Album of the Year 2015 #2: Björk - Vulnicura : r/indieheads Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/indieheads icon
r/indieheads icon
Go to indieheads
r/indieheads

Reddit’s largest community for alternative, experimental, independent, and underground music.


Members Online

Album of the Year 2015 #2: Björk - Vulnicura

Order in the court (of internet peers). Today's installment of our month-long Album of the Year 2015 series comes from our favorite Iceland fetishizing teenager u/staralfurs. She'll be writing about Björk's most recent album, Vulnicura. I've never posted one of these thing before so hopefully the formatting isn't too fucked up. But without further ado let's get into the writeup.


Artist: Björk

Album: Vulnicura


Listen:

YouTube

Spotify

Apple Music


Background by u/staralfurs

Björk Guðmundsdóttir has been making and releasing music since age 11. When her self-titled debut was released as per the recommendation of some music teachers, she was playing the piano and covering Stevie Wonder songs in Icelandic. By the 80s, she was a leader of punk groups and pop acts alike. Her first major project was The Sugarcubes, recording hits that managed to obtain a cult-like international following from 1986 to 1992. Once she forced the last Sugarcubes record out, she wanted to go solo, and she did this in a massive way. Her first two albums, Debut and Post, were innovative pop records that spawned even more success for Björk. After several harrowing episodes with a stalker fan (who eventually killed himself in 1996), she was forced to mature rapidly, a growth that is reflected in her discography. Her acclaimed electronic and trip-hop influenced Homogenic was released the next year, followed by multiple soundtracks and film appearances, the minimal Vespertine in 2001, the entirely acapella Medúla in 2004, freaky Afrobeat-inspired Volta in 2007, and National Geographic-sponsored Biophilia in 2011.

Now, in 2015, Björk has to mature in an entirely different context. While she previously had relationships with former Sugarcubes member Þór Eldon and electronic artist Goldie, her longest-lasting was with artist Matthew Barney. The relationship lasted for 13 years, until 2013 when they decided to break it off. Now, after years of a sort of Björk dry spell, she has released Vulnicura to the public. Originally set for a March physical release date, it was made available digitally in January when it leaked very soon after the announcement. The album, weaved together with production by Arca and The Haxan Cloak, is a harrowing chronological account of Björk and Barney’s split, and how she got over it.


Review by u/staralfurs

Breaking up is hard to do. Anybody knows it. Even Björk, who has been in multiple relationships in the past. But this is different. Her partner, her daughter’s father, was just not giving enough anymore. Over a decade was long enough. And if you’re Björk, you use that pain as motivation.

For this documentation, she did form a new relationship, and that was one between experimental producers Arca and The Haxan Cloak. Between these two were some of the most innovative electronic masterpieces of the decade so far, with connections to acts such as Kanye West, FKA twigs, and HEALTH, and their own solo projects. Now they’ve landed in Björk’s own world, one that was once filled with swan-themed attire, dancing cat boyfriends who wear suits, multi-colored pufferfish-esque wigs, and a fair bit of artistic nudity. This, of course, is right up their alley. All three of these artists are very similar in that they have their own completely unique and almost unsettling trademarks. Their three planets colliding seem nothing more than natural, not just an explosion.

The first six tracks of this album are labelled: nine months before, five months before, three months before, two months after, six months after, eleven months after. These songs catalog the year of pain leading up to and following her breakup. The beginning half, with “Stonemilker,” “Lionsong,” and “History of Touches,” are maybe some of the most pop-sensible tracks on this whole record, and rely heavily on a large string section that continues to make appearances throughout the record. They deal with the lack of feeling, the lack of intimacy, and the dramatic conclusion to this chapter of her life. Then, it all boils over, and needless to say, Björk is really pissed. “Black Lake,” “Family,” and “Notget” are emotional titans. At over 10 minutes, “Black Lake” is a sprawling documentation of the initial feelings proceeding the split with sporadic bursts of lyrical play, sounding almost like this songstress is having a real argument, and bringing up her points as she stops to catch her breath. As she progresses, these initial thoughts and doubts grow into pure anger and frustration, and the shattering climax begins.

The last three tracks, “Atom Dance,” “Mouth Mantra,” and “Quicksand,” are the only three that are not directly connected to the main issue of this album. Still, they manage to illustrate her thoughts just as well as any of the cuts before them. “Atom Dance” is a sweet duet with Antony Hegarty of Antony and the Johnsons about learning to open up to love and let past wounds heal. “Mouth Mantra,” originally written after Björk had vocal surgery and could not speak for nearly a month, uses the metaphors originally written to illustrate this struggle to explain an entirely different conflict. Being in a tumultuous relationship is like having your mouth sewn shut, and with time, you can find the strength to sing again. Finally, the skittering “Quicksand” closes this album with yet another set of word play that was written separately from the rest of the album. It still manages to sum up every major point of the record: she is broken, she is looking for something different for her and her daughter, and she wants to let go of her sorrows. Then, it abruptly ends, just like her former love.

Björk has just recently turned 50. Can a musician who has been working for nearly 35 years have a coming-of-age story at this point in their lives? How can something so drastic affect their music? Homogenic and the context surrounding the record’s release helped a Björk in her early 30s to become more mature, and Vulnicura almost does the same for this woman who should be slowing down, but shows absolutely no signs of doing so. Her sound is sharper and tighter than ever, her attitude is even stronger, and she is truly back at her peak for the first time in years. “Vulnicura” means “cure for wounds,” and anything that has ever scratched her soul is healed with this album’s release.

Matthew Barney and his high-profile relationship with her will definitely be remembered – as the driving force that made one of the most memorable albums in recent memory, and the thing that helped Björk win this battle with her past and with herself.


Favorite Lyrics by u/staralfurs

Is there a place

Where I can pay respects

For the death of my family?

  • Family

When we're broken we are whole

And when we're whole we're broken

  • Quicksand

These abstract complex feelings

I just don't know how to handle them

Should I throw oil on one of his moods

But which one?

The joy peak

Humor peak

Frustration peak

Anything peak

For clarity

  • Lionsong

Every single fuck

We had together

Is in a wondrous time lapse

With us here at this moment

The history of touches

Every single archive

Compressed into a second

All with us here as I wake you up

  • History of Touches

At last the view is fierce

All that matters is

Who is open chested

And who has coagulated

Who can share and

Who has shot down the chances?

  • Stonemilker


Talking Points

  • What is your favorite song/lyric?

  • Production wise, what was your favorite moment on this record?

  • Do the themes/lyrics here have a deep personal connection to you?

  • Do you think that Björk made the right decision in releasing this album early upon its sudden leak?

  • How do you think Barney feels about the release of this album?

  • What kind of impact do you feel that female indie/alternative artists and feminism had on music this year?

  • What do you think could be in store for Björk after this album’s phase is over?


Thanks for the write-up u/staralfurs. Tomorrow u/dankdadburrito will be writing about Beat the Champ or The Most Lamentable Tragedy. I'm not sure which because he's a flip-flopping motherfucker but I'll be back next Wednesday writing about one of MY favorite albums of 2015, Sleater-Kinney's No Cities To Love!

Archived post. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast.
Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options
u/staralfurs avatar

our favorite Iceland fetishizing teenager u/staralfurs

fucking incredible

u/Apotheosis91 avatar

Because I couldn't do this write-up myself I'm just going to answer all your questions in rapid succession.

  1. All of History of Touches. Also:

No one is a lover alone, most hearts fear their own home

2. The Arca synths around 1:30 of Notget is one of the most memorable musical moments of 2015 for me no question. I still giggle like an idiot whenever it happens.

3. This album dropped a few days after I had the first major fight of a then-budding relationship and the lyrics and tone were hugely relevant at the time, and caused me to pretty much instabond with this record. So yes.

4. Also yes. This album is wintery as fuck and if it got dropped in an already stuffed-to-the-brim March 2015 not many people would have given it the time it deserved, myself included.

5. He either fully supports Bjork in her quest for peak Bjorkness, or hasn't and will never listen to the album. I don't really blame him for that.

6. Huuuuuuge. This year was a banner year for women in music (thanks to Mother Bjork and Sister Sleater-Kinney's January blessings), and we got a lot of very important albums from female artists. Half Free, Deep In The Iris, Apocalypse Girl, and Me, just to name only a small handful.

7. Probably a five-year break followed by a meditation on raising her daughter as a now-single mother and possibly exploring a budding new relationship a-la Vespertine. I expect themes of motherhood and sexuality via very organic natural imagery, co-produced by the next up-and-coming boundary-pushing producer du jour. After which she will complete her transition from human to biological deity, and convert her body into a cloud of spores so that her life-energy may live through all of us for eternity. So you know, the usual.

u/squidwardsmellsgood avatar

I can't believe Bjork is 50 years old. Absolutely amazing that she can still release such quality material so many years into her career. Thanks for the review! I had yet to read into the backstory/context of the record, so I appreciate that you provided a little clarity. :DDD

u/ReconEG avatar

Also guys, here is the schedule for the upcoming AOTY write-ups! If you're on the schedule make sure you're getting your write-ups done or tell me ASAP if you can't!

u/ReconEG avatar

Oh thank God this is up

Anyways, this album is probably my second favorite of the year behind TPAB, and this album came out a little before a breakup of mine which I won't talk about as I've already done it enough. This album really helped me through those times as it displayed the big emotions that come with a breakup I was afraid to show.

I'll just answer some of the talking points like u/Apotheosis91 did:

1.) This is a tough one but I feel like I have to give the edge to "Lionsong" for it's pop approach, but still not holding back on the experimental mix of strings and Arca's experimental electronic production. Favorite lyric:

You fear my limitless emotions

I am bored of your apocalyptic obsessions

Did I love you too much

2.) When the beat drops and Antony really comes in on "Atom Dance" or that really weird violin drop in "Family"

3.) As I already mentioned, yes it did. I actually wrote part of my review for this album on a blog I used to write while at a Panera's with my ex.

4.) Yes, I think it was the right decision for an artist of her caliber. If the album leaked, what's the point of waiting to put it out digitally?

5.) Not happy, probably. There was something in the news a few months ago about him suing her for withholding their child from him, so for this album to take a biased stance instead of a more balanced one has to hurt a lot.

6.) I think we've seen a lot of albums from female indie/alternative artists tackling feminist themes, many of them succeeding like some of the examples u/Apotheosis91, but others failing like CHVRCHES or Grimes.

7.) I really do hope she'll continue to work with Arca and let the more experimental elements of his production shine, as his contributions added a lot to this project. But with Björk, we really won't know until her next album comes out.

u/willforthrill avatar

How would you say that CHVRCHES and Grimes failed at feminism?

u/ReconEG avatar

Well, not failing at feminism, but more or less presenting it musically. CHVRCHES in that they just made a pretty mediocre synth pop album with mostly vague lyrics I couldn't attach myself to, and Grimes in that she seemed to have no real focus of what she wanted her album to be. Dipped into many genres like bubblegum pop, k-pop, country, hip-hop, and synth pop but her aspirations were a little too high.

I really don't want to come off as saying Lauren Mayberry or Grimes are bad voices for feminism in music, as they both have been very vocal about the subject and are right a lot of the time, but I just didn't really care for their albums.

u/willforthrill avatar

That's fair. For me, feminism in art is more effective when it's practiced rather than preached. Nobody likes being lectured (which is what I feel like Lauren Mayberry of CHVRCHES does), but when artists like Björk or Sleater-Kinney or even Grimes just go out there and make kickass music without bringing attention to the fact that they are women, that speaks a lot more to me. Being progressive only means so much to me if you aren't actually making good music.

More replies
More replies
More replies
u/Maschine_Design avatar
Edited

Father, Mother, Child

I love Vulnicura, one of my top albums of the year. A return to form (though I was a fan of Biophilia) and strings! Oh the strings! What impresses me most is that the album is construction of naritive and track listing which reveals a triptych of triptychs. The first three tracks deal with Barney, the next three are all about Bjork and the final three are addressed to their child. This is replicated in the song Family, which itself is made up of three segments.

1
Stonemilker and Lionsong are venting frustration and realizing the relationship that was once so beautiful is now doomed. History is quite simply the obituary. All three are really concerned with Barney and his obsessions and his lack of interest in the relationship.

2
The next three songs deal with Bjork. Black Lake is a heart breaking song where Bjork is exposing her fresh wound for the world to see.

It is Family that really exposes the map of the album as it deals, in the same order, the three people involved in this broken relationship. The song opens with droning stings and a mantra about the triangle of love, clearly a reference to Barney. Then comes a vivid flurry of sharp strings, a concerning tone is taken, Bjork sings about how she will save her child from the danger of broken love. Finally the song opens up like sunshine, All Is Full Of Love style, as Bjork builds the bridge and starts the healing process for their child.

After the realization of the last song, Notget is Bjork finally letting out her anger towards Barney, but at the same time forgiving him. "If I regret us/I’m denying my soul to grow".

3
The final three songs could honestly be taken from Biophilia, if it weren't for the instrumentation. Atom Dance is so beautiful and sounds like a wonderful song for a mother to sing to their child, love is still a beautiful thing. The next, Mouth Mantra is a warning to not remain silent, and be strong. Quicksand is a bit harder to decipher, but the message seems to be about a link between mothers and their daughters.

[deleted]
[deleted]

u/willforthrill: I'm doing Beat the Champ, for your information. Also, I prefer sneakers so I'm not much of a "flip-flopping motherfucker."

u/staralfurs: Not much of a Björk fan, but good review either way.

u/staralfurs avatar

thank u sweet child

u/willforthrill avatar

Nah you flip-flopped

[deleted]
[deleted]

I flipped, but I haven't flopped. (yet)

u/willforthrill avatar

I actually hope that you do flop bc +@ forever

[deleted]
[deleted]

i love +@ but sometimes you need to build a legacy by beating the champ.

besides the monitor is still my favorite album of all time, i spent a week on the FYC for it

u/mutazed avatar

I love both bands but TMLT is way better then BTC. The Mountain goats have been on a steady decline since Get Lonley.

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
u/PlayerNo3 avatar

I remember listening to Stonemilker for the first time. I was not prepared for how heartbreaking it is.

u/Zachapi avatar

This album was announced and leaked a couple days after I had finished listening to her entire discography. It's a shame the leak messed up her plans for releasing it, but wow. I love this album to death. It also caused me to finally look into Arca's solo work. I'm still putting off the Haxan Cloak though. If so many releases weren't so goddamn impressive this year it would have been a strong AOTY contender and I still listen to it all the time.

i love this album. it also has a lot of nice memories for me because as i live in new york, i was able to get the full björk "experience" this spring with her exhibit at MoMA. not just the retrospective itself, but also the music videos: "black lake" in a theater that was made specifically to have the best sound quality, and i got to watch the "stonemilker" video twice with the oculus rift headset. and, when my sister and i went through the exhibit the first time, björk herself walked past us to check everything out, as we went on the second day it was open!!

also, i hope that this album did have a positive impact on feminism this year. björk is very vocal about her work in the studio and making sure that women are recognized for doing their own production, etc. there was even a blog made about this after a comment she made in an interview