Pina Colada

1/19/2024

I stopped by the bar for a Pina Colada, and got a tiny cup of rum and softserve frozen mix for $14. Really overpriced and unimpressive. Shout out to the patrons who hang out on the beach.

8/23/2023

We've always come here for lunch but never dinner. We will now always do dinner here, it was fantastic. Our server was wonderful. She didn't rush us and always came back to check on us in a reasonable amount of time. For appetizers we ordered the coconut shrimp(probably the best we've had) and a side Caesar salad. We had the key lime margarita and a Pina colada, both tasty. We both ordered the surf and turf, me picking the scallops and my husband choosing the lobster tail. The filet was cooked to perfection along with tasting amazing! And of course the open air dining room with the wind flowing through is a nice touch.

4/29/2023

Had the tacos with a LARGE piña colada. Perfect place for whale watching. Restaurant is right on the beach. Breezy and sunny. Service was good, location excellent. Beach goers between us and the water. RBTL.

9/25/2022

I decided to take a quick trip to Key West today. As I was walking around after going to the Southernmost bouie, I stopped for a drink on the corner and got to chatting with the server, she suggested Southernmost Cafe for a good lunch.

It is right on the beach, and I don't know what the smell was but it was pretty funky. Seaweed? It wasn't as bad on the patio but you could still definitely smell it.

The restaurant was all open, roosters and birds walking in, which is funny. There was a gentleman who had a water gun and was trying to keep them at bay.

I ordered a pina colada which was tasty and have the deck hand. It was a fresh cut of fish which I had blackened, was served with a unique coleslaw and a scoop of rice.  It was good. I particularly liked the coleslaw.

The server was nice enough and had good follow-up.  Meal was satisfying.

7/22/2021

This cute cafe is next to the Southernmost Mansion, which is also by the Southernmost buoy. You first see the host and they will seat you right in front of the ocean water. It is a pretty view and the weather is sunny with a nice breeze. We ordered water, sodas, a mojito, and a piña colada. We didn't order any food but the menu has a variety of things to choose from. I saw there was pizza, salads, and soup just to name a few. Also, to use a restroom, you have to walk up the stairs to the mansion and make a right. There is one stall per restrooms for women and men. Overall, it is a good lunch spot for family and friends.

5/3/2021

Their smoked fish dip is a top 10 best food I've ever had. Have been trying to find something comparable in the past few years of other FL trips, and we will likely come back to Key West to sit and enjoy this dip (and pina coladas) again!

3/2/2021

Food was delicious, great portions. Drinks were also amazing. Frozen Pina coladas were so refreshing. Clean atmosphere and friendly staff. I would highly recommend it!!!

7/7/2020

Visited Southernmost Beach Cafe late on a Saturday morning for brunch. I sat in a covered but open air space, chickens & pigeons roamed around like they owned the place. The hostess was brash but our server was excellent. The cafe is oceanside, so there's a beautiful view of the beach while dining. My beverage my choice was the Sunkist 13 - a frozen concoction of Pina Colada, Mango & strawberry daiquiri. It was an overly sweet mix & a good way to start the day. For eats I had the blackened Yellowtail Snapper tacos & fries. The tacos were tasty &  served on corn tortillas The fries were warm, perfectly salted & very good. I'm glad my Mom recommended this spot, it was a wonderful experience.

6/24/2020

Such a cute spot along the water. Food was amazing. Truly the best mojito I've had. Perfect amount of mint and rum. Also had a piña colada which was very beachy. Great location and easy to find parking. Staff was exceptional! Definitely a must try!

11/12/2019

Okay so the only reason I came here for dinner is because I'm a reality TV junkie and remembered that the cast of Bravo's Southern Charm (Charleston) stayed here. The cafe is outdoors but with a roof and even though it was nighttime I could tell that the property was beautiful. We had views of their private beach which looked nicer than some of the other hotel's beaches. I would say the ambiance is better than  the food. It seemed like everything I asked for, I received the opposite. I ordered the Miami Vice (strawberry daquiri with pina colada) and was asked if I wanted an extra shot of rum in it. I declined. My drink was brought out and the waiter told me I was special (tis true, haha) so it had the extra shot in it, which was generous but then it tasted just like rum instead of the other flavors. I ordered conch chowder and a tomato burrata salad and asked for the salad first. I was immediately served the chowder. It was more of a vegetable soup than the cream based chowder I expected but good thing it was spicy because that made it tastier. My salad would have been better if I had been able to salt it but since there was none on the table I thought it might be rude to ask since I've heard that some restaurants purposefully don't provide salt and pepper because they believe the food doesn't need additional seasoning. I had a wonderful tomato burrata the previous day at Bagatelle which was served with a pesto that elevated it. I also asked for a napkin and didn't receive it. So the food was okay but besides the beach there were some cool photo ops nearby such as a giant adirondack chair and a wave crashing on a low painted blue wall.

8/27/2018

Visited this Saturday night for dinner with a group of eight. Were seated right next to the beach on a most beautiful Key West evening. The restaurant has a big patio style are for seating and it is next to a beach that has a small pier. Lots of people walking over to take pictures.

The server was fast and friendly. Explained to us the specials of the day and put in our drink orders right away. The drinks were brought by another server and our waters were refilled by someone else. I had the Piña Colada (Cafe Colada) and it was delicious. My wife had the Mango Mojito and that was also very delicious.

For dinner my wife and I split the Fried Chicken which came with loaded mash potatoes, corn on the cob and we added a side of the Lobster Mac and Cheese. The chicken was very tender and perfectly fried in the outside. I believe that it was cooked Sous Vide style before frying because the tenderness and cooking was perfect. I loved it. The potatoes were good but the Lobster Mac and Cheese was completely amazing. Super creamy and good amount of lobster in it.

Overall, I had a really good experience here and their portions are not small at all. Service was excellent and I will definitely visit again next time I'm in Key West.

4/1/2018

We had some drinks at this Café. I ordered a Mango Mojito and a Key West Pina Colada for my girlfriend. The drinks where 3,5/4 out av 5 in taste. We really enjoyed it since we could bring them to the beach without any problem at all. Great location!

6/28/2017

After venturing to the southernmost point marker in Key West, a friend mentioned that we should meet him for drinks at this cute little cafe.  It was located at the very end of Duval and South Street and had beautiful views of the ocean.  There parking for vehicles (paid parking), bikes, and mopeds, but I will say that walking was the best decision for us.

Upon entering, there's a Starbucks where you can order your normal coffee and whatnot but that wasn't what I came for so we headed straight to the bar for some good drinks and a good time.  We took our seats at the bar and had a beautiful view of the ocean.  The place wasn't super loud and had a real laid back vibe.  

The bartender took our order quick and I had a Miami Vice (a pina colada and strawberry daiquiri mixture) and my husband had a few beers.  I liked that the staff made us feel very welcomed, didn't rush us, the prices weren't super expensive, and told they us about how much they love living here and some of their places to eat and venture out to.  

They do serve food and everything they had on the menu looked good but I didn't order any food.  I was there purely for the views of the water and for laughs and I got both!

3/31/2017

Service was horrible. Best piña colada?! That would require it to be frozen - mine was more like a melted 7-11 milky slushy. Severely over priced dinner. The only thing I'd come back here fore would be the view.

12/13/2016

Good food. Came here for lunch. Got key lime Pina colada and Catch BLT wrap with seasoned fries. Food was good. View is great from the cafe.  Key lime Pina colada was really good.

7/29/2016

Last weekend I came to the beach with my family, I must say the staff is very friendly and attentive. Asked for towels for the chairs I rented and was given to me. The mojitos and piña coladas wore good. The bar tender was on point every time I came up to him. Got a couple drinks and ordered food. This is my second time coming and it has been awesome.

5/24/2016

Great food and drinks.  The short rib BLT is amazing and their breakfast corned beef hash is the best I've ever had.  Location is right on the beach, pina coladas are very good.

5/23/2016

Best beach cafe on the island...I recommend the shark bites and the coconut shrimp! And the pina coladas!!

3/18/2016

This place is a MUST if you're in key west! They have awesome food and drinks. I had the key lime Pina colada and the Bloody Mary. For breakfast I had the breakfast tacos and they were delicious. Everyone at my table was happy with their food. Our server was awesome as well. The restaurant overlooks the water and has a cute little beach.

12/30/2015

Great food and location, only one detail:
I ordered the fish sandwich with pasta salad as side and was not disappointed. My only comment/concern is that I asked if the pina colada had any dairy as I am lactose intolerant and the waitress at first confirmed It didn't, but after I asked her to double check the information she said it did contain dairy. In this case it was  fine but I thinks staff should be better trained to work with allergies and intolerances