiphorus, meaning "useful," is mentioned in Saint Paul's second letter to Timothy: May the Lord grant
mercy to the house of Onesiphorus, for he often refreshed me, and was not ashamed of my chain, but when he
was in Rome, he sought me diligently, and found me (the Lord grant to him to find the Lord‘s mercy in that
day); and in how many things he served at Ephesus, you know very well (II. Timothy, 1: 16); Greet Prisca and
Aquila, and the house of Onesiphorus (II. Timothy, 4: 19).
19
And as she did not stand away from the window, her mother sends to Thamyris; and he comes gladly, as if
already receiving her in marriage. And Theocleia said: I have a strange story to tell thee, Thamyris; for assuredly
for three days and three nights Thecla does not rise from the window, neither to eat nor to drink; but looking
earnestly as if upon some pleasant sight, she is so devoted to a foreigner teaching deceitful and artful discourses,
that I wonder how a virgin of such modesty is so painfully put about. Thamyris, this man will overturn the city of
the Iconians, and thy Thecla too besides; for all the women and the young men go in beside him, being taught to
fear God and to live in chastity. Moreover also my daughter, tied to the window like a spider, lays hold of what
is said by Paul with a strange eagerness and awful emotion; for the virgin looks eagerly at what is said by him,
and has been captivated. But do thou go near and speak to her, for she has been betrothed to thee (Acts of Paul
and Thecla,8 ).
116
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
night, only to be discovered the next morning and accused of impropriety. This time both of
them are dragged before the governor, with the result that Paul is expelled from the city and
Thecla is condemned to be burnt on the pyre, to her furious mother‘s delight. Once the fires
are lit around her, however, God sends a miraculous torrent of rain which put out the fire and
allows Thecla to escape to Paul, who is mourning her death outside the city (ATh, 5-23).
From there, they proceed to the city of Antioch20. Upon their arrival in Antioch, a
magistrate named Alexander, notices Thecla and falls in love with her, and tryto bribe Paul
with gifts and presents. Alexander attempts to rape Thecla, and she tears his ceremonial cloak
in the process. So, again she is dragged before a governor‘s tribunal and condemned to be fed
to wild beasts in the arena of Antioch. Although Thecla meets Queen Tryphaina, who admires
her faith, she is thrown to the wild beasts. Despite all the attacks by the wild beast, bears and
seals in the pool, she miraculously survives unscathed. The governor ultimately releases
Thecla because Queen Tryphaina has fainted watching Thecla‘s trials. After this incident, the
governor and Alexander fear retribution from the emperor Caesar. Because there is a good
relation between Queen Tryphaina and Caesar. After releasing, Thecla leaves Antioch, having
thus survived her second martyrdom, and she finds Paul in the city of Myra (ATh, 24-39).
Paul approves her trials and sends her out to preach the Gospel. She then returns to her home
city of Iconium and, finding her former fiancé dead, calls on her mother to believe in Christ.
Without any further elaboration the story abruptly ends with the notice that Thecla spent the
remainder of her life in Seleukeia (ATh, 40-43).
The cult of st. Thecla around the world
Thecla‘s final resting place is described as Seleucia (modern day Silifke, Turkey), a town
near the southern coast of Asia Minor, about 100 km south-east of Iconium and 50 km south-
west of Tarsus at the end of the Acts of Thecla. After seen her mother in Iconium, she turned
back to Seleuica and enlightened with the word of God and finally rested in a glorious sleep
(ATh, 43). Seleucia became a center for Thecla devotion and a shrine dedicated to Thecla
(Hagia Thecla) was established on a hill just to the south of the city and by the fourth century
many pilgrims from Asia Minor and from all over the Mediterranean world flocked into this
holy site (Davis, 2008:36).
A female pilgrim, traveller, Egeria, took a three-day detour from her itinerary of holy sites
to visit Thecla‘s shrine21. Egeria stated the existence of many monastic cells for men and
women and describes the huge wall to guard the church against the people who are known as
malicious. (Egeria, 1919: 43). The statements of Egeria shed light on the existence of a
church and probably the actual shrine (martyrium) of Saint Thecla was associated with that
church (Davis, 2008:36)22. In addition to the cave church, Emperor Zeno built a larger basilica
in the fifth century for the memory of St. Thecla as a gratitude for the saint‘s intercession on
his behalf after defeating Basiliscus23 . An improvement was observed toward the end of the
20
Perhaps not the Syrian one.
21
Then, starting from Antioch and journeying through several stations, I came to the province called Cilicia,
which hasTarsus for its metropolis. I had already been at Tarsus on my way to Jerusalem, but as the memorial of
Saint Thecla is at the third station from Tarsus, in Isauria, it was very pleasant for me to go there, especially as it
was so very near at hand (Egeria, 1919: 41).
22
Thecla‘s shrine was relocated to a nearby cave at the southern end of the same hill;there, a small, three-aisled
basilica was built into the natural grotto of limestone (Davis, 2008:36).
23
But Zeno, after a vision, so they say, of the holy, greatly tried protomartyr Thecla, who encouraged him and
promised the restoration of the empire, marched on Byzantium, after suborning with gifts those who were
besieging him; he drove out Basiliscus in the second year of his control of the realm and handed him over to his
enemies when Basiliscus approached the holy shrines. This Zeno dedicated a huge sanctuary of outstanding
magnificence and beauty to the protomartyr Thecla at Seleucia, which lies near the country of the Isaurians; he
adorned it with very many imperial dedications, which are preserved even in our time (Evagrius, 2000: 142).
117
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
fifth century and at least two other churches were built in this period, as well as a public bath
and a number of large cisterns (Davis, 2008:38). Without doubt, the increasing number of the
buildings at Hagia Thecla reflects the changing needs of rapidly growing pilgrims. Today,
these buildings lie in ruins, but their remains testify to the crowds of pilgrims that once visited
Thecla‘s hilltop shrine. (See: Figure II). The Acts of Thecla starting as an oral version then
the author of the non-canonical Acts of Paul finally published Thecla‘s story as part of that
larger narrative. By the fifth and sixth centuries, the Acts of Thecla was modified with
biographical details about what Thecla did in her final days at Seleucia, and especially her
final act as a martyr and an extended version was emerged (Davis, 2008:39-40).
Figure II: Hagia Thecla
the archeological site in Seleucia (Davis, 2008: Figure:4).
The recognition of the St. Thecla also spread quickly throughout the Mediterranean world.
By the end of the fifth century AD, Thecla was glorified as an exemplary virgin and martyr
not only in Asia Minor, but also in Italy, Gaul, Germany, North Africa, Armenia, Cyprus,
Palestine-Syria, and Egypt. Among these regions, Egypt seems to have been an especially
fertile ground for the cult of St. Thecla (Davis, 2008:83-84). Egyptian devotion to Thecla is is
more scattered and fragmentary than in Asia Minor. So, combining the devotion to Thecla in
Egypt is harder than in Asia Minor. Thecla‘s name and image observed on a wide variety of
media: Greek and Coptic papyri and parchment manuscripts, limestone grave stelae, wall
paintings, textile fragments, wooden combs, terra cotta oil lamps, and pilgrim flasks. This
material evidence for Thecla devotion spans in date from the fourth to the seventh centuries
(Davis, 2008:84).
118
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Origen of Alexandria, a theologian, knew the Acts of Paul and Thecla and approved it by
quoting some statements from it in the first half of the third century. By the mid-fourth
century, Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria, indicate that Thecla inspired a large community of
virgins in Alexandria and chose to draw images liberally from the Acts of Paul and Thecla
and presents Thecla as the ultimate model for women‘s piety in his treatise called as On
Virginity. The statements of Athanasius started in Alexandria triggered the spread of Thecla
cult to the rest of the Egypt. He made a visit to Thecla‘s pilgrimage shrine at Seleucia. (Davis,
2008:85-86). Alexandrian women adopted Thecla as their patron Saint. A virgin existence at
home is important to guarantee salvation and protection for the family living there (Davis,
2008:86-87).24
In ancient times known as Mareotis, today called as ―Abu Mena‖, a town, a monastery
complex and Christian pilgrimage center, is located 45 km southwest of Alexandria.The
church, baptistry, basilicas, public buildings, streets, monasteries, houses and workshops in
this early Christian holy city were built over the tomb of the martyr Menas of Alexandria,
who died in AD 296. It is an ancient pilgrimage centre of the Egyptian martyr Saint Menas.
Many pilgrims flocked into the Menas shrine for healing and bought many souveniers
stamped with the image of the saints such as small clay flasks (ampullae) holding holy water
or oil. Today, hundreds of these ampullae survive in museum collections throughout the
Mediterranean world (Davis, 2008:115-116). The image of the holy martyr Thecla ―among
the beasts‖ was observed on a number of surviving Menas flasks.Thecla appeared on pilgrim
flasks from Abu Mina as the only female Saint figure. Probably Menas as a male saint and
Thecla as a female saint were chosen to provide distinct, gendered models for male and
female pilgrims (Davis, 2008:124). The scene of Thecla‘s second martyr trial among the
beasts appears on sixteen different, published examples of Menas ampullae (on the reverse
side) that date to the fifth or sixth century (480–560 ce). (See: Figure III).
Figure III: Within a circular medallion
24
Davis quoted from the following work: Ps-Athanasius, Canon 98, The Canons of Athanasius, Patriarch of
Alexandria, ed. and trans. W. Riedel and W. E. Crum (London: Williams and Norgate, 1904; repr. Text and
Translation Society, 9, Amsterdam: Philo Press, 1973), 53. 14–15 (Arabic text); 62 (translation).
119
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
a more crudely limned figure of Thecla again stands with her hands (tied?) behind her back, but now her upper
torso is modestly draped in a robe that reaches to her feet. In this scene, she is flanked by only two beasts—on
the right an animal (probably a poor representation of the bear) turns to her with head upraised and mouth open,
while on the left a lion with a large mane rears up at her. The bulls are absent; instead, two inscription above the
scene, naming the figure, ―Saint Thecla‘. The border of the medallion reads another Greek inscription which
confers the ―Blessing of St Menas, Amen‖. Pilgrim flask depicting Saint Thecla (reverse), h. 27 cm; diam.17.5
cm: Paris, Musee du Louvre, Departement des Antiquites grecques, etrusques, et romaines, MNC 1926
(photograph by M. Chuzeville). See Appendix A, no. 16. (Davis, 2008:285).
Thecla‘s image with Menas in fifth, sixth, and seventh century Egypt is an interesting
point. Someone attributed this link to the geographical connection with Asia Minor25. The
importation of Thecla‘s cult to Egypt follows the same path as the geographical relocation of
Menas‘ martyrium. The second comment on Menas and Thecla connection based on a story26.
Although there was no archeological evidence for Thecla shrine, this story indicates
Thecla shrine in the Mareotis. So, the pairing of Menas and Thecla on the pilgrim flasks be
due to the proximity of another shrine dedicated to Saint Thecla in the Mareotis (Davis,
2008:128).
RESULT
The Acts of Thecla of the second century AD. emerged as an oral tradition then formed
into the document called as ―The Acts of Paul and Thecla‖ and ―The Life and Miracles of
Saint Thecla‖. Thecla became an important female figure throughout the world especially for
the Christian history and culture day by day. Thecla is described as the pillar of chastity and
honoured as martyr of Iconium despite some doubts related with her death. She despises all
earthly goods and prefers the suffering of life. The familiarity of her not only spread to the
Asia Minor but also in Europe, Syria27 and Egypt. The cult of Thecla became widespread in
both East and West and seems to have reached a peak of popularity in the fifth century. It
contributed a lot to the Christian art and literature.The separate circulation and the subsequent
survival of the Acts of Paul and Thecla were also due to the veneration of Thecla, who was
commemorated on 23 September (in the West) and on 24 September (in the East).
Revered as a model martyr and worshipped as a saint, in some parts of the Christian world
Thecla vied for centuries with Mary, the Mother of Jesus herself, as the most important person
outside the Trinity and many of the church fathers praised her as a model virgin-martyr. A
great number of pilgrims flocked to churches and other shrines devoted to Thecla in Asia
Minor, Syria and Egypt in search of her divine healing.
The religion, the sine qua non element of the civilizations, is one of the indispensable
part of all cultures and histories. If you learn the history of religions, you can also obtain the
chance of learning the history of mankind. Rome, Cairo, Jerusalem, Istanbul and Urfa are just
a few examples that are grateful for their popularity to the religions and their elements.
25
Menas, as a native Egyptian, conscripted as a soldier under Diocletian and stationed in Phrygia in Asia Minor.
He was martyred under the Roman emperor Diocletian when he publically declared his Christian faith. Devotees
would have identified him as a native Egyptian, martyred in Asia Minor and then imported as a saint back to
Egypt (Davis, 2008:121-122).
26
One of the stories in that collection tells of a rich woman, Sophia. She decides to travel to Abu Mina in order
to dedicate her possessions to the Saint Thecla. Departing from her hometown of Philoxenite, the port town on
Lake Mareotis that accommodated pilgrims in transit to Abu Mina, she travels alone on foot through the desert
‗until she approaches the martyr shrine of Saint Thecla Egypt. In the vicinity of this shrine of Thecla, a soldier
sexually assaults Sophia; however, she is miraculously saved by Saint Menas, who arrives on horseback and
carries her to the safety of his sanctuary (Davis, 2008:128).
27
There is a St. Thecla Monastery in Maalula, 50 km north of Damascus.
120
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Konya, formerly known as Iconium should introduce its Christain culture in addition to
the Seljukian and Ottoman heritage and search for new ways to present them to the public
without hesitation. The Christians, the Jews and the Muslims coexisted in peace and
prosperity in this geography in the past and represented many noteworthy experiences for
humanity. Konya, known as the capital city of tolerance based on Rumi‘s philosophy, is one
of the leading city that should hug all the nations and keep on its traditional hospitality in
every aspect. St. Thecla should be examined in all aspects and we can also underline her
hometown, Iconium, while we are introducing her. Nowadays, Konya, just only benefit from
Rumi and Seljukian assets in touristic aspects. After adding St. Thecla and the other Christian
cultures and figures to the concept of Konya in the advertising activities of Konya, the
familiarity of Konya will be increased throughout the world.
Bibliography
Baldwin, Simeon E. (1907). Religion still the Key to History. The American Historical
Review. Vol. 12. No. 2. pp. 219-243.
Braudel, Fernand(1992). Tarih Üzerine Yazılar (Çev. M.Ali Kılıçbay). Ankara. İmge Kitabevi.
Campbell, G. , Doddridge, P. , Macknight, J. (1827). The New Testament. London. Published
by Wightman and Cramp.
Celerier, Pierre (1985). Dünya Hakemi Türkiye. BTT. Sayı. 2.
Chrysostom, John (1851). The Homilies of S. John Chrysostom, Archbishop of Constantinople
on the acts of the Apostles. Part I. Home. I.- XXVIII. (Translaed by John Henry Parker and F.
And J. Rivington). Oxford.
Cramer, J.R. (1832). A Geographical and Historical Description of Asia Minor. Vol.I. Oxford
University Press.
Davis, Stephen, J. (2008). The Cult of Saint Thecla: A Tradition of Women's Piety in Late
Antiquity. New York. Oxford University Press.
Egeria (1919). The Pilgrimage of Etheria ( Ed. M. L. McClure and C. L. Feltoe). New York.
Macmillan Company.
Elliott, James K. (1993). The Apocryphal New Testament. A Collection of Apocryphal
Christian: Literature in an English translation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Evagrius, Scholasticus (2000). The Ecclesiastical History of Evagrius (Translated with an
introduction by Michael Whitby). Liverpool. The Liverpool University Press.
Fant, Clyde E. Reddish, Mitchell G. (2003). A Guide to Biblical Sites in Greece and Turkey.
New York. Oxford University Press.
Goodspeed, E. Johnson (1901). The Acts of Paul and Thecla. The Biblical World. Vol. 17.
No. 3. The University of Chicago Pres. pp. 185-190.
Gregory of Nyssa (1967). The Life of St. Macrina by St. Gregory of Nyssa: Ascetical Works,
Fathers of the Church. Washington, DC. Catholic University of America Press.
Gündüz, Şinasi (2004). Pavlus: Hıristiyanlığın Mimarı. Ankara. Ankara Okulu Yay.
Hippolytus of Rome (2010). Commentary on Daniel. (Translated by T.C. Schmidt).
CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform
Lightman, Marjorie, Lightman, Benjamin (2008). A to Z of Ancient Greek and Roman
Women. New York. Infobase Publishing.
121
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
MacDonald, Dennis R. (1983). The Legend and the Apostle: The Battle for Paul in Story and
Canon. Philadelphia. The Westminster Press.
McGiffert, Arthur Cushman (1909). Was Jesus or Paul the Founder of Christianity? The
American Journal of Theology. Vol. 13. No. 1. pp. 1-20.
Mellink, Machteld J. (1966). Anatolia: Old and New Perspectives. Proceedings of the
American Philosophical Society. Vol. 110. No. 2. Archaeology: Horizons New and Old. pp.
111-129.
Merriam, Gordon P. (1926). The Regional Geography of Anatolia. Economic Geography.
Vol. 2. No. 1. pp. 86-107.
Methodius (1958). The Symposium: A Treatise on Chastity (Edited byT. C. Lawler). New
York. Paulist Press, 1958
Gleditsch, Kristian S., and Ward, Michael D. ( 2000). War and Peace in Space and Time: The
Role of Democratization. International Studies Quarterly ,44. p.1-29.
Pederson, Rena (2006). The Lost Apostle: Searching for the Truth About Junia. San
Francisco. A Wiley Imprint.
Pesthy, Monika (1996). ―Thecla Among the Fathers of the Church,‖ The Apocryphal Acts of
Paul and Thecla Studies on Early Christian Apocrypha. (Edit. Jan N. Bremmer). Kok Pharos
Publishing House.
Petropoulos, John C.B. (1995). Transvestite Virgin With a Cause: The Acta Pauli et Thecla
and Late Antique Proto-―Feminism‖. Greece and Gender, (edited by B. Berggreen and
Nanno Marinatos. Norwegian Institute at Athens.
Ramsay, W. M. (1893). The Holy City of Phrygia. Contemporary Review. 64.
Ramsay, William Mitchell (1902). The Geographical Conditions Determining History and
Religion in Asia Minor. The Geographical Journal, Vol. 20. No. 3. p. 257-275.
Ramsay, William,M. (1908). The Cities of St. Paul: Their Influence on His Life and Thought,
the Cities of Eastern Asia Minor. New York. A.C. Armstrong.
Ramsay, William Mitchell (1923). Geography and History in a Phrygo-Pisidian Glen. The
Geographical Journal, Vol. 61, No. 4. pp. 279-296.
Strabon (2005). Geographika (Çev. A. Pekman). İstanbul. Arkeoloji ve Sanat Tarihi
Yayınları.
Tertullian (1908). De Baptismo. (Edited by J. M. Lupton). Cambridge University Press.
Xenophon (1998). Anabasis. (Çev. Tanju Gökçöl). İstanbul. Sosyal Yayınları.
Welch, J. L. (1996). Cross Dressig and Cross Purposes. Gender Reversals and Gender
Cultures: Anthropological and Historical Perspectives. (Edit. Ramet Sabrina). London.
Routledge.
122
Unlocking the Potential of Religious Tourism in Manisa, Turkey
Assist.Prof.Dr.Burak Kartal1, Prof.Dr.Mustafa Tepeci2 and Hakan Atlı2
Celal Bayar University
1
Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences
2
School of Applied Sciences, Manisa, Turkey.
burak.kartal@cbu.edu.tr
mustafa.tepeci@cbu.edu.tr
hakan.atli@cbu.edu.tr
Abstract
Today, having a marketing perspective is becoming a necessity for nonprofit organizations.
Museums, churches, and other types of nonprofit organizations have added marketing tools
into their way of doing business. Branding is such a valuable tool which has been frequently
used by cities recently. One of the goals of citywide branding efforts is to attract more tourists
to a city. If a city has outstanding religious assets, it will inevitably make use of them to
increase the number of its visitors and that is considered as „faith or religious tourism‟. In this
study, we tried to assess the potential of Manisa for faith tourism and shed some light on the
ways of increasing that potential. Towards that end, in addition to a comprehensive literature
review, we conducted a number of depth interviews with the experts of culture, tourism,
religion, and religious assets in Manisa. The findings indicate that Manisa has highly
important religious monuments belonging to three major religions including three of the seven
churches mentioned in the apocalypse section of the Bible. Besides, many suggestions have
been made regarding possible changes in product, referring to religious monuments and sites
in this study, and other marketing mix elements like possible ways of promoting the product.
Keywords: religious tourism, faith tourism, city marketing, Manisa.
1. Introduction
Turkey is one of the most important countries in the world for international tourism
numbers. Turkey moved up one position to sixth place (with 29.3 million tourists) in 2011 for
tourist arrivals and the twelfth in tourism receipts (WTO, 2012). In 2011, tourism generated
approximately 11% of Turkey‟s GDP and employed 1.94 million people, or 8.1% of total
employment (Travel and Tourism Economic Impact, 2012). However, most of the tourism
development in Turkey has been in the mass tourism (sun, sea and sand) area and the
development has taken place on a narrow coastal line along the Aegean and the
Mediterranean coasts. Mass tourism is of great importance for the economic development of
Turkey but it has such some shortcomings as lower spending per tourist, seasonality and
intense pressure on the environment and on local communities.
Previous studies emphasize the potential of religious or faith tourism development in
Turkey (Egresi, Bayram, Kara and Kesik, 2012; Tandoğan and Avcı, 2012). It is widely
known that Turkey is the repository of many Jewish, Christian and Islamic religious
monuments and values (https://www.goturkey.com). The three celestial religions cohabit on
Anatolia through the tradition of respect and understanding for the freedom of faith and
worship since centuries that continues today in contemporary Turkey (Ulusoy and Yılmaz,
2002). In this study, religious tourism or faith tourism are used interchangeably.
There is not much research in the literature that shows the causes, dimensions,
consequences, market share and the value of faith tourism. Rundquist (2010) estimated that
around 300 million people travel across the world for religious and faith objectives. Aktaş and
123
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Ekin (2007) reported that religious tourism accounts for only 1% of the total number of
international tourists to Turkey. According to the Turkish Statistic Institute‟s "Foreign and
Citizen Visitors by Purpose of Visit Survey", in 2011, 102.314 foreigner and 4.428 citizens
who are resident abroad came to Turkey for religion and/or pilgrimage reasons (Tourism
Statistics, 2011). Considering the total number of over 29 million tourists visiting the country
in 2011, religiously motivated tourist numbers indicate Turkish tourism needs to improve its
marketing efforts for religious tourism and to offer products and values to attract religiously
motivated tourists. Thus, there is a need to assess the potential of Manisa for faith tourism and
shed some light on the ways of increasing that potential.
2. Literature Review
2.1. Religious tourism
Researchers state that religious tourism is among the least explored tourist activities in the
world of modern tourism and the most understudied research areas in tourism research (Olsen
and Timothy, 2006; Vukonic,1998: 83). However, it is one of the oldest types of tourism
(Rinschede, 1992: 53; Rundquist, 2010). Religious tourism can be defined as the visit of
sacred places, to participate or follow-up in religious ceremonies, and the pilgrimage in the
form of visits or activities in order to fulfill of religious duties in the evaluation of tourism
understanding (Usta, 2001:41). It mostly covers tourist trips to perform of the religious beliefs
and/or in order to see the centers of faith attraction in the evaluation of the tourism
phenomenon. In fact, religious and sacred sites are being visited more by curious tourists than
by spiritual pilgrims and therefore commodified and packaged for all tourists (Olsen, 2003;
Shackley, 2001).
Religious tourism often involves visiting holy cities of particular faiths of followers whose
journeys to these sites take place on the anniversaries of events that are of importance to their
religions. Traditionally, those involved in religious tourism were referred to as pilgrims. But,
in modern times that term is not widely used because of the many non-religious individuals
also embark on trips to holy sites. Many of these sites are of cultural or historical as well
as religious interest (http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-religious-tourism.htm).
The global revival of religious pilgrimage and tourism has occurred for several reasons
such as the rise of spirituality, growing share of old people, media coverage regarding
religious sites and events, the globalization of the local through the mass media, and seeking
peace and solace in an increasingly turbulent world (Egresi et al., 2012; Olsen and Timothy,
2006). For religious tourism, the commodity to be packaged is ancient or present day
religions, places and the rituals over worshipping attached to these belief systems (Örnek,
2002). People want these belief systems be protected and transferred to next generations so
that they could be able to keep their cultural identity and historical conscience. All ancient
place of worship, sacred sites, and pilgrimage shrines are important places of our existence
today and of our future objective.
Researchers state that public interest for religious tourism has grown in recent years
because of the economic potential of religious tourism (Olsen and Timothy, 2006).
Religiously motivated tourist or visitors of sacred places spend today more than they did in
the past (Wright, 2007), and they spend more for shopping than other groups of travelers (Bar
and Cohen-Tattab, 2003). Several advantages are seen for promoting and increasing market
share for religious tourism, including more tourists and possibly higher tourism earnings,
learning our cultural legacy, increased respect of the people of different religions who
worship in these places, learning to regard members of other religions and the improvement of
the peace on the world and the dialogue among religions (Olsen and Timothy, 2006; Örnek,
2002).
124
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Grabbing the benefits of religious tourism will be easier by adopting a marketing
perspective. In her book Brands of Faith, Einstein (2008) argues that religion has become a
product and accordingly faces competition not only from other religions but also from other
secular leisure activities. She even adds that repackaging religion is justifiable and necessary
to a certain degree. By adopting a similar perspective, trying to attract tourists to a city or a
religious site from other cities or countries for religious purposes can also be considered as
marketing of religion. Religious marketing calls for offering a product or better to say a
religious asset that best suits customers‟ needs like pilgrimage or moral satisfaction at a
reasonable cost and conveniently. Customers are also need to be informed about the merits of
traveling, seeing, and experiencing that religious monument or site.
2.2. Religious tourism in Turkey
There is no doubt that religious tourism has big potential to develop in Turkey,
considering just over hundred thousand religiously motivated tourists visiting the country in
2011 (Tourism Statistics, 2011). The country owns religious and sacred sites as well as
religious events and conferences and exhibitions of cultic objects that appeal to religious
adherents. Many religious events happened on this land; Turkey is home to many Christians,
Islamic and Jewish religious treasures. The believers desire to see the places where the events
described in their holy books have occurred and trace their cultural and religious roots on
foreign lands (Kasar 2002). Turkey has significant religious sites and biblical stories that are
summarized below to experience for religiously motivated tourists
(https://www.goturkey.com/en/pages/content/858; Fant and Reddish, 2003; Yenipınar, 2002).
Many locations in Turkey are mentioned in the Old Testament.
Ur or Şanlıurfa which is the birthplace of Abraham.
Harran which is the native town of Rebecca and Rachel. Abraham and Sarah moved
after having left Ur.
In the new Testament, Antioch was the place where the name “Christians” was first
used in reference to the followers of Jesus.
Mountain Ararat where Noah‟s Ark was grounded.
Garden of Eden, the plain between Tigris and Euphrates
Constantinople became the center of the church in the east. Hagia Sophia a former
Orthodox patriarchal basilica, later a mosque, and now a museum in Istanbul.
Cappadocia-the region of exceptional natural wonders, and a unique historical and
biblical heritage.
Saint Paul, the leading missionary of the Christian faith lived in Tarsus.
The seven churches, which are the first places that Apostle Paul visited in order to
promote Christianity, are in the Western Anatolia region of Turkey. Seven Churches of
Revelations: Ephesus, Sardes, Pergamon, Philadelphia Laodicia, Smyrna and Thyateira.
Christianity spread to Europe and the rest of the world through Anatolia.
The settlements in Aegean area have served as holy places and important sources
during the spread of Christianity. Christians who have fled the oppression in Jerusalem have
sought and found shelter in Anatolia.
Ephesus, where Virgin Mary spent her last years. After Jesus was crucified, St. John,
fearing for Virgin Mary‟s life decided to move her to Anatolia. Near Ephesus there is another
site of pilgrimage: the cave of the seven sleepers.
125
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Although Turkey has such an enormous potential for faith tourism there were few
arrangements for religious tours. For example, one of Turkey‟s leading inbound tour
operators, offers the 11-day Christian faith tour, 'In the Footsteps of St. Paul'. Groups can
explore the spiritual route of St. Paul across Turkey, including Antioch, Tarsus, Konya,
Pisidian Antioch (Yalvac) and the House of Virgin Mary in Izmir, the Grotto of St. Peter in
Antakya and the UNESCO World Heritage Sites of Hierapolis and Pamukkale.
(www.magister.com.tr).
It is known that there are many daily or weekly city tours to several Islamic values in
Turkey. The participants are mostly domestic tourists and retired or third age groups. Islam
supports in various tourism activities to enhance religious and social functions and to travel
for searching the beauty and creating adventure of Allah. The most important attractions for
Islamic tourists are Mevlana or Rumi –his shrine became a place of pilgrimage– (Konya),
Blue and Süleymaniye Mosques (İstanbul) Selimiye Mosque (Edirne), Divriği Grand Mosque
(Sivas), and Grand Mosque (Bursa).
In addition to the economical gains, Turkey can benefit from promoting faith or religious
tourism in several ways. One, religious tourism lower or dismiss the certain prejudices of the
guests. Visitors learn to respect the culture and humanity that exists in Turkey (Örnek, 2002).
Second, faith tourism gives the opportunity to the entrepreneurs to attract tourists year round
instead in its concentration during a short summer time. Third, the tourism demand for Turkey
is concentrated on Antalya, İstanbul and a narrow coastal area of Aegean and Mediterranean.
Other parts of the country could benefit from the development of tourism. Fourth, religious
places create a demand of accommodation around them (Baltazzi, 2002) and trigger other
infrastructural and economical development, thus, decreasing regional inequality and causing
more welfare.
Government officials, city planners, entrepreneurs and all stakeholders need to work
together to promote development of religious tourism. We have to protect Turkish and Islamic
works as well as works of Christianity and before (Örnek, 2002). Most of the religious values
today need repair, restoration, cleaning and signs for easy way of access. There should be
detailed information plaques in religious places so that visitors experience and gain the most
insights.
2.3. Religious tourism and monuments in Manisa
Acknowledged as the city of princes, Manisa has always been important in history due to
its strategic location, fertile lands, mythological Mount Sipylus (Spil), rich natural resources,
and fine climate. Thus, it‟s no surprise that the city was selected as the best city suitable for
investment among 200 cities worldwide by FDI magazine of Financial Times in 2004 (Genç,
2007:156) and as one of the top ten investment areas in the world for Chinese entrepreneurs in
2007 (www.mosb.org.tr, 2008). Also in the past, it was the last training ground for Mehmed
the Conqueror or Suleyman the Magnificent before becoming the Sultan of the Ottoman
Empire.
Having witnessed many civilizations, different cultures, and early periods of all three
major religions, Manisa is embellished with various historical and religious monuments.
Therefore, it is one of the prominent cities in Turkey in terms of faith tourism. In accordance
with the goals of this study, the potential of Manisa for faith tourism can be seen by looking at
some of these monuments.
Three out of the seven churches of Anatolia (or Asia Minor) mentioned in the apocalypse
section of the Bible are in Manisa. In addition to these significant churches, one of the oldest
synagogues in the world, Sardes Synagogue and many historical and famous mosques, tombs,
126
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
and dervish lodges are located in Manisa. Despite efforts to attract tourists to religious sites by
improving regarding infrastructure (wiring excavation sites, constructing public toilets, and
etc.) and enhancing promotional efforts (Manisa Guide, 2012:45-46), little progress has been
realized so far.
Thyateira Church (Akhisar)
Having a strategic location, Akhisar (historically Thyateira) has always been important in
terms of trade and military. Though the city was founded by Lydians and governed by
Seleucid and Pergamon Kingdoms, it was the time of Romans during when Christianity
spread in the region very quickly. Hence, the Thyateira Church became one of the famous
three churches in Manisa along with Philadelphia and Sardes that were mentioned in the
Bible. Other four churches in Anatolia which are also close to Manisa but founded in
neighbouring cities are Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamon, and Laodicia. However, it should be
noted that the term „church‟ used here is a reference to the early Christian communities lived
here rather than the physical church structures which may have been built later on (Manisa
Culture & Tourism Magazine, 2012:27; Manisa Municipality Booklet, 2008:74-76; Manisa
Leaflet, 2012). The ruins of the church structure in Thyateira which have substantial faith
tourism potential were uncovered during excavations at a place called Hill (Tepe) Cemetary
(Manisa Guide, 2012:34; Manisa Guide, 2007:102). Opened on August 6th, 2012, Akhisar
Museum gathered the historical artifacts of the city in one building which is located next to
the antique Thyateira. The museum building is 650 square meters and located inside a 1250
square meter garden (Manisa Culture & Tourism Magazine, 2012:24). The new museum can
be seen as a first step of efforts for increasing the faith tourism potential of Thyateira.
Philadelphia Saint Jean Church (Alaşehir)
Alaşehir is mostly established on Philadelphia antique city that is situated at a narrow
valley at the foot of Bozdağ. Among the remnants of the city are the debris of an ancient
theatre located at Toptepe and three columns of Saint Jean Church belonging to the first ages
of Christianity (Manisa Municipality Leaflet, 2012:10; Manisa Leaflet, 2012). Even though
the history of Alaşehir dates back to 3000 BC and has been glamorous during the Hittite era,
the new city named Philadelphia is believed to be rebuilt during the reign of Pergamum King
Attalos II 2nd century BC. In the excavations made in the 1980s, some relics including those
of Saint Jean Church have been unearthed. In the 6th century, the church was built with a
typical basilica plan and vaulted galleries. In later periods, some renovations and repairs have
been applied to the basilica. Among the few remnants of the church, giant elephant legs,
shows how magnificent the church was at its time. As mentioned in the apocalypse section of
the Bible, the city was a meeting place for the followers of Saint Paul (Dogan, 2012:39-43;
Manisa Guide, 2012:38; Manisa Guide, 2007:106).
Sardes (Sard) Church and Synagogue (Salihli)
As the capital of the antique Lydian Kingdom, Sardes is famous for inventing minted
coins, operating gold mines around the Paktolos River (Sart Stream), and the Sardes Church
mentioned in the Bible. The city also comprises a grand synagogue, thought to have been built
between AD 161 and 169, which points to the presence of a Jewish community in Sardes in
the past (Manisa Municipality Booklet, 2008:73; Manisa Guide, 2007:95; Ucar, 2008:25).
The structure of the synagogue is considered as a masterpiece and there is a gymnasium next
to it (Manisa Guide, 2012:28). Even though the city began to languish after 4th century AD, it
kept its importance to some extent as a commerce, transportation and administration hub until
7th century AD (Ucar, 2008:26; Manisa Touristic Inventory, 2003:43; Manisa Leaflet, 2012;
Manisa Municipality Leaflet, 2012:14).
127
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
In terms of religious monuments, there is a chapel which is located behind the Temple of
Artemis and thought to have been built in the 5th century and an impressive synagogue. In the
synagogue can be seen floor mosaics, ornamented walls with colored marble panels, and a
table used as altar (Aksakal, 2009). Also, over eighty inscriptions including six fragments in
Hebrew and the rest in Greek were found in the synagogue. It is probably the most
outstanding monument belonging to Jews in the Aegean region from Antiquity (Ghiuzeli,
2013).
Other Churches in Manisa
There are two other churches in Manisa that are noteworthy. First one is a wooden
Armenian Church said to be located in the Manisa Castle in the 17th century. It was seen by a
famous Armenian traveler, Simeon of Poland and written in his travel book (Manisa Guide,
2007:86). The other one is The Church of Virgin Mary in Kula. The church which dates back
to 1831 is one of the two churches left from the Orthodox congregation lived in the region.
After renovations, the building now serves as a cultural center (Manisa Culture & Tourism
Magazine, 2012:74-76).
Mosques
Among many mosques in Manisa, Ulu Mosque, Muradiye Mosque, and the Sultan
Mosque are the most famous ones due to different reasons like history, architect, and Mesir
festival.
Ulu Mosque
Ulu Mosque is the most important historical and religious monument left from the
Saruhanoglu Principality. It was built in 1366 by the order of Muzafereddin Ishak Bey and its
architect is Emet bin Osman. The complex was built in the north foot of Mount Spil and
comprises of a mosque, an old madrasah named Fethiye, a tomb where Ishak Celebi and his
family are believed to be buried, and a Turkish bath which was restored in 2006. There are
two fountains lying on each side of the madrasah‟s crown door. The madrasah was built on
the ruins of a Byzantine church. The mosque has a short bodied green, blue, yellow, and
purple colored minaret and its pulpit was built by a special wood carving technique called
kündekari. It can be considered as an ornamenting masterpiece of the principalities period.
The pulpit is now in the Manisa Museum (Manisa Guide, 2007:28; Manisa Guide, 2012:48;
(Manisa Municipality Booklet, 2008:44).
Muradiye Mosque
Muradiye mosque was built between 1583 and 1585 for Murat III. It is the only structure
of architect Mimar Sinan in the Aegean region. The construction was initially administered by
Mahmud Aga and then by Sedefkar Mehmed Aga upon the death of the previous one. The
mosque was built of cut-stone on a 'reverse T plan‟. The mosque has tremendous intricate
artworks inside just as its heavily decorated door. Its highly valuable marble pulpit is worth
mentioning. Madrasah of the complex has the classical Ottoman architectural style. Today,
madrasah and charitable establishment parts are used as museum. There is a library between
the madrasah and the mosque built by Huseyin Aga in 1812 (Manisa Guide, 2007:32; Manisa
Guide, 2012:52-53). Muradiye Mosque underwent significant restoration during the reign of
Abdülhamit II (Manisa Municipality Booklet, 2008:48).
Sultan Mosque
Ayse Hafsa Sultan, the mother of Kanuni Sultan Süleyman and the wife of Yavuz Sultan
Selim had the Sultan Mosque built in Manisa between 1522 and 1539. The surrounding
complex includes an almshouse, an inn, an elementary school, and a hospital (darussifa). The
128
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
architect of the complex is Ser Mimar Acem Alisi. The mosque has three domes and two
minarets. The soup kitchen and the inn in the complex collapsed due to the fire set by Greeks
in the Turkish War of Independence. Hospital building is currently being operated by Celal
Bayar University as a library. The mosque is also known as Mesir Mosque since the famous
Mesir Paste is scattered from the top of this mosque to public every year during the Mesir
Festival in March (Manisa Guide, 2007:30; Manisa Guide, 2012:52; Manisa Municipality
Leaflet, 2012:18; www.bayar.edu.tr, 2012).
Mevlevihane
Mevlevihane was built on an order by Ishak Celebi, the grandson of Saruhan Bey, in the
Northern skirts of Spil Mountain in 1369 and used as a Mevlevi dervish lodge until the end of
19th century. Its architect is Emet Bin Osman. A number of restorations were made
throughout centuries and the last one was carried out by Celal Bayar University in 2001.
Since 2005, it has been used as a museum operated by the same University. At the same time
it is used for cultural activities (Manisa Guide, 2007:42; Manisa Municipality Leaflet,
2012:48; www.bayar.edu.tr, 2012 ).
Kula Tapduk Emre Tomb
Tapduk Emre Tomb, which is similar to Saruhan Bey Tomb in Manisa, is an important
faith tourism destination in Emre Village, Kula. There are ten graves in the Tomb supposedly
belonging to Tapduk Emre and his family. One grave having an axe picture on its stone just in
front of the tomb‟s door is even said to be where Yunus Emre, famous poet and sufi dervish,
is buried. There are also two Turkish bath relics, a fountain, and a madrasah dating back to
AD 954 in the village (Manisa Guide, 2007:54).
Kula Carullah Bin Süleyman Mosque
The village where Tapduk Emre Tomb is located comprises another interesting temple,
Carullah bin Süleyman Mosque. The mosque was built in 1547 AD but later, in 1808
ornamented with pictures of scenery and tall apartments up to six storeys (Kula Municipality,
2013). It is hard to find such a mosque with pictures and intriguing to see those apartments
drawn at that time.
Other Mosques & Tombs & Dervish Lodges (Tekke)
Both in the city center and in its towns, Manisa has a number of other important historical
mosques (e.g. Ivaz Pasha Mosque, Cesnigir Mosque, Hatuniye Mosque), tombs (e.g. Yiğitbaşı
Veli Tomb, Ayn-ı Ali Tomb, Yirmiiki Sultanlar Tomb, Revak Sultan Tomb), and dervish
lodges (e.g. Entekkeliler of the Rufais, Kabak Tekkesi) that have significant touristic
potential.
3. Research Goal and Methodology
After reviewing the literature regarding faith or religious tourism, marketing of faith
tourism assets, and historical and religious monuments in Manisa, we determined to carry out
a qualitative study first, to assess the exact potential for reliigous tourism in Manisa and
second, to lead the way to increase that potential. In doing so, several depth interviews were
conducted with different parties related to the subject of this study.
As it would be very difficult to find experts who may have a word on the two research
goals cited above, snowball sampling is preferred to identify and reach them. People and
institutions regarding religious tourism were called, visited, and asked for the names of right
interviewees. As a result, a total of 13 interviews were arranged and successfully
accomplished.
129
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
The sample is comprised of at least one director, manager, or representative from each of
the following institutions: Provincial Directorate of Culture & Tourism, Governorship of
Manisa; Manisa Municipality Culture and Social Affairs Department; Manisa Museum; Celal
Bayar University‟s Institute of Social Sciences, Office of the Mufti in Manisa, Christian
Communities Association in Turkey, Manisa Rural Tourism Association, Akhisar Municipal
Assembly. Besides, two representatives from different travel agencies and a former city
mayor were interviewed just as the imam of a historical mosque in Manisa. The duration of
each interview was between 40 minutes and one hour. Since interviewees we contacted are
experts of one or a few aspects of the topic, they usually are not capable of answering all our
questions. Thus, we adopted a semi-structured interview and used probes as needed. As
Malhotra (2007:159) points out probing is used in all depth interviewing techniques and can
be seen as an integral part of them. At the end of each interview, we submitted a form
involving the questions we asked and requested that the form be returned to us completed in a
week. By that way, interviewees had the chance to present new ideas and make
recommendations on the topic in a wider time frame. The whole data collection phase took
place in one month.
The interview form consists of two sections and several questions. In the first section,
there are closed-ended questions on ranking the importance of religious monuments in Manisa
in terms of their religious tourism potential. In the second section, there are 11 open-ended
questions some of which touch on issues like infrastructure, employee related and similar
problems, current efforts and tours on religious tourism in the city, economic and social
effects of such tourism, and specific recommendations about growing faith tourism potential.
4. Findings
The findings of both literature review and the interviews conducted are presented
according to the order of questions in the interview form and can be seen as follows:
After a literature review on Manisa‟s religious assets, we ended up with over 80
monuments which may be potential candidates for religious tourism. Among them three
churches (Sardes Church, Thyateira Church, Philadelphia Saint Jean Church), three mosques
(Muradiye Mosque, Sultan Mosque, Ulu Mosque), and one synagogue (Sardes Synagogue)
evidently come to the fore almost with a consensus based on the interviews. At this point, we
need to divide the religious monuments into two groups since their target markets are
different: Christian / Jewish and Islamic.
Although Jews had a considerable population in Manisa until the beginning of 20th
century (Emecen, 1997), today no Jewish religious monument could be identified by the
researchers of this study other than the synagogue in Sardes. However, there are two other
churches that can be taken into account. First one is The Church of Virgin Mary in Kula that
is used as a cultural center nowadays. A few respondents think that it may also have religious
tourism potential but to some lesser degree. On the other hand, none of the respondents give a
similar chance to the Armenian church which does not exist right now but believed to be in
the Manisa castle once.
As far as Islamic monuments are concerned, Mevlevihane is a close follower of the three
major mosques. Other Islamic monuments which have quite religious tourism potential
according to some respondents are Kula Tabduk Emre Tomb, Kula Carullah Bin Süleyman
Mosque, Ayn-ı Ali Tomb, Yiğitbaşı Veli Tomb, and Hatuniye Mosque.
According to respondents, these are the mosques that are worth seeing in the towns of
Manisa: Hacı Recep Mosque, Kurşunlu Mosque, Necip Mosque, Çarşı Mosque, and Taş
Mahalle Mosque in Kula; Ulucami, Sheikh İsa Mosque, Sarı Ahmet Vefik Pasha Mosque, and
130
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Hergelen Mosque in Akhisar; Karaosmanoğlu Mosque, Sarıhoca Mosque, and Kabasakal
Mosque in Kırkağaç; Minareli Mosque, Kırkoluk Mosque, and Ulupınar Mosque in Soma;
Yıldırım Beyazıt Mosque and Sheikh Sinan Mosque in Alaşehir; Halime Hatun Mosque in
Gölmarmara; Halime Hatun Mosque in Turgutlu; İrezler Mosque in Demirci.
All respondents are certain that Manisa has enormous potential for religious tourism
provided that shortcomings are addressed. There seems to be a new awakening on the subject
but concrete steps are missing so far. However, everyone thinks that economic benefits of
such an endeavor will be huge.
Despite the fact that Manisa has tremendous potential in religious tourism, there are many
problems and shortcomings that need to be overcomed. In order to address this issue, we
asked what can be done in terms of infrastructure, transportation, and environment to attract
more tourists to the religious sites. As for the mosques and churches in city centers, parking
for buses is a serious problem along with toilet facilities especially for women. Also,
information boards are inadequate in almost every site. Not only there should be more of
these boards, but also their contents need to enriched and foreign languages used be varied.
Excavations at Thyateira and Philadelphia should be extended deeper to bring out more
historical remains and the surroundings of three churches and the synagogue be organized
better. For example, one respondent suggested building a little amphitheater without
destroying anything on the field so that tourist groups can listen to their guides and get
information about the churches and synagogue nearby these structures and seated at comfort.
The roads between any two destinations of these four sites are generally in good condition
with the exception of Akhisar – Salihli route. The road between these two towns through
Gölmara would better be repaired and enlarged.
There are mixed thoughts about hosting and dining services in the vicinity of the religious
sites. The number, quality, and price of these services may also differ between the city center
and its towns. Yet, most respondents share the opinion that these facilities and services will
not be sufficient in the long run and when demand jumps up.
An important source of income related to religious tourism is selling souvenirs and other
goods near the sites of attraction. For now, none of the respondents remembers selling of such
a product. Nevertheless, one respondent claims that Provincial Directorate of Culture &
Tourism, Governorship of Manisa performed a study last year to determine possible cultural
products to sell and a group of young entrepreneurs in Akhisar started production of some of
them. New products like miniatures of religious monuments may be added to that product line
and offered for sale at gift stores.
All respondents agree that new personnel are needed for religious tourism activities but
think quite differently about who should take part in these activities. It is assumed that current
guides usually do not have enough specific knowledge about the religious monuments in
Manisa. Two suggestions seem to be valid in terms of personnel. First one is training and
using current personnel of mosques in religious tourism with proper incentives. Second one is
finding, training, and using new religious tourism volunteers. If volunteers and guides are
specifically prepared for religious tourism and if they can be reached by calling a specific
phone number or applying a designated office, then the problem of personnel can be
alleviated effectively and with low cost. Also, authorities of the three celestial religions can
take part in training of personnel.
In Manisa Guide 2012, Provincial Directorate of Culture & Tourism, Governorship of
Manisa offers a religious tour option for those who are not travelling with an agency. The
outline of this tour is given below (Manisa Guide, 2012:202):
131
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Morning:
Akhisar Thyateira excursion site (Thyateira Church) (Manisa-Akhisar: 48 kilometers)
Break: Gölmarmara (Akhisar-Gölmarmara: 28 kilometers)
Bintepeler King Tombs
Sardes recreational site (Sardes Church and Synagogue)
Lunch: Salihli (Odun meatballs) (Gölmarmara-Salihli: 36 kilometers)
In the afternoon:
Alaşehir Philadelphia excursion site (St.Jean Church) (Salihli-Alaşehir: 38
kilometers) (Alaşehir-Manisa: 110 km)
In addition to this plausible tour option, travel agencies both in the city and nationwide
have tours destined to Manisa and its historical towns. The amateur tours operated by local
people and groups also benefit from travel agencies at least to meet legal conditions. Most of
these tours come to the major mosques in Manisa from neighboring cities. Overall, we see
that travel agencies can provide a tour option for those who want to see the religious sites in
Manisa. On the other hand, a sound and successful religious tourism organization seem to be
missing.
When we asked about the cooperation between central and local governmental
organizations on the subject, we noticed that there is strong desire but weak action. Increasing
the religious tourism potential of Manisa can be considered as a part of the city‟s recent
branding efforts. A specific team of experts from each organization can be formed and an
action plan be prepared to determine the steps to be taken regarding religious tourism. The
Governorship of Manisa can supervise the efforts and universities can contribute with their
knowledge, facilities, and expertise in education, marketing, and publishing.
It is known that that people with different faiths have lived together in peace for centuries
on this beautiful land. When asked about the possible change in social life and reactions to
rising number of religious tours, respondents had no worry about any negative consequence
and stressed the high degree of tolerance in the region. Some respondents even assert that
local people will benefit from religious tourism by having a wider perspective through
experiencing differences. Anyway, communities living around the sites would better be
informed and prepared about the importance and economic benefit of religious tourism.
The last question of the interview form calls for specific recommendations which
respondents might have to increase the religious tourism potential of Manisa. Since the
respondents are mostly experts of their fields, some of them came up with interesting ideas.
These ideas are meshed with findings from the literature review and answers to the other
questions and presented in the conclusion and discussion part.
5. Conclusion and Discussion
First and foremost, this study highlights the enormous potential of Manisa for religious
tourism. Based on experts‟ views, over 80 religious monuments in the city have been ranked
in terms of importance. At the top of the list are three churches (Sardes Church, Thyateira
Church, Philadelphia Saint Jean Church) and one synagogue (Sardes Synagogue) for
Christian and Jewish tourists and three mosques (Muradiye Mosque, Sultan Mosque, Ulu
Mosque) for Muslim tourists.
There are also many mosques in the towns of Manisa that are worth seeing such as Hacı
Recep Mosque, Kurşunlu Mosque, Necip Mosque, Çarşı Mosque, and Taş Mahalle Mosque in
132
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Kula; Ulucami, Sheikh İsa Mosque, Sarı Ahmet Vefik Pasha Mosque, and Hergelen Mosque
in Akhisar; Karaosmanoğlu Mosque, Sarıhoca Mosque, and Kabasakal Mosque in Kırkağaç;
Minareli Mosque, Kırkoluk Mosque, and Ulupınar Mosque in Soma; Yıldırım Beyazıt
Mosque and Sheikh Sinan Mosque in Alaşehir; Halime Hatun Mosque in Gölmarmara;
Halime Hatun Mosque in Turgutlu; and İrezler Mosque in Demirci.
The interviews conducted along with a literature review put forward a number of
suggestions about ways of increasing Manisa‟s potential for religious tourism. Below you can
find these striking recommendations and some of the interesting findings of this study:
The problems and shortcomings with regards to religious monuments and sites should
be overcomed. The need for repair and restoration in structures, improving information
boards, parking and other auxiliary services are some suggestions.
Hosting and dining services are believed to be insufficient in the long run. Accordingly,
necessary future arrangements should be planned.
Preparations for selling souvenirs (like miniatures of religious monuments) and other
religious and cultural goods near the sites of attraction can be made. A study conducted last
year by Manisa Provincial Directorate of Culture & Tourism, Governorship of Manisa to
determine possible cultural products to sell was detected.
New personnel and guides should be hired and trained for religious tourism activities.
New tour options can be planned for religious tourism in addition to the current one
proposed by Manisa Provincial Directorate of Culture & Tourism, Governorship of Manisa.
No negative reaction is expected in surrounding communities of the sites to the possible
rise in the number of religious tours.
A catalog needs to be written specifically for religious tourism. It may give detailed
information about religious monuments in Manisa and include a map and adequate knowledge
regarding hosting, dining, transportation, parking, and so on.
Brochures, booklets, and posters with the theme of religious tourism should be prepared
and sent to selected travel agencies, hotels, and religious schools and colleges both in Turkey
and in the world. Besides, participation to international tourism and travel fairs may be
considered. The countries with the highest percentage of Christians and high levels of
personal of income should be given special emphasis in promotion activities.
In addition to selling souvenirs (e.g., miniatures, postcards), local food (i.e., Mesir paste,
Mesir delight) and local drinks (i.e., Mesir tea, Sübye) can be offered at gift shops or stores to
be opened next to religious monuments.
A specific team of experts from each related organization can be formed and an action
plan be prepared to determine the steps to be taken regarding religious tourism. A wise
planning and an effective implementation of religious tourism efforts require an intense
coordination among parties such as The Provincial Directorate of Culture & Tourism -
Governorship of Manisa, Manisa Municipality Culture and Social Affairs Department, Celal
Bayar University (Institute of Social Sciences and Departments related to History, Turkish
Literature, Tourism, Marketing and Music), Office of the Mufti, Manisa Museum, Manisa
Rural Tourism Association, Council of Monuments, Directorate General of Foundations,
Directorate General of Religious Affairs, Christian Communities Association in Turkey,
Chief Rabbinate of Turkey, The Association of Turkish Travel Agencies, and The Chamber of
Izmir Tourist Guides. All these stakeholders should be consulted but don‟t need to take part
actively in implementation. The Governorship of Manisa can supervise the implementation
133
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
process and Celal Bayar University can contribute with its knowledge, facilities, and expertise
in education, marketing, and publishing.
The new generation in Manisa, Salihli, Akhisar, and Alaşehir can be educated on
religious tourism assets in their city and its towns. For example, puppet shows, cartoons, and
school trips may be used in kindergartens and schools towards that goal.
New museums or new sections specific to artifacts of the religious structures are
necessary as there is limited space for them in museums. There are many religious artifacts
like crosses, incense burners which are not on exhibition in museums due to space limitations.
The religious tourism activities would better be merged with those of other types of
tourism. For example, those who come to Manisa to see historical mosques and tombs can
have an organic breakfast at Mount Spil watching the view of Manisa city and Gediz Plain;
and the tourists of Sardes can be given a chance to enjoy thermal springs of Salihli.
With the rising popularity of experiential and event marketing, tourists coming to
Manisa to see religious monuments will be better off experiencing the atmosphere of these
monuments. To that end, sufi music concerts, poetry days, and religious conversations can be
organized once or twice a week and be scheduled in accord with tour programs. Likewise,
personnel working at the historical sites can wear costumes of old times. For example, tourists
may see personnel, animators, or folk dancers at Sardes in Lydian costume and at
Mevlevihane in Dervish clothes.
The implementation of all the activities suggested above should be based on a well-
designed plan. The sequence of activities is very important. For example, the starting point
should be the „product‟, which in this case refers to historical monuments and sites. It‟s no use
calling in tourists from all over the world before structures are restorated, guides are trained,
and the whole process is organized.
Finally, we should keep in mind that it will take time for Manisa to become an
outstanding touristic point of attraction. After all, „patience‟ is a great virtue of life leading to
success, which has been adopted by societies of all the three celestial religions lived in
Manisa.
This study has some limitations though. Firstly, the findings are based on a qualitative
study which limit their generalizability. Yet, the sample of interviewees is fairly large and
utmost attention is given to the selection of them. Secondly, despite our efforts, we were
unable to reach a representative reflecting the views of Jewish people. Although there is just
one historical synagogue in Sardes, learning the views of all parties related to religious
monuments in Manisa would be better. In the future, more stakeholders can be involved in the
data collection process. Also, the views of general public on the topic can be investigated
through surveys in order to determine the details of religious tourism activities.
References
Aksakal, A.H. (2009). Sardes - The capital city of the Lydia Kingdom. Manisa: Emek
Publishing.
Aktaş, A. and Ekin, Y. (2007). Case study 5: The importance and the role of faith (religious)
tourism as alternative tourism resources in Turkey. In R.Raj and N.Morpeth (Eds), Religious
Tourism and Pilgrimage Festivals Management: An International Perspective, (pp.170-183).
Wallingford, UK.CABI Publishing.
Baltazzi, A. (2002). We cannot have faith tourism before we stop wars. The Book of the Faith
Tourism Days. (p.165-167). October 23-27. Kuşadası: Şubat yayıncılık.
134
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Bar, D. and Cohen-Hattab, K. (2003). New kind of pilgrimage: The modern tourist pilgrim of
nineteenth century and early twentieth century Palestine. Middle Eastern Studies, 39 (2), 131-
148.
Dogan, U. (2012). The Religious Brotherhood Hidden in History. Manisa Culture & Tourism
Magazine, January-February, Provincial Director of Culture and Tourism, Lamineks
Publishing, No.3.
Egresi, I., Bayram, B., Kara, F. and Kesik, O.A. (2012). Unlocking the potential of religious
tourism in Turkey. Geo Journal of Tourism and Geosites, 9 (1), 63-79.
Einstein, M. (2008). Brands of Faith: Marketing Religion In A Commercial Age. NY, USA:
Routledge.
Emecen, F.M. (1997). Unutulmuş Bir Cemaat Manisa Yahudileri. İstanbul: Eren Publishing.
Fant C.E.and Reddish, M.G. (2003). A guide to biblical sites in Greece and Turkey. New
York: Oxford University Press.
Genç, F. (2007). Turkey Real Estate Yearbook 2007. Real Estate Publishers.
Ghiuzeli,H.F.(2013). The Ancient Synagogue of Sardis. http://www.bh.org.il/database-
article.aspx?48726, 13.01.2013.
http://www.bayar.edu.tr/eng/Campus_Life/social_facilities.html, 13.01.2013.
http://www.mosb.org.tr/EN/HaberOku.asp?i=3, (2008). The Best Industrial Zone To Invest In
(10.01.2013).
Kasar, J. (2002). Faith tourism will make Turkey stand out in the world. The Book of the Faith
Tourism Days. (p.152-155).October 23-27. Kuşadası: Şubat yayıncılık.
Kula Municipality (2013). http://www.kula.bel.tr/pages/carullah-bin-suleyman-camii.html,
13.01.2013.
Malhotra, N. K. (2007). Marketing Research – An applied orientation, 5th Edition, New
Jersey, USA: Pearson Education, Inc.
Manisa Culture & Tourism Magazine (2012). December-January, Provincial Director of
Culture and Tourism, Lamineks Publishing, No.5.
Manisa Guide (2007). Manisa Governorship Introduction and Culture.
Manisa Guide (2012). Manisa Governorship Introduction and Culture.
Manisa Leaflet (2012). The cradle of culture and civilizations. Provincial Directorate of
Culture & Tourism, Governorship of Manisa.
Manisa Municipality Booklet (2008). Yapım: AdRhPositive.
Manisa Municipality Leaflet. (2012). Manisa Historical and Touristic Sites.
Manisa Touristic Inventory. (2003). Provincial Directorate of Culture & Tourism,
Governorship of Manisa.
Olsen, D.H. (2003). Heritage, tourism and the commodification of religion. Tourism
Recreation Research, 28 (3), 99-104.
Olsen, D.H. and Timothy, D.J. (2006). Tourism and religious journeys. In D.J.Timothy and
D.H.Olsen (Eds), (p.1-21). Tourism, Religion and Spritual Journeys. New York: Routledge.
Örnek, Y. (2002). The sector needs depth to manage faith tourism. The Book of the Faith
Tourism Days. (p.143-147).October 23-27. Kuşadası: Şubat yayıncılık.
135
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Rinschede, G. (1992). Forms of religious tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 19 (1), 51–67.
Rundquist, K. (2010). Leap of Faith. Religious tourism report, ASTA Network, Autumn, 40-
43.http://www.jewishtravelagency.com/JewishTravel/ASTA0810_040_REV-FINAL.pdf
Shackley, M. (2001). Managing sacred sites: service provision and visitor experience.
London: Continuum.
Tandoğan, U. and Avcı, E. (2012). Kuşadası‟ndaki seyahat acentalarının İzmir‟in inanç
turizmi potansiyelini değerlendirme performansı üzerine bir uygulama. Seyahat ve Otel
İşletmeciliği Dergisi, 9 (2), 17-33.
Tourism Statistics (2011). Turkish Statistical Institute. Ankara.
www.turkstat.gov.tr/IcerikGetir.do?istab_id=69
Travel and Tourism Economic Impact, (2012). Turkey. World Travel and Tourism Council.
http://www.wttc.org/site_media/uploads/downloads/turkey2012.pdf
Uçar, M. (2008). Antik Kral Yolunda Zümrüt Bir Kent – Salihli, Salihli Municipality, Bursa:
Cansal Publishing.
Ulusoy B.and Yılmaz, M.N. (2002). After the faith tourism days. The Book of the Faith
Tourism Days. (p.9-10). October 23-27. Kuşadası: Şubat yayıncılık.
Usta, Ö. (2001). Genel Turizm. İzmir: Anadolu Matbaacılık.
Vukonic, B. (1998). Religious Tourism: Economic Value or Empty Box, Zagreb International
Review of Economics and Business, 1 (1), 83-94.
WTO (2012). http://mkt.unwto.org/sites/all/files/docpdf/unwtohighlights12enlr.pdf
Wright, K.(2007). Religious tourism: a new Era, a dynamic industry. Leisure Group.
Yenipınar, U. (2002). The Book of the Faith Tourism Days. (p.159-161). October 23-27.
Kuşadası: Şubat yayıncılık.
136
The Role Of Service Quality In Promoting Tourism Development In Obudu
Mountain Resort
Enemuo,O.B & Barra TEMPLE
Department of hotel management and tourism
Micheal okpara university of agriclture umudike
Nigeria
Abstract
This work evaluated the role of quality hospitality service in promoting tourism development
in Obudu mountain resort. Service quality is an attitude or global judgment about the
superiority of service; it is the result of the comparism that customers make between their
expectation about a service and their perception of the way the service has been performed.
Quality service is an essential part of the tourists’ experience; thus, a crucial aspect of
satisfying tourist. The objectives of the research were to identify the various services offered
to tourist at the resort, evaluate how tourists perceive the quality of service offered at the
resort and to determine the effect of quality hospitality service on tourists’ intention to revisit
the resort and on the profit margin of the hospitality establishment in the destination.
Data of this research was generated using quantitative technique. Simple frequency
percentages and mean were used to analyze the data generated for the study. The findings of
the analysis revealed that quality hospitality service has an effect on tourist intention to revisit
the resort, profitability of the establishment and consequently, tourism development.
However, certain ancillary services have to be provided in order to make guest/tourist stay
worthwhile. It is however important that stakeholders and managers in tourism industry
combine the resources at their disposal; both human and capital in a flexible design to meet
the needs of tourists/guests and if possible surpass their expectation.
Introduction
Tourism is a multi faceted activity; its complexity makes the concept difficult to define.
Tourism experts define the term from their perspectives; however, there is a general
consensus that tourism involves travel (Odutan, 2010). Tourism comprises of activities of
people travelling to and staying in places outside their usual environment for not more than
one consecutive year for leisure, business or other purposes (Holden, 2008).Tourism in
Nigeria is still in its infancy, considering the large accumulation of resources which are yet
untapped (Dantata, 2011). Among these are the size of the country and its rapidly developing
structure (Anji, 2008). Despite the abundant sunshine characteristics of the tropical
environment, the length and breadth of the country offers attractive tourism resources
manifested in physical resources, like magnificent waterfalls, impressive rock formations,
beautiful landscapes, vast tracts of unspoiled nature ranging from coastline of natural beaches,
unique wildlife/ecotourism resources, abundant monuments and museums, rich cultural
heritage/resources of great historical antecedents and man-made resources (Yemi, 2008).
The hospitality industry includes lodging, accommodation, restaurant, event planning,
cruise lines and ancillary activities in the tourism industry (Charles, 2004). Hospitality is the
action of being hospitable in other words welcoming, helpful and providing a service for
someone who is visiting (Goeldner, Ritchie and Mclntosh, 2008).Goeldner, Ritchie and
Mclntosh, (2008) opined that hospitality is one of the four categories of resources in tourism
supply, a product of the tourist receiving destination. Consequently these resources are the
basics or prerequisite for tourism development (Philip, John and James, 2006). Westone
(2003) however, noted that the boundaries between tourism, travel and hospitality are not easy
137
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
to define, because they blend into and overlap one another. Emphatically, there is just a thin
line between hospitality and tourism; tourists require an overnight stay for tourism to be
complete (Holden, 2008). As stated earlier, the hospitality industry includes lodging and
accommodation, which is a requirement for tourism to be complete.
To succeed in the international tourism market place, a destination must ensure that its
overall attractiveness and the integrity of the experience it delivers to visitors must equal or
surpass that of many alternative destinations open to the potential visitors (Larry and
Chulivon, 2003). Hence, the need for this study; to bring to light the importance of the quality
service that is offered to tourists /visitors and its role in promoting tourism development and
consequently economic development.
The relative large number of tourism destination available both nationally and
internationally has intensified competition between destinations for tourists. In addition,
changes in technology and consumers taste means that tourism products and services have
shortening life cycles, this leads to the need to continually innovate and adapt tourism product
offerings. These and other factors prompted the study of the role of service quality in
promoting tourism development in Obudu mountain resort.
Objectives Of The Study
The major objective of this research is to evaluate the role of service quality in promoting
tourism development.
The specific objectives are to:
1. To identify the various services offered to tourists by Obudu mountain resort.
2. To determine tourists’ perception of the quality of services offered by Obudu
Mountain resort.
3. To determine the influence of service quality on tourists’ intention to revisit the
destination.
4. To determine the effect of service quality on the profit margin of the hospitality
establishment at the destination.
5. To verify ways to improve the quality of services offered by hospitality establishments
at the destination.
Methodology
Research design
The study used survey research design.
Area of study
This study was carried out in Obudu mountain resort in Cross River State. The state of
Cross River is located on longitude 5⁰45 N and latitude 8⁰30 N. The state was created on the
27th of May 1967. It has an area of 20,156km2 (7,782 Sqmile) and a density of 93km2 (240
sqmil).
Population for the study
The population for the study consisted of guests lodging in the resort and the management
of the hotel as at the time the study was carried out. The population of the study however
consisted of a hundred and fifty nine (159) guests/tourists (This information was gotten from
the guest register) and six (6) top managers.
138
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Sample and sampling techniques
The sample size was determined using the yaro yamani formula, which states:
Where: n = Sample size
1 = constant
N = Population
e = margin of error
Calculated thus: n =
n = 113.77
n = 114
This yielded a total of one hundred and fourteen (114) respondents and six (6) managers
who formed the sample of the study. The sample of the study was determined by simple
random and purposive sampling techniques. Guests lodging in the resort were randomly
selected and the top managers of the resort were purposively selected
Instrument for data collection
The study employed quantitative methods of data collection. The instrument used for the
study was a questionnaire. The structured questionnaire was divided into three sections.
Section A centred on the respondents demographic characteristics, Section B the purpose of
visit and the respondents perception of the quality of service offered. Section C contained
questions on management’s maximization of profit. The questionnaire used the likert scale
with the following keys;
1- Very poor
2 – Poor
3 – Good
5 – Excellent
4 – Very good
Data collection techniques
The researcher administered 98 questionnaires by hand to guests/tourists at obudu
mountain resort, Cross River while 16 questionnaires were administered by the staff at the
reception. The researcher had an assistant who administered 6 questionnaires by hand to top
managers at obudu mountain resort and collected the completed questionnaires on the spot.
However, the questionnaires administered to guests/tourists were retrieved on the spot by the
researchers while the other questionnaires administered by the staff at the reception were all
returned to the reception. 114 completed questionnaires were collected from guests/tourists
and 6 completed questionnaires were collected from top managers at the resort.
139
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Data analysis techniques
Simple descriptive analysis was used to analyse objective one, three and five; objective
two was analysed using the five point likert scale.
The total score of the five levels of perception was fifteen (15) that is, the summation of
5,4,3,2 and 1. The average (mean) of these perceptions was 3.0; any response with a mean of
3.0 and above was regarded as agreed (indicating quality service) while any response below
3.0 was regarded as disagreed (indicating poor service quality). The grand mean (clustered
mean) was used to assess the overall quality of service offered by the resort.
The grand mean used was calculated using the formula below
Where ∑x = summation of means
n = number of means
RESULT AND DISCSSION
RESEARCH QUESTION ONE: What are the various services offered by the hospitality
establishment in Obudu mountain resort?
Table 4.1 Distribution of additional services offered by the hotel.
Option Frequency Percentage
24 hours room service - -
Laundry/dry cleaning service 84 73.7
Business centre/internet service 102 89.5
Sporting facilities 114 100
Travel agency 102 89.5
Banking services 114 100
Shops 114 100
Car hire service 114 100
Concierge service 90 78.9
Table 4.1 above showed that none of the respondents stated 24 hours room service as an
additional service offered by the hotel, 73.7% stated laundry/dry cleaning service as an
additional service offered by the hotel, 89.5% stated business centre/internet service as an
additional service offered by the hotel, 100% stated sporting facilities as an additional service
offered by the hotel, 89.5% stated travel agency as an additional service offered by the hotel,
100% stated banking services ,shops and car hire service as an additional service offered by
the hotel, while 78.9% stated concierge service as an additional service offered by the hotel.
RESEARCH QUESTION TWO: How do tourists perceive the quality of service offered
by hospitality establishment in Obudu mountain resort?
140
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Table 4.2 Perception of service quality by respondents
S/N PERCEPTION OF SERVICE QUALITY TOTAL SCORE MEAN DECISION
1. The resort has a good physical environment of the hotel. 546 4.8 AGREED
2. The staff at the front desk are courteous 504 4.4 AGREED
3. The hotel staff are orderly and neat time 474 4.2 AGREED
4 The hotel staff perform well at the first 468 4.1 AGREED
5. The service offered by the hotel staff is efficient as regards time 396 3.5 AGREED
6. The decor and furnishing of the lobby area and room are attractive 510 4.5 AGREED
7. The room furnishing are comfortable 510 4.5 AGREED
8. The hotel/s room service is standard 198 1.7 DISAGREED
9. There is a speed of service delivery 342 3 AGREED
10. There is a high standard of the restaurant and 474 4.2 AGREED
Bar service; food and beverage offered by the hotel
11. There are high fire safety facilities and security measures in the hotel 450 3.9 AGREED
12 The management give individual attention to the guest 384 3.4 AGREED
13. The hotel offer quality of service 474 4.2 AGREED
TOTAL 6168 54.2
CLUSTER MEAN 3.9
Source: Field survey 2012
Table 4.2 above showed that the respondents indicated that they like the physical
environment, the staff at the front desk are courteous, the staff appear orderly and neat, they
had a good check-in procedure, the hotel’s staff performed the service well the first time, the
services offered by the hotel’s staff is efficient as regards time, the décor and furnishing of the
lobby area and room are attractive, the room furnishing is comfortable, a speedy service
delivery, a good restaurant and bar service; food and beverage, good fire safety facilities and
security measures, the management gives a good amount of attention to guest, the hotel offers
quality service and had 4.8, 4.4, 4.2, 3.8, 4.1, 3.5, 4.5, 4.5, 3, 4.2, 3.9, 3.4 and 4.2 means
respectively. While respondents stated that the hotel’s room service is poor and had a mean of
1.7. This indicated that guests perceive that the hotel offers quality service considering the
clustered mean of 3.9 (from decision rule any mean response of 3.0 and above should be
regarded as quality service).
RESEARCH QUESTION THREE: What is the effect of quality hospitality services on
tourists’ intention to revisit the destination?
Table 4.3 Tourists’ intention to revisit the hotel again.
Option Frequency Percentage
Yes108 94.7
No 6 5.3
TOTAL 114 100%
Source: Field survey 2012
141
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Table 4.3 showed that 94.7% of the respondents have the intention to visit the hotel again,
while 5.3% of the respondents stated they do not have the intentions to visit the hotel again.
RESEARCH QUESTION FOUR: What is the effect of quality service on the profit
margin of the hospitality establishment in the destination?
Table 4.4 Rate of profit maximization
Option Frequency Percentage
1% - 20% - -
21% - 40% - -
41% - 60% 1 16.7
61% - 80% 3 50
81% - 100% 2 33.7
Table 4.4 showed that 16.7% of top managers started 41% - 60% rate of profit
maximization, 50% stated 61% - 80% rate of profit maximization, while 33.3% stated
81% - 100% as rate of profit maximization.
RESEARCH QUESTION FIVE: In what ways can the quality of service offered by the
hospitality establishment in Obudu mountain resort be improved?
Table 4.5: The ways by which the resort can improve its services.
Option Frequency Percentage
Offering of room service 114 100
Increase in speed of service delivery 36 31.6
Provision of constant power supply 114 100
Table 4.5 showed that 100% of the respondents stated that the hotel can improve its
services by offering room service, 31.6% stated that an increase in the speed of service
delivery can improve the services offered by the hotel while 100% stated that the provision of
constant power supply can improve the services offered by the resort.
DISCUSSION OF FINDINGS
Table 4.2 showed that the respondents stated that the services offered by the hospitality
establishment in Obudu mountain resort were laundry/dry cleaning services, business
centre/internet services, sporting facilities, travel agency, banking services, shops, car hire
service and concierge service. All of the respondents stated sporting facilities, banking
services, shops and car hire services as services offered Obudu mountain resort. Also a few of
the respondents did not state laundry/dry cleaning service, business centre/internet service,
travel agency and concierge service as services offered by the hospitality establishment and
none of the respondents stated 24 hour room service as a service offered by the hospitality
establishment in Obudu mountain resort. This is in line with an article on city-hotel.com that
stated that other services offered to guests of a hotel can be considered as bonuses; they are
laundry service, fitness and gyms, banking services and many other things. These services can
142
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
be included in in the price of the room or paid separately. Recently the new trend is the
separation of the service sectors in hotels.
Table 4.3 showed respondents’ perception of service quality. This indicated that guests’
perceive they are offered quality service because the clustered mean of the overall responses
was 3.9 which were higher than the decision rule that stated that any mean response above 3.0
should be regarded as high quality service. Quality or service is whatever the guest perceives
it to be; services are subjectively experienced process where production and consumption take
place simultaneously, thus buyer – seller interactions or service encounters have a critical
impact on perceived service; as Chin-Tsai Kuo (2007) stated that the need to explore
perceptions of tourists in order to satisfy their demand was motivation for his study and his
findings showed that perception of service quality was affected by even age group.
Table 4.4 showed that majority of the respondents stated they had intention to revisit the
destination as a result of the quality of service offered in Obudu mountain resort, this is in line
with Baker and Crompton (2008) that service quality influences tourists’ revisit intentions; a
higher service quality will more likely bring visitors back. Kozak (2001) defining revisiting
stated it as the willingness of tourists to travel other touring spots in a certain destination or in
the same country.
Table 4.5 showed that quality service has a positive effect on the profit management of
the hospitality establishment.50% of the respondents stated 61% - 80% was stated as the rate
of profit maximization, 33.3% of the respondents stated 81% - 100%, while 16.7% of the
respondents stated 41% - 60% as the rate of profit maximization for the first half of the year,
2012. This corresponds with Ehigie (2006) which suggest that there is a significant
relationship between quality service and customer loyalty retention; and when this happens;
the profitability of an establishment would increase. Consequently, the obvious need for
satisfying a firms’ customer is to expand the business, gain a high market share and to acquire
repeat and referral business; all of which will lead to improved profitability (Bersky, 1992)
Table 4.6 showed that all of the respondents indicated that offering of room service by the
hospitality establishment and the provision of constant power supply as ways to improve the
quality of service offered. Also 31.6% indicated increase in the speed of service delivery as a
way to improve the quality of service offered in Obudu mountain resort. This is line with
Dantata (2011) that the development of a complete of a tourism package (adequate lodgings,
transportation, standard infrastructure and other ancillary services and providing prompt and
courteous service will not only attract tourist, but encourage the visitors to spend money and
most importantly come back. Alizera et al (2007) stated that dimensions such as quality of
accessibility, infrastructures and quality of service offered have significant, direct and positive
relationship with satisfaction of tourist, their intend to return to the destination and eventually
the development of tourism in a region. Therefore to achieve competitive advantage and
ensure the overall satisfaction of guests/tourists, tourist destinations need to improve the
quality of service they offer.
Major Findings
The major findings of the study are:
1. Obudu mountain resort offers certain ancillary services to guests/tourists but does not
offer 24 hours room service; detracting the overall quality of service being offered to
tourists/guests.
2. The physical environment, room decor and furnishings and quality of food and
beverage offered to guests/tourists enhance the quality of service, creating an intention for
most guests/tourists to revisit the destination.
143
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3. The quality of service offered to guests/tourists has a positive effect on the
profitability of the establishment, the revenue generated by the resort and the economic
activities in the destination.
4. The quality of service offered by Obudu mountain resort can be improved, if the resort
offers 24 hours room service and provides a constant power supply.
Conclusion
This work has attempted to evaluate the role of quality hospitality service in promoting
tourism development in Obudu mountain resort. For the best indicators of service quality in
the tourism sector, the tourists’ experience might be the key indicator. Consequently, the
quality of service involved in tourism plays an important role in the process of delivery
(Whylie, 2000). Furthermore service quality is intangible and should be a crucial area interest
to providers of tourist services, if they are to cause tourist revisit and increase the economic
activities in the destination; which would in turn lead to tourism development.
5.3 Recommendations
The following recommendations were drawn from the findings of the research work.
1. Management of hospitality establishments should create a flexible service design that
would deliver quality service in order to always meet the ever changing needs of guests
2. Infrastructures such as assessable roads, efficient communication, constant power
supply should be put in place at potential tourist destinations to enhance the overall tourist
experience
3. Government and stakeholders in the hospitality and tourism industry should formulate
policies that would ensure an effective delivery of quality service to guests’/tourists’ and the
strict compliance of these policies.
Refernces
Aryi, C . (2004). An investigation of perceived value dimensions: Implications for hospitality
research. Journal of Travel Research, 42,226-234.
Chin-Tsaikuo, V. (2007). Targets and standards of quality in sport services.
Sport Management Review, 3, 1-22.
Ehigie, H.(2008). Investigating ways of public participation in
Tourism Development, Journal of Cultural Management Research, before, third pre-
issue,Tehran, Iran.
Holden, A. (2008). Environment and Tourism. 2nd edition. Canada: Routledge.
Kozak, P. (2001). Marketing, 5th Edition, PearsonEducation, Frenches Forest, Australia. Eda
Antilgan; Serkan Akinci; Safak Aksoy Managing Service Quality; 2003; 13, 5; ABI/INFORM
Global pg. 412
Philips V.,John, D., & James, S. (2006). Tourist satisfaction in Singagpore - a perspective
fromIndonesian tourists. Managing Service Quality, 13(5), 399-411.
Weston, N. (2003). Delivering quality service:Balancing customer perceptions and
expectations. New York, N.Y.: Free Press.
Yemi, C. V. (2004). Cross-cultural invariance of measures of satisfaction and service quality.
Journal of BusinessResearch, 57, 901-912.
144
Being ‘the European other’: Codification and commodification of Ottoman
Heritage in Bosnia & Herzegovina
Dr. Senija Causevic,
University of London, School of Oriental and African Studies, London, UK
senija.causevic@soas.ac.uk
Dr. Derek Bryce
University of Strathclyde, Business
School, Glasgow, UK
derek.bryce@strath.ac.uk
Abstract
This research examines the role of tourism in the construction of what the Balkan means in
modern European discourse. Empirical research, in the form of deep participant observation
of the guided tours, and the interviews with the tour guides on the interpretation of Ottoman
Heritage, namely Islamic, Jewish and Christian, took place in Bosnia and Herzegovina‟s cities
of Sarajevo, and Mostar. The research findings are in line with Zizek‟s and Todorova‟s
argument that in modern European discourse, the Balkans are presented as the ‘European
other’, thus creating a binary discourse of what belongs to Europe and what is considered to
be still internal, but European „other‟. For the purpose of generic tourism interpretation and
easy commercial gain, the complex and syncretic Ottoman history in Bosnia and Herzegovina
(B&H) is simplified and truncated so that it actually reinforces this wider binary discourse,
i.e. the binary between east and west, whereas west is represented as Christianity and east is
represented as Islam. Being unaware of the consequences of such a simplification, tourism
may contribute further divisions in Europe, allowing the „seduction‟ of decision makers with
some dubious potential short-term gains. This practice overlooks reconciliatory aspects which
tourism may bring with some more historically grounded interpretation which take into an
account a syncretic nature of Ottoman laws. Through the lens of heritage codification, this
research argues that Ottoman heritage should not be taken for granted, and tourism activities
need to be recognised not only as an economic enhancer, but an interpretation of the religious
heritage built during the Ottoman period in B&H, plays an important part of the total process
of normalisation of social relationships, not only in B&H itself, but it also has implications on
European identity. We thus investigate the interpretation of Ottoman heritage in order not
only to enhance the possibility of deeper understanding of shared history and identity amongst
the country‟s people, but also to highlight the significance of B&H and the wider Ottoman
context as important markers of ways of being European that need not depend upon binary
spatial divisions of „east and west‟ or „Christendom and Islam‟. We note, however, the
intersection of the utility of that binary both for certain strains of ethno-nationalist opinion in
BH as well as a commercial heritage sector of tourism driven to offer the country up in a
familiar, consumable narrative.
Keywords: Ottoman heritage, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Tourism
1. Introduction
This research examines the role of tourism in the construction of the meaning of the
Balkans and its relation to the construction of European identity in the modern European
discourse. The starting point of this research is the premise argued by Jeffrey, (2008),
Todorova, (2000), and Zizek, (2008) that European identity is created through imagining a
145
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
binary between Europe and European other, i.e. the Balkans which was imagined as
primordial and exotic part of Europe. In that particular context, Jeffrey (2008) explores
European‟s discoursive reaction, and its need to pose a „Balkanist‟ anxiety (Todorova, 2009)
in order to construct its own identity, thus quarantining the Balkans as the land of „primordial
evil‟ (ibid). The research deploys the term ‘Balkanism’, a term coined by Todorova (1996)
which is analogous to Said‟s (1978) term ‘Orientalism’ where Balkan is positioned as
European „internal other’ whereas Said‟s ‘orient’ is ‘external other’ thus cannot be a part of
the concept. Jeffrey (2008) considers this particular narrative to be ‘normative and
mainstream’ in the European sense. This particular narrative, in its untamed sense, has
unfortunately been used by some right wing nationalist Serbian and Croatian ideologies in
former Yugoslavia for a purpose of keeping European identity by violently externalising
Islam in Europe (ibid) through exterminating Muslim population in the Balkan. Similar
narrative has also been utilised by some contemporary fascist movements around Western
Europe [author observation]. In that sense this binary discourse could be positioned as a
background and excuse for doing genocide in Srebrenica for instance, so that Islam is kept
away from European identity (ibid).
The Western European attitude towards the Balkans, Zizek (2008) illustrates through his
analysis of the movies directed by Emir (Nemanja) Kusturica which have the Balkans as their
settings. These movies are very popular in Western Europe. Zizek coined the term ‘reverse
racism’ in order to explain the popularity of Kusturica‟s movies, especially the movie
„Underground‟ in the west. Basically Zizek (1999, 2008) argues that because the Balkans are
a part of Europe, they can be spoken of in a racist clichés which would not be dared to be
applied to Asia or Africa, as Zizek argues, „Political struggles in the Balkans are compared to
ridiculous operetta plots.‟ Fascist radical atrocities which some of the paramilitary Serbian
formations did in Bosnia were actually downplayed in the movie thus presenting the war in
the carnivalesque way, as Bosnian novelist Aleksandar Hemon pose it, ‘as a collective
savage madness’.
Zizek (2008) argues that European self is actually constructed through positioning and
imagining the Balkans as European lower self, as pointed here, „When discussing the
Balkans, the tolerant [European] multiculturalist is allowed to act out his repressed racism and
treat the Balkans in a racist clichés‟. One of the issues which allows to speak about Balkan in
racist clichés is Islam which acts as a point to strengthen the binary between what belongs to
Europe and what does not.
Orient is, as Said (1978) argued, constructed as European external other, Balkans is
constructed as European internal other. What both Balkans and Orient have in common is the
Ottoman Empire. We conceptualise our research by taking Todorova‟s argument (1996)
where Balkan is represented as the Ottoman legacy, and not to conceptualise it in a sense of
Ottoman legacy in the Balkans. Further, we supplement Delanty‟s (2003) argument of the
Ottoman-Islamic constellation as being essentially European. The full scope of an enquiry
into the interplay of these prevailing and potential narratives of Europe(s) is beyond the scope
here. Our focus is moderated to an extent by the fact that Bosnia and Herzegovina (B&H) is a
former Ottoman Eyalet (province) where the socio-cultural legacy of Ottoman imperial rule as
‘management and maintenance of difference’ (Barkay, 2008) is particularly pronounced.
Through this research, we study the role of tourism within these processes. We study the
codification of Ottoman heritage in B&H and its commercialisation and representation for
tourism purposes. Our empirical focus is B&H cultural heritage sites dating from the period of
Ottoman rule (15th-19th centuries). We do not approach these studies through classifying
them by their individual religious and ethnic attribution as Muslim, Jewish, Orthodox,
Catholic or Bosniak, Sephardic, Serb or Croat but as „Ottoman‟ in terms of the historical
146
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
period and legacy they date from. Its focus is on how the entire mode of organisation across
religious, language, and class boundaries that can collectively be called „Ottoman‟, can be
represented as heritage. Before we move on to our empirical data, we briefly review the
historical circumstance and points related to the representation of Ottoman heritage in B&H.
2. Ottoman heritage in the Balkans
The Ottoman state expanded by the decline of the existing Muslim and Christian imperial
powers in Anatolia and southeast Europe; the Seljuq Sultanate of Rum and the Byzantine
Empire, i.e. East Roman Empire which contradicts the simplistic narrative driven by some of
the Western European authors which constitute „the Turks‟ as part of an undifferentiated
Islamic offensive on Christendom (İnalcık, 1994; 2006; Almond, 2009). Rather, it was an
intrinsic component of geopolitical events within a Euro-Mediterranean ‘greater Western
world’ (Goffman, 2002: 7-9). Ottoman expansion in South-Eastern Europe, i.e. West Balkans
was done rapidly. By the late fifteenth century, it incorporated Macedonia, Greece, Albania,
Bulgaria, Serbia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Moldavia, Wallachia (modern Romania) and a
significant part of current Croatia (İnalcık, 1994; Lopasic, 1994).
At the time of the Ottoman conquest in the late 1500s, the Bosnian Kingdom nobility was
mainly Catholic, tied to Rome, Venetian Dalmatia and Hungary (Lopasic, 1994). Yet,
majority of peasant population and indeed some of the nobility, adhered to the ‘heretical’
schismatic and dualist Bosnian Church whose teaching resembles Manichaeism to some
extent. Through undermining the legacy of the existing feudal elites, the Ottomans offered an
improvement in the material situation of the peasants, (İnalcık, 1954) which makes it clear
that „Islamisation‟ of the Bosnian population was not mandatory, (Lopasic, 1994) setting
aside the „devşirme‟ levy periodically replenishing the Ottoman military and bureaucracy with
Christian peasant boys forcibly converted to Islam at their young age. Voluntary conversion
proceeded gradually, becoming more intense during the mid 16th century peak of Ottoman
military success in Central Europe.
The height of Ottoman expansion in Europe culminated under Sultan Suleiman I (r: 1520-
1566) where the territory of Southeast Europe remained relatively stable military frontier
between Ottoman and Habsburg lands from the end of Suleiman‟s reign until the first
significant Ottoman reverses in the region after 1683 (Murphey, 1999). A set of relatively
stable, and at least managed social relations developed amongst Muslims, Christians and Jews
which can be identified as specifically Ottoman (Barkey, 2008). The legacy of Ottoman social
organisation includes institutionalised interrelationship of religion, social class and state
employment (Bieber, 2000). Islam was a supreme, the religion of the ruling class, with
subordinate, yet legitimate status reserved for Christianity and Judaism, which crosscut with
socioeconomic status. Finally, society was divided between those occupying positions in the
state administration, inclusive of Askeri, representatives of three recognised religions, and the
large population of Raya (the flock), a general word for subject people regardless whether
they are Muslims, Christians or Jews. The main difference between Muslim and non-Muslim
population is in certain privileges, but also the responsibilities given to Muslim population.
While exempt from the „head tax‟ levied on Jews and Christians, Muslims were instead
obliged to serve in the army. Yet, many Christians, though, served voluntarily (Barkey,
2008). Communities were largely self-regulating under the Millet system, wherein one was
born into a recognised community, submitted to its „spiritual, financial and administrative
authority‟ and could not exit it other than by conversion to Islam (Ortaylı, 2004: 18). Yet
people crossed these „boundaries‟ relatively easy in a scope of their social, economic and
legal interests. The Roman Catholic and post-Reformation Protestant churches did not occupy
correspondingly formal positions within the governing apparatus of the Ottoman state, as it
was the case with the Orthodox Church and Judaism (Barkay, 2008, Bieber, 2000). However,
147
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
legal provision was made for the toleration of both in separate cases, as is the case of an
Ahdnama (contract based on Sharia), giving religious freedom to Catholics within the
boundaries of Ottoman secular law (kanun), under the provision of Sultan Mehmed II given to
the custodian of the Franciscan order in B&H, Fra Angelo Zvizdovic, The document was also
a template for subsequent Fermana (decrees) for the protection of the non-Muslim population
more generally (Čaušević , 2005). From the late 15th to late 17th centuries, the Ottoman state
successfully developed and implemented this policy of toleration towards its non-Muslim
population (Vickers, 1999). However, Barkey (2008) argues that although the instances like
Ahdnamatestify a kind of humanistic characteristic of Ottoman legacy, on the other side, the
minorities within Islam, i.e. Shi‟a, Alevi and certain Sufi „heresies‟ and emerginf Sunni
Wahabi movement in the 18th century were repressed. After the conquest of the holy cities of
Mecca and Medina, Ottoman legacy legitimised itself as a guardian of Sunni orthodoxy, thus
the minorities within Islam itself constituted an existential threat to Ottoman legitimacy
(Newman, 2006). This is due to the possibility to regulate the subordinate status of Jews and
Christians as Zhimmi (Peoples of the Book) within the schools of Islamic jurisprudence
recognised by the Ottomans which was not possible within Islam itself. Further, they did not
constitute an existential, ideological threat of the same order as some competing legitimacies
within Islam.
Toleration of religious difference was a pragmatic means for an Islamic empire to exercise
control in regions with significant non-Muslim populations. As Barkey (ibid: 120) maintains,
‘difference was perceived as the norm, a condition that need not be altered, but managed’.
Islam was not only supreme in terms of its position as the „state religion‟ but provided the
legal framework, within which difference was tolerated, regulated and, if necessary,
suppressed. So, what emerged in the Balkans, perhaps most obviously and throughout the
empire more generally, was a situation where Islam constituted „the primary marker of
[political] inclusion‟ and whose legal tenets towards Muslims, Jews and Christians formed a
framework of relations best described as „separate, unequal and protected‟ (ibid). So, the
„classical‟ Ottoman period was one in which „religion was considered more important than the
linguistic and cultural group to which [people] belonged‟, as distinct from later „national‟
identifications emerging in the 19th and 20th centuries (ibid: 80). This is neither to set aside
the genuinely felt intensity of ethno-nationalist identities around which resistance to Ottoman
rule in Europe and subsequent, related emergence of Turkish nationalism emerged nor their
more recent manifestation in the break-up of Yugoslavia. Rather, it is to question the
timelessness of such ethnic discourses, to argue that the expansion and consolidation of
Ottoman rule occurred under very different conditions and that, therefore, an associated
codification of heritage legacy ideally should not be framed simply within nationalist or
binary „civilisational‟ rubrics. Later periods, when national identities did provide the symbolic
basis for resistance to imperial rule, Barkey (ibid) argues, clearly do not represent the eruption
of latent inter-ethnic tensions, but the diminished ability of the Ottoman state to manage
relations of difference and participatory access to power and the interractions between the
centre and periphery. This Ottoman social legacy renders problematic the „mainstream‟
European discursive and their explanation and construction of the 1990s conflict in
Yugoslavia as the logical consequence of embedded, „timeless‟ ethnic hatreds, subsumed by a
regime in which discrete nations were artificially woven together. This narrative posits that
repressed hatred was unleashed in the early 1990s as the Yugoslav state unravelled, causing
brutal inter-communal war (see for instance Malcolm, 1994, Simms, 2001 on this critique).
However, as Kovač (2006) argues, the non-existence of ethnically based politics for most of
the Ottoman era created a heterogenic social texture in BH, constituting a „normality‟ of
social experience for centuries.
148
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
2.1 Research approach
Our research explores the role of tourism in creating the particular constructs and
narratives of the Balkans, its meanings and representations. We study the representation of
Balkans in the context of the formation of its own identity. We question the role of tourism
and specifically Ottoman heritage codification in B&H and interpretation of that heritage in
constructing the notion of identity formation and belonging. In doing so, we have done both
textual and visual semiotic research of the written tour guides and brochures, both available
off line and in the on line format. Further, the rest of the fieldwork we have conducted in the
cities of Mostar and Sarajevo in B&H. We have chosen Sarajevo and Mostar as the main part
of our research inquiry because both cities are very popular tourism destinations partly
because of their rich and invaluable Ottoman Heritage which is promoted for tourism
purposes. We have conducted the interviews with the tour guides, museum custodians and
tourists and also we did an overt participant observation of the city tours.
Although critical theory is a very convenient tool to be deployed as a research approach
when normative assumptions need to be challenged, it is still rarely deployed in tourism
studies. However, more and more tourism researchers have started using this particular
approach in order to emancipate usually silent tourism voices, challenged meta-theories and
create emancipatory knowledge (Causevic and Lynch, 2011). According to Kincheloe and
MacLaren (1998, 2005), there are many different approaches to critical theory. Further,
critical theory is not a uniformed approach, but very complex and discoursive. Yet, critical
theories share some of the common characteristics, which are interdisciplinarity, dialecticism,
epistemological reflexivity and emancipation (Habermas, 1978). Tourism per se is an
interdisciplinary field of research; Hollingshead (2009) actually argued that tourism s actually
a postdisciplinary study context. In any ways, it is a field of study which creates the dialogue
between the disciplines and in such a way creates new knowledge. Further, this particular
kind of research creates the knowledge through the epistemological reflexivity (Bourdieau,
1986) which encourages the reflection upon our assumptions about the world, and knowledge,
questions the creation of the new knowledge, and helps to think about the implications of such
assumptions for the research and its findings (Willig, 2001: 32). According to Bauer and Roth
(2003), the knower and the known are in the dialectic unit, thus the knowledge created bares
the mark of the epistemic subject and that particular relation which in fact is reflected upon
through the epistemological reflection. Last but not the least, the emancipation is always
imbedded as one of the main characteristics of critical theory. However, as Kincheloe and
MacLaren (2005) argue, emancipation should be used very carefully in a postcolonial and
neo-colonial narrative as „emancipation‟ in that particular context has a meaning which can
easily be subjugated to „emancipation‟ understood as a core of the colonialism (Jack, 2008).
However, in our case, the emancipatory concept comes from challenging the normative
perspective and technical knowledge (Habermas, 1978) through which the binary discourse
was developed.
2.2. Research Findings
The tourists who come to B&H usually read the tour guides and the official promotional
material created by both public and private tourism associations and enterprises in B&H.
Most of the material is consistent with the interpretation of the Ottoman heritage which goes
in line with the east-west binary concept, i.e. orient, and occident whose meeting point is in
B&H.
As for instance illustrated here,
Bosnia and Herzegovina has emerged from the ashes of war to become one of the most
exotic destinations of southeast Europe, an ancient crossroads where east meets west.
149
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Bradt Guide
Furthermore, a tourism business advertises its trip to Sarajevo in this way;
Sarajevo, the capital of Bosnia and Herzegovina, is known as a place where East
meets West. In the European Jerusalem, as many call it.
Both local and foreign tour guides, tour operators and official tourism association of B&H
actively feature the slogan that Sarajevo is the place where East and West meet which appears
to be a pure theoretical simplification. Another, very popular slogan, which is especially
popular among the local is the comparison between Sarajevo and Jerusalem. Although tour
guides naively feature this comparison in the guided tours observed, and in promotional
material, some tour guides are reluctant to this particular comparison. Locals want to promote
their city as a peaceful place where different religions exist and live side by side. As narrated
by the tour guide and few other decision makers who visited Jerusalem and experienced for
instance very frequent check points, difficulties to enter into the main Al Aqsa mosque for
non-Muslims, fear and violence, both in structural and physical terms (Galtung, 1996). In that
sense, comparison in a simplistic commercial tourism term which further can detrimental
effects on Bosnian tourism because that particular simplification is not sound in a wider
tourism marketing and positioning terms. The only issue which makes Sarajevo and Jerusalem
comparable, is that in a very small radius, one can find religious heritage, i.e. Orthodox and
Catholic church, Mosque and a Synagogue at one place. In Sarajevo, these are the product of
Ottoman legacy in the Balkans, and a specific and complex history of the place, where
throughout the history there were no demarcated ghettos, thus its heritage cannot easily be
truncated so that it resembles Jerusalem. In order to make a valid comparison, some important
characteristics of both Jerusalem and Sarajevo would need to be truncated, therefore besides
there is no marketing sense to compare these two cities, there is also neither historical point of
doing so. Thus, this particular simplification, although very sensational in tourism terms, it is
naively used by the tour guides and guided books.
Another significant point of interest is a so-called binary between the east and the west, as
noted by Said (1978). In this particular context, the binary is constructed through its constant
reproduction. This can be very dangerous for local communities. For instance, the tour guides
in Mostar advertise themselves as „Mostar-where east meets west’ which can be very
dangerous material in a post-Dayton B&H where Mostar is the city officially divided into
East and West Mostar where Croatian Catholics live in its west, and Bosnian Muslims live in
its east part. Such a representation of Mostar is institutionalising this east-west binary and
does not allow the normalisation of social relationships to take place, and as a matter of fact
and although not the focus of this paper, but it needs to be mentioned that east and west in
Mostar actually very rarely meet.
The data show that, for the commercial tourism purposes, a rich and complex Ottoman
Heritage in Bosnia is interpreted in a way that it actually needs to „make sense‟ to the foreign
visitors. In that context, the tour guide explains Ottoman heritage in a deliberately simplified
way. The tour guide is limited by the time. The tour is short. Further, the tourists are in a
search of something more sensational thus speaking about the brutal conquest from the east
makes much more sense for the tourists and the tour guide per se. The tour guides, especially
these in Mostar, constantly report that they do not have enough time to explain the
complexities of the Ottoman heritage. They use the binary discourse between the east and
west because „it is something the tourists are familiar with’ (Interview transcript).
150
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
For the pragmatic reasons, the tour guide uses the binary discourse. The tourists are
already informed about the east-west binary discourse, i.e. it is recognisable and easily
received. The historical concept is simplified into a binary because only in such a way it
„makes sense‟ to the western visitors. Talking about the syncretic characteristics of Ottoman
legacies in the Balkans is complex and western tourists are not familiar with such rhetoric. On
another side, it has also been noted that Turkish visitors appear not to be very familiar with
the syncretic nature of Ottoman Empire. While visiting a Sephardic synagogue and museum
in Sarajevo which has been erected in 1566, most of the Turkish visitors have very similar
understanding of the Ottoman Empire heritage as the Western tourists had, i.e. syncretic
legacy of Ottoman Empire has been marginalised and east-west binary plays a primate. This
particular exemplar shows that both Turkey and Western European countries in fact have very
similar understanding of the past. Due to this particular fact, in this particular context,
complex historical legacies are deliberately simplified and condensed in a shape to both
accommodate pragmatic, operational circumstances as well as the historico-civilisational
subject positions of visitors.
The museum custodian in the Jewish Museum and Synagogue which was erected in 1566,
says that it is difficult for many visitors to understand the context within which Jewish life
took place in Bosnia because of certain assumptions taken from situations elsewhere. Many
tourists ask the custodian if it was difficult for Jews to live with Muslims; the tour guide
assumed that this was due to the constant coverage of the Middle Eastern conflict and
subsequent education. Under such circumstances the museum custodian actually challenges
these assumptions by highlighting the position of Jews in Sarajevo as a valued for their skills
and knowledge, and an important part of the Ottoman mode of social organisation (Barkey,
2008). However, the custodian highlights to the tourists that, ‘this museum shows the life of
the Jewish community in Sarajevo and also how well integrated the community was’.
Another Sarajevo tour guide, explained that in the beginning of his career, he said that for
him, thinking of Bosnia in a syncretic terms is ‘normal, something what we take here for
granted, the way we grew up in Sarajevo’ he commented that at the beginning of his career he
was not aware of the importance of presenting that „normality‟. Further, while visiting
Despica House which represents the life of bourgeois Christian Orthodox families in
Sarajevo, tourists feel perplexed because the first floor of the house is designed in „Ottoman
style‟. The custodian said that the tourists bring a lot of prejudices and he also points out how
important it that through this particular ethnographic presentation to show this home „as it
was, this was fashionable at that time, and comfortable too. So, wealthy people would be able
to afford it, having lots of cushions was like having plasma TV now’. This statement, indeed,
corresponds with Sugar‟s (1977) account of the diffusion of elite taste in Balkan cities up to
and including the late Ottoman period: „because the Muslims had both old and new rich
among them, this group automatically enjoyed the highest prestige and gave the tone to "high
society".
3. Conclusion
The richness of the heritage in B&H is that it is simultaneously Christian, Jewish and
Muslim, yet, the organisational framework underwriting it in its historical and legacy terms
is, of course, Ottoman. Nevertheless, Ottoman heritage in BH is now summed up under
exclusionary ethnonationalisms internally and binary constructs that drives commodification
and codification of the country‟s heritage reinforced into the binary between east and west
(Islam and Europe), and also the binary between Europe and European other, i.e. the Balkans.
Commodification and codification of the Ottoman heritage plays an important part in the
process of building the European identity. Žižek (1999, p. 4) argues that Balkan is the most
suitable for the construction of European superiority, arguing that European rhetoric applies
151
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
„reflexive‟ politically correct racism. We are dealing with an imaginary cartography, which
projects onto the real landscape its own shadowy ideological antagonisms, in the same way
that the conversion-symptoms of the hysterical subject in Freud project onto the physical body
the map of another, imaginary anatomy, where according to Žižek (2008) Balkan is
constructed rather as a backward and primitive „self‟ rather than an alien „other‟.
The story of „the meeting point between the east and the west‟ is not only a part of the
tourism offer in Sarajevo; it is a story of Istanbul as well, in both cities, the
differentiation between ’East’ and ’West’ is Islam. However, the entire
story of Islam in Europe generally and the Ottoman case specifically, is
far more complex than this discourse suggests (Almond, 2009; Goffman,
2002). Similarly, the simplification of the Balkans as the European
‘other’ is also rather more complex then it is presented in the normative
discourse. This shows further simplification; as to some tourists, the Ottoman past in
Bosnia may be more easily understood as Turkish imperial occupation of Bosnian territory,
rather than presenting and explaining the active participation of Slavic, Albanian, Greek,
Hungarian and Romanian populations in an Ottoman context (Barkey, 2008). It appears that
presenting it as simply „Ottoman‟ does not „fit‟ with Western understanding of how this
empire „worked‟.
We understand that historically locatable modes of social organisation in particular spatial
contexts do not sit within the standard definitions of „intangible heritage‟ as reviewed by
Kirshenblatt-Gimblett (2004) but, nonetheless, we suggest the change in heritage codification,
arguing for the conceptualization of the social organization and management of the
multireligious societies during the Ottoman times becomes codified as an intangible heritage
and provides a frameworks for particular forms of narrative-associational understanding of
built heritage sites to retain the potential to be recovered and redeployed.
References
Almond, Ian (2009) Two Faiths, One Banner: when Muslims marched with Christians across
Europe’s battlegrounds. London: I.B. Tauris.
Balagija, A. (1940). Les Musulmans Yougoslaves (etudes sociologique). Alger: La Maison des
Livres.
Barkey, Karen. (2008). Empire of Difference: the Ottomans in comparative perspective.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bieber, Florian (2000) Muslim Identity in the Balkans before the Establishment of Nation
States. Nationalities Papers. (28)1
Causevic, Dz. (2005). Pravno - politicki razvitak Bosne i Hercegovine : dokumenti sa
komentarima. Sarajevo: Magistrat.
Causevic, S. and Lynch. P. (2011). Phoenix Tourism: Post-Conflict Tourism Role. Annals of
Tourism Research. 38(3), 780-800.
Delanty, G. 2003. The making of a postwestern Europe: A civilizational anlaysis. Thesis
Eleven. 72(1). 8–25.
Galtung, Johan (1996). Peace by peaceful means: Peace and conflict, development and
civilisation. London: Sage.
Goffman, Daniel (2002) The Ottoman Empire and Early Modern Europe. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
152
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Habermas, J. (1978). Knowledge and Human Interests (2nd ed). London:
Heinemann.
Hunt, Margaret (2009) Women in 18th-Century Europe. London: Longman
İnalcık, H. (1954). Ottoman Methods of Conquest. Studia Islamica. 2. 103-129.
İnalcık, H (1994). The Ottoman Empire: the classical age 1300-1600. London: Phoenix.
Jack, G. (2008) 'Postcolonialism and Marketing', in: M. Tadajewski & D. Brownlie
(eds) Critical Marketing: Contemporary Issues in Marketing. Chichester: John Wiley. 367-
387.
Jeffrey, Alex (2008) Contesting Europe: the politics of Bosnian integration into European
structures. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space. 26(3) 428-443.
Kincheloe, J. L., & McLaren, P. L. (1998). Rethinking critical theory and qualitative research.
In N. K. Denzin & Y. S. Lincoln (Eds.), The landscape of qualitative research (pp. 260–300).
Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
Krshenblatt-Gimblett B, (2004). “Intangible Heritage as Metacultural Production” Museum
International 56(1-2) 52-65
Kovač, N. (2006). Political Reflections. in Mahmutčehajić, R. (Ed.). Unity and Plurality in
Europe. Sarajevo: International Forum. pp. 87-101.
Lopasic, A (1994). Islamization of the Balkans with Special Reference to Bosnia. Journal of
Islamic Studies. (5)2, 163-186.
Malcolm, N. (1994). Bosnia: A short history. London: Macmillan.
Murphey R. (1999) Ottoman Warfare: 1500-1700, Routledge, London.
Ortaylı, İlber (2004) Ottoman Studies. Istanbul: Bilgi University Press
Said E, 1978 Orientalism (Penguin, London)
Sugar, Peter F (1977) Southeastern Europe under Ottoman rule, 1354-1804. Seattle:
University of Washington Press.
Todorova, M. (1994). The Balkans: From Discovery to Invention. Slavic Review, 53(2). pp.
453-482.
Todorova, M. 1996. The Ottoman legacy in the Balkans. In Imperial legacy: The Ottoman
imprint on the Balkans and the Middle East, ed. L. C. Brown, 45–77. New York: Columbia
University Press.
Todorova, M. (2009). Imagining the Balkans. Oxford University Press (updated verison).
Vickers, Miranda. (1999). The Albanians: a modern history. London: IB Tauris
Willig, C. 2001 Introducing Qualitative Research in Psychology: Adventures in Theory and
Method. Open University Press: Philadelphia.
Žižek, Slavoj (1996), “Underground, or Ethnic Cleansing as a Continuation of Poetry by
Other Means”, InterCommunication, No. 18, Autumn 1996, 19 paragraphs,
http://www.ntticc.or.jp/pub/ic_mag/ic018/intercity/zizek_E.html
153
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Žižek, S., 1999. „You May!‟. London Review of Books [Online] vol. 21 no. 6 pp. 3-6.
Available from http://www.lrb.co.uk/v21/n06/slavoj-zizek/you-may [Accessed 25 December
2012].
Žižek, S., 2008. The Military-Poetic Complex. London Review of Books [Online] vol. 30 no.
16 p. 17. Available fromhttp://www.lrb.co.uk/v30/n16/slavoj-zizek/the-military-poetic-
complex [Accessed 25 February 2013].
Žižek, S. (2008). Violence. Verso Books. London
154
Faith-Based Tourism to Turkey as Cultural Diplomacy for American
Christians
Allison Block, Taylan Gurbuz
Turkuaz Tours, LLC
e-mail: info@turkuaztours.com
Abstract
Miscommunication, misunderstanding and animosity between Christians and Muslims seem
to be at an all-time high. There have certainly been times in distant history that there has been
friction or even outright conflict between the two major religions. However, the level of
enmity has skyrocketed recently--particularly safer 9/11.
Our paper, “Faith-Based Tourism to Turkey as Cultural Diplomacy for American Christians”
will outline the history of Christian and Muslim perceptions of each other, the primary
reasons that the number of Americans visiting Turkey is significantly lower than it could be,
why religious tours to Turkey by Americans will alleviate this animosity, the target sites that
should be visited, and keys to reaching target audiences within the United States.
The primary methodology is media analysis, in addition to personal interviews and anecdotes,
and research from academic journals, holy books, and other reference sources.
Keywords: American Christians, Turkey, Faith-based Tourism
1. Introduction
The world‟s Muslim population is expected to increase by about 35% in the next 20 years,
rising from 1.6 billion (23%) in 2010 to 2.2 billion by 2030, according to a recent report by
the Pew Research Center‟s Forum on Religion & Public Life (Grim, 2011). Furthermore, the
Center also states that the Christian population has seen a fourfold increase over the past 100
years, from about 600 million in 1910 to more than 2 billion in 2010 (32%) (Hackett, C.,
Grim, B., 2011). Considering the current figures, Christians and Muslims constitute more than
half of the world‟s population. Thus, the state of relations between these two groups is critical
not only to the groups themselves, but to the state of affairs of the world at large. This
situation is realized, unfortunately, not in the reports of peacemaking activities or joint
cooperations, but rather in cases of miscommunication, discrimination, and at times, outright
war.
The media is saturated with stories these days about the misunderstandings, discord and
utter violence between Christians and Muslims. Some are representative of the realities.
Others are blatant misrepresentations of the facts, consequently exacerbating the situation.
Muslims perceive “the West” as “arrogant, greedy and selfish...and are portrayed in the
Muslim media as a society obsessed with sex, drugs and alcohol, a society that doesn't
understand the larger meaning in life,” (Jamal, 2006). The West perceives Muslims as
“fanatics, not respecting democracy,” (Jamal, 2006). These stereotypes and clichés are not,
and cannot be, a reflection of either faith or of the faithful. There must be a way forward.
Cardinal Francis Arinze (1997) made five suggestions for the shape that Christian-Muslim
relations should take: Better Knowledge of the Other; Acceptance of the Other and Respect
for Differences; Actual Engagement in Dialogue; Joint Witness to Shared Values; and Joint
Promotion of Peace. These five suggestions can certainly be carried out on an individual
basis, but are best implemented organizationally to have the greatest impact.
The two major groups that are poised to initiate the movement to positively influence this
state of affairs and change the course of Christian-Muslim relations are Turks and Americans,
more specifically, Turkish Muslims and American Christians. There are numerous reasons to
155
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
begin such interfaith dialogue with these two groups, first of which is the long-standing
relationship between the two countries. Although the Turkish-American relationship has seen
better days, this is primarily a political perspective on the relationship. Herein lies an
opportunity to open the dialogue between the two faiths outside of a political framework.
Tourism is a natural medium in which to create an atmosphere for interaction between
Turkish Muslims and American Christians, specifically, tourism for American Christians to
visit the Christian and Muslim sites in Turkey. Not only would such tourism serve as a means
to draw attention to the wealth of sacred sites in Turkey, but also as a platform for which the
visitors to interact with the faithful and faith leaders of Turkey, and for each to learn more
about the faith of the other.
Naturally, a targeted tourism campaign on its own cannot change the perception of a
destination or a group of people in one fell swoop. Any study of tourism and cultural
diplomacy must begin with an honest review of the past--the past of the destination country,
and the perception that the target audiences have of the destination. For that reason, this study
begins with a review of Christian-Muslim relations within a broad scope, and narrowed
slightly to focus on Turkish Muslims and American Christians, starting from the Crusades to
more recent current events.
Next is a review of the reasons why Americans do not visit Turkey for faith-based tours.
This can be considered part of a traditional marketing strategy as defining the target audience
and what their needs and wants are. This section is followed by a summary of the trends in
faith-based tourism and the role that Turkey can play for American Christians within this
scope, aiming to explain that faith-based tourism is not simply what Turkey as a country has
to offer, but rather something that tourism trends are signifying--that the traveling and
spiritual populations are demanding.
The subsequent section outlines the destinations that are most suitable for such tourism,
followed by a description of how to target audiences to participate in organized faith tourism
programs. To have the widest reaching impact, faith tourism cannot simply be targeted to a
general audience, as sun and sand tours may be. The primary reason for this is the niche
crowd that is curious and interested in such tours, and secondly, the outcomes of faith-based
tourism, within the scope of this paper, are more intangible than revenues and volume of
tourists.
1.1 Relevance and Objectives
This study aims to outline the history and opportunities for faith-based tourism in Turkey
for Americans, and a broad scope for projects that can emerge from such concepts. Faith-
based tourism in Turkey is a niche market with a number of outcomes that can result from the
broader goals of the projects. These can be explained in the form of a traditional public
relations communication plan:
GOALS:
To improve relations, open dialogue, and improve perceptions between American
Christians and Turkish Muslims.
STRATEGIES:
To provide a platform, hospitable to dialogue, understanding, and future cooperation
between American Christians and Turkish Muslims.
156
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
OBJECTIVES:
Organize tours to Turkey for each specific American target audience, providing an
opportunity for American Christians to visit holy sites and relics of Turkey, both Christian
and Muslim.
These goals, strategies and objectives are undoubtedly more abstract and nearly
impossible to measure, as most tourism projects might be able to do. However, abstract they
may be, by building better relations, understanding, and dialogue between American
Christians and Turkish Muslims, many other goals of both communities and of each
individual country may be reached through the natural positive impact of such projects.
1.2 Methodology
This desk study was carried out through personal and phone interviews, e-mail, meetings,
literature reviews, and internet research. The nature of this study is to present the current
statistics and reports on the status of the Turkish-American relationship (with a focus on
Turkish Muslim and American Christian relations), and propose a strategy by which faith-
based tourism to Turkey can be used as a means to develop an interfaith dialogue between the
two groups.
1.2 Limitations
This study is limited in the sense that there was no primary statistical research carried out
to reach the conclusion. All statistical research used was secondary and tertiary data.
Additionally, the case studies used in this study are also limited to the experience of the
authors, who have included the case studies from clients of their own tourism company.
Additionally, both authors claim no theological authority or education, therefore any false
claims, misinterpretations, or inaccurate assertions about the nature of Christianity or Islam
are absolutely unintentional, and the utmost effort was made to research the veracity of any
statements on either faith.
2. History of Christian/Muslim Relations and Perceptions
When considering the roots of Christian-Muslim relations, the scope of the relationship
extends over many centuries and a vast geography. However, to narrow the focus of such an
expansive history, when reviewing the nature of faith tourism within the context of Turkish-
American relations, it is best to limit the discussion to events, and the subsequent impact of
those events, that have directly had an effect on Turkish-American relations.
Therefore, this study will provide a brief explanation of Christian-Muslim relations during
the time of the Crusades, followed by an account of Christian-Muslim relations in the
Ottoman Empire. The final section gives an in-depth examination of the current events that
have shaped Christian-Muslim relations within the context of Turkish-American relations.
2.1 Crusades
“Christian-Muslim relations over the centuries have developed on a kind of layer by layer
basis: what happened in one community in one generation produced a reaction in the other
community which in turn contributed to the development of formulations and attitudes in the
first community in later generations. In Christian-Muslim relations, memories are long and
thus the Crusades, for example, still exercise a powerful influence, many centuries later, in
some parts of both the Christian and Muslim worlds.” --Hugh Goddard, “A History of
Christian Muslim Relations” (2000).
157
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Whether perceived as an aggressive attack of religious fanatics or a defense of access to
land that has, and continues to be, a symbol and holy site of the three major Abrahamic faiths,
the Crusades served as a catalyst for animosity between Christians and Muslims.
Since the marked spread of Christianity under the Byzantine Emperor Constantine (reign:
306-337 AD), Jerusalem was a pilgrimage destination for Christians. In spite of the fact that
Jerusalem was controlled by Muslim forces from 638, Christians were still granted permission
to visit the city. However, as the Seljuk Empire rapidly expanded its territory, by 1071 they
had taken control of Jerusalem and forbade Christian pilgrims to enter. This sparked great
concern throughout the Byzantine Empire, seeing as they had been defeated in the battle of
Manzikert (modern Malazgirt, Turkey) in the same year. The Byzantine Empire was in
decline, in terms of territory, leadership, and finances. Though the Eastern and Western
Roman Empires had officially parted ways in the Great Schism of 1054, the Eastern Empire
solicited the support of their fellow Christians in their defense. At the request of Alexius I
Comnenus, Pope Urban II, in one of the most influential speeches of all time, called on his
people to “take up the cross” and defend their faith. Thus, the First Crusade officially began in
1095.
The remainder of the 12th century was dominated by the Second and Third Crusades, with
marked periods of peace between Christians and Muslims. A lack of financial capital to carry
out the Fourth Crusade caused the Crusading forces to forfeit their initial efforts to take back
the Holy Land via Egypt, landing them instead in Constantinople (Istanbul) and establishing
the “Latin Empire”, meanwhile ransacking and demolishing the city in 1204. The Byzantines
recaptured the city in 1261, bringing the short-lived Latin Empire to an end. As a result, the
Fourth Crusade became more about deepening the divisions between the Eastern and Western
Empire, rather than between Christians and Muslims.
In sum, the Crusades were an ineffective tool from the perspective of the two sparring
Christian factions, in that they were not able to spread Christianity in the manner that they
intended, they were unable to unite completely as one Christian body, nor were able to
expand their territory, albeit the latter being only a minor objective to most. Furthermore, one
must remember the context in which the Crusades occurred. Very little was understood of
Christians by Muslims, and vice versa, and as a result, not all Christians could get behind this
crusading concept, and those that did found justification for their violence. Roger Bacon, a
Franciscan friar and one of the critics of the crusades, states his justification for his lack of
support for the Crusades, declaring them ineffective because “those who survive, together
with their children, are more embittered against the Christian faith.” (Neff, 2012).
2.2 Ottoman Empire
Non-Muslim minorities (mostly Jews and Christians) in the Ottoman Empire (1299-1923)
were organized under what was known as the “millet” system, though the concept of “millet”
can be traced back as early as the 4th century. It was strengthened by Sultan Mehmet II after
he conquered Constantinople. The term is derived from the Arabic word “millah” which
denotes nation or community (in Turkish, it means “people”). Interestingly enough, the millet
under the Ottoman Empire were administratively arranged according to their religion, rather
than their nationality. The legal system of the Ottoman Empire was based primarily on Sharia
(Islamic law), and thus these communities were recognized as “The People of the Book”,
who, in return for the payment of a tax (ceza) were permitted to practice their own religion,
and establish their own governance and administrative systems accordingly (within a specific
scope). The authority of each millet system went only so far. For example, each millet was
granted permission to have their own courts that operated according to their own legal system,
except in cases where another millet was involved, cases of murder, or disruption to public
158
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
order. Essentially, the scope of the millet system extended only to cover personal law, and
was inapplicable for cases in which a Muslim or another millet was involved. Later, the millet
began to use the Muslim courts in cases where it was not necessarily compulsory.
This system, though generally agreed upon, encouraged tolerance, but did not signify
equality. In the early days of the implementation of the millet system, non-Muslims were
forced to wear certain clothing of certain colors to overtly signify their millet. Muslims were
obviously given preference in government positions, and thus more rights and responsibilities.
Only later were more non-Muslims included in the high levels of administration.
What makes the millet system unique was not its “fairness”, but rather its uniqueness
compared to other government systems in the world at that time. The Jews who were expelled
from Spain were accepted with welcome arms by the Ottomans. One can hardly imagine that
any place in Europe during the Ottoman Era would have tolerance for authorizing a minority
group such leniency and self-government. This characteristic was operationally functional
until towards the end of the Ottoman Empire, when nationalism was on the rise worldwide,
and administration by the millet system declined in importance.
2.3 Current Events
Not only do the events of the distant past have an impact on today‟s Christian-Muslim
understanding, but current events are also a major factor in the perception that one group has
of the other. Whether a result of media coverage or based on reality, conflict between
Christians and Muslims around the world has negatively impacted the sincere efforts that are
being made to heal historic wounds. These conflicts, though fundamentally arising from
conflict between states, have cultural and religious aspects that come into play. This results in
conflict that is perceived as political or economic, but the repercussions naturally spill over
into cultural and religious “finger pointing”.
This concept of conflict along cultural lines, rather than that of the nation state, was first
introduced as a comprehensive theory about international relations by Samuel Huntington in
his 1993 article and further developed in his book, “The Clash of Civilizations” (1996).
Huntington‟s main thesis supports the idea that "The most important distinctions among
peoples are [no longer] ideological, political, or economic. They are cultural." (Huntington,
1996). However widespread this theory was accepted, it ignores many contextual aspects of
conflict. David Brooks (2011) in his op-ed in the New York Times rightly accuses Huntington
of the fundamental attribution error, which is defined in psychology as “the tendency to
overestimate the internal and underestimate the external factors when explaining the
behaviors of others.” (Heffner, 2001). This situation is affirmed in the aftermath of September
11th, the Iraq War, and Turkish-US relations.
2.3.1 9/11, Afghanistan, Iraq
On the morning of September 11, 2001, Americans awoke to the news of the worst
terrorist attack on American soil. Nineteen terrorists from the militant Islamist group, Al
Qaeda, boarded flights on the east coast of the United States, with the intent of high jacking
the flights and causing great damage to Americans on their own land. Nearly 3000 people
died on that day, and major damage was inflicted on buildings, including New York‟s Twin
Towers, and the United States Pentagon in Washington, DC. Al Qaeda leader, Osama Bin
Laden, who initially denied any involvement, later claimed responsibility for organizing the
attacks, citing three major motivations for carrying out such acts of brutal violence: the
presence of US troops in Saudi Arabia, US support of Israel, and sanctions against Iraq. As
early as 1996, Bin Laden and his followers had issued a fatwa, declaring a holy war against
the United States, which he had been planning to execute even before that date. The aftermath
159
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
of this senseless and vehement event reverberated throughout the world, impacting relations
between Turkey and the United States, as well.
Turkey has been a key element of US policy in the region since the 1940s, based on it
becoming a charter member of the United Nations, and its geopolitical location at the
intersection of three regions that have been, and continue to be, essential to regional security:
the Middle East, the Balkans, and Central Asia. The relationship between the two countries
was solidified by the Truman Doctrine, which affirmed US financial and military support for
Turkey‟s security. The partnership was augmented by Turkey‟s participation in the Korean
War with the United Nations, and its subsequent membership in the North Atlantic Treaty
Organization (NATO).
The first real strain on Turkish-US relations came during the first Gulf War. The
relationship was tested to a greater extent after September 11th and the successive US
invasion of Iraq.
A number of political gaffes by the Bush Administration in the aftermath of September
11th attacks further exacerbated what was at first a military response, into a clash of religious
ideology. In response to the September 11th attacks, the Bush Administration designated its
military response as “Operation Infinite Justice”. Due to widespread protests by Muslims,
stating that Allah is the only one who can dispense “infinite justice”, the name was promptly
changed to “Operation Enduring Freedom.” Such careless classification is one example of
how a political/military conflict, though its origins can be said to be cultural/religious, can
escalate beyond its original intent.
Furthermore, a number of characterizations by the Bush Administration (“axis of evil”,
“you‟re either with us or you‟re with the terrorists”, “we are the good”, and “civilized world”)
led to a backlash among Muslims around the world. By far, the phrase that incited the most
anger and outrage was, “This crusade, this war on terrorism, is going to take a while,”--a
blatant reference to the Crusades of the 12th century. Certainly, such rhetoric would fail in
any attempt to “win the hearts and minds” of “the other.”
The Bush administration‟s claim that the only strategy to fight the “war on terrorism” was
war, and the disproportionate military action, failed to recognize the deeper roots of terrorism-
-the socio-economic and political strains in the regions where the terrorism originated. This,
too, caused further hostility due to the perceived lack of sincerity on the part of the US
government to resolve the issue with justice and peace.
In spite of a lack of evidence linking Iraqi President Saddam Hussein to the September
11th attacks, as proven by the 9/11 Commission, the Bush Administration forged ahead with
their false claims about Saddam and his connection to the attacks, swaying a large portion of
the American public to support the invasion of Iraq. The Turkish public was not as convinced.
The Turkish government was publicly in favor of supporting the US mission in Iraq. The
Turkish public, however, held a diametrically opposed belief that the United States would
neglect any attempts to garner international cooperation, and act unilaterally--in spite of
Turkish public opinion. In a March 2003 survey of Turkish public opinion towards the United
States in the context of the Iraq question, 90.5% of Turks had a negative opinion of President
George W. Bush, and 85.1% had a negative opinion of the United States (Uslu, 2005). This
was an increase over a previous survey conducted by the Pew Global Attitudes Project in the
Summer of 2002, (Kohut, 2012), when 41% of respondents had a “very unfavorable” opinion
of the United States, yet the peak of displeasure with the US came in Spring 2007, when 75%
of respondents had a “very unfavorable” opinion of the United States. As of Spring 2012,
60% of the Turkish population still holds the same views.
160
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
These situations do not occur inside a box. As a result of the United States‟ brazen
political/military actions, the Turkish perception of Christians continued to decline. In March
2004, 31% of Turks held a favorable view of Christians, and in 2006, this number dropped to
just 16% (Kohut, 2006).
These political/military conflicts also had a negative impact on Americans opinion of
Muslims. In 2006, Americans had a 54% favorable opinion of Muslims (Kohut, 2006).
Americans also believed that among the top three reasons for Muslim nations‟ lack of
prosperity were government corruption (37%), lack of education (21%), and Islamic
fundamentalism (15%) (Kohut, 2006).
The once robust, dynamic and solid relationship between Turkey and the United States
began to decline as a result of political and military conflict outside of the territory of both
nations, and escalated to a point where Christian-Muslim relations were deeply scarred. The
damage to the relationship is further illustrated in the more recent reactions from the public.
2.3.2 Muhammad Cartoon/Koran Burning
On September 30, 2005, a daily newspaper in Denmark, Jyllands-Posten, published a set
of 12 cartoons, depicting the Prophet Muhammad in what some deemed a satirical or
humorous light. However, many Muslims around the world took great offense, not only for
the portrayal of the Prophet Muhammad, which is forbidden in Islam, but for the manner in
which he was depicted. In spite of an apology that was issued by the newspaper, claiming that
it had no intent to offend anyone, the cartoons had already been published in numerous other
publications, sparking outrage and protests, leaving more than 200 dead worldwide, including
Andrea Santoro, a Catholic priest in Turkey. Santoro was killed by a 16 year-old who claimed
he was influenced by the cartoons.
Yet in spite of this worldwide outrage and violence, only 65% of Americans had even
heard about the controversy, while 89% of Turks were familiar with it (Kohut, 2006). Of the
population of Americans who were familiar with the controversy, 60% blamed the issue on
Muslim intolerance, and 84% of Turks blamed it on Western disrespect (Kohut, 2006).
Furthermore, only 42% of Americans were sympathetic to Muslims who were offended by the
cartoons, regardless of their feeling toward the protests, and 80% of Turks claimed sympathy
for the offended Muslims.
The agitation that erupted following the cartoon controversy was echoed in the violent
responses to a threat by extremist Terry Jones, pastor of the Christian Dove World Outreach
Center in Florida, in July 2010, to burn 200 Qurans on the anniversary of the September 11th
attacks. Days prior to the event, Jones cancelled the burning, but not before at least 20 people
were killed in Asia and the Middle East as a result of the protests sparked by Jones‟ threat. In
spite of his promise to never burn a Quran, he did so just six months later in the sanctuary of
his church.
Though the aforementioned events were carried out by extremists, and certainly are not
representative of Christians or Christianity, or of Muslims or Islam, actions filled with such
vitriol receive a disproportionate coverage through formal and informal media (mass media
and social media), and incite further violence and animosity between Christians and Muslims.
These reactions are often founded on a lack of knowledge about “the other”. Unfounded
misconceptions are also to blame for the reason why dialogue between Christians and
Muslims can be difficult to initiate. Yet the fact is that misconceptions exist and negatively
impact the interest in and desire of American Christians to travel to Turkey.
161
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3. Why do Americans not Visit Turkey?
Long gone are the days when international travel was inaccessible to all but the wealthy
and privileged. The world is superconnected today, making visits abroad far more common
than even 20 or 30 years ago. Yet compared to some other countries, European countries in
particular, Americans simply do not travel.
In spite of Western Hemisphere Travel Initiative that came into effect in 2007, requiring
the presentation of passports by US citizens when entering the United States, the number of
passports issued by the United States Department of State has seen a steady decline since that
very year, falling to 13,125,829 in 2012 (US Department of State, 2012) as illustrated in
Figure 1 below. Approximately 35% of Americans hold passports, yet very few of those
passport holders leave the country. For example, in 2009, there were 97,597,368 passports in
circulation, and yet only 14.6 million Americans traveled overseas that year, which means
less than five percent of all US residents (Chalmers, 2012).
Figure 1 US Passports Issued by Fiscal Year
Source: United States. Dept. of State. United States Department of State Passport Statistics. Web. 30 Dec. 2012.
There are numerous domestic reasons why Americans do not travel internationally. First
and foremost is likely due to the United States‟ own rich geographic and cultural diversity.
The sandy beaches of Florida, the snowy mountains of Colorado, the vast plains of the
Midwest, and the sweeping deserts of the Southwest, to name a few, offer an expansive
variety of destinations that few other countries can claim. Furthermore, Americans live in a
culture that socially and financially rewards hard work, thus, very rarely do they have the time
to take off of work, or use the time available to them. In 2012, the average US worker
received an average of 12 vacation days, down from 14 in 2011, but used only 10 of those
days (Anthony, 2012). This pales in comparison to European workers, who receive
approximately 25 to 30 days of vacation, and use nearly every one available (Anthony, 2012).
162
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
The aforementioned reasons are explanations why Americans do not travel in general.
There are further explanations why only 667,159, 642,768, and 757,143 Americans traveled
to Turkey in 2009, 2010, 2012, respectively (Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism, 2012).
Among those are Americans‟ lack of knowledge about Turkey and the Biblical history of
Turkey, Americans‟ perception of Islam.
3.1 Lack of Knowledge about Turkey and Biblical History
Considering the long-standing relationship of Turkey and the United States, it comes as
somewhat of a surprise that Americans know so little about Turkey, and have inaccurate
perceptions of the country. However, considering that six in ten (63%) young American
adults between the ages of 18 and 24 surveyed in a recent National Geographic-Roper poll
cannot find Iraq or Saudi Arabia on a map of the Middle East, and three-quarters (75%)
cannot find Iran or Israel, their ability to correctly identify Turkey as a relative neighbor
amongst these countries, which have appeared in the media far more frequently, is a high
expectation (2006). Half of the respondents of the survey think it is important but not
absolutely necessary either to know where countries in the news are located (50%) or to be
able to speak a foreign language (47%). Furthermore, speaking a foreign language is “not too
important” (38%) to the young adults in the survey, and only 14% find it “absolutely
necessary” (National Geographic-Roper Survey, 2006). Americans are simply not well
informed--nor do they seem to care. Due to the fact that the little information that people
possess about other countries is abstract, these opinions are rarely subject to influence.
(Anholt, 2009).
It is difficult for Americans to differentiate between what they know (or do not know)
about Turkey culturally or as a tourism destination, compared to what they perceive of it
politically. Furthermore, their lack of knowledge about Biblical history prevents any effort to
associate modern Turkey with the roots of the spread of Christianity and major Biblical events
that occurred on Turkey‟s soil. In a Pew survey about religious knowledge, Americans were
questioned about figures, stories and locations in the Bible, only 45% of respondents could
correctly name the first four books of the New Testament of the Bible (the Four Gospels)
(Lugo et al., 2010). When questions about which Bible figure is most closely associated with
his willingness to sacrifice his son for God, 60% responded correctly with Abraham.
Considerably far fewer respondents are likely to be familiar with the significant role that
Abraham plays in Islam, as a prophet and apostle of God, sharing this belief with Christianity.
It is not surprising that just over half (52%) of Americans answered correctly that Ramadan is
the Islamic Holy Month (Lugo et al., 2010). This is equally a reflection on the lack of
knowledge about Islam and the negative perceptions that are held of the religion.
3.2 Perception of Islam
Many Americans have the misperception that Turkey, as a Muslim country, is potentially
unsafe for travel (Wilson, 13). This is likely due to the fact that people often wrongly attribute
Islamic practices or understandings of the faith, which are based on culture, and are not
teachings of the faith (Rae, 2002). Though nearly the entire population of Turkey claims to be
Muslim, not all believers are well-versed in their own faith, or fully devoted to the whole of
their faith‟s teachings. In her writings on Christian-Muslim relations, Pauline Rae stated:
“Not every culture claiming religious sanction for their practices is totally authentic to the true
teachings of their religion. Muslims are no different from Christians in this regard.” (2002).
In fact, according to the Pew study “Muslims want Democracy”, in which 68% of Turkish
respondents believe that it is very important that people of all faiths be allowed to freely
practice their religion. Additionally, 61% of Turks claim that suicide bombing and other
forms of violence against civilian targets are never justified in order to defend Islam from its
163
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
enemies, and 9% state that it is rarely justified. More than half of Turks (58%) also recognize
that there is a struggle between groups who want to modernize Turkey and Islamic
fundamentalists, and 67% of those respondents claim to identify with those who want to
modernize, and only 16% side with the fundamentalists. In the end, 71% of Turkish
respondents believe that democracy is preferable to any other kind of government (Kohut,
2012).
Though it may be true that not all Muslims fervently adhere to their faith, nor do many of
them endorse a radical interpretation of their faith, unfortunately, the few that do espouse such
an extreme or violent rendering of their religion are the ones that Americans hear about in the
media. In a Pew survey about How Muslims and Westerners perceive each other, only 44% of
Americans view Muslims as honest and 43% perceive Muslims as fanatical (Kohut, 2012).
Furthermore, a mere 19% of American respondents believe that Muslims have respect for
women (Kohut, 2012). These daunting statistics are a clear reminder that in spite of the fact
that there is very little knowledge about Islam among Americans, there is still a negative
perception of the religion.
4. Faith-based Tourism and Americans
Believers have long placed a priority on pilgrimages to holy sites, though not formally
labeled as such. Visits to the Holy Land for Christians, the Hajj to Mecca for Muslims, and
other sites for various faiths around the world have been destinations for the faithful for
thousands of years. Believers have traveled thousands of miles to visit sites that have held
importance in their faith. In recent years, the scope of faith tourism has expanded for many
faiths to include destinations that have spiritual importance that were rarely known or
included as spiritual destinations. Within this context, faith tourism as an alternative form of
tourism is on the rise. In fact, faith-based tourism has become one of the fastest growing
segments of the tourism industry (Tourism Review, 2012).
The World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) estimates that the faith tourism sector alone
accounts for more than 300 million people a year, with about 40% of those visitors going to
Europe, and more than 50% heading to Asia (Fraser, 2012). In the United States, the faith
tourism market has expanded by 5% since 2007, in spite of the economic crisis (Brodhecker,
2012). Of all outbound travelers, 35% are considering faith based travel, and 17% hope to do
so in the next five years (Brodhecker, 2012).
Almost half of tourists who travel for the purpose of enhancing their faith (Brodhecker,
2012), seek a more personal and experience-based vacation (Verrastro, 2012). Considering
that a majority of the faith destinations for Christians are outside of the United States, 25% of
travelers are motivated to travel internationally for the first time based on their faith
(Brodhecker, 2012).
Notwithstanding these statistics, demonstrating that there is a market for tourists eager for
travel based on their faith, Turkey has yet to be widely perceived as a faith tourism
destination. This opportunity cannot be dismissed, not only to increase the market share of
Turkey within the scope of faith-based tourism, but also to demonstrate Turkey‟s unrivalled
richness and abundance of holy sites, and the more ethereal objective of interfaith dialogue
through demonstrating the similarities of Christianity and Islam.
4.1 Turkey as a Unique Faith Destination
There is not a single country in the world with the exception of Turkey, which can claim
possession to such a vast and varied wealth of sites that are relevant to Christian history, with
a layer of modern Islamic history. Thus, by exposing American Christians to Turkey through
164
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
tourism provides an opportunity to expose both Christians (and Muslims, as well), to not only
the historic sites, but also the similarities between Christianity and Islam.
Figure 2 Comparison of Christianity and Islam
Beliefs, Christianity Islam
Doctrine
and
Practices
Sacred Text Bible (Old Testament (Jewish Bible) Koran
and New Testament)
Bible The inspired and inerrant word of God Respected word of the prophets
in the original manuscripts (2 Tim. but the Bible has been corrupted
3:16). through the centuries and is only
correct in so far as it agrees with
the Koran.
Koran The work of Muhammad. It is not The final revelation of God to all
inspired, nor is it scripture. There is no of mankind given through the
verification for its accurate archangel Gabriel to Muhammad
transmission from the originals. over a 23 year period. It is without
error and guarded from error by
Allah.
Nature of God Trinity (Father, Son, Holy Spirit); Unity (One Substance, One
Monotheistic Person); Monotheistic
Other Angels and Demons Angels, Demons and Jinn
Spiritual
Bodies
Jesus He is the word who became flesh A very great prophet, second only
(John 1:1, 14). He is both God and to Muhammad. Jesus is not the
man (Col. 2:9). son of God (9:30) and certainly is
not divine (5:17, 75)) and he was
not crucified (4:157).
Birth of Jesus Virgin Birth Virgin Birth
Death of Jesus The place where Jesus atoned for the Jesus did not die on the cross.
sins of the world. It is only through Instead, God allowed Judas to
this sacrifice that anyone can be saved look like Jesus and he was
from the wrath of God (1 Pet. 2:24). crucified instead.
Resurrection Affirmed Denied
of Jesus
Muhammad A non-inspired man born in 570 in The last and greatest of all
Mecca who started the Islamic prophets of Allah whose Qur'an is
religion. the greatest of all inspired books.
Divine Through the Prophets and Jesus (as Through Muhammad, recorded in
Revelation God himself), recorded in the Bible the Koran
165
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Original Sin This is a term used to describe the There is no original sin. All
effect of Adam's sin on his people are sinless until they rebel
descendants (Rom. 5:12-23). against God. They do not have
Specifically, it is our inheritance of a sinful natures.
sinful nature from Adam. The sinful
nature originated with Adam and is
passed down from parent to child. We
are by nature children of wrath (Eph.
2:3).
Salvation A free gift of God (Eph. 2:8-9) to the Forgiveness of sins is obtained by
person who trusts in Christ and His Allah's grace without a mediator.
sacrifice on the cross. He is our The Muslim must believe Allah
mediator (1 Tim. 2:5). No works are exists, believe in the fundamental
sufficient in any way to merit doctrines of Islam, believe that
salvation since our works are all Muhammad is his prophet, and
unacceptable to God (Isaiah 64:6). follow the commands of Allah
given in the Koran.
God's Role in Predestination, Various forms of Predestination
Salvation Grace
View of the Islam is respected as a fellow Christians are respected as
Other monotheistic religion, but Muhammad "People of the Book", but they
is not seen as a True Prophet have mistaken beliefs and only
partial revelation
House of Church, Chapel, Cathedral, Basilica Mosque, Mescid
Worship
Day of Sunday Friday
Worship
Religious Priest, Bishop, Patriarch, Pope, Pastor, Imam
Leaders Minister, Preacher, Deacon
Major Sacred Baptism, Communion The Five Pillars
Rituals
Major Cross, Crucifix, Dove, Fish, Alpha Crescent, Allah's Name in Arabic
Symbols and Omega, Chi Rho, Halo
Day of Occurs on the day of resurrection Occurs on the day of resurrection
Judgment (John 12;48) where God will judge all where God will judge all people.
people. Christians go to heaven. All Muslims go to paradise (3:142,
others to hell (Matt. 25:46). 183-185, 198). All others to hell
(3:196-197). Judgment is based on
a person's deeds (5:9; 42:26;
8:29).
Man Made in the image of God (Gen. Not made in the image of God
1:26). This does not mean that God (42:11). Man is made out of the
166
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
has a body, but that man is made like dust of the earth (23:12) and Allah
God in abilities (reason, faith, love, breathed life into man (32:9;
etc.). 15:29).
Biblical Viewed as True Prophets
Prophets
Shared Adam, Enoch (Idris), Noah (Nuh), Abraham (Ibrahim), Isaac (Ishak), Jacob
Prophets (Yakup), Joseph (Yusuf), Job (Eyup), Aaron (Harun), Moses (Musa), David
(Davut), Solomon (Suleyman), Ezra (Uzair), Elijah (Ilyas), Jonah (Yunus),
Ezekiel (Duhl-Kifl), Daniel (Danyal), Zechariah (Zakariya), John (the
Baptist) (Yahya), Jesus (Isa)
Key: Red: Disagreement, Green: Shared Belief, Yellow: Similar Belief
Source: Slick, Matt. “Comparison Grid Between Christianity and Islamic Doctrine”. Christian Apologetics &
Research Ministry. Web. 09 Jan. 2012.
Figure 2 demonstrates the similarities and differences between Christianity and Islam.
Broad generalizations may have been made about either faith, which is acknowledged by the
authors, and the chart is simply to outline general points about the two religions. The boxes
highlighted in red indicate disagreement, green indicates agreement, and yellow indicates
similarities. It may seem, at first glance that the discrepancies in belief far outweigh the points
of agreement or even the similarities. However, it is worth noting that some of the
dissimilarities are about practice and symbols (church vs. mosque, day of worship). It is also
worth pointing out the significant number of shared prophets between the two religions, as
well as the shared belief in the nature of those prophets. It is acknowledged that there are
fundamental departures in belief between Christianity and Islam. However, greater mutual
understanding, respect, and even admiration are possible when people of both faith can
interact to discuss the similarities and differences between Christianity and Islam.
4.2 Observations/Case Studies
Indeed, similarities do exist between Christianity and Islam. Turkey is supremely
positioned to offer a platform to open this dialogue between the two faiths through tourism.
Yet for any country or group of individuals (in this case, Turkish Muslims) attempting to
change its target audiences‟ (American Christians) preconceived notion of it, a simple ad
campaign is entirely insufficient. Relevance must be established in the mind of the audience.
Once relevance is established, the perception becomes more personal, rather than abstract, and
thus, change is possible (Anholt, 2009).
According to Anholt (2009), the ideal realization of this relevance is when one visits
another country as a tourist. He states that the most effective method to create relevance and
change perceptions is by “using positive, direct experience to create an image where there is
currently a mixed or weak image created through indirect experience, and where there is a
good reason to trust in the quality of the direct experience”. He further states that “people will
often change their minds completely and permanently about a country after they have visited
it.” (Anholt, 2009).
The authors of this study are tour operators themselves, with a focus on bringing
American Christians to Turkey for the primary purpose of visiting sites of Christian history,
secondarily to visit Islamic holy sites, and on a tertiary level, to provide a neutral and peaceful
platform for American Christians and Turkish Muslims to interact and engage in dialogue. An
informal survey is sent to guests subsequent to their visit to Turkey. To date, all participants
167
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
in the tours led by the authors are first time visitors to Turkey. Ninety percent of the
participants considered themselves Christian.
When asked to select statements that were familiar to the participants regarding their
knowledge of Turkey prior to their visit, most knew very little about Turkey, beyond its large
population, predominantly Muslim population, that Turkey was part of the Ottoman Empire,
and Istanbul was once the capital of the Byzantine Empire. On a scale of 1-5 (1=Negative,
2=Somewhat Negative, 3=Neutral, 4=Somewhat Positive, 5= Positive), the average response
was 3.9 to the question “How did you feel about Turkey prior to your visit?” One hundred
percent of respondents gave a rating of 5 (same scale as above) to the question about their
opinion of Turkey following their visit. These responses indicate that the participants in faith
tours in Turkey already had a somewhat positive perception of the country prior to their visit,
regardless of their knowledge about Christian history. Notable was the 100% response rate for
the “positive” perception of Turkey following the visit.
When respondents were questioned about their perception of Islam prior to their visit, the
average response was 3.7, and following the visit, the average response was 4.6. This is best
reflected in the follow-up question “How is this trip likely to change your perception of Islam
and the way you interact with Muslims?” One responded, “I feel that Christianity and Islam
have much more in common than I realized.” Another notable response was in regards to the
Turkish practice of Islam, “I think I already interacted very positively, but I appreciated the
religious tolerance of the country (non-Muslims could eat during Ramadan).” The responses
indicate that participants learned more than they had previously known about Islam, and their
perception was positively influenced.
All participants were asked if they would recommend traveling to Turkey to a friend,
relative, or colleague. Their responses were a unanimous “yes”, which can be inferred that the
experience that the participants had in Turkey was quite positive, overall, and they would
unequivocally suggest or encourage others to visit as well.
The participants in the aforementioned tours all came to Turkey on their own ambition
and inclination. Though their responses to the survey question indicate that their perceptions
about Turkey and about Islam changed in a positive direction, and that they would
recommend others to travel to Turkey, the reliability of small groups of individuals to act on
such experiences is rather low. A directed campaign, aimed at bringing leaders (whether in
the community or faith community) on a personalized tour of Turkey, tailored to their
interests, has been proven as a far more effective method at achieving the goals of further
developing a dialogue between Christians and Muslims, and striking a wider audience to
whom Turkey can be recommended as a faith tourism destination.
5. Target Audiences
According to Travel Market Report, an industry-specific publication, trends in faith based
travel include: more families and intergenerational groups embarking on faith-based trips
together, more vacations that involve volunteering, and more people of faith traveling to
experience fellowship (Verrastro, 2012). Considering these trends, the targeted audiences
should be carefully selected. The groups should be selected for the impact they will have on
their respective communities upon their return. What is implied by the “trickle-down” effect
is that these community leaders that participate in a faith-based tour of Turkey will return to
the United States and share their experience with other members of their communities.
According to Anholt, “good destination marketing can create networked or „viral‟ marketing
effects well beyond the people who actually visit the country: they can become highly
effective advocates of the country‟s image and thus extend the reach of the original
promotions well beyond the size of the (original) audience” (Anholt, 2009). This will have a
168
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
twofold impact. First, it will have the potential to encourage others to visit Turkey as a tourist,
whether on a typical vacation or part of a faith-based tour, thus increasing the image and
perception of Turkish Muslims and American Christians through interaction on a one-to-one
basis. Though intangible, the second and most valuable, is the diffusion of information,
theology, history, impressions and interactions with Turks and the religious practitioners of
the country. This presents an opportunity to present Turks and Islam in a positive light to
Americans and American Christians, as a result of the positive experience of the participants
while in-country. Furthermore, such organized tours will also give Americans and American
Christians the opportunity to explain American values, perspectives, and perceptions, and
Christian theology, in an environment that is conducive to dialogue and understanding. In
sum, as Anholt explains, programs that focus on working via “influencers” are incredibly
effective at engaging both communities directly and effectively, and simultaneously
extending the scope of such programs (2009).
When determining a target audience, the destination must create an image of itself that
distinguishes it from the others, and making itself a distinct destination from all other choices
that a consumer may have. It must evoke the appropriate images and perception in the mind
of the customer that satisfy their needs and wants.
By and large, the needs and wants of a travel customer are intangible. This is particularly
true for faith tourism. For example, the principal motivation for tourists who participate in
faith-based travel is to visit a site that is historically or spiritually significant to their faith,
commonly as a pilgrimage. Certainly, the destination itself is concrete, but the resulting
emotion and spiritual impact that visiting the site will have on potential visitors is very
difficult to elucidate. Thus, it is of utmost importance that faith-based destination marketers
precisely and fully understand the spiritual and/or religious nature of the destination to be able
to elicit the necessary emotional impact to move customers to visit.
6. Target Destinations
As previously mentioned, Turkey is a unique destination for faith tourism. Not only can
Christian tourists to Turkey visit sites of Christian heritage, but simultaneously visit sites that
are sacred in Islam as well. The following destinations are just a few of the many sites in
Turkey that provide the opportunity for faith-based tourists to visit primarily Christian
heritage sites, while including sites of Islamic heritage also.
6.1 Istanbul
The most well-known city in Turkey--whether in terms of contemporary history or ancient
times--is undoubtedly Istanbul. Since as far back as 660 BC, there has been some form of
civilization settled in what is today known as Istanbul, particularly around the historic
peninsula area. The name “Byzantium” allegedly comes from this era, when Greek settlers
from the state of Magara established the city named after their king, Byzas. Yet it was not
until Byzantium, the Eastern capital of the Roman Empire, became Constantinople, after its
Emperor Constantine in 330 AD, and that the city began to emerge as a significant location in
world history. Constantinople served as the capital of the Roman Empire from 330-395, after
which it officially became the Eastern Roman (Byzantine) Empire. With a brief stint of
governance by the Western Roman (Latin Empire) from 1204-1261, Constantinople remained
named as such until 1453, after which it became the capital of the Ottoman Empire, and there
is debate as to whether it was referred to as either Konstantinnye or Istanbul. Either way,
Istanbul became the official name of the city after the foundation of the Turkish Republic, yet
it no longer remained the capital city.
169
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Such rich, complex, and varied history of a city naturally gives way for a wealth of sites
for faith tourists to visit. The layered history of Istanbul makes it possible to visit a structure
that may have at one time been a church, may have been later converted to a mosque, and is
today a museum. Alternatively, parts of modern mosques may have used the ruins from
various buildings from the Byzantine Era. Furthermore, numerous holy relics of both
Christianity and Islam have been held in Istanbul at one point or another, and those that
remain can be seen today.
6.1.1 Hagia Sophia
The most striking complex around the entire Istanbul area is inarguably the Hagia Sophia.
The Hagia Sophia (Church of Divine Wisdom; Aya Sofya in Turkish) that stands on
Istanbul‟s historic peninsula today is actually the third church to stand on that site. The first
church was inaugurated in 360 AD, a short time after the conversion to Christianity by the
Byzantine Emperor Constantine. This church was burned to the ground during rioting in the
early 5th century, and a second church was inaugurated in 415. The second church was
destroyed in the Nika Riots of 532, which also killed tens of thousands of citizens. The
enthusiasm and determination to prove his strength following these riots led the Emperor
Justinian I to build the largest and most grandiose house of worship that anyone had ever
seen. The current Hagia Sophia remained as the largest basilica in the world until the erection
of the Seville basilica. During the Fourth Crusade in 1204, the Crusaders were relentless in
their ransack and pillaging of the city. They managed to maintain the structure of Hagia
Sophia, but were merciless when it came to looting the holy relics and taking a majority of
them back to St. Mark‟s Basilica in Venice. The city and the church were returned to the
Byzantines after 1261, for approximately 200 more years, when it became a mosque after the
Ottoman conquest of Istanbul in 1453. Today, one can visit the Hagia Sophia, a museum, to
see the juxtaposition of the striking symbols of both faiths, and view the mosaics, which
simply may not have survived had it not been for the plastering of them due to Muslim
iconoclasm.
6.1.2 St. Savior in Chora (Kariye) Museum
The only church to rival Hagia Sophia, in terms of grandiosity and majesty is the St.
Savior in Chora. Like the Hagia Sophia, the structure has suffered the same riots and
earthquakes, and survived hundreds of years as a church, then a mosque, and now a museum.
Its size may not compete with the Hagia Sophia in size, but it far outshines it with its almost
50 mosaics, most of which are depictions from the New Testament, the Virgin Mary, and
Jesus Christ. The mosaics inside were created at a later date than those in the Hagia Sophia,
but serve as one of the finest examples of late Byzantine artwork. The church was converted
to a mosque approximately 50 years after the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople, at which
time the mosaics were plastered over, as was the case with many other churches that were
converted to mosques, due to the prohibition of iconic images in Islam. In the 16th century the
church was converted into a mosque and in 1948 officially became a museum.
6.1.3 Church of the Holy Apostles (Fatih Camii)
Though all that remains of this once sacred place of worship, the Church of the Holy
Apostles, are a few column pieces and foundation blocks, those few fragments are worthy of
mention. The Church of the Holy Apostles was commissioned around the year 330, by the
Emperor Constantine, who desired to gather the relics of the Twelve Apostles of Jesus in the
church--hence its name. The only acquired relics were reported to be those of Saints Andrew,
Luke, and Timothy, but there were numerous other relics of Christian leaders, saints and
martyrs. Most significantly, it was believed to house part of the “Column of Flagellation”, to
which Jesus was bound and whipped by Roman soldiers during His Passion and before His
170
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Crucifixion. The remains of this column are currently housed in the Patriarchal Church of St.
George in Istanbul. What does remain on the site, however, is part of the courtyard of what is
currently Fatih Camii (Fatih Mosque).
Sultan Fatih Mehmet (the Conqueror) ordered the construction of this mosque as a
reflection of his magnificent conquest of Istanbul in 1453. The structure was damaged and
rebuilt numerous times over the course of the years, and the current structure has been
standing since 1771. The sultan and his wife are buried in the türbeler (tombs) behind the
mosque.
6.1.4 Hagia Irene
Hagia Irene, the Church of Divine Peace, holds a significant place in Christian history as
the site of the Second Ecumenical Council in 381, at which the Nicene Creed, the profession
of faith that was previously adopted in 325 in the city of Nicaea (Iznik, Turkey), was
confirmed. It is reported to have been the first church of Constantinople, even before Hagia
Sophia. Like many other structures from the Byzantine era, the building has suffered heavy
damage from rioting and earthquakes, but unlike the other structures, it was never converted
to a mosque. During the Ottoman period, it was used as an arsenal. It is now operated by the
Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism, and special permission is required to enter the
church, which is located within the outer courtyard of Topkapi Palace.
6.1.5 Topkapi Palace
Serving as the primary residence of the Ottoman Empire for 400 years (1465-1856) of
their 624-year reign, Topkapi Palace holds numerous valuables, not only from the Ottoman
Empire, but also many holy relics from Islam and Christianity. For example on display in the
Third Courtyard of the Palace, in the sultan‟s private chambers are the following relics: the
pot of Abraham, the turban of Joseph, the staff of Moses, the sword of David, the scrolls of
John, and the holy relics of Muhammad, including his footprint, a piece of his tooth, hair of
his beard, the seal of the Prophet, an autographed letter, and his swords and bow. Because of
the sacred nature of these relics and the rooms in which they are housed, a mufti is always
present here, reciting the Koran.
6.2 Antakya, Tarsus
6.2.1 Footsteps of Paul and other apostles
The most prominent figure from this area is St. Paul, significant for the efforts he made to
spread the acceptance of Christianity. He was born in Tarsus, Turkey, just a few years after
the birth of Jesus. The remains of the home of Paul‟s family and a functioning well can be
seen by visitors today.
As a Roman citizen, he had special rights and privileges, such as not being imprisoned
without a trial or being crucified. His Roman citizenship saved Paul many times during his
ministry. Across the Roman Empire, he was a prominent apostle of Christianity during the
diffusion of the Gospel by the early Christian communities. In the area of Jerusalem, Apostle
Paul was known to be a very devoted Christian, though interestingly, prior to his conversion,
he confesses that he persecuted “the church of God” “beyond measure” (Galatians 1:13–14;
Philippians 3:6; Acts 8:1–3), standing by as a witness to the stoning of Stephen. His
conversion was a monumental moment for the spread of Christianity. Though his conversion
was a drastic change in his belief system, he adhered to it fervently, mentioning in the first
chapter of the book of Romans that he was called to be an apostle by as a servant of Christ.
His faith took him on three major missionary journeys to spread the word of God. His first
journey began in Antioch (Antakya, Turkey), with Barnabas and Barnabas‟ cousin, John
171
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Mark. On this first mission, they visited Perge (10 miles east of Antalya, Turkey), Antioch in
Pisidia (Yalvaç), Iconium (Konya), Lystra (19 miles south of Konya), and Derbe (15 miles
north-northeast of Karaman). They returned to the cities they had previously visited in an
attempt to gather support again. They returned to Antioch by boat from Attalia (Antalya,
Turkey).
Paul‟s second missionary journey departed again from Antioch (Antakya), this time with
Silas as his traveling companion. They visit Derbe and Lystra again, where they met Timothy
and invited him to travel with them. They also went to Pisidian Antioch (Yalvaç) again, and
traveled overland to Alexandria Troas (near Bozcaada, Turkey), where they were joined by
Luke. This was followed by journeys to Samothracia, Neapolis, Philippi, Amphipolis,
Apollonia, Thessalonica, Berea, Athens and Corinth (cities that are part of modern day
Greece). He stayed in Ephesus (south of Izmir) for a short while, heading back to Jerusalem
for Passover, and returning to Antioch.
The third missionary started around Galatia (central Anatolia) and Phrygia (west central
Anatolia), followed by a trip to Ephesus, where St. Paul stayed for nearly three years, during
which time he wrote what is now known as the books 1 & 2 Corinthians in the Bible. He then
traveled through Macedonia and with a change of plans turned to Corinth (modern day
Greece). He visited numerous other cities throughout modern day Turkey on his return to
Jerusalem.
Paul‟s writings are mostly aimed at the communities he visited while traveling. Fourteen
epistles of the New Testament are attributed to Paul (though some books‟ authorship is
disputed by scholars). These books are: Romans, First Corinthians, Second Corinthians,
Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, First Thessalonians, Second Thessalonians,
First Timothy, Second Timothy, Titus, Philemon, and the “anonymous” Epistle to the
Hebrews.
6.2.2 Antakya (Antioch)
Antioch is referred to as the cradle of Christianity: it was the base for Paul's missionary
journeys, as mentioned above, the place where Jesus‟ followers were first called "Christians"
(Acts 11:26), and also where the Gospel of Matthew may have been written. Today visitors
can see the Church of St. Peter, believed to have been dug by the Apostle Peter as a gathering
place for the early Christians, thus it is believed to be the first church. In the latter part of the
3rd century, ten church assemblies were held in Antioch. Other famous figures from Antioch
include St. Luke, Archbishop of Constantinople John Chrysostom (the “golden mouthed”,
known for his eloquence in preaching), St. Simeon, and Habibi Neccar, who came to be
known as the first Christian martyr.
The story of Habibi Neccar is described in the Koran, in which according to some
interpretations, two of Jesus‟ disciples visited Antioch where they met Habibi Neccar. The
disciples were arrested and imprisoned, with plans to execute them. When Habibi Neccar
learned of their condition, he said “Obey those who ask no reward from you for themselves”.
Neccar and the disciples were then killed. Habibi Neccar is translated by some to mean
“beloved (habib) one of Jesus (neccar)”, because the word “neccar” means “one who gives
shape to a tree”, implying the word carpenter, and thus, the connection to Jesus, the carpenter,
is made. Habibi Neccar is buried in his namesake mosque, where his tomb is said to be next to
Sham‟un, who could either be St. Simeon, or even Simon Peter himself. This mosque is
allegedly the oldest in Anatolia, and the first mosque dedicated to a Christian.
172
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
6.4 Konya
Today Konya is recognized for its significance as religious center associated with
Celaleddin Rumi and the Sufi Mevlevi Dervishes (Whirling Dervishes). Rumi was a mystic,
poet and philosopher who lived in Konya from 1227 to 1273. He is the author of the Islamic
mystic masterpiece, the Mesnevi, containing instructions on spiritual life and how to achieve
perfection in one‟s love of God. For Rumi, love was superior to all.
During Rumi‟s time, Konya was the capital of the Seljuk Empire. There are numerous
buildings that can still be seen from this era, including the Alaettin Mosque, the largest and
oldest mosque in Konya (1221) on Alaettin Hill, the site of Konya's original acropolis; the
Karatay Medresesi (school), built in 1251, which is now a museum exhibiting Seljuk tiles;
Ince Minareli Medresi (literally, the Slender Minaret Medrese (school)), named so for its
slender minaret, in comparison to the others, and today houses a museum displaying stone and
wooden artifacts from the Seljuk and Ottoman eras. Most significant is the Mevlana Museum
also known as the Green Mausoleum or Green Dome. Here lies the tomb and shrine of
Mevlana Celalettin Rumi, and is the original tekke (lodge) of the Mevlevi Dervishes.
Iconium, as Konya was known during early Christianity, was a significant place for the
missionary journeys of Paul. In fact, Paul and Barnabas preached here on the first missionary
journey and converted many people to Christianity (Acts 14:1-6). Among those converts were
Thecla, who became a passionate follower of Paul, much to the chagrin of her parents. She
alluded execution for her faith more than once, and reputedly ran a nunnery and hospital for
the sick, as she, herself, was allegedly a miraculous healer.
6.5 Cappadocia
The natural geographic beauty of Cappadocia, with its unique volcanic peaks and valleys,
has made the area perfect for its residents, over thousands of years, to dig caves in which to
live and worship. Christians found refuge in these complex and extensive tunnels and caves in
the 2nd century when they found themselves under Roman persecution. These underground
homes allowed the residents to survive for months at a time with intricate ventilation and
defensive traps throughout the multi-leveled edifices. The most famous Christian figures of
the region were known as the Cappadocian Fathers: Basil the Great, bishop of Caesarea;
Basil‟s Brother Gregory of Nyssa; and friend Gregory of Nazianzus, later Patriarch of
Constantinople. They lived here during the 4th century.
Today, the highlight of the tourist attractions in the region is the Göreme Open Air
Museum, at which 10 different cave churches can be visited, all of which have some type of
Byzantine-era frescoes, most of which are quite well preserved. Furthermore, two of the 36
underground cities are open to tourists--Derinkuyu and Kaymaklı. In both, visitors can have a
better understanding of how underground life was for inhabitants, including their kitchens,
stables, bedrooms and wineries.
6.6 Ephesus and Environs
6.6.1 Seven Churches of Asia
Modern Turkey, near its Aegean (Western) coast, is home to the Seven Churches of Asia,
mentioned in the first chapters of the Book of Revelation in the Bible. The Book of
Revelation, like many of the other books of the New Testament, begins as a letter from a
prominent faith leader to specific communities--in the case of Revelation, the leader is John
the Apostle and the communities are seven churches of Asia Minor. John relays that he
received a vision imploring him to write messages to “the seven churches: to Ephesus and to
173
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Smyrna and to Pergamum and to Thyatria and to Sardis and to Philadelphia and to Laodicea.”
(Revelation 1:11).
Figure 3 Seven Churches of Revelation
Ephesus Smyrna Pergam Thyatria Sardis Philadelphia Laodicea
um
Modern Ephesus, Izmir Bergam Akhisar Sardis Alaşehir (near
Day Efes a Denizli)
City
Name
Bible Rev. 2:1-7 Rev. 2:8- Rev. Rev. Rev. 3:1- Rev. 3:7-12 Rev.
Verses 11 2:12-17 2:18-28 5 3:14-21
Sites Basilica St. Arche 4th- Sardis Byzantin Stadiu
of St. Polycarp ologic 6th Synag e m
John Church al centu ogue Basilica
Scarco
Museu ry
Ephesus Archeolo Temp phagi
m publi
Museum gical le of
c
Museum Red Arte
Great buildi
Basilic mis
Theater Izmir ngs
a
Agora Byza
Zeus ntine
Altar Churc
(in h
Berlin
Museu
m)
Nature The church The church The The The The church The
of the that had that would church church church of patient church
Church forsaken its be afflicted that was with a that endurance. of
first love for ten called to false appeared indiffere
days. repent. prophet alive, but nce.
ess was
(Jezebel spirituall
). y dead.
Sources: Faithlife Study Bible Application. New International Version. Logos Bible Software. App. 01 Jan.
2012.; Hays, Holly. Sacred Destinations. 2005-2010. Web. 14 Jan 2013.
Figure 3 shows the seven churches, their modern day city name, the verses in which their
messages appear in the Bible, the sites that remain related to Christianity, and the nature of
the church to which the message of Revelation was directed.
6.6.2 Great Theater
Paul spent at least two years preaching in Ephesus in the. It was here in the Great Theater
that he gave his sermon condemning the worship of pagan idols. Paul, as told in the Book of
the Acts of the Apostles (19:23-41), was a threat to the local silversmiths, who sculpted
figures of Artemis, feared that if Paul was successful in converting the Ephesians to
174
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Christianity, they would be out of work. Today, the theater is within the campus of the ancient
city site, which is encompassed as a museum.
6.6.2 Church of Mary
The Church of Mary, also known as the Double Church, was where the Third Ecumenical
Council, the Council of Ephesus, was held in 431. The most significant theological decision
that was made at this gathering was the nature of Jesus being one person, not two “people”:
both complete God and complete man, thus declaring the Virgin Mary as "Theotokos", bearer
of God. A declaration was also made at this council that the Nicene Creed, which was written
and agreed upon at the First and Second Ecumenical Councils (Nicaea and Constantinople,
respectively), was complete and no further revisions would be allowed. The remains of the
church and its well preserved baptismal font can be seen by visitors today within the Ephesus
site.
6.6.3 Basilica of St. John
In Selçuk, just a few miles north of the ancient city of Ephesus, sits the remains of the
Basilica of St. John, is a tribute to the saint constructed by Justinian in the 6th century, atop
what is likely St. John‟s final resting place. St. John is recognized to be an apostle, the author
of the Fourth Gospel, and a prophet, as the author of the book of Revelation. The remains of
the site today include some walls and columns of the basilica, as well as the baptistery and
mosaics.
6.6.4 House of the Virgin Mary
John was accompanied on his journey to Ephesus by Mary, who is said to have lived out
her final years in a small house now known as the House of the Virgin Mary, set atop Bülbül
Dagi (Mt. Koressos) near Ephesus. The stone building that stands today is said to be from the
6th or 7th centuries, but the foundations have been proven to originate from a much earlier
date, around the 1st century. The springs that run under the house are said to have healing
properties, evident in the canes and crutches that are left inside the house by the healed. This
site today is visited by Christians and Muslims alike (Muslims also regard Mary as the mother
of the Prophet Jesus, and accept the virgin birth).
6.7 Iznik
Though Iznik (Nicaea) today has been relegated to a sleepy town of about 20,000 people
on the shores of Lake Iznik, it was once a center for Christianity, being the location for the
First and Seventh Ecumenical Councils. The First Ecumenical Council of Nicaea in 325 was
called by Emperor Constantine the Great to discuss the Arian heresy, and it was at this
council that the concept of the Trinity was more clearly defined and the first draft of the
Nicene Creed was written. Both the Trinitarian Doctrine and the Nicene Creed were finalized
at the subsequent Council of Constantinople in 381. Unfortunately, the location of the
building where the First Council of Nicaea was held is underwater in Lake Iznik. However
there are numerous Roman remains throughout the city including city walls, towers and gates.
One important building that is still standing almost in its entirety is St. Sophia. The
Seventh Ecumenical Council (Second Council of Nicaea) was held there in 787 to discuss the
veneration of icons. An imperial edict by Leo III was made to suppress the veneration of
icons, and made officially forbidden by his son, Constantine V, in what was known as the
First Iconoclasm of the Byzantine Empire. The council reinstated permission for the adoration
of icons, but not their worship. St. Sophia was converted to a mosque in 1331, during the
Ottoman Empire and was abandoned around 1922. It is currently open for visitation.
175
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
7. Conclusion
There is no doubt that Christian-Muslim relations are at a critical juncture. Numerous
sources are to blame for the misunderstandings, discord and utter violence between the two
groups. With members of each faith armed with better knowledge of the other, they will
certainly come to accept and respect each other more, recognize their shared values, and
cooperate to foster peace. Faith-based tourism is one particular medium that can aim to bridge
the gap, open the platform for dialogue, and thus, further develop understanding and
acceptance. By changing the perception that American Christians have of Turkey and Islam,
they will be more likely to consider Turkey as a destination for their faith-based tourism
desires. A well planned program to promote Turkey to specific, key audiences will inevitably
have an immediate impact on the participants in such tours, but careful selection of the
audiences will guarantee an even broader impact. With its rich intermingling of Christian and
Muslim history, Turkey is uniquely poised to present the opportunity for interaction and
dialogue between the two faiths.
References
Anholt, Simon. “„Is this about me?‟--The critical issue of relevance.” Journal of Place
Branding and Public Diplomacy (2009) 5, 253-259. Web. 01 Jan. 2013.
Anthony, Jillian. “Stressed Americans don't use their measly vacation time”. CNN Money. 16
Nov. 2012. Web. 02 Jan. 2013.
Arinze, F. “Christian-Muslim Relations in the Twenty-First Century.” Center for Muslim-
Christian Understanding, Georgetown University, Washington, DC. Lecture. 5 June 1997.
Web. 10 Dec. 2012.
Brodhecker, Cindi. “Understanding Faith Tourism: Defining the different types of religious
groups and their unique needs.” Group University. 21 Dec. 2012. Web. 30 Dec. 2012.
Brooks, David. “Huntington‟s Clash Revisited.” Op-Ed. The New York Times. 3 March 2011.
Web. 07 Dec. 2012.
Chalmers, William D. “The Great American Passport Myth: Why Just 3.5% Of Us Travel
Overseas!” Huffington Post. 29 Sep. 2012. Web. 07 Dec. 2012.
Faithlife Study Bible Application. New International Version. Logos Bible Software. App. 01
Jan. 2012.
Fraser, Jane. “Plenty Like to Keep the Faith.” The Sydney Morning Herald. 23 Sep. 2012.
Web. 10 Dec. 2012.
Goddard, Hugh. A History of Christian Muslim Relations. Chicago: New Amsterdam Books,
2000. Print.
Grim, Brian, Karim, Mehtab S. “The Future of the Global Muslim Population: Projections for
2010-2030.” Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life. 27 Jan. 2011. Web. 03 December 2012.
Hackett, Conrad, Grim, Brian. “Global Christianity: A Report on the Size and Distribution of
the World's Christian Population”. Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life. 19 Dec. 2011.
Web. 21 Dec. 2012.
Hays, Holly. Sacred Destinations. 2005-2010. Web. 14 Jan 2013.
Heffner, Dr. Christopher L. “Psychology 101”. 01 April 2001. Web. [accessed 07.12.2012].
Huntington, Samuel. Clash of Civilizations. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1996. Print
176
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Jamal, Amaney. Interview by Mark O‟Keefe. “Islam and the West: How Great a Divide?”
Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life. 10 July 2006. Web. 3 Dec. 2012.
Kohut, Andrew. “The Great Divide: How Westerners and Muslims View Each Other.” Pew
Global Attitudes Project. 22 June 2006. Web. 14 Dec. 2012.
Kohut, Andrew. “Most Muslims Want Democracy, Personal Freedoms, and Islam in Political
Life”. Pew Research Center, Global Attitudes Project. 10 July 2012. Web. 05 December
2012.
Lugo, Luis; Cooperman, A., Green, J., Smith, G. “US Religious Knowledge Study.” Pew
Forum on Religion & Public Life (2010). 28 Sep. 2010. Web. 20 Dec. 2012.
National Geographic Education Foundation/National Geographic Society. “2006 Geographic
Literacy Study”. National Geographic-Roper Public Affairs. United States. May 2006. Web.
12 Dec. 2012.
Neff, Blake. “Historicity & Holy War: Putting the Crusades in Context”. The Augustine
Collective--Dartmouth Apologia. 2 Feb.2012. Web. 05 Dec. 2012.
Rae, Pauline. “Christian-Muslim Relations”. Compass: A Review of Topical Theology.
Autumn 2002, Vol 36, No 1. Web. 10 Dec. 2012.
Tourism-Review.com. “Faith Tourism: One of the Fastest Growing Industries”. 23 Jan. 2012.
Web. 10 Dec. 2012.
Türkiye Cumhuriyeti. Kültür ve Turizm Bakanlığı. “2009-2011 Yıllarında Ülkemize Gelen
Yabancıların Milleyetlerine Göre Karşılaştırlılması”. Web. 04 Jan. 2012.
United States. Dept. of State. “United States Department of State Passport Statistics”. Web.
30 Dec. 2012.
Uslu, Nasuh, Toprak, Metin, Dalmis, Ibrahim, Aydin, Ertan. “Turkish Public Opinion towards
the United States in the Context of Iraq Question”. Middle East Review of International
Affairs, Vol. 9, No. 3, September 2005. Web. 20 December 2012.
Verrastro, Nick. “Agents Essential to Dynamic Faith Based Travel Niche.” Travel Market
Report. 31 May 2012. Web. 10 Dec. 2012.
Wilson, Mark. Biblical Turkey: A Guide to the Jewish and Christian Sites of Asia Minor.
Istanbul: Ege Yayınları, 2010. Print.
177
Role of Religious Tourism in Conflict Resolution
Dr. Adejoh Apeh Matthew
The Federal Polytechnic, Bauchi
Department of Hospitality and Tourism Management,
School of Science and Technology,
Bauchi Nigeria
adejoh.am@gmail.com
Abstract
The paper analyzes discourse on religious tourism and its influence on conflict resolution.
Religion is a very complex concept, which includes many important characteristics. Religious
tourism, which is connected to sacred practices and discussion of diverse religious doctrines
and values, has become one of the most important features of religion. Nowadays, in the
modern era of globalization, people are actively sharing different ideas. Therefore, it is
important to utilize religious tourism in order to share values, which can later contribute to
conflict resolution. As the result, education and communication should become obligatory
components of religious tourism.
Keywords: Religious tourism, pilgrimage conflict resolution
1. Introduction
Travelling is very popular nowadays. Tourism industry is one of the most profitable
economic spheres. In fact, people choose to travel because of diverse reasons and motivations.
Usually, exhausted from daily routine, people travel in order to relax and revive their energy.
In our postmodern society, tourism is one of the most important economic industries for many
developing countries. Nevertheless, there are also moral purposes of tourism. That is why it is
important to pay attention to the phenomenon of religious tourism, which can also be referred
to as pilgrimage tourism.
In fact, tourism is a complex concept. Mill and Morrison once mentioned, “Tourism is a
difficult phenomenon to describe, all tourism involves travel, yet all travel is not tourism”
(Raj, 2007). Religious tourism involves travelling individually or in group for pilgrimage,
mission work, fellowship vacations, crusades, retreats, and the likes. Journeys relating to
religious sites and festivals, pilgrimage or spirituality, have long been a feature of human
travel (Raj, 2007). Nevertheless, although religion is usually perceived as benevolent, it can
sometimes be violent and hostile. For example, there exist various armed groups around the
world, such as al-Qaeda, which claim religious justification for their activities (Haynes,
2009).
That is why, it is necessary to mention that religious tourism can be beneficial to conflict
resolution – a system of redressing “a process in which one party perceives that its interests
are being opposed or negatively affected by another. Pilgrimage theories focus primarily on
religious motivation for visiting religious sites (Schott, 2008). Thus, it is important to mention
that peacemaking can be one of the goals of religious tourism.
2. Religious Tourism and Peacemaking
Religion is a very complex concept, which includes many important characteristics. For
example, Raj (2007) mentions that religion is an age-old dynamic concept embracing ancient,
living (including traditional living religions of primal societies) faiths and the emergence of
new religious and quasi-religious movements (also recognized as secular alternatives to
179
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
religion). According to this definition religion is not only a set of sacred practices such as
worshiping. In fact, religion is an act of faith, which can have many forms, such as
pilgrimage. It is on record that many great journeys and trips by individuals and groups have
been wholly or partially inspired by belief, e. g. the exodus of the people of Israel, the spread
of Islam, the journey of the Buddha, the Crusades, and Colonial conquests (Dallen, Timothy
and Olsen, 2006)
There are many historical examples of connections between religion and travel. For
instance, Islam as a vital, vivacious and expanding religion, in which Muhammad‟s migration
from Mecca to Medina in AD 622 was the genesis of the rapid spread of Islam throughout the
world (Raj, 2007). Therefore, it is necessary to define the term “religious tourism”.
In fact, it is not easy to give a single definition to “religious tourism”. Very often cultural
and religious travel are used synonymously because the majority of cultural tourists visit
religious sites as part of their itinerary, and are thus often referred to as religious tourists
(Nieminen, 2012). Nevertheless, it is necessary to stress that unlike cultural tourism, religious
tourism can have many functions. Therefore, religious tourism as a form of travel is either
about observing or participating in different activities according to one‟s belief, and is about
sharing a religious experience with someone and witnessing the faith (Nieminen, 2012).
According to this definition, religious tourism is also focused on sharing religious
practices. In fact, the number of tourists travelling purely for religious reasons is relatively
small, while many studies conclude that spiritual motivations for engaging in pilgrimage
outweigh religious ones (Richards, 2007). It also includes discussion of diverse religious
doctrines and values. Thus, both cultural and religious tourism complement each other, and
the promotion of religious tourism today seen as both devotional and cultural is a proof of the
existence of this common “search” (Swatos, 1998). Therefore, religious tourism is a broad
term, which involves many aspects.
Religion is usually involved in different conflicts. One of the reasons is that there are
various religious doctrines, which are competing with each other. If speaking in terms of
contemporary conflicts, there are three common forms that involve religion, namely religious
„fundamentalisms‟; „religious terrorism‟, especially involving „failed‟ states, such as
Afghanistan, Iraq, or Somalia; and controversies that surround „the clash of civilization‟ thesis
(Haynes, 2009). Thus, differences between East and West are creating many religious
conflicts. For example, Christianity and Islam have many traditions and values that can clash.
As a result, when claiming both absolute and exclusive validity, religious conviction can
lead to intolerance, over-zealous proselytisation and religious fragmentation (Haynes, 2009).
There are also many examples when religion has a different interpretation of law and
individual rights. For example, leaders within faith-based organizations may seek to
legitimize abuses of power and violation of human rights in the name of religious zeal
(Haynes, 2009). Therefore, such situations can lead to serious conflicts.
Religious tourism is closely connected to international relations. While religious conflict
resolution began to emerge only in the 1990s, religion has always been an integral part of
international relations (Shore, 2009). In addition, religion needs to be taken seriously in
international conflict resolution, because the changing nature of international conflict
necessitates consideration of religion as a dimension in resolution (Shore, 2009). Therefore,
religion is an important part of international conflict resolution, because it is influencing
moral obligation.
Conflict resolution, or in other words peacemaking, is a process, which involves variety of
important components. First of all, conflict resolution is impossible without strong leaders,
180
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
which are able to guide and inspire people. „Religious peacemakers‟ are religious individuals
or representatives of faith-based organizations that attempt to help resolve inter-group
conflicts and build peace (Haynes, 2009). These leaders should have particular qualities,
which can help them achieve their peacemaking goals. For instance, true peacemakers are
propelled by their faith; they have an unusual capacity to deeply understand others and
experience with great compassion their hopes and their pain (Little, 2005).
Religion can also help war-torn countries transit to democracy and sustainable peace
building, because it often plays such a strong role in civil society (Shore, 2009). Therefore,
religion can contribute to creation of effective civil society, which is able to peacefully
involve in political process. Religion can provide people with understanding of peaceful
negotiation, moral values and respect. Thus, people would be able to build effective
government based on these basic religious values. Religious texts are also important sources
of religious motivation. For example, Qu‟ran was used as a resource to help women become
empowered (Little, 2005). Therefore, religious texts play a very important role in conflict
resolution and transition to peaceful state.
Tradition and symbolism are also important elements of peacemaking. Common religious
traditions can contribute to conflict resolution in many situations. For instance, Ethiopia‟s
tradition of eldership can bring communities to peace in a way that politicians or professionals
with their frequent lack of understanding of key local traditions never can (Little, 2005). Thus,
pilgrimage can be especially beneficial for places where people share the same religious
traditions.
Nevertheless, very often communities who do not share same religious traditions face
conflicts. In such cases, religion helps in finding common ground through debates. For
example, Nigerian Peacemakers Pastor Wuye and Imam Ashafa were bitter enemies leading
militant religious groups, and decided to organize a debate between their respective Christian
and Muslim communities (Little, 2005). It seems like Christianity and Islam have completely
different religious approaches and traditions. However, despite this fact, both leaders came to
a surprising realization that their religions had more similarities than differences, and now
they work together to break stereotypes of religious “other”. This is a perfect example of how
a common religious ground can impact peacemaking.
Education is another important element of peacemaking. In fact, peace should not only be
achieved, but also preserved. The promotion of religion, official religious education, the
growth of diaspora tourism influenced the development of educational-religious tourism for
educational and religious reasons sand purposes (Dallen, 2006). There are also many
successful examples of religious education, which contributed to conflict resolution. For
instance, Abuna Elias Chacour, a Palestinian Christian Istraeli citizen living in the Galilee,
founded the Mar Elias Educational Institutions to educate a new generation on the possibility
of coexistence in a land as diverse as the religious and ethnic identity he himself represents
(Little, 2005). As a result, many students from diverse religious background are educated in
this school. Religious tourism can also contribute to this practice. By travelling to new regions
and sharing knowledge and experiences on conflict management it is important to establish
principles of peacemaking in many regions.
The fact is that communication is a vital tool for the peacemaking. Many religious leaders
are writing different peace notes, which encourage religious peacemaking. For example,
Nigerian peacemakers Pastor Wuye and Imam Ashafa drafted and signed the Kaduna Peace
Agreement, helping to calm years of widespread violence perpetrated in Kaduna State in the
name of religion (Little, 2005). Therefore, diplomacy and written agreements are also good
ways of preserving peace.
181
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Nowadays there are many peace building religious organizations, which are promoting
conflict resolution in different parts of the world. They have specifically been identified as
following:
1. „emotional and spiritual support to war-affected communities‟,
2. effective mobilization for „their communities and others for peace‟,
3. mediation „between conflicting parties‟, and
4. a conduit in pursuit of „reconciliation, dialogue, and disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration‟ (Haynes, 2009).
Therefore, the role of such organization in religious tourism is increasing.
3. Conclusion
The importance of pure pilgrimage can be clearly seen in sites such as Lourdes, Mecca
and Chiang Mai (Raj, 2007). Nevertheless, it is also necessary to find universal ways to
resolve conflicts through religious tourism. Nowadays, it is possible to think of interactions
between religion and globalization in other ways (Lehman, 2009). For instance, today people
are actively sharing political practices, such as democracy. Therefore, if it is possible to share
democratic values, religious views can also be transmitted from one country to another.
Religious tourism should play a major role in peace building process in the modern era of
globalization. Religious tourism is also focused on sharing religious practices. That is why it
is necessary to arrange different religious conferences and other events. In fact, religion is
becoming less popular, while spirituality or the search for belief through spirituality is more
of a trend, which will reshape the characteristics of religious tourism in the future (Nieminen,
2012). That is why such meetings can significantly contribute to peace building process and
conflict resolution in many areas.When beliefs and values are shared in the light of fear of the
Almighty professed, it is most likely that peace will reign as we respect one another‟s
feelings.
Religious reconciliation needs to use more of the language and methods of modern
conflict resolution (Little, 2005). It is important to promote communication between diverse
religious views. For example, it is possible to use language, which can be understood by
different religious traditions. This communication should be focused on common features of
different religions. For instance, the notion that there is God and He expects His people to
behave in a moral way is similar in many religions. Thus, peacemaking can be achieved by
finding some common grounds between different religions.
Crusades, retreats and missionary outreaches are known to provide fertile training ground
for peace building. Private and public agencies that are committed to sponsoring these
programmes are overtly and covertly contributing to harmonious co-existence among citizens.
Overall, religious tourism should play a major role in peace building process in the
modern era of globalization. That is why it is necessary to arrange different religious
conferences and other events. Religious tourism and communication, which are focused on
common features of different religions, can effectively solve diverse conflicts.
182
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
References
Dallen, T., & Olsen, D. (Eds.). (2006). Tourism religion and spiritual journeys. Oxon:
Routledge.
Haynes, J. (2009). Conflict resolution and peace-building: The role of religion in
Mozambique, Nigeria and Cambodia. London: Commonwealth & Comparative Politics.
Lehmann, D., (2009). Religion and globalization. Retrieved from
http://www.davidlehmann.org/david-docs-pdf/Pub
pap/Religion%20and%20Globalization%20proofs.pdf
Little, D. (Ed.). (2007). Peacemakers in action: Profiles of religion in conflict resolution.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nieminen, K., (2012). Religious tourism - a Finnish perspective (Thesis). Retrieved from
https://publications.theseus.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/51755/Nieminen_Katri.pdf?sequence=1
Raj, R., & Morpeth, N. D. (Eds.). (2007). Religious tourism and pilgrimage festivals
management: An international perspective. Wallingford: CABI.
Richards, G. (2007). Cultural tourism: Global and local perspectives. Binghamton: Haworth
Hospitality Press.
Schott, S. B. (2008). Religious tourism in America: Identity formation of sites and visitors
(Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest database. (UMI 3313163).
Shore, M. (2009). Religion and conflict resolution: Christianity and South Africa's truth.
Burlington: Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Swatos W. (Ed.). (1998). Encyclopedia of religion and society. London: AltaMira Press.
183
Alternative Tourism in Isparta City: Faith Tourism in Psidia Antiocheia
Ancient City
Ast.Prof. Dr. İsmail KERVANKIRAN
Süleyman Demirel University
Faculty of Arts and Science Department of Geography
ismailkervankiran@sdu.edu.tr
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Hüseyin KAYA
Süleyman Demirel University
Faculty Education Department of Social Studies Education
huseyinkaya@sdu.edu.tr.
Tourism can be defined as the movement of people to a specific destination, this is out of
normality of work and home, to perform activities at these destinations by using facilities that
fulfill their needs (Gunn, 1994: 5).
Tourism is unique to the modern age providing nations and communities come together as
a result of needs as recreation, entertainment and living in a different atmosphere, the desire to
know the charming beauties fed by nature and art, the development of trade and industry and
comfortable transportation facilities (Kahraman and Türkay, 2009). Tourism concept is
defined by the Turkish Institute of Language as “The whole of the events occured as a result
of entertainment, vacation, culture, visiting friends and relatives, active sport, meeting,
vocational reasons, education, health, transit and such purposes from the living place to other
places” in the the dictionary of terms.
Tourism as being one of the mostly improved fields in the world causes international
competition as a result of providing the development of the countries. Countries are working
to attract more tourists by integrating alternative tourist products with the existing tourist
products in order to supass their opponants. Daily changing demands of people in tourism
force tourism firms to find different touristic products and facilities. In accordance with this
alternative types of tourism as cultural tourism, thermal tourism, ecotourism, rural tourism
and faith tourism appeared recently.
Faith tourism, among these types of tourism is one of the oldest through the human
history. People if not by name “tourism”, constantly used to visit the places that they consider
as divine in the past. Today people visit places for veneration according to their religions as
well. The travels from constant living areas to the places to meet the religious needs are
considered as faith tourism according to the tourism concept.
Human beings have felt the need of belonging to a religion since creation. Consequently, a
number of various religion and faith groups appeared since the first man on earth in history.
Hence divine places were visited with mass movements by the human beings. In accordance
with these movements “faith tourism” appeared as an alternative tourism phenomenon. Faith
tourism has indicated great developments especially in the last 30 years. The highest rise took
place in 90’s (Wright, 2007).
People used to accept the places to be seen as divine and traveled to these centers
constantly or in particular periods. Almost all the religions have some time in a week or in the
year to worship and since they are universal numerous people from all over the world travel
these faith centers.These travels dependent to the charm of divine places used to be carried
out by the rich in the past whereas recently turned to be a mass movement with the
185
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
participation of millions from all over the world. For instance, the hajj visit of muslims to
Makkah and Medinah, Vatikan visit of christians for a week after December are such
examples. Such visits cause believers to feel relieved for performing their religious duties.
Because the interest is increasing to the faith tourism, tourism firms around the religous
places are inclining as well. Besides performing their duties people visit historical and cultural
places and participate in congresses, symposiums, religious meetings and conferences. Thus,
an important source of income is provided financially. the most important source of income
after oil is the currencies that Muslim pilgrims leave in Saudi Arabia. every year millions of
people are visiting Mecca and Medina which are significant places in terms of spiritual
values, for Hajj and Umrah worship, they accommodate in hotels buy souvenirs and benefit
from other businesses. As a result of all these activities a significant revenue is taken.
As a result of severe repression and destruction policies either the development of the first
civilizations in Anatolia or the apostles in the early periods of Christianity, the Jews in the
Middle Ages in their dwelling areas forced them to settle to these places, so besides a large
number of Ġslamic Works of Turks, a lot of synagogue and the churches in Anatolia took
place. Understanding, tolerance and respect of the Islamic nation in deep parallel artefacts that
have survived to the present day Turkey, brings an advantageous position than other countries
(http://www.kultur.gov.tr).
Turkey has very important advantages in terms of alternative tourism products and
resources in its geography in the world. One of the sources that is found in Turkey destination
and can not be substituted is the presence of many living area and spaces significant for the
members of the three monotheistic religions. This directly raises the faith tourism among
other alternative tourism activities that can be developed. 6 of the 8 sacred religious centers
(Selçuk, Demre, Tarsus, Istanbul, Iznik, Cappadocia) which adopted in the Christian world as
divine are located within the borders of Turkey. In addition, Istanbul, Konya and Sanliurfa
provinces, important for Muslims costitute the faith tourism centers (Kanıbir ve Kaşlı, 2007).
In recent years, many tour operators and travel agencies focused on the faith tourism
which is becoming a significant field of tourism, especially in the 90’s. Anatolia has a lot of
faith centers that can host and attract more tourists with a higher income than the normal
tourists. The important issues while using these belief centers are the growth of religious
tourism and to provide the diversity of tourism in the country. some tasks can be done in order
to attract more tourists for this type of alternative tourism. an inventory of religious places in
Anatolia with a rich potential in terms of faith tourism. The Ministry of Culture and Tourism
should address new markets and other countries that will participate in faith tourism by a
market research with a good advertising campaign as carried out in the United States (Güzel,
2010).
Religious tourism has socio-cultural, economic and political effects, also contributes to the
provision of cross-cultural interaction and world peace as well. Anatolia, alongside a wealth
of natural tourism resources, have sacred places because of being in an area where many
civilizations and the nation's three major religions meet. This is therefore the advantage of
Turkey, the global tourism market and tourism product diversification increases the
competitiveness of tourism in the country for becoming a center of attraction for the whole
year in terms of spreading the faith tourism.
The Religious Tourism In Psidia Antiocheia Ancient City
Isparta Province, as the land of roses and famous for its carpet is located in the western
part of the Mediterranean region at inland so called "Lake District". The surface area is 8933
km ² and 68% of the surface area is mountainous. The altitude is 1030 m. There are a total of
186
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
12 districts with the Central town. It is located at a transition region between the
Mediterranean climate and continental climate in Central Anatolia. It has a rich flora and
fauna (Isparta Governance, 2006). Isparta Province has 11 hotels licenced by the Ministry of
Culture with 534 hotel rooms and 1091 bed capacity and 55 hotel and hostel accommodation
facilities with 2416 bed capacity with Municipal licence, in general there are 67
accommodation facilities and a total of 3561 bed capacity and also 14 travel agencies. 150
418 domestic and 17 246 foreign visitors, a total of 167 664 arrived in the region in 2010 and
the same year 39 143 people visited the museum and archaeological sites
(www.ispartakulturturizm.gov.tr).
To compete in the global tourism market and to ensure the sustainability of tourism,
religious tourism opportunities in terms of infrastructure and superstructure spaces that
enhance the attractiveness of the tourism product and promotion of national and international
markets, should be carried out properly. Providing tourism with appeals depends on sufficient
possibilities of tourism enterprises and convenient transportation. There are such possibilities
as lake tourism, winter tourism, rural tourism, ecotourism, cultural tourism, religious tourism,
rose tourism, nature tourism, etc with rich tourism potential in the province of Isparta.
However, as well as tourism potential, tourism investments need to be even more. one of the
most important shortcomings in Isparta tourism is the lack of adequate tourism facilities. In
order to increase the interest of the private sector in the region, the public sector should
provide the necessary support.
Isparta is not one of the important tourism centers of Turkey. Indeed, Isparta is not
included among the major destinations on the web page of the Ministry of Tourism. This is
because, Isparta does not have a tourist asset that will attract the attention of the whole world.
However, in particular in terms of cave tourism, cultural and religious tourism It has
considerable wealth. Also Isparta has a potential to be developed in terms of alternative types
of tourism (Turkoglu et al, 2005).
In order to raise the standards of tourism in the province of Isparta, public officials,
private sector, local communities and all tourism actors have significant roles. These tasks are
the most important ones in the public incentives to increase the provision of facilities to
investors from outside, qualified institutions, to increase the interest of the private sector in
the region, increasing the awareness of publicity of tourism, tourism facilities, improving the
quality of service, professional presentations, result-oriented plans and "Isparta Tourism
Action Plan” prepared by the experts , ensuring the sustainability of the natural and cultural
tourism values of short, medium-and long-term conservation plans for the creation of the
province of alternative tourism products to be integrated with the main tourist product, tourist
profiles, continuous monitoring, both national and international festivals, congresses,
symposia and festivals should be organized.
Antiocheia, established along the southern slopes of the Sultan mountains about 1 Km
from the north of Yalvac town of Isparta province. The ancient city is the capital of the
Pisidia, on behalf of the city founder the name ' antiocheia ' was given (Map 1). For more than
twenty cities in Anatolia called antiocheia so they are separated from each other with the
names of the region. Prominent structures of Pisidia Antiocheia' are the Temple of Augustus,
Aqueducts, St. Paul's Church, Tiberius Square, Roman Baths, Theatre, Main Street and west
gate is located.
Yalvaç (Antiocheia), established in the last period of Hellenism became very important
during the reign of the Romans. W. Ramsay's excavations in this region, highlighted the role
of Pisidia Antiocheia. Here, the head of the statue of Augustos, aqueducts, and other remnants
of this region is oriented to the status of the transfer of the Romans (Demirgil and Demirgil,
187
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
2009). Anatolia, is very important in terms of the years of the first ascent of Christianity. This
land has hosted the first Christian communities. Which is Saint Paul an important figure of the
Christians, was born in Anatolia and visited a lot of points in here with missionary activities.
Our country with religious tourism potential in addition to the potential of sea-sun-sand
tourism has extraordinary richness and eco-tourism potential as part of the alternative tourism
(Berk, 2011).
Figure 1: Location Map of Pisidia Antiocheia
Pisidian city, is one of the first settlements laid the foundations of Christianity and spread
all over the world, and has been recognized as the second center of pilgrimage for Christians.
Every year, hundreds of people come to this city to worship. With this feature, it has an
important place for faith tourism. Taken within the framework of History and museum
tourism Pisidia Antiocheia is one of the important places. The ancient city, is above all a
source and document from past to present in terms of language, religion, art, history and
science issues and socio-economic areas. storage of the protection of a variety of works
obtained as a result of excavations, exhibition of these works for people in order to have more
information about the works is an important tourism approach in terms of Anatolian
Civilizations and the reflection of local culture for Yalvaç (Kuter ve Erdoğan, 2006).
St. Paul's Road is the second long-distance walking route after the Lycian Way in Turkey.
This route is 260 km long, begins from Perge in Pamphylia and ends at Pisidia settlement in
Antiokheia area (Yalvaç) (Figure 1). St. Paul and his friends 46 A.D. moved from Perge to
Pisidian Antiokheia (Yalvaç) in the north. The route of St. Paul is not known exactly. What is
known in this route is that the date and nature intertwined. The starting point of the route is
Aspendos or Perge. After the confluence of two tracks on the Adada ancient city, follow the
188
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
same route. The region between Perge and Taurus Mountains is full of impassable curves.
The rivers fed by snow waters flowing from the plateau into the sea, farms, jungles,
highlands, valleys, canyons and lakes along the way are the extraordinary beauties. Because
the region indicates major changes in terms of climate and altitude, a different geography with
forest and steppe areas meets us (Clow and Richardson, 2005).
Yalvaç city important for faith tourism is the missionary voyages of St. Paul- an important
figure in the spread of Christianity- in the ancient city of Pisidia . St. Paul's gave his first
known sermon in this city, and at later years and St. Paul's Church was built in the name of
this person. the interest in the region is increasing with each passing day by emphasizing the
importance of this city in terms of Christianity and presentation of this church. But it is
clearly seen that there is so much to do to catch the desired development trend. To succeed it
and turning Yalvaç into a center for faith tourism will be a significant factor for the future
development of the city. There are so many centers significant for Christian world over the
Anatolian land. Some of these places are important to Christianity, such as the Vatican and
the pope was declared as official places of Christian crosses officials.
For example, the Pope of the 16th By Benedickt announced 2008 as the "St. Paul Year",
St. Paul, one of the 12 apostles of Jesus, came and preached his first sermon in order to spread
Christianity at Yalvac, Isparta in Anatolia, known as the place and the for 500 thousand
tourists were expected to visit there. This figure is a substantial figure at all (Güzel, 2010).
Today, the demand for faith tourism is increasing every day. Pisidian Antiocheia ancient
city which contains St. Paul's Church, one of the oldest churches in Anatolia, located in
Turkey's most important venues for faith tourism. If investments for the development of
tourism rational planning and effective advertisement in the region, the demand will increase
and tourism sector will be at a desired level.
CONCLUSION
The World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) estimates that 300 million tourists every
year throughout the world have been traveling for religious purposes. This economical value
of these travels costs about 18 billion dollars. In addition, tourist movements in the religious
tourism market are expected to increase by 20% by 2020. All this shows that, religious
tourism in the future will be one of the important types of alternative tourism.
The ancient city of Pisidian Antiocheia is a major attraction in terms of religious tourism.
However, the ancient city tourist demand is below the expectations. Some studies for the
development of tourism in this area is required. These are the most important ones in
infrastructure, superstructure, promotion and marketing. Infrastructure, roads, electricity,
water, sewer, zoning plans, and so on. As such, accommodation, recreational facilities, food
and beverage outlets, shopping, culture, art houses, recreation centers, parks, gardens and
recreational areas, etc. can be counted among them. Infrastructure, superstructure and carries
out promotional activities with the public and private sectors. The priority of the private
sector is in marketing. In the study area, effective factors for faith tourism not being at the
desired level in the region are lack of adequate tourism enterprises, the lack of promotion and
marketing, supporting the different tourist products, lack of faith, not completely putting
forward the ancient city of Pisidian Antiochiea in the ancient area and adequate protection
against both physical and human factors should be the measures. In order to increase the
tourist demand to region public sector and private sector should cooperate and give common
contributions.
189
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Reerences
Berk, F.M. (2011). Ġnanç ve Doğa Turizminin Kesiştiği Nokta: Aziz Paul Yolu. 1. Uluslar
arası 4. Ulusal Eğirdir Turizm Sempozyumu, Isparta.
Demirgil, S. ve Demirgil, H. (2009). Isparta’nın Kısa Tarihi. Editör: Gül, H. ve Boybeyi, S.
Geçmişten Günümüze Isparta. Atatürk Kültür Merkezi Yayını, No:370.
Gunn, C.A. (1994). Tourism Planning: Basics, Concepts, Cases, 3rd Ed. Washington, Taylor
& Francis.
Güzel, F.Ö. (2010). Turistik Ürün Çeşitlendirmesi Kapsamında Yeni Bir Dinamik: Ġnanç
Turizmi. Süleyman Demirel Üniversitesi, Vizyoner Dergisi, C.2, S.2. s.87-100.
http://www.tdk.org.tr/terimler.html Erişim Tarihi: 18.12.2012.
http://www.kultur.gov.tr/, Erişim Tarihi: 19.12.2012.
http://www.ispartakulturturizm.gov.tr/belge/1-84335/konaklama-istatistikleri.html, Erişim
Tarihi: (19.12.2012).
ISPARTA VALĠLĠĞĠ, Ġl Çevre Ve Orman Müdürlüğü (2006), Isparta Çevre Durum
Raporu, Editör: Tuzcu, D., Isparta Çevre Ve Orman Ġl Müdürlüğü Yayını.
Kahraman, N. ve Türkay, O. (2009). Turizm ve Çevre. Detay Yayıncılık, Ankara.
Kanıbir, H. ve Kaşlı, M. (2007). İnanç Turizmi. Editör: Bulu, M. ve Eraslan, Ġ.H.
Sürdürülebilir Rekabet Avantajı Elde Etmede Turizm Sektörü Sektörel Stratejiler ve
Uygulamalar. Ġstanbul: Uluslar arası Rekabet Araştırmaları Kurumu Derneği Yayınları,
No:2007/1.
Kuter, N. ve Erdoğan, E. (2006). Yalvaç, Pisidia Antiocheia Antik Kenti ve Çevresinin Peyzaj
Özellikleri ve Turizm Açısından Değerlendirilmesi. Süleyman Demirel Üniversitesi Orman
Fakültesi Dergisi Seri: A, Sayı: 1, Sayfa: 111-123.
Sargın, S. (2006). Yalvaç’ta Ġnanç Turizmi. Fırat Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, Cilt:
16, Sayı: 2 Sayfa: 1-18. Elazığ.
Türkoğlu, M, Gövrede, B. ve Meydan Ç. (2005), Isparta Ġli Turizmin Sorunları ve Çözüm
Önerileri, Süleyman Demirel Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi, Yıl/Volume:1,
Sayı/Number:1, s:29-38, Isparta.
Wrıght, K. (2007). Religious Tourism, Leisure Group Travel Special Edition, November,
pp:8-16.
190
Religious Recourses and Pilgrim tourism in
Georgia
Marina Metreveli
PhD, Professor
Leading Tourism Specialist, Economic Sector and Economic
Policy Committee, Parliament of Georgia, Tbilisi, Georgia
E-mail: marinametreveli@yahoo.co.uk
Web.: ww.marinametreveli.ge
Heritage in Georgia is almost synonymous with religious heritage. Few countries in the world
possess such an intensity of built religious patrimony in a small territory as the foundations of
their heritage tourism sector as Georgia does. Georgia is already an increasingly popular
destination, but owing to its important religious history, the multitude of ancient churches and
holy relics at home there, and the inseparable mix of religious and natural heritages capes, the
country has the potential to develop further in three areas of heritage tourism: domestic
pilgrimage; international pilgrimage among Orthodox Christians from Eastern Europe and
countries of the former USSR; and non-religious cultural tourists from all over the world.
This brief research note describes the current situation regarding religiously based heritage
tourism recourses and pilgrim tourism trends in Georgia.
Keywords: Georgia; Caucasus; religious tourism; churches; heritage tourism; pilgrimage
Introduction
Pilgrimage is one of the earliest forms of organized tourism and involves visits to holy
sites by religious worshippers for communion with deity, forgiveness for sins, healing, or
other manifestations of personal spiritual growth. Most religions of the world today endorse
or accept some form of religious travel, and this form of tourism is growing in importance in
regions which possess sites that are venerated as sacred by the world’s faithful. Sites visited
by pilgrims include churches, mosques, temples, gravesites, sacred groves and grottos, rivers,
mountains, sites of miracles, and locations of divine visitations. These places, among many
others, are deemed sacred and are venerated by the faithful and sanctified by faith
organizations, so that they have become important destinations for devotees.
In addition to being places of worship for people of a specific faith, many sacred spaces
are viewed by the larger traveling public as important destinations and attractions in their own
right because of their historical or aesthetic value (Jackson & Hudman, 1994; Shackley, 2001;
Timothy & Olsen, 2006). Thus, some of the most important cultural attractions in Europe, the
Middle East, Asia and Latin America are religious in nature. Buddhist temples and
monasteries in Thailand and Bhutan; mosques in Jordan, Turkey, and Egypt; and churches
and cathedrals in Latin America and Europe all form an important part of the heritage
attraction base for religious adherents and non-adherents alike (Nolan & Nolan, 1992;
Timothy & Nyaupane, 2009). A package tour of England would be incomplete without
mandatory stops at Westminster Abbey or Canterbury Cathedral. A trip to Bangkok,
Thailand, would be deficient without a visit to the Temple of the Emerald Buddha or the
Temple of the Reclining Buddha. Many such religious sites throughout the world have been
listed by UNESCO as important World Heritage Sites with universal appeal and value, adding
yet an additional layer of allure for potential visitors.
This research note describes tourism and the rich religious heritage of the Republic of
Georgia and its role in Christianity through the ages. At present, the country’s religious
heritage is one of its most salient tourism assets and is popular among domestic and
191
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
international travelers. Based on its rich living and built cultural past, Georgia’s potential
tourism growth is substantial; this paper outlines three particular areas in which the nation’s
heritage tourism has some of the strongest potential for growth.
The religious history of Georgia
Georgia is situated in the Caucasus region of Eurasia. It has long been a crossroads where
east and west, north and south were commercially, socially, and spiritually connected (Coene,
2009; Griffin, 2001). Georgia’s ancient boundaries and socio-political influence extended far
beyond its current national borders to include much of present-day Armenia, Azerbaijan,
Russia, and Turkey. Because of the country’s role as a junction of trade and transit, it
developed a unique mix of western and eastern cultures unlike any other place. Georgia’s
well-established position at the boundary of Europe and Asia, and its known trade routes
made it a logical destination for the spread of Christianity from the Holy Land as it made its
way through Southern and Eastern Europe.
Following the crucifixion of Jesus Christ, his apostles scattered to begin their missionary
efforts throughout the Mediterranean region and the Caucasus. According to Georgian
religious historians, St Andrew, one of Jesus’ apostles, preached the Christian gospel in
Georgia (then composed of two Georgian kingdoms – Colchis and Iberia) and won many
converts in the first century AD. Colchis and Iberia were among the first states to accept
Christianity as their official state religion early in the fourth century AD (319 or 337 AD)
(Alasania, 2006). Other Christian apostles preached in Georgia, including St Jude (St
Thaddaeus), Simon the Zealot, St Matthias, and St Bartholomew, and according to Georgian
tradition, Simon and St Matthias were buried in Georgia.
Based upon the doctrines and principles taught by St Andrew in the first century, the
Georgian Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Church was established and adopted as the state
religion in the fourth century. Around that time, the first Georgian Orthodox churchwas built
at Mtskheta. The current Svetitskhoveli Cathedral was built in the twelfth century on the
foundations of the original fourth-century church and has become one of the most salient
religious sites in the country and functions as the seat of the archbishop of Mtskheta and
Tbilisi.
Over the centuries, many invading forces have threatened Christianity in Georgia.
Invasions by Persians, Arabs, Turks, and Mongols, to name just a few, aimed in part to
diminish the role of the church and to topple the established Georgian Orthodox Church
(Griffin, 2001; Pelkmans, 2006). Georgian history is rich with accounts of people suffering
for their faith, including over 100,000 martyrs in 1226, who refused to deny their faith.
Thousands of monks and nuns were also put to death during the medieval period by invading
hordes. The Georgians are proud of their ancestors’ ability to withstand the invasions from the
south and east that tried not only to repress the actions of the Church but also to topple the
Georgian nation. This religious and political history has developed, within the Georgian
national psyche, a great sense of pride and adoration for the Georgian Orthodox Church and
today nearly 85% of the country’s population belongs to the faith. Additionally, the church is
among the most influential establishments in the country from social, economic, and political
perspectives. The early foundation of the church facilitated the early development of Georgian
secular culture as well. Poetry, art, literature, intellectual discourse and music are important
elements of Georgian identity that were boosted by the country’s religious institution from the
outset and remain a salient part of the people’s national ethos (Suny, 1994).
192
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Religious Recourses and Pilgrim tourism in Georgia
The history of the Orthodox Church is the foundation of the heritage of Georgia. While
dramatic mountain landscapes and nature provide a lot of the much-desired backdrop for
tourism in Georgia (Nasmyth, 2006), the country’s religious built heritage forms an equally
important core of contemporary tourism (Lew, Hall, & Timothy, 2008; Metreveli & Timothy,
2010).
There are, in Georgia, today an estimated 35,000 historic monuments, many of which are
religious in origin. Some 5000 of these places are protected by the state; so there is much
more work to be done to safeguard the country’s additional heritage resources. Three of the
most significant sites have been inscribed on UNESCO’s World Heritage List (WHL),
including the historic village of Chazhashi in Upper Svaneti with its unique architecture and
landscape, the Historical Monuments of Mtskheta (churches and religious architecture), and
the Bagrati Cathedral and Gelati Monastery. In addition, 15 important sites have been added
to UNESCO’s Tentative List (one is a natural site), which means that Georgia plans to
nominate them for the WHL in the near future. As Table 1 shows, most of the nominated
cultural or mixed sites are either religious monuments or have a religious component or
connotation. This is illustrative of the importance of religious patrimony in the heritage
product of Georgia.
Toward the end of the twentieth century, with the collapse of the communist Soviet
government in 1991, which shunned religious practices and adopted an official dogma of
atheism, religious devotion began to grow. With increased freedom to worship and practice
the faith of their forebears, the number of religious adherents has grown tremendously since
the early 1990s. This has resulted in the large-scale building of new churches, but more
importantly for this discussion, it also resulted in the preservation and restoration of many
ancient churches and monasteries throughout the country that had been overwhelmingly
neglected during the Soviet era. The atheist government in power between 1921 and 1991
discouraged religious worship and de-prioritized the conservation of spiritual places, whereas
the new government has re-prioritized the country’s ecclesiastical heritage as worthy of
protection and promotion for touristic and other purposes.
Table 1. Georgia’s 14 cultural heritage properties on the Tentative WHL.
Heritage property Location Religious site or
associated
religious site?
Alaverdi Cathedral Kakheti region Yes
Ananuri Mtskheta-Mtianeti region Yes
David Gareji monasteries and hermitage Signagi and Dedoplistskaro Yes
districts
Dmanisi Hominid archaeological site Lower Cartli region No
Gremi Church of Archangels and Royal Kakheti region Yes
Tower
Kvetera Church Kakheti region Yes
Mta-Tusheti Kakheti region No
Nicortsminda Cathedral Racha region Yes
Samtavisi Cathedral Gori district Yes
Shatili Mtskheta-Mtianeti region Yes
Tbilisi historic district Cartli region Yes
Uplistsikhe cave town Gori district Yes
Vani Imereti region Yes
Vardzia-Khertvisi Samtskhe-Javakheti region Yes
Source: UNESCO (2012).
193
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Given this shifting perspective and prioritization, Georgia has seen a widespread and
growing interest in tourism based upon its spiritual past. The most salient form of religious
tourism is domestic pilgrimages, with a smaller contingent of Georgians traveling to holy sites
outside their country’s borders. In 2006, approximately 3000 Georgian pilgrims traveled in
their own country to churches and other sacred sites for spiritual purposes.
The same year, 254 pilgrims visited Tao-Klarjeti (Turkey), 607 visited Jerusalem, 42
visited Egypt, and 43 visited Italy. In 2011, the number increased to some 50000 domestic
pilgrims and 10034 to the same sites abroad (Department of Pilgrimage Tourism, Patriarchate
of Georgia, 2012). These data do not give an accurate portrayal of domestic and outbound
religious tourism because private tour companies are typically unwilling to provide
information to government officials. However, they are based on best estimates and do
demonstrate an emerging measure of growth in the pilgrimage sector. Although many
Georgians do visit historic churches and monasteries for their historical and aesthetic value, it
is expected that as the former atheistic influence of the Soviet Union continues to subside
among the Georgian population, increasing numbers of churchgoers will undertake
pilgrimages domestically and abroad.
In addition to the relics and properties in Georgia, the Georgians also built or acquired
sacred edifices in other parts of the world during and after the medieval period, the way other
Christian churches did. For instance, there are Georgian Orthodox buildings in
Israel/Palestine, Syria, Cyprus, Greece, and Bulgaria. The Monastery of the Cross in
Jerusalem (presently under the jurisdiction of the Greek Patriarch of Jerusalem), St. Jacob’s
Convent in Jerusalem (presently under the jurisdiction of the Armenian Church of Jerusalem),
the Iberon Monastery on Mount Athos in Greece, and the Petritsoni Monastery in Bulgaria
(now known as the Bachkovo Monastery) are a few prominent examples.
Another aspect of religious heritage tourism is foreigners visiting sacred places, because
the holy sites are an important part of Georgian culture and are among the most prominent
ancient monuments in the country. Almost every region and district has historic churches or
monasteries, which creates an immense heritage resource base also for non-pilgrim visitors,
who can travel along the routes that highlight the most important historic properties. The
importance of these sites is unmistakable, as their attention by UNESCO attests, and they are
important heritage resources given their unique architecture, natural surroundings, interesting
history, and new efforts at conservation.
Table 1 provides information on international arrivals in Georgia between 2000 and
20011. There has been considerable growth in arrivals during the early twentieth century, but
it is very difficult to extrapolate the number of people who visit religious heritage sites, and
the government has no estimates in this regard. It is likely, however, that a significant
proportion of international tourists do, in fact, visit religious heritage locations while in
Georgia, since these are among the country’s most prominent attractions. In addition, it is
possible that some of the visitors from the countries of Eastern Europe and the former Soviet
Union (CIS) are Orthodox Church members themselves and have come to Georgia on some
sort of pilgrimage.
The potential for growth of religious tourism As already noted, the potential for
pilgrimage tourism in Georgia is noteworthy, particularly among domestic residents, who are
members of the Orthodox Church. However, there is a probable demand among the Georgian
Diaspora abroad as well and perhaps among other Orthodox Church members from countries
such as Ukraine, Greece, Serbia, Armenia, Belarus, Bulgaria, and Russia. This possibility is
heightened by the ostensible existence of many sacred artifacts brought to the country from
the Holy Land by the ancient apostles.
194
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
According to Georgian church historians and Eastern Orthodox religious traditions, the
robe of Jesus (the Chiton of Christ) from the time of his crucifixion was brought to Georgia
by a rabbi, who purchased the garment from a Roman soldier shortly after the death of Christ.
The chiton is said to be preserved beneath Svetitskhoveli Cathedral in Mtskheta.
As per the information of the Border Control Department, the number of visitors in
Georgia in 2000 was 373 746; in 2003, 301 051 people visited Georgia and in 2004, the
country had 364 512 visitors. In 2005, 559 427 people visited the country; 762 193 (in 2006),
1 05 036 (in 2007), 1 288 039 (in 2008), 1 497 415 (in 2009) and the number of tourists was 2
029 447 in 2010. The number of visits to Georgia in 2000-2010 increased by 5.4 and the share
of tourism in the country GDP was 3,92% in 2006, 4,10% in 2007, 3,72% in 2008 and 4% in
2009, 2010, 2011. The number of tourists in Georgia in 2011 was 2 819 144 marked by 39%
increase as compared to the previous year.
Table 1. Number of incoming tourists in Georgia (Border Control Department of Georgia, 2011)
195
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Table 2. Trends of International Visitors in Georgia 2009-2012 (National Tourism Administration of
Ministry of Economy and Sustainable Development of Georgia, 2012)
Trends of International Visitors in Georgia 2009-2012
400000
350000
300000
250000
2009
200000
2010
150000
2011
100000
2012
50000
0
r
r
e
r
r
st
ay
y
ch
y
ril
ry
be
be
be
be
n
l
ar
gu
Ju
Ap
ua
M
Ju
ar
em
em
m
to
nu
Au
M
br
ce
Oc
Ja
pt
v
Fe
De
No
Se
Several additional holy relics are said to have been deposited in Georgia, in addition to the
apostles Matthias and Simon being buried there. The mantle of Elijah is believed to be
preserved in Georgia, and the original icon of Mary, the mother of Jesus, was brought to the
country by St Andrew, where it was kept in the Atskveri Cathedral for many years. When
Georgia adopted Christianity in the early fourth century, the Roman emperor Constantine sent
the following gifts to the new Christian nation: of a piece of the cross of the crucifixion, two
nails from the cross, the board upon which Jesus stood while he was crucified, and an original
icon of Jesus.
Clearly these traditions, the sites associated with the sacred artifacts, and the locations
where the apostles preached have the potential to become a more important part of the
pilgrimage product. It would behoove the Department of Tourism and Resorts to highlight
these attractions in its domestic promotional efforts and in the parts of Europe where Eastern
Orthodox churches are most dominant. The state Patriarchate, parliament, and other tourism
policy-makers should cooperate more closely to develop a pilgrimage policy that would raise
the status of Georgia as one of Christianity’s premier religious destinations, particularly for
tourists from Eastern Europe and CIS.
The country has a lot to offer even for non-pilgrim tourists. Curiosity seekers, casual
heritage visitors, serious heritage enthusiasts, and amateur historians should have considerable
interest in the ancient religious legacy of Georgia. More promotional efforts should focus on
the World Heritage Site status of three of the country’s most scenic areas and the fact that 15
more have recently been placed on UNESCO’s Tentative List.
Many heritage specialists believe that a site’s placement on UNESCO’s WHL can be used
to a country’s tourism advantage, as it becomes a brand to help in promotional efforts (Boyd
& Timothy, 2006; Fyall & Rakic, 2006; Hall & Piggin, 2003; Timothy, 2011). Regardless of
whether or not tourists are adherents to Orthodox Christianity, they should find the country’s
rich array of historic churches and monasteries to be an interesting part of its cultural
landscape worthy of a visit. The ancientness of Georgia’s churches should prevail in the
Department of Tourism and Resorts’ promotional efforts to attract non-pilgrim tourists as
well.
196
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Conclusion
This short research note provides a descriptive overview of the importance of religious
heritage and its relics in the cultural tourism milieu of Georgia. Very little has been written
about tourism in the Caucasus region, including Georgia; this paper contributes additional
perspectives about a country whose primary heritage appeal lies in its spiritual and religious
past. The country is unique as regards its religious heritage. Few places in the world can boast
of such a focused heritage landscape, geared toward a unique religious past. Even the Holy
Land and Rome are home to a much wider array of heritages beyond religion, while by far
Georgia’s main cultural product is its churches and monasteries. This intensity of religious
resources has the potential to make the country one of the most important heritage
destinations in Europe.
There is much work to do in Georgia to be able to understand domestic pilgrims, foreign
pilgrims, and international heritage tourists who might visit the churches because of their
aesthetic appeal or historical significance in the development of the Georgian nation. This
should be an important priority for the government to expand its tourism industry.
References
Alasania, G. (2006). Twenty centuries of Christianity in Georgia. IBSU Scientific Journal,
1(1), 117–129.
Boyd, S.W., & Timothy, D.J. (2006). Marketing issues and World Heritage Sites. In A. Leask
& A.
Fyall (Eds.), Managing World Heritage Sites (pp. 53–66). Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
Coene, F. (2009). The Caucasus: An introduction. London: Routledge.
Department of Pilgrimage Tourism, Patriarchate of Georgia. (2009). Pilgrimage data.
Retrieved January 9, 2010, from http://www.patriarchate.ge/_en/?action=home
Department of Tourism and Resorts. (2010). Arrivals of non-resident visitors at national
borders of Georgia 2000–2009. Tbilisi: Author.
Fyall, A., & Rakic, T. (2006). The future market for World Heritage Sites. In A. Leask & A.
Fyall (Eds.), Managing World Heritage Sites (pp. 159–175). Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
Griffin, N. (2001). Caucasus: A journey to the land between Christianity and Islam. Chicago,
IL: University of Chicago Press.
Hall, C.M., & Piggin, R. (2003).World Heritage Sites: Managing the brand. In A. Fyall, B.
Garrod, & A. Leask (Eds.), Managing visitor attractions: New directions (pp. 203–219).
Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
Jackson, R.H., & Hudman, L.E. (1994). Pilgrimage tourism and English cathedrals: The role
of religion in travel. Tourist Review, 4, 40–48.
Lew, A., Hall, C.M., & Timothy, D.J. (2008). World geography of travel and tourism: A
regional approach. Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
Metreveli, M., & Timothy, D.J. (2010). Effects of the August 2008 War in Georgia on
tourism and its resources. In O. Moufakkir & I. Kelly (Eds.), Tourism, progress and peace
(pp. 134–147). Wallingford: CABI.
Metreveli, M., & Timothy, D.J. (2010). Religious heritage and emerging tourism in the
Republic of Georgia. Journal of Heritage Tourism. Vol. 5, No. 3, August 2010, 237–244
Nasmyth, P. (2006). Walking in the Caucasus: Georgia. London: Mta Publications.
197
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Nolan, M.L., & Nolan, S. (1992). Religious sites as tourism attractions in Europe. Annals of
Tourism Research, 19, 68–78.
Pelkmans, M. (2006). Defending the border: Identity, religion and modernity in the Republic
of Georgia. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Shackley, M. (2001). Managing sacred sites: Service provision and visitor experience.
London: Thomson.
Suny, R.G. (1994). The making of the Georgian Nation. Bloomington: Indiana University
Press.
Timothy, D.J. (2011). Cultural heritage and tourism: An introduction. Bristol: Channel View.
Timothy, D.J., & Olsen, D.H. (Eds.). (2006). Tourism, religion and spiritual journeys.
London: Routledge.
Timothy, D.J., & Nyaupane, G.P. (2009). Cultural heritage and tourism in the developing
world: A regional perspective. London: Routledge.
UNESCO. (2010). Tentative lists. Retrieved June 22, 2010, from http://whc.unesco.org/en/
tentativelists/
198
The Knowledge of Students of Tourism about Sacred Monuments on the
Territory of Serbia
Snežana Štetić
College of Tourism, Belgrade
Serbia
e-mail: snegics@gmail.com
Sanja Pavlović
University of Belgrade
Faculty of Geography, Serbia
e-mail: spavlovic20@gmail.com
Dario Šimičević
College of Tourism, Belgrade
Serbia
e-mail: dario@dancomsistem.com
Sara Stanić
University of Belgrade
Faculty of Geography, Serbia
e-mail: sara.stanic.zemun@gmail.com
Abstract
Sacral architecture represent a significant part of the cultural heritage in Serbia. They are the
bearers of cultural identity, multiculturalism and the proof that in the territory of Serbia are
twenty-eight ethnic groups, which are multi-religious, and the largest are: Christian (Orthodox
and Catholic), Muslim and Jewish. The largest group of categorized cultural monument of
great importance makes 400 churches, mostly Orthodox, and other religious, which were
appeared for a long time. This paper explores students' knowledge about the religious (sacred)
monuments in Serbia at the Faculty of Geography, Department of Tourismology and at the
College of Tourism in Belgrade. The article emphasizes the existing students’ knowledge
about permeation and connection of different religions, about places of worship in Serbia and
their territorial distribution, as well as about their artistic values. The open-ended survey were
analyzed the educational structure regard to year of study, level of study (undergraduate,
master's, doctoral), socio-demographic characteristics of the respondents (gender, age).
The first group of questions refers to the knowledge that students have about the historical,
cultural and artistic values of religious monuments. The second issue deals interests, opinions,
ways of information, information about tourist attractions, experiences, perceptions of sacred
monuments, understanding the presence and interpenetration of different religions in Serbia.
Keywords: sacred monuments, tourism, Serbia
1. Research on places of worship and religious tourism
Since religion is understood as a portion of culture, many scholars see religious tourism as
part of a broader cultural tourism (Rinschede, 1992). In this way, we do not talk only about
one type of tourism, but this also includes visits to places of worship, as well as attendance to
religious conferences, cultural and religious events, exhibitions of cult objects, as well as
concerts of sacred music (Vorzsak & Gut, 2009).
199
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Previous research on places of worship and religious tourism are numerous and
heterogeneous. Recent surveys indicate that the motivation for religious tourism is manifold
and multilayered. Not all visitors to religious sites are "pious travellers." There is an
increasing number of tourists who visit religious places of worship for non-religious reasons.
They travel primarily to familiarize with historical, cultural and architectural values of sacred
monuments. However, the largest number of tourists travels to have rest and recreation and
they go sightseeing and visit various religious sites as part of their trip. This is precisely the
reason for the authors of this paper to study the level of tourism students' knowledge
regarding sacred monuments and religious tourism.
Understanding of religious faith and respect for the sacred affects the distinction of
categories of visitors to religious facilities. Vukonić (1990) singles out two categories of
pilgrim tourists:
• tourists – practitioners (religious tourists) who regularly fulfill religious commitments,
• tourists – believers (religious tourists) who do not fully accept religious principles and
visits sacred facilities out of curiosity.
The same author has analyzed the motivation for visiting religious buildings and noted
that it can be:
• to participate in religious celebrations (church fairs, bringing out relics),
• to meet the holy places,
• to respect the saint who the holy place is dedicated to,
• to worship relics of saints,
• to explore the religious traditions of people living in other religious environment, or
visiting the country of origin in order to get to know the culture and religion of their
ancestors.
The study conducted in the Turkish province of Mardin, a destination with a large number
of religious and cultural facilities of Islam and Christianity, revealed that religious sites are
visited because of their historical and cultural values, and not because of their sacred and
spiritual values. Many tourists come to Mardin owing to multi-religious and multi-cultural
character of the province (Egres et al., 2012).
Religious contents are the most specific and most visible when the relationship between
religion and tourism is concerned. Immovable facilities, including sacred or some other
religious buildings are the objects of tourists’ attention and interest. They were originally
intended for religious contents, but some of the sacred facilities gradually lost their original
purpose and survived as cultural and historical sites (Stamenković, 2005).
The function of religious contents in tourism is determined by their function in religion.
Religious contents in sacral facilities are factors in tourism offer where tourists primarily meet
their religious, and secondarily their cultural, artistic and aesthetic needs. In a broader sense,
other facilities of religious communities and organizations in inbound tourism offer can be
used to provide services to tourists (monasteries, religious schools, monastery lodgings). The
most common religious themes in tourism are places of worship, and a considerable
significance is also attached to religious feasts (Geić, 2002).
Tourists visit historical sacred sites because of the possibility of cultural and educational
experiences (Olsen, 2006). They are looking for authentic experiences that are related to a
particular historical place (Macleod, 2006). When sacred facilities become commercialized,
they often lose their authenticity (McKercher & du Cros, 2002). The level of
200
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
commercialization reduces visitors’ expectations about what is appropriate in a religious
place, i.e. in a sacred object (Nolan & Nolan, 1992).
Since the 1980s the unique characteristics and the importance of sacred places have been
analyzed and the contribution that they have for cultural diversity has been recognized.
Cummings (1987) believes that the value of sacred places is not measured by politics, history,
or religion, and that the concepts of sacral places and sacred sites are broadly defined.
Cultural monuments, among them sacred facilities of different religions, are building and
architectural structures, which often enrich tourists’ stay in a certain place, which means that
in the case of Serbia they are complementary, rarely independent tourist values. They are
characterized by the time of their origin, their historical significance, cultural and artistic
values (Ćirković, 2003).
The research conducted at the University of Split has shown that students are poorly
informed about the religious tourism as a segment of tourist offer, but they believe that the
media coverage of religious tourism is insufficient. The objective of this paper is to determine
the way in which students perceive the religious tourism as a specific socio-cultural
phenomenon and their participation in religious tourism. Almost half of 300 surveyed
students have not participated in religious tourism, which is influenced by study programs,
attitudes toward religion, the importance of religion in life (Duvnjak et al., 2011).
The research on religious tourism must be linked to the research within the origin and
development of the specific tourism forms. As tourism is a very important economic, social
and ecological factor of the development of a society on the global level, researchers must
also possess knowledge about various changes that occur in its development (Štetić, 2007).
Understanding these changes is usually a key to the successful operation of the tourist sector.
2. Methodology of the paper
Since the development of specific forms of tourism must be considered in a specific way,
we have approached the problem from the theoretical point of view corroborated by the
survey research, which preceded the later data analysis processing through historical,
empirical and mathematical models, in order to get valid results for further processing and
concluding. The survey research was carried out through questions about students' scientific
knowledge on places of worship and religious tourism, through the knowledge about religions
in Serbia and their role in education. Sample survey knowledge of students of tourism about
sacred monuments in the territory of Serbia included two sets of questions that were answered
by students of the College of Tourism and Department of Tourismology at the Faculty of
Geography, University of Belgrade. 153 students of various levels of study, age and gender
participated in this survey. Analyzes were carried out according to the level of study and
gender.
It was performed a comparative analysis of the two groups of responses to determine how
much students know about the sacred monuments, what is the compliance level of theoretical
knowledge on the one hand and their interests, perceptions, experiences on the other side. The
results show that students' knowledge of the sacred monuments depend on the level of studies,
curriculum, interests, and their tourist value affecting artistic, cultural and historical value, an
initiative of individuals and organizations (associations).
3. Religions in Serbia
Religious movements of the world population are almost as old as mankind. Global
development of a society and an increase of the world population lead to a steady increase in
the number of religions. Today we cannot list all the existing religions and which part of the
201
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
population is included in them with certainty (Štetić, 2007). In this paper, we point out why
those religions that have an outstanding role in building religious facilities and in the
emergence of new type of tourism - religious tourism.
The Balkan Peninsula has always been a scene of historical conflicts and reconciliation
where the events have intertwined and nations fought and defended. Religious and national
identity are closely interconnected and they influence each other, especially in the Balkans,
where three civilizational circles – Byzantine-Orthodox, Western European (Catholic-
Protestant) and Ottoman-Islamic – adjoin, interfere and converge (Radisavljević-Ćiparizović,
2011).
Serbia is a multiethnic and multi-confessional state. Orthodoxy, Catholicism and Islam are
enriched by the presence of Judaism and Protestantism, and all confessions together
contribute to the richness of diversity and abundance of sacred facilities. In the north of the
country Orthodoxy encounters and permeates with Catholicism, in the south – with Islam
(Kuburić, 2010).
The revival of religious beliefs in various social and cultural contexts has been manifested
differently. In Serbia there are two interpretations related to this phenomenon that indicate
contextual distinction of this process in academic research: the return to the religions and the
return of the religion. The first interpretation refers to the increase of individual interest in
various religious traditions, beliefs and rituals. The second interpretation implies an increase
of the social importance of religion and religious institutions (Pavićević, 2012). In this
context, sacred objects should be analyzed so that they develop students’ awareness of
intertwining different religions and their consciousness of tolerance.
Arriving at the Balkan Peninsula, the South Slavs encountered with Christianity, which
was organized by church and jurisdictionally dependent on major ecclesiastical seats in Rome
and Constantinople at that time. In the early Middle Ages still unified Christianity was present
in the Balkans.
It can be said that Islam has an “areal” character on the Balkan Peninsula (communities
that are spread in the form of several separate areas) (Šećibović, 2001). The population of
Islamic believers in the Balkan Peninsula represents regionally differentiated and ethnically
heterogeneous religious community (Vukomanović, 2003). More than five centuries of Islam
in the Balkans had a significant impact in creating tradition which characterizes the mentioned
part of Europe. In this part of Europe Islam has been kept and retained as a traditional social
element until today by the population converted to Islam at the end of the Middle Ages.
This paper explores the level of knowledge about religions, cultures and sacred objects in
Serbia among students of tourism, aimed at considering their awareness of the role and
importance of religion for the extension of tourism offer.
4. Education and Religion
Educational standards in national strategies are an expression of cultural and social
particularities of a country. Understanding the role that education has in a state is enabled by
shaping national education systems, histories, cultures and values. The guideline which
regulates relations between religious and institutionalized education in Europe is the
recommendation of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe in 1999, in which
education is a decisive way to combat ignorance and stereotypes. The same recommendation
implies revising school and university programs to improve the understanding of different
religions. This recommendation is a guide aimed at the creation of conditions for the survival
and development of various cultures and religions in the same social framework, which are
based on an understanding of various worldviews and different ways of life.
202
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Understanding the differences between religions cannot be achieved by getting to know a
single religion. It is necessary to provide an opportunity to explore the history of world
religions in institutionalized education (Trifunović, 2010). At the Faculty of Geography,
University of Belgrade, Department of Tourism and at the College of Tourism students are
taught about different religions, especially those that are widespread in Serbia through the
contents of several courses. In the teaching process, more attention is paid to monumental
heritage, i.e. sacred objects and historical conditions in which they were built, and less to the
features of religions. Furthermore, through the study of different tourism forms the basis for
connecting history, culture, religion and tourism is created.
In order to establish dialogue and tolerance among religious communities it is necessary to
educate and train believers for them. The system of education should insist on studying and
disseminating positive examples, creating awareness about the value of tolerance as a means
for freedom and religious beliefs, and creating the personality of believers with broad culture
(Ĉupić, 2008).
If we want to develop sustainable and quality tourism in Serbia, then a proper link
between high quality tourism development and sacred sites must be found including places of
worship into tourist offer. Tourism product that will thus be qualified for the domestic and
foreign market must be distinctive and interesting for tourist demand.
5. Research on the knowledge of students of tourism about places of worship
The survey on knowledge of 153 students of tourism about places of worship in Serbia,
was conducted at the College of Tourism and the Faculty of Geography in Belgrade. This
survey identified the students' knowledge about the artistic values and time dating of sacred
facilities, about intertwining various religions and their territorial distribution. The answers
were classified into correct, partially correct and incorrect. The proportion of male and
female students at the College of Tourism was approximately the same (there were 53.7%, of
female and 46.3% male students) and the respondents were mainly the students of the third
year. Among the surveyed students at the Faculty of Geography, 73% were female and 27%
male and students of all ages and levels of study participated in the survey.
In the first question students were asked to list four monasteries whose fresco painting
represents the highest level of artistic achievement worldwide. (Figure 1) Monasteries in
Serbia with the world-famous fresco painting are Sopoćani, Studenica, Mileševa, Deĉani,
Graĉanica, Kalenić. The frescoes paintings an icons of churches in these monasteries are
among the best preserved achievements of the time in which they were created.
203
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 1 Graphically display the answer to the first question
the correct
incorrect
answer
answer
11.8%
29.4%
the correct answer
partially correct answer
incorrect answer
partially
correct answer
58.8%
Source: author’s calculations
The results show that the majority of surveyed students gave partially correct answers to
the question, because they did not specify exactly four monasteries, but less. Errors were
made in quoting all the monasteries that they knew. Usually, these were: Ţiĉa, Patriarchate of
Peć, Manasija, ĐurĊevi stupovi, Ljubostinja, Ravnica, whose fresco painting has a national
significance. The largest number of incorrect responses was blank spaces, without any
answer. Blank spaces indicate that, although the students study subjects dealing with these
fields they do not retain this knowledge after passing the exam.
In the second question they were supposed to write down in which part of Serbia there
were the greatest number of Catholic churches. (Figure 2) The sub-question was to explain
why the most Catholic churches are located in this part of Serbia. The western part of the
Balkan Peninsula is the important sphere of influence of Catholicism. This confession
dominated in the Habsburg Empire until the time it disappeared in 1918, and today it is most
numerous in Vojvodina.
Figure 2 Graphically display the answer to the second question
incorrect
answer the correct
16.3% answer
46.4% the correct answer
partially correct answer
incorrect answer
partially
correct answer
37.3%
Source: author’s calculations
In the partially correct answers the students wrote that the greatest number of Catholic
churches is in Vojvodina, but could not explain why. The highest percentage of answers was
204
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
correct, which means that they were well acquainted with the territorial distribution and
historical conditions in which Catholicism existed in Serbia.
The third question was: "Where is the Altun-alem Mosque located and when was it
constructed?" (Figure 3) This facility of sacred architecture is situated in Novi Pazar and was
built in the sixteenth century.
Figure 3 Graphically display the answer to the third question
the correct
answer
incorrect 7.2%
answer
the correct answer
45.8%
partially correct answer
partially incorrect answer
correct answer
47.1%
Source: author’s calculations
The greatest percentage of responses was partially correct, in which the students wrote
that Altun-alem Mosque is in Novi Pazar, but they did not know when it was built. The
percentage of incorrect answers was approximately the same. Wrong answers were: in Niš,
Istanbul, Prizren, Priština, Belgrade, Prijepolje, but there were also blanks as an answer.
The fourth question was: "Where is the Bajrakli Mosque and when was it built?" (Figure
4) The Bajrakli Mosque is the only active and preserved building of Islamic religious
architecture in Belgrade, constructed in the seventeenth century.
Figure 4 Graphically display the answer to the fourth question
the correct
incorrect
answer
answer
9.8%
24.2%
the correct answer
partially correct answer
incorrect answer
partially
correct answer
66.0%
Source: author’s calculations
The highest percentage of answers was partially correct: the students knew that Bajrakli
Mosque is located in Belgrade, but did not know when it was built. The incorrect answers
claimed that this religious building was located in Niš, Istanbul, Novi Pazar, Peć, Priština,
Prizren or the question stayed unanswered.
The fifth task was that the students explain territorial distribution of mosques as religious
facilities in Serbia. (Figure 5) The official data on the number of mosques in Serbia do not
exist because in the South and Southwest Serbia they are constantly under construction, but
their territorial distribution is known. Twenty-nine of these sacral buildings are under the state
protection as cultural monuments. Most mosques are located in southern Serbia, Kosovo,
205
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
southwest Serbia, one is in Niš and one in Belgrade, and one is under construction in Subotica
in northern Serbia.
Figure 5 Graphically display the answer to the fifth question
the correct
answer
17.0%
the correct answer
partially correct answer
incorrect
partially incorrect answer
answer
51.6% correct answer
31.4%
Source: author’s calculations
A significant number of incorrect answers were blank without any response or with
mentioning only a part of Serbia where the mosques were situated, without explanations of
their territorial distribution and mention of the Islamic faith population.
The sixth question asked that the students cite three cities in Serbia in which synagogues
are located. (Figure 6) Belgrade Synagogue is the only currently active Jewish place of
worship in Serbia. The synagogue renovated in Niš is not used for religious ceremonies but
for exhibitions, concerts, literary events. The synagogue in Novi Sad hosts classical music
concerts and other performances, the synagogue in Subotica is being reconstructed.
Figure 6 Graphically display the answer to the sixth question
incorrect
answer the correct
13.7% answer
47.1% the correct answer
partially correct answer
partially
correct answer
incorrect answer
39.2%
Source: author’s calculations
In the most partially correct answers Belgrade and Novi Pazar are listed, in the incorrect -
Smederevo, Novi Pazar, Shkodra, Panĉevo, Zrenjanin, Priština, Prizren, Baĉki Petrovac.
The seventh question was: "Where is the Peace Chapel situated and what is its historical
significance?” (Figure 7) The Peace Chapel or the Chapel of Our Lady of Peace is located in
Sremski Karlovci, not far from where Karlovac Peace between the Holy Alliance (Austria,
Russia, Poland and Venice) and Turkey was signed in 1699. There are the crescent and the
cross, symbols of Islam and Christianity, on the roof of the chapel, which makes this
monument unique.
206
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 7 Graphically display the answer to the seventx question
the correct
answer
5.9%
partially correct
answer the correct answer
27.5%
partially correct answer
incorrect answer
incorrect answer
66.7%
Source: author’s calculations
There was the greatest percentage of incorrect answers to this question, which means that
the students did not know that the Peace Chapel in Sremski Karlovci had been built in 1699 in
memory of Karlovac Peace. A significant number of incorrect answers were blank. In
partially correct answers the students only stated the name of the place containing the Chapel
of Peace, but did not mention the year when the peace had been signed.
6. Conclusion
The results of the survey on the knowledge of students of tourism about places of worship
in Serbia show that there is mainly (generally?) the largest percentage of partially correct and
incorrect answers, and the least correct answers in the responses. Students mostly make errors
in dating and territorial distribution of facilities of Islamic religious architecture. Considering
the dating of the monuments it is evident that the students of the Faculty of Geography make
mistakes in one or two centuries back in the past (in one answer – three centuries), and the
students of the College of Tourism give very few answers where the dates should be
specified.
The territorial distribution of the mosques is explained by the presence of the Muslim
population in some parts of Serbia, but the responses listing all parts of Serbia where mosques
are situated in larger number – are rare. The errors in questions where the Altun-alem and
Bajrakli Mosque are located are apparent, but it is interesting to state that instead of Novi
Pazar and Belgrade the students list those places where there are mosques (Peć, Priština,
Prizren, Prijepolje, Niš). The largest number of incorrect responses is left to the question
about the Peace Chapel, rare monument of permeating and intertwining religions in Serbia.
The knowledge of the polled students of tourism about places of worship in Serbia are
incomplete, although teaching contents include material on sacred facilities of Christian and
Islamic architecture (at the Faculty of Geography they are taught within the course
Monumental Heritage and Tourism and at the College of Tourism through the subject
Cultural Heritage and Tourism and Tourism Geography).
Approximately equal participation of female and male students in the survey at the Higher
School of Tourism caused an analysis of responses depending on the gender structure. Male
students gave 47% of incorrect answers in relation to the total number of answers that they
gave, and female students – 42%. There were 30% of partially correct answers of male, and
37% of female students. Male students gave 23% correct answers in relation to the total
number of responses, female students – 20%. Evidently, the differences in their knowledge
207
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
about religious buildings are not so big according to gender of those studying at the College
of Tourism. In the beginning of the survey at the College of Tourism, ten first-year students
were also polled. However, these survey sheets were not taken into account because they do
not have a single course that deals with these issues in the first semester and therefore we
were not able to quantify their answers.
At the Faculty of Geography the analysis was carried out according to the year and level
of study. The first-year students of undergraduate studies had the highest percentage of
incorrect answers in relation to the number of respondents (52%); this is followed by the
second-year students (43%) and the third-year students (25%); then graduate master studies
(23%) and the fourth-year students of undergraduate studies (22%); the lowest percentage of
incorrect responses was among PhD students (3.5%). Partially correct answers were mostly
given by third-year undergraduate students (59%), then fourth-year students (57%), students
of master studies (51%), first-year students (37%), PhD students (35%) and the second-year
undergraduate students (34 %).
The largest number of correct answers was given by doctoral students (62%), students of
master-graduate studies (26%), second-year students of undergraduate studies (23%), fourth-
year students (21%), third-year students (16%), and the least – first-year students of
undergraduate study (11%). The research has shown that students at graduate-master and
doctoral studies have less knowledge than expected as regards the level of study. The
knowledge of the first-year undergraduate students was mainly learned in primary and
secondary schools, because so far they did not attend courses in which they could learn about
places of worship in Serbia.
The Accuracy of responses depends not only on the level and year of study, but also on
the generation of polled students, their random selection, size of the sample, and students’
interest in a particular subject. An important factor in data accuracy is forgetting or avoiding
learning in which century or year a sacred facility was constructed. The research should take
into account the fact that not all surveyed students have taken the exam that is largely related
to these questions, and that they come to study at the university with different prior
knowledge.
These surveys will be part of a larger project that the authors will continue to deal with.
Also, our desire is to conduct similar surveys in other countries and to make a comparative
analysis of the obtained data. This would be particularly very important for directing
educational processes in order to inform students of tourism and other faculties about the
religions from other countries and to establish a bridge of understanding, friendship and
development of religious tourism.
References
Cummings, P. (1987). Sacred Sites in Contemporary Cultures. In: Old Cultures in New
Worlds. 8th ICOMOS General Assembly and International Symposium. Programme report –
US/ ICOMOS, Washington, pp. 551–557.
Ĉupić, Ĉ. (2008). Intereligijski dijalog i tolerancija. In (Vesna Djukic ed.) Religije Srbije –
mreža dijaloga i saradnje. Beograd: Beogradska otvorena škola, pp. 81-85.
Ćirković, S. (2003). Spomenici kulture od izuzetnog znaĉaja kao turistiĉka vrednost Srbije.
Glasnik Srpskog geografskog društva, 83(2), pp. 71–86.
Duvnjak, N. et al. (2011). Religijski turizam kao poseban socio-kulturni fenomen – na
primjeru istraţivanja meĊu studentima Sveuĉilišta u Splitu. Nova prisutnost, 9, pp. 425–446.
208
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Egresi, B. et al. (2102). Tourism At Religious Sites: A Case From Mardin, Turkey.
Geographica Timisiensis, 21(1), pp. 5-15.
Geić, S. (2002). Turizam i kulturno-civilizacijsko naslijeđe. Split:Veleuĉilište.
Kuburić, Z. (2006). Crkve i verske zajednice u Srbiji i Crnoj Gori. In: Zbornik radova Četvrti
međunarodni interdisciplinarni simpozijum Susret kultura. Novi Sad: Filozofski fakultet, pp.
341–352.
Macleod, N. (2006). Cultural tourism: Aspects of authenticity and commodification. In Smith,
M. & Robinson, M. (eds.) Cultural tourism in a changing world. Clevedon: Channel View
Publication, pp. 177-190.
McKercher, B. & du Cros, H. (2002). Cultural tourism: The partnership between tourism and
cultural heritage management. New York: Haworth Hospitality Press.
Nolan, M. & Nolan, S. (1992). Religious sites as tourism attractions in Europe. Annals of
Tourism Research, 19, pp. 68-78.
Olsen, D. (2006). Management issues for religious heritage attractions. In Timothy, D. &
Olsen, D. (eds.) Tourism, religion and spiritual journeys. New York: Routledge, pp. 104-118.
Pavićević, A. (2012). Uloga religije u identitetu graĊana Srbije: izmeĊu liĉnih izbora i
kolektivnih predstava. Zbornik Matice srpske za društvene nauke, 139, pp 159–172.
Radisavljević–Ćiparizović, D. (2011). Hodoĉašća na poĉetku trećeg milenijuma: verski i
nacionalni identitet hodoĉasnika u Srbiji u dva empirijska istraţivanja. In Mladenović, A.
(eds.) Religioznost u Srbiji 2010: istraživanja religioznosti građana Srbije i njihovog stava
prema procesu evropskih integracija. Beograd: Hrišćanski kulturni centar, Centar za evropske
integracije, Fondacija Konrad Adenauer, pp. 73–93.
Rinschede, G. (1992). Forms of Religious Tourism. Annals of Tourism Research 19, pp. 51-
67.
Stamenković, I. (2005). Religijski turizam, oblici i motivi na primeru pravoslavlja. Zbornik
radova Departmana za geografiju, turizam i hotelijerstvo, 33–34, pp. 173–188.
Šećibović, R. (2001). Balkan – graniĉni prostor religija. In Vukomanović, M. & Vuĉinić, M.
(eds.). Religije Balkana: Susreti i prožimanja. Beograd: Beogradska otvorena škola, pp. 105–
113.
Štetić S. (2007),Posebni oblici turizma, Beograd, LI
Trifunović, V. (2010). Religijsko obrazovanje i kulturni identitet. Zbornik Matice srpske za
društvene nauke, 133, pp. 39–48.
Vorzsak, M. & Gut,AC.M. (2009). A Strategic Prognosis of Religious Tourism in Romania.
In Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Cultural Heritage and Tourism.
Rhodes: WSEAS Press, pp. 29–34.
Vukomanović, M. (2003). Zapad i islam. In Vukomanović, M. & Vuĉinić, M. (eds.).
Religijski dijalog – drama razumevanja. Beograd: Beogradska otvorena škola, pp. 159–171.
Vukonić, B. (1990). Turizam i religija. Zagreb: Školska knjiga.
209
Tourism and the Transformation of Ritual Practice with Sand Pagoda
Ploysri Porananond
Division of Tourism, Faculty of Humanities,
Chiang Mai University, Thailand
ploysri.p@cmu.ac.th
Abstract
This study examines the transformation process in traditional beliefs and practices with sand
of Lanna culture that reflects the influence of tourism, the growth of capitalism, the
commoditisation process and the decline of Buddhism to local community of Chiang Mai.
Traditionally, there were the customary practices and beliefs relating to the bringing of sand
to the temples to make sand pagoda of Lanna people in Songkran festival. There were also the
functions, beliefs and meanings of sand pagodas associated with the tung, a colourful paper
flag used to decorate sand pagodas. This is based on the belief that dead relatives and friends
residing in hell can catch the long tails of the tungs in order to reach heaven. Later, the
traditional Buddhist belief associated with the making of sand pagodas, as well as the tung,
has disappeared in Songkran. The bringing of sand to temples and sand pagodas became a
contest between the members of the temples in the city for money and awards. Afterward, a
large sand pagoda, additional to the activity of bathing the pagoda, was built by an abandoned
temple in the city, as part of an effort to raise money to reconstruct the temple. Furthermore,
making sand pagodas and decorating them with the tungs began to commoditise for tourists.
Similarly, a sand parade was established to carry sand to nearby temples, and then it was re-
organised in more elaborate and colourful. Recently, sand pagodas were transformed into art
installations to attract tourists during Songkran days for the purpose of expressing Lanna
culture in Songkran. Moreover, sand pagodas were also found in front of pubs and restaurants
in the city during Songkran. Accordingly, sand pagodas transformed their forms and
functions, not only in terms of sites but also beliefs, meanings and values. These phenomena
reflect not only the power of tourism, the growth of capitalism and commoditisation but also
signs of Buddhism decline in the local society of Chiang Mai, a major tourist destination in
Thailand.
Keywords: tourism, sand pagoda, commoditisation, Buddhism decline
1. Theoretical Approach
1.1 Ritual and symbolic meanings
Turner (1967, p.19) defines ritual as ‘prescribed formal behaviour for occasions not given
over to technological routine, having reference to beliefs in mystical beings and powers’.
Turner (1969) further views that ritual practices can reflect social structure of communities.
Thus, social conflicts bring into play to reduce or resolve conflicts in communities, in this
way ritual is the ‘social glue’ of the society. In Turner’s view, social drama appears through
ritual practices or performances, when the notion of social drama is introduced as ‘a device to
look beneath the surface of social regularities into the hidden contradictions and eruptions of
conflict in social structure’ (Turner, 1957, p.89).
Likewise, Turner (1968, p.1-2) explains that ritual has symbolic meaning, when ritual
symbol is seen as ‘smallest unit of ritual which still retains the specific properties of ritual
behaviour’. Hence, ritual symbols can be objects, activities, words, relationships, events,
gestures, or spatial units (Turner, 1967, p.19). In Turner’s perspective, ritual, religious beliefs
and symbols are related. Thus, well definition of ritual is defined as ‘a stereotyped sequence
211
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
of activities involving gestures, words, and objects, performed in a sequestered place, and
designed to influence preternatural entities or forces on behalf of the actors’ goals and
interests’ (Turner, 1977, p.183). Rituals in this way have plenty of meaningful symbols in
which information is revealed with values to community. Symbols in ritual display their
powers to act upon and change the persons involved in ritual performance.
Based on Turner’s ideas, ritual is viewed as a ‘window’ on the cultural dinamics by which
‘people make and remake their worlds’ (Bell, 2009, p. 3). In the study on religious rituals,
Bradshaw and Melloh (2007) identify ritual in three broad approaches. In formal definitions,
ritual is viewed as different activity from other forms of behaviour in terms of its distinctive
features. In terms of the purposes, ritual serves in human life, in this way ritual serves
collective needs of people, for instance, maintenance of group solidarity, rehearsal of group
values, maintenance of social distinctions and categories, containing of social conflict,
facilitating of transitions between categories or states of life. In symbolic approaches, ritual is
an activity that conveys meaning. Hence, ritual is considered as activity which is interpreted
as having some meanings.
Accordingly, rituals can be perceived as extraordinary practices. Similar to others,
Gilmore (1998, p.26) defines ritual as a repetitive sequence of activity, culturally sanctioned
and regularized, but always involving an appeal to the supernatural; spirits, gods.’ Ritual is
‘social action; its performance requires the organised cooperation of individuals.
According to DaMatta (1991, p.20), the ritual is
a basic vehicle in transforming something natural into something social through some
sort of dramatization […] a dramatization or crucial way of calling attention to certain
aspects of social reality.
In this view, rituals become special moments constructed by society under the control of
the social system. For DaMatta ‘the world of ritual is the world of the […] purely ideological’
(DaMatta, 1991, p.49) and there is no society without ritual. The important point is the
symbolic expression of ritual, which can enable people to share values and goals in common.
In some societies, ritual practices become, for instance, important means of expression
(Gilmore, 1998).
1.2 Tourism and the transformation of rituals
Interestingly, socio-economic change and tourism development together can provide a
major impetus to transform the traditional rituals of ethnic groups into tourist attractions.
Many rituals or performances of ethnic groups that have long been ignored or repressed are
included for tourists’ attention. In some cases, even the household rituals of ethnic groups are
developed into exotic celebrations of the community for tourists. This results in an increasing
number of rituals and places to serve large numbers of tourists. Furthermore, the other
traditional identities of these ethnic groups become developed as urban tourist attractions.
Mathew-Salazar (2006) describes how the traditional household ritual to honour the ‘mother
earth’ or ‘Pachamama’ of the Indian community has been developed into a tourist attraction
for the economic benefits of the community. Furthermore, the neighbouring communities
imitate the process of the ‘mother earth’ in order to develop similar traditional rituals in their
communities as a tourist spectacle. As a result, the rituals of these Indian communities are
developed into a series of traditional celebrations to promote the visits of tourists throughout
that region of the country. The traditional time of the ‘mother earth’ ritual was later moved, so
that it was celebrated in the same month as the carnival, in order to attract large numbers of
tourists during this period. This transformation reflects the influence of capitalism and
tourism, not only on the organisation and practices of the rituals, but also on the changes in
value and meanings of them to the community members.
212
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Similarly, Greenwood’s (1989) study of the Alarde celebration in the Spanish town of
Fuenterrabia states that the celebration can also be ritualistic or sacred, because it reflects not
only social structure of the community but also symbolic meanings to local people. He also
debates the influence of tourism through the municipality authority that results to the
transformations of this community’s ritual celebration in terms of space and the performances.
The process turns the cherished celebration into the meaningless performances for community
members.
Cohen (2001) discusses how the ritual practices in the Vegetarian Festival in Phuket,
which was first conducted under the traditional beliefs and practices in their hometown of the
Chinese workers in Southern part of Thailand, supported the emotion of these workers from
the dead of their friends and relatives from the epidemic. Later, ritual practices in the festival
became major tourist attractions of the city. Furthermore, the ritual practices of the spirit
mediums have been appeared in more horror performances. However, these terror
performances attract numbers of tourists to join the rituals and festival. Changes in socio-
economy, as well as tourism development in Thailand are considered as major factors to the
transformation of the ritual practices.
1.3 Tourism and the commoditisation of rituals
Cohen (1988, p. 380) defines commoditisation as ‘a process by which things (and
activities) come to be evaluated primarily in terms of their exchange value, in a context of
trade, then becoming goods (and services)’. Later, commoditisation is viewed more critically
by Gotham’s study and refers to ‘the dominance of commodity exchange-value over use-
value and implies the development of a consumer society where market relations subsume and
dominate social life’ (Gotham, 2002, p. 1737). The commoditisation process can transfer the
exchange value of trade into goods or commodities, which can be priced or marketed. Once
commodities are conceptualised as items produced for their monetary value, the introduction
of the ‘sign value’ can stimulate more consumption via the spectacle. The commoditisation
process seems to fit a modern, developed and consumer society, where capitalism and
monetary value can grow.
Meethan (2001) views tourism as part of the process of commoditisation and consumption
that exists in capitalism. Tourism itself is also recognised as a commodity (Watson and
Kopachevsky, 2002). Signs and images are constructed to attract spending and consumption.
In this way, cultural practices in terms of ritual symbols and images have in some cases
become commodities to sell for consumption. Then, sign-value, which replaces the use-value
and exchange value of commodities, becomes important. In Gotham’s view (2001), ‘sign
value’ - the value of images and symbols - is not related to reality.
In this way, cultural practices or performances such as ritual symbols can be transformed
into commodities or products for sale to consumers. The new symbols of rituals as
commodities can decrease their traditional meanings and value to community members. The
process causes ritual practices to be ‘meaningless’ or ‘placeless’ for communities and their
members (MacLeod, 2006).
213
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
2. Ritual beliefs and practices with sand in Lanna culture
Traditionally, the practice with sand in Lanna1 culture happened on the second day of the
Songkran festival, April 14, which was called Wan Nao. It was a preparation day of food,
desserts and the tung, for the religious activities on the following day (April 15), Wan Phaya
Wan, which translates as ‘the most important day of the year’. During the afternoon of April
14, local people went to the nearby river with silver utensils or buckets to carry sand from the
river to the temples. Sand was then gathered into a 'sand pagoda' in the temple compound for
the tungs, which were hung on branches of the 'Kuang tree' to be used by each household of
the temple’s members to decorate the pagoda the next morning. In Buddhist beliefs about the
Universe, sand in the compound of the temple represents the sea, and the main hall of the
temple represents the Earth. Although Payomyong (1976) and Manopet (1994) both suggest
that carrying the sand to the temple is believed to replace the sand which is carried out
inadvertently on the soles of shoes during visits to the temple throughout the year, the idea
behind this practice has hitherto gone unidentified. Nonetheless, carrying sand to the temple
has been regarded as a traditional practice of the Lanna people for a long time.
In the morning of April 15, which is called Wan Phaya Wan, desserts, other food and
tungs are brought to the temple. At the main hall of the temple, all prepared desserts and other
food are gathered to be donated to relatives and friends who have passed away. The Lanna
people call this religious activity 'Than Kan Kao' (Rungruangsri, 1997). People then bring
tungs which are hung on branches of the 'Kuang tree' and used to decorate the sand pagoda
(Payomyong, 1976; Manopet, 1994). A religious ritual called 'Than Tung' follows next. This
is based on the belief that those dead who are residing in hell can catch the long tails of the
tungs in order to reach heaven (Manopet, 1994).
3. Transformation of ritual practices and beliefs with sand pagoda
Practices with sand, which reflected profound beliefs in Buddhism, as well as social
structure of local people in Chiang Mai in the 1950s, transformed into competitive practices,
huge sand pagoda, sand parade and art installation in the following decades.
3.1 The practices with sand from the 1950s to the 1980s
During the 1950s, bringing sand from the Ping River to Buddha Sathan (a Buddhist site
located near Nawarat Bridge) and the nearby temples to make the sand pagodas was a popular
activity for the local young people on the afternoon of April 14. Young women rarely had the
chance to appear in public spaces, so they would ask their parents if they could attend the
sand activity, which was usually allowed (Chaiwan, 2003-interview). After splashing water
onto each other in the Ping River (Satrabhaya, 1960-photo), these young people put sand into
their water containers, such as silver bowls or buckets, and brought it to Buddha Sathan or the
nearby temples. Then, in the compounds of the temples or Buddha Sathan, these young
people made their own pagodas, after which they prayed at their sand pagodas for good
fortune (Thai Rath, April 18, 1969, p.1). Thus, there were hundreds of small pagodas in the
compound of the temples and Buddha Sathan during this period (Khon Muang, April 15,
1968, p. 1). These individual pagodas could be gathered into one main sand pagoda for
Buddhist activity the next day. Bringing sand to the temples for sand pagodas was still
practiced in the 1960s and 1980s.
1
Culture of people who lived in Lanna Kingdom around 700 years ago which had Chiang Mai as its capital.
Lanna culture is seen as a culture stemming from their deeply instilled Buddhist beliefs. At present, the term
Lanna people refers to the people who live in the northern provinces of Thailand.
214
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 1 A lady pouring sand for a sand pagoda in the compound of a temple in 1953
Source: Boonserm Satrabhaya collection
In 1983, the level of water in the Ping River was higher than in earlier years, and the sand
bed in the middle of the river disappeared. It has been said that sand was being extracted from
the river for building construction works around the city and that this affected the depth of the
Ping River (Satrabhaya, 2003-interview). The higher level of water resulted in decreasing
numbers of people in the river during Songkran in 1983, but sand was still brought from the
river for sand pagodas. Thus, there were still many sand pagodas in the compound of Buddha
Sathan in 1983 (Raming, April 16, 1983, p. 9). It is said that during the 1980s, people still
brought sand from the Ping River to make sand pagodas at Buddha Sathan and the nearby
temples (Satrabhaya, 2003-interview).
Figure 2 Sand pagodas in the compound of Buddha Sathan in 1983
Source: Raming (1983), April 16, p. 9
215
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3.2 Turning the making of sand pagodas into a contest
In the late 1990s, the traditional practice of bringing sand from the Ping River to the
nearby temples and Buddha Sathan disappeared (Satrabhaya, 2003-interview). However, sand
pagodas still existed in these places. Sand was purchased from suppliers and then brought to
the temples by pick-up cars. The members of the temples paid for this arrangement, as they
were too busy with their careers and responsibilities and could not find their time for this
customary practice (Satrabhaya, 2003-interview). The high level of water made sand difficult
to access in the Ping River. This can be considered as one of the factors to the change to the
practice with sand in Songkran.
In 1999, the making of sand pagodas in Buddha Sathan became a contest between the
representatives of each temple in the city. The local Young Buddhist Group (a group of young
local people who were members of temples in the city) was the major organiser of this
competition, with money and a cup being the reward for the winners. It was reported in the
local newspaper that ‘the Youth Group organise the contest for making sand pagodas in
Songkran for money and a cup prize as a reward for the winners’ (Thai News, April 8, 1999,
p.3). This describes the change in meaning of making sand pagodas, and the local Buddhist
group was the organiser in this changing practice. Moreover, some regulations for this contest
of making sand pagodas were introduced by the organiser, the local Youth Group. Later, in
2001, the number of competitors increased from fewer than 20 to 22 groups of the temples’
members in the city (Thai News, April 14, 2001, p. 8). It is clear that not only had the
traditional practice of bringing sand to temples been changed; the small individual sand
pagodas became, in effect, items made as competition and were larger in size, as well as
altered in pattern and design. This indicates that there were not only changes to the practice
with sand; the traditional meaning of bringing sand to the temples to make sand pagodas had
disappeared too. These phenomena reflect the changes in the Buddhist beliefs of local people
which in turn influenced changes to the practices associated with belief and meaning of sand
pagodas in Songkran.
216
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 3 Sand pagoda-making for the contest at Buddha Sathan in 2003
Source: Thai News, April 12, 2003, p.1
Figure 4: The contest of making sand pagodas at Buddha Sathan in 2004
Source: Ploysri Porananond
In 2001, the amount of prize money in the contest of making sand pagodas at Buddha
Sathan was increased to 10,000 bahts, with a champion cup being awarded by the Prime
Minister. In addition, the local Young Buddhist Group, as the organisers of this contest, made
the announcement that the objective of the contest was to prolong the Lanna tradition, as well
as to make attractive activities in Songkran (Thai News, April 14, 2001, p.8). However, the
Chiang Mai Municipality was the sponsor of this activity, with the aim of creating more
activities in Songkran to attract tourists. This reflects the capitalist process and socio-
economic changes in the local society that affected the changes in meaning, value and
attitudes influencing the practices with sand. Tourism promotion can also be considered as
another major factor for the establishment of this contest.
217
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3.3 Transforms to tourist attractions and experiences
In 2003, the Jed Lin Temple, started to make a large sand pagoda, additional to the
activities of bathing the pagoda, in order to attract tourists. Thus, tourists were invited to
practice Buddhist activities and donate their money for the renovation of this old temple (Thai
News, April 11, 2003, p.1). Consequently, the sand pagoda at the Jed Lin Temple was
promoted as the largest sand pagoda ever built, in order to attract tourists and their donations.
In effect, the sand pagoda was transformed by the Jed Lin Temple into a commodity for
tourists, with Songkran being used as a marketing event and the appropriate time for this
purpose. The local religious groups, such as the monks and members of local Buddhist group,
were the main organisers. This was an ironic situation given the decline in importance of its
original religious significance. The change partly reflects the decline in the importance of
Buddhist beliefs, but also the increasing strength of capitalism in the local area, as well as the
growth of tourism-led economic development strategies in Thailand.
Figure 5 Huge sand pagoda at the Jed Lin Temple in 2003
Source: Thai News (2003), 11 April, p. 1
In 2010 at Buddha Sathan, sand was used as an invitation to donate money for the making
of sand pagodas. This reflects another way of commoditising sand for the Buddhist tourists in
Songkran. Again, the local Buddhist group with responsibility for Buddha Sathan is involved
in this. People are invited to buy the tungs to decorate the sand pagodas, demonstrating the
change in value and meaning of making the sand pagodas and the tungs for the organisers.
Making a sand pagoda and decorating it with tungs was believed to be a good thing for
Buddhists to do at least once a year. However, these beliefs seem now to have disappeared
amongst local people in Chiang Mai. Although the custom of making sand pagodas may exist
in much the same way that it did in the past, the value and meanings of sand pagodas for the
participants involved in this process has changed significantly. It has become a device to
make money from tourists who would like to engage with Buddhist practices and the Lanna
culture in Songkran.
218
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 6 A sign inviting people to donate money for the making in 2010
of sand pagoda at Buddha Sathan
Source: Ploysri Porananond
Figure 7 The establishment of sand pagodas in the compound of in 2010
Buddha Sathan for tourists’ donations
Source: Ploysri Porananond
3.4 Transforms to the sand parade in Songkran
By 1999, the traditional practice of bringing sand to the temples had become part of the
2
parade of carrying sand by the Youth Group. In 2002, the parade to carry Mai Kham and
sand to Buddha Sathan and nearby temples on Ta Pae Road was rehearsed in the afternoon of
April 14. The parade started from the eastern bank of the Ping River and moved across
Nawarat Bridge to Buddha Sathan and the temples. The Chiang Mai municipality was the
organiser of this parade. The establishment of the sand parade on the afternoon of April 14
can be considered as an attempt to conduct an activity to attract tourists.
Although the parade to carry sand to Buddha Sathan and nearby temples aimed to
preserve the traditional practice with sand of the Lanna people (Punyasopa 2004-interview),
2
Pronged sticks, which are brought to be placed beneath the ‘Salee’ or the ‘Boh’ trees in temples. It is believed
to be a practice to prolong Buddhism.
219
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
the practice was not relevant to the present lifestyle and beliefs of the local people. Although
the bringing of sand from the Ping River to Buddha Sathan and nearby temples has
disappeared, sand has not disappeared in Songkran at all. Sand has been present in Songkran
for decades, but in different forms and designs and also with different participants and
organisers.
By 2010 sand was carried by being placed in large silver bowls, hung on each end of a
wooden stick. This differs from the practice in 1953, when each person put sand in a silver
bowl and carried it by hand to Buddha Sathan or nearby temples to make sand pagodas. The
way of carrying sand in the parade can be seen as a show to attract the audience. On the other
hand, bringing sand to Buddha Sathan in this way has no value for the participants because it
does not relate directly to beliefs of the ones who carry the sand; rather, they are just the
performers in the parade.
Figure 8 The way to carry sand in the parade in 2010
Source: Ploysri Porananond
Figure 9 Local women carrying sand in the parade in April 2010
Source: Ploysri Porananond
Furthermore, making a sand pagoda as it was in the past is now promoted and
demonstrated as a practice (Chiang Mai News, 15 April, 2008, p. 12). However, this can be
seen as a nostalgic feeling of the relevant groups, due to the socio-economic changes in local
society that have led to the disappearance of the traditional practice of bringing sand to
220
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
temples to make sand pagodas. Consequently, the belief and value of bringing sand and
making sand pagodas has disappeared too. Its value, according to the practice and its
meanings, is not relevant to the lives of local people at present. On the other hand, making
sand pagoda was presented to tourists as part of Lanna traditional practices.
Figure 10 The promotion of making sand pagodas as part of traditional
Lanna culture in 2008
Source: Special Scoop, Chiang Mai News (2008), 15 April, p. 12
3.5 Sand pagodas as art installations in Songkran
Sand pagodas and the tung have now basically become art installations in the public space
in Songkran, with the Chiang Mai municipality the sponsor of the activities. The stated
purpose of this event is to present Lanna culture to the tourists. However, there is little value
or meaning in this kind of sand pagoda for local people, because these sand pagodas do not
involve their lives or beliefs.
The places in which to install sand pagodas have changed from the compound of the
temples to other public spaces. In 2010, sand pagodas colourfully decorated with the tungs
were installed in the area at the foot of Nawarat Bridge. Although the establishment of sand
pagodas is said to preserve the traditional practice of the Lanna culture, sand pagodas at the
foot of the Nawarat Bridge area are not valued by local people in the same way as was the
original, traditional practice. At the same time, sand pagodas are also established in front of
pubs or restaurants around the city moat - the popular area for the play with water - to
decorate these places during Songkran. This underlines the loss of the traditional meaning of
sand pagodas for local people and tourists in Songkran. As mentioned previously, sand
pagodas have largely become pieces of art, which can be installed or decorated in any place
during Songkran days. Sand pagodas, which used to be made in the holy places such as
Buddha Sathan and temples, are now established in any space in the city as an attractive form
of art in Songkran.
221
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 11 Sand pagodas at the foot of Nawarat Bridge in 2010
Source: Ploysri Porananond
Figure 12 Sand pagoda as art installation in 2010
Source: Ploysri Porananond
The tungs used to be prepared in households on April 14 as a decoration for the sand
pagodas. The tungs also had another traditional function in Buddhist belief, as a carrier to
support the spirits of the dead on their journey into heaven. The place to prepare or produce
the tungs has also changed. At present, the tungs are found in a ready-made form in the
market place. In this way, people do not have to spend their time preparing the tungs at home;
instead, the tungs are easy to find and buy, which suits the modern lives of the people in the
city. In addition, these tungs are more decorative and colourful than the tungs in the past.
222
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 14 A tung for sale in the market place in 2010
Source: Ploysri Porananond
4. Reflections on the power of tourism, commoditisation and the decline of Buddhism
Tourism, capitalism and commoditisation associated with the decline of Buddhism in
Chiang Mai can be considered as factors influencing the transformations of practices with
sand for sand pagodas. The practices were traditionally believed to be the mediums which
assisted the communication between the living and the dead, helping the latter to travel into
heaven. As a result of the changes, they became commodities to sell for economic advantage.
Tourism development of Chiang Mai from the 1960s can be claimed as major factor to the
changes in practice with sand in Songkran festival. According to Songkran festival was first
promoted for tourists as an exotic Lanna culture. Later, Songkran became the most popular
tourist activities in Chiang Mai. However, tourism may not be the only factor to the
transformations in Songkran, as well as the practice with sand.
According to Turner (1967, 1968) rituals are special moments constructed by society
under the control of the social system and ‘the world of ritual is the world of the […] purely
ideological’ (DaMatta, 1991, p.49). The symbolic expression of ritual can enable people to
share values and goals. In this sense, the practice with sand in Songkran in the 1950s can be
seen as the ritual practice of local people to serve their beliefs. The practice also had value for
them, symbolising that they would have good fortune in their lives, as well representing their
support for the spirits of their relatives and friends on the journey via the tungs to heaven. In
this sense, the traditional practice with sand and tung was a time for communication between
humanity and spirituality (DaMatta, 1991). Consistent with the theories of De Bres and Davis
(2001), the practice with sand in the 1950s helped to create images of Songkran at the time as
the centre of the Lanna people’s cultural identity.
Spaces for sand pagodas in temple compounds in the 1950s can be seen as ritual spaces, as
these spaces had meanings and values to local people who participated in making them.
Following Bird (2002) and Derrett’s (2000) view, local people had a ‘sense of place’ for the
temple compounds, due to these spaces being different from other local spaces in terms of
meaning and value; they are spaces for the traditional practice with sand. Furthermore, the
practice with sand can be seen as unique characteristics and a particular identity – that is,
Lanna cultural identity.
223
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
In 1999, the construction of sand pagodas at the compound of Buddha Sathan was turned
into a competition between members of temples in the city, with money and a cup being the
reward for the winners. Then, in 2001, the number of competitors was increased to 22 groups,
the amount of prize money in the contest was increased, and a trophy was awarded by the
Prime Minister (Thai News, April 14, 2001, p. 8). This phenomenon reflected social change in
the local society of Chiang Mai, as well as the decline of Buddhist beliefs and the growth of
capitalism. Making sand in the competition with money as the reward also mirrors change in
the values of local people, with money becoming the aim of the practice with sand. Practice
with sand in this way cannot be respected as ritual practice in Turner’s sense (1967, 1968);
although sand was shaped into a pagoda figure, this practice does not allow people to share
spiritual values and goals in a sense that has any significance comparable with the original
practice, which was associated with good fortune in life and the spirits of the dead.
The construction of the huge sand pagoda at the abandoned Jed Lin Temple, in order to
attract tourist donations, first appeared in Songkran in 2003. This phenomenon again not only
reflected the decline of Buddhism but also the growth of capitalism among the local Buddhist
groups. Thus, sand pagodas which used to represent the traditional belief were turned into a
tourist attraction in Songkran, with local Buddhist groups and monks being involved in this
process. This can also reveal changes in the meaning of making sand pagodas and the decline
in its religious importance. Thus, the sand pagoda was judged as a commodity to sell or
display for the gaze of tourists, in return for money received in donations. In this sense, again,
sand pagodas lost their ritualistic symbols, because the aims to make them were not based on
Buddhist beliefs.
Similarly, an invitation to donate money for the making of sand pagodas and selling the
tungs to decorate the sand pagodas at Buddha Sathan in the late 2000s transformed the use of
Buddhist activities - which used to have high value and meanings for local people in the past -
into a commodity for the practices of tourists. As with the bringing of sand in the sand parade,
the making of sand pagodas as art installations in front of pubs and restaurants around the city
moat, reflect traditional religious practices being turned into tourist attractions for economic
purposes. As a result, the traditional meanings and values of making sand pagodas have
disappeared.
Meethan (2001) views tourism as part of the process of commoditisation and consumption
that exists in capitalism. Wang (2000), more specifically, considers how the tourist experience
has been related to commoditisation. In this sense, tourist activities and experiences can be
judged as commodities to be packaged, marketed and sold. The traditional practice with sand
was changed and sand pagodas began to be used as commodities to sell as tourist activities
and experiences. The contest of making sand pagodas at Buddha Sathan and the making of the
huge sand pagoda can be considered the commoditisation of these pagodas as tourist activities
and experiences. Surprisingly, the local Buddhist groups are involved in the commoditisation
of the traditional sand pagodas. This reveals the growth of capitalism in Thai society in this
period, as well as the decline of Buddhism. Sand pagodas were also used as pieces of art to
decorate spaces for tourists. Thus, they were starting to be used as commodities by different
groups of local people during Songkran days.
The move of sand pagoda spaces from temples’ compound into public areas, near Nawarat
Bridge and in front of pubs and restaurants around the city moat, reflects the decrease in these
pagodas’ meanings. They have lost the symbolic pattern of the pagoda as the holy monument
in a temple which acts as a medium by which the living communicates with the dead. In this
sense, sand pagodas in the 2000s became ‘meaningless’ for the involved groups; at the same
time, the sense of belonging this traditional practice offered local people disappeared too
because of increasing commoditisation. Following Gotham’s view (2001), sand pagodas in
224
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
the 2000s became only ‘sign value’ or the value of images and symbols of Lanna culture in
the Songkran without its traditional belief, practices and meanings.
5. Conclusion
Sand pagoda used to be the unique ritual practice of Lanna culture in Songkran festival
that mirrored the profound belief in Buddhism of local people in Chiang Mai. The
transformations to sand pagodas in terms of practices, spaces and symbolic meanings reflect
changes in socio-cultural values in the local society of Chiang Mai, associated with the
growth of capitalism, the power of tourism and commoditisation. In this respect, sand pagodas
transform into ‘meaningless’ or ‘placeless’ commodities for local communities in the city of
Chiang Mai.
References
Bell, C. (2009). Ritual Theory, Ritual Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bradshaw P. and Melloh, J. (2007). Foundations in Ritual Studies. London: SPCK
Cohen, E. (1988). Authenticity and Commoditization in Tourism. Annals of Tourism
Research, 15, pp. 371-386.
Cohen, E. (2001). The Chinese Vegetarian Festival in Phuket: religion, ethnicity, and tourism
on a southern Thai island. Bangkok: White Lotus Press.
DaMatta, R. (1991). Carnivals, Rogues, and Heroes: an interpretation of the Brazilian
dilemma. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
De Bras, K. and Davis, J. (2001). Celebrating group and place identity: a case study of a new
regional festival. Tourism geographies. 3 (1), pp. 326-337.
Derrett, R. (2000). Making sense of how festivals demonstrate a community's sense of place.
Event Management, 8, pp. 49-58.
Gilmore, D. D. (1998). Carnival& Culture: sex, symbol and status in Spain. New Haven and
London: Yale University Press.
Gotham, K.F. (2002). Marketing Mardi Gras: commodification, spectacle and political
economy of tourism in New Orleans. In Urban Studies 39 (10), pp. 1735-1756.
Greenwood, D. (1989). Culture by the Pound: An Anthropological Perspective on Tourism as
Cultural Commoditization. In Valene L. Smith (ed.) Hosts and Guests. Philadelphia:
University of Pennsylvania Press. pp. 129-138.
MacLeod, N. (2006). The placeless festival: identity and place in the post-modern festival. In
D. Picard and M. Robinson (eds.) Festivals, Tourism and Social Change. Clevedon: Channel
View Publications. pp. 222-237.
Manopet, S. (1994). The legend of Tung. In the publication for the 20th celebration of The
Northern Bank Day. (in Thai)
Mathews-Salazar, P. (2006). Becoming all Indian: gauchos, pachamama queens and tourists
in the remarking of an Andean festival. In D. Picard and M. Robinson (eds.) Festivals,
Tourism and Social Change. Clevedon: Channel View Publications. pp. 71-83.
Meethan, K. (2001). Tourism in Global Society: place, culture, consumption. New York:
Palgrave.
Payomyong, M. (1976). Lanna traditions within twelve months. Chiang Mai: Sor Sapkarnpim.
(in Thai)
225
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Turner, V. (1957). Schism and continuity in an African society: A Study of Ndembu village
life. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Turner, V. (1967). The forest of symbols: Aspects of Ndembu ritual. Ithaca: Cornell
University Press.
Turner, V. (1968). The drums of affliction: A study of religious processes among the Ndembu
of Zambia. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Turner, V. (1969). The Ritual process: Structure and anti-structure. Chicago: Aldine.
Turner, V. (1977). Symbols in Africa ritual. In J. L. Dolgin (et al) Symbolic anthropology: A
reader in the study of symbols and meanings. New York: Columbia University Press. pp.183-
194
Wang, N. (2000). Tourism and Modernity: a sociology analysis. Oxford: Elsevier.
Local Newspaper
Khon Muang, April 15, 1968, p. 1
Thai Rath, April 18, 1969, p.1
Raming, April 16, 1983, p. 9
Thai News, April 8, 1999, p.3
Thai News, April 14, 2001, p. 8
Thai News, April 11, 2003, p.1
Chiang Mai News, 15 April, 2008, p. 12
226
The Passengers Islamic Perspective in Airline Hospitality
Ehsaneh N.M. Nameghi1
Mohammad Ali Shadi2
National Univeristy of Malaysia, Graduate School of Business, Malaysia1
IAU, Science & Reseach Branch,Faculty of Humanities and Social Science, Iran2
ehsaneh_nameghi@yahoo.com
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to investigate hospitality from the perspective of the Muslim
Malaysian passengers. There is no doubt that religion can be considered as a crucial factor
which has influence on service receivers purchasing behavior. However the role of Islam on
shaping passengers expectation from hospitality within flights is scant. This study investigates
the key factors of hospitality according to Muslim passengers‘ perspectives by using an in-
depth interviews. In-depth interview were conducted in Malaysia research leading university
among academicians who are frequent flyers using various full service airlines. Findings
represent themes that should be considered as the determinants of Muslim passengers‘
satisfaction and loyalties to airlines. This study provides insights toward airline companies
which have focused on Muslim passengers as their target market. This study can be
considered as premier on exploring hospitality concept from Islamic perspective in an airline
context.
Keywords: Airline Hospitality, Islam, Passengers Expectation
1. Introduction (First-level heading, Times New Roman 12, bold)
The impact of culture on purchasing behavior of product and service consumers is
confirmed by different studies (Mattila, 1999; Ueltschy & Krampf, 2001; Crotts, Ron
Erdmann, 2000). Hospitality as a reciprocal relationship between the host side (service
provider) and the guest side (service receivers) (Lashley, 2008) is about guests overall
assessment of service provision (Ghobadian et al., 1994; Ingram 1999; Brotherton, 1999). In
fact positive guest assessment toward quality of treatment would lead to fulfillment of their
expectation following by provision of satisfaction and memorable experience.
Culture can be considered as one of the determinants of the guests‘ judgment toward
memorable experience (Ueltschy & Krampf, 2001; Lashley, 2008). However, Asian context
studies mainly have looked into service receivers‘ behavior from non-Muslim cultural
perspective (Tsang,2011; Kuo et al., 2012) and the studies which have look at quality of
service provision from Muslim perspective is very scant (Gayatri et al. 2011). Although
service quality can be considered as the basis for the hospitality provision, hospitality service
excellence is one step beyond service quality excellence (Severt, 2008; Hemmington, 2007).
Therefore, present study can be considered as initiator of hospitality assessment from Muslim
perspectives using qualitative as well as quantitative approach.
2. Literature Review
Although a wide- range of research have been carried out in hospitality context from
various perspectives (refer to Hing, 1997; Line & Runyan, 2012), few studies have looked
into hospitality from Islamic perspective. Most of the aforementioned studies have been
conducted on Chinese context or other non-Muslim countries. The requirement of research in
this Islamic area endorses an exploration into cultural and religion impact on passengers
airline hospitality judgment. This study can be considered as preliminary stage for exploring
227
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Muslim passengers‘ evaluation of airline hospitality by investigating cultural influences on
their assessment.
Islamic culture can considered as one of the main approaches in today‘s world since 20
percent of world population (around1.2 billion people) are followers of this religion(The
Canadian Society of Muslims, n/a; CIA Publication, 2004). Furthermore, Islam contains
various traits (Ball & Haque, 2003; Siddiqui, 1997) which may have different impact on
assessing quality of services performed.
Hospitality has been described as ―friendly and generous reception of guests or strangers‖
(Oxford English Dictionary, 2002), while Chambers of English Dictionary (2001) explains it
as ―entertaining strangers and guests kindly and without reward, showing kindness, generous
and bountiful. The Collins Concise English Dictionary has described hospitality as a
―kindness in welcoming strangers or guests," while Cassee (1983) has defined hospitality
more holistic, as a harmonic combination of tangible and intangible components such as food,
beverage, beds, ambiance, environment and behavior of the staff (Brotherton, 1999).The root
of the word hospitality is coming from Latin and is a medieval Latin ―hospes‖ which means
guests and hospitari (be a guest), and hospitabilis (put up as a guest) (Ottenbacher et al.,
2009).
Based on Lashley (2008), hospitality is meeting the physiological and psychological needs
of the guests. In other word, hospitality should be defined as an emotional and functional
reciprocity between host and guest. Host should have the potential to provide a memorable
experience and good feeling for its guest following by a good memory of service offering for
its guests as well. Different researchers have focused on the concept of hospitality based on
emotional and functional dimension, although they do not highlight that. Morrison and
O‘Gorman (2008) have defined the principles of hospitality as follows: guests is always
welcome, service should be offered at different levels, hospitality is performed according to
the guests necessities, specific hospitality performance is required for guests who have special
needs, hospitality provision must consist of basic needs such as (food, drink and
accommodation) as well as other needs. In addition availability of food and drink for guests
must be all the time they arrive.
Hepple, Kipps and Thomson (1990) define hospitality based on four characteristics,
firstly. Hospitality is a reciprocity behavior between host and guest, second it contains
interactive contact between service provider and receiver, thirdly hospitality is a mixture of
tangible and intangible factors and finally; host tries to fulfill the psychological and
physiological factors such as security and comfort.
2.1 The relation between culture and hospitality
Culture as a complex phenomenon or system consists of belief, customs, knowledge,
moral , law, art and any other behavior or habits obtained by society members, (Levy, 2010;
Schiffman et al., 2001). Culture can be either approached from cognitive (categorizing people
according to mindset, Hofstede, 1994) or behavioral (observing culture through people
behavior, Reisinger & Turner, 2003,) perspective. Since culture is based on collective
framework of individuals‘ interaction in society Winsted, 1997, consumers from various
cultural groups and roots would have different expectations, norms, thoughts accordingly
(Mattila, 1999; Lam, 2002). Therefore, different consumers requirements and decisions due to
their surrounding culture dogmas is comprehensible (Hirschman, 1981;Ueltschy & Krampf,
2001;Hofstede, 1980).
This cultural diversity can be generalized to other contexts such as hospitality and quality
of the services offered (Imrie et al., 2000, 2002; Mattila, 1999; Tsang, 2011). Lashley (2008)
228
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
has formulated hospitality as three domains model which cultural domain in hospitality is
vital domain since it defines features of all communities as well as societies. In addition
understanding guest side cultural characteristics can help for better service provision.
Studies have stated cultural values might present special regulations for consumers‘
evaluation toward service quality (Ellis et al., 2003; Strauss &Mang, 1999; Imrie et al., 2002).
In addition in case that cultural aspect can be accommodated in service quality by service
providers, the potential of predicting consumers‘ behavior with better precision would be
higher (Donthu & Yoo, 1998), which can leads to customers‘ satisfaction, perceived service
quality (Mattila, 1999; Winsted, 1997) as well as loyalty (Liu et al., 2001). It is important to
mention that level of considering weight for culture in service offering is highly dependent to
the service providers ―epic‖ ( consider all market have the same global culture and
standardize service offering Espinoza, 1999; Kettinger et al., 1995) ―emic‖ ( customize and
differentiate service offering based on cultural group Espinoza, 1999) approach toward
culture.
Different studies have stated that quality of hospitality provision of the host side (Tse &
Ho, 2009) as well as hospitality perception of the guest side (Espinoza, 1999; Smith &
Reynolds, 2001) varies across different cultural groups. Hsieh and Tsai (2009) have
confirmed the impact of culture on consumers‘ behavior by concluding that American and
Taiwan hotel guests have different understanding toward quality of treatment in hotels. The
differences are mostly in the categories named as ―assurance‖, ―reliability‖, ―tangibles‖,
―empathy‖ and ―reaction‖. Other studies also confirmed on the national culture impact on
consumers‘ assessment of travel services using a Hofstede model (Crotts & Erdmann, 2000).
They studied five groups of passengers from Germany, Taiwan, Japan, Brazil and UK.
Study‘s results reveal that passengers from high masculine societies will to report
dissatisfaction more compared to low or moderate masculine societies. In addition passengers
from less masculine cultures (e.g. Brazil and Taiwan) found to be more loyal to specific
airline compared to those belonging to high masculine societies (Japan, UK and Germany).
Other studies have also express that different treatment manner for nationalities such as
American and Chineses (Malhotra & McCort, 2001), Hispanic and Anglo (Ueltschy &
Krampf, 2001) and Japanese and American (Winsted, 1999), Chinese, Taiwanese, Japanese
and American (Gilbert & Wong, 2003).
Despite number of theoretical discussion over association among quality of service and
culture (Espinoza, 1999; Kettinger et al., 1995) as well as empirical research about impact of
culture on service quality conceptualization and dimensions(Espinoza,1999; Malhotra et al.,
1994; Kettinger et al.,1995; Winsted‘s,1999), exploring theoretical relationship between
culture and hospitality (Lashley, 2008) and its implication (Levy, 2010) is scant. Indeed most
of the hospitality studies are marking cross cultural comparison of service quality attributes in
hospitality context (Mok & Armstrong, 1998; Tse & Ho, 2009; Reisinger & Turner,1999;
Mattila,1999; Tsang & Ap, 2007; Furrer et al., 2000; Shanahan & Hyman, 2007) Rather than
investigating treatment manner and hospitality per se among cultural groups. In addition
hospitality concept has been theoretically underpinned from Greek and Roman, and Christian
approach (Lashley, 2008; Arterbury, 2005; Hershberger, 1999) but it is not theoretically
explored from Islamic philosophy. In fact few considerable attempts have investigated service
quality concept from Muslim perspective (Gayatri et al., 2011) or implementing hospitality in
Islamic context (Stephenson et al., 2010). Sobh and Belk (2011) explored Islamic hospitality
in private domain of hospitality ,but understanding Islamic hospitality in commercial domain
has not been explored. Present study can be considered as initiator of understanding Islamic
hospitality in commercial domain of hospitality in general and in aviation industry in specific.
229
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
2.2 Islamic impact on hospitality
Religion can be considered as one of the elements of culture that have impact on service
receivers assessment toward quality of service receive and hospitality performance. Many
studies have looked into Confucian beliefs as the basis for service offering judgment (Imrie et
al., 1999, 2000, 2002; Calvert, 2001; Lam, 2002). Despite enormous emphasize of Islam on
treatment manner and hospitality, very few studies have looked into Muslims perceptions just
from service quality perspective (Gayatri et al., 2011). Therefore this gap provides
opportunity to explore Islamic hospitality in commercial domain in general and in aviation
industry in specific. Islam followers believe that since they are responsible toward Allah, they
should absolutely obey god‘s willingness (Kadivar, 2003; Rice, 1999). This awareness guides
them to take care of their behavior because they want to succeed in after death life and they
understand that good after death situation is highly dependent to their life performance and
behavior (Rice, 1999; Gayatri et al., 2011).
For Muslims who obey Quran‘s morality, respecting and treating guest is recommended
by Allah commands. Hence Muslim hosts tries to welcome their guests warmly and properly.
Indeed Muslims consider having guests as an opportunity to receive Allah pleasure and
delight. Based on Islamic thought Muslims tries to not only pay attention to their family
circle, but also this attention is expanded to neighbors as well as guests who deserve it. Of
course treating properly does not means that guests have the right to stay as much as they
want and mostly three days is a recommended duration and after that it is host charity
(O'Gorman, 2007). Hospitality is observable in various Islamic regions such as ancient Persia
(O'Gorman, 2007) and denominations (sunni, shia, sufis). In Sufism hospitality is practiced in
order to always be in remembrance of God (Milson, 1975).
Prophet Ibrahim can be considered as the first role model of hospitality in Islam. Food
provision was considered as a cue to soften the relationship between host and guest and tie the
friendship knot between them so that the guest become part of the host family. Also when
guest side eats the food, normally shows that they don‘t have hostile intentions (O'Gorman,
2007). Prophet Ibrahim was afraid when his guest refuse to eat the food (Qur‘ān 51:23), but
then Jebrail (Gabriel) declares that they are divine messengers. In Islamic culture, eating
together brings some obligations and duties (Doughty, 1888) such as protecting the guest side.
Even in some countries (e.g. Iran) there was a practice that when people eat bread and salt,
they consider respect and duties interchangeably and should help each other any time they
need help. This nowadays become like a proverb in Iran that ―he/she (the guest) eat the salt
but broke his/her (the host side) salt pot (referring to disrespect and unhelpful manner of guest
to host) (O'Gorman, 2007). Islam prophet Muhammad (PBUH) also can be considered as the
essence of hospitality concept. He always treated all the guests regardless of their ethnicity as
well as religious. He advised Muslims to treat their guest properly and states that hospitality is
a symptom of faith. To conclude prophet Muhammad (PBUH) behavior and manners shows
that guests should be welcome cheerfully, entertained as well as fell comfort.
3. Method
A qualitative research approach was applied in order to describe and investigate the
Muslim passengers‘ airline hospitality experiences. This would help to understand the
applicability of commercial hospitality model in an airline context from Islamic perspective.
In order to collect data, semi-structured in-depth interviews were conducted. Semi structured
in-depth interviews enable the researcher to better understand the phenomenon under study
(Creswell, 2003). Indeed in-depth interviews pre-requirement are the researcher good
listening power (Lee & Broderick 2007) as well as existence of empathy between researcher
and respondents (Branthwaite & Patterson 2011).
230
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
3.1 Participants
The sample of present study encompasses of Muslim Malaysian academicians who have
travel experiences with full service airlines in business class. Academicians were chosen as
participants since they have good opportunities to patronize a range of full business class in
different airlines due to their academic journeys to conferences. Hence, their experiences can
explain the common themes inherent in commercial hospitality. By using purposive sampling
technique; 10 academicians (full professors), consisting of 5 males and 5 females with
different academic majors and area of specialization have been chosen as present study
targeted sample.
3.2 Procedure and Data Analysis
In-depth interview format included eight sections, consisting questions related to how
hospitality in general and how airline hospitality in specific are defined by the respondent;
memorable experiences of respondents in airline hospitality (e.g., during flights); values and
feelings influencing respondents‘ perceptions toward airline hospitality that should be
explained; assessing perception of respondents toward importance of existence of some well-
known hospitality items in airline contexts (e.g. warmth welcoming, directing passengers to
the seats); assessing perception of respondents toward importance of existence of not
confirmed hospitality items in airline contexts (e.g. do you consider punctuality as an airline
hospitality?); determining the perception of passengers on the level of hospitality that should
be provided by the business class versus economy class; investigating the possible factors that
predict (antecedent) airline hospitality and investigating the possible factors that may
moderate the relationship between airline hospitality and passengers satisfaction.
The semi-structured in-depth interview permitted respondents to feel more relaxed; hence
they extended their responses during answering questions (such as providing narratives and
examples that explained their experiences). Interview objectives were introduced and
questions were open-ended in order to give a chance to respondents for clarifying their
responses. The interviews duration were from 30 to 1.5 hours, with an average length of 40
minutes. In order to have proper data analysis, all in-depth interviews were audio-recorded
and transcribed precisely into text. In addition field notes during and after each interview was
written for highlighting important issues raised during interviews. Researchers used the four
commercial hospitality themes extracted from the literature in order to identify the elements
respondents considered as an Islamic airline hospitality experiences. A qualitative data
analysis procedure (categorasation, abstraction and comparison) was followed. In addition
interviews were read several times to obtain the total essence of responses for better
categorization. Islamic elements identified were clustered under constructs during abstraction
and comparison stage.
4. Research Findings and Discussions
Interpersonal interaction
The ‗interpersonal interaction‘ dimension refers to friendship, social contacts,
companionship and affiliation in the commercial hospitality context. In addition cabin crews‘
interactions manner such as smiling, eye contact, pleasant tone of speaking and made
passengers feeling welcome can be considered as elements of interpersonal interaction theme.
Despite respondents emphasize on importance of eye contact, they believed that this
importance is highly dependent on passengers‘ cultural and religion issues as well as personal
sensitivity. This means that some cultures (e.g. Muslims) may not like and consider eye
connection as the representative of hospitality and may interpret it differently:
231
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
“I have another experience in the gulf air that one steward was looking
and trying to talk with the wife of one of the passengers and asking her
what she would like and I could see that the partner , the spouse was
offended , so to me this are cultural sensitivity , I mean for some
countries and religions eye contact is ok but for some cultures( too much
looking) is not good. So I think cabin crews should be very sensitive to
cultural differences (Respondent 5, GH)”.
Psychological connection
The ‗psychological connection‘ dimension explains the emotional and psychological
attachment of the guest side to the host side. Respondents explained their airline hospitality
experiences by expressing the cabin crews‘ behavior and treatment manner. Participants liked
to be recognized, respected and honored by the cabin crews. Indeed guests need to feel they
are important, and to feel that their needs will be both recognized and met (Lashley, 2008).
In addition, an effort of cabin crews to recognize passengers personally, have impact on
passengers self-image. This will ends to enhancement of passengers-cabin crews‘ relationship
and provision of memorable experience as well as sense of staying in their own home. Some
Muslim respondents have explained their in-flight memorable experience by emphasizing on
cabin crew help on taking care of their requests and helping them with their Islamic needs
which was beyond responsibility of the cabin crews:
“Another experience is that when I went to Europe and I forgot to bring
my baya telekum(praying dress), and I borrow it from them and I
promise them to return and this was beyond their duties and I like it
…..so they were sensitive to my needs and this was very important for
me, ….(Respondent 7, ISK)”.
Openness to Different Cultures
Another factor captured is ‗openness to different cultures‘ which determines passengers
experience and satisfaction toward intercultural exchange. The emphasize of this dimension is
on the needs of cabin crews (host side) as well as passengers (guest side) who must be open-
minded in terms of cultural and religion differences. Indeed this leads to mutual
understanding improvement in guest–host transactions. In General, respondents stated that
airlines provide good hospitality experiences. However, some participants perceived different
barrier (e.g. treatment manner, facilities provided) as the main problem which hinders
passengers‘ satisfaction:
“I expect that they don’t ask me to seat next to the big guys for example
and that is important for me, and this are some of basic need that I need
to be taking care of………(Respondent 6, KHA)”
The reason that may cause passengers dissatisfaction is due to the concept of Mahrem and
non-Mahrem which was explained earlier. Since airline seats normally is not so big and
spacious (with the exception of first class), feeling comfortable for a long air journey is not
really easy, specifically if the person next to you is a man who does not care about his sitting.
Some respondents believe when airlines provide some facilities based on the culture and
religious of the passengers, that can be considered as the hospitality in the airlines:
“………….for the Muslims some airlines provide some corners for the
prayers, so this is another aspect but I think they should be very sensitive
about different needs of different groups of people depending on culture
(Respondent 7, ISK)”.
232
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
To conclude, cultural and religion differences is an issue that needs to be taken into
account in an airline hospitality context. These differences can manifests in language,
physical environment and treatment manner. The level of sensitivity that airlines apply in
their hospitality provision can be considered as an important competitive advantage which
leads to their future success. In addition present study emphasizes on significance of
intercultural communication skills as previous studies have also confirmed (Sizoo, 2006).
Sensation satisfaction
The ‗sensation satisfaction‘ dimension refers to an enjoyable atmosphere which has a
significant impact on hospitality experiences. Indeed as Cohen (1999) stated, sensation
includes all five human senses such as visual, auditory, olfactory, tactile and gustatory (Teng,
2011), which can lead a simple service provision to memorable experience (Hemmington,
2007) for the passengers. The type of the foods and drinks served during the flight were other
concern of the respondents which can cause passengers dissatisfaction and providing not
positive memorable flight experience:
“…….in one of my traveling experience the foods (served) was pork and
this flight was not Malaysian and I was quite sensitive about that……
(Respondent 6, KHA)”
“I have an experience about the Malaysian Airlines and I was with my
wife and she was wearing Hejab and the person (Stewardess) serving the
alcohol was muslin and during the lunch time, she was offering to me
and my wife alcohol and that is really insensitive you know. Maybe they
have to serve that because there might be some people like it, but that
would be very offensive for me and why this happens, because of the lack
of cultural sensitivities there. I am sure in Malaysia offering a Muslim
(an alcohol) is very offensive. So crews can be very nice to passengers
but when they say or ask passengers that do you like to have wine! Then
whatever nice thing they did during flight and whole good service
provision to me will be no longer nice (Respondent 5, GH)”
To conclude the finding of in-depth interviews emphasize that cabin crews need to be
aware of Islamic requirements of the passengers from interactions, psychological connections,
openness to different culture and sensation satisfaction perspective.
In other word, passengers need to be treated with proper manner and behavior (such as
smiling, eye contact), but it should be not offensive. This means cabin crews should have
enough emotional intelligence in order to understand the level of their interaction with
passengers which have various cultural and religion backgrounds. In addition cabin crews
attempt to fulfill of religious requirement of their passengers (such as provision of spaces for
praying of their Muslim passengers in long haul flight even if they don‘t have any specific
praying room, or provision of Islamic meals for their Muslim passengers) can be considered
as bonus and competitive advantage for airline to be promoted and penetrated in Muslim
market.
In addition a quantitative approach was also employed, in order to confirm the findings of
in-depth interviews. Therefore, a questionnaire survey was conducted in Kuala-Lumpur
International Airport (KLIA) among 391 Muslim and Non-Muslim passengers who have
experience of flying within last six months. The results of post-hoc analysis indicate that there
is a significant difference between Muslim and Non-Muslims passengers‘ in terms of the
weight they consider for items such as cabin crews eye contact, spending time with
passengers or initiating small talk with passengers. Therefore the finding of quantitative
233
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
technique confirms the findings of qualitative approach indicating that although quality of
treatment manner is important for Muslim passengers; they expect certain regulations in
service provision which needs to be taken into account.
5. Conclusion
This study offered insight into how Islam influences the essence of hospitality assessment.
This study offers Islamic elements under commercial hospitality themes. Conceptual as well
as empirical investigation of commercial hospitality from Islamic perspective is very scant.
Present study attempt to understand Islamic elements in commercial airline hospitality in
general and in aviation industry in specific. The necessitate for research on Islamic elements
which have influence on commercial hospitality is highlighted. Airline managers can consider
present study findings as an Islamic hospitality criterion in an airline context in order to
penetrate and promote better in Muslim market.
References
Al-Qaradawi, Y. (1985). The Lawful and the Prohibited in Islam (Al-Halal wal Haram fil
Islam). Islamic Book Trust, Malaysia.
Arterbury, A. E. (2005). entertaining angels early Christian hospitality in its Mediterranean
setting. Sheffield Phoenix Press.
Ball, C. and Haque, A. (2003). Diversity in religious practice: implications of Islamic values
in public workplace , Public Personnel Management. Vol. 32 No. 3, pp. 315-30.
Branthwaite, A., Patterson. S. (2011).The power of qualitative research in the era of social
media. Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal, Vol.14 No.4, pp.430-440.
Brotherton, B. (1999). Towards a definitive view of the nature of hospitality and hospitality
management. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol.11 Np.4,
pp.165-173.
Calvert, P.J. (2001). International variations in measuring customer expectations. Library
Trends, Vol. 49 No. 4, pp. 732-58.
Canadian Society of Muslims. (n/a) Muslim population statistics, available at: http:// muslim-
canada.org/muslimstats.html (accessed 2 May 2008).
Cassee, E.H. and Reuland, R. (1983). Hospitality in hospitals. in Cassee, E.H. and Reuland,
R. (Eds), The Management of Hospitality, Pergamon, Oxford, pp. 143-63.
CIA Publication (2004). CIA‘s world fact book. available at: www.cia.gov/cia/publications/
factbook/ (accessed 10 March 2008).
Cohen, R.J. (1999). What qualitative research can be. Psychology & Marketing 16 (4), 351–
368.
Creswell, J.W. (2003). Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Method
Approaches, 2nd ed. Sage, London.
Crotts, J.C., Erdmann, R., (2000). Does national culture influence consumers' evaluation of
travel services? A test of Hofstede's model of cross-cultural differences‖.Managing Service
Quality, Vol. 10 Iss. 6, pp. 410- 419
Donthu, N. and Yoo, B. (1998).Cultural influences on SQ expectations‖, Journal of Service
Research, Vol. 1 No. 2, pp. 178-86.
Doughty, C.M., Travels in Arabia Deserta (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press 1888)
234
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Ellis, J.H.M, Williams, D.R. and Zuo, Y. (2003). Cross-cultural influences in Chinese
retailing: a comparative study of local and international supermarket in China. Asian Business
Management, Vol. 1 No. 2, pp. 205-21.
Espinoza, M.M. (1999). Assessing the cross-cultural applicability of a SQ measure.
International Journal of Service Industry Management, Vol. 10 No. 5, pp. 449-68.
Furrer, O., Shaw-Ching Liu, B. and Sudharshan, D. (2000).The relationships between culture
and service quality perceptions: basis for cross-cultural market segmentation and resource
allocation. Journal of Service Research, Vol. 2 No. 5, pp. 355-71.
Gayatri, G., Hume, M. Sullivan Mort, G. (2011).The role of Islamic culture in service
quality research. Asian Journal on Quality, Vol. 12 Iss. 1 pp. 35 – 53.
Ghobadian, A., Speller, S. and Jones, M. (1994).SQ: concepts and models‖, International
Journal of Quality & Reliability Management. Vol. 11 No. 9, pp. 43-66.
Gilbert, D., Wong, R.K.C. (2003).Passenger expectations and airline services: a Hong Kong
based study. Tourism Management, Vol.24, pp.519-532
Hattstein, M. (1998), World Religions, Konemann, New York, NY.
Hemmington, N. (2007).From service to experience: understanding and defining the
hospitality business. The Service Industries Journal, Vol.27 No.6, pp.747–755.
Hepple, J., .Kipps, M, Thomson, J.(1990).The concept of hospitality and an evaluation of its
applicability to the experience of hospital patients. International Journal of Hospitality
Management, Vol.9 No.4, pp.305-318.
Hershberger, M.(1999). Christian view of hospitality: Expecting surprises, Herald Press.
Hing, N. (1997). A review of hospitality research in the Asia Pacific region 1989-1996: a
thematic perspective. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management
Vol.9/7 pp.241–253.
Hirschman, E.C. (1981). American Jewish ethnicity: its relationship to some selected aspects
of consumer behavior. Journal of Marketing, Vol. 45 No. 3, pp. 102-10.
Hofstede, G.H.(1980). Culture‘s Consequences: International Differences in Wordrelated
Values. Sage Publications, Beverly Hills, CA.
Hofstede, G.H. (1994). Management scientists are human. Management Science 40 (1), 4–13.
Hsieh, A. T., and Tsai, C.W. (2009).Does national culture really matter? Hotel service
perceptions by Taiwan and American tourists. International Journal of Culture, Tourism and
Hospitality Research, Vol. 3 No. 1, pp. 54-69,
Imrie, B.C., Cadogan, J.W. and McNaughton, R. (2002). The SQ construct on a global stage.
Managing SQ, Vol. 12 No. 1, pp. 10-18.
Imrie, B.C., Durden, G. and Cadogan, J. (1999). A conceptual model of service quality:
acontrasting cultural perspective. paper presented at the Annual Conference of the European
Marketing Academy, Berlin, 11-14 May 1999.
Imrie, B.C., Durden, G.R. and Cadogan, J.W. (2000).Towards a conceptualization of SQin the
global market arena. Advances in International Marketing, Vol. 1 Supplement, pp. 143-62.
Ingram, H., (1999). Hospitality: a framework for a millennial review. International Journal of
Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol.11/4, pp.140-147.
235
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Kadivar, M. (2003). An introduction to the public and private debate in Islam. Social
Research, Vol. 70 No. 3, pp. 659-80.
Kettinger, W., Lee, C. and Lee, S. (1995). Global measures of information service quality: a
cross national study. Decision Sciences, Vol. 26 No. 5, pp. 569-88.
Kuo, C.M. Chen, L.C. Lu, C. Y. (2012). Factorial validation of hospitality service attitude.
International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol.31, pp.944-951.
Lam, T. (2002). Making sense of SERVQUAL‘s dimensions to the Chinese customers in
Macau. Journal of Market-Focused Management, Vol. 5 No. 1, pp. 43-58.
Lashley, C., (2008). Studying hospitality: Insights from social sciences. Scandinavian Journal
of Hospitality and Tourism, Vol.8 No.1, pp.69-84.
Lee, N., Broderick, A. J. (2007).The past, present and future of observational research in
marketing. Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal, Vol.10 No.2, pp.121-129.
Levy, S.E. (2010).The hospitality of the host: A cross-cultural examination of managerially
facilitated consumer-to-consumer interactions. International Journal of Hospitality
Management, Vol.29, pp.319–327
Line, N.D., Runyan, R. C. (2012).Hospitality marketing research: Recent trends and future
directions. International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol.31, pp.477– 488.
Liu, B.S.-C., Furrer, O., Sudharshan, D. (2001). The relationships between culture and
behavioral intentions toward services. Journal of Service Research, Vol.4 No.2, pp.118–129.
Malhotra, N. and McCort, J. (2001). A cross-cultural comparison of behavioural intention
models. International Marketing Review, Vol.18 No.3, pp.235-269.
Malhotra, N.K., Ulgado, F.M., Agarwal, J. and Baalbaki, I.B. (1994). A comparative
evaluation of the dimensions of service quality between developed and developing
countries.International Marketing Review, Vol. 11 No. 2, pp. 5-15.
Mattila, A.S. (1999).The role of cultural and purchase motivate on in service encounter
evaluations‖. Journal of Service Marketing Vol.13 (4/5), pp.376–389.
Milson, M. (1975).Adab al-Muridin, Abu Al-Najib Al-Suhrawaradi, Harvaed University
Press.
Mok, C. and Armstrong, R. W. (1998). Expectation for hotel service quality: do they differ
from culture to culture? Journal of Vacation Marketing, October 1998; Vol. 4 No.4, pp. 381-
391.
Morrison, A. O‘Gorman, K.(2008). Hospitality studies and hospitality management: A
symbiotic relationship. International Journal of Hospitality Management 27,214–221.
O‘Gorman, Kevin D. (2007). Iranian hospitality: a hidden treasure. International Journal of
Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol.9 No.1. pp. 31-36. ISSN 0959-6119.
Ottenbacher, M. Harrington, R. &Parsa, H.G .(2009). Defining the Hospitality discipline: a
discussion of pedagogical and research implications. Journal of Hospitality & amp; Tourism
research, Vol.33,263.
Reisinger, Y., Turner, L. (2003). Cross-cultural Behaviour in Tourism—Concepts and
Analysis. Butterworth-Heinemann, Burlington, MA.
Reisinger, Y and Turner, L. (1999). A cultural analysis of Japanese tourists: challenges for
tourism marketers. European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 33 No. 11, pp. 203-277.
236
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Rice, G. (1999). Islamic ethics and the implication for business. Journal of Business Ethics,
Vol. 18 No. 4, pp. 345-58.
Schiffman, L., Bednall, D., Cowley, E., O‘Cass, A., Watson, J. and Kanuk, L. (2001),
―Consumer Behaviour‖, Australian 2nd ed., Prentice Hall, Sydney
Severt, D. Aiello, T. Elswick, S. & Cyr, C. (2008). Hospitality in hospitals? International
Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol.20 No.6, pp.664-667.
Shanahan, K. J. and Hyman, M. R.(2007).An exploratory study of desired hotel attributes for
American tourists vacationing in China and Ireland. Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol.13,
107
Siddiqui, A (1997).Ethics in Islam: key concepts and contemporary challenges. Journal of
Moral Education, Vol. 26 No. 4, pp. 423-31.
Sizoo, S.(2006). A comparison of the effect of intercultural sensitivity on employee
performance in cross-cultural service encounters: London vs. Florida. Journal of
Euromarketing, Vol.15 No.4, pp.77–100.
Smith, A.M. and Reynolds, N.L. (2001). Measuring cross-cultural SQ: a framework for
assessment. International Marketing Review, Vol. 19 No. 5, pp. 450-81.
Strauss, B. and Mang, P. (1999). Culture shocks‘ in inter-cultural service encounters?
Journal of Service Marketing, Vol. 13 No 3/4, pp. 329-46.
Stephenson, M., L., Russell, K.A., Edgar, D. (2010).Islamic hospitality in the UAE:
indigenization of products and human capital. Journal of Islamic Marketing, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp.
9-24.
Sobh, R., Belk, R., (2011). Domains of privacy and hospitality in Arab Gulf homes. Journal
of Islamic Marketing, Vol. 2 No. 2,pp. 125-137.
Teng, C.C.(2011).Commercial hospitality in restaurants and tourist accommodation:
Perspectives from international consumer experience in Scotland. International Journal of
Hospitality Management, Vol.30 No.4, pp.866-874.
Tsang, N.K. F., and Ap, J. (2007). Tourists' Perceptions of Relational Quality Service
Attributes: A Cross-Cultural. Journal of Travel Research, pp.345-355
Tsang, N.K.F.(2011). Dimensions of Chinese culture values in relation to service provision in
hospitality and tourism industry, International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol.30,
pp. 670–679
Tse, E.C. Y., and Ho, S.C., (2009). Service Quality in the Hotel Industry: When Cultural
Contexts Matter. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, Vol.50: 460 originally published online 17
June
Ueltschy, L.C. and Krampf, R.F. (2001).Cultural sensitivity to satisfaction and SQ measures.
Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, Vol. 9 No. 3, pp. 14-31.
Winsted, K.F. (1997).The service experience in two cultures: a behavioral perspective.
Journal of Retailing, Vol.73 No.3, pp.337-360.
Winsted, K.F. (1999).Evaluating service encounters: a cross-cultural and cross-industry
exploration. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, Vol. 7 No. 2, pp. 106-241.
237
Upon This Rock I Will Build My Church: Constructions of Christianity
(and Their Consequences) at American Religious Youth Music Festivals
Kellee Caton
Thompson Rivers University
Tourism Management, Faculty of Adventure, Culinary Arts, and Tourism, Canada
kcaton@tru.ca
Colleen Pastoor
Thompson Rivers University
Tourism Management, Faculty of Adventure, Culinary Arts, and Tourism, Canada
colleenpastoor@gmail.com
Yaniv Belhassen
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Hotel and Tourism Management, Guilford Glazer Faculty of Business and Management,
Israel
yanivbel@bgu.ac.il
Billy Collins
Thompson Rivers University
Tourism Management, Faculty of Adventure, Culinary Arts, and Tourism, Canada
bcollins@tru.ca
Mark Wallin
Thompson Rivers University
Journalism, Communications, and New Media, Faculty of Arts, Canada
mwallin@tru.ca
Abstract
Christian youth music festivals (CYMFs) attract tens of thousands of participants each year;
however, they have received surprisingly little attention in the literature on festivals, events,
and tourism. This exploratory study seeks to better understand the CYMF phenomenon, and
in particular, the role of these festivals in promoting positive social values, such as tolerance,
inter-group harmony, and peace. To this end, an ethnographic field study was undertaken
examining two popular CYMFs held annually in the United States: Lifest and the Cornerstone
Festival. Fieldwork involved participant observation at each of these festivals in 2011, formal
interviews with festival organizers and performers, and more than 30 informal interviews with
festival participants. Based on this fieldwork, the paper attempts to present an ethnographic
portrait of each of these festivals, and then to analyze the ideological position promulgated by
each. It concludes that Lifest and Cornerstone are very different, in terms of the constructions
of Christian doctrine and Christian identity that each festival advances, and that these
constructions of the meaning of Christianity and of what it means to be a Christian have
consequences for inter-group relationships in the United States and beyond. Specifically,
Lifest is critiqued for advancing a form of fundamentalist Christianity that isolates its
followers from others outside this in-group and encourages them to conceive of their faith as
existing in conflict with being tolerant of difference. Cornerstone, on the other hand, is
explored as a very different kind of CYMF, which advances constructions of Christianity that
favor integration with the world and the championing of progressive social causes that bring
people together across lines of difference. The paper thus illustrates that religious tourism, in
239
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
this case to Christian youth music festivals, can both promote and inhibit the development of
the kinds of attitudes and values that lead to inter-group tolerance and harmony.
Keywords: Christianity, ideology, peace
1. Introduction
I’m not a regular churchgoer, but each time I attend services with my parents at their
Protestant church or with my in-laws at their Catholic church, I am always struck by the
shared ritual—common between these two, in many other ways, quite different Christian
traditions—of pausing at a midpoint in the service for congregants to reach out to those seated
around them and wish them the simple blessing ―Peace be with you.‖ But peace is a complex
thing, and Christianity, despite the Bible’s exhortation to ―love thy neighbor as thyself,‖
hasn’t always been on the side of advancing it. Although the Crusades might be the most
stunning example of this religious tradition at its worst, we don’t need to look further than the
current era to find instances of the way that Christianity—like all major world religions—is
both advancing and hindering humanistic concerns. American evangelical Christianity is a
particularly interesting tradition to consider in this regard because of this movement’s long
and complicated imbrication in the American political scene, culminating with the rise of the
Religious Right over the last four decades.
To fruitfully explore evangelical Christianity’s relationship with the promotion of peace is
not to ask questions of a theological or doctrinal character. Instead, we must look at
evangelicalism as a social force—at the way this movement operates in the world and at it its
consequences for the lives of individuals, communities, and broader society. Central to such
an interrogation is the exploration of evangelicalism’s subculture, as perhaps more than any
other branch of American Christianity, this faith movement has articulated and sustained itself
through cultural practices and systems that lie outside the bounds of the Sunday sanctuary—
most notably, practices related to leisure, entertainment, and tourism (Marsden, 2006;
Carpenter, 1997; Schultze, 2002). Questions of the evangelical subculture’s role in the
advancement or hindrance of peace thus dovetail nicely with emergent concerns in tourism
studies about the role of tourism in the same. Recent efforts, such as the establishment of the
International Centre for Peace through Tourism Research, along with publications like
Moufakkir and Kelly’s (2010) edited volume Tourism, Progress and Peace, have helped to
place concerns about the role of tourism in promoting intergroup harmony and social
improvement higher on the agenda of tourism scholarship. Nevertheless, religious tourism is
an understudied area in the realm of peace and tourism research—hence, the need for the
present conference on religious tourism and tolerance.
In this paper, with the help of my team of co-authors, we aim to explore a particular aspect
of evangelical Christian tourism—travel to American Christian youth music festivals
(CYMFs)—in order to analyze the role these festivals play in the furthering of peace (or lack
of peace), defined broadly, as discussed below, in keeping with Haessly’s (2010) conception
of peace as representing far more than simply the absence of war or physical violence. I write
here in first person, as the lead author of this piece, because it facilitates my ability to share
reflections gleaned from my lifetime of engagement with American Protestant Christianity,
and because the paper’s central argument, about the ways that CYMFs influence the
production of peace at different levels in American society, is my own, and I take sole
responsibility for the criticisms of evangelicalism expressed in the proceeding pages (although
certainly my various co-authors share some or all of my concerns in this regard). The paper
as a whole, however, is a joint effort, in the sense that it is part of a larger project, with the
ethnographic data from the two CYMFs examined in this paper having been collected (and its
analysis confirmed) by the second author, scholarly understanding of tourism and the
evangelical subculture having been contributed by the third author, and expertise in the area
240
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
of music festivals as spaces of sociopolitical import having been provided by the fourth and
fifth authors. A motley group of current and former Christians, Jews, and agnostics, we have
each contributed personal experiences and observations, as well as formal scholarship, to this
project, and we are united in our interest to understand American evangelicalism and its role
in the world.
The paper begins by contextualizing the present study with regard to concerns in the
literature about the relationship between tourism and peace and about the role of religious
tourism and heritage festivals in ideological production. The study’s method-related details
are then shared, after which, an analysis is presented of two popular American CYMFs, Lifest
and Cornerstone, which represent different manifestations of the production of evangelical
Christian identity and meaning through tourism practice. Each festival, and the religio-
cultural tradition of which it is a part, has its own complex implications for peace-building.
The paper thus illustrates the way one particular form of religious tourism—the American
evangelical Christian rock festival—can simultaneously create and undermine conditions
conducive to creating peace in the American socioscape, and in the world more broadly.
2. Tourism, Religion, and Peace
Tourism’s potential to promote peace is a longstanding concern within the academy, and
one that has been reenergized of late, as part of the recent ―critical turn‖ (Ateljevic, Pritchard,
and Morgan, 2007; Ateljevic, Morgan, and Pritchard, 2012) in tourism studies. Although
early work in this area—such as d’Amore’s (1988) sentinel research note in Tourism
Management, ―Tourism—A Vital Force for Peace‖—may have emphasized a more traditional
notion of peace as the absence of armed conflict between nation-states or other groups,
concerning itself primarily with tourism’s facilitation of cross-cultural contact, which could
provide opportunities for people to meet others perceived as being different from themselves
face to face and therefore promote stereotype reduction (i.e., the contact hypothesis—
Tomljenovic, 2010), more recent work has tended to consider peace as a broader concept than
simply the absence of violence. Haessly’s (2010) conceptualization of ―positive peace‖ nicely
captures the broadening of this notion, as he argues that peace is best imagined not merely as
an absence (of war, turmoil, suffering) but as a presence—of wholeness, contentment, and
profound integration, as captured in the Russian notion of mir, or of harmony and unity in
diversity, as in the Chinese concept of ping. Haessly has examined various religious
traditions and notes that they tend to share such notions of peace, recognize that peace is
characterized by both an individual and a social dimension, and hold that these features of
individual and social well-being are interdependent.
Contemporary peace researchers have added flesh to this characterization, describing
positive peace as ―the presence of some desirable conditions in society, including integration,
justice, harmony, equity, freedom, wholeness, the promotion of the dignity of each person and
the wellbeing of all of a society’s citizens (Macquarrie, 1973; Wallensteen, 1988; Brock-Utne,
1989)‖ (Haessly, 2010, p. 5). Central to this image is the idea of the members of a society
being able to actualize their potential, a notion taken up by philosopher-activists Martha
Nussbaum and Amartya Sen in their ―capabilities movement‖ (Nussbaum, 2011). In the
contemporary world, Haessly highlights several concrete concerns as being central to the
creation of positive peace: the promotion of a worldview that does not draw lines between
―us‖ and ―them‖ but recognizes all people as part of a human family, and hence seeks to
overcome racism, sexism, and all other forms of bigotry and exclusion; a concern for human
rights around the globe, in terms of people having the right to life, to adequate food and
shelter and the environmental resources that sustain life, to health care, to education, to
meaningful work, to security, to free expression, to treatment with dignity, and to
241
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
participation in decisions affecting their lives; the prioritization of ecological security; and a
commitment to non-violent paths to social change.
Work on the relationship between tourism and peace is growing and has considered,
among many other issues, host–guest interactions in contact zones for ethnic groups with a
history of tense relations, such as Arabs and Jews in the Sinai (Uriely, Maoz, and Reichel,
2009; Maoz, 2010); tourism’s ability to unite acrimonious groups through large-scale events
that celebrate the human spirit (Schulenkorf and Edwards, 2010); solidarity tourism, or travel
for political purposes, to protest human rights violations or to promote reconciliation between
groups (Higgins-Desbiolles, 2003; Higgins-Desbiolles and Blanchard, 2010); tourism as a
catalyst for development and social normalization in post-conflict areas (Bujisic, 2011;
Causevic and Lynch, 2011), representation and stereotyping in tourism (Echtner and Prasad,
2003; Caton, 2011); and philosophical explorations of the essence of the tourism experience
and its role in promoting or hindering peace (Pernecky, 2010).
Religion and spirituality in tourism is a robustly developing concern in the literature, as
well. Work in this domain includes extensive considerations of tourism and pilgrimage
(Cohen, 1979; Digance, 2006; Belhassen, Caton, and Stewart, 2008; Collins-Kreiner, 2010);
investigations concerning the commercialization of spirituality (Nolan and Nolan, 1992;
Shackley, 2006); explorations of the New Age phenomenon (Pernecky, 2006; Timothy and
Conover, 2006); and general overviews of the relationship between the phenomena of religion
and tourism (Vukonic, 1996; Sharpley, 2009). However, as noted, this area of research has
only recently begun to intersect with explorations of tourism and peace. This paper seeks to
advance discussion at this intersection through the exploration of American evangelical
Christian tourism—specifically that to religious youth music festivals, often called ―Christian
rock festivals,‖ as a reference to their rock-and-roll orientation in terms of genre. In so doing,
it also advances the literature on tourism and peace more generally, by exploring religious
tourism as a site of ideological production that can have consequences for peace—a highly
under-researched phenomenon. Only a handful of interrogations in this direction are thus far
extant, including Moufakkir’s (2010) analysis of Jerusalem tourism brokers’ use of tourism to
promote various political goals; Sofield and Li’s (1998) consideration of religious tourism as
a political apparatus of the state in China; Vukonic’s (1992) exploration of emergent
pilgrimage to Medjugorje, which provoked a negative response from the socialist government
of the former Yugoslavia, and thus played a role in the troubles in the Balkans in the 1990s;
Hill’s (2008) work on New Age tourists’ appropriations of Quechua cosmology and ritual and
their role in furthering the practice of othering and perpetuating ―racialized structuralized
inequality‖; and the work of various scholars, including Bowman (2000), Sizer (1999),
Belhassen (2009), Belhassen and Santos (2006), and Belhassen and Ebel (2009), on Christian
pilgrimage to the Holy Land, its ideological and political implications, and the need for
responsible pilgrimage.
Religiously based festivals have not been given their due in tourism scholarship, but
festivals in general have often been explored as sites of ideological production in tourism
studies and beyond. Indeed, from the earliest days of western civilization, special events have
served powerful ideological purposes, reaching well beyond any entertainment value they
may have provided, with the Ancient Olympics, for example, having served primarily as an
activity for generating civic pride among warring Greek city-states (Gomez-Lobo, 1997), and
the Roman Circus Maximus having been used to draw attention away from sociopolitical
concerns by providing a distraction for citizens; ―bread and circuses,‖ from the Latin ―panem
et circenses,‖ was the going metaphor for the strategy of combining substantive security for
the citizenry with superficial means of appeasement through the elaborate staging of circus
games and other forms of entertainment to increase political power through populism. Events
242
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
as sociopolitical phenomena continued through the medieval era and into the present day, and
scholarship on this issue includes, among many other explorations, Mullaney’s (1983)
deconstruction of a series of Renaissance events and spectacles to reveal cultural
understandings of otherness, Banet-Weiser’s (1999) analysis of beauty pageants as discursive
spaces of national identity construction, and Xu’s (2006) consideration of the modern
Olympic Games as a space for official national articulation of discourses surrounding the
politics of multiculturalism and modernity. Scholars of cultural politics have also explored
festivals as sites of contestation, as different groups vie to articulate local culture in terms
favorable to their own goals and position (e.g., Jeong and Santos, 2003; Cohen, 1998; Davila,
1997). It is against this backdrop of festivals as spaces of ideological production that our
interest in Christian youth music festivals emerges.
3. Study Method
Given the lack of extant work on the phenomenon of CYMFs, the present study proceeded
in an inductive and exploratory manner, using what has been referred to in the qualitative
methods literature variously as a mini-, micro-, or compressed time–ethnographic approach
(Jeffrey and Troman, 2004; Hammersley, 2006). Such an approach draws on the
anthropological tradition of ethnography, with its emphasis on participant-observation and a
holistic approach to the gathering and analysis of data, which often comes in many forms,
including direct field observations, experiential understandings, formal and informal
interviews with others in the research context, and physical and electronic documents
pertaining to the field site. It differs from traditional ethnography, however, in its length of
engagement with participants; whereas a traditional ethnographer might spent a year or more
living and working among a cultural group she wished to study, a researcher conducting a
compressed time ethnography would instead engage in participant-observation during
concentrated time periods deemed particularly relevant for gaining an understanding of the
group or phenomenon in question.
Compressed time ethnography has obvious limitations, in that it does not allow for the
researcher to build long-term relationships with study participants or to view each of their
lives in its full context, but it can be appropriate in certain situations where traditional
ethnography is not possible. In the case of this project, which involves a subculture of
participants who are geographically spread out and who only come together for brief but
intense periods (i.e., when a given CYMF is under way), the compressed time ethnographic
approach allowed the researcher collecting the data (this paper’s second author, Colleen) to
reap some of the benefits of traditional ethnography, in the sense of being able to immerse
herself in the phenomenon, to understand it from an experiential point of view, and (in some
instances) to bond with participants on the level in which they tended ordinarily to bond with
each other in the liminal context of the festival. These brief periods of intense participant-
observation were then supported by a broader and longer-term engagement with the
phenomenon through formal interviews with festival organizers outside the timeframe of
festival operations, analysis of documents pertinent to the festivals studied, and secondary
research regarding the larger contexts of the Christian music subculture and Christian youth
movements.
The fieldwork was conducted between 2010 and 2012 and was anchored by participant-
observation in the summer of 2011 at two important CYMFs in the United States: Lifest and
the Cornerstone Festival. Colleen spent a total of 11 days attending the two festivals,
camping on site, unobtrusively observing attendees, participating in various aspects of each
event, and conducting more than 30 informal interviews, ranging in length from 15 minutes to
two hours, with attendees, performers, staff, and volunteers. Observations and casual
interviews took place at campsites, music performances, retail markets, exhibitions, activities,
243
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
and seminars at each festival site. Participating in the same activities as the other festival
attendees facilitated a quick sense of trust and rapport between the researcher and the study
participants, although all participants were made aware that the researcher was attending the
festival for research purposes as well as to participate in the celebration of Christian music,
and that her goal in conducting informal interviews was to better understand the phenomenon
of CYMFs and the experiences of attendees and performers at these events. In keeping with
the inductive study design, the informal interviews were open-ended, allowing interviewees to
describe their experiences and to negotiate the meanings of those experiences within the
context of the interview conversation (Rubin and Rubin, 1995).
Interviews with festival organizers were more formal in nature and lasted between one and
two hours. In these interviews, Colleen sought to gain an understanding of each festival’s
history and of its organizers’ purpose in producing their respective event. She also sought to
understand the organizers’ perceptions regarding the effects of their festival on attendees and
the relationship of the festival to popular youth culture at large. An additional formal
interview was conducted with Andrew Beaujon, author of Body Piercing Saved My Life:
Inside the Phenomenon of Christian Rock (2006), an engaging book which offers a
journalistic snapshot of the unique subculture surrounding Christian rock. In his interview,
Beaujon was able to offer the perspective of an ―outsider‖ who had spent significant time
exploring Christian rock festivals, and this helped to complement Colleen’s more emic
perspective, as she has participated in the Christian youth music subculture for several years,
as well as the obviously emic perspectives of Lifest and Cornerstone attendees, organizers,
performers, and volunteers. Finally, the research included consideration of textual materials,
including the official Web sites of each festival and the organization behind it, event
programs, educational leaflets and advertisements found on site at the festivals, and Web
discussion boards for Christian music enthusiasts.
4. Christian Youth Music Festivals and the Evangelical Subculture
CYMFs must be understood not simply as desirable leisure opportunities pursued by
groups of like-minded young people, but as an integral part of a broader evangelical
subculture, with complex roots in both theology and American social and political history.
What is known today as evangelical Christianity can be traced back to Martin Luther and his
revolutionary stand against prevailing Christian doctrine and practice, in what history
remembers as the Protestant Reformation. Luther felt the Church had badly misconstrued
God’s message by coming to focus on a theology of works, in which one earned salvation
through actions (hence the idea of purchasing pardons for one’s misdeeds), rather than a
theology of grace, in which salvation depended simply on embracing Jesus Christ as the
messiah, whose crucifixion had redeemed humans from sin (Nichols, 2007). Luther
advocated a return to the gospels, or the ―good news‖ of Jesus Christ come as humanity’s
savior, and the word evangelical derives from the Greek expression for one who shares the
good news.
Evangelicalism thrived in North America, and by the nineteenth century, evangelical
Christians were an important part of the American political scene, championing such
progressive causes as abolition, women’s rights, and amelioration of urban poverty (Balmer,
2006). Evangelicals in that day generally favored a theological position known as
―postmillennialism,‖ one of the various ways of interpreting the colorful and cryptic passages
of the Bible, such as the Book of Revelation, that deal with the notion of the ―end times‖—
what, in theological terms, has become the branch of religious study known as eschatology.
In short, postmillennialism is the belief that Jesus will return after God’s kingdom has been
established on earth and humanity has experienced a 1000-year golden age of peace,
prosperity, and happy living in accord with Christian principles. As postmillennialists,
244
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
nineteenth-century evangelicals’ progressive political activism was thus logically aligned with
the project of bringing the kingdom of heaven into being on earth, a task they saw as the
responsibility of humanity to help initiate (Balmer, 2006).
But as the century wore on, things were not going as planned. American southerners were
not responsive to northern evangelicals’ calls for an end to slavery, and the Civil War, which
abolitionists thought would be a reasonably quick effort, due to the obvious moral superiority
of their anti-slavery position, instead deepened into a nearly half-decade struggle that tore the
nation apart (Balmer, 2010). At the same time, the American landscape was changing, as the
Industrial Revolution led to rapid urbanization, with its concomitant problems of poverty,
poor working conditions, and poor sanitation in cities. The immigrants who took up residence
in the burgeoning cities of the American North were a diverse lot, often of Catholic or Jewish
religious identification, and evangelicals felt their grip on the American socioscape slipping
away. As Balmer (2010) notes, such social conditions, in the eyes of nineteenth-century
evangelicals, hardly looked like the millennial kingdom come to earth. Evangelicals thus
needed a new eschatology—a new way of interpreting the Bible’s end times prophecies—that
better suited the verve of the times. They found this new interpretation in the dispensational
premillennialist theology of a former Anglican priest, John Nelson Darby (Weber, 1987).
Darby argued that all of human history could be divided into distinct ages, or ―dispensations,‖
with each era representing a different covenant between God and humanity. As Balmer
(2010, p. 34) explains, according to Darby, ―God had struck a particular deal, or covenant,
with Adam, for instance, and another with Noah and Abraham, and with the people of Israel.‖
Darby argued that humanity was living in the final dispensation and that Jesus would return at
any moment to fulfill God’s promise of taking his followers to heaven in the rapture, leaving
the rest of humanity behind to face the great tribulation, after which point the millennial
kingdom would be established (Balmer, 2010).
The idea that Jesus would return to earth before the 1000-year golden age, and that
humanity should expect things to get worse before they got better, easily made more sense to
the beleaguered social reformers of the Civil War era, who weren’t seeing much hope in
bringing about the millennial kingdom on their own. A consequence of this shift of theology,
however, was that it effectively absolved Christians of all responsibility for social activism
and improvement (Balmer, 2010).
By the beginning of the twentieth century, evangelicals had begun to feel that their values
were becoming in need of protection from what were then often articulated as ―modern‖
impulses within society at large (Marsden, 2006). Mainline Protestant denominations (e.g.,
Presbyterianism, Lutheranism) and their congregants were viewed as having sold out to these
forces of modernism, condoning such practices as dancing, drinking alcohol, embracing
immodest fashion trends, and consuming entertainment products that promoted lifestyle
elements of greed, materialism, sex outside of marriage, and so forth. To insulate themselves
and their children from such temptations, evangelical Christians constructed a rich subculture,
complete with its own schools, artistic products, and avenues of entertainment (Carpenter,
1997). They generally withdrew from politics, perceiving, in line with their premillennialist
views, that the world was hopelessly lost to sin and evil, and they instead focused fully on
living piously and converting others to the faith so that their souls would not be lost at the
coming of the rapture, when Jesus would lift his followers into the air, carrying them to
heaven to avoid the great tribulation before the golden age of the millennium would finally be
ushered in—a series of events felt by most people in the movement to be imminent.
Twentieth-century evangelicals’ distrust of mainstream culture did not stop the movement
from drawing on rhetorical forms from popular culture in order to engage followers,
especially youth. Evangelicalism had long had somewhat of a theatrical element to it, dating
245
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
even back to the open-air preaching of George Whitefield in the 1700s, which had all the
trappings of good dramatic oratory and spurred listeners to emotional responses. As the times
changed, evangelical leaders were not hesitant to employ new technologies and cultural
forms, such as televangelism programs, radio broadcastings, film, and the Internet, to promote
their message among their laity (Cobb, 1998; Erickson, 1992; Melton, Lucas and Stone, 1997;
Zaleski, 1997). At the same time, evangelicals needed a safe space from mainstream culture,
where they could raise their children in ways that minimalized contact with the values and
practices of the outside world, which they considered corrupting. Thus, an evangelical
subculture began to take form, existing in parallel with mainstream America and providing its
own ―Christian versions‖ of all things deemed essential to a twentieth-century life, including
leisure and entertainment options.
Christian entertainment products, such as music, films, and novels, thus served two
purposes simultaneously: through their rhetoric, they provided a call to Christianity that was
different from (and for young people, certainly more engaging than) the typical Sunday
sermon, and they also served as a rallying force for creating a sense of community and
cohesiveness among followers (Carpenter, 1997). This latter outcome was particularly
important for evangelical youth, who often faced a sense of alienation from their mainstream
peers, both because of their parents’ (or their own) choices to cordon them off from the
activities of their classmates and because of discrimination against them by some classmates
who viewed their beliefs and their separatist tendencies as strange. I recall many a friend
from my childhood, growing up in the American ―Bible belt,‖ who was not allowed to attend
the string of high school dances that served as bright spots for so many of us in the annual
academic calendar; their reactions to this fate ranged from annoyance, or even anger, at their
parents for ―being so out of touch,‖ to pride at exhibiting a proper Christian ―witness‖—a
popular term in the evangelical subculture, meaning testimony through behavior—by
steadfastly sacrificing these widely coveted social opportunities in the name of their faith.
It is against this backdrop of the construction of America’s evangelical subculture that the
phenomenon of the American Christian youth music festival was born. Christian rock
festivals provided youth with the opportunity to participate in the music festival experience—
a quintessential part of American teen cultural life—without having to leave the shelter of a
subculture supportive of their spiritual values. They also provided a venue for Christian
musicians to share their music, as these artists had generally found themselves shut out of the
mainstream music industry after the cultural upheavals of the 1960s (Dueck, 2000;
Thompson, 2000).
From there, however, the story becomes more complex. I have been speaking of
evangelical Christianity thus far as though it were some sort of perfectly coherent,
homogenous movement, which it is certainly not nor ever has been. From the beginning,
evangelicalism has had many strands, and this is nowhere more evident than in the current
ethnographic study, which examines two very different CYMFs, premised on two very
different ideologies, in terms of what it means to be a follower of Jesus in twenty-first-century
America.
The first CYMF considered here, Lifest (pronounced ―life fest‖), is a Christian music
festival held each July at a community exhibition grounds in Oshkosh, Wisconsin. The
festival began in 1990 as a walk-and-run fundraiser and evolved into a full-on festival,
featuring Christian music acts, in 1999. A five-day event, Lifest attracts an average of over
16,000 attendees on any given day of the festival, some of whom camp on-site and some of
whom drive in for the day to attend music shows and seminars. Most participants are youth
under the age of 18, and they typically attend the festival with their parents or with a church
youth group. Tourists to the event come from near and far; Colleen counted license plates
246
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
from 30 U.S. states and several Canadian provinces on the festival premises. Slogans for the
festival include ―Party with a Purpose,‖ ―More than Music,‖ and ―Where Kids Have the Time
of Their Life without Hiding from Their Parents‖ (Lifest, 2012). The 2011 Lifest event
attended by the researcher featured live Christian music acts, comedians, and speakers on
multiple stages, as well as seminars and workshops for youth pastors and leaders.
Lifest is run by Life Promotions, a nonprofit organization that produces faith-based
programs and events for churches and value-based programs for public schools in the United
States. The organization was founded in 1982 by Bob Lenz, a Christian speaker who still
serves as president today, and emphasizes the need to reach youth before the age of 18
through a focus on intervention and education to encourage positive life decision-making
(Life Promotions, 2012). Program topics include abstinence, cults, domestic discord, reverse
discrimination, alcohol, pornography, drug abuse, and so forth (Life Promotions, 2012).
Ideologically, Lifest is characterized by its affiliation with conservative evangelical
Christianity, which is the mainline form of evangelicalism in the United States today.
Followers of this movement hold the Bible to be the literal and inerrant word of God, which is
provided as a guide for how human beings should live their lives (although, in reality, this
literalism is practiced selectively, as Balmer (2006) demonstrates in his analysis of
evangelicalism and politics); they believe that Christians bear a responsibility to proselytize
and ―share the good news‖ of Jesus’ coming with nonbelievers; and they hold that acceptance
of Jesus as the messiah is the only path to salvation and a heavenly afterlife. This form of
Christianity is also often characterized by the experience of being ―born again,‖ meaning to
have had a conversion experience in which one comes to Jesus of his or her own volition and
accepts him as his or her personal savior and path to an eternal afterlife with God.
Conservative Christianity also tends to be characterized by its promotion of traditional social
values—such as heterosexual marriage and differential roles for men and women—which are
often viewed by its members as being under attack by mainstream culture.
Lifest’s enmeshment in conservative Christian culture was immediately apparent upon
setting foot in the festival grounds, with vendor booths on display addressing hot-button
social issues like abortion or offering attendees the opportunity to sponsor children in
developing countries or to learn about how they could engage in mission work. The latter
type of information was particularly ubiquitous, with most tents offering some sort of
promotional material for missionary involvement, thus illustrating the festival’s strong
evangelical moorings. Artists and speakers on stage would also frequently ask attendees to
―raise their hands and worship,‖ a common worshipping style associated particularly strongly
with the conservative branch of Christianity in America.
Essentially, Lifest exists to convert young people to Christianity, to help those who
already identify as Christian to strengthen their faith and their ties to the church, and to
provide a space in which Christian youth can experience elements akin to mainstream popular
culture that they will find attractive (e.g., loud music, edgy fashion) but in a protective setting
in which the ideological messages of these elements are tightly controlled. It is hoped that by
drawing on elements akin to popular culture, the festival organizers will able to communicate
with youth in ―a language they understand,‖ in order to deliver what is ultimately an
evangelical message, as well as other secondary associated messages about a safe and healthy
way to live their lives according to conservative Christian principles. Seminars for youth
leaders were advertised as helping these adults learn to ―capture the hearts of youth with
messages of hope,‖ as well as helping them to ―get a new perspective on youth culture, music,
and what it means to be relevant in an ever-changing world.‖ The testimonials from
festivalgoers published on Lifest’s official Web site (Lifest, 2012) go far in capturing the
essence of the festival’s purpose. As one parent expressed, ―My 9 year old son accepted Jesus
247
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
at Lifest 2011!‖ Another commented that attending Lifest ―is like giving your life to Jesus all
over again.‖ A third wrote, ―This year I brought my 16 year old nephew to Lifest with me,
praying that he would be moved enough to want to learn more. He not only wants to learn
more but on his own he decided to accept Jesus as his savior. As I saw him headed toward the
prayer tent, my eyes swelled up with tears.‖ As a final attendee stated, ―Sometimes God
speaks in a still, small, quiet voice; sometimes he speaks through amplified music. But He
always has a way of getting through.‖
The second festival considered here, Cornerstone, differed strikingly from Lifest in many
ways during its years of operation. Cornerstone has a long pedigree, dating back over a
quarter of a century to 1984, when it was founded by the Jesus People USA movement (or
JPUSA, pronounced ―japooza‖), a counterculture Christian group which sprung from the
hippie movements of the 1960s and 1970s. Jesus People (also sometimes called ―Jesus
Freaks‖) movements were commonly found throughout the United States in this era, but they
declined with the general collapse of the hippie subculture, and JPUSA currently refers
specifically to a particular group descended from this legacy, which remains active near
Chicago, living communally and sharing all goods and property. It is this group that
organized the Cornerstone Festival for 29 years until the event officially came to an end in
2012.
Cornerstone rose from the cornfields near Bushnell, Illinois, for six days each summer,
with most attendees camping on site and spending their days taking in music acts, seminars,
and art exhibits and workshops. The festival attracted predominantly young people, but there
was also a significant component of older attendees who returned to the festival year after
year, and this group was especially prevalent in 2011, as the organizers pushed for a
―reunion‖ theme in an attempt to shore up declining participation numbers, with festival
attendance having tanked from a height of 20,000 participants to fewer than 10,000 in recent
years. Like Lifest, Cornerstone drew event tourists from a wide geographic area; again,
license plates from most U.S. states were observed in 2011, and a significant Canadian
contingent managed to find one another to create an impromptu celebration of Canada Day
early on in the festival week.
Counterculture values were core to Cornerstone: the festival functioned to counter both
the mainstream world’s values of materialism and intense individualism and the socially
conservative values espoused by fundamentalist Christianity—especially the notion that the
arts and heavy music of the rock and metal genres are sinful. Indeed, the history of JPUSA is
one of individuals ―united in a general distrust not only of secular society but also of
mainstream religious institutions‖ (Johnston, 2011, citing Di Sabatino, 1999). Despite this
stance, JPUSA characterizes itself as aiming to work with other, more institutionalized
churches and organizations, while simultaneously describing itself as a haven for a dropout,
rejected generation. This commitment could be seen at the 2011 festival, which featured
formal worship sessions from various Christian traditions, including Eastern Orthodox and
Catholic. (Notably, this stands in marked contrast to Lifest, which has a strong conservative
Protestant bent despite festival organizers stating in an interview that the festival is meant to
be welcoming to people from all Christian denominations.)
JPUSA has garnered criticism, and sometimes even ridicule, from wider Christian and
secular circles for being too radical in its pursuit of communal living and too avant garde in
its artistic sensibilities, but this has not stopped the group from continuing to articulate its own
notion of Christianity, which is purposely resistant to more entrenched expressions of
Christian doctrine and practice. The group draws on Christian scripture to emphasize values
of creativity (Psalm 149:3; Psalm 33:3), distrust of bureaucratic and hierarchical structures
(Romans 13:3), freedom (Psalm 119:45; Isaiah 61:1; John 8:36; Acts 13:39; Romans 8:21; 2
248
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Corinthians 3:17; Galatians 5:1), pleasure (Ecclesiastes 8:15; 1 Timothy 6:18), direct and
honest contact among persons (2 Timothy 2:15; Romans 12:16; 1 Corinthians 1:10; 2
Corinthians 13:1), and the need to discard restrictions and inhibitions (2 Samuel 6:22;
Matthew 6:26). Its vision is perhaps best expressed in the interpretation set forth by John
Thompson (2000), a sympathetic author who has studied the history of the Christian
counterculture music scene extensively, of Christianity’s central figure, Jesus Christ:
Who was more rebellious than Jesus of Nazareth? He railed against authority, spoke
against personal and religious corruption, and took a stick and a whip to the temple. He healed
the sick on the Sabbath, and he encouraged people to walk away from their jobs, sell their
belongings, and give their money to the poor. He even refused to remain dead, according to
the account of the resurrection. He owned only the clothes on his back, and had no home of
his own, and got his tax money from the mouth of a fish. He was such a rebel that the
religious leaders had him executed. Find one rocker with even a tenth of that rebellious fire.
Yet Jesus has been reimagined in our postmodern world as a slow-moving, gentle, cryptic,
and painstakingly polite rabbi, not the ruffian whom the San Hedrin thought was so
dangerous. . . . From a certain perspective, Jesus and rock music are perfectly suited to each
other.
In keeping with the image they advance of Jesus as a rebellious and spunky philosopher
and servant who advocated equality among people and love of one’s neighbor, Cornerstone’s
organizers welcomed a variety of activists for progressive social causes to participate in the
festival each year, from speakers who offered workshops on healing race relations or
addressing urban homelessness to booths where attendees could collect information and sign
petitions for social change. Like Lifest, there were many booths featuring information on
missionary activities, but there was more of an emphasis placed on taking care of others in the
spirit of Jesus as a healer of the sick and an advocate for the poor than on evangelizing for the
sake of saving souls alone. And in keeping with the picture, described above, of Jesus as a
ruffian rebel, Cornerstone, from its outset, was open to performers whose controversial artistic
styles tended to leave them excluded from the mainstream CYMF circuit. In JPUSA’s view,
Christianity at is core demands counterculture values and forms of expression.
In 2012, Cornerstone closed its gates for the last time, with organizers citing the festival’s
inability to maintain financial viability in a poor economy. Given that most attendees drove
to the festival, often across long distances, it is perhaps not surprising that rising gas prices
and an ―employer’s economy,‖ in which taking time off from work can more easily result in
one’s job being given to somebody else, ultimately did the event in, especially given the low-
income status of a large proportion of its followers. It is also the case, as Cornerstone
organizers expressed in their interviews, that bands whose only refuge was once Cornerstone
are now finding more acceptance on the mainstream rock festival circuit, as popular culture
becomes more tolerant of overt expressions of Christian identity as long as the performer’s
goal is not overtly evangelical in nature. The festival’s refusal to compromise its principles
and seek sponsors who offer donations based on the number of ―souls saved‖ by the event—a
tactic pursued by many other CYMFs—may also explain why it was hit harder by the
recession than other programs (Johnston, 2011). Finally, Cornerstone’s closing may be due in
some part to the simple vagaries of the life courses of key individuals involved in its
production, as the festival’s longtime director moved on after the 2011 event, and follow-up
contacts by Colleen revealed that several other festival organizers were in the process of
leaving the JPUSA commune to transition into other life projects.
The Cornerstone Festival was clearly a product of evangelical Christianity, and its
founders and followers embraced many of the same core beliefs as those who gravitate toward
Lifest: a belief in Jesus Christ as the path to salvation, a view of the Bible as the word of God
249
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
and the guide for a Christian life, and a firmness in the responsibility to live one’s life as a
testament to Christ. Indeed the experience of being born again is common to Cornerstone
attendees, and Johnston (2011), in his ethnographic study of the festival in 2008, reports the
experience of a group of his research participants ―praying over him,‖ a common evangelical
practice in which a person who is struggling with his or her faith is surrounded by believers,
who offer a prayer that the person will be able to successfully connect with Jesus and feel
Christ’s power working in his or her life. At the same time, however, Cornerstone’s
organizers and attendees tend not to adhere to certain aspects of religious and social belief and
practice associated with conservative evangelicalism, such as a skepticism toward Christians
who are not conservative Protestants as not really being true followers of Jesus, an adherence
to traditional social views, or a literal reading of passages in the Bible that marginalize
women or gays and lesbians. Instead, they constitute themselves as rebelling against mainline
evangelicalism and bringing their faith back in line with the example of Jesus as a social
activist who exemplified a life of putting others first and embracing those on the margins of
society. Although their social views may be reminiscent of evangelicalism’s nineteenth-
century roots in the championing of progressive causes, there is no evidence that this group
has shifted its thinking, theologically, back to the kind of postmillennialism that characterized
their forebears, or that still characterizes mainline Protestant Christianity. Instead, they are
truly a breakaway movement within a breakaway movement—a subculture within a
subculture—whose views and practices stand as a testament to a long journey of
contingencies that led them first away from mainstream American culture and then away from
mainstream evangelicalism.
Cornerstone and Lifest are thus very different manifestations of the CYMF phenomenon.
As such, they illustrate the complexity of the evangelical subculture and its constitution
through leisure and tourism practices. I now turn to a discussion of the role of these festivals
in shoring up different notions of Christian identity and the implications of such constructions
of Christian identity for the creation of conditions conducive to nurturing positive peace in
American society and beyond.
5. Christian Music Festivals, the Evangelical Subculture, and American Politics:
Implications for Positive Peace
Growing up in the United States in the last quarter of the twentieth century, I lived
through an era, still ongoing, of ―bumper sticker wars,‖ in which the pulse of the American
religio-political scene could be read with little effort, as part of the standard workaday
commute. ―God Made Adam and Eve, Not Adam and Steve!‖ one car would crow, in a
condemnation against homosexuality. ―Hate Is Not a Family Value,‖ another car would
retort. A particularly popular choice during my teen years read ―In Case of Rapture, This
Vehicle Will Be Unmanned,‖ implying that the driver would have ascended into heaven,
leaving his hapless vehicle abandoned on the road. In this case, the response from some non-
evangelicals was ―When the Rapture Comes, Can I Have Your Car?‖—or sometimes the
more pointed political response, ―When Will the Rapture Take All the Republicans Away?‖
The clever ―As Long as There Are Tests, There Will Be Prayer in Public Schools,‖ received
the tart response, ―Don’t Pray in My School, and I Won’t Think in Your Church.‖
Such proclamations of automotive self-expression can no doubt represent the extreme,
hyperbolic ends of the spectrum, in terms of serving as a gauge on public opinion.
Nevertheless, no close observer of American politics in recent decades could easily miss what
has been an emerging imbrication of evangelical Christianity with right wing politics.
Although people rarely stop to think about it, American evangelicalism’s current level of
political involvement is curious, given the movement’s longstanding shyness toward the
political realm, in line with its premillennialist orientation that the earth is lost and doomed,
250
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
and that a Christian life is best served by turning inward and focusing on one’s salvation and
the afterlife. In having chosen to re-involve itself in the political sphere, evangelicalism’s
close relationship with the contemporary Republican Party is perhaps even more curious,
given the movement’s much more left wing stance during America’s key nation-building era
of the 1800s. Popular understanding holds that this relationship was born in response to the
Roe v. Wade decision of 1973, legalizing abortion in the United States, a judicial action that
supposedly caused the evangelical community to erupt in subsequent protest. Balmer (2006)
debunks this myth, however, noting that evangelicals were not immediately galvanized by this
issue; indeed, key movement leaders even issued statements supporting the Court’s decision
on abortion rights. Instead, the key political issue centered around taxation status for religious
schools, which were being forced to abandon racially based admissions policies if they
wished to continue to qualify as charitable organizations under the U.S. tax code, as a result of
a very different court decision, this time at the district level: Green v. Connally. As Balmer
(2006) argues, the issue hinged not so much on the desire of evangelicals to pursue an agenda
of racial segregation per se, but on the larger problem it represented: that of perceived
government interference in religious practice (albeit simply through the withdrawal of
favorable tax terms to religious schools deemed to be prima facie not humanitarian in nature,
based on their embracing of racial segregation). Thus, evangelicals reentered the political
scene in an organized way not because there had necessarily been any shift in their
eschatology reinvigorating them to become involved in ameliorating the problems of the
world, but quite simply because they felt their subculture—their safe place in a ruinous world
not long for existence—was under attack.
It would be a gross exaggeration to say that all American evangelical Christians are
strongly political or that, of those who are, all identify with the right wing. Nevertheless, a
strong alliance exists between the evangelical movement and the Republican Party, and
studies from numerous disciplines have documented American evangelicals’ propensity to
align themselves with the domestic social and foreign policy agendas of leaders to the right on
the political spectrum (Thumma, 1991; Jelen, 1994; Hunsberger and Jackson, 2005;
Baumgartner, Francia, and Morris, 2008). Such issues include, perhaps most prominently,
opposition to abortion rights, opposition to gay rights and especially marriage equality,
support for the state of Israel, and a hawkish approach to American foreign policy in the
Middle East.
This alliance was, in many ways, deliberately forged by an invisible hand of political
maneuvers in the 1970s, when conservative activist Paul Weyrich, who had been trying to
galvanize evangelicals as a potential voting block for years, finally succeeded in recruiting
movement leaders James Dobson and Jerry Falwell to his cause in the wake of the Green
decision and Bob Jones University’s unsuccessful attempt thereafter to sue the federal
government to maintain both its tax-exempt status and its operating policies, which prohibited
interracial dating among its students. Convincing evangelical leaders that involvement in the
political process was their best route to defending their beleaguered subculture and that the
Republican Party was best suited to serve their needs and enshrine their values in public
policy, Weyrich won key evangelical figures for his conservative movement, a process which
involved no little chicanery, as Weyrich was able to successfully pin the Bob Jones situation
on Jimmy Carter (himself a card-carrying evangelical!) and the Democratic Party, despite that
Carter was actually not yet president when that event occurred (Balmer, 2006). Once an
alliance had been born, leaders worked to create a more full and robust platform that would
compel evangelical voters. They also worked to consolidate their political voice through the
creation of organizations like the Moral Majority, a group which sought to unite evangelicals
with other types of religious adherents, including conservative Catholics and Jews, in the
251
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
quest to advance ―traditional values‖ in the American public sphere, and the Christian
Coalition, unsuccessful 1988 presidential candidate Pat Robertson’s organization to unite
various branches of conservative Christianity and mobilize them against perceived attacks on
―family values,‖ which in practice tended to result primarily in activism against abortion and
gay rights. Thus, although not all evangelicals are overtly political, and although dissent is
certainly evident, conservative politics have become very much embedded in the evangelical
subculture, a fact evident in any glance at American voting patterns.
As spaces in which American evangelical culture is nurtured, consolidated, and
transmitted to the next generation, then, mainstream evangelical CYMFs like Lifest can, on
some level, serve as a force for the perpetuation of right wing ideologies and conservative
political convictions among youth. Although festival organizers may not see themselves as
promoting political messages, just as Belhassen’s (2009) study participants who led groups of
religious tourists on evangelical pilgrimages to Israel did not view their activities as political,
such implications are nevertheless present. In their motivational speaking sessions, Life
Promotions speakers do not actively promote the Christian Right’s agenda, and in fact often
encourage criticism of this movement’s approach in subtle ways. They caution youth, for
instance, against taking a ―morality-based‖ approach to Christianity, or one which focuses on
following the right behavioral codes or coming down on the right side of political debates
instead of on enhancing one’s relationship with Jesus. However, they say nothing to
challenge interpretations of scripture that lead to negative attitudes toward sexual minorities
or followers of other religious traditions. Similarly, they speak of loving those who are
―different‖ from oneself, but the categories of difference enumerated tend to be racial
minorities, the elderly, the disabled, and the poor, or perhaps social categories, like ―nerds‖ or
other types of kids who are low on the social hierarchy in teenage contexts. Notably absent is
the overt mention of a need to exhibit love and tolerance toward sexual minorities, such as
gays or lesbians, or members of other religious traditions, such as Muslims. Listeners have to
be able to make that extrapolation in their own minds—and there’s no real reason to believe
they do, especially given the negative messages they may hear about these groups at home,
from their local or national evangelical leaders, or in the Christian media. Evangelical
prejudice against sexual minorities and religious out-groups continues to be well documented
in the psychology literature (Hunsberger and Jackson, 2005), and events that socialize youth
into the evangelical subculture without challenging these prejudices perpetuate them—
intentionally or not.
Meanwhile, the social pressures to fit in with one’s peers on the Christian social scene can
be enormous. I recall well from my own adolescence the sincere pain and fear that
characterized the teen years of some of my close friends, as they struggled to achieve the
experience of faith that was expected of them by their parents and friends at church. One
friend, who was extremely gifted musically, repeatedly threw away all the cassette tapes in
her collection that did not fall into the Christian music genre, backsliding each time into an
interest in popular music only to eventually renew her religious commitment and purge her
cassette box again. At the time, I found her actions a bit silly, and I remember thinking that
she was wasting an awful lot of money buying music that she was just going to throw away
after her next conversion experience. As an adult, I am able to much more sympathetically
recognize the genuine torment that characterized her actions, as she struggled to live what her
parents, pastor, and youth group were defining for her as a Christian lifestyle, hoping that her
choice to forego the influence of secular music would help her to more fully experience
Christ’s presence in her life and to live up the expectations of herself and others, regarding
what it should ―feel like‖ to be a Christian.
252
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
CYMFs like Lifest therefore have complex implications for the building of positive peace.
On one hand, they provide a safe space for Christian youth who may feel alienated from
mainstream society, allowing them to feel a sense of inclusion and worth as part of a
community, while being able to experience some of the trappings of mainstream adolescence,
such as rock-and-roll music and current fashion trends. At the same time, however, the
evangelical youth leisure subculture may make it difficult for teens to explore other aspects of
their identity beyond religion, and the Christian youth scene may also be quite coercive in
terms of scripting a single normative path to a young person’s experience of Christian faith.
Perhaps more importantly, from a sociological point of view, this subculture may insulate
young people from those who are different from them, especially in terms of sexuality or
religious persuasion, and it may perpetuate prejudice through the advancement of particular
doctrinal orientations that discourage tolerance and equal rights.
The Cornerstone Festival can, in many ways, be read specifically as an act of resistance
against this outcome. Cornerstone’s organizers see themselves as rebels, both against a
mainstream society characterized by materialism and greed and a mainstream evangelical
subculture characterized by narrow-mindedness and a failure to focus on the actual teachings
of Jesus. They feel that conservative evangelicalism has failed to uphold its commitment to
care and advocacy for those who are disadvantaged in society—those the Bible terms ―the
least of these‖—for whom Jesus’ followers, mirroring his example, are supposed to take
responsibility for looking after. In essence, they perceive mainstream evangelicalism as
having defaulted on Jesus’ legacy. They thus tend to champion causes that would be
generally associated with progressive, leftist politics in the United States: inclusiveness, equal
rights, poverty alleviation, environmental protection, and so forth. The festival thus served as
a space of comfort and support for individuals who feel alienated from mainstream society
and mainstream evangelicalism, and attendees frequently expressed to Colleen that they lived
for this event each year, relying on it for spiritual sustenance and community. It also,
however, served to advance an alternative construction of Christianity and Christian identity,
thus opening a potentially different path for young people who felt drawn to Christianity but
also to types of social reform that might be frowned upon by their more conservative leaders,
parents, or peers.
CYMFs can thus be seen as flashpoints for the experience and expression of different
ways of Christian being. Some festivals tend to buttress the status quo, supporting the
maintenance of a conservative evangelical subculture that tends to thwart the building of
positive peace in U.S. society, through its support of a right wing power structure that seeks to
deny gay rights, cut assistance to disadvantaged members of society, and prevent wealth
redistribution through taxation structures that favor the rich. Others, like Cornerstone, resist
the alliance between evangelicalism and the Republican Party and provide attendees with
educational opportunities, such as workshops and art features, which spur discussion of the
Bible’s complexities and offer information on how to get involved in social activism projects
that reduce poverty and promote inclusiveness. The fact that Cornerstone has now closed its
gates, while events like Lifest are going as strong as ever, may lead one to take a rather
pessimistic view regarding which of these versions of the evangelical subculture will prevail
in the future. Only time will tell.
6. Conclusion
Haessly (2010, p. 5) conceptualizes peace as a state in which ―human beings can achieve
their true potential while caring for themselves, each other and all of creation.‖ Prejudice
against those outside one’s social group is a barrier to actualizing such a vision. So is feeling
alienated because of one’s spiritual beliefs. CYMFs create a safe space for youth to
experience popular culture forms of entertainment and to bond with their fellow Christian
253
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
peers. As such, they offer a space of teenage normalcy and of solidarity, important features in
helping youth to build and maintain self-esteem, an essential feature for realizing peace in the
lives of young individuals during the turbulent teenage years, when a lack of inner peace can
easily turn tragic. In their insulation of youth and maintenance of a rather closed evangelical
subculture, however, CYMFs perpetuate conditions that can interfere with positive peace-
building, both by failing to challenge right wing ideology within the evangelical movement
and by failing to promote engagement of youth with peers outside their religious circle, which
could help to build bridges between evangelicals and members of groups traditionally targeted
by prejudice. CYMFs with alternative ideologies and practices have been forged, as
exemplified by Cornerstone, but they lack the structural support of the mainstream
evangelical community (e.g., corporate sponsorships), and thus are more difficult to maintain.
It therefore remains to be seen whether alternative forms of leisure and tourism practice,
which challenge ideologies that militate against the building of positive peace, will continue
to arise and maintain a foothold in the evangelical community. One thing is certain, however:
the evangelical movement’s importance in U.S. politics, and the concomitant significance of
the American people’s political choices on the world stage, will ensure that this subculture’s
leisure and tourism practices will remain a phenomenon to be closely watched by researchers
interested in the connections between religion, tourism, and peace.
References
Ateljevic, I., Morgan, N., and Pritchard, A. (eds.) (2012). The Critical Turn in Tourism
Studies: Creating an Academy of Hope. London: Routledge.
Ateljevic, I., Pritchard, A., and Morgan, N. (eds.) (2007). The Critical Turn in Tourism
Studies: Innovative Research Methodologies. Oxford: Elsevier.
Balmer, R. (2006). Thy Kindgom Come: An Evangelical’s Lament. New York: Basic Books.
Balmer, R. (2010). The Making of Evangelicalism: From Revivalism to Politics and Beyond.
Waco, TX: Baylor University Press.
Banet-Weiser, S. (1999). The Most Beautiful Girl in the World: Beauty Pageants and
National Identity. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Baumgartner, J., Francia, P., and Morris, J. (2008). A Clash of Civilizations? The Influence of
Religion on Public Opinion of U.S. Foreign Policy in the Middle East. Political Research
Quarterly, 61, pp. 171–179.
Beaujon, A. (2006). Body Piercing Saved My Life: Inside the Phenomenon of Christian Rock.
Cambridge, MA: De Capo Books.
Belhassen, Y. (2009). Fundamentalist Christian Pilgrimages as a Political and Cultural Force.
Journal of Heritage Tourism, 4, pp. 131–144.
Belhassen, Y., Caton, K., and Stewart, W. (2008). The Search for Authenticity in the Pilgrim
Experience. Annals of Tourism Research, 35, pp. 668-689.
Belhassen, Y., and Ebel, J. (2009). Tourism, Faith and Politics in the Holy Land: An
Ideological Analysis of Evangelical Pilgrimage. Current Issues in Tourism, 12, pp. 359–378.
Belhassen, Y., and Santos, C. (2006). An American Evangelical Pilgrimage to Israel: A Case
Study on Politics and Triangulation. Journal of Travel Research, 44, pp. 431–441.
Bowman, G. (2000). Christian Ideology and the Image of a Holy Land. In J. Eade and M.
Sallnow (eds.) Contesting the Sacred: The Anthropology of Christian Pilgrimage. London:
Routledge, pp. 98–121.
254
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Brock-Utne, B. (1989). Feminist Perspectives on Peace and Peace Education. New York:
Pergamon Press.
Bujisic, M. (2011). Social Implications and Possibilities of Post-War Tourism in Iraq: When
Former Enemy becomes a Tourist. Journal of Tourism and Peace Research, 2(2), pp. 16–31.
Carpenter, J. (1997). Revive Us Again: The Reawakening of American Fundamentalism. New
York: Oxford University Press.
Caton, K. (2011). Pedagogy and the Other: Discursive Production in Study Abroad. Journal
of Tourism and Peace Research, 2(2), pp. 1–15.
Causevic, S., and Lynch, P. (2011). Phoenix Tourism: Post-Conflict Tourism Role. Annals of
Tourism Research, 38, pp. 780–800.
Cobb, J. (1998). Cybergrace: The Search for God in the Digital World. New York: Crown.
Cohen, E. (1979). A Phenomenology of Tourist Experiences. Sociology, 13, pp. 179–201.
Cohen, C. (1998). ―This Is de Test‖: Festival and the Cultural Politics of Nation Building in
the British Virgin Islands. American Ethnologist, 25, pp. 189–214.
Collins-Kreiner, N. (2010). Researching Pilgrimage: Continuity and Transformations. Annals
of Tourism Research, 37, pp. 440–456.
d’Amore, L. (1988). Tourism—A Vital Force for Peace. Tourism Management, 9, 151–154.
Davila, A. (1997). Sponsored Identities: Cultural Politics in Puerto Rico. Philadelphia:
Temple University Press.
Di Sabatino, D. (1999). The Jesus People Movement: An Annotated Bibliography and
General Resource. Lake Forest, CA: Jester Media.
Digance, J. (2006). Religious and Secular Pilgrimage: Journeys Redolent with Meaning. In D.
Timothy and D. Olsen (eds.) Tourism, Religion and Spiritual Journeys. Oxon, UK:
Routledge, pp. 36–48.
Dueck, J. (2000). Crossing the Street: Velour 100 and Christian Rock. Popular Music and
Society, 22, pp. 127–148.
Echtner, C., and Prasad, P. (2003). The Context of Third World Tourism Marketing. Annals
of Tourism Research, 30, pp. 660–682.
Erickson, H. (1992). Religious Radio and Television in the United States, 1921–1991.
Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
Gomez-Lobo, A. (1997). The Olympics in the Ancient World. Estudios Publicos, 65.
Haessly, J. (2010). Tourism and a Culture of Peace. In O. Moufakkir and I. Kelly (eds.)
Tourism, Progress and Peace. Oxfordshire, UK: CABI, pp. 1–16.
Hammersley, M. (2006). Ethnography: Problems and Prospects. Ethnography and Education,
1, pp. 3–14.
Higgins-Desbiolles, F. (2003). Reconciliation Tourism: Healing Divided Societies! Tourism
Recreation Research, 28, pp. 35–44.
Higgins-Desbiolles, F., and Blanchard, L. (2010). Challenging Peace through Tourism:
Placing Tourism in the Context of Human Rights, Justice and Peace. In O. Moufakkir and I.
Kelly (eds.) Tourism, Progress and Peace. Oxfordshire, UK: CABI, pp. 35–47.
255
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Hill, M. (2008). Inca of the Blood, Inca of the Soul: Embodiment, Emotion, and Racialization
in the Peruvian Mystical Tourist Industry. Journal of the American Academy of Religion, 76,
251–279.
Hunsberger, B., and Jackson, L. (2005). Religion, Meaning, and Prejudice. Journal of Social
Issues, 61, 807–826.
Jeffrey, B., and Troman, G. (2004). Time for Ethnography. British Educational Research
Journal, 30, pp. 535–548.
Jelen, T. (1994). Religion and Foreign Policy Attitudes: Exploring the Effects of
Denomination and Doctrine. American Politics Quarterly, 22, 382–400.
Jeong, S., and Santos, C. (2004). Cultural Politics and Contested Place Identity. Annals of
Tourism Research, 31, pp. 640–656.
Johnston, B. (2011). Constructing Alternative Christian Identity: An Ethnography of Jesus
People USA’s Cornerstone Festival. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of South
Florida.
Lifest. (2012). http://lifest.com [accessed January 14, 2013].
Life Promotions. (2012). http://www.lifepromotions.com [accessed January 14, 2013].
Maoz, D. (2010). Warming Up Peace: An Encounter between Egyptian Hosts and Israeli
Guests in Sinai. In O. Moufakkir and I. Kelly (eds.) Tourism, Progress and Peace.
Oxfordshire, UK: CABI, pp. 65–82.
Macquarrie, J. (1973). The Concept of Peace. San Francisco: Harper and Row.
Marsden, G. (2006). Fundamentalism and American Culture. New York: Oxford University
Press.
Melton, J., Lucas, P., and Stone, J. (1997). Prime-Time Religion: An Encyclopedia of
Religious Broadcasting. Phoenix, AZ: Oryx.
Moufakkir, O. (2010). Re-evaluating Political Tourism in the Holy Land: Towards a
Conceptualization of Peace Tourism. In O. Moufakkir and I. Kelly (eds.) Tourism, Progress
and Peace. Oxfordshire, UK: CABI, pp. 162–178.
Moufakkir, O., and Kelly, I (eds.). (2010). Tourism, Progress and Peace. Oxfordshire, UK:
CABI.
Mullaney, S. (1983). Strange Things, Gross Terms, Curious Customs: The Rehearsal of
Cultures in the Late Renaissance. Representations, 3, pp. 40–67.
Nichols, S. (2007). The Reformation: How and Monk and a Mallet Changed the World.
Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books.
Nolan, M., and Nolan, S. (1992). Religious Sites as Tourism Attractions in Europe. Annals of
Tourism Research, 19, pp. 68–78.
Nussbaum, M. (2011). Creating Capabilities: The Human Development Approach.
Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press.
Pernecky, T., and Johnston, C. (2006). Voyage through Numinous Space: Applying the
Specialization Concept to New Age Tourism. Tourism Recreation Research, 31, pp. 37–46.
Pernecky, T. (2010). The Being of Tourism. Journal of Tourism and Peace Research, 1(1),
pp. 1–15.
256
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Rubin, H., and Rubin, I. (1995). Qualitative Interviewing: The Art of Hearing Data, 2nd
Edition. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Schulenkorf, N., and Edwards, D. (2010). The Role of Sport Events in Peace Tourism. In O.
Moufakkir and I. Kelly (eds.) Tourism, Progress and Peace. Oxfordshire, UK: CABI, pp. 99–
117.
Schultze, Q. (2002). Touched by Angels and Demons: Religion’s Love–Hate Relationship
with Popular Culture. In D. Stout and J. Buddenbaum (eds.) Religion and Popular Culture:
Studies on the Interaction of Worldviews. Ames: Iowa State University Press, pp. 39–48.
Shackley, M. (2006). Empty Bottles at Sacred Sites: Religious Retailing at Ireland’s National
Shrine. In D. Timothy and D. Olsen (eds.) Tourism, Religion and Spiritual Journeys. Oxon,
UK: Routledge, pp. 94–103.
Sharpley, R. (2009). Tourism, Religion and Spirituality. In T. Jamal and M. Robinson (eds.)
The Sage Handbook of Tourism Studies. London: Sage, pp. 237–253.
Sizer, S. (1999). The Ethical Challenges of Managing Pilgrimages to the Hold Land.
International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 11, pp. 85–90.
Sofield, T., and Li, F. (1998). Tourism Development and Cultural Policies in China. Annals of
Tourism Research, 25, pp. 362–392.
Thompson, J. (2000). Raised by Wolves: The Story of Christian Rock and Roll. Toronto: ECW
Press.
Timothy, D., and Conover, P. (2006). Nature Religion, Self-Spirituality, and New Age
Tourism. In D. Timothy and D. Olsen (eds.) Tourism, Religion and Spiritual Journeys. Oxon,
UK: Routledge, pp.139–155.
Thumma, S. (1991). Negotiating a Religious Identity: The Case of the Gay Evangelical.
Sociology of Religion, 52, pp. 333–347.
Tomljenovic, R. (2010). Tourism and Intercultural Understanding or Contact Hypothesis
Revisited. In O. Moufakkir and I. Kelly (eds.) Tourism, Progress and Peace. Oxfordshire,
UK: CABI, pp. 17–34.
Uriely, N., Maoz, D., and Reichel, A. (2009). Israeli Guests and Egyptian Hosts in the Sinai:
A Bubble of Serenity. Journal of Travel Research, 47, pp. 508–522.
Vukonic, B. (1992). Medjugorje’s Religion and Tourism Connection. Annals of Tourism
Research, 19, pp. 79–91.
Vukonic, B. (1996). Tourism and Religion. Oxford: Elsevier.
Wallensteen, P. (ed.) (1988). Peace Research: Achievements and Challenges of the Past
Twenty-
Five Years: 1963–1988. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Weber, T. (1987). Living in the Shadow of the Second Coming: American Premillennialism,
1875–1982. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Xu, X. (2006). Modernizing China in the Olympic Spotlight: China’s National Identity and
the 2008 Beijing Olympiad. The Sociological Review, 54, pp. 90–107.
Zaleski, J. (1997). The Soul of Cyberspace: How New Technology Is Changing Our Spiritual
Lives. San Francisco: Harper Edge.
257
Recreational and the Geotourism Value Estimated Babek Castle Using
Conditional Valuation Method
Fariba Ayase, Mohammad Hosein Fathi, Adel Mohammadi Far,
Mina Farokhi Someh
1
M.A in Geomorphology, Tabriz University, Iran
2
Phd student of Geomorphology, Ardebil University, Iran
Mail to:Hossein.mousavi047@gmail.Com
3
M.A in of geography and urban planning, Tabriz University, Iran
4
Phd student of geography and urban planning, Tabriz University, Iran
Abstract
Babak Castle 60 kilometers north of the city of Ahar and 5 kilometers from the city West
nomads between deep and dense forests are located. This castle due to special status position
among beautiful forests and beautiful nature area Arasbaran the one hand and due to Join old
and ancient, tourist areas and Geotourism is important to our country. Therefore, it can study
the tourist value in forecasting needs, and deficiency is effective regional tourism
development. Especially prone to the region Ecotourism and Geotourism investment due to
nature is pristine and beautiful. The purpose of this study to estimate recreational and
economic value of this historic castle using Rate is conditional. Factors affecting the amount
of people willing to pay the Logit model are used. Data through the use of questionnaires and
interviews with 150 visitors from these regions were collected. The results showed that up to
90% visitors pay for the present and recreation visits are mentioned in the education and
income variables, number of family members, gender and Offer the possibility of significant
willingness to pay of their age, but variable in terms of was not statistically significant.
Average willingness to pay USD 985 people and annual economic and recreational value of
this castle 246,250,000 tomans respectively. Research has been done to the satisfaction of
tourists in this region Geotourism evaluated and a suggestion for ptimal use of existing
capabilities and facilities in the region is based on.
Keywords: value promenade, long Rate, pattern Logit, Babak Castle, Geotourism.
Introduction:
The tourism as a fledgling industry in recent years a large impact on the economic
situation, social and cultural world. Creating jobs, foreign exchange revenues, regional
stability, contributing to world peace, helping to invest in cultural heritage, improving the
environment, development of rural areas the tourism attractions and prevent out-nomadic
population, and as such has been the industry's benefits.(Sadre Mousavi and
fellow,2005,pp129-143). In addition creating a healthy and productive society for sustainable
economic progress and development in need of the development and maintenance leisure
places or tourism areas to response has to the a growing demand of people. Analysis of factors
influencing people's need from point of view economic and social can be to substantial
assistance predict the needs and eliminate shortages the tourism areas. Including these factors,
value that people are expressed the stated sums willing to pay. One of the standard ways,
flexible and applied in research to measure the willingness to pay and recreational values and
existence of environmental resources is conditional valuation method. Many researchers have
investigated amount of benefits derived from visiting recreation areas and the geotourism uses
contingent valuation method that their studies can be an important step towards a correct
understanding the benefits of investment in the tourism sector in the country. Including
research can be noted the following: Recreational and economic value of the average of five
national parks in South Korea 10/54 dollars per family per year gained (Han, Lee, 2002).
259
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Value of wilderness areas in Iceland 243/16 euro earned in the year (Mc millan, Leinhoop,
2007). Economic and recreational value of the annual leopard valley region of Qom based on
travel grant 83,395 rials per hectare achieved ( 2000,Mirzaee ). To investigate the role of geo
tourism in development the South East one part of Spain has And to the conclusion has
achieved that the attention and investment in geo tourism sector, attract tourists to the area
and the fullness income for residents is provided (Thomas ,hos, 2007). To assess the
economic impacts of tourism attractions in the periphery of rural areas and its role in the
economic development of this areas is discussed (Bebenk, 2006). To assess the economic
value of recreational Ali Sadr Cave and several other attractions geo tourism contingent
valuation method and willingness to pay 4,520 rials per person is estimated (Soraghi, 2007).
The other hand due to nature-oriented tourism (ecotourism and geo tourism) is now at the
head of Planning so that several Asian countries including China to attract tourists to the
tourist attractions and nature guides, has been able to increase several times their foreign
exchange revenues. Our country also having very high potential for tourism and nature guides
is likely great economic investment in this sector that can provide many foreign exchange
revenues for the country. Including tourism regions Babak Castle in East Azerbaijan
province's, due to the specific location among beautiful forests Arasbaran, the beautiful and
untouched nature, mineral waters, beautiful Aras River in surroundings on the one hand and
due to ancient of history the other hand country is one of the main tourist areas that every
year climbers and domestic and foreign tourists many are attracted. It should be noted that
well known Babak Castle before to be names goat, president and girl Castle (Rostamzadeh,
2004, 22). According to the latest statistics provided by the province tourism organization
around 250,000 people a year visit the area. So in this study an attempt has been made to the
factors affecting the amount willingness to pay of visitors to this historic castle and economic
and recreational value estimation of are examined to contingent valuation method.
Location and natural features of the region
Babak Castle, 60 kilometers north of the city of Ahar and in 5 km West the city of
Kaleibar among the dense forests is located. Babak Castle is located in region that is part of
the mountainous masses Arasbaran. This Mountainous mass is at the highest latitude of Iran
and south of Aras River Which forms the of Iran northern border with the countries
Azerbaijan and Armenia. This Mountainous mass is of main strings Azerbaijan which located
in between the three main volcanoes Ararat, Sahand, Sabalan and active tectonics in come the
form of a set of complex and much of its limestone rocks and igneous rocks formed and tufit,
marl, shale and conglomerate are also seen. This collection was belongs to senozoeic periods
and have emerged effect Alpine orogenic severe movements. This historic castle is located at
an altitude of 2300 to 2700 meters above sea level and due to volcanic activity and the active
tectonic own in the range have elevated peaks with very steep slopes (generally over 2500 m)
and deep valleys, 400 to 600 meters. Often is region of soils of the type calcareous and brown
soils. Placed in the path fronts of humid Mediterranean climate and Siberian has caused for
winter precipitations as snow in the highlands accumulated In spring and summer, small
rivers but permanent to feed that most them in direction north on the move and Pours to Aras
river. In addition slopes proper nutrition, lead to have been great springs genesis and has
created forest environment and various and picturesque landscapes wildlife. Arasbaran the
region is also affected Mediterranean climates is the eclipse Caspian and ghafghaz climates
and due to the large difference in height, has a variety of weather and climates. The number of
foggy days was in this the high range and in altitude, due to accumulation of fog and clouds
and cold weather, high dew is produced. Monthly maximum relative humidity is 85% in June.
Average annual of temperature at various locations have extreme changes such that this
difference is 12 °C. In the lower areas, is the mean annual of temperature 17 °C and at
260
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
altitudes, 12 °C. Climatic conditions in this region based on the Domarten method, are semi-
humid temperate summers cool. Existence many historic castles in the area, including the
historic castle of Babak, has added to its attractions.
Materials and Methods:
In this study to estimate value of recreation and geo tourism Babak Castle was used
contingent valuation method and and data needed through completing the questionnaires
designed with visiting of visitors the castle Babak that had an independent income were
collected in the summer of 1388. The questionnaires were designed in two parts. The first
section information about the personal, social and economic characteristics, the individual's
response and in the second part of the questions was raised about the willingness to pay. In
these Section three proposed price amounts 30000 and 50000 and 70000 Rials for dependent
and interrelated questions were designed. This Suggested quantities were chosen based on a
pretest. The sample included 150 subjects using Cochran formula and data from 25
questionnaires were obtained pre-tested. Sampling method using is simple random sampling.
In this study to measure the amount the willingness to pay of visitors dichotomous choice
questionnaires two dimensional by Haneman and Carson (1985) was used modified and
adjusted. this method tries that willingness to pay (WTP) of individuals under certain
hypothetical market scenarios, to determine and is requires determine and selection of a
higher initial offer that is give further propose to answer "Yes" and offer less to answer "No".
The selection method twofold assumed to be individuals are desirability function following
(Amirnejad, et al, 2006,PP 665-675).
Which indirect utility function U, individual income y and S vector of is from other
economic and social factors. Each visitor is present to pay the amount from your income as
suggested amount (A) for recreational use or the environmental sources that the use caused of
create favorable for him be. Favorable rates caused by the use of environmental resources
than state that he does not use environmental sources that following equation shows it
(Haneman, 1984, pp 332-341).
In this formulas are are random variables with zero mean that are distributed
randomly and independently of each other. Make a difference in the desirability ( ) is in
the impact use of environmental of resource is:
The structure of double questionnaires in the survey willing to pay has a dependent
variable with twofold choice. Thus been used logit model to investigate the effect of different
explanatory variables on the WTP of visitors to determine recreational value. Based on logit
model the probability of ( ) This person accepts one of the suggestions, as the following
equation is expressed (Haneman,1984.pp 332-341).
Which is cumulative distribution function standard logistic with a difference and
some social and economy variables including income, the proposed amount, age, gender,
household size and education in the this study is inserted. , , estimable coefficients
are as expected were 0, , .
There are three methods to estimate WTP values : The first method is called the mean
WPT from which to calculate the expected value of WTP in the range zero to infinity by
261
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
numerical of integration is used. The second method is called average total WTP to calculate
the expected value of wtp win the range to by numerical of integration can be. The
third method, called the mean WTP is part of it for the calculation of the expected value of
WTP by numerical of integration in the range of zero to offer maximum (A) is used. Among
these methods, the third method is better because this approach limits consistency and
compatibility with the theory of statistical performance and the ability of gather and maintains
is calculated from the following equation (lee and Han, 2002, pp 531-540).
E (WTP) willingness to pay the expected the amount and Intercept is adjustment. By
the sentence socio - economically, to sentence the original intercept added. Logit models may
be linear or logarithmic to form functions are estimated that linear function form to calculate
mean WTP is easier and has been used from it in most studies. Logit model parameters to the
method maximum likelihood were estimated using Shazam software and mathematical
calculations with the software Maple. Tensile strength K th explanatory variable in the logit
model the can be obtained from the following equation:
Stretch each explanatory variable does expressed that one change percentage in ( ) is
cause of change the some percentage in the probability of success the dependent variable
( ). Depending on the type explanatory variables, there are two separate methods for
calculating the net effect in logit model: If quantitative variable is change in the
probability of success dependent variable ( ) to effect of changing of one unit in that
is called to name final effect as following equation is calculated.
1- As can be seen in this pattern value of changed in likelihood, based on the initial
probability and depends on the initial values of all independent variables and their
coefficients.
2- If is virtual variable, effect of final for this variable is change in the probability of
success dependent variable ( ) in result of change ( ) from zero to one while the
other variables are kept at one fixed value. The amount final effect virtual explanatory
variable is can be calculated by the following equation:
Other variables fixed values ( ), as "Sample of state" is known. Mode of to determine
The amount status Sample is that for Virtual variables their mod the amount and for other
variables their mean values are considered.
Review and Discussion
Functions and services valuation non-market of environmental is important for many
reasons (oug, 2001, mihsa, 2000, emav, 1998) that the main the reasons can be mention items
such as: identification and understanding of environmental and ecological resources by
humans, environmental issues presented to the decision makers and planners, providing link
between economic policies and natural of incomes, sensing role and importance of
environmental resources in support of sustainable development and human welfare and
prevent the destruction and unwise exploitation. In order by using valuation indicators and the
questionnaires design and determining amounts of offer obtained recreational and the
geotourism value Babak Castle. Results from a questionnaire survey showed that more than
80 percent of tourists addition to Visits of this historic castle, the purpose of your trip enjoy
262
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
the region beautiful nature and phenomena as have been Answering status to three proposed
amount in Table no (1) is coming: The results show that from 150 the visitor this area, 48
person’s initial amount of offer, 120 persons down amount of offer (30,000) and 30 persons
have accepted the high amount of offer.
Table 1. Answering status to three proposed amount for calculate the economic value of
recreation Babak Castle
Admission status initial amount of down amount of high amount of
offer 50000 rials offer 30000 rials offer 70000 rials
Admission of Number 48 120 30
the proposed Percent 32 80 20
amount
Rejection of the Number 98 30 58
proposed Percent 65/33 20 38/66
amount
sum Number 146 150 35
Percent 97/33 100 58/66
For evaluate the presence or absence linear relation in this study analysis of variance test
was used. The results of these tests showed that between explanatory variables used in the
model, there is not linear relation. San and Mackinnon (1984) were presenting statistical
under the title LM2 for testing anisotropy variance at Logit and Probit models. This statistic is
based LM method and at that an artificial regression using the results of formed Logit or
probit model estimates and this artificial regression is used for testing the anisotropy variance.
Amount of statistic LM2 in pattern processed is equal to 3/3 and since the ( )از انجا کهvalue
probability this statistic is equal to 65% شssumption of homogeneity of variance in the model
is accepted (Whister, 1999). Intended logit model was estimated to form linear and
logarithmic functions. The results of the assessment these two patterns showed that amounts
determine the MAC Fadn and likelihood ratio form linear function than the logarithmic form
been above Thus, was used from linear model. For evaluate the overall meaningful the
estimated regression was used from statistic likelihood ratio (LR). The value of this statistic,
in degrees of freedom 7 is equal to 170/ 27 and since that this amount is higher than the value
probability value (p-) the proposed, therefore overall pattern estimates from statistically is
significant in the 1% level. Coefficient values of the determine the Estrella, Madala, Krag –
Auhler and Mac Fadn for logit model was estimated that is respectively 60%, 49%, 65% and
48%. These amounts considering dependent variable the number of observations are favorable
numbers. Percentage of correct prediction model estimated is also more than 84% and since
the acceptable value percentage of correct predictions for logit and probit models is equal to
70 percent, amount percentage of correct predictions obtained in this pattern show desirable
number. So above pattern is reliable for further analysis.
263
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Table 2. The results of the estimation of logit pattern
variables amount of value of the stretching the the final effect
estimated statistic + total weight
coefficients
عرض از مبدا -4/46 -2/64 -1/97 -1/004
age 23% 1/03 42% 21%
sex -1/25 -2/19 -37% -20%
education 30% 3/71 1/55 80%
household size -66% -3/36 -1.41 -75%
income 0.000008% 3.68 1.69 83%
proposed price 0.00022% -2.44 -19% -91%
As table 2 show estimated coefficients for explanatory variables of sex, education,
household size, income and proposed price Is statistically significant at the 5 percent of level.
Age, education and income have a positive effect and sex, household size, and proposed price
has a negative effect on the willingness to pay of visitors is of this historic castle. But variable
the age statistically is not significant. Increasing number of households willing to pay to
reduce and increase the number of years of education has led to an increased willingness to
pay. Stretch of total weight related to income and education variables, is equal to the of 1/69
and 1/55 show that with fixed other factors one percent increase in income level and
education increase the possibility of willing to pay the visitors 1/69 and 1/55 percent. Stretch
of amounts studied for variables household size and proposed price that is equal to -1/41 and -
0/89 show that with fixed other factors one percent decrease in household size and proposed
price the possibility of willing to pay the visitors1 /41 and -19 percent decrease. The ultimate
effect of related to independent variables of education and income is respectively 3/71and 3/
68. In other words, by increasing one unit mentioned of variables the possibility reception
willing to pay by visitor increase 3/71and 3/ 68. Is the final effect of proposed price of -19
percent namely increase one unit above variable leading to a decrease the probability of
acceptance Willingness to pay in visitor as much as 19 percent will be. Average willingness
to pay using equation (5) was obtained for each visitor 985 Tomans. Thus economic and
recreational value of the annual this castle is calculated according to the following equation:
Average willingness to pay × number of annual visitor
985 × 250000 = 246250000 Tomans
Tendency to sum of obtained and number of tourists visiting of this region shows that the
study area's a great potential order to entry tourism and increase revenues from its that in case
of tendency to removal deficiency and investment in order to increase welfare service such as
parking, retire in path, Improved situation ways of communicating and health status (health
services, rubbish collection, ...) could cause increased the number of tourists, rural
employment and income is in the area in addition to helping the local economy, In
preservation and conservation of these areas for future generations is also effective.
264
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
References:
Amirnejad, H., S. khalilian , and M.H. Assareh (2006).Estimating the existence value of north
forests of Iran by using a contingent valuation method Ecological Economics,58:665-675.
Ashim, G.B. (2000). Green national accounting: Why and How? Environment and
Development Economics, 5: 25-48.
Bebenek Slawomir,(2006) geotourism management of abiotic nature object as a chance for
rural areas development. University of science and Technology, A1. Mickiewicza30
Guo, Z., X. Xiao, Y. Gan and Y. Zhen (2001). Ecosystem functions, services and their values
cases study in Xingshan country of China. Ecological Economics, 38: 141-154.
Haneman,W.M.(1984)Welfare evaluation in contingent valuation experiments with discrete
responses. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 71:332-341
Judge, G.,C.Hill.W.Griffiths,T. Lee,and H. Lutkepol(1982) Intruduction to the theory and
practice of econometrics . New York : Wily
Khodaverdi, M., hayati, Bob Allah and Muhammad Kavosi, Estimate the recreational value of the
tourist village of East Azerbaijan Kandovan using contingent valuation, environmental science, No.
IV, Summer 1387,52-43.
Lein hoop,N,and D. MacMillan (2007) valuing wideness in Iceland: Estimation of WTA and
WTP using the market stall approach to contingent valuation land use policy 24:289-295
Lee,c.,and S.Han(2002) Estimating the use and preservation values of national parks tourism
resources using a contingent valuation method Tourism Management, 23: 531-540
Mitzaee,M . (2000). Study of plant cover and ecological valuation in semi desert region of
south west of Gom province ,M,SC , plant science, Tarbiat Modares university
Rostamzadeh nomads, Sohail, 1383, to study Babak Castle, Faculty of Tehran University.
Sadr Mousavi, Mir Satar & Javad dakhili kahnemoyi, (1384), evaluation of tourism facilities,
tourists view of East Azerbaijan province, Geographical Journal 61, pp. 129-143.
Saraghy, Esa (1387), analyzing the development of ecotourism attractions Papdar Province, School of
Humanities and Social Sciences University.
Thomas A.hos(2007) landscapes of meaning geotourism and the sustainable Exploitation of
the European geo heritage. National Geographic.pp.14-19
Vaze, P. (1998). System of environment and economic accounting (SEEA). London: ONS,
U.K.
Whister,D.(1999) An Introductory Guide to SHZAM .www.shazam.Econ.uba.ca.logit Test for
Heteroskedasticity.
265
Halal and Haram foods-drinks in the views of Rumi
Zabihi Robab, Zabihi Ebrahim, Raoufi Farzaneh
Mashhad Education Organization
Farhang- High School, Iran
e-mail: robabzabihi@gmail.com
Abstract
Objectives: Mowlana Jalal ad-Din Muhammad Balkhi Rumi (1207-1273), is a great poet and
mystic whose works in religion and mysticism are well known and highly respected in a
better part of the Middle East cultures. In this article we have tried to summarize his opinions
and views expressed about foods and drinks.
Methodology: The most famous books of Rumi which are available in persian were
extensively revievew and all phrases related to any kind of foods or drinks retrieved.
According to any word’s meanings and its bibliography, the Rumi’s views were guessed and
categorized.
Results: According to the views expressed in Rumi’s 5 main books (Fihi-mafihe, Makatib,
Kolyat Shams, Majales haftgane, Masnavi Ma'navi; he believed in two types of food: 1- body
food which he mention it as sweet and fat; 2- Soul food which he name it jaan food.
According to Rumi’s views, halal or haram (religiously allowed or banned) for these two
types or foods/drinks are different. While Rumi, as a well known Islamic cleric, does not
allow alcohol consumption, he name sentimental foods of jaan as the wine of the soul which
he believes would enormously benefits the human. Love is the cornerstone of all human jaan
foods and it is in higher rank compared to body’s foods which Rumi call them the grass!.
Rumi believes that if somebody neglects to eat halal (good) jaan foods, his/her soul would get
sick and ill. So for having a strong soul someone should seek halal jaan food and avoid
harams. Finally, Rumi believes that the jaan foods are not some kind of materials but they are
like lights which might be absent to ordinary body senses
Keywords: soul, jaan, Masnavi, mysticism
1. Introduction
Jalal al-Din Muhammad Rumi, also named under Mevlana or Movlana or Movlavi, was
born in Balkh, about the year 604 AH and died in Konya in the year 672 AH. Rumi was a
great mystic who promoted himself to a high levels of sentimental information and wisdom
through numerous travels full of austerity. For this reason he gives much more prices to the
human soul and spirit than the body. He wrote in Masnavi this song:
( ای تزادر تْ ُوَ اًذیؼَ ایEiy Baraad-dar to ham-eh Andisheh-ee)
( هاتمی خْد اطتخْاى ّ ریؼَ ایMaa Bagh-ee Khud Osstokhaan-o Risheh-ee)
Which means:
My bro, you are essentially just thoughts;
the rest of you is only some bones and tendons.
His cloths and foods (as far as related to himself) were simple as possible. His food,
especially when eating alone, was a little bread with yoghurt or a small snack eating them by
satisfaction. This was not, of course, because he was a greedy or voracious person.
For this reason drinks, foods, Halal or Haram had different meaning to Movlana. For the
instance, he look at the body foods meant as grass compared to the food of soul which seems
to him as the light. Clarifying this different view of Movlana about Halal and Haram, which
267
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
are two internationally well known terms in Islam, based on Rumi’s available works, is the
subject of this article.
2. The character of food in the views of Rumi
Movlana, at the first section of his book Monajat-Nameh (meaning praying) compares the
soul unity to wine and addresses: “taste to the soul of the fans the wine of unity” and believes
that a good person should have close look at what he/she eats! And watch his/her carrion eater
spirit and devilish desires. Also it might be a test trap from deity. He symbolizes the believers
to the snake-fish and declares that the snake eats wind and soils same as the devilish soul’s
food which is soil and wind. How does foods look like soil?! Look at the fate of fatty and
sweet foods (two kind of delicious foods in Rumi’s era), which god has created them from
soil, how they become soils. Now that you learnt the bread and meat are just painted soil!
Seek another food. The other snake’s food is wind!, which wind?. The wind of arrogance and
conceit. As soon as humans feel full of bread (foods), pursue arrogance and conceit. Here the
believers’ moods are not just snake and not merely fish either, but it is snake-fish. Once, the
snake side of their souls take them toward soils and wind and the other time the fishy side of
their soul takes them toward water (which symbolizes the life pleasures).
3. Halal and Haram from Rumi’s point of view
Rumi believes in two types of food: 1 - sweet and fatty food substances, which he says
about:
«:»چزب ّ ػیزیي کن دٍ ایي هزدار را
meaning: feed less sweet and fatty substances to this carrion (the body) ( هْالًا خالل الذیي دمحم
هْلْیAH 1355 (AD 1976))
which this type of food originates from outside of the body and is like grass.
2- The second type of food is for human soul and spirit which their Halal or Haram differ
fundamentally from the previous kind of foods. Rumi argues that this is the lovers' and the
soul's food which originate from inside of human. He mentions:
)472غشل،"تادٍ ی عؼك ای غالم ًیظت زالل ّ ززام" (دیْاى ػوض
meaning: Oh! buddy!, the wine of love is neither Halal nor Haram,
or:
""ػزاب زك زالل اًذر زالل اطت
meaning: the wine of truth is definitely Halal
The soul's and spirit's foods are more important to Rumi's, he advise to:.. make a cocktail!
of confession and asking god forgiveness to refresh and nourish your heart and religion. This
world's food is like a step mother's breast milk, which you might aspirate. Congratulation to
that baby who got his/her wisdom teeth and got read of this step mother and her breast milk!
and now his/her food, instead of that milk, is sentimental findings.
Rumi believes that his soul is grown up from a kid and should not metnion to the secrets!
as a fetus feed from the mother's blood and then this blood change to breast milk. Then after
his/her teeth grown up, he/she stop eating breast milk and start new foods. Rumi symbolizes
this world's food to the grass and says: "...do not bring me grass, I'm not animal, an angle eats
by watching the god's beauty".
268
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
According to Rumi, the human soul's food is the spirit livelihood and your heart would
lead you to heartily guided people, while your body would imprison you in soils and water
and materialism. Hence, he ask:
(34 تخغ،دفتز اّل،"ُیي غذای دل تذٍ" (هثٌْی
meaning: "give me the soul's food"
because if you only seek the body food, your bodily spirit would grow up and the bodily
spirit is like hell. The hell is like a dragon which even if drink seven seas! it would be still
thirsty and even if eat all the world its stomach says: I want more!. So. as you feed more
sweet and fatty foods this bodily spirit, it asks for more and more!
Rumi believes that the food of chosen (higher ranked) ones are not materially substances
and there is no need for throat or any other objective means, but they mainly eat from the
god's glow. It is the reason that he prays (before sunrise) as:
ّ " اللِن اخعلٌی ًْرا فی للثی ّ ًْرا فی تـزی ّ ًْرا فی ػعزی ّ ًْرا فی تؼزی ّ ًْرا فی لسوی ّ ًْرا فی دهی
اللِن سدًی ًْرا.ًْرا هي تیي یذی ّ ًْرا فی خلفی ّ ًْرا فی تستی ّ ًْرا فی فْلی ّ ًْرا عي یویٌی ّ ًْرا عي ػوالی
)287ؽ، افالکی-ّ اعطٌی ًْرا ّ اخعلٌی ًْرا یا ًْر الٌْر تززوتک یا ارزن الزازویي "(هٌالة العارفیي
meaning: "...Oh! Lord, please set light in my heart and light in my eyes and light in my
mind and light in my skin and light in my muscles and light in my blood and light in my hands
and light in my back and light in my below and light in my above and light in my left and light
in north. Oh! my almighty, give me light and increase my light and put me in light, oh! my
lord, you are lights of the lights. "(2009 ,)افالکی
He believes that the human has missed his real food which is the soul's food. For all
humans there are soul's foods but because of the soul illness they mistakenly take clay (soil
and water) which makes their souls more sick, pale!, and weak. It is the reason that in Quran
god says: "... the martyrs are alive and they are fed by their god..." This type of foods doesn't
need mouth or plate to be eaten!
In “Daftar-e Sevvom” (meaning 3rd booklet) book, Rumi says: “ ..Oh! Zziaa-Oll-Hagh-
Hessaa-Mmooddin!, disclose the secrets treasure a give up excuses. Your real food is the
truth food not warm blood and vessels..”
The glow of Shams (disambiguation: “The sun” in Arabic, or, “Sahms” The Rumi’s
mentor) does not come from oil and lamp. As the Gabriel angle’s food does not come from the
kitchen but it’s from the lord’s companionship…” and “… the food of God’s favorite men is
from the truth not ordinary food and plate …”
Rumi in another place (Daftar-e Sevvom- section 1) says about drinking: “…
How shame that when it comes to thoughts, the human throat (an idiom) is very narrow
and can’t swallow!. When wine of the truth wanted to appear in Mount Sinai (referring to
Moses story) they could not swallow this drink and the mount exploded!..”
According to Rumi, food donation is not a hard job! and could be accomplished by
anyone, however, giving throat to somebody is just the Lord’s job!. The Lord gives throat to
the body and the soul!. He gives the soul’s throat to make you a goddess and clean you from
deception and dishonesty. So, this gift throat, which drinks the Lord’s secrets should not
disclose them to inconsiderate people and should be remained muted like flowers, which have
drunk hundreds secrets of the Lord’s beauty.
Like a fetus which doesn’t have any food except blood while staying in the womb, the
Lord does not feed you by the world’s secrets until you come out of your ordinary world!.
269
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Your food would be like blood to that fetus while your world is materialistic. Then, it is up to
you to choose your food! For example; pig meat and carrion are two Haram foods for the
body in Islam but backbiting is Haram for the soul!. Like the real world, people souls have
different appetites and they choose their favorite foods for their souls! Humans are like guest
on the creation’s table and it is just like the Lord has created different foods for different
tastes.
Rumi classifies the people’s throat illnesses into two types which they shall visit a
physician who are body physicians or soul physicians to heal their God gift throat. The first
type of physicians have their own bodily ill patients and look at the heart as a blood pump
machine!. They are foods and fruits physicians and look after the bodily soul. Rumi jokes
about them as:
)121 " آى طثیثاى را تْد تْلی دلیل" (دفتز طْم تخغ.
Meaning: “ …for these physicians urine is a sign!...” (Daftar-e Sevvom- section 1)
These physicians ask for wage for doing their jobs.
In contrary, the 2nd type of physicians, the soul physicians could look at the heart without
any tools because they have got the wisdom and are inspired by the Lord’s glory. For cure,
they say which act is useful or harmful, which talk promote you or is poisonous for your
health. They have based their treatments on Lord’s revelation and do not ask for wage
because they believe that God would pay them a lot. They invite the patients for healing and
announce that their medications heal all patients.
Rumi believes in 3 degrees of soul: 1) Soul of animal, 2) Soul of human, 3) Soul of God
chosen talents
The animals’ soul is like an oil-lamp which only foods keep them alive. If this lamp dies
out, it doesn’t affect the neighbors’ home and doesn’t make there dark!. Those who posses
only animal souls and eat only bodily foods are like wolves and dogs whose their souls are
completely not related. Where Rumi mention:
)17 تخغ،4" خاى گزگاى ّ طگاى ُز یک خذاطت" (دفتز
Meaning: “…The dogs and wolves soul are all separated.. ” (Daftar-e Chahharrom-
section 17)
But those who brought faith in God are like a unified soul, where he says:
"...هتسذ خاى ُای ػیزاى خذاطت..."
Meaning: “…The souls of God’s lions are unbified. ” (Daftar-e Chahharrom- section 17)
2) The 2nd degree of soul is the human soul, he says about this degree of the soul:
هائذٍ عمل اطت ًی ًاى ّ ػْی ًْر عمل اطت ای پظز خاى را غذی.."
))اس خش آى خاى ًیاتذ پزّرع ًیظت غیز ًْر آدم را خْرع
)74 تخغ،4 (دفتز
Meaning:
The (human soul’s) food is thinking not bread and vegetables;
Buddy!, thinking glow is food for the (human) soul
(Daftar-e Chahharrom- section 74)
270
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Movlana declares that if you don’t want to be like a donkey (animal), eat less bodily and
materialistic foods to be able to eat glow foods:
)74 تخغ،4 " (دفتز...لموَ ُای ًْر را آکل ػْی تا غذای اؿل را لاتل ػْی..."
To be able to eat the real foods
And eat pieces of glow foods
(Daftar-e Chahharrom- section 74)
If you get the chance to eat the glow foods just for one time!, you would never be
interested in ordinary bread and foods.
3) The 3rd degree of soul is the soul of God chosen talents. They are called “Olyaa Al-
laah” (Arabic: )اّلیا هللا. These are saints whose their foods are the Lord’s glow and truth.
The glow which is the human soul’s food is body food for these God chosen talents (“Olyaa
Al-laah”). Rumi says about them:
)13تخغ،5لیک اس چؼن خظیظاى تض ًِاى))(دفتز زثذا خْاًی ًِادٍ در خِاى
Meaning: The Lord has set a generous table of foods in this world but it is hidden to
parsimonious people’s eyes.
(Daftar-e Pan-jom- section 13)
And he believes that anybody who eat from the Lord’s glow would talk (and behave)
magically and legitimately:
)90 تخغ،3 چْى ًشایذ اس لثغ طسز زالل " (دفتز " ُز کَ تاػذ لْت اّ ًْر خالل
271
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
References:
افالکی ع .ا .ا .)2009( ,.هٌالة العارفیي.
هْالًا خالل الذیي دمحم هْلْی (AH 1355 (AD 1976)).کلیات ػوض تثزیشی تِزاى ,اهیز کثیز.
تز لة دریای هثٌْی(تیاى هماؿذ اتیات)،کزین سهاًی – تِزاىً،ؼز لطزٍ 2 ،1381،ج
هثٌْی هعٌْی(تز اطاص ًتایح لًْیَ) تَ تـسیر ّ پیغ گفتار عثذالکزین طزّع چاپ اّل 1375 :اًتؼارات علوی ّ
فزٌُگی
ػزذ هثٌْی ػزیف،تذیع الشهاى فزّساًفز،تِزاى،ػزکت اًتؼارات علوی ّ فزٌُگی 1380چاپ دُن
تسز در کْسٍ،عثذالسظیي سریي کْب،اًتؼارات علوی،تِار 1372چاپ چِارم
هدالض طثعَ(ُفت خطاتَ)،هْلْی خالل الذیي دمحم اتي دمحم ،تا تْفیك ٍ .طثساًی،تِزاى ،کیِاى1365،
هدالض طثعَ ی هْالًا ،تَ تـسیر ازوذ رهشی آلایْرکُ،وزاٍ تزخوَ ی تزکی دمحم خلْؿی،تَ اُتوام دکتز فزیذّى ًافذ
اّسلْق،اطتاًثْل،هطثعَ ی تْسلْرت1937،
ػزذ کاهل فیَ ها فیَ،گفتار ُایی اس هْالًا خالل الذیي دمحم تلخی ،کزین سهاًی،1330،اًتؼارات هعیي
سهاًی،کزین،ػزذ کاهل فیَ ها فیَ گفتار ُایی اس هْالًا،خالل الذیي دمحم تلخی،اًتؼارات هعیي ،چاپ اّل1390،
ػزذ هثٌْی هعٌْی هْلْی،ریٌْلذ الیي ًیلکظْى،تزخوَ ّ تعلیك زظي الُْتی
ػزکت اًتؼارات علوی ّ فزٌُگی 1374،
کلیات ػوض تثزیشی ،هْالًا خالل الذیي دمحم هْلْی تا تـسیسات ّ زْاػی تذیع الشهاى فزّساًفز،اهیز کثیز1355،
گشیذٍ فیَ ها فیَ ،هماالت هْالًا،تا تلخیؾ،همذهَ ّ ػزذ زظیي دمحم الذیي الِی لوؼَ ای ،ػزکت اًتؼارات علوی ّ
فزٌُگی ،1377،
هیٌا گز عؼك ،کزین سهاًی ً،ؼز ًی1382،
هْلْی خالل الذیي دمحم،فیَ ها فیَ،تـسیسات ّ زْاػی،تذیع الشهاى فزّساًفز،چاپ طْم،اًتؼارات اهیز کثیز،
تِزاى1358،
هکتْتات هْالًا خالل الذیي رّهی ،تـسیر دکتز تْفیك ٍ .طثساًی (تا همذهَ هززْم عثذ الثالی گْلپیٌارلی تز تزخوَ
هکتْتات) ،تزکیَ
سریي کْب،عثذ السظیي،پلَ پلَ تا هاللات خذا ،درتارٍ سًذگی،اًذیؼَ ّ طلْک هْالًا،تِزاى،علوی 1377،
272
A socio-demographic study on Iranians Hajj-pilgrims
Zabihi Ebrahim, Zabihi Robab, Emrani Ali-Asghar, Raoufi Farzaneh
Babol University of Medical Sciences
Cellular Molecular Biology Research Center
e-mail: e.zabihi@mubabol.ac.ir
Mashhad Education Organization
robabzabihi@gmail.com
Abstract
Objectives: The Hajj pilgrimage has become the one of the most favorite religious tours in
Iran, as an active Isalmic country, after Islamic revolution in 1979. The Hajj participants
(“Hajji’s” in Persian) have a wide socio-cultural characteristics and with different attitudes
toward this religious journey. The aim of this study was to evaluate some these socio-
demographic properties of a small random population of Persian Hajj pilgrims.
Methodology: Using a specifically designed questionnaire, some of the most important
demographic and soci-economic information related to the pilgrims were obtained during
their enrollment process for the Hajj at 4 different Hajj tour stations (Karavaan) during 2012.
The obtained results were analyzed using SPSS® software and presented using descriptive
statistics.
Results: The provided information by 121 Persian pilgrims who filled the questionnaires were
analyzed. There was no significant sex ratio heterogeneity (female/male: 59/61) among the
pilgrims. The mean of pilgrims ages was 52±10 yrs (mean ± SD) with no significant sex-age
correlation. More than 30% of the study samples had academic education (college or
university). However, 87% of the sample population declared to have annual incomes less
than 15000 USD. Surprisingly more than 73% of the pilgrims had previously participated in
Hajj tours and most of them were satisfied with its price (59%) and its sentimental outcomes
(90%). More than 84% of the pilgrims believe that their participation in Hajj ceremony
increased their friendships and peace towards other Islamic nations.
Conclusions: Hajj pilgrimage is a subsidized religious journey provided by Islamic
government of Iran that could be of benefits for many low income Persian Muslims to
participate in this internationally accredited religious event. They not only feel sentimental
satisfaction after the Hajj ceremony, but also it could be useful for Islamic people unification
and peace.
Keywords: Income, education, sentimental
1. Introduction
Saudi Arabia Ministry of Hajj has announced that every year about 3 million pilgrims
from all over the globe come to Saudi-Arabia to participate in Hajj (or Umrah) pilgrimage
(Ministry of Hajj-Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, 2009). With a share of better than 10% of annual
participating Hajjis, Iran has the highest pilgrims in this unique international religious
occurring, among all Muslim countries (2012 ; نمانيده ولي فقيه در امىر حج و زيارت2002 )قهرودي.
As the world largest religious occurring , Hajj brings together many races from different
countries, even though some of them might be in conflict or even war against the others!, and
provides a chance for different people from different nations peacefully interact (Greater
Kashmir 2012) .
Hajj is a religious duty and one of 5 pillars of Islam which must be carried out at least
once in a Muslim lifetime who could afford to do so. It is a huge socio-economic motive
among Muslims of all over the world specially among Iranian. After Islamic revolution in
273
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Iran, the tradition of Iranians to participate in Hajj has been highly promoted and improved
both by government and non-governmental organizations. It is believed that Hajj for Iranian
has become a kind of religious tourism accompanied by a life refreshment and world
exploring. Many Iranians who travel on education or business purposes, might never find the
chance to participate in Hajj and Saudi Arabia as pilgrims but at the depth of any Muslim
Iranian Hajj is a great chance to fulfill his/her religious duty and open new horizons in his/her
life specially if they have not got the chance to visit outside of the country. Mecca in Saudi-
Arabia and two holly cities in Iraq (Karbla & Najaf) are the two most desired religious places
to visit for Iranians. Despite participating in Hajj is once enough during whole one Muslim’s
life, but the public ambition to repeat this holly journey seems to be much higher specially for
those who participated once. While Iran’s population has been roughly doubled after Islamic
Revolution in Iran (United Nations Population Fund, 2012), the total annual number of Hajj
pilgrims have been increased nearly 10 fold!. To have a better picture of Iranian’s Hajj
pilgrims, we designed this sociio-economic study.
1.1. Methodology
As a cross-sectional study conducted on 300 participants who had enrolled for Hajj
pilgrimage in 2012, a validated questionnaire was designed (for its English translation see
App. 1) and after explaining the purpose of the study, filled anonymously by own pilgrims or
by the investigators for those who might needed help.
1.2 Statistical Methods:
Quantitative data are presented as Mean ± S.D. and the differences among between
categories were evaluated either by ANOVA or chi-square tests. A P-value less than 0.05
assumed statistically significant.
2. Results
There was no significant difference between women/men gender ratio among the
candidate pilgrims (women 59/men 61) in this study (P<0.05). The mean of pilgrims ages was
52±10 yrs (mean±SD) with no significant sex-age correlation (P<0.05) (Table 1).
Table 1. Age and gender information of the surveyed Hajj pilgrims
Gender Number of Pilgrims (%) Age (mean±SD)
Female 59 (48.7%) 53.8±8.2
Male 61 (50.4%) 49.9±11.2
N/A 1 (0.9%) -
total 121 (100%) 52±10
* No significant age difference was observed among the 2 genders
Only 13.2% of pilgrims (mostly female) were single. More than 30% of the study samples
had academic education (college or university) (Fig 1). However, more than 87% of the
sample population declared to have annual incomes less than 18000 USD (Fig 2).
Surprisingly more than 73% of the pilgrims had previously participated in Hajj tours and most
of them were satisfied with its price (59%) and its sentimental outcomes (90%). More than
84% of the pilgrims believe that their participation in Hajj ceremony increased their
friendships and peace towards other Islamic nations.
274
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Figure 1. Pilgrims education levels
Figure 2. Pilgrims annual income
3. Discussion and Conclusion:
According to the survey results, Hajj pilgrimage is a favorite religious ritual among
Iranians of both sexes (at least in Mashhad, a city at the east of Iran). The equal sex ratio
among Iranians Hajj pilgrims is significantly different from the world Hajj pilgrims sex ratio
of 56% (male)-44% (female) percentages reported by Royal Embassy of Saudi Arabia (1998).
This might be originated from Persian-Shiaism culture of Iran which gives more room for
women to participate in socio-religious activities compared to some other Islamic countries
where the male domination is more obvious (Mahallati, 2011). Despite of Islam permission
and municipal laws in Iran, Polygamy is a controversial issue and a bizarre phenomenon in
Iran's major provinces. Also the average of pilgrims ages (52±10 yrs) is well below the Iran's
life expectancy annual report (which in 2012 was about 74 yrs) by Iran's Ministery of Health
(2012) (2012 , )جهان نيىزwhich could justify the couple who participate the Hajj together and
this would keep the female/male ratio near to 50:50 (Table 1).
275
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
The higher education levels among the pilgrims (more than 30% of the pilgrims have
academic degrees) is in concordance with Iran's last decades public education progress, which
has been addressed by United Nation (2012) as 84.6% rate of literacy (United Nations
Population Fund, 2012). The skyrocket progress in Iranian women academic education,
recently has been buzzing in the media.
The average annual income of the Iranian pilgrims is lower than destination country
(Saudi Arabia) per capita. The high percentage of repetitive Hajj journey among Iranian
pilgrims (more than 73%) might not only arouse economic but also health issues. Since
nowadays the world's Muslim population has passed the 1.2 billion in number, a practical
planning to give all Muslims the Hajj opportunity at least once at one's whole life is a big job
for Saudi Arabia's Ministry of Hajj.
As a final word, the Iranian Hajj pilgrims seem to be very happy with the subsidized
opportunity given by their Islamic government. This a good opportunity for poor people to
encounter with other nations in a peaceful and spiritual atmosphere, but good planning of the
country resources for this holy ritual to enable more Iranians get the opportunity to travel to
the holy land of Mecca remains as a big responsibility for the Iranian authorities.
References
Greater Kashmir. (2012). "4 million perform Hajj." Retrieved 14 December, 2012, from
http://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/2012/Oct/30/4-million-perform-hajj-43.asp.
Ministry of Hajj-Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. (2009). "Numbers of Hajj pilgrims (1996 -
2006)." Retrieved Dec. 14, 2012, from http://www.hajinformation.com/main/l.htm.
." Retrieved Dec 14, 2012, from " ساالنه ی ايران در حج سهميه.)2002( . خ,قهرودي
http://noorportal.net/news/ShowNews.aspx?ID=9926.
." Retrieved 15 Dec . 2012, "سهميه حج تمتع و عمره ی ايران.)2012( .نمانيده ولي فقيه در امىر حج و زيارت
from http://www.asriran.com.
Retrieved December 14, 2012, from ". "نرخ اميد به زندگی در ايران اعالم شد.)2012( .جهان نيىز
./http://www.ghatreh.com/news
276
International Conference on Religious Tourism and Tolerance, 9-12 May 2013, Konya /TURKEY
Appendix 1) The design questionnaire for socio-demographic study on Iranians Hajj-pilgrims
Dear Pilgrim:
The following questionnaire is designed to assess your Hajj journey.
Your honest responses will be very helpful in the future planning.
Personal information:
Age:......years Gender: □Male □Female Marriage: □ Single □ Married
Level of Education:
□ End of Primary (up to