Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back (2017) - Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back (2017) - User Reviews - IMDb
Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back (2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
25 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Even those who love everything Journey to the West or the Monkey King should only check it out if it was free
Skaigear23 June 2017
Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back is a sequel to 2013's Journey to the West: Conquering the Demons, which I really liked. It is directed by Hong Kong veteran, Tsui Hark and written by Stephen Chow, who did not return to direct this one. The movie stars an all-new cast playing characters from the first movie, with the only person returning being Shu Qi. The first movie I thought was a really good Stephen Chow movie without Stephen Chow, and what really worked for me were the characters and their likability and humor. I really liked Wen Zhang and Shu Qi's chemistry with each other, and it made me root for their forbidden love to come to fruition. This movie loses Wen Zhang, being replaced by Kris Wu, and Shu Qi is delegated to a cameo appearance, and man are they big losses, because the actors in this movie did not hold up well at all. Neither did the script though, as frankly I felt this movie is just a mess. Drastic character changes out of the blue, inconsistencies and conveniences to push the plot forward litters throughout.

Unlike the first film where it was more of a prelude to the classical story, Demons Strike Back actually plays out the episodic narrative from the classical novel, with memorable arcs such as the spider demons and white skeleton being rendered in Stephen Chow slapstick style. We actually get to see Tang Monk along with the three disciples he conquered during the first movie journeying to the west this time around. While the plot moves along episodically, the main focus here is the tension between Tang and the Monkey King, as the former still blames the latter for Shu Qi's character's death. This relationship between master and disciple is so poorly written I spent the entire time not really caring for either character, since they themselves do not seem to care judging by the terrible things they do to one another. Tang is having visions of Shu Qi from the first movie, and blames the Monkey King for her death. I am very disappointed to see this is route they went with for the sequel, after all Shu Qi tempted Tang the entire first movie, but he did not once gave in once to her. Now that he is enlightened and is journeying west, all of a sudden he is lusting for her? That just seems very inconsistent. But I guess consistency is the last thing you should expect in these types of movies.

Even though Stephen Chow did not return to direct the movie, his style of humor is still emulated here. However, being a Chow fan since I was a kid, I was sorely disappointed with how unfunny this movie was. Not that they did not try, but the actors just do not have the comedic chops to pull off this type of humor. At times, things got really dumb and silly with a mind control dancing scene which is recycled from the first movie, and a crying grown man trying to pass as funny. Another thing that was off putting was the characterization of Piggy, who was always a pervert, but never the serial rapist as he was in this one. He literally attempts to rape every girl he encounters and it is played for laughs. As someone who has watched enough interpretations of Journey to the West, this was simply not funny and kind of ruined things for me. I did chuckle a few times throughout, and there are a few good gags such as when Sandy got turn back into a giant fish, but overall this was not the clever Stephen Chow film I am accustomed to.

The action in the film was good, but it is typical C-grade special effects-laden Chinese film affair. There was never a moment where I felt danger for any of the characters because the build-up to these action scenes tends to be humorous and lacking of tension. The main highlight for me is definitely the spider demons scene, it is by the far the most exciting action set piece in the movie. The CGI is pretty average, but at least the Chinese and Hong Kong film industries are improving in this department since the disastrous eye sore that was the Donnie Yen Monkey King movie.

Kris Wu, former K-pop star musters all of his charms and good looks and gives out a fine performance as Tang. Lin Gengxin, the Monkey King was intense and likable. The rest of the cast did the best they could, but as I mentioned before, they were simply not funny enough in my opinion. The best thing about the movie was the definitely the collection of attractive Chinese ladies assembled here. Yao Chen, Wang Likun and Lin Yun are all beautiful and charming. I love my female eye candy, and whenever these actresses were on screen, my eyes were glued.

Overall the movie is very pedestrian, but passable popcorn affair. Not horrible by any means, definitely watchable for some colorful action scenes. However, too many misses on jokes and poor plot and character developments cannot save the movie from mediocrity. Even those who love everything Journey to the West or the Monkey King should only check it out if it was free and you have a couple of hours to spare.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Why change the cast?
UnderworldRocks28 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Canadian "Cannon King" Wu Yifan cannot act. His performance is cringeworthy.

This movie is no match for the original.

I award it 3 stars.

1 star for the humorous dialogue between the Spider Demon and the Pig Demon. Something was lost in translation. In Chinese, the word for "spider" is homophonic to "a pig". They both sound like "zhizhu". Such is the humor of the scene where the Pig Demon was infatuated with the Spider Demon, and the Spider Demon refused, saying she was "zhizhu", and the Pig replied, "I'm also zhizhu."

1 star for the flashback cameos of Shu Qi, who portrayed the dead lover of the Monk Tang. It's always great to see her.

1 star for the Skeleton Demon. The portrayal of the Skeleton Demon is very anti-traditional. In this movie. she was an innocent and kind demon who fell in love with the Monk Tang. That's news. The actress was great in Stephen Chow's 2016 Movie The Mermaid.

Such a disappointment that the actors from the original did not return.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Witless, charmless and ultimately pointless, this sequel is notable only for Tsui Hark's visual excesses as compensation for its sheer emptiness
moviexclusive28 January 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Just by the fact that 'Journey to the West 2 (JTTW2): The Demons Strike Back' represents the first-ever collaboration between Hong Kong cinema icons Stephen Chow and Tsui Hark should make you excited about this sequel to Chow's 2013 fantasy comedy, which concluded with the monk Tang Sanzang embark on the titular journey to retrieve the Buddhist sutras that the classic source material is best known for. Whereas Zhang Wen played the timid and tentative Tang in the earlier movie, it is former Exo band member Kris Wu who has been cast here; ditto, not Huang Bo or Chen Bing Qiang or Lee Sheung Ching reprise their roles as Tang's companions Monkey King, Pigsy and Sandy respectively, which are now played by Hark's latest muse Lin Gengxin, Yang Yiwei and Mengke Bateer – and just for the record, only the earlier movie's Shu Qi returns to cameo as Miss Duan, a fellow demon exerciser whom Tang admitted being in love with only upon her accidental death at Monkey King's hands. Oh yes, the lack of continuity is somewhat puzzling, considering how it has only been four years since and the story here follows from the earlier movie.

Yet it becomes distinctly clear during the 109-minute movie which feels like it goes on for twice as long that the much touted Chow-Hark collaboration here is really just a gimmick, as well that the almost total change in cast from the original represents not just the cash- grab intentions of this sequel but also the importance – or lack thereof – which both Chow in his capacity as writer cum producer and Hark in his as director have placed on artistic considerations. Indeed, 'JTTW2: The Demons Strike Back' is a witless, charmless and pointless, whose search for its own story is even more obvious than Tang's search for the sutras and which tries copiously to use CGI to compensate for its glaring absences. Put it simply, this is an utter disappointment, marking one of the most humourless Chow comedies we've seen and an awful misstep for the 66-year-old Tsui on a second-wave of his illustrious but uneven directorial oeuvre following 'Detective Dee' and 'The Taking of Tiger Mountain'.

First and fundamentally, there is no story here, meandering from a travelling circus where Tang's attempt to show the villagers that he and his disciples are capable of magic results in total destruction of the humble village, then to an isolated compound in the woods where a female spider demon and her consorts have killed its inhabitants and are waiting to devour Tang, and lastly to a carnival-like kingdom in India where a Minister (Yao Chen) and her servile king (Bao Bei'er) bait Tang with a white-boned spirit Felicity (Jelly Lin from 'The Mermaid'). Connecting the three acts is supposedly the rekindled resentment between Tang and Monkey King, the former still alternately crushed and angry over the death of Miss Duan and the latter boiling over the former's hold over him. And yet, the narrative is anything but character-driven, chiefly because Chow doesn't develop their conflict to be anywhere near compelling or resolve it in any convincing, let alone poignant, way.

The rest really is either distraction or filler. How else would you describe Pigsy's one-note lecherous tendencies, which sees him turn into a handsome scholarly type in front of female beauty? Or Sandy's poisoning at the hands of one of the spider demons, which causes him to turn into a giant mucus-blowing fish similar to his introduction at the start of the first movie? Pigsy and Sandy add little to the dynamic between Tang and Monkey King, used here only as comic relief. The same can be said of the demons that they encounter along their way, the eight-legged ones leading to a battle that briefly alludes to Tang's humanism versus Monkey King's violence and goes no further and the subsequent no more than an excuse for Tsui to flex his CGI muscles to conjure up an epic showdown in the middle of a crashing ocean with a giant rock monkey, numerous false Buddhas and an immortal gold vulture.

Had your measure of entertainment been premised on CGI, you would probably be squealing delightfully. Since his 'Legend of Zu' days, Tsui has loved creating fantasy worlds with the use of technology, and its advancements have only led him to think bigger. Yet there is only so much that Tsui as a visual magician can do to salvage a movie which had very little to begin with, which we suspect was the reason why Chow decided to get someone else to do the directing (rather than bear the ignominy alone); and in turn, Tsui compensates and over-compensates with his excesses, which ultimately only underscores how empty and meaningless this whole affair is.

It is even more inexcusable seeing as how Chow is intimately familiar with the 'Journey to the West' tales coming off his other revisionist telling 'A Chinese Odyssey' in the 90s. There are hardly any bits of humour here, and even Chow's signature tricks (such as characters calling each other '扑街') become exhaustive and pandering. The cast has hardly any chemistry, especially inexcusable seeing as how Chow has always stressed finding the right actors (even those with no prior experience, like Kitty Zhang or Jelly Lin) in his movies. And there is no purpose here, given how Tang is no closer to retrieving his scriptures at the end of it and how Tang and Monkey King seem to have found closure to their differences like in the last movie. The fact that this had been a promising Chow-Tsui collaboration makes watching 'JTTW2: The Demons Strike Back' even more dispiriting, so just avoid this journey at all costs and go find somewhere else to walk, just anywhere else really.
37 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
1 star for seeing Shu Qi again
erudemu3 August 2017
Being a huge fan of the first movie (it's still in my top 5), i was waiting to see this for a long time. I was unhappy about changing whole cast but after seeing the movie, i understand that was the minor problem.

Since this movie is a sequel, we have right to compare it with first movie. You know what, there is nothing to compare. This one is awful. Casting, acting, even scenario are all bad. So disappointing.

I gave first movie 10 stars but this movie is not even close to earn 2 stars. Only 1 star for Shu Qi.

This must be the worst job of Stephen Chow as producer and Tsui Hark as director.
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
A CGI Garbage bin
ron_capuccino26 March 2018
No story, no character development, ugly battles and a bad taste CGI festival. The first episode was definitely not the best Chow but this sequel is just a waste of ime and money.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Waste of Time
kupukupumu4 May 2017
Coincidentally, I just watched L.O.R.D which has many same lead casts with this movie. And I have to say, this movie is as bad as that one. I almost can't believe it is directed by the experienced Tsui Hark.

Almost everything in this sequel is boring and uninteresting, except the songs. The movie is so boring, yet still not suitable for kids due to some scenes. If you have not watched this, better skip this than to waste your time.
11 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Took A Chance On This And It Did not Pay Off
jane-hamet26 July 2020
I suppose I should have known since it is a sequel.

There was not too much to the story. The shape sifting travel companions journey to the west for the education and salvation of a monk and along the way they find many adventures. The story is very thin and an excuse for a series of non-stop special effects where as things should be the other way around.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Poor sequel
samyaksambuddha23 April 2018
This did not do well. The fantasy has been attempted with a different but poor approach. A combination of traditional powers and modern technology is also attempted but that too on the poor side. The good cards established in the first part are skipped and replaced by inferior elements. The Buddha is introduced abruptly without logical consistency. Comedy is also poor. This did not do well. Disappointed.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
I really want my ticket money back
xmszer2 February 2017
There is no doubt that this movie having very success in China, maybe will be the top one seller on this month. But,For my opinion , a good box office never equal to good movie, especially in China. Cause you never will know how important a actor can have their fans with money without brain. Their fans will never eject how their idol is never suit for acting. I tell the truth, no one laughed at the cinema instead of awarded. Even the children told to his mother to leave the sit because it really boring.A lot of people over-read about this movie, even the writer said "stop this, i never mean that".i don't think you made up a very analogical reason to say this movie is good is really good for the movie.
15 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Combines the best things from both directors
Cornelia_vanderbilt28 January 2017
I have been looking forward to this movie for years because I'm a huge fan of both Stephen Chow and Tsui Hark and it didn't disappoint! The nonsensical comedy is very Stephen Chow and the plot is engaging, my friends and I spent the whole time laughing. No one can write a good comedic sequence like Stephen Chow. Tsui Hark's half of the contribution can be seen in the special effects and action, the effects are pretty good although not perfect. The cinematography for this is amazing, there were a lot of beautiful shots.

I wanted the original cast from the first movie to return but the new cast didn't disappoint. The monk in particularly was very funny.

I rate this a 10 because it's everything I wanted from both of them. It certainly delivered!
32 out of 66 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
A Pathetic Follow-Up to a Splendid First Part
johnnghome19 February 2018
It is just unbelievable how two parts of a movie can be so extreme. "Journey to the West Conquering the Demons 2013" is a very well made movie that leaves the viewer wanting more. I was really excited about this follow up "The Demons Strike Back (2017)" until I had a chance to watch it... and wasted my time.

The movie seems to be mostly CGI. The CGI is jumpy and almost feels like watching a movie in fast motion. The colour contrast is much too unpleasantly vibrant and sharp.

The storyline... well there is none really. It is more like watching a plotless cartoon of punches. Some parts of the movie even get a little embarrassing and irritating such as watching the emperor throw tantrums.

Overall, I would give this move minus two stars but zero star is the worst I could do.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Remove your expectations like you did in the first movie!
yueicaru8 June 2018
There are so many hate in this movie here in IMDb, but hater always hate. People nowadays like to compare and expect the best, but then gets easily disappointed more than ever.

For me, this movie is a perfect sequel and a must-watch for teens and adults. The recast is not as bad as they say and the actors fit their roles perfectly. The story is unpredictable and humorous with amazing visuals just like the first movie. There's also more CGI, not like GoT or Avengers quality, but better than the first and still satisfying. I really enjoyed the movie and I'm very excited to see what will happen next. The same feelings I had after finishing the first movie, surprised and thrilled.

This is my first review and I hope you see this fair and unbiased. Don't believe what others say. Watch the first movie and then give this one a chance. You'll not regret it!
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Go in with an open mind
soonyoongkit2 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
You need to go in with an open mind. Forget about what you know on the classic "Journey To The West", do not expect the traditional "Journey To The West" movies where Monkey King rules the world. Although some would not like the idea of the Red Kid "Hong Hai Er" in CGI form, but I found it amazing that the character was represented differently and uniquely. The entire city linked very well to his character and reminded me of "Alice in the Wonderland". The idea of this kind of adoption is totally new, in fact, may be unacceptable to many viewers. Tsui Hark has been my all time favorite HK director and though this movie may not be his best, but the concept and idea were refreshing.
8 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
A journey to the best
lizzykin4 February 2017
With the iconic director, Stephen Chow, as producer and screen writer and Hark Tsui, as director and popular superstar Kris Wu as the leading actor, the highly anticipated movie "a Journey to West: Demon Chapter" has every reasons to be business successful. Majority of people go to movie to enjoy Stephen Chow's signature sense of humor and the mind-blowing special effect, which by the way, is one of the best in China. The movie did live up to their expectation. The highest box office has proved that audience is satisfied.

But movie critics may hesitate to see the movie because they think it would be another remake of the classic Chinese traditional folk tale "a journey to west". As it turns out, the movie "a Journey to West: Demon Chapter " is everything but cliché.

Based on the novel, the relationships among character had further developed, new screenplay gave those characters more human touch and the movie was able to show another side of main character. Especially by demonstrating the interaction between Tang Seng and The Monkey King, and the flash back of Ms. Duan, the movie has shown us that Tang Seng was not only a determined monk but also a man with emotions and wisdom. Without giving too much details, I have to say that the plot of the movie is exciting and more importantly, surprising. Last but not lease, the actors are also worth mentioning. The way the movie portraits character is unexpected yet amazingly enjoyable, from the artistic style design to the actor selection, especially Tang Seng, Kris Wu has shown that he is more than just a pretty face.

All in all, "a Journey to West: Demon Chapter" is a success both in box revenue and among critics.
13 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Great Film
logatherum2 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Journey to the West was such a great film! It was one of my favorite foreign films I have seen. I really thought it was super strange, but I have to give the producers/ directors credit because it really was so bizarre in a unique way; I had not seen anything like it! I thought that the actors were also very talented, even the extras, and sometimes that isn't always the case in action movies because I often find that when extras try to act scared, it is obvious they are acting. It was probably extra hard to act in this film as well, since the actors had to initially react and be afraid of a creature that hadn't been put into the frame yet (since the beasts were only computer graphics). I really do not know anything about computer graphics or digital design, but from my view, this aspect of the film was really well done. I didn't really find any part to look "fake", and of it even came close to that, it was more funny than noticeably fake. This is also probably the most comical foreign film I have ever watched; many others I have seen are not, so this was a nice break from all the dramatic and serious films I am used to watching Culturally, I thought that Journey to the West was very interesting, including the fact that demons are a part of the Chinese culture (or were at one time). Since these particular "demons" were not real neither in the film nor real life, whether the actors believe in them (for the sake of their culture) or not, it was a break from the other foreign films I've seen, to see a film centered around such fictitious beasts. Although I did my really understand what was going on for some of the film, my attention was definitely kept and never once was bored. My only complaint would be that it was very hard to understand and keep up with (at least in my opinion).
8 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Same as the first one.
yoghert_5518 December 2018
It feels pretty much the same.

But there is a bit more CGI, while also that CGI being a bit cheaper than the first one. So that's a bit unfortunate. But it's ok, the CGI is better in the big fights, and they are pretty cool, especially the one in the city.

Overall I'd say the first one was a 9 and this is more a 7.5 which is still good for this crazy weird fantasy :)
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back*******
amai27393 February 2017
Taking over for directing duties for this sequel is Tsui Hark, while Stephen Chow wrote & is producing this, 2 legendary film makers collaborating. Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back, Let me just say this, this is slightly not as good as its predecessor in storytelling but very entertaining, nonetheless. I do believe, this was a risk that Stephen Chow took with this sequel but I fairly enjoyed it. I love the visuals, the action sequences filled with astounding CGI (The special effects were far better than I expected, another instance that I thought was amazing Computer-generated imagery was when Sun Wukong gets into his monkey form), this movie's style definitely has Tsui Hark written all over it. In my opinion, I thought this movie lack the cohesiveness the first movie had. But then there's something about this one that I am very fond of. Maybe it's the unique take on it, I've always liked Stephen Chow's inventiveness for his films, his imagination. Overall, I truly enjoyed it, I thought it was an entertaining movie, get a laugh, a fun & action packed journey, with eye-popping CGI, worth watching.
6 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
The Journey loses it's excitement in the translation I think?
subxerogravity15 February 2017
Journey To The West bored me, the same way that Monkey King 2 bored me. I'm starting to think that maybe the monkey king is not my thing (Although, DragonBall has to be some sort of adaption to the character do to a big likeness between the two (Same way Marvel's Thor is similar but does not full mimic the Norse mythology).

Maybe unlike anime, I can't watch these movies with subtitles . As an American use to Hollywood Blockbusters when I see an actor alone on a screen interacting with characters that were made in a computer, I'm expecting a lot more action adventure to my Fantasy, but all I got here was talk. This may have not been that bad but I feel that the comedy did not translate well with subtitles. Having to read and look at the visuals did not work this time.

Plus the anime style cartoonery did not translate well to live action. Some of the visual gags timing was fine, but it really did not click. I appreciate the attempt but I just thought it was stupid in the long run.

Like with Monkey King 2, my favorite part of this film was the lone epic action scene at the end of the movie that was big and the reason that anyone would buy a ticket to see it in 3D. Although it's not worth the ticket cause that one scene does not make this movie. I've seen films that one part can make the whole movie but The Demons Strike Back is not complex enough for that. It starts slow continues slow and then ends epic but that greatness does not make up for all the slowness.

The visual effects are OK but not good enough for a picture to bore me with them. Very standard an unimpressive (Except for the 3D spectacular that ends the film).

Maybe my knowledge (Or lack of) the Monkey King is steering my judgement, maybe I'm expecting too much from a Chinese Blockbuster (My favorite part was at the end credits when the filmmakers did a bit that confirms that this movie is the Chinese version of the Blockbuster), but this latest adaption of Journey To The West is not doing it for me at all. Maybe I need to see if they do an English dub that might translate better, and change my mine.
7 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Monkey King no longer like banana
ayltt21 February 2017
Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back better than the vast majority of Chinese films. In contrast, the other Journey to the West movies are cottage stuff (especially Journey 3 by Jeffrey Lau). Slander should be from Hong Kong garbage films lover, enjoy eating bananas and assumed that monkey always eat bananas, but do not ask Stephen Chow and Tsui Harks' Monkey King also eat bananas. Their Monkey King already in a Journey of seeking Tao and Buddhism.
8 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Best movie ever made
durianzilla12 June 2020
This is the best movie ever made because the Xue hua piao piao pei fung xiao xiao guy was in it. Automatic 10/10
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
My Idol
tinhbotngheacumin5 August 2018
With the iconic director, Stephen Chow, as producer and screen writer and Hark Tsui, as director and popular superstar Kris Wu as the leading actor, the highly anticipated movie "a Journey to West: Demon Chapter" has every reasons to be business successful. Majority of people go to movie to enjoy Stephen Chow's signature sense of humor and the mind-blowing special effect, which by the way, is one of the best in China. The movie did live up to their expectation. The highest box office has proved that audience is satisfied.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Stephen Chao should really just stick with acting.
OllieSuave-0074 November 2017
Saw this movie on a plane and while it was OK to pass the time with, the film as a whole was pretty bad. The humor was poorly done with unfunny jokes and unfunny slapstick stuff. While the action was pretty intense in some parts, particular the fight between the monks' disciples with the White Bone Spirit, it was too heavy on the CGI.

The monk Tang Sanzang was portrayed like a clueless clown and the three disciples, Monkey King, Pigsy and Sandy, acted pretty useless for the most part. There was too much arguing and bickering among one another, particularly between Tang Sanzang and the Monkey King.

It was hard to believe that the great Hark Tsui directed this movie, but not surprised that funnyman Stephen Chao produced. He really should just stick to acting, as I honestly think his talents are better used on stage.

Grade D-
3 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
If first one was bad this is even worse
sauravjoshi855 March 2020
Journey to the west: The demons strike back is a fantasy comedy movie directed by Tsui Hark and stars Kris Wu, Lin Gengxin, Yao Chen, Lin Yun, Yang Yiwei, Mengke Bateer and Wang Duo.

This movie is entirely dependent on VFX and fails miserably in terms of storyline. The movie is slow and at some point turns boring.

Acting is good by the characters but they also couldn't save the poorly executed movie.

Avoid if you can.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
The student in every teacher, a child in every man.
Ascendingsun4 January 2020
The Poem in the novel "Journey to the West" - "I used to have a sincere love in front of me. I didn't cherish it. I regret it when I lost it. The most painful thing in the world is this. If God can give I have a chance to come again, I will say thse words to that girl: I love you. If I have to add a deadline to this love, I hope it is-ten thousand years! "

Tang Seng embarked on the path of Scripture, burying the survivors in his heart.

If the thought of this being a sequel is erased, the film presents a strong notion of timelessness or transcience of time. There is a past not witnessed in the film, and yet carried along in memories, there is the future, moments imagined, feared or desired. And there is the now, witnessing things go by., events seeming real or unreal. The ghostly girl Tang Seng loses at the end feels like a reincarnation of his missed old love, and when he says to her that his heart still belongs to his old love, it is like the past repeats itself, he is letting things go by, not owning or holding onto them, he lets them die. He becomes a mere observer. The last scene of him imagining Miss Duan in place of his disciple makes one see that love he once felt is taking shape of other people on his journey. There is no longer only one person, there's many.

Tsui Hark is mainly a master of character building in very efficient ways, and as a technical virtuoso, also a craftsman of visual poetry serving his philosophical concepts and ideas, Journey To The West is a beautiful example of his open heart and spirit let loose, depicting the world of illusions or undead, whether demons, spirits or ghosts of people lost in memories. The music by Raymond Wong captured my heart with its exquisite innovative touches ranging from Mexican to Chinese influence, the last time he was musically involved with Tsui Hark was for Love In The Time Of Twilight in 1995.

I find the power of the film residing in its ability to focus on the depth behind each character presented in a way that can entertain on a surface level just as much. It is reflecting the time when a lot of people facing their own inner demons, when leaders revealing their own true self, their immaturity, sometimes being treated like coddled children. And also spiritual masters who show their own hypocrisy. All these observations come from my own experience.

The film is a jewel embedded in my memory, memorable and significant, for its uplifting energy as well as political, social and spiritual angles.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Meandering Mess
scythertitus17 April 2021
Suffers from a lot of the same problems as the first but lacks the central love story to keep it all together.

Kind of continues the story but feels like filler, aimless wandering where some feelings over events are aired out. It might look better if a third film comes out to connect it.

Overall it's okay, but it feels more like DLC than an actual sequel, and the casting changes are pretty jarring.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews

Recently Viewed