An Officer and a Spy (film)
|An Officer and a Spy|
|Directed by||Roman Polanski|
|Based on||An Officer and a Spy|
by Robert Harris
|Edited by||Hervé de Luze|
|Music by||Alexandre Desplat|
|Box office||$18.9 million|
An Officer and a Spy (French: J'Accuse) is a 2019 historical drama film directed by Roman Polanski about the Dreyfus affair, with a screenplay by Polanski and Robert Harris based on Harris's 2013 novel of the same name. The name J'Accuse has its origins in Émile Zola's bold article in l'Aurore in January 1898 in which the famous author accused many persons of France of continuing to support the increasingly blatantly erroneous accusations against Dreyfus.
The film had its premiere at the 76th Venice International Film Festival on 30 August 2019, winning the Grand Jury Prize and the FIPRESCI Prize. It received twelve nominations for the 45th César Awards, the most nominations of any eligible film, and eventually won the awards for Best Adaptation, Best Costume Design, and Best Director. The film was also nominated in four categories at the 32nd European Film Awards, including for Best Film, Best Director, Best Actor, and Best Screenwriter, ultimately winning none. It received David di Donatello and Polish Film Awards nominations as Best Foreign and Best European film respectively.
In 1894, Alfred Dreyfus, captain of the French army, is found guilty of high treason for passing military secrets to the German Empire. He is degraded and condemned to exile on Devil's Island; his affair triggers a noticeable echo in France since Dreyfus is Jewish. One year later, officer Georges Picquart, former superior of Dreyfus himself, is appointed head of the secret service section in the French army (Deuxième Bureau). The man, despite alleged anti-Semitic sentiments, is aware that the trial against Dreyfus was rather summary and biased by his origin; therefore, noticing some irregularities in the dossier of the affair, he decides to conduct an investigation to verify the man's guilt. Picquart discovers that the so-called bordereau, the document that would prove his guilt, was not written by Dreyfus, as the graphologist Alphonse Bertillon had declared, but by another soldier: Major Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy. According to Picquart, he is the real spy, but the evidence has been prejudiced or even falsified to the detriment of Dreyfus.
Picquart is convinced of Dreyfus' innocence and tries to reopen the trial to exonerate him and arrest Esterhazy, but meets the opposition of his superiors: admitting Dreyfus' innocence would result in a great scandal that would lead to the discovery of corruption in the army, while the man, as a Jew, is the perfect scapegoat. Picquart is then removed from office and sent on a mission far from Paris; However, he manages to return and tell everything to a friend of him, the lawyer Louis Leblois, who begins to organise a committee for the rehabilitation of Dreyfus, involving his colleague Fernand Labori, members of the Parliament and intellectuals, including the famous author Émile Zola.
Picquart's insubordination leads to his arrest, but on the same day Zola publishes in the newspaper L'Aurore the article entitled J'accuse, which would become famous, where he fiercely criticises the irregularities of the trial of Dreyfus and exposes all the people involved in the case. Zola, on a complaint from the government, is tried for defamation and, due to the false declarations made in the courtroom by the soldiers called to witness, the writer is sentenced to one year in prison. While the entire France is divided between innocent and guilty parties, the intellectuals signing the pro-Dreyfus petition are targeted by popular hatred. Later, after losing a duel against Picquart, Lieutenant Colonel Hubert Joseph Henry, who had testified against Dreyfus, admits he gave perjury, only to die shortly after, apparently suicide.
Following Henry's depositions, Picquart is acquitted and released, while Dreyfus is repatriated for a second trial; shortly before the decisive hearing, the lawyer Labori suffers an assassination attempt and is unable to defend Dreyfus. The man is sentenced again, but the sentence to be served is made lighter by the recognition of the extenuating circumstances. In 1899, the Prime Minister grants Dreyfus a pardon. Picquart would like to continue fighting to prove his innocence, but Dreyfus, exhausted, accepts it. Seven years later there will be full acquittal and reintegration into the army.
In 1907, Picquart is appointed Minister of War, also thanks to the recognition of the judicial error to the detriment of him. Dreyfus asks him for an audience and protests because the years in which he has unfairly served his sentence have not been recognised, preventing him from reaching the rank of lieutenant colonel. Picquart cannot make this concession to him as the political climate has changed again, which causes Dreyfus' outrage. The two men greet each other with respect, never to see each other again.
- Jean Dujardin as Colonel Georges Picquart
- Louis Garrel as Captain Alfred Dreyfus
- Emmanuelle Seigner as Pauline Monnier
- Grégory Gadebois as Hubert-Joseph Henry
- Hervé Pierre as Charles-Arthur Gonse
- Wladimir Yordanoff as Auguste Mercier
- Didier Sandre as Raoul Le Mouton de Boisdeffre
- Melvil Poupaud as Fernand Labori
- Éric Ruf as Jean Sandherr
- Mathieu Amalric as Alphonse Bertillon
- Laurent Stocker as Georges-Gabriel de Pellieux
- Vincent Perez as Louis Leblois
- Michel Vuillermoz as Armand du Paty de Clam
- Vincent Grass as Jean-Baptiste Billot
- Laurent Natrella as Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy
- Bruno Raffaelli as Juge Delegorgue
- Pierre Poirot as officier Vallecalle
- Paulo Henrique as officer of état major
- Stefan Godin as General Darr
- Luca Barbareschi as Philippe Monnier
- Mohammed Lakhdar-Hamina as Bachir
- Luce Mouchel as Madame Sandherr
- Fabien Tucci as Sûreté agent
- Franck Mercadal as Capitaine Calmont
- Philippe Magnan as Attorney Brisset
- Pierre Forest as Colonel Maurel
- Jeanne Rosa as Martha Leblois
- Benoît Allemane as Georges Charpentier
- Ludovic Paris as Arthur Ranc
- Gérard Chaillou as Georges Clemenceau
- Nicolas Bridet as Mathieu Dreyfus
- André Marcon as Émile Zola
- Jean-Marie Frin as President of the Jury
- Swan Starosta as Lucie Dreyfus
- Thierry Gimenez as Colonel Jouaust
- Denis Podalydès as Maître Demange
Robert Harris was inspired to write the novel by his friend Polanski, who has long had an interest in the Dreyfus affair. Harris followed the novel with a script of the same story, titled D, with Polanski announced as director in 2012.
This film was the third occasion Harris has worked with Polanski. Harris previously co-wrote The Ghost Writer with Polanski, which was also an adaptation of one of Harris's novels, The Ghost. The two first worked together in 2007 on a film adaptation of Harris's novel Pompeii, which was cancelled just before filming due to a looming actors' strike.
Although set in Paris, the film was first scheduled to shoot in Warsaw in 2014, for economic reasons. Production was postponed after Polanski moved to Poland for filming, and the US government filed extradition papers. The Polish government eventually rejected them. By that point, new French film tax credits had been introduced, which allowed the film to shoot on location in Paris.
The film was budgeted at €60m and was next set to start production in July 2016, but its production was postponed again while Polanski waited on the availability of a star, whose name was never announced.
The film had its world premiere at the Venice Film Festival on 30 August 2019. At the Venice Film Festival, the film won the Grand Jury Prize. It was released in France on 13 November 2019, and in Italy on 21 November 2019.
An Officer and a Spy holds 76% approval rating on review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, based on 33 reviews, with an average of 6.7/10. On Metacritic, the film holds a rating of 56 out of 100, based on 9 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews". The film received a standing ovation during its premiere in Venice. David Sexton, writing for the Evening Standard, gave the film a rating of 4 out of 5, declaring that: "It's an absolute masterclass in how to make a historical film".
Polanski's attendance at the Venice Film Festival was his first appearance at a major film event since he was expelled from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences in May 2018. During the festival, the head of the jury Lucrecia Martel stated: "I don't separate the man from the art. I think that important aspects of the work emerges in the man. [...] A man who commits a crime of this size who is then condemned, and the victim considers herself satisfied with the compensation is difficult for me to judge... It is difficult to define what is the right approach we have to take with people who have committed certain acts and were judged for them. I think these questions are part of the debate in our times." Martel also stated she would not attend a gala dinner in support of the film. Polanski's producers threatened to pull the film from the festival lineup. Martel later clarified her comments, stating: "According to some reports after today's press conference, I believe my words were deeply misunderstood. Since I don't separate the work from the author and I have recognized a lot of humanity in Polanski's previous films, I am not opposed to the presence of the film in competition. I don't have any prejudice towards it and of course I will watch the film like any other in the competition. If I had any prejudice, I would have resigned my duty as the president of the jury." Alberto Barbera, the festival director of Venice, had previously defended the film being in the lineup, stating: "We are here to see works of art, not to judge the person behind it. I hope we can just discuss about the quality of the film and not about Polanski and the case with L.A. County."
U.S. distribution companies rejected invitations to a buyers' presentation during the Cannes Film Festival. Howard Cohen of Roadside Attractions stated: "I think we would consider it, though I'm not even sure how I personally feel. People have been releasing his films for years. Now, we are looking at it through a different lens, with good reason. We have to search our souls if it's the right thing to do. What does it mean to release this movie? I don't think that's a settled question even in my mind."
In November 2019, five days before the official release of An Officer and a Spy in France, Polanski faced accusations of rape by a French woman, Valentine Monnier. Upon the release, French feminist groups invaded or blockaded several cinemas, having the film cancelled in some places.
When the film was nominated for 12 César Awards in January 2020, women's groups said that the French film academy was acclaiming "an abuser and rapist on the run". Eventually, Polanski as well as other crew members of An Officer and a Spy did not attend the 45th César Awards ceremony. No one was there to accept the awards on Polanski's behalf. The César Award for Best Director to Polanski was poorly received by the audience. Several people walked out in disgust, including Best Actress nominee Adèle Haenel.
|Award||Date of Ceremony||Category||Recipient(s)||Result||Ref|
|César Awards||28 February 2020||Best Film||An Officer and a Spy||Nominated|||
|Best Director||Roman Polanski||Won|
|Best Actor||Jean Dujardin||Nominated|
|Best Supporting Actor||Grégory Gadebois||Nominated|
|Best Adaptation||Roman Polanski and Robert Harris based on the novel by Robert Harris||Won|
|Best Cinematography||Paweł Edelman||Nominated|
|Best Editing||Hervé de Luze||Nominated|
|Best Sound||Lucien Balibar, Aymeric Devoldère, Cyril Holtz and Niels Barletta||Nominated|
|Best Original Music||Alexandre Desplat||Nominated|
|Best Costume Design||Pascaline Chavanne||Won|
|Best Production Design||Jean Rabasse||Nominated|
|Bodil Awards||8 May 2021||Best Non-American Film||An Officer and a Spy||Nominated|||
|David di Donatello Awards||3 April 2020||Best Foreign Film||An Officer and a Spy||Nominated|||
- "Biennale Cinema 2019 | J'accuse". La Biennale di Venezia. 19 July 2019.
- Keslassy, Elsa (18 November 2019). "An Officer and a Spy Leads French Box Office Despite Roman Polanski Controversy".
- "An Officer and Spy". Box Office Mojo. Retrieved 21 December 2021.
- "J'accuse – Awards". imdb.com. Retrieved 14 August 2020.
- Anthony, Andrew (29 September 2013). "Robert Harris: 'Whenever a crowd is running one way, I run the other'". The Guardian. Retrieved 8 September 2018.
- "Roman Polanski to Direct Dreyfus Affair Drama 'D'". Hollywoodreporter.com. Retrieved 8 September 2018.
- McClintock, Pamela (9 May 2012). "Roman Polanski to Direct Dreyfus Affair Drama 'D'". The Hollywood Reporter. Archived from the original on 13 May 2012.
- Variety 1 February 2007: Polanski propels 'Pompeii'. Retrieved 30 January 2012
- Rotten Tomatoes 12 September 2007: Roman Polanski Flees Pompeii. Retrieved 30 January 2012
- Mr. Beaks (5 March 2010). "Mr. Beaks Interrogates The Ghost Writer Novelist-Screenwriter Robert Harris!". Ain't It Cool News. Retrieved 5 March 2011.
- "Polanski wants to make next movie in Poland". Archived from the original on 23 November 2016.
- "Polanski tournera " Dreyfus " en France". 24 October 2016.
- "Polański delays filming of spy thriller". Archived from the original on 5 April 2016.
- "Jean Dujardin on Instagram: "Au boulot! 1er jour de tournage de #jaccuse de #romanpolanski @robertharrishome #colonel #mariegeorgespicquart"". Instagram. Archived from the original on 24 December 2021.
- "Jean Dujardin on Instagram: "Fin de tournage! Merci à toute l'équipe. #jaccuse de #romanpolanski photo @guyferrandis"". Instagram. Archived from the original on 24 December 2021.
- AlloCine. "J'accuse : Jean Dujardin chez Roman Polanski pour son film sur l'affaire Dreyfus".
- Vivarelli, Nick (25 July 2019). "Joker, Ad Astra, The Laundromat, Marriage Story to Compete in Venice". Variety. Retrieved 25 July 2019.
- "Venezia 76 Competition". labiennale.org. 25 July 2019. Retrieved 25 July 2019.
- Anderson, Ariston. "Venice: Todd Phillips' 'Joker' Wins Golden Lion, Roman Polanski Wins Silver Lion". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 8 September 2019.
- "J'Accuse". Gaumont Film Company. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- "L'ufficiale e la spia". 01 Distribution. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- "The Dreyfus Affair (2019)". Rotten Tomatoes. Fandango. Retrieved 10 October 2021.
- "An Officer and a Spy Reviews". Metacritic. Retrieved 21 November 2019.
- Ulivi, Stefania (30 August 2019). "Venezia 2019, Roman Polanski: "Io come Dreyfus". Applausi al suo film "J'accuse"". Corriere della Sera.
- "Venezia 76, applausi a 'J'accuse' di Polanski. Dujardin: "Un grande film diretto da un regista-sciamano"". www.repubblica.it.
- Satta, di Gloria (31 August 2019). "Festival del cinema, Polanski oltre le polemiche elogi e applausi per il suo J'accuse". ilmessaggeroit.
- "An Officer and a Spy: Masterclass in how to make an historical film". Evening Standard. 30 August 2019.
- Pulver, Andrew (1 October 2018). "Social media outrage over Roman Polanski film J'Accuse". The Guardian. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Grisar, PJ (6 September 2019). "Does Roman Polanski's New Film Make The Dreyfus Affair About Him?". The Forward. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Sugarman, Daniel (5 September 2019). "Why we should not be watching Roman Polanski's film on the Dreyfus Affair". The Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Barfield, Charles (28 August 2019). "Venice Jury President Lucrecia Martel Has Complicated Feelings About Polanski's Inclusion: "I Don't Separate The Man From The Art"". The Playlist. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Anderson, Ariston (28 August 2019). "Venice Jury Head Lucrecia Martel Says Polanski Has Right to Be in Lineup but She Won't Celebrate Him". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Anderson, Ariston; Roxborough, Scott (29 August 2019). "Venice: Roman Polanski's Producers Threaten to Pull Film After Jury President's Comments". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Vivarelli, Nick (29 August 2019). "Venice: Producer Considered Withdrawing Roman Polanski's Film After Jury President's Remarks". Variety. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Tartaglione, Nancy (28 August 2019). "Venice Jury President Lucrecia Martel Clarifies Comments On Roman Polanski: No Prejudice Against Competition Film 'An Officer And A Spy'". Deadline Hollywood. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Anderson, Ariston (25 July 2019). "Venice Chief Alberto Barbera Defends Lack of Women Directors, Roman Polanski Inclusion in Lineup". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Siegel, Tatiana; Roxborough, Scott (20 May 2019). "Cannes: Roman Polanski Film Gets Secret Presentation for Buyers". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Barfield, Charles (24 May 2019). "Woody Allen & Roman Polanski Are Both Getting The Cold Shoulder From US Distributors For Their New Films". The Playlist. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Sperling, Nicole (24 May 2019). ""Who Would Want to Spend Their Time on That?": Hollywood Weighs New Releases from Woody Allen and Roman Polanski". Vanity Fair. Retrieved 2 November 2019.
- Chrisafis, Angelique (29 January 2020). "Outrage as Polanski film nominated for 12 'French Oscars'". The Guardian. Retrieved 4 March 2020.
- Roxborough, Scott (27 February 2020). "Roman Polanski Will Not Attend Cesar Awards". The Hollywood Reporter.
- Césars : Roman Polanski désigné meilleur réalisateur, Les Misérables meilleur film
- Willsher, Kim (1 March 2020). "Polanski's 'Oscar' divides elite world of French cinema". The Guardian.
- Portrait of A Lady On Fire Star Adèle Haenel Storms Out of Awards Show After Roman Polanski Wins
- Roxborough, Scott (28 February 2020). "'Les Miserables' Wins Best Film at Cesar Awards, Polanski Takes Best Director". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 24 March 2022.
- "Årets Bodilnomineringer er ude!". City Lights Filmblog (in Danish). 27 February 2021. Retrieved 24 March 2022.
- "Accademia del Cinema Italiano - Premi David di Donatello". www.daviddidonatello.it. Retrieved 24 March 2022.