Why You Shouldn't Look Up 'What Happened On This Day in History?’
23 min read

Why You Shouldn't Look Up 'What Happened On This Day in History?’

Why You Shouldn't Look Up 'What Happened On This Day in History?’
John Wilkes Booth assassinates President Abraham Lincoln at Ford's Theatre in Washington, D.C., April 14. On April 26, Booth is shot and killed by Union soldier Boston Corbett in the barn of Virginia farmer, Richard Garrett. Illustration (1870) of Lincoln Assassination, courtesy Ford's Theatre.

It started simply enough. Two dramatic events “On This Day in History” – April 26 – crossed my social media transom early this morning. Each pertained to Virginia history, so I thought maybe I’d write something of interest for The Falls Church Independent. 

Little did I know that, after some cursory research, I discovered way too much happened historically “on this day.” Not only that, but it appears a ridiculous amount of important stuff occurred every other “day in history” as well.

But, I digress. 

Certainly the two items of Virginia history that I saw occurred on April 26 are highly significant to world history as well as fascinating episodes in human drama. They were:

April 26, 1607 Three shiploads of English settlers arrive on the shore of present-day Virginia. The settlement of Jamestown is founded less than three weeks later. Sent by the Virginia Company of London, the colonists arrive hoping to find gold and other valuable resources.

April 26, 1865 John Wilkes Booth is killed at a Virginia farm twelve days after assassinating President Abraham Lincoln.

Human drama and historical significance in the first case is clear. 

Little did the Virginia settlers know... Painting: "Burial of the Dead," depicting The Starving Time, Winter, 1609-1610. Courtesy Encyclopedia of Virginia.

When settlers from the Virginia Company of London – 104 men and boys; “fair maidens” would be sent for later – arrived in Jamestown “on this day” in 1607, little did they know three things: First, instead of hanging their prisoner John Smith, as they desired, their instructions from London were to put the man in charge, hence the “Captain” John Smith of whom we know. Second, during the “Starving Time” a few winters later, many in the struggling settlement would either die of malnourishment, or engage in cannibalism, or both (but not in that order). And third, despite pathetic beginnings in Virginia – don’t forget the Lost Colony of Roanoke of 1587 – the colony’s eventual success would set England on the path to eventual colonial supremacy in the Americas, leading both to Great Britain’s predominance as a world empire, and, ironically, to the anti-colonial American Revolution. 

An Archeological Diversion...

And if you’re a skeptic that the English would eat each other at Jamestown, it’s been confirmed through archeological records. Even though six different accounts of cannibalism are contained in the Jamestown records – including one from former Jamestown president George Percy in 1625 recounting that during the Starving Time, “notheinge was Spared to mainteyne Lyfe … as to digge upp deade corpes outt of graves and to eate them.” 

According to Archeology.org, “William Kelso, an archaeologist with Preservation Virginia who has excavated Jamestown since 1994, doubted Percy’s horrific descriptions — until [the Spring of 2014], when his team found the butchered skull of a 14-year-old girl buried in a trash pit along with the remains of horses and dogs, other sources of food for the desperate colonists. Jane, as the girl is now known, was originally thought to have been an upper-class settler, but recent analysis found her skeleton has low lead levels. The rich at Jamestown ate from pewter dishes, essentially giving themselves lead poisoning. Jane’s remains are the first physical evidence of cannibalism at any American colony. 'There’s no doubt cannibalism happened,' says Kelso. 'It says how close to failure this colony came.' "

From Archeology.org: "Four butchery marks found on the skull of a 14-year-old girl who died at Jamestown constitute the first evidence for cannibalism during the colonization of the New World." Courtesy Smithsonian Institution/Don Hurlbert and Preservation Virginia.

As far as the second key event “On This Day” in 1865, I’m sure it’s obvious to many. Just five days after the end of the U.S. Civil War, when Lee surrendered to Grant at Appomattox Court House in Virginia, ending the bloodiest war in American history, the noted American actor, John Wilkes Booth, of Maryland – son of famous English/American Shakespearian actor Junius Brutus Booth –  assassinated perhaps the nation’s greatest president, Abraham Lincoln, during a performance of “Our American Cousin,” a comedy, at Ford’s Theatre in Washington, D.C. Not only had Lincoln signed the 13th Amendment abolishing slavery into law just a few months before, but he managed in just four years to defeat the secessionists while sounding a conciliatory tone about putting the United States back together with a “new birth of freedom” while being guided by the "better angels of our nature."

After shooting Lincoln – as well as stabbing Lincoln’s guest Major Henry Rathbone who tried to defend the President – Booth infamously jumped down from the presidential box onto the stage at Ford’s Theatre shouting to the audience, with a dagger in one hand, “Sic Semper Tyrannis,” purportedly quoting Brutus's words upon assassinating Caesar – and breaking the actor's left leg upon landing.  

Dagger used by Booth to stab Major Rathbone. Wikipedia photo.

The American Battlefield Trust then picks up on Booth’s whereabouts following the very public assassination. “Booth moved south, making several stops at the homes of Confederate sympathizers, as well as unaware citizens, he crossed the Potomac into Virginia on April 23rd. On the morning of April 26th, Troopers of the 16th New York Cavalry caught up with him at the farm of Richard Garrett near Port Royal. His accomplice, David Herold, surrendered, but Booth remained in Garrett’s barn which was quickly set aflame by the cavalrymen. One soldier, Boston Corbett, approached the barn and claimed to have seen Booth leveling his pistol at him, so Corbett fired a round from his revolver. The bullet severed Booth’s spinal cord and paralyzed him. John Wilkes Booth died three hours later. His last words were spoken while looking at his hands. “Useless, useless, useless.” He is buried in an unmarked grave at the family plot in Green Mount Cemetery in Baltimore.”

A photograph of Union soldier Boston Corbett in his U.S. Army uniform. Wikipedia photo.

And, of course, there was fallout in other ways from Booth’s rash acts. Returning to the scene at Ford’s Theatre, when Major Rathbone attempted to apprehend Booth, “Booth stabbed and seriously wounded him,” per Wikipedia. “Rathbone may have played a part in Booth's leg injury. Although [Rathbone] recovered, [his] mental state deteriorated afterwards, and in 1883, he murdered his wife, Clara, in a fit of madness, later being declared insane by doctors and living the rest of his life in a lunatic asylum.”

1865 Mathew Brady photograph of Rathbone. Wikipedia photo.

Too Many Other Events Also Took Place “On This Day in History”

Having fallen into Wikipedia’s Major Rathbone rabbit hole, I decided to look for more authoritative historical sources on what happened “on this day” in history. So, I found an Associated Press (AP) article published proudly in the Wausau Pilot and Review of Wisconsin concerning what happened on this 117th day of 2024. The problem is, too many damn things.

In addition to the bit about Jamestown settlement and the death of John Wilkes Booth, we also hear about: 

Chernobyl: “On April 26, 1986, an explosion and fire at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant in Ukraine caused radioactive fallout to begin spewing into the atmosphere. (Dozens of people were killed in the immediate aftermath of the disaster while the long-term death toll from radiation poisoning is believed to number in the thousands.)”

Mary Phagan: “In 1913, Mary Phagan, a 13-year-old worker at a Georgia pencil factory, was strangled; Leo Frank, the factory superintendent, was convicted of her murder and sentenced to death. (Frank’s death sentence was commuted, but he was lynched by an anti-Semitic mob in 1915.)”

The Gestapo: “In 1933, Nazi Germany’s infamous secret police, the Gestapo, was created.”

Tanzania: “In 1964, the African nations of Tanganyika and Zanzibar merged to form Tanzania.”

“Boxcar”:  “In 1968, the United States exploded beneath the Nevada desert a 1.3 megaton nuclear device called ‘Boxcar.’”

Studio 54: “In 1977, the legendary nightclub Studio 54 had its opening night in New York.”

On this day in history, Studio 54 opened. Facebook photo.

Count Basie: In 1984, bandleader Count Basie, 79, died in Hollywood, Florida.

Nelson Mandela: “In 1994, voting began in South Africa’s first all-race elections, resulting in victory for the African National Congress and the inauguration of Nelson Mandela as president.”

Nelson Mandela, 1994. Wikipedia photo.

Howard Dean: “In 2000, Vermont Gov. Howard Dean signed the nation’s first bill allowing same-sex couples to form civil unions.”

Swine Flu:In 2009, the United States declared a public health emergency as more possible cases of swine flu surfaced from Canada to New Zealand; officials in Mexico City closed everything from concerts to sports matches to churches in an effort to stem the spread of the virus.”

Charles Taylor: “In 2012, former Liberian President Charles Taylor became the first head of state since World War II to be convicted by an international war crimes court as he was found guilty of arming Sierra Leone rebels in exchange for “blood diamonds” mined by slave laborers and smuggled across the border. (Taylor was sentenced to 50 years in prison.)”

George Jones: In 2013, singer George Jones, believed by many to be the greatest country crooner of all time, died in Nashville at age 81.

Bill Cosby:  “In 2018, comedian Bill Cosby was convicted of drugging and molesting Temple University employee Andrea Constand at his suburban Philadelphia mansion in 2004. (Cosby was later sentenced to three to 10 years in prison, but Pennsylvania’s highest court threw out the conviction and released him from prison in June 2021, ruling that the prosecutor in the case was bound by his predecessor’s agreement not to charge Cosby.)”

Russia vs. Ukraine: “In 2022, Russia pounded eastern and southern Ukraine as the U.S. promised to “keep moving heaven and earth” to get Kyiv the weapons it needed to repel the new offensive, despite Moscow’s warnings that such support could trigger a wider war.”

And too many birthdays to even keep track of! Today’s Birthdays: Actor-comedian Carol Burnett is 91. R&B singer Maurice Williams is 86. Songwriter-musician Duane Eddy is 86. Actor Nancy Lenehan is 71. Actor Giancarlo Esposito is 66. Rock musician Roger Taylor (Duran Duran) is 64. Actor Joan Chen is 63. Rock musician Chris Mars (The Replacements) is 63. Actor-singer Michael Damian is 62. Actor Jet Li (lee) is 61. Actor-comedian Kevin James is 59. Author and former U.S. Poet Laureate Natasha Trethewey is 58. Actor Marianne Jean-Baptiste is 57. Rapper T-Boz (TLC) is 54. Former first lady Melania Trump is 54. Actor Shondrella Avery is 53. Actor Simbi Kali is 53. Country musician Jay DeMarcus (Rascal Flatts) is 53. Rock musician Jose Pasillas (Incubus) is 48. Actor Jason Earles is 47. Actor Leonard Earl Howze is 47. Actor Amin Joseph is 47. Actor Tom Welling is 47. Actor Pablo Schreiber is 46. Actor Nyambi Nyambi is 45. Actor Jordana Brewster is 44. Actor Stana Katic is 44. Actor Marnette Patterson is 44. Actor Channing Tatum is 44. Americana/roots singer-songwriter Lilly Hiatt is 40. Actor Emily Wickersham is 40. Actor Aaron Meeks is 38. New York Yankees outfielder Aaron Judge is 32.

Asking ChatGPT to Simplify

Finally, I resorted to ChatGPT to try to simplify my search. Soon, I had regretted my prompts and queries to the know-it-all chatbot. I was informed confidently of another never-ending array of April 26th historical events: 

Guernica [How had AP missed that?] “1937: Guernica Bombing: During the Spanish Civil War, on April 26, 1937, the town of Guernica in Spain was bombed by German and Italian aircraft, resulting in significant civilian casualties. The event inspired Pablo Picasso's famous painting "Guernica" and drew international attention to the brutality of modern warfare.”

Guernica, 1937. Oil on Canvas. Pablo Picasso. Museo Reina Sofia, Madrid, Spain

Sinking of the Sultana: “1865: Sinking of the Sultana: The steamship Sultana, carrying Union soldiers recently released from Confederate prison camps, exploded and sank in the Mississippi River near Memphis, Tennessee, on April 26, 1865. It remains one of the deadliest maritime disasters in United States history, with an estimated 1,800 to 1,900 lives lost.”

Louisiana Purchase [Seriously, AP?]:  “1803: Louisiana Purchase Treaty Signed: On April 26, 1803, the United States and France signed the Louisiana Purchase Treaty, which effectively doubled the size of the United States by acquiring the territory of Louisiana from France for $15 million.”

Tiananmen Square [Okay, Now I'm Really Disappointed with the AP Piece in the Wasau Pilot and Review!]: “1989: Tiananmen Square Protests Begin: On April 26, 1989, mass pro-democracy protests began in Tiananmen Square in Beijing, China. The demonstrations, led by students and intellectuals, called for political reform and greater freedom. The protests culminated in the Tiananmen Square Massacre on June 4th.”

Tiananmen protests began on this day, April 26, 1989. Iconice image: June 5 1989. "Tank Man" (Tiananmen Square protester). Photo by Jeff Widener AP.

Pazzi Conspiracy: “1478: Pazzi Conspiracy: On April 26, 1478, the Pazzi Conspiracy took place in Florence, Italy. The conspiracy, led by the Pazzi family and supported by Pope Sixtus IV, aimed to overthrow the ruling Medici family. The assassination attempt on Lorenzo de' Medici failed, leading to the brutal suppression of the conspirators.”

Geraldo Rivera: “1986: Geraldo Rivera Opens Al Capone's Vault: On April 26, 1986, American television journalist Geraldo Rivera hosted a live two-hour special titled "The Mystery of Al Capone's Vaults." Rivera promised to reveal the contents of a secret vault purportedly belonging to the infamous gangster Al Capone. However, the vault turned out to be empty, disappointing viewers worldwide.”

Battle of Bautzen Ends: “1945: Battle of Bautzen Ends: On April 26, 1945, during World War II, the Battle of Bautzen ended with a Soviet victory. The battle, fought between German and Soviet forces, was part of the larger Soviet offensive aimed at capturing Berlin. The Soviet victory at Bautzen contributed to the eventual defeat of Nazi Germany.”

Finally, It Was All Too Much…

Before long, I was rerouted in my exhaustive research back to a Wikipedia listing covering “All Things April 26th.” I’m afraid its tiresomeness was beyond my capacities. Notwithstanding, I present it forthwith – as if you couldn't find it online for yourselves:

Events [April 26]

Pre-1600

1601–1900

1901–present

Births

Pre-1600

1601–1900

1901–present

Deaths

Pre-1600

1601–1900

1901–present

Holidays and observances


Who even knew today was Intellectual Property Day or it was the Christian Feast Day of Stephen of Perm? And, why was Stephen of Perm even called that?... 

Stephen Of Perm. "Beautiful hand-painted icon of Saint Stephen of Perm." Egg tempera and gilding. Available at Blessed ArtMart for $106.99. Courtesy BAM.

By Christopher Jones