Alabama honors the 3 Black women whose bodies were subjected to experimental surgery with a statue called the "Mothers of Gynecology" | Lipstick Alley

Alabama honors the 3 Black women whose bodies were subjected to experimental surgery with a statue called the "Mothers of Gynecology"

Freja

Team Owner
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
111,808
Solutions
3
Reaction score
Reactions
659,504 275,048 8,224
767,793
Alleybux
659,800
Z625V6RX45EZ3APV3XTFFDJXK4.jpg


Alabama Honors 3 Black Women Whose Bodies Were Subjected to Experimental Surgery​

The three enslaved women, who were victims of famed gynecologist Dr. J. Marion Sims, are immortalized in a statue called the "Mothers of Gynecology."


If you make it to Montgomery, Ala., you’ll want to pay a visit to the state’s newest monument dedicated to three Black women whose bodies were experimented on by a 19th century doctor best known for advancing women’s health.

Anarcha, Lucy and Betsey, the names of the three statues that represent the “Mothers of Gynecology,” were unveiled Friday. They represent three of the women Dr. J. Marion Sims operated on while in Montgomery, the Associated Press reports. The three statues stand almost 15 feet high and were made from common metal items—including tools, bicycle parts, and surgical and gynecological instruments—which were donated to the project.

“The endeavor is to change the narrative as it relates to the history and how it’s portrayed regarding Sims and the women that were used as experiments,” said Michelle Browder, the artist who created the monument. “They’re not mentioned in any of the iconography or the information, the markers.”

Sims is considered to be a pioneer in the field of gynecology and credited with developing medical devices and a surgical technique to treat a complication of childbirth. His dirty work came when he conducted experimental surgery without anesthesia on enslaved Black American women between 1845 and 1849.

Keep in mind that anesthesia was pretty new at the time. The first public demonstration using ether was in Boston in 1846. We have long known that Black bodies have been used for medical experimentation (think the Tuskegee experiments and Henrietta Lacks), but the unveiling of this monument shows us we may never know how many Black women were abused for the sake of advancing science.


Many of the Black women Sims operated on are not known. In 2018, New York City officials voted to remove a bronze star of the famed doctor in Central Park and moved it to Brooklyn’s Green-Wood Cemetery, where Sims is buried.

That said, you can find a statue of Sims at the Alabama State House in Montgomery.

“No one talks about these women and their sacrifices and the experimentations that they suffered,” Browder said. “And so I feel that if you’re going to tell the truth about this history, we need to tell it all.”

FPFK7JI62NB7PAKZRY6ORP5LEY.jpg



MichelleBrowder.jpg

Michelle Browder
 
Last edited:

cuteNcranky

General Manager
Joined
Dec 31, 2019
Messages
2,636
Reaction score
Reactions
31,842 980 293
33,922
Alleybux
47,927
i hate that America just gets to wait a generation for the abused and inflicted to die and forget, and poof ... absolution.

edit: typo.
 
Last edited:

leesalisa

Starter
Joined
Jan 30, 2008
Messages
465
Reaction score
Reactions
1,290 14 2
1,287
Alleybux
19,565
They're not even human. Just a bunch of parts. Look like robots. This is disturbing.

They're not even whole. They have no arms and no feet.

I agree and I think that’s what the artist is trying to capture here. In the eyes of this particular white man, black women were less than others. He simply viewed/used us as machines to help himself.
 

Soul2Soul

Team Owner
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
5,464
Reaction score
Reactions
36,913 2,179 529
43,096
Alleybux
235,460
I agree and I think that’s what the artist is trying to capture here. In the eyes of this particular white man, black women were less than others. He simply viewed/used us as machines to help himself.

I get it, but I don't like it. I think their faces need to be seen for once in their life.
 

GrandMarquis

Grand LeMarquis Noir
Joined
Aug 22, 2020
Messages
32,607
Solutions
1
Reaction score
Reactions
164,428 14,621 9,658
161,782
Alleybux
165,174
if you have ever been to the slavery museum in Montgomery you'd understand how this is far better exhibit and a step in the right direction.

i was so appalled by the narrative in that museum bc it was an exploitative exhibit. it was eerie and corny at the same time with no accountability on the side of white slaveholders and the racism white people inflicted.

I walked around waiting to see if they would put on blast the names of the white people who were in the pictures and the stories but it was conveniently left out.

these statutes reflect how we were treated as Black people to this day, either we are magic negros or subhuman creatures. this display manifests both.

may his name be remembered in infamy and these women be revered and celebrated for their contributions to modern day science like Henrietta Lacks.

you'd think after all the contributions directly to medical science, doctors would at least be more compassionate towards us especially BW.
 

Jackalope

Starter
BANNED
Joined
Sep 27, 2021
Messages
274
Reaction score
Reactions
620 283 681
-61
Alleybux
0
if you have ever been to the slavery museum in Montgomery you'd understand how this is far better exhibit and a step in the right direction.

i was so appalled by the narrative in that museum bc it was an exploitative exhibit. it was eerie and corny at the same time with no accountability on the side of white slaveholders and the racism white people inflicted.

I walked around waiting to see if they would put on blast the names of the white people who were in the pictures and the stories but it was conveniently left out.

these statutes reflect how we were treated as Black people to this day, either we are magic negros or subhuman creatures. this display manifests both.

may his name be remembered in infamy and these women be revered and celebrated for their contributions to modern day science like Henrietta Lacks.

you'd think after all the contributions directly to medical science, doctors would at least be more compassionate towards us especially BW.
Never forget.

Also why can't I add reactions to people's posts?
 

Mikyoko

Food Alchemist
Joined
Sep 17, 2019
Messages
3,118
Reaction score
Reactions
34,370 1,893 1,452
34,662
Alleybux
348,342
I love the direction of the sculpture. The medical system has failed so many. I see why people don’t even want to step foot into a hospital.
 
Joined
Apr 27, 2021
Messages
647
Reaction score
Reactions
5,107 144 2
5,105
Alleybux
0
The man was another Joseph Mengele type, using those he thought beneath him as lab rats. It still happens. I like that the statue draws attention to it. I shudder to think what those women went through.
 

dazzling killjoy

They don’t mean dick to me
Joined
Jul 13, 2019
Messages
9,141
Reaction score
Reactions
54,865 2,085 1,245
58,486
Alleybux
192,600
I like that they are named as mothers. (TRAs crying, in 5...4...3...2...)
But they should have done better by these women. I really do not care that they were memorialized not as women, but in the pov of the evil doctor. They were robbed of their humanity in life, must they also be robbed after? Unfair.
 

spoiledwater

Proud Elder Millennial
Joined
Mar 2, 2010
Messages
44,195
Reaction score
Reactions
540,081 16,194 6,471
596,277
Alleybux
1,298,384
It's a good art piece. Because it sparks interest/debate.

If they looked normal, it would be easy to breeze past this exhibit, without asking what happened here.
 

TI1067

Devonah Blackwell, The New, Hidden Tuskegee
Joined
Sep 12, 2020
Messages
3,338
Reaction score
Reactions
16,102 1,103 428
15,928
Alleybux
606,150
Z625V6RX45EZ3APV3XTFFDJXK4.jpg


Alabama Honors 3 Black Women Whose Bodies Were Subjected to Experimental Surgery​

The three enslaved women, who were victims of famed gynecologist Dr. J. Marion Sims, are immortalized in a statue called the "Mothers of Gynecology."


If you make it to Montgomery, Ala., you’ll want to pay a visit to the state’s newest monument dedicated to three Black women whose bodies were experimented on by a 19th century doctor best known for advancing women’s health.

Anarcha, Lucy and Betsey, the names of the three statues that represent the “Mothers of Gynecology,” were unveiled Friday. They represent three of the women Dr. J. Marion Sims operated on while in Montgomery, the Associated Press reports. The three statues stand almost 15 feet high and were made from common metal items—including tools, bicycle parts, and surgical and gynecological instruments—which were donated to the project.

“The endeavor is to change the narrative as it relates to the history and how it’s portrayed regarding Sims and the women that were used as experiments,” said Michelle Browder, the artist who created the monument. “They’re not mentioned in any of the iconography or the information, the markers.”

Sims is considered to be a pioneer in the field of gynecology and credited with developing medical devices and a surgical technique to treat a complication of childbirth. His dirty work came when he conducted experimental surgery without anesthesia on enslaved Black American women between 1845 and 1849.

Keep in mind that anesthesia was pretty new at the time. The first public demonstration using ether was in Boston in 1846. We have long known that Black bodies have been used for medical experimentation (think the Tuskegee experiments and Henrietta Lacks), but the unveiling of this monument shows us we may never know how many Black women were abused for the sake of advancing science.


Many of the Black women Sims operated on are not known. In 2018, New York City officials voted to remove a bronze star of the famed doctor in Central Park and moved it to Brooklyn’s Green-Wood Cemetery, where Sims is buried.

That said, you can find a statue of Sims at the Alabama State House in Montgomery.

“No one talks about these women and their sacrifices and the experimentations that they suffered,” Browder said. “And so I feel that if you’re going to tell the truth about this history, we need to tell it all.”

FPFK7JI62NB7PAKZRY6ORP5LEY.jpg



MichelleBrowder.jpg

Michelle Browder
As a black woman & TI currently being used as an involuntary human guinea pig--illegally & without consent, I say fµck a statue!! Run me my money/financial compensation owed to me. .
 

lovingme

General Manager
Joined
Feb 5, 2013
Messages
4,023
Reaction score
Reactions
19,463 390 173
23,653
Alleybux
320,840
I didn't read the article, just the headline. But ? @ them trying to romanticize using black women's bodies for experimental surgery. This is bµllsh!t.
 

enchanted

Fall is Beautiful
OLDHEAD
Joined
Feb 10, 2006
Messages
88,076
Reaction score
Reactions
345,873 13,203 10,054
377,407
Alleybux
2
Just like Nazi sadist Josef Mengele, this man enjoyed hearing the women's screams. He was a sadistic brute disguised as a "doctor".
 

liquid alloy

General Manager
Joined
Jan 22, 2020
Messages
3,215
Reaction score
Reactions
22,962 536 100
25,293
Alleybux
354,172
His dirty work came when he conducted experimental surgery without anesthesia on enslaved Black American women between 1845 and 1849.

Truly horrifying. Those of us who've had exams and surgeries can explain how invasive, uncomfortably and scary the experience can be...now to add to what those women endured to get us to that point. Just wow.
 

Lalasizzahandsq1

Nailed it.
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Messages
1,572
Reaction score
Reactions
19,863 1,166 175
20,809
Alleybux
12,500
The statues are gorgeous. It’s a shame people don’t get Michelle’s artistic vision or the medium she uses. She uses scrap metal and different found/donated objects in all her work- it has nothing to do with viewing the women as less than. Ya’ll projecting.


Alabama artist looks to change the narrative with monument to 'mothers of gynecology'
Excerpt from Michelle’s interview about this piece:
TAS: I understand this is a layered piece that connects the conditions these women endured to modern disparities. Can you tell me about the concept of the monument and what it speaks to?
MB: I've created all types of imagery around painting, found objects. We have a statue that a friend of mine created, and we turned her into Anarcha, a Black woman looking up towards the heavens. It also depicts a sister circle because these women were sisters. They formed a sisterhood of suffering, where they would care for one another after these horrendous experimentations or experiments.Alabama artist looks to change the narrative with monument to 'mothers of gynecology'
 

daStampede

Anti-Black Mods' Favorite Target
Joined
Apr 20, 2012
Messages
32,316
Reaction score
Reactions
263,545 5,785 1,477
299,829
Alleybux
13,404
People can review the sculptures and still be moved emotionally and talk about what led to this. It's ok. The Mothers of Gynecology should make us have discussions and feel some type of way about how we were treated, how we are being treated/not treated today and how we can change that.

I welcome the debate that this causes and it's a painfully real statement to how Black Women are viewed. Parts and Tools and rarely a whole person.
 

wanderwoman

alleybuxstrugglelife
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
30,284
Solutions
3
Reaction score
Reactions
319,586 7,880 3,415
372,560
Alleybux
2,272,050
Yes, romanticized.

The horror is too deep for it to be simply sculpted away. It's "sweet" if you get what I mean. Maybe I'm leading with outrage but that's just how I feel.
I agree that was my take too. These women didn't birth gynecology, they were victims of it. The name feels problematic for me. In time will people know the full story or just the name.
 

isabella03

General Manager
Joined
Aug 28, 2021
Messages
1,415
Reaction score
Reactions
15,351 1,091 929
14,437
Alleybux
410
The statues are gorgeous. It’s a shame people don’t get Michelle’s artistic vision or the medium she uses. She uses scrap metal and different found/donated objects in all her work- it has nothing to do with viewing the women as less than. Ya’ll projecting.


Alabama artist looks to change the narrative with monument to 'mothers of gynecology'
Excerpt from Michelle’s interview about this piece:
TAS: I understand this is a layered piece that connects the conditions these women endured to modern disparities. Can you tell me about the concept of the monument and what it speaks to?
MB: I've created all types of imagery around painting, found objects. We have a statue that a friend of mine created, and we turned her into Anarcha, a Black woman looking up towards the heavens. It also depicts a sister circle because these women were sisters. They formed a sisterhood of suffering, where they would care for one another after these horrendous experimentations or experiments.Alabama artist looks to change the narrative with monument to 'mothers of gynecology'
I too love the statue. I see it as reminder of what happened to them, so history cannot forget what they have gone through. The message wouldn’t have through aswell with a simple statue.
 

Lalasizzahandsq1

Nailed it.
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Messages
1,572
Reaction score
Reactions
19,863 1,166 175
20,809
Alleybux
12,500
I agree that was my take too. These women didn't birth gynecology, they were victims of it. The name feels problematic for me. In time will people know the full story or just the name.
Yes, romanticized.

The horror is too deep for it to be simply sculpted away. It's "sweet" if you get what I mean. Maybe I'm leading with outrage but that's just how I feel.

Did ya’ll read the article? They are named the mothers because the “doctor” who experimented on them is named the father of gynecology. It’s literally placing credit where it is actually due. He never should’ve been given that title in the first place. They also moved Dr. Sims’ statue from downtown and relaced it with these women who were ignored by history. It’s all explained in the article. Nothing romanticized or sweet about it.
 

Jesuisvert91

Team Owner
Joined
Aug 23, 2021
Messages
10,443
Reaction score
Reactions
54,655 3,874 1,928
52,781
Alleybux
502,773
I don’t want statues. Ide much rather they educate people about this Travesty.

no.
 

Attachments

  • 6D463490-1844-4A9C-A8F3-C1D745CC8A20.gif
    6D463490-1844-4A9C-A8F3-C1D745CC8A20.gif
    292.7 KB · Views: 16

2phat

Pro BW
Joined
Oct 10, 2013
Messages
18,659
Reaction score
Reactions
117,601 5,996 4,740
123,950
Alleybux
534,918
Who is the artist? I like 3D art, and it looks good but not for this. I would've preferred to see them as the beautiful human women they were. A smooth, delicate and finely detailed statue like all of America's anti-heroes get (but better).
 

StrangeXdefault

Team Owner
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
41,253
Reaction score
Reactions
493,783 16,740 4,402
543,288
Alleybux
178,780
Z625V6RX45EZ3APV3XTFFDJXK4.jpg


Alabama Honors 3 Black Women Whose Bodies Were Subjected to Experimental Surgery​

The three enslaved women, who were victims of famed gynecologist Dr. J. Marion Sims, are immortalized in a statue called the "Mothers of Gynecology."


If you make it to Montgomery, Ala., you’ll want to pay a visit to the state’s newest monument dedicated to three Black women whose bodies were experimented on by a 19th century doctor best known for advancing women’s health.

Anarcha, Lucy and Betsey, the names of the three statues that represent the “Mothers of Gynecology,” were unveiled Friday. They represent three of the women Dr. J. Marion Sims operated on while in Montgomery, the Associated Press reports. The three statues stand almost 15 feet high and were made from common metal items—including tools, bicycle parts, and surgical and gynecological instruments—which were donated to the project.

“The endeavor is to change the narrative as it relates to the history and how it’s portrayed regarding Sims and the women that were used as experiments,” said Michelle Browder, the artist who created the monument. “They’re not mentioned in any of the iconography or the information, the markers.”

Sims is considered to be a pioneer in the field of gynecology and credited with developing medical devices and a surgical technique to treat a complication of childbirth. His dirty work came when he conducted experimental surgery without anesthesia on enslaved Black American women between 1845 and 1849.

Keep in mind that anesthesia was pretty new at the time. The first public demonstration using ether was in Boston in 1846. We have long known that Black bodies have been used for medical experimentation (think the Tuskegee experiments and Henrietta Lacks), but the unveiling of this monument shows us we may never know how many Black women were abused for the sake of advancing science.


Many of the Black women Sims operated on are not known. In 2018, New York City officials voted to remove a bronze star of the famed doctor in Central Park and moved it to Brooklyn’s Green-Wood Cemetery, where Sims is buried.

That said, you can find a statue of Sims at the Alabama State House in Montgomery.

“No one talks about these women and their sacrifices and the experimentations that they suffered,” Browder said. “And so I feel that if you’re going to tell the truth about this history, we need to tell it all.”

FPFK7JI62NB7PAKZRY6ORP5LEY.jpg



MichelleBrowder.jpg

Michelle Browder



This is highkey disrespectful


They aren't "mothers of Gynecology"... they were literally VICTIMS of Gynecology

But you know Black folks love to run away from the word as if it's shameful to be a victim of something and not an undisputed fact :eyeroll
 

froggyluv2

Team Owner
Joined
Dec 11, 2013
Messages
17,769
Reaction score
Reactions
114,516 5,608 5,179
110,890
Alleybux
337,136
They're not even human. Just a bunch of parts. Look like robots. This is disturbing.

They're not even whole. They have no arms and no feet.


It's art, that's the symbolism and the message----these women were not granted their full humanity, we don't even know their names or much about who they were beyond very stoic descriptions of their anatomy and footnotes of their actual person.

We honor who they were and their presence while also acknowledging the parsing of their humanity, the dissection of their womanhood all of which creates visual figures that take on an ephemeral visage that is almost akin to some of the spiritual totems created by some groups to evoke larger ideas of consciousness. In this case, that consciousness becomes representative of all black women and our experiences of denied humanity both during and after slavery as well as our inner divinity that remains intact despite the attempts by society to destroy and take.
 

wanderwoman

alleybuxstrugglelife
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
30,284
Solutions
3
Reaction score
Reactions
319,586 7,880 3,415
372,560
Alleybux
2,272,050
Did ya’ll read the article? They are named the mothers because the “doctor” who experimented on them is named the father of gynecology. It’s literally placing credit where it is actually due. He never should’ve been given that title in the first place. They also moved Dr. Sims’ statue from downtown and relaced it with these women who were ignored by history. It’s all explained in the article. Nothing romanticized or sweet about it.
I did read the article and you are entitled to your opinion. My opinion is the name is problematic and America has a history of watering down African American symbols like these.

Do people think of MLK as a radical today? No, but they should. Why don't they? Because his more radical messages have been largely ignored and all we've heard since his violent death has been his less controversial speeches and a "sanitized" version of his message.

America spent years after the Civil War, rehabilitating the image of the south and the confederacy before they went full bore into glorifying it with the KKK and the Daughters of the Confederacy.
 

wanderwoman

alleybuxstrugglelife
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
30,284
Solutions
3
Reaction score
Reactions
319,586 7,880 3,415
372,560
Alleybux
2,272,050
I'm glad I'm not the only one. I appreciate the sentiment, but something feels dehumanizing about them.
I think that's the point of the statue though. To show the legacy of black (women in the case) bodies being commoditized for white advancement and enrichment.
 

MooShoo2

I ain't stupid...
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
Reactions
12,629 955 72
14,445
Alleybux
1,295
Once again these women are objectified, all for allegedly art?

It would have been better to put the "doctor" in art form, and show him for the monstronsity that he was.

These women are put on display once again. Can they rest ever?
 

Similar Threads

News Alley

Top Bottom