南華早報: 《12怪盗》amateurish, nonsensical, boring,so awful - 娛樂台 - 香港高登討論區

南華早報: 《12怪盗》amateurish, nonsensical, boring,so awful

2024-03-29 10:11:34 建立時間 2024-03-30 11:31:33 最後回覆時間
44 回覆 7 正評 2 負評
2024-03-29 10:11:34
We 12 movie review: Cantopop boy band Mirror make group debut in a heist comedy so awful, it’s a litmus test of fandom

Witless, lifeless, amateurish, nonsensical and boring, this film starring all 12 members of Cantopop boy band Mirror is meant only for their most devoted fans

In a production meant to capitalise on the boy band’s immense popularity, the eccentric Yeung Wai-lun provides much of the little fun there is to be had

https://cdn.i-scmp.com/sites/default/files/styles/1200x800/public/d8/images/canvas/2024/03/28/0f8372ee-9512-4349-b494-d64c2e443504_4513521e.jpg?itok=0tX0QxOo&v=1711620581

1/5 stars

All 12 members of Hong Kong’s reigning Cantopop boy band Mirror star in a movie together for the very first time in We 12, an unabashedly hollow piece of fan service masquerading as a mainstream commercial feature made for general consumption.
In the past few years, the city’s faltering film business has occasionally been enlivened by the acting of several Mirror members, including Anson Lo Hon-ting (It Remains), Keung To (Mama’s Affair), Edan Lui Cheuk-on (Hong Kong Family), Anson Kong Ip-sang (Back Home) and Lokman Yeung (Mad Fate).

Sadly, their individual charisma is swept aside for this publicity exercise for the collective, which adopts an ill-advised, equal-opportunity approach to idol making: each member gets roughly the same screen time and all 12 of them enjoy top billing – their names are even listed in alphabetical order in the credits in case anyone’s feelings might be hurt.
2024-03-29 10:12:32
But noble intentions do not a good movie make. Playing like a heist comedy dreamed up by a five-year-old kid, this witless, lifeless bore of a film is so amateurishly conceived (by director Berry Ho Kwok-man and screenwriter Cheung Lai-sze), it makes last month’s The Moon Thieves – also starring Lui, Lo and Keung – look like a classic of the genre.

Professional due diligence dictates that this writer must begin to provide a plot synopsis sooner rather than later but, readers, that is frankly beside the point here.

Suffice to say that this nonsensical story involves 12 master thieves – played by, and named after, the Mirror members – who are given a rare group mission: to steal a world-threatening mosquito zapper at a science award ceremony held in a Hong Kong hotel, which is guarded by the evil security manager Johnny (Yeung Wai-lun).

The group’s secretive boss begins by declaring that these young men are sorely lacking team spirit – a quip on Mirror’s real-life activities – and this statement immediately raises another question in the viewers’ minds: why should these 12 be anywhere near a world-saving mission in the first place?

As another illustration of the scattershot nature of this mess, every protagonist has been supplied with a special ability, like “lock-picking”, “lip-reading” or “hypnosis”, although quite a few read like unintended jokes: “agility” and “strategic planning” being two, while the guy with “sixth sense” is lauded for being lucky.

https://cdn.i-scmp.com/sites/default/files/d8/images/canvas/2024/03/28/1caf443d-a52a-416a-9c15-b01c0b35c2d3_c8567dc8.jpg
2024-03-29 10:13:01
Ironically, if not unexpectedly, the effortlessly eccentric Yeung Wai-lun proves the funniest presence in a production meant solely to capitalise on the boy band’s immense popularity. The sweet Malaysian actress Lin Min-chen and members of fellow pop group Error also have diverting cameos, although this is undoubtedly Mirror’s show.

https://cdn.i-scmp.com/sites/default/files/d8/images/canvas/2024/03/28/aaf92eda-f290-40a7-a121-efe43d6f424f_741ac6ff.jpg
2024-03-29 10:25:08
So?https://upload.hkgolden.media/comment/tvjbqdyv.akwyq3jzy0p.o5as2s3hids.qtr.png
2024-03-29 10:41:42
So?https://upload.hkgolden.media/comment/tvjbqdyv.akwyq3jzy0p.o5as2s3hids.qtr.png

似大陸人,下下用錢撻人
2024-03-29 10:45:42
睇trailer 已經趕客啦,係咁loop d鏡粉話好睇hard sell
2024-03-29 11:01:27
套戲目的- 根本就係賺錢
冇咩好評
一個願打一個願捱

重點呢套戲, 可以睇得出
邊D影評係收錢, 邊D冇
2024-03-29 11:06:07
貼錢比我都唔會睇
2024-03-29 11:08:05
曾特首巴打,又會唔會笑?:-]bg
2024-03-29 12:19:09
睇trailer 已經趕客啦,係咁loop d鏡粉話好睇hard sell

本身套戲就係拍俾fans睇
人地講明「鏡式幽默」
咪即係玩inside joke, 自己人先至睇得明囉
咁關街客撚事

d街客又嘈嘈閉,都on9既
又唔係拍俾你地睇,咁多嗲[sosad] [sosad] [sosad]
就算佢地搞幾百場謝票場都唔關你地事啦[sosad]
因為人地根本就冇預你地班街客睇[sosad]
2024-03-29 12:36:11
又盜月者又12怪盜
短時間上兩套咁近似既戲
自己打自己之餘仲要好混亂
2024-03-29 12:49:10
睇trailer 已經趕客啦,係咁loop d鏡粉話好睇hard sell

本身套戲就係拍俾fans睇
人地講明「鏡式幽默」
咪即係玩inside joke, 自己人先至睇得明囉
咁關街客撚事

d街客又嘈嘈閉,都on9既
又唔係拍俾你地睇,咁多嗲[sosad] [sosad] [sosad]
就算佢地搞幾百場謝票場都唔關你地事啦[sosad]
因為人地根本就冇預你地班街客睇[sosad]


當然關我哋事
搞到其他戲少咗場次
2024-03-29 12:51:57
又盜月者又12怪盜
短時間上兩套咁近似既戲
自己打自己之餘仲要好混亂

公道D講,盜月者係拍得幾好,起碼我呢D街客會為左張繼聰,白只同edan入場睇先
2024-03-29 12:52:07
睇trailer 已經趕客啦,係咁loop d鏡粉話好睇hard sell

本身套戲就係拍俾fans睇
人地講明「鏡式幽默」
咪即係玩inside joke, 自己人先至睇得明囉
咁關街客撚事

d街客又嘈嘈閉,都on9既
又唔係拍俾你地睇,咁多嗲[sosad] [sosad] [sosad]
就算佢地搞幾百場謝票場都唔關你地事啦[sosad]
因為人地根本就冇預你地班街客睇[sosad]


當然關我哋事
搞到其他戲少咗場次

2024-03-29 13:05:19
不止虛火,直頭係老鼠屎
2024-03-29 13:10:23
又盜月者又12怪盜
短時間上兩套咁近似既戲
自己打自己之餘仲要好混亂

公道D講,盜月者係拍得幾好,起碼我呢D街客會為左張繼聰,白只同edan入場睇先

仲有呢兩套戲,分屬唔同電影公司發行#oh#
盜月者—英皇電影
12怪盜—安樂電影
MKV應該係做經紀統籌及協作之一。:)maf
2024-03-29 13:26:35
睇trailer 已經趕客啦,係咁loop d鏡粉話好睇hard sell

本身套戲就係拍俾fans睇
人地講明「鏡式幽默」
咪即係玩inside joke, 自己人先至睇得明囉
咁關街客撚事

d街客又嘈嘈閉,都on9既
又唔係拍俾你地睇,咁多嗲[sosad] [sosad] [sosad]
就算佢地搞幾百場謝票場都唔關你地事啦[sosad]
因為人地根本就冇預你地班街客睇[sosad]


當然關我哋事
搞到其他戲少咗場次

唔好懶人地乜乜物物阻住你
就算冇鏡仔上戲都一樣冇人入戲院
邊個票房高就自然多戲院上
所以點解而家成日要催票
因為票房直接影響下星期派片

我成日都話
香港幾百萬人
你地有本事咪課對家
鏡粉就唔會食到個餅啦


聖誕電影|戲院票房20年新低 
影業協會洪祖星:諗唔到差得咁緊要

2023-12-28

撰文:陶嘉心

今個聖誕檔期,香港戲院票房總收入低於2,000萬元,按年跌四成,創20年來新低。香港影業協會理事長洪祖星今日(28日)形容是香港影業最慘淡一年:「諗唔到會差得咁緊要。」他指出,港人北上熱潮對票房有影響,疫情後首個聖誕港人外出旅遊影響更大:「唔只大人,係一家大大細細都出晒去(旅行)。」

影業協會和戲院商會指,平安夜(24日)至周二(26日)的聖誕檔期,香港票房有限公司數據顯示,中西票房總收入為19,598,975元,遠低於去年同期的32,848,164元,跌幅為40.33%。

在該3天,以《水行俠與失落王國》票房收入6,598,882元最高、《旺卡》以3,471,670元居次,第三位是迪士尼的《星願奇緣》3,257,571元,日本動畫電影《蒼鷺與少年》以2,366,842排第四。港產電影《年少日記》及《爆裂點》分居第5及6位,收入為1,303,737元及588,612元。

香港影業協會理事長洪祖星今日在電台節目稱,以往聖誕檔期最高票房電影,單日有400萬至500萬票房,但今個檔期最高票房電影三日只有約600萬、即平均每日只有200萬,「諗唔到會差得咁緊要」,他說:「問我點解?真係唔知點解,唔知點解今年(聖誕檔期總票房)會比去年少40%,真係最慘淡一年。」

他相信,3年多疫情下,港人聖誕無法旅行導致今個聖誕「個個外出」是原因之一,被問到港人北上熱潮對票房影響,他稱有影響,但不只「北上」一個原因:「去全世界旅行都多,唔只大人,係一家大大細細都出晒去(旅行)。」

本港電影市場收入持續低迷,新冠疫情前的2019年的同期(24日至26日)的聖誕檔期,電影票房按年亦有雙位數跌幅。香港票房有限公司當年數字為29,425,931元,比前一年的40,945,494元跌28.13%。
2024-03-29 13:35:38
盜月者有2700萬票房,到時睇下12怪盜過唔過到呢個數咪知個宣傳策略邊個啱囉

盜月者果期有飯2,臨時劫案,spy family互𠝹,控12怪盜呢期獨市,已經讓左round
2024-03-29 13:37:46
報左鏡安法
2024-03-29 13:46:26
特首曾話既
十二鏡狗既戲
唔係拍比街客睇
唔歡迎街客睇
唔會有街客睇
#yup#
2024-03-29 14:13:31
又盜月者又12怪盜
短時間上兩套咁近似既戲
自己打自己之餘仲要好混亂

Mirror就嚟爆煲
所以要盡快揸乾佢

你地唔知鏡粉越嚟越失控
無論對外定對內
佢地自己d fan club內部都出晒事

2021年啱啱爆紅嗰時
排活動至都都係早一日排都宵
而家《12怪盜》係早10日排
仲發展出排隊黨
用櫈仔同紙仔排隊(有專人看守)
同黑社會冇分別

點解話唔會有妹豬出活動
因為試過有唔少妹豬唔知頭唔知路
去錯對家勢力範圍被人趕

就算自己人都有呢個情況
追星體驗差,咪唔玩囉

有部份活動都開始出現輕微人踩人
睇下幾時爆單大野

佢地爭位影相
有d唔係因為真係鍾意粒星
而係經營佢地既ig, 享受followers帶嚟既虛榮感
粒星對佢地嚟講只係要嚟呃like既流量密碼

佢地做某d過激行為會傷害到粒星(無論肉體定名聲)
佢地根本唔care
甚至有堆係影相賣photobook
之前講過有神徒賣慈善photobook, 營業額有40幾萬
錢佢就冇袋,但呃咗個慈善光環(因為印書本錢都係搵其他人出)

賣photobook嗰班
真係好撚好賺
所以點會唔搏老命去爭位


仲有班有心理病既私追跟出跟入
有d真係唔關鏡仔事
因為有心理病嗰班有部份都係有追星歷史
只係某d鏡仔既曝光率乎合咗佢地追星既慾望
2024-03-29 14:16:52
12 monkeys
2024-03-29 14:20:51
特首曾話既
十二鏡狗既戲
唔係拍比街客睇
唔歡迎街客睇
唔會有街客睇
#yup#



唔係謝票場即刻要拍烏蠅[sosad]
https://upload.hkgolden.media/comment/v54ylokz.fk2e0moghnj.livtdtueegw.cqw.jpg
https://upload.hkgolden.media/comment/nhapkv03.uiy2i3jfybl.wuzpuryuenb.ofj.jpg


原來謝票場貴咁多
唔怪得話要跑幾百場[sosad]
https://upload.hkgolden.media/comment/kdwax3j0.az032t3rokj.3gectak5q0j.jpi.jpg
2024-03-29 14:22:50
喺SCMP寫影評用呢啲字眼其實都玩到幾盡
2024-03-29 14:25:40
喺SCMP寫影評用呢啲字眼其實都玩到幾盡

證明我鏡黃到金
2024-03-29 14:27:08
話時話好期待鬼婆老師呢條片[bomb]
https://upload.hkgolden.media/comment/4snfpvza.sotp2tlfxxj.clolu4p2mo0.3pd.jpg
吹水台 高登熱 最 新 考古台 娛樂台 時事台 財經台 遊戲台 硬件台 電訊台 軟件台 手機台 Apps台 體育台 感情台 講故台 飲食台 親子台 寵物台 旅遊台 潮流台 動漫台 玩具台 音樂台 影視台 攝影台 學術台 校園台 上班台 汽車台 電 台 成人台 站務台 活動台 直播台 創意台 買賣台 區塊鏈台 健康台 優惠台 超自然台 AI技術台