Has there been a fake movie from a real movie turned into a real movie. : r/movies Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/movies icon
r/movies icon
Go to movies
r/movies
A banner for the subreddit

The goal of /r/Movies is to provide an inclusive place for discussions and news about films with major releases. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. Read our extensive list of rules for more information on other types of posts like fan-art and self-promotion, or message the moderators if you have any questions.


Members Online

Has there been a fake movie from a real movie turned into a real movie.

Discussion

Like in the movie Tropic Thunder, what if they actually made that fake movie into a real movie. I’m not saying I want that movie, but was discussing this with a friend and we both wondered if that has been done before. We both were thinking of movies where they were making a fake movie and it spiralled into this. So I ask you people of Reddit, has this been done before.

Edit: So this idea we had was a fictional behind the scenes making of movie (not documentary) of a fake movie. Then that fake movie would be released after the BTS movie.

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options

grindhouse's fake trailers have almost all become real films at this point. most recently, thanksgiving. machete and hobo with a shotgun were the others.

u/melcolnik avatar

We’re just missing Edgar Wright’s “Don’t” and Rob Zombie’s “Werewolf Women of the SS”

Edgar wright making a weird modern version of the living dead at manchester morgue would be sick.

But... He did.

No, that was Westchester. It all blew over.

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies

I am extremely upset that we never got Werewolf Women of the SS.

u/CalmPanic402 avatar

...With Nicolas Cage as Fu Manchu!

😳

I can't watch the video at this moment, I'm on public transport

More replies

I'm still waiting for "The Night the Reindeer Died" from the beginning of Scrooged.

"You've been a real good boy this year, Lee"

more replies More replies
u/DasGanon avatar

There is Ilsa, She Wolf of the SS. But it's not that good

It does have a piss fetish scene, though

more replies More replies
more replies More replies
More replies

IIRC Zombie said he shot enough material to make a short movie. The world needs more Cage as Fu Manchu.

u/ANALOGPHENOMENA avatar

Edgar Wright has expressed that he has no interest in making a full version of “Don’t” because he said “all the best bits are already in the trailer”.

More replies
u/ZombieJesus1987 avatar

I'm legitimately surprised Rob Zombie hasn't made "Werewolf Women of the SS" yet

More replies

Hobo with a shotgun was surprisingly pretty good. Perfectly captured that bizarre, nihilistic 80s low budget exploitation film feeling

It also perfectly captured the kind of movie Rutger Hauer made practically his whole career. Outside of a handful of big budget films, Hauer almost never turned down a paycheck.

And yet he delivered one of the best monologues in film history IMO

u/stunafish avatar

Two of the best lol.

  1. Tears in the rain

  2. Hobo addressing the maternity ward

more reply More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
u/Rasselkurt007 avatar
Edited

Did not realize Hobo with a shotgun came from there

it was actually the fake trailer that came with the real movie version of machete. And machete started as a fake trailer before planet terror.

Hobo with a Shotgun only played in before the Grindhouse movie in the US iirc, the rest of the world apparently didn’t have it. 

Even with Robb Wells in it? I would've figured it was a Canadian film.

more replies More replies
more replies More replies
u/Rasselkurt007 avatar

That is what wiki says “it is based on the faux-trailer of the same title featured in the Robert Rodriguez and Quentin Tarantino film Grindhouse (2007).“

more replies More replies
More replies

Oh shit me neither

More replies

I was sad they didn’t make Thanksgiving take place in the 70’s and look like an old movie similar to the original trailer.

More replies
u/Lcbrito1 avatar

On that note, since this wan't what OP asked, but is still somewhat relevant, the Deadpool movie that came after Ryan leaked a CGI trailer of his Deadpool as a nod to: "hey I can do this, help me make it happen, people of the world"

Whaaaaat? Ryan didn't leak it! No one actually officially knows hoe it got leaked. *wink wink

More replies
u/TheSoulessWanderer avatar

Thanksgiving got a movie!!???? WHAT!?

u/SupaKoopa714 avatar

Yeah, just last year, it's a really fun slasher flick.

More replies
More replies
u/Theweddingfunker avatar

Oh man I remember when Attack of the Show, showed the trailer for Hobo with a Shotgun. Really tripped me out, years later when I heard it was going to become a legit movie.

More replies

Buzz Lightyear from Toy Story.

u/Athlete-Extreme avatar

Nothing disturbed me more about this movie more than the fact that they marooned Buzz. Not only that but they made him a screw up. The movie was such a bummer lol

What gets me is they actively didn’t want to be anything like the cartoon show because Lasseter apparently hated it.

Lasseter had been out of the company for 6 years now. He wasn't at Pixar when Lightyear was being developed.

more replies More replies

That's the funny thing-- that cartoon was 100% believable as a show that tied in with the toy and the bed sheets, etc. Buzz was even rendered in the same art style as he was on the back of the box.

Can anybody honestly look at the toy, the merch, and the commercial from Toy Story 1 and tell me that looks like merchandise for the Lightyear movie? Or that Andy would go see that movie and get hooked on it? Or that the movie even reads as something that would come out in 1995? Lol no way

Yeah, the movie itself was actually pretty decent, but the themes and story are all very modern. The 1990s just weren’t doing LGBT relationships in mainstream movies (let alone kids movies,) and the plots tended to be a lot more straightforward with clear hero and villain. The bitter, old Buzz as the villain just didn’t feel very 90s: that plot became popular in the 2010s (The Flash tv show and movie, Lego Movie 2, etc.)

more replies More replies
more replies More replies
u/Lin900 avatar

But Lasseter hated Lightyear

Lasseter: “Don’t make Buzz Lightyear of Star Command.”

makes Lightyear

Lasseter: “No, not like that.”

More replies

Pearls before fucking swine I swear

More replies
u/BeerBrat avatar

There was absolutely nothing about that flick that would lead to Andy wanting that toy. What we wanted was a space adventure action flick. What we got was navel gazing about mortality.

More replies
u/TheJoshider10 avatar

Not only that but they made him a screw up.

Ah the classic Disney formula of butchering beloved legacy heroes, never gets old!

More replies

Oh man that was a good movie and the series that followed was one of my favorites as well. Buzz Light-year of Star Command had a pretty good story if I remember correctly.

My first thought as well

More replies
u/AlumGrizzly avatar

There had to have been someone in the production of McBain asking if it was a Simpsons movie.

Edited

Someone on YouTube did make a super cut of all the clips in to one 5-10 min episode.

Edit: McBain movie high quality

MENDOZAAAAAAA!!!

u/zrayburton avatar

That’s amazing

More replies

Not really. If you're talking about the Christopher Walken movie McBain, at least, that came out in 1991, same year as the first Simpsons bit. It's likely to have just been a coincidence with the naming

More replies

I'm still waiting for Angels with Filthy Souls

“You've been smoochin' with everybody! Snuffy, Al, Leo, Little Moe with the gimpy leg, Cheeks, Boney Bob, Cliff.”

u/joshua182 avatar

"Its a lie!".

I burst into laughter just reading that. It’s my favourite line in all of Home Alone

More replies
u/bkm007 avatar

“I could go on forever baby”

More replies
u/mutebathtub avatar

The name is a spoof on the real movie, Angels with Dirty Faces.

Great film too 

More replies
More replies

‘Keep the change you filthy animal’

I'm still waiting for Hamlet from Last Action Hero.

NOT TO BE!

More replies
More replies
u/Dominicsjr avatar

Such a fun Easter egg when it’s reused in Detective Pikachu.

And then we need the porn version, angels with filthy soles

And then we need the porn version, angels with filthy soles

We can get Tarantino to direct.

More replies
More replies
u/caffeinatedlackey avatar

Not a movie, but the fake show MILF Island from 30 Rock basically became a reality show last year with MILF Manor on HBO.

u/coolpapa2282 avatar

Give Netflix enough time and we'll get Black Frasier too.

It’s on nbc every Thursday around 9 or 9:15.

u/_TLDR_Swinton avatar

This sherry's not the only thing that's fruity and precocious.

u/elpaco313 avatar

This joke. It’s amazing.

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
u/Seahearn4 avatar

If we're doing TV shows, Chapelle's Show had the skit "Trading Spouses" as a spoof of Trading Spaces. And then the series Wife Swap premiered a couple years later. And there might have been a competing show about the same time actually called Trading Spouses, but I might be wrong about that.

Ted lasso also started out as a commercial

u/prylosec avatar

Fox came out with Trading Spouses: Meet Your New Mommy in 2004, a year after the Chappelle Show skit.

More replies
More replies
u/SwedishLovePump avatar

I’m still waiting for Celebrity Homonym.

“No, it’s the other one“

More replies
More replies

Sadly the world's not ready for bitch hunter.

u/Ok-Fig6407 avatar

And the point of MILF Island was that it was a ridiculous idea and yet, here we are.

More replies
More replies
u/skrilledcheese avatar

Fingers crossed for Cleaver from the sopranos.

Forget Many Saints. Cleaver is the Sopranos movie we all wanted.

A couple years ago someone posted a poster from Cleaver on r/saw and some people thought it was a real upcoming sequel lol

u/chiefs_fan37 avatar

They did a mockumentary making of Cleaver video. It’s on YouTube. It’s so funny

More replies
u/dontrespondever avatar

I must be loyle to my capo. 

More replies
u/imapassenger1 avatar