Future-Reliance deal: Amazon tells SC that Singapore EA award is valid and needs to be executed

Future-Reliance deal: Amazon tells SC that Singapore EA award is valid and needs to be executed

Singapore’s Emergency Arbitrator (EA) award, restraining Future Retail Ltd (FRL) from going ahead with its Rs 24,713 crore merger deal with Reliance Retail, is “valid” and needs to be executed, Amazon on Tuesday told the Supreme Court which commenced hearings on its pleas against the amalgamation. A bench comprising justices R F Nariman and B R Gavai started hearing the arguments from senior advocate Gopal Subramanium, appearing for Amazon.com NV Investment Holdings LLC, who apprised the apex court of the facts and legal proceedings so far in the case.
The US-based e-commerce giant said the EA award of Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) was enforceable and the single-judge bench of the Delhi High Court rightly gave an interim order in its favour granting a stay on the ongoing amalgamation.
Subramanium said a division bench of the high court erred in entertaining the Future group’s appeal and granting it relief by paving the way for the deal.
Assailing the order, the senior counsel for Amazon said, “the emergency arbitrator (EA) is not a ‘coram non judice’ (not before a judge)” and hence the award of EA is enforceable and the high court under a provision of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act has to act to execute it and not sit in appeal against the interim award.
The top court would recommence hearing on the pleas either on Thursday or next Tuesday.
On February 22, in its interim order the apex court had asked the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) not to pass the final order on the amalgamation.
The Future group had moved the tribunal seeking regulatory approvals to the Rs 24,713 crore deal with Reliance.
Amazon moved the top court against the order of the Delhi High Court division bench which paved the way for the Reliance-FRL deal.
On February 8, the division bench had stayed the single-judge direction to FRL and various statutory authorities to maintain the status quo on the mega deal.
The interim direction was passed on FRL’s appeal challenging the February 2 order of the single judge.
In August last year, the Future group had reached an agreement to sell its retail, wholesale, logistics, and warehousing units to Reliance.
Subsequently, Amazon took FRL into EA before the SIAC over alleged breach of contract by the Future group.
Amazon had first filed a plea before the high court (single judge) for enforcement of the October 25, 2020, EA award by SIAC restraining FRL from going ahead with the deal with Reliance Retail.
The high court division bench had however said that it was staying the single-judge order as FRL was not a party to the share subscription agreement (SSA) between Amazon and Future Coupons Pvt Ltd (FCPL) and the US e-commerce giant was not a party to the deal for amalgamation between FRL and Reliance Retail.
It had further said it was of the prima facie view that the shareholding agreement (SHA) between FRL and FCPL, the SSA between FCPL and Amazon, and the deal between FRL and Reliance Retail “are different” and “therefore, the group of companies doctrine cannot be invoked”.
Another reason given by the court for its interim order was that there was prima facie no reason to seek a status quo order before the single judge.
The high court had said there were a lot of contentious issues involved in the matter and it was not going to adjudicate on them at this stage.
It had also said that its observations were only prima facie and the single judge ought not to be influenced by them when pronouncing the order on Amazon’s plea for enforcement of the EA award by SIAC restraining FRL from going ahead with the deal.
FRL, in its appeal, had claimed that if the February 2 order was not stayed it “would be an absolute disaster” for it as the proceedings before the NCLT for approving the amalgamation scheme have been put on hold.
It had contended that the single judge’s status quo order will effectively derail the entire scheme which has been approved by statutory authorities in accordance with the law.
In its suit before the single judge for enforcing the EA award, Amazon has sought to restrain FRL from taking any steps to complete the transaction with entities that are a part of the Mukesh Dhirubhai Ambani (MDA) Group.
Amazon has also sought detention of the Biyanis, directors of FCPL and FRL and other related parties in civil prison and attaching of their properties for alleged “wilful disobedience” of the EA order.
After the SIAC’s EA order, Amazon wrote to the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), stock exchanges and CCI, urging them to take into consideration the arbitrator’s interim decision as it is a binding order.
FRL thereafter moved the high court to restrain Amazon from writing to Sebi, CCI, and other regulators about SIAC’s order, saying it amounts to interfering with the agreement with Reliance.
A single judge on December 21 last year had on FRL’s plea passed an interim order allowing Amazon to write to the statutory authorities, but also observed that prima facie it appeared the US e-commerce giant’s attempt to control Future Retail was violative of FEMA and FDI rules.
Against the observation, Amazon moved an appeal before a division bench and during its pendency, it filed the suit for the enforcement of the EA award.

News Related


How To Manage Windows 11 Virtual Desktop: Creating, Renaming, Viewing, and MORE!

Windows 11 is Microsoft’s latest computer software. Compared to Windows 10, it offers more advanced features and other functionalities that would make your desktop experience better and smoother. (Photo : ... Read more »

Reddit Rolls Out Feed Similar to TikTok That Compiles Videos From Subreddits You Follow

(Photo : GettlyImages/ SOPA Images ) Reddit app Reddit iOS app is getting an upgrade, and its latest feature is similar to that of TikTok. Most social media platforms are ... Read more »

Fitbit Charge 5 screen and colors shown off in new image leaks

Less than three weeks ago we got our first glimpse at what could be the Fitbit Charge 5, and now new renders have leaked out that give us a much ... Read more »

This weekend's Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 3 and Flip 3 pre-orders could save you $1,500

Looking for a pre-order on the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 3 or Galaxy Z Flip 3? We’ve been tracking deals on both devices since their initial reveal on Thursday and ... Read more »

Despite Covid, Bangalore helps Tesco engineer a success story

If there was one company that did not face any pandemic-related blues last year, it was British retailer Tesco. Online sales went up by 82%, while in-store sales rose 40% ... Read more »

Prosus says Naspers exchange successful, cross-structure deal to proceed

Prosus, the technology investor, said on Friday that all conditions of its offer to buy Naspers shares have been met and a deal to set up a cross-holding structure between ... Read more »

How tech can drive away hiring blues

India’s largest general staffing firm Quess Corp has developed a digital tool to match a blue-collar worker’s skills with the required job profile. The worker – who may be exploring ... Read more »

Industry Veteran Bob Slinn Joins FunPlus as Business Development VP

FunPlus, a world leader in independent mobile game development and publishing, proudly announces having Bob Slinn onboard its senior leadership team as the new Vice President of Business Development. As ... Read more »

2021 Bronco: Ford to replace hardtops after discovering extreme water causes 'unsatisfactory appearance'

Every customer and dealer who has taken possession of a 2021 Ford Bronco with a hardtop will get the tops replaced at no cost because they are beneath company standards ... Read more »

Apple AirPods Pro deals are available for $189.99 this weekend

Those looking for premium true wireless earbuds can find big savings up for grabs right now, with AirPods Pro deals popping up at a range of retailers this weekend. You’ll ... Read more »

Bisexuelle Serien-Vorbilder & leidige Klischees: Hört die neue Folge des Moviepilot-Podcasts Streamgestöber

Wir knöpfen uns im Moviepilot-Podcast Streamgestöber in über 100 Folgen Serien & Filme bei Netflix, Disney+ und Co. vor. In der neuen Folge haben wir die Autorin Nadine Primo zu ... Read more »

To achieve AGI, we need new perspectives on intelligence

This article is part of “,” a series of posts that explore the ethical, moral, and social implications of AI today and in the future. For decades, scientists have tried ... Read more »

Google Announces Stadia's Touch-Focused Game 'Humankind' Release and Fi $400 Discount on Galaxy Flip 3

(Photo : GettlyImages/ SOPA Images ) Google Stadia video games Google Stadia users will be able to try the console’s first-ever touch-focused control scheme, “Humankind,” this month. The game is ... Read more »

Without purpose-built games, PSVR 2 could be a big mistake for Sony

PSVR 2 is official, and with reports stating that Sony’s virtual reality device could hit store shelves as early as Christmas 2022, it’s arriving a lot sooner than the original ... Read more »

Automaker battle over the word 'Cruise' ramps up: Ford wants GM's trademark rights rescinded

The battle over the word “cruise” just got uglier between two Detroit automakers. Less than a month after General Motors sued Ford Motor Co. for trademark infringement over the name ... Read more »

Quantum computing: New breakthrough could set the stage for massive speed boost

Researchers in Japan have made a discovery that could unlock opportunities to combine classical and quantum computing technologies in new ways, resulting in a massive boost in processing power. Spearheaded ... Read more »

The 5 best Amazon deals you can get this weekend

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. It’s the weekend, and that means it’s time to relax—but since ... Read more »

Claim a $50 gift card when you pre-order the Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 at Best Buy

The latest in the line of Samsung watches, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 hits the shelves later this month. You can already pick up an excellent offer on the next ... Read more »

Facebook Messenger is getting end-to-end encryption for calls

End-to-end encryption has arrived for voice and video calls both for Facebook, in a move to probably instill in users the sense of a platform secure from snoopers. Since the ... Read more »

Russian space officials try to blame NASA astronaut for Soyuz air leak in 2018: report

© Provided by Space A closeup image of the suspected drill hole that astronauts discovered in the Soyuz MS-09 spacecraft in 2018. CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — NASA’s head of human ... Read more »

Go read this story of tech workers who secretly work multiple remote jobs

For journalists and others in creative and technical fields, having a side hustle or doing freelance work is extremely common. In addition to a day job an editor, for example, ... Read more »

ICYMI: We listened to Samsung's $150 Galaxy Buds 2

After a brief hiatus, ICYMI is back to give you a helpful summary of all the gadgets and gizmos we’ve put to the test recently. This week, Billy Steele lent ... Read more »

Cloud: Microsoft et Amazon s'affrontent pour un mégacontrat à 10 milliards

© Ted S. Warren/AP/SIPA Cloud: Microsoft et Amazon s’affrontent pour un mégacontrat Les deux géants américains Amazon et Microsoft espèrent remporter un contrat de services de cloud informatique avec l’agence de renseignement ... Read more »

The week in science news: Olympic Bat, controlled qubits, and speeding metal stars

This week’s science news was an eclectic mix of astronomy, conservation, and more trouble for Boeing’s Starliner capsule. There was trouble for Olympic Bat, who was taken down just 127 ... Read more »

Sonic the Hedgehog 2 movie: 8 actors we want to see in future Sonic films

It was an announcement that nobody saw coming. On August 10, Idris Elba – the award-winning actor whose credits include Luther and The Suicide Squad – unexpectedly revealed that he ... Read more »

Dermatologists explain how to choose an SPF lip balm and share their favorite picks

Our editors independently selected these items because we think you will enjoy them and might like them at these prices. If you purchase something through our links, we may earn ... Read more »

Sony's PS5 Trophies might be better than Xbox Achievements now

If you’re a fan of collecting PS5 Trophies, like me, Sony’s upcoming PlayStation 5 system update gives the shiny virtual accolades some much-needed care and attention. In fact, I think ... Read more »

This OLED TV has a great sound system, but I'm too scared to use it

We all know the dream of the packed-out home cinema: a cozy, blackout, soundproofed AV paradise with an amazing 4K TV and speakers belting out cinema-worthy soundtracks and effects. But ... Read more »

Cyber Monday gaming chair deals 2021: what to expect

Cyber Monday gaming chair deals are not to be missed. If you’re looking for a considerable discount on a gaming chair that you’ve had your eye on for some time, ... Read more »

AMD Might've Indirectly Confirmed Their Next-Gen RDNA3 GPUs

AMD still hasn’t announced their next-gen GPUs based on the RDNA3 architecture, but they might’ve just confirmed it indirectly. WCCFTech reports that AMD added support for Navi 31 and Navi ... Read more »

After criticism, Apple to only seek abuse images flagged in multiple nations

Representational image. After a week of criticism over a its planned new system for detecting images of child sex abuse, Apple Inc said on Friday that it will hunt only ... Read more »

PS5 restock Twitter tracker: it's now easier at Walmart, GameStop and Best Buy

The PS5 restock news for 2021 you’ve been waiting for is here, and if you follow our PS5 restock Twitter tracker Matt Swider – and turn on notifications for alerts ... Read more »

Understand Python and all of its programming power with this $30 training bundle

TLDR: The Premium Python Programming Certification Bundle includes 10 courses in everything from Python coding basics to higher functions like machine learning and beyond. Data science fields, including the ultra-hot ... Read more »

iPhone Flip as iPhone 12 Mini's Successor? New Study Shows Foldable Version Could Replace Apple Smartphone's Miniature Version

After a new study revealed that Apple could replace its iPhone 12 Mini with a foldable smartphone model, iPhone Flip could become a reality. (Photo : Screenshot from Twitter post ... Read more »

Battlegrounds Mobile iOS launch date leaked; BGMI iOS set to release on August 20 in India

BGMI will apparently launch on August 20 for iOS Battlegrounds India iOS version release date has been leaked. According to a new report BGMI on iOS will release in India on August ... Read more »