'He's gonna kill somebody': Poland murder suspect was denied long-term mental health care despite pleas
Skip to content
Advertisement

'He's gonna kill somebody': Poland murder suspect was denied long-term mental health care despite pleas

34-year-old Justin Butterfield of Poland is accused of murdering his brother on Thanksgiving morning

'He's gonna kill somebody': Poland murder suspect was denied long-term mental health care despite pleas

34-year-old Justin Butterfield of Poland is accused of murdering his brother on Thanksgiving morning

TONIGHT. DRIVERS ARE ALSO ASKED TO AVOID THE AREA. MORE DETAILS ARE EMERGING ABOUT THE MAN WHO ALLEGEDLY KILLED HIS BROTHER IN POLAND ON THANKSGIVING... HIS EX-GIRLFRIEND SAYS HE LIVED WITH SEVERE MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES THAT - SHE CLAIMS - WERE IGNORED BY AUTHORITIES FOR YEARS... JAMES CORRIGAN - JOINS US LIVE IN STUDIO. JAMES, YOU SAT DOWN WITH HER TODAY. TERRY IT WAS THURSDAY MORNING IN POLAND WHERE 34- YEAR-OLD JUSTIN BUTTERFIELD ALLEGEDLY KILLED HIS BROTHER GABE DAMOUR IN HIS HOME, AND THOSE WHO KNOW BUTTERFIELD SAY THAT AN INCIDENT LIKE THIS HAS BEEN COMING. HIS EX- GIRLFRIEND TODAY TELLING ME THAT DESPITE REPEATED PLEAS FROM HERSELF AND HER FAMILY, THE AUTHORITIES AND HEALTH CARE FACILITIES NEVER REALIZED THE THREAT JUSTIN WAS TO HIMSELF AND OTHERS. 20;42;34;08 I DON'T TRULY THINK JUSTIN WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS. I KNOW THAT HIS PHYSICAL BODY DID IT BUT HIS MIND WAS NOT THERE. FOR THE LAST FOUR DAYS, YAICHA PROVENCHER AND HER FAMILY HAS BEEN LIVING THEIR WORST NIGHTMARE, FOLLOWING THE MURDER OF GABE DAMOUR ON THURSDAY BY HIS BROTHER, JUSTIN BUTTERFIELD OF POLAND. FOR 8 YEARS, SHE DATED BUTTERFIELD AND HAD A CHILD WITH HIM UNTIL 2018, WHEN HIS MENTAL STATE TOOK A TURN. 20;15;17;24 HE STARTED GETTING REALLY PARANOID AND TELLING ME THAT CARS WERE FOLLOWING HIM AND HE STARTED WRITING DOWN LICENSE PLATES 20;15;36;08 (COVER) IT KIND OF PROGRESSED FROM THERE IN 2019, BUTTERFIELD WAS DIAGNOSED WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA, AND THE ISOLATION OF THE PANDEMIC MADE HIS EPISODES WORSE. 20;27;14;02 (COVER) HE WENT ON A HIGH SPEED CHASE IN... (AUDIO JUMP 20;27;18;19) BATH, BELIEVED ALIENS WERE AFTER HIM AND WAS HIDING IN THE FRIGID COLD IN THE WATER. 20;28;01;14 (JAMES) HOW LONG WERE HIS STAYS IN THE HOSPITAL? YOU KNOW, THAT LOVELY 72 HOUR HOLD. THAT 72 HOUR HOLD, IN YOUR OUT. 20;28;18;02 (COVER WITH MIDCOAST VO?) THE ONLY PERSON I DID GET TO TALK TO WAS THE CASE WORKER MIDCOAST HOSPITAL 20;28;30;08 SHE HAD ORIGINALLY CALLED ME AND TOLD ME THAT THEY WERE GOING TO HOLD HIM INVOLUNTARILY. THE NEXT DAY, I GOT A PHONE CALL, AGAIN FROM THE SAME WOMAN TELLING ME THAT HE WAS BEING RELEASED. I BEGGED THEM TO KEEP HIM AND I TOLD THE LADY, I TOLD THAT CASEWORKER HE'S GONNA KILL SOMEBODY. AND THAT'S GONNA BE ON YOU. BECAUSE SHE KNOWS WHO SHE IS. AND SHE SAID, WELL, I HOPE NOT. AND I SAID, IT'S GONNA HAPPEN. AS RECENTLY AS TUESDAY, PROVENCHER SAID BUTTERFIELD BROKE INTO HER HOME AND STOLE HER CAT, ONCE AGAIN WITHOUT REPERCUSSIONS. SHE SAYS THAT DESPITE AT LEAST FIVE HOSPITAL VISITS AND DOZENS OF RUN-INS WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT IN JUST THE PAST YEAR, THE LONG- TERM HELP HE NEEDED NEVER CAME UNTIL IT WAS TOO LATE. 20;37;24;16 (JAMES) DID THE SYSTEM FAIL JUSTIN? YES. THE SYSTEM FAILED MY WHOLE FAMILY. (JAMES) WHAT SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED? 20;41;57;21 WHAT SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED IS HE SHOULD HAVE STAYED IN A LONG TERM FACILITY AND REALLY SHOWED THAT HE MADE PROGRESSION BEFORE HE WAS RELEASED... BECAUSE NOW SOMEBODY'S GOT DEAD I MEAN, SOMEBODY'S GONE. PROVENCHER TOLD ME THAT DESPITE BUTTERFIELD'S EPISODES AND CONSISTENT RUN- INS WITH THE LAW, THAT NEITHER LAW ENFORCEMENT OR HEALTH CARE WORKERS BELIEVED HE WAS A DANGER TO HIMSELF OR OTHER
Advertisement
'He's gonna kill somebody': Poland murder suspect was denied long-term mental health care despite pleas

34-year-old Justin Butterfield of Poland is accused of murdering his brother on Thanksgiving morning

Thirty-four-year-old Justin Butterfield is accused of murdering his brother, 38-year-old Gabe Damour, on Thanksgiving morning in Poland, but Butterfield's ex-girlfriend says the man who allegedly committed the crime is not the man she once knew."I don't truly think Justin was responsible for this," said Yaicha Provencher, Butterfield's ex-girlfriend. "I know that his physical body did it but his mind was not there."Provencher says she dated Butterfield from 2010 to 2018. The couple had a child together. "He was really goofy and really funny," Provincher recalled of Butterfield. "He was really good at making people laugh. He was a really good dad to his son."In 2018, Provincher says Butterfield took a turn for the worse after a physician prescribed him Adderall, which she says exacerbated his schizophrenia. "He started getting really paranoid and telling me that cars were following him and he started writing down license plates," Provincher said. "It kind of progressed from there."Provincher says Butterfield's condition worsened even further due to the isolation of the pandemic. "The very first time I started noticing that he was exhibiting signs of hallucinations, I called the police," Provincher said. "I called the police to see if they could bring him to the hospital, and I was flat out told that they didn't believe me and he was fine. They said, 'He's answering what day it is. He's answering his name.'Earlier this year, Butterfield led police on a chase in Bath which Provincher says ended with him submerged in freezing water. Despite what she says were dozens of run-ins with law enforcement and at least five hospital visits over the past year, she says neither law enforcement nor health care workers believed he was a danger to himself or others."The only person I did get to talk to was the case worker at Midcoast hospital," Provincher said, referring to the aftermath of the Bath incident. "She had originally called me and told me that they were going to hold him involuntarily. The next day, I got a phone call, again from the same woman telling me that he was being released. I begged them to keep him and I told that caseworker he's gonna kill somebody, and that's gonna be on you. And she knows who she is. And she said, 'Well, I hope not.' And I said, 'It's gonna happen.'"Provincher says if law enforcement and health care workers had believed the repeated warnings from herself and his friends that the tragedy would have been prevented."What should have happened is he should have stayed in a long-term facility and really showed that he made progression before he was released," Provincher said. "And I do think that those who did not give him what he needed or didn't listen to the people that knew him best and kept him out here in society do need to be held with some sort of accountability." Provincher says she is speaking out to raise awareness about the lack of mental health care for people like Butterfield."I think that we really need to look within ourselves and our system and figure out how we can best serve these types of situations," Provincher said. "Because right now, we're not. And now, me and my kids have the rest of our lives that we have to deal with this."Butterfield is currently being held in Androscoggin County Jail without bail. He is facing charges of murder.

Thirty-four-year-old Justin Butterfield is accused of murdering his brother, 38-year-old Gabe Damour, on Thanksgiving morning in Poland, but Butterfield's ex-girlfriend says the man who allegedly committed the crime is not the man she once knew.

"I don't truly think Justin was responsible for this," said Yaicha Provencher, Butterfield's ex-girlfriend. "I know that his physical body did it but his mind was not there."

Advertisement

Provencher says she dated Butterfield from 2010 to 2018. The couple had a child together.

"He was really goofy and really funny," Provincher recalled of Butterfield. "He was really good at making people laugh. He was a really good dad to his son."

In 2018, Provincher says Butterfield took a turn for the worse after a physician prescribed him Adderall, which she says exacerbated his schizophrenia.

"He started getting really paranoid and telling me that cars were following him and he started writing down license plates," Provincher said. "It kind of progressed from there."

Provincher says Butterfield's condition worsened even further due to the isolation of the pandemic.

"The very first time I started noticing that he was exhibiting signs of hallucinations, I called the police," Provincher said. "I called the police to see if they could bring him to the hospital, and I was flat out told that they didn't believe me and he was fine. They said, 'He's answering what day it is. He's answering his name.'

Earlier this year, Butterfield led police on a chase in Bath which Provincher says ended with him submerged in freezing water. Despite what she says were dozens of run-ins with law enforcement and at least five hospital visits over the past year, she says neither law enforcement nor health care workers believed he was a danger to himself or others.

"The only person I did get to talk to was the case worker at Midcoast hospital," Provincher said, referring to the aftermath of the Bath incident. "She had originally called me and told me that they were going to hold him involuntarily. The next day, I got a phone call, again from the same woman telling me that he was being released. I begged them to keep him and I told that caseworker he's gonna kill somebody, and that's gonna be on you. And she knows who she is. And she said, 'Well, I hope not.' And I said, 'It's gonna happen.'"

Provincher says if law enforcement and health care workers had believed the repeated warnings from herself and his friends that the tragedy would have been prevented.

"What should have happened is he should have stayed in a long-term facility and really showed that he made progression before he was released," Provincher said. "And I do think that those who did not give him what he needed or didn't listen to the people that knew him best and kept him out here in society do need to be held with some sort of accountability."

Provincher says she is speaking out to raise awareness about the lack of mental health care for people like Butterfield.

"I think that we really need to look within ourselves and our system and figure out how we can best serve these types of situations," Provincher said. "Because right now, we're not. And now, me and my kids have the rest of our lives that we have to deal with this."

Butterfield is currently being held in Androscoggin County Jail without bail. He is facing charges of murder.