'Bad Teacher' review: Funnier than the film
SF Gate LogoHearst Newspapers Logo

'Bad Teacher' review: Funnier than the film

By
"Pilot" -- Ari Graynor on the set of the CBS pilot BAD TEACHER scheduled to air on the CBS Television Network.
"Pilot" -- Ari Graynor on the set of the CBS pilot BAD TEACHER scheduled to air on the CBS Television Network.Sonja Flemming/CBS

ALERT VIEWER

Bad Teacher: Sitcom, 9:30 p.m. Thursday on CBS.

If there's one thing the new CBS sitcom "Bad Teacher" proves, it's that you can't keep a bad thing down.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

The sitcom is based on the 2011 film starring Cameron Diaz (also one of the sitcom's producers) as a gold-digging teacher from hell.

The film followed the "bad" template set by "Bad Santa" and continued more recently by "Bad Grandpa," but wasn't as funny as it could have been. The sitcom is funnier than the film, perhaps because it's working in a smaller time frame but also because many of the performances are winning.

The setup is that a buxom "trophy wife" named Meredith Davis (Ari Graynor) learns after her divorce from her rich, cheating husband that she's not getting any of his money because of a prenup. Naturally, the news prompts her to get a job as a teacher in order to meet rich, single dads so she can continue the lifestyle to which she's become accustomed.

She's completely unqualified for the job, but is hired anyway after manipulatively sympathizing with Principal Carl Gaines (David Alan Grier) about his recent divorce.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

She makes a splash on her first day both in the hallways and in the teachers' lounge, earning the immediate enmity of prim, by-the-book veteran history teacher Ginny (Kristin Davis), slavish admiration from frumpy biology teacher Irene (Sara Gilbert) and a reminder from gym teacher Joel (Ryan Hansen) that they went to high school together and that he may have been one of the few guys she didn't hook up with.

At every turn, Meredith's plan to land a hunky meal ticket is short-circuited by her inner warmth and concern for the underdog - particularly a friend's stepdaughter, Lily (Sara Rodier), too smart to be treated with respect by the school "mean girls."

Lily isn't alone. She is among several girls who would be targeted by the popular set even if they weren't members of the school safety patrol and forced to wear unflattering neon yellow safety vests.

The show has its funny moments, and the cast is pretty good, especially the younger actors. In addition to Rodier as a kind of flesh-and-blood Lisa Simpson, Grace Kaufman does a superb job as Bronwen, the daughter of a wealthy real estate mogul who wants to date Meredith but only if his daughter approves. She does not, to put it mildly.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Kristin Davis is quite good but underutilized here. Ginny knows Meredith is a phony, and that knowledge, not to mention the resentment she feels toward her, should provide more laughs than it does. There are a few moments that promise better interplay between the two characters in future episodes.

The show, created by Hilary Winston, is at its best when teacher really is "bad." At those moments, it approaches a wicked, and wickedly funny, level of satire. As you might expect, though, every episode ends with a warm and fuzzy moment - well, as warm and fuzzy as the "Bad Teacher" can be.

Bottom line: It's not as "bad" as the movie and that's pretty good, but if it was more bad, it could be better. Get it? Good.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

David Wiegand is The San Francisco Chronicle's executive features editor and TV critic. E-mail: dwiegand@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @WaitWhat_TV

David Wiegand is an assistant managing editor and TV critic for the San Francisco Chronicle. A native of Rochester, N.Y., he holds a bachelor's degree in English and a master's in journalism from American University in Washington, D.C.

He joined The Chronicle in 1992 as a copy editor with the arts section and became entertainment editor in 1995 and executive features editor in 2006. He took on the job of television critic in 2010, writing regular TV reviews and columns not only for The Chronicle but for other papers in the Hearst chain.

Before The Chronicle, he was managing editor of Dole Newspapers in Somerville, Mass., and editor of the Amesbury (Mass.) News.