What To Watch If You Love 'In the Dark'

watchworthy
Updated May 8, 2024 50 items
Ranked By
311 votes
98 voters
Voting Rules
Vote up the films and television series that you know other fans of 'In the Dark' will love.

Wondering what to watch after In The Dark? If the lighthearted drama of the series has you hungry for more whodunits with a twisted sense of humor, you're in luck! Since the public fascination with mystery shows is not ceasing any time soon, there are loads of other movies and TV shows like In The Dark ready for you to start bingeing.  

If you’re on the hunt for movies and TV shows similar to In The Dark, Veronica Mars is a great TV series about a high school student trying to solve her best friend's murder. Dead to Me is another great show, following a grieving widow as she searches for answers.  

For fans of In The Dark looking for good movie recommendations, Brick is an excellent film that moves a film noir style to a high school setting. Other good movies and shows featured on this list include Russian Doll, Zero Effect, and Search Party. 

If you have a favorite movie or TV series like In The Dark on this list, give the project a thumbs up!  

With more than 40 million people visiting Ranker every month, we are able to offer you data-driven recommendations based on voting across thousands of film & TV polls. 

  • Prodigal Son
    Photo: Fox
    1
    16 VOTES

    Prodigal Son

    Prodigal Son is a psychological thriller that delves into the twisted relationship between a criminal psychologist, Malcolm Bright (Tom Payne), and his notorious serial killer father, Dr. Martin Whitly (Michael Sheen). With a compelling storyline, this gripping series explores the complexities of family dynamics while maintaining an air of suspense throughout. The show has garnered critical acclaim for its talented ensemble cast, including standout performances by Bellamy Young and Lou Diamond Phillips. Nominated for several awards, Prodigal Son consistently keeps viewers on the edge of their seats as it masterfully navigates the murky waters of morality and the haunting legacy of a murderous past.
    16 votes
    More Prodigal SonRight Arrow
  • Dead to Me
    Photo: Dead to Me / Netflix
    2
    50 VOTES

    Dead to Me

    In a tale of friendship and dark secrets, Dead to Me delivers a compelling narrative that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. This critically acclaimed dark comedy series has garnered multiple award nominations, including an Emmy nod for its lead actress Christina Applegate. The plot revolves around the unlikely bond formed between two grieving women, Jen (Applegate) and Judy (Linda Cardellini), as they navigate through loss, deception, and the pursuit of justice. With each episode unveiling new twists, Dead to Me expertly weaves humor and heartbreak, creating a unique viewing experience that resonates with audiences.
    50 votes
    More Dead to MeRight Arrow
  • Stumptown
    Photo: Stumptown
    3
    7 VOTES

    Stumptown

    In the vibrant city of Portland, Oregon, a tenacious private investigator takes center stage in a thrilling yet grounded crime drama. Stumptown, inspired by the graphic novel series, follows Dex Parios (Cobie Smulders) as she navigates her complex personal life while solving cases with grit and determination. Balancing action-packed sequences with moments of heartfelt emotion, the show has garnered critical acclaim, earning a Satellite Award nomination for Best Television Series. With a strong ensemble cast, including Jake Johnson as Grey McConnell and Michael Ealy as Detective Miles Hoffman, Stumptown offers viewers a refreshing take on the genre, blending mystery and humor seamlessly.
    7 votes
    More StumptownRight Arrow
  • Imposters
    Photo: Imposters
    4
    27 VOTES

    Imposters

    A beautiful con artist leaves a trail of broken hearts until her former targets decide to retaliate.
    27 votes
  • You
    Photo: You
    5
    17 VOTES

    You

    A dangerously charming man falls in love with women and inserts himself into their lives.
    17 votes
    More YouRight Arrow
  • Search Party
    Photo: Search Party
    6
    8 VOTES

    Search Party

    In a subtle yet intriguing fusion of dark comedy and mystery, Search Party has managed to carve its own niche in the television landscape. The show, which has garnered critical acclaim and a dedicated fan base, follows the journey of Dory Sief (Alia Shawkat) as she becomes entangled in a perplexing missing person case. As Dory's obsession intensifies, her circle of friends, played by a talented ensemble cast, find themselves amidst a whirlpool of unexpected twists and turns. Praised for its sharp writing and impeccable performances, Search Party offers an engrossing tale that masterfully unravels the complexities of human nature while exploring themes of identity, purpose, and the pursuit of truth.
    8 votes
    More Search PartyRight Arrow
  • Veronica Mars
    Photo: Hulu
    7
    18 VOTES

    Veronica Mars

    Set against the sunny backdrop of Neptune, California, Veronica Mars intricately weaves together elements of mystery, drama, and dark humor. The show follows the story of a tenacious high school student, Veronica Mars (Kristen Bell), who moonlights as a private investigator under the guidance of her father, Keith Mars (Enrico Colantoni). Throughout its three-season run, the series garnered critical acclaim, securing numerous award nominations for its intelligent storytelling, sharp wit, and engaging character development. As Veronica tackles an array of complex cases, audiences are drawn into the twists and turns of each investigation while also witnessing the challenges she faces in her personal life.
    18 votes
    More Veronica MarsRight Arrow
  • Roswell, New Mexico
    Photo: Roswell, New Mexico
    8
    17 VOTES

    Roswell, New Mexico

    In the sleepy town of Roswell, New Mexico, a gripping tale of love, mystery, and otherworldly secrets unfolds. This sci-fi drama series brings together an ensemble cast delivering powerful performances, with the likes of Liz Ortecho (Jeanine Mason) and Max Evans (Nathan Parsons) taking center stage. As characters navigate through their entwined destinies, viewers are treated to a compelling narrative that delves into themes of loyalty, identity, and sacrifice. The show has garnered critical acclaim for its engaging storytelling and strong character development, earning it a dedicated fan base. With each passing episode, the stakes are raised, making Roswell, New Mexico an unmissable journey into the unknown.
    17 votes
    More Roswell, New MexicoRight Arrow
  • Fargo
    Photo: Fargo
    9
    7 VOTES

    Fargo

    Venturing into the frosty landscape of Minnesota, this darkly humorous crime drama weaves a complex web of deception and violence. With each season presenting a self-contained narrative inspired by the Coen Brothers' original film, viewers are immersed in the entangled lives of its multidimensional characters. Among them, Lorne Malvo (Billy Bob Thornton) embodies pure chaos, leaving a trail of destruction in his wake. The series has garnered critical acclaim for its exceptional storytelling and stellar performances, resulting in numerous award nominations, including Emmys and Golden Globes. Fargo's distinct blend of wit, suspense, and intricate plotlines ensures a memorable viewing experience without compromising on substance.
    7 votes
    More FargoRight Arrow
  • The End of the F***ing World
    Photo: The End of the F...ing World
    10
    4 VOTES

    The End of the F***ing World

    The End of the Fing World, a dark comedy-drama series, invites viewers on an unexpected journey alongside two misfit teenagers, James (Alex Lawther) and Alyssa (Jessica Barden), as they embark on a chaotic road trip. The critically acclaimed show, based on Charles Forsman's graphic novel, explores themes of love, loss, and self-discovery while balancing both humor and heartbreak. With its talented ensemble cast and captivating storytelling, the series has garnered numerous accolades, including a British Academy Television Award nomination for Best Drama Series. The End of the Fing World masterfully navigates the complexities of adolescence and human connection, leaving audiences eager for more.
    4 votes
    More The End of the F***ing WorldRight Arrow
  • Happy!
    Photo: Happy!
    11
    5 VOTES

    Happy!

    In a world where dark humor and twisted fantasy collide, the television series Happy! offers viewers a refreshing and unconventional viewing experience. The show follows the journey of Nick Sax (Christopher Meloni), a former detective turned hitman, as he navigates the gritty underbelly of crime in New York City. Accompanied by his newfound companion, an animated blue unicorn named Happy (voiced by Patton Oswalt), the duo embarks on a quest to save a young girl from peril. This Syfy original series has earned critical acclaim for its brilliant blend of noir-inspired storytelling, captivating visuals, and gripping performances. With a Primetime Emmy nomination for Outstanding Original Main Title Theme Music, Happy! proves that it's not your average crime drama.
    5 votes
    More Happy!Right Arrow
  • Ozark
    Photo: Ozark/ Netflix
    12
    3 VOTES

    Ozark

    In the shadowy world of financial crime, Ozark weaves a gripping narrative that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. This critically acclaimed drama series, with multiple Emmy and Golden Globe nominations to its name, follows the perilous journey of Marty Byrde (Jason Bateman) as he navigates the treacherous waters of money laundering for a ruthless drug cartel. Alongside his resourceful wife Wendy (Laura Linney), the couple encounters an array of complex characters and dangerous situations in the seemingly tranquil lakeside town. With its masterful storytelling and captivating performances, Ozark offers a thrilling exploration of morality, family dynamics, and the consequences of one's actions.
    3 votes
    More OzarkRight Arrow
  • Scream Queens
    Photo: Scream Queens
    13
    14 VOTES

    Scream Queens

    In a striking fusion of horror and comedy, Scream Queens delivers a refreshing take on the slasher genre. Set within the enigmatic halls of a prestigious college, viewers follow a group of sorority sisters as they navigate a sinister world filled with dark secrets and masked killers. With an ensemble cast led by Emma Roberts (Chanel Oberlin) and Jamie Lee Curtis (Dean Cathy Munsch), the show's witty dialogue and clever plot twists have garnered it multiple award nominations, including a Golden Globe nod for Curtis. As the mystery unfolds, audiences are left guessing who will survive and who is behind the bloodcurdling terror.
    14 votes
    More Scream QueensRight Arrow
  • Russian Doll
    Photo: Russian Doll
    14
    12 VOTES

    Russian Doll

    In an intricately woven narrative, Russian Doll offers a fresh take on the comedy-drama genre. The Emmy-nominated series follows the life of Nadia Vulvokov (Natasha Lyonne), as she finds herself caught in a seemingly endless loop of her own 36th birthday party. With each cycle, the protagonist uncovers deeper layers of her past and personal growth, while grappling with the perplexing nature of her situation. As the show progresses, viewers are treated to a clever mix of humor and introspection, complemented by an outstanding performance from Lyonne. Russian Doll masterfully explores themes of self-discovery, redemption, and the intricacies of human connection, leaving audiences eager for more.
    12 votes
    More Russian DollRight Arrow
  • Psych
    Photo: USA Network
    15
    4 VOTES

    Psych

    In the realm of crime-solving comedies, Psych stands out as a refreshing take on the genre. With eight seasons under its belt, this USA Network series garnered a loyal fan base and multiple award nominations. The show follows the adventures of Shawn Spencer (James Roday Rodriguez), a clever yet quirky amateur sleuth with an uncanny ability to solve crimes by posing as a psychic detective. Alongside his level-headed best friend, Burton "Gus" Guster (Dulé Hill), the duo tackles cases for the Santa Barbara Police Department, often employing unconventional methods. The show's charm lies in its witty banter, clever plotlines, and endearing characters, making it a must-watch for fans of lighthearted detective stories.
    4 votes
    More PsychRight Arrow
  • Emergence
    Photo: Emergence
    16
    13 VOTES

    Emergence

    Emergence, an intriguing mystery drama, delves into the life of a police chief who stumbles upon a young girl near the site of a mysterious accident. The unfolding narrative reveals an enigmatic web of conspiracy and secrets, as the chief, Jo Evans (Allison Tolman), works tirelessly to protect the child from unknown forces. With its skillful blend of thrilling suspense and emotional depth, the show has garnered critical acclaim for its engaging storytelling and strong performances. Among its accolades, Emergence has been nominated for the Saturn Award for Best Network Television Series, showcasing its impact within the television landscape.
    13 votes
  • Bones
    Photo: Fox
    17
    2 VOTES

    Bones

    Dr. Temperance Brennan uses impressive forensics skills to solve murders.
    2 votes
    More BonesRight Arrow
  • Fargo
    Photo: Fargo
    18
    7 VOTES

    Fargo

    Fargo, a dark comedy-crime film, is an unforgettable journey into the frozen heart of Minnesota. Jerry Lundegaard (William H. Macy), a car salesman in Minneapolis, hatches a desperate scheme involving his wife and two bumbling criminals, Carl Showalter (Steve Buscemi) and Gaear Grimsrud (Peter Stormare). The plan backfires when it attracts the attention of Marge Gunderson (Frances McDormand), the pregnant police chief of Brainerd. McDormand won an Oscar for her portrayal of Gunderson, whose tenacious investigation unravels the plot amidst the snow-swept landscapes. The film's unique blend of horror and humor has earned it a cult following and multiple awards, including two Academy Awards.
    7 votes
    More FargoRight Arrow
  • New Tricks
    Photo: New Tricks
    19
    7 VOTES

    New Tricks

    Detective Sandra Pullman heads the Unsolved Crime and Open Case Squad.
    7 votes
  • Castle
    Photo: Castle
    20
    7 VOTES

    Castle

    In a thrilling blend of crime-solving and wit, the highly acclaimed television series Castle follows the unconventional partnership between mystery novelist Richard Castle (Nathan Fillion) and no-nonsense NYPD Detective Kate Beckett (Stana Katic). Their dynamic chemistry unfolds over eight seasons as they work together to unravel New York City's most perplexing cases. Lauded for its engaging storylines and memorable characters, the show earned multiple nominations from the Primetime Emmy Awards and People's Choice Awards. Castle's unique combination of suspense, humor, and evolving relationships keeps viewers engaged through its eight seasons.
    7 votes
    More CastleRight Arrow
  • Private Eyes
    Photo: user uploaded image
    21
    5 VOTES

    Private Eyes

    Private Eyes is the tenth studio album by Hall & Oates, released in 1981. The album includes two #1 hits—the title track, "Private Eyes" and "I Can't Go for That", as well as the top ten hit "Did It in a Minute". "I Can't Go for That" also spent a week at the top of the R&B charts—a rare accomplishment for a white band.
    5 votes
  • Death in Paradise
    Photo: Death in Paradise
    22
    3 VOTES

    Death in Paradise

    A detective inspector is transferred from London to the island of Saint-Marie in the Caribbean.
    3 votes
    More Death in ParadiseRight Arrow
  • Daybreak
    Photo: Daybreak
    23
    5 VOTES

    Daybreak

    In a post-apocalyptic world where zombies, known as "ghoulies," roam the earth, Daybreak stands out with its dark humor and unique storytelling approach. The show follows high school outcast Josh Wheeler (Colin Ford) as he navigates this new reality, seeking to find his missing girlfriend Sam Dean (Sophie Simnett). Alongside him are an eclectic group of survivors, including former bully Wesley Fists (Austin Crute) turned pacifist samurai and 10-year-old pyromaniac Angelica Green (Alyvia Alyn Lind). With its coming-of-age narrative and genre-bending style, Daybreak has garnered a dedicated fanbase, despite its unfortunate cancellation after just one season. The show's inventive take on the apocalypse, combined with its engaging ensemble cast, leaves a lasting impression on viewers.
    5 votes
    More DaybreakRight Arrow
  • What We Do in the Shadows
    Photo: FX
    24
    5 VOTES

    What We Do in the Shadows

    Delving into the realm of the supernatural with a comedic twist, What We Do in the Shadows offers viewers an amusing look at the lives of four vampire roommates navigating the modern world. This mockumentary-style series, based on the 2014 film by Jemaine Clement and Taika Waititi, has garnered critical acclaim and multiple award nominations for its witty writing and engaging performances. The eccentric ensemble, led by Nandor (Kayvan Novak), Laszlo (Matt Berry), Nadja (Natasia Demetriou), and Colin Robinson (Mark Proksch), brings to life the peculiarities of immortal beings attempting to blend into contemporary society, resulting in countless laugh-out-loud moments and memorable character interactions.
    5 votes
    More What We Do in the ShadowsRight Arrow
  • Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
    Photo: Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
    25
    5 VOTES

    Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

    Chilling Adventures of Sabrina offers a dark and enchanting twist on the classic teenage witch tale, drawing viewers into its bewitching world. This supernatural drama series has garnered critical acclaim, with numerous award nominations to its name. The story follows Sabrina Spellman (Kiernan Shipka), a half-witch, half-mortal, as she navigates the treacherous realms of magic, high school, and family ties. Alongside her friends and powerful aunts, Sabrina faces sinister forces that threaten both her mortal and magical existence. The show masterfully blends horror elements with coming-of-age themes, making it a must-watch for fans of the genre.
    5 votes
    More Chilling Adventures of SabrinaRight Arrow
  • American Vandal
    Photo: American Vandal
    26
    5 VOTES

    American Vandal

    American Vandal, a true-crime mockumentary series, skillfully satirizes the ever-growing fascination with crime documentaries. The show unravels fictional high school crimes, such as the notorious spray-painted phallic symbols in its debut season. With clever humor and surprisingly engaging storytelling, audiences are taken on a journey through the twists and turns of each case. The series features characters like aspiring documentarian Peter Maldonado (Tyler Alvarez) and the accused prankster Dylan Maxwell (Jimmy Tatro), both delivering outstanding performances. Garnering several award nominations, including a Peabody Award, American Vandal masterfully balances comedy and intrigue, leaving viewers eager for more.
    5 votes
    More American VandalRight Arrow
  • Agatha Raisin
    Photo: Agatha Raisin
    27
    4 VOTES

    Agatha Raisin

    Amateur sleuth Agatha Raisin investigates eight entertaining murder mysteries.
    4 votes
    More Agatha RaisinRight Arrow
  • Room 104
    Photo: Room 104
    28
    4 VOTES

    Room 104

    Set within the confines of a seemingly ordinary hotel room, Room 104 explores the captivating stories that unfold behind closed doors. Each episode delves into the lives of the diverse characters who temporarily inhabit the space, revealing their secrets and desires. The anthology series has garnered praise for its innovative storytelling approach, seamlessly blending genres such as drama, comedy, and horror. Notable performances include Jay Duplass as Jim, a man grappling with his past, and Natalie Morales as Anne, an estranged daughter seeking closure. With its ever-changing narrative, Room 104 keeps viewers intrigued and invested in the tales that unravel within these four walls.
    4 votes
    More Room 104Right Arrow
  • Nancy Drew
    Photo: Nancy Drew
    29
    9 VOTES

    Nancy Drew

    Mystery and intrigue come together in a modern adaptation of a classic literary character, Nancy Drew. This thrilling series follows the adventures of the clever young detective, Nancy Drew (Kennedy McMann), as she navigates through the secrets and shadows of her seemingly idyllic hometown. With a strong ensemble cast and a compelling narrative, the show has garnered critical acclaim, earning nominations for prestigious awards such as the Saturn Awards and Teen Choice Awards. As viewers delve deeper into the enigmatic world of Nancy Drew, they are treated to an engaging blend of supernatural elements, suspenseful twists, and complex relationships that keep them invested in the story without revealing too much.
    9 votes
    More Nancy DrewRight Arrow
  • Eerie, Indiana
    Photo: Lionsgate
    30
    2 VOTES

    Eerie, Indiana

    Eerie, Indiana is a cult classic series that centers on Marshall Teller, a teenager who moves to the small town of Eerie, which he soon discovers is the epicenter of weird and supernatural occurrences. Alongside his friend Simon, Marshall investigates the strange happenings, from residents who don't age to dogs that form a secret society. The show combines elements of horror, science fiction, and comedy as it explores themes of suburban life and the peculiar underbelly of American culture. Though it had a short run, Eerie, Indiana has since been praised for its creativity and ahead-of-its-time storytelling approach, and gaining a dedicated following.
    2 votes
    More Eerie, IndianaRight Arrow