Back to the Rough Ground: Practical Judgment and the Lure of Technique

Front Cover
University of Notre Dame Pess, Sep 1, 1997 - Philosophy - 512 pages

Back to the Rough Ground is a philosophical investigation of practical knowledge, with major import for professional practice and the ethical life in modern society. Its purpose is to clarify the kind of knowledge that informs good practice in a range of disciplines such as education, psychotherapy, medicine, management, and law. Through reflection on key modern thinkers who have revived cardinal insights of Aristotle, and a sustained engagement with the Philosopher himself, it presents a radical challenge to the scientistic assumptions that have dominated how these professional domains have been conceived, practiced, and institutionalized.

 

Contents

Foreword to the Paperback Edition by Alasdair MacIntyre
The Company of Philosophers
Conversation as a Mode of Philosophical Inquiry
THE RETRIEVAL OF PHRONESIS AND TECHNE IN MODERN
R G Collingwoods Critique of Techne in The Principles of
Hannah Arendts Distinction between Action and Making in The Human Condition
B The Universal Scope of Philosophical Hermeneutics
Language Hermeneutics and Practical Philosophy
The Appeal to Experience in Nicomachean Ethics 10 9 and 1 3
Phronesis and Character as Modalities of Experience
Nous or Perceptiveness with Regard to Ultimate Particulars as a Crucial Element
in Phronesis 7 Suggested Examples of Ultimate Particulars Elucidated by Reference to De Anima and Wittgenstein
The Openness of the Phronetic Approach and How It Differs from Deductivism
The Relationship between Universals and Particulars in the Sphere of Phronesis and Eupraxia
Recovering the Experiential Background 1 Aristotles Failure to Distinguish between Techne as an Ability to Analyze and Techne as an Ability to Make
Evidence of Two Different Tendencies in Aristotles Treatment of Techne

Reflection on Language
The Challenge of Critical Theory
Praxis Mediated through Modern Thought
Habermas and Hermeneutics
Ambiguities of Rationalization
Interlude
PHRONESIS AND TECHNE IN ARISTOTLE
The Primacy of Theory and the Questionable Status of Practice
The Place of Techne and Phronesis and of the Distinction between Them in Aristotles Writings
Its Essential Reference to Fabrication and Its Closeness to Theory
Phronesis as a Form of Experience 1 Aristotles Reserve about the Role of Knowledge in Virtue The Emergence of a Circle between Phronesis and Ch...
The Key to Understanding the Circle Is Experience
The Nonassimilation of Experience Raises Questions about Techne in Metaphysics 1 1
Aristotles Neglect of the Role of Experience in Techne Related to His Characteristic Approach to Genesis
The Role of Matter in Aristotles Thought Supports an Emphasis on Experience
Implications of the Analogy between Techne and Nature
Implications for Techne of Aristotles Account of Change
Aristotles Account of Soul Supports a Conception of Techne as Embodied
Deliberation Reconsidered and Conclusion
The Main Themes
Import for Practices
Bearings in Philosophy
Notes
Bibliography to Introduction and Part 1
Index
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (1997)

Joseph Dunne teaches philosophy of education at St. Patrick's College, Dublin City University. He has co-edited several books and is the author of many scholarly articles and reviews.

Alasdair MacIntyre is research professor of philosophy at the University of Notre Dame. He is the author of numerous books, including Whose Justice? Which Rationality? (Notre Dame Press, 1988) and Three Rival Versions of Moral Enquiry: Encyclopaedia, Genealogy, and Tradition (Notre Dame Press, 1990).

Bibliographic information