(PDF) Merriam Webster Dictionary of English Usage | Hamed Rahimi - Academia.edu

Merriam Webster Dictionary of English Usage

Hamed Rahimi
This Paper
A short summary of this paper
35 Full PDFs related to this paper
Ci WjeMum-luels&i Webster's Dictionary of EnglishUsage. The definitive guide to Modern English usage. Scholarship, authority, and the support of more than 20,000 illustrative quotations from some of the best writers in the language. Webster's Dictionary of EnglishUsage Entry irregardless This adverb, apparently a blend of irre- spective and regardless, originated in dialectal Ameri- can speech in the early 20th century (according to the History of American Dialect Dictionary, it was first recorded in the usage western Indiana in 1912). Its use in nonstandard speech had become widespread enough by the 1920s to make it a natural in a story by Ring Lardner: I told them that irregardless of what you read in books, they's some members of the theatrical profession that occasionally visits the place where they sleep —Ring Lardner, The Big Town, 1921 Its widespread use also made it a natural in books by usage commentators, and it has appeared in such History of books regularly at least since Krapp 1927. The most the criticism frequently repeated comment about it is that "there is no such word." Word or not, irregardless has continued in fairly common spoken use, although its bad reputation has Analysis of not improved with the years. It does occur in the casual contemporary speech and writing of educated people, and it even usage finds its way into edited prose on rare occasion: . . . allow the supplier to deliver his product, irre- gardless of whether or not his problem is solved —John Cosgrove, Datamation, 1 Dec. 1971 Examples of . . . irrespective of whether the source is identified contemporary - and irregardless of whether all that news is dissem- usage inated to the general public —Robert Hanley, N.Y. Times, 25 Oct. 1977 The spherical agglomerates occur in these pow- ders, irregardless of starting composition —Pred- icasts Technology Update, 25 Aug. 1984 But irregardless is still a long way from winning general acceptance as a standard English word. Use regardless Conclusion and instead. recommendation A GENUINE MERRIAM-WEBSTER9 ISBN 0-0777T-035- c l More people take our word for it 38915 780877"790327" Webster's Dictionary of EnglishUsage Webster's Dictionary of English Usage is a work of unparalleled au- thority and scholarship from Merriam- Webster, America's leading dictionary publisher for almost 150 years. Our editors have long been documenting the use of those words that pose spe- cial problems of confused or disputed usage. Thus this work brings to the reader resources that include what is believed to be the world's largest archive of 20th-century English usage, almost 14 million citations (examples of words used in context), collected over 100 years from thousands of sources, ranging from the Times Literary Sup- plement to Scientific American. Webster's Dictionary of English Usage is intended to serve the reader or writer who wishes to go beyond the personal predilections of a particular commentator or the subjective pro- nouncements of a usage panel. It is ideal for anyone who wants to under- stand the nature of the problematical usage and what others have had to say about it; how accomplished writers actually deal with the matter, whether what they do is in keeping with the received wisdom or not; and the basis for the advice offered. Webster's Dictionary of English Usage presents all of these things in a clear and readable fashion. For those who love the language this is not just a reference book to be picked up only to settle a dispute or solve a practical writing problem. Here is the real stuff of language, the opportunity to experi- ence its vitality through more than MERRIAM-WEBSTER INC. Springfield, MA 01102 20,000 illustrative quotations from the best writers in the language. Webster's Dictionary of English Usage belongs on the bookshelf or desk of everyone who is serious about the language. Its wealth of information and careful guidance will amply repay the modest investment of its purchase. ADDITIONAL REFERENCES FROM MERRIAM-WEBSTER • THE UNABRIDGED DICTIONARY Webster's Third New International — A masterpiece of modern defining—more than 460,000 entries, with 200,000 usage examples and 1,000 synonym articles. 3,000 terms illustrated. Sim- plified pronunciation key and clear, informative etymologies. The standard authority. • DESK SIZE DICTIONARY Webster's Ninth New Collegiate—The newest in the famous Collegiate Series. Almost 160,000 entries and 200,000 definitions. Entries for words often mis- used and confused include a clear, authoritative guide to good usage. No other dictionary resolves more issues —how to spell it, how to say it, how to use it. And it is the dictionary that tells you how old a word is. • THESAURUS Webster's Collegiate Thesaurus—At last a new and innovative thesaurus that makes word-finding easy. More than 100,000 synonyms, antonyms, idiomatic phrases, related and con- trasted words to choose from. An in- valuable guide to a more precise and effective use of the language. MERRIAM-WEBSTER INC. Springfield, MA 01102 Webster's Dictionary of English Usage d ® ® Merriam-Webster Inc., Publishers Springfield, Massachusetts A GENUINE MERRIAM-WEBSTER The name Webster alone is no guarantee of excellence. It is used by a number of publishers and may serve mainly to mislead an unwary buyer. A Merriam- Webster® is the registered trademark you should look for when you consider the purchase of dictionaries or other fine reference books. It carries the reputation of a company that has been publishing since 1831 and is your assurance of quality and authority. Copyright © 1989 by Merriam-Webster Inc. Philippines Copyright 1989 by Merriam-Webster Inc. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Main entry under title: Webster's dictionary of English usage. Bibliography: p. 974 1. English language—Usage—Dictionaries. PE1460.W425 1989 428/.003 88-37248 ISBN 0-87779-032-9 All rights reserved. No part of this book covered by the copyrights hereon may be reproduced or copied in any form or by any means—graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including photocopying, taping, or information storage and retrieval systems—without written permission of the publisher. Made in the United States of America 3456RA919089 Preface Webster's Dictionary of English Usage examines and ers, and others. The Explanatory Notes attempt to antic- evaluates common problems of confused or disputed ipate users' questions with information about the con- English usage from two perspectives: that of historical ventions employed within the dictionary itself. Fol- background, especially as shown in the great historical lowing the last entry is a Bibliography, which serves the dictionaries, and that of present-day usage, chiefly as dual purpose of recording those commentaries on usage, shown by evidence in the Merriam-Webster files. Most dictionaries, grammars, and other works frequently con- of the topics treated have been selected from existing sulted during the writing of this book and being a source books on usage, primarily those published in the second of suggestions for further reading. half of the 20th century; a few have emerged too recently It is the fate of most of the harmless drudges in the to have yet become part of the tradition of usage com- lexicographical world to receive their most material mentary. We have also ranged freely over much earlier tribute in the unread front matter of a book. This time- books, many of which contain the seeds of current con- honored tradition will be continued here. By rights the cerns. Most of our topics have been commented on by entire Merriam-Webster editorial staff could be listed, numerous writers; the pet peeves of individual com- since almost everyone has contributed at least indi- mentators have in the main been passed over. During rectly, but instead we will list only those who worked the course of writing this book, new books on usage directly on the book. Staff members are grouped accord- were published, and they find mention in entries written ing to their several tasks. The conspicuous avoidance of after they were received, but no systematic attempt has alphabetical order in listing names is intended only to been made to incorporate mention of them in entries provide a temporary escape from the tyranny of the written before they were received. alphabet. Besides articles dealing with the traditional concerns The articles were written by Stephen J. Perrault, of usage, we have included many illustrating idiomatic Kathleen M. Doherty, David B. Justice, Madeline L. English usage, chiefly in the area of which prepositions Novak, and E. Ward oilman. They were taken in hand go with which nouns, verbs, and adjectives. In our selec- for copyediting by James G. Lowe, Madeline L. Novak, tion of these we have simply included those that have John M. Morse, and Stephen J. Perrault. The quotations come readily to our attention and have not tried to have been verified by Kathleen M. Doherty, who also make an exhaustive search for them. A thorough treat- compiled the bibliography. Eileen M. Haraty has con- ment of English idioms would require an entire book at nected all the loose wires of cross-reference. The both- least as large as this one. We think our selection is fairly ersome business of proofreading has been carried out by generous—there are about 500 entries—and we have Daniel J. Hopkins, Paul F. Cappellano, Peter D. Haraty, been careful to illustrate instances of varying usage. A Julie A. Collier, Kelly L. Tierney, and Robert D. Cope- number of common spelling problems are also dis- land, as well as some of the aforementioned. The manu- cussed briefly. While the emphasis of this work is prop- script was deciphered and turned into readable type- erly on usage in writing, a small group of articles has script for the compositor by Georgette B. Boucher, been devoted to problems of pronunciation. Barbara A. Winkler, and Helene Gingold; other kinds of Insofar as practicable, we have generously supplied invaluable clerical assistance have been performed by the articles with illustrative quotations on the theory Ruth W. Gaines and Gloria J. Afflitto. Madeline L. that examples of actual usage are more valuable to one Novak directed the book through its typesetting stages. who is actually grappling with a problem in usage than Francine A. Roberts cajoled copies of rare books from are the made-up examples many commentators rely on. various college and university libraries. The entire The bulk of these quotations have been taken from the manuscript has been reviewed by Frederick C. Mish, Merriam-Webster files. We have supplemented our own Editorial Director. resources, as necessary, with quotations taken from James Thurber once referred in a letter to "the perils other published sources, such as the historical dictio- of typo and garble." No reference work is immune from naries and Otto Jespersen's seven-volume Modern these perils in spite of the diligent efforts of copy editors English Grammar. We have tried to identify parenthet- and proofreaders. We can only hope that if you encoun- ically every citation taken from these publications. ter a typo or garble that has slipped through, you are not This preface is followed in the front matter by two misled or confused. We would be glad to know of any sections which we recommend to all users of this work. that are found. A Brief History of English Usage will provide useful ori- We believe that Webster's Dictionary of English entation for readers who wonder how questions involv- Usage contains a wealth of information, along with ing no more than a tiny portion of the huge vocabulary some quite practical advice, and that you will find it a of English and a handful of grammatical constructions useful, interesting, and occasionally entertaining work came to take on so much importance to teachers, writ- of reference. E. Ward Gilman Editor 4a Explanatory Notes Articles of the title combined with the date (as Prentice Hall 1978 or Heritage 1969). Each article in this dictionary, like the entries in a gen- A dictionary referred to as a record of usage is usually eral dictionary, is introduced by one or more boldface given its title without a date on its first appearance in an words indicating the subject for discussion: article (as Dictionary of American Regional English) but media is thereafter referred to by a customary abbreviation (as glimpse, glance DARE). The exception to this last rule is the Oxford reason is because English Dictionary, which is consistently cited by the agreement: indefinite pronouns well-known abbreviation OED. Noah Webster's An American Dictionary of the English Language and its Words that are homographs are distinguished by italic successor editions are cited in this way: editions from labels indicating part of speech: 1828 to 1909 appear as Webster and the year of publi- cation. The two most recent (and most familiar) edi- hold, verb tions are simply called Webster's Second and Webster's hold, noun Third, for the most part, but a date is sometimes added An article that treats more than one aspect of its sub- when it seems to be helpful in the context. ject may be divided into sections, each section intro- Full references to all works cited in these ways appear duced by a boldface arabic numeral. Where it seems use- in the Bibliography at the end of this volume. ful, the topic of the section is indicated with an introductory word or phrase: locate... Illustrative Quotations 1. Locate "settle." . . . This book includes thousands of illustrative quotations 2. Located "situated." . . . intended to clarify and to test the discussion. These may 3. Locate "find." . . . very occasionally be run in with the text but are usually The articles in this dictionary are too diverse and indented and are always followed by an attribution, typ- many are too complex for all to be treated according to ically consisting of the author's name (if known), the a single uniform pattern. The longer ones, however, usu- title of the book or serial, and the date of publication. ally contain all or most of the following elements: origin When the sources discussed in the last section are and development of the usage with examples, origin and quoted, however, the usual shortened form of attribu- development of criticism of the usage, the contempo- tion is used. rary status of the usage with examples, review of alter- We have not italicized the word or construction being natives, summary and recommendation. The order and illustrated in a quotation, so that the typographic con- proportion of the elements vary with the requirements ventions of each passage as we found it can be repro- of the topic, of course. duced with reasonable accuracy. We have tried not to interfere with spelling. If the editor of an old work cited in a modern edition modernized the spelling, we have used it; if the editor preserved the old spelling, we have Citation of Sources used that. We have only very rarely modernized spelling on our own and then only to make old words more eas- Sources cited within the text of an article—as distinct ily recognizable. We have, however, silently corrected a from illustrative quotations, discussed below—are han- few typographical errors irrelevant to the matter under dled in two different ways. Works cited infrequently are discussion. identified at each appearance by author, title, and date Quotations have been dated, insofar as possible, in of publication. Works cited frequently are treated in a order to establish the antiquity of a locution or its cur- different way, in order to conserve space. References to rency at some particular time or to show when an unfa- these works—chiefly books of commentary on English miliar writer was working. As a reader you can generally usage, handbooks for writers of various kinds, gram- assume that any quotation from the last fifty years or so mars, and dictionaries—take a shortened form, most represents current usage—editors have frequently pre- often the author's last name and the date of the book's ferred a clear older quotation to an ambiguous or publication (as Fowler 1926 or Bolinger 1980). This unhelpful newer one. form of attribution has conveniently allowed us to refer The date given for a work that has passed through either to author or to work as the discourse requires. several editions is, in general, the date of the edition The context will always make clear which reference is actually seen by us. Exceptions are made for famous intended. works of earlier periods, for which the date is usually Handbooks and dictionaries cited as sources of usage that of original publication, even though we may have opinion may instead be cited by an identifying element consulted a modern edition. This policy has inevitably 5a 6a Explanatory Notes led to some inconsistencies that the observant reader throughout the book. These may take any of several may notice between our dates and those given by other forms. If the term where the discussion is located is sources. These are most likely with old works (as the mentioned within the text, a parenthetical "(which see)" poems of Chaucer or the plays of Shakespeare) for is placed immediately after the term. All other cross-ref- which we may have used one conventional set of dates erences are in small capital letters; they may appear at while an older reference work, such as the Dictionary of the end of an article or section of an article, or they may Americanisms or the Oxford English Dictionary, may receive separate entry: have used a different one. Similar problems are created by different editions of a work. Henry Alford's A Plea good 1 . Feel good, feel well.... for the Queen's English, for instance, originally appeared See also FEEL BAD, FEEL BADLY. in 1864. Our copy is the American edition of 1866. under the circumstances See CIRCUMSTANCES. Some usage commentators may refer to the earlier edi- tion and others to the later; you may thus find his name No separate entry is made, however, if it would fall with 1864 in one place and 1866 in another. immediately before or after the article where the discus- We have taken a few liberties with the sources of quo- sion is located. Thus, the misspelling quandry is dis- tations, generally omitting initial the when it is part of cussed at quandary, but no entry for the former appears. the title of a periodical, and abbreviating supplement, magazine, journal, and review. Short titles like Robin- son Crusoe and Tom Sawyer are used for a few well- Pronunciation known works. Articles on problems of pronunciation necessarily include pronunciation respellings. The symbols used in Cross-Reference these respellings are essentially those of Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary and are explained on the Directional cross-references to articles where relevant Pronunciation Symbols page, which faces the first page discussion may be found are employed liberally of the dictionary. A Brief History of English Usage English usage today is an area of discourse—some- the doubters sought to put flesh on the bare bones of times it seems more like dispute—about the way words English by importing words from Latin, Italian, and are used and ought to be used. This discourse makes up French—the European languages of learned and grace- the subject matter of a large number of books that put ful discourse. Among those who enriched English from the word usage in their titles. Behind usage as a subject the word stock of Europe were Sir Thomas Elyot and Sir lies a collection of opinions about what English gram- Thomas More. Opposed to these enrichers of the lan- mar is or should be, about the propriety of using certain guage were purists such as Roger Ascham and Sir John words and phrases, and about the social status of those Cheke, who preferred their English, rude as it might be, who use certain words and constructions. A fairly large untainted by foreign imports. The imported learned number of these opinions have been with us long terms became known as inkhorn terms, and their use enough to be regarded as rules or at least to be referred and misuse by the imperfectly educated became the sub- to as rules. In fact they are often regarded as rules of ject of much lively satire—some of it written by Shake- grammar, even if they concern only matters of social speare, among many others. status or vocabulary selection. And many of these rules In addition to the controversy over imported words are widely believed to have universal application, even there were other concerns, such as the state of English though they are far from universally observed. spelling. In those days people mostly spelled things the To understand how these opinions and rules devel- way they sounded, and there was little uniformity oped, we have to go back in history, at least as far back indeed. A number of people consequently became inter- as the year 1417, when the official correspondence of ested in spelling reform. Among these was the school- Henry V suddenly and almost entirely stopped being master Richard Mulcaster, who may have served as the written in French and started being written in English. model for Shakespeare's pedant Holofernes. Mulcaster By mid-century many government documents and even and the somewhat later Edmund Coote were interested private letters were in English, and before 1500 even in regularizing spelling as best they could. There were statutes were being recorded in the mother tongue. This more radical reformers, too—John Hart, Sir Thomas restoration of English as the official language of the royal Smith, and William Bullokar are examples—who bureaucracy was one very important influence on the devised phonetic alphabets to better represent English gradual emergence of a single standard dialect of English speech sounds. Bullokar is worthy of note for another out of the many varied regional dialects that already reason: in 1586 he published Bref Grammar for existed. English now had to serve the functions formerly English—the first English grammar book. It was prob- served by Latin and French, languages which had ably intended as an introduction to the subsequent already assumed standard forms, and this new reality study of Latin grammar. was a powerful spur to the formation of a standard in So 16th-century interest in language produced two of writing English that could be quite independent of var- the basic tools of the writer on usage. Bullokar, out of iable speech. The process was certainly not completed his interest in regularizing and reforming, had been within the 15th century, but increasingly the written moved to write a grammar of English. And the vocab- form of the language that modern scholars call Chancery ulary controversy—the introduction of inkhorn terms English had its effect, in combination with other influ- by the enrichers and the revival of English archaisms by ences such as the newfangled process of printing from the purists (of whom the poet Edmund Spenser was movable type. one)—led another schoolmaster, Robert Cawdrey, to But the rise of Standard English did not by itself gen- produce the first English dictionary in 1604. erate concern over usage. There was no special interest The 17th century provides several more signposts on in language as such at that time. Indeed, the English his- the way to the treatment of usage as we know it. One of torian G. M. Trevelyan called the 15th century, until its these is the expression of a desire for regulation of the last fifteen or twenty years, the most intellectually bar- language by an academy similar to the ones established ren epoch in English history since the Norman con- in Italy in the 16th century and in France in 1635. Calls quest. Not until Henry VII had established himself on for the establishment of an English academy came as the throne near the end of the century did the intellec- early as 1617; among the writers to urge one were John tual ferment of the European Renaissance begin to be Dryden in 1664, John Evelyn in 1665, and Daniel Defoe felt in England. By the middle of the 16th century the in 1697. English Renaissance was in full flower, and the revival More grammar books were also published at this of learning and letters brought with it a conscious inter- time. Ben Jonson's appeared posthumously in 1640. It est in the English language as a medium for literature is short and sketchy and is intended for the use of for- and learned discourse. There were those who had their eigners. Its grammar is descriptive, but Jonson hung his doubts about its suitability. Still, the desire to use the observations on a Latin grammatical framework. It also vernacular rather than Latin was strong, and some of seems to be the first English grammar book to quote the 7a 8a History of English Usage Roman rhetorician Quintilian's dictum "Custom is the discussing the construction where a preposition comes most certain mistress of language." at the end of a clause or sentence, he says, "This is an John Wallis, a mathematician and member of the idiom, which our language is strongly inclined to." Royal Society, published in 1658 a grammar, written in Lowth's grammar was not written for children. But he Latin, for the use of foreigners who wanted to learn did what he intended to so well that subsequent gram- English. Wallis, according to George H. McKnight, marians fairly fell over themselves in haste to get out abandoned much of the method of Latin grammar. Wal- versions of Lowth suitable for school use, and most sub- lis's grammar is perhaps best remembered for being the sequent grammars—including Noah Webster's first— source of the much discussed distinction between shall were to some extent based upon Lowth's. and will. Wallis's grammar is also the one referred to by The older descriptive tradition of Jonson and Wallis Samuel Johnson in the front matter of his 1755 was not quite dead, however. Joseph Priestley's gram- dictionary. mar, first published in 1761, used false syntax too, but John Dryden deserves mention too. He defended the in the main Priestley was more tolerant of established English of his time as an improvement over the English usages that Lowth considered to be in error. In his later of Shakespeare and Jonson. He is the first person we editions he politely but firmly disagreed with Lowth on know of who worried about the preposition at the end specific points. Priestley's grammar enjoyed some suc- of a sentence. He eliminated many such from his own cess and his opinions were treated with respect, but he writings when revising his works for a collected edition. was not imitated like Lowth. He seems to have decided the practice was wrong The most successful of the Lowth adapters was because it could not happen in Latin. Lindley Murray. Murray was an American living in C. C. Fries tells us that 17th-century grammars in gen- England—Dennis Baron informs us that he had made a eral were designed either for foreigners or for school use, considerable fortune trading with the Loyalists during in order to lead to the study of Latin. In the 18th cen- the American Revolution and had moved to England tury, however, grammars were written predominantly ostensibly for reasons of health. Friends asked him to ' for English speakers, and although they were written for write a grammar for use in an English girls' school, and the purpose of instructing, they seem to find more fun he obliged. Murray considered himself only a compiler, in correcting. A change in the underlying philosophy of and that he was. He took over verbatim large patches grammar had occurred, and it is made explicit in per- from Lowth and teased them out with pieces taken from haps the first 18th-century grammar, A Key to the Art of Priestley and a few other grammarians and rhetoricians. Letters. . . , published in 1700 by a schoolmaster named He removed the authors' names from the false syntax A. Lane. He thought it a mistake to view grammar sim- and stirred in a heavy dose of piety. He silently and ply as a means to learn a foreign language and asserted primly corrected Lowth's jocular little clause to "to that "the true End and Use of Grammar is to teach how which our language is strongly inclined." The resulting to speak and write well and learnedly in a language mixture was one of the most successful grammar books already known, according to the unalterable Rules of ever, remaining a standard text in American schools for right Reason." Gone was Ben Jonson's appeal to a half century. custom. George Campbell's The Philosophy of Rhetoric, 1776, There was evidently a considerable amount of general is not a grammar book proper, but it contains a long dis- interest in things grammatical among men of letters, for cussion of grammatical proprieties. Campbell starts out Addison, Steele, and Swift all treated grammar in one sensibly enough; he says that grammar is based on way or another in The Tatler and The Spectator in 1710, usage, and he rejects notions of an abstract or universal 1711, and 1712. In 1712 Swift published yet another grammar. But he then proceeds to examine usage, con- proposal for an English academy (it came within a whis- cluding that the usage that counts is reputable, national, ker of succeeding); John Oldmixon attacked Swift's pro- and present use. He goes on to present nine canons of posal in the same year. Public interest must have helped verbal criticism, by one or another of which he can create a market for the grammar books which began reject any usage he chooses to. By the time all the dis- appearing with some frequency about this same time. cussions of barbarisms, solecisms, and improprieties are And if controversy fuels sales, grammarians knew it; finished—the discussions are well supplied with exam- they were perfectly willing to emphasize their own ples from many of Bishop Lowth's favorite whipping advantages by denigrating their predecessors, some- boys—it is quite apparent that the reputable, national, times in abusive terms. and present use that passes all tests is simply whatever We need mention only a few of these productions suits the taste of George Campbell. here. Pride of place must go to Bishop Robert Lowth's Books of grammar and rhetoric had existed in English A Short Introduction to English Grammar, 1762. from the 16th and 17th centuries. The 18th century's Lowth's book is both brief and logical. Lowth was influ- new contribution was the book of unvarnished usage enced by the theories of James Harris's Hermes, 1751, a opinion, best exemplified by Robert Baker's anony- curious disquisition about universal grammar. Lowth mously published Reflections on the English Language, apparently derived his notions about the perfectability 1770. (Baker was apparently anticipated in this genre by of English grammar from Harris, and he did not doubt Observations upon the English Language, 1752, another that he could reduce the language to a system of uniform anonymous publication, ascribed by Sterling A. Leon- rules. Lowth's approach was strictly prescriptive; he ard to one George Harris.) We know nothing of Baker meant to improve and correct, not describe. He judged except what he put down about himself in his preface. correctness by his own rules—mostly derived from He says that he left school at fifteen, that he learned no Latin grammar—which frequently went against estab- Greek and only the easiest Latin, that he has never seen lished usage. His favorite mode of illustration is what the folio edition of Johnson's Dictionary, and that he was known as "false syntax": examples of linguistic owns no books. He fancies he has good taste, however, wrongdoing from the King James Bible, Shakespeare, and he clearly understands French. His book is pat- Sidney, Donne, Milton, Swift, Addison, Pope—the terned on Remarques sur la languefrançoise, 1659, writ- most respected names in English literature. He was so ten by Claude Faure de Vaugelas, a leading member of sure of himself that he could permit himself a little joke; the French Academy. History of English Usage 9a Baker's Reflections is a random collection of com- wealth of illustrative material from his collection of ments, mostly about what he considers misuses, based examples to bear on the various points of contention. chiefly on books that he has borrowed or read. He brings Hall's evidence should have been more than enough to forward no authorities to support his ipse dixit pro- overwhelm White's unsupported assertions, but it was nouncements, many of which are on the order of "This not. Partly to blame is the public's disdain of the schol- is not good English" or "This does not make sense." Yet arly, and partly to blame is Hall's style—he never makes a surprising number of the locutions he questioned are a point succinctly, but lets his most trenchant observa- still to be found as topics of discussion in current books tions dissipate in a cloud of sesquipedalian after- on usage. It is less surprising, perhaps, that the moderns thoughts. White's books, Mencken tells us, remained in are still repeating Baker's conclusions. print until the 1930s; Hall's collection of examples The 19th century is so rich in usage lore that it is hard became part of the foundations of the Oxford English to summarize. We find something new in the entrance Dictionary. of journalists into the usage field. Reviews had com- Two other 19th-century innovations deserve men- mented on grammatical matters throughout the 18th tion. William Cullen Bryant's Index Expurgatorius, century, it is true, but in the 19th newspapers and mag- 1877, is the start of the American newspaper tradition azines with wider popular appeal began to pronounce. in usage—works written by newspaper editors. Bryant One result of this activity was the usage book that con- was editor-in-chief and part owner of the New York Eve- sists of pieces first written for a newspaper or magazine ning Post. His Index is simply a list of words not to be and then collected into a book along with selected com- used in the Post; there was no explanatory matter. Lists ments and suggestions by readers (this type of book is of forbidden words were popular for a time afterward, still common today). Perhaps the first of these was A but the fashion passed. The newspaper editor as usage Plea for the Queen's English, 1864, by Henry Alford, arbiter has continued to the present, however. The dean of Canterbury. Alford was vigorously attacked by pseudonymous Alfred Ayres in The Verbalist, 1881, George Washington Moon, a writer born in London of seems to have been the first, or one of the first, of these American parents, in a work that eventually became to arrange his comments in alphabetical order, creating titled The Dean's English. The controversy fueled sev- a sort of dictionary of usage. eral editions of both books and seems to have enter- In the early decades of the Republic, many Americans tained readers on both sides of the Atlantic. patriotically supported the home-grown version of the On the American side of the Atlantic the puristic language against the language of the vanquished British strictures of Edward S. Gould, originally newspaper and oppressors. There were proposals for a Federal magazine contributions, were collected as Good English English—Noah Webster was in the forefront of the in 1867. Gould was apparently annoyed to find that movement—and for the establishment of an American Alford had anticipated him on several points, and academy to promote and regulate the language—John devoted a section to belaboring the Dean, only to dis- Adams made one such proposal. cover that Moon had anticipated him there. He The British, for their part, were not amused by the acknowledged the justness of Moon's criticisms and presumption of former colonials. Americanisms had then appended a few parting shots at Moon's English, been viewed askance as early as 1735, but the frequency before tacking on an assault on the spelling reforms of and the ferocity of denunciation markedly increased in Noah Webster and a series of lectures on pulpit oratory. the 19th century, as British travelers, some of them lit- Moon replied with The Bad English ofLindley Murray erary folk like Captain Marryat, Mrs. Frances Trollope, and Other Writers on the English Language, 1868, listed and Charles Dickens, visited the United States and by H. L. Mencken as being in its eighth edition in 1882, returned to England to publish books of their travels, under the title Bad English Exposed. (Gould was one of almost always disparaging in tone. They seldom failed the "other writers.") Language controversy sold books to work in a few criticisms of the language as well as the in America as well as in England. uncouth character and manners of Americans. British The most popular of American 19th-century com- reviewers, too, were outspoken in their denunciation of mentators was Richard Grant White, whose Words and things American, and especially Americanisms. Their Uses, 1870, was also compiled from previously American writers put up a spirited defense for a time, published articles. He did not deign to mention earlier but the writing class eventually began to wear down commentators except to take a solitary whack at Dean under the onslaught. By 1860, in an article crying up Alford for his sneer at American English. His chapters Joseph Worcester's dictionary, the Atlantic Monthly on "misused words" and "words that are not words" hit could call American English "provincial." The general many of the same targets as Gould's chapters on "mis- attitude after the Civil War seems to have been one of used words" and "spurious words," but White's chap- diffidence rather than defiance. The diffident attitude is ters are longer. Perhaps his most entertaining sections of interest here because it was in the second half of the deal with his denial that English has a grammar, which 19th century that Americanisms began to make their is introduced by a Dickensian account of having been way silently into American usage books as errors. Many rapped over the knuckles at age five and a half for not of these, such as balance for remainder and loan for understanding his grammar lesson. White, who was not lend, are still denigrated by American usage writers and without intellectual attainments—he had edited Shake- their native origin passed over in silence. speare—was nevertheless given to frequent faulty ety- We have said nothing about 19th-century grammars, mologizing, and for some reason he was so upset by the and not much needs to be said about them. If those progressive passive is being built that he devoted a grammars were computers, the most successful could be whole chapter to excoriating it. These last two features called clones of Lindley Murray. Some dissatisfaction caught the attention of the peppery Fitzedward Hall, an with the older English traditions existed, especially in American teacher of Sanskrit living in England. the first half of the 19th century in this country, but little Hall produced a whole book—Recent Exemplifica- seems to have resulted from it. Books with innovative tions of False Philology, 1872—exposing White's errors, systems met with little success. Goold Brown, in his and returned to the attack again with Modern English in Grammar of English Grammars, first published in 1851, 1873. Hall was a new breed of commentator, bringing a collected most of the grammars published up to his own 10a History of English Usage time, and used them for his examples of false grammar. of Eric Partridge, particularly Usage and Abusage, 1942, He also exhibited at length their inconsistencies and dis- has been influential. agreements. Goold Brown permitted himself one mild In recent years, while some English books about usage observation (most were rather tart): "Grammarians have concerned themselves with traditional questions of would perhaps differ less, if they read more." propriety, others have taken a different path, explain- By the end of the 19th century, differences had devel- ing the peculiarities of English idiom to learners of oped between the ways usage issues were being treated English. in England and in the United States. Except for the The treatment of usage in 20th-century America, fruits of the Alford-Moon controversy, there seem to be however, hews steadfastly to the traditional line of lin- very few British books concerned exclusively with usage guistic etiquette. School grammars are elaborately problems. The most frequently reprinted of these few graded and decked out with color printing, but the most was one written by a Scot: William B. Hodgson's Errors successful are still solidly based on Lowth and Murray. in the Use of English, 1881. British literati were not indif- College handbooks have proliferated since 1917, the ferent to such issues, but they seem mainly to have put date of the earliest one in our collection. The contents their comments in reviews and letters and works of these works have not changed greatly, however; the directed primarily to other subjects. Walter Savage Lan- essential sameness of the "Glossaries of Usage" dor, for instance, delivered himself of a number of idio- attached to them suggests that their contents are to some syncratic views about language and usage in one or two extent determined by a desire to carry over from the pre- of his Imaginary Conversations. John Stuart Mill put a vious edition as much as possible and to cover what the few of his opinions into A System of Logic. competition covers. General-purpose guides for those America, on the other hand, saw the growth of a small whose schooling is complete are still produced regularly, industry devoted to the cultivation of the linguistically and in a wider variety of shapes and sizes than in the insecure, who were being produced in increasing num- 19th century. These have developed offshoots in the bers by American public schools using the grammar of form of books aimed at business writers and others Lindley Murray combined with the opinions of Richard aimed at technical and scientific writers. Grant White. After the Civil War little handbooks for The newspaper tradition has also continued strong. the guidance of the perplexed appeared with some fre- Some usage questions are dealt with in house stylebooks quency. We have mentioned one of these, Alfred Ayres's (now often published for outsiders, as well), and news- The Verbalist. Others bear such titles as Vulgarisms and paper editors have written usage guides for the general Other Errors of Speech, Words: Their Use and Abuse, public, though these usually have a strong newspaper Some Common Errors of Speech, and Slips of Tongue slant. Especially prominent among these are the several and Pen. The production of popular books on usage top- books of Theodore Bernstein, particularly The Careful ics continues to be common in the 20th-century United Writer, 1965. States. A characteristic of writing on usage has been, right The different approaches of the British and Ameri- from the beginning, disagreement among the writers on cans to usage questions have continued along the lines specific points. Various attempts at reconciling these dif- evident in the last half of the 19th century. Fewer books ferences have been made, especially in the 20th century. devoted to usage issues have been produced in England, One of the earliest dates from 1883. C. W. Bardeen, a and the arena there has been dominated by two names: schoolbook publisher, put out a little book in which he Fowler and Gowers. H. W. Fowler's best-known work is tried to discover a consensus by examining some thirty Modern English Usage, 1926, an expanded, updated, sources, including a number of current usage books, and alphabetized version of The King's English, which some grammars, some works on philology, some on he had produced with one of his brothers in 1906. This synonymy, and Webster's and Worcester's dictionaries. book gained ready acceptance as an authority, and it is Roy Copperud has produced books on the same general usually treated with considerable deference on both plan in 1970 and 1980. sides of the Atlantic. It is a thick book in small print, Another approach to the problem of varying opinion packed with a combination of good sense, traditional has been the survey of opinion. Sterling A. Leonard attitudes, pretension-pricking, minute distinctions, and made the first in 1931. Leonard's survey was replicated a good deal of what Otto Jespersen, the Danish scholarly in 1971 by Raymond D. Crisp, and a similar survey was grammarian of the English language, called "language conducted in England by G. H. Mittins and three col- moralizing." Fowler, in the tradition of Alford and leagues and published in 1970. The results of these sur- Richard Grant White, found much to dislike in the veys are quantified, so that interested readers can dis- prose of contemporary newspapers. He had no gadfly cover the relative acceptability or obloquy of each tested like George Washington Moon to challenge his author- item. Somewhat the same idea has also been tried with ity, although he did dispute a few constructions with the usage panel, an assembled panel of experts to whom Otto Jespersen in the pages of the tracts issued by the each individual item is submitted for approval or dis- Society for Pure English. In some of these disputes a approval. Again, quantification of relative approval or characteristic pattern emerges: the historical grammar- disapproval is the aim. ian finds a construction in literature and wonders how The 20th century is the first in which usage has been it came to be; Fowler finds the same construction in the studied from a scholarly or historical point of view, newspapers and condemns it. although Fitzedward Hall's Modern English of 1873 Sir Ernest Gowers came into usage commentary from should probably be acknowledged as a precursor. a different direction: he was asked to prepare a book for Thomas R. Lounsbury collected a number of his maga- British civil servants to help them avoid the usual zine articles into The Standard of Usage in English, bureaucratic jargon of British officiai prose. The result 1908, which examined the background of attitudes and was Plain Words, 1941. This slender book has gone issues. J. Lesslie Hall's English Usage, 1917, checked through several editions, growing a bit each time. In 141 issues drawn from the work of Richard Grant White 1965 a new edition of Fowler appeared, edited by Gow- and from several college-level grammars and rhetorics ers, to which Gowers added a number of his own favor- against evidence from English and American literature. ite topics. In addition to Fowler and Gowers, the work Sterling A. Leonard in The Doctrine of Correctness in History of English Usage lia English Usage 1700-1800, 1929, provided the first thor- dency in modern linguistics toward the study of lan- ough examination of the origins of many attitudes about guage in more abstract ways. If the popular idea of usage usage in the 18th century. is represented by the continuing series of books pro- Looking back from the late 1980s we find that the duced by the journalists Philip Howard (in England) 1920s and 1930s were a time of considerable interest in and William Safire (in the United States) and by the the examination and testing of attitudes and beliefs continuing publication of traditionally oriented hand- about usage and in a rationalization of the matter and books, there is also some countervailing critical opin- methods of school grammar. Various publications writ- ion, as shown by such books as Dwight Bolinger's Lan- ten by Charles C. Fries and Robert C. Pooley, for exam- guage—the Loaded Weapon, Jim Quinn's American ple, seemed to point the way. They had relatively little Tongue and Cheek, Dennis Baron's Grammar and Good influence in the following decades, however; the school- Taste, and Harvey Daniels's Famous Last Words, all books by and large follow the traditional lines, and the published in the early 1980s. popular books of usage treat the traditional subjects. A A historical sketch of this length necessarily must notable exception is Bergen and Cornelia Evans's A Dic- omit many deserving names and titles and pass over tionary of Contemporary American Usage, 1957. The many interesting observers and observations. This we book takes the traditional view of many specific issues, regret, but do not apologize for, as the need to omit what but it is strong in insisting that actual usage, both his- we would prefer to include seems almost omnipresent torical and contemporary, must be weighed carefully in in our work as lexicographers. Much of the historical reaching usage opinions. information herein draws heavily on materials available If the mainstream of usage commentary has contin- in Leonard's Doctrine of Correctness; Charles Carpenter ued to run in the same old channels, there have none- Fries's The Teaching of the English Language, 1927'; theless been some undercurrents of importance. Serious George H. McKnight's Modern English in the Making, examination of the received truths has continued. Mar- 1928; H. L. Mencken's The American Language, 4th garet M. Bryant's Current American Usage, 1962, edition, 1936, and Supplement 1, 1945; Baron's Gram- reported the results of the testing of many specific items mar and Good Taste, 1982; and Daniels's Famous Last against actual use as shown in current books, magazines, Words, 1983. These books constitute a rich mine of and newspapers. Articles in scholarly books and jour- information for the serious student of English usage and nals (like American Speech) evince continuing interest its history, to whom we also recommend a perusal of in real language and real usage in spite of a strong ten- our bibliography. Pronunciation Symbols 9 . . . . banana, collide, abut O . . . . bone, know, beau 0, , 9 . . . . humdrum, abut O . . . . saw, all, gnaw, caught . . . .immediately preceding \ 1 \ , \ n \ , \ m \ , \ r j \ , as œ . . . . French boeuf, German Hôlle in battle, mitten, eaten, and sometimes open\'ôp- 3 m \ , lock and key \ - 3 r j - \ ; immediately following Ôë. . . . French feu, German Hôhle \ 1 \ , \ m \ , \ r \ , as often in French table, prisme, titre O l . . . . coin, destroy O r . . . . further, merger, bird p. pepper, lip T. . . . red, car, rarity . I . . . . as in two different pronunciations 9-r of hurry Yhar-ë, 'ha-rë\ S . . . . source, less a . . . .mat, map, mad, gag, snap, patch S n . . . .as in shy, mission, machine, special (actually, this is a single sound, not two); with a hyphen between, à . . . .day, fade, date, aorta, drape, cape two sounds as in grasshopper \'gras-,hàp-ar\ a . . . .bother, cot, and, with most American speakers, fa- t . . . . tie, attack, late, later, latter ther, cart t h . . . . as in thin, ether (actually, this is a single sound, a . . . .father as pronounced by speakers who do not not two); with a hyphen between, two sounds as in rhyme it with bother; French patte knighthood Ynït-,hùd\ t h . . . .then, either, this (actually, this is a single sound, au.. . . now, loud, out not two) b.. . . baby, rib U . . . .rule, youth, union Yyun-yanX, few \ ' f y u \ ch.. . .chin, nature Ynâ-char\ (actually, this sound is \t\ + \sh\) U . . . .pull, wood, book, curable Ykyur-a-balX, fury \'fyù(9)r-ë\ d. . .did, adder U £ . . . . German fullen, hiibsch e.. . . bet, bed, peck U £ . . . . French rue, German fiihlen ,ë.. . .beat, nosebleed, evenly, easy V . . . . vivid, give ë.. . . easy, mealy W . . . .we, away; in some words having final \ ( , ) o \ , f.. . .fifty, cuff \ ( , ) y i i \ , or \ ( , ) ù \ a variant \ 3 - w \ occurs before vowels, as in Yfal-3-wirj\, covered by the variant g . . go, big, gift \ a ( - w ) \ or \ y a ( - w ) \ at the entry word h.. . .hat, ahead y . . . .yard, young, cue \ ' k y i i \ , mute \'myiit\, union Yyùn-yan\ hw.. . . whale as pronounced by those who do not have the same pronunciation for both whale and wail y. . . . indicates that during the articulation of the sound represented by the preceding character the front of i.. . . tip, banish, active the tongue has substantially the position it has for the articulation of the first sound of yard, as in ï.. . .site, side, buy, tripe (actually, this sound is \ a \ French digne \dëny\ + \ i \ , or \ â \ + \ i \ ) Z . . . . zone, raise j . .job, gem, edge, join, judge (actually, this sound is \ d \ + \zh\) Z n . . . . as in vision, azure \ ' a z h a r \ (actually, this is a sin- gle sound, not two); with a hyphen between, two k.. . .kin, cook, ache sounds as in hogshead \'hôgz-,hed, 'hâgz-\ k.. . . German ich, Buch; one pronunciation of loch \ . . . . slant line used in pairs to mark the beginning and 1.. . .lily, pool end of a transcription: Y p e n \ . . . . mark preceding a syllable with primary (strongest) m.. . . murmur, dim, nymph stress: \'pen-m9n-,ship\ n.. . .no, own , . . . . mark preceding a syllable with secondary (medium) stress: \'pen-man-,ship\ n . .indicates that a preceding vowel or diphthong is pronounced with the nasal passages open, as in - . . . . mark of syllable division French un bon vin blanc \œ n -bô n -va n -blà n \ ( ) . . . . indicate that what is symbolized between is present . .sing \ ' s i n \ , singer \ ' s i n - 9 r \ , finger Yfin-gar\, in some utterances but not in others: factory \'fak- ink \ ' i n k \ t(3-)rë\ A a, an There is an article on the proper use of a and an ing the clipped forms as barbarisms, but commenting in almost every usage book ever written, although that he thought the practice had fallen into general dis- hardly a native speaker of English has any difficulty with grace because of the attacks of the satirists and that it them—in fact one seldom thinks about them at all in never showed itself in books. speech. Perhaps Dr. Campbell was premature in announcing The difficulty, when there is any, is to be found in the abandonment of the practice of abbreviating, for writing. The basic rules are these: use a before a conso- usage books down to the present day wag their fingers at nant sound; use an before a vowel sound. Before a letter the practice. MacCracken & Sandison 1917, for or an acronym or before numerals, choose a or an instance, lists several truncations disapprovingly— according to the way the letter or numeral is pro- among them auto, phone, photo, exam, and gym. Guth nounced: an FDA directive, a U.N. resolution, a $5.00 1985 continues the critical tradition but changes the bill. truncations: Actual usage, of course, is more complex than the simple rules would lead you to expect. Here is what Avoid informal abbreviations. Avoid clipped forms actual usage shows: like bike, prof, doc, fan mag, exec, econ. (Other short- 1. Before words with an initial consonant sound, a is ened forms, like phone, ad, and exam are now com- usual in speech and writing. This is in line with the basic monly used in serious writing.) rule. Aside from the social acceptability of clipped forms 2. Before h in an unstressed or weakly stressed sylla- (Emily Post in 1927 disapproved phone and photo), ble, a and an are both used in writing (an historic, a there are other considerations to be taken into account. historic) but an is more usual in speech, whether the h Handbooks in general recommend avoiding abbrevia- is pronounced or not. This variation is the result of his- tions in "formal" writing. Flesch 1964 disagrees, torical development; in unstressed and weakly stressed however: syllables, h was formerly not pronounced in many words where it is pronounced at the present time. A few It's a superstition that abbreviations shouldn't be words, such as historic and (especially in England) hotel, used in serious writing and that it's good style to are in transition, and may be found with either a or an. spell everything out. Nonsense: use abbreviations You choose the article that suits your own whenever they are customary and won't attract the pronunciation. attention of the reader. 3. Occasionally in modern writing and speech and Flesch's advice seems sound; but care should be taken regularly in the King James Version of the Bible, an is to observe what in fact is customary. It is obvious that used before h in a stressed syllable, as in an hundred. what is customary in technical writing will be different Again, we have the same historical change: many more from what is customary in journalism or in scholarly words were pronounced with a silent initial h in the past articles. If you are uncertain, you should consult an than are at present. A few words, such as heir, hour, and appropriate style manual or handbook. General advice honest, generally have silent initial h; some others, like can be found in any of a number of composition hand- herb or humble are pronounced both ways. Use a or an books and in general style manuals, such as Webster's according to your own pronunciation. Standard American Style Manual. 4. Before words beginning with a consonant sound See also ETC.; I.E., E.G. but an orthographic vowel, an is sometimes used in speech and writing (an unique, such an one). This use abdomen This word may be pronounced with the is less frequent now than in the past. main stress on the first syllable or on the second: Vab- 5. Before words with an initial vowel sound, an is da-manN or Xab-'dô-manV The former version predom- usual in speech and writing. This is in line with the basic inates among laypeople; physicians are more evenly rule. divided. 6. Occasionally, and more often in some dialects than others, a is used in speech before words beginning with abhorrence Bernstein 1965 notes that abhorrence, a vowel sound. The Dictionary of American Regional when followed by a preposition, takes of. This is true in English reports this to be frequent in the United States; a large majority of cases. the evidence suggests it may have been somewhat more common in the past. . . . an abhorrence of draughts —Times Literary 7. A is normally unstressed, and pronounced \ a \ . Supp., 14 Nov. 1968 When stressed, as in "He's a vice president, not the vice president," it is pronounced \ ' â \ in the United States, . . . my natural abhorrence of its sickening inhuman- but often \ ' a \ in Canada. ity —George Bernard Shaw, Back to Methuselah, 1921 abbreviations Abbreviations have been receiving The word has also been used with a few other preposi- bad notices since the 18th century. Such writers as Addi- tions, however, such as to (an instance of which was cor- son and Swift satirized the fashionable practice of the rected to of by Lindley Murray in 1795), against, and time of using truncated or clipped forms of long for. These are less frequent by far, and are in the main words—such as pozz, phizz, plenipo, and hippo for pos- to be found in older literature. itively, physiognomy, plenipotentiary, and hypochon- dria—in conversation. Ordinary contractions—can't, He recognized her as "Goldy," famous in Hsi-Yu for haven't, shan't, isn't, for instance—were likewise sati- her abhorrence to sleeping alone —Sericana Quar- rized. Campbell 1776 took notice of the practice, class- terly, April 1952 abhorrent abject . . . abhorrence against relationship with Wickham Our earliest evidence for the phrase, however, does not —Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, 1813 refer to economic circumstances: . . . my unbounded abhorrence for this miserable . . . while they profess to build upon Naturalism an wretch —P. B. Shelley, quoted by Matthew Arnold, edifying and attractive philosophy of life, they dis- Essays in Criticism, Second Series, 1888 guise from themselves and others the bare and abject poverty of the scheme —W. R. Inge, The Church in abhorrent When used with a preposition, abhorrent the World, 1928 is almost always followed by to: Nickles strikes further at abject by claiming it "tends Not only was success abhorrent to their ethical prej- to generate clichés in clusters, vitiating any noun it udices —Lewis H. Lapham, Harper's, May 1971 accompanies." This is a patent overstatement. Abject . . . words like "unfair" whose very sound is abhor- connotes two kinds of low degree: one of low circum- rent to him —Joseph Conrad, Chance, 1913 stances—abasement—and one of servility or spineless- ness—debasement. It can be applied directly to persons: abide 1 . The original principal parts of abide are Farmers who have to work 16 hours a day to pay abode, past, and abidden, past participle. The OED rent and interest on mortgages in addition to buying notes that in time the past and past participle coalesced necessities for their families are not free: they are in abode, and abidden fell into disuse, although a few abject slaves —George Bernard Shaw, New Repub- 19th-century writers tried to revive it. During the 19th lic, 2 2 Nov. 1954 century a regular past and past participle abided came into use. It is more likely to be used now than abode is. . . . the time would come that no human being Abode, while not very much used by modern writers, is should be humiliated or be made abject —Katherine kept alive by its use in such familiar literary works as Anne Porter, The Never-Ending Wrong, 1977 "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow," and in works referring to an earlier era, as Samuel Hopkins Adams's Grand- . . . Bloom beholds himself, in a hideous vision, father Stories (1955). looking on at Blazes Boylan and Molly, an abject 2. Except for can't abide and abide by, which are in con- cuckold —Edmund Wilson, Axel's Castle, 1931 tinuing vigorous use, most senses of abide have a rather He was abject before Wolf Larsen and almost grov- literary or old-fashioned flavor. They do, however, con- elled to Johansen —Jack London, The Sea-Wolf, tinue in reputable, if somewhat infrequent, use. 1904 3. Evans 1957 comments that can't abide is "commonly disparaged." One source of the disparagement is Par- . . . a sinner, and a repentant prostrate abject sinner tridge 1942, who calls the expression "a low-class col- —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, loquialism"—he does allow that in American use it 1859 might be "homely or half-humorous," an opinion he may have derived from Krapp 1927, who commented More often it is applied to the actions and conditions on the expression's "somewhat archaic and rustic char- of such persons: acter." Evans defends can't abide as having force and . . . my critical intelligence sometimes shrivels to an flavor. Indeed it is hard to see what the objection was. abject nodding of the head —Lewis H. Lapham, The expression goes back to the 16th century; Shake- Harper's, May 1971 speare uses it several times in his plays: . . . the aversion my person inspired even in its most She could not abide Master Shallow — 2 Henry IV, abject and obsequious attitudes —Samuel Beckett, 1598 Evergreen, June 1967 It is true that Shakespeare puts it into the mouths of The possibility of humiliation . . . touched a vein of commoners—those who speak prose rather than blank abject cowardice in his composition —H. G. Wells, verse. Modern evidence, however, shows that the usage Joan and Peter, 1 9 1 8 is perfectly proper: . . . which may have been intended to prove how Then, what submission, what cringing and fawning, open-minded and aesthetically susceptible Canaday what servility, what abject humiliation —Charles is even to work he cannot abide —Harold Rosen- Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities, 1859 burg, New Yorker, 1 Jan. 1972 . . . when the least sickness attacked her, under the This sense of abide is usually used in a negative con- most abject depression and terror of death —W. M. struction or in one with negative implications: Thackeray, Vanity Fair, 1848 My inability when I was young to abide most males The sensation of nameless terror and abject fear . . . of my own age disguised loneliness that no amount overmastered me completely —Rudyard Kipling, of variety assuaged —Donald Hall, N. Y. Times Book "The Strange Ride of Morrowbie Jukes," 1888 Rev., 16 Jan. 1983 . . . having dictated to our enemies the terms of a most abject surrender —Archibald MacLeish, Sat- abject Nickles 1974 and Safire (N.Y. Times, 2 Sept. urday Rev., 9 Feb. 1946 1984) call the phrase abject poverty a cliché. Our evi- dence shows that abject is frequently used to modify . . . without fear, but with the most abject awe of the poverty; in this use abject is not much more than an aristocracy —T. S. Eliot, "Philip Massinger," intensifier: Selected Essays, 1932 . . . the Place Maubert, still at the end of the nine- Conway survived and penned an abject apology to teenth century the area of the most abject poverty — Washington —American Guide Series: Maryland, Times Literary Supp., 14 Nov. 1968 1940 abjure abortive These examples are typical uses of abject. The most fre- uncommon. Here are three examples to show that it is quently modified nouns, after poverty, are fear, terror, used on occasion: surrender, and apology. It seems unlikely that any of the writers cited considered abject to have a vitiating effect. . . . Mr. Doddington, from whose disapproval the story of Gavin and the Concannons' party had not been able to be kept —Elizabeth Bowen, Horizon, abjure, adjure A number of commentators (such as September 1945 Harper 1985, Shaw 1975, Bremner 1980, the Oxford American Dictionary 1980, Bernstein 1965, Evans . . . so social and religious life would be able to be 1957) warn that these words are confused with some fre- carried out on a normal basis —L. S. B. Leakey, Mau quency. Evidence of such confusion is not to be found Mau and the Kikuyu, 1952 in the Merriam-Webster files; if it does exist, it is appar- ently corrected in manuscript. Abjure means "to . . . a simple experiment able to be performed by renounce, reject, avoid"; adjure "to urge or advise ear- anyone —Monsanto Mag., December 1953 nestly." Besides differing in meaning, the two words Using the last example for illustrative purposes, we can take different grammatical constructions. Abjure regu- avoid the passive infinitive by revising it to include can larly takes a noun as direct object. The noun often is, or could: but need not be, abstract; it is rarely a personal noun. Galileo was summoned before the Inquisition at . . . a simple experiment that anyone could (can) Rome, and there he was made to abjure the Coper- perform; nican theory —S. F. Mason, Main Currents of Sci- or entific Thought, 1953 . . . a simple experiment that can (could) be per- formed by anyone. Just one whiff of that vast butchery . . . is enough to make a sensitive person abjure meat forever —Ian abortive A love of etymology and the consequent dis- Fleming, Thrilling Cities, 1963 membering of English words into their presumed con- Adjure, on the other hand, typically takes a personal stituent parts has led many a usage commentator down noun or pronoun followed by to and an infinitive: the primrose path of error (see ETYMOLOGICAL FALLACY). Safire 1982 seconds a correspondent's objection to the The wives and daughters of the Germans rushed use of abortive to describe a failed mission to rescue about the camp . . . adjuring their countrymen to U.S. hostages in Iran in 1979. Safire claims to see in the save them from slavery —J. A. Froude, Caesar, 1879 suffix -ive an implication of continuation or perma- nence, and he maintains that abortive must therefore There is no use adjuring them to take part in it or "suggest a continuous process of aborting." This is, of warning them to keep out of it —Malcolm Cowley, course, a conclusion that could only be reached by Exile's Return, 1934 ignoring the use of the whole word in English in favor Adjure, incidentally, is used quite a bit less frequently of speculating about what it might mean. No "continu- than abjure. ous process of aborting" is suggested by Shakespeare's line ablative See INCOMPARABLE. Why should I joy in any abortive birth? —Love's Labour's Lost, 1595 able to In constructions where able is followed by to and the infinitive, the infinitive is nearly always in the Safire further asserts that "'abortive efforts' should be active voice, whether the subject is human or nonhu- used only when the emphasis is on a series of past fail- man. Human subjects are more common: ures." In actuality the word is often used to modify a plural noun, but emphasis on past failures may or may . . . people have traditionally been able to walk into not be present: museums free —Huntington Hartford, The Public Be Damned, 1955 . . . a magazine existed,—after so many abortive attempts —Van Wyck Brooks, The Flowering of So far, I have been able to keep my enthusiasm . . . New England, 1815-1865, rev. éd., 1946 under control —John Fischer, Harper's, November 1970 . . . and forget that abortive efforts from want of heart are as possible to revenge as to generosity — But the City that lay between was not his ground, Thomas Hardy, The Mayor of Casterbridge, 1886 and Richard II was no more able than Charles I to dictate to its militia —G. M. Trevelyan, English He knew it was like feeling over a chilling motor for Social History, 1942 loose wires, and after two or three abortive motions he gave it up —Wallace Stegner, "The Traveler," in She hopes to find Somebody able and willing to buy Perspectives USA, Summer 1953 her freedom —Lafcadio Hearn, Glimpses of Unfa- miliar Japan, 1894 Moreover, many a writer from Shakespeare to the present has used the word of a single incident with no There are those from whom not even death has been hint of recurrence or permanence: able to disconnect me —George P. Elliott, Harper's, September 1970 The power that had proved too strong for this abor- tive restoration —Arnold J. Toynbee, Center Mag., The passive infinitive is much less common. Some com- March 1968 mentators (Longman 1984, Perrin & Ebbitt 1972) opine that the construction sounds awkward; perhaps it often After the abortive Decembrist insurrection in 1825 does, and awkwardness may account for its being fairly —George F. Kennan, New Yorker, 1 May 1971 abound about In describing her abortive visit —Margery Sharp, 3. Copperud 1970, Johnson 1982, Bernstein 1958, Bry- Britannia Mews, 1946 son 1984, and Janis 1984 point out that about can be used redundantly with figures when other signs of In September, 1938, came the Munich crisis The approximation, such as the mention of a span ( 150 to result was only an abortive armistice —Franklin D. 200) or the verb estimate, are present. Bernstein quotes Roosevelt, campaign address, 28 Oct. 1940, in Noth- a couple of instances from the New York Times. If the ing to Fear, ed. B. D. Zevin, 1946 evidence in the Merriam-Webster files is representative, There was an abortive conspiracy against the life of this is a minor problem—we have nearly no evidence of the Princeps —John Buchan, Augustus, 1937 its occurrence in edited prose. Perhaps sharp-eyed copy editors catch it regularly, or perhaps the phenomenon Only at the third did our visit prove abortive —Sir occurs in other contexts, such as student writing. Arthur Conan Doyle, The Return of Sherlock Bernstein also mentions the use of a round number as Holmes, 1904 an implicit indication of approximation, but shows no example that involves redundancy. The use of about . . . Mr. Pickwick expressed a strong desire to recol- with round numbers is extremely common, and is for lect a song which he had heard in his infancy, and the obvious purpose of indicating that the number is not the attempt proving abortive, sought to stimulate his exact. About is also frequently used with nearly exact memory with more glasses of punch —Charles Dick- and less than round numbers for the same purpose: ens, Pickwick Papers, 1836-37 The edges of the base of the great pyramid are about Two slips of ground, half arable, half overrun with 756 feet long; and the lengths of these four edges an abortive attempt at shrubbery —Sir Walter Scott, agree, with an error of only about two-thirds of an The Surgeon's Daughter, 1827 (OED) inch —School Mathematics Study Group, Geome- Our first design, my friend, has prov'd abortive — try, Part 1, 1965 Joseph Addison, Cato, 1713 (OED) . . . weighs about 172 pounds —Current Biography, February 1966 abound When a person, place, or thing abounds— that is, is copiously supplied—it usually abounds in or . . . were producing 108 million net cubic feet of gas abounds with. and about 1,270 net barrels of crude oil —Annual Report, Atlantic Richfield Co., 1970 Literary men indulge in humbug only at a price, and Bancroft abounded in humbug —Van Wyck Brooks, 4. Bernstein 1958, 1965 objects to the expression "about The Flowering of New England, 1815-1865, rev. ed. the head" as "police-blotter lingo." This is perhaps an 1946 expression that has gone out of date. Here is a typical example, from a story in the Saturday Evening Post in . . . London abounds in public monuments —Max 1954: Beerbohm, And Even Now, 1920 He slapped Mr. Norris heavily about the head sev- Yet if life abounded in mysteries —Normal Mailer, eral times —Harold H. Martin Harper's, March 1971 Bernstein's objection was originally made in 1953. We . . . buoyed by the most personal of human hopes, he have little evidence of the use since. At one time it had abounded with good nature —Francis Hackett, some facetious, as well as more serious use, but it seems Henry the Eighth, 1929 simply to have dropped out of currency now. Copperud 1970 says it is (or was) standard, anyway. . . . a school ostensibly abounding with fair-sized 5. Johnson 1982 dislikes the about construction shown drips —J. D. Salinger, Nine Stories, 1953 in this example: Both prepositions are in frequent use; when the object . . . does not know what the Sixties were all about — is a relative pronoun, with appears to be more common: Garry Wills, Harper's, January 1972 . . . those ironies with which history abounds —John He opines that the construction appeared about two Dewey, Freedom and Culture, 1939 decades earlier and may now be going out of fashion. The expression, usually in the form "what . . . is (all) The pictures with which it abounds —Charles about," seems to have reached a high tide of popularity Lamb, Essays ofElia, 1823 in the late 1960s and early 1970s and is slowly receding, but it is still found from time to time, as in this quota- about 1 . Vizetelly 1906 noted that about was com- tion attributed to actress Shari Belafonte-Harper: monly interchangeable with almost and "formerly, such was condemned." MacCracken & Sandison 1917 still My father has a tough time with what Hollywood's had some doubts about the use, except in connection about— US, 2 Jan. 1984 with numbers. This issue has seldom been mentioned Here are some earlier examples: since, though Perrin & Ebbitt 1972 note it, calling about "Standard but mainly Informal." Shaw 1970, however, What the p.-o.-w. hold-up in Korea was really all maintains the old position, recommending that about in about — The Bulletin (Sydney, Australia), 30 Dec. the sense of "almost" or "all but" be avoided in formal 1953 English. He is more moderate in 1975. If there was no Many all over the country know very well what bal- reason to avoid it in 1906, there is no reason to avoid it let is about —Edwin Denby, in The Dance Encyclo- now. pedia, ed. Anatole Chujoy, 1949 2. Perrin & Ebbitt 1972 say around is more common than about in reference to physical position; the asser- . . . Europeans have only the vaguest conception of tion cannot be confirmed from the Merriam-Webster what American music is about —Virgil Thomson, files. Both are exceedingly common. See AROUND 1. The Musical Scene, 1947 above absent Reader's Digest 1983 says that the construction is stan- . . . the above is Theseus's opinion —William Blake, dard; its frequency of use, however, does appear to be Annotations to Swedenborg's Of Heaven and Hell, 2d declining. éd., 1784 6. For two further current idiomatic uses of about, see AT ABOUT and NOT ABOUT TO. It is not of pictures like the above that galleries, in Rome or elsewhere, are made up —Nathaniel Haw- thorne (cited in Hall 1917) above 1 . Sometime during the later part of the 19th century, a number of critics began objecting to the use Let us pretend that the above is the original plot — of above as an adjective and as a noun, presumably on Ring W. Lardner, Preface, How to Write Short Sto- the grounds that above is an adverb. The earliest objec- ries, 1924 tion we have found seems to have been directed at Dean Alford in the 1860s; at least in A Plea for the Queen's We judge that both adjective and noun uses of above English (1866) he defends his use of above as an adjec- are standard, notwithstanding the objections of a few tive, saying that while it was not elegant, it was not holdouts for 19th-century opinion. Gowers's revision of uncommon. The critics, except for being generally Fowler 1965 sums the matter up: unhappy about both uses, are a bit uncertain of just There is ample authority, going back several centu- what is so bad. Vizetelly 1906 says that above is "inele- ries, for this use of a[bove] as adverb, adjective, or gantly used as a noun" but finds the adjective use more noun, and no solid ground for the pedantic criticism objectionable; the Heritage 1969 usage panel, on the of it sometimes heard. other hand, found the adjective acceptable, but the noun unacceptable. Some commentators object that such uses 2. "Above should not be used for 'more than.'" This of above smack too much of commercial or legal lingo; curious statement from Vizetelly 1906 may have had its on the other hand, Whipple 1924 and other writers on origin in William Cullen Bryant's 19th-century Index business writing recommend against its use. Expurgatorius for the New York Evening Post, which he The issue appears to be more long-lived than substan- edited. Bryant objected to the use of either above or over tial. More than a century ago, the adjective was in this sense. It is an odd usage for any critic to pick on; adjudged legitimate (Bardeen 1883); MacCracken & it goes back to the 16th century and has good literary Sandison 1917 call both adjective and noun "allow- credentials: able," although "The most careful speakers . . . prefer preceding or foregoing." Copperud's 1970 consensus It was never acted; or, if it was, not above once — finds both acceptable; Perrin & Ebbitt 1972 find them Shakespeare, Hamlet, 1601 standard; Bernstein 1971 calls them "legitimate and After that, he was seen of above five hundred breth- above-board." Yet Harper 1985 and Freeman 1983 are ren at once —1 Corinthians 15:6 (AV), 1611 still objecting. Utter 1916 says that the adjectival use of above (as in . . . added that he had not made above three or four "the above address") "has been idiomatic in English [words] in his Dictionary —James Boswell, Journal since Anglo-Saxon times." He does not, however, pro- of a Tour to the Hebrides, 1785 vide examples. The OED shows no citation earlier than "It is above a week since I saw Miss Crawford." — 1873, but many earlier ones, from Dickens, Thackeray, Jane Austen, Mansfield Park, 1814 Scott, and Hawthorne, among others, have been cited by other investigators. The oldest we have found is from I know that place well, having spent six weeks there Campbell 1776: above twenty years ago —William Cowper, letter, 28 July 1784 Guided by the above reflections.... The adjective above is not uncommon in writers on lan- . . . telling Aubrey that he cannot remember being drunk above a hundred times —Harold J. Laski, let- guage and usage: ter, 19 Mar. 1928 The facts of the case being now sufficiently supplied by the above list —Robert Bridges, S.P.E. Tract 2, He doesn't look above forty —The Journals of 1919 Arnold Bennett, ed. Frank Swinnerton, 1954 . . . a few remarks on some of the above words may . . . and it took above 10 minutes to get the police — perhaps instil caution —Fowler 1926 Edward Dahlberg, Prose, Spring 1972 . . . for a comment on the above use of the word We have no record of the stricture on this sense of "claims," consult Chapter 1 —Bernstein 1958 above having persisted beyond Whipple 1924; the objec- tion to over in the same sense has been longer-lived (see The above discussion gives us some idea about the OVER). complexity —Braj B. Kachru, in Greenbaum 1985 Other writers also have used it: absent Bernstein 1977 and Copperud 1980 both com- I don't for a moment doubt that for daily purposes ment on the appearance of absent as a preposition in he feels to me as a friend—as certainly I do to him constructions such as this: and without the above reserve —Oliver Wendell Absent such a direct threat, Mr. Carter professes to Holmes d. 1935, letter, 12 Jan. 1921 feel no pressure —William Safire, NY. Times, 20 "Fear God, Honour the Queen" . . . I was brought up Dec. 1976 on the above words —Sir Bernard Law Montgom- Both of these commentators note that the preposition is ery, This Week Mag., 1 June 1952 entered in Webster's Third, and neither condemns it. The use of above as a noun is somewhat more lightly Copperud concludes by saying, "Whether absent as a attested in our files. It too has been around at least since preposition will win any wide acceptance only time will the 18th century; the first OED citation is dated 1779. tell." absolute adjectives absolute adjectives Such evidence as we have accumulated since Coppe- It is also used in ordinary prepositional phrases: rud wrote his remark indicates that the prepositional use is gaining acceptance, though perhaps grudgingly. In a world absent politics and biology, they'd be Safire 1984 discusses it; unsurprisingly, he approves it chasing Tammy Mercer to do Kool-Aid commer- but notes some opposition. Harper 1985 puts the prep- cials in a couple of years —Jonathan Evan Maslow, ositional use, which the editors ascribe to "a few rather Saturday Rev., 26 Nov. 1977 pretentious columnists," to a vote of their usage panel; unsurprisingly the panel rejects it by a thumping 92 per- absolute adjectives Absolute adjective is one of the cent in writing, and 95 percent in speech. (Three panel- terms used by usage writers to refer to adjectives that are ists use the preposition in their quoted rejections.) not, or (more often) should not in the view of the writer, What is the background of this use? It is not quite as be compared or intensified (other terms applied to these new as our commentators think. The earliest citation in words include incomparables and uncomparable the Merriam-Webster files is from 1945; it is used in adjectives). paraphrasing a decision of the Supreme Court of South How many words belong to this class? Here is one Dakota: commentator's answer: We think it clear, continued the Supreme Court, that Our language contains perhaps a score of words that under this definition, absent any other facts, there may be described as absolute words. These are words arises an implied contract —JAMA, 24 Feb. 1945 that properly admit of no comparison or intensifi- cation —Kilpatrick 1984 The origin of the preposition is clearly in legal writing. Here are a couple more examples: A score, perhaps? In the first column of page 1280 of Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary, a page cho- Absent a general usage or custom, the importance of sen at random, we find ultrashort, ultrasonic, ultrason- particular treaty provisions becomes apparent —in ographic, ultrastructural, ultraviolet, ululant, umbellate, Edwin D. Dickinson, Cases and Materials on Inter- umbelliferous, umber, umbilical, umbilicate, umbonal, national Law, 1950 umbral—a baker's dozen of adjectives most persons would be hard put to use in the comparative or super- Absent such a reservation, only the Court of Claims lative. It should take no great effort to fill out our has jurisdiction —Bare v. United States, 107 F. score—how about ancillary, residual, aliphatic, Trias- Supp. 551, 17 Nov. 1952 sic, epoxy, diocesan, diphthongal? The plain fact is that It seems likely that someone reading extensively in judi- a majority of adjectives in English admit of no compar- cial American English would be able to discover even ison—they are of too narrow an application, or too tech- earlier examples of the use. nical, to be so used, or they simply name a quality that Up until the early 1970s all of our evidence for it cannot exist in degrees. came from published judicial decisions or reports of Then why, you may ask, is there a question at all? The such decisions. In the 70s we began to see a spread of reason is simple: the absolute adjectives that concern the preposition into quasi-legal contexts and into the the usage writers have, almost without exception, reported speech of lawyers and politicians: actually been used in the comparative, in the superla- tive, or with an intensifier. Partridge 1942 includes a list A program of unconditional amnesty, absent some of some eighty uncomparable adjectives; Bernstein 1971 accommodation on the part of the beneficiaries gently derides this selection by using some of them, in a would be a disservice to the memory of those who quite normal manner, with modifiers such as more and fought and died in Vietnam —Hubert H. Hum- less. But Bernstein has his own treasured list, and so do phrey, quoted by James A. Wechsler, NY. Post many other usage writers. It seems to be traditional to (undated citation received from a correspondent 15 list as words not susceptible of comparison words that Dec. 1975) have, in fact, been compared. The tradition seems to have originated in the 18th But by the late 1970s and the 1980s, the use of the prep- century. Lowth 1762 says, "So likewise adjectives, that ositional absent had broadened somewhat, appearing in have in themselves a superlative signification, admit not such publications as Saturday Review, Newsweek, New properly the superlative form superadded," and he cites York Times, Wall Street Journal, College English, and as examples chiefest and extremest. Lowth found these New Yorker. Most of the time now it is used to begin an in poetry, and is inclined to be tolerant of them in that introductory phrase: medium. Priestley, revised éd., 1798 also comments on Moreover, absent either huge further spending the subject: " . . . yet it is not uncommon to see the com- reductions or major tax increases, . . . the govern- parative or superlative of such words; being used, either ment's budget deficit is as likely to grow as to shrink through inadvertency, or for the sake of emphasis." —Benjamin M. Friedman, Wall Street Jour, 13 Jan. Priestley's approach also seems tolerant. 1982 But Lindley Murray 1795 is not tolerant. Murray, who compiled his grammar from many earlier works Absent baseball's antitrust exemption, this agree- including those of Lowth, Priestley, and Campbell, and ment . . . would be illegal —John F. Seiberling, N Y. here uses examples from all three, takes Lowth's Times, 29 May 1983 remarks from their original position in a footnote and Absent a hyphen, the epithet must be taken at face elevates them to the status of a rule; he also adds "or value —Maxwell R. D. Vos, letter, in Safire 1984 comparative" to Lowth's "superlative form." He labels all the examples "incorrect." What I want is a clear blue sky, fresh sparkling Murray's Grammar was widely popular and widely waters, a handsome log house not made from a kit imitated. As Murray had elaborated on the rules he took but put up for me by friends. Absent that, I want suc- over from Lowth and Priestley, so later grammarians cess in lawsuits —George W. S. Trow, New Yorker, elaborated on Murray. Where Lowth mentioned two 12 Mar. 1984 adjectives, Murray lists six (plus an etc.); Goold Brown absolute comparative absolutely 1851 reproduces the list of Samuel Kirkham, English varieties of the absolute comparative are difficult to dis- Grammar in Familiar Lectures (1825), which contains tinguish, and perhaps need not be distinguished for 22 adjectives and concludes with "and many others" practical purposes. The following examples of older and mentions Joseph W. Wright, A Philosophical Gram- should suffice to make the point: mar of the English Language (1838) as listing 72. Goold Brown, however, does not share the usual view . . . the way to teach rhetoric to older young people of these adjectives. He begins his discussion by saying, —Ruth G. Strickland, in The Range of English, 1968 "Our grammarians deny the comparison of many adjec- . . . when even the older girls are new to the organi- tives, from a false notion that they are already superla- zation —Mabel A. Hammersmith, Girl Scout tives." He then goes on to demonstrate, using Kirk- Leader, January 1968 ham's 22, that they are not superlatives; his method is to show—to use modern terminology—that Kirkham Starting independent study for older students, who (and all the rest) have confused semantics with are most prepared for it —Arno Karlen, Change, morphology. July-August 1969 Goold Brown's criticisms do not seem to have affected the issue much, unless they were somehow The age of the counselors is another factor in con- responsible for the shift in terminology from "superla- trolling applicants, especially older, professionally- tive" meaning to "absolute" meaning. Usage writers trained ones —Thomas M. Martinez, Trans-Action, have continued the lists of the pre-Goold Brown gram- March 1968 marians, our modern commentators perhaps having The constant counterpoint of this search has been an inherited some of the material from late 19th-century awareness of the older traditions of Europe —Cur- handbooks such as those written by William Matthews, rent Biography, December 1964 Words: their Use and their Abuse (1880), Edward S. Gould 1870, and Alfred Ayres 1881 (all cited in Bardeen . . . disciplinary notions and forms were taken over 1883). from the past and from the most prestigious of the The reason for the mismatch between actual usage older universities —Norman Birnbaum, Change, and the writers' expressed preference is simple: the lists July-August 1969 are wish lists. The reason such words are compared was succinctly summed up as long ago as 1946: The absolute comparative is a favorite device of advertisers, who for various reasons prefer to leave the Adjectives expressing some quality that does not comparisons implied in "a brighter smile," "a new love- admit of degrees are not compared when used in lier you," or "higher mileage" up to the perceptions of their strict or full sense; as, square, perpendicular, the consumer. circular, absolute, eternal, illimitable, complete, per- With terms relating to age, the comparative form is fect, etc. often more polite than the positive: But such adjectives are often used in a modified or approximate sense, and when so used admit of . . . a book dealer who is loved by an older woman comparison. —Current Biography, June 1966 If we say, "This is more perfect than that," we do . . . an Institute for Retired Professionals, allowing not mean that either is perfect without limitation, older people to putter around in their own courses but that "this" has "more" of the qualities that go to —J. Kirk Sale, Change, July-August 1969 make up perfection than "that"; it is more nearly perfect. Such usage has high literary authority —Fer- For some reason "an older woman" or "an older man" nald 1946 seems younger than "an old woman" or "an old man." Bryant 1962 concludes that both forms of the absolute To summarize, a majority of adjectives, perhaps a comparative are used in informal standard English, but substantial majority, do not admit of comparison sim- a number of the fixed phrases and other conventional ply because they are too technical or have a meaning forms occur in English of any level of formality: that truly does not allow such modification. Most of the adjectives called uncomparable by usage writers have, . . . what physiologists term a consensus, similar to in fact, been compared or modified by adverbs of degree that existing among the various organs and functions other than more and most, for two reasons. First, they of the physical frame of man and the more perfect tend to be common words with more than one meaning animals —John Stuart Mill, A System of Logic, 1843 and are liable to comparison in some senses, if not all. Second, the comparative degree is commonly used to absolute constructions, absolute clauses S e e ABSO- mean "more nearly," as Fernald explains. LUTE PHRASES. See also COMPLETE, COMPLETELY; CORRECT; EQUAL 2; ESSENTIAL, adjective; PARAMOUNT; PERFECT; PREFERABLE; UNIQUE. absolutely Usage commentators have taken up a couple of points about absolutely. 1. Howard 1978 notes the emergence of absolutely in absolute comparative The absolute comparative is England as a vogue word for yes; he thinks it fairly the comparative form of an adjective used where the recent. The usage appears, from dictionary evidence, to positive might be expected; either no comparison at all have been originally American: the earliest citation in is implied, or no comparison is overtly stated although the OED Supplement is from Mark Twain's The Amer- it may be inferred by the reader or hearer. The second ican Claimant, 1892. It appeared in British English of these types is also called incomplete comparison. somewhat earlier than Howard thinks; the OED Supple- Except for a few familiar fixed phrases that are clearly ment lists it from Alec Waugh in 1917 and James of the first type—higher education, higher learning, the Joyce's Ulysses, 1922. Harper 1985 labels it entirely greater Boston area, better stores everywhere, the acceptable in both speech and writing. It appears to be younger generation, the finer things in life—the two more common in speech. absolute phrases absolute phrases 2. At least since the 1920s commentators have been dis- I washed my hair and it was absolutely glorious — paraging the intensive use of absolutely. Thus Ball 1923: Abby Darer, in Ladies' Home Jour., January 1971 Absolutely is a favorite word nowadays; like posi- This second use, as you can see, is more open to criti- tively, quite, literally, and some other words, it is cism as unnecessary or meaningless than the first; there much used, but seldom needed. is a considerable difference between the use of absolutely in "no drug can be proved absolutely harmless" and that I. A. Richards, in Basic English audits Uses, 1943, says in "he was absolutely shattered when he was not invited." The weakened use, however, does have liter- In all but a few contexts absolutely is an absolutely ary authority. If it is a fault, it is, to paraphrase the 18th- (completely) meaningless intensifier century grammarian Joseph Priestley, but a venial fault. There are two separate uses here. The first is use as what Quirk et al. 1985 terms a "maximizer"—it indicates the absolute phrases A participial phrase that is not greatest degree of something. Here are a few typical overtly connected to the rest of the sentence is called an instances: absolute phrase or absolute construction. Quirk et al. 1985 uses the term absolute clause but extends the class Unwilling to make myself disagreeable . . . , I abso- to include constructions from which the participle has lutely refused —Benjamin Franklin, Autobiography, been omitted. Absolute phrases may contain either a 1788 past or present participle. An absolute phrase has a head, usually a noun or pronoun, which the participle She was no longer absolutely bent on winning him modifies. We may think of it as the subject of the phrase. —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, The subject of the absolute phrase and that of the sen- 1859 tence are always different: Constance was absolutely in the wrong —Arnold The scholars increasing fast, the house was soon Bennett, The Old Wives' Tale, 1908 found too small —Benjamin Franklin, Autobiogra- And where else but in England can one find three phy, 1788 expensive but flourishing weeklies devoted to abso- Miss Ward's match, indeed . . . was not contempti- lutely nothing but the life of the rich and the titled? ble, Sir Thomas being happily able to give his friend —Aldous Huxley, The Olive Tree, 1937 an income —Jane Austen, Mansfield Park, 1814 . . . its legitimacy, if not absolutely assured, is cer- But I don't believe that any writer under thirty— tainly strengthened —Thurgood Marshall, Center geniuses excepted—can stay writing in the attic for- Mag., September 1969 ever without drying up —Joan Aiken, The Writer, . . . while Ralph Fox avoided doctrinal cant abso- May 1968 lutely —Times Literary Supp., 19 Feb. 1971 If the subject of what would otherwise be an absolute . . . neither disavowal nor avowal seemed absolutely phrase is suppressed as though it were the same as that essential —John Kenneth Galbraith, Harper's, Feb- of the main clause, a dangling participle results. Here are ruary 1971 two excerpts from a speech of Richard M. Nixon (quoted by William Safire, N.Y. Times Mag., 19 June . . . these letters should be rewritten until they are 1983) that illustrate the problem. In the first example, absolutely perfect —Amy Vanderbilt, Ladies' Home both subjects are the same—/—and the phrase is prop- Jour., September 1971 erly attached to the clause; in the second, they are dif- ferent—/ and tendency—and connection is not made: Although it can be argued that the adverb might have the phrase dangles: been omitted in some of these instances without great loss, its intensifying or maximizing purpose is clear. We Speaking candidly, I believe some of our Chinese have another set of instances, however, in which the friends have misunderstood and misjudged Presi- intensity of the adverb is much diminished. Such use is dent Reagan's position on the Taiwan issue. not especially modern: Speaking as an old friend, there has been a disturbing She grew absolutely ashamed of herself —Jane Aus- tendency in statements emanating from Peking to ten, Pride and Prejudice, 1813 question the good faith of President Reagan . . . so absolutely flooded by the Hawkesbury and its S e e DANGLING MODIFIERS. tributaries, that the farmers are forced to fly for their Perrin & Ebbitt 1972 point out that absolute phrases, lives —Anthony Trollope, from Australia and New when short, are direct and economical; and that when Zealand, 1873, in Wanderers in Australia, ed. Colin they follow the main clause, they are a convenient way Roderick, 1949 to add details. Reader's Digest 1983 warns that absolute phrases with a pronoun subject (as "he having gone on John McClain of the New York Journal-American ahead") are often felt to be awkward or old-fashioned. (March 19, 1965) described the sets as "absolutely A number of absolute phrases have been so frequently magnificent beige and pastel etchings" —Current used that they are now fixed phrases: Biography, December 1967 No, my friends, I go (always, other things being Markel had been absolutely shattered when he had equal) for the man who inherits family traditions — not been invited —Gay Talese, Harper's, February Oliver Wendell Holmes d. 1894, The Autocrat of the 1969 Breakfast-Table, 1858 . . . my piano playing was absolutely terrible —Rose- I suggest that the university's most feasible function, mary Brown, Ladies' Home Jour., September 1971 all things considered, is essentially what it has been absolutist abusage for nearly a millennium now —Robert A. Nisbet, In reference to voting, abstain usually takes no prepo- Psychology Today, March 1971 sition. From may be used, and rarely in appears: So, beyond the damage to the front end, the valves No less than 213 Diet members abstained in the final had to be reground. It came to $350 all told —Gar- vote —Collier's Year Book, 1949 rison Keillor, Lake Wobegon Days, 1985 abstract The verb abstract, in most of its senses, absolutist See PURIST. takes the preposition from, if it takes one at all. The usual pattern is to "abstract a thing from something absolve Bernstein 1965 observes that when absolve is else." Occasionally we find that "something is followed by a preposition, the choice is from or some- abstracted by something else" or "something is times of. Before 1965 from was certainly more frequent abstracted into something else." These last two patterns than of, but since then the proportion of of to from has are much less frequent than constructions with from. increased noticeably. Both prepositions are in current Here are some examples of the usual construction: good use. With the nail of his right forefinger he abstracted a By this device I am absolved from reading much of string of meat from between two teeth —Liam what is published in a given year —Lewis H. O'Flaherty, The Informer, 1925 Lapham, Harper's, May 1984 Immediately afterwards he was abstracted from the . . . his subjects were absolved from their allegiance scene, and has not been heard from since —H. J. to him —Arnold J. Toynbee, Center Mag., March Muller, Saturday Rev., 4 Dec. 1948 1968 . . . the logical impossibility... of wholly abstracting Having thus absolved himself from the duty of mak- this knowledge from all reference to the matter con- ing the essential discriminations —F. R. Leavis, The tained in the form —Bertrand Russell, Foundations Common Pursuit, 1952 of Geometry, 1897 . . . to absolve you from your promise —Willa . . . an apparition, rather insubstantial and eerie, Cather, Death Comes for the Archbishop, 1927 abstracted from time and space —Edmund Wilson, . . . in order to establish their independence and New Yorker, 2 2 Nov. 1952 absolve the guide of any responsibility —Jeremy . . . the Romantic project was to abstract from reli- Bernstein, New Yorker, 30 Oct. 1971 gion its essential "feeling" and leave contemptuously . . . the 1965 pronouncement by Vatican II absolving behind its traditional formulations —Theodore Jews, as a people, of guilt in the death of Christ — Roszak, The Making of a Counter Culture, 1969 Cyril E. Bryant, Christian Herald, December 1969 . . . basic esthetic criteria and standards he has . . . arrested but later absolved of any complicity in abstracted from long intimacy with time-tested mas- the plot —Current Biography 1953 terpieces —Aline B. Saarinen, NY. Times Book Rev., 7 Nov. 1954 . . . in return, Dollar was absolved of personal liabil- ity for the line's debts —Time, 27 Nov. 1950 Nor can it be doubted that some kind of social pic- ture can be abstracted from literature —Rene Wellek A less frequent, but still current, construction uses for: & Austin Warren, Theory of Literature, 1949 . . . the manner in which Chicago police were . . . the large illustrated Rabelais which she had absolved for the brutality they visited on the young abstracted from the library —Robertson Davies, —Donald McDonald, Center Mag., July/August Tempest-tost, 1951 1970 And an example of each of the rarer constructions: We may perhaps absolve Ford for the language of the article—it seems somewhat too academic for his . . . these together do not supply more material to the unassisted pen —Roger Burlingame, Backgrounds of soil than is annually abstracted by the extensive Power, 1949 roots of trees, of bushes, and by the fern —Richard Jefferies, The Open Air, 1885 abstain When abstain is followed by a preposition, it . . . conscientiously and with great purity made the is regularly from. uncompromising effort to abstract his view of life They seemed careful to abstain from rich, extrava- into an art work —Norman Mailer, Advertisements gant, or passionate language —Norman Mailer, Har- for Myself, 1959 per's, November 1968 abusage Nickles 1974 labels abusage "an obsolete . . . an act of renunciation, his decision to abstain and needless form of abuse." Needless it may be, but it from meat —William L. Shirer, The Rise and Fall of is not obsolete. The OED has only 16th- and 17th-cen- the Third Reich, 1960 tury citations, but Eric Partridge revived the word in the . . . now of course he would have to abstain from his title of his 1942 book: Usage and Abusage. Since Par- allusions to the "son of the poet—you know" — tridge revived it the word has been limited in use to Joseph Conrad, Chance, 1913 commentators on English usage: . . . was abstaining from her customary work simply . . . Edwin Newman was called on to open the pro- from an excess of prudence —Arnold Bennett, The ceedings on the strength of his two books on English Old Wives'Tale, 1908 abusage —John Simon, Esquire, June 1977 abut abysmal 10 There is a limit to the propriety of rejecting new abysm Reader's Digest 1983 adverts to abysm as an usage, or abusage —Anthony Burgess, Saturday old variant of abyss that is now archaic or obsolete. This Rev., 2 Sept. 1978 is not quite correct, though it is close. Both abysm and abyss were in use in the 14th century for the void According to recent reports . . . the dictionary "lays believed in the old cosmography to exist below the down the law" about word usage and abusage —Ken earth. Abyss has continued in vigorous use; abysm Kister, Library Jour., 15 Nov. 1979 might well have become obsolete except for Shake- speare. In The Tempest (1612) he wrote this line: abut Bernstein 1965 opines that the intransitive verb abut takes against for a wall and on for a line; Krapp What seest thou else 1927 allows upon or against for Bernstein's walls and In the dark backward and abysm of time? upon for his line. Both of these commentators are partly right. Evidence in the Merriam-Webster files shows that This line has continued to echo in later writers: on is the preposition of choice when something con- . . . the surviving memory, signalling out of the dark ceived of as having chiefly lateral extension is in mind: backward and abysm of time the images of perished The England of the later Middle Ages . . . abutted on things —Robert Louis Stevenson, Memories and Scotland —G. M. Trevelyan, A Shortened History of Portraits, 1887 England, 1942 . . . the mind grows dizzy at contemplating the . . . important and populous states that abut on the abysm of time between —Norman Douglas, Siren Great Lakes —Harold L. Ickes, New Republic, 12 Land, 1 9 1 1 Feb. 1951 To advocate . . . appeared in English in the dark The northeast and southeast arms of this cross abut backward and abysm of time, but during the eigh- on Ninth Avenue —Lewis Mumford, New Yorker, teenth century it seems to have dropped out of gen- 19 Apr. 1952 eral use —H. L. Mencken, "The American Lan- guage" (1936), in Yale Rev. Anthology, 1942 Upon is occasionally used: . . . the illumination, through people, of the dark . . . a lot which abuts upon a public or private alley backward and abysm of American time —Carlos —Zoning for Truck-Loading Facilities, 1952 Baker, Saturday Rev., 20 Aug. 1955 When the thing abutted is conceived of as having a ver- . . . the Cherry Lane Theatre, which is located some- tical as well as lateral extension, against and on are both where in the dark backward and abysm of Green- used: wich Village — Wolcott Gibbs, New Yorker, 19 Feb. 1955 . . . a partition abutted against a window —Hugh Morrison, Early American Architecture, 1952 Other modern use of abysm also exists but is rare. . . . the Nechako Plateau, which abuts against the Pleasantly and with delicacy he picks his way among Rocky Mountains —Canadian Geographical Jour., some of the less quoted lyrics, avoiding such abysms September 1952 as "The Vampire" and some of the more purple . . . pieces —New Republic, 21 Oct. 1940 The Whitney abuts at right angles on the Modern Museum —Lewis Mumford, New Yorker, 15 Oct. . . . those other forces to whom he gave his love and 1955 loyalty, which were taking his administration down to an abysm of political dishonor —The Autobiog- Other prepositions are occasionally used: raphy of William Allen White, 1946 Here a retaining wall is to abut into a rocky hillside abysmal, abyssal Oddly enough, abysmal, derived —Clarence W. Dunham, Foundations of Structures, from abysm, a relatively little used word, is the more 1950 commonly used adjective of this pair; abyssal, derived On the Soviet side of Potsdamer Platz, which abuts from abyss, which continues in vigorous use, is limited on to West Berlin —Time, 29 June 1953 mostly to technical contexts. Abysmal is used for the most part figuratively, but it has some use of actual The transitive abut sometimes admits of a prepositional depths: phrase after the direct object; various prepositions are used: . . . he tosses off the abysmal Royal Gorge of the Arkansas with the phrase "perpendicular precipices" Sparks, abutting Reno on 1-80 east —Dodge News —David Lavender, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 25 Sept. Mag., February 1972 1966 This Caroline Ridge province abuts the Philippine . . . driven at a good speed, often it appeared to me Sea along the southern side of the Mariana Trench within a few inches of abysmal precipices —W. R. —Alfred G. Fischer et al., Science, 5 June 1970 Arnold, The Postmark, May-June 1955 Owners with two-story brick houses were permitted . . . only a few miles from the beach the bottom to abut their piazzas to the sea wall —Hugh Morri- breaks off into the abysmal depths of the ocean — son, Early American Architecture, 1952 Thomas Barbour, That Vanishing Eden, 1944 A good diagnostician abuts the whole of himself . . . not much happens to star-light in its long passage against the whole of the patient —Encore, January through the abysmal depths of interstellar space — 1947 Paul W. Merrill, The Nature of Variable Stars, 1938 academe academe 11 Or the depths may be figurative: James Russell Lowell (quoted in the OED) to mean "a seat of learning" is wrong. Evans says that Academe Geology gives one the same abysmal extent of Time properly refers to Plato's academy; he censures its use that Astronomy does of Space —Thomas Carlyle, otherwise as a pomposity, instancing the title of Mary The Life of John Sterling, 1851 McCarthy's novel Groves of Academe (1952). Reader's . . . two octaves below the standard bassoon, with the Digest 1983 essentially agrees with Evans; they find in phenomenal bottom note B,,, flat, though whether Mary McCarthy's "ironic" title the origin of modern that abysmal pitch can be directly audible to the journalistic use, of which they disapprove, recommend- human ear is more than doubtful —Robert Doning- ing the use of academia instead. ton, The Instruments of Music, 2d ed. rev., 1951 These notions need to be disentangled and examined. First, we have academe used to mean a place of learn- . . . the great head reared up, mouth open in a slack, ing. As far as we can tell, this use was invented by savage grin, eyes black and abysmal —Peter Shakespeare, who needed a three-syllable word for Benchley, in Cosmopolitan, July 1974 academy: Sometimes there is an allusion to the original abysm: From women's eyes this doctrine I derive: They are the ground, the books, the academes, . . . as if the spirit were steeped in abysmal blackness From whence doth spring the true Promethean fire. —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, —Love's Labour's Lost, 1595 1859 What Shakespeare has done here is to establish a literary Often figurative use suggests a sense of immensity or expression—he used it both literally and figuratively in profundity: the same play—that would be echoed by later writers, Such staggering smugness, such abysmal ignorance Tennyson and Lowell among them. Fowler's objection leave one breathless —William L. Shirer, The Rise came 330 years too late. and Fall of the Third Reich, 1960 A 17th-century writer named Peacham cited in the OED also used the word, suggesting to someone that . . . he had known the abysmal depletions that follow "thy solitary Academe should be some shady grove intellectual excess —Edmund Wilson, A Piece of My upon the Thames' fair side." This is the earliest attach- Mind, 1956 ment of grove in English, but it took Milton to firmly unite the two words. In the fourth book of Paradise . . . the abysmal solitude of aging —Maya Angelou, Regained (1671) Satan is lecturing the Son of God on NY. Times, 4 Feb. 1973 the literature and culture of the gentiles. He mentions But perhaps most often abysmal denotes wretchedness Athens: or low quality or sometimes quantity: See there the olive-grove of Academe, . . . exploiting the just political grievances and the Plato's retirement, where the Attic bird abysmal living conditions of the people there —New Trills... Republic, 6 Sept. 1954 Here Academe means Academus; like Shakespeare The weather, even by London standards, was abys- before him, Milton changed the usual word for the sake mal —Frank Deford, Sports Illustrated, 12 July 1982 of his meter. No one seems to have followed Milton's spelling of the hero's name, but the phrase grove of Aca- . . . I have suffered abysmal baseball luck when deme has stayed with us, eventually becoming plural by watching the Yankees —Roger Angell, New Yorker, the mid-19th century. 16 July 1973 So we have Shakespeare's academe, both literal and figurative, and Milton's grove of Academe, referring to Earnings of the whole textile industry, traditionally Plato's Academy. Our evidence suggests, not surpris- low, were an abysmal 1 per cent of sales —News- ingly, that the phrase occurred chiefly in poetry. Being a week, 1 Aug. 1955 literary allusion, its reference was not necessarily pre- Abyssal is found chiefly in contexts referring to the bot- cise. Sometimes it might pretty clearly indicate the Pla- tom of the sea: tonic surrounds: . . . to where the continental slope meets the abyssal Fulfilment of his boyhood's dream, ocean floor —Neil H. Jacoby, "Pacem in Maribus," Greece welcomes now the freedman's son; A Center Occasional Paper, 1970 He haunts the groves of Academe, And quaffs the springs of Helicon The creatures appear to limit their habitat to the —John Osborne Sargent, Horatian Echoes, 1893 dark, cold, high-pressure abyssal plains below depths And other times it might suggest a wider reference: of 10,000 feet — N Y. Times, 2 Apr. 1970 And whether in the groves of Academe, academe, academia Copperud 1970 reports that Or where contending factions strive and strain both Fowler 1926, 1965 and Evans 1957 disapprove of In the mid-current of life's turbid stream, academe as applied to a place of learning, an academy. His honour knew no stain Fowler maintains that Academe properly means Aca- —Charles L. Graves, "Samuel demus, a hero of Greek mythology: an olive grove in Henry Butcher," 1856 Athens sacred to his memory was near the place where Plato established his philosophical school, and it gave The same characteristics of the phrase also are evi- the name, Academy, to Plato's school. Fowler therefore dent in prose. Sometimes the reference is clearly to opines that the "grove of Academe," mentioned by Mil- Plato: ton, is correct in reference to Plato's Academy, and that . . . his studious fréquentation of that Hercynian for- the use of the phrase in Shakespeare, Tennyson, and est, which takes the place of the groves of Academe academe academe 12 in German philosophical writing —George Saints- He deliberately lived outside Detroit and away from bury, A History of Nineteenth Century Literature, the other auto people, in the Ann Arbor groves of 1896 academe —David Halberstam, Harper's, February 1971 And sometimes not: It is some years since I've been in an American uni- Out of the groves of Academe comes a voice of lam- versity, but I can't believe that activist corruption entation for the political sins of New York. It is that there has hit the very decor of academe as it has in of Arthur Twining Hadley, president of Yale Uni- Italy —Anthony Burgess, Saturday Rev., 13 May versity —N Y. Herald, 24 Jan. 1904 1978 Here the reference is clearly to the academic world or . . . pleasant cafes are being opened by enthusiastic the academic community. This sense can also be found refugees from the theater, the arts, academe, and the without the groves: professions —John L. Hess & Karen Hess, The Taste of America, 1977 He lived within a stone's throw of Academe, and he threw the stone —American Mercury, November . . . deep in the thickets of academe where feminism 1928 trysts with sociology —Anne Crutcher, Wall Street Jour., 3 Feb. 1982 As the sense relating to the academic world or com- munity grew in use (with and without groves), specific The writer in the tower of Academe looks out upon reference to Plato's Academy receded. By the time that the world like a god —Earl Shorris, N Y. Times Book Evans 1957 was trying to restrict Academe to Platonic Rev., 1 July 1984 reference, such use had all but disappeared. Loss of spe- Academia is a more recent word. It has been filtered cific reference is further demonstrated by the diminish- through Latin from the Greek. Its earliest appearance in ing use of the capital A. Lowell had used Shakespeare's our files is as a synonym for Plato's Academy: academe with a lowercase a in 1870; the newer sense began to appear lowercase in American publications in From the Acropolis to the gardens of the Academia the mid-1920s, and by the 1950s lowercase prevailed, —C. M. Thompson, translation of Georges Clemen- although capitalized examples may still be found from ceau, Demosthenes, 1926 time to time. We do not know exactly what Mary McCarthy had in This use appears not to have caught on. In 1946 it mind when she chose Groves of Academe as a title, but turned up as a synonym for the most popular sense of we do know the phrase was well established by 1952, academe: even in its widest reference (the Graves poem cited . . . beyond the complacent paddocks of academia, above is dated 1856). Her novel may well have added to clubdom, or social status —Lucien Price, Atlantic, the popularity of both the phrase and the word June 1946 academe. Here are some examples of how academe is actually It has stuck: used. Shakespeare's original figurative sense is still alive, although the contexts are not so elevated: . . . the self-directed scholar who investigates items about which he is from time to time curious, without Out of the groves of a ragtime academe . . . came concern for the shaping of policy, the government of Fats Waller's stride-style piano —Barry Ulanov, A tribes, or the fashions of academia —David Ries- Handbook of Jazz, 1957 man, New Republic, 12 Jan. 1953 He was intent on carving a career of public service, . . . splendid new texts from two doyennes of Man- not within the halls of academia but on the national hattan's Chinese cooking academe —Ellen Stern, and international stage —Times Literary Supp., 16 New York, 9 June 1975 Jan. 1964 It is also used to mean an academic: . . . where the mandarins of academia dine with top Pentagon officials and Senators —Robert Reinhold, Young academes who have not read the works listed NY. Times, 18 Aug. 1974 say my choice is capricious —Ezra Pound, Polite Essays, 1937 Like the homosexual professors who are rising fast in American academia —Pauline Kael, in The Film, But by far the most common use is to indicate the aca- 1968 demic environment, community, or world: . . . students . . . itchy to close their notebooks and Here is the essence of academe: the trials and tribu- break out of the halls of academia —Susan lations of midnight oil —The Bookman, March 1925 McDonald, Hampshire Life, 7 Feb. 1986 . . . it is clear that he speaks of the publishing scene . . . the Potential Gas Committee, whose members from the remoteness of the groves of academe — represent all branches of the industry, as well as the Charles J. Rolo, Atlantic, July 1956 government and academia —David Osborne, Atlan- tic, March 1984 . . . out of the sweat of the schoolroom where it belongs into the Groves of Academe —Times Lit- The modern traffic from academia to public life can erary Supp., 14 Nov. 1968 show nothing to its medieval counterpart —Gordon Leff, Times Literary Supp., 20 Nov. 1981 . . . because the most influential men in business, labor and academe appeared ready to help him — Conclusion: The use of Academe to refer to Plato's Max Frankel, NY. Times, 8 Jan. 1968 Academy seems to be moribund: we have no evidence accede 13 accent of its use since the 1920s. Academe for Academus was Sleek, modern design accentuates shining simulated used only by Milton, and survives only in the fixed stone —Sears, Roebuck Catalogue, Fall and Winter phrase groves of Academe, where its origin is in general 1955 forgotten, as the prevalent lowercasing of the phrase attests. People who insist that these are the only correct Grayish daylight seeping into the tunnel accentuated uses are living in the past. the rough texture of the walls —Joseph Wechsberg, Both academe and academia are in current good New Yorker, 12 May 1956 usage in American and British English meaning "aca- . . . a slender, small-breasted girl, with an erect car- demic life, environment, community, world." When riage, which she accentuated by throwing her body these words begin to steal each other's metaphors and backward at the shoulders —F. Scott Fitzgerald, The insinuate themselves into other hoary metaphors of aca- Great Gatsby, 1925 demic life—when we find groves of academia, halls not of ivy but academia, towers not of ivory but of Aca- The scolding of the New England woman, that had deme, and thickets rather than groves of academe—it is but accentuated his awkwardness and stupidity — clear that they have firmly established themselves in the Sherwood Anderson, Poor White, 1920 language. They appear to be used with about equal fre- quency at the present. Accent may emphasize a setting off by contrast; accen- tuate is seldom used thus: accede Janis 1984 points out that this word is spelled -cede not -ceed. The Oxford American Dictionary notes The corners of the towers are accented by brick that it is also a homophone of exceed and so subject to quoins —American Guide Series: Maryland, 1940 being confused. We do not happen to have run across . . . had traces of Castilian beauty which she accented examples of either mistake, and while they seem not with pendulous amethyst earrings —Ludwig Bemel- unlikely in some kinds of writing, they do not find their mans, Now I Lay Me Down to Sleep, 1943 way into print. Accede is regularly followed by to: . . . retain the 1952 basic body styling, but the lines have been accented with additional chrome —News- . . . for the purpose of forcing employers to accede to week, 20 Oct. 1952 their demands —Eugene J. McCarthy, Dictionary of American Politics, 1968 A Sauternes . . . finished off the meal, agreeably accenting the dessert —Jane Nickerson, N. Y. Times I don't want to accede to persistent demands to Mag., 20 June 1954 repeat myself—Susan Sontag, in Vogue, 1 Aug. 1971 . . . patch pockets accented with buttons — Women's Pacifism acceded to the place of belligerency in the Wear Daily, 3 June 1953 British heart —Michael Straight, New Republic, 18 Apr. 1955 . . . a pasty complexion and a wide, even smile accented by a rather pointy nose —Jack Falla, Sports accent, accentuate Accentuate is what Fowler 1926 Illustrated, 23 Jan. 1984 would call a "long variant" of accent. In this case instead of condemnation, there is approval. Fowler Accent is also used when the writer wants to single out notes that accentuate is being used for figurative senses or stress some particular: and accent for literal and technical ones; this is differ- entiation (a favorite process of Fowler and other mem- Gunther's account of his record at SHAPE accents bers of the Society for Pure English), and Fowler the General's deep belief in working toward a Euro- approves and encourages it. Fowler would be pleased to pean Federation —Charles J. Rolo, Atlantic, March learn that in the years since his writing the differentia- 1952 tion has continued. Accent has more meanings, mainly Although Dr.Heller in the past has made suggestions technical, but accentuate has more usage. in this vein, he hardly accents them in his book — The Merriam-Webster files show that when accent is Leon H. Keyserling, New Republic, 25 Mar. 1967 used in a nontechnical way, it may be used to mean "to give prominence or emphasis to": . . . thirty regional dramas, the more recent ones accenting Texas —Richard L. Coe, Holiday, May/ . . . skirts, pants, culottes and shorts that zero in on June 1973 the fanny—and accent the belly —Women's Wear Daily, 27 Oct. 1975 Accentuate is seldom used in this way, except in the The problem of tying so far-flung a nation together phrase accentuate the positive, which has been rein- . . . is accented by the population's uneven distribu- forced by a popular song with that title. Accent is also tion —J. Hervie Haufler, General Electric Investor, sometimes used in the phrase: Winter 1972 An occasionally negative pronouncement tends to be . ; . the cheapness and potency of tequila, which mild and regretful; then it quickly accents the posi- helped accent his paranoid and manic moods —Sy tive —Alfred Kazin, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 29 Jan. Kahn, Jour, of Modern Literature, 1970 1984 Accentuate, however, is considerably more common in We would rather accentuate the positive —Gerard such use: Onisa, Media & Methods, March 1969 Intimacy breeds rivalry, accentuates the meaning of In the course of some missionary work . . . White- moods —Thomas J. Cottle, Change, January-Feb- head stoutly accentuated the positive —Russell Wat- ruary 1971 son, Newsweek, 15 Jan. 1973 accept 14 access Accentuate has developed an additional meaning, And it is in this spirit that they [authors of a work approximately "to intensify or increase" that is not on French grammar] make use of such terms as shared by accent: punctual in their usual acceptation —Howard B. Garey, Language, April-June 1957 . . . the frail health she experienced as a result may have accentuated her natural tendency to meditate Occasionally it is used like acceptance: —Dictionary of American Biography, 1944 His record is plainly true and worthy of all accepta- . . . the Bank's operations would tend to accentuate tion —Times Literary Supp., 16 Nov. 1951 rather than to moderate the cycle —Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science, January 1947 "All right, then!" he cried bitterly, with sudden acceptation of the other's story —Thomas Wolfe, Of . . . needs which are accentuated or created by the Time and the River, 1935 culture —Abram Kardiner, The Individual and His Society, 1939 Acceptance is much the more frequent word. It occa- sionally is used much like acceptation: The 1959 crisis in Tibet accentuated, though it by no means initiated, strains in relations —Times Liter- There is also a common acceptance among far too ary Supp., 9 Apr. 1970 many teachers that the field trip is a device for expos- . . . they certainly accentuate rather than attenuate ing youngsters to museum facilities without any par- the divisiveness in the faculty —T. R. McConnell, ticular preparation or use of their experience upon AAUPBulletin, September 1969 return to the classroom —Gilbert Hagerty, New- England Galaxy, Fall 1970 Milwaukee's precipitous decline in the American League East was accentuated by a 10-game losing But mostly it does duty as the noun for accept in its streak —Herm Weiskopf, Sports Illustrated, 3 Oct. common and specialized senses: 1983 . . . uncritical acceptance of sense experience —Iris So the differentiation between accent and accentuate Murdoch, The Fire and the Sun, 1977 noticed and encouraged by Fowler 1926 has continued, although it cannot be called complete. Except for the . . . that expression of mildly cynical regret and two general uses mentioned above where accent still acceptance that one often notices in people who have predominates, accentuate holds the field for most gen- seen much of life —Thomas Wolfe, You Can't Go eral and figurative uses, and has developed a use of its Home Again, 1940 own not shared by accent. . . . a general uncritical acceptance of novelty as advance —Howard Mumford Jones, Saturday Rev., accept, except Nearly every handbook published 23 Apr. 1955 between 1917 and the present carries a warning against confusing accept and except. A good half of these unnec- . . . a fine indifference to things that did not interest essarily distinguish the preposition or conjunction him, and an acceptance of those that did —Osbert except from accept, which is only a verb. The verb Sitwell, Noble Essences, 1950 except is, however, sometimes written in place of accept: . . . the acceptance of English as the language of North America —I. A. Richards, Basic English and Still excepting bookings for 1984 —advt., Morgan Its Uses, 1943 Horse, December 1983 . . . in spite of their acceptance into the new structure This confusion must be due entirely to similarity of —Martin Bernai, N.Y. Rev. of Books, 23 Oct. 1969 sound, for the meanings of the two verbs are so dissim- ilar as to obviate confusion on that score. Even though . . . high product acceptance in the extensive agricul- Queen Elizabeth I wrote except for accept in one of her tural . . . industrial and logging markets —Annual own letters (noted in McKnight 1928), the 1983 use Report, Caterpillar Tractor Co., 1952 must be accounted an error. Queen Elizabeth I spelled as she pronounced, and she spelled before there were Through its acceptance corporation it helps sur- such amenities as spelling books and dictionaries for mount problems of home financing —Frederick reference. Gutheim, New Republic, 26 July 1954 acceptance, acceptation Fowler 1926 proclaims access 1. Access, excess. The Oxford American Dic- acceptance and acceptation "fully differentiated" in tionary 1980 and Shaw 1962 warn against the confusion meaning. The differentiation is not quite complete even of these two words, which sound very much alike. The now, however, although it characterizes most use of OED notes that access was used quite a bit in the past these words. Acceptation is the less frequently used for excess; it also notes that the sense "addition, word, and its usual meaning is "a generally understood increase" approaches excess in meaning. meaning of a word or understanding of a concept": We have no clear-cut evidence of confusion, and con- fusion would seem possible only in those senses of . . . are never supposed to be understood in the literal access—"outburst, fit" and "an increase by addition"— acceptation of the words —Tobias Smollett, Travels that are used in constructions with o/'similar to those in Through France and Italy, 1766 which excess is also used. For instance: In its technical acceptation as a term of psychology Adrian's report accused his pupil of an extraordinary —Arthur Pap, Elements of Analytic Philosophy, access of cynicism —George Meredith, The Ordeal 1949 of Richard Feverel, 1859 accessorize 15 accidently An excess of zeal in that direction entangled them in We'd love to get into making accessories, because if difficulties with their bishops —Oscar Handlin, The a woman isn't accessorized properly, the whole thing American People in the Twentieth Century, 1954 goes down the drain —Edith Head, Holiday, November/December 1973 . . . until the chiefs, in a sudden access of wickedness, took it from them —G. M. Trevelyan, English We've selected a suit dress, accessorized it with a hat Social History, 1942 and bag —American Girl, February 1953 . . . for the teeth the government wanted were never A quaint old Early American clock and a pair of there (in a legislative act) until other judges in an antique porcelain flower pots filled with green foliage excess of patriotism put in false ones —Zechariah which ties in with the wallpaper pattern nicely acces- Chafee, Jr., Free Speech in the United States, 1941 sorize the narrow mantel shelf —Betty Lenahan, Sunday Republican (Springfield, Mass.), 20 Apr. Mr. Cruncher, in an access of loyalty, growlingly 1958 repeated the words after Miss Pross —Charles Dick- ens, A Tale of Two Cities, 1859 And even toy horses are now accessorized. Among the additional items you are at liberty to buy for . . . he had gotten his little pants so filthy, by crawling them is a blacksmith set —New Yorker, 11 Dec. extensively under houses in some excess of industry 1965 —Peggy Bennett, The Varmints, 1947 . . . herringbone jackets accessorized with long silk . . . the momentary rise in us of that curious access aviator scarves —Richard Natale, Cosmopolitan, of tenderness which may bring tears to the eyes —C. April 1975 E. Montague, A Writer's Notes on His Trade, 1930 Accessorize is a relatively new word—it has been around It is possible for the words to be exchanged in a few of since 1939—and it is found almost entirely in contexts these examples, but real confusion on the part of the dealing with fashion and interior decoration, where it is authors seems unlikely. Access is most frequently used well established. It is undoubtedly a handy word in such of emotions, and is not infrequently modified by sud- writing. If you are writing on something else, however— den; when excess is used of emotions, it is frequently philosophy, geometry, grammar, art history—you will pluralized. probably never need accessorize. 2. The most commonly used senses of access, when fol- See -izE 2. lowed by a preposition, take to: "Will that restrict your access to information?" — accident See MISHAP. Upton Sinclair, A World to Win, 1946 . . . a man with access to the President —David Hal- accidently, accidentally Shaw 1962 and Watt 1967 berstam, Harper's, July 1969 disparage the spelling accidently as a misspelling or an illiteracy. Copperud 1970 notes that "although Webster . . . to provide poor citizens with access to the now sanctions the second spelling, it is unusual enough nation's courts —Donald McDonald, Center Mag., so that it is likely to be considered an error." March/April 1971 If the OED is right, accidently was formed in the early . . . the difficulty of gaining access to complete copies 16th century, in a sense now obsolete, from the obsolete of such vital sources —Times Literary Supp., 19 adjective accident; by the 17th century it was in occa- Feb. 1971 sional use as a variant of accidentally. In the latter use it has continued to appear sporadically up until the pres- accessorize Popular writers on language enjoy lam- ent time. Its continued use is undoubtedly encouraged pooning advertising copy, which tends to make a target by its more closely representing the usual pronunciation about as elusive as the proverbial side of a barn. Here is of accidentally than the predominant spelling does. a typical instance: Here are a few 20th-century examples: As it happened, I did not have time to sparkle my . . . when the millet stalks which Robin looked upon table because I was busy following instructions given as breakfast were accidently rustled by a passing foot in another advertisement and was accessorizing my —Freya Stark, A Winter in Arabia, 1940 spacious master bedroom with oil paintings — "He asked me if it were true that it was accidently Edwin Newman, Esquire, December 1975 that you were locked up in the museum...." — One object of Newman's scorn here is the verb acces- Oliver St. John Gogarty, Mourning Became Mrs. sorize, which seems to have been discovered by usage Spendlove, 1948 commentators in 1975. Here is Harper 1975 on the A conniving ranch foreman . . . accidently kills the subject: drunken chief —Oscar Lewis, N. Y. Herald Tribune Accessorize is a bastard offshoot of the noun acces- Book Rev., 6 Jan. 1952 sory. It has appeared in advertising copy like the fol- During childhood a brother had accidently shot an lowing: "The new kitchen range is accessorized with arrow into his right eye —Australian Dictionary of stainless steel." This says nothing that "trimmed" Biography, 1966 doesn't say better and more simply. Avoid accessorize. . . . they promoted him to vice president before acci- dently discovering the mythical account —Bill Sur- The advice implied here—that trim is preferable to face, Saturday Rev., 13 July 1968 accessorize—shows the weakness of relying on a single example. Try using trim in place of accessorize in these One policeman accidently shot another last night — examples and see what the effect is in each case: NY. Times,6 5u\y 1971 accommodate 16 accompany . . . the lightweight lambskin jacket, very soft and When the transitive accommodate is used in the pas- textured (as the young woman behind me in the sive, it is used with whatever preposition seems most bank line kept "accidently" confirming) —Gary B. appropriate according to sense. Here, again, to is the Trudeau, in a clothing catalog, Summer 1984 most frequent. The spelling accidently is not an illiteracy, but it is much It was completely accommodated to their culture — less frequent than accidentally, and even though it has John Kenneth Galbraith, The Scotch, 1964 some reputable use, it may be thought a misspelling. . . . while the latter is covertly accommodated to events —John Dewey, Freedom and Culture, 1939 accommodate 1 . Copperud 1970, Holt 1976, Phy- thian 1979, and Janis 1984 all warn that this word is . . . then congratulates himself on being accommo- often misspelled with one m: accomodate. It certainly is. dated with a machine —Thomas Love Peacock, And it has been so misspelled for some time: Headlong Hall, 1 8 1 6 We were accomodated in Henrietta St. —Jane Aus- . . . careers of the "movie brats," each of whom is ten, letter, 25 Sept. 1813 accommodated by a full chapter —Robert F. Moss, Saturday Rev., 23 June 1979 It even sneaks into schoolbooks: . . . I looked in the mirror and saw that though my The lens in your eye changes quickly (a doctor would nose was still long and sharp, it was newly accom- say it accomodates) —You and Science (9th grade modated by a softened cheek —Lore Segal, New text), Paul F. Brandwein et al., 1960 éd. Yorker, 25 July 1964 The example of Jane Austen and many hundreds of oth- Brummell's cravat was twelve inches broad, and had ers (including a few dictionary editors) notwithstanding, to be accommodated between his chin and his shoul- you should remember to double that m. The same warn- ders —English Digest, December 1952 ing goes for accommodation. 2. Bernstein 1965 says that accommodate can take either The girl was accommodated at the station for the to or with as a preposition. Our files show that when a night —Springfield (Mass.) Union, 22 Aug. 1953 preposition is used, to predominates. It is used with the About seventy of them were accommodated in intransitive: wards — Nevil Shute, Most Secret, 1945 . . . she accommodated quickly to the traditional It is not easily accommodated among the peculiari- bisexuality of the British theatre and the British ties of our constitutional system —Dean Rusk, in upper classes —Brendan Gill, Harper's Bazaar, Fifty Years of Foreign Affairs, ed. Hamilton Fish November 1972 Armstrong, 1972 . . . presupposed a certain stable element in Ameri- can life that you learned . . . to accommodate to — accompanist See PIANIST. Edward Grossman, Harper's, February 1970 . . . learn how to live together and to accommodate accompany When accompany is used in the passive to each other —Ramsey Clark, Center Mag., July/ voice, notes Whitford & Foster 1937, "by is nearly August 1970 always used unless the idea is that of combining or sup- plementing." Shaw 1962 repeats their view. Bernstein The transitive verb may take to after a reflexive pro- 1965 specifies "with (things), by (persons)" and several noun or after another direct object: later commentators echo him. None of these statements . . . the musician who seems mad to a bourgeois are quite right. Accompanied by is the usual form, world because he cannot accommodate himself to its regardless of the situation; by is always used with per- demands —Times Literary Supp., 21 May 1970 sons and is usual with things. Accompanied with is lim- ited to things, but citations of it are both markedly less . . . a secular morality . . . that accommodates itself frequent and older; most recent use shows by in all to what man will actually do —Daniel P. Moynihan, cases. Here are some typical examples: American Scholar, Autumn 1969 . . . children should be accompanied by an adult — A bride, to help take care of such a creature, Karla Kuskin, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 11 Nov. 1979 And accommodate her young life to his —Robert Frost, North of Boston, 1914 . . . sudden arguments would flare up accompanied by much cussing and finger jabbing —Richard M. . . . he had to accommodate his step to hers — Le vine, Harper's, April 1971 Michael Arlen, These Charming People, 1924 With is much less frequently used, though not rare: The use of violence is accompanied by anger, hatred and fear, or by exultant malice and conscious cruelty I wish I might accommodate you with a supper of —Aldous Huxley, Ends and Means, 1937 pemmican —Elinor Wylie, The Orphan Angel, 1926 . . . to accommodate them with valuable jobs — Any inflammation or infection of the diaphragm will James Gould Cozzens, Guard of Honor, 1948 be accompanied by a shortness of breath —Morris Fishbein, The Popular Medical Encyclopedia, 1946 . . . we were determined to accommodate our basic interests with those of other powers —Dean Ache- Just how far the fact of uniformity is accompanied son, in The Pattern of Responsibility, ed. McGeorge by a sense of equality —John Dewey, Freedom and Bundy, 1951 Culture, 1939 account 17 accrue . . . a lofty mountain . . . from the top of which a sul- appears that the usual financial uses grew out of a more phurous vapour, accompanied sometimes by smoke general sense. The typical examples below show the and flames —Sir James G. Frazer, Aftermath, 1937 word in its various constructions and also make clear which prepositions are idiomatic with accrue. Bernstein . . . has accompanied her appealing, precise, pastel- 1965 says accrue takes to, but in fact to is used only to colored drawings with some equally sprightly verse indicate the recipient of the accruing; from, through, and —George A. Woods, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 19 Sept. for are usual for indicating its source: 1954 . . . the gain which accrues to his poetry . . . from his . . . his delivery is impassioned and accompanied superiority, and the loss which accrues to it from his with emphatic gestures —Current Biography 1947 defects —Matthew Arnold, Essays in Criticism, Sec- Putting up the ridge-pole was accompanied with a ond Series, 1888 swig of rum —American Guide Series: New Hamp- I have addressed the navvies on the advantages that shire, 1938 would accrue to them if they married wealthy ladies of rank — W. S. Gilbert, The Sorcerer, 1877 account, noun See ON ACCOUNT OF. . . . and some good repute accrues to him from his increased wealth —Thorstein Veblen, The Theory of account, verb When account is used as an intransitive the Leisure Class, 1899, in Outside Readings in Eco- verb, it is regularly followed by the preposition for: nomics, Arleigh P. Hess, Jr., et al., 1951 . . . arms and space programs account for seventy per . . . a good deal accrued eventually to my benefit cent of available federal expenditures —Donald through these visits —Osbert Sitwell, Noble Es- McDonald, Center Mag., July/August 1970 sences, 1950 . . . won twenty-seven games while losing ten, . . . the réclame that would accrue to everyone con- thereby accounting for nearly half of his team's total cerned —S. J. Perelman, New Yorker, 1 Jan. 1972 victories for the year —Roger Angell, New Yorker, . . . Macbeth, surrounded by disasters which have 11 Nov. 1972 accrued from his evil ambition —Clyde S. Kilby, . . . still incapable of accounting for facts that are Poetry and Life, 1953 obvious to introspection —Noam Chomsky, Colum- However, to make any such study and analysis of the bia Forum, Spring 1968 savings which may accrue through the use of elec- . . . the Humour definition quite fails to account for tronic equipment —John W. Mauchly, Systems, the total effect produced —T. S. Eliot, "Ben Jonson," September-October, 1954 in Selected Essays, 1932 . . . whatever credit or blame accrues for easing the way of the People's Republic into the United accountable One is accountable to someone who is Nations —Richard H. Rovere, New Yorker, 18 Sept. due an explanation for something done or not done. 1971 . . . public officials are agents of the people and The intransitive verb can, of course, be used without accountable to them for their public acts —Hyman prepositions: G. Rickover, Center Mag., September 1969 Though Florence's flood was an incalculable disas- The F.B.I, has not been forced to address such issues ter, certain unexpected advantages accrued —Kath- in public because it has never been accountable to arine Kuh, Saturday Rev., 2 2 July 1967 the public —Victor S. Navasky, N. Y. Times Book . . . the thesis that there is a threshold dose below Rev., 14 Mar. 1976 which no harm accrues —The Economist, quoted in They would, finally, make the schools accountable Atlas, March 1970 for results —Peter Janssen, Saturday Rev., 5 Feb. My hatred has no consequences. It accrues only in 1972 my mind —Renata Adler, New Yorker, 24 Apr. 1971 Accrue also has transitive use: accrue Copperud 1970 advises us that two commen- tators recommend leaving accrue to legal and financial It's been around five years now, accruing readers, contexts; Bryson 1984 offers the same message. This even disciples, in snowball fashion —Robert Lam- being the case, we will largely ignore legal and financial bert, Media & Methods, March 1969 uses and concentrate on those more general and literary contexts that tend to provoke criticism. While participating..., a student would accrue ben- Bryson 1984 begins by telling us that the word must efits on a monthly basis —Frank Newman, Change, mean to be added to bit by bit. The source of his notion May 1972 is obscure; it is not to be found in the OED definitions People changed through the arithmetic of birth, mar- (or in Merriam-Webster's) nor is it supported by ety- riage, and death, but not by going away. So families mology, since accrue comes ultimately from a Latin just accrued stories, which through the fullness of verb meaning "to grow." Perhaps Bryson had accrete in time, in those times, their own lives made —Eudora mind. Anyway, he illustrates his assertion with this Welty, Esquire, December 1975 example: "A balloon, for instance, cannot accrue." That is certainly true. The foregoing examples show that accrue can be used Accrue has been used in contexts other than the legal unexceptionably in contexts having nothing to do with and financial kind since the 16th century. Indeed, it law or finance. The two following suggest that it can also accuse 18 Achilles 9 heel be used when the author has been fishing for a word, and Here are a couple of examples of each: has apparently not caught the right one: . . . two Negroes who had been accused by a federal . . . as the film goes along, some of Buck's dignity grand jury in Jackson, Mississippi of perjury —Cur- accrues to the Preacher, who becomes an engagingly rent Biography, July 1965 childlike figure, and some of the Preacher's anarch- ism rubs off on Buck —Joseph McBride, Rolling Niebuhr accuses secular social thinkers of these erro- Stone, 20 July 1972 neous beliefs —Ralph Gilbert Ross, Partisan Rev., January-February 1954 It is hard to say why, but some of the reasons accrue from overzealous building, when concrete was If you accuse me of being a gross optimist —Melvin poured over the top of the greenery, the palms were M. Belli, Los Angeles Times Book Rev., 23 May 1971 blighted, and the beaches cut away —Horace Sutton, Carlyle has been accused of making a habit of this Saturday Rev., 10 Dec. 1977 shifting of the phrase modifier in his writings —Mar- garet M. Bryant, Modern English and Its Heritage, You can use accrue in contexts neither financial nor 1948 legal, if you take care to use it clearly in one of its accepted meanings. Your dictionary will show you what those are. accused No one quibbles over uses of the adjective accused like this: accuse The usual preposition used with accuse, to . . . the accused teacher should be informed before indicate the charge, is of; it has been the usual one at the hearing . . . of the charges —AAUP Bulletin, least since John Gower in the late 14th century. But December 1967 from time to time other prepositions have come into use with accuse, and grammarians and commentators have But several commentators—Copperud 1970, Bernstein been at pains to correct them. In 1762 Bishop Lowth 1971, Reader's Digest 1983—note that accused is also corrected these two well-known writers for using for: used in such combinations as the accused spy, the accused assassin, the accused murderer: Ovid, whom you accuse for luxuriancy of verse — John Dryden, "Essay on Dramatic Poesy," 1668 Previously, accused shoplifters had been disciplined by an administration committee —Glynn Mapes, Accused the ministers for betraying the Dutch — Security World, May 1968 Jonathan Swift, The History of the Four Last Years of the Queen, 1758 Copperud advises avoiding these because they imply guilt before it is established; Reader's Digest calls the Evidence in the OED shows for with accuse to have use an error; Winners & Sinners (19 Apr. 1985) finds it come in around the middle of the 17th century; the lat- "journalese"; Bernstein finds the meaning of accused est citation wither is dated 1809; the OED calls it obso- "distorted" but "accepted" and advises avoiding it as lete, along with in and upon (of which no examples are ambiguous. A combination like the accused murderer shown). actually is journalistic shorthand for "the person The occasional use of with seems to have originated accused of the murder"; it is probably not often misun- in the 20th century. Our earliest evidence is from Lurie derstood as "the murderer who has been unlucky 1927, who corrects this example from an unnamed enough to be caught and charged." While many com- newspaper: mentators say such uses of accused are quite common, our files hold few examples other than those held up as Jeremiah Jenks, having sold butter for more than the bad examples. Reader's Digest prefers and approves market price, was accused with being a profiteer. alleged in place of accused in such combinations. See Lurie supposes with to have come from confusion of ALLEGED, which has had its share of detractors, too. charged with and accused of (see SYNTACTIC BLEND). This is, perhaps, more of a problem for journalists Bernstein 1965, 1977 also criticizes the use of with, and' than for other writers. concurs in Lurie's theory of its origin. Aside from the See also SUSPECTED 1. examples provided by Lurie and Bernstein, Merriam- Webster editors have gathered only one additional citation: Achilles' heel Although the story of Achilles' vulner- able heel is ancient, the phrase Achilles' heel meaning "a In 1947, the FTC accused Monarch and Stolkin with vulnerable point" seems to have been used in English "misrepresentation...." —Newsweek, 3 Nov. 1952 only since the middle of the 19th century. Before that century was out, it had developed a spelling without the Most examples are from journalistic sources (one is apostrophe—perhaps thanks to George Bernard Shaw, quoted speech, however, and Reader's Digest 1983 cites who seems to have been the first to write it that way. Louis Nizer's autobiography). Accuse with seems to Our most recent evidence on the question of whether appear seldom and sporadically. the apostrophe should appear or not is split exactly SO- The usual constructions are accuse + object (noun or SO. For what it's worth, publications like the New York pronoun) + of + noun, which is the older one, and Times and Saturday Review can be found on both sides accuse + object + of + gerund. The first goes all the of the aisle. British journals—Times Literary Supple- way back to Gower's Confessio Amantis (1393). The ment, The Guardian, New Scientist, The Listener—tend construction with the gerund turns up in Swift's sen- to use the spelling without the apostrophe. Reader's tence wither, the OED shows none earlier. Evidence in Digest 1983 likes to see the apostrophe kept. Either way the Merriam-Webster files suggests that the gerund con- you choose to write it, you will find yourself in decent struction is somewhat more common in current use. company. acid test 19 acquaint add test Back in 1920 when H. W. Fowler was com- . . . rationally testing our hypothesis by the acid test piling his magnum opus (Fowler 1926), he noted that of seeing how it works in experience —Gardner acid test had the greatest vogue of all the popularized Murphy, in Feelings and Emotions, ed. Martin L. technicalities he was listing. He attributed the popular- Reymert, 1950 ity of the phrase to Woodrow Wilson's conspicuous use of it during World War I. The OED Supplement cites The acid test will be whether the members of the Wilson: United Nations, in it and through it, will be able to stop an aggressor —Sir Leslie Munro, United The treatment accorded Russia by her sister nations Nations: Hope for a Divided World, 1960 in the months to come will be the acid test of their good will — The Times, 9 Jan. 1918 . . . he has avoided the acid test of declaring himself in detail on Vietnam —Thomas P. Murphy, Trans- The same statement was paraphrased just a couple of Action, March 1968 weeks later: Even when all these acid tests are ruthlessly applied, however, the inventory of probable Scandinavian He said the attitude of other nations toward revolu- phonic and lexical influences in English remains tionary Russia was the acid test of their democracy impressive—JohnGeipel, The Viking Legacy, 1971 and good faith —Saturday Evening Post, 25 Jan. 1918 Deciding to put Patria Mia to the acid test without beating about the bush, I ordered calamari luciana The OED Supplement shows that the figurative sense as my entrée the first time I set foot in the place — of acid test—"a crucial test"—had actually been in use Jay Jacobs, Gourmet, February 1979 as early as 1912, but Fowler was probably right in attrib- uting its sudden popularity to Wilson. The Saturday . . . Sawyer has devised an acid test for friendship: Evening Post report is the earliest citation in the Mer- take a job that requires getting up at 5:30 in the after- riam-Webster files. It was soon followed by more evi- noon —Margo Howard, People, 5 Nov. 1984 dence from 1918, 1919, and the early 1920s, and the term was entered in the 1923 Addenda section of Web- ster 1909. acoustics Acoustics takes a singular verb when it As is often the case with a phrase that has become refers to the science, and a plural verb when it applies popular in a relatively short time, acid test was soon dis- to the characteristics (as of an auditorium) that enable paraged as a cliché—as early as 1929 by one John Y. T. distinct hearing. Greig in Breaking Priscian's Head; or, English as She Will Be Spoke and Wrote. A number of subsequent Acoustics is the science of sound —Acoustical Ter- commentators—some as recent as Shaw 1975 and minology, 1951 Bremner 1980—have repeated that judgment. Howard 1983 gives a somewhat different opinion, calling the The acoustics of the place are not very good —Virgil term "old-fashioned," which it may be in British Thomson, The Musical Scene, 1947 English. Our files do not have enough evidence to con- firm or refute his opinion; we do have evidence, how- ever, that acid test is still flourishing on this side of the acquaint 1 . Two sources—Bernstein 1965 and Atlantic. Chambers 1985—remind us that acquaint should be fol- The expression is a metaphor derived from the prac- lowed by with. It was not always so. Johnson's Dictio- tice of testing gold with acid. The use of acid test in print nary (1798 ed.) for the sense Johnson defined "To for the chemical operation is rare; and even though we inform" carries this note: "With is more in use before have evidence of other technical uses of acid test, the the object, than of." He includes a quotation from figurative use is by far the dominant one in 20th-century Shakespeare using of. Actually, the construction English. acquaint someone could also be used with a clause intro- The question of what constitutes a cliché is not simple duced by that or even a contact clause. Shakespeare uses (see the discussion at CLICHÉ), SO we will leave you to all four possibilities, but even with him with is the most judge acid test from these examples, drawn from eight common. The OED shows the construction with that decades of use. We do note that the phrase seems not to from Fielding and Sir Walter Scott but calls the con- be much used in literary contexts. struction with of obsolete. The of construction is not quite obsolete, but it is certainly of very low frequency: Every banking institution in this country to-day applies an acid test to applications for loans. Is the I'll presently acquaint the Queen of your most noble note which it will receive capable of discount with offer—Shakespeare, The Winter's Tale, 1611 the Federal Reserve Bank? — The Nation, 28 Mar. 1918 . . . acquainted him formally of the honour which Providence and Sr. Azafia had in store for him —E. . . . the scientist is content to hold them up to the Allison Peers, Spanish Tragedy 1930-1936, 1936 acid test of present-day efficiency — World's Work, November 1928 Here are examples of acquaint with a that clause and a contact clause: The peculiar drudgery . . . of reading papers is the acid test of the teacher —English Jour., December I must acquaint you that I have received new-dated 1935 letters —Shakespeare, 2 Henry IV, 1598 . . . should say something about selling textbooks, for May I be bold to acquaint his Grace you are gone in the American economic system that is the acid about it? —Shakespeare, All's Well That Ends Well, test of any product —Textbooks in Education, 1949 1603 acquaintanceship 20 acquiesce But with predominates, from Shakespeare's time to our At intervals I was able to renew my acquaintance- own: ship with this room —Lucien Price, Dialogues of Alfred North Whitehead, 1954 Misery acquaints a man with strange bedfellows — Shakespeare, The Tempest, 1612 . . . both Hawthorne and Thoreau profited more from their acquaintanceship than has been generally . . . his near relation to you makes you more partic- allowed —Earle Labor, CEA Critic, January 1971 ularly acquainted with his merits —Edmund Burke, speech, 1780, in Burke's Speeches at Bristol, ed. It also reveals the width of his acquaintanceship — Edward Bergin, 1916 Graham Reynolds, Times Literary Supp., 6 June 1980 Any young gentlemen and ladies, who wish to acquaint themselves with the English language — acquiesce Around the turn of the century acquiesce Noah Webster, quoted in Horace E. Scudder, Noah began to receive attention from usage commentators. Webster, 1882 Vizetelly 1906 seems to have begun things with a pro- hibition of with after the word; he prescribes in. Krapp . . . you expect to be informed of the secret with 1927 prescribes in and censures to; so does Carr & which I am acquainted —Mary Shelley, Franken- Clark, An ABC of Idiom and Diction, 1937. Similar stein, 1818 views are expressed in Follett 1966, Bernstein 1965, Harper 1975, 1985, Macmillan 1982, Ebbitt & Ebbitt . . . not very well acquainted with our Parliamentary 1982, Reader's Digest 1983, and Chambers 1985. Dic- or political affairs —Sir Winston Churchill, The tionaries are less dogmatic; Webster's Third states Unrelenting Struggle, 1942 "often used with in, sometimes with to, and formerly . . . music-lovers who are thoroughly acquainted with with"', Heritage 1982 concurs in this assessment. with Bruckner —Winthrop Sargeant, Saturday Rev., The OED shows that acquiesce has been used with 28 Aug. 1954 several prepositions—from and under in senses now obsolete, and in, to, and with in the current sense. In and . . . to acquaint a boy with how to use tools and han- to are of equal antiquity, both having been used by dle materials —James B. Conant, Slums and Sub- Thomas Hobbes 1651, who is the earliest user of the urbs, 1961 modern sense cited in the dictionary. The OED marks to and with obsolete, but in fact to has continued in use, His interest in modern writers acquainted him with although in is used considerably more often. Here are a such philosophers as Pascal, Voltaire and Rousseau few samples of the construction with to: —Edmund White, NY. Times Book Rev., 19 June 1983 . . . to have Carrie acquiesce to an arrangement — Theodore Dreiser, Sister Carrie, 1900 2. Acquaint is one of the terms Gowers 1948 found over- worked in British governmental prose; Chambers 1985 Some abundance within herself would not let Theo- seems to take a similar line in suggesting acquaint with dosia acquiesce completely to the hour, to any hour is rather formal for tell or inform and reporting that or to any experience, as being sufficient —Elizabeth some people think acquaint someone with the facts is a Madox Roberts, My Heart and My Flesh, 1927 cliché. British and American usage may differ in this . . . had, just before Kalgan's fall, acquiesced to Mar- regard, for Merriam-Webster files have little evidence of shall's proposal for a ten-day truce — Time, 21 Oct. the supposed cliché. Many of our citations do, however, 1946 come from educational sources, in which there is often a tendency to bureaucratic prose. Gowers suggests tell or . . . political sociologists today are often reluctant to inform as substitutes, but acquaint, with its overtones of acquiesce to Michels' law —Lewis S. Feuer, Jour, of familiarity, cannot always be felicitously replaced. Philosophy, 11 Nov. 1954 Man's freedom must at last acquiesce to the inhib- acquaintanceship Characterized as "a needless vari- iting claims of his fellows and to the melancholy ant" by Fowler 1926 and "unnecessary" by Evans 1957, necessity of death —Theodore Roszak, The Making acquaintanceship was formed in the early 19th century, of a Counter Culture, 1969 apparently to distinguish the meaning "state of being acquainted" from acquaintance "a person with whom None of these examples is incorrect or nonstandard. But one is acquainted." It does serve to make the distinc- acquiesce in is the predominant construction: tion, but most people have continued to use acquain- . . . no organism acquiesces in its own destruction — tance for both meanings. Curiously, Long 1888 writes: H. L. Mencken, Prejudices: Second Series, 1920 "Prefer: . . . Acquaintanceship to acquaintance, as an abstract noun. Reserve acquaintance for persons or . . . it was wrong to acquiesce in the opinion that things one is acquainted with." The word evidently had there was nothing to be done —Compton Macken- some status as a carrier of the distinction before it was zie, The Parson's Progress, 1923 condemned by Fowler. He discreetly acquiesced in the election of one of the Acquaintanceship is not widely used, but is not rare. principal assassins —John Buchan, Augustus, 1937 It tends to show up in literary contexts. To acquiesce in discrepancy is destructive of can- They struck up an acquaintanceship —Samuel Hop- dour —Alfred North Whitehead, Science and the kins Adams, Incredible Era, 1939 Modern World, 1925 . . . found an acquaintanceship with alcohol easy . . . a pose which was accepted and acquiesced in by enough, but one with women formidably difficult — Delacroix —Sacheverell Sitwell, The Dance of the William Styron, Lie Down in Darkness, 1951 Quick and the Dead, 1936 acquit act 21 . . . the general intellectual tendency is to acquiesce nym, seems to be too little known to the general public in what one no longer feels able to change —Irving to serve as the customary term standing in contrast with Howe, Partisan Rev., January-February 1954 acronym in a narrow sense. Such burning issues among etymologists of a few decades ago as whether mini- . . . one should not on that account acquiesce in it — cam and motel were allowable as acronyms seem to Bertrand Russell, London Calling, 1 Apr. 1955 have faded into the past—we have no current evi- Dr. Brown's refreshing refusal to acquiesce in certain dence that such blends are referred to as acronyms any current fashions —Times Literary Supp., 10 July more. 1969 A number of commentators warn against the indis- criminate use of acronyms that may not be familiar to the reader of general text—sound common sense. Of acquit When acquit means "to discharge com- course, if one is writing for a technical audience, one has pletely," it is often used in the construction acquit (a more leeway in the use of acronyms. But even in tech- person) ^/(something charged): nical articles, many authors gloss new acronyms for . . . was acquitted of robbery on an alibi —Time, 30 their readers' information at least upon their first Oct. 1950 appearance in the text. Many a seemingly catchy acronym has proven to . . . cannot therefore be acquitted of being out of have a short life, as the list of disapproved acronyms in touch in some respects —Times Literary Supp., 23 Nickles 1974 illustrates: only two or three of his pageful Apr. 1971 are still easily recognized. Pyles & Algeo point out other examples: the spate of offsprings patterned on World . . . neither pamphlet nor book could acquit him of War H's snafu are mostly forgotten, although fubar has indecency —Henry Seidel Canby, Walt Whitman, had at least a temporary revival among computer 1943 hackers. For may substitute for of in this construction but is rare: In the end, Mary Todd Lincoln stands acquitted for act, action Both act and action can be similarly used any evil intent —Gerald W. Johnson, New Republic, to denote something done. In theory, an act is conceived 23 Feb. 1953 of as individual and momentary or instantaneous; an action involves discrete stages or steps and is conceived From was formerly in use, but is no longer: of as occupying more time than an act. However, even If I sin, then thou markest me, and thou wilt not though many writers and speakers give little thought to acquit me from mine iniquity —Job 10:14 (AV), the theory, in most cases, as we shall see, the two words 1611 tend to fall into different patterns of use. Sometimes, it is true, either word might have been When the person is not present in the sentence, other used: constructions may be found: . . . deGaulle made public his proposal on December The military "jury" . . . voted 3-1 to acquit on the 28. This action brought a reply from Algiers — charges of failure to report for duty and resisting Arthur L. Funk, Current History, November 1952 arrest —Steve Wise, Great Speckled Bird, 24 Jan. 1972 . . . one of the first acts of President Buchanan was to appoint him —Dictionary of American Biography, acronyms A number of commentators (as Copperud 1928 1970, Janis 1984, Howard 1984) believe that acronyms can be differentiated from other abbreviations in being So far as we can tell from these extracts, deGaulle's pronounceable as words. Dictionaries, however, do not action might just as well have been Buchanan's act, and make this distinction because writers in general do not: vice versa. Nevertheless, differences in usage are usually appar- The powder metallurgy industry has officially ent. When act is modified by something descriptive, for adopted the acronym "P/M Parts" —Precision example, it tends to be followed by o/and a noun: Metal Molding, January 1966 . . . performing numerous acts of kindness to those Users of the term acronym make no distinction in need —Times Literary Supp., 8 Feb. 1968 between those which are pronounced as words . . . and those which are pronounced as a series of char- . . . engaged in an act of arson, or an act of revolu- acters —Jean Praninskas, Trade Name Creation, tionary heroism, depending on his view —Jerome 1968 H. Skolnick, Trans-Action, November 1968 It is not J.C.B.'s fault that its name, let alone its acro- . . . they could never catch Reston in an act of arro- nym, is not a household word among European gance or selfishness —Gay Talese, Harper's, January scholars —Times Literary Supp., 5 Feb. 1970 1969 . . . the confusion in the Pentagon about abbrevia- . . . sit down to commit an act of literature —Wil- tions and acronyms—words formed from the first liam Zinsser, 1975 letters of other words —Bernard Weinraub, N. Y. Times, 11 Dec. 1978 The physical act of moving is even worse—the sheer awfulness of facing that jammed and cluttered attic Pyles & Algeo 1970 divide acronyms into "initialisms," —•Anna Fisher Rush, McCall's, March 1971 which consist of initial letters pronounced with the let- ter names, and "word acronyms," which are pro- Once the act of reading has begun —Joe Flaherty, nounced as words. Initialism, an older word than acro- NY. Times Book Rev., 27 Mar. 1977 activate 22 activate One phrase is a notable exception: . . . a general program that . . . was not put into action at first —Current Biography, May 1965 The sex act has to do more for humans than for other creatures —Robert Jay Lifton, N.Y. Times Book Its editorial offices are in Manhattan, near the action Rev., 19 Aug. 1979 —Herbert Mitgang, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 13 Jan. 1980 Action tends to be preceded by its modifier: . . . a similar CNVA protest action —Current Biog- activate, actuate powers in Fowler 1965 disparages raphy, October 1965 activate as a popularized technicality replacing actuate; Shaw 1975, 1987 considers the meanings of the two . . . his bungling unilateral actions during the Corsi- words to be "confused when used to refer to persons" can campaign —Arthur L. Funk, Current History, and both he and Evans 1957 attempt to discriminate November 1952 between them. Here is what evidence in the Merriam- Webster files shows. . . . his occasional political actions . . . seem unre- Both words are currently much used in technical con- lated to any other aspect of his character —Times texts, although activate seems to be used more fre- Literary Supp., 14 Mar. 1968 quently and widely. Technical uses are not disputed, so There are squatter actions going on all the time — we pass them over, except to note that when a person Philip St. George, quoted in N.Y. Times, 23 Mar. sets some mechanism in motion, either word might be 1980 used, but activate is more frequent in our more recent citations: When a prepositional phrase introduced by o/follows action, it usually functions as a genitive: Then he actuated the mechanism, and the mass of metal fell with a muffled, reverberating thud — It is the actions of men and not their sentiments Arnold Bennett, The Old Wives' Tale, 1908 which make history —Norman Mailer, Advertise- ments for Myself, 1959 . . . the throttle being actuated by hand —Priscilla Hughes, Now There's No Excuse, 1952 . . . the future of our children depends in great mea- sure on the actions of our political leaders —Lena L. Whenever Dr. Kelman activates a switch, the wall Gitter, Children's House, Fall 1968 . . . begins to slide away —Brian Vachon, Saturday Rev., 15 Apr. 1972 Action has a collective use that act does not: . . . small sonic pingers that could be activated in an . . . the only time in which it took decisive action — emergency —John Devany & Sylvia Earle, "My Times Literary Supp., 16 Jan. 1969 Two Weeks Under the Sea," in Networks, ed. Mar- jorie Seddon Johnson et al., 1977 . . . immediately pressed for Congressional action — Current Biography, December 1965 When the words are used in reference to persons, they are usually distinguished. Actuate, which has a long . . . after the Socialists' April triumph, action against background of literary use, almost always indicates an them was indicated —John Paton Davies, N.Y. interior cause for the action: Times Mag., 13 July 1975 Notwithstanding the high veneration which I enter- Action is also used attributively, while act is not: tained for Dr. Johnson, I was sensible that he was . . . scrutiny by . . . environmental action groups — sometimes a little actuated by the spirit of contradic- Annual Report, Owens-Illinois, 1970 tion —James Boswell, Life of Samuel Johnson, 1791 . . . lots of exciting action photographs H. . . . men, who . . . are always actuated by the hope of Simonds, National Rev., 17 Dec. 1971 personal advantage, or by the dread of personal pun- ishment —Thomas Love Peacock, Headlong Hall, In addition, both act and action fit into characteristic 1816 idiomatic constructions where no native speaker of English would be tempted to interchange them: for Individuals may be actuated by a sense of justice — instance, caught in the act, a piece of the action. (Those William Ellery Channing, Discourses on War, 1903 involving actoften invoke the performance sense of that . . . the spirit that actuated the grandfather having word.) Here is a sampling: lain fallow in the son —Samuel Butler, The Way of All Flesh, 1903 "She had a class act going there." —Cyra McFadden, The Serial, 1977 (class action is a legal term) Still, as he is actuated by a sense of duty —W. S. Gil- bert, The Pirates of Penzance, 1879 . . . Washington must get its act together —Wassily Leontief, N.Y. Times Mag., 30 Dec. 1979 . . . that very British spirit of freedom which has actuated them throughout —Osbert Sitwell, Triple " . . . to try to clean up his act." —John Maher, Fugue, 1924 quoted in Harper's Weekly, 20 Oct. 1975 . . . the man who is actuated by love of power is more . . . a bulletin on how the hairdressers are getting into apt to inflict pain than to permit pleasure —Bertrand the act —Lois Long, New Yorker, 8 Sept. 1956 Russell, Atlantic, March 1952 . . . no action has yet been taken —Hugh Thomas, When activate is applied to individuals, it almost always Times Literary Supp., 11 Apr. 1968 implies an external force: " . . . tomorrow they swing into action...." — . . . her life in art is closely related to the places where unnamed announcer, WTIC radio, 23 Feb. 1975 she has lived and visited, to the natural phenomena active voice 23 actual that have activated her —Katharine Kuh, Saturday site. Here are some other examples of actual in its con- Rev., 22 Jan. 1977 trastive use: He was rarely seen by day, but the feast of St. Patrick I had enjoyed my actual sins, those I had committed had altered his habits and activated him this noon rather than those I had been accused of —Ernest —Herman Wouk, Aurora Dawn, 1947 Hemingway, "Miss Mary's Lion," 1956 . . . he lacked the force to control his party and the . . . I'm no judge of the feelings of actual or prospec- personality and leadership to activate the public — tive parents —Rose Macaulay, Potterism, 1920 Sidney Warren, Current History, May 1952 . . . how would he set out to make any actual person Infrequently actuate is used of an external stimulus and a character in a novel? —Bernard DeVoto, The activate oi an internal one: World of Fiction, 1950 . . . a society too ill-organized to actuate the gener- . . . the services it provides . . . to actual and poten- osity of decent human beings —Times Literary tial publics —Jerome H. Skolnick, AA UP Bulletin, Supp., 4 Mar. 1939 September 1969 . . . many persons, hitherto vaguely sympathetic, . . . a very popular subject indeed among intending become . . . energized and activated out of indigna- and actual undergraduates —Malcolm Bradbury, tion —Richard Hofstadter, Harper's, April 1970 Times Literary Supp., 25 July 1968 Activate is, in general, the more likely word to be used . . . his wonderful dramatic monologues . . . are writ- of something that is compared to or conceived of as ten in verse that uses, sometimes with absolute mas- machinery: tery, the rhythms of actual speech —Randall Jarrell, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 21 Mar. 1954 The federal government finally was activated — Donald Canty, City, March-April 1972 Phythian 1979 mentions actual, too, objecting to "the Economists are accordingly much more interested in common phrase in actual fact." The phrase is probably societies activated by command than in those run by more common in speech than in print, for it is not abun- tradition —Robert L. Heilbroner, The World of Eco- dantly attested in our files. nomics, 1963 In actual fact, Fishpond Lake is not the beautiful . . . exhortations . . . fail to activate the more costly paradise that Bethlehem's camera makes it out to be. self-sacrificing behaviors —James H. Bryan, Psy- Whereas it looks large, serene, and lush in the ad, it chology Today, December 1969 is actually cramped and barely covered with scrub brush —Peter Harnik, Environmental Action, 15 Those who have activated the evil forces loose in the May 1971 world today —JAMA, 26 June 1954 The phrase seems justified in this instance by contrast "I ain't a vegetarian, and Garbo does not have big with the pseudo-factuality of what the camera shows. feet," he said, activating knowing titters —New The phrase has appeared in somewhat altered forms: Yorker, 1 July 1950 He did, as an actual fact, miss Cards terribly —Hugh To summarize, actuate has a long history of literary Walpole, Fortitude, 1913 use; it is applied to people who act for internal reasons. Activate is more often used of things thought of as Actual has, besides its use in pointing up a contrast, mechanical in their operation; when applied to people, an intensive function sometimes meant to stress it almost always indicates the working of some external authenticity: spur to action. . . . she demanded that the soldiers' uniforms in active voice See PASSIVE VOICE. "Fatinitza" be trimmed with actual sable! —Carl Van Vechten, Saturday Rev., 29 May 1954 actual, actually Both words are tarred with the brush of meaninglessness by Copperud 1970, who cites Fowler . . . some of his suits have actual whalebone up the 1965 and Evans 1957 in support of his view, although ribs —Lois Long, New Yorker, 27 Mar. 1954 Evans and Fowler (actually Gowers, since Fowler 1926 It is also used as a simple intensive: does not mention it) condemn only actually. We will examine the words separately. It would be an actual benefit to the town if a few men Copperud's objection to actual lies in a single quoted owned the factory —Sherwood Anderson, Poor sentence: "The stocks were sold at prices above actual White, 1920 market prices." The trouble with this example is that it lacks its preceding context. In a majority of instances of But whatever the actual human and physical cost, the use of actual in our files, it contrasts with some other the political shock was devastating —Allen S. Whit- adjective, either stated or implied. Combined with ing, Life, 21 Feb. 1969 price, actual is usually so contrasted: . . . many heavy leatherites will think twice about . . . actual prices received (as opposed to posted confronting an actual well-dressed lady —Blair prices) have not kept pace —Fred L. Hartley, Annual Sabol, Vogue, November 1976 Report, Union Oil Co. of California, 1970 The intensive actual can reasonably be challenged as In Copperud's example, the contrasting price may have unnecessary in many instances. In the following quota- been mentioned or implied in an earlier sentence in tions, it could probably have been omitted if the author such a way as to make the use of actual entirely appo- so chose. The choice is a matter of style and taste. It actual 24 actual might be a useful exercise to try to determine whether "... but as I have actually paid the visit, we cannot the sentences sound better with or without actual. escape the acquaintance now." —Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, 1813 . . . there ensued a long conversation as they walked as to whether waiters made more in actual wages Actually he was less angry than perplexed —Jean than in tips —F. Scott Fitzgerald, "May Day," in Stafford, The Mountain Lion, 1947 The Portable F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1945 . . . how to obtain a cooperative apartment without A doctrine that identifies what ought to be with the actually cheating —Richard Schickel, Harper's, Feb- lowest elements of actual reality cannot remain ruary 1971 acceptable for long —Aldous Huxley, The Olive Tree, 1937 It may be used to suggest something unexpected: I have rounded the figures to make the arithmetic Now they were off... , leaving Jason standing and easy, but the orders of magnitude are not far from actually waving —Rita Madocs, Ladies' Home the actual facts —Robert M. Solow, Think, May- Jour., September 1971 June 1967 I had been actually invited —F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby, 1925 On the other hand, Auden is steadily increasing his mastery over the actual craft of verse —G. S. Fraser, . . . Mother Goose (a real person actually named in Little Reviews Anthology 1949, éd. Denys Val Mary Goose) —American Guide Series: Massachu- Baker, 1949 setts, 1937 . . . a delightful rendition that awed the audience Of course any of these uses would be normal in especially when they learned that both Glee Clubs speech, too. But in conversation the sense may be weak- had but an hour's combined rehearsal time before ened or even absent, and it is presumably this use that the actual concert —Duncan Dobie III, Dartmouth has occasioned censure of actually as unnecessary. Alumni Mag., May 1954 When its semantic content is low, actually may be serv- ing a special purpose in conversation—that of a filler Actually is a more difficult subject. It is the more (see FILLERS)—as Phythian 1979 and Bremner 1980 widely disparaged word, and disparagement of it is observe (in different terms). "Actually is usually used to somewhat diffuse. In addition, the usages that seem to give the speaker a moment in which to think," says Phy- have excited the criticism are primarily spoken rather thian. The filler actually is likely to be syntactically a than written usages, so that printed evidence of the dis- sentence adverb, and it is probably this use that Evans puted usages is not as abundant as one would like it to 1957 characterizes as "a worn-out import from be and as it would be if a primarily written use were in England." There is no strong evidence on which to base question. We will first examine typical written usage the supposition that it is an import. As a sentence before passing on to the spoken. adverb, actually is typically found at the beginning or It should not be surprising to find actually used in sometimes in the middle of an utterance in American adverbial functions corresponding to the adjective func- use, and at the end of an utterance in British use: tions of actual. It is used to point up a contrast: Actually, if we weren't so worried about forcing inde- Whereas it looks large, serene and lush in the ad, it pendence on them, they would be less likely to beat is actually cramped and barely covered with scrub us over the head with it —Bruno Bettelheim, Ladies' brush —Peter Harnik, Environmental Action, 15 Home Jour., January 1971 May 1971 Actually, the people who truly are Mrs. Lieberman's But actually there is a pattern which underlies these dearest friends are a great deal like her —John contradictory orders —Margaret Mead, And Keep Corry, Harper's, February 1971 Your Powder Dry, 1942 Because I've seen some of the recent criticisms—the Sea anemones may resemble pretty flowers, but continuing criticism, actually—of the statistics — actually they are deadly animals —Murray T. Prin- William Ruckelshaus, quoted in N.Y. Times Mag., gle, Boy's Life, April 1968 19 Aug. 1973 But the most common use is to stress the reality or . . . he didn't fall about laughing, he helped me a lot factuality of something. In this use, actually is not nec- actually —Saffron Summerfield, quoted in Spare Rib essarily emphatic: (London), December 1974 As much a Wykeham Diary as a Langham Diary, . . . could not even find out how many airplanes actually —Alan Ryan, The Listener, 28 Mar. 1974 there actually were —David Halberstam, Harper's, February 1971 Conclusion: criticism of actual and actually as unnec- essary is of very limited value in a usage handbook. The . . . nobody actually knows . . . whether fewer books usages criticized are primarily spoken, and few people are being read —J. Donald Adams, N. Y. Times Book trouble to chasten their speech in accordance with the Rev., 11 Apr. 1954 pronouncements found in usage books addressed to . . . showing the picture that was actually on the air writers. Both actual and actually have legitimate uses in —Denis Johnston, Irish Digest, June 1954 writing, which have been illustrated here. It can be argued that in many instances they can be omitted from Rose really meant what she said. She was actually sentences in which they appear without changing the beginning to forget —C. S. Forester, The African sense; but if you will read the sentences quoted without Queen, 1935 the actual or actually, you will find in very many cases actuate 25 A.D. that something is missing, that actual or actually is far . . . when a non-publishing ad. had been removed — from useless in context. Where these words do not add Quentin Oates, The Bookseller, 6 Apr. 1974 much to meaning, they often improve the rhythm of a sentence and help set off the more important words But in attributive combinations (such as ad-man, ad- effectively. Judicious use of these and many words of writer) the period is generally omitted in the presence of similar function can be a mark of a smooth and under- a hyphen (the OED Supplement does have a citation for standable style. The tersest message is not always the an unhyphenated ad. man). most readily understood. The most frequently used British equivalent of the originally American ad appears to be advert (with no actuate See ACTIVATE, ACTUATE. period): ad "Standard for advertisement" says Copperud 1970 . . . when I come up about the advert, I specially said of this word. Several later commentators (Harper 1985, no mornings —Alan Coren, Punch, 23 Dec. 1975 Perrin & Ebbitt 1972, Ebbitt & Ebbitt 1982, Colter 1981) In one of the Sunday papers I saw an advert in cap- agree in the main, excluding it only from the most for- itals —John Fowles, The Collector, 1963 mal of contexts. But lest you think that at last there is one item of usage comment on which everyone agrees, . . . the adverts on the telly —Alan Sillitoe, The we must record the fact that there are dissenters. Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, 1959 Colloquial shortening of advertisement. Prefer the . . . certain crucial terms are used in a highly ambig- full word —Bell & Cohn 1981 uous way (hardly a good advert for linguistics) — David Crystal, Linguistics, 1971 This clipped form and others like it (such as math, exam, bike) are appropriate in informal speech, but Advert pops up occasionally in American sources: in formal writing the words usually appear in full — . . . despite an advert implying there were —Thomas Macmillan 1982 Plate, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 23 Mar. 1975 These nay-sayers have their predecessors, being part of a tradition: A.D., B.C. B.C. is here for the record—there is no dispute about it and never has been. B.C. follows the Ad. and Advertising—Do not use the abbreviation year and follows the word century: —Whipple 1924 . . . sometime before 2000 B.C., corn was introduced Ad: unauthorized abbreviation for advertisement — —Katherine Hinds, Brown Alumni Monthly, Octo- MacCracken & Sandison 1917 ber 1982 Whipple 1924 is a handbook on business writing; We have Panini's analysis of Sanskrit from the MacCracken & Sandison 1917 is the earliest college fourth century B.C. —Edward Finegan, Attitudes handbook in our collection. These represent two Toward English Usage, 1980 streams of opposition to ad. Of the college-handbook opposition we do not know the origin, other than a gen- A.D. is a different story. It presents three problems: eral disapproval of clipped forms (see ABBREVIATIONS). Does it go before or after the year? Can it be used with The business opposition seems to have arisen in the in? Can it be used after century? advertising fraternity itself. H. L. Mencken, The Amer- The traditional and still most frequently used styling ican Language, Supplement I, 1945, gives its history: places A.D. before the year: The American advertising men, in the glorious days A.D. 1942 was the year —Time, 28 Dec. 1942 when the more forward-looking of them hoped to lift . . . objects, which date from A.D. 200 —Newsweek, their art and mystery to the level of dogmatic theol- 10 July 1944 ogy, astronomy, ophthalmology and military sci- ence, carried on a crusade against the clipped form Until A.D. 1200 the Great Plains were virtually ad, but it came, alas, to nothing. unpopulated —Albert H. Johnston, Publishers Weekly, 29 Dec. 1975 Mencken traces the beginning of this campaign to 1918, and says that nothing has been heard of it since 4 Mar. Some writers and publishers, however, place A.D. after 1933. If the admen have given up the campaign them- the date like B. C: selves, a few writers of college handbooks are still car- rying the old banner. Even so, a large majority find ad Strictly speaking, we should use A.D. only with num- acceptable in general and informal writing: bers indicating particular years (43 A.D., 8-10 A.D.) —MacCracken & Sandison 1917 It [the word better] can even sound unpleasantly snobbish, as in those ads that end with "At better Lucian flourished approximately 125-190 A.D. — stores everywhere" —Simon 1980 Insect Enemies of Books, 1937 Janis 1984 and Ebbitt & Ebbitt 1982, among others, . . . the vast platform that before 70 A.D. had sup- point out that ad is a clipped form rather than an abbre- ported the Temple —John Updike, Bech is Back, viation, and is not terminated by a period. This is cer- 1982 tainly true in American practice. British practice seems mixed; when used alone, it seems to be often treated like MacCracken & Sandison 1917 finds that usage justifies an abbreviation and given the period: placing A.D. either before or after the year (they chose after); Reader's Digest 1983 also finds placement after . . . marked on the ad. dummy as it goes to the edi- the date acceptable, especially in writing in which such torial department —Allen Hutt, Newspaper Design, dates are frequent. 2ded., 1971 MacCracken & Sandison brings up the question of in: adage 26 adapt "Though purists insist on 'He died 48 A.D.' [not in 48 . . . the Café des Artistes, which Lang will turn into A.D.], usage allows in " The objection to in is based what he calls a neighborhood restaurant. It will on insistence on the literal translation of the Latin anno adapt the concept of the English ordinary that Domini "in the year of the Lord." Bremner 1980 is still became popular in early New York taverns —Hor- defending the position of the 1917 purists, but no other ace Sutton, Saturday Rev., 15 Nov. 1975 commentators mention it. It is hard to feel certain whether the concept will be used Insistence on the literal "in the year of the Lord" is with or without modifications, though in this instance it also the basis for the objection to using A.D. after cen- doesn't seem to matter much. But such hermaphrodite tury; the use is illogical if you insist on the literal inter- constructions are rare. Usually the two verbs are easily pretation. Bremner 1980 does. But many people will distinguished both by meaning and typical construction. agree with Johnson 1982 when he terms the etymologi- Here are a few typical examples of adapt: cal objection to A.D. after century "rather a fussy point" and adds "there is little to be gained by binding A.D. . . . the principle by which the Law was adapted to forever to its original exact meaning." There is plenty of changing conditions —Edmund Wilson, A Piece of evidence that writers and publishers have found A.D. My Mind, 1956 convenient to use after century: . . . a method the writer can adapt to his material — . . . fourth century A.D. —Leonard Bloomfield, Lan- Ted Morgan, Saturday Rev., August 1979 guage, 1933 . . . to adapt what was already known about them to Arabians borrowed coffee from the Abyssinians television —Richard Poirier, Saturday Rev., 22 Apr. about the twelfth century A.D. —Science News Let- 1972 ter, 28 July 1945 . . . where huge mammals were skinned, boned, and . . . came over from Ireland in the second century adapted for use —Julia Howard, Science 80, March/ A.D. —Thomas F. O'Rahilly, Early Irish History and April 1980 Mythology, 1946 . . . a script that he himself adapted from the original . . . built in the first half of the third century, A.D. — by Euripides —Current Biography, May 1966 Current Biography, October 1967 Here are some typical examples of adopt: . . . the first century A.D. —John P. Dessauer, Book Publishing, 2d éd., 1981 . . . those who adopt this course must at least be clear about the likely dynamics of the process —Noam Bremner 1980, on the side of the literalists, suggests that Chomsky, Columbia Forum, Winter 1969 only B.C. be used with century; any century without . . . as was the custom, he was adopted into his future B.C. could then be assumed to be A.D., and there would wife's family —Current Biography, December 1965 be no need for the illogical designation. His solution would work were the use of A.D. not already established, Common policies were to be adopted for foreign but as matters stand it hardly seems a realistic goal. trade, agriculture, and transport —Current Biogra- Ebbitt & Ebbitt 1982 report that some sophisticated styl- phy, May 1966 ists and Latinists analyze both A.D. and B.C. as non- translated adverbials, applying to both years and cen- . . . has been adopted as prospective Liberal parlia- turies; their interpretation sidesteps all controversy. mentary candidate for the Garston division of the In summary, B.C. goes after the year and after cen- city — The Times (London), 15 Nov. 1973 tury; A.D. is more often placed before the year than . . . I was adopted almost at once by a townsman — after; it is widely used after century. Some commenta- Richard Joseph, Your Trip to Britain, 1954 tors attempt to rate these stylings on a basis of formality, but our evidence tends to undercut that argument. The The two verbs can even be used with complete clarity in question is most likely to be decided as a matter of indi- the same sentence: vidual or house style; in other words, consistency of . . . had been slow to adapt to a changing world or to application is more important than which styling is adopt modern education —Rosanne Klass, Satur- selected. day Rev., 5 Feb. 1972 adage See OLD ADAGE. Adept is both a noun and an adjective. Some exam- ples of the noun: adapt, adopt, adept Under the heading Adapt/Adopt Kilpatrick 1984 says, "No good reason suggests itself for She has . . . become an adept in ambiguities —John the two words ever to be confused " And even less Leonard, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 13 May 1973 reason for adept, which is not even a verb like the other Blake may be regarded as an adept of ancient mys- two, to be confused. Yet many handbooks, from the ele- tical doctrine —W. L. Renwick, English Literature mentary-school to the college level are at pains to distin- 1789-1815, 1963 guish them. Let us hope someone actually benefits from all this help. We have evidence of an error or two among Luigi was an adept at understatement —John our citations, but they may easily be typographical in Buchan, The House of the Four Winds, 1935 origin and not from any confusion in the writer: Evans 1957 thinks in preferable to at after the adjective. The next Kraft show, adopted from Hemingway's But at appears to be used more often, and other prepo- Fifty Grand—Current Biography, September 1967 sitions are used as well: It is possible to use one or the other of the verbs in a The Swede is adept at the gentle pastime of fishing context vague enough that only the author knows which in troubled waters —W. Somerset Maugham, The verb is intended: Moon and Sixpence, 1919 adapter 27 address . . . so adept at the lovely polishing of every grave She was addicted to gaudy shawls and the most God- and lucent phrase —Stella Gibbons, Cold Comfort awful hats —The Autobiography of William Allen Farm, 1932 White, 1946 . . . were far from adept at lobbying —Emily Hahn, . . . he was neither stupid, simple-minded, nor New Yorker, 24 Apr. 1971 addicted to strait-jackets and pigeonholes —Stanley There is no intrinsic reason why a lawyer should not Edgar Hyman, The Armed Vision, 1948 be adept in grammar and logic —Scott Buchanan, In appearance, Herbert Morrison is short, chunky, "So Reason Can Rule," 1967 addicted to colorful ties and boutonnières —Mollie . . . is so adept in extracting himself plausibly from Panter-Downes, New Yorker, 31 Mar. 1951 the most compromising situations —Victor Heiser, Catherine Morland, having become addicted to nov- An American Doctor's Odyssey, 1936 els of terror —Lionel Trilling, Encounter, September . . . the only surprise is that he is so adept with both 1954 instruments —Don Heckman, Stereo Rev., Septem- He must have been as addicted to clear thinking as ber 1971 Larkey Waldron —Oliver St. John Gogarty, // Isn 't . . . as you become more and more adept as a ham This Time of Year At All! 1954 —Arthur Henley, Boy's Life, May 1968 I've mentioned before how I feel about the use of . . . is a working ranch-dog and is equally adept on football as a metaphor for national policy. all kinds of stock — Dog World, June 1976 President Ford is evidently addicted to it — Thomas H. Middleton, Saturday Rev., 14 June 1975 adapter, adaptor Phythian 1979 wants us to distin- guish adaptor "an electrical device" from adapter "a . . . you can become addicted to losing fights with person who adapts." Even for British English he is only any society you're in —William Stafford, Writing partly right. Both adapter and adaptor are used in Brit- the Australian Crawl, 1978 ish English for devices (and not only electrical ones), He was hopelessly addicted to the Senators, a team and adapter is used for a person, while adaptor is not. of monumental incompetence on the baseball dia- In American English adapter is usual for both persons mond —Russell Baker, Growing Up, 1982 and devices; adaptor is relatively infrequent. There is a British tradition (Fowler 1926, Treble & Val- addicted Copperud 1970 tells us that Bernstein 1965 lins 1937, Longman 1984) of warning writers not to fol- and Evans 1957 advise reserving the participial adjec- low addicted by an infinitive, although the regular prep- tive addicted for what is harmful; Bernstein dislikes its osition is to. OED remarks that the infinitive was facetious use for what is not harmful. Partridge 1942 formerly used in this way but shows no example of it also finds addicted to pejorative and recommends not later than the 16th century. using it neutrally unless one is being facetious. But evi- dence in the OED shows neutral use to have existed from the 17th century at least: additionally Copperud 1964, 1970 does not like additionally used as a sentence adverb; clumsy, he He was much addicted to civil Affairs —Thomas thinks, for also. The sentence he gives as an example Stanley, The History of Philosophy, 1660 (OED) does seem somewhat awkward. The word, however, seems to be used primarily as an alternative to in addi- His majesty is much addicted to useful reading — tion or besides. Although our examples are not notably Munius,' Letters, 1771 (OED) awkward, the word has a fairly low frequency of occur- Neutral and mildly humorous use has continued rence—perhaps many writers do find that it has more undiminished: syllables than they usually want in an adverb. Dear Sir, that is an excellent example Additionally, we witnessed last April the senseless Of an old school of stately compliment murder of a night watchman at a university campus To which I have, through life, been much addicted in Santa Barbara —Ronald Reagan, Change, July- —W. S. Gilbert, The Sorcerer, 1877 August 1969 . . . those addicted to late dinner and those who still Additionally, it held that its doctrines were so per- revelled in the primitive simplicity of high-tea — fectly formulated that it was impossible to improve Osbert Sitwell, Triple Fugue, 1924 on them —Times Literary Supp., 29 Jan. 1971 They were addicted to travel, and spent only a Additionally, the student is being encouraged to sur- month or so of each year in England —Stella Gib- vey this material to learn about basic reference bons, Cold Comfort Farm, 1932 sources —Susan P. Miller, in Greenbaum 1985 . . . as a man, addicted to pleasure, to work, and to And additionally, working in this new, fictional fresh air —John Galsworthy, quoted in Correct approach, I followed Hemingway's grand method — English, January-February 1939 Gertrude Samuels, The Writer, May 1968 . . . he himself, addicted to books and too blind to participate in games —Edmund Wilson, The Wound address Flesch 1964 warns against using address as a and the Bow, 1941 pompous substitute for speech. Since an address by def- inition is "a formal prepared speech delivered to a spe- . . . rich sportsmen addicted to deer shooting — cial audience or on a special occasion," it is hard to see George Bernard Shaw, Everybody's Political What's what the point of the warning is. Address is frequently What, 1944 used in combinations that indicate the occasion—inau- adept 28 adequate gural address, commencement address. It is not used for . . . simple causes which did not seem to him ade- an impromptu speech. quate —Joseph Conrad, Chance, 1913 . . . the President attempted to reassure the nation on . . . could be relied on to be socially adequate, in spite this point in his television address —New Yorker, 12 of a dangerous distaste for fools —Rose Macaulay, May 1973 Told by an Idiot, 1923 In his first public address as an FCC member —Cur- It may be that there is nothing more demoralizing rent Biography, July 1967 than a small but adequate income —Edmund Wil- son, Memoirs of Hecate County, 1946 adept See ADAPT, ADOPT, ADEPT. Follett calls adequate enough "too familiar" and "nonsense" (Evans, Partridge, and Bremner 1980 also adequate Follett 1966 touches on most of the points find it redundant), but our files have no examples of it. about adequate that others (Copperud 1964, 1970, 1980, Along with adequate enough, Follett mentions more Evans 1957, Partridge 1942) comment upon. He deals adequate, less adequate, insufficiently adequate with d with idiom, first noting that adequate is normally fol- approval; he believes adequate "resistant to compari- lowed by to: son." Oddly enough, adequate escaped Partridge's lengthy list of adjectives that he thought should not be . . . occasions when school textbooks are not ade- compared. Like other adjectives usage commentators quate to the purpose —Albert H. Marckwardt, Lin- call "uncomparable" or "absolute," adequate is an guistics and the Teaching of English, 1966 adjective with which more patently means "more . . . his resources weren't adequate to the ambition nearly": —F. R. Leavis, Revaluation, 1947 If a more adequate return is to be achieved —Augus- This supply of literature was long found adequate to tus C. Long et al., Annual Report, Texaco Inc., 1970 the demand —T. B. Macaulay, The History of England, vol. I, 1849 . . . would regret the lack of a more adequate formal education —Current Biography, September 1966 The materials at present within my command hardly appeared adequate to so arduous an undertaking — The future of civilization depends on our having a Mary Shelley, Frankenstein, 1818 more adequate supply of both —Robert M. Hutch- ins, Center Mag., September 1968 However, he does not note that it is also followed by for: The convention asked for a more adequate Indian Biggest casting problem: an actress adequate for the policy —Ray Allen Billington, Westward Expan- double role —Time, 2 4 Apr. 1944 sion, 1949 But projective coordinates . . . though perfectly ade- . . . continued to champion the poem as the most quate for all projective properties —Bertrand Rus- adequate expression of the complex ambiguity of sell, Foundations of Geometry, 1897 experience —Current Biography, July 1964 And the nobility was not much more adequate for . . . not only is he the most ignorant and provincial the role attributed to it by Montesquieu —Times of all the Marxist critics . . . but probably the least Literary Supp., 21 Sept. 1951 adequate Marxist —Stanley Edgar Hyman, Antioch Rev., Winter 1947-1948 Follett says that idiom requires the gerund rather than the infinitive after to: The intensifier very is occasionally found: . . . mind . . . is not always adequate to mastering the . . . some very adequate salaries are given to a few — forms of rage, horror, and disgust —Norman Mailer, American Guide Series: New Jersey, 1939 Advertisements for Myself, 1959 . . . a very adequate summary of it was made by T. However, the construction with the infinitive is more E. Hulme in a lecture —Herbert Read, The Philoso- common in actual use: phy of Modern Art, 1952 . . . attain the perfect music of their style under the Copperud and Follett both observe that adequate is stress of a stimulus adequate to arouse it —Havelock used in a conventional way by reviewers to convey faint Ellis, The Dance of Life, 1923 praise or faint derogation. The sense (OED Supplement dates it from 1900) is generally recorded in dictionaries. . . . tolls and concession rentals... will be more than adequate to cover the principal and interest on all . . . not particularly inspired. An adequate perfor- the bonds — Wall Street Jour., 5 Nov. 1954 mance —Henry Barnard Stafford, Saturday Rev., 30 Mar. 1940 Psychological explanations alone are not adequate to understand today's student radicals —Kenneth Ken- . . . is at best adequate as the slight, brooding pro- niston, Change, November-December 1969 ducer and moonstruck lover —Judith Crist, Satur- day Rev., 11 Dec. 1976 Follett does acknowledge use without any comple- ment, and in the Merriam-Webster files, adequate The sense is not limited to use by reviewers: appears most frequently without a complement: " . . . After all, in any other walk in life it doesn't mat- A rat has to have a protected home and an adequate ter if you're not very good; you can get along quite food supply —Victor Heiser, An American Doctor's comfortably if you're just adequate...." —W. Odyssey, 1936 Somerset Maugham, The Moon and Sixpence, 1919 adhere 29 adjacent adhere Copperud 1964 finds his risibilities tickled by Lewis Allen in Only Yesterday (1931), but Harding's use such expressions as "adhere to a plan," but in his 1970 seems to have been technically impeccable: book he admits he is alone—nearly everyone else finds such use perfectly standard and normal. Little wonder: . . . the terms of this Convention which is open to the OED traces this sort of use back to the 17th century adhesion by all countries of the world —UNESCO and even quotes "adhere to a plan" from an 1897 book. Copyright Bulletin, No. 3, 1951 The regular preposition is to: Adhesion of some, if not all, of the Little Entente I adhere to my resolution of not going there at all — Governments to the Rome protocols of 1934 and Thomas Love Peacock, letter, 29 Nov. 1818 1936 —Arnaldo Cortesi, NY. Times, 10 Nov. 1936 . . . how firmly they adhere to their own delusions — . . . the Communist International won at first the Times Literary Supp., 9 Apr. 1970 adhesion of several powerful and well-established labor organizations —H. B. Parkes, Marxism—an . . . causes all the fruit to rot, so that in digging up the Autopsy, 1939 plant nothing is found but foul matter adhering to the leaves —Sir James G. Frazer, Aftermath, 1937 . . . his ardent attachment to Washington, and his adhesion generally to the federal party —Horace E. Follett 1966 is dubious about the transitive use of Scudder, Noah Webster, 1882 adhere, even though it was to be found in the dictionary. It is in reputable use, and the use is most often both lit- Follett ascribes the political use of adhesion to trans- eral and technical: lations from the French, and French may indeed have had some influence on the diplomatic usage, at least, The crystal was adhered to a prism of known index though we have no clear evidence of that. He also says —Technical Highlights 1967, November 1967 it "has begun to make its way into English and Ameri- can writings on politics," but the OED shows it began The hairs to which the fly is adhered begin to bend, to do so in the 17th century. General figurative use and pass their prey to hairs nearer to the center of seems somewhat less frequent than the political: the leaf—The Sciences, September 1964 . . . a too strict adhesion to those so-called iaws' — Occasionally figurative use of the transitive verb may be Eric Partridge, "Imagination and Good Sense in Ety- found: mology," 1952 The economic principles to which Mr. Simon and . . . marital breakups . . . are usually regarded by Mr. Greenspan adhere, and to which they adhered counselors as a failure of adhesion —Vance Packard, the unwitting Mr. Ford —John Kenneth Galbraith, The Sexual Wilderness, 1968 Esquire, May 1977 Our files, then, show that this is not a simple matter of adherence, adhesion A number of theorists com- "one word, one sense." Adherence is more often figura- ment on the distinction between adherence and adhe- tive than literal; adhesion is somewhat more often used sion from Vizetelly 1906 through Follett 1966 and on to literally and technically, and its chief figurative use is in Chambers 1985. The thrust of all three is the same: the general area of politics and diplomacy. adherence is generally used figuratively, adhesion liter- ally. This analysis is not far wrong, but it needs some adjacent Adjacent is often followed by to: elaboration in detail. Adherence is mostly used . . . the border region below the Bolovens Plateau figuratively: and adjacent to the Highlands —Robert Shaplen, . . . a religious adherence to what appears to me truth New Yorker, 24 Apr. 1971 and reason —Edmund Burke, (Speech on) Concili- All I knew was the state—one adjacent to the state ation with the Colonies, 1775 Beardsley was in —Vladimir Nabokov, Lolita, 1958 . . . mask their intentions of continuing the struggle " . . . something adjacent to your talents and inter- for world mastery by a superficial adherence to the ests—commercial art, perhaps." —Lore Segal, New ideals of human brotherhood —Oscar Handhn, The Yorker, 25 July 1964 American People in the Twentieth Century, 1954 Copperud 1970 reports some concern over the meaning Donald's adherence to the firm of Middleton was of adjacent, emphasizing that it means "near but not now the topic —Angus Wilson, Anglo-Saxon Atti- necessarily touching." This information is readily avail- tudes, 1956 able in dictionaries. Clearly adjacent—excluding its But it is also used literally: mathematical uses—sometimes means touching and sometimes not: . . . results in imperfect adherence of rubber to the fabric —Industrial Improvement, January 1946 . . . the academic speaker's strings of adjacent nouns —Stringfellow Barr, Center Mag., May 1968 The tremendous adherence achieved through sticky- back, a double sided adhesive fabric —Bookbinding . . . it is not likely that pure accident caused three and Book Production, January 1952 adjacent windows to take a Spanish tone —Henry Adams, Mont-Saint-Michel and Chartres, 1904 Adhesion is a bit more complex. Its various technical . . . a line of separation between adjacent warm and and literal senses account for half, or perhaps a bit more cold masses of air —Dictionary of American Biog- than half, of the citations in our files. But figurative use raphy, 1929 is not at all uncommon. It falls into two varieties— political-diplomatic and general. President Harding's Adjacent events need not be contiguous —James use of "adhesion to a treaty" was criticized by Frederick Jeans, The New Background of Science, 1934 adjectives 30 administer On Cape Cod, on the adjacent islands of Nantucket big-city dailies. Evans 1957 has a long article discussing and Martha's Vineyard —American Guide Series: these. The noncount use, which some grammarians Massachusetts, 1937 refer to as "the absolute use of the adjective," seems to have excited little discussion in usage books. The count He despised the six field officers at the adjacent table nouns, however, have drawn the attention of Harper —Norman Mailer, The Naked and the Dead, 1948 1985, which devotes a usage panel question to the pro- . . . through the piazza of St. Peter's and the adjacent priety of a handful of advertising uses such as a tooth- streets —Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Marble Faun, paste that leaves a "clean in your mouth" and a washing 1860 machine with a special device for washing "your déli- cates." There is no principle involved in this sort of dis- Other commentators (such as Flesch 1964 and Gowers cussion; the strained syntax of advertising is used solely in Fowler 1965) make various comments on adjacent, to catch attention and evoke a predictable response. but there seems to be no serious problem in the use of Whether délicates will join unmentionables in the dic- this word. tionary only time will tell. adjectives 1 . Under the heading adjective most com- adjectives as nouns See ADJECTIVES 4. mentators on usage place a miscellaneous collection of faults they are intent on exposing and eradicating. Some adjure See ABJURE, ADJURE. include general observations on matters of grammar and rhetoric, as well. In this book, most of the usage adjust, adjusted 1 . Copperud 1970 notes that prices issues that adjectives are involved in are treated under are "adjusted"—upwards, as a rule—in his discussion separate headings. See, for instance, ABSOLUTE ADJEC- of euphemisms. See EUPHEMISMS. TIVES; ABSOLUTE COMPARATIVE; DOUBLE COMPARISON; FLAT 2. Bernstein 1965 says adjusted takes to. This is true, as ADVERBS; IMPLICIT COMPARATIVE; PARTICIPLE 2 ; SENTENCE far as it goes, but the participial adjective is more often ADJECTIVE; SUPERLATIVE OF TWO. used without a complement than with one. When there 2. For those to whom some of the descriptive terminol- is a complement, to is the most common preposition: ogy of adjectives may be unfamiliar, we will mention . . . a program . . . as dramatic and as sound and as here that there are two kinds of adjectives, from the adjusted to today and tomorrow as the programs of standpoint of their position in the sentence. Their con- 1933 —Leon H. Keyserling, New Republic, 8 Feb. ventional names are used from time to time in articles 1954 in this book. Adjectives that stand in front of the nouns they modify are attributive adjectives: . . . factory in which the workers are perfectly adjusted to the machines —Aldous Huxley, Brave The full and careful report was published. New World Revisited, 1958 When the adjectives follow a form of be or a linking This characteristic of the participial adjective merely verb (or copula), they are predicate adjectives: reflects the behavior of the verb: The report that was published was/w// and careful. . . . account of one man's addled efforts to adjust to Appositive adjectives may follow their noun, or they his own obsolescence —Jane Clapperton, Cosmo- may precede it and its other modifiers (such as an article politan, March 1976 or possessive), often as part of a longer phrase: . . . a delightful girl who could adjust to any confu- The report, full and careful, was published. sion —James A. Michener, Report of the County Chairman, 1961 Full and careful in its attention to detail, the report was published in a national magazine. . . . was trying to adjust to being the head of my fam- ily —Mrs. Medgar Evers, Ladies' Home Jour., Sep- 3. Idiomatic placement of adjectives. Harper 1975, 1985 tember 1971 points out that some precisians—"nit-pickers" is Har- per's word—object to the illogical placement of adjec- . . . had no difficulty in adjusting to more than a mil- tives in such expressions as "a hot cup of coffee,""a lion dollars —Hamilton Basso, The View from Pom- brand-new pair of shoes." The argument is that it's the pey'sHead, 1954 coffee that's hot, the shoes that are brand-new. Similarly objectionable is your leisurely cup of coffee after dinner. Adjust is also used with for. Harper points out that the placement of these adjectives . . . is altered when we adjust for the predisposition is idiomatically correct, so the nitpickers may be —Stanley L. Payne, The Art of Asking Questions, ignored. Partridge 1942 cites an authority who points 1951 out the absurdity of "stylish gentlemen's suits." In his zeal for logic, the critic has lost sight of both sense and Adjust for tends to occur in financial contexts. Thus it idiom. Gentlemen's suits is for all practical purposes a would not be out of the ordinary to read of figures unit. To try to separate it with a modifier—"gentlemen's "adjusted for inflation." stylish suits"—is to violate normal English word order and so create an utterly unnecessary bump in the road administer 1 . As late as 1942 Eric Partridge was down which your thought and your readers' attention expressing disapproval of administer when used of a are supposed to be traveling together. blow; he cites with approval Weseen 1928 on the ques- 4. Adjectives as nouns. Adjectives are used as nouns tion. Several earlier handbooks also censured the use, essentially in two ways: as noncount nouns to indicate beginning perhaps with Utter 1916 who termed it a quality or a number of a group having a quality—the "humorous" (as did the OED), but Vizetelly 1920 was beautiful, the sublime, the just, the unemployed—and as not amused and neither were several subsequent com- count nouns—moderns, an all-time high, the ancients, mentators. Bernstein 1971, calling the objectors administrate 31 admission "driven-snow purists," cites Webster's Second in as administer, although our citations of its use have defense of the use and asks, "What more is needed to increased somewhat in recent years. It appears to be administer a fatal blow to those purists?" Not much, developing an intransitive as well as a transitive use. apparently; no writer since Partridge seems to have William Safire (N Y. Times Mag., 6 Oct. 1985) quotes a objected. The use may have developed from the admin- linguist, William Kretzschmer, Jr., as finding that istering of medicine, which is not always pleasant. If the administrate is becoming differentiated from adminis- earliest uses were humorous, current use is neutral, ter. Our evidence is too sparse at the present to confirm straightforward, and standard: any differentiation. The spider descends, embraces its victim while admission, admittance "Admittance is usu[ally] administering a paralyzing bite, then slowly wraps it applied to mere physical entrance to a locality or a securely in silk —William G. Eberhard, Natural His- building: admission applies to entrance or formal accep- tory, January 1980 tance (as into a club) that carries with it rights, privi- . . . administered an overwhelming defeat to her leges, standing, or membership." This discrimination Republican opponent —Current Biography, Sep- appears in Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary, tember 1967 and others like it can be found in usage books from Vizetelly 1906 to Harper 1985. Ambrose Bierce 1909 2. The Oxford American Dictionary tells us that "nurses stands alone: he refuses to sanction admission for do not administer to the wounded," echoing a senti- admittance in "The price of admission is one dollar." ment expressed in Follett 1966 and F. K. Ball's Con- The distinction is one you can certainly make in your structive English, 1923. Longman 1984 also notes that writing if you want to. Copperud 1970 reports some some disapprove of this intransitive use of administer. commentators as feeling that the distinction is disap- The OED traces the sense to The Spectator in 1712. No pearing and others as feeling that the two words are sim- definite reason seems to be adduced by objectors as a ply synonyms. Certainly there have been writers of basis of their objection, although there is an underlying repute who have not observed the distinction. feeling that administer should forever be a transitive Physical entrance: verb and that, in this use, it is usurping the place of min- ister. Perhaps it is also the relative infrequency of this . . . somebody must gain admittance to his cell — use that makes them feel it to be improper. It is entirely George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, standard: 1859 Dr. Binder had often traveled with his wife into the Tom lifted him in his arms, and got admission to the Peruvian jungles to administer to the Indians —Cur- Inn —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Fev- rent Biography, September 1964 erel, 1859 . . . the church was erected over a period of years, Permission to enter an academic institution: 1906-36, to administer to the largest French parish . . . the parental demand that their offspring obtain in Lewiston —American Guide Series: Maine, 1937 admittance to a four-year college —James B. Co- . . . to prevent him from administering to the last nant, Slums and Suburbs, 1961 wants of Pulaski —Dictionary of American Biogra- . . . the attempt of James Meredith, a Negro, to phy, 1928 obtain admission to the University of Mississippi — 3 . See ADMINISTRATE. Current Biography, July 1965 Permission to join the union as a state: administrate Usage writers will sometimes pass along misinformation because they have not used . . . a constitutional provision . . . it had to eliminate important resources such as the historical dictionaries. from its constitution as a condition of admittance in Copperud 1970, 1980 tells us administrate is an Amer- 1912 —Thomas P. Neill, The Common Good(\2\h- icanism. It is not; it was first used in British English in gradetext), 1956 the 17th century. Nickles 1974 calls it a back-formation; . . . until the size of the population warranted the ter- it is not, having been coined out of pure Latin. Nickles ritory's admission as a state —John H. Haefner et further informs us it is overused. That is a matter of al., Our Living Government (12th-grade text), 1960 judgment, of course, but as a matter of fact it is a much less frequently used word than its synonym administer. Permission to join the United Nations: Jerry Adler, writing in Newsweek (8 Dec. 1980), quotes William Safire to the effect that administrators no longer . . . the demand from overseas for the immediate administer, but administrate. Our files contain abun- admittance of Communist China to the United dant evidence that they administer. Sometimes they do Nations —Richard H. Rovere, New Yorker, 8 Aug. both: 1953 I'm a good administrator when I have something to . . . celebrating Japan's admission to the United administer. I mean, I really think I administered the Nations —Current Biography, December 1965 Civil Aeronautics Board very effectively, and the Entrance to society: Public Service Commission. But I don't have any- thing to administrate here —Alfred E. Kahn, quoted . . . a very accessible and, at the same time, highly in NY. Times, 9 Nov. 1980 enviable society. Whatever the quality that gained you admittance —Virginia Woolf, The Death of the Administrate is an unstigmatized entry in OED, Web- Moth, 1942 ster's Second, and Webster's Third. It might not have been noticed at all had not H. W. Fowler put it in his . . . all the nice men she knew of moved in circles list of long variants in 1926. It is not used nearly as often into which an obscure governess had no chance of admit 32 admit admission —George Bernard Shaw, Cashel Byron's Although many authors have used admission and Profession, 1886 admittance synonymously, there is no harm in your making the distinction outlined in the Collegiate if you Or to some other institution: want to. Except for the sign "No Admittance" and the . . . admittance to the academy is a coveted honor — use of admittance as a technical term in electricity, Current Biography, March 1964 admission is the more frequent word in all uses in cur- rent English. . . . insisting now on stricter standards of admission to the church —Edmund S. Morgan, N.Y. Times admit 1 . Admit to. Copperud 1970 records himself Book Rev., 13 July 1980 1964, Follett 1966, Fowler 1965, and Heritage 1969 as For a fee paid to gain entrance, admission is much more objecting to the use of admit to in a sense approximating common, but admittance is not unknown: confess. Bremner 1980, Colter 1981, and Bryson 1984 concur in finding fault with it; Chambers 1985 does not . . . open to anyone with 500 yuan to spare, which at object. Bernstein 1965 merely notes its use with to (per- 3,000 yuan to the dollar, is not a ruinous admittance haps thinking of other meanings of admit that are used —James Cameron, N.Y. Times Mag., 9 Jan. 1955 with to), but in 1977 he notes objections to admit to by "the idiom watchdogs." . . . there is no admission fee —Village Voice, 28 This objection seems to have its origin in some edi- Feb. 1968 tion of Fowler published after World War II; it is not in . . . the price of admission is starkly prohibitive — Fowler 1926 nor in the corrected editions of the 1930s Norman Cousins, Saturday Rev., 21 Feb. 1976 and early 1940s; it is in Gowers's 1965 revision but is cited by Copperud as early as 1960. The basis for the These last two examples show contexts in which admit- objection is the assertion that confess can be followed tance is no longer used—in the attributive position, and idiomatically by to, but admit cannot. But the assertion in the phrase "price of " is wrong. When admit is used as an intransitive verb There is a distinction between the two words when meaning "to make acknowledgment," it is regularly fol- preceded by no. The sign "No Admittance" refers to lowed by to: physical entrance, but no admission is likely to mean no admission fee: The acquaintance of a lady very much misjudged and ill used by the world, Richard admitted to — ALL FREE—NO ADMISSION —advt., Ochiltree George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, County (Tex.) Herald, 15 Jan. 1967 1859 Documentary film . . . shown several times daily. No While he does not admit to being a member of the admission —Where Mag., 15 Mar. 1975 Gestapo neither does he deny it —N. Y. Herald Tri- bune Book Rev., 21 May 1939 The persons who deal with the entrance of students to educational institutions regularly use admission, often But no one could be found who would admit to in the plural: seeing an attack on Duboko —MacKinlay Kantor, in Best American Short Stories, ed. Martha Foley, . . . college admissions officers —Robert L. Foose, 1942 NEA Jour., January 1965 "I admit to a touch of grey above the ears, such as . . . an open admissions policy —Theodore L. Gross, you might expect in a man of my years . . . " —Eric Saturday Rev., 4 Feb. 1978 Linklater, Private Angelo, 1946 Admission is the usual word for the granting of some- Stokowski, who admits to 66 —Time, 5 Oct. 1953 thing not proven or an acknowledgment that something is true: . . . he might incriminate himself if he should admit to membership —Curtis Bok, Saturday Rev., 13 Feb. To ask for a pardon was, he said, an admission of 1954 guilt —Robert Penn Warren, Jefferson Davis Gets His Citizenship Back, 1980 The lady had some records, but she was wary about admitting to having any specific ones —Rexford G. Fifty-four percent of the Harper 1985 usage panel, how- Tugwell, Center Mag., September 1968 ever, confesses to not distinguishing in speech between "admittance to the theater" and "admission of guilt." . . . most of us cannot admit to intellectual fashions Perhaps they did not think out the implications of their or political passions we have discarded —Naomi statement. Admittance in the sense it would have in Bliven, New Yorker, 17 July 1971 "admittance of guilt" is labeled obsolete in the OED, . . . the one-sided relationship that Proust . . . seeks which shows no citations since the 17th century. It to secure from the world around him, but seldom appears, rather, to be very rare; Merriam-Webster edi- admits to —Angus Wilson, N. Y. Times Book Rev., tors have unearthed a couple of 20th-century instances. 11 Apr. 1976 One was an oral use by Johnny Pesky, a former Boston Red Sox shortstop: . . . we are less consciously familiar with its rules. We have admitted to them less, but they are there not- . . . by his own admittance yesterday, said that he withstanding —Margaret Drabble, Saturday Rev., 27 always hated to . . . — 2 May 1971 May 1978 The other was in print by a distinguished historian: . . . though Canada admits to no Middle West, the This is splendid until one is brought up sharply by nerve he touches runs all the way down Middle this naïve admittance —J. H. Plumb, Saturday Rev., North America —Ronald Bryden, N. Y. Times Book 29 July 1967 Rev., 3 June 1984 admittance 33 adopted This idiom appears to be well-established indeed. The . . . evidence for the way in which Renaissance artists uses referring to gray hair and age cannot be replaced by really thought is insufficient to admit of dogmatism admit alone without rephrasing—surely a sign of an —John Pope-Hennessy, NY. Times Book Rev., 8 established idiom. To say with Colter 1981 that admit May 1977 is never followed by to or with Follett 1966 that it is archaic in tone is to exhibit a certain unfamiliarity with Jane Austen was even able to use a clause as subject: the language writers use. That Edmund must be for ever divided from Miss 2. Other uses of admit with to (and into). There is one Crawford did not admit of a doubt with Fanny — other intransitive use of admit that takes to: Mansfield Park, 1 8 1 4 ... tickets which admit to the famous Chelsea Use with a personal subject in modern prose is rare: Flower Show —Popular Gardening, 11 Apr. 1976 . . . we admit of creatures who are transitions from . . . reached the door admitting to the kitchen —John one kingdom to another —Rene Wellek & Austin Morrison, The Creeping City, 1949 Warren, Theory of Literature, 1949 It appears to be chiefly British. The sense "allow, permit" is also used as a transitive As a transitive verb admit takes to in several common without of: uses: To Garfield . . . and to all of the men of his genera- The maid admitted him to the living room —Irving tion educated under the old academic system, it Stone, McCall's, March 1971 admitted no debate —The Nation, 18 July 1923 . . . one of the first non-Communist journalists . . . this procedural logic does not admit more than admitted to China —Harper's, February 1969 minute changes —Paul Henry Lang, Saturday Rev., 26 June 1954 . . . they have admitted to their pages execrable examples of English prose —J. Donald Adams, N. Y. . . . a situation as wretched as Rhodesia's may admit Times Book Rev., 1 Mar. 1954 no right solutions —Carll Tucker, Saturday Rev., 3 Mar. 1979 In 1962 Trinidad and Tobago was admitted to the United Nations —Current Biography, February See also ALLOW 2; PERMIT OF. 1966 admittance See ADMISSION, ADMITTANCE. . . . was subsequently admitted to practice both before the New York bar and the U.S. Supreme ad nauseam This phrase from the Latin has been at Court —Psychology Today, February 1969 work in English since the 17th century, when writers regularly learned to read and write Latin. Writers today Admit is also used with into: are less familiar with Latin, and more likely to spell the phrase wrong when they trot it out to show off with. "If . . . the process of admitting a new state into the you are determined to use this poor old thing," says Kil- Union —Stanley E. Dimond & Elmer F. Pflieger, patrick 1984, "at least spell it right." Somebody goofed Our American Government, 1961 in these examples: . . . she regretted admitting sorrow into their lives — Again Dobler has researched his subject ad nauseum Jean Stafford, Children Are Bored on Sunday, 1953 and again he has created a veritable horde of ste- . . . he is prepared to admit into history the irrational reotyped characters —N.Y. Times Book Rev., 12 and the unconscious —Peter Stansky, N.Y. Times Sept. 1976 Book Rev., 25 July 1976 As Brendan becomes the Horatio Alger of porn, we None of these uses is the subject of criticism. trace, ad nauseum, his rise to wealth and power — 3. Admit of. Fowler 1926 points out that the combina- Publishers Weekly, 5 Sept. 1977 tion admit of is more limited in application than it once Even if these particular examples are typos, as they may was and that it usually takes a nonhuman subject. well be, it behooves the writer to be careful. Numerous later commentators echo the same senti- ment; for instance, Chambers 1985: "The subject of the adopt See ADAPT, ADOPT, ADEPT. verb . . . must always be impersonal or abstract." The commentators are, in the main, correct. adopted, adoptive Usage writers since Fowler 1926 and Krapp 1927 have been telling us that the rule is . . . his eyes . . . would not admit of their being adopted children, adoptive parents. And it usually is so strained upon any definite object without... risk — in practice. Formerly adopted had a fair amount of use Thomas Hardy, The Return of the Native, 1878 applied to parents, as Fowler, Krapp, and Evans 1957 observe: . . . the banqueting-hall, always vast enough to admit of many more guests —Lafcadio Hearn, Glimpses of . . . the estate of the last of Janice's adopted parents Unfamiliar Japan, 1894 —Erie Stanley Gardner, The Case of the Stuttering Bishop, 1936 . . . many crucial dilemmas simply do not admit of analysis on one page —Dorothy Fosdick, N.Y. . . . worked upon her adopted father with his threats Times Mag, 23 Jan. 1955 of the wrath to come —Max Peacock, King's Rogue, 1947 The problems of ecology... admit of a rational solu- tion —Aldous Huxley, Center Mag., September We have no recent evidence of this use in print, 1969 although it may still persist in spoken English. adult 34 advance Adoptive, too, crosses the usage boundary and is ment writing. Copperud 1970 finds in addition a couple sometimes applied to children (Johnson's 1755 Dictio- of American commentators who discourage its use; the nary has a citation from Francis Bacon for "adoptive consensus, says Copperud, is that adumbrate is "formal, son"): literary, and unsuitable for ordinary contexts." The problem, of course, is knowing just what contexts are The Stein menage also included Mme. Gabrielle ordinary. To be sure, the word is not found in children's Osorio and her adoptive daughter —Edward T. stories or on the sports pages. It is, however, occasion- Cone, American Scholar, Summer 1973 ally found in political writing—mostly British: But most writers follow the pattern suggested in the . . . if the policy of milk direction adumbrated by the usage books: Ministry is not balanced with reason —The Econo- First, let's consider the risks to adoptive parents — mist, 20 Dec. 1947 Claude Forell, The Age (Melbourne), 17 Apr. 1975 Such attitudes are only faintly adumbrated in the Conservative manifesto —Henry Fairlie, Observer Claire Kellerman, 18, adopted daughter of Sally Rev., 20 Mar. 1966 Kellerman —Peter Carlson, People, 9 Aug. 1982 . . . the famous "Mr. X" article that adumbrated the The usage writers are silent about other relationships Cold War policy of "firm containment " — adopted and adoptive are used for. Adoptive is used not Patrick J. Buchanan, TV Guide, 19 Apr. 1980 only for parents but for homes, families, and other relatives: But mostly it is a word found in criticism and in other writings of learned people: . . . the agency refused to return Lenore because she was already in an adoptive home —Eileen Hughes, . . . he was much better at adumbrating his doctrine Ladies' Home Jour., September 1971 through rhetorical devices —William Empson, Sewanee Rev., Spring 1948 . . . expect adoptive families to be easily found — Catherine Calvert, Town & Country, December 1982 . . . to overcome student self-protectiveness is a ter- ribly ambitious enterprise, which can only be adum- He falls in love with his adoptive sister —Time, 31 brated even in the best institutions —David Ries- Mar. 1947 man, American Scholar, Summer 1969 Both words are used for a new country, city, or state and . . . ideas first adumbrated in the work of these and for people who have them: other modern masters —Hilton Kramer, N. Y. Times Mag., 4 Nov. 1919 And naturally they discussed their adopted home. America came in for both good and bad marks — advance 1 . Advance, advanced. As adjectives these Paule Marshall, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 9 Jan. 1983 words are rarely, if ever, used of the same things, and why usage writers, who treat them frequently, believe . . . foreign-born Americans who were loyal, dedi- they are a problem is not clear. Any good dictionary will cated defenders of their adopted country —William show you the differences. Here are a few typical S. Garmon, Averett Jour., Autumn 1970 examples: . . . who was knighted in his adoptive England in . . . with a little advance warning plus tip, the prin- 1980— Diane MeWhorter, N. K Times Book Rev., 1 cipal steward was always ready to prepare his own May 1983 special recipe of crêpes Suzette —Caleb Pirtle HI, . . . a heterogeneous cross section of New Yorkers, Southern Living, November 1971 born and adopted —Carey Winfrey, N. Y. Times, 1 . . . you could show up on registration day without Jan. 1980 advance notice —Tom Wicker, Change, September . . . written by an adoptive Californian —Darrell 1971 Berrigan, Saturday Evening Post, 3 July 1954 . . . advisors had already reviewed advance copies of Northeast's plan —Homer Page, Not Man Apart, adult 1 . Both the end-stressed pronunciation, \ s - July 1971 'dsltX, and the fore-stressed version, Vad-,9lt\, are per- fectly acceptable, whether the word is used as an adjec- . . . modernizing their building regulations to allow tive or as a noun. Xs-'daltX seems somewhat more prev- the advanced systems of construction —Harold alent in the U.S., and especially so as an adjective; Vad- Howe II, Saturday Rev., 20 Nov. 1971 ,9lt\ is the form currently recommended in England. . . . the education of those less gifted or less advanced 2. Copperud 1980 describes adult as "the current euphe- —Jerome S. Bruner, Saturday Rev., 15 Jan. 1972 mism for pornographic." Howard 1977 writes "what seedy cinemas and pornographic publishers describe as . . . employees with bachelor's as well as advanced 'adult' is in fact childishly prurient." The sense has been degrees —Lucia Mouat, Christian Science Monitor, recognized in dictionaries. 19 Aug. 1980 Advanced age ended Dr. Schweitzer's practice as a adumbrate Adumbrate is a hard word, a learned surgeon —Current Biography, July 1965 word, frequently found in works of literary and art crit- icism. Around the time of World War II it came in for 2. The phrases advance warning, advance planning, and some disparagement by the British commentators Sir advance preparations are sometimes censured as redun- Ernest Gowers and Eric Partridge (Gowers 1948, Par- dant (see REDUNDANCY). We have little evidence of their tridge 1942) when it began to surface in British govern- use in print. In the first example in section 1 above, advancement 35 adverbial genitive advance warning is roughly synonymous with advance The usual preposition in modern use is over: notice, which has not been called redundant. Janis 1984 defends advance planning, judging that it is not redun- The exacting life of the sea has this advantage over dant when advance means "early." the life of the earth, that its claims are simple and 3. Advance, advancement. These nouns overlap occa- cannot be evaded —Joseph Conrad, Chance, 1913 sionally in meaning, but we have little evidence that . . . it is generally conceded that Soviet chess players they cause difficulty for writers. A few commentators hold an advantage over competitors of other nation- insist that advance means "progress," advancement alities —Current Biography, July 1967 "promotion," but the words have more senses than that, as a check of your dictionary will show. Here are a few Of still prevails in take advantage of: examples: ... bullying or taking an unfair advantage of the . . . a great advance in the ability of moviemakers to other person —Margaret Mead, And Keep Your Pow- render physical reality more accurately —Richard der Dry, 1942 Schickel, Harper's, March 1971 In modern use o/most often denotes a simple genitive . . . the fruits of research and scientific advances — relationship: Carnegie Quarterly, Summer 1970 . . . personal favoritism or the advantage of a family . . . the peculiar role assigned his hero in the advance name —Charles Frankel, Columbia Forum, Sum- of civilization —Richard Poirier, A World Else- mer 1970 where, 1966 The author of the second poem has the advantage of . . . had come to feel it almost an emancipation from dealing with a more unusual death —Florence Tre- the conventional feminine freedoms, certainly an fethen, The Writer, May 1968 advance over the starved lives that so many of her friends gained from their independent, mutual shar- The advantages to an economy of this sort of liter- ing marriages —Angus Wilson, The Middle Age of acy are apparent —Robert Pattison, On Literacy, Mrs. Eliot, 1958 1982 . . . an authentic advance upon traditional Marxism Here are a few other idiomatic phrases with advantage: —Theodore Roszak, The Making of a Counter Cul- ture, 1969 . . . restaurateurs are more and more finding it in their advantage to tinker with menus —Dave Rank, . . . failed to obtain an advance of salary from the Cooking for Profit, July 1982 lycée —Times Literary Supp., 16 Apr. 1970 The program of the Corporation included the She wears clothes from them all—and wears them to advancement of education through support of spe- advantage —Gail Cameron, Ladies' Home Jour., cific undertakings —Collier's Year Book, 1949 August 1971 . . . for university students at every stage of their A miner will learn . . . to use his body to best advan- advancement —E. Adelaide Hahn, Language, April- tage —Laurence Learner, Harper's, December 1971 June 1954 What we should do is make it to everyone's advan- Middle-aged executives, bureaucrats, and salaried tage to reach environmental goals —Peter F. professionals favor mandatory retirement for rea- Drucker, Harper's, January 1972 sons related to their own advancement —Paul Woodring, Saturday Rev., 1 Aug. 1976 adverbial disjunct See SENTENCE ADVERB. 4. Advance feedback is noted as business jargon by Janis 1984. We have no evidence of it (so far) in our files. adverbial genitive Bryant 1962 and Evans 1957 tell us that in Old English the genitive of some nouns could advancement See ADVANCE 3. be used adverbially. For instance, the genitive of the Old English word for day could be used to mean "by day." advantage In the sense of "superiority of position or Evans notes that many of our adverbs that end in an condition," advantage was formerly followed by of: \ s \ or \ z \ sound—nowadays, always—are survivals of this form. But, says he, "Today there is no feeling that Lest Satan should get an advantage of us — 2 Co- this is a genitive relationship and an apostrophe is never rinthians 2:11 (AV), 1611 used in words of this kind." We undoubtedly have the advantage of England, in One survival of the old adverbial genitive is in certain promoting a comparative purity in language among adverbs of time: "He never works evenings or Sundays" the entire mass of our population —William S. Car- (test sentence from Leonard 1929). The propriety of this dell, circular issued in the name of The American construction seems to have been questioned at some Academy of Language and Belles Lettres, 1821 (in time in the past, although we have not encountered the Baron 1982) questioning in our reading of the commentators. Utter 1916 calls these adverbs "sometimes condemned." He The phrase "have the advantage o f with personal sub- defends them as an "old idiomatic usage," as do most ject and object at one time was used in polite conver- other commentators. Leonard's 1929 survey found the sation to admit not remembering having been intro- construction acceptable to about 75 percent of his duced before: respondents. Here are a few typical examples: "You have the advantage of me; I don't remember During his college days at Harvard he taught days ever to have had the honour." —Richard Brinsley and studied nights —Dictionary of American Biog- Sheridan, The Rivals, Ml5 raphy, 1929 adverbial nouns 36 adverbs . . . he sold cars, mowed lawns, sang nights and week- It is only fair to warn you that different grammarians ends whenever he could get bookings —Current may put different limitations on the class of adverbials. Biography, July 1967 If you are interested in learning more about the adver- bial, you will find considerable detail in Sledd 1959 or . . . waking up mornings in my own vomit —Conrad Quirk et al. 1985 (nearly 175 pages in the latter). Adver- Rooks, quoted in Evergreen, December 1967 bials are not mentioned very often in this book, but the I got to thinking that I went to work nights and Sat- term is frequently used in discussing matters of usage by urdays in a paper mill when I was a boy —Bergen the authors of composition handbooks. Evans, address at Marshall University, June 1968 Many commentators (Evans 1957, Fowler 1926, Mittins adverbs 1 . An adverb is a member of one of the tra- et al. 1970, Quirk et al. 1985, for example) observe that ditional part-of-speech classes. The class of adverbs is this adverbial genitive of time is better established in highly useful to grammarians and lexicographers, for American English than in British English. It is not, how- into it they toss many terms otherwise resistant to clas- ever, dead in British English, as Evans thought in 1957. sification. Adverbs modify verbs, adjectives, other The new OED Supplement under nights lists Australian adverbs, verbals, phrases, clauses, and sentences. They and Canadian examples. It may be rather more com- probably even modify nouns on occasion—at least they mon in spoken than in written British English: commonly modify adjectives used as nouns ("the very wealthy"). . . . but I don't stay up nights worrying —John Len- Some interesting aspects of the usage of adverbs can non, quoted in Current Biography, December 1965 be found under these headings: FLAT ADVERBS; SENTENCE ADVERB. Bryant finds the use firmly established in informed stan- 2. Copperud 1970, 1980 talks about an erroneous idea dard speech and writing in the U.S. Jespersen 1909-49 widespread among newspaper journalists that adverbs (vol. 7) gives a few citations from American literature: should not separate auxiliaries from their main verbs (as . . . their cats were pretty sociable around her nights in "you can easily see" or "they must be heartily con- —Mark Twain, The Stolen White Elephant, 1882 gratulated"). This bugaboo, commentators agree, seems to have sprung from fear of the dread split infinitive (see I've got to work evenings! —Sinclair Lewis, Arrow- SPLIT INFINITIVE). Copperud cites five commentators on smith, 1925 the subject, all of whom see no harm in placing an adverb between the parts of a verb, and one of whom Summers I used to cover Missouri —Thornton Wil- (Fowler 1965) prescribes such placement. Fowler (under der, Heaven's My Destination, 1934 position of adverbs) has a long and detailed discussion, I went over there afternoons —Ernest Hemingway, complete with numerous examples in which the adverb A Farewell to Arms, 1929 has been improperly (to his mind) shifted so as to avoid the split. Since dividing the auxiliary from the verb with an adverb has been approved at least since Lindley Mur- adverbial nouns One of the charming and infuriat- ray 1795, it would seem that Fowler is justified in calling ing aspects of English is that English nouns may upon the avoidance a superstition. occasion function as adverbs. Some handbooks and Comments in the 18th-century grammars of Priestley, other textbooks refer to these as adverbial nouns. A cou- Lowth, and Murray indicate a considerable interest in ple of examples: the placement of adverbs. Murray, for instance, rejects Every night she runs four miles. (Clark et al. 1981) "We always find them ready when we want them," cor- recting the placement to "We find them always The tie cost a dollar. (Roberts 1954) ready " For more discussion of this sort of adverb placement, see EVEN and ONLY 1. Other grammarians would analyze the examples above 3. Copperud 1970, 1980 states flatly that "an adverb as noun phrases (every night, four miles, a dollar) used should not intervene between a verb and its object," cit- as adverbs. Adverbial nouns are one member of the ing Fowler, himself, Evans, and Follett as being of that larger class of adverbials. opinion. The statement is oversimplified. For instance, See ADVERBIAL GENITIVE for another kind of adverbial the sentence noun. He claimed quickly the victory adverbials A noun, noun phrase, prepositional is certainly more awkward than phrase, verbal phrase, or clause that functions in a sen- tence in the same way an adverb would is called by He claimed the victory quickly. many grammarians an adverbial. A few typical exam- But if we change the object to a clause, ples might include these: He claimed quickly that he had won They arrived Monday. means one thing, and I finished the book last week. He claimed that he had won quickly We left on a chartered bus. something else. Thus, you as writer have to think the She entered the competition hoping to set a new problem of meaning through for yourself in each case, record. and not just rely on a simple rule of thumb. (Here, for You must make a greater effort to achieve your goals. instance, "He quickly claimed . . . " might be the best possible solution in both cases.) His house was broken into while he was away on Another exception can occur with those phrasal vacation. verbs—verbs followed by particles—where the close adverse 37 adverse connection of the adverbial particle to the verb may or intention, averse to feeling or inclination. Or, as it keep it comfortably before the direct object: was put in the Literary Digest of 10 Feb. 1934, "We are adverse to that which we disapprove, but averse to that Clemens struck out the side in the seventh inning. which we dislike." This question, then, is partly a matter of grammar, I . . . hope that our periodical judges will not be very partly of style, and partly of idiom. You will need to rely adverse to me —William Cowper (in Webster 1909) on your common sense and your ear for the language rather than on a rule. Mr. Richards . . . was adverse to his union with this young lady —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Rich- adverse, averse 1 . Many commentators, British and ard Feverel, 1859 American, warn us against confusing adverse and averse in such sentences as Protestants . . . adverse to all implicit submission of mind and opinion —Edmund Burke (in Webster He is not adverse to an occasional brandy —The 1909) Observer, cited in Bryson 1984 The Roosevelts are, as you may suspect, not averse The word in such a sentence should be averse, we are to travel; we thrive on it —Franklin D. Roosevelt, told. Beyond that specific judgment, little help is given address to Congress, 1 Mar. 1945, in Nothing to us, for the most part. Here is some information we think Fear, ed. B. D. Zevin, 1946 will be more helpful. . . . he was never averse to another encounter. All the The two words are only close in meaning in the com- devil that was in him challenged the devil in Wolf bination adverse/averse to. Adverse, however, is usually Larsen —Jack London, The Sea-Wolf, 1904 used attributively: Under certain circumstances, to be explained later, I . . . 18 to 30 percent of all hospitalized patients have am not averse to pillorying the innocent —John an adverse reaction to one or more of the drugs they Barth, The Floating Opera, 1956 are given —David Zimmerman, Ladies' Home Jour., October 1971 Miss Carew, averse to the anomalous relations of courtship, made as little delay as possible in getting Are any of us . . . certain that an adverse wind will married —George Bernard Shaw, Cashel Byron's not sweep away our possessions —Henry Miller, Profession, 1886 The Air-Conditioned Nightmare, 1945 But the distinction is a subtle one and not observed uni- . . . her own conduct must be carefully regulated so as not to give rise to a breath of adverse comment versally, even by respected writers: —Stella Gibbons, Cold Comfort Farm, 1932 . . . for Leonora Penderton was a person who liked to We do not face an adverse balance of trade —Paul settle herself and was adverse to complications — A. Samuelson, New Republic, 26 Mar. 1945 Carson McCullers, Reflections in a Golden Eye, 1941 . . . maintaining a cheerful countenance under Her Majesty, as I have said, was by no means averse adverse circumstances —George Bernard Shaw, to reforms —Edith Sitwell, Victoria of England, Cashel Byron's Profession, 1886 1936 Averse, on the other hand, is rare as an attributive The criticized uses of adverse to all occur in negative adjective: sentences. It is in such contexts that it is most difficult to distinguish opinion or intention from feeling or incli- . . . he was on his way to fame despite the averse crew nation. In the sentence about brandy at the beginning of —Jane Ross, Early American Life, April 1977 this discussion, one suspects inclination, as one does in this: Even when used with to, adverse is most often used with a thing rather than a person as the object of the . . . and he is not adverse to reading about himself— preposition: N. Y. Times, cited in Bernstein 1962 . . . Johnson firmly and resolutely opposed any But either nuance may be plausibly inferred in these restraint whatever, as adverse to a free investigation instances: of the characters of mankind —James Boswell, Life of Samuel Johnson, 1791 Aside from his desire to see the natives come out on top, Jarel was not at all adverse to the idea of a trick . . . was able to hear all testimony adverse to her — being played on Dulard —Sylvia Louise Engdahl, AAUPBulletin, December 1967 "Enchantress from the Stars,*' 1970 in Literature, Carl B. Smith et al., 1980 But it is really almost completely adverse to the very interests which it pretends to protect —Leland Olds, . . . Holbrook would not be adverse to a regular TV New Republic, 14 Sept. 1953 series —NY. Times, cited in Bernstein 1977 His own written enunciations were adverse to his In summary, adverse and averse are only synonymous chances of escape —George Meredith, The Ordeal of when used of persons and with to. Adverse is most often Richard Feverel, 1859 used as an attributive adjective and of things; averse is . . . the whole Parliamentary tradition as built up in extremely rare as an attributive and is regularly used of this country . . . is adverse to it — S i r Winston Chur- persons. When used with to and of persons a subtle dis- chill, The Unrelenting Struggle, 1942 tinction can be drawn, but it is not universally observed, and in negative contexts it is hard to make out whether When used of people, adverse and averse are essen- the distinction is being observed or ignored. tially synonymous, but adverse chiefly refers to opinion 2. See AVERSE TO, FROM. advert 38 adviser advert, verb Fowler 1965 and Flesch 1964 are fully established "in its own sphere." As you can see reported in Copperud 1970 to consider advert to as from the examples, it is not limited to business corre- obsolete for refer to. Sir Ernest Gowers, editor of Fowler spondence. It sometimes carries the sense of "to inform 1965, considers it an archaism, and he remarks on it officially": elsewhere as one of the words he considers overworked in British official prose. Advert to, however, is not obso- The Immigration and Naturalization Service lete; it is still in use, chiefly as a learned alternative to advised Krips that he must either depart voluntarily refer to or to turn the mind or attention to. Here are a or be detained —Current Biography, June 1965 few typical examples: But more often it simply means "inform": So let us escape from all this for a while and advert to a fascinating subject —Simon 1980 . . . which prompted our inquiring lawyer to write thus: " . . . If it does deal with said subject will you . . . it will not be enough to advert to the dignity of kindly advise where I can buy said book." —John man, the connectedness among things —A. Bartlett Barkham, Saturday Rev., 13 Feb. 1954 Giamatti, Profession 79, 1979 Jiro Tokuyama . . . advised me that today 80 percent Webster set out to correct Pickering's views on the of young Japanese husbands in urban communities American corruption of the English language, turn over their pay envelopes, unopened, to their adverting only briefly to the oblique personal refer- wives —Vance Packard, The Sexual Wilderness, ence —Ronald A. Wells, Dictionaries and the 1968 Authoritarian Tradition, 1973 He had not advised his friends of his marriage — The point which I think needs comment is the dis- Willa Cather, The Old Beauty and Others, 1948 tinction, adverted to by William James —Mortimer J. Adler, The Conditions of Philosophy, 1965 . . . a stone guide-post advised him that Gaza was still eight miles distant —Lloyd C. Douglas, The Big However, the type of cooperation I advert to can be Fisherman, 1948 brought about in any of America's institutions of higher learning —Charles E. Wilson, Think, June 1957 advisedly Cranky old Ambrose Bierce in 1909 objected to the use of advisedly to mean "intentionally." He said it "should mean that it was done after advice." advert, noun See AD. Bernstein 1971 dismantles Bierce's ill-founded opinion: "when you do something advisedly your counsel is self- advice See ADVISE 1. contained." Phythian 1979 agrees with Bernstein. They are right and Bierce wrong: advise 1 . Advise, advice. Numerous commentators I am working as a judge at the Los Angeles County and handbooks, from grade school on up, warn us not Fair, and I use the word "working" advisedly — to confuse advise and advice: advise is a verb, advice is Frank J. Priai, N.Y. Times, 15 Aug. 1979 a noun. If this advice seems like old stuff to you, we have some citations to show you: . . . and strictly "educationally" speaking (inverted commas are used advisedly) —Times Literary She can spot creative genius in a stick-figure draw- Supp., 2 Apr. 1971 ing, pack a mean lunch and give great advise — I often say that one must permit oneself, and that advt., N.Y. Times Mag., 27 Apr. 1980 quite advisedly and deliberately, a certain margin of . . . honor bound to advice prospective students of misstatement —Benjamin N. Cardozo, "Law and the dismal prospects for employment —Biographi- Literature," 1925, in Selected Writings of Benjamin cal Dictionary of the Phonetic Sciences, 1977 N. Cardozo, ed. Margaret E. Hall, 1947 The U.S. Constitution spells the noun advice when it The constituent principles of the modern point of speaks of the Senate's role in relation to treaties made view, as accepted advisedly or by oversight by Adam by the President. So does this distinguished modern Smith and his generation —Thorstein Veblen, The writer: Vested Interests, 1 9 1 9 Its Board of Pardons, established in 1883, consists of adviser, advisor Both of these spellings are in cur- five responsible citizens appointed by the governor rent good use. Copperud 1970 and Reader's Digest 1983 with the advice and consent of the state Senate — note adviser as being the spelling preferred by journal- William Styron, This Quiet Dust and Other Writ- ists; Copperud cites one of Porter Perrin's works as say- ings, 1982 ing advisor is probably predominant, but it is not, at least in the Merriam-Webster files—we have more evi- So should you. dence for adviser. For what it's worth, Reader's Digest 2. Copperud 1970 cites a considerable number of com- tells us that advisor is the preferred spelling of fortune mentators who object to the use of advise to mean tellers. "inform." They chiefly object to its use in business cor- respondence. The objectors, it should be noted, are nei- . . . appointed to the five-man panel of advisers — ther in business nor writing for those who are; Janis Current Biography, July 1965 1984, who is addressing business people, finds it only "sometimes stilted" and thinks the phrase "Please be A chief advisor in the administrations of Franklin D. advised" is often deadwood—it is, in fact, only a polite Roosevelt and of succeeding presidents —Current formula. Reader's Digest 1983 notes that the sense is Biography, February 1966 advocate 39 aegis The military euphemism of the Vietnam war era was . . . promising to act as his advocate with Katherine spelled adviser: —James Sutherland, English Literature of the Late Seventeenth Century, 1969 . . . though the Marines are "advisers," a Vietnamese seldom questions a U.S. sergeant's advice —Sher- We are their advocate with the credit company — wood Dickerman, The Reporter, 6 Apr. 1967 unidentified spokesperson, NBC Radio News, 9 June 1974 advocate 1 . Bernstein 1965 tells us the noun advocate takes the preposition of, the verb for. Both these gener- 2. A couple of issues of some historical interest adhere alizations are off the mark. to advocate. In the late 18th century the verb advocate Advocate the verb is used almost entirely as a transi- was supposed to be an American innovation. Benjamin tive verb and usually takes no preposition at all. When Franklin in a letter to Noah Webster in December 1798 a prepositional phrase does happen to follow the direct described to advocate as an innovation he had encoun- object, the preposition can be for but can just as easily tered only upon his return from France; he asked Web- be in, on, or by, among others: ster to reprobate the word (along with several other innovations—to notice, to progress, to oppose—that are While Henry advocates federal loan programs for perfectly standard today). An English traveler named individual needy students —Current Biography, Henry Wamsey in 1794 also noted to advocate as a nov- June 1966 elty. The verb was not entered in Johnson's Dictionary The use of for is seen when advocate is intransitive, but of 1755, but H. J. Todd added it in his expanded version the intransitive is fairly rare. The OED (which marks it of Johnson published early in the 19th century. Todd obsolete) does show citations with for: three from the remarks that a Mr. Boucher gave credit to Americans 17th century and one from the 19th: for this particular enrichment of English; Todd says they do not deserve the credit, since the word was used by I am not going to advocate for this sense of actual Milton and Burke. But Mencken 1963 (abridged) notes —Fitzedward Hall, Recent Exemplifications of False it was attacked as an Americanism by Robert Southey Philology, 1872 as late as 1838. All this and more can be found, more entertainingly recounted, in Mencken. The noun advocate most usually takes of to show Fowler 1926, 1965 asserts that advocate, unlike rec- what is being advocated: ommend, propose, urge, is not idiomatically followed by . . . advocates of our disastrous military-oriented a //z0/-clause. In fact, although clauses are considerably policies in Asia —Chester Bowles, Saturday Rev., 6 less common than nouns and gerunds as direct objects, Nov. 1971 they are not in the least unidiomatic: . . . wrong if he takes me as an advocate of amorality . . . he used the occasion to join Walter Reuther in in the conduct of foreign policy —Arthur M. Schles- advocating that organized labor in the United States inger, Jr., Harper's, October 1971 work within the Democratic party —Current Biog- . . . as an advocate of probity and thrift he could be raphy, November 1966 seen splitting wood in front of his house each morn- ing —John Cheever, The Wapshot Chronicle, 1957 The officers advocate that the large, unwieldy units be replaced by smaller ARVN mobile brigades — For is also used sometimes to indicate what is being Robert Shaplen, New Yorker, 24 Apr. 1971 advocated: . . . is an advocate for the extended use of psychiatry in the field of law —Morris L. Ernst, New Republic, aegis Back in 1939 the editors of Webster's Second 8 June 1953 (1934) added a new sense of aegis in the New Words Section: "Patronage; sponsorship; auspices; as, under I am certainly not an advocate for frequent and the aegis of the Liberal Club." Bernstein 1965 criticizes untried changes in laws and constitutions —John this sense of aegis. The new definition had been occa- Morley, in The Practical Cogitator, ed. Charles P. sioned by uses like this one: Curtis, Jr. & Ferris Greenslet, 1945 It is improper to pass from the questions of Seneca's More often, though, for indicates on whose behalf one influence upon the Tragedy of Blood and upon the advocates: language of the Elizabethans without mentioning the Let them . . . be advocates for their organizations — group of "Senecal" plays, largely produced under the Leslie H. Gelb & Morton H. Halperin, Harper's, aegis of the Countess of Pembroke —T. S. Eliot, June 1972 "Seneca in Elizabethan Translation," in Selected Essays, 1932 . . . the responsibility of acting as a personal advo- cate for his chief —McGeorge Bundy, in Preface to The history of aegis up to the development of the The Pattern of Responsibility, 1951 1939 sense is fairly straightforward. Its earliest meaning Young Heinrich became a sort of advocate for his was a shield or breastplate originally associated in clas- people before the tribunal of Mr. Britling's mind — sical mythology with Zeus and Athena. This meaning H. G. Wells, Mr. Britling Sees It Through, 1916 has had some use in literary English: With may be used for the authority to whom one advo- Where was thine ^Egis, Pallas, that appalled Stern cates a cause: Alaric? —Lord Byron, Childe Harold's Pilgrimage, 1812 (OED) And if any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous: And he is the pro- The purposes of >Egis-bearing Jove —William Cul- pitiation for our sins —1 John 2:1-2 (AV), 1611 len Bryant, The Odyssey of Homer, 1877 (OED) aegis 40 aegis From the shield or breastplate, the transition to a Before the brief era of reform came to Philadelphia's sense meaning "protection" is plain enough: schools . . . under the aegis of Mark R. Shedd and Richardson Dilworth —Peter Binzen, Saturday They were sheltered by the aegis of the laws —Con- Rev., 5 Feb. 1972 nop Thirlwall, A History of Greece, 1836 (OED) . . . urging his government to send troops—to . . . behind the aegis of a big and bright and newly include his son—under the aegis of the United forged telephone-inspector badge —Albert Payson Nations —Sir Leslie Munro, United Nations: Hope Terhune, Further Adventures of Lad, 1922 for a Divided World, 1960 " . . . now that the Imperial aegis protects m e . . . . " — That was not our fault, however, but that of the Holy Raphael Sabatini, The Strolling Saint, 1924 Alliance under the aegis of Metternich —A. L. Rowse, Britain To-Day, September 1944 Had they come to Philippi to preach the tidings of the Messiah under the aegis of their Roman citizen- This sense is sometimes used in the context of the thea- ship? Their aegis was God — Sholem Asch, The ter and films to connote the functions of producer, direc- Apostle, 1943 tor, or distributor: It is urged that motion pictures do not fall within the Her first Hollywood picture as a free-lance star, no First Amendment's aegis —Joseph Bursty n, Inc. v. longer under the aegis of Selznick —Current Biog- Wilson, 72 S. Ct. 777, 1952 raphy, September 1965 . . . we witnessed the power of the people, and even . . . last done on film so satisfyingly by Joe Mankie- now our bodies are wrapped in the magic aegis of wicz in 1953 under the star-studded aegis of M-G-M their love —William Crain, East Village Other, 10 —Judith Crist, New York, 8 Feb. 1971 Nov. 1970 When used of individuals, the meaning may some- You should observe that this sense of aegis does not times be close to "leadership": necessarily come in the phrase under the aegis of That phrase is not attested until 1910. A sharp-eyed reader for He joined the Fabian Society, which under the intel- the OED Supplement found this example in the 11th lectual aegis of Sidney and Beatrice Webb had repu- edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica in the article on diated the violent revolutionary doctrines of Karl billiards: Marx —Time, 6 Aug. 1945 . . . the nontonalists, relatively weak, but united Under the aegis of the Billiard Association a tacit under the aegis of Schoenberg —Robert Evett, understanding was arrived a t . . . . Atlantic, July 1971 The sense here is neither of the first two, of course, but Aegis is also used in a sense of "a strong or guiding rather the new sense "patronage, sponsorship, auspices" recorded in Webster's Second; it is easy enough to see influence": how this meaning developed from that of "protection." Gide was unable even to approach this goal at first, It is this meaning, especially used with under, that has all the more so because he began his literary activi- produced, in its various subsenses, the predominant ties under the aegis of symbolism —Carlos Lynes, uses in 20th-century English. Reader's Digest 1983 Jr., in Forms of Modem Fiction, ed. William Van thinks these are secondary uses, but they are not. Cop- O'Connor, 1948 perud 1970 could not find them in dictionaries, but he must have skipped Webster's Third and the 1963 Col- . . . little was added to the requirements of notice and legiate Dictionary abridged from it. hearing developed by the courts under the aegis of In addition to T. S. Eliot and the encyclopedia, here the due process clause —Nathaniel L. Nathanson, are some examples of "sponsorship, patronage, American Political Science Rev., June 1951 auspices": The feminine dramas of Little Women unfold under the aegis of a father deified by absence —H. M. So why not a series of rock concerts, produced under Parshley, Translator's Preface to Simone de Beau- the aegis of the Fillmore —Richard Goldstein, New voir, The Second Sex, 1952 York, 24 May 1971 Without realizing it, many American mothers, under It was written (and published) under the aegis of the the aegis of benevolent permissiveness . . . actually Council on Foreign Relations —Willard L. Thorp, neglect their children —Time, 28 Dec. 1970 Yale Rev., Summer 1954 Further senses of aegis appear to be developing, but they . . . it was under the aegis of Sir Barry Jackson . . . are not readily or fully identifiable yet. One of these car- that many of the later Shaw plays saw the light —W. ries a notion of an identifying name or label: Bridges-Adams, The British Theatre, rev. éd., 1946 The new publication . . . will appear under the aegis . . . under the aegis of London University, university of Breskin Publications —Plastics Newsfront, Janu- colleges have been started . . . in the Sudan and East ary 1951 Africa —Eric Ashby, London Calling, 20 May 1954 The disc is issued under the aegis of Middlebury Col- lege —Bertrand H. Bronson, Western Folklore, Often the word carries the notion of direction, super- October 1954 vision, guidance, or control: . . . Fawcett Crest reports that nearly 19 million soft- . . . the Central Office for South Vietnam, which runs cover copies of 16 Taylor Caldwell novels are in the war in the South under Hanoi's aegis —Robert print under its aegis alone —Nan Robertson, N. Y. Shaplen, New Yorker, 24 Apr. 1971 Times, 11 Dec. 1976 aerate 41 affinity These examples show the main areas of expansion that And of effect, noun (we will omit affect, noun): aegis is occupying in 20th-century English prose. It is a word that has developed largely within this century, and . . . prose which essays effects beyond the mere con- it shows no sign at present of settling down. veying of basic information —Anthony Burgess, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 5 Feb. 1984 aerate Bryson 1984 reminds us not to misspell this An unimaginative crescendo of stage effects —Jon word aereate, as is sometimes done: Pareles, JV.y. Times, 16 Jan. 1984 . . . kept the water aereated —Scouting, April 1953 The verbs affect and effect and the nouns affect and effect are clearly enough differentiated in meaning that This is a case of minding your ds and ^'s. it is unlikely that you will go wrong if you pay attention to your intended meaning. If you entertain any nagging affect, effect There are two verbs affect. The first doubts, a dictionary will settle them. means, among other things, "to make a show of liking; to put on a pretense of," and the second, "to produce an affiliate 1 . Affiliate is used with both with and to. effect in or on, influence." Effect has been used for the Affiliate with is usually but not always American; affili- second of these since at least 1494 and for the first since ate to is usually but not always British. We have Cana- 1652. Clearly, we are talking about a long-term confu- dian evidence for both combinations: sion here. It happens that effect is a verb, too, with a meaning roughly "to bring about." And, to complete the . . . which will be affiliated with the University of picture, both affect and effect are nouns. Even though Alaska —Michael A. Pollock, Change, October 1971 effect is the only one in common use (affect is a technical term in psychology), affect is sometimes put in its place. We finally affiliated with the Newhope Baptist All of this history of befuddlement has left us with a Church —Mrs. Medgar Evars, Ladies' Home Jour., fat collection of warning notices. Nearly every hand- September 1971 book published in the 20th century—from Vizetelly . . . it was affiliated with the University of Glasgow 1906 to Chambers 1985—contains one. Does anybody —Sir James Mountford, British Universities, 1966 pay attention? Our evidence suggests that nearly every- one who gets published does, although we have substan- . . . to affiliate it with a prevailing approach to the tial evidence for mistaken usage too. Although the verb lyric stage —Irving Kolodin, Saturday Rev., 26 Sept. affect and the noun effect are a semantic pair—if you 1964 affect something, the result is an effect—and this fact alone is bound to create some uncertainty, confusion is . . . loose national federations with which the local probably not the whole problem. More likely it is often bodies affiliated —Oscar Handlin, The American simply inattention to spelling. When, for instance, a People in the Twentieth Century, 1954 professional basketball player named Darryl Dawkins commented upon some electrodes attached to his shoul- . . . which is not affiliated with a university —John der during a game for therapeutic purposes, and a wire E. Robbins, Institutions of Higher Education in Can- service sent the comment out as "It effected my inter- ada, ca. 1944 planetary funksmanship," it was not Dawkins who used . . . it was affiliated to the University of Edinburgh in the wrong verb but a careless professional journalist. 1933 —Sir James Mountford, British Universities, Many other of our examples of the mistake probably 1966 attest to poor proofreading, or no proofreading; a few— such as dictionary manuscript errors and mistakes in . . . said his organisation was affiliated to a world- business letters—suggest ordinary inattention in wide body — The Guardian, 28 Nov. 1973 writing. Here are a handful of correct usages of the several . . . socially it was advisable that everyone should be verbs: affiliated to the religious customs prevalent in his country —George Santayana, Persons and Places, . . . the luxury of contemporary London, which he 1944 affected to find nauseating —Paul Fussell, Samuel Johnson and the Life of Writing, 1971 The urban imagery that affiliates Mr. Eliot to Bau- delaire —F. R. Leavis, New Bearings in English That is all I have, I said, affecting a pathos in my Poetry, new éd., 1950 voice —Flann O'Brien, At Swim-Two-Birds, 1939 . . . 150 colleges, many affiliated to the universities This was the last age in which writers were seriously —Canada Today, 1953 affected by the doctrines associated with the tradi- tional literary 'kinds' —John Butt, English Litera- 2. There is some evidence that in the middle of the 19th ture in the Mid-Eighteenth Century, edited & com- century affiliate was used in the U.S. in the sense of pleted by Geoffrey Carnall, 1979 "associate, fraternize." Thornton 1939 defines it as "Erroneously used instead of fraternize." Perhaps No one at AAI measured how day care affects the Thornton considered the use a bit below the salt, but the company —Andrea Fooner, Inc. Mag., 5 May 1981 Dictionary of American English did not stigmatize it. . . . drop them a card and tell them your release has The use was also noted in H. W. Horwill's An Anglo- been effected —Flannery O'Connor, letter, 19 Apr. American Interpreter (1939). The sense does not appear 1963 to be current, at least in print. . . . this President has a mandate to effect some seri- ous changes —Andrew Hacker, N.Y. Times Book affinity Fowler 1926 declared that between and with /tev., 24Oct. 1982 are the normal prepositions with affinity and that to and affinity 42 affinity for should not be used. This assertion appears to be . . . the mysterious affinity between them —Zane based on his analysis of the word as indicating a recip- Grey, The Mysterious Rider, 1921 rocal relationship only, while to and for suggest a more one-sided relationship. Unfortunately for the analysis, . . . there is an affinity between them and their Afri- the use of affinity for a one-sided relationship was can friends —Michael Blundell, London Calling, 3 already three centuries old, attested as early as 1616 in Feb. 1955 the OED (sense 8). Follett 1966 elaborates Fowler's . . . I have always felt a real affinity with Havel's treatment by basing his assertion that the meaning is a point of view —Tom Stoppard, quoted in NY. strong mutual attraction on the word's original mean- Times, 25 Oct. 1979 ing, "relationship by marriage." Of course, observation suggests that many relationships by marriage are not . . . a true rabbit d o g . . . which it took but one glance based on strong mutual attraction; in-laws are often to see had an affinity a rapport with rabbits —Wil- related solely by the happenstance of marriage. But the liam Faulkner, Intruder in the Dust, 1948 real weakness of Follett's argument lies in its assump- tion that a word's earliest meaning must restrict its later . . . the passion of Giovanni and Annabella is not semantic development to some favored pattern. A little shown as an affinity of temperament —T. S. Eliot, time spent with a dictionary that places senses in histor- "John Ford," in Selected Essays, 1932 ical order will persuade you that development of new . . . racism therefore did obeisance to the affinities of meaning often does not take place in that way and that, the Celtic soul and the Slavic soul —Ruth Benedict, moreover, there is usually no good reason why it should. Race: Science and Politics, 1945 In modern use, affinity is used with for and with most often, with to and between somewhat less often, and . . . the man who on the out-of-town hustings makes with a few other prepositions occasionally. Perhaps it much of his affinity for "the street people, my peo- will be most helpful to show a few illustrations of the ple, the workers of my city" —Andy Logan, New important general meanings of affinity and the preposi- Yorker, 30 Oct. 1971 tions used with each. The original meaning: The sympathy is sometimes extended to foods to sug- gest that things go well together: In a few months it was announced that he was closely related by affinity to the royal house. His . . . new crackers that have a true affinity for cheese daughter had become, by a secret marriage, Duchess —New Yorker, 12 Dec. 1953 of York —T. B. Macaulay, The History of England, Rum also has an amazing affinity for foods we love vol. I, 1849 —Marilyn Kay ter, American Way, December 1971 It is also used of family relationships: A frequent use of affinity is to denote an attraction to Every creature that bears any affinity to my mother or liking for something: is dear to me, and you, the daughter of her brother —William Cowper, letter, 27 Feb. 1790 What an affinity for Christianity had this persecutor of the Christians! —Matthew Arnold, Essays in Crit- The family relationship may be figurative: icism, First Series, 1865 . . . its degree of affinity with any other language or . . . revels in Macaulay, who has a special affinity for dialect —Mario Pei, Word, August 1949 the eternal schoolboy —W. R. Inge, The Church in the World, 1928 The period of ten years that follows is full of exper- imental variation, but there is a recognizable stylistic . . . they punish themselves, by their natural affinity affinity between the extremes —Herbert Read, The for the defective —C. S. Peirce, "Evolutionary Philosophy of Modern Art, 1952 Love," 1893, in The Philosophy of Peirce, ed. Justus Buchler, 1940 " . . . Whatever bears affinity to cunning is despic- able." —Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, 1813 If you have no affinity for verse, better skip this — Oliver St. John Gogarty, It Isn 't This Time of Year This use is often close in meaning to "resemblance" or At All! \954 "similarity": I think you have an affinity for aging British ladies . . . it is likely his Elvish language shows some affin- of unimpeachable integrity —Flannery O'Connor, ities with Finnish —Current Biography, October letter, 11 May 1963 1967 . . . affirms a general affinity between the police and His affinity for controversy got him into further trou- the military—both refer to outsiders as 'civilians' — ble —Michael & Sheila Cole, Psychology Today, Allen Young, quoted in Playboy, September 1968 March 1971 . . . something in the English character, something . . . this affinity for exotica made itself felt in St. Den- mystical, tough and fierce, has a special affinity to is's repertory —Anna Kisselgoff, N. Y. Times Book Hebrew —Edmund Wilson, A Piece of My Mind, Rev., 10 Oct. 1976 1956 Sometimes affinity suggests a natural or sympathetic A common figurative sense is "a feeling of kinship, aptitude or liking for something, a natural talent, a flair: sympathy, rapport": . . . Weingartner had a close affinity with this style, . . . I feel a certain affinity to the situation and to the and I recall some Haydn symphonies . . . that are institution —Keith M. Cottam, Library Jour., 1 Feb. well-nigh unsurpassable —Paul Henry Lang, Satur- 1967 day Rev., 26 June 1954 affirmative 43 aforementioned Gifted with an affinity for the art song —Current effluent, which is also sometimes pronounced with main Biography, November 1966 stress on the second syllable. Confusion is far less likely when main stress falls on the contrasting initial vowels. . . . Irishmen, who seem to have an affinity for poli- tics —Green Peyton, San Antonio: City in the Sun, 1946 aforementioned, aforesaid Copperud 1970 cites himself and Flesch as finding these words unsuitable for . . . early displayed an affinity for finance and book- ordinary contexts; Strunk & White 1959 finds aforesaid keeping —Current Biography, April 1966 "damaging in standard prose"; Nickles 1974 labels both The attempt to limit the prepositions affinity can be words "legal lingo" to be avoided. Although these two used with has never had any basis in other than artificial words are used in legal contexts, they also appear in gen- notions and thus has achieved no striking success. In eral contexts, where they are not used in quite the same addition to the examples shown above, there are many way as in documents. technical uses of affinity (as in chemistry and botany) Aforementioned seems to be somewhat the more com- that usually go with for (but sometimes to or another mon word. It is widely employed as part of a standard preposition). You can use affinity with any preposition auditor's statement: that seems natural. In our opinion, the aforementioned financial state- ments present fairly the consolidated financial posi- affirmative, negative An objection is sometimes tion o f . . . —Annual Report, Atlantic Richfield Co., made to the use of affirmative and negative in such sen- 1970 tences as "The witness answered in the negative." Cop- perud 1964, 1970, Flesch 1964, Watt 1967, and Heritage It also appears in rather ordinary contexts, many of 1982 may be recorded among the objectors; Gowers (in which—perhaps surprisingly—are written in an infor- Fowler 1965) objects to it as pompous; he sees it as a mal style: Parliamentary convention that has been satirized to . . . in the aforementioned times when not just nat- such an extent that it is now seldom used in Britain. He ural-shoulder but all suits were eschewed in favor of has also found it in American use, however, and he jeans —David Platt, Playboy, April 1980 quotes an effusion of self-evident pomposity. Copperud 1970 also notes a magazine report that sec- The first of the six, the aforementioned Oberhoffer, retaries at NASA headquarters in Houston were then remained at the helm until 1922 —Roland Gelatt, saying "negative" rather than "no." The practice pre- Saturday Rev., 29 Oct. 1977 sumably derives from military aviation use, where affir- Grandaddy of them all, the aforementioned Bo- mative and negative replace yes and no in radio com- nanza International —Charles Biderman, Barron's, munications as less likely to be garbled by static: 8 May 1972 . . . the squawk box rasped, "Admiral, 1591 says he In 1966 the aforementioned Mr. Jenkins, in one of will have to ditch." his earlier though not wiser pronouncements — "Can he ditch near the destroyers?" "Albion," Security World, May 1968 "Negative." "Is his wingman still with him?" . . . the aforementioned impartial and incorruptible "Affirmative." chance —Frank Stockton, "The Lady or the Tiger?" —James A. Michener, The 1882, in Worlds of People (textbook), 1951 Bridges at Toko-Ri, 1953 The word is used at times for humorous effect: It should be further noted that affirmative and nega- tive can be used with answer in sentences where simple "Four gin-and-tonics is whose idea of healthful replacement with yes or no is not desirable: sport?" said the aforementioned spouse of aforesaid with a snarl that so incensed the snarlee that I—I . . . a question that can't be answered in the affirma- mean, the snarlee—did spitefully consume the four tive—for if it could, there would be no need to ask and then two more —John Ciardi, Saturday Rev., 22 it —Jon Landau, Rolling Stone, 2 Mar. 1972 Jan. 1972 A final note: usage writers are apt to disparage usages Margaret is, I regret to say, called Mopsy and she like this as modern barbarisms. But this expression was burns genteely [sic] for the unworthy Luke. In the around long before the courtroom reportage rejected by end she gets him but not before everybody gets Copperud, Flesch, and Watt developed: entangled in the aforementioned plot devices — Edward Fitzgerald, Saturday Rev., 26 July 1952 . . . I met an old woman in the street, who accosting me, asked, if I were a physician. When I answered in . . . the height of its forehead being lost in the still the affirmative . . . —Tobias Smollett, translation of more perilous height of the aforementioned hat — René Le Sage, Gil Bias, 1749 Irish Statesman, 22 Nov. 1924 We have less evidence for aforesaid than for afore- afflict See INFLICT, AFFLICT. mentioned. It does not appear regularly in any formulaic statements that we are aware of. Like aforementioned it often appears in contexts of a light or humorous nature: affluent There are several reasons for preferring the pronunciation with main stress on the initial syllable: I had just finished "sottin'" 48 tender celery plants \'af-,lu-3nt\. The variant with main stress on the sec- in a neat row in my tillage when a large, yellow ond syllable, Xa-'flu-antN, is disapproved by usage writ- Thomas Cat hastened in a generally south-north ers, is less common among educated speakers (though direction and placed a foot precisely on each plant certainly in respectable use), and could be confused with aforesaid en passant. The reason for this intrusion afraid 44 after was immediately clear—four large and excited dependent clause. Utter says that this "construction has hounds in full cry —John Gould, Christian Science long been good English," even though the censorious Monitor, 18 July 1980 condemn it as colloquial. Among the censorious must be listed Krapp 1927, who calls it colloquial. Aforementioned and aforesaid furnish one convenient The element of fear in Bierce's example is not strong, way to refer back to something mentioned earlier, per- a fact that makes his revision seem less than sensible. In haps on occasion to avoid the often sullied above (see Utter's (I'm afraid I can't go) and Krapp's (I'm afraid ABOVE 1). They come from legal lingo and are used in you'll have to wait for the next train) examples, it is legal contexts. In ordinary contexts they seem to be even weaker. This aspect of the expression is picked on often used informally and for humorous effect. by our next two commentators, Bremner 1980 and Free- man 1983. Here is what Bremner says: afraid 1 . Chambers 1985 and Evans 1957 discuss the constructions afraid is found in. It is derived from a past Try to avoid afraid unless the context calls for fear, participle in Middle English and is used now as a pred- fright, terror, alarm. Don't use it casually, as in "I'm icate adjective, not as an attributive adjective. Afraid afraid not" can be followed by a clause: And Freeman: Afraid that any precipitous action on his part might well cost him his position —NE A Jour., January The expression "She's afraid he's right" is an infor- 1965 mal—and incorrect—way of saying "She fears that he's right." And "I'm afraid not" is folksy for "I He seemed afraid, if he were kind, he might be ridi- think not." The use of afraid should be restricted to culed —Edwin A. Peeples, Saturday Evening Post, reflect a real cause for fear, fright, or alarm. 25 Dec. 1954 As noted above, Utter mentions the long history of this It can be followed by an infinitive: construction. Shakespeare certainly used it: . . . ready to say bluntly what every one else is afraid I am afraid, sir, Do what you can, yours will not be to say —T. S. Eliot, "Charles Whibley," in Selected entreated — The Taming of the Shrew, 1594 Essays, 1932 I am afraid this great lubber, the world, will prove a . . . is not afraid to go out and ask a playwright or a cockney —Twelfth Night, 1602 director just what he thinks he's doing —Richard Schickel, Harper's, November 1970 I am half afraid he will have need of washing —The Merry Wives of Windsor, 1601 The usual preposition after afraid is of, which can be followed by a noun or a gerund: And it has been used in impeccable literary sources ever since: We have been much too much afraid of the Russians —Edmund Wilson, A Piece of My Mind, 1956 Disagreeable enough (as most necessities are) but, I am afraid, unavoidable —Thomas Gray, letter, 16 " . . . She told me she was afraid of him. He had July 1740 (OED Supplement) threatened to kill her." —Dashiell Hammett, Red Harvest, 1929 I am afraid you do not like your pen. Let me mend it for you —Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, 1813 " . . . were you so afraid of a man like Keegan, you (OED Supplement) wouldn't step forward . . . ?" —Anthony Trollope, The Macdermots of Ballycloran, 1847 . . . though even that is more, I am afraid, than my powers are up to —Henry Adams, letter, 9 Feb. 1859 Some of us are afraid of dying —Thomas Pynchon, K, 1963 But when I use it now, I am afraid, it will usually be a dignified way of circling round the more indefin- But I am now as much afraid of drinking as of bath- able aspects of a novelist's skill —Bernard De Voto, ing —Tobias Smollett, Humphry Clinker, 1771 The World of Fiction, 1950 Afraid is also followed by for; in this construction the . . . I am afraid that often in reading the Cantos I feel object is not the source of the threat but rather what is as if what is being said were not much better than threatened: nothing —F. R. Leavis, New Bearings in English Poetry, new éd., 1950 . . . clerks, who had come early because they were afraid for their jobs —Wirt Williams, The Enemy, I am afraid that it is a feeling that I share —William 1951 Styron, This Quiet Dust and Other Writings, 1982 The men aren't afraid for their jobs, either, because The expression may at times suggest informality, but it unemployment is negligible —John Fischer, Har- is in no way incorrect. per's, January 1969 . . . once or twice she is in real physical danger and after 1 . In Irish dialect after is used in a construction genuinely afraid for herself — Times Literary Supp., to be after doing something about whose meaning there February 1969 seems to have been some confusion. P. W. Joyce in English As We Speak It in Ireland (1910) explains it as 2. Bierce 1909 directs us flatly, "Do not say 'I am afraid an idiom by which the Irish get round the perfect it will rain.' Say, I fear that it will rain." End of direc- tense—instead of "I have finished my work" they use "I tion. Vizetelly 1920 cannot find any reason for this pro- am after finishing my work." Some older American dic- scription; Utter 1916 opines that the objection seems to tionaries seem to have thought it to mean "to be about be based on the theory that an adjective cannot take a to" rather than "to have just done"; Gowers (in Fowler aftermath 45 aftermath 1965) notes that some English novelists have made the in many other sources using standard English. A few same mistake. Here are a few genuine Irish examples: samples: 'Listen to me,' says I, 'do you think I did this on pur- Returning to Liverpool after having attained some pose? I'm after having two punctures " —Rex popularity in Hamburg, they were booked for several MacGall, Irish Digest, November 1955 months in the Cavern —Current Biography, Decem- ber 1965 Cracked Mary it is, that is after coming back this day from the asylum —Lady Gregory, The Full Moon, My impression, after having excavated in several of 1910 the sites —Edward P. Lanning, Peru Before the Incas, 1967 I'm after thinking of something good, something very good unless I'm very much mistaken, said Fur- The first of these is more than a little suspect and I riskey —Flann O'Brien, At Swim-Two-Birds, 1939 give it here (after having seen only the six copies recorded in this country) simply as an illustration — 2. Longman 1984 thinks after meaning "afterwards" is Fredson Bowers, Principles of Bibliographical not suitable for formal writing unless accompanied by Description, 1949 an adverb like soon or shortly. The OED shows this con- struction used by Shakespeare, Thomas Fuller, Edmund She died in 1947 after having launched some Burke, and Horace Walpole, among others. Modern hundreds of boys on their course in life —Times Lit- examples are standard but not of the highest formality: erary Supp., 17 Feb. 1950 . . . during your trip through Britain (and . . . across the Channel if you're touring the Continent after) — aftermath Let us begin by demonstrating how the fig- Richard Joseph, Your Trip to Britain, 1954 urative senses of aftermath are used. In one sense it is applied to something that follows from something else: . . . walking to church with them on a Sunday, and a result or consequence. This following or resulting going home after to a roast —Mary Deasy, The Hour thing is very often unpleasant, but need not necessarily of Spring, 1948 be so: During those periods when Thomas, and after, But- How could he know she would arrive an hour later ler, were occupied elsewhere —Current Biography alone, that there would be a snowstorm in which she 1947 wandered about in slippers, too confused to find a taxi? Then the aftermath, her escaping pneumonia It quite commonly goes with expressions of time: by a miracle, and all the attendant horror —F. Scott . . . Latin was the language of international scholar- Fitzgerald, "Babylon Revisited," in The Portable F. ship in his day, as for centuries before and after — Scott Fitzgerald, 1945 W. F. Bolton, A Short History of Literary English, . . . perhaps it is a mistake to resuscitate his theory, 1967 with all its melancholy aftermath of 'art for art's For years after, when Sallie and I went to the sake' —Herbert Read, The Philosophy of Modern National Arts Club, Mary Austin was there —The Art, 1952 Autobiography of William Allen White, 1946 In pioneer days, when an editor could term a fellow He kept telling me for a week after, that those danc- citizen a "low-born loon" with no fear of legal after- ing girls wore . . . the prettiest dresses —Eudora math —American Guide Series: Tennessee, 1939 Welty, The Ponder Heart, 1954 Deep pessimism is perhaps a natural aftermath of the shock of recognizing that the vaunted "progress" And, of course, it is used with adverbs: of modern civilization is only a thin cloak for global Not long after, a trio of friends... came in to see her catastrophe —Barry Commoner, New Yorker, 2 Oct. —Robert M. Coates, New Yorker, 25 May 1963 1971 . . . some of them not long after converted to fascism . . . the feigned death of Juliet and its aftermath of —Times Literary Supp., 5 June 1969 grief—Winthrop Sargeant, New Yorker, 1 May 1971 . . . the name "Georgy," having once been mispro- One of the truly dramatic aftermaths of the World nounced "Doody" in childhood, may take on the lat- War has been the awakening and expansion of com- ter form forever after —Selected Writings ofEdward mercial life in the Latin-American countries —The Sapir, ed. David G. Mandelbaum, 1949 Nation, 16 Jan. 1929 Soon after, in November 1947 —Current Biography, As a gratifying aftermath of the recent aeronautical June 1965 exposition manufacturers of aircraft have received orders — NY. Times, 30 Mar. 1919 . . . lightning again ripped the world apart and the thunder came tumbling right after —Rita Madocs, It is worth remarking that there is a tendency toward Ladies' Home Jour., September 1971 more unpleasant aftermaths in recent use of the word. The other main figurative use of aftermath is for a . . . and disappeared shortly after —Dictionary of period immediately following some event. Usually the American Biography, 1928 event is an important and ruinous one, such as a war. In this sense aftermath is often found in the phrase in 3. Jensen 1935 considered after redundant with a perfect the aftermath of participial phrase. Jensen seems to have stood alone. The use is entirely standard in biographical writing, Perhaps the greatest crime of the war and its after- where the order of events is emphasized, and is found math —Manchester Guardian Weekly, 17 Feb. 1922 afterward 46 ageism It bodes ill for a future in which the life and strength ment, we have evidence from veterinary sources that of Britain, compared to the other Powers, will be aftermath might be considered bad for sheep or horses tested to the full, not only in war but in its aftermath to graze on because of possible infestation with para- —Sir Winston Churchill, address in Commons, 18 sites. Perhaps the unpleasant connotations came from Jan. 1945, in Voices of History 1945-1946, ed. farmers with sick livestock. Nathan Ausubel, 1946 afterward, afterwards Copperud 1970 says that . . . salutary effect of Eliot's earlier criticism in curb- both forms are used in the U.S. while afterwards pre- ing the carelessness and gush of the aftermath of vails in British English; Watt 1967 opines that afterward Romanticism —Edmund Wilson, Axel's Castle, is more common in the U.S. Standard reference works 1931 and our evidence confirm these observations. It is just as well that there was no competitive piano or violin playing in the immediate aftermath of against 1 . Conjunction. Hodgson 1889 censured the theirs —Irving Kolodin, Saturday Rev., 2 Jan. 1954 conjunction against ("Have it ready against I come") as a vulgar usage; Bardeen 1883 considered it disputable. In the aftermath of the Coronation —Punch, 2 Sept. Reader's Digest 1983 mentions regional use. The con- 1954 junction against was created by functional shift from the preposition back in the 14th century. It had perfectly When old William Jennings Bryan, the advocate of acceptable literary use for several centuries: the Bible, died in the exhausted aftermath of that trial— Time, 6 Feb. 1956 And they made ready the present against Joseph came at noon —Genesis 43:25 (AV), 1611 . . . in the melancholy aftermath of Vietnam — Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., Harper's, March 1969 "I will be prepared, says he, against you come again." —Daniel Defoe, Moll Flanders, 1722 . . . the ice ages—in the aftermath of which we are now living —Times Literary Supp., 1 Jan. 1971 Throw on another log of wood against father comes home —Charles Dickens, Pickwick Papers, 1837 With that background we may turn now to the usage (OED) writers. The earliest in our files is Vizetelly 1920, who As a standard locution, the conjunction is now archaic; tells us that aftermath is "a word persistently misused." it survives only in dialect (the Dictionary of American His adverb should have alerted him to the fact that he Regional English has examples) and in fiction repre- had missed the direction of usage. But it did not, and he senting archaic or dialectal speech: goes on to entangle himself in the etymology and agri- cultural senses of the word. Math is an old word for One of the men . . . called out, "Let 'em come on. "mowing"; after is simply after. Literally, then, after- They'll drive just like hogs against they get out on the math means "after mowing." The citations in the OED, pike." —Elizabeth Madox Roberts, The Time of from the 17th century on, show the word being used to Man, 1926 refer to the herbage that grows in a field after the first crop—of hay, for instance—has been mowed. But Vize- See also WITHOUT. telly thinks the word means "second mowing"—with 2. The pronunciation \a-'gin\ represented by the spell- stress on second—and so refers to an event. He then ing agin is generally treated as dialectal or rural (the Dic- draws conclusions about what figurative extensions are tionary of American Regional English covers it gener- allowable based on his misconception of the original ously under again). Lounsbury 1908 points out that this meaning. No wonder the world does not go along with form, like others that survive among the less educated, him. represents the original form of the preposition in Middle Evans 1957, 1962 follows a similar line of argument, English. basing conclusions on a supposed right relationship of extended meanings to the original. Evans feels the word ageism Simon 1980 asperses ageism as an illiteracy. should be restricted to real consequences, not just sub- He also purports, ironically, not to understand its mean- sequent events; he notes that the consequences are usu- ing. Ageism is a product of that new use of-ism to mean ally unpleasant but does not insist that they must be. "prejudice, discrimination," which seems to derive Gowers in Fowler 1965 sees extended use as "firmly from racism and earlier gave the language sexism. At established" and thinks it pedantry to object to the worst, the word might be judged rather trendy (it origi- unpleasant aspect of the meaning on etymological nated around 1970): grounds (as it would be, if anyone did so). Copperud " . . . Don't leave anything valuable lying around, like 1970 thinks they both favor restriction to unpleasant your stash. She's one heavy old lady, and we let her results, which is not quite the case, and he agrees. move in because we wanted to make a statement Clearly a tangle of opinion surrounds this word, but as about ageism in America, but she's got these sticky the examples above show, the opinion really does not fingers " —Cyra McFadden, The Serial, 1977 matter. Both figurative senses are well established in standard writing. . . . Granny Jump is a living warning against ageism Since aftermath originally referred to a crop that —Joy Chant, Times Literary Supp., 28 Mar. 1980 grows after a first crop is cut, it is easy to see how it came . . . few gerontologists... have taken up arms against to be used figuratively for one thing that happened after one of the most insidious forms of ageism—the another. How it came to acquire its generally unpleasant myth of senility —Robin M. Henig, N.Y. Times connotations is not so clear. Here are two hints. The Mag., 3 Dec. 1978 OED cites the poet Robert Southey as writing "No after- math has the . . . sweetness of the first crop" and the Such ageism may well be a major reason many peo- poet Coventry Patmore as using the phrase "the bloom- ple age poorly in this society —Ann E. Gerike, letter, less aftermath." Beyond these suggestions of disappoint- Newsweek, 17 Nov. 1986 agenda 47 agenda Our files show that the word has even reached Australia, This singular agenda has continued in standard use: so it may be with us for a while. Some writers will find it a conveniently brief way of putting a notion that oth- There was an agenda or program of the conference erwise requires a phrase; others may well prefer to leave — The Autobiography of William Allen White, 1946 it alone. The original agenda, which was to have covered many motions —Mollie Panter-Downes, New agenda Everybody agrees, according to Copperud Yorker, 13 Oct. 1951 1970, 1980, that agenda is standard in English as a sin- gular, with agendas as its plural. We have about a dozen It's a vast agenda —Pi ime Minister Harold Wilson, commentators—both English and American—who are BBC radio broadcast, 1 June 1967 also in agreement in addition to Copperud's group of experts. Against this formidable array stands the OED President Carter's agenda for America is too impor- Supplement: tant to be jeopardized by a defense of the indefensi- ble —Norman Cousins, Saturday Rev., 2 Apr. 1977 agenda . . . treated as a singular (a use now increas- ingly found but avoided by careful writers). But many have another agenda as well —Elizabeth Drew, New Yorker, 6 Dec. 1982 The OED Supplement is supported by a couple of letter writers: the novelist Upton Sinclair objecting to the In those instances where a plural is necessary, agen- appearance of "a broad agenda" in the New Republic in das is the standard form. The OED Supplement shows 1951 and a correspondent to William Safire in the New agendas as early as 1907. Our evidence suggests that the York Times in 1984 objecting to "a hidden agenda." plural is relatively uncommon. Everyone further agrees that agenda is the plural of agendum in Latin. The use of agendum in English to The two agendas, which were not as far apart as the mean "a list or program" is considered a slip by Evans draft agendas of some past East-West conferences — 1961 and pedantic by a few other commentators. It is Time, 12 Mar. 1951 considerably less frequent than agenda, but it has been in use since 1898 and is entered as standard in But the agendas of faculty meetings rarely include dictionaries. such issues —Ruth R. Hawkins, Change, Novem- ber-December 1969 Each instructor or student leader receives an agen- dum of suggested "overhead" or general discussion . . . a Trojan horse filled full of all kinds of budget- questions —Major James L. Jackson, Ph.D., College busting measures and secondary agendas —David English, March 1954 A. Stockman, quoted by William Greider, Atlantic, December 1981 Many commentators say that agendum means "something to be done." This is more a direct transla- Agendum, usually in the form agenda, has some rela- tion of the Latin word than a well-established meaning tively infrequent use to mean "an item on the agenda": in English. In fact, it is so rare in English that it is not recognized in Webster's Third. But it does exist: They should have the right to initiate agenda, to dis- cuss the entire range of university concerns —Wil- Principal agendum of the pages standing at the ros- liam M. Roth, Saturday Rev., 10 Jan. 1970 trum steps was to lift the train of each ascending del- egate with combined dexterity, good timing and dis- This use may be curtailed by the use of the wordier but cretion —Time, 2 May 1938 self-explanatory agenda item to convey the same sense: The present use of agenda did not arise until the end . . . it may be useful to survey some of the agenda of the 19th century. It barely made the OED, which items and problem areas he will confront —Samuel included a single italicized example from 1882 under Halperin, Change, January-February 1971 the entry agend, a spelling no longer used. It appears to . . . the President moved on to other agenda items have caught on quickly enough—agenda-paper appear- without asking for reactions —Irving Janis, Psychol- ing in 1887, agendum in 1898. The use of agenda for the ogy Today, November 1971 list was such a rapid development that dictionaries had not yet caught up with it when this Kansas journalist felt William Safire (N. Y. Times Mag., 16 Sept. 1984) tries it necessary to explain details of usage in 1928: to trace the development of the expression hidden An "agendum" is "something to be done." In the agenda. He finds its roots in the use of agenda for a plural—"agenda"—it means a "memorandum political program, a use that has been around since at book." In diplomatic speech it comes nearer to sig- least the 1950s: nifying a "program." In this sense it's most conve- It now appeared that military aggression was most niently mentioned in the singular, rather than the definitely on the agenda of international Commu- plural—one "agenda," not a whole flock of "agen- nism —Edgar S. Furniss, Jr., Yale Rev., Autumn dums." —Charles P. Stewart, Emporia (Kans.) 1954 Gazette, 11 Feb. 1928 Our earliest citation for hidden agenda suggests that the The feeling that agenda referred to a single entity was term was already familiar when the author used it: developed early: . . . it was resolved that "items 1 to 4 on the agenda The schooling process has a hidden agenda—an need not be discussed" —The Strand, September invisible curriculum—that sorts knowledge into 1900 packages . . . ; that categorizes persons as successes or failures with a fixed criterion; that mistakes con- The agenda drawn up for the Congress contains the formity for allegiance —John Gagnon, Change, following items —Soviet Union Rev., 31 Jan. 1925 October 1971 aggravate 48 aggravate The collection had indeed a hidden agenda—it was so often does, and that the condemnation of this use a running argument with Stalinism —Steven Mar- of aggravate has become a fetish. cus, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 8 Feb. 1976 Copperud 1970: The consensus is that the struggle to The phrase continues to be popular: limit aggravate to the traditional sense has been lost. In a field where polemics and ideology are the norm, Sellers 1975: Aggravate and annoy are not Walker's book is a refreshing exception. It has no synonymous. hidden agenda —Stephen Stich, Times Literary Supp., 29 Apr. 1983 Bander 1978: This word is incorrect in the sense of irritate or annoy. This credibility could not be long sustained if readers come to believe that our articles are tainted by some Little, Brown 1980: . . . in writing it should not be hidden agenda —Wall Street Jour., 3 Apr. 1984 used in its colloquial meaning of "irritate" or "exasperate." In the last two examples, hidden agenda is beginning to come close in meaning to ulterior motive. Reader's Digest 1983: The use of aggravate to mean Agenda, then, is fully established as a singular in stan- 'irritate, anger'... is standard and correct. dard English, with a plural agendas available, if you Einstein 1985: To aggravate is to take something need it. Agendum, with a plural agenda, has infrequent that irritates and make it worse. use as "something to be done," slightly greater use as "an item in an agenda," and some use as an equiva- There are many more commentators, but by now the lent to agenda. Agenda and agendum also have a few general idea is clear: in recent years opinion has begun other uses; for them we recommend an unabridged to swing away from the White-Mill condemnation, but dictionary. there are still holdouts. For other foreign plurals, see LATIN PLURALS. Aggravate was introduced into English in the 16th century, straight from the past participle of the Latin aggravate, aggravation, aggravating There is a verb aggravare, "to make heavier." It replaced an earlier body of opinion with a long tradition holding that word aggrege, used by Chaucer and earlier writers, aggravate should only be used to mean "make worse" which had dropped out of use around 1500. It was first and that its use to mean "irritate, exasperate, annoy" is used in several senses now obsolete but by 1597 was wrong, incorrect, childish, vulgar, colloquial, or (at best) being used in its "make worse" sense. Only fourteen informal. A good deal of expressed opinion on this topic years later, in 1611, it appeared in the "annoy" sense. has accumulated since Richard Grant White con- The 1611 use is by one Randle Cotgrave, who used it demned it in 1870 and John Stuart Mill labeled it "a (along with exasperate) to gloss a word in his French- vulgarism of the nursery" in one of the later editions of English dictionary. Clearly Cotgrave considered the his A System of Logic (1872), but it is by no means meaning familiar enough to make aggravate useful as a unanimous. Here is a sampling: gloss. The evidence suggests, however, that the "annoy" Richard Grant White 1870: . . . misused by many sense was primarily in spoken use. The OED, which persons ignorantly... by many others thoughtlessly, labels the sense familiar, shows only a 17th-century in the sense of provoke, irritate, anger. book of travels and Samuel Richardson's epistolary Hodgson 1889: Its employment as a synonym for novel Clarissa (1748) before the 19th century. Samuel 'irritate' or 'vex,' being quite superfluous, cannot be Pegge, a Londoner interested in dialect, included the defended "annoy" sense in a list of Cockneyisms he published in 1807—further evidence that the sense was current in Bierce 1909: But a person cannot be aggravated, speech. Some of our earlier American citations also even if disagreeable or bad. Women are singularly come from the realm of speech—even though fictional: prone to misuse of this word. . . . for writin' only aggravates your opponents, and Utter 1 9 1 6 : . . . we may aggravate a man's ill temper never convinces them —Thomas C. Haliburton, . . . but not the man himself. The Clockmaker, 1837 Whipple 1924: Aggravate means to make worse and "O, go 'long with you, Tom, before you aggravate me never should be used as a synonym for annoy, exas- again " —Mark Twain, Tom Sawyer, 1876 perate, or vex. Fowler 1 9 2 6 : . . . should be left to the uneducated. It It seems likely that during the 19th century the usage is for the most part a feminine or childish colloqui- of the "annoy" sense increased, especially in writing or alism printing. Mill complains that it "has crept into almost all newspapers, and into many books"; White's dislike Treble & Vallins 1937: The use of aggravate with a may have been similarly inspired, as many of his com- personal object... is purely colloquial It should plaints about language are based on journalistic exam- never appear in written English. ples. White's objection, however, seems to center pri- marily on etymology—he insists on the literalness of Bernstein 1958: . . . it should not be used to mean "make heavier" and conveniently ignores the extension "irritate" or "exasperate." of meaning to "make worse." (The etymology of this Shaw 1970: Standard usage: Sneezing aggravated his word still comes in for mention—as recently as Free- wound. The mosquito annoyed—not aggravated— man 1983 and Kilpatrick 1984.) One of the earlier expositors of etymology, Hodgson (1889), rather under- me. mines his own argument, in the course of showing off Fowler 1965 (Gowers's revision): It is time to rec- his knowledge of Latin, by revealing that the secondary ognize that usage has beaten the grammarians, as it sense of aggravare is "to bear down upon or annoy." aggravate 49 aggravate Sir Ernest Growers in Plain Words (1947) credits The noun aggravation has been used in the sense Dickens with giving "powerful encouragement" to the "irritation" at least since the time of Jane Austen: usage, and, if appearance in novels counts for a bit more than newspaper use, then Dickens and Thackeray prob- . . . and to have Miss Crawford's liveliness repeated ably were influential. They are cited, at least, as evi- to her at such a moment, and on such a subject, was dence for the sense in numerous dictionaries. Gowers a bigger aggravation —Jane Austen, Mansfield Park, further observes (in Fowler 1965) that "writers have 1814 shown no less persistence in refusing to be trammeled " . . . his showing he took me for anything wonderful by this admonition [to avoid the use]." Here are a few would have been, I think," the young man reflected, examples from a number of writers (and the speech of "but an aggravation the more." —Henry James, The one U.S. President) in a variety of settings: Ivory Tower, 1917 'I'm very much obliged to you, Misses Brown,' said Aggravations between people South and North were the unfortunate youth, greatly aggravated —Charles getting worse —Carl Sandburg, Abraham Lincoln, Dickens, Dombey and Son, 1848 (OED) 1926 . . . no doubt our two countries aggravate each other The "irritation" sense divides usage with earlier senses from time to time —Oliver Wendell Holmes d. about evenly, but our most recent evidence shows that 1935, letter to Sir Frederick Pollock, 27 Dec. 1895 it is beginning to predominate. There are times when the French get aggravated and The participial adjective aggravating has seldom been displeased by us —Jimmy Carter, quoted in N.Y. used to mean anything except "annoying" since early in Times, 14 Feb. 1980 the 19th century; it may have been, in fact, what set the critics off (it is the form cited by Mill). It is certainly well She noticed his pleasant and contented manner . . . attested: and it merely aggravated her the more —Theodore Dreiser, Sister Carrie, 1900 . . . its grievances had become so numerous and The mere sight of her twisted mouth . . . seemed to aggravating —Diedrich Knickerbocker (Washington aggravate him to further abuse —John Cowper Irving), A History of New York, 1809 Powys, Ducdame, 1925 . . . kicking pupils with his nailed boots, pulling the . . . he aggravated 'em a lot by making 'em think he hair of some of the smaller boys, pinching the others would —Will James, Smoky, 1926 in aggravating places —Charles Dickens, Nicholas Nickleby, 1839 The man's lack of friends amazed and then began to aggravate and trouble Clancy —John Cheever, New . . . the summons had to be taken out at Stratford-le- Yorker, 24 Mar. 1951 Bow (that is where this aggravating man is living) — Lewis Carroll, letter, 11 Nov. 1886 Nothing so aggravates an earnest person as a passive resistance —Herman Melville, "Bartleby the Scriv- Among the many b o y s . . . was one more aggravating ener," 1856 than the rest —Rudyard Kipling, "Baa Baa, Black Sheep," 1888 . . . the celebrated incident of Mr. Yarborough's declining to participate directly in the motorcade, . . . only it is aggravating to have you talking about . . . greatly aggravating the President —William F. so small a business —George Bernard Shaw, letter to Buckley, Jr., National Rev., 19 Nov. 1971 Ellen Terry, 16 Sept. 1896 Keitel... was aggravated at the delay —William L. But Archbishop Tenison, though much out of favour Shirer, The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, 1960 with the Queen, outlived her in a most aggravating manner —G. M. Trevelyan, Blenheim, 1930 (Gow- . . . when his silly conceit and his youthful pompos- ers 1948) ity about his not-very-good early work has begun to aggravate us —William Styron, This Quiet Dust and The final effect is interesting, but aggravating — Other Writings, 1982 Irwin Shaw, New Republic, 29 Dec. 1947 John Stuart Mill's comments contained the complaint . . . he can be extremely aggravating and silly —Cyril that when the word is used in its proper sense, the mean- Connolly, The Condemned Playground, 1946 ing "it is probable, is already misunderstood." Jespersen 1905, who reprinted Mill's comments, remarked that he . . . all the funny papers and Coca-Cola pictures plas- "exaggerated." This is surely true: the "make worse" tering the walls were, he complained, crooked and sense of aggravate is by far the more common in edited aggravating —Truman Capote, Other Voices, Other prose, and there never seems to have been a problem of Rooms, 1948 misunderstanding. Dickens certainly used the sense as . . . blow hot, blow cold, the most aggravating man well as the "annoy" sense: —Herman Wouk, Marjorie Morningstar, 1955 'I have a long series of insults to avenge,' said Nich- . . . this most stimulating, original, aggravating olas, flushed with passion; 'and my indignation is writer —Times Literary Supp., 28 Sept. 1967 aggravated by the dastardly cruelties practiced on helpless infancy in this foul den.' —Charles Dickens, Aggravating as they were to Flaubert —William Sty- Nicholas Nickleby, 1839 ron, This Quiet Dust and Other Writings, 1982 The "make worse" sense continues in vigorous use Conclusion: the senses of aggravate, aggravation, and today and remains the primary meaning of the verb. aggravating involving annoyance were strongly estab- The case with the derivatives aggravation and aggra- lished well before John Stuart Mill and Richard Grant vating is somewhat different, however. White found fault with them. They seem never to have aggress 50 agree been entirely vulgarisms, as some early commentators . . . it is difficult not to agree with Byron that Pope asserted, and there is no doubt that they continue well was profoundly moved when he wrote this poem — established in speech and writing today. They are stan- Bonamy Dobrée, English Literature in the Early dard. Aggravate in this sense is considerably less fre- Eighteenth Century, 1700-1740, 1959 quent in edited prose than in the "make worse" sense; aggravation is somewhat more likely to mean "irrita- . . . he agreed with Lowell's opposition to the war — tion" than not; aggravating is seldom used except to Eric F. Goldman, Harper's, January 1969 express annoyance. Latin has a much better-developed system of adjec- tive-noun concord. Every adjective must agree with aggress Heritage 1982 notes some current objection its noun in three categories: number, gender, and to aggress as psychology jargon even though the verb case —H. A. Gleason, Jr., An Introduction to has long been in use. We have but slight evidence of the Descriptive Linguistics, rev. éd., 1961 verb's questionable status: This agrees with seismic evidence —C. A. Cotton, I asked him [Harvey Kurzman] if women could be Geographical Jour., June 1953 funny in print. "Absolutely not," he said, "they don't Four of the nation's leading white urbanologists . . . aggress as well as men. (Author's note: his verb) " were agreed about the nature of the urban crisis — —Janie T. Gaynor, Harper's Weekly, 14 June 1976 Allen B. Ballard, Change, March 1973 Our evidence shows that aggress has been more or less . . . they agreed as to the unreadiness of Italian confined to contexts dealing with behavior and psychol- Somaliland for political independence —Collier's ogy during the past twenty years or so, but from the time Year Book, 1949 of World War II well into the 1950s it was used primar- ily in political contexts. Here is a sample of the older . . . no two of his admirers would be likely to agree usage; the last citation is probably partly psychological: in their selection —Bliss Perry, The Pocket Univer- sity, 1924 [Von Ribbentrop] said it was not Germany who had aggressed against Poland —Sir Nevile Henderson, We agreed in our estimate of Beecham —The Jour- Life, 16 Oct. 1939 nals of Arnold Bennett, ed. Frank Swinnerton, 1954 The Peiping Politburo may decide neither to aggress . . . as so often in morals and in motivation, the further nor to negotiate - i V T . Times, 4 Feb. 1951 upper and lower classes agree against the middle — Basil Cottle, in Michaels & Ricks 1980 Westerners even aggressed against one another — Adlai E. Stevenson, Call to Greatness, 1954 Evans 1957 reminds us that agree is also commonly followed by a clause or an infinitive phrase: Yet it would appear from recent events that the users of force rarely think they are aggressing, and never Traditional theories of esthetics agreed that coherent admit they are —E. B. White, New Yorker, 15 Dec. form emerges from the basic principle of fused ele- 1956 ments —Frederick Goldman & Linda R. Burnett, Need Johnny Read?, 1971 . . . stay away from those of lesser rank, for fear of being aggressed against —Norman Podhoretz, Mak- . . . Deerslayer agrees to surrender his claims —Rich- ing It, 1967 ard Poirier, A World Elsewhere, 1966 2. In British use, the transitive agree often replaces the ago See SINCE 2. agree on or agree to of American English. Longman 1984, Chambers 1985, and Burchfield 1982 find these agree 1 . Numerous handbooks from as long ago as uses acceptable; Gowers (in Fowler 1965) accepts agree 1917 to the 1980s tell us that agree takes various prep- "agree on" but not agree "agree to." Frederick T. Wood, ositions idiomatically in various senses. The preposi- English Verbal Idioms ( 1964), thinks the use exists only tions to, on, and with are most frequently mentioned, in the passive; it is, however, also active. Here are some but some sources—chiefly older ones—mention others. examples. Note that you can substitute either agree on Here is a selection of typical constructions with various or agree to in some of them, a fact which may suggest prepositions; of all these only in seems to be showing that Gowers's distinction is a bit overcareful. signs of age. " . . . since this has to be, in its small way, a combined . . . the company agreed to mediation —Current operation, we should want to agree the commander Biography, June 1953 with you people." —Nevil Shute, Most Secret, 1945 . . . members of the Swedish Academy failed to agree . . . and after much discussion the following articles on a candidate —Current Biography 1951 were agreed —Sir Winston Churchill, Closing the Ring, 1951 ... they were always agreed on what movie they should see —Katherine Anne Porter, Ladies' Home This no doubt was what Lord Salisbury agreed at the Jour., August 1971 Little Bermuda conference —New Statesman & In 1831 the payment by France of outstanding Nation, 17 Oct. 1953 claims . . . was agreed upon by treaty —Francis D. The price has yet to be agreed —Times Literary Wormuth, "The Vietnam War: The President versus Supp., 21 May 1970 the Constitution," April 1968 Some of the invaders returned to the Continent but Christ, the boondocks of Oregon must agree with others, after agreeing peace terms, twice raided the you, Stan —Lee Marvin, quoted in Rolling Stone, 21 country south of the Thames —D. J. V. Fisher, The Dec. 1972 Anglo-Saxon Age, 1973 agreement 51 agreement: indefinite pronouns On a small job you will probably have to agree a set verb, and that proximity agreement is more often found fee with your architect —John Bath, Australian in unplanned discourse than in writing. Home Beautiful, June 1975 Fries 1940 notes that gross violations of concord— use of a number-distinctive form that matches neither As the awaited seed catalogues arrive there are long the formal nor the notional number of the subject—are discussions . . . with the housekeeper to agree vege- found only in uneducated English. Sentences like table and herb varieties —This England, Winter 1983 And them bass fiddles that's electrified, they're so loud, and the average man that plays 'em don't know This use is rare but not unknown in the U.S.: how to turn 'em down —Birch Monroe, quoted in But as happens so often with U.S.-Japan conversa- Bluegrass Unlimited, September 1982 tions, the parties departed with different impressions that are typical of the speech of uneducated people, are of what had been agreed —Sol W. Sanders, Business seldom treated in books on usage and grammar, simply Week, 23 Mar. 1981 because everyone recognizes them as nonstandard. They will not receive much attention in this book either. agreement In this book agreement usually refers to In the articles immediately following, we have broken either the agreement in number between the subject and the large subject of agreement into several smaller sec- verb of a sentence, or to the agreement in number tions, which we hope you will find easier to refer to than between a pronoun and its antecedent. The term con- one long treatment would be. In addition, many specific cord, used by some American and many British writers, problems that usage writers treat separately have been can be considered a synonym; it turns up here and there put at their own places. See, for instance, AS WELL AS; in various articles, especially in the terms notional con- EACH; MANY A; NONE; ONE OF THOSE WHO; THERE IS, THERE cord a.n<\ formal (or grammatical) concord. There are, in ARE; THEY, THEIR, THEM. fact, two kinds of agreement in English: There are two kinds of concord: formal concord, in agreement: collective nouns See COLLECTIVE NOUNS. which there is harmony of form, and notional con- cord, in which there is harmony of meaning. In such a sentence as "Two boys were in the room," we have agreement: indefinite pronouns The indefinite pro- both formal and notional concord, the subject and nouns anybody, anyone, each, either, everybody, every- the verb both being plural in both form and mean- one, neither, nobody, somebody, someone share an inter- ing. But sometimes we have notional concord only, esting and often perplexing characteristic: they are as "None were left," where the subject, though sin- usually grammatically singular and often notionally plu- gular in form, takes a plural verb because it is plural ral. The result is mixed usage with respect to number in meaning; and sometimes we have formal concord agreement with verbs and pronouns. only, as "Everybody was late," where the subject, Bryant 1962 reports 25 studies of verb agreement with though plural in meaning, takes a singular verb indefinite pronouns and finds both singular and plural because it is singular in form —Paul Roberts, Under- verbs in use, but with the singular outnumbering the standing Grammar, 1954 plural in the ratio of six to one. Curme 1931 and Quirk et al. 1985 both say the singular verb is usual; the sin- It appears that in early modern English the pull of gular verb also predominates in the Merriam-Webster notional agreement (or concord) was very strong. files. Curme associates the occurrence of a plural verb McKnight 1928, after quoting sentences from the 17th- after any of the indefinite pronouns (except neither) century writers Francis Bacon, Thomas Browne, and with older English (he cites Tom Jones, for instance). John Milton, says: You are safe in assuming that the singular verb will be right. The grammatical number in pronoun or verb is Pronoun agreement has been more problematical. determined by the number, plural or singular, of the Conflict here revolves around the use of the pronouns idea rather than by the grammatical number of the they, their, them, themselves to refer to the indefinite subject Obviously the earlier Elizabethan free- pronouns. Such use, OED evidence shows, goes back to dom had not yet been reduced to formal grammati- the 14th century. It has been disparaged as improper cal regularity. since the 18th century, however, when such grammari- ans as Lowth and Lindley Murray decreed the indefinite The tug-of-war between notional and formal agreement pronouns singular. Two considerations have strength- underlies most of the agreement problems we deal with. ened the use of the plural pronoun in reference to a pre- There is one additional contributor to these problems. ceding indefinite. The first is notional concord; the indef- It is what Quirk et al. 1985 calls the principle of prox- inite pronouns are often notionally plural—some, imity (it is also called attraction and blind agreement)— indeed, more often than others—and in early modern the agreement of the verb with a noun or pronoun inter- English (before the 18th century) agreement is largely vening between it and the subject. No doubt it likewise governed by notional concord. The other is the much- was in operation at an early time. Here is an instance touted lack of a common-gender third person singular written by Swift and cited by Strang 1970: pronoun in English. How early they, their, them begins The common weight of these Halfpence are . . . to be used as a common-gender singular is uncertain; perhaps Sir Kenelm Digby's use of their referring back The verb are here matches Halfpence rather than to one in the middle of the 17th century (cited in the weight; it appears in the sentence as printed in 1724. OED) represents such a use. Strang tells us that in 1725 are was corrected to is. Quirk Let us look at a few examples from the letters of remarks that conflict between formal concord and Thomas Gray, written in the second quarter of the 18th attraction through proximity tends to increase with the century, nearly a quarter century before Lowth and a distance between the noun head (true subject) and the half century before Murray. In the first he speaks of agreement, notional 52 agreement, pronoun "People of high quality" in Paris and of their devotion . . . always look around . . . to see if any of the girls to gambling: playing in the street was her, but they never were — Bernard Malamud, The Magic Barrel, 1958 Another thing is, there is not a House where they don't play, nor is any one at all acceptable, unless Whenever anyone uses the pressure of usage to force they do so too —21 Apr. 1739 you to accept the nonsensical and swallow the sole- cism, here's what to tell them —Safire 1984 Notional agreement seems to explain they in this instance, as it does in the next: agreement, notional See NOTIONAL AGREEMENT, NO- . . . if any body don't like their Commons, they send TIONAL CONCORD. down into the Kitchen —31 Oct. 1734 agreement: organizations considered as collective In this letter Gray is complaining of not being written nouns Quirk et al. 1985 says that collective nouns to; them might be interpreted here as a common-gender "differ from other nouns in taking as pronoun corefer- singular: ents either singular it and relative which or plural they and relative who without change of number in the What! to let any body reside three months at noun " Copperud 1970 (under collective nouns) Rheims, and write but once to them? —18 Sept. asserts, "Ordinarily, nouns for organizations considered 1739 as an entity, like company, are referred to by //, not At any rate the plural pronouns, whether through they " notional agreement or through being used as common- Copperud is too dogmatic. Our evidence shows that gender singulars, were well entrenched when Lowth names of companies and other organizations function issued his opinion, as his footnote attests; in it he cor- like other collective nouns, being sometimes singular rects the translators of the King James Bfble, Addison and sometimes plural (see also COLLECTIVE NOUNS). A in The Spectator, and Richard Bentley, the scholar and few examples of the singular construction: critic. Lindley Murray has even more passages to cor- And Harvard may consider itself very fortunate — rect, but their authors are unidentified. Lowth's tradi- President's Report, Harvard University, 1950-1951 tion continued deep into the 19th century. Hodgson 1889, for instance, corrects the grammar of such sea- . . . until GM was tooling up for its 1940 models — soned practitioners as Mrs. Gaskell, Jane Austen, Syd- American Mercury, May 1953 ney Smith, John Ruskin, Charles Reade, and Leslie Ste- phen. (Our latter-day critics satisfy themselves with Some examples of the plural: smaller game, reproving anonymous journalists, media The D.A.R. are going to do another pageant —Sin- personalities, and a mixed bag of educators and bureau- clair Lewis, Dodsworth, 1929 crats.) Hodgson also notes the problem of the common- gender singular; he cites a 19th-century grammarian The NBS now admit that they can confirm —New named Bain, who approved the plural use. "Grammar- Republic, 11 May 1953 ians," writes Bain, "frequently call this construction an error, not reflecting that it is equally an error to apply The announcement by the University of Oklahoma 'his' to feminine subjects. The best writers (Defoe, Press that they are reissuing —The Pleasures of Pub- Paley, Byron, Miss Austen, &c.) furnish examples of the lishing, August-September 1954 use of the plural as a mode of getting out of the diffi- I wrote to the Pinkerton Tobacco Company.... Mr. culty." The professor's tolerant attitude toward the plu- E. D. Wanamaker, their president —Curtis I. Kohn, ral did not satisfy Hodgson, however; he insisted that in Safire 1982 the gender difficulty should be removed by revision (the same advice set forth in such 20th-century sources as And like other collective nouns, organizations some- Bernstein 1962 and Bremner 1980). times appear with a singular verb but a plural pronoun Curme 1931 found the use of the plural to be typical in reference: of older literature and to have survived in popular . . . M-G-M . . . hopes to sell their records in 5,000 speech; Bryant 1962 considers they, their, them estab- key stores —Time, 2 4 Feb. 1947 lished as the third person common-gender singular in all but the most formal usage. . . . the National Bureau of Standards has not been The howls of the spiritual descendents of Lowth and sufficiently objective, because they discount entirely Lindley Murray notwithstanding, the plural they, their, the play of the market place —New Republic, 13 Apr. them with an indefinite pronoun as referent is in com- 1953 mon standard use, both as common-gender singular and to reflect notional agreement. We give you a few exam- Chrysler is the only American car maker who builds ples below. Since many of the individual indefinite pro- their convertible from start to finish —cited by Wil- nouns have received considerable comment, they have liam Safire, NY. Times Mag., 15 June 1986 been treated separately (see ANYBODY, ANYONE; EACH; It seems reasonable to expect that use of the plural pro- EVERYBODY, EVERYONE, for instance), and more examples noun, even after the singular verb, will continue to of each will appear at those entries. flourish as large corporations, through their advertising and public-relations releases, try to present a more . . . nothing was done without a clatter, nobody sat human and less monolithic face to the public. still, and nobody could command attention when they spoke —Jane Austen, Mansfield Park, 1814 agreement, pronoun: nouns joined by and, or Someone told me last night that they —Eleanor When the 18th-century grammarians were laying down Roosevelt, "My Day," 1941, cited in H. L. Mencken, the law of grammatical agreement, Lowth 1762—in a The American Language, Supplement II, 1948 footnote—made the statement that the "conjunction agreement, pronoun 53 agreement, subject-verb disjunctive," or, requires agreement in the singular ing their time —R. B. McKerrow, Rev. of English number. To illustrate his point, he reprinted this Studies, XVI, 1940 sentence: No man or woman can hesitate to give what they A man may see a metaphor, or an allegory, in a pic- have —Woodrow Wilson, speech, 17 Sept. 1918 (in ture, as well as read them (it) in a description — H. L. Mencken, The American Language, abridged, Joseph Addison, Dialogues upon the Usefulness of 1963) Ancient Medals, 1702 Mencken notes that this is the line as Wilson spoke it, Lowth, of course, was correcting Addison's them to //. according to the papers reporting it. But when it was It was a general practice of the 18th-century grammari- published in his Selected... Addresses, the professional ans to give examples that contravened their rules, for Wilson emended "they have" to "he or she has." purposes of correction; the practice has for us moderns In our view, singular nouns joined by and will seldom the weakness of leaving us wondering whether anybody present a problem; notional and grammatical agreement did, in fact, follow the rules the grammarians laid down. will join to call for a plural pronoun. When singular Addison, one of the master stylists of English prose who nouns are joined by or, notional and grammatical agree- died in 1719 and never knew that grammarians a half ment will likely conflict. It would appear that the farther century later would make frequent use of him as a bad the pronoun is from the set of nouns referred to, the example, was simply following notional agreement, as more likely it is to be plural in accordance with notional everyone did before the middle of the 18th century. agreement. And the farther the pronoun is from its refer- Notional agreement did not disappear with the preach- ent, the less likely it is to be noticed by some zealous ments of Lowth and his contemporaries, moreover, as a spiritual descendant of Bishop Lowth. You should feel perusal of articles in this book will demonstrate. free to use a plural pronoun where it sounds right and When singular nouns are joined by and, notional natural to you, even though some stickler for grammat- agreement will not often clash with grammatical agree- ical agreement may spot it. Where it does not seem nat- ment (but see some of the examples at EACH): ural, stick to the singular. Ask yourself who was the greater writer—Addison or Lowth? One goaded professor once denied that two & two make four, merely because a pro-Adler student said they did --Time, 17 Feb. 1952 agreement, pronoun: singular nouns with plural pronouns See THEY, THEIR, THEM. . . . in a gentle stupefaction of mind, & very tolerable health of body hitherto. If they last, I shall not much complain —Thomas Gray, letter, 5 Mar. 1766 agreement, subject-verb: a bunch of the boys But singular nouns joined by or are more likely to be A bunch of the boys were whooping it up in the affected by notional agreement at the expense of gram- Malamute saloon —Robert W. Service, "The Shoot- matical agreement (as Lowth well knew but could not ing of Dan McGrew," 1907 accept): The usage question is this: should the verb be were or We shall be pleased to send a free specimen copy . . . was whooping it up? The answer, say the experts (Kil- to a friend or relative on receipt of their address — patrick in Pittsburgh Press, 11 Aug. 1985, Jacques Bar- advt, London Calling, 2 2 July 1954 zun in Safire 1982, Winners & Sinners, 5 Aug. 1983), is were. Why? There are several reasons. First, we can see . . . no lady or gentleman would so far forget them- two of the three forces that chiefly determine agree- selves —George Bernard Shaw, Plays Pleasant and ment—proximity and notional agreement—pulling in Unpleasant, 1898 (in Jespersen) the direction of the plural. Second, we have the plain How quickly the American student makes friends sense of the subject-verb relation: the boys whoop, not with a book or a man and treats them as if they were the bunch. And if boys is the real subject of the sentence, his contemporaries —Time, 2 Aug. 1954 then the phrase a bunch of is functioning essentially as a modifier—it is, in fact, very similar to what many We would soon become a nation of sleepless neurot- modern grammarians call a predeterminer. Here are a ics if the average man or woman was not endowed few more examples: with courage, some common sense, and the ability to resist the continual assaults against their peace of A rash of stories in the Chicago media have reported mind —Harrison Smith, Saturday Rev., 30 Jan. —cited by James J. Kilpatrick, Pittsburgh Press Sun- 1954 day Mag., 11 Aug. 1985 . . . a man or a woman would come in here, glance Yet the flock of acolytes surrounding each jefe are around, find smiles and pleasant looks waiting for not expected to justify their servility —Alan Riding, them, then wave and sit down by themselves — Distant Neighbors: A Portrait of the Mexicans, 1985 Doris Lessing (in Reader's Digest 1983) A crew of Pyrates are driven —Jonathan Swift, Gul- In the next example the author starts out with the him liver's Travels, 1726 (in McKnight 1928) or her prescribed by grammatical agreement, but then A set of writers have lately sprung up in England — abandons it for the less unwieldy plural pronouns of Columbia Mag., March 1787 (in Shopen & Williams notional agreement: 1980) If you have a young brother or sister of, say, fifteen . . . a host of people who are interested in language years old or so, think that you have him or her before —Charlton Laird, Foreword to Finegan 1980 you and that you are trying to explain the point of your article to them and at the same time to prevent A trio of génies are —Bryant Gumble, cited from a them from thinking what an ass you are to be wast- television broadcast in Counterforce, June 1983 agreement, subject-verb 54 agreement, subject-verb . . . a class of sentences which are superficially par- But, notwithstanding this, if the subject of the affir- allel —Brian Joseph, Language, June 1980 mation be nearly related, the verb is rather better in the singular number. Nothing but the marvellous and Thus, only a fraction of such deposits are actually supernatural hath any charms for them. insured —Consumer Reports, January 1983 Moreover, the preponderance of users view trans- Priestley's approach is reflected in some 20th-century parency as blue-sky technology —Eugene Lowen- commentators (Vizetelly 1906, Barzun 1975, Freeman thal, Datamation, August 1982 1983, who quotes Fowler), but where our moderns allow the singular verb with compound singular nouns close Though experts and common sense agree that the plu- in thought, Priestley rather insisted on it, quoting David ral verb is natural and correct, actual usage still shows a Hume's "His politeness and obliging behaviour few holdouts for the singular verb. Except for the first— were changed" and saying "was would have read Lindley Murray perhaps was too conscious of the gram- better." matical subject—the examples below may be the result The insistence that only the plural verb is correct of nervous copy editors or indecision on the part of the seems to have begun with a writer named Philip Withers writers: in 1788 (cited in Leonard 1929); his attack on the sin- gular verb was based entirely on logic. He appears to . . . many errors have been committed: a number of have influenced several later grammarians including which is subjoined, as a further caution —Lindley Lindley Murray 1795. Murray assembled his grammar Murray 1795 (but the errors are subjoined, not a largely from Lowth and Priestley, but in this instance he number) insists on the plural verb, mentioning Lowth's excep- . . . a set of numbered rods, developed by John tions but finding them "evidently contrary to the first Napier, which was used for calculating —Ellen Rich- principles of grammar." man, Spotlight on Computer Literacy, 1982 Modern grammarians are not so insistent.. Curme 1931 and Quirk et al. 1985 agree that in modern practice . . . a neat, little package of words that describes the plural verb prevails after coordinate singular nouns Bird's play —Gerry Finn, Morning Union (Spring- with and: field, Mass.), 29 Jan. 1985 (but the words describe, not the package) While Keats and Chapman were at Heidelberg — Myles na gCopaleen (Flann O'Brien), The Best of . . . are run through a set of computer algorithms that Myles, 1968 rearranges them —The Economist, 17 May 1986 (the algorithms rearrange) . . . Trixie La Monte, Margie White, Florence Lee- per, Donna Rogers, Doris Hudson, Sandra Lee and When you have a collecting noun phrase (a bunch of) Rita Green, who even at the moment you are fasci- before a plural noun (the boys), the sense will normally natedly reading this are probably catching their be plural and so should the verb. deaths of colds by denuding themselves hourly See also NUMBER 1; ONE OF THOSE WHO. somewhere —George Jean Nathan, The Entertain- ment of a Nation, 1942 agreement, subject-verb: compound subjects 1. Joined by "and " Before the 18th-century grammarians . . . the streak of sentimentality and the lack of true undertook to prune the exuberant growth of English, no originality which mark much of his creative writing one seems to have worried whether two or more singu- —New Yorker, 18 Nov. 1985 lar nouns joined by a copulative conjunction (and) took a plural or a singular verb. Writers of the 16th and 17th . . . the bitterness and heartache that fill the world — centuries used whatever verb sounded best and did not Frank Sullivan, A Rock in Every Snowball, 1946 trouble themselves about grammatical agreement. "Scoffing and girding is their daily bread," wrote If the Arab and Israeli left are to develop a common program —Noam Chomsky, Columbia Forum, Gabriel Harvey in his 16th-century dispute with Winter 1969 Thomas Nashe and Robert Greene (cited in McKnight 1928). Shakespeare could write "art and practice hath But both recognize that when the nouns form "a collec- enriched" in Measure for Measure and in Much Ado tive idea" or "a oneness of idea" (the terms are About Nothing "All disquiet, horror, and perturbation Curme's), the singular verb is appropriate—notional follows her" (both cited in McKnight). The King James agreement prevails in such cases. Bible at Daniel 5:14 has "light and understanding and excellent wisdom is found in thee" (cited in Hall 1917). . . . the end of all the privacy and propriety which So when Lowth 1762 set his rule down, he was well was talked about at first —Jane Austen, Mansfield aware of mixed usage. He favored the plural but allowed Park, 1 8 1 4 for the singular "sometimes," using James Greenwood's earlier analysis that the singular verb "is understood as I think the time involved and the red tape is one of applied to each of the preceding terms"; thus, we find in the biggest problems —Richard L. DeChant, Mod- the Bible: ern Industry, February 1967 Sand, and salt, and a mass of iron, is easier to bear, Brinsley, whose education and maintenance was a than a man without understanding —Ecclesiasticus charge on the rates of his native county —Flann 22:18 (Douay), 1609 O'Brien, At Swim-Two-Birds, 1939 Priestley 1761 takes a different approach but reaches a The name and address of the grocery was painted on similar conclusion: the slats —E. L. Doctorow, Loon Lake, 1979 It is a rule, that two distinct subjects of an affirma- Time and patience is necessary —Cats Mag., tion require the verb to be in the plural number December 1981 agreement, subject-verb 55 agreement, subject-verb The News Service's depth and scope represents the However strong the disjunctive notion that Quirk best in American journalism —advt., cited by Wil- finds attached to or (and nor) may be, there is abundant liam Safire, N.Y. Times Mag., 1 May 1983 evidence from the past—and some from modern writ- ers—that the notion of plurality of the subjects can at Curme also notes an exception to the required plural times overbalance that of disjunctiveness. Not only did verb in a way that sounds much like Greenwood and Withers roast Blair for using plural, but Lindley Murray Lowth: "when each of a number of singular noun sub- 1795 accompanied his rule with several counterexam- jects is considered separately, the verb is in the singu- ples using the plural, their authors tastefully suppressed. lar." He cites Emerson: Curme 1931 notes that the negative neither... nor often A fever, a mutilation, a cruel disappointment, a loss contains a plural idea under the negative; he cites sev- of wealth, a loss of friends, seems at the moment eral instances from the 15th century to the 20th, includ- untold loss. ing these: The same principle appears to operate in these cases: Neither search nor labor are necessary —Samuel Johnson, The Idler, No. 44 Every legislator, every doctor, and every citizen needs to recognize —Ronald Reagan, Abortion and Neither he nor his lady were at home —George the Conscience of the Nation, 1984 Washington, diary, 2 Dec. 1789 The power of the algorithm, and the phonological . . . neither the friendship nor the sorrow seem so approach to spelling, is strengthened when the error profound —Robert Bridges, Forum, May 1923 list is examined —Richard E. Hodges & E. Hugh Rudorf, Elementary English, May 1965 More recently we have some unattributed examples col- lected by Kilpatrick 1984 for censure: "Neither price nor We have seen so far that in present-day English coor- menu description are a fair guide" and "Neither Johnny dinate singular nouns compounded by and (or and nor his teacher have mastered the art of writing." understood) usually are followed by a plural verb. The Curme also finds examples with or with no negative singular verb is appropriate when the nouns form a uni- attached; these, he opines, probably come from the tary notion or when they refer to a single person (as in author's feeling that the statement applies in all cases, "My friend and colleague says"). It is also possible to even though applicable to only one or two at a time. He intend that the singular verb be construed with each instances these extracts: noun separately; when such a construction is intended, it should perhaps be accentuated by distributive adjec- My life or death are equal both to me —John tives (as each, every) or punctuation. You should not Dryden forget that some people who evaluate other people's lan- guage have no idea the singular verb can ever be used, A drama or an epic fill the mind —Matthew Arnold, and even those whose understanding does encompass Essays in Criticism this possibility can disagree over what is a single idea— Baker 1770 did not like "what your Justice and Honour Acting, singing, or reciting are forbidden them —H. require" and Safire in 1983 did not like "The News G. Wells Service's depth and scope represents...." Readers What are honor or dishonor to her? —Henry James might well be divided on the acceptability of this example: The notion determining the agreement in these exam- ples often seems to be "this or that or both (or all)." We The consultant and evaluation team has by this time have similar instances among our citations: converted the application task list —Datamation, February 1982 But it's when sex or scurrility are used for their own sakes that they are in bad taste —Flannery O'Con- 2. Joined by "or" (or "nor"). Lowth 1762 says that sin- nor, letter, 10 Mar. 1956 gular nouns joined by or take the singular verb; Priestley 1761 agrees; Leonard 1929 notes that Philip Withers in In summary, compound singular nouns with or or nor Aristarchus (1788) raked the Scottish rhetorician Hugh are supposed to take a singular verb and in current use Blair over the coals for using a plural verb with nouns usually do. The plural verb is most likely to appear joined by or. Quirk et al. 1985 notes that or is notionally where the notion of plurality is suggested by negative disjunctive and that the singular verb is the rule. construction or when the writer is thinking of "this or that or both." . . . if the average man or woman was not endowed with courage —Harrison Smith, Saturday Rev., 30 3. Quasi-coordination by words like "with," "along Jan. 1954 with," "together with" or by punctuation. Quirk et al. 1985 points out that when a singular noun is joined to . . . neither she nor any other of the book's characters another by a quasi-coordinator (the term is Quirk's) like has endurance —E. L. Doctorow, N. Y. Times Book with, rather than, as well as, etc., grammatical concord Rev., 25 Aug. 1985 calls for the singular verb. Murray 1795 implies the same view of things through his examples but does not In English, neither chicken nor beef nor soup has for- attempt to articulate a rule. Here are some examples: mal gender —William Safire, N.Y. Times Mag., 10 Aug. 1986 . . . that tale in prose . . . which was published at Christmas, with nine others, by us, has reached a sec- Quirk further notes that when plural nouns are so ond edition —Charles Lamb, letter, 7 June 1809 joined, the plural verb is used, and when nouns of dif- ferent number are so joined, the principle of proximity . . . the Petterell with the rest of the Egyptian Squad- tends to be called in, and the verb usually agrees with ron was off the Isle of Cyprus —Jane Austen, letter, the nearest noun. Freeman 1983 makes the same point. 1 Nov. 1800 agreement, subject-verb 56 agreement, subject-verb Quasi-coordinators are semantically equivalent to coor- phrase is viewed as a single u n i t . . . ," says Quirk et al. dinators (as and), notes Quirk, and thus notional con- 1985. Quirk appends such examples as cord can interfere with grammatical concord: Ten dollars is all I have left. This word, with all those of the same race, are of uncertain etymology —Samuel Johnson, A Dictio- Two miles is as far as they can walk. nary of the English Language, 1755 Two thirds of the area is under water. . . . A piece of cake, along with cakewalk, were Quirk's observations are consistent with the evidence in expressions used by Royal Air Force Pilots —Safire Curme 1931. Much earlier Fitzedward Hall, in an article 1984 excoriating William Cullen Bryant (published in 1880 Parenthetical insertions are also separate in theory and reprinted in Bolton & Crystal 1969), had taken time and should not affect grammatical agreement. Paren- in a footnote to prefer Bryant's "Eight dollars a month thetical insertions may be set off by commas, dashes, or is the common rate" to T. B. Macaulay's "Four shil- parentheses: lings a week, therefore, were . . . fair agricultural wages." Hall notes that Macaulay was not consistent—he also . . . their management—and their companies' bal- used the singular verb: "The ambassador told his mas- ance sheets—has suffered —Margaret Yao, Wall ter that six thousand guineas was the smallest gratifi- Street Jour., 11 June 1980 cation that could be offered to so important a minis- ter." Commas are the weakest way of setting off a parenthet- Copperud 1970, 1980 also recommends the singular ical element that is not otherwise signaled; conse- verb. quently, they may be thought not to be setting off a 3. Subject and complement of different number. People parenthesis at all: are often uncertain about the number of a linking verb They suggest that it is not just the world, and civili- in sentences like "Potatoes are a vegetable." The uncer- zation as we know it, that are going to the dogs — tainty lies, says Curme 1931, in the uncertainty a copula Howard 1984 (linking verb) creates about whether the noun before or the noun after is the true subject. Curme goes on to say, You would think, however, that actual parentheses () "The present tendency is to avoid a decision on this per- would clearly remind a writer that the material included plexing point by regulating the number of the copula by is not to affect the number agreement of the sentence. a mere formal principle—namely, as the nominative But real writers forget—even writers on language and before the copula is often the subject, it has become the grammar. rule to place the copula in accord with it, whether it be a subject or a predicate." Copperud 1970,1980 cites sev- Southern Black English (and some white dialects eral of his sources as agreeing to what Curme observes influenced by it) have bossman as an elaboration on to have become customary—to treat the first noun as t)0Ss —J. L. Dillard, American Talk, 1976 the subject. The custom seems not to have changed over The occurrence of phenomena, criteria, strata with is the last 50 years and more: the noun before the verb or was shows up the careless writer, even though governs it. agenda (and data for some) have achieved the sin- gular number —Barzun 1975 agreement, subject-verb: one or more, one in The very complex gravity field of Mars (and the sim- (out of) . 1 . Bernstein 1962, 1977, Freeman ple one of Venus) have been mapped —John S. 1983, and Bryson 1984 remind us that the phrase one or Lewis, in The New Solar System, ed. J. Kelly Beatty more is plural in meaning and should take a plural verb; etal., 1982 Bernstein 1958 asserts the same of one or two. What rel- evant evidence of these constructions we have in our See also AS WELL AS. files agrees with the commentators: One or two of the red brick and green copper pavil- agreement, subject-verb: miscellaneous problems ions . . . still remain —Gerald Weissman, The 1. Titles. Curme 1931 notes that titles of written works Woods Hole Cantata, 1975 are treated as singular even if the title is plural. Our evi- dence generally confirms this: . . . one or more of whose members have seen fit to order the removal —Mark Van Doren, American . . . Shakespeare's Sonnets has remained the excep- Scholar, Autumn 1951 tion —A. Kent Hieatt, PMLA, October 1983 In a majority of our instances, however, those phrases Pronoun reference, however, may be plural in notional do not govern a verb. agreement: 2. Chambers 1985, Heritage 1969, 1982, Longman 1984, I have been reading the Lives of the Poets for thirty and Simon 1980 agree that the phrase one in (a larger years, and can testify that in all that time I have number) or one out of (a larger number) should take the never known the day or the hour when I failed to singular verb. Our evidence for this construction is not find interest, instruction, amusement, somewhere in plentiful, but most of the modern examples we have their pages —John Wain, Samuel Johnson, 1974 found are either being held up as items to be corrected because they occur with a plural verb, or they simply occur with a plural verb and are not noticed. This 2. Amounts of money, periods of time, etc. "The princi- appears to be a case where actual usage is more often ple of notional concord accounts for the common use of governed by notional agreement than by grammatical a singular with subjects that are plural noun phrases of agreement: the writers who use the construction realize quantity or measure. The entity expressed by the noun that it represents a statistical proportion and thus stands agreement, subject-verb 57 agreement, subject-verb for a multitude of individuals. A few examples of the mostly in unplanned discourse, such as speech or per- plural verb: sonal letters. Instances do, however, sneak past the eyes of copy editors and proofreaders and reach print. Bern- One out of ten soldiers, he reported, are unable to stein 1962 and Simon 1980 cite a few examples. We recognize an enemy on a dark starlit night at a dis- have even found a few in the works of those who write tance of only ten yards —Science News Letter, 14 on usage: Oct. 1944 . . . the word regards have no Nominative —Baker Nationwide, an estimated one in four adults are 1770 functionally illiterate —Gannett Foundation news release, cited in New Yorker, 2 2 July 1985 His system of citing examples of the best authorities, of indicating etymology, and pronunciation, are still ONE IN THREE PUPILS GET POOR EDUCA- followed by lexicographers —Howard 1984 TION —headline in The Times (London), cited in New Yorker, 28 Jan. 1985 It should be noted that proximity does not always influ- ence a singular verb to be plural; sometimes the proxi- Our earliest example with a singular verb is from Jane mate noun is singular and the subject plural: Austen; in it the singular notion is probably reinforced by the negative: And the words that close the last story in the book has the music of a requiem —Padraic Colum, Intro- . . . there is not one in a hundred of either sex who is duction to James Joyce, Dubliners (Modern Library not taken in when they marry —Mansfield Park, edition), 1926 1814 You, the educated consumer, is our best customer — Jespersen 1909-49 cites a different passage from Mans- advt., cited in Bernstein 1977 field Park without a preceding negative and a bit of John Ruskin's Fors Clavigera, 1871-84 with a negative. It Proximity agreement may pass in speech and other may appear from our citations that the singular is the forms of unplanned discourse; in print it will be consid- minority usage in the modern era, but the citations are ered an error. And it is one that is probably easier to fall really too few to permit an assured judgment on the into than you might expect—let the examples above be matter. Clearly, at the very least, the singular is still in a warning. respectable use: One in four in our labor force is organized —New agreement, subject-verb: w/raf-clauses Republic, 15 Dec. 1952 What is frightening is to discover how easily we can . . . 1 in 4 teachers in the Southeast was undecided be misled —Alden Whitman, Harper's, April 1972 compared with only 1 in 8 in the Northeast —NE A Jour., December 1964 What officials have done is essentially this —Fred- erick N. Robinson, General Electric Investor, Sum- mer 1971 agreement, subject-verb: the principle of prox- imity Quirk et al. 1985 describes the principle of The two clauses beginning with what in the examples proximity (also called attraction and blind agreement) are the subjects of their sentences. The pronoun what in as the tendency of a verb to agree with a closely preced- the first example is the subject of the clause; in the sec- ing noun or noun phrase rather than with the subject. ond, it is the object. The usage problem with these what- Quirk further observes: clauses is primarily the number of the verb in the main sentence, and, when what is the subject of the clause, the Conflict between grammatical concord and attrac- number of the verb in the clause. Copperud 1970, 1980 tion through proximity tends to increase with the reports various long discussions of the subject, mostly distance between the noun phrase head of the subject from different perspectives. From the welter of analysis and the verb, for example when the postmodifier is and opinions he discerns one clear point of agreement: lengthy or when an adverbial or a parenthesis inter- what is not necessarily singular in construction but can venes between the subject and the verb. Proximity be plural. Commentators not covered by Copperud tend concord occurs mainly in unplanned discourse. In to agree, except Simon 1980, who has to go back to Par- writing it will be corrected to grammatical concord tridge 1942 for support in requiring the singular. The if it is noticed. best discussion of this question is in Bryant 1962; the citations in the Merriam-Webster files gathered since A couple of instances collected from the 1954 Army- 1962 generally confirm the findings of the studies she McCarthy hearings in Pyles 1979 will serve as examples: reports. The filing of the false, fraudulent charges are a com- The first point to observe is that mixed usage occurs plete contradiction —Joseph McCarthy in only a limited number of cases, namely when the complement of the verb of the main sentence is plural. . . . as far as coddling Communists are concerned — In the great majority of what-c\ause sentences in our Roy Cohn files, everything is singular, and there are no problems. And more recently: When the what in the wto-clause is the object of the clause and when the predicate noun following the main The reaction that I have taken to these steps are verb is plural, it tends to pull the verb with it. Bryant appropriate —Jimmy Carter, quoted in N. Y. Times, reports the plural verb favored by about three to one 14 Feb. 1980 over the singular. Here are examples of both kinds: Our evidence for proximity agreement suggests that What we need and crave are shows as handsomely Quirk's observations are correct; we find it operating preposterous a s . . . the kind George Edwards used to a half 58 ahold put on at Max's Gaiety —George Jean Nathan, The a half, a half a See HALF 2. Theatre Book of the Year, 1946-1947 ahold Copperud 1970 and Bernstein 1958 both label What we need in government, in education, in busi- ahold dialectal (as do several dictionaries) and discour- ness . . . are men who seek to understand issues in all age its use in standard prose (Bernstein found it in a their complexity —J. W. McSwiney, Annual Report, New York Times article). The Dictionary of American The Mead Corp., 1970 Regional English lists it, with attestations from several What we are getting is old answers to old questions states: Florida, Arkansas, Georgia, Maryland, West Vir- —Daniel Boorstin, Look, 20 Aug. 1968 (Perrin & ginia, Kentucky, Missouri, New York, New Jersey, Ebbitt 1972) Ohio, Illinois. Citations in Merriam-Webster files sug- gest Michigan, Wisconsin, Massachusetts, Alabama, When what is the subject of the clause, and the what- Texas, and California as well. If it is indeed dialectal, it clause is the subject of the sentence, things get a bit more is well spread around (we have it in a few British sources complicated. Perrin & Ebbitt 1972 points out that usage also). is consistent when the w/zatf-clause, linking verb, and The idiom we are discussing here most often follows predicate nominative agree in number—being either all get (catch, have, seize, take, lay, and grasp as well) and singular or all plural. Bernstein 1958, 1962, 1965 and is regularly followed by of. When hold is followed by a Johnson 1982 concur and urge writers to try for such a different preposition—on, upon, over—it always takes consistency. Simon 1980, however, wants only the sin- the indefinite article; only with of is the article idiom- gular and reproduces the following sentence for criti- atically omitted. The majority idiom, then, is (to take cism, though it illustrates the consistent plural: the most common verb) get hold of; the minority or dialectal idiom is get ahold of, with the article separate What have [Rubins's italics] surfaced are similes, from or attached to hold. The OED (under get 13b) viscous streams of them —Josh Rubins, Harvard shows the idiom as to get (a) hold of; no nonstandard Mag. label is appended. Its earliest citations, however, lack The consistent singular is actually the most common the article. case: Part of the difficulty with ahold is simply the way it is styled in writing or print. When the article is separated What is absent from the present book is any attempt from hold, the expression is not especially noticeable, as to think in terms of practical problems —Times Lit- in these examples (the first two British): erary Supp., 2 2 Oct. 1971 . . . signal-towers improved the east coast defences; a Mixed usage occurs when the subject what in the clause stronger hold was taken of Wales —Jacquetta & is singular but the predicate nominative is plural. In Christopher Hawkes, Prehistoric Britain, 1949 such cases the main verb tends to be plural: . . . until you can get a hold of the splinter —Peter What bothers Professor Teeter most are the guesses, Heaton, Cruising, 1952 hunches, speculations, and fancies in which many A reporter got a hold of this tax business —Sally language shamans like me indulge —Safire 1984 Rand, quoted in Studs Terkel, Hard Times, 1970 What is needed from the left wing of university But when a is attached to hold, with or without a reform are programs that begin to specify the steps hyphen, the expression calls more attention to itself: of change —John Gagnon, Change, October 1971 If you can't get ahold of a voltmeter —Len Feldman, Bryant further points out that when the complement Rolling Stone, 6 June 1974 consists of two or more predicate nouns, the verb is plu- ral if the nouns are plural and singular if the nouns are I got ahold of the dean at Miles College —E. D. singular: Nixon, quoted in Studs Terkel, Hard Times, 1970 What impresses them are planes and divisions and We found this export control business was a nasty ships —Harry S. Truman, radio address, 26 June nettle to grasp ahold of —Gerald C. Smith, quoted 1953 (in Bryant) in Wall Street Jour., 30 Nov. 1984 What is most striking about Johnson is the vigor of The pronunciation spelling aholt is also used: his ideas, the variety of his knowledge, the forceful- ness of his conversation —J. C. Mendenhall, English I swum to de stern uv it, en tuck aholt —Mark Literature, 1650-1800, 1940 (in Bryant) Twain, Huckleberry Finn, 1884 (Dictionary of American Regional English) When the complement of the main verb is a that-c\&use the verb is singular: I must admit some of the birds tried to get aholt of me —Colin Maclnnes, Absolute Beginners, 1959 What does follow is that the issue is susceptible to Shot said that when he died, he grabbed aholt of him rational methods —Phillip H. Scribner, AA UP Bul- . . . and he like to have never got away —Flannery letin, September 1971 O'Connor, letter, 11 Jan. 1958 Clearly usage is mixed in these complex sentences, Bremner 1980 thinks ahold does not exist except as but you need not regard what as inflexibly singular. "an illiterate provincialism." Recent evidence suggests Dwight Bolinger notes in a letter reprinted in Safire 1984 otherwise; although it still appears primarily in tran- that in the influence of the plural predicate noun over scriptions of speech, it does turn up in edited prose: the main verb English is similar to French and Spanish. It is desirable to be consistent, but, in an area where Sometimes, if you could get ahold of a representative notional agreement appears to hold absolute sway, it is who was a regular guy —Norman Mailer, The Naked perhaps even more desirable to be natural. and the Dead, 1948 aim 59 aim The words [good stuff\ suggest something gratify- have originated in England—the OED Supplement cites ingly material, whereas in baseball they describe that John Marston in 1602 and John Selden in 1649; it is which, ideally, one cannot get ahold of —Roy attested in America from Anne Bradstreet in 1650 (Dic- Blount, Jr., Sports Illustrated, 18 May 1970 tionary of American English). Foster 1968 says the expression was current in England in the 18th century, The expression is frequently used in the sense of "get in instancing Samuel Johnson: touch with": They pleas'd their Age, and did not aim to mend — "I'll get ahold of Blatty to put his nomination on the Prologue Spoken by Mr. Garrick, at the Opening of agenda tomorrow." —Leon Uris, Saturday Evening the Theatre in Drury Lane, 1747 Post, 30 May 1964 He also quotes an old rhyme: 1 got ahold of General Cushman —Richard Helms, 2 Aug. 1973 (U.S. Senate Watergate hearings) Gamesters and puss alike doe watch, And plaie with those they aim to catch. Although ahold usually has a literal meaning, it does occasionally appear in figurative uses: Foster opines that the construction survived in the U.S. after declining in British use, and was then reintroduced I'm most happy when I'm three and a half or four from the U.S. in the 20th century. It is clearly flourish- months into a picture I'm over the worst hurdle ing on both sides of the Atlantic now: of it. I feel I've got ahold of it; I'm the boss —Caro- lyn Wyeth, quoted by Richard Meryman, N.Y. . . . Mr. Trudeau aims for the jugular as often as he Times Mag, 7 Jan. 1970 aims to please —Herbert Mitgang, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 12 July 1981 Okay, girl, get ahold of yourself—Christina Ferrare De Lorean, People, 29 Nov. 1982 The communes aim to supply these —Margaret Mead, Barnard Alumnae, Winter 1971 But it is primarily a spoken construction, and its most frequent appearance is in the transcription of speech: . . . a format aimed to give pleasure to hand and eye —Times Literary Supp., 19 Feb. 1971 As soon as Lyndon got ahold of the damn thang — Sam Houston Johnson, quoted by Larry L. King, . . . this provision aims to ensure on all future occa- Harper's, April 1970 sions the kind of independent reporting which the United Nations got —Dean Acheson in The Pattern When Rosalynn gets ahold of you, it's going to be of Responsibility, ed. McGeorge Bundy, 1951 even worse —Jimmy Carter, quoted by B. Drum- mond Ayres, Jr., N. Y. Times Mag, 3 June 1979 . . . we aimed to be absolutely ready from May 15 onwards —Sir John Hunt & Sir Edmund Hillary, . . . success is not such a fabulous goal. It's like air— GeographicalJour., December 1953 you can't get ahold of it —Tammy Grimes, quoted by Kristin McMurran, People, 2 Feb. 1981 The stringent sedition laws thus aimed to mobilize a completely united population —Oscar Handlin, The It felt good getting ahold of it —Darryl Strawberry, American People in the Twentieth Century, 1954 quoted by William Nack, Sports Illustrated, 23 Apr. 1984 "I want to know if you aim to use steel spurs." — Burl Ives, Wayfaring Stranger, 1952 In summary, hold when followed by of and preceded by get or another verb in the idiom of the majority of It aims to drive the Europeans and all other foreign- English speakers and writers from Shakespeare to the ers out —L. S. B. Leakey, Mau Mau and the Kikuyu, present is not accompanied by a: get hold of. Since the 1952 late 19th century, the minority idiom with a seems to have been gaining in respectability, but it is still primar- . . . aiming to say something about the soul —C. Day ily a spoken rather than a written form. When tran- Lewis, The Grand Manner, 1952 scribed from speech, it is generally styled as one word, . . . aimed to link the fortunes of an individual family ahold. with actual text-book events —Leslie Rees, Towards An Australian Drama, 1953 aim 1. Aim to, aim at. Copperud 1970, 1980 reports some uncertainty about the status of aim followed by to Aim at, however, has not dropped out of use: and the infinitive. Fowler 1926 plumps for the aim at . . . a recent story aimed at helping French youths to construction, but does not disparage aim to, calling it good American (he notes that Emerson was fond of it) see the U.S.A. —David Butwin, Saturday Rev., 26 even though not good English. Fowler's reviser, Sir Feb. 1972 Ernest Gowers, notes (in Fowler 1965) that aim to has . . . aimed at helping motorists to understand the become established in British English, citing an MP. In truck driver's point of view —Julie Candler, Ford America, Bernstein 1965 fears that some think aim to Truck Times, Summer 1970 has too much of "the dust of the frontier" about it, but Shaw 1970 inexplicably relegates the aim at expression . . . research activities aimed at developing man's to "colloquial or dialectal" status. The following discus- capability to work in the sea —Annual Report, sion should clarify the present situation. Union Carbide Corp., 1970 Dialectal status: the Dictionary of American Re- . . . proposals aimed at correcting the deficiencies — gional English finds aim to formerly widespread in Eileen Hughes, Ladies'Home Jour., September 1971 American speech but now chiefly limited to the South- ern and south Midland areas; in print, however, it does . . . a new television series aimed at helping high not appear to be receding. The construction appears to school students —American Labor, December 1969 ain't 60 ain't . . . has aimed at wooing back women audiences — the spelling represented a way of pronouncing the word. Current Biography, December 1967 Nowadays we tend to pronounce a word according to the way we see it spelled. Thus, ain't looks stranger to 2. Aim at, aim for with a noun. Colter 1981 thinks only us than it did to those who spoke and wrote it two or at and not for should be used with aim, but he is alone three centuries ago. in his belief; Chambers 1985 and Janis 1984 say either Another complication is that we cannot be entirely may be used, and in fact both are widely used: certain whether ain't began as a shortening of are not or . . . Mr. Trudeau aims for the jugular —Herbert Mit- am not. We do know that it had an earlier spelling an't gang, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 12 July 1981 (or sometimes a'n't), which you can see would not be difficult to derive phonologically from are or am; the . . . climbed down a bank, aiming for a promontory spelling ain't seems originally to have represented one —Edward Hoagland, Harper's, February 1971 particular way of pronouncing the contraction more often spelled an't. Bender found that an't arose almost . . . when Mr. Causley neglects this rare gift and aims simultaneously from both am not and are not. The pho- specifically for children —Times Literary Supp., 2 nology of these derivations is discussed in Jespersen Apr. 1971 (vol. 5) and in Hill's article mentioned above. Our pres- The thing to aim for in posture —James Hewitt, ent evidence—and there is doubtless more to be Irish Digest, April 1955 found—shows am not the earliest: . . . the highway aims straight for Lake Champlain — Miss PRUE. YOU need not sit so near one, if you have American Guide Series: Vermont, 1937 any thing to say, I can hear you farther off, I an't deaf —William Congreve, Love for Love, 1695 . . . to keep the antennas aimed at the earth —Henry S. F. Cooper, Jr., New Yorker, 11 Nov. 1972 The earliest evidence for are not is from 1696: . . . one sometimes wonders what effect their creator LORD FOPPINGTON. . . .these shoes a'n't ugly, but is aiming at —Edmund Wilson, New Yorker, 18 they don't fit me —Sir John Vanbrugh, The Relapse Sept. 1971 Evidence in Jespersen shows that Jonathan Swift, in his . . . we cannot even be sure what Hamlet is aiming at Journal to Stella, was using an't for am not, are not, and —William Empson, Sewanee Rev., January-March is not around 1710: "I an't vexed," "an't you an impu- 1953 dent slut," "Presto is plaguy silly tonight, an't he?" It . . . aim at results which the other sciences can nei- would thus appear that either an't also developed from ther prove nor disprove —Bertrand Russell, Selected isn 't somehow or that it was extended in use to the third Papers, 1927 person singular. Jespersen advances (somewhat tenta- tively) this third derivation, which Strang 1970 repre- In the long run men hit only what they aim at — sents as isn't - » i'n't -* e'n't —• ain't. Bender, on the Henry David Thoreau, Walden, 1854 other hand, supposes an't = isn't is simply an extension of the form to the third person. To complicate matters, Occasionally toward(s) may be used: we have here the curious fact that an't - isn't is attested . . . products, systems and services aimed toward earlier than i'n't, although e'n't is of about the same vin- better living —Annual Report, American Home tage. Until more and clearer evidence is turned up, we Products Corp., 1970 cannot be sure which route led to third person singular a(i)n 't. It is towards London that touring companies aim — We also have to take account of a fourth line of deri- Peter Forster, London Calling, 11 Nov. 1954 vation in which an't and ain't are used for has not and have not. The derivation of ain't from has or have not ain't The history of ain't is both complicated and is a favorite of a couple of investigators (see Stevens, obscure, and the amount of real historical investigation above, for instance), but such evidence as we have sug- devoted to it has been very small compared to the reams gests that this is a later development, apparently in the of paper that have been written to condemn it. Much of 19th century. The earliest citation for it in the Dictio- what has been written is not informative, and some of nary of American Regional English is dated 1838. It is it is misinformative. We will try here to lay out what is not, however, an Americanism, being recorded also in known about ain 't and how it came to be in its present the English Dialect Dictionary. The derivation itself is disesteem, and then examine the ways in which it has fairly straightforward: 18th-century ha 'n 't, for both has been and still is used. not and have not, becomes an't by loss of the h (in later The grammarians Jespersen 1909-49 and Curme American English the h will sometimes be restored to 1931 made brief examinations of the origin ofain't; but, produce hain 't). as far as we know, a short study by Professor Harold H. Let us pause to recapitulate. Ain't comes from an't Bender of Princeton (also the chief etymologist for Web- which in turn comes from am not (perhaps by way of ster's Second) in Word Study, March 1936, is the first amn't, which still survives in Irish English and— devoted entirely to an examination of the subject. (Two according to Gowers in Fowler 1965—in Scots English later ones—among many—that you may find of interest too), from are not (one common pronunciation of are are Martin Stevens, "The Derivation of 'Ain't'," Amer- was close to that of air; Baron 1982 cites a 1791 Amer- ican Speech, October 1954, and Archibald A. Hill, "The ican spelling reformer named Chambers whose system Tainted Ain't Once More," College English, June 1965.) spelled are as er), from is not (perhaps through i'n't and One of the things that makes ain't stand out is its en't), and later from have not and has not (through apparent lack of direct connection to any of the inflected han't). So the connection of ain't with be (and have) is forms of be: am, is, are, were, was, etc. The reason is not quite as obscure as it might appear on the surface. ultimately a shift in the way we perceive words. When How ain't came to the widely disparaged status it now ain't was first used in writing in the early 18th century, occupies is scarcely more obvious than its origin. Strang ain't 61 ain't 1970 notes that several negative contractions—among can't, don't, haven't, isn't, hasn't, didn't, couldn't, them don't, shan't, won't, as well as an't—seem to have wouldn 't and shouldn 't in a sort of descending scale of developed around 1600; they begin to show up in liter- acceptability. He saves the worst for last: ary sources, especially the Restoration dramatists, toward the end of the century (Mario Pei in The Story Won't for will not, and ain't for is not or are not are of Language, 1949 asserts ain't was established in usage absolutely vulgar; and ain't for has not or have not, by King Charles II). But in the early 18th century, some is utterly intolerable —quoted by Shirley Brice of these abbreviated forms begin to be criticized; Addi- Heath, in Shopen & Williams 1980 son (The Spectator 1 3 5 , 1 7 1 1 ) and Swift (The Tatler 230, 1710 and Polite Conversations, 1738) are among It is to be noted that Peabody was attempting to dis- the earliest to disparage them, although (as we have criminate among not only the various contractions, but seen) Swift used them himself. The earliest mentions of also the different uses of ain't. A few early 20th-century an't specifically are in lists of condemned contractions. commentators also discriminate: The Reverend John Witherspoon, as "The Druid," con- ain't. Avoid as inelegant. In such a phrase as "he tributed a number of papers to the Pennsylvania Journal ain't," it is both vulgar and ungrammatical —Vize- on things he didn't care for in American English; his No. telly 1906 VI (16 May 1781) says: Baron 1982 cites John Bechtel in Slips of Speech (1903) I will mention the vulgar abbreviations in general, as as making a similar discrimination. By 1926 H. W. Fow- an't, can't, han't, don't, should'nt, would'nt, ler could view first-person use of ain't quite differently could'nt, Sec. (in Mathews 1931) from other uses: The Dictionary of American English mentions a similar A(i)n't is merely colloquial, & as used for isn't is an listing in B. Dearborn's Columbian Grammar of 1795, uneducated blunder & serves no useful purpose. But and Leonard 1929 mentions the English grammarian it is a pity that a(i)n 't for am not, being a natural con- Philip Withers in 1788 as offering similar criticism. traction & supplying a real want, should shock us as Ain't is lumped with other contractions for condemna- though tarred with the same brush. Though I'm not tion in 1825 by the American grammarian Samuel Kirk- serves well enough in statements, there is no abbre- ham. The first to single out ain't specifically seems to viation but a(i)n't I?for am I not?.... have been Alford 1866. While he notes that ain't is very frequently used "even by highly educated persons," he Fowler's defense of ain't I? was repeated on this side of does not approve, partly because he thinks ain't bears the Atlantic: no resemblance to am not and are not. Oddly enough, Bardeen 1883 lists only Alford (from among his list of What is the matter with ain't I? for am not I? Noth- two dozen commentators) as opposed to ain't, but he ing whatever, save that a number of minor gram- does mention that the dictionaries of Webster and marians object to it —American Mercury, August Worcester consider it indefensible. 1927 (probably H. L. Mencken) Hill in the College English article mentioned above But such nice differences have generally been aban- quotes the linguist Raven I. McDavid, Jr. to the effect doned by the minor grammarians, both British and that ain't lost status as a pronunciation while the American, and they have held the whip hand. Here is broader of the two pronunciations probably represented Josephine Turck Baker 1927: by an't gained status (a shift which would eventually lead to the appearance in British books of aren 't I—with / ain't and Ain't I are always incorrect, I'm not and the r not pronounced; see AREN'T I). Jespersen tells us Am I not being the correct forms. As a contraction that in the 19th and 20th centuries authors put ain 't "is in place of isn 't, ain't is a vulgarism. not" in the speech of vulgar or uneducated characters. And her single-minded view has become a tradition: Thus Jane Austen has a vulgar woman say: ain't is a vulgarism altogether too frequently used for " . . . I'm sure I don't pretend to say that there an't" am not, aren't, isn't, hasn't, haven't, and still other — S e n s e and Sensibility, 1811 verbal negatives. It is, if possible, worse for am not, Charles Dickens puts it in the mouth of his detestable has not, have not, than for is not and are not. But Yorkshire schoolmaster: there is really no such word. Don't use it —Opdyke 1939 'So it is,' said Squeers. 'Ain't it, Nickleby?' —Nich- ain't. Nonstandard for am not. isn't, aren't, or hasn 't olas Nickleby, 1839 —Guth 1985 And George Bernard Shaw has a prizefighter say: It will be seen that whatever discrimination was earlier "Oh, no," said Skeene, soothingly; " . . . sparring made among different uses of ain't has been lost; and in ain't the real thing " —Cashel Byron's Profes- Opdyke's remark about nonexistence the historical con- sion, 1886 nection of ain't to am not, are not, etc., is entirely unrec- ognized, possibly because the earlier form an't had American pedagogues of the 19th century were willing dropped out of use around the end of the 19th century. to take Witherspoon's 1781 observations (based in turn We cannot be sure why an't vanished, but it did. The on Addison's Spectator strictures of 1711) and make loss probably had something to do with its most presti- them part of the teaching of English. But some discrim- gious pronunciation being more frequently spelled ination seems to have been attempted at times, at least aren't in the 19th century and the less prestigious pro- in the advice given to graduates of the Newburyport nunciations being spelled ain't. Ain't appears to have Female High School in 1846 by a man named Peabody. become the regular spelling in American English at a He advises great care and discretion in the employment fairly early date. of the negative contractions, working his way through Now that we have traced the history of the word from ain't 62 ain't the ordinary conversational English of educated 17th- I'm from my generation, you know, if you ain't and 18th-century English men and women through its working you're doing something wrong —Lena transformation into the bugbear of the American school- Home, quoted in Northeast Mag., 3 Feb. 1985 teacher of the 20th century, we can turn our attention to how this much vilified word is actually used. When the She's the doctor from Australia who goes around entry for ain't in Webster's Third tried in 1961 to telling everybody we're all gonna die, that if we keep describe actual use based on the information then avail- these politicians in there, they're going to blow up able, it caused a great deal of controversy in the press, the world. I ain't buying it —Arlo Guthrie, quoted especially the portion of the usage note that allowed that in Yankee, August 1986 ain't was "used orally in most parts of the U.S. by many Well, I have my doubts, folks. I recently saw the first cultivated speakers esp. in the phrase ain't /." And only 1980s graffiti exhibition . . . and, let me tell you, a couple of years ago a correspondent in a remote corner these artists ain't —Gerald Peary, Flare, April 1984 of the Southwest troubled himself to tear off a piece of paper bag, inscribe on it his opinion that no one in his But that was before I learned one of my favorite town would stoop so low as to use ain 't, and mail it to speakers can be purchased in only one city in Texas, Merriam-Webster. Such outbursts remind us that the and it ain't Houston, folks —Henry Hunt, Houston statement of James H. Sledd that "any red-blooded Post, 26 Aug. 1984 American would prefer incest to AinT (cited by Raven I. McDavid, Jr., PADS, April 1967) is only slightly The congruently informal ain't, if we may call it that, exaggerated. can also be used for characterizing purposes. In the next The use of ain't in present-day spoken English is hard example we see Will Rogers projecting his stage person- for dictionary editors to assess accurately, since most ality in print: dictionary evidence is from print. We do know that it is Just imagine, if you can, if the flesh of this Country common among the less educated and among children, were allowed to wander around promiscuously! especially when talking to their peers. We do have evi- Why, there ain't no telling where it would wind up dence that educated persons whose regular vocabulary —Will Rogers, The Illiterate Digest, 1924 still includes ain't use the term in talking to relatives and to peers with whom they are both friendly and on a The characterizing ain't in writing is often meant to first-name basis (there is an intelligent discussion of this mark the speaker as belonging to a lower class or being in Hill). poorly educated or being black or being countrified. While we have little evidence of unguarded, friendly, This use is common in fiction: peer-to-peer conversation in our files, we do have let- ters. From the old days to the present, the use of ain't in 'What! he ain't rich then?' Foker asked —W. M. a letter marks a close and warm relationship. Thackeray, The History of Pendennis, 1850 Ain't you mightily moped on the banks of the Cam! "Oh, Lord!" exclaimed Cashel, "don't say that. —Charles Lamb, letter, February 1801 You're joking, ain't you?" —George Bernard Shaw, Cashel Byron's Profession, 1886 Where is Moore? Why an't he out? —Lord Byron, When he returned he said, "What have I got that I letter, 29 July 1816 can pay? Ain't I been a poor man every day of my Thence to Dresden. Ain't I glad, though the weather life?" —Bernard Malamud, The Magic Barrel, 1958 is no better —Henry Adams, letter, 6 Apr. 1859 The Jews, Ford said. They ain't like anyone else I know —E. L. Doctorow, Ragtime, 1975 Nurse doesn't know I'm writing. Aint I lawless! — Ellen Terry, letter, 4 Mar. 1897 " . . . You ain't do nothing like that, did you Mitch, huh?" —Vern E. Smith, The Jones Men, 1974 Ain't it hell to have a head of the State in the family? —Harry S. Truman, letter, 11 May 1952 Although most common in fiction, the characterizing ain't can also be found in other forms of writing. The I trust you find my handwriting as bad as yr own. I first example describes an unpromising family of white ain't strong enough to hit a key tonight —Flannery farm helpers, the second a Southern sheriff. O'Connor, letter, 26 Mar. 1957 . . . these . . . look like they've been joined up with Ain't is also used in what Professor Hill calls a "con- the human race for only a couple of months now. gruently informal style." This may be spoken—as in an Mrs. W. says she went to school for one day and interview or even in a talk—or written—as in an article. didn't loin . . . nothin and ain't went back —Flan- If ain't has a special function in these examples, it is to nery O'Connor, letter, 25 Jan. 1953 emphasize their informality. . . . the country people's ignorance he found irresist- ible and I think it tickled him to perplex their foolish Like, they had these three heavies coming down the heads, white or black, with the same old leading street and me walking toward them. Now right away question: "You heard about old Nat Turner, ain't that ain't right. Three guys coming at me, I run, right you?" —William Styron, This Quiet Dust and Other . . . ? —Steve McQueen, Newsweek (6 Jan. 1964); Writings, 1982 interview reproduced in Current Biography, October 1966 An editorial in the Boston Globe (5 Sept. 1983) also notes that the characterizing ain't can be used in He ain't too interested in what the contemporary reportage: world thinks about him —William Faulkner, talk to students at University of Virginia, quoted in Bar- It may well quote the person accurately, but it may nard 1979 also be a code word, used in a sly way to tip off the ain't 63 ain't reader to the fact that the person being quoted is What is wrong with all this, of course, is that it just poor, illiterate, or black. ain't so —Archibald MacLeish, quoted in English Jour., November 1968 It is a moot point whether accuracy or characterization is the purpose here: No, no, cried the America of World War II—"Say it ain't so, Lyndon." —Philip Roth, Reading Myself The grocery store ain't got no limits on how many and Others, 1975 groceries they sell. I ought to be able to sell all the guns I want —Blake Roberts, a Greenville, S.C., gun It ain't over till it's over —Mike Williams, stock- dealer, quoted by Wayne King, N. Y. Times, 13 Mar. market analyst, in news telecast, 16 Dec. 1985 1975 . . . doomsayers . . . have been warning us that we ain't seen nothing yet —Louis Rukeyser, "Wall Another of the most common public uses of ain't Street Week" (PBS television), 13 Mar. 1981 makes use of the word's ability to attract attention. This use pops up unsurprisingly in advertising and in politi- Leftovers ain't what they used to be —Apartment cal slogans. It is also used in otherwise rather straight- Life, January 1980 forward prose for purposes of contrast. Davies has the Order of Lenin—just conferred. He's . . . Reagan . . . continued to use the line he had used an economic royalist—"ain't that sompin?" — when he kicked off his campaign on Labor Day: Harry S. Truman, diary entry, 22 May 1945 "You ain't seen nothin' yet." —Elizabeth Drew, New But, overall, to borrow Burt Lance's phrase, the sys- Yorker, 3 Dec. 1984 tem ain't broke —Albert R. Hunt, Jr., Wall Street You ain't seen nothin' until you've seen . . . —tele- Jour.,5}\x\y 1979 vision advt, 16 Feb. 1980 Another use of ain't, seldom mentioned though often . . . and that ain't hay —singing commercial, 24 Feb. heard, is in popular music. You have only to recall 1981 songs with lines like "It ain't necessarily so," "The old gray mare, she ain't what she used to be," "Ain't she . . . firms who can make things smell like what they sweet?" to realize that the medium of popular music ain't —Bennett Cerf, Saturday Rev., 1 Mar. 1953 alone could have kept ain't alive without much help from other sources. The function of ain't in the lyrics of So what? Jack Dempsey isn't; Babe Ruth isn't; Joe songs is obvious: it has only one syllable, and it is more Louis and Douglas MacArthur ain't —George Jean clearly heard and more easily enunciated than the isn 't Nathan, Beware of Parents: A Bachelor's Book for it usually replaces. Children, 1943 Now we come to the famous tag question "ain't I?" Louise ain't what she used to be in voice —Metro- We have seen earlier that Fowler 1926 regretted its being nome, January 1952 considered indicative of low breeding and that The American Mercury wondered what is the matter with it. The old pervading desire to show the schoolmarm The tag question was used by the linguistic geographers that the cultured ain't so cultured —Sheridan Baker, to elicit oral uses of ain 7; their results influenced the College English, November 1964 (in Hill) statement in Webster's Third that caused so much con- troversy. Hill's article discusses the tag question; so do I ain't referring to strip-mining, scoop-shovel opera- Einstein 1985 and others. A few hardy souls approve the tors —Malcolm S. Forbes, Forbes, 1 Feb. 1974 locution: . . . misprint, catachresis, misspelling, solecism, bar- Only in the first-person-negative interrogative of the barism, and other evidence that English ain't what it verb "to be" is the contraction "ain't" acceptable in used to be. It never was —Howard 1980 standard speech —William Safire, N. Y. Times Mag., To look at the objects you wouldn't think they were 23 May 1982 worth very much. The Hope Diamond they ain't — Edwards Park, Smithsonian, August 1983 I'll accept 'ain't I?' instead of 'am I not?' That's use- ful —Abe Burrows, in Harper 1985 This is an infuriating misuse by an ignoramus who thinks 'authoring' three books is somehow a grander Even Bernstein 1977 admits the utility of the tag: achievement than writing them. It ain't —Charles There can be no doubt that ain't I is easier to say Kuralt, in Harper 1975, 1985 than aren't I or amn't I and sounds less stilted than You will probably have noticed by now that many of am I not. Nevertheless.... these attention-getting uses of ain't occur in familiar phrases. Such catch phrases and variations on them Bernstein nevertheless rejects the tag and questions the make up a goodly portion of the word's use, both orally validity of the usage note in Webster's Third. There may and in writing. We add a few more samples: be legitimate reasons for a certain skepticism about the use ofain't I. One is that much of Linguistic Atlas mate- This show might be described as a working-class rial was gathered about a half century ago; it is hard to comedy, but although it works pretty hard, well— know if the information is still valid. The Dictionary of class it ain't —Cleveland Amory, TV Guide, 20 Mar. American Regional English does not mention the tag 1976 specifically, although the editors do reprint E. Bagby Atwood's summary of its distribution in A Survey of The wackiness of movies, once so deliciously amus- Verb Forms in the Eastern United States (1953). But ing, ain't funny anymore —Richard Schickel, Har- even if the tag is logical, is grammatically sound, is per's, March 1971 approved by some, and is desired by others, does it air 64 air actually come up very often in real speech? Although, as half-witted, which I ain't." —Sir Winston Churchill, conceded above, we do not have enough direct evidence in N.Y. Times, 12 Jan. 1978 to answer that question conclusively, we do have a fair amount of indirect evidence from letters and such show- John ain't been worth a damn since he started wear- ing that ain 7 occurs frequently in inverted expressions, ing $300 suits —Lyndon B. Johnson, quoted by such as questions. Larry L. King, New Times, 20 Aug. 1976 As for the Fraiilein, ain't she a one-er, that's all — Eleven-thirty at night ain't a time to read up on this Henry Adams, letter, 8 Nov. 1859 very complicated higher-education problem —Ger- ald R. Ford, quoted by John Hersey, N.Y. Times Ain't I a beast for not answering you before? — Mag., 20 Apr. 1975 Alfred, Lord Tennyson, letter (in Jespersen 1909-49) Reagan dodged a question about the Hodel report Oh aint it a dark day —Ellen Terry, letter, 2 Oct. Wednesday night at his nationally televised news 1896 conference. "I ain't talking," he said —Ronald R. Reagan, in My cousin thought this a remarkable coincidence, Morning Union (Springfield, Mass.), 10 Jan. 1985 illustrating how remarkable coincidences can be. Now ain't it? —Flannery O'Connor, letter, 24 Apr. You're looking at a man what ain't straining — 1951 George C. Wallace, quoted by B. Drummond Ayres, Jr., N.Y. Times, 30 Mar. 1975 (Other examples may be found above.) So all we can say for sure is that when the tag is necessary, ain't will prob- "If at the end of four years they want to throw me ably occur in it in some people's speech. out, it's O.K. with me," the Mayor responds, adding: One use of ain't that many handbooks agree is com- "I like my job very much, but it ain't the end of the mon is facetious or jocular or humorous use. We do not world if I don't have it." —Edward Koch, quoted by have much evidence for such use. Here is an obvious Richard Haitch, N.Y. Times, 6 July 1980 case: Conclusion: We have seen that ain't is a stigmatized We like to make jokes, for instance, about the lan- word in general use; in ordinary speaking and writing it guage of tax forms. Heh heh, we chuckle, ain't them tends to mark the speaker and writer as socially or edu- bureaucrats a caution? —Mitchell 1979 cationally inferior. We have also seen that it is in wide- spread use but usually in particular circumscribed ways Don't be surprised if you're not chuckling. Ain't in itself that tend to remove the stigma from its use. Study the ain't funny. It is a fact, of course, that ain't can com- examples here. Then decide when and how you will use monly be found in humorous writers from Bill Arp to the word, if at all. Though you may choose—indeed, be Artemus Ward to Mark Twain to Ring Lardner and Will well advised—to forgo making sentences like "I ain't Rogers. But its use is generally appropriate to the char- had dinner yet" a regular feature of your conversation acter (sometimes the narrator) using it; the humor does or writing, at times you will probably find ain 7 a very not reside in the use of ain 7. What the handbooks prob- useful word despite (or even because of) the controversy ably mean is that many educated people, when they use that surrounds its use. ain 7, try to use it in such a way as to show that it is not part of their serious day-to-day vocabulary. Such disin- fecting of the word seems most frequently to be accom- air Copperud 1970, 1980 finds the verb air "broad- plished by the use of the familiar fixed phrases we illus- cast" unexceptionable, and Janis 1984 agrees. Earlier trated earlier. An old chestnut like "things ain't what the term had been objected to as jargon by Bernstein they used to be" or its wry contemporary cousin "nos- 1958; Harper 1975, 1985 agrees with Bernstein. Bern- talgia ain't what it used to be" is the verbal equivalent stein had condemned the word in a 1955 Winners & of a wink or nudge intended to show that you are not so Sinners; the Morrises seem to have had this "new" verb ill-bred as to really use ain't. It's not really an attempt called to their attention by a correspondent in 1971. But at jocularity or humor—it's an attempt at distancing. the verb had been appearing in print for at least 15 years when Bernstein spotted it in a New York Times head- We have saved till last a clutch of citations—from line. Our earliest citations are essentially technical, but speech—for ain't as used by various public figures. Sev- by 1943 air had appeared in fiction: eral are U.S. presidents or others active in the political life, but few of these uses sound like self-conscious "Now, now, boys!" said the account executive attempts by the educated to affect the speech of the gen- genially. "The program isn't aired until three eral electorate. Most sound perfectly natural and o'clock!" —Marguerite Lyon, And So to Bedlam, untouched by irony: 1943 . . . education means moving a man from where he By 1945 it was appearing in the weekly news magazines: is to where he ain't —Robert Frost, cited by Calvin The Post, Times, Daily Mirror, and Journal-Ameri- H. Plimpton, Amherst College Bulletin, January 1967 can all aired special news programs —Time, 16 July 1945 . . . Harry Truman would not say. To one probing And it had become quite common by the end of the reporter he quipped: "You just want to find out 1940s: something and you ain't going to do it." —Time, 25 July 1949 . . . which has been aired at one time or another on the four major radio networks —Current Biography You think it's going to be done, but it ain't —Julia 1948 Child, television show, 3 Mar. 1971 . . . the local radio station was going to air it —Chris- Sir Winston . . . said the portrait of him seated and topher Morley, The Man Who Made Friends with wearing his characteristic bow tie "makes me look Himself, 1949 à la 65 alibi Henry Morgan and Herb Sheldon each air at 6:30 ried over to Fowler 1926, from whence it came to Krapp p.m. —The Billboard, 15 Apr. 1950 1927. It does not seem to have been called archaic by any other commentators, although a Dictionary of Our evidence shows no diminution of use. You may Unusual Words published in 1948 included it with the safely follow Copperud and Janis, whose judgment on Othello quotation above, and Janis 1984, who may have the word is sound for this late in the second half of the looked only into Fowler, thinks that it is "considered 20th century. But you can always use broadcast if you archaic by many." happen not to like air. Since the word seems to have continued in use all along, Gowers's comment that it had been "picked up à la This imported preposition has its grave accent and dusted" is not especially apt; it has, however, con- over the a printed often enough, even in American use, siderably increased in use since the 1930s, to judge by that the unaccented form is considered a secondary vari- evidence in the Merriam-Webster files. A selection of ant. And although it has been used in English contexts examples: since the end of the 16th century, some writers still feel that it is French and italicize it. It is widely used in We have lived and we have learned, albeit the lesson English outside the field of cookery as well as within. was a costly one — Vanity Fair, January 1920 Longman 1984 and Fowler 1965 note that its form is . . . through a hundred channels where waters flowed fixed in English (as it is in French for reasons of the with steady force, albeit under a glassy surface —Sir underlying grammar). In English the preposition is often Winston Churchill, Great Contemporaries, 1937 followed by a proper name, and even when the name is clearly masculine the feminine article la is retained. It took that pause to make him realize Here is a selection of fairly recent examples of its use: The mountain he was climbing had the slant As of a book held up before his eyes . . . going on to other things, whether à la David (And was a text albeit done in plant) Frost or à la Jonathan Miller —Times Literary —Robert Frost, A Witness Tree, 1942 Supp., 26 Nov. 1971 The wind was new albeit it was the same that had . . . chomping on a large cigar à la Castro —Alan blown before the time of man came to the hillside — Ridkig, Saturday Rev., 24 July 1976 Elizabeth Madox Roberts, The Time of Man, 1926 . . . eating up the keyboard à la Horowitz —Harold That these ties, albeit the deepest, should have left C. Schonberg, Harper's, April 1971 me so remarkably free was a happy circumstance for . . . the camera does a semicircular track à la Vertigo my philosophy —George Santayana, Persons and —John Simon, New York, 6 Dec. 1976 Places, 1944 . . . a division-sized posse prepared to go in à la . . . the glamorous, albeit fast, colors of modern jour- Entebbe —Pine Bluff (Ark.) Commercial, quoted in nalism —Vladimir Nabokov, New Republic, 13 Jan. NY. Times, 13 Nov. 1979 1941 I was filling in with my drumsticks all kinds of com- . . . betraying clearly what the relationship between plicated rhythmical riffs a la Castanet parts — them was, albeit a fleeting one —Vita Sackville- Michael Tilson Thomas, quoted in Rolling Stone, 14 West, The Easter Party, 1953 Sept. 1972 . . . I watched the trees and the rain with increasing . . . will now try to ignore the flap and get the renom- interest albeit with no radio support —E. B. White, inations over with, a la politics-as-usual —Wall New Yorker, 25 Sept. 1954 Street Jour., 3 June 1980 . . . conversation might have found its natural level, albeit low —Mary McCarthy, Atlantic, August 1970 albeit Copperud 1970, 1980 observes that "a genera- tion ago" albeit was considered archaic but is "now . . . I should doubt very much that a literary manner being revived." The source of the notice of revival is of this sort was a matter of instinct. It is purely pre- Gowers (in Fowler 1965). This is a most curious busi- conscious, and learned, albeit imperfectly —Donald ness, since albeit seems never to have gone out of use, Hall, Goatfoot, Milktongue, Twinbird, 1978 though it may have faded somewhat in the later 19th . . . they had treated me as a pal, albeit a junior one century. If it did, the revival began decades before the —Anthony Bailey, New Yorker, 29 July 1985 commentators noticed. Johnson's Dictionary of 1755 had the word with three illustrations, one from Shakespeare's Othello ( 1605): alibi The extended sense of alibi meaning any excuse is an Americanism; although it was overlooked by the Of one, whose . . . eyes, Dictionary of American English, the Dictionary of Albeit unused to the melting mood, Americanisms recorded the noun, citing a 1912 story in Drop tears, as fast as the Arabian trees Collier's. "The rot started in the United States," says Their medicinal gum. Howard 1980. He cites Big Bill Tilden (as does OED Supplement): The OED quotes from 18th- and 19th-century sources including Southey, Thackeray, and the Irish novelist Don't offer alibis for losing —Lawn Tennis, 1922 Charles Lever. Poutsma 1904-26 quotes from Kipling, and we have found albeit in the verse of the elder This sense was apparently popular in spoken American Holmes and of Yeats. Nonetheless, the brothers Fowler English from around the time just before World War I. 1907 found it to be an archaism, citing two contempo- That it already had a good foothold is attested by Ring rary sources for censure. The opinion of 1907 was car- Lardner's use of the word in the title of one of his best- alibi 66 alibi known stories, "Alibi Ike" (first published in 1915). The ler 1926 seems not to have noticed it, so the earliest Brit- story begins: ish disapproval we have found is in Partridge 1942. Subsequent British commentators followed Partridge— His right name was Frank X. Farrell, and I guess the a complaining letter to the Picture Post in 1949, an edi- X stood for "Excuse me." Because he never pulled a torial in the Manchester Guardian in 1950, Lord Cones- play, good or bad, on or off the field, without apol- ford in the Saturday Evening Post in 1957. Gowers in ogizin' for it. Fowler 1965 gives it a fairly long disapproval, quoting "Alibi Ike" was the name Carey wished on him the two unnamed English politicians. Others sustain the tra- first day he reported down South. dition: Sellers 1975, Phythian 1979, Bryson 1980, Long- A bit further on Lardner writes: man 1984, and Chambers 1985 record widespread dis- approval. Howard 1980 doesn't like it either but "He's got the world beat," says Carey to Jack and I. considers it established. "I've knew lots o' guys that had an alibi for every There is a bit of a British-American split here. While mistake they made But this baby can't even go some American handbooks and commentators follow to bed without apologizin' " —Ring Lardner, the early condemnation (for instance Shaw 1962, Bell & "Alibi Ike," in How to Write Short Stories, 1924 Cohn 1980, Oxford American Dictionary 1980), more are neutral (for instance Nickles 1974, Reader's Digest Lardner's association of alibi with baseball is appropri- 1983, Janis 1984, Bremner 1980, Kilpatrick 1984), and ate; sports contexts are among the earliest for the word both Bernstein 1971 and William Safire (New York in this sense. Besides Big Bill Tilden, we have these Magazine, 24 July 1983) defend it; in Bernstein's words: examples: Among the countless alibis that go hand in hand The hand-wringers suppose that it is merely a syn- with bad golf — Vanity Fair, December 1919 onym for excuse, but it is more than that. It carries a connotation of slight or outright dishonesty and it . . . "I dropped it because the sun was in my eyes." represents a plea to get out from under. Sport's oldest alibi —N.Y. Times, 16 May 1928 Even the usage panels of Heritage 1969, 1982 and Har- No room is left for alibis in the pre-battle statements per 1975, 1985 split nearly evenly on it. The use, there- of Gene Tunney, Jack Dempsey, and their two man- fore, seems to be regarded with considerably less disfa- agers —Emporia (Kans.) Gazette, 22 Sept. 1927 vor in the U.S. than in the U.K. The sense itself, however, to judge from the examples in the British But writers for American newspapers and magazines handbooks, is now established on both sides of the used it in other contexts, too—especially politics. Atlantic. Here are a few examples more recent than the After putting through his program, the governor ones given above: must face the people at the polls without alibis — Emporia (Kans.) Gazette, 3 Feb. 1927 . . . we lie to ourselves, in order that we may still have the excuse of ignorance, the alibi of stupidity Leaders of the Labor Party are quite willing to allow and incomprehension —Aldous Huxley, The Olive the Liberals to hold a check rein over them if they Tree, 1937 can only obtain office. It would give them a perfect alibi —N.Y. Times, 21 Oct. 1928 Partly, they are the new alibi of great wealth —Har- old J. Laski, New Republic, 5 Aug. 1946 They want an alibi to gouge the public —Time, 18 Jan. 1926 Direct treachery by friends in publishing a private manuscript was one alibi a poet could plead —J. W. It even began to crop up in the fiction of others than Saunders, Essays in Criticism, April 1951 Ring Lardner: . . . I intend to let everyone know about them, even And the meaning Aline had to jump at, knowing if I am depriving reluctant hosts of an excellent alibi nothing, get instinctively or not at all. Esther would —New Yorker, 20 Mar. 1954 be one to leave herself always a clear alibi —Sher- wood Anderson, Dark Laughter, 1925 . . . given the noise of a helicopter ride there may have been some misunderstanding. But I do not use As soon as any new expression becomes widespread this as an alibi —Henry J. Kissinger, quoted in N. Y. and popular enough, it will draw critical attention. The Times, 12 June 1974 extended sense of alibi had only to wait until 1925 for disapproval: John A. Powell in How to Write Business It is, on the other hand, a wonderful alibi for refusing Letters (1925) said it should not be used, and M. V. P. to attempt anything less —Hilton Kramer, N.Y. Yeaman in American Speech, November 1925, noticed Times Book Rev., 19 Feb. 1984 it unfavorably—his examples are from conversation. In Australia, The Bulletin (New South Wales) for 14 Apr. The American Heritage usage panel, almost half of 1927 answered a letter from a lawyer complaining about which accepted the extended sense of alibi as a noun, the new alibi: rejected intransitive use of the verb in writing by a wide margin. The OED Supplement shows that the verb has The Yanks have corrupted it to signify any sort of been in use since 1909. It too was establishing itself by defence, explanation or excuse. Thus a man arriving the 1920s and is now fully established, in general prose, with a black eye offers his "alibi" that he got it chop- in both transitive and intransitive uses: ping wood. It may be only vernacular American as yet, but it has got into the newspapers and fiction, He let the men alibi away to their heart's content — and hence is probably beyond eradication. Printer's Ink, 23 Aug. 1923 Krapp 1927 also notes the new sense "In careless collo- . . . haughtily refuse to alibi themselves when sus- quial speech," and Weseen 1928 calls it a misuse. Fow- pected —Emporia (Kans.) Gazette, 25 Oct. 1926 alien 67 all-around . . . a belief that is very much in the service of moral all 1. See ALL OF; ALL THAT; ALL READY, ALREADY; ALL alibi-ing —Weston La Barre, The Human Animal, TOGETHER, ALTOGETHER. 1954 2. In the worrisome world of pronoun agreement with indefinite pronoun referents (see, for instance: EACH; . . . wherein he endeavors to alibi reversal, surprise, EVERY; EVERYBODY, EVERYONE; THEY, THEIR, THEM), some and defeat —S. L. A. Marshall, Saturday Rev., 9 Oct. textbooks have recommended substituting construc- 1954 tions with all in place of constructions with each or They cannot point to the basest elements of their every in order to make both pronoun and referent gram- public and say, "They wanted chaff and slops," and matically and notionally plural. All is unquestionably thus alibi their failures —Frank Luther Mott, The plural in such constructions as these: News in America, 1952 . . . all of us have our part —Wyllis E. Wright, Wil- . . . this secretary asked if she mightn't take the mes- liams Alumni Rev., November 1953 sage, and alibied. "You see, the delegates are all in No one is held in higher esteem by all here, no mat- the meeting now," she said —New Yorker, 23 Sept. ter what their faith, than the American monsignor — 1950 John Cogley, Commonweal, 25 Dec. 1953 They might enter with a rather rough admonition of, Some textbooks, therefore, advise taking such sentences "What do youse guys think you're up to anyhow?" as This, however, was merely to alibi the fact that they were crashing —Anita Loos, Gourmet, January Every child should brush his/his or her/their teeth, 1970 and converting it to . . . he didn't alibi. He took the blame for his four All children should brush their teeth. interceptions —Dave Anderson, N Y. Times, 8 Sept. 1980 in order to avoid the difficult pronoun-referent choice presented by the first sentence. If you are uncomfortable The extended senses of alibi have been around for with using his or her or the generic his or their, you may about three quarters of a century, and they have been well want to consider using a construction with all to upwardly mobile in status—the noun perhaps more avoid the problem. than the verb. The usage is more controversial in British 3. All... not. Nickles 1974 and Kilpatrick 1984 note English than American English but is established in that in a conversational style of sentence with all and a both. negative (not), the negative element is often postponed so that it follows the verb, instead of preceding all. Copperud 1970, 1980 mentions several other com- alien In 20th-century English, when alien is used with mentators on the subject, including Fowler 1926. Fowler a preposition, the choice is most often to: points out that the all... not form is old, and instances . . . the contempt he felt for a quality so alien to the this well-known example: traditions of his calling —W. Somerset Maugham, All that glisters is not gold —Shakespeare, The Mer- The Moon and Sixpence, 1919 chant of Venice, 1597 Are such relationships alien to the principles of Kilpatrick 1984 gives some more modern examples: UNO? —Sir Winston Churchill, quoted in Time, 18 Mar. 1946 . . . all of the people who supported Ronald Reagan in California were not opposed to him on this tax bill . . . an acrid empty home with everyone growing —Lyn Nofziger alien to one another —Norman Mailer, The Naked and the Dead, 1948 . . . indicates that all places are not undercounted to the same extent —James Trussell At one time, alien was also commonly used with from, especially in literary contexts. While still found occa- . . . all seventy-four hospitals did not report every sionally, alien from is much less frequent now than alien month — Washington Post to: The point Kilpatrick is making with these examples is that in conversation these constructions are not ambig- . . . soon discerned his looks uous, but that they can be in print. In the last example Alien from Heaven, with passions foul obscured did none of the hospitals report? Or did only some fail —John Milton, Paradise Lost, 1667 to report? In writing it would be entirely unambiguous Here, oft the Curious Trav'ller finds, put this way: "not all seventy-four hospitals report every The Combat of opposing Winds: month." Kilpatrick's examples also show this poten- And seeks to learn the secret Cause, tially ambiguous construction with every, everyone, and Which alien seems from Nature's Laws everything. He quotes Ann Landers: —Jonathan Swift, "The Gulph of Everyone in San Francisco is not gay. all human Possessions," 1724 Putting the not first will remove the ambiguity: . . . to become a moral nihilist was to papa unthink- able, so alien was it from all his habits —Rose Not everyone in San Francisco is gay. Macaulay, Told by an Idiot, 1923 This is a point worth keeping in mind when you write. I felt somewhat alien from this company because of my experience with would-be Communists —Kath- all-around, all-round Copperud 1970, 1980 cites a erine Anne Porter, The Never-Ending Wrong, 1977 few commentators as worrying about which of these alleged 68 allergic synonyms is more logical or otherwise preferable. What Our evidence is not sufficient to tell whether alleged all the discussion omits is the only thing of real interest: is more often applied to persons or to actions and things all-around is American and has no British use; all-round in straight reporting. In contexts that are not reportorial has both British and American use. Here are a few we find it much more commonly applied to actions and examples of each: things—even Ambrose Bierce would not have been dis- pleased by most of our evidence. . . . unbeatable as all-around satisfying entertain- ment —Judith Crist, Saturday Rev., 17 Apr. 1976 . . . the Watergate affair and other alleged malprac- tices by members of his campaign staff—Richard H. . . . his exceptional all-around athletic performance Rovere, New Yorker, 18 Nov. 1972 —Current Biography, February 1966 . . . a controversial segment dealing with alleged FBI The new ideal is the all-around boy —Malcolm undercover operations —Robert Lewis Shayon, Sat- Cowley, New Republic, 2 2 Nov. 1954 urday Rev., 4 Dec. 1971 . . . such a strange thing as an all-around left-handed One result of the frequency of the word in journalistic man —Mark Twain, "How to Make Hist. Dates use has been the development of a humorous Stick," written 1899 (A Mark Twain Lexicon, 1938) application: . . . a fearless, self-confident swimmer, surfer, all- The only thing we could find was a bottle of alleged round athlete —Lyn Tornabene, Ladies' Home brandy —George S. Patton, Jr., War as I Knew It, Jour., January 1971 1947 . . . a round tin of alleged pork and egg, ground up . . . the all-round incompetence revealed by the Cri- together and worked to a consistency like the inside mean War —Times Literary Supp., 16 July 1970 of a sick lobster's claw —A. J. Liebling, New Yorker, . . . but Antigua has an all-round climate —Alec 19 May 1956 Waugh, Love and the Caribbean, 1958 A spelling reminder may not come amiss: alleged is no longer spelled, as it once was, with a -dge-. . . . one of the best all-round men in surgery —Dic- 2. When alleged is used as an adjective (as in "the tionary of American Biography, 1929 alleged arsonist"), it is often pronounced as three sylla- bles, though not as often as the adjective learned mean- alleged 1 . As long ago as 1909 Ambrose Bierce was ing "erudite" (as in "learned counsel") is pronounced as grousing about the use of allege in "the alleged mur- two. In the case of learned, the extra syllable helps to derer." "One can allege a murder, but not a murderer," underscore the sharp difference in meaning between says Bierce, basing his criticism on the meaning of the learned in "learned counsel" and learned in "learned verb. But even then alleged was already leading an inde- and innate behavior patterns." By comparison, the pendent existence as an adjective, not necessarily to be semantic split between the adjective alleged and past trammeled by the meanings of the verb. participial uses of the verb allege is not so sharp, and The adjective is attested as early as the 16th century the extra syllable is not as consistently used. Both pro- (as allegit) in Scots law; it perhaps came into main- nunciations are acceptable, however. stream English from this source, as the earliest attribu- tive alleged (in this meaning) cited in the OED is from allergic Usage commentators often fail to discover a Sir Walter Scott's The Fair Maid of Perth (1828). None new use until it is too late for their opinion to have any of the OED citations shows alleged applied to a person, influence on whether or not it becomes established. as in "the alleged murderer." This particular use may Copperud 1970 reports Bernstein 1965, Evans 1957, and have originated in American journalism—as Bierce's Follett 1966 all in disapproval of the nonmedical complaint suggests—but if it is an Americanism, none extended sense of allergic, "having an aversion." Phy- of the standard compendia of Americanisms have taken thian 1979 dislikes it too. The sense found its way into note of it. And since Bierce was apparently the first to Webster's Second in the 1950 Addenda section, albeit notice the use, it probably arose around the turn of the with a slang label (about which some of the editors were century. doubtful). The new sense was first called to public atten- Alleged has become a fixture of both print and broad- tion by Dwight L. Bolinger in Words, October 1937, the cast journalism. Its use is approved by Reader's Digest very year in which it is first attested. The OED Supple- 1983 (in preference to accused). Other commentators ment cites as its earliest evidence a New Yorker cartoon accept its inevitability but point out that it is sometimes printed in January 1938. A sample of early uses from carelessly applied; they warn against such examples as our files: "the alleged suspect." For St. Louis shoppers allergic to holiday crowds — . . . is seeking three quarters of a million dollars in Time, 19 Dec. 1938 alleged libel damages —"Morning Edition," Na- tional Public Radio, 2 2 May 1986 Newspapermen, on the whole, are allergic to him — Life, 31 Oct. 1938 Occasional careless use occurs outside straight report- . . . for some strange and yet unexplained reason, ing, too: women continue to be allergic to the charms of Mr. . . . alleging that the Company's underground electric Wodehouse's tales —Times Literary Supp., 13 May service plans violated antitrust laws and claiming 1939 alleged treble damages of $4.5 million —Annual By the late 1940s the sense was fully established, and it Report, Virginia Electric & Power Co., 1970 continues so despite the belated censure: This alleged account of sexual ambidexterity in high The twins were at all times entirely allergic to good life —Times Literary Supp., 18 Dec. 1969 influences —Elizabeth Goudge, Pilgrim's Inn, 1948 all of 69 all of If he was allergic to Scott, Byron, and Shelley, he was What all we of the general public have learned — among the first to recognize Coleridge, Burns, and Dorothy Canfield Fisher, ALA Bulletin, April 1943 Wordsworth —John Mason Brown, Saturday Rev., 31 July 1948 Most modern handbooks (and there are many) expect all o/before a pronoun: The majority abandoned their cars and set out to walk. I, who am allergic to rain, remained like a snail We all of us complain —Joseph Addison, The Spec- in its shell —S. P. B. Mais, The English Scene To- tator, No. 93, 1711 (OED) day, 2ded., 1949 We all of us, from our own feelings, can understand . . . for the sensitive who are allergic to social sheen —Lionel Trilling, Partisan Rev., September-Octo- and waste —Cyril Connolly, Encounter, January ber 1940 1955 King, like most all of us —Dan Wakefield, Los Ange- He is allergic to facts —William W. Watt, Ph.D., les Times Book Rev., 25 Apr. 1971 Famous Writers Mag., Spring 1968 The students, almost all of whom live at home — . . . I was allergic not only to things British, but to James B. Conant, Slums and Suburbs, 1961 English literature as well —Oscar Cargill, CEA . . . has written some twenty books, almost all of Critic, March 1972 which have been published —Current Biography, . . . says he is allergic to chain-link fencing and January 1964 barbed wire —John McPhee, New Yorker, 11 Sept. Your letter gave pleasure to all of us —Jane Austen, 1971 letter, 11 Oct. 1813 all of Copperud 1970, 1980 reports "a morass of con- Vizetelly (and his followers) recommended that all of flicting opinion" about the propriety of whether all them be replaced by they all or them all; all can always should be followed by of where of is unnecessary, as in follow the pronoun: "All (of) the percussion instruments" (American Mer- Fought you with them all? —Shakespeare, / Henry cury, January 1935, where of is included). Copperud IV, 1598 goes on to say, "The point is hardly an important one, since the choice has no effect on meaning and is unlikely And they all dead did lie —Samuel Taylor Coleridge, to be noticed by the reader." "The Rime of the Ancient Mariner," 1798 (OED) Copperud is right. But much has been written about this unimportant point, all the same. Let's begin with "Your patron saint, such as we all have." —Henry Bernstein 1971, who says, "The use of the word of after James, The American, 1877 all has for some time offended certain authoritari- . . . solidarity between Gatsby and me against them ans " These authoritarians seem to have included all _ _ F . Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby, 1925 one named Quackenbos (Practical Rhetoric, 1896, cited by Hall 1917), Bierce 1909, and Vizetelly 1906. Hall They all played "Body and Soul" —radio broadcast 1917 reports Alford 1864 as defending the locution, so program title, 1986 there were perhaps earlier objectors in England. The phrase singled out by Vizetelly for particular censure, Bierce took out after all o/followed by a noun; "all of oddly enough, was all of them. He does not seem to have his property" was the phrase he found to be "contradic- been aware that this phrase dated all the way back to tory." Some other early commentator must have found Shakespeare: such phrases redundant too—Utter 1916 mentions redundancy in his puzzled comment on the objection to I do forgive thy rankest fault—all of them —The all of them—for redundancy, not contradiction is the Tempest, 1 6 1 2 basis of remarks about all o/down to the present time. Here, in fact, w^do have mixed usage, but (as Copperud . . . so shall the Prince, and all of them —Much Ado and Bernstein suggest) it is not an issue of great impor- About Nothing, 1599 tance. Whether you use the pronoun all, with of, or the adjective all, without of is a matter of style, not of right Ay, all of them at Bristow lost their heads —Richard or wrong. Here are some examples, first of the adjective II, 1596 followed by nouns: Evidence in the Middle English Dictionary shows that All my pretty ones? —Shakespeare, Macbeth, 1606 at least as early as the 13th century all could modify a following pronoun. Thus, the King James Bible (1611) . . . with all his feet off the ground —Ford Madox has in Isaiah 53:6 Ford, // Was The Nightingale, 1933 All we like sheep have gone astray All his long struggle proves —Stanislaus Joyce, Interim, vol. 4, 1954 —a locution picked up directly from Wycliffe's 1382 translation. By Shakespeare's time idiom required all of Perhaps the most unique of all these hills —Donald us; the King James Bible in following Wycliffe had used A. Whiting, Ford Times, February 1968 an archaic form. All followed by a personal pronoun has .. . bringing all these old stories together —Times nearly disappeared from modern English; we have only Literary Supp., 9 Apr. 1970 a few examples: Just record on cards all those terms from this book We have been, all we Americans, strangely compla- —Robert Burchfield, in U.S. News & World Report, cent —Ecclesiastical Rev., April 1939 11 Aug. 1986 allow 70 allow The adjective is often used before an indefinite With a personal subject, in the active voice: pronoun: Whether his relationship with the Duchess was any- . . . all these become the subjects —Theodore thing more than the last platonic imbroglio of an Roszak, The Making of a Counter Culture, 1969 eccentric and slightly senile old codger Mr. Hough And here are some examples of the pronoun: does not allow himself to contemplate —Times Lit- erary Supp., 18 Dec. 1969 . . . during Nehru's last illness, Mrs. Gandhi handled all of his affairs —Current Biography, June 1966 I tried to leave, but they wouldn't allow it —E. L. Doctorow, Loon Lake, 1979 . . . all of this happens in a flash —William G. Moul- ton, NEA Jour., January 1965 The trial judge allowed testimony by the . . . officer —Security World, November 1969 You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can't fool Having promised the government... to stay off the all of the people all of the time —ascribed to Abra- streets, they did not allow a single incident —Tad ham Lincoln by A. K. McClure, Lincoln's Yarns and Szulc, NY. Times, 9 Jan. 1969 Stories, 1904 (in Bergen Evans, A Dictionary of Quo- . . . he allowed everyone to believe... that American tations, 1968) participation in the war was not inevitable —Times . . . a face-to-face talk, with all of its give and take — Literary Supp., 9 Apr. 1970 Edward P. Bailey, Jr., Writing Clearly, 1984 In the passive voice: The pronoun, like the adjective, can be used before an indefinite pronoun: This they must not be allowed to do! —Joseph Miller, Not Man Apart, July 1971 All of this, and much more —Will Herberg, National Rev., 25 Aug. 1970 . . . how rapidly the economy can be allowed to expand —Robert M. Solow, Think, May-June 1967 One additional point: a few handbooks (as Prentice- Hall 1978 and Little, Brown 1980, 1986) call for all of After Eisenhower pleaded with him, Roosevelt said before a proper noun, by which, their examples show, De Gaulle could be brought from Algiers to London they mean geographical names. Our evidence, however, and allowed to broadcast —Stephen E. Ambrose, is that both all and all of arc used before such terms: Johns Hopkins Mag., April 1966 . . . the best-equipped kitchen in all Boston —Cur- With an impersonal subject: rent Biography, February 1967 . . . the menu, which allowed each astronaut 2,500 . . . all Alexandria turned out —Lawrence Durrell, calories a day —Current Biography, November 1965 Mountolive, 1958 The catwalk was too narrow to allow them to step . . . the artlessness of all Ohio —Kay Boyle, Saturday back from the tank at all —Paul Horgan, Ladies' Evening Post, 11 Dec. 1954 Home Jour., January 1971 . . . the most fishable river banks in all New England . . . a routine surgical procedure to unblock his —Edward Weeks, New England Journeys, no. 3, esophagus and allow him to eat —Ronald Reagan, 1955 Abortion and the Conscience of the Nation, 1984 . . . the largest and most receptive audiences for new 2. Allow of. The intransitive allow, used with of has music in all of Europe —Current Biography, Decem- excited the disapproval of Copperud 1964, but it is per- ber 1964 fectly reputable. Reader's Digest 1983 accepts allow of with an impersonal subject, but not with a personal one. . . . the most rugged country in all of Colombia — Our evidence for use with a personal subject is old; Preston E. James, Latin America, rev. éd., 1950 impersonal subjects predominate in current usage. We can conclude that all of is usual before personal pro- nouns, both all and all of arc used before nouns—the all . . . I consented at the request of Lyell and Hooker to users seem to be a bit stronger on the literary side. The allow of an abstract from my manuscript . . . to be choice is a matter of style and it is likely to turn on the published —Charles Darwin, reprinted in The Prac- rhythm and emphasis of your sentence. It is unlikely tical Cogitator, ed. Charles P. Curtis, Jr. & Ferris that most of your readers will even notice which con- Greenslet, 1945 struction you have chosen. . . . the real charm of the 1930's bushwah Commu- See also BOTH 4. nism was the set of fine amateur theatricals it allowed of later —G. Legman, The Fake Revolt, allow 1 . Vizetelly 1906 and Bierce 1909 make an issue 1967 of distinguishing between allow and permit; they both insist that permit is better for the giving of express con- It takes a very sophisticated man to admit that the sent or authorization and would restrict allow to uses world is run by forces that do not always allow of where no objection or prevention is attempted. Shaw rational analysis —G. R. Urban, Center Mag., Jan- 1975 follows Vizetelly's interpretation, and the Oxford uary 1969 American Dictionary assures us that careful writers observe the distinction. Good writers, however, do as The past is the proper study of autobiography, for it seems best to them, and while some observe the distinc- allows of tranquil recollection —John Simon, in The tion, others do not. Here are some examples of allow in Film, 1968 its senses that are close to permit. See also ADMIT 3; PERMIT OF. allow 71 allow 3. The Dictionary of American Regional English lists respondence of Flannery O'Connor, a Georgian who four senses of allow with regional connections, some of used many regional expressions in her letters: which have come under attack as misuses, village idi- oms, vulgarisms, or provincialisms. We will take them My uncle Louis allowed he saw you the other day but up in order of increasing complexity. you didn't see him —letter, 1 June 1957 "To plan, intend" (DARE sense 4). The DARE labels . . . she allowed that they were going to query Rod- this sense chiefly Southern and Midland. They cite gers and Hammerstein —letter, 9 Mar. 1957 examples from Mark Twain, Bret Harte, Edward Eggle- ston. In this sense, allow is regularly followed by to and She also used allow in the blended sense: the infinitive: . . . heard Willard Thorpe read a paper on "The Gro- "I allowed to go back and help," Ellen said —Eliza- tesque in Southern Literature." He (Thorpe) allowed beth Madox Roberts (born in Kentucky), The Time as how the roots of it were in antebellum Southern of Man, 1926 writings—letter, 10 Dec. 1957 "To admit, concede" (DARE sense 3). This sense is . . . she allowed as how she liked the book —letter, mostly mainstream; it is not labeled in Webster's Third 24 Jan. 1962 or in the OED. It has a considerable literary We have evidence of Canadian use too—or at least use background: by Canadian-bom authors: You'll allow, that nothing receives infection sooner, They all allowed it was the most splendid thing in or retains it longer, than blankets, feather-beds, and the world —Thomas C. Haliburton, The Clock- mattresses —Tobias Smollett, reprinted in Encore, maker, 1837 November 1944 "That," he allowed, beaming, "is my favorite city in Those were your words.... it was some time, I con- the United States." —Mordecai Richler, Saturday fess, before I was reasonable enough to allow their Rev., 8 Jan. 1977 justice —Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, 1813 And by an Indiana native, not noted for his use of "Slay him not, Sir Knight," cried the Grand Master, regional terms: "We allow him vanquished." —Sir Walter Scott, Ivanhoe, 1819 . . . the meritorious critic, P. P. Howe, thinks other- wise and allows it was Wilde's utter disinterest — . . . I flatter myself, that it will be allowed that I, at George Jean Nathan, The Theatre Book of the Year, least, am a moral man —W. M. Thackeray, The 1946-1947 Book of Snobs, 1846 But it is the use in widely distributed newspapers and . . . one must allow that Pierre's promise of alle- magazines with no smack of the regional about them giance was kept —Henry Adams, Mont-Saint- that is puzzling. Winners & Sinners disapproves this Michel and Chartres, 1904 use: While he never disparaged Mr. Hoover, he allowed This sense continues to be used in mainstream English, that the late founder of the Federal Bureau of Inves- usually, as earlier, followed by a clause: tigation "was a man of the old school." —N.Y. Times, 20 May 1975 . . . asked if "Time and Time Again" would have a sequel, as rumored, he allowed it might —John K. But many similar uses appear in the Times and else- Hutchens, N. Y. Herald Tribune Book Rev., 27 Sept. where, and they seem to be deliberate rather than 1953 . inadvertant: Epstein allows that the priest was on the right track Brunot allowed as how a certain number of sets — Time, 14 Mar. 1955 could be sold by mail —Bennett Cerf, Saturday Rev., 21 Mar. 1953 Do ordinary people have more sense than profes- sionals ordinarily allow? —Nature, 20 Sept. 1969 Harry Truman met the press, felt the cloth of a reporter's cord suit and allowed as how he had one We must . . . allow that economic pressure in itself just like it —Time, 29 June 1953 can be generally disruptive —Elizabeth Janeway, Atlantic, March 1970 Renée Simmons, a 7-year-old..., shyly allowed that the roller skates were the best thing she had come The DARE remarks that its senses 1 ("to suppose, across —Lisa Hammel, N.Y. Times, 7 July 1967 think, consider") and 2 ("to assert, remark, opine, declare") are often hard to distinguish; some books, like . . . my faculty critic allowed as how the topic of drug the OED and Reader's Digest 1983, do not try to distin- use was a timely one —Robert J. Armbruster, Johns guish them. Sense 1 is marked chiefly Southern and Hopkins Mag., Spring 1971 Midland; 2 is not labeled, indicating widespread dialec- Premier Chou expressed cordiality toward the tal use. United States but allowed as how neither he nor . . . When someone holds an opinion and expresses it, Mao Tse-tung, who is studying English, are planning you cannot with certainty assign the use to either American visits —John Hughes, Christian Science sense—it is a blend of the two. It is this blended use that Monitor, 10 Oct. 1972 is the most common in our files, and it sometimes takes most peculiar turns. First, we show a couple of examples All allowed that they liked it all right —John Fischer, that mean merely "say." These are both from the cor- Harper's, November 1972 all ready 72 all that Sounding like Polonius, Papp went on to allow that impress but to charm with just-plain-folksiness. If you anything the British can do, we can do better —Karl are unsure of how to use these expressions through unfa- E. Meyer, Saturday Rev., 2 2 July 1978 miliarity, or are simply not comfortable with them, we suggest you avoid them. But they are available to be . . . and Imogene Glover allowed as how she was used for the purposes described and in contexts like intending to buy her son a sleeveless sweater —Enid those quoted above. Nemy, N.Y. Times, 12 Aug. 1980 See also AS HOW. Any hardwood will do, Henry allows, but hop horn- beam . . . is preferable —Nancy Means Wright, Blair all ready, already In the closing decades of the 20th & Ketchum's Country Jour., November 1980 century the distinction between all ready and already no longer needs explanation except perhaps for school chil- Reader's Digest 1983 quotes William Safire: dren. It is primarily a spelling problem now, one only Nixon allowed as how the best way to knock Rom- rarely muffed by grown-ups: ney down in the polls was to remove his winner sta- tus by beating him in New Hampshire —Before the A few of these have been sold for breeding purposes Fall all ready —Holstein-Friesian World, 1 Mar. 1952 with the observation that allow as how is being used for All ready is two words. When they occur together as a a mildly satirical effect. But there has to be more to it fixed phrase rather than a coincidence (as in "We are all than that in our examples above—what would be the ready to leave"), they mean ready; all is merely an point, for instance, of satirizing, no matter how mildly, intensive. The phrase exists chiefly in speech, and is sel- a 7-year-old girl on roller skates? dom to be found in edited prose except transcribed The picture is further complicated when the "con- speech. It is therefore seldom a problem. cede, admit" sense is combined with "say," as it is Already is an adverb. It is used in sentences like this: rather frequently: The train had already left when we got to the station Riots conceivably are a good thing, Banfield allows, —Corder 1981 but we can't be very sure of that —Richard Todd, Atlantic, September 1970 all right See ALRIGHT, ALL RIGHT. . . . admits that the $5,000-per-couple tariff is fairly all-round See ALL-AROUND, ALL-ROUND. steep, and stands to net First Metropolitan a neat profit. "It's priced to reflect the uniqueness of the all that The usage in question here is simply the tour," he allows —Bruce McEwen, quoted by Robert adverbial that (see THAT 5) with the intensifier all added Levy in Dun's, October 1971 to it; it is almost always found in negative constructions: The official cleared his throat and allowed as how . . . Durham City . . . had not changed all that much that was so —William H. Honan, Saturday Rev., since medieval times —Sam Pollock, London Call- May 1973 ing, 10 June 1954 . . . a chastened Beutel allowed as how he wanted to They are not all that worried now. They took Taft return —Gary Paul Gates, TV Guide, 24 Aug. 1979 more seriously than Goldwater —C. L. Sulzberger, N.Y. Times, 9 Oct. 1963 . . . admitted he had been scared up there. But then he allowed as how he is always scared in the wind — Copperud 1970 cites himself, Bernstein 1965, and Her- Jim Doherty, Sports Illustrated, 11 Aug. 1980 itage 1969 in disapproval, although he concedes that Fowler 1965 says it is approaching literary acceptance. Conclusion: Allow "intend" (I allowed to help) is Copperud claims the expression is a Briticism that chiefly Southern and Midland; allow "concede" (You sounds affected in the U.S. Mittins et al. 1970, on the must allow that . . . ) has dialectal use but also much other hand, cite a British usage book that says it is an mainstream use, of which there is a long tradition; allow Americanism. As you might expect from such contra- "say" (Uncle Louis allows he saw you) is dialectal; allow dictory statements, not all that is common on both sides "suppose, think" (We allowed you wasn't coming) is of the Atlantic. chiefly Southern and Midland and somewhat old-fash- ioned. But when allow "say" combines with allow A large tomcat came along the gutter and found a "think" or allow "concede," we seem to have something fish head; he spurred it once or twice with his claws different. Allow that and allow as how have escaped and then moved on: he wasn't all that hungry —Gra- from the bottle of regionalisms into general prose; they ham Greene, The Confidential Agent, 1939 seem to be used, especially by journalists, as leavening to help in the creation of a light, informal style. While He likes to act country, but he don't have all that far allow "concede" can be found in very serious writing— to go—he is country —Eudora Welty, The Ponder Heart, 1954 It is allowed that Hegel may have propounded indi- vidual doctrines which could be of some interest: in Piggy rebuked him with dignity. aesthetics, in political philosophy, perhaps even in "I haven't said anything all that funny." —Wil- philosophy of religion —Times Literary Supp., 19 liam Golding, Lord of the Flies, 1954 June 1969 . . . took a look at the cemetery designed by the great Sir Joseph, but didn't think it all that impressive — —allow "state as an opinion or concession" especially Clémence Dane, The Flower Girls, 1954 with as how cannot. The current use of allow as how is somewhat similar to the use of ain 't in some of its fixed . . . asking at the wrong time why they did not go phrases, for both are signs of a style that aims not to back to their Banks and Braes, if they were all that all the 73 all-time fashed about the lack of them —Wilson Neill, Scots struction in speech in many areas of the United States. Mag., October 1957 Surveys made for the Dictionary of American Regional English found the construction in 40 of the 50 states, but Slowly he becomes aware that the world isn't all that it is especially common in Southern and South Midland easy to conquer —Hollis Alpert, Saturday Rev., 3 speech with a positive adjective and in inland Northern Oct. 1964 and North Midland speech with a comparative adjec- By itself, the temporary walkout was not all that tive. Informants on all educational levels use the con- important —Newsweek, 27 June 1966 struction. For example, . . . anything that it takes a computer to work out is That's all the fast this horse can run. (DARE) not gong to be checked all that quickly —Times Lit- erary Supp., 8 Sept. 1966 is the spoken equivalent of the written Even here Johnson is not being all that original: That's as fast as this horse can run. wishes of exactly this sort are a well established eigh- Or teenth-century satiric convention —Paul Fussell, Samuel Johnson and the Life of Writing, 1971 That is all the tighter I can tie it. (American Speech, December 1953) It was not that he would find life there dangerous or even, at the time, all that expensive —John Kenneth is the spoken equivalent of Galbraith, New York, 15 Nov. 1971 That's as tight as I can tie it. Farmers are not used to theatre and they're not all that polite —Rick Salutin, in Canadian Theatre If the handbooks are to be trusted, all the fart her (or fur- Rev., Spring 1975 ther) for the written as far as is particularly common. We have no evidence of the expression in written Separate diseases, even though they were recognized English, except in reports of speech. The as ... as con- as distinct clinical entities and given different names, struction prevails in written English. were not regarded as all that separate in their under- lying mechanisms —Lewis Thomas, Atlantic, April all-time Copperud 1970, 1980 and Kilpatrick 1984 1981 object to all-time record as redundant; Bernstein 1971 . . . incredibly rich and tasty and not all that difficult defends all-time high (aspersed by an editor of his to prepare —Craig Claiborne et al., N.Y. Times acquaintance) as well as other uses of all-time in con- Mag., 24 Apr. 1983 texts where it is not superfluous. In these days of ram- pant record-keeping, all-time is not necessarily out of Ebbitt & Ebbitt 1982 calls the construction "informal place as an intensifier. Records are reported by the day, and imprecise"—complaining, as it were, about its pri- month, quarter, year, decade, and many other units mary virtues. It is used for understatement, sometimes of time. Modification of record is often essential for with ironic intent. Harper 1975, 1985 and the survey of clarity. All-time has been used with record since the Mittins et al. agree in finding it unobjectionable in 1930s: speech. Some of the foregoing examples are from real or fictional speech, but many are not. It has been used in Gehrig ties all-time record with four straight home fiction, in reportage, and occasionally in more serious runs —NY. Times, 4 June 1932 writing. It appears to be established as standard. . . . 1936 was an all-time record year for the com- mercial producers —Harper's, February 1938 all the l.All the plus a comparative adverb (or some- times adjective) is an English idiom that occurs in stan- . . . flew from England to South Africa in 45 hours, dard written English; in it all the functions as a simple an all-time record —Time, 4 Apr. 1938 intensifier: It is still in use: . . . the omission found by me was an all the deadlier record of poor Soames' failure to impress himself on . . . who has set an all-time major-league record for his decade —Max Beerbohm, Seven Men, 1920 saves during the season —Roger Angell, New Yorker, 11 Nov. 1972 . . . hating their clean white shiny faces and loving the Johnsons all the more —Morley Callaghan, The . . . must set an all-time record for boredom in tele- Loved and the Lost, 1951 vised sports —Jonathan Evan Maslow, Saturday Rev., 10 Dec. 1977 They will like you all the better for not filling their minds with any nonsense about jurisprudence — Most of the use of all-time is taken up in modifying a Robert M. Hutchins, Center Mag., January 1969 relatively few nouns. Among the most common are high, low (more common with all-time than record is), . . . from Soviet sources and therefore all the more and great. revealing—Geographical Jour. June 1954 Betting also hit an all-time high —Audax Minor, . . . and when this is the case the humanist is all the New Yorker, 12 May 1973 farther from revealing the relevance of the humani- ties to the contemporary concerns of most living . . . the power of traditionally shocking words to men —American Council of Learned Societies, shock is at an all-time low —Thomas H. Middleton, Agenda, 27-28 Oct. 1950 Saturday Rev., 11 Dec. 1976 2. All the plus an adjective or adverb in the positive or . . . Dame Alicia Markova, an all-time ballet great — comparative degree replaces the written as . . . as con- Walter Terry, Saturday Rev., 12 Feb. 1972 all together 74 allude Time has been writing all-time as one word without a The trouble was, however, that it was so concerned hyphen since the 1940s, but most publications use the and involved and relevant and all together and right- hyphenated form. on —Cleveland Amory, TV Guide, 13 Mar. 1971 . . . records for us Boswell-like the public all-together all together, altogether 1 . Copperud 1970, 1980 Angels —Times Literary Supp., 11 Jan. 1968 warns us that these expressions are often confused; a score of books or more from 1907 to the present warn This use too can turn up with the spelling of the adverb: us not to confuse them. Evidence in the OED suggests, . . . just a nice, warm altogether sort of a family — in fact, that all together "in a group"—actually an inten- Walter Schackenbach, quoted in N. Y. Times, 5 Mar. sified form of all—was up until the late 16th or early 1984 17th century spelled altogether. Thus, what the modern handbooks call confusion would appear to be simply a In spite of the instances from 1765 to 1984 of the adver- substitution of an obsolete spelling for what is now the bial spelling in place of the usually adjectival phrase, all usual form. together does not appear to be in danger of being The problem is perhaps exacerbated by the sense of replaced by the old one-word form. Still, you will want the adverb altogether that means "in all, in sum, in to take care in your choice of spelling, case by case. toto": 2. We are assured by Copperud that when altogether means "nude" in the phrase in the altogether, it is Altogether, about 1,500 insects died in the Harvard spelled as one word. Why this warning is necessary is laboratories —Isaac Asimov, Think, May-June not clear, for no evidence of a two-word spelling has 1967 been brought forward since the expression first appeared in the novel Trilby by George du Maurier in 1894, and . . . altogether she has recorded twelve discs for this we have none. Perhaps the possibility of punning wor- label —Current Biography, June 1967 ries the pundits: This sense was at least once converted to all together, perhaps by someone who was trying too hard not to con- . . . these kids continually indulged in swimming all fuse the two: together in the "altogether" —The Bulletin (Sydney, Australia), 9 May 1903 Kazanski batted in five runs all together —N.Y. Times, 9 Aug. 1956 (cited in Winners & Sinners 15 A more interesting question is how du Maurier's "for Aug. 1956) the 'altogether'" became in the altogether, as it had by 1903. No one offers a guess. It is, however, the opposite error that the handbooks seem mostly interested in. It is first spotted in Fowler & Fowler 1907, where an example from something John all told Bernstein 1965, who is perhaps more aware Ruskin wrote is cited. Fowler 1926 adds a few more of etymology than most of us, is alone in objecting to examples. The OED Supplement takes notice, with the use of this phrase when enumeration is not examples from 1765 to 1930. The Merriam-Webster involved. The phrase is derived from the sense of tell files contain a few examples too: that means "count." But the phrase is used in general summation too, perhaps because many people are Put it altogether, and it added up to a tragic Labor unaware of the "count" meaning of the verb. Here are a Day weekend —Deerfield (Wise.) Independent, 2 couple of examples of each kind of summation. The Sept. 1954 numerical is more frequent. . . . designs these three pieces with enough panache All told, he figures, the government next year will to be worn with basic black, or altogether as an borrow about $800 billion —Lindley H. Clark, Jr., ensemble —Boston Proper Catalog, Spring/Summer Wall Street Jour., 30 Dec. 1981 1982 All told, some 63 species of birds breed in the Falk- Here are a few examples of all together: lands —Tui De Roy Moore, International Wildlife, September-October 1982 . . . life . . . is wider than science or art or philosophy or all together —Jacques Barzun, quoted in Current All told, the "natural" granolas are not nearly as Biography, September 1964 good for you —Jane E. Brody, N. Y. Times, 12 Dec. 1979 . . . the crowd rose to them, clapping all together in time —William Hunter, Glasgow (Scotland) Herald, All told, a bad and boring book —Joseph W. Bishop, 14 June 1974 Trans-Action, February 1970 All together can be divided by intervening words, as those know who remember the satirist Tom Lehrer's allude 1 . Allude has been the subject of much com- line "We'll all go together when we go": mentary since sometime around the middle of the nine- teenth century. Richard Grant White 1870 is the earliest We must all be there together —Cleveland Amory, critic in our library to discuss the subject, but Bardeen Saturday Rev., 28 June 1969 1883 lists two sources from the 1860s, so White was not There is a modern use of together as an adjective—a the originator. The gist of the 19th-century argument is use sometimes associated with psychobabble—that is that allude has a certain subtle meaning—"delicate" is occasionally given emphasis by the addition of all: White's term—involving indirection and wordplay that has been sullied if not entirely spoiled by the unlettered Does he look nervous? Does he have it all together? and unwashed, who cannot tell the difference between —V. Lance Tarrance, quoted in N.Y. Times Mag., allude and say, mention, name, speak of. Around the 15 June 1980 turn of the century there is a slight shift in the wind: the allude 75 allude new commentators (Vizetelly 1906, Bierce 1909, Utter . . . it was against all the rules of their code that the 1916, for instance) abandon the lament for what is being mother and son should ever allude to what was lost and turn to straightforward prescription. "One can uppermost in their thoughts —Edith Wharton, The allude to a thing only indirectly," says Utter 1916; Age of Innocence, 1920 "What is alluded to is not mentioned, but referred to indirectly," says Bierce 1909. And so it goes, down to Never once did he allude to the reason for her visit the present: "To allude to is to refer to indirectly" (Pren- —Daphne du Maurier, Ladies' Home Jour., Septem- tice Hall 1978); "To allude is to make indirect mention ber 1971 of something" (Corder 1981); ""Allude means to refer to . . . but Boswell never heard Johnson allude to the a person or thing indirectly or by suggestion" (Macmil- matter —John Wain,. SamuelJohnson, 1974 lan 1982). "Allude is often misused for refer," says Cop- perud 1970, 1980. The resemblance between the two was strong, except What is most important for you as a modern reader that Dolly had a bust—a difference she alluded to or writer to realize about these commentators—the dis- several times —Jay Mclnerney, Bright Lights, Big tant and the recent alike—is that their whole argument City, 1984 is based on a set of false assumptions. First is the assumption of the primacy of the etymology. White In these contexts—which are of common occurrence— insists that allude must involve wordplay because the the reader is not given enough clues to identify one word is derived from the Latin alludere "to play with." meaning or the other. These passages are not in the least Vizetelly 1906 also talks at length about the etymology, incorrect or carelessly written—they are simply too gen- but Bierce 1909 dismisses it: "That meaning is gone out eral to help discriminate fine shades of meaning. of it." And indeed it had. The OED shows 1607 as Then too, the very indirectness of reference of allude the date of the latest example of allude used for word- has contributed to the development of the direct sense. play. We will illustrate this with a passage written by John The second false assumption is that the ignorant and Adams; his use of allude is a textbook example— uneducated are responsible for the "direct" sense (as indeed, he probably could not have chosen a différent opposed to the prescribed "indirect" sense). Even the word. But please notice where the actual allusion occurs OED subscribes to this view. Only Lounsbury 1908 has with respect to where allude appears: looked carefully enough to recognize that the sense has "been employed not simply by ordinary men, but by I concluded with a motion, in form, that Congress speakers and writers of high cultivation, and in a few would adopt the army at Cambridge, and appoint a instances of high authority." Examples of this class of General; that though this was not the proper time to use are given below in the course of the discussion. nominate a General, yet, as I had reason to believe The third false assumption is that the new "direct" this was a point of the greatest difficulty, I had no use has driven or will drive the old subtle sense out of hesitation to declare that I had but one gentleman in the language. The fact is that it has done no such thing my mind for that important command, and that was in well over 100 years. You can use the "indirect" sense a gentleman from Virginia who was among us and just as well today as you could two centuries ago: very well known to all of us, a gentleman whose skill and experience as an officer, whose independent for- You can disguise its aggressiveness all you want with tune, great talents, and excellent universal character, veils of subordinate clauses and qualifiers and ten- would command the approbation of all America, tative subjunctives, with ellipses and evasions—with and unite the cordial exertions of all the Colonies the whole manner of intimating rather than claim- better than any other person in the Union. Mr. ing, of alluding rather than stating —Joan Didion, Washington, who happened to sit near the door, as N.Y. Times Book Rex., 5 Dec. 1976 soon as he heard me allude to him, from his usual modesty, darted into the library-room —reprinted in The fourth false assumption is that the "direct" use is The Practical Cogitator, ed. Charles P. Curtis, Jr. & a misuse. It is not. It is simply a logical extension from Ferris Greenslet, 1945 the indirect use, and indeed is an inevitable develop- ment from the surviving senses of allude—inevitable This passage demonstrates that when the indirect sense from the very indirectness of the earlier use. of allude is clearly the one being used, the indirect ref- Why inevitable? you may ask. Most readers, even erence itself is very likely to occur well ahead of the those who later become authors, learn the use of words word. And if you begin reading in the middle, or if part from the contexts in which they find them. Allude is of the passage is excerpted, you may never realize the often found in contexts in which it is not possible to care with which allude was selected. know for certain whether the word is to be taken in its Allude to has another sense—approximately "to men- "indirect" sense or not. Some examples are offered here. tion in passing"—that the handbooks (but not the large In the first, those readers familiar with what Dr. John- dictionaries) tend to overlook. Here is a classic example son said of Goldsmith will know if allude here is indi- of the use from George Jean Nathan: rect or direct; others will not: If, suffering from a selfish conviction that I was He had . . . none of that charm of style to which Dr. doing too great a share of the work, I wrote him Johnson alluded when he wrote of Goldsmith, that somewhat acrimoniously to that effect, instead of he touched nothing he did not adorn —Thomas Sec- making matters worse by replying directly to the idi- combe, Introduction to Everyman edition of George otic contention all that he would do would be to send Borrow's Lavengro, 1906 me a lengthy list of his ailments, thus breaking my heart, together with some such irrelevant footnote I wonder if you and Mrs. Aubrey Moore will ever as, "I hope you put aside a case of that Roederer allude to your acceptance of an invitation which she against my birthday, which occurs on September declined —Lewis Carroll, letter, 16 Nov. 1896 12th. In general, as you know, I detest birthday près- allusion 76 allusion ents, but mature reflection has led me to conclude able only in particular moments —Edgar Allan Poe, that I should make an exception of wines and liquors "The Fall of the House of Usher," 1839 of high tone.*' He writhes when anyone so much as hints at a ref- I have alluded to his maladies. —The Intimate erence to his work, and actually groans aloud today Notebooks of George Jean Nathan, 1932 when V. alludes to a dramatization of Brave New World —Robert Craft, Stravinsky, 1972 Nathan, having mentioned the maladies in passing, goes on then to expand upon the subject considerably. This She remembered what a sweet, lovely, polite girl my use of allude is not rare—it is accounted for by defini- sister was, and was shocked that I should be so tions in the OED and Webster's Third. Again we find thoughtless as to write as I had about her intimate the allusion itself placed at some distance from allude. life, especially to make jokes about her unfortunate In our next example, from Thackeray, the actual allu- tendency to gain weight. Since unlike Alexander sion (in the edition at hand) is on the preceding page: Portnoy, I happen never to have had a sister, I assumed it was some other Jewish Athena with a It is not snobbish of persons of rank of any other tendency to gain weight to whom my correspondent nation to employ their knife in the manner alluded was alluding —Philip Roth, Reading Myself and to — The Book of Snobs, 1846 Others, 1975 The manner alluded to involves the use of the knife to At one of the plenary sessions, Churchill alluded eat peas with. Between the description of the act and obliquely to his idea —New Statesman & Nation, 19 Thackeray's resumption of the subject on the next page Dec. 1953 there is interposed a considerable bit of matter devoted to Thackeray's social relationship with the man who so . . . sexual matters only obliquely alluded to —How- used his knife. But the allusion is not, in fact, merely ard Kissel, Women's Wear Daily, 25 Oct. 1976 mentioned in passing—it is the chief motivating action . . . proposals, which were never called proposals, of the essay. Thackeray's allusion is at once more but always alluded to slightingly as innovations — remote—physically—and less casual than Nathan's. Compton Mackenzie, The Parson's Progress, 1923 (And even Nathan's reference has been purposely planted to supply a bridge to the further discussion of " . . . The trouble with fruit, though, is that it gives maladies.) him that intestinal condition I alluded to." —Jean From a variety of rhetorical strategies or unintended Stafford, Children Are Bored on Sunday, 1945 effects, then, the "indirect" sense can shade into the "direct" sense; they are, so to speak, simply different To be such a master of the inward richness of words parts of a continuum. There does not appear to be any- is to take visionary possession of the things to which thing out of the ordinary in the development, and, given the words allude —Richard Poirier, A World Else- the number of ambiguous examples likely to be encoun- where, 1966 tered, it hardly seems possible that allude could have . . . the records of the colony allude to beer as one of continued pure in the narrow stream of signification the its commodities —Dictionary of American History, commentators had laid out for it. What we have in real- 1940 ity is a word with three interrelated uses—indirect, ca- sual, direct—that can shade into one another impercep- This theory is alluded to in the title; it is explicitly tibly. We conclude this exegesis with a selection of stated, by my count, at least thirty times in the examples from this century and the last—most of them book —David Littlejohn, Commonweal, 30 Jan. considerably shorter than the preceding examples— 1970 some of which will fit obviously into one or another of the three categories of use, and some of which will not. . . . serves as a kind of fable, to which the rest of the They are all impeccably standard. novel will repeatedly allude in one way or another — Times Literary Supp., 1 Nov. 1968 She alluded once or twice to her husband but her I'm bound to allude to some classic of literature tone was not such as to make the allusion a warning whether it's Pindar or Homer or Virgil —Erich —James Joyce, Dubliners, 1914 Segal, quoted in Vogue, 1 Aug. 1971 He ascribed the poverty of her attire to the attempts to keep herself respectable, which Ellen during sup- By now you will have a good enough sense of how allude per had more than once alluded to —Samuel Butler, is actually used to be able to ignore with safety the blink- The Way of All Flesh, 1903 ered directions of the handbooks. 2. Allude, elude. MacCracken & Sandison 1917 warn Hazlitt has written a grammar for Godwin; Godwin against confusing allude and elude. The verbs sound sells it bound up with a treatise of his own on lan- about the same, but differ considerably in meaning, as a guage, but the grey mare is the better horse. I don't glance at your dictionary will demonstrate. We do have allude to Mrs. Godwin, but to the word grammar — evidence that they are occasionally confused: Charles Lamb, letter, 2 Jan. 1810 . . . widespread recognition has alluded Larry Sparks Never once did she allude to anything that had —Bluegrass Unlimited, February 1982 occurred since her marriage —Ellen Glasgow, Bar- ren Ground, 1925 If you are doubtful, get out that dictionary. He never alluded so directly to his story again —E. E. Hale, The Man Without A Country, 1863 allusion Fowler 1926 and a few other commentators (as Bryson 1984) discuss their disapproval of the sense . . . that intense mental collectedness and concentra- development of allude under this heading. See the dis- tion to which I have previously alluded as observ- cussion at ALLUDE 1. ally 77 alone ally Ally is used about equally with to or with when it The adjective is sometimes hyphenated to its noun: requires a preposition: . . . the blond with the almost-beard —Ned Hoopes, Closely allied to his pride was his very strict sense of Media & Methods, November 1968 justice —Robert A. Hall, Jr., A Short History of Ital- ian Literature, 1951 . . . and an almost-doctorate from Harvard —Busi- ness Week, 22 July 1972 Allied to this general problem is the need in many cases to retrain teachers —James B. Conant, Slums Almost also has some uses as an adverb that look much and Suburbs, 1961 like adjective uses: It is to ally you with the events of the page —Bernard Almost everybody should be happy —Forbes, 1 Dec. DeVoto, The World of Fiction, 1950 1970 John Dewey and Thorstein Veblen were allied in his . . . he was almost a virgin —David J. Pittman, mind with the Chicago sociologist George Herbert Trans-Action, March-April 1971 Mead —Alfred Kazin, NY. Times Book Rev., 16 Sept. 1979 . . . the students, almost all of whom live at home — James B. Conant, Slums and Suburbs, 1961 Our files show that when ally is used with to, the verb is usually in the past tense or in the past participle; when . . . how young an animal—a baby almost —Stephen ally is used with with, a greater variety of tenses appears. Jay Gould, Natural History, December 1983 Ally is also used with against sometimes: 3. The use of almost before never (and other negatives . . . the great resources and wealth of the Arab states such as no and nothing) comes in for passing mention should be allied against the temptations . . . of god- in Harper 1975, 1985 and Copperud 1980. Harper less communism —David L. Lawrence, Land believes that some people still object to this combina- Reborn, November-December 1953 tion, but the issue is an old one, dating back to the 18th century, and seems to draw little attention now. Cop- perud and Jespersen 1917 both mention James Boswell, almost 1 . See MOST, ALMOST. who was prevailed upon to change such sentences as "I 2. Copperud 1970, 1980 tells us that almost as an adjec- suppose there is almost no language" to "we scarcely tive modifying a noun is standard and well established, know of a language" by the argument that almost no or but that in the U.S. this use is likely to be considered a almost nothing was not English. Boswell apparently had mistake. Who considers it a mistake now we do not his doubts, but revised all the same. Jespersen adduces know, but around the turn of the century there seems to examples from British, Scottish, and American English have been some controversy about it. Vizetelly 1906 to demonstrate that the construction was not especially considers that the adjective use "has not received the rare. Among the English writers Jespersen quotes are sanction of general usage." Hall 1917 reports the text- Bacon, Cowper, and Jane Austen: books of three rhetoricians—A. S. Hill, Quackenbos, Genung—as condemning the construction, but he cites . . . she has found almost nothing —Jane Austen, examples of its use by Thackeray, Hawthorne, Coleridge Mansfield Park, 1814 and others. Evidence in the Merriam-Webster files shows the adjective use to be standard, but not espe- The same phrase occurs in Ford Madox Ford: cially frequent. Here is a sampling, including many . . . if he wants to find Louis Treize stuff . . . for American sources: almost nothing— The Last Post, 1928 At Barking, in the almost solitude of which so large Jespersen cites Henry James, too: a portion of my life was passed —Jeremy Bentham, "Reminiscences of Childhood," 1843 He himself was almost never bored —The Ameri- can, 1877 The contrast between Harding's zest for physical exercise and his almost torpor when in repose — These are a couple of more recent examples from our Mark Sullivan, Our Times, vol. 6, 1935 files: . . . the car skidded, plowing sideways to an almost . . . has accomplished almost nothing —Joseph P. stop —Ernest Hemingway, "The Short Happy Life Lyford, Center Mag., May 1968 of Francis Macomber," in The Short Stories, 1938 . . . you could almost never get him in so far that he . . . a potential, an almost Prime Minister —Times couldn't get out and beat you —R. C. Padden, Har- Literary Supp., 12 Feb. 1938 per's, February 1971 There was a flash of almost admiration —Christo- It is hard to imagine anyone objecting to them. pher Morley, The Man Who Made Friends with 4. Copperud 1970, 1980 and Johnson 1982 object to Himself, 1949 almost before comparatives like more, less, and better . . . a little fellow whom only an almost miracle can on the grounds that it violates logic. Although both set on his feet —Henry Seidel Canby, Saturday Rev., seem to feel the construction is common, we have no 13 Sept. 1952 examples of it in the Merriam-Webster files. It may be chiefly or exclusively an oral use. . . . the present limits and the future possibilities of the almost science of economics —Robert Lekach- alone From Ayres 1881 to Jensen 1935 a modest man, New Republic, 10 Aug. 1953 amount of objection was entered to alone meaning "only," as in So the U.S. embraces an almost imperialism — Michael Harrington, American Power in the Twen- It is written, That man shall not live by bread alone tieth Century, 1967 —Luke 4:4 (AV), 1611 alongside of 78 alot Jensen explains that the sense is not current; but in fact . . . airplanes that will stand up fairly well alongside the sense was current in the 19th century when Ayres of the best in the world —Yale Rev., 1936 wrote, and is still current in carefully edited standard prose: . . . now engaged alongside of us in the battle — Dwight D. Eisenhower, Britain To-Day, September He alone lynches in cold blood —G. Legman, Love 1944 and Death, 1949 They also use them alongside of the ideograms — . . . not all of whom had their minds on baseball Mario Pei, The Story of Language, 1949 alone —Al Hirshberg, quoted in Current Biography, . . . postulate a second substance whose essence is March 1965 thought, alongside of body —Noam Chomsky, . . . decided that fur trading alone would never make Columbia Forum, Spring 1968 New Netherland a proper colony —Samuel Eliot This work had to be carried forward alongside the Morison, Oxford History of the American People, first —Harry S. Truman, State of the Union Address, 1965 7 Jan. 1953 Follett 1966 and Barzun 1975 try to tease some ambi- Should it, in a draft..., have been published along- guity out of sentences like those above in order to justify side the flawless final writing of The Great Gatsby? a preference for only that Ayres simply states. But when —James Thurber, New Republic, 22 Nov. 1954 alone means "only", it regularly follows the noun it modifies. One can argue that . . . bring the launch alongside the Lamb Island dock —Daphne du Maurier, Ladies' Home Jour., Septem- Davis now alone unites them —Henry Adams, let- ber 1971 ter, 23 Apr. 1863 Did the novel grow out of the critical study, or along- is ambiguous, since it is not certain whether alone side i t . . . ? —J. M. Cocking, Times Literary Supp., means "only" or "all by himself," but the ambiguity is 21 May 1982 really created by the intervention of now between the name and alone. Reverse the adjective and adverb, and . . . ever since she graduated (alongside Nancy Davis presto—no more ambiguity. In any case, worrying Reagan) from Smith College —William F. Buckley, about ambiguity here is worth little, because the sen- Jr., New Yorker, 31 Jan. 1983 tence says essentially the same thing no matter which interpretation you give alone. When an author wants to aloof The usual preposition following aloof is from: emphasize "by oneself," alone is usually placed after a . . . the Peels were always quite aloof from the ordi- verb or copula: nary social life of the town —Arnold Bennett, The She wished only to be alone —Stella Gibbons, Cold Old Wives'Tale, 1908 Comfort Farm, 1932 He stood aloof from worldly success —John Buchan, Pilgrim's Way, 1940 alongside of, alongside Longman 1984 tells us alongside of is widely disliked, but little evidence of . . . remain aloof from the war —Irwin Shaw, The widespread dislike has reached our files. The Oxford Young Lions, 1948 American Dictionary, Shaw 1962, and Harper 1975, . . . morbidly aloof from reality —William Styron, 1985 mention it. It is, of course, perfectly proper, and Lie Down in Darkness, 1951 historically antecedent to the single word preposition, alongside, recommended by our four commentators. I felt curiously aloof from my own self —Vladimir The adverb alongside came first, was then used as a Nabokov, Lolita, 1958 preposition with of and later the o/was dropped. (For a counter case where the commentators object to drop- . . . remain resolutely aloof from the Vietnam war — ping of see COUPLE, adjective.) The OED shows that Norman Cousins, Saturday Rev., 28 June 1975 alongside o/was used by Thomas Jefferson and Nathan- iel Hawthorne in the 19th century. Occasionally to is used: Our files show that alongside has been more fre- . . . the United States remained coldly aloof to the quently used in the modern era than alongside of and suggestion—Collier's Year Book, 1949 that alongside is much more common in our most recent evidence; use of the two-word form may be . . . respectful but aloof to Marx, Engels, and Lenin beginning to recede. Our evidence also suggests that the —Lucien Price, Dialogues of Alfred North White- nautical origin of these words is no longer a major factor head, 1954 in their use and that figurative use is at least as common Other prepositions may be used to indicate somewhat as the literal use that refers to physical position. We will different relationships: give you a sampling of 20th-century use of alongside of and then a few, mostly recent, examples of the single- He is terse, cool-headed in a crisis, inclined to be word preposition. aloof with strangers —Tris Coffin, Nation's Busi- ness, April 1954 Alongside of your last letter a day or two ago came a dear little note from your daughter —Oliver Wen- . . . holding herself aloof in chosen loneliness of pas- dell Holmes d. 1935, letter, 5 Nov. 1923 sion —Paul Elmer More, Selected Shelburne Essays, 1921 . . . Tacitus really has the spirit of great drama and alongside of him the medieval chroniclers . . . seem alot, a lot A lot is apparently often written as one dull and tame —Harold J. Laski, letter, 15 Aug. 1925 word—perhaps by people in a hurry—for we have an aloud 79 alright even dozen handbooks reminding their readers to write I got your letter all right. —Edward Fitzgerald, letter, it as two words, and presumably there are others. Two 1844 (S.P.E. Tract 18) words is the accepted norm: What happened to the phrase between Chaucer and Each of these writers had plainly worried about my Shelley we simply don't know. It may have continued in Nat Turner a lot —William Styron, This Quiet Dust oral use all along but have been seldom used in works and Other Writings, 1982 that have survived. Or it may have been re-formed in The Kremlin must be a lot like this —Jay modern English. At any rate, before the nineteenth cen- Mclnerney, Bright Lights, Big City, 1984 tury ended, alright had appeared in print. Our evidence for the one-word spelling alot comes I think I shall pass alright —Durham University mostly from memos, drafts, private letters. It occasion- Jour., November 1893 (OED Supplement) ally sees the light of day in newspapers where proofread- ing has not been careful enough: Alright did not appear in a Merriam-Webster dictio- nary until 1934, but several dictionary users had spotted "When I was in junior, I was on the power-play its omission earlier and had written to us to urge its alot," Turgeon said —Morning Union (Springfield, inclusion. The earliest of these was a New York busi- Mass.), 3 Nov. 1983 nessman named William E. Scott: See also LOTS, A LOT. I wish you would submit to your experts the feasi- bility of putting the word alright into use. As a mat- aloud See OUT LOUD. ter of fact it is used quite extensively without the authority of dictionaries because it is the quick com- already See ALL READY, ALREADY. mon-sense way of doing. The cable and telegraph companies are the ones who profit by the lack of an alright, all right Is alright all right? The answer is a authoritative ruling that alright is synonymous with qualified yes, with these cautions. First, all right is much all right — 2 5 Sept. 1913 more common in print than alright. Second, many peo- ple, including the authors of just about every writer's Scott's letter suggests some of the influences that kept handbook, think alright is all wrong. Third, alright is alright in use. A still stronger force is that of analogy: more likely to be found in print in comic strips (like words like altogether, already, and although were simi- "Doonesbury"), trade journals, and newspapers and larly formed in Old or Middle English, and had come magazines (Rolling Stone, Cosmopolitan, Punch, or The into modern English as solid words. When alright came American Rifleman, for instance) than in more literary to be a matter of dispute, many commentators recog- sources, although it does appear from time to time in nized the force of analogy and then had to devise rea- literature as well. sons to deny its applicability. How did alright come to be in this situation? It has a The controversy over the appropriateness of alright complex and somewhat mysterious history. It seems to seems to have begun in the early 20th century. In August have been formed in Old English as ealriht, but was 1909, this answer to a letter from a reader appeared in used in senses that are now obsolete. In those days the Literary Digest. It was probably written by Frank before printing, the spelling and compounding of a word Vizetelly; his A Desk Book of Errors in English (1906) depended entirely on scribal practice, which varied con- carries the same message. siderably. Early citations for the word in the OED and Middle English Dictionary show such variant forms as The correct form is "all right"; this is the commonly eall right, alrihtes, al riht, alriht, all rihht, al rizt, and al accepted form to-day. Formerly "alright" had some right. It is not until Chaucer's "Criseyde was this lady vogue and like "already" was formed of two words, name, al right" (ca. 1385) that we find an early citation but altho "all ready" was displaced early in our lit- for what sounds like a modern use. erature (1380) by "already" "all right" did not meet After Chaucer, however, there is a long gap in the with the same fate. record, and we have no examples of all right until the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, where it There was reaction against alright in Great Britain too. In 1924 the Society for Pure English published a sym- appears as part of a longer phrase, all right as my leg, in which all is a pronoun. posium on alright (Tract 18), and here H. W. Fowler took up the cudgels against it. He appears to have been STAND. Five guineas. [Gives her money.] irritated by alright primarily because he considered it PAR. Are they right? [Examines them.] No Gray's- bad spelling. His Modern English Usage of 1926 con- Inn pieces amongst 'em. densed his 1924 denunciation; from that point on nearly All right as my leg. all usage commentators fall into line. We have recorded —George Farquhar, Sir Harry Wildair, 1701 thirty-five to forty commentators, both British and (quoted from S.P.E. Tract 18, 1924) American, expressing disapproval; only one or two dis- sent. It should be noted, however, that the usual way of In Robinson Crusoe (1719) we find "desir'd him to . . . disapproving alright is to append a pejorative label (as keep all right in the Ship" (OED), with all still a pro- illiterate or colloquial) to it or to deny it exists; no very noun. Uses of the two words as a fixed phrase begin to cogent reasons are presented for its being considered turn up only in the first half of the nineteenth century. wrong. That was all right, my friend. —Percy Bysshe Shel- Even the critics of alright admit it is found more often ley, Scenes from Goethe's Faust, 1822 (OED) in manuscript than in print; undoubtedly it would be even more frequent in print than it is if copy editors 'Stand firm, Sam,' said Mr. Pickwick, looking down. were less hostile. (Theodore Dreiser used it repeatedly 'All right, sir,' replied Mr. Weller. —Charles Dick- in the manuscript of The 'Genius' in 1914; H. L. ens, Pickwick Papers, 1837 (S.P.E. Tract 18) Mencken had him change it to all right.) Our evi- also 80 also dence shows that it is used in letters, real and fic- "Okay honey, I've ironed your blue ensemble if tional: that's alright...." —Jim Guzzo, Springfield (Mass.) Republican, 30 Dec. 1984 I hope that this procedure is alright with you —edi- tor, N.Y. publishing house, letter received at Mer- From the beginning alright seems to have reached riam-Webster, 1964 print primarily in journalistic and business publica- tions. We have plenty of evidence that it continues to I had intended to ask you to give a lecture much like appear in these publications: you have in the past. I hope that is alright with you —director, technical writing institute, letter received There's plenty of luxury here alright —Variety, 28 at Merriam-Webster, 1984 Jan. 1942 Yes, I did get your letter alright —Margaret Ken- The first batch of aquatic ovines will get by alright nedy, The Feast, 1950 —T. J. McManus, Tasmanian Jour, of Agriculture, May 1962 He told Regina that he had told me and she said that was alright —Flannery O'Connor, letter, July 1952 War is there alright —Richard Gilman, New Repub- lic, 25 Nov. 1967 Miss O'Connor used both spellings: . . . came out alright in the end —National Jeweler, . . . but if so I can do without it all right —letter, 1 January 1942 Jan. 1956 Berkeley is a weird city, alright —Ralph J. Gleason, Rolling Stone, 13 May 1971 One of the points involved in the discussion of the propriety of alright hinges on the assertion that all right Alright, alright—I know, it was all the fault of those represents one stress pattern in speech, and alright confounded British colonialists! —Brian Walker, another. Evans 1962 alludes to this point when he says, Bicycling!, January 1971 "My own—dissenting—opinion is that most people who write alright instead of all right (when they mean We got through it alright —A very Corman, Cosmo- "alright" and not "all right") are not slovenly. They are politan, October 1974 simply asking for the privilege of making a distinction in writing which is accepted in speech." This argument . . . the movie tells us it's alright for him to cheat his is difficult to evaluate because stress patterns are observ- customers —David Sterritt, Christian Science Mon- able only in speech, whereas alright is purely a spelling itor, 11 Sept. 1980 variant. But it is a fact of some relevance, perhaps, that Gutenberg's movable type was alright for the middle when alright is used in fiction, it is very often used in ages —British Printer, February 1976 representing the speech of the characters: They will see him alright for food and female com- "My briefing alright, First Sergeant?" —Josiah Bunt- pany —Jonathan Sale, Punch, 1 Oct. 1975 ing, The Lionheads, 1972 Finally, we have a little evidence from books where 'Alright. O.K. I'll write him a cheque right now.' — speech is not being re-created. Mordecai Richler, The Apprenticeship of Duddy Men don't want a woman to wilt on them. That was Kravitz, 1959 alright in Mother's time —Vivian Ellis, Faint Har- " . . . It's goin' to be alright...." —Waldo Frank, Not mony, 1934 Heaven, 1953 The first two years of the medical school were alright "Alright, wait a minute," —Langston Hughes, —Gertrude Stein, The Autobiography of Alice B. Laughing to Keep from Crying, 1952 Toklas, 1933 "Well, alright, but you're going to miss your Trying to decide if it is alright to say anxious when golf . . . " —Pat Frank, Hold Back the Night, 1952 you mean eager —Quinn 1980 Alright, already! I'll turn on the grill! —Gary B. Tru- Summary: in its modern use alright has reached print deau, Guilty, Guilty, Guilty, 1973 primarily through journalistic and business publication and is still to be found in those sources. It has appeared It appears in Molly Bloom's soliloquy: now and again in literature, at least from the mid-twen- ties, though mostly in fictional dialogue. Its critics . . . however alright well seen then let him go to her acknowledge that it is more often to be found in manu- —James Joyce, Ulysses, 1922 script than in print; it would likely be much more nearly as frequent as all right if it were not so regularly sup- It is also used in other transcribed speech. pressed by copy editors. It seems to have some accep- tance in British English—in spite of disapproval in Brit- "Alright, darling. I was wrong. I apologise." — ish handbooks: it is the standard spelling in Punch and Eamonn Andrews, Punch, 1 May 1974 the King's Printer at Ottawa officially sanctioned its use Mom said, "Yes, it's lonely here alright. It's lonely." as far back as 1928. The OED Supplement calls it simply —John Allan May, Christian Science Monitor, 1 "a frequent spelling of all right." It remains a commonly Aug. 1953 written but less often printed variant of all right. It is clearly standard in general prose, but is widely con- . . . so let's look at Bittman. Bittman says he is trying demned nonetheless by writers on usage. to blackmail the White House. Alright you called Bittman —Richard M. Nixon, in The White House also This word raises two related problems for usage Transcripts, 1974 commentators, and we will take them one at a time. also 81 also First we have the matter of also used as a loose con- By October of 1983, the CNN Headline News Ser- nective roughly equivalent to and. Some of the com- vice . . . was going out to six hundred and seventy- mentators call this also a conjunction, but in the lan- five cable systems, . . . and also to a hundred and guage of traditional grammar it is a conjunctive adverb. forty-three commercial television stations — The palm for discovering this problem goes to the Thomas Whiteside, New Yorker, 3 June 1985 brothers Fowler (Fowler 1907), who showed Richard Grant White using the conjunctive also: . . . a lifelong favorite of Borges and also frequently alluded to —Ambrose Gordon, Jr., Jour, of Modern 'Special' is a much overworked word, it being used Literature, 1st issue, 1970 to mean great in degree, also peculiar in kind — Words and their Uses, 1870 Like Izzy, Moe was a natural comedian, and also like Izzy, he was corpulent —Herbert Asbury, in The The Fowlers added two more examples, both from The Aspirin Age 1919-1941, ed. Isabel Leighton, 1949 (London) Times. Since 1907 this construction has picked up considerable unfavorable notice, especially in . . . slices of liver and also of kidney —Annual Rev. handbooks, right into the 1980s. Criticism is strongest of Biochemistry, 1946 when the elements joined by also are words or phrases As mentioned earlier, Reader's Digest 1983 finds the (as in the example from White), but some commenta- conjunctive also acceptable in speech and informal writ- tors extend it to the joining of clauses. The curious thing ing, but would avoid it in formal writing. The rest tend is that no one but the Fowlers has an attributed example to disapprove it in writing, period, although Fowler to bring forward. The question becomes, then, who uses 1926 will allow it when the writer needs to emphasize this construction, and where? The coverage in college that what follows is an afterthought. The relative dearth handbooks suggests it turns up in student papers, and it of evidence for its use strongly suggests that we have apparently occurs in speech—Reader's Digest 1983 here much ado over very little. Also is a much less fre- finds it acceptable in speech and most of the handbooks quently used word than and; apparently most people disapprove it only in writing. Margaret M. Bryant says make do with and in writing as their additive in English in the Law Courts (1930) that it is common conjunction. in speech. Her examples show it to have been common also in 19th-century American wills. Here is an exam- The second problem involves beginning a sentence ple, much abridged: with also. Follett 1966, Janis 1984, Harper 1985, Bander 1978, and Perrin & Ebbitt 1972 suggest avoiding also at I give, devise, and bequeath to my beloved wife . . . the beginning of a sentence. Bernstein 1971 allows some my homestead . . . with the buildings thereon . . . ; sentences to begin with also; his example turns out to be also all my farming tools and utensils . . . ; also one an inverted sentence of a kind also approved by Follett, thousand dollars. Perrin & Ebbitt, and Janis. This type of inverted sen- tence does exist: This use continues common in wills, and judges are still having to decide what also means in disputed cases. Also created was a Governor's Commission for Effi- Wills are rather a special kind of writing, however. ciency and Improvement in Government —Current More apt for your guidance are literature and contem- Biography, December 1964 porary general published prose, and our files yield exam- ples of conjunctive also in both categories: Also old are the words from Old English and Middle English —W. F. Bolton, A Short History of Literary . . . these are the only eels I have heard of here;— English, 1967 also, I have a faint recollection of a little fish some five inches long, with silvery sides and a greenish But the evidence in our files shows it to be of relatively back —Henry David Thoreau, Walden, 1854 infrequent occurrence. Most of the sentences beginning with also in our files are of the straightforward type the Accompanying it were two accessories, also bits of commentators seem to disapprove: pottery —Herman Melville, The Confidence Man, 1857 Also, at the mouth of the Nile, fish in the Mediter- ranean used to feed on organisms conveyed by the . . . tends to obscure the new affiliations of psychol- silt —William Styron, This Quiet Dust and Other ogy with the sciences of biology, sociology, and Writings, 1982 anthropology; also its claim to be considered as a natural science itself —Thomas Munro, The Arts Also, certain even-numbered groups of protons and and Their Interrelations, 1949 neutrons are particularly stable —Current Biogra- phy, June 1964 . . . and they occasionally go to galleries together; also Mitterand fancies old books, and occasionally Also, it was in itself, as I have said, a period of they browse together in bookshops —John New- depressed spirits —Sacheverell Sitwell, All Summer house, New Yorker, 30 Dec. 1985 in a Day, 1926 Our examples are not numerous, however, and concor- Also, he was not in the Congresses which debated the dances of major authors often omit also, so it is hard to danger of war —Jonathan Daniels, in The Aspirin be sure just how common this use is in published Age 1919-1941, ed. Isabel Leighton, 1949 writing. Also, Latin seems to have been used for cultural pur- The handbooks' approach to the conjunctive also is poses much more exclusively than in western coun- to recommend conversion to and or and also. (The tries—Gilbert Highet, The Classical Tradition, 1949 commentators who prescribe and also are presumably not the same ones Nickles 1974 notes as condemning Also, during the summer, so-called interim disciplin- and also as a redundant phrase.) And also is common in ary rules were promulgated —Sylvan Fox, N.Y. all kinds of writing: Times, 9 Jan. 1969 alternate 82 alternate The objections to this use of also are not usually stated turns" for alternate, and "offering or expressing a clearly; it is simply described as "weak." Bernstein 1971, choice" for alternative. But not much light is shed on one of the few books to elaborate on the topic, sees it as how these words are confused, if indeed they are, nor on essentially just an aspect of the problematic conjunctive what actual use is. We will begin our examination with use of also. Beginning a sentence, it suggests that what Fowler 1926. follows is an afterthought and thus that the writer is dis- Fowler says that alternative (and alternatively) "had organized and self-indulgent. Despite occasional refer- formerly, besides their present senses, those now belong- ences by other critics to functional classes like conjunc- ing" to alternate (and alternately). He claims that the tion, adverb, conjunctive adverb, it is difficult to escape two words are now (in 1926) completely differentiated, the conclusion that this is entirely a matter of style, and a claim somewhat vitiated by his following it immedi- has nothing to do with grammar. The objection seems ately with an example, presumably from some British about as soundly based as the widely believed notion newspaper, of alternatively meaning "by turns." This that you should never begin a sentence with and. Our violation of his dictum he terms "confusion." evidence agrees with the statement in Perrin & Ebbitt There are two separate considerations here. The first that also usually stands within the sentence. But some is the use of alternative where alternate might be writers of high repute do use it as an opener, and you expected; the second, alternate where alternative might can too, when you think it appropriate. be expected. The first use is, so far as we know, the oldest sense of the adjective alternative, attested in 1540. Johnson alternate, verb Bernstein 1965 tells us this verb takes missed it in his 1755 dictionary, but Todd added it in with, but that is only half the story. One person or one his expanded edition at the beginning of the 19th cen- thing may alternate with another or others; one person tury. Robert Herrick used it in a poem: or thing may alternate between (usually) two things. Some examples of with: That Happines do's still the longest thrive . . . the popluation has in fact pressed close upon the Where Joye and Griefs have Turns Alternative. food supply, and security has alternated with famine —Hesperides, 1648 —Lewis Mumford, Technics and Civilization, 1934 This sense of the adjective is now quite rare, and it sur- The plan enabled Robertson to alternate seven vives chiefly in the form of its derived adverb: weeks of study with seven weeks of work —Current Biography, January 1966 . . . the door-knob, wherein oil and rust alternatively soothed and retarded the scrape of metal upon metal Basso Norman Scott, who this season alternates with —Elinor Wylie, Jennifer Lorn, 1923 Moscona and three others in the part —Time, 28 Mar. 1955 In one hand she held a peeled hard-boiled egg and a thick slice of bread and butter in the other, and . . . dark green alternating with light green stripes, between her sentences she bit at them alternatively bluish green, bluish or yellowish gray, light cream, —Aldous Huxley, Antic Hay, 1923 yellowish brown, etc. —Jane Nickerson, N. Y. Times Mag., 4 July 1954 There are two courses open to them, which can be taken alternatively, sequentially or together —Mar- Some examples of between: garet Mead, Saturday Evening Post, 3 Mar. 1962 Alternating between sensuous and explosive styles —Look, 2 Feb. 1960, in Current Biography, June The second use—that of alternate where alternative 1965 might be expected—is a more vexatious one to trace. The OED marks the sense obsolete, citing only Robert The reader alternates between admiration . . . and Greene ( 1590). But it seems to have had a revival in the irritation —Times Literary Supp., 5 Mar. 1970 second third of the 20th century. Our earliest citations for this revival do not, unfortunately, include much in . . . alternating perpetually between physical and the way of context; they supply more in the way of opin- mental activity —Agnes Repplier, The Fireside ion than information. In 1933 a column in the Literary Sphinx, 1901 Digest termed the phrase "an alternate bill of goods" The weather alternated between blinding sand- incorrect, but did not provide enough context to show storms and brilliant sunlight —Willa Cather, Death just what was being referred to, spending most of its Comes for the Archbishop, 1927 space on the explication of the difference between alter- nate and alternative. A letter from linguist Dwight L. . . . the rest of the spectators continued to alternate Bolinger to this company in 1943 mentions alternate as between maddening immobility and creeping move- a euphemism for substitute in alternate goods: again not ment—Irving Wallace, The Plot, 1967 much actual context is supplied but such information as is given suggests that both phrases may have been com- We have one citation with among, which may be a copy mercial terms used in retail advertising at the time. The editor's doing: revival was not strictly an American phenomenon, how- . . . the author alternates among mod slang, clichés ever; Gowers 1948 complains of its occurrence in offi- and quotes from literary giants —Albert H. John- cial British writing. ston, Publishers Weekly, 24 July 1978 American citations begin to show up in some num- bers in the 1940s and early 1950s. Among these there are three new categories of use where alternative had not alternate, alternative, adjectives The adjectives been (and would not be) used—book clubs: alternate and alternative, say many commentators, are often confused; they advise keeping them separate. The His Collected Stories, a Book-of-the-Month Club senses recommended are "occurring or succeeding by alternate selection —Time, 18 Dec. 1950 alternative 83 alternative politics: . . . choice between two unpleasant alternatives — Freeman 1983 . . . was named alternate United States delegate to the fifth General Assembly of the United Nations — . . . involving two equally unsatisfactory alternatives Current Biography 1950 —Kilpatrick 1984 and highways: Copperud 1970, 1980 says "The idea that alternative . . . an alternate route, built by the Federal Govern- may apply to a choice between two and no more is a ment in 1932 —American Guide Series: Virginia, pedantry." Howard 1980 and Gowers in Fowler 1965 1941 call it "a fetish." Most other recent commentators, how- ever, take note of the existence of a "traditionalist" or These three uses continue to the present, with no com- "purist" position—a position that insists on restriction petition from alternative. to two. More general uses also appeared about the same time: The development of this "traditionalist" position is curious indeed, for it involves the overlooking of the Right now, the U.N. weighs the advantage of having original objection to the use of the noun in favor of what Russia at its conference table against the alternate was then essentially a side issue, brought in to reinforce advantage of having a set of basic principles on the original objection. To trace this development, we which members are agreed —New Yorker, 31 Mar. must go back to 1870. 1951 The earliest commentary on alternative that we have found is that of Gould 1870. Here is what he Early copper shortages stimulated manufacturers to says: investigate alumnium as an alternate material — Bulletin, American Institute of Architects, March This word means a choice—one choice—between 1952 two things. Yet popular usage has so corrupted it, The book also contains the complete alternate lyrics that it is now commonly applied to the things them- —Saturday Rev., 29 Nov. 1952 selves, and not to the choice between them; as thus, "You may take either alternative"; "I was forced to But they found an alternate, and very free-trade, way choose between two alternatives." And, indeed, of expressing themselves—the smuggling of opium some people go so far as to say "several alternatives —Christopher Rand, New Yorker, 29 Mar. 1952 were presented to him." Nevertheless, if the primary meaning is respected, . . . certain forms have considerable prestige as com- there can be but one alternative in any one case. Two pared with alternate forms for practically the same alternatives is a contradiction in terms. meaning —C. C. Fries, cited by Harry R. Warfel, in Who Killed Grammar?, 1952 Why would Gould emphasize one choice, rather than Such uses as these, from much the same kinds of two things? The reason seems to lie in dictionary defi- sources, continue unabated in current use, at least in the nitions. Gould was a vociferous proponent of Joseph U.S. In addition, the antiestablishment use of the Worcester's Dictionary in the late 19th-century war 1960s—alternative journalism, alternative schools, and between the dictionaries of Webster and Worcester. The the like—is expressed by both adjectives, with alterna- definition of alternative in Worcester's 1860 edition tive somewhat more common. reads "The choice given of two things." A quotation The evidence in the Merriam-Webster files shows this from 18th-century poet Edward Young is added. curious tendency: alternative is becoming more and Worcester's definition was taken directly from Samuel more a noun, and the adjective appears to be in the pro- Johnson's Dictionary of 1755: "The choice given of two cess of being replaced (at least in American English) by things; so that if one be rejected, the other must be alternate. Except in botany, the adjective alternate in its taken," with the same quotation from Young. Each of sense "by turns" is giving way to the verb alternate and these lexicographers had a reason for the definition. its participle alternating. We cannot be sure that this Johnson had to depend on Young's usage for his defi- trend will continue, but if it does, differentiation, far nition—Young was apparently the earliest literary figure from having been complete in 1926, will have continued in English to use the term (the OED shows only a 1624 along markedly different lines from those announced by letter earlier). Worcester had to depend on Johnson— Fowler. although he unfortunately pruned off the helpful second half of Johnson's definition—because in his position as the chief competitor of Webster's successors, he could alternative, noun Harper 1975, in a question to its not use Webster's definition. Webster in 1828 had usage panel about dilemma, uses the phrase "one of two noticed the application of the term to the thing to be equal alternatives." Panelist Heywood Hale Broun took chosen: "That which may be chosen or omitted; a this notice (excised from the 1985 edition): "This is a choice of two things, so that if one is taken, the other tautology, since these alternatives, like the horns of a must be left. Thus when two things offer a choice of one dilemma, come only in pairs." Do alternatives come only, the two things are called alternatives." Noah thus only in pairs? The writing of recent usage commentators recognized two uses—the choice and the thing chosen; suggests that they do not: if Worcester recognized them, he presumably felt he could not admit it lest he be accused of plagiarizing his . . . two or more alternatives —Longman 1984 former employer. . . . the number of alternatives should be definite — To return to Gould: his objection, then, depended Bryson 1984 entirely upon Johnson's definition via Worcester. Ayres 1881 agreed with Gould's view. But they had no foun- . . . anyone who doesn't like the other alternatives — dation for their objection—the extension of meaning Reader's Digest 1983 to the thing or things to be chosen had taken place alternatively 84 although long before. The OED cites Sterne's Tristram Shandy alternatives must choose one of the three. This is not (1760): quite right, for it applies only part of the time. In a use like this: There was no alternative in my Uncle Toby's wardrobe. The three basic funeral alternatives are . . . —Home- making: Skills for Everyday Living, 1981 (school This citation is, as the OED points out, ambiguous; it text) might but probably does not mean "choice." There are other early uses, however: the imperative notion obtains, enforced by a death in . . . forced to take the other alternative —Henry the family. But in other instances: Fielding, Journal of a Voyage to Lisbon, 1755 . . . I feel bound to offer you the alternative of com- . . . while another alternative remains —Jane Aus- ing alone, or coming with Edy some other Sunday, ten, Lady Susan, 1814 (OED) or letting us send a trap to Witley to bring you both to lunch or tea next Sunday week, or, in short, any- Poor Rip was at last reduced almost to despair; and thing you please —George Bernard Shaw, letter to his only alternative, to escape from the labor of the Ellen Terry, 20 Apr. 1899 farm and clamor of his wife, was to take gun in hand and stroll away into the woods —Washington none of the alternatives need be taken—indeed, Miss Irving, "Rip Van Winkle," 1820 Terry never made the suggested vacation visit. The sub- tle imperative that alternative contains but choice does Between these alternatives there is no middle ground not is the one first put down by Samuel Johnson—if you —William Cranch (cited in Webster 1828) take one, you must forgo the other or others. Choice The OED (A appeared in 1884) defines four senses (as does not necessarily carry the same implication. do most modern dictionaries) and notes that except for While the history of this objection is rather complex, Johnson's sense, the others were unknown to dictio- the actual status of the word in usage is not. The exten- naries until "very recently." sion of alternative from a choice between two to the Hodgson 1889, while following the current objection things or courses to be chosen and then to a choice of to the application to the thing or course chosen, brings more than two has been long established in reputable in etymology; after a disquisition upon Latin alter and usage. its derivatives and congeners, he cites with approbation a definition from Whatley's Synonyms (1851): "a choice alternatively, alternately See ALTERNATE, ALTERNA- between two courses" (the italics are Hodgson's). In his TIVE, adjectives. emphasis on two, Hodgson joins Noah Webster, who concluded his definition with altho Alt ho is one of the simplified spellings whose In strictness, then, the word can not be applied to adoption was urged by the Simplified Spelling Board more than two things, and when one thing only is and other bodies concerned with spelling reform around offered for choice, it is said there is no alternative. the end of the 19th century (see SPELLING REFORM). Krapp 1927 says altho is to be found here and there Evidence in the OED shows that if the word had not through all the modern period of English, but that it did been extended to a choice of more than two in Noah's not have much widespread use until the movement for time—and his "in strictness" suggests that indeed it spelling reform had reached its peak. Baron 1982 notes already had—it would soon be. The OED's earliest cita- that altho was one of a dozen reformed spellings tion for extension to three is from the logician John adopted by the National Educational Association in Stuart Mill: 1898. Our evidence shows that by the 1920s quite a few The alternative seemed to be either death, or to be authors and publishers were using at least some of the permanently supported by other people, or a radical reformed spellings in print, including this one: change in the economical arrangements —Principles . . . Bryant's list remains a significant document, of Political Economy, 1848 altho its impressiveness has departed —Brander The editors also quote Gladstone in 1857 extending the Matthews, Essays on English, 1921 number to four. Hodgson supplies evidence of three And altho in this country —Publishers Weekly, 2 alternatives from 1853 and 1857. Our files have this Nov. 1918 from a letter of Henry Adams to his brother: Altho forced to resign —Literary Digest, 20 Nov. . . . and if your three alternatives are right, I acknowl- 1926 edge I'm wrong — 2 2 Apr. 1859 Some authors and publishers continued up into the The traditionalists after Hodgson tend to follow the 1950s: etymological argument and ignore the original, although Vizetelly 1906 quotes Gould, and some of his later pro- Altho Nida speaks of native tutors —Morris Swa- nouncements mention that theme. But both schools of desh, Word, April 1954 objectors were too late: the horse was long out of the Our most recent evidence suggests, however, that altho barn before they arrived to lock the door. All four senses is dropping out of use in print, altho it may well con- given in the OED are in current reputable use—even tinue to thrive in personal writing. Fowler 1926 examines them minutely without objecting to any. Harper 1975, 1985 draws attention to "a certain although, though Although these conjunctions have imperative connotation" that alternative carries but been essentially interchangeable since about 1400 choice does not. They say that a person faced with three (according to the OED), usage books seldom fail to altogether 85 amalgamate include them, apparently because people keep wonder- 2. The use of alumni as a singular is called substandard ing whether one or the other is preferable. And no mat- by Copperud. Our only genuine evidence of straightfor- ter how much detail a study might contain, the results ward use is from speech: always come out the same: the conjunctions are inter- changeable. (Bryant 1962 has a detailed examination, . . . another UCLA alumni —Frank Gifford, football for instance.) telecast, 12 Nov. 1984 Although the lake was by now black, though the sky It has also been used facetiously: still dimly reflected white, turning from time to time As a loyal alumni, you'll be aghast to know that the to peer ahead, he guided himself by the flickering head football coach has to get by on just $96,000 a lights of the Stresa shore —Bernard Malamud, The year —Jeff Millar & Bill Hinds, "Tank McNamara" Magic Barrel, 1958 (cartoon), Boston Globe, 24 Jan. 1982 Though is more frequently used than although, perhaps because it is shorter. Assertions of delicate shades of dif- a.m., p.m. These abbreviations are usually used with ference in formality made by some commentators can- the hour as a short substitute for "before noon" and not be confirmed by the citations in Merriam-Webster "after noon" (or whatever phrase you may use for the files. The difference seems merely to be a matter of per- same idea). Copperud 1970 tells us that he and Evans sonal choice. 1957 agree that expressions like "6 a.m. in the morning" Though is used as an adverb; although is not. are redundant; our files show precious little evidence of such expressions, a fact which may indicate that they A fine book though —W. H. Auden, N Y. Rev. of exist mainly in speech. Books, 27 Jan. 1972 The abbreviations are occasionally used as an infor- mal substitute for morning and afternoon or evening: altogether See ALL TOGETHER, ALTOGETHER. I flew in from Vienna this a.m. —Irving Wallace, The Plot, 1967 alum See ALUMNUS, ALUMNA. "Judith? No—that is, yes—I saw her this a.m." — alumnus, alumna 1 . As any dictionary will tell you, Josephine Pinckney, Three O'Clock Dinner, 1945 alumna is pluralized alumnae; alumnus is pluralized Last Thursday, at one in the p.m. —New Yorker, 19 alumni. These words have not developed English plu- Aug. 1972 rals. Alumna is used for female graduates and alumnus for males, although it is sometimes used also of women. . . . my wife suggests that we can see a Charlie Chap- Alumni is the form usually used for a mixed bag of grad- lin movie tomorrow p.m. —Oliver Wendell Holmes uates of both sexes. Janis 1984 points out that the d. 1935, letter, 30 Oct. 1921 clipped form alum (not to be confused with the chemi- cal compound of the same spelling) is available to those who feel that alumni is not sufficiently asexual or those amalgam Amalgam in its nontechnical senses takes who have trouble spelling Latin: of when it needs a preposition: . . . second-guessing from undergrads and die-hard . . . synthetic new genres that are amalgams of the alums—Edwin McDowell, Wall Street Jour., 5 Dec. old —Peter Winn, NY. Times Book Rev., 10 June 1972 1979 . . . join the 951 alums who have put, or are planning The average reader imagines him as a rather to put, Randolph-Macon in their wills —Carolyn Byronic, darkly brooding individual, an amalgam of Morrison Barton, Randolph-Macon Woman's Col- Baudelaire, Robinson Jeffers, and MacKinlay Kan- lege Alumnae Bulletin, Winter 1971 tor — S . J. Perelman, New Yorker, 1 Jan. 1972 Alumnus is also used for a former member, employee, . . . the British Walker Cup team, traditionally an inmate, or contributor of any of a number of amalgam of the top amateurs from England, Scot- institutions: land, Wales, and Ireland —Herbert Warren Wind, New Yorker, 10 Apr. 1971 In fact, I still get the 69th Division alumni bulletin or whatever it's called —Frank Mankiewicz, quoted in The Washingtonian, October 1978 amalgamate When amalgamate, in its nontechnical uses, requires a preposition, into and with are used: . . . the Liverpool Repertory Company, whose alumni include Sir Michael Redgrave and Rex Har- Indian, African, and Portuguese ingredients and rison —Current Biography, October 1965 cooking techniques began to amalgamate into the rich Brazilian cuisine of today —Elizabeth Lambert . . . Saturday Night Live alumnus Michael O'Dono- Ortiz, Gourmet, October 1975 ghue —Timothy White, Rolling Stone, 24 July 1980 Dirac amalgamated the varied equations into one — Alumna is not unknown in this use, but is fairly rare: Current Biography, October 1967 . . . another debutante, albeit a Lee Strasberg . . . the Workers' Union was amalgamated with it — alumna, whose Cecilia is teary-eyed vapidity — Current Biography 1948 Judith Crist, Saturday Rev., 11 Dec. 1976 . . . a chance to size me up, test me out by my reac- . . . widowed, loaded, an alumna of analysis and a tion to his sallies, amalgamate me with his previous veteran of A.A. —Martin Levin, N. Y. Times Book audience —Edmund Wilson, Memoirs of Hecate Rev., 16 Mar. 1975 County, 1946 amateur 86 ambivalent amateur Bernstein 1965 presents us with the choice With in a somewhat different relationship is suggested: of of, in, or (sometimes) at for a preposition with which to follow the noun amateur. Although all of them can . . . my brother Philip, who had ambitions in this be used without violating English idiom, our files show direction —C. P. Snow, The Conscience of the Rich, that only of has much in the way of current use. Of s 1958 preeminence is partly due to its being the only preposi- tion used when amateur is used in its earliest sense— ambivalent, ambiguous Ambivalent is a much "devotee, admirer"—or in a use close to that meaning: newer word than ambiguous; while the latter has been in the language since the 16th century, ambivalent is not "No, seriously," he said, in his quality of an amateur attested until 1916, and its earliest citations are from of dogs —Arnold Bennett, The Old Wives' Tale, translations of Jung and Freud. Its first use in English, 1908 then, was as a technical term in psychology, but it seems to have found itself a niche in popular usage fairly They are amateurs of Horace in the best sense of that quickly as a descriptive word for a state in which one word —Edward Townsend Booth, Saturday Rev., 4 holds simultaneous contradictory feelings or in which Oct. 1947 one wavers between two polar opposites. Ambiguous had earlier been used for analogous situations; conse- As all amateurs of marzipan must agree —New quently, the words sometimes are used in similar Yorker, 8 Dec. 1956 contexts. He was an amateur of gadgets, but he was not even My attitude toward the plan . . . will be called by an engineer on the model of Watt or Fulton —O. B. some of my friends ambiguous, or perhaps—since Hardison, Jr., Entering the Maze, 1981 the word is now in fashion—"ambivalent." —Albert When used in the sense of "one not a professional," Guérard, Education of a Humanist, 1949 amateur followed by of tends to have a bookish tang Keats confused, confounded two centuries that probably favors its selection in such contexts: By ambivalent, ambiguous Mating of truth with beauty . . . edition of Donne is intended, I expect, for the —Richard Eberhart, Accent, Spring 1947 university student and the advanced amateur of English letters —D. C. Allen, Modern Language . . . her frustrating and ambiguous role—acknowl- Notes, May 1957 edged neither as wife nor as mistress —William L. Shirer, The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, 1960 . . . I must co-opt for our profession one or two ama- teurs of the discipline —John Kenneth Galbraith, In all matters Blum's ambivalent position was moti- Esquire, May 1977 vated by a desire to preserve unity —Joel Colton, Yale Rev., March 1954 . . . a simplistic amateur of letters, boring students with one's own enthusiasm —John Bayley, NY. Both ambivalent and ambiguous may connote duality: Times Book Rev., 27 Feb. 1983 To adopt the Committee's own ambivalent phras- The prepositions of, in, or at serve to connect amateur ing, that may or may not be the result — Wall Street with the name of some activity, profession, discipline, Jour., 1 Apr. 1955 or field of study or interest. Our citations show that in recent time the indication of such a relationship has But, like the bearded lady of the fair ground, it wears been more and more taken over by the adjective ama- an ambiguous appearance —Iain Colquhoun, New teur: when in the past you might have been an amateur Republic, 18 Oct. 1954 of, in, or at photography, nowadays you are much more But they are seldom really confused, because ambig- likely to be an amateur photographer. The prepositions, uous tends to stress uncertainty and is usually applied to of course, are still likely to be used where no fully appro- external things while ambivalent tends to stress duality priate agent noun is available, or where the writer sim- and is usually applied to internal things: ply chooses not to use the agent noun. English fleets and armies forced the ambiguous ben- ambiguous See AMBIVALENT, AMBIGUOUS; EQUIVOCAL, efits of modern civilization on the reluctant Chinese AMBIGUOUS, AMBIVALENT. —D. W. Brogan, The English People, 1943 . . . in the matter of Miss Thompson's ambiguous ambition Both the prepositions ./or and o/are in use femininity —Diana Trilling, N. Y. Times Book Rev., with ambition, but the most common construction (in 22 Apr. 1973 our evidence) is to and the infinitive. Here's a sample: . . . the complaint is commonplace that spoken lan- . . . developed an ambition to become a writer — guage is too ambiguous and conceptually fuzzy — Current Biography, February 1967 Nehemiah Jordan, Themes in Speculative Phychol- ogy, 1968 . . . carrying out his ambition to reform the map of the world —Benjamin Farrington, Greek Science, . . . only partially excavated but illuminating for the 1953 new light they throw on the ambiguous world of the Maya —Katharine Kuh, Saturday Rev., 28 June Dvorak had a great ambition for special success in 1969 his D minor symphony —John Burk, Boston Sym- phony Orchestra Program, 5 Feb. 1972 His intensely ambivalent attitude to his father—of admiration for his positive qualities and bitter He had nursed the ambition of becoming a foreign hatred for his insensitivity and brutality —Anne correspondent—Times Literary Supp., 29 Feb. 1968 Fremantle, Commonweal, 6 Dec. 1946 amenable 87 America He has Thackeray's fruitfully ambivalent attitude . . . these, like the other faults of the book, are too toward his own class —Clifton Fadiman, Holiday, well diffused throughout to be amended —T. S. October 1954 Eliot, Preface to 1928 edition of The Sacred Wood He spoke of the number of people... who had urged These two uses are quite a bit more common than the him to withdraw from the festival, and of his own "make emendations" sense. Here are a few examples of ambivalent feelings —Eric F. Goldman, Harper's, the last: January 1969 The new seal followed exactly the old one in design, Ambivalent may be followed by the prepositions except that "F.D. IND. IMP." was amended to "FIDEI toward(s) and about: DEF" —82d Annual Report of the Controller of the Royal Mint, 1951, 1953 In an era when Americans were not yet ambivalent about the fruits of science —Harriet Zuckerman, The translation was amended here and there by his Trans-Action, March 1968 own pen —Lucien Price, Dialogues of Alfred North Whitehead, 1954 . . . if its author had been a little less ambivalent about its potential audience —Times Literary Supp., Arthur Wilmart's translation has been shortened and 9 Dec. 1965 amended —Saturday Rev., 29 Jan. 1955 . . . I'm a trifle ambivalent toward "Room Service" Emend is much the less common word and is usually —John McCarten, New Yorker, 18 Apr. 1953 applied only to the correction of a text: American woman, ambivalent towards lighting — The decision to keep the original arrangement of the Margaret Mead, And Keep Your Powder Dry, 1942 poems, but print the final corrected text, emended only in some instances —Times Literary Supp., 19 The handful of commentators who object to ambivalent Feb. 1971 used other than in its original narrow sense are out-of- date. The extended uses are well established. It is rarely used with a somewhat broader application: See also EQUIVOCAL, AMBIGUOUS, AMBIVALENT. Not especially gifted with literary originality, the amenable Amenable is regularly followed by to: Roman Paul borrowed Plato's image and emended it to suit his needs —Henry Silverstein, Accent, Win- As an idea "circle" is amenable to punning applica- ter 1947 tions —Roger Greenspun, in The Film, 1968 . . . the more serious objection that my criterion, as I am both submissive to facts and amenable to argu- it stands, allows meaning to any indicative statement ment—Virgil Thomson, The Musical Scene, 1947 whatsoever. To meet this, I shall emend it as follows —Alfred Jules Ayer, Language, Truth and Logic, 2d Ever amenable to party demands, the President éd., 1946 responded —Samuel Hopkins Adams, Incredible Era, 1939 In summary, amend is the more common word, sometimes applied to the emendation of text but much amend, emend When was the last time you needed more often used in extended and figurative senses. to use the verb emena*! Our evidence suggests that writ- Emend is much less often used, is usually applied to the ers usually feel little need for this bookish and technical correction of text, and is rare in extended use. word. Yet a number of usage commentators feel the need to distinguish the seldom-used emend from the America, American From 1791 to the present peo- much more common amend. Kilpatrick 1984, for ple have questioned the propriety or accuracy of using instance, objects to the use of amend meaning "to make America to mean the United States and American to emendations." His assertion about use is wrong, how- mean an inhabitant or citizen of the United States. ever, as Chambers 1985 and Shaw 1975 show. In fact, amend has been used in the sense of "make emenda- America is used very generally both by writers and tions" since Caxton in the 15th century. But it has a public speakers, when they only intend the territory wider use as well, which Kilpatrick recognizes: of the United States It may have first come into use as being much shorter to say Americans, than cit- . . . the Commission hopes to amend its rules — izens of the United States —Gazette of the United Forbes, 15 May 1967 States, 16 Feb. 1791 (Dictionary of American English) Laws that are not repealed are amended and amended and amended like a child's knickers — Every once in a while someone comes along who is George Bernard Shaw, The Intelligent Woman's perturbed about Americans calling themselves Guide To Socialism and Capitalism, 1928 Americans, feeling that we have no right to use this term exclusively, that citizens of all the nations of Then there are these uses: the American continents are Americans —letter to . . . I honestly thought Goldwater would also amend editor, Christian Science Monitor, 1 Aug. 1967 the error of his ways —Karl Hess, quoted in Play- It is becoming presumptuous and inaccurate to refer boy, July 1976 to North Americans as "Americans," especially in . . . inflamed with a desire to amend the lives of the context of defending or upsetting Central Amer- themselves and others —C. S. Peirce, reprinted in icans, South Americans and Latin Americans —Wil- Encore, March 1947 liam Safire, N. Y. Times Mag., 3 June 1984 Afterwards he amended his discourtesy, and I forgot Safire followed his remark with a call for his readers to the offence —Rudyard Kipling, Kim, 1901 suggest "new monickers for United States citizens," but American Indian 88 amid his call seems to have brought in few suggestions, since 1962, Bryson 1984, and Simon 1980 that amid and no mention of them was contained in Safire 1986. H. L. amidst should go with singular nouns (there is some dis- Mencken in American Speech, December 1947, had agreement whether the singular noun can be a collective quite a long list of suggested replacements for American. noun or a mass noun or not) and among with plural The list contains (in approximate historical order from nouns (or separable, enumerable, or countable items). 1789 to 1939) such terms as Columbian, Columbard, The origin of this belief is obscure; it does not appear in Fredonian, Frede, Unisian, United Statesian, Coloni- Fowler's discussion of the words and does not seem to can, Appalacian, Usian, Washingtonian, Usonian, Ues- have concerned the 19th-century commentators. There sian, U-S-ian, Uesican. None of these proposed substi- may be some hint of an origin in Campbell 1776 and tutes has caught on. Murray 1795, who both object to among with indefinite Despite the perceived difficulty with America and pronouns that they deem singular. Yet, neither amid American in this use, the terms are fully established. nor amidst is mentioned in their discussions. Cotton Mather seems to have been the first writer to use Simon's version of the distinction is this: "Among American for a colonist, back before the dawn of the clearly pre-supposes a number of surrounding but sep- 18th century. It became established during the course of arate entities . . . ; whereas amid denotes a position in that century. The historian Samuel Eliot Morison cites the middle of something larger but of a piece and not a naval expedition of 1741 as being the first time the divisible...." Bernstein takes about the same tack: English referred to colonial troops as Americans rather "'Among' means in the midst of countable things. than provincials. Benjamin Franklin used both America When the things are not separable the word is 'amid' or and American in this sense. The Dictionary of American 'amidst.'" Bryson is in essential agreement. Evans, how- English also cites George Washington: ever, makes the distinction on a different basis, saying that amid is more likely to be followed by a singular The name of American, which belongs to you in word and among by a plural. Copperud prefers amid your national capacity, must always exalt the just with singular nouns that are not collectives. Thus, we pride of patriotism, more than appellatives derived may note some uncertainty among the commentators from local discriminations —Farewell Address, 1796 about just what it is they would have us observe. The Here are two other commenators: feeling of uncertainty is heightened by Simon, who crit- icizes (at the instance of a correspondent) his own sen- The general term American is now commonly tence beginning "Among richly homoerotic over- understood (at least in all places where the English tones"); he should have used amid, he says, but we are language is spoken) to mean an inhabitant of the aware that his plural overtones would satisfy Evan's cri- United States, and is so employed except where terion. Simon is presumably basing his mea culpa on the unusual precision is required —John Pickering, An notion of the inseparability of the overtones. American Glossary, 1816 You may suspect that a distinction based on criteria so elusive is not founded on actual usage—and indeed The use of America for the United States & Ameri- it is not. Amid and amidst are followed by both singular can for (citizen) of the U.S. . . . will continue to be and plural nouns as well as by nouns that denote sepa- protested against by purists & patriots, & will doubt- rable or countable items. less survive the protests —Fowler 1926 Singular nouns with amid: If you feel diffident about these words like Safire, or Amid such a world . . . our ideals henceforth must require "unusual precision," the equivalent phrases are find a home —Selected Papers of Bertrand Russell, readily available. In other cases, America and American 1927 will do. . . . to reconcile, amid his womanizing, with his wife American Indian See NATIVE AMERICAN. —Judith Crist, Saturday Rev., 2 Apr. 1977 . . . and amid a babble of goodnights the ladies came amid, amidst 1 . Copperud 1970, 1980 tells us that forward —Allen Tate, Prose, Fall 1971 amid and amidst are criticized as bookish, literary, or quaint by four commentators; Harper 1985 finds them . . . there is amid the garbage a steady supply of good out of fashion—formerly common but now "literary writing —Jacques Barzun, Atlantic, December 1953 words" to be stricken in favor of among or in. This Amid a snowstorm of press gossip —Penina Spiegel, notion seems to have originated with Fowler 1926. US, 13 Aug. 1984 There was probably little basis for Fowler's opinion in 1926; there is no basis whatsoever for its repetition by . . . worked on the steaming docks, amid the coal- later commentators. The words are in frequent current dust —Van Wyck Brooks, The Flowering of New use, as you will see from the examples given in section England, 1815-1865, rev. éd., 1946 3 below. 2. Fowler opines that amidst is more common than Amidst with singular nouns: amid; Evans 1957 finds amid more common in Ameri- . . . she fled Cambodia amidst gunfire —Cable Neu- can use and amidst in British use; Reader's Digest 1983 haus, People, 11 Mar. 1985 says amid is the more usual choice. Our evidence— mostly American—supports none of these generaliza- Amidst the junk mail and the hate mail and the tions. We find amidst somewhat more frequent before crank mail —Aristides, American Scholar, Autumn 1960, amid somewhat more frequent 1960-1980, and 1979 since 1980 the two words of about equal frequency. Both forms are in frequent use; you can use whichever sounds He was merely walking amidst an inferior form of better to you. life —Richard Wright, Negro Digest, January 1947 3. Amid, amidst, among. A curious belief is expressed in . . . amidst an unlimited magnificence —Edmund variant terms by Evans 1957, Copperud 1970, Bernstein Wilson, "The Ambiguity of Henry James," in Amer- amidst 89 among lean Harvest, ed. Allen Tate & John Peale Bishop, mentators make, and that their use is not restricted to 1942 "literary" or "quaint" publications. You will also note that among can be substituted for amid or amidst . . . where the last czar and his family had lived, in very few of the examples. The fact is that among uncomfortably, amidst too much furniture —John and amid (amidst) tend to seek different contexts Steinbeck, Russian Journal, 1948 anyway, and so the distinction the commentators are Those eyes of his, that mouth amidst a stubble of trying to urge is not only factitious but largely super- beard —Ion L. Idriess, Madman's Island, 1938 fluous. The invocation of among by commentators on amid Amid With plural nouns: and amidst seems to be related to the use of among with certain singular nouns and indefinite pronouns. This . . . my plight amid complex issues —William Staf- subject is treated at AMONG 2. ford, Writing the Australian Crawl, 1978 Amid the partygoers at Luchow's restaurant —Peo- amidst See AMID, AMIDST. ple, 20 Sept. 1982 amn't See AIN'T; AREN'T I. . . . resigned amid charges of misconduct —Eliza- beth Drew, NY. Times Mag., 1 Oct. 1973 amok See AMUCK, AMOK. Amid bulging wicker and pasteboard suitcases and among 1 . See BETWEEN 1. bundles done up in cloth sat elderly men —Andy Logan, New Yorker, 12 May 1951 2. Several commentators have brought among into a discussion that involves distinguishing between among . . . amid scenes of riot and debauch —Times Liter- and amid or amidst on somewhat questionable grounds ary Supp., 27 Feb. 1953 (see AMID, AMIDST 3). These commentators restrict among to use with plural or countable or separable There they all fell, amid yells and hissing curses and nouns. The question of the propriety of using among shrieks of pain —Liam O'Flaherty, The Informer, with a singular noun or an indefinite pronoun is an old 1925 one, going back at least to Priestley in 1761: Amidst with plural nouns: The preposition among always implies a number of . . . floating amidst the planets and stars —Evan things; and, therefore, cannot be used in conjunction Thomas, Time, 26 Nov. 1984 with the word every, which is in the singular number. Which is found among every species of liberty. Amidst visitors, orderlies and chatter, we listened Hume's Essays, p. 92. The opinion of the advance of gravely —T.R.B., New Republic, 19 Apr. 1954 riches in the island seems to gain ground among every body. Hume's Political Essays, p. 71. . . . which still endure amidst the soulless ruins — Henry Miller, The Air-Conditioned Nightmare, 1945 We do not know whether this opinion originated with . . . situated in palaces, amidst beautiful parks — Priestley or some earlier grammarian, but Murray 1795 Janet Flanner, New Yorker, 27 Oct. 1951 picked it up and transmitted it down the ages. Some- where along the way the specific reference to every was . . . amidst the cries of "Mazeltov! Mazeltov!" — lost, and the question became simply whether among Alfred Kazin, New Republic, 5 Feb. 1945 could be used with a singular noun. When a correspon- dent wrote to this company about the problem in 1939, . . . amidst the lifeless personages who surround her an editor sent this reply: —Robert Pick, Saturday Rev., 31 Mar. 1945 . . . amidst all the proposed new subsidies —Michael We regret t h a t . . . you are still uncertain of the pro- priety of among used with a collective noun. Kinsley, Harper's, January 1983 This usage has the authority lent by examples Another frequent construction finds amid or amidst from the earliest English, from Chaucer, from Steele, with a collective noun or indefinite pronoun followed by and from more modern writers. Longfellow wrote a preposition having a plural noun as its object: "We were among the crowd that gathered there." When the collective noun obviously means the . . . amidst a crackle of blue sparks —A. J. Cronin, members of something, among may properly pre- The Green Years, 1944 cede the singular collective noun in many contexts, as "to circulate among the audience." . . . amid some of the richest and most detailed period sets —Judith Crist, The Washingtonian, Our editor's letter was in harmony with the evidence November 1970 shown at the appropriate sense in the OED. The OED . . . amidst an astonishing variety of other pandemics notes that this sense of among is used with collectives —John Wilkinson, A Center Occasional Paper, and singular nouns of substances. The latter use is still December 1970 alive, but now much less common than use with collec- tives. Two examples: Amid such a welter of uncertainties —Sir James Mountford, British Universities, 1966 A hagfish will get right in among the muscle of the fish it is parasitising, dissolving the muscle and kill- . . . amid a pandemonium of cheers —John Buchan, ing the fish —David Wilson, Body and Antibody, Castle Gay, 1930 1971 We can thus see that actual usage does not follow the Among the smoke and fog of a December afternoon varying distinctions about amid and amidst the com- —T. S. Eliot, "Portrait of a Lady," 1917 amongst 90 amount Probably in is more common with such nouns, as the The greatest masters of critical learning differ among OED also observes. Among is used with nouns that are one another. collective and also denote a substance: Campbell recommends themselves for one another; in Often, I think, he slept in our barn among the hay — fact, Addison in an earlier Spectator (cited in the OED) Adrian Bell, The Cherry Tree, 1932 had written "quarrelled among themselves." Evans 1957 also mentions the construction. We cannot tell . . . it slipped off the stone and down among the gorse much about it. It is probably not wrong—the indefinite —Arthur Loveridge, Many Happy Days I've Squan- pronouns are notionally plural—but it is exceedingly dered, 1944 rare, and may well sound odd to many ears on that . . . some land animals hibernate among the vegeta- account. We have only this one example: tion —W. H. Dowdeswell, Animal Ecology, 2d éd., . . . the trio of directors . . . also share among each 1959 other the credits for production, writing, photo- Other collective nouns are more frequent: graphing, and editing —Arthur Knight, Saturday Rev., 1 Nov. 1953 Among the plunder from the church was a large sil- ver image —American Guide Series: New Hamp- Themselves is far more common in such contexts. shire, 1938 4. Among, amongst. Most of the commentators who mention these words note that amongst is less common . . . Henry James is, among a large part of our read- but both are correct. Our evidence confirms this; it also ing public, held to be to blame —Lionel Trilling, shows amongst a bit more common in British use than Kenyon Rev., Winter 1948 American. The few commentators who call amongst quaint or overrefined are off target. Here is a selection Among the luggage which I take on board —William of mostly recent and unquaint examples: Beebe, Jungle Peace, 1 9 1 8 We would sell the raft . . . and go way up the Ohio These are lost among a vast bulk of verse interesting amongst the free states —Mark Twain, Huckleberry only by its oddity —F. R. Leavis, New Bearings in Finn, 1884 English Poetry, new éd., 1950 Among her evidence was a report —Time, 6 Feb. . . . a dead spot amongst the maze of microwave beams —John W. Verity, Datamation, July 1982 1956 . . . nothing could happen, among a certain class of Amongst the evidence were verbal slams from such society, without the cognizance of some philan- network luminaries... —John Weisman, TV Guide, thropic agency —Arnold Bennett, 1899, in The Jour- 11 Sept. 1981 nals of Arnold Bennett, ed. Frank Swinnerton, 1954 Amongst other things, it is about the horrible family —Twyla Tharp, quoted in Horizon, September 1981 One may hazard that the Economic History Review is not among his bedside reading —Times Literary One or two of the red brick and green copper pavil- Supp., 2 4 Apr. 1969 ions . . . still remain amongst the rubble —Gerald Weissman, The Woods Hole Cantata, 1975 . . . he is not really a politician and lacks any orga- nised political backing among the public —Ian Ste- . . . this impulse almost universal amongst scholars phens, London Calling, 29 Apr. 1954 and teachers —William Stafford, Writing The Aus- tralian Crawl, 1978 Collective nouns are notionally plural, which is why they fit with among. Differences in time and place can . . . in divided usage amongst adults —Strang 1970 have an effect on the way such a noun is apprehended. Leonard in his 1932 usage survey included a sentence . . . alcohol use and drinking problems amongst from De Quincey that seemed to puzzle many of the women —Times Literary Supp., December 1980 Americans tested: amongst See AMONG 4. I enjoy wandering among a library. amount 1 . Amount, number. Many 20th-century To many Americans library connotes an institution commentators explain the difference between amount rather than a collection, and hence the among seemed and number. The general rule seems first to have been strange. A similar use is this: stated in more or less contemporary terms by Vizetelly He thought of the Australian gold and how those 1906: who lived among it had never seen it though it Amount is used of substances in mass; number refers abounded all around them —Samuel Butler, The to the individuals of which such mass is constituted. Way of All Flesh, 1903 (Our only earlier commentator is Raub 1897, who han- Among may certainly be used before a singular noun, dles the matter a little differently by discriminating especially when it is a collective noun. Our evidence amount, quantity, and number in a short synonymy suggests such use may be slightly more common in Brit- paragraph.) Almost all modern commentators echo ish English than it is in American, but it is not rare in Vizetelly. They are partly right, but the flat distinction either. does not account for all standard usage. 3. A related use of among involves its combination with Number is regularly used with plural count nouns to the indefinite pronouns one another and each other. The indicate an indefinite number of individuals or items: original objection seems to have been raised by Camp- bell 1776, who quoted this sentence from The Spectator, There were a number of serious (heavy) journalists No. 321 for correction: —Michael Heir, Esquire, April 1970 amuck 91 amuck There is a number of misprints —Albert H. Smith, There have been 110,000 American casualties—one Notes and Queries, October 1966 third the amount in World War I —N. Y. Times, 22 June 1952 . . . a number of forces in Western life —Vance Pack- ard, The Sexual Wilderness, 1968 . . . we could absorb a vast amount of South Ameri- can products —Thurman W. Arnold, The Bottle- . . . a number of other schools —James B. Conant, necks of Business, 1940 Slums and Suburbs, 1961 One of the minor mysteries of modern life is the . . . a number of activities government undertakes — large amount of police cars with flashing lights and New Republic, 21 June 1954 sirens —Alan Coren, Punch, 15 July 1975 There are . . . a number of Arabic dialects —James . . . an Eighth Avenue saloon that had become T. Maher, The Lamp, Summer 1963 known affectionately as the Tavern of the Bite, in Amount is most frequently used with singular mass deference to the unique amount of worthless IOUs nouns: collected during each day's business —Robert Lewis Taylor, New Yorker, 12 Nov. 1955 Given a reasonable amount of prosperity —Aldous . . . brunets possess a great amount of the substances Huxley, The Olive Tree, 1937 required for the production of pigment —Ashley . . . the doctrine requires a ridiculous amount of eru- Montagu, Man's Most Dangerous Myth: The Fallacy dition —T. S. Eliot, "Tradition and the Individual of Race, 2d éd., 1945 Talent," 1917 . . . every professional activity requires a fixed . . . it took a certain amount of faith —Hollis Alpert, amount of calories —Psychological Abstracts, April Saturday Rev., 13 Nov. 1971 1947 . . . the amount of independence they would like to This less common use of amount is sometimes criti- have —Eulah C. Laucks, Center Mag., January 1968 cized, but the critics bring forward no cogent reason for condemning it, only the condemnation itself. Colter A considerable amount of misinformation exists 1981 says this: "When 'amount' is used with plurals— regarding the temperatures of tropical countries — the amount of people—it sounds plain dumb." Most Preston E. James, Latin America, rev. éd., 1950 other commentators, such as Bernstein 1965, Shaw . . . losing . . . a fair amount of their accent —N. Y. 1970, and many handbooks, merely state the distinc- Times, 30 Nov. 1976 tion. The use is well established in general prose. 2. Flesch 1964 finds the phrase in the amount of wordy Lincoln Library 1924 insisted that amount could be and suggests replacing it with of or for. Such a revision used only of substances or material; the six examples may work in some contexts, but in the example below above all demonstrate that the criticism was invalid. It such a substitution would make nonsense. seems to have arisen in Ayres 1881, who was offended by the phrase amount of perfection. The insistence on The Cuban trade balance with the United States for substance or material is now a dead issue. Of course, the first three quarters of 1943 was favourable in the amount is used of material mass nouns too: amount of $103,518,000 —Britannica Book of the Year 1944 But the lion would certainly come down to the plain with the amount of game that was here now —Ernest The phrases in the amount o/and more often to the Hemingway, "Miss Mary's Lion," 1956 amount of are used with large amounts of money and are not always easily omissible or replaceable: . . . spent any amount of money on him —Times Lit- erary Supp., 20 Feb. 1969 . . . had supported the Choral Masterworks Series of 1952 to the amount of $40,000 —Current Biogra- . . . the amount of snow that we usually have —Rich- phy, July 1966 ard Joseph, Your Trip to Britain, 1954 3. The verb amount is regularly followed by to: Alexander added to his heavy troops archers, sling- ers, and javelin men, and a certain amount of cav- Probably the population never amounted to more alry —Tom Wintringham, The Story of Weapons than a few hundred souls —Jacquetta & Christopher and Tactics, 1943 Hawkes, Prehistoric Britain, 1949 Amount is also used with plural count nouns when . . . a cumulative cheerfulness, which soon amounted they are thought of as an aggregate: to delight —Thomas Hardy, The Return of the Native, 1878 . . . who wrote the U.N. that he'd be glad to furnish And according to my uncle, the scrapes he was any amount of black pebbles —New Yorker, 20 Sept. always getting into didn't really amount to much — 1952 Peter Taylor, The Old Forest and Other Stories, 1985 . . . the high amount of taxes —Harper's Weekly, 29 Sept. 1975 amuck, amok The notice in Copperud 1970 that amuck is the preferred spelling is now out of date; the Surely twelve men, whose eyes were opened, having disparaging remarks about the spelling amok in Evans the knowledge of the Most High, were better than 1957, Fowler 1965, and Bremner 1980 have apparently any amount of lecturers —Richard M. Benson, An not influenced writers to reject it. Amok is currently the Exposition of the Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans, more common spelling in the U.S. Reader's Digest 1983 1898 agrees. amuse 92 analogy amuse The verb amuse (and its past participle With is also idiomatic but seems always to have been amused used adjectivally) commonly occurs with the much less frequent than to. We have no evidence for it prepositions at, by, and with. At is somewhat less com- more recent than the first example here: mon than the others, in part because it follows no form of the verb but the past participle. This is usually silicon tetrafluoride or silicon tetra- chloride, analogous with carbon tetrachloride —Sci- . . . at first surprised, then cynical, and eventually ence News Letter, 16 Sept. 1944 amused at this procession —David Halberstam, Harper's, January 1969 Russia's present economic situation is analogous with the situation of the United States after the Civil . . . it was a private satisfaction . . . to see people War —Struggling Russia, 5 Apr. 1919 occupied and amused at this pecuniary expense — Henry James, The American, 1877 . . . not by means superior to, though analogous with, human reason —Charles Darwin, On the Origin of To be amused by what you read —C. E. Montague, Species by Means of Natural Selection, 1859 A Writer's Notes on His Trade, 1930 A small mob . . . amused itself by cheering —Joseph analogy Bernstein 1965 mentions only between or Conrad, Chance, 1913 with as being used with this noun; Follett 1966, only with. They seem to have missed such other prepositions . . . amused the citizens by issuing a series of fancy as to, of, and among. The examples below also inciden- proclamations —Green Peyton, San Antonio: City tally illustrate many of the typical constructions in in the Sun, 1946 which analogy may be found. . . . no one will have the slightest difficulty in being amused by it —Daniel George, London Calling, 19 . . . tracing the analogies between star and metal or Aug. 1954 herb and element —Maurice Evans, Essays in Crit- icism, July 1953 A King may be pardoned for amusing his leisure with wine, wit, and beauty —T. B. Macaulay, The . . . those who would draw any kind of facile analogy History of England, vol I, 1849 between the situation in Vietnam today and Munich —Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., N Y. Times Mag., 6 . . . a witness who was seen amusing himself with a Feb. 1966 lady on a haycock —Oliver Wendell Holmes d. 1935, letter, 20 May 1920 Analogies between sex manuals and cookbooks are being made in all literary quarters —Marcia Selig- . . . adult thumb-suckers, amusing themselves with son, McCall's, March 1971 comic strips, TV, cars —Elmer V. McCollum, Johns Hopkins Mag., Winter 1966 Then k is said to determine or to measure the state of analogy among the things —Georg Henrik Von . . . would begin to amuse himself with some other Wright, A Treatise on Induction and Probability, woman —Marcia Davenport, My Brother's Keeper, 1951 1954 . . . the sash, door, sheathing, chimney-top, and pen- Amuse can also be followed by to and an infinitive: dills are restored on analogy with examples else- where —Fiske Kimball, Domestic Architecture of the . . . I had been amused to note that... —O. S. Nock, American Colonies and of the Early Republic, 1922 The Railways of Britain, 1947 A certain analogy with spherical Geometry . . . is also proved —Bertrand Russell, Foundations of analogous When it is followed by a complementary Geometry, 1897 prepositional phrase, analogous almost always takes Like other popular views, this one follows the anal- to: ogy of the most usual experience —William James, Pragmatism, 1907 ... suggesting that both sound and light were wave vibrations, colours being analogous to notes of dif- . . . an impatience with all distinctions of kind cre- ferent frequencies —S. F. Mason, Main Currents of ated on the analogy of a class-structured society — Scientific Thought, 1953 Leslie A. Fiedler, Los Angeles Times Book Rev., 23 May 1971 . . . the binucleate mycelium of the Basidiomycetes . . . is certainly analogous to the ascogenous hyphae . . . utters them on the analogy of similar forms from which the asci arise —Constantine John Alex- which he has heard —Leonard Bloomfield, Lan- opoulos, Introductory Mycology, 2d éd., 1962 guage, 1933 . . . the doctrines of Symbolism were in some ways He preferred a more solemn analogy of himself as a closely analogous to the doctrines of Romanticism medico politico —Irving Kristol, Encounter, Decem- —Edmund Wilson, Axel's Castle, 1931 ber 1954 Faulkner's style makes the reader's experience anal- . . . uses the image of intensive husbandry as an anal- ogous to the hero's —Richard Poirier, A World Else- ogy of the human situation —Times Literary Supp., where, 1966 9 Mar. 1951 . . . developing in a manner analogous to that of the . . . he went on, thoroughly mesmerized, it seemed, literary review —Annette Michelson, Evergreen, by the analogy he was drawing to his experiences — August 1967 Joseph Lelyveld, NY. Times Mag., 26 Feb. 1967 analysis 93 and/or . . . the analogy of these societies to human and children to string together independent clauses or sim- insect communities is quite superficial —Alexis Car- ple declarative sentences with ands: "We got in the car rel, Man, the Unknown, 1935 and we went to the movie and I bought some popcorn and " A s children grow older and master the more . . . women in prison build a society on an analogy sophisticated technique of subordinating clauses, the to the family —Paul Bohannan, Science 80, May/ prohibition of and becomes unnecessary. But appar- June 1980 ently our teachers fail to tell us when we may forget about the prohibition. Consequently, many of us go analysis The phrase in the final (or last or ultimate) through life thinking it wrong to begin a sentence with analysis is disparaged by a few commentators—Flesch and. 1964 calls it "beloved by pompous writers," Gowers in Few commentators have actually put the prohibition Fowler 1965 "a popularized technicality," Strunk & in print; the only one we have found is George Wash- White 1959 "a bankrupt expression," and Nickles 1974 ington Moon: a cliché. It seems not to bother anyone else. The OED Supplement shows the original form to It is not scholarly to begin a sentence with the con- have been in the ultimate analysis, which it dates back junction and —The Bad English ofLindley Murray to 1791. This form of the phrase has been essentially and Other Writers on the English Language, 1868 (in replaced by the shorter forms with last and final since Baron 1982) about the last third of the 19th century. The phrase is not often found in informal contexts. The form with Phythian 1979 does advise following the "old rule," but final is occasionally used without the. Here are a few he recommends it not as a rule but as a general guide- examples from respected writers; we see nothing amiss line. Many commentators advise not overusing and at in them. the beginning of a sentence. It is perhaps overuse that led to this criticism: In final analysis the minority that we respect is first and foremost the smallest minority of all—the indi- The book has another distinction in that practically vidual conscience —William O. Douglas, Being an every other sentence begins with one of those sus- American, 1948 pended, capital-letter "Ands" which are becoming so popular —Saturday Rev., 12 Feb. 1927 . . . as also, in the final analysis, nations will act to limit national sovereignty —Margaret Mead, Satur- The Literary Digest seems to have had so many inqui- day Rev., 10 Jan. 1970 ries about the propriety of beginning a sentence with and throughout the 1920s that its editors came up with In the final analysis . . . ways must be found to pro- a stock answer. Here is the version of 5 April 1930: duce the greatest good for the greatest number in the shortest period of time —Carl Marcy, N. Y. Times The practise of beginning sentences with the con- Book Rev., 21 Aug. 1983 junction "and" dates from 855, and can be verified from The Old English Chronicle (Parker M. S.). The In the last analysis, we will not sit by and do nothing use may be found also in Shakespeare's King John when a chronic slump is developing —Paul A. Sam- (act iv, scene 1), the Gospel of St. John, xxi:21; uelson. quoted in Current Biography, May 1965 Grote's "History of Greece," and KJngsley's I can, in the last analysis, talk only about my own "Hypatia." work —Shirley Jackson, The Writer, January 1969 Here are two contemporary examples of initial and. In Forgive me for speaking personally, but in the last the second example, it even begins a paragraph: analysis no one can speak for any person except him- self ^ J o h n Mason Brown, Saturday Rev., 3 July He didn't believe I found the cart abandoned at a tilt 1954 in an alley. And then I turned over into his hands the cash receipts. To the penny —E. L. Doctorow, . . . whether she could, in the last analysis, be abso- Loon Lake, 1979 lutely counted on —Louis Auchincloss, A Law for "Now, boys," he said, "I want to read you an essay. the Lion, 1953 This is titled The Art of Eating Spaghetti.'" And he started to read. My words! He was reading analyzation Although Macmillan 1982 thinks this my words out loud to the entire class —Russell word does not exist, it does, and has since the 18th cen- Baker, Growing Up, 1982 tury. It is formed, perfectly regularly, from the verb ana- lyze. It is a rarely used alternative to analysis—so rare 2. There are several other usage problems involving that it is scarcely worth the space taken to disparage it and. These are covered at such entries as AND SO; AND in Macmillan, McMahan & Day 1980, and Janis 1984. WHICH, AND WHO; AGREEMENT, SUBJECT-VERB: COMPOUND You need not use it if you find it clumsy or sesquipe- SUBJECTS 1 ; FAULTY PARALLELISM; GOOD AND; a n d TRY dalian, of course. Few writers do use it, in fact. AND. anchorperson See PERSON 2. and etc. See ETC. and 1. Everybody agrees that it's all right to begin a sentence with and, and nearly everybody admits to hav- and/or And/or, says Janis 1984, is "a formal expres- ing been taught at some past time that the practice was sion used in law and commerce...." It is, in fact, more wrong. Most of us think the prohibition goes back to our widely used than that, but Janis has aptly described its early school days. Bailey 1984 points out that the pro- origin. David Mellinkoff shows us in The Language of hibition is probably meant to correct the tendency of the Law (1963), that and/or was used first in maritime and so 94 and so shipping contracts (of a kind called charter party) in the . . . will deduce that the speaker is poorly educated middle of the 19th century. Who first used the device— and/or stupid —Robert Claiborne, Our Marvelous and |and I Native Tongue, 1983 it was then written or —we do not know, but or I or I The award . . . goes to a trade-book editor under 40 no doubt the first user thought it a convenient way to who has shown special talent in discovering and/or indicate some limited variability in the contract. The getting the best work out of his authors —Victor S. trouble was, however, that one party to the contract Navasky, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 15 Apr. 1973 might take one view of the matter and the other party a different view. So the interpretation of and/or became a . . . discriminatory laws were passed almost every- matter of litigation in 1854. where to make certain women were treated as slaves English judges had long practice in interpreting and/or children —Pete Hamill, Cosmopolitan, April English conjunctions in contracts. Not only were there 1976 residual problems from translating Latin into English— In the public mind it is generally considered to be three Latin conjunctions, ant, vel, and sive, of different carried out by priests and/or ministers —Times Lit- functions in Latin, were all translated into English as erary Supp., 19 Mar. 1970 or—but judicial interpretation had already allowed for and = or and or = and. (There is further information The book containing (1) the rites and ceremonies for on American judicial interpretation of and and or in the services, and/or (2) the rules and customs of dis- Margaret M. Bryant, English in the Law Courts, 1930.) cipline —Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church, And into these shifting tides of legal opinion came and/ 1957 or. There were three judges involved in the first and/or . . . attempts to dramatize the presumably hectic case; they reached three different conclusions as to what and/or nefarious goings-on in the newsrooms of big- it meant. Mellinkoff cites a later case involving and/or city tabloids —Harrison Smith, Saturday Rev., 21 in a shipping contract. Again there were three judges Aug. 1954 and three differing opinions. This time none of the three As Brando hummed and/or drummed in some opinions agreed with any of the first three opinions. secluded hideaway—Time, 13 Oct. 1958 And/or thus began in a cloud of legal ambiguity, but such an inauspicious infancy proved no deterrent in its . . . and a bow or belt in the back, depending on the use. size and/or sophistication of the girl who gets it — And/or seems to have established itself with some New Yorker, 24 Nov. 1956 rapidity both in legal and business contexts. In the 1920s it attracted the vigorous opposition of Samuel Hardin These examples are fairly typical of the general uses of Church, then president of Carnegie Institute in Pitts- and/or; we do have some, of course, that are vaguer than burgh, who seems to have been grievously offended by these. You may have observed that in each of these and/ its occurrence in some correspondence with the Inter- or is used between only two options and that it can read- state Commerce Commission. Church peppered pub- ily be understood in the sense "A or B or both." But if lishers and lexicographers with letters of protest, term- the number of options is increased, the number of pos- ing and/or an atrocious barbarism and "a hideous sibilities multiplies, and the chance for ambiguity like- invention." Church's objection seems to have been aes- wise increases. In "A, B, and/or C" lie "A or B or C," thetic; he proposed replacing the hideous invention with "A and B or C," "A or B and C," "A and B and C." The its unsightly virgule by a new word (are you ready for knotty problems of maritime law mentioned above were this?): andor. in fact of "A, B, and/or C" type. Little wonder the judges Most of the more recent criticism in our files is like- could reach so many conclusions. wise aesthetic—ugly is the usual epithet—although a Most of the examples in our files use and/or between few consider it confusing or ambiguous, and a few two alternatives. We have only a few examples of the (Johnson 1982, Shaw 1970, 1975, Reader's Digest 1983) "A, B, and/or C" type, two of which we give you here: find it compact and convenient. Opdyke 1939 interest- . . . someone who feels he has been the victim of neg- ingly says that defenders of and/or claim Daniel Defoe ligence by physicians, nurses, and/or hospitals — used it, perhaps in The Compleat English Tradesman Center Mag., November/December 1971 (1725, 1727), but no actual citations are produced. Mel- linkoff says the term has both defenders and disparagers All you will end up with will be a set of platitudes, in the legal profession. A number of commentators rec- truisms, and/or trivialities —Nehemiah Jordan, ommend replacing "A and/or B " with "A or B or both." Themes in Speculative Psychology, 1968 A note on form: and/or is nowadays usually found with the virgule. It has been written from time to time In these instances the multiplicity of possible combina- with a hyphen (and-or) and infrequently with only a tions seems not to matter. Which might suggest, to space (and or). The one-word form advocated by some, that and/or serves no purpose in them and might Church seems entirely disused, although we had one well have been avoided. notification of its adoption by the Georgia legislature in If you have a need to use and/or, we recommend that 1954. you use it only between two alternatives, where the While most of the handbooks refer to legal, commer- meaning will obviously be "A or B or both." In longer cial, technical, or bureaucratic contexts, none of them series and/or will likely be either vague or unnecessary. provides much in the way of illustrative material. Our evidence shows that it has a wider use; we present some and so Bierce 1909 objected to the use of and so as examples of that here. wordy, but modern books generally ignore it. It is, of course, in perfectly good use: . . . and read aloud extracts therefrom for the general benefit and or diversion of the company —Flann To my intense disappointment I was turned down, O'Brien, At Swim-Two-Birds, 1939 and so I went to another Presbyterian college —Wil- and which 95 anent liam Styron, This Quiet Dust and Other Writings, probably goes unnoticed for the most part. It is therefore 1982 a venial sin. We suggest that you try to avoid it, how- ever, for when it is spotted, it distracts the reader's And so the methods will be settled, and then I shall attention from more important matters—namely, what be returning —Jonathan Swift, Journal to Stella, 27 you are saying. Nov. 1710 According to rumor, they did not like each other and anent The old preposition anent "concerning, about" so the arrangement might be termed a feudal part- appears to have undergone a revival during the 19th nership —Heywood Broun, New Republic, 8 Mar. century. The OED notes the sense as being "common in 1939 Scotch law phraseology, and affected by many English writers." The OED evidence suggests little use of the He had never confided in them or shared his hopes word in the 17th and 18th centuries; an early 19th-cen- or feelings and so they saw no marked change in his tury citation is from Sir Walter Scott; he may have behavior —E. L. Doctorow, Ragtime, 1975 helped spread the use among English men of letters. The OED's comment about affectation was not taken up by . . . smiled broadly at Coverly all during the pause usage commentators until the 20th century, beginning and so it was not an anxious silence —John Cheever, with Utter 1913, Vizetelly 1922, Fowler 1926, and The Wapshot Chronicle, 1957 Krapp 1927. Their two chief words of disapproval are affected and archaic. Later commentators continue in and which, and who These headings, sometimes essentially the same vein, right up to Janis 1984 who is compounded (as in Copperud 1970, 1980) with but, still calling anent archaic. Copperud, 1970, 1980 notes cover a number of constructions marked by faulty par- that dictionaries list it as standard. allelism (which see) in the use of conjunctions and rela- Anent is an odd word. It has a bookish air about it— tive pronouns (and sometimes other connectives). The you rarely (or perhaps never) hear it used in ordinary problem is better exemplified than described: conversation—but it seems to pop up in contexts that are not at all bookish (along with some that are). Fowler . . . a lady very learned in stones, ferns, plants, and notes the frequency with which it is met in letters to the vermin, and who had written a book about petals — press. It is still found in letters to the editor: Anthony Trollope, Barchester Towers, 1857 (in A. S. Hill 1895) Anent your editorial with its "Go ahead and gripe" message —letter to the editor, InfoWorld, 19 Sept. In the example and joins a clause ("who had written a 1983 book . . . " ) with an adjective phrase ("learned in stones . . . " ) not structurally parallel to it. The usual corrective Anent your allusion to the military predilection for measure would be to insert who was after lady and, per- the noun-comma-adjective format —letter reprinted haps, then omit the who after and. inSafire 1982 Copperud gives this a fairly long entry, Fowler 1926, 1965 devotes about five pages to it, and several other The combined usage of letter-to-the-editor writers handbooks discuss the question. There is no doubt that and literary as well as nonliterary people has brought this construction is a fault; A. S. Hill, in Principles of anent back to life. Here is a healthy sample of such Rhetoric (1895), calls it "an offence against ease." It is usage. It is clearly not archaic, nor in most cases does more accurately an offense against elegance or precision. the level of affectation seem especially high. Dead words It is a minor offense, however; the examples we have are do sometimes rise from the grave, and this is one of readily understandable notwithstanding the fault; one them. third of the Heritage 1969 usage panel even found it I find another remark anent "pupils"—a bold spec- acceptable. Here are a few samples: ulation that my 1,000 pupils may really "go on" in the future life —Lewis Carroll, letter, 14 Feb. 1886 . . . Stephen, with a glance serious but which indi- cated intimacy, caught the eye of a comely lady — . . . a remark anent the advancement of the spring — Benjamin Disraeli, Sybil, 1845 (in Hill) George Moore, The Brook Kerith, 1916 . . . preserve for him his Highland garb and accoutre- . . . was writing anent the suggestion that Colonel ments, particularly the arms, curious in themselves, House's trip to Europe . . . was for the purpose of and to which the friendship of the donors gave addi- adjusting certain alleged squabbles —Arthur D. tional value —Sir Walter Scott, Waxerly, 1814 (in Howden Smith, The Real Colonel House, 1918 Hill) . . . a brief note from Felix anent some hostile review . . . the hold he exerted over the friend of his youth, in the New Republic of my last book —Harold J. and which lasted until her death, is here, rather trag- Laski, letter, 28 Nov. 1920 ically, revealed —Times Literary Supp., 31 Aug. 1951 . . . but he wrote letters telling of his progress and his thoughts anent the proper dissemination of religion Declarations made under Article 36 of the Statute of —F. Tennyson Jesse, The Lacquer Lady, 1930 the Permanent Court of International Justice and which are still in force shall be deemed . . . to be Anent the origin of sweet corn —Biological acceptances —Charter of the United Nations, 1945 Abstracts, January 1943 . . . dispute over the dying wartime President's The and which construction, in its various guises, is a remarks anent the League of Nations —Newsweek, fault that can be found, at least occasionally, in the work II June 1944 of good writers. It is most likely simply an inadvertency. Since it generally does not seem to interfere with the There is another marvelously wacky correspondence reader's understanding of the passage it appears in, it between Mr. Thurber and both customs officials and angle 96 Anglo the Connecticut State Tax Commission, anent a trenchant portrait —Albert A. Johnston, Publishers small bottle of wine sent as a gift —Irwin Edman, Weekly, 11 Mar. 1974 N.Y. Herald Tribune Book Rev., 1 Nov. 1953 An analysis of the headlines taken from all the Anent this, a report from Sweden on establishment papers in any country, on the same day, will show of the nation's fourth dental school —Dental Survey, that many are angled politically —David Kimball, March 1966 The Machinery of Self-Government, 1953 . . . and saying, anent the rumors of my going to India, that perhaps a word might go to Ellsworth Anglo A nglo is an ethnic term of relatively recent vin- Bunker —John Kenneth Galbraith, Ambassador's tage used to distinguish those of English ethnic or Journal, 1969 English-speaking background from others. The Dictio- nary of Canadianisms dates Canadian use from 1800; The nattering nabobs of negativism on the national U.S. use is much more recent, dating from the mid- networks will no longer natter negatively anent 1930s. Nixon —Richard H. Rovere, New Yorker, 1 May There are at present two chief uses. The first is Cana- 1971 dian; it distinguishes the Canadian of English ethnic and "A middle-class white son-of-a-bitch without goals language background from one whose background is will usually break your heart," a trainer remarks, French. anent fighters —Judith Crist, New York, 29 Oct. . . . the language we Anglos have all been speaking 1973 unwittingly—Canajan —Val Clery, Books in Can- Anent the practice of snaring ptarmigan with brass ada, July-September 1973 wires —Henry Tegner, Scottish Field, February 1975 We all know Quebec isn't entirely French.... there A line from his 'Prologue to Macbeth', anent the are still nearly a million Anglos in the province — apparition of Banquo —D. J. Enright, The Listener, Sonia Day, letter to the editor, Word Watching, June 22 May 1975 1983 The second arose in the southwestern U.S. and origi- nally distinguished the American of English-speaking angle Angle, "the viewpoint from which something is background from one of Spanish-speaking background. considered," is described by Copperud 1970, 1980 as "mildly criticized" and "under a faint shadow that is But as far as the newcomer can see, the ordinary fast disappearing." Since many of the books that criti- Anglo is little more civilized, less blatant, or less con- cize this sense of angle are school or college handbooks, fident of his own noisy progress because of his con- it may be used more often in student papers than tact with the two more gracious cultures —Dudley instructors like. The Merriam-Webster files do not show Wynn, New Mexico Quarterly, February 1935 evidence of the overuse asserted in the handbooks; atti- tude, point of view, position—the words Guth 1985 calls The Spanish-speaking also are still about. They dress angle an overused synonym for—are used with consid- for the most part like Anglos now —Conrad Richter, erably more frequency than angle. Angle appears most Holiday, December 1953 frequently in reviews. Here are some examples: But Anglo has been extended to other kinds of distinc- A solidly good, offbeat Bicentennial book idea that tions. In the 1980s these have not yet sorted themselves cries out for a wider angle and a richer sense of the out into uses that are both discrete and fixed enough to American cartoonists' diversity —Albert H. John- be recognized as separate meanings. Here is a sample: ston, Publishers Weekly, 27 Oct. 1975 Unless you happen to be Spanish, Mexican, or It is a special angle of vision granted to certain writ- Indian, when you go to Santa Fe you are casually ers who already write good English —William Zins- classed as an "Anglo," even if you are Greek, ser, N.Y. Times Mag., 2 Dec. 1979 Chinese, or British —Edith Moore Jarrett & Beryl J. M. McManus, El Camino Real, 3d éd., 1960 Roughly speaking, there are three main angles from which a novel can be criticized —Times Literary . . . a rate of depression midway between that of Jew- Supp., 25 July 1968 ish women with European-born mothers on the one hand and Anglo women on the other —Pauline Bart, And the angle of vision here is very different — Trans-Action, November-December 1970 Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., Saturday Rev., 2 Sept. 1978 In Miami, if you are not Cuban and not black, you are, by local definition, an Anglo —Herbert Burk- . . . a travel article, like any good article, must have holz, N.Y. Times Mag., 21 Sept. 1980 an angle or approach, a peg or slant, that will make it interesting to the audience —John J. Chalmers, . . . third graders in Denver—some Hispanic kids, The Writer, July 1968 some Indochinese, with half the class Anglo —Law- rence Fuchs, People, 6 Dec. 1982 The verb angle, in the past participle, is used in a similar sense: To Anglo minds, Latins often seem to typify the macho ethos; how then does Puerto Rico happen to It was all on paper, all of it, angled from Matthew have women in many of its top jobs? —Lorraine Brennan's point of view —Irving Wallace, The Plot, Davis, Vogue, January 1984 1967 How far these terms are disparaging, it is hard to tell. Admirers of Churchill may well be angered or sad- We have some evidence that the U.S. Anglo has been dened or both by this harsh but freshly angled and considered a derogatory term, but evidence in print sug- angry 97 animadversion gests that it is apparently not so apprehended a great With is sometimes used with inanimate or abstract majority of the time. If the term was in origin dispar- objects: aging, its usefulness as a classifying term has obscured that intent. Most of our current evidence—and there is . . . angry also with the change of fortune which was a lot—appears neutral. reshaping the world about him —James Joyce, A There is also use of Anglo in British English. Our evi- Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, 1 9 1 6 dence for it is somewhat thin, but at least sometimes it I think I was all the angrier with my own ineffective- refers to one who is English, as distinguished from Irish, ness because I knew the streets —The Autobiography Scottish, or Welsh—and perhaps others. This term may of Malcolm X, 1966 be used disparagingly: At is used with objects that are persons and objects that From the start Scotland produced brilliant players, are actions or things: saw them bribed away to play in England and spat after them the contemptuous term "Anglos" —Brian I have heard some people so extravagantly angry at James, Sunday Times Mag. (London), 2 June 1974 this play —George Farquhar, Preface to The Incon- stant, 1702 angry From Vizetelly 1906 to Chambers 1985 much Yet I am angry at some bad Rhymes and Triplets — advice and prescription has been written about the prep- Jonathan Swift, letter, 28 June 1715 ositions that can be used with angry. Much of the dis- I find no considerable Man angry at the Book — cussion deals with whether the object of the anger is Alexander Pope, letter, 16 Nov. 1726 human, animal, or inanimate; often particular preposi- tions are prescribed for particular objects. Much of the "I do not see, Sir, that it is reasonable for a man to prescription is plainly in conflict with actual usage, such be angry at another...." —Samuel Johnson (1775), as Shaw 1970's "Idiomatically, one is angry with, not at, in James Boswell, Life of Samuel Johnson, 1791 a person."Angry at (a person) has been around since Shakespeare's time (the OED cites Timon of Athens, . . . there is nothing which makes us so angry at the 1607) and is still in use. people we love as their way of letting themselves be The chief prepositions are with, at, and about. With is imposed upon —Margaret Deland, Old Chester the most frequently used preposition when the object is Tales, 1898 a person: Jealous of the smallest cover, Indeed, be not angry with her, bud —William Wych- Angry at the simplest door; erly, The Country Wife, 1675 —D. H. Lawrence, Collected Poems, 1928 I fancy I shall have reason to be angry with him very I became angry at him and I went after him —Henry soon —Jonathan Swift, Journal to Stella, 9 Aug. Clark, quoted in Sports Illustrated, 15 July 1968 1711 They might be angry at him —Gay Talese, Harper's, I am sorry to be angry with you —Samuel Johnson January 1969 (1776), in James Boswell, Life of Samuel Johnson, 1791 About is used of persons or actions or things: Be not angry with me, Coleridge —Charles Lamb, letter, 24 Oct. 1796 . . . they are so angry about the affair of Duke Ham- ilton —Jonathan Swift, Journal to Stella, 2 Feb. She wanted somebody to be angry with —George 1712 Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, 1859 Still it's better to have Mr. L. angry about her than . . . I hope she isn't angry with me for talking non- about other topics —C. P. Snow, The Conscience of sense about her name —Lewis Carroll, letter, 28 the Rich, 1958 Nov. 1867 Mr. Reed is angry about what he perceives to be neg- You have often made me angry with you, poor little ative characterizations of black men in fiction and innocent —George Bernard Shaw, Cashel Byron's drama —Brent Staples, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 23 Profession, 1886 Mar. 1986 . . . angry with herself for having suffered from it so Other prepositions are also possible: much —Joseph Conrad, Chance, 1913 . . . he feels angry towards your community —Fred She was angry with Clare for crying —Rose Macau- Sharpe, 6th Annual Report, Peace Officers Training lay, Potterism, 1920 School, 1952 The author is very angry with anyone who dislikes She said, 'I was only angry for my sweet little baby.' the cockney manner of speech —Times Literary —Angus Wilson, Anglo-Saxon Attitudes, 1956 Supp., 20 Feb. 1953 It does not seem reasonable, on the basis of the evidence On this day Mary was angry with me —Ernest Hem- here and in the OED, to make rigid distinctions about ingway, "Miss Mary's Lion," 1956 which prepositions are proper in which uses. He was angry with himself, still more angry with Rose —C. P. Snow, The New Men, 1954 animadversion, animadvert 1 . Of these hard words Bernstein 1965 observes that the verb takes upon. " . . . I get that it's okay to be angry with you." —R. Actually, both the noun and verb are followed by on or D. Rosen, Psychobabble, 1977 upon, as Simon 1980 says. The instance of animadver- anniversary 98 annoy sion to that he detected probably resulted from the writ- in speech." At that time we had but a single example in er's confusing animadversion with aversion, which usu- print: ally takes to (but see section 2 below). A few examples of the usual prepositions: On the 15-month anniversary of Defense he had at last accepted a way to get everything done that must There are quite a few animadversions, for example, be done —Time, 8 Sept. 1941 on the plight of women —Anatole Broyard, N. Y. Our evidence since then is scant. Our correspondent Times, 28 Aug. 1980 of 1967 seems to have been right: it is probably not uncommon in speech (we do have some confirming evi- I refrain from further animadversions on the quality dence), but it remains uncommon in print. The exten- of tone —Richard Franko Goldman, The Concert sion to a period of time other than a year does not seem Band, 1946 especially irrational, however, in the absence of an alter- . . . animadversions upon the shortcomings of his native word for the idea. fellow biographers —Times Literary Supp., 21 Dec. 1973 annoint See ANOINT. . . . the justice of his animadversion upon his old acquaintance and pupil —James Boswell, Life of annoy Since early in this century, some commenta- SamuelJohnson, 1791 tors have been trying to help us with the prepositions that go with annoyed, the past participle of this verb. . . . let us notice and animadvert on the vogue use of Their distinctions are various and are based on such reiterate—Howard 1977 considerations as whether one is or feels annoyed, whether the annoyer is an action, thing, or person, and . . . had wearied of animadverting upon the late whether annoyed means "pestered." As is usual with King's devotion to duty —Malcolm Muggeridge, such attempts, actual usage proves more complex than Saturday Evening Post, 19 Oct. 1957 the proffered distinctions. Here are some examples of . . . to the extent of our animadverting upon his eco- the common prepositions, with, at, and by, and the less nomics or his politics —John Crowe Ransom, Sewa- common about: nee Rev., Spring 1953 . . . annoyed the British in Philadelphia with a satir- ical ballad —American Guide Series: Pennsylvania, 2. The animadversion to detected by Simon 1980 may 1940 just possibly have been more than a casual confusion of aversion to with animadversion (upjon. We have some . . . if she annoys him with her watchfulness —H. M. slight evidence of the use of animadversion as a longer Parshley, translation of Simone de Beauvoir, The and perhaps more impressive or emphatic form of aver- Second Sex, 1952 sion. Our evidence for this use is sparse, and so far as we know, it is recognized by only two dictionaries, Mac- . . . get greatly annoyed with anything in it that hap- millan Dictionary (1973)—a high-school dictionary— pens to interfere —Elmer Davis, But We Were Born and one of its derivatives for lower grades. William D. Free, 1954 Halsey and his editors give as sense 2 of animadversion: . . . annoyed about a trembling hand —Current Biog- "dislike or antipathy; aversion: He became a vegetarian raphy, December 1964 because of his animadversion toward meat." We have no evidence of animadversion used with toward, but we do . . . annoyed at the waste of it all —Alan Rich, New have one example with to: York, 8 Feb. 1971 It embarrasses me now that I ever could have ques- . . . became annoyed at newspaper reports —John tioned the ingenuousness of her Polish sentiments Barkham, Saturday Rev., 13 Feb. 1954 and suspected her animadversion to the U.S.S.R. of My hostess was annoyed at me —Maude Phelps being simulated —Robert Craft, Stravinsky, 1972 Hutchins, Epoch, Fall 1947 It is possible that this sense is more common than our . . . are often puzzled and sometimes annoyed by the evidence suggests. If evidence continues to accumulate ways of other peoples —William A. Parker, Under- to the point that the meaning seems to have established standing Other Cultures, 1954 itself in the language, it will have to go into dictionaries, so the puzzled can look it up. Then, if tradition prevails, . . . she was disturbed and next annoyed by the usage experts will begin to lament the destruction of silence —Jean Stafford, Children Are Bored on Sun- another splendid word and the decline of literacy. For day, 1953 now our judgment has to be that this sense is still . . . much annoyed by the wolves that still existed in nonstandard. Florida then —Marjory Stoneman Douglas, The Everglades: River of Grass, 1947 anniversary Kilpatrick 1984 animadverts on the use He was annoyed by the cold, the starvation, and of anniversary to mark the recurrence of a period other chiefly by the coarseness of the dying soldiers — than a year. He cites among his examples a Wall Street Morris Bishop, Saturday Rev., 11 Dec. 1954 Journal report of Poland's "six-month anniversary" of Though annoyed by the tone of the Tringsbys' letters a military crackdown. —Elizabeth Bowen, The Heat of the Day, 1949 This use seems to be chiefly an oral one that is found very infrequently in print. A correspondent wrote to ask . . . he was distinctly annoyed by Clara's advent — us about it in 1967, claiming it to be "not uncommon Elinor Wylie, Mr. Hodge and Mr. Hazard, 1928 anoint 99 anticipate Annoy and annoyed are followed by constructions other ante-, anti- Several handbooks warn against confus- than those consisting of preposition and noun. A ing these prefixes. Ante- means "earlier, before," and sample: anti- (sometimes found as ant- or anth-) "opposite, opposed, against." See a good dictionary for fuller defi- It annoys me to have smokers blow smoke in my nitions. There was an anti- in use as a variant of ante- face —H. Thompson Fillmer et al., Patterns of Lan- at one time, but it seems to have become disused guage, Level F (textbook), 1977 because of the possibility of confusion with the . . . I was annoyed to lose it —Nora Wain, The "against" anti-. So there is now no excuse for a mistake House of Exile, 1933 with these prefixes. Some of his friends were annoyed to recognize them- selves in the latter book —Dictionary of American antecedent The adjective antecedent is less attested Biography, 1929 in our files than the noun; as an adjective it is not usu- ally placed in a construction requiring a preposition, but Annoyed that the university administrators had pub- when it is, the preposition is to. licly aired their views —Current Biography, January 1966 For him, character and society are antecedent to talk —Richard Poirier, A World Elsewhere, 1966 "It's annoying that we have to rush. . . . " —Adven- tures Here and There (5th grade textbook), 1950 If we believe that we have rights antecedent to gov- ernment — Time, 26 Sept. 1955 anoint Often misspelled annoint, says Copperud 1970, 1980. The spelling annoint is already recognized anterior Our evidence of anterior as an attributive as a standard variant in the sense of anointing as a adjective runs pretty heavily to technical contexts. As a sacred rite. But our evidence confirms Copperud: the predicate adjective it usually takes to. It tends to be ann- spelling is spreading to the other sense of anoint: found in rather learned or at least elevated styles. . . . former times when no boy would annoint him- In political theory, even a constitutional system self below his navel —Prose, Fall 1971 entails powers anterior to those specified in the Con- stitution—National Rev., 17 Nov. 1970 . . . his views and his new power have served to annoint him as the spiritual leader of the new bloc . . . the Babylonian epic Gilgamesh, which is a gen- of ultraconservatives —N.Y. Times Mag., 8 Feb. uine epic by any definition and is not only anterior 1981 to the Bible but may also have influenced both the Greek and the Indian epics —Moses Hadas, Com- . . . oysters poached in white wine and annointed mentary, October 1957 with beurre blanc —Town & Country, June 1980 . . . a parallel liberation which Croce seeks in his pre- We also have a couple of annointments. None of these sentation of Art as ideally anterior to Thought — spellings is yet recognized in dictionaries. Cecil Sprigge, Benedetto Croce, 1952 an't, a'n't This is the original contraction that even- anti- See ANTE-, ANTI-. tually gave us ain't. It may possibly have originated as an Irishism; at least the earliest evidence we have found so far occurs in the writing of Congreve, Farquhar, and anticipate "The verb anticipate is often used with the Swift. The contraction seems to have dropped out of use meaning 'to foresee (something) and take action to pre- in the U.S. around the middle of the 19th century and vent it, counter it, meet its requirements, etc' Some in England a bit later. In America it was replaced by people consider this to be the only correct meaning of ain't; in England it seems to have been replaced by anticipate, but for most speakers of English this verb has aren 't, although a few writers use ain 't. See AIN'T; AREN'T another meaning, equivalent simply to 'foresee' or I. Here are a few examples from the past: 'expect' " Thus Chambers 1985. While this state- ment is reasonable as far as it goes, it is based on the Miss PRUE. YOU need not sit so near one, if you have mistaken assumption that anticipate has but two senses. any thing to say, I can hear you farther off, I an't deaf The OED identifies nine senses, most of which are still —William Congreve, Love for Love, 1695 active; even Webster's Ninth New Collegiate offers six CHERRY. . . . I hope, Sir, you an't affronted — transitive and one intransitive. When the Chambers edi- George Farquhar, The Beaux Stratagem, 1707 tors go on to observe that "it is perhaps unfortunate that anticipate has taken on this wider meaning," they are . . . an't I a reasonable creature? —Jonathan Swift, nodding in the direction of many earlier commenta- Journal to Stella, 18 Feb. 1711 tors—Reader's Digest 1983, Copperud 1970, 1980, Bry- son 1984, Phythian 1979, Burchfield 1981, Sellers 1975, SIR PETER. TWO hundred pounds! what, a'n't I to be Gowers 1948, to name some—who condemn the in a good humor without paying for it? —Richard "expect" use. Brinsley Sheridan, A School for Scandal, 1783 The original objection seems to have been made by It is thought he has gone sick upon them. He a'n't Ayres 1881. Ayres decided that certain examples he had well, that's certain —Charles Lamb, letter, 26 Feb. collected meant "expect" and were wrong. To prove his 1808 contention, he points to the etymology of the word and a number of different definitions presumably taken from An a'n't I a woman? —Séjourner Truth, recorded by an unnamed dictionary, none of which is "expect." This Frances D. Gage, May 1851 (in J. L. Dillard, Amer- is merely a game being played with the words that have ican Talk, 1976) been used to define anticipate; nothing whatsoever has antidote 100 antipathy been proved. But no matter. Along comes Bierce 1909 ers can be much subtler than commentators are often to take the same position; Bierce, however, discards all willing to recognize. but one approved sense of anticipate, which has made life much simpler for later commentators. Copperud antidote 1. The OED and other dictionaries note that 1980, for instance, refers to the word's "pristine sense," antidote can be followed by against, for, or to. Evidence although several of the OED's senses are from the six- in our files shows that all three are in use for both literal teenth century and the "forestall" sense is not among and figurative senses. Of the three, to is the most com- them. monly used at the present time, for next, and against the The plain fact of the matter is that in some instances least. A few examples: anticipate comes close in meaning to some meanings of expect. And in some instances it comes close to predict, An antidote against nerve gases —Time, 19 Mar. foresee, look forward to, forestall, foreshadow. But none 1956 of these words are precise synonyms for anticipate; they serve only to suggest meaning. It is therefore vain to . . . no surer antidote against the dull monotony of erect a whole edifice of lexical right and wrong on the travel —Douglas Carruthers, Beyond the Caspian, shifting sands of occasional near synonyms. 1949 Here are some examples of anticipate that do not . . . the first effective antidote for PCP — N Y. Times, mean "forestall." Some of them do not mean "expect" 11 Feb. 1980 either. All of them are perfectly standard. . . . hate may be the only antidote for despair — Always she was restlessly anticipating the day when David Black, New Times, 11 July 1975 they would leave —Arnold Bennett, The Old Wives' Tale, 1908 . . . an antidote to the arsenical blister gases —Rus- sell L. Cecil & Robert F. Loeb, Textbook of Medi- Pleasure not known beforehand is half wasted; to cine, 8th éd., 1951 anticipate it is to double it —Thomas Hardy, The Return of the Native, 1878 . . . the grim reality of life in Kiev acted as a strong antidote to romantic notions —Glenn Plaskin, TV. Y. He became more dependent on her; and she antici- Times, 6 Feb. 1983 pated that he would become more exacting in his demands on her time —George Bernard Shaw, 2. A few commentators warn against confusing antidote Cashel Byron's Profession, 1886 with anecdote. The likelihood of this malapropism would seem to be low, but it has happened: . . . said she would give me her tickets to the antici- pated celebration at party headquarters —Eisa Max- . . . if I could tell an antidote about self-incrimina- well, Woman's Home Companion, April 1954 tion —Police, September-October 1967 . . . which the beau monde of the Cambrian moun- If you have tell before or about after, antidote is clearly tains was in the habit of remembering with the great- not the word you want. est pleasure, and anticipating with the most lively satisfaction —Thomas Love Peacock, Headlong Hall, 1816 antipathy Bernstein 1965 says that antipathy takes to, toward, or against; Lincoln Library 1924 says to, She certainly had not anticipated taking a whole day sometimes for or against, and between; Krapp 1927 says to get through a belt of reeds a mile wide —C. S. to but n o t ^ r or against; Webster 1909 says to, against, Forester, The African Queen, 1935 between, sometimes for. We had better straighten this out. "I can tell you that our overall bomber losses are Construction with against seems to be archaic. We proving light. Only a fraction of what we anticipated, have no recent evidence for it, although it was once what we were prepared for." —James Gould Coz- current: zens, Guard of Honor, 1948 What a strange antipathy I have taken against these No obstacles were anticipated —Eileen Hughes, creatures! —George Farquhar, The Inconstant, 1702 Ladies' Home Jour., September 1971 . . . nothing is more essential than that permanent Both had anticipated and foretold a bit of rain before inveterate antipathies against particular nations . . . night —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard should be excluded —George Washington, Farewell Feverel, 1859 Address, 1796 Each side anticipates that the other will add to its The use of between (two persons or things), while not armament —Jerome D. Frank, Psychology Today, common, is still current: November 1968 . . . there was a marked antipathy between their rad- Some marketers anticipate that by Labor Day icalism or liberalism and the conservative peasant motorists will be paying as much as 50 to 60 cents ideas of the mass of Italian immigrants —Oscar for a gallon of gasoline —August Gribbin, National Handlin, The American People in the Twentieth Cen- Observer, 28 Apr. 1973 tury, 1954 The antipathy between Mr. Barbieri and Mr. Lee has All of these examples fall within the range of the grown —William Borders, NY. Times, 15 Oct. 1967 OED's sense 9. You will see that no single word, like expect or predict, and no phrase, like look forward to, The antipathy between the groups is deep —Renata quite comprehends every one. The usage of actual writ- Adler, Pitch Dark, 1983 anxious 101 anxious To has been and continues to be the most common The learned dictionary-maker, of course, collapsed com- preposition: pletely at this shrewd observation, and Mr. Ayres pre- sumably went on his merry way, illuminating other Whose peering eye and wrinkled front declare learned men. This particular learned dictionary-maker A fixed antipathy to young and fair seems not to have looked at anxious in the OED (A —Richard Brinsley Sheridan, appeared in 1884); if he had, he would have discovered The School for Scandal, 1783 that his use of anxious had already existed for some 160 . . . perceived above a dozen large bugs. You must years when he was corrected. Even lexicographers can know I have the same kind of antipathy to these ver- be taken unawares. min —Tobias Smollett, Travels Through France and From its modest beginnings in the Ayres anecdote Italy, 1766 and Bierce's prescription, the anxious-eager question rapidly became a shibboleth in American usage. It Hogarth's antipathy to France —Agnes Repplier, In appears in Utter 1916, MacCracken & Sandison 1917, Pursuit of Laughter, 1936 Vizetelly 1922, Ball 1923, Whipple 1924, Powell 1925, . . . who shares this antipathy to the indefiniteness of and others down to Bernstein 1965, 1977, Shaw 1970, aesthetic morality —Havelock Ellis, The Dance of 1975, Bremner 1980, Bell & Cohn 1981, Janis 1984, Kil- Life, 1923 patrick 1984, and Harper 1975, 1985. Fowler 1926 pooh-poohed the whole matter with the result that anx- . . . a definite antipathy to permitting outside doctors ious-eager has not found much of a place in English to come into their home communities and take over usage books, being noticed only in Partridge 1942 and their practice —JAMA, 3 Apr. 1943 Bryson 1984 among those we have seen. There are two aspects to the question, both touched . . . Grandmother's belief that the medical profession upon by Bierce. The first is semantic—do not use anx- needed informed lay augmentation was the basis for ious for eager—and the second is idiomatic: "Anxious her implacable antipathy to hospitals —James A. should not be followed by an infinitive." Let's begin Maxwell, New Yorker, 24 Nov. 1951 with meaning. . . . the growing sensibility cult with its antipathy to Bierce's semantic equation, anxious = eager in this the generic explicitness of the novel —Anthony J. use, is an oversimplification subscribed to by most, but Hassall, Novel, Spring 1972 not all, of the commentators who disapprove it. Utter 1916, for instance, admits anxious to (do something) While for and toward appear somewhat less fre- when the eagerness is qualified by a troubled mind quently than to, both are in regular use, and they are about the endeavor. Partridge 1942 seems to be thinking about equally common: along similar lines when he rules out anxious meaning "eager" or "desirous," but permits it for "solicitous" The antipathy Lessing felt for the French wit — and "earnestly desirous" (which might in practice be dif- Irving Babbitt, The New Laokoon, 1910 ficult to distinguish from plain "desirous" but must be . . . both species knew instinctively of his pro- passed because it is the OED definition). The word, in nounced antipathy for them —Osbert Sitwell, Noble fact, fairly often has the notion of anxiety mingled with Essences, 1950 that of eagerness; it is not unreasonable to suppose that this is how the use developed. Here is Dr. Johnson hold- Her one antipathy is for Schrader, whose work she ing forth: has never liked —Robert F. Moss, Saturday Rev., October 1980 . . . there must always be some degree of care and anxiety. The master of the house is anxious to enter- Little remains of the Puritanical antipathy toward tain his guests; the guests are anxious to be agreeable them as immoral —Thomas Munro, The Arts and —in James Boswell, Life of Samuel Johnson, 1791 Their Interrelations, 1949 Without Johnson's mention of anxiety, a reader might And the American antipathy toward a preventive take anxious to mean "eager" here. A few more exam- nuclear strike —Stephen A. Garrett, Center Mag., ples that suggest a mixture of eagerness and anxiety are July-August 1971 these: anxious The discovery that anxious must not be used Even without his books, Don Quixote set forth once to mean "eager" seems to have been made in the U.S. again, anxious as before not to lose any time, "for he in the early 20th century. Bierce 1909 is the earliest could not but blame himself for what the world was usage book we have found that prohibits the usage, but losing by his delay " —Malcolm Muggeridge, apparently Alfred Ayres beat him to the punch. A cor- Punch, 8 Apr. 1953 respondent reading the Chattanooga, Tennessee, Times in 1901 sent us a clipping from that paper with the fol- The Court may be anxious to dispose of this poten- lowing quotation: tially troublesome affair —Arthur E. Wise, Saturday Rev., 20 Nov. 1971 Only a few days ago, I heard a learned man, an LL.D., a dictionary-maker, an expert in English, say Most spiders are shy and far more anxious to avoid that he was anxious to finish the moving of his than to attack man —Katherine W. Moseley, Mas- belongings from one room to another. sachusetts Audubon, June 1971 "No, you are not," said I. . . . all the Christian churches in Africa are anxious "Yes, I am. How do you know?" to escape from "the foreignness of Christianity" — "I know you are not." Times Literary Supp., 2 Oct. 1969 "Why, what do you mean?" "There is no anxiety about it. You are simply Bierce's association of the "eager" sense with the con- desirous." —Alfred Ayres, Harper's, July 1901 struction with to and the infinitive is probably a clue to anxious 102 anxious the way in which the sense developed in the 18th cen- . . . he smiled broadly at Coverly all during the pause tury. A few books—Scott-Foresman 1981, Swan 1980— and so it was not an anxious silence —John Cheever, distinguish the senses of anxious by their typical con- The Wapshot Chronicle, 1957 structions. Anxious about and anxious at are associated with the "worried, troubled" sense, and anxious to and . . . her sister . . . for whose happiness she grew daily anxious for with the "eager, desirous" sense. A. S. more anxious —Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice, Hornby, in A Guide to Patterns and Usage in English 1813 (1954), also places anxious that in the "eager, desirous" . . . a little tired, and more than a little anxious and column. The examples that follow show that actual nervous —Arnold Bennett, The Old Wives' Tale, usage is not quite as neat as they suggest. 1908 The anxious at construction does not show up in our files, nor in the OED. We do have an anxious lest: . . . he who had once been oily and unctuous, a man of plenty and of ease, was now become anxious and He was anxious lest they were broken and thus make harried —Pearl Buck, The Good Earth, 1931 an evil omen —Pearl Buck, The Good Earth, 1931 Allen Dulles would not have been impressed by the Anxious about is well attested. The examples are for risk involved, though a modestly competent lawyer the "worried" sense, but a couple are equivocal and the would, one imagines, have been anxious —John source of anxiety can often be trivial: Kenneth Galbraith, New York, 30 July 1973 "We want to make a table [at cards] for Mrs. Rush- The "eager" sense is said to be found in the anxious worth, you know. Your mother is quite anxious for, anxious that, and anxious to constructions. While about it, but cannot very well spare time to sit down this is true in the main, the first of these constructions herself, because of her fringe." —Jane Austen, is used for both the "worried" and "eager" senses: Mansfield Park, 1814 . . . Cicero, anxious for his own safety —J. A. As an American, I hope we shall. As a moralist and Froude, Caesar, 1879 occasional sermonizer, I am not so anxious about it —Oliver Wendell Holmes d. 1894, The Autocrat of She was wounded by the disapproval of many of her the Breakfast-Table, 1858 friends, and anxious for the future of Hull House — Robert Morss Lovett, All Our Years, 1948 "So you're anxious about my reputation." —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, 1859 Distraction display very rarely occurs except when a The male is hilarious and demonstrative, the female bird is anxious for its nest and eggs or young — serious and anxious about her charge —John Bur- Edward A. Armstrong, Bird Display and Behaviour, roughs, Wake-Robin, 1871 2ded., 1947 . . . will ease the professor's mind on a point that he His sisters were very anxious for his having an estate seemed anxious about —George Bernard Shaw, — J a n e Austen, Pride and Prejudice, 1 8 1 3 Cashel Byron's Profession, 1886 All seemed pleased with the performance and anx- He would be too anxious about his son, I thought, he ious for another of the same sort —Kingsley Amis, would care too much —C. P. Snow, The New Men, Lucky Jim, 1954 1954 . . . unlike many idealistic spokesmen for the left... Partridge and one or two other British sources object to Bevan was always anxious for power —Kenneth O. anxious of; why, they do not tell. The OED has a little Morgan, Times Literary Supp., 14 Nov. 1980 evidence of its use from the 18th century; they mark it obsolete, but it is in fact only rare: Anxious that is found with the "eager" sense, although some of these examples carry connotations of concern The Arizona statesman's practice has since been to as well: seem anxious of an election outcome so as to stir his supporters to greater campaign activity —Current . . . is anxious for the sake of both that there shd not Biography 1951 be a disappointment —Jane Austen, letter, 7 Oct. 1808 But the most common constructions in which the . . . Constance insisted, anxious that he should live "worried" senses of anxious are found are those of the up to his reputation for Sophia's benefit —Arnold attributive adjective and the plain predicate adjective Bennett, The Old Wives' Tale, 1908 without any following prepositional phrase: . . . and visibly anxious that his wife should be on 'Tie a rope round him—it is dangerous!' cried a soft easy terms with us all —Agnes Repplier, Eight De- and anxious voice somewhere above them — cades, 1937 Thomas Hardy, The Return of the Native, 1878 Don Juan was anxious that his son be given a spe- Two anxious days followed while the ship was being cific role in Spanish public life —Current Biography, loaded —Thomas B. Costain, The Black Rose, 1945 October 1964 . . . avoid envy; anxious fears; anger fretting inwards —Francis Bacon, Essays, 1625 . . . Japan's chiefs felt certain Germany would win. This being so they were anxious that they, and not The household income cannot be large, yet there is the Germans, should seize the Dutch, British and no sign of want, or even of anxious thrift —Rebecca French possessions in the Far East —L. E. Snell- West, New Yorker, 14 Feb. 1953 grove, The Modern World Since 1870, 1968 anxious 103 anxious The most prominently represented construction of He was willing, perhaps anxious, to take the Eastern anxious in our files is the one reprehended by Bierce: command —J. A. Froude, Caesar, 1879 anxious with to and an infinitive. The construction occurs in spoken English. Here we have Sir Winston . . . anxious as I was to tell them my story, I durst Churchill in a debate in the House of Commons, some- not interrupt —Robert Louis Stevenson, Treasure time after World War II: Island, 1883 . . . intellectual highbrows who are naturally anxious Punch was always anxious to oblige everybody — to impress British labor with the fact that they Rudyard Kipling, Wee Willie Winkie and Other learned Latin at Winchester —quoted by William Child Stories, 1888 Safire, N.Y. Times Mag., 10 Oct. 1982 He was so anxious to do what was right —Samuel (Safire could not refrain from adding "Churchill meant Butler, The Way of All Flesh, 1903 to say eager, not anxious,^ but anxious/eager is not a . . . schoolmasters may be pathetically anxious to shibboleth in British English, and if Churchill had guide boys right —A. C. Benson, From A College meant to say eager he no doubt would have said eager.) Window, 1906 We find it also in letters: . . . city bankers anxious to furnish him capital — I feel no hesitation in saying, I was more anxious to Sherwood Anderson, Poor White, 1920 hear your critique, however severe, than the praises of the million —Lord Byron, letter, 6 Mar. 1807 I am particularly anxious in this lecture not to assume the role of a Christian apologist —W. R. I hope I should be ready to go, if He called me now, Inge, The Church in the World, 1928 but I'm not the least anxious to be called yet —Lewis Carroll, letter, 12 Feb. 1887 . . . the gravely courteous air of a dog who is anxious to show himself interested in what interests his mas- Mr. Cameron is anxious to have us come down, but ter —Mary Austin, Starry Adventure, 1931 Hay pleads his beautiful treaties —Henry Adams, letter, 1 Feb. 1900 . . . I am not anxious to appraise the good or evil in the Soviet system —Bertrand Russell, The Scientific My book came out yesterday officially, though no Outlook, 1931 copies are yet to hand; I am more anxious than I can say to know how it strikes your eminence —Harold . . . many firms are anxious to employ their cash prof- J. Laski, letter, 28 Mar. 1919 itably —Manchester Guardian Weekly, 19 Jan. 1940 . . . information which our enemies are desperately Thanks so much for the comments which I'll always anxious to obtain —Franklin D. Roosevelt, fireside be anxious to get, good or bad —Flannery O'Con- chat, 9 Dec. 1941, in Nothing to Fear, ed. B. D. nor, letter, 30 Apr. 1952 Zevin, 1946 And we have evidence from other kinds of writing: The average immigrant was pathetically anxious to His manner was perhaps the more seductive, become an American —Allan Nevins & Henry Because he ne'er seem'd anxious to seduce Steele Commager, The Pocket History of the U.S., —Lord Byron, Don Juan, Canto xv, 1824 1942 . . . the men looked hard at him, anxious to see what . . . more ready to sell other things besides drink, less sort of a looking "cove" he was —Herman Melville, anxious to send their customers away tipsy —G. M. Omoo, 1847 Trevelyan, English Social History, 1942 . . . ever anxious to ameliorate the condition of the . . . Paris, where there are a great many young writers poor —Anthony Trollope, The Macdermots of Bal- anxious to experiment in literary form —Cyril Con- lycloran, 1847 nolly, The Condemned Playground, 1946 In any weather, at any hour of the day or night, I . . . poets like Auden and Milton are more anxious to have been anxious to improve the nick of time — persuade than poets, like Herbert, or Vaughan, or Henry David Thoreau, Walden, 1854 Crashaw, of actual religious experience —G. S. Fraser, in Little Reviews Anthology 1949, ed. Denys I could give many facts, showing how anxious bees Val Baker are to save time —Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, 1859 . . . the Japanese themselves are anxious to assume their proper international role —Dean Acheson, in Miss Manette . . . was extremely anxious to see the The Pattern of Responsibility, ed. McGeorge Bundy, gentleman from Tellson's —Charles Dickens, A Tale 1951 of Two Cities, 1859 He was so anxious to get a fly into the water that he Sir Austin . . . appeared so scrupulously anxious to had to reproach himself for haste —John Cheever, hear the exact extent of injury sustained by the The Wapshot Chronicle, 1957 farmer —George Meredith, The Ordeal of Richard Feverel, 1859 1 know nothing of this democracy . . . but I am anx- ious to learn —Myles na gCopaleen (Flann O'Brien), The male is very active in hunting out a place and The Best of Myles, 1968 exploring the boxes and cavities, but seems to have no choice in the matter and is anxious only to please . . . Elizabeth was initially anxious to improve the and encourage his mate —John Burroughs, Wake- conditions of the peasants —Times Literary Supp., Robin, 1871 2 Oct. 1970 any 104 any This couple seemed anxious to avoid Philip's four Here are a few examples of the idiom from writers friends, or at least spoke as little as possible —Doris more recent than Addison: Lessing, The Good Terrorist, 1985 We boast that we belong to the nineteenth century We believe these examples show clearly and amply and are making the most rapid strides of any nation the major patterns in which anxious occurs. Anyone —Henry David Thoreau, Walden, 1854 (in Reader's who says that careful writers do not use anxious in its Digest 1983) "eager" sense has simply not examined the available evidence. Its population would have remained the most care- fully screened of any body of settlers ever to have come to America —N. Y. Times Book Rev., 20 Apr. any 1. The pronoun any can be either singular or plu- 1947 (in Bryant) ral in construction—even Harper 1985 and Bernstein 1977 agree. Bernstein believes the plural construction to Although its coverage of the government, Capitol be more common, but we cannot confirm his belief from Hill and the world is more complete than any paper the evidence in our files, in which the two constructions in the city —Time, 29 Dec. 1952 are roughly equal: . . . the price deflator for construction has risen by far . . . had reached its final shape before any of his vol- the most of any —Garfield V. Cox, Jour, of Business, umes of poems were published —The Tiger's Eye, January 1954 December 1947 Why does Jennifer House sell more convertible . . . nor is any of his novels purely a novel of ideas sofabeds in Manhattan than the convertible depart- —Frederick J. Hoffman, in Forms of Modern Fic- ment in any Manhattan department store? —advt, tion, ed. William Van O'Connor, 1948 N. Y. Times Mag., 18 Apr. 1982 2. Longman 1984 notes that any with a singular noun The studies cited in Bryant suggest that the more log- may be referred to by a plural pronoun. ical constructions—"of any other" and "of all"—pre- scribed by the handbooks are more commonly met in . . . he would at no time be a willing party to any art- print nowadays than the older any idiom. The rewriting ist breaking their contract —The Times (in of any as any other or all is a simple enough correction, Longman) and it may be that more recent writers have tended to . . . he kept his door wide open so that any one of his use the prescribed forms. If this is the case—and the evi- 12,000 employees could walk in and spill their trou- dence is not conclusive—the older idiom may be on the bles — Time, 17 Nov. 1952 wane. Perrin & Ebbitt 1972, for instance, finds any other not just more logical but more idiomatic. A couple of Lurie 1927 thought this construction a "transgression examples: against good form in grammar." He quotes an uniden- tified newspaper: The tobacco industry has funded more scientific research on smoking and health problems than has . . . it is a wonderful thing for any person to be so any other source —Annual Report, R. J. Reynolds imaginative that they think they are still attractive. Industries, Inc., 1970 What Lurie did not understand, and the Longman edi- . . . obtained for New Haven more renewal money tors do, is that notional agreement is the principle in per capita than that received by any other city — operation here. It is a long-established construction: Current Biography, December 1967 Any man that has a Humour is under no restraint or In conclusion, we must agree with Reader's Digest fear of giving it a vent; they have a proverb among 1983: you can revise any in such a construction to any them which, maybe, will show the bent and genius other or all easily if you want to, but the any idiom is of the people as well as a longer discourse —William old, well-established, and standard. Congreve, "Concerning Humour in Comedy," 1695 4. Any as an adverb. When any is used as an adverb it Congreve's use shows the typical singular-verb-plural- usually modifies an adjective, but it sometimes also pronoun agreement of many indefinite pronouns and occurs by itself after a verb in the sense "at all." This adjectives. use was disparaged by American usage writers (Bache See THEY, THEIR, THEM and the articles under 1869, Ayres 1881, Compton 1898) toward the end of the AGREEMENT. 19th century; their comments were repeated in the early 3. Of any, than any (illogical comparison). In 1705 20th (MacCracken & Sandison 1917, Utter 1916, Lin- Joseph Addison, in the preface to a book of travels in coln Library 1924). Utter noted it had long been in use Italy written by someone else, noted that the author but thought it did not have "the sanction of the best writers." It appears in the journals of Lewis and Clark . . . has wrote a more correct Account of Italy than (in 1805 Clark wrote, "the three horses with me do not any before him. (OED) detain me any") and in Mark Twain: "It is a good tune—you can't improve it any" (Innocents Abroad, Two centuries later Vizetelly 1906 calls the construction 1869—in OED Supplement). Here are a few more incorrect, objecting to "the finest of any I have seen." examples: Bryant 1962 reports that the construction with a super- lative (or, less often, a comparative) and of ox than has . . . Fat and Red didn't let that worry them any — been in use since the time of Chaucer. The handbooks Fred Gipson, Cowhand: The Story of a Working and commentators following Vizetelly's lead are Cowboy, 1953 engaged in the ex post facto application of logical anal- ysis to a long-established idiom—with entirely predict- And prices have not fallen any —Commonweal, 19 able results. Oct. 1945 any and all 105 anymore . . . to eat our dinner under the shade and rest . . . Anyone who thinks he's pure is surely not —Flan- before we dug any — J . Frank Dobie, Coronado's nery O'Connor, letter, 1 Jan. 1956 Children, 1931 . . . a cheap way for a well-heeled anyone to see his "You're not helping it any," I said —Robert Clark, name in the company of bookish folk —Bernard in Coast to Coast: Australian Stories 1946 Kalb, Saturday Rev., 20 Mar. 1954 As a usage issue this one is pretty cold now. Longman Any one who tries to discuss this problem candidly 1984 mentions some dislike of the use in Britain as an is at once met with the suggestion that he is unaware Americanism. The OED Supplement, however, shows it —Wendell L. Willkie, N. Y. Herald Tribune, 21 Nov. in such British sources as Kipling, Agatha Christie, and 1943 Punch. Anyone who wishes to find his bearings —H. B. any and all This phrase, an emphatic form of any Parkes, Marxism—An Autopsy, 1939 intended to cover all possibilities, has its chief use in . . . when anybody was condemned to be impaled, or legal documents such as contracts and official knouted, or beheaded, he or she promptly retained regulations: the Empress as intercessor at a handsome fee — He shall have the power to suspend any and all George Bernard Shaw, letter, 31 Dec. 1897 members so offending —Rules and Regulations of Notional agreement: the Fire Department, Springfield, Mass., 1949 But if I did say or do an ill thing to anybody, it Bernstein 1958,1965, Copperud 1964, and Shaw 1975 should be sure to be behind their backs, out of pure disparage its use in ordinary prose; the one epithet they good manners —William Wycherly, The Plain agree on is "trite." Whether writers have yielded to Dealer, 1676 authority on this point or whether the phrase is just not very appealing, our evidence shows it rather uncommon . . . as anybody in their senses would have done — in extralegal use. A few examples: Jane Austen, Mansfield Park, 1814 . . . over a thousand being arrested in one night and It is fatal to anyone who writes to think of their sex the fact of any and all arrests being kept an official —Virginia Woolf, A Room of One's Own, 1929 secret —A. Morgan Young, The Rise of a Pagan State, 1939 . . . it will then be open for anyone to take up the quarrel, if they think there is any public advantage . . . he had not realized how completely mistrusted in so doing —Sir Winston Churchill, The Unrelent- and feared were any and all Indians here in Eastern ing Struggle, 1942 Pennsylvania —F. Van Wyck Mason, The Winter at Valley Forge, 1953 He is afraid to have anyone mention sin without having them add "Nuts with that sin bunk" —New There is, then, prior to any and all principles of logic Republic, 4 Aug. 1952 a principle of metaphysics declaring for this self-con- sistency —Modern Schoolman, January 1954 "Anyone can think what they please," she said rather grimly —Louis Auchincloss, A Law for the Lion, It is perhaps sometimes unavoidable in text relating to 1953 legal matters: . . . anyone may progress to these better posts if they The company contends that the grant of immunity have the required qualifications —Employment from further prosecution which was part of the bar- Opportunities in the Civil Service (Canada), 1953 gain disposes of any and all federal criminal charges —The Economist, 1 Feb. 1975 . . . it may be difficult for anyone to find their path through what may be a sort of maze —Ford Madox You will probably have little need of it. Ford, quoted in Graham Greene, Collected Essays, 1969 anybody, anyone 1. These indefinite pronouns share with other indefinite pronouns the characteristic of tak- . . . anyone in your office can be generating their own ing a singular verb and, more often than not, a plural reports within 15 minutes —advt., InfoWorld, 27 pronoun in reference. See AGREEMENT: INDEFINITE PRO- Feb. 1984 NOUNS; THEY, THEIR, THEM; NOTIONAL AGREEMENT, You haven't told anyone at work. When they ask NOTIONAL CONCORD. This use of the plural pronoun— about Amanda you say she's fine —Jay Mclnerney, they, their, them—has traditionally been disapproved Bright Lights, Big City, 1984 by grammarians who do not recognize the existence of notional agreement, but the use is winning greater 2 . Both anybody and anyone were formerly spelled as acceptance. Copperud 1970 records Bryant, Evans, and two words, but the open styling is now reserved for Flesch as finding the plural pronoun acceptable, and the instances in which any is a separate adjective. four commentators he cites as disapproving it in writing 3. Anybody else's. See ELSE. are said to be "indulgent" of it in speech. Reader's Digest 1983 finds it acceptable. Usage is, of course, not uniform; some occurrences anymore 1 . Both anymore and any more are found in follow notional agreement, and others formal agree- current written use. Although usage prescribers disagree ment. Here are a few samples of each. about which form to use—"preferably spelled as one Formal agreement: word" (Shaw 1975); "two words" (Bremner 1980)—the one-word styling is the more common. Feel free to write . . . before releasing a child to anyone except his par- it as two words, if you prefer. ents — J . Edgar Hoover, NEA Jour, January 1965 2 . Anymore is regularly used in negative contexts ("we anyone 106 anyplace never go there anymore"), in questions ("do you listen states as New York, New Jersey, Iowa, Minnesota, Cal- to the radio anymore?"), and in conditional contexts ("if ifornia, and Oregon. It is still predominantly a spoken you do that anymore, I'll leave"). It is used in a number feature, although, as the citations above show, it does of positive statements in which the implication is appear in fiction and occasionally in journalistic negative: sources. Both the older American Dialect Dictionary and the new DARE note that it is used by persons of all There's only one woman for him any more —Owen educational levels; it is not substandard, and it is not a Wister, The Virginian, 1902 feature of speech that is considered indicative of social Damn few people take the time to read anymore — standing. William Du Bois, The Island in the Square, 1947 Bryant 1962 conjectures that the positive anymore may have come to the U.S. with Scotch-Irish immi- The Washingtonian is too sophisticated to believe grants in the 18th century. There is an any more listed any more in solutions —Russell Baker, N. Y. Times in the English Dialect Dictionary that occurs in both Mag., 14 Feb. 1965 positive and negative contexts, but its meaning is differ- ent from that of the American usage. D. H. Lawrence, . . . thought about whether such a profession as however, did put it into the mouth of the character merely pork butcher exists any more —Times Lit- named Rupert Birkin in his novel Women in Love, pub- erary Supp., 13 Mar. 1969 lished in 1920: . . . she found it harder and harder to sort out any- more what was worth saving and how best to save it "Quite absurd," he said. "Suffering bores me, any —Russell Baker, Growing Up, 1982 more." Few private owners have worthwhile collections And P. W. Joyce, in English As We Speak It in Ireland anymore —Spencer Davidson, Avenue, March 1984 (1910), notes the existence of a positive use of any more in the West and Northwest of Ireland. It is also used in None of these uses draws comment. But anymore is Canada. Modern Canadian English Usage (1974) also used in contexts with no negative implication, reports 8 or 9 percent of its respondents using the posi- much to the consternation and perplexity of some usage tive anymore with the highest incidences found in writers: Ontario and Newfoundland. Although many who encounter the usage for the first Every time I even smile at a man any more the time think it is new, it is not: the earliest attestation papers have me practically married to him —Betty cited in the DARE is dated 1859. Grable, quoted in Time, 25 Nov. 1940 3. Some handbooks and dictionaries caution against Useta be I had to go down to the still and carry my confusing the adverb anymore ("we don't go there any- own whisky outa the Hollow, but anymore I'm such more") with the phrase any more where more is a pro- a good customer they tote it up here . . . for me — noun or adjective, as in "we don't have any more" or "I Charley Robertson, Shadow of a Cloud, 1950 can't eat any more pizza." The adverb may be written either closed or open, as noted in section 1 above, but In a way he almost felt sorry for him, any more — the phrase should certainly be written open. James Jones, From Here to Eternity, 1951 anyone 1 . See ANYBODY, ANYONE. Listening is a rare art anymore —Alma Holland, 2. The usage panel of Heritage 1969, 1982 objects to the Writer's Digest, March 1970 use of anyone in the sentence "She is the most thrifty Who I would vote for anymore is the stronger person of anyone I know." This is the same construction learner, of whatever party —Stewart Brand, Esquire, as the one discussed at ANY 3, with anyone in place of July 1970 any. It sometimes seems to me that all I do anymore is go any other See ANY 3. to funerals —Harry S. Truman, quoted in Merle Miller, Plain Speaking, 1973 anyplace For a word as recent as anyplace, it might seem a bit surprising that we know so little of its origins. Every time we leave the house anymore, I play a It first came to the attention of Merriam-Webster edi- game called "Stump the Housebreaker" —Erma tors through handbooks warning their readers not to use Bombeck, syndicated column, 24 Jan. 1973 it—Utter 1916, MacCracken & Sandison 1917, Whipple "There's a funny thing about women any more," 1924, Lincoln Library 1924, Krapp 1927, and several said author and humorist Peg Bracken, "and that's others. The editors of Webster's Second had all of this that there isn't much funny about women any comment in the early 1930s, but no printed evidence of more." —Bob Curtright, Chicago Tribune, 24 Apr. its use; they assumed it must be an oral use and entered 1977 it with the label Colloq. The adverb seems to be American in origin—Phy- . . . everybody's cool anymore —Bill White, N.Y. thian 1979 assures us that it is both American and Yankees baseball telecast, 26 Mar. 1984 wrong—and probably cropped up sometime around the This usage is dialectal. It has been discovered anew turn of the century. But we did not begin to find it in almost every year since 1931 and has been abundantly print with any frequency until the 1940s: documented. The Dictionary of American Regional U-turn allowed any place except at traffic light — English reports it to be widespread in all dialect areas of American Guide Series: Pennsylvania, 1940 the U.S. except New England. It appears to have been of Midland origin—the states where it is most common . . . the minister never went any place in the house appear to be Kentucky, West Virginia, Indiana, and but the parlor and the diningroom —New Republic, Oklahoma—and has spread considerably to such other 29 July 1940 anytime 107 anywheres . . . doubted whether there would be much sympathy We have no British evidence since 1945. Here are a few in America for fascism any place —Irwin Shaw, Yale adverbial examples: Rev., Summer 1944 . . . have entered the city from a state in the deep . . . if you just quit, you found yourself on a sort of a South anytime within the last month —James B. black list and they wouldn't let you work anyplace Conant, Slums and Suburbs, 1961 else —Edmund Wilson, Memoirs of Hecate County, 1946 If you run short of money . . . feel free to put the bite on me anytime —Leon Uris, Battle Cry, 1953 Although the early objectors give no reason for their . . . I can get a job anywhere anytime —Jack Ker- objections, Evans 1957 and Bernstein 1971 say that the ouac, The Town and The City, 1950 objection is based on the replacement of the adverb where in the compound with the noun place. Bernstein Things won't improve anytime soon —Robert L. points out that place has other adverbial uses and that Simison, Wall Street Jour., 30 May 1980 other nouns, too, have been used with adverbial force. Anyplace seems to have been gaining slightly in fre- quency of use in print since the 1940s, and is long since anyways None of the senses of anyways are standard established as standard. The one-word form has gradu- contemporary English, but you should not conclude that ally replaced the two-word form that was earliest they are substandard, as Copperud 1970 does. When attested. Here is a sample of use from the past four anyways means "anywise," it is archaic: decades: And if the people of the land do any ways hide their eyes — L e v i t i c u s 2 0 : 4 (AV), 1 6 1 1 Italian women dress more elaborately during the Venice season than they do anyplace else any time . . . who have no places, nor are anyways dependent in the year —Janet Flanner, New Yorker, 23 Sept. on the King —Thomas Gray, letter, 24 May 1742 1950 The other uses—"to any degree at all" and "in any Anyplace would be better than these taverns —Rich- case, anyway, anyhow"—are dialectal. The Dictionary ard Bissell, A Stretch on the River, 1950 of American Regional English marks both senses now chiefly South and South Midland, though some of the . . . the worthiest effort in musical scholarship to be earliest evidence for "to any degree at all" is from New produced anyplace in the world —Irving Kolodin, England. A few examples: Saturday Rev., 26 July 1952 Then the trial began, and, as you might expect, it Men could get the call anyplace, but it always hap- didn't look anyways good for the defense —Stephen pened to them when they were alone —St. Clair Vincent Benêt, "The Devil and Daniel Webster," McKelway, New Yorker, 18 May 1957 1937, in American Harvest, ed. Allen Tate & John Peale Bishop, 1942 . . . it was worse in Poland than anyplace else —Wil- liam L. Shirer, The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, "Anyways," said Jackie, "better late than never " 1960 —John Dos Passos, Number One, 1943 He wants us to look at what we can see everyday, . . . I think I will go to New York anyways sometime anyplace, here —Robert Coles, Trans-Action, May next summer —Flannery O'Connor, letter, 25 Jan. 1968 1953 . . . never quite at home anywhere in this world, The "anyway" use exists in some British dialects, too. never quite the citizens of anyplace this side of The OED notes Dickens, and our files contain this: Heaven —Leslie A. Fiedler, Jour, of Modern Liter- ature, 1st issue, 1970 Anyways, it could not be found there —Joseph Con- rad, Youth, 1902 Now there just aren't that many men among us who could go anyplace, never mind to work, after five anywheres Anywheres is an Americanism (not pints —Malcolm S. Forbes, Forbes, 15 Sept. 1970 recorded in the OED or the Supplement) that has been Anyplace north of the Potomac was unthinkable — censured as nonexistent, illiterate, or nonstandard ever William Styron, This Quiet Dust and Other Writ- since MacCracken & Sandison put out their handbook ings, 1982 of language etiquette for Vassar girls in 1917. Subse- quent handbooks treat it much like a social disease. See also EVERYPLACE; NOPLACE; SOMEPLACE. Bryant 1962 believes it to be a receding form; our evi- dence would tend to bear her out, but the Dictionary of American Regional English has evidence as recent as anytime This adverb is generally spelled as one word. 1981. The word is not dead yet. Here are a few samples Johnson 1982 tells us that the one-word spelling is all from our less fastidious past (remember that anywheres right when it can be replaced by the phrase "at any is primarily a speech form and seldom appears in print time" but when it cannot be so replaced, it should be outside of fiction): spelled as two words. Johnson's rule of thumb is a sen- sible one, though occasionally it is not observed: "Anywheres in this country, sir?" —Herman Mel- ville, Pierre, 1852 This is dressing that's fun, never a burden for any- time of day —advt., NY. Times, 28 Apr. 1980 . . . if you are anywheres where it won't do for you to scratch, why you will itch all over in upwards of a Evans 1957 and Phythian 1979 agree anytime is not in thousand places —Mark Twain, Huckleberry Finn, British use—Phythian in fact insists it does not exist. 1884 apart from 108 apostrophe . . . I would rather live in Detroit than anywheres Apathy of audience to all the good things —The else —Ring Lardner, You Know Me Al, 1916 Journals of Arnold Bennett, ed. Frank Swinnerton, 1954 . . . it looked impossible that I'd ever be anywheres else —Joseph C. Lincoln, Galusha the Magnificent, . . . general apathy still prevailed regarding the 1921 potential of conventional agriculture —Rockefeller Foundation: President's Five-Year Rev. & Annual From this beginning, a skilled writer could go most Report, 1968 anywheres —Ring Lardner, Preface, How to Write Short Stories, 1924 apostrophe 1 . The original use of the apostrophe in Now instead of trees we have parking meters on English appears to have been as a mark of elision used Main Street... and very few trees anywheres else — to indicate in writing and printing the omission of a let- John O'Hara, Collier's, 2 Mar. 1956 ter—usually a vowel—that was not pronounced. Ben Jonson's Grammar (1640) lists such examples as these: Anywheres is attested in the U.S. from the late 18th century. It appears to have been originally a New Th' outward man Ify' utter Ifthou'rt England term that spread. is time t' awake A man t' have See also NOWHERES; SOMEWHERES. The plays of Restoration dramatists such as Etherege, apart from Apart from is a fixed two-word preposi- Wycherley, Congreve, and Farquhar abound in such tion in English. Some commentators believe it to be the contractions. A great many of them are still familiar: British equivalent of American aside from, but in fact it she'll, I'll, 'em, can't, 'tis, e'en, e'er, he's, I've, among oth is used on both sides of the Atlantic: ers. And some are no longer familiar: i'fac, 'ygad, to't, in't, an't, on't, i faith, 'zbud, wo't, dar'st, for example. But 'ain't' will always be facetious in British English, (One can't help noticing that the pronoun it was reduced apart from cockney —Anthony Burgess, in Harper to 't in a great many spoken environments.) 1985 In his own writings Ben Jonson frequently used the apostrophe to mark omission of silent e in the -ed end- Apart from being a brother of the Secretary of State ing of verbs. "Timber, or Discoveries" (written before —Atlantic, April 1953 1637) shows borrow'd, deform'd, refus'd, expung'd, ban . . . without necessarily suggesting that it is some- ish'd, squar'd, among others. The convention of spelling thing wholly apart from other written English —W. -ed as -'d when the e was not pronounced was more F. Bolton, A Short History of Literary English, 1967 common in verse than in prose for the purpose of emphasizing scansion. It seems, however, to have Apart from that, the British and U.S. viewpoints become more frequent in prose during the early 18th coalesce —William O. Douglas, Center Mag., March century. In Defoe, for instance, can be found many an 1969 arriv'd and order'd The practice provoked some curious remarks by Swift and Addison in the Tatler and Spec- . . . very much as before apart from some mildly tator objecting to the practice. It is not overly clear gloomy talk —Times Literary Supp., 2 Oct. 1970 today what their objection was. Here, for instance, is Apart from ceremonial performances of Handel's Addison in The Spectator, No. 135 (4 Aug. 1711): "Messiah," we are in the Christmas doldrums — Winthrop Sargeant, New Yorker, 1 Jan. 1972 . . . by closing in one Syllable the Termination of our Praeterperfect Tense, as in the Words drown'd, See also ASIDE FROM. walk'd, arriv'd, for drowned, walked, arrived, wh has very much disfigured the Tongue, and turn'd a apathy Apathy is not very frequently used in a con- tenth part of our smoothest Words into so many text in which a preposition connects it to its object. Clusters of Consonants. When it is, toward and towards are most common. Addison seems to be writing about speech, but his own Individuals maintained their sanity by developing inconsistency is curious; not only do we have turn'd in an apathy toward their experiences —George Robert the same sentence in which he decries the practice, he Carlsen, English Jour., March 1949 has earlier used observ'd, us'd, and deriv'd. It is hard to tell what he is driving at. At any rate, the convention of . . . the American apathy toward the struggles of marking the unpronounced e of the -ed ending by an colonial peoples —New Republic, 28 Mar. 1955 apostrophe gradually died out. Their apathy toward course designing borders on Also gone are such early 18th-century apostrophized ignorance —William Oscar Johnson, Sports Illus- spellings as Defoe's cou 'd, shou 'd, wou d—showing that trated, 15 July 1968 the / was not pronounced. Cou 'd is a most curious case; Strang 1970 notes that "the native word coud was . . . apathy towards the Hindu-Moslem question — altered to could on the model of should, would. " Defoe's Manchester Guardian Weekly, 21 May 1937 apostrophe thus indicates the omission of a letter that didn't belong there in the first place. Strang also notes About, to, and regarding are also in use: the occasional use of the apostrophe to mark imaginary . . . a general apathy about this whole business of omissions, for instance has, as if it were contracted reading —Mortimer J. Adler, How to Read a Book, from haves. 1940 The chief modern uses of the apostrophe are about the same as those of the late 17th century, with certain . . . professional and public apathy about Australian old conventions having been discarded. We still use the drama —Leslie Rees, Towards an Australian apostrophe to show contractions (didn't, I'll) and to Drama, 1953 mark features of speech (singin ', N'Orleans). In addi- apostrophe 109 apostrophe tion, the apostrophe is used to mark the omission of Today all these pronouns are regularly written without numerals: the apostrophe: hers, ours, yours, theirs, its. 5. Simon 1980 speaks of " . . . the Great Apostrophe class o f 8 politics during the '60s Plague: the newfangled insertion of apostrophes in ordi- Some words or their variants are consistently spelled nary plurals." It can be pointed out that Joseph Addison with apostrophes: in The Spectator, 4 Aug. 1 7 1 1 , pluralized Genius into Genius's, but it is far from certain what Addison meant fo'c'sle bos'n rock 'n' roll by his apostrophe. It marks the omission of e, but in Addison's time such an omission usually meant that the 2. The apostrophe is used to mark the possessive case of syncopated syllable was not pronounced; perhaps Addi- nouns and indefinite pronouns. The Grammar of son pronounced the plural of genius the same way as he Joseph Priestley (rev. éd., 1798) contains the basic mod- did the singular. ern system: The phenomenon is not as recent as many writers The GENITIVE case is that which denotes property or think, but older evidence is scarce. Robert Baker in 1770 possession; and is formed by adding (s) with an apos- censured the use in his time of 's after nouns ending in trophe before it to the nominative; as Solomon's vowels (as idea's, opera's, virtuoso's) and -s (as the Wisdom; The Men's wit; Venus's beauty; or the apos- Genius's of Addison). But we do not have enough evi- trophe only in the plural number, when the nomi- dence to assume with confidence that this late 18th-cen- native ends in (s) as the Stationers' arms. tury practice has led to the present one. At any rate it has certainly become more noticed in recent years by Current usage deviates very little from the general sys- writers of English texts and writers on usage. Bernstein tem described by Priestley. The chief variation in cur- 1977, Simon 1980, Harper 1975, 1985, and Janis 1984 rent use is in the case of nouns ending in an \ s \ or \ z \ all notice 's plurals in the U.S.; Howard 1984 and Long- sound, such as audience, waitress, index. Even with man 1984 note them in Britain. No one has an expla- these -'s is usual: audience's, waitress's, index's. Some nation for the practice, but it is widely assumed to be writers prefer the apostrophe alone, especially if the practiced chiefly by the less well educated—handwritten word is followed immediately by a word beginning with signs offering "Fresh Strawberry's" or "Auto Repair's" the same sound: for convenience' sake (see SAKE). are often cited. Such plurals also turn up in handwritten For other questions relating to the use of the posses- letters sent to this office: " . . . these type of dictio- sive, see GENITIVE. nary's." Bernstein and Janis mention their appearing in 3. The apostrophe is sometimes used with -s to form the ads; several such have been noticed here too: plural of letters, numerals, abbreviations, symbols, and words used as words. . . . the finest Tibetan Mastiffs —Dog World, May Letters are usually pluralized with - 's 1984 The floating mover judge's look for —Chronicle of mind your p's and q's the Horse, 25 May 1984 although capital letters are sometimes pluralized with Apostrophized plurals also turn up in other text: -s alone. The use of - 's to form the plurals of numerals, abbre- . . . by using he to refer to all people, she's and he's viations and symbols is not now as common as plural- alike —Carol Tavris, Vogue, June 1984 ization with simple -s; 1970s, CPUs, &s are more likely to be found than their apostrophized counterparts. A The buyback's included Texaco's purchase —N.Y. dissent can be found in Safire 1980; he prefers 1980's, Times, 13 June 1984 andtheSO'stothe '80s. I thought we kept the weirdo's locked up —"Brock" Words used as words—such as might be given as cartoon, Morning Union (Springfield, Mass.), 25 July examples from a text: too many howsoever's—are usu- 1984 ally pluralized with -'s. But words representing sounds or words used as words in common phrases are plural- No apostrophe is necessary or wanted in any of the ized with -s alone: above examples. 6. Words formed from abnormal elements, such as the oohs and aahs of the crowd numerals, abbreviations, and the like, are often pro- the whys and wherefores of the issue vided with an apostrophe before the addition of a suffix: Theodore Bernstein's Dos, Don'ts & Maybes of OD'd on heroin English Usage 86'd our party 4. Her's, our's, your's, their's. Lowth 1762 notes that 4-H'ers these pronouns "have evidently the form of the posses- 7. If you need any further evidence that the apostrophe sive case"; Baker 1770 likewise spells them with the has not been universally understood, a correspondent of apostrophe. But even then usage was mixed: Lowth on Simon's sent in as an example a sign reading "Larr'y 66 the preceding page in his paradigm spells all of them Service." To this gem we can add only without the apostrophe, even its. Priestley 1798 spells them without the apostrophe but later comments, T'was not always so —Southwest Art, May 1984 "Sometimes these possessives have an apostrophe Commenting on the apostrophe, Robert Burchfield, edi- before the s, when they are found without their substan- tor of the newest OED Supplement, has said: tives, which gives them more the appearance of a geni- tive case." He gives as an example "That you may call The apostrophe was only a moderately successful her your's" from a novel. Jonathan Swift writes "better device, and it is probably coming to the end of its to be in your hands than her's" in his Journal to Stella usefulness, certainly for forming plurals and marking (21 Nov. 1710). Priestley regularly spells it's with the possession. It may only be retained for contractions apostrophe, as does Jane Austen later (see ITS, IT'S). —quoted in Boston Sunday Globe, 12 May 1985 apparently 110 apportion apparently, evidently Entries in Kilpatrick 1984 append Append regularly takes to: and Bremner 1980 at the adjective apparent express concern about the contradictory senses of the word and ... failed to append the sticker to the windshield — about the problem of distinguishing it from evident. Springfield (Mass.) Republican, 3 Jan. 1954 These problems are, as a matter of fact, fully treated in T h i s e n t i t l e s h i m t o a p p e n d t h e letters " S . C . " . . . t o good desk dictionaries and synonymy books. But Kil- his name —Current Biography 1950 patrick's underlying concern seems really to be with the adverbs, and here, at least in the case of apparently, dic- To this is appended a calendar —Benjamin Farring- tionary treatment tends to be less than full, dictionary ton, Greek Science, 1953 editors having the habit of tucking -ly adverb deriva- tives at the end of adjective entries without definitions . . . stories, orderly set down, with the objection in order to conserve space. appended to each story —Charles Lamb, Essays of A. S. Hill 1895 distinguishes between apparently and Elia, 1823 evidently in this way: Apparently is properly used of that which seems, but appendix A generous number of commentators, but- tressed by the evidence in various dictionaries, assure us may not be, real; evidently, of that which both seems that both appendixes and appendices are standard and and is real. acceptable plurals for appendix. A couple of British Hill's observation is still essentially right. Evidently books find appendices more common in the U.K., and regularly suggests that there is some overt reason for a few American ones find appendixes more common in drawing an inference: the U.S. The Merriam-Webster files do not lack evi- dence in this matter, and we believe that both plurals It evidently didn't want to share its ocean with us, may be found with almost equal frequency on both sides because it hauled off for about a hundred yards — of the Atlantic. A correspondent in 1977 informed us Patrick Ellam, "The Dangerous Deep," in Networks, that in the U.K. appendixes is preferred in medical con- ed. Marjorie Seddon Johnson et al., 1977 texts; appendices in publishing contexts. Our evidence gives the lie to the second half of the assertion, but we . . . went off, evidently satisfied that he had upheld cannot prove or disprove the medical contention. We private-property rights —Roy Bongartz, N Y. Times have evidence for both plurals in American medical Mag., 13 July 1975 contexts. As for publishing contexts: His father was evidently a man of means, for in 1782 he presented his son with a farm of 220 acres —Dic- . . . 100 pages of exceedingly miscellaneous appen- tionary of American Biography, 1929 dixes —N. Y. Times Book Rev., 5 Aug. 1984 Apparently is used as a disclaimer, as if the author were The appendixes are particularly valuable —Times telling us, "This is what it seems to be, but I won't Literary Supp., 21 May 1982 vouch for it." . . . 30 pages of appendices —N. Y. Times Book Rev., There is a difference, apparently, between the aims 9 Aug. 1981 of Leningrad and Moscow —John Tebbel, Saturday . . . study of the appendices to the working timetables Rev., 8 Jan. 1972 —Times Literary Supp., 15 July 1983 . . . beginning and then putting aside several manu- Take your pick. scripts, apparently dissatisfied with all of them — Irving Howe, Harper's, October 1970 apportion The verb apportion may idiomatically take There was apparently no investigation into the the prepositions among, to, and between when a com- child's welfare and the mother's fitness —Eileen plementary prepositional phrase is required. Hughes, Ladies' Home Jour., September 1971 Among has a certain cachet in writings on American The explanation for this apparently abject sell-out — government because of its use in the U.S. Constitution: Times Literary Supp., 26 Mar. 1970 Representatives and direct taxes shall be appor- . . . gives an artistic effect apparently closer to a pos- tioned among the several States —Article I, Section sible original than the scenes from Dante —T. S. 2 Eliot, "Tradition and the Individual Talent," 1917, in American Harvest, ed. Allen Tate & John Peale . . . apportion the expenses among the member states Bishop, 1942 —Frank Abbott Magruder, National Governments and International Relations, 1950 Evidently is sometimes used in contexts where appar- It is left to the reader to apportion compassion . . . ently could also be used: among those who suffer in the novel —Frances Mr. Dahl evidently believes that others will in the Gaither, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 2 May 1954 long run follow the same course, even where recent To is about as frequent as among, between somewhat history reads as a record of backsliding —Times Lit- less frequent: erary Supp., 30 July 1971 . . . the roles are apportioned rather to episodes than Still, it always connotes some evidence in corrobora- to character —Richard Ellmann, Times Literary tion; apparently may connote that, if there is evidence, Supp., 21 May 1971 it does not necessarily corroborate. Our evidence and that in Kucera & Francis 1967 . . . the apportioning to each producer his share in show apparently to be much more frequently used than goods and services —Kennard E. Goodman & Wil- is evidently. liam L. Moore, Today's Economics, 1960 appositive genitive 111 appositives Nietzsche . . . urges that the law should apportion In weak apposition, they are from different syntactic special privileges to a cultural elite —Arthur Pap, classes: Elements of Analytic Philosophy, 1949 Her choice of a career, reporting the news, has But he will be a brave man who will apportion brought her great happiness. responsibility for Britain's attitude between parties and classes —Roy Lewis & Angus Maude, The Here we have a noun phrase in apposition with a gerund English Middle Classes, 1950 phrase (or "-ing-clause" in Quirk's terminology); they are members of different syntactic classes. . . . difficult to apportion the responsibility between Then Quirk discusses restrictive and nonrestrictive the two —Joseph Conrad, reprinted in Correct apposition. In nonrestrictive apposition (our examples English, April 1939 so far are all nonrestrictive) the appositives are in dif- . . . to apportion the judicial power between the ferent units of information which in speech are signaled supreme and inferior courts —John Marshall, Mar- by different stress and intonation and often a pause, and bury v. Madison, 1803 in writing are signaled by punctuation—usually com- mas. The two nonrestrictive appositive units contribute relatively independent information, with the first unit appositive genitive See GENITIVE 1. usually acting as the defined expression and the second as the defining expression. Because the appositives are distinctly separate units, the defining and defined roles appositives Since Copperud 1970, 1980, Janis 1984, can be switched by merely reversing their order: and Safire (N. Y. Times Mag., 16 Feb. 1986) (along with many handbooks) are at some pains to distinguish Sally Williams, the coach of the visiting team, pre- restrictive and nonrestrictive appositives for purposes dicted victory. of punctuation and they connect the distinction with somewhat dubious inferences about meaning, it may be The coach of the visiting team, Sally Williams, pre- helpful if we say something here about the behavior of dicted victory. appositives. These comments are based on Quirk et al. In restrictive apposition the two units are not separated 1985, wherein the subject is dealt with in considerable in speech or by punctuation in writing: detail and with admirable clarity. An appositive is defined in school grammar books as I wish I could shimmy like my sister Kate. . . . a noun or pronoun—often with modifiers—set Of course, these characteristics can be combined in var- beside another noun or pronoun to explain or iden- ious ways. Here, for instance, we have partial, strict, tify it —Warriner's English Grammar and Compo- nonrestrictive apposition: sition, Complete Course, 1986 Mr. Holohan, assistant secretary of the Eire Abu Quirk distinguishes three sets of characteristics of Society, had been walking up and down Dublin for appositives. First, there is full and partial apposition. In nearly a month —James Joyce, Dubliners, 1914 full apposition, either of the nouns can be omitted from the sentence, and what remains will still be an accept- Quirk has many more examples and much more detail. able English sentence. In the resultant sentence, each One thing Quirk does not mention is the rule-of- noun will have the same grammatical function, such as thumb inference that Copperud, Safire, and Janis the subject or direct object. In addition, the sentences expound upon about the number of items in the class to made by omitting one or other of the nouns will have which the appositives refer based on the restrictive or the same meaning in the real world—"in extralinguis- nonrestrictive status of the appositives. Their theory is tic reference," to use Quirk's term. Thus, in this sen- that a nonrestrictive appositive signals but a single one tence of the items in the extralinguistic world, while a restric- tive appositive means that one out of a group of more A cousin of mine, Leonard Davis, has been elected than one in the extralinguistic world is being identified. to Congress. Thus, "His wife, Helen, attended the ceremony" would mean but one wife, and "He sent his daughter Cicely to we can omit either noun college" would suggest more than one daughter. The inference will be valid in most cases but can be untrust- A cousin of mine has been elected to Congress. worthy if drawn too casually. From "Springfield, a city Leonard Davis has been elected to Congress. in Massachusetts, . . . " no reasonable inference about the number of Springfields is possible, though the appos- and still have acceptable English sentences with the itive is plainly nonrestrictive. The particular Springfield remaining noun as subject. And the nouns are corefer- has either been identified in earlier context or isolated ential—they both stand for Leonard Davis, the new in the writer's mind. And then we have this nonrestric- congressman, in the extralinguistic world. Appositives tive example: that do not meet all three criteria are said to be in partial apposition. He sent the older daughter, Kathleen, to a good con- Quirk next notes strict and weak apposition. In strict vent —James Joyce, Dubliners, 1914 apposition the appositives belong to the same syntactic class: Older signals two daughters, in spite of the nonrestric- tive appositive. If it is argued that there is but one older Journalism, her choice of a career, has brought her daughter, we will concede that to be most likely. Still, great happiness. we have no trouble in conceiving of a context where two older daughters are being contrasted with a younger one, In the example sentence, both journalism and her choice and in that context the appositive in Joyce's sentence of a career fall into the class of noun phrases. would suddenly become restrictive and need to lose its appraise 112 approve commas. Quirk says only that "restrictiveness . . . indi- More frequently the preposition links apprehensive to a cates a limitation on the possible reference of the head"; usually impersonal cause of concern. In such cases, a no numbers are given. It seems safest to identify restric- selection of prepositions is available. Of is the most tive and nonrestrictive appositives as Quirk does, by common: informational relationship and by differing rhythm, stress, and tone. . . . whole troops of hungry and affrighted provin- cials, less apprehensive of servitude than of famine appraise, apprise No fewer than ten sources warn us —Edward Gibbon, The Decline and Fall of the against using appraise for apprise. The examples given Roman Empire, 1788 suggest that the confusion occurs chiefly in speech; our . . . no sooner would they stow themselves away . . . files yield but a single example of the mistake in print: than they would rush out again, as if apprehensive of . . . had not properly appraised herself of Mrs. Mac- some approaching danger —John Burroughs, Wake- duffs nature —Rex Ingamells, Of Us Now Living, Robin, 1871 1952 The violence of his temper and his reputation for Even if you did not know the difference in meaning cruelty had made the City apprehensive of what between these two words, you could tell them apart by would happen if he succeeded his father —Robert their typical constructions. Apprise, which means "give Graves, /, Claudius, 1934 notice to," usually occurs in the construction apprise . . . made a great many people apprehensive of aggre- one of: gations of more than one or two birds —Deborah ... Hitler . . . had not bothered to apprise them of Howard, Massachusetts Audubon Newsletter, his thoughts —William L. Shirer, The Rise and Fall December 1970 ofthe Third Reich, 1960 About is also quite common: . . . had kept him apprised of the high regard in which he is held —Hollis Alpert, in The Film, 1968 "Then she didn't seem apprehensive about what might happen here while she was away?" — S. S. Sometimes the of phrase is replaced by a that clause: Van Dine, The Greene Murder Case, 1927 . . . in a guarded way which apprised him that she The child with an infection ofthe bone will probably had been in touch with Renata —Marcia Davenport, refuse to have the arm or leg examined and will be My Brother's Keeper, 1954 apprehensive about having it touched —Morris Fishbein, The Popular Medical Encyclopedia, 1946 Appraise, which means "evaluate," is used in neither of those constructions. The object of appraise is usually He was apprehensive about the increase of China's inanimate or abstract: influence inside the Communist world —Norman Cousins, Saturday Rev., 30 Oct. 1971 . . . made it difficult for friends and foes alike to appraise his performance —Ronald P. Kriss, Satur- Regarding is sometimes chosen: day Rev., 11 Mar. 1972 . . . were outspokenly apprehensive regarding its full Less often the object is a person: significance—Collier's Year Book, 1949 John was conscious that Jabez Winkleman had been . . . was perhaps apprehensive regarding the ultimate studying him with shrewd eyes, appraising him — effect in Japan —Rodger Swearingen, Current His- Clarence Budington Kelland, Saturday Evening tory, July 1952 Post, 25 Dec. 1954 There is a verb apprize which means "appraise, Sometimes a clause will be used instead of a phrase: value." It is quite rare. As I stood aside to let that carriage pass, apprehen- sive that it might otherwise run me down —Charles appreciate Ever since Ayres 1881 various critics have Dickens,^ Tale of Two Cities, 1859 felt it necessary to find fault with one sense or another of appreciate. Not infrequently one critic approves the . . . apprehensive lest this evacuation inspire the very sense another disparages. Bierce 1909 and Vizetelly extreme Left to become even bolder —Collier's Year 1906, for instance, specifically approve a meaning that Book, 1949 Ayres disapproves: "to increase in value." Bernstein 1971 approves "be grateful" while Evans 1957 dislikes apprise See APPRAISE, APPRISE. it. Bierce and Follett 1966 set up a primary sense and decry the decay of the word from it. Other commenta- tors have various other points to make. One century of approve 1 . When used as an intransitive verb with criticism has produced no clear, consistent, and legiti- the meaning "to take a favorable view," approve takes mate concern. Reader's Digest 1983 lists the senses the preposition of: found in most dictionaries and declares them all accept- able. So they are. Trust your dictionary. ... she doesn't approve of fighting —Margaret Mead, And Keep Your Powder Dry, 1942 apprehensive When the object of concern is a per- . . . does not mean that it favors it or even always son, apprehensive takes for: approves of it —Roger Angell, Holiday, November Watching these contests, I could not help feeling 1953 apprehensive for Fitzgerald, whose physical condi- The New York critics generally approved ofthe way tion was precarious at best —Andrew W. Turnbull, she handled the part —Current Biography, June New Yorker, 7 Apr. 1956 1964 approximate 113 approximation When used as a transitive verb—usually in the sense of . . . a rational number which is approximately equal "to sanction officially"—it can take by to indicate the to the given irrational number —Edwina Deans et agent of approval: al., Extending Mathematics, 2d éd., 1968 . . . magic hath been publicly professed in former . . . along a corridor approximately 200 miles long — times, . . . maintained and excused, and so far Times Literary Supp., 14 Nov. 1968 approved by some princes —Robert Burton, The A few examples without numbers: Anatomy of Melancholy, 1621 . . . a quadrangle running approximately east and . . . the plan must be approved by state legislators — west —Johns Hopkins Mag., April 1966 Peter Janssen, Saturday Rev., 5 Feb. 1972 . . . have approximately the same feeling for it that 2. Foster 1968 discusses a British concern of the earlier the Black Panthers have for the Urban League — 20th century to restrict the transitive verb to the "official John Corry, Harper's, October 1970 sanction" sense, and the "favorable view" sense to the intransitive. The transitive verb, however, had been in . . . pills which never had a taste but whose brand use in the "favorable view" sense earlier than in the names are approximately remembered —Anthony "official sanction" sense, so it is not surprising that the Burgess, N.Y. Times Mag., 4 Dec. 1977 urged distinction failed to make much headway. These These uses are typical, and to judge from them there examples provide some evidence of its failure: seems to be no very strong reason to avoid Jane secretly approved his discernment —Rose approximately. Macaulay, Potterism, 1920 approximation Follett 1966 says that approximate . . . a friend, whom he liked, but whose conduct he (presumably the verb) takes no preposition (see APPROX- could not approve —Osbert Sitwell, Noble Essences, IMATE, where its use with to is illustrated) and that 1950 approximation takes to. This latter statement is partly true, but will not fully bear comparison with actual Along with George Orwell, whom he never knew and usage. did not always approve, Lewis now looks like the fin- In mathematics we find approximation used with to, est British polemicist of the mid-century —George of, and for: Watson, Times Literary Supp., 24 Sept. 1982 ... successively better approximations to L — School Mathematics Study Group, Calculus, Part I, approximate As an intransitive verb, approximate 1965 can take to: To get a better approximation of the mathematical The desire to approximate to a certain pattern has idea of a point —School Mathematics Study Group, been evoked in him from without —Van Wyck Geometry, Parti, 1965 Brooks, in A Century of the Essay, ed. David Daiches, 1951 . . . rational approximations for irrational numbers —Chuan C. Feng et al., A Course in Algebra and . . . the result approximates more to fantasy than to Trigonometry with Computer Programming, 1969 science fiction —John Christopher, The Writer, November 1968 In other contexts we find both to and of, with more recent nontechnical writing favoring of: A study of medieval delinquency that rests princi- pally on gaol delivery records can only approximate ... the second approximation to the vertical pres- to veracity —R. B. Pugh, Times Literary Supp., 15 sure gradient —E. V. Laitone, Bulletin of the Amer- Feb. 1980 ican Physical Society, 2 Sept. 1965 . . . its guying of upper class English must have . . . a first approximation to the data which would be approximated to the real thing —Howard 1984 thus obtained —James B. Conant, Slums and Sub- urbs, 1961 approximately The view of approximately originat- . . . an extremely simple mechanism requiring only ing in Flesch 1964 and Follett 1966, reported in Cop- an approximation to accuracy —Roger Burlingame, perud 1970 and seconded by Nickles 1974, is that this Backgrounds of Power, 1949 adverb should be replaced by about or nearly or almost . . . a close approximation of reality —Ralph Linton, when it can be. These opinions appear to have been The Cultural Background of Personality, 1945 issued with little regard for how the word is actually used. It is in frequent use but is found most often in . . . a terrifyingly close approximation of her own sit- such contexts as corporate annual reports, technical uation —Richard Poirier, A World Elsewhere, 1966 works, and reference works. Our evidence shows it also appears in general prose of a serious cast but almost . . . in which the common language will be English, never in casual or informal contexts, where such substi- or some approximation of it —Herbert A. Simon, tutions as those suggested would be particularly suit- Think, May-June 1967 able. Its most common single application in our files is . . . the early accounts and estimates . . . are often to numerical quantities. Some examples of typical use: cruelly inadequate approximations of the historic truth —Max Lerner, Saturday Rev., 29 May 1976 Humble's share o f . . . reserves of crude oil and nat- ural gas liquids currently is estimated to be approx- . . . every effort should be made to achieve the closest imately 2 billion barrels —Annual Report, Standard approximation of it that is possible —Robert M. Oil Co. (New Jersey), 1970 Hutchins, Center Mag., January 1968 apropos 114 archive apropos, apropos of, apropos to Apropos is a word than Science Citation Index source documents —C. taken into English from the French phrase à propos in R. Sage, American Documentation, October 1966 the second half of the 17th century. It has functioned variously as an adjective, adverb, noun, and preposi- Mudrick quotes a fan letter apropos of the Life, and tion. No one would have given it a second thought, per- apropos to his argument —D. J. Enright, Times Lit- haps, had not Fowler 1926 written erary Supp., January 1980 apropos is so clearly marked by its pronunciation as The combination is also used, though less often, as a French, & the French construction is, owing to à pro- preposition equivalent to apropos of: pos de bottes, so familiar, that it is better always to use of rather than to after it. . . . . . . it was, I think, apropos to some zoological dis- cussion —John Gibson Lockhart, Memoirs of the Fowler gives no further elucidation, but presumably he Life of Sir Walter Scott, 1838 felt ofio be better because it translates the French de of the longer phrase. At any rate, such later commentators Apropos to this, you ask me what my plans are — as Copperud 1970, 1980 and Bernstein 1965 take Fow- Henry Adams, letter, 3 Nov. 1858 ler's recommendation to be a virtual commandment to . . . the excellent and uplifted of all lands would write use of and not to use to. me, apropos to each new piece of broad-minded folly Apropos of functions in English as a compound prep- —Rudyard Kipling, excerpt from his Autobiography, osition; it has been functioning as a compound prepo- reprinted in N. Y. Times, 10 Feb. 1937 sition in English since the middle of the 18th century. Some dictionaries—for instance, Webster's Ninth New As prepositions, apropos o/and apropos are usual. Apro- Collegiate—recognize it as such. Some examples follow: pos to is in occasional use; it is rare but not wrong. . . . tell you a story apropos of two noble instances of fidelity and generosity —Horace Walpole, letter, apt See LIABLE 2. 1750 (in Stanford Dictionary of Anglicised Words and Phrases, 1892) Arab See ETHNIC DESIGNATIONS: PRONUNCIATION. It was such an odd expression, coming apropos of nothing, that it quite startled me —Bram Stoker, archive, archives The singular and plural forms of Dracula, 1897 archive have existed side by side since the word first came into the language in the 17th century. Montgom- . . . apropos of the election of 1900, when McKinley ery & Stratton 1981 assures us that "an archives" is pre- ran against Bryan —Edmund Wilson, New Yorker, ferred by archivists. We cannot confirm or deny that 20 Oct. 1951 statement, but our evidence does show greater use of the plural than the singular in the names of institutions. For Apropos of the Congressional vote to terminate instance: action in Cambodia . . . he writes —Barbara W. Tuchman, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 11 Nov. 1979 From 1954 the National Archives has carried out training programmes for its serving archivists — Early in the 20th century it began to be used without Library Science Abstracts (London), 1956 of as a preposition having the same meaning: An act to establish a National Archives of the United . . . remarked the other day, apropos the formal end- States Government— U.S. Code, 1948 ing of the censorship —Dorothy Thompson, Satur- day Rev., 20 May 1939 In unofficial use, however, the plural archives more often than not is used with a plural verb: One of Oscar Wilde's characters made, apropos another character, the famous remark, "He always . . . until the Russian archives are opened —Times behaves like a gentleman—a thing no gentleman Literary Supp., 14 Nov. 1968 ever does" —Joseph Wood Krutch, Saturday Rev., 30 Jan. 1954 The archives contain some of Jefferson's correspon- dence—American Guide Series: Virginia, 1941 "The subject is unpleasant to dwell on," he writes primly, apropos the "life-denying nihilism" in Con- The archives in the European capitals were searched rad's "Heart of Darkness" —Dwight Macdonald, —Van Wyck Brooks, The Flowering of New New Yorker, 13 Oct. 1956 England, 1815-1865, rev. éd., 1946 A propos the exclusively female consciousness — At the time the section of the OED containing archive John Bayley, Times Literary Supp., 22 Aug. 1980 was published (1885), the plural form had taken over in the sense of "a place housing documents," and prepon- The use of to with apropos is not so much wrong derated in the sense of "a collection of documents." In (even Fowler did not call it wrong) as rare. The combi- more recent usage, however, the pendulum has begun to nation is used in two ways. First, we find to used when swing back, and the singular use is now about as com- apropos is a predicate adjective meaning "appropriate": mon as the plural in both senses: . . . the remark was particularly apropos to the large He has had access to the whole of Lady Astor's wisdom of the stranger's tone and air —Nathaniel archive, including her draft of an autobiography — Hawthorne, American Notebooks, 1838 (in Stanford British Book News, December 1972 Dictionary of Anglicised Words and Phrases, 1892) Miss Carroll's reconverted farmhouse has become This indicates that Nuclear Science Abstracts source something of a Steinian archive —Michiko Kaku- documents are more apropos to this particular group tani, NY. Times, 1 Aug. 1979 area 115 aren't I Both singular and plural are in figurative use: The confrontation model pervades every area of international politics —Richard Barnet, Harper's, . . . memorizing practically every line, thus making November 1971 herself a living archive —Hedrick Smith, Saturday Rev., 24 Jan. 1976 . . . TV news is another area in which being female is But we must have more than an intellectual desire, somewhat analogous to being black —Harvey Aron- filed away in the archives of idea —Charles A. Lind- son, Cosmopolitan, April 1973 bergh, Saturday Rev., 27 Feb. 1954 . . . the unusually large number of salable titles this year—most of them in the fantasy area —Richard R. area Copperud 1970, 1980 reports a few members of Lingeman, TV. Y. Times Book Rev., 11 Dec. 1977 his consensus as objecting in a rather general way to area used as a vague or faddish term in place of field, Any form, insofar as we can name it . . . associates problem, issue, or question—themselves no great shakes itself with an area of thought —Donald Hall, Goat- in respect to specific application. Copperud's critics are foot Milktongue Twinbird, 1978 echoed by Nickles 1974 and Janis 1984. The objection to vagueness is not compelling—you The spread, and perhaps the increasing frequency, of use area (or field or problem, etc.) in a vague and impre- use has contributed to the establishment of two phrases cise way when you do not want a more precise term, or in which area figures: "in the area of X" and "in the X when there is no such term. The vagueness is not inad- area." Janis takes note of "in the area of—he terms it vertent. The extension of area from spatial reference to informal for about. His example relates to money; we a more figurative sense is neither illogical nor far- likewise have evidence for this use from business fetched. It is hard, therefore, to find any sound basis for contexts: objection. Sylvania earns in the area of 15% pretax - -Forbes, 1 What probably brought forth the complaint was the Dec. 1970 relatively recent and apparently sudden onset of the usage (the sudden popularity of an expression or con- In other contexts the meaning of the phrase comes struction always seems to excite negative comment—for closer to "with respect to": some examples see ARGUABLY; AS; HOPEFULLY; LIKE, AS, AS IF; SPLIT INFINITIVE). Most of our evidence for this fig- In the area of plotters, Hewlett-Packard, Tektronix, urative extension of area comes after World War II. In or Houston Instruments can sell you . . . —Eric Tei- addition, much of the early evidence comes from edu- cholz, Datamation, 4 Mar. 1980 cation—a discipline frequently reproved for its use of In the area of international relations he has upheld jargon—and some from law, similarly the object of military assistance —Current Biography, January reproof. Here are a few typical examples from our early 1966 evidence: In the areas of race relations, student protesters and . . . one course in each of the three Areas: Natural anti-war protesters . . . he has the approval o f . . . — Sciences (including Mathematics); Social Studies; Peter Steinfels, Commonweal, 9 Oct. 1970 and Arts, Letters and Philosophy —Official Register of Harvard University, 1947 "In the X area" has a similar financial application: The work in the Area of the Holy Scriptures is coor- Most of the disbursements have been in the $1000 dinated to present the study of the Bible as an essen- area —Jay Merritt, Rolling Stone, 12 June 1980 tial unity —San Francisco Theological Seminary, 1948 Catalog It also has some vogue among those who speak for pub- lic officials, when they are interviewed on radio or tele- ... the appointment of principal bibliographers in vision and wish to avoid, for whatever reason, being too the areas of the humanities and the social sciences specific: —Current Biography 1947 . . . shot in the stomach a r e a . . . the knee area . . . the . . . all measures affecting a particular area of the law chest area —Springfield, Mass., police spokesman, —Charles J. Zinn, "How Our Laws Are Made," in television news, 13 Aug. 1984 U.S. Code, 1952 Extension to more general areas (or fields or realms or Even this intentional vagueness can be put to use by a domains), though not well attested in our files, came clever writer: fairly early: . . . she insisted that Bond's do something about the You have limited the area of illusion and you have voluminous excesses of the pants, which in the seat set conditions which the novelist must meet —Ber- area could have accommodated both me and a nard De Voto, The World of Fiction, 1950 watermelon —Russell Baker, Growing Up, 1982 When we move to more recent evidence, we find a All of the uses of area illustrated here are in fact from considerable spread in application and the addition of standard English, and a few are even from literary another specific locus of frequent use—annual reports English. You need not be afraid of using a vague word of corporations. Some examples of the spread: when a vague word is what you need. . . . the Company's development in the area of con- sumer products and services —Thomas E. Hanigan, aren't I Aren't I has been a bugbear of American Jr., in Annual Report, W. R. Grace & Co., 1970 commentators since about the beginning of the 20th century. Frank H. Vizetelly in his many guises is one of . . . one of those statements that fall within the twi- the earliest. In Mend Your Speech (1920) he terms it light area of being neither right nor wrong —Times erroneous, and in the Literary Digest (5 June 1926) a Literary Supp., 22 Jan. 1970 solecism; in the same magazine in February 1927 he argot 116 arguably says, "It is to be hoped that American editors will curb arguably You will notice as you browse around in this undesirable alien. It has no authoritative standing this book that the sudden—or seemingly sudden—pop- anywhere, not even in England, and its usage is marked ularity of an expression or construction will almost evidence of illiteracy." Strong words. What occasioned invariably attract the negative comment of people con- such vehemence? cerned with usage. The split infinitive and the adverb It is a widely noted phenomenon of modern English hopefully are two well-documented cases. Arguably is that there is no satisfactory filler for the blank in sen- another such. The British seem to have been first to dis- tences like this: "I'm a little late, I?" Perhaps the cover it: Howard 1977 calls it "modish" and "grossly most logical filler, ain't, has been cried down success- overused"; Phythian 1979 calls it "fashionable and fully by the pedagogues (see AIN'T), leaving only amn 't, unnecessary." Longman 1984 also notes some objection a'n't or an't, and aren't. Now, strange as it may seem, to it and to its base adjective arguable. On the American these three boil down to the same thing. Amn't, which side, William Safire commented on it in his newspaper Gowers in Fowler 1965 says is still in use in Scottish and column in 1983 and James J. Kilpatrick in 1985. Now Irish English, in Southern English speech loses the that it has been noticed, it may reasonably be supposed sound of the m and becomes a'n't, or an't, which are that other commentators will take up the cudgels against attested in print from the late 17th century. Aren't is a it. fairly recent contraction; we have little evidence of its Both arguable and arguably are of relatively recent existence before the 20th century. (We do have a vintage, even though arguable turned up as a gloss on a Boswellian transcription "I ar'n't" from the speech of "a French word in a glossary of 1611. Contextual citations poor boy from the country" in 1775, but it probably is do not appear until 1860 for arguable and 1890 for argu- only Boswell's way of transcribing the sound other writ- ably. Our evidence shows occasional use of the adjective ers spelled an't or a'n't.) In Southern English speech it during the first half of the 20th century, and very little is pronounced the same, or nearly the same, as an't. of the adverb. Usage of both begins to pick up notice- Thus the same spoken word could be realized in writing ably in the 1960s. An editorial in the Boston Globe in by either an't or aren't. For reasons that we do not late 1984 notes the increasing frequency with which argu- understand, the spelling aren't began to replace an't in ably has been appearing in that newspaper. And our aren't I in British drama and fiction early in this cen- most recent evidence—from the past 10 years or so— tury. This aren 't I, then, is a curious hybrid: its meaning shows the adverb beginning to outstrip the adjective. comes from am and its spelling from are. Safire 1986 contains a discussion of the arguably Aren't I on paper looks incongruous, and in those problem. He finds the root of the American objection in American dialects that pronounce the r, it sounds incon- the fact that the adverb is regularly used in a positive gruous. Thus the early outrage of American commen- way—from the idea of "argue in favor of—but the tators. Many later commentators have also disparaged adjective is regularly used in a negative way—from the expression, though the bases for objection have "argue against." Safire thinks it strange to have such a grown more diverse. Several point out its ungrammati- semantic switch from the adjective to the adverb. cally; Krapp 1927 found it "sometimes employed in a Actually he is overstating the case somewhat. Argu- kind of kittenish feminine English" (an opinion able has been and is used with both positive and nega- recorded by Evans 1957 and paraphrased by Copperud tive implications. Here are some examples of the use 1964); Shaw 1975 calls it pompous and affected; Red Safire is referring to (though a few are not especially Smith, a Harper 1975 panelist, termed it a "Nice Nelly negative): usage." But the acceptability of the phrase has been growing. Sixth-formers might enjoy the book tremendously; There never seems to have been much fuss about it in whether they would thereby have been introduced to England; Fowler 1926 doesn't mention it at all, nor do philosophy proper is arguable —Times Literary Treble & Vallins 1937; Partridge 1942 notes that the Supp., 11 Sept. 1969 spelling is common but disapproves it (he favors a'n't); Gowers in Fowler 1965 terms it "colloquially respect- . . . often offering incentives of arguable legality — able." American commentators have begun to soften N.Y. Times, 2 4 Apr. 1977 their opposition; Bremner 1980 plumps for its accep- Even if every word they wrote were objective truth, tance; Reader's Digest 1983 finds it perfectly reasonable the applicability of their work to human behavior for those who dislike the other alternatives. Both the would remain arguable —GraceAnne Andreassi Heritage and Harper usage panels find it acceptable in DeCandido, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 13 Feb. 1983 speech, although they reject it in writing in favor, pre- sumably, of uncontracted am I not? (What point the dis- . . . at least one hardly arguable truth—that men and tinction between speech and writing has in this instance women are different —Atlantic, March 1970 is unclear, since the form is unlikely to appear in writing except in recorded speech, actual or fictional, or in very . . . the dictum that foreign relations were supreme informal writing that is close to speech.) Safire (N. Y. among the influences that shape the history of Times Mag., 23 May 1982) prefers ain't I, however. nations. This may be arguable, but for the immedi- ate past it is certainly maintainable —Barbara W. Given the continuing hostility to ain't I, it looks as Tuchman, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 11 Nov. 1979 though aren't I will win its way to respectability on both sides of the Atlantic. These are completely neutral examples: argot Argot is a vocabulary and idiom that is peculiar . . . like a doctrine in mediaeval theology, arguable to a certain group. It is sometimes more or less secret, almost indefinitely —Marquis W. Childs, Yale Rev., but perhaps its most important function is to identify Summer 1949 the user as a member of the group. Fowler 1965 dis- cusses argot and other similar language terms under . . . an arguable issue that he does not pause to argue jargon; Bernstein 1965 under Inside Talk. See also —Walter Goodman, N. Y. Times Book Rev., 31 Oct. JARGON. 1982 argument from etymology 117 aroma And these are positive examples: Richard Savage was, arguably, the most hopeless case among all Johnson's acquaintances at this time There is no saying what he might have done. It is —John Wain, Samuel Johnson, 1974 arguable that he exhausted himself in "The House with the Green Shutters" —George Blake, Introduc- . . . described as arguably Britain's greatest living tion (1927) to Modern Library edition of George bard —Kingsley Amis, Antaeus, Spring 1975 Douglas Brown, The House with the Green Shutters Sportswriters have been blamed for the popularity of . . . an explanation is offered that if not self-evident this use. As the foregoing examples show, sportswriters is at least arguable —Gerald W. Johnson, N. Y. Her- had nothing to do with its beginnings—the credit or ald Tribune Book Rev., 20 Sept. 1953 blame belongs to reviewers, critics, and writers on a variety of subjects. Sportswriters do use it, however: It is arguable that the wounds left by these political traumas of the 1950s have not yet healed sufficiently Arguably the greatest European sprinter of all time for an objective appraisal of Evatt's later career — — The Oxford Companion to Sports and Games, ed. Times Literary Supp., 30 July 1971 John Arlott, 1975 . . . it's perfectly arguable that letting down all the . . . arguably the greatest skate racer ever —Chip barriers of "decency" . . . will pose more problems Greenwood, Rolling Stone, 7 Feb. 1980 for the really creative artist than it solves —Robert M. Adams, Bad Mouth, 1977 . . . arguably the two finest forwards in history —Joe Klein, Inside Sports, May 1982 The adverb, then, does not show a complete reversal of attitude from the adjective; rather it springs from just . . . arguably the country's leading authority on col- one side of the adjective's usage, which may be curious lege football —Jill Lieber, Sports Illustrated, 1 Sept. but is not alarming. 1982 The adverb functions as a hedge against too absolute In summary we may say that arguably is used in a a statement. Early citations show no particular pattern positive sense and that it is primarily a qualifier or of use: hedge against too strong a statement. It derives from . . . a lawyer who urges a defense which he believes one side of its parent adjective arguable. It is of fairly to be false may be held, arguably enough, to be . . . a recent popularity, but did not originate with sports- disingenuous man —Atlantic, April 1927 writers. Safire does not find the usage objectionable and the . . . opposite values each arguably good for the Boston Globe editorialist concludes that it fills a need in nation —Henry Seidel Canby, Saturday Rev., 13 the language. The objection of the British commentators July 1946 that it is merely a faddish replacement for perhaps or . . . arguably, Mount Morris was inauspicious —Eliz- probably is off-target; arguably may be close in meaning abeth Bowen, The Heat of the Day, 1949 to those two, but it carries its own connotation. Unless you are a person who habitually avoids what happens to Many of the weaknesses of the Middle Eastern states be in fashion, there seems to be no reason to avoid argu- are arguably the result of their failure to recognize ably. and meet adequately the problems of a prolonged social crisis —Sir Hamilton A. R. Gibb, Atlantic, argument from etymology See ETYMOLOGICAL October 1956 FALLACY. Fairly early on (as early as 1920, according to the OED aroma In the world of the usage writer aroma always Supplement), arguably was used to modify a compara- suggests a pleasant odor—Copperud 1980, Bernstein tive adjective: 1965, and Bryson 1984 tell us so. Evans 1957 is a bit But the theatre, behind the scenes, has an emotional more cagey; he says that our forefathers, much given to freemasonry of its own, certainly franker and argu- euphemism and jocularity, tended to use it otherwise, ably wholesomer than the stiffnesses of suburban but recommends hewing to the pleasant smell line. Cop- society outside —George Bernard Shaw, Preface, perud also notes the existence of facetious use. The Shaw- Terry Letters, 1931 Perhaps the sense of smell is the most plebeian of the senses, or perhaps the nose is sooner aware of unpleas- . . . a better film critic than almost anybody else: ant odors than pleasant ones, but in any case the words arguably better than anybody else writing for non- associated with olfactory sensations tend to acquire less specialist magazines —Times Literary Supp., 12 pleasant connotations over time. Aroma has pretty well Mar. 1970 resisted this tendency; it is most often used of pleasant And, most recently, it is used to qualify a superlative: smells: This is, arguably, the best Shakespeare film to date . . . spiced among these odors was the sultry aroma —Eric Bentley, New Republic, 3 Aug. 1953 of strong boiling coffee —Thomas Wolfe, You Can't Go Home Again, 1940 . . . Yeats, arguably the latest great poet in English — Times Literary Supp., 23 Apr. 1964 . . . the pleasing aroma of fresh produce —The Lamp, Summer 1971 . . . arguably still the best introduction to the world that underlies and surrounds the works of art —John It may have, in technical contexts, an entirely neutral E. C. T. White, Johns Hopkins Mag., Spring 1967 use: . . . when monarchy was arguably the single most The aroma of a loaf should not be strong, sour, or important factor in politics —Peter Stansky, Satur- gassy as a result of underbaking —Frank J. Gruber, day Rev., 20 Jan. 1973 Baker's Digest, February 1955 around 118 around The euphemistic and humorous uses also continue; they "Around carries the concept of circularity." From are not as frequent as the pleasant smell uses: Bierce on, the subject becomes a regular feature of usage books and handbooks. . . . the critical scene in the comedy is set off by the An interesting aspect of the around-about issue is its gruesomely strong aroma of the old dog, who has ability to migrate from sense to sense of around and eaten . . . too much fish —Christopher Morley, from one construction to another, as if the commenta- Book-of-the-Month Club News, May 1948 tors were not quite sure of what they should be advising . . . the particular meadows smell for which Secaucus people to avoid. Bierce added a prepositional use to the is celebrated—a blend dominated by the pungent adverb criticized by Schele De Vere; Jensen 1935 criti- aroma of pigs —John Brooks, New Yorker, 16 Mar. cizes adverbial uses, which also figure in Watt 1967 and 1957 Prentice-Hall 1978. Somewhere along the line the sense of around meaning "approximately" or "near" is picked The foregoing examples all refer to real odors. Unre- up, and for Bernstein 1965, Shaw 1970, Nickles 1974, marked by the commentators is the considerable figu- and Janis 1984 it has become the chief focus of criti- rative use of aroma for a distinctive quality or atmo- cism. This sense had not even been recorded when sphere. In this use aroma is pleasant, unpleasant, or Schele De Vere made the original comment. neutral as the context dictates: And there is another aspect of the use of around to consider: the difference between British and American . . . an atmosphere, impalpable as a perfume yet as usage. All of the various usages criticized by American real, rose above the heads of the laughing guests. It commentators are predominantly American in use and was the aroma of enjoyment and gaiety —Stella Gib- some are American in origin. Why American commen- bons, Cold Comfort Farm, 1932 tators are so persistently diffident about our native " . . . And by now it is all beginning to lose its eccen- usages is somewhat of a mystery. Recent British com- tric charm, Nathan, and is taking on a decidedly para- mentators (Longman 1984, Burchfield 1981) do not dis- noic aroma...." —Philip Roth, Atlantic, April 1981 parage the "approximately" use, for instance; they merely say it is more usual in the U.S. than in Brit- The aroma of the continental tradition hangs about ain; Chambers 1985 even finds it in informal British the sayings —John Dewey, Freedom and Culture, use. 1939 Since the "approximately" or "near" sense of around is at present the one most often objected to, we will Figurative use is at least as common as use for an actual give here some examples of its use by American smell. authors: Aroma in its current meanings is a relatively recent word, not attested until the early 19th century. It first meant "spice" and then "the distinctive odor of a . . . looking forty instead of what she was, around spice." When it connotes a pleasant smell, aroma is twenty-two —American Mercury, March 1928 more often associated with food than any other single The idea of becoming a composer seems gradually to source of odor. have dawned upon me some time around 1916 — Aaron Copland, Our New Music, 1941 around 1 . Around, about. The propriety of using Around ten o'clock the little five-piece band got tired around in senses it shares with about seems first to have of messing around with a rhumba —Raymond been questioned by M. Schele De Vere in his American- Chandler, The Simple Art of Murder, 1950 isms of 1872. He modestly defers to John Russell Bartlett, whose 1859 edition of his Dictionary of Amer- It was around two bells. The starboard watch had icanisms gave a couple of examples, but Bartlett merely just gone below —Captain Harry Allen Chippendale, listed the examples rather than censuring them. Bardeen Sails and Whales, 1951 1883 notes only Schele De Vere's stricture and the fact He was a bullet-headed man of around sixty —John that the sense is recorded in Webster 1864 with this Cheever, The Reporter, 29 Dec. 1955 quotation: . . . overhung the rim of the bench at an angle of I was standing around when the fight took place — around thirty degrees —John Updike, New Yorker, N. Y. Police Gazette 3 Dec. 1955 Such a source in the dictionary seems to surprise Bar- Around six thousand years ago —Lewis Mumford, deen, but it was a well-traveled quotation, having first New Yorker, 3 Mar. 1956 appeared in Bartlett and having been used by Schele De Vere too. Bardeen describes the use as "in dispute." My father, for around half a century, was the leading Other usage writers of the time ignored the issue, Liberal of the community —John Kenneth Gal- althought it did surface upon occasion in the braith, The Scotch, 1964 newspapers: Around the turn of the century, grammarians How regularly "around" is used and abused when adjured writers not to use people for persons individ- "about" is the right word! Thus: "I guess we will be ually—Bernstein 1971 able to go around Noo York with you this after- noon." —letter to editor, Springfield (Mass.) Repub- . . . a word that would have been unprintable until lican, 18 Dec. 1902 around 1960 —John Gross, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 15 July 1984 Ambrose Bierce picked the subject up in 1909, objecting to "The débris of battle lay around them" and "The Although the OED marks this sense U.S., other British huckster went around, crying his wares." Bierce brought commentators recognize its existence in British English; something new to the subject—a reason for objecting: everybody agrees that about is much more common. arrant 119 array Here are a few samples from writers of British English: It was Wood who should have gone to Australia, and Luckhurst to India, not the other way around — . . . a rate of natural increase for Quebec of around Tony Lewis, Cricketer International, August 1976 17 per thousand —B. K. Sandwell, The Canadian Peoples, 1941 . . . these days it is usually the other way round — Times Literary Supp., 2 2 Oct. 1971 If the land be in need of lime, this should be applied around November —Henry Wynmalen, Horse " . . . Actually, I shall be in all evening, if you would Breeding and Stud Management, 1950 like to call around" —Michael Ryan, Irish Digest, December 1955 Leopoldina Terminal debentures were also better at 86 and the ordinary units changed hands around 1 s. " . . . I just got your letter and came straight round 6d. —Railway Gazette, 15 Dec. 1950 . . ." —Iris Murdoch, A Fairly Honourable Defeat, 1970 . . . at around the same price —The Bulletin (Sydney, Australia), 10 Feb. 1954 It was visiting day and there were a lot of women around to see their husbands —Graham Greene, . . . around and before the beginning of the Christian Travels with my Aunt, 1969 era —Stuart Piggot, London Calling, 10 June 1954 Sometimes the same writer will even use both: Around fourteen per cent, of students —Sir James . . . the old steam-engines that used to chug around Mountford, British Universities, 1966 Edinburgh —David Daiches, The Listener, 13 Dec. . . . around that time, many of the halls built for 1973 dancing came to be converted into skating-rinks — . . . railway line that ran right round the city —David Frances Rust, Dance in Society, 1969 Daiches, The Listener, 13 Dec. 1973 In sum, you can use around in senses it shares with And these are American examples of both round and about without apologizing or feeling diffident—espe- around in the same expression: cially if you are an American. A handful of surveys made back around 1954 showed about more common So I worked on him a bit, you know, telling him how than around even in American use; nothing seems to he owes me and he starts to come around and then have been done recently to estimate relative frequency. he says " . . . I'll see what I can do." —Philadelphia See also ABOUT. bar patron, quoted in Michael J. Bell, The World 2. Around, round. Everybody knows that around is more from Brown's Lounge, 1983 common in American English and round more common A great obstacle to nuptials would seem to be in British English. "More common" does not imply O'Neal's . . . children . . . but apparently they have exclusiveness, however; both words are in use on both now come round —Kristin McMurran, People, 11 sides of the Atlantic and have been for a good while— May 1981 even though the OED notes that around was rare before 1600. Clearly you can use whichever word you feel is most A number of commentators say, and evidence in the natural for you, whether you are British or American. OED Supplement shows, that some originally American uses of around have become established to some extent arrant See ERRANT, ARRANT. in British English. In addition to the "about, approxi- mately" sense documented above, there is the phrase array The verb array is used with many prepositions. have been around: When used in the sense of "dress," it usually takes in: I'd been around long enough to find out t h a t . . . — ... the subsequent arraying of their persons in the Len Deighton, Spy Story, 1974 poppy-colored jerseys that she considered suitable to the gloom of the day —Elizabeth Goudge, Pilgrim's . . . was a friend of some of the really big wheels Inn, 1948 south of the b o r d e r . . . . Moar had been around — Ronald A. Keith, Bush Pilot With a Briefcase, 1972 . . . arrayed in gaudy attire —Walter Pater, Marius the Epicurean, 1885 These next examples show the perhaps unexpected cross-national use of around and round: . . . had arrayed herself in lipstick, rouge, perfume — Herman Wouk, Marjorie Morningstar, 1955 . . . he has not got around to this conundrum —John V. Kelleher, Irish Digest, December 1954 If the sense is close to "equip," in or with may be used: . . . destined to be finally extinguished when we got around to it —Manchester Guardian Weekly, 10 . . . almost every county of England arrayed in arms Nov. 1944 against the throne —T. B. Macaulay, The History of England, vol. I, 1849 . . . all explanations must accommodate to them, not the other way round —William Stafford, Writing the . . . arrayed with the most advanced equipment — Australian Crawl, 1978 General Electric Investor, Summer 1972 In these examples we have British evidence for both Many prepositions are used when the meaning is "to words in similar constructions: get or place in order": A look around Krefeld —Manchester Guardian . . . had his students arrayed on the stage —Gilbert Weekly, 9 Mar. 1945 Rogin, New Yorker, 5 June 1971 An English friend whom he took round California — They arrayed themselves before us —Leon Uris, Foster 1968 Battle Cry, 1953 arrive 120 arrive . . . chairs were rounded up and arrayed in front of American tenor Jess Thomas arrived on the roster of the Muller platform —John Brooks, New Yorker, 27 the New York Metropolitan Opera in 1962 —Cur- Apr. 1957 rent Biography, June 1964 . . . chairs arrayed before a platform —Clifton Dan- Two policemen at length arrived upon the scene — iel, NY. Times Mag., 12 Dec. 1954 OED Food was his material; his life's art was to array it Into is also sometimes used: upon mahogany and damask —British Books of the Month, March 1953 Neighbors arrive into what is already a madhouse scene —Elizabeth Bowen, New Republic, 9 Mar. . . . scarcely had time to array his men at the town- 1953 ward wall —A. C. Whitehead, The Standard Bearer, 1915 . . . with which persons may arrive into the world at birth —Psychiatry, May 1945 . . . four brass buttons arrayed in a hollow square — Lois Long, New Yorker, 30 Oct. 1954 When things—material or immaterial—arrive, we find in, at, or on: When there is a notion of drawing up forces, against is usual: . . . a just appreciation of Baudelaire has been slow to arrive in England —T. S. Eliot, "Baudelaire," in . . . arraying formidable resources against persons who gather and disseminate news —Playboy, April Selected Essays, 1932 1973 . . . was safe when Allen's lob to Johnson arrived at . . . the French encyclopedists, who were arrayed the bag too late —Joseph Durso, N. Y. Times, 1 Sept. against the church —Harry S. Ashmore, Center 1969 Occasional Papers, February 1971 Swift's words arrive on the page with the regular tap . . . each group is arrayed against one or more other of a day's rain —V. S. Pritchett, Books In General, groups —Margaret Mead, in Personality in Nature, 1953 Society, and Culture, ed. Clyde Kluckhohn & Henry . . . the day that particular issue . . . arrived on the A. Murray, 1948 New Hampshire newsstands —The Reporter, 17 Aug. 1954 arrive 1 . The question of what prepositions to use with arrive has been a matter of comment since 1770. If the object is the point of departure, from is the most Baker 1770 prescribes at, rather than to, for literal sen- common, with out o/finding a little use: ses; either at or to for figurative senses. The figurative . . . many of them recently arrived from the hill senses do not seem to occur to later commentators: country —Cabell Phillips, N. Y. Times Mag., 30 May Raub 1897 says "Û/ a place, in a vehicle, from a place," 1954 and Bernstein 1965 says only at or in without explana- tion. We will take up literal and figurative senses sepa- . . . who arrived in 1849 from Munich —American rately, the literal first. Guide Series: Tennessee, 1939 When the place of arrival is the object, we find in and at: When material aid arrived from the Soviet Union — Current Biography, June 1967 . . . arrived in the United States —Current Biogra- phy, April 1968 . . . a lost begrimed dark burnt army abruptly arrived out of some holocaust —Marshall Frady, Harper's, . . . when we first arrived in Stonington —Dana Bur- November 1970 net, New England Journeys, 1953 . . . belches begin arriving out of your body —Rich- Ninety per cent of the emigrants arrive in New York ard Brautigan, A Confederate General from Big Sur, City —Geographical Rev., January 1954 1964 Safely arrived at the capital —Christian Herald, When the object is the means of arrival, we find by, on, October 1967 and occasionally in: . . . members arrived at the classroom with arms full . . . but, after arriving by boat, it was found to be too of books —Marel Brown, Christian Herald, March heavy to transport —American Guide Series: Loui- 1954 siana, 1941 Either may be used of birth: . . . the visitor who arrives, as I did, by air —George When Harley Johnston came into the world, he Lichtheim, Commentary, October 1957 arrived at a small manor house —Donn Byrne, A Francis Cooke, who arrived on the Mayflower — Daughter of the Medici, 1935 Current Biography, February 1967 Late that autumn a boy baby arrived in their home . . . other invisible persons arriving in close carriages —Irving Bachelier, A Man for the Ages, 1919 —Herman Melville, Pierre, 1852 On or upon may be used in some instances: In figurative use, the object in mind is almost always . . . by early morning the uniformed youngsters the point of arrival and the preposition in modern use began to arrive on the dock —Frank Oliver, The is overwhelmingly at. The OED recognizes the use of to, Reporter, 6 July 1954 which it labels obsolete. To is perhaps not quite obso- ary 121 as lete, but it was more common in the 18th century (when ary Ary, from e'er a, from ever a, is a dialectal term Baker took note of it) than it is in the 20th. meaning "any, a single; either." The Dictionary of American Regional English records its occurrence I have arrived to vast courage and skill that way — throughout the U.S., but it is most frequent in Southern Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, reprinted in Encore, and Midland speech. November 1944 See, I was loading more coal than ary a man they had . . . and those, who could not otherwise arrive to a down there —Gobel Sloan of Haysi, Virginia, Perfection,... made use of the same Experiment to quoted in Our Appalachia, ed. Laurel Shackelford & acquire it —Jonathan Swift, "A Discourse Concern- Bill Weinberg, 1977 ing the Mechanical Operation of the Spirit," 1710 In the 19th century ary was considered a New England- . . . power arrives to them accidentally and late in ism; it was in use there, and was not entirely confined their careers —Hilaire Belloc, Richelieu, 1930 to the usage of the less educated: . . . he had at least arrived at what he considered a reasonable point —Norman Mailer, Harper's, . . . which, though very clean, yet hasn't the vestige March 1971 of a table-cloth on ary a table —Henry Adams, letter, 9 Feb. 1859 The investigator arrives at a list of units —W. F. Bol- ton, A Short History of Literary English, 1967 The spelling ary seems to be American, but the con- struction is old: . . . want to do considerable exploring in college before arriving at a career decision —Milton S. Has the old man e'er a son, sir —Shakespeare, The Eisenhower, Johns Hopkins Mag., February 1966 Winter's Tale, 1611 . . . when their eldest child was arriving at school age . . . and I'd foot it with e'er a Captain in the county —Frederick Lewis Allen, The Big Change, 1952 —Richard Brinsley Sheridan, The Rivals, 1775 . . . each in his own way, suddenly arrived at invent- It turns up spelled arrow in Fielding's Tom Jones: ing twentieth-century art —Janet Flanner, New Yorker, 6 Oct. 1956 "I don't believe there is arrow a servant in the house." (OED) . . . to arrive at general conclusions —Robert A. Hall, Jr., A Short History of Italian Literature, 1951 The OED also cites Smollett's Humphrey Clinker; Schele De Vere's Americanisms (1872) quotes another . . . the deepest secret of the universe at which we can instance from Tom Jones. arrive —John Cowper Powys, The Meaning of Cul- The only use of ary in modern English writing is in ture, 1939 the representation of speech, especially in fiction: It's restful to arrive at a decision —Robert Frost, "If I said ary thing, I don't remember it now" — New Hampshire, 1923 Charley Robertson, Shadow of a Cloud, 1950 . . . began to arrive at a certain importance —Osbert Sitwell, Triple Fugue, 1924 " . . . a street so wide it has footpaths on ary side . . ." —Conrad Richter, The Trees, 1940 From may indicate a figurative as well as a literal source: James Whitcomb Riley used it in verse: . . . a century in which totalitarianism arrives as eas- Nary bee in ary hive —Farm-Rhymes, 1883 ily from the Right as from the Left —Barbara Ward, N. Y. Times Mag., 20 June 1954 a s There are a number of questions—both picky and more substantial—involving the little word as—"one of 2. Harper 1975, 1985 notes with regret the transitive use the most overworked words in the English language," of arrive and depart by airlines people—simply the according to Shaw 1970. Overwork is a fate shared by usual verb without the preposition. The OED shows most small function words in English; Mr. Shaw himself such use (not in airlines lingo, though) from the late works as as hard as anyone else. (As is the fourteenth 17th century; even Tennyson indulged in it once. Our most frequent word in the Brown University Corpus, files show no evidence of a spread from the airlines to according to Kucera & Francis 1967.) general use. We will treat at this entry several uses of as that tend 3. How long does it take a new sense of a word to make to be lumped together in handbooks. When as forms itself at home? The sense of arrive meaning "to achieve part of a compound, correlative, or phrase whose use is success" is recorded in the OED Supplement as making questioned, the whole construction will be found at its its arrival in 1889; its first appearance is marked by own alphabetical place. A number of these follow the inclusion in quotation marks. This sense took its time: present article. See also LIKE, AS, AS IF. here are two examples more than 60 years later with the 1. Causal "as." Bryant 1962 reports that causal as word still enclosed in quotation marks: appears in standard contexts but is quite a bit less fre- quent than because and since. Many other commenta- The new rich, financiers and industrialists, had tors object to the use; the most frequent objection is the "arrived." —Times Literary Supp., 15 June 1951 possibility of ambiguity in the uncertainty, in certain . . . the railroad had decidedly "arrived" —G. Ferris made-up sentences, whether as signifies "because" or Cronkhite, American Quarterly, Summer 1954 "while." Here, for example, is the ambiguous sentence from Copperud 1970: Quotation marks are no longer used; the sense is fully established. As the door was locked, he turned and walked away. as 122 as The weakness of an example like this is that it is pre- Simpling our Author goes from Field to Field, sented with no supporting context. The context would And culls such Fools, as may Diversion yield disambiguate, as linguists say, the sentence. We might —George Farquhar, Prologue, know that the locking of this particular door was a pro- The Beaux Strategem, 1707 cess sufficiently lengthy to permit our protagonist to turn and walk away, or that our protagonist was simply Each house shall keep a journal of its proceedings, balked of his purpose. On the other hand, if you have and from time to time publish the same, excepting difficulty imagining a context into which this sentence such parts as may in their judgment require secrecy would fit comfortably, that fact is a sign that the exam- —Constitution of the United States, 1787 ple has little demonstrative value. . . . appreciation of and interest in such fine, pleas- Actually, cases where causal as is clearly ambiguous ant, and funny things as may still be around —James are hard to find; the objection seems somewhat flimsy. Thurber, letter, 20 Jan. 1938 The objection of Copperud 1970 and one or two others that causal as is unidiomatic will not bear scrutiny. Here . . . with such poor things as are our own —Leacock are some genuine examples of causal as; you can judge 1943 whether they are ambiguous or unidiomatic: Plato and Aristotle faced the same problems of man The class of'24's valedictorian did not make it from in society as confront the modern philosopher — Southern California this year, for instance, as his Report: Royal Commission on National Develop- wife had died —Tom Gavin, Sunday Denver Post, 7 ment in the Arts, Letters, & Sciences, 1949-1951 Oct. 1984 (Ottawa, Canada) As you are but young in the trade, you will excuse . . . faced by the same sort of problem as confronts me if I tell you, that some little inaccuracies have many local housing committees —Times Literary escaped your eye —Thomas Gray, letter, 10 Aug. Supp., 1 Oct. 1954 1757 . . . such innovations as they actually have made — THESEUS. Oh! then as I'm a respectable man, and James Sledd, in Essays on Language and Usage, 2d rather particular about the company I keep, I think éd., ed. Leonard F. Dean & Kenneth G. Wilson, I'll go —W. S. Gilbert, Thespis, 1871 1963 " . . . I shall prepare my most plaintive airs against . . . a tarred timber barn, behind which such of the his return, in compassion to his feelings, as I know young as fancied and some as didn't used to box — his horse will lose." —Jane Austen, Mansfield Park, Benedict Kiely, New Yorker, 20 Aug. 1973 1814 A banjo can set up such a racket as will work the fill- Martin told Jimmy Miranda to take the 3-year-old ings loose from your teeth —Michael O'Rourke, colt to the lead, and the strategy seemed brilliant as Nation Rev. (Melbourne), 24 Apr. 1975 no one challenged Ten Below through slow early fractions —Steven Crist, NY. Times, 26 Sept. 1982 In this construction as cannot be easily replaced by another relative pronoun like that or which. . . . and as it is always well to prepare for contingen- The relative pronoun as without a preceding such or cies, I will just notify you —Henry Adams, letter, 9 same is a more complex matter. The OED found it Apr. 1859 obsolete in standard English but current in various dia- . . . in cases of doubt I often leave them out, but I am lects; the Dictionary of American Regional English apt to put them in, as they help the reader —Oliver declares it formerly widespread in American English but Wendell Holmes d. 1935, letter, 27 July 1931 now restricted to the Midland and Southern areas. We have three kinds of evidence in our files. First, we have . . . I accepted at once as I like to make trips by plane transcriptions of actual speech: —Flannery O'Connor, letter, 11 Sept. 1955 'I writes notes and letters for some as buys paper of At the last possible minute, John carefully polishes m e . . . . ' —Henry Mayhew, London Labour and the all the brass, as it tarnishes so easily —Suzy Lucine, London Poor, 1851 Morgan Horse, April 1983 She said to me: 'There's a lot of old maids in this As this chapter had no observable merits it did not village, sir, as wants men ' —The Journals of seem worth reprinting here —Robert Burchfield, Arnold Bennett, ed. Frank Swinnerton, 1954 Note on the Text, 1984 reprint of Cobbett 1823 "Not," he said, "what you would call bookshops. Causal as is a standard and acceptable alternative to There's some as stocks novels; there's some as stocks because and since, but it is less frequently used than religion " —Harold J. Laski, letter, 26 Aug. 1925 either. Objection to it on grounds of ambiguity seems dubious at best, since ambiguous examples in published Then there is other dialectal evidence (British and writing are hard to come by. American): See also SINCE 1. Agriculture was ordained by Him as made us, for our 2. Relative pronoun. The use that is questioned here chief occupation —Thomas C. Haliburton, The breaks down into two kinds of constructions, one per- Clockmaker, 1837 fectly standard and one chiefly dialectal. In the standard construction, the relative pronoun as is preceded by . . . we was goin to tell the Gospel to them as had ears such or same: —Robert Penn Warren, in New Directions, 1947 Therefore let Princes, or States, choose such Ser- . . . a lot of things happened inside of you as never vants, as have not this marke —Francis Bacon, ought to —Richard Llewellyn, None But the Lonely Essays, 1625 Heart, 1943 as 123 as "Never trust a bloke as says that," Bert said —Alan 3. Conjunction. The use of as as a conjunction where Sillitoe, Saturday Night and Sunday Morning, 1958 that, or sometimes if or whether, could be substituted has been attacked by various commentators at least I had me a little spell and took some pills as cost 60<t since Ayres 1881 discovered "Not as I know." Subse- a throw —Flannery O'Connor, letter, 4 Aug. 1957 quent commentators from Bierce 1909 to Janis 1984 and Guth 1985 have decried it as ungrammatical, incor- And, curiously, we have as a third group a few examples rect, or nonstandard. None of these commentators gives appearing in contexts intended to be standard. These us a reason for the condemnation; in fact, none of them examples may simply reflect the natural idiom of the has much to say about it beyond the criticism. writer. This use, like the one discussed in section 2 above, is He has only to shake his well-stocked sleeves to pro- a survival of an older one. The OED notes its existence vide a shower of comic images as point to what he from Caxton's time in the 15th century. Lowth 1762 calls "his relish for the ridiculous." —Times Literary lists it in a footnote of old-fashioned or out-of-date uses. Supp., 3 Mar. 1950 It had high literary use in the 17th and early 18th centuries: The same people as objected to "Inkhorn terms" . . . poured derision upon those who "peppered their talk And certainly, it is the Nature of Extreme Selfe-Lov- with oversea language" —David C. Brazil, The True ers; As they will set an House on Fire, and it were Book about Our Language, 1965 but to roast their Egges —Francis Bacon, Essays, 1625 There has never before been a time as exists today when school committees needed to present a united I gain'd a son; front —Alton S. Cavicchi, MASC Jour. (Mass.), Feb- And such a son, as all men hail'd me happy ruary 1968 —John Milton, Samson Agonistes, 1671 (in Lowth) . . . coffeehouse featuring many of the performers as . . . disposed to conclude a peace upon such condi- have appeared on Robert Lurtsema's "Morning Pro tions, as it was not worth the life of a grenadier to Musica" —advt., WFCR (Amherst, Mass.) Program refuse them —Jonathan Swift, The Four Last Years Guide, February 1978 of the Queen (in Lowth) There was something so amiable, and yet so piercing In addition, there is a fixed phrase beginning "them as" in his looks, as inspired me at once with love and followed by a third-person present singular verb. In the terror —Joseph Addison, The Spectator, No. 63 (in first of the examples below, the phrase is represented as Lowth) the speech of an unlettered character. In the other two the fixed phrase is used—as are many fixed phrases with These literary uses have dropped away. The OED notes ain 't—in such a way as to disinfect it of the suspicion survival in southern British dialects; the DARE in of illiteracy and make it a leavening agent in the writing. American. It remains almost entirely an oral use in American English. It can occasionally be found in pos- 'Them as looks down their nose don't see far beyond itive constructions: it,' said Laffin —Robert Gibbings, Lovely Is the Lee, 1945 Billy Sessions asked me if I thought you all would read his play & I allowed as I thot you would —Flan- I'll stick to my casualty page; them as likes that kind nery O'Connor, letter, 1 July 1959 of thing can have their newsworthy floozies —Alan Villiers, Ships and the Sea, January 1953 But usually it is followed in negative constructions, usu- In literature, for example, it is often said that "the ally after the verbs know, see, or say: novel is dead", or that "the sentence is obsolete". All I don't know as you'll like the appearance of our right for them as thinks so —Clancy Sigal, Times place —Harriet Beecher Stowe, Dred, 1856 (in OED) Literary Supp., 6 Aug. 1964 I don't know as it makes any difference in respect to The plain relative pronoun as without such or same is a danger —Walt Whitman, letter, 9 Feb. 1863 survival of older use. It must have been fading in the middle of the 18th century, for Lowth 1762 remarks in "Just as you say," returned the rejected. "I ain't sure a footnote that it is no longer common. Here are three as you'd be exactly the o n e . . . . " —Francis Lee Pratt, of his examples, all from the 17th century: "Captain Ben's Choice," in Mark Twain's Library of Humor, 1888 An it had not been for a civil gentleman, as came by —William Congreve, The Old Bachelor I don't see as it's been any use —Edith Wharton, Ethan Frome, 1911 (in American Dialect Dic- The Duke had not behaved with that loyalty, as he tionary) ought to have done —Edward Hyde, Earl of Clar- endon (title not given) I didn't know as I'd go —Thornton Wilder, Our Town, 1938 (in ADD) In the order, as they lie in his preface —Thomas Middleton, Works But the last five years anyway we've managed to market it all in retail containers. I don't know as I It looks to us as if the plain relative pronoun as would should say all, but the majority of it —Mac Joslyn, be a little tricky to use if it is not part of your natural quoted in New England Farmer, October 1984 idiom. You need not, of course, avoid its survival in this proverb: This as must have been a regular feature of the idiolect of the detective novelist Erie Stanley Gardner. He put it Handsome is as handsome does. into the language of many of the characters in his sto- as . . . as 124 as as ries—including characters whose speech is standard. using as in its "like" sense when it can be taken for the One sample: other. Here is an example: Well, after reading that letter, I don't know as I . . . convicted of assaulting a security guard . . . and blame Minerva — The Case of the Negligent Nymph, breaking up the hotel's furniture. Said the judge to 1949 the defendants upon sentencing them: "You acted as buffoons." —TV Guide, 4 Jan. 1985 This use of the conjunction as is not ungrammatical, If the judge had used like, his meaning would have been erroneous, or illiterate, but you must remember that it apparent at once. is now a speech form—whether dialectal or not—and is 5. Copperud 1970 and one or two others raise an objec- not found in ordinary expository prose. tion to the preposition as used after what they term See also AS HOW. "designating verbs": name, appoint, elect, and the like. 4. Preposition. Phythian 1979 believes that "correct Verbs like elect and appoint are what linguists call grammar" does not accept as as a preposition, but that "ditransitive verbs"—they take two objects: is not the case. As has a few prepositional uses no one quibbles about: We elected Helene president. When I sailed as a boy, yachting was confined to He was appointed vicar. relatively few centers —Carleton Mitchell, Boating, They considered her a genius. January 1984 The problem with a blanket objection to the insertion of . . . language is primarily learned as speech —Wil- as between the objects is that some similar verbs, such liam Stafford, Writing the Australian Crawl, 1978 as install, are not ditransitive: He acted as her manager —E. L. Doctorow, Rag- He was installed as vicar last week. time, 1975 If the occasional insertion of an unnecessary but harm- It was as Julie Lamber in Theatre . . . that she first less as in won almost unanimous praise from Broadway critics —Current Biography, December 1964 He was appointed as vicar, . . . they respect every man as a man —J. Bronowski, avoids the unidiomatic American Scholar, Autumn 1969 He was installed vicar. Here's a good Ph.D. thesis for somebody: Weber as it is a minor fault indeed. a literary man —Harold C. Schonberg, N. Y. Times, 6. As, such as. Sellers 1975 objects to as used for such 16 July 1967 as, calling it "a sloppy Americanism." His compatriot Phythian 1979 finds it entirely acceptable. These two There is another sense of the prepositions as that means examples show that it is not an Americanism, and is not the same as like: necessarily sloppy. ... each of them, as their predecessors, neatly tai- . . . some little inaccuracies have escaped your eye, lored to the pocket —Times Literary Supp., 26 Jan. as in the 9th page Lab'rinth's & Echo's, (which are 1967 Nominatives plural,) with Apostrophes after them, as tho' they were Genitives singular —Thomas Then I said, "Do you think that he is not as other Gray, letter, 10 Aug. 1757 men?" —Jim Henderson, Open Country Muster, 1974 I was often astonished when my mother did me some deed of generosity, as when she bought me my . . . that grimness is as nothing compared to what first Sunday suit with long pants —Russell Baker, was to come —Robert Penn Warren, Democracy Growing Up, 1982 and Poetry, 1975 Because of the propensity of conjunctional as to be used a s . . . a s 1. As . . . as, so ... as. As a general rule, it with what are called truncated clauses, it is sometimes is safe to observe that as . . . as is regularly used in pos- hard to tell whether the conjunction or preposition was itive statements, and either as ... as or so... as in neg- intended: ative statements. This state of affairs was not always the case. Comeau was thin and Adams was fat, but after years Lamberts 1972 says that up until about a century ago, of association they moved as matched planets — so ... as was the regular form in negative statements. It John Updike, Couples, 1968 is a very old construction; the OED shows so. . .as from the 13th century on. Apparently as ... as began to be It sounds and reads as a forced word • -John O. Bar- used in negative statements sometime in the 18th cen- bour, quoted in Harper 1985 tury; Marckwardt & Walcott 1938 cite a study that found the construction in Swift, Johnson, Boswell, and Some writers choose as automatically out of fear of mis- others. Leonard 1929 notes that a grammarian named J. using like; such uses are often ambiguous because the as Mennye in 1785 was apparently the first to insist on so can be understood in its "like" sense or in its "in the after not. Since 18th-century grammarians prescribed character or capacity o f sense. In the E. L. Doctorow most of their rules in cases of divided usage, we can quotation above, "He acted as her manager," as reflects fairly assume that Mennye was aware of as . . . as being the latter sense; it is easy to see how "He acted like her used after not. Lowth 1762 was probably not aware of manager" would mean something quite different. Cop- divided usage: he describes the so ... as construction, perud 1964, Freeman 1983, and others warn against illustrated entirely with examples of negative state- as as 125 as as ments, but states no rule and uses neither the word neg- The mystery about as ... as and so ... as is why so ative or not. Mennye's book was published in New . . . as has begun to decline in regularity of usage York. Leonard says that he had a large number of fol- (although certainly it is far from defunct). There is prob- lowers in the authors of 19th-century grammars and ably no one reason, but three possible contributing fac- handbooks. In a grammer by Joseph Hervey Hull pub- tors can be identified. First, English does not in general lished in Boston in 1829, for example, the sentence have different grammatical structures for negative state- "This is not as good as that" appears in a list of "incor- ments; in most cases they are simply positive statements rect phrases" to be corrected by the pupil. negated. Second, as Bryant and others point out, many Bryant 1962 cites a study showing that in the middle as... as comparisons are fixed in English as regular pat- of the 19th century only about 11 percent of the writers terns (as cool as a cucumber, as sly as a fox, as clean as studied were using negative as ... as; by the middle of a whistle, as dry as dust, etc.) where negation would not the 20th century negative as ... as was used by more normally produce an introductory so. And third, the than 52 percent of the writers studied. As early as 1927, grammarians themselves may have made a contribu- G. P. Krapp asserted that negative as ... as was usual tion. By the time not as ... as began to draw even with in speech. Surveys—Leonard 1932, Mittins et al. 1970, not so . . . as, Mennye's prescription had been repeated Crisp 1971—all show it to be established. for about a century. Some observers feel that the con- Handbooks, however, followed their 19th-century stant use of false syntax—the presentation of examples counterparts and continued to insist on so... as in neg- to be corrected—served to reinforce rather the patterns ative contexts well into the first half of the 20th century. the grammarians deemed incorrect than those supposed The prescription may be most firmly established in the to be correct. field of business writing; we have one such text (Him- We should not overlook the occurrence of so... as in street & Baty) prescribing so in negative contexts as positive contexts. While it does not appear to have been recently as 1977. Most current handbooks join Bern- especially common at any time, neither does it appear stein 1971 in counting it among Miss Thistlebottom's to have been rare. The OED has examples from the 15th hobgoblins; they all recognize the legitimacy of both century to the 19th century. It survives especially in a constructions, although a few (for instance Janis 1984, few expressions concerned with time. Boswell used Freeman 1983) find the so... as construction more for- these: mal or more appropriate in formal contexts. Assertions about relative formality, however, do not . . . a spinnet, which, though made so long ago as bear much scrutiny, at least with respect to writing. A 1667, was still very well toned —Journal of a Tour study made at Merriam-Webster before the publication to the Hebrides, 1785 of Webster's Third and based on citations gathered from the late 1930s up to the early 1950s showed the negative He even more or less puts it into Dr. Johnson's speech: as ... as more common than so .. . as, but the great bulk of the citations for both constructions are from the He told me that "so long ago as 1748 he had read same sources and in a few instances from the same 'The Grave, a Poem' but did not like it much." — authors. There is no particular difference in formality. Life of Samuel Johnson, 1791 Further, evidence from collections of letters (such as H. L. Mencken used a similar expression: Jane Austen's or Henry Adams's) shows a tendency to follow the prevailing mode. Jane Austen, writing in the . . . so late as 1870 —The American Language, Sup- early 19th century, regularly uses as ... as in positive plement II, 1948 contexts: More often, however, we find positive so ... as where . . . I was as civil to them as their bad breath would as ... as might have been used when the writer appears allow me —20 Nov. 1800 to want the additional emphasis of so that comes from its use as a degree word: and so . . . as in negative ones: She is not so pretty as I expected — 1 2 May 1801 Super-duper profs even go so far as to try to enter real politics —Anthony Lambeth, Change, Summer Henry Adams, writing at the end of the 19th century, 1971 uses both as ... as and so . . . as in negative contexts: Now it may strike us as somewhat incredible that a The Church never was as rotten as the stock- viewpoint ostensibly so liberating as that of Boas exchange now is —17 Feb. 1896 could lead to a defense of traditionalism —New Republic, 19 Apr. 1939 No history . . . contains contrasts so dramatic and so gorgeously tragic, as the contrast between the Cathe- . . . delighted musicians so different as Paul White- drals of the 13th and the Chateaux of the 15th cen- man and Duke Ellington —Gilbert McKean, Satur- turies—25 Sept. 1895 day Rev., 27 Sept. 1947 Both as ... as and so ... as are used in negative con- Our recent evidence, too, shows little difference in ele- structions; you can choose the one that sounds better in vation between the constructions: any given instance. In positive constructions as... as is Serious first novels don't do nearly as well as they the prevalent form; positive so . . . as is not wrong but should —John Irving, N.Y. Times Book Rev., 25 simply much less common. May 1980 2. Copperud 1970 notes a couple of commentators who object to as ... as constructions with the first as omit- He would eat hot soup and drink whiskey and ted; he also notes that Evans 1957 considers it accept- sweat—my Uncle Jake did not, decidedly, do any- able. The OED records it without stigma and lists cita- thing so delicate as perspire —Aristides, American tions from about 1200 on, including ones from such Scholar, Winter 1981-82 writers as Wyclif, Shakespeare, Spenser, Milton, and as bad or worse than 126 ascertain Richardson. Here are a couple of more modern But I do as best I can —Harry S. Truman, letter, 18 instances: Aug. 1948 It was jolly as could be —Henry Adams, letter, 22 We climbed wearily into the car, squeezing in as best Apr. 1859 we could —S. Dillon Ripley, Search for the Spinv Babbler, 1952 He's hooked bad as I am —Robert Strauss, quoted in N. Y. Times Mag., 20 May 1984 . . . down the ruts of the midway to where, or where as best he could see in the dark, she had gone 3. If a pronoun follows an as ... as comparison, is it to through her rites —John Cheever, The Wapshot be in the nominative case or the objective case? Is it Chronicle, 1957 "She is as tall as I" or "She is as tall as me"? Commen- tators differ. Longman 1984 prefers the nominative; . . . while the great mass work very little and amuse Heritage 1982 permits either but says that traditionalists themselves as best they can —August Heckscher, in prefer the nominative; Phythian 1979 thinks that the Automation, Education and Human Values, ed. W. nominative would be regarded as pretentious even W. Brickman & S. Lehrer, 1966 though correct; Evans 1957 thinks the objective is preferred. He pictured himself as this hard, lonely man—side- Our evidence is of little help in this instance, because stepping the Byron cliché as best he could, only to the typical "Is Mary as tall as I (or me)" construction is land splat in the Bogart —Wilfrid Sheed, People Will very rare in the sort of discursive prose most of our evi- Always Be Kind, 1973 dence comes from. What is more, as is often omitted from concordances of prose works precisely because its As best I could tell —William Least Heat Moon, great frequency of occurrence would add to the bulk of Blue Highways, 1982 the work. And as it is not a dialectal construction, those dictionaries that concern themselves with speech forms It looks like a perfectly respectable idiom to us. are not much help either. Grammarians and commen- tators have their opinions, but hard evidence seems dif- ficult to come by. The apparent trend among commen- ascent, assent One of the 8th-grade English texts in tators toward approving the objective case seems to be our collection warns students not to confuse ascent and related to the use of the objective case after linking assent—a quick check in your dictionary will show you verbs. that although they sound the same, they are not at all related. Whoever wrote this should have checked a dic- See also IT'S ME; THAN 1. 4. See AS GOOD OR BETTER THAN. tionary, or an 8th-grade English text: as bad or worse than See AS GOOD OR BETTER THAN. He analyzes the course of Russia's assent to super- power status —Advance Book Information, Oxford University Press, July 1983 as best James J. Kilpatrick, in a column printed in the Portland Oregonian of 2 Nov. 1985, worries about his use of "we must do as best we can"—several of his ascertain As late as Nicholson 1957 we find objection readers had written in to chide him about it. Kilpatrick to the use of ascertain used to mean simply "to find believes "as best we can" to be a respectable idiom but out"; Nicholson insists it must mean "to find out or concedes that it might be a Southern regionalism and learn for a certainty, by experiment, investigation, or wonders if anyone else uses it. The answer is yes. In fact examination." The problem with this insistence is that Bernstein 1977 specifically puts the stamp of approval it depends upon the ways definers in various dictionar- on it: ies have handled ascertain and neglects the far more important question of how good writers have actually It is perfectly proper to say, "He did the job as best used ascertain. Definers may have been influenced by he could." the etymology of the word and a desire to semantically The idiom itself seems to have been little noticed, tie this one surviving sense to older defunct senses. It is although at least one American desk-size dictionary certainly hard to tell, in a great many contexts, the dif- includes it, and Janis 1984 stigmatizes it as nonstan- ference between "finding out or learning" and "finding dard. Our evidence shows that the phrase is not an out or learning for certain." American regionalism. Our oldest citation comes from The objection is of obscure origin, perhaps alluded to sometime in the 19th century, in an excerpt from an as early as 1889 by Walter Pater in his Appreciations. It undated and unpublished manuscript written by Jane seems to have been in its fullest flower in the 1920s: Austen's niece that is included as a footnote in R. W. Whipple 1924 emphasizes "definitely," and in 1927 Chapman's edition of Miss Austen's letters: both Krapp and Emily Post object to its use as simply "find out." These three suggest that the use may have But . . . he then found himself a ruined Man, and been a popular one at the time, and quite likely a con- bound to provide as best he could for his Mother and versational one. Krapp's example—"I will ascertain if Aunt —Caroline Austen, Reminiscences Mr. Jones is free to see you"—is not typical of our examples of written use. But Jane Austen had already Here are some later examples: established the less strenuous use: . . . the one-armed man, conscious of his helpless plight, entrapped in the mêlée, fled as best he might Morland produced his watch, and ascertained the through the familiar intricacies of the old hotel — fact—Nonhanger Abbey, 1818 Charles Egbert Craddock, "The Bushwackers," 1899 . . . they had the advantage of ascertaining from an We must get along as best we can without it —Utter upper window that he wore a blue coat, and rode a 1916 black horse —Pride and Prejudice, 1813 as far as 127 as far as It was thereafter available for other writers to use, and howling monkeys this past week, for all the work I've use it they certainly have: been able to get done —E. B. White, letter, 8 Feb. 1942 It was not difficult for one who knew the city well, to find his house without asking any question. Having The Bikini was originally called the "atome" by M. ascertained its situation . . . —Charles Dickens, A Heim, and the sky was the limit so far as advertising Tale of Two Cities, 1859 it —NY. Times, 20 Feb. 1959 (in Bernstein 1962) The boy crept along under the bank to ascertain Pauls would be taken seriously, they felt, and as far from the nature of the proceedings if it would be pru- as doing business with Germany this was the most dent to interrupt so splendid a creature as Miss Eus- important long-range consideration —James Feron, tacia on his poor trivial account —Thomas Hardy, NY. Times Mag, 31 Oct. 1965 The Return of the Native, 1878 As far as being mentioned in the Ten Command- . . . even went the length of reading the play of "King ments, I think it is —Billy Graham, newspaper col- John" in order to ascertain what it was all about — umn, 1974 George Bernard Shaw, Cashel Byron's Profession, 1886 As far as temperament, the Abyssinian cat is a most affectionate and loving companion —Ruth A. Zim- . . . his whole attention concentrated on ascertaining mermann, Cats Mag, December 1980 by ear what he had been accustomed to judge by sight —C. S. Forester, The African Queen, 1935 Although these examples are characteristic of the con- . . . to catch intermittent glimpses of