Summer of My German Soldier (TV Movie 1978) - Summer of My German Soldier (TV Movie 1978) - User Reviews - IMDb
17 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Sentimental tale with an uncompromising ending...
moonspinner5510 February 2001
A touching story told with tenderness: awkward young Jewish girl in WWII America befriends an escaped German POW who is hiding out in her clubhouse. They discuss their lives and beliefs (he's anti-Hitler), she sneaks him food, he becomes her only friend and ally. All this reminded me of the much-better theatrical film "Whistle Down The Wind", where Hayley Mills befriends convict Alan Bates, but you certainly can't fault the direction here, which is smooth, or the performances, which are sterling. Mature in her pre-teen years, Kristy McNichol carries most of the picture and never hits a false note. Suddenly, when the prisoner is discovered (and Kristy is found out as well), the movie gets very tough. Her father, shocked and ashamed that his child would consort with "that Nazi", lays into her with a quiet fury I have seldom seen before (he tells her "You are dead to me," which must be devastating for a little girl to hear). The final scenes don't cop out; there are no big reunions, no hand-holding climaxes. The girl has to face the world, and in doing so learns a bitter lesson about neighbors, friends, and family. A startling film.
17 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
things may happen, but memories last forever
lee_eisenberg11 July 2007
"Summer of My German Soldier" was one of the many TV movies that became a staple of the small screen in the 1970s (others were "Brian's Song", "Sybil" and "Someone's Watching Me!"). It portrays a Jewish girl (Kristy McNichol) befriending a German POW (Bruce Davison) in WWII-era Georgia. One of the things that the movie shows is that many of the German soldiers weren't really Nazis, but were just drafted. Watching the movie, I got a real sense of how things must have been in the South back then; I mean, can you imagine being a Jewish person accused of supporting the enemy?

So, I certainly recommend this movie. I believe that it's always important to show the things portrayed here. Occasional overacting keeps the movie from being a full-scale masterpiece, but they usually do quite well. I hope that the movie eventually comes out on DVD. Also starring Esther Rolle and Michael Constantine (the "My Big Fat Greek Wedding" patriarch).
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An old favorite
suessis7 January 2003
When I was in 7th grade(back in 1977), I was asked to read the novel that this was based on as part of my English class studies. I can remember being very touched by it and excited when a TV version came out a year later.

Kristy McNichol was a popular TV actress when this film was produced and was already playing a daughter in a dysfunctional family on the hit TV series "Family". It was clear that she had the range and ability to pull off this part. I recall her as being a bit "stiff" at times, but over all she does a good job. She carries the movie well.

Esther Rolle is fantastic as the domestic who appears to be the only one in the household that seems to truly care for her. Barbara Barrie as the somewhat frightened and slightly neurotic mother is also good, as is young Robin Lively (who would eventually appear as the black widow Lana Milford in "Twin Peaks")as the sweet younger sister who seems to be the focus of the parent's affection. Bruce Davidson is also appropriately appealing as the German soldier of the title

The best performance, however, belongs to Michael Constantine. It is truly powerful and merited more recognition than it got at the time. The bitterness and coldness he expresses makes the scenes in which he appears difficult to watch, but makes it much easier to understand the quiet desperation of the rejected daughter. Constantine gives everything the right intensity and seems to have a good understanding of the underlying psychological motivations.

The film differs from the book only in some small ways. It is wonderful and inspiring to watch, and I hope that it gets released again on to video or DVD.
24 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of the last great TV movies
Kathryn-33 August 2001
This is an incredibly moving story, based on Bette Greene's teen novel. The entire cast is wonderful - Kristy MacNichol, Bruce Davison, Esther Rolle. Just brilliant. I saw this when I was about 12, and read the book and the sequel. Have managed to catch it on TV a couple of times since. Such a heart-wrenching story, the kind they don't know how to make any more. More's the pity.
18 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What a GREAT MOVIE!!!!
fries2918 November 2006
This movie was one of the best I have ever seen. Just the other day I was reminded of this movie by something on TV. It came back to me like a dam flooding over. I have never been more touched by a movie than by this one. After the movie was over I actually could not quit crying for about 2 hours. No movie has ever moved me that way before. I was 15 at the time of the movie and have not seen it since but am hoping I can find a copy to buy so that I can watch it whenever I want to. If someone suggests you see this movie with them, GO....you will not be disappointed.

Peggy Fries
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Summer of My German Soldier-A Love Story to Remember
edwagreen18 July 2007
This movie should have easily qualified as a film

that best promotes human understanding among people.

It may be rather annoying to even try to comprehend that a young Jewish southern girl could would give shelter to an escaped German prisoner of war.

Kristy McNichol depicts an amazing portrait of the unhappy, young girl thirsting for acceptance and love. Michael Constantine gave a remarkable performance as her difficult father and Esther Rolle, as the maid, Ruth, gave a superb Emmy-winning performance as an understanding maid caught up with these events.

Bruce Davison portrays the German who is supposedly not guilty of Nazi atrocities. This is how his role appears. He has escaped, but he joined the German army and he might have been a member of the Hitler youth movement.

The action takes place in 1944 Georgia, in a rural area. The townspeople are filled with prejudice. Even the FBI inspector acts as if he would like to get something on the Jews. Notice the opposite interpretation that as McNichol is in bed, Davison is hunted down and ultimately shot. It is interesting to see that society views McNichol as a traitor for harboring an escaped prisoner of war. The film also deals with an extremely complex relationship that exists between father and daughter. Constantine's outburst at his daughter at the end is some acting. As the mother, Barbara Barrie, is given little to do. It was annoying that she is stereotyped as the typical Jewish mother with that loud shade of lipstick on her lips.

Memorably done and well worth viewing.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Taught me something
auntydle29 October 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I haven't seen this movie in 30 years so I don't know if I would like it as much as I did when I was 12. At the time, however, I loved this movie. This is a great "starter chick-flick" for young pre-teen girls. Be careful of the ending, though. There are tears and harsh emotions.

Looking back at it from a 2008 perspective (with so much more knowledge of child psychology, politics and political correctness), I think it would be interesting to watch again. Patty's uncaring, abusive father, indifferent mother and favored sister all contributed toward making her vulnerable and starving for companionship. Patty was sad when Anton left. She was heartbroken when he was killed. The rage that was directed toward her afterward was shocking. After all, she was only 12 years old.

The thing that I most strongly retained is how this movie taught me even "enemy" soldiers are people too. Not all German soldiers were hateful Nazis. When I was older, I saw TV shows like Hogan's Heroes and The Rat Patrol which also made the point that the "regular" German soldiers were not the same as the Gestapo.

"Regular" soldiers were drafted. The Gestapo were handpicked among volunteers for their special attitudes of hate. I believe that one of the privileges of being a Nazi was that they had special assignments and, therefore, didn't go into battle. Their specialties were interrogation and torture.

Later, during the cold war, I would think about Russian soldiers and remember SOMGS. We were taught that the Soviet Union was "evil". But the reality was that Russian soldiers weren't out to destroy America. They had a job. Their government probably told them that our government was out to destroy their way of life. Which, in a way, was true, since the US fought to end Communism.

The lesson is still applicable today. German soldiers were not the same as Nazis just as Muslims are not the same as Al Qaeda.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
heartbreaking coming-of-age story
thomandybish7 July 2001
The extrodinary television movie concerns a young Jewish girl in Georgia who aids an escaped German POW and the resulting devestation it brings her family, primarily in her relationship with her father. Esther Rolle as the family domestic and Martin Balsam as the aloof father are fantastic. Hard to believe a film of this calibre was produced for television; it certainly sets a high standard.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A story of a town full of prejudice.
niccy66617 November 2001
This film is a study piece for my english class, but it's depth and meaning has amazed me. Since we're looking closely into all the facts and characters in this film, its and interesting tale of love, hate, war, and prejudice. Well Recommended!

Story: A girl named well-off jewish Patty Bergen meets an escaped prisoner of war, she then hides him in her playhouse in her huge gardens, and as they get to know each other, they begin to see the others qualities, and they earn each others love. Patty's father despises her and treats her like dirt. Anton (the prisoner of war) almost blows his cover to protect her, but patty manages to stop him before he is seen by anyone.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
masterpiece on bias
alfa-624-37668831 August 2021
It must have been 43 years ago since I watched The Summer Of My German Soldier, but I never forgot how Kristy McNichol touched me deeply. I cried all the way till the end. I remember Kristy helped a soldier into hiding but was not allowed to because he was officially an enemy of the Jews, but in real life just a nice boy. In the end Kristy is abandoned by her community because of collaboration with what her people regard tevil. Kristy is deeply lonely and although she is just een teen girl, she is already massively dissapointed in mankind.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Chased like a fox on a hunt.
mark.waltz14 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
When a group of German soldiers arrives in a small Georgia town to be incarcerated on a work Farm, curious teenager Kristy McNichol befriends one of them, the handsome and smart Bruce Davison, and helps him when he escapes. She sees him as a human being, kind and attentive, not as an alleged former nazi. The mostly Jewish community is aghast by the presence of the alleged Nazis, young men forced into fighting without regards to their own personal feelings, and their assumptions of what these young men are like turns them into vigilantes as they try to find him, regardless of whether they are dead or alive. McNichol is at the height of her star quality here, her radiant personality jumping off of the TV screen and stealing your heart. When she is forced to watch a young little girl perform a song and dance routine, you can see her annoyance, and obviously performed by the young girl to be annoying, you look forward to McNichol telling her off even though she shows guilt afterwards.

As for Davison, he is as handsome as he was as a young actor in the Lucy version of "Mame", and his German accent is quite convincing. His character is noble, thoughtful and sincere, and while you do not really get a lot of his backstory, you do get the impression that he has more democratic ideals than fascist. The only thing is that his character is obviously older than MacNichol's which does give a rather eye raising view to their romance. It makes sense that she would I have a crush on him, especially as she is more idealistic thanks to her friendship with call Esther Rolle who is a mentor to her and treats her like a daughter. When she stands up to MacNichol's hard nosed father. Michael Constantine, you get to see her soul especially when she reveals her own circumstances (a son over in Germany fighting) while helping out Davison. Esther won the Emmy for this and really deserved it.

Barbara Barrie is gentleness personified as Constantine's put upon wife with Anne Haney perfectly stuffy as the judgmental town busybody, playing her with all the venom of a snake Margaret Hamilton's Miss Gulch would admire. James Noble is the FBI agent who shows conflict in his feelings about Davison being hunted like a fox caught killing chickens. A perfect script and great direction aides this TV drama in becoming very special in showing humanity in all its hidden glory although with most of the townspeople, the humanity is hidden by their own prejudices. Davison really strikes a cord when he indicates that the end of the war will show his country destructed by their own people, true evidence to where his heart lies.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stale
richard.fuller115 May 2004
I would catch this cornball melodrama years ago and its ridiculous attempts at confronting discrimination and racism and showing love can conquer better than war or hate is as preachy and as alienating as the most disapproving image of Mother Superior or any other kind of Catholic priest or charismatic evangelist.

Other posts have relayed what the story was about. I can honestly say I didn't catch on to it being a wonderful love story, that's for sure.

McNichol and Davison were hardly a sweet teen romance. I recall Constantine's quiet "youre dead to me" comment to McNichol, but McNichol would also scream at all those around they were murderers when the escaped German prisoner was shot and killed.

Talk about cheesy angst, over and over again with this thing.

But I guess the funniest moment for me was at the very end with Anne Haney, the elderly lady perhaps best known for her final appearances in "Mrs. Doubtfire" when Robin Williams shoved his face in that cake, and she was in "Liar, Liar" with Jim Carrey as his assistant.

Haney is a gossipy neighbor lady, representing society at large in this one woman.

As McNichol and her only ally, it seems, Esther Rolle (who won a supporting actress Emmy for this thing) are walking down the streets, enduring all the glaring stares of disapproval.

Haney spews out the most incredible slur I think I have ever heard, "Jew Nazi n*gg*r lover."

I was totally confused how one could be a Jew lover and a Nazi lover as one was killing the other in WWII, when this movie was taking place. Where on Earth did the Jew figure into it?

Rolle would then deliver a tirade on Haney "leave this child be!" which of course would be highly unlikely for a Black woman to talk to a white woman like that in the forties, as anyone who checks out Oprah Winfrey's imprisonment in "Color Purple" will see.

This movie was alot of wishful thinking; that people could speak so freely and that others would be silenced so easily. Unfortunately all it does is more dividing of the masses, leaving society as a whole back at square one, if we are to believe the messages here.
2 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Not as good as the book
breige11 April 2003
We read the novel Summer of my German Soldier in school and then we watched the film.If you have read the book before you saw the movie,like I did,you might feel a bit more disappointed.The feelings weren't shown as intensely as the book shows them.Also the relationships are not as clearly shown as the book.But it is still a good film to watch if you have not read the book.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Why Patty was unloved
jeffyoung128 October 2018
By reading the synopsis and other poster's comments you know just about everything in this movie so there really are no spoilers. Plus Wikipedia tells the whole story. So I'm not going there. This movie dates back to 1978 and everyone who is interested in this movie knows the entire storyline. This post is about why Polly was so unloved by her parents. In fact her father, Harry disdained her and the mother was indifferent. Yet the younger sister was deeply beloved by the parents who showered attention, love, and physical affection. This shows the complexity of human nature when it involves, love, affection, and caring for one's offspring. Psychologists and researchers have long known that parents are not always equal in how they feel and show love to their offspring. Often the individual parent cannot understand themselves why they feel more love for one child over the other. In another Hollywood movie, the father loved his eldest son, who died in a car crash, over his youngest son. I think the movie's title was, Stand By Me. In, 'The Summer Of My German Soldier', Patty learns the horrific truth from her father behind his coldness towards her. The father, Harry, related to Polly how much his late, mother-in-law disliked Harry and never wanted her daughter to marry him, even though both families are Jewish. In return, Harry despised his mother-in-law. When Polly was born and grew up, she reminded Harry of his despised, late mother-in-law. As a result, Harry felt similar emotions towards his own daughter and could not love her. Polly was the innocent victim of two people's deep animus towards each other. At the end of the movie, Harry tells Polly that she will live at their home until he is no longer legally responsible for her. That means age 18, after high school. Then Polly will have to leave home forever. Your heart really goes out to Polly. You want to hate the father, Harry, as a real bast**d, but somehow you feel a twinge of understanding for his mindset. What if the mother-in-law had liked Harry a lot? Some husbands are lucky like that. Polly's life would have been radically different.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Found a blooper
borisratnik21 March 2006
I did not read the original book, so I can't say if the movie stuck to it or not, but I'm always looking for continuity bloopers in films. Every movie has at least one, and it's fun to look for them.

Here's a blooper for you: when Anton decides not to escape on the freight train and he is surprised by Patty, there is a scene where they stand facing each other while the train passes by in the background. Just for a moment, on one of the freight cars, a plaque, about 1 foot by 2 feet, is visible. On it is a series of colored horizontal lines of varying lengths. This plaque is actually a laser-readable bar code, which contains the serial number of the freight car, its dimensions and capacities, and the name of the railroad it belongs to. A laser would read each plaque as the train rolled past a freight-yard checkpoint.

These plaques were invented by IBM in the late 'sixties and were introduced in 1970. They are the ancestors of the Universal Product Code, the bar codes we all know and love today, introduced in 1974.

But, this movie is set in 1943 or 1944. Oops!
0 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
People like to kill Nazi's, Nazi's like to kill people! So that is why you don't wanna see this movie
colin-4132 June 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I was forced to read this sappy "love story" between a German 24 year old POW and a 12 year old Jew. That has "political correctness" written all over it. Its kind of like the movie "SPIRIT" in which a horse wants to be free but those "evil" Americans wont let it because they need it. Well i have good news the Americans are "evil" in The German soldier and his summer book. Why!!! Horses where given to us by god and if the Americans needed a horse the can darn well use it. In the same sense the German had been trying to kill Americans, but this book/movie makes it seem OK! The casting is absolutely awful!!!!!!!!!!!! The girl is Hispanic the mother is white the dad it probubly from mostly white descent and the little sister is "shirley templish." The acting is pretty bad too, the serious parts become comedy! Concluson-Bad movie, bad book, but both have different endings, don't read or see either one!
1 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Simply Remarkable!
amost197216 January 2021
I will always have a special place in my heart for James Noble as Gov. Gaitlin on "Benson", and for Sonny Shroyer as Deputy Enos Strate on 'The Dukes of Hazzard".

Buckle up Now- You will love this classic film! I first saw this film in 1982, which was shown by our 5th grade teacher Mrs. Northrup, at Lawton Elementary School in Ann Arbor, Michigan- I knew that she really loved me! I loved her a lot too!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed