The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West
Mr. Z's -Old Town is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

1. Mr. Z's -Old Town

7.5
501 Southard St (at Duval St.), Key West, FL
Pizzeria · 57 tips and reviews

Ben G.Ben Guzman: Cheesesteak with onions, mushrooms, and whiz is great!

Bryan K.Bryan Kihlmire: If your getting a cheesesteak, the cheese fries are a must as well!!!

Michael F.Michael Fenner: Best cheesesteaks on the island. Try the cheesesteaks or pizzasteak. Everything here is amazing. Hit it up on your walk home from duval for even better results.

Caroline's Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

2. Caroline's Cafe

8.4
310 Duval St (at Caroline St), Key West, FL
American Restaurant · 98 tips and reviews

Don B.Don Becker: Best cheese steak outside of Philly.

Jenn T.Jenn Tofanelli: Lettuce wrap salad. Or order the cheese steak except with chicken. Super delish. And fantastic people watching.

Candace D.Candace Datz: Randall is the best server on Duval. And the shrimp po' boy is awesome.

Dante's is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

3. Dante's

8.0
955 Caroline St, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 50 tips and reviews

TammyTammy: BBQ Quesadilla and Cheesesteak are excellent!

Richard N.Richard Noble: Amazing shrimp poboy! Great prices, huge portions

Cathy B.Cathy Belcher: Great for lunch and drinks by the pool!

Half Shell Raw Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

4. Half Shell Raw Bar

8.3
231 Margaret St, Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 106 tips and reviews

ᴡ R.ᴡ Richardson: Best oyster shooters and oyster po' boys . . . . . Get the po' boy classic (with cole slaw and Munster cheese). Best in town for over 20 years!

Beth C.Beth Conley: Lobster Po Boy and oysters are great, the view is amazing..

Chris R.Chris Requena: Best place in Key West for excellent, reasonably priced oysters!

Fogarty's and Flying Monkey's is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

5. Fogarty's and Flying Monkey's

8.0
227 Duval St (at Caroline St), Key West, FL
Cocktail Bar · 145 tips and reviews

Jayson M.Jayson Mullen: shrimp po boy is TO DIE FOR

Jim E.Jim Eldridge: Best Frozen drinks. Good food too. I had the turkey club. Tasty and I could substitute salad for fries.

Natalie G.Natalie Guerra-Valdes: Great shrimp po boy. Conch fritters leave a lot to be desired. Go to Conch Shack for the best conch fritters - just 2 blocks away

Publix is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

6. Publix

8.0
3316 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Grocery Store · 16 tips and reviews

Chelsea M.Chelsea Montagu: Public subs are the bomb!!!!!!!!!

Damon B.Damon B: Freshly made sandwiches to order. Great service

Johnny ♍ O.Johnny ♍ Ortiz: getting dog food i like publix better......................

Roostica Wood-Fire Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

7. Roostica Wood-Fire Pizzeria

8.5
5620 Macdonald Ave., Key West, FL
Pizzeria · 22 tips and reviews

William J.William Jamar: Italian Grinder was great. Sausage, Egg and Cheese breakfast was great also.

Geanne B.Geanne Bowman: What a treat! Delicious, fresh food. The pizza crust is hand tossed in the open cucina(kitchen) . Salads were great too.

Amélia S.Amélia Santos: Such a cool pizzeria, great service, delicious pizza and burrata!

Mr. Z's -New Town is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

8. Mr. Z's -New Town

7.2
2798 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Pizzeria · 6 tips and reviews

Marilyn ManHoeMarilyn ManHoe: You want a Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak, and you NEED an order of Cheese Fries.

Jennifer R.Jennifer Russo: Best Philly cheesesteak sandwich outside of Philly that you can get in my opinion - and I've have ones from Philly! Oh and the cheese fries are amaze balls

Monique M.Monique Melton: Everything is killer here!

Denny's is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

9. Denny's

8.7
2710 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Breakfast Spot · 2 tips and reviews

Ghaida✨Ghaida✨: Strawberry fried pancake was awesome!

DilekDilek: A classic diner with good food

Cuban Coffee Queen is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

10. Cuban Coffee Queen

9.1
284 Margaret St, Key West, FL
Coffee Shop · 73 tips and reviews

C H.C H: Best iced Cuban coffee in Key West old town

Kate Z.Kate Zimmer: Great breakfast sandwiches & coffee. Iced coffee is made with coffee ice cubes = no watered down caffeine.

Magdalena S.Magdalena Soto: Cuban Queen Mix Sandwich is massive enough for two people to share! good service... and cafe cubano!

The Sandbar Sports Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

11. The Sandbar Sports Grill

8.2
511 Greene Street, Key West, FL
Sports Bar · 6 tips and reviews

Eric A.Eric Andersen: The “Joey Style” wings are a fantastic blend of sweet and spicy, definitely my pick on the menu

Molly S.Molly Smith: Loved this spot! Try the lobster Mac and cheese along with a hurricane! If Chili Dawg is performing live music this is a must stop at in Key West!

Chad W.Chad Wise: If the food was any better... It would still be pretty mediocre 🙄

Pinchers Crab Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

12. Pinchers Crab Shack

6.9
712 Duval St (btwn Angela St & Dupree Alley), Key West, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 44 tips and reviews

Michael E.Michael Ellis: Poboys (oyster) are delicious. Had 2 for the price of 1 draft beer. Good service

Silvia R.Silvia Rocha: Shrimp scampi wonderful! Perfect!

Eli G.Eli Gomez: Everything about this place is great. We got the cheese and crab dip as an app-- delicious. We split the crab roll for a main dish. Ah-mazing! Free parking in the back!

Goldman's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

13. Goldman's Deli

8.2
2814 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL
Deli · 15 tips and reviews

Chelsea S.Chelsea Sawaya: Cute little diner with great service and even better bagels!

arzu k.arzu kucuktalay: Best breakfast!!!

Nico B.Nico Benedetti: Best bagels on the island.

Harpoon Harry's Restaurant and Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

14. Harpoon Harry's Restaurant and Bar

8.3
832 Caroline St, Key West, FL
Diner · 43 tips and reviews

Michael B.Michael B: Bloody mary, the lobster and crab omelet was excellent.

Chris T.Chris Torralba: Jon Stroz is a jerk!

Chad N.Chad Newman: For breakfast, the 2-2-2 special can't be beat. Great price and it will fill you up.

Ana's Cuban Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Sub Sandwiches in Key West.

15. Ana's Cuban Cafe

8.2
1330 Simonton St, Key West, FL
Cuban Restaurant · 18 tips and reviews

Aleksandra A.Aleksandra Arcipowska: what a wonderful spot. coconut water. great smoothies and cuban specialties!

Ross H.Ross H.: Best banana milkshake EVER!!!

Sharky G.Sharky Griffith: Anything you get here is wonderful and fresh.