The Greatest Arizona Diamondbacks of All Time

Ranker Sports
Updated May 2, 2024 40.3K views 54 items
Ranked By
15.1K votes
1.8K voters
15 reranks
Voting Rules
Please only rank the players based on their time with the Diamondbacks

This is a list of the greatest Arizona Diamondbacks ever. Along with the Tampa Bay Rays, the Arizona Diamondbacks are baseball's youngest franchise. However, this doesn't mean that the franchise is devoid of talent or Hall of Fame players. In 2001, the club made history when it defeated the New York Yankees in seven games to win its first World Series after only three years of existence. Many of the best players in Diamondbacks history were on that championship team including two of the best Diamondbacks ever in pitchers Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling. The Diamondbacks dynamic duo almost singlehandedly mowed down hitters en route to the franchise's only championship. They are considered two of the greatest pitchers of their generation and the city was fortunate to have them as members of the Arizona Diamondbacks roster for years.

Luis Gonzalez is considered the greatest hitter to don Diamondbacks colors. Like the rest of the franchise, Gonzalez's best season came in 2001 when he had an eye-opening 57 home runs, 142 RBIs along with 100 walks. Looking to follow in Gonzalez's footsteps is Diamondbacks first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. Already one of baseball's feared hitters, Goldschmidt's breakout 2013 campaign landed him a berth in the All Star game in only his third season. He is already considered one of the greatest Diamondbacks to play the game. 

This list of the greatest Arizona Diamondbacks players of all time encompasses the club's greatest players in its short history. If you see someone missing from this list, free to add him. Vote the Arizona Diamondbacks player who you consider to be the best in its history.

Most divisive: Mark Trumbo
Over 1.8K Ranker voters have come together to rank this list of Arizona Diamondbacks
  • Randy Johnson
    1
    1,312 votes

    A towering force on the mound, Randy Johnson struck fear into the hearts of opposing batters throughout his illustrious 22-year career, particularly during his unforgettable time with the Arizona Diamondbacks. Known as "The Big Unit," Johnson's menacing presence, devastating fastball, and wicked slider combined to make him one of the most dominant pitchers in MLB history, while his top-tier work ethic and fierce competitiveness exemplified the spirit of a true champion. Forever remembered for his pivotal role in bringing the Diamondbacks their first and only World Series title in 2001, Johnson's legacy as an all-time great remains rooted in the deserts of Arizona.

  • Paul Goldschmidt
    2
    1,067 votes

    Arguably the best position player to have donned a Diamondbacks uniform, Paul Goldschmidt's steady and powerful offensive prowess made him a constant threat whenever he stepped into the batter's box. A model of consistency, "Goldy" demonstrated an uncanny ability to spray line drives to all fields while possessing the pure power to send titanic blasts beyond the outfield fences. In addition to his offensive talents, Goldschmidt was a slick fielder at first base, making him an invaluable cornerstone for the Diamondbacks during his tenure in Arizona.

  • Luis Gonzalez
    3
    969 votes

    Forever etched in Arizona sports lore for his iconic walk-off single to clinch the 2001 World Series, Luis Gonzalez's storied tenure with the Diamondbacks went far beyond that one magical moment. A five-time All-Star with a sweet swing that produced both gaudy home run totals and a high batting average, Gonzalez was the quintessential middle-of-the-lineup threat that pitchers dreaded facing. As much a leader in the clubhouse as he was a force on the field, "Gonzo" consistently demonstrated the heart and determination that made him a beloved figure among Diamondbacks fans.

  • Curt Schilling
    4
    873 votes

    As half of the legendary "one-two punch" atop the Diamondbacks' rotation alongside Randy Johnson, Curt Schilling's masterful command of the strike zone and diverse arsenal of pitches made him a formidable force on the mound. Famed for his ability to elevate his performance in the most crucial moments, Schilling's postseason heroics are the stuff of legend, particularly in the Diamondbacks' thrilling 2001 World Series run. Though his tenure in Arizona was relatively brief, Schilling's indelible impact and laser-focused intensity continue to be remembered fondly by fans in the Valley of the Sun.

  • Zack Greinke
    5
    383 votes

    A consummate professional with a methodical approach to his craft, Zack Greinke was a shining example of how skill and intelligence combine to create dominance on the mound. With a cerebral style that kept hitters guessing, Greinke's pinpoint control and exceptional pitch selection made him a puzzle few could solve. Though his time with the Diamondbacks was a rollercoaster ride at times, Greinke's superb talent and unrelenting work ethic leave an undeniable mark on the franchise's history.

  • Steve Finley
    6
    624 votes

    A graceful and athletic center fielder with a penchant for spectacular defensive plays, Steve Finley was a vital contributor during the Diamondbacks' formative years, both at the plate and in the field. With the speed to cover significant ground and a smooth, consistent swing that generated power and contact alike, Finley was a reliable force throughout his tenure in Arizona. Often lauded for his clutch performances and steady demeanor, Finley played an integral role in the Diamondbacks' rapid rise to prominence and eventual World Series success.

  • David Peralta
    7
    186 votes

    Exemplifying the essence of perseverance through his journey from pitcher to outfielder, David Peralta's relentless drive and passion for the game have made him a fan favorite in Arizona. With his infectious energy and natural hitting ability, Peralta has emerged as a cornerstone of the Diamondbacks' lineup, consistently delivering clutch hits and impressive power displays. Additionally, his tireless work ethic and dedication to improving his craft have made Peralta a shining beacon for teammates and fans alike.

  • Brandon Webb
    8
    574 votes

    Featuring a devastating sinker that left countless batters shaking their heads in disbelief, Brandon Webb carved out a brilliant, if tragically shortened, career as one of the most dominant pitchers in Diamondbacks history. With his uncanny ability to induce groundouts and limit damage, Webb became a fixture atop the Arizona rotation, making batters dread their encounters with him. While injuries ultimately forced an early end to Webb's career, his place among the Diamondbacks' all-time greats is more than secure.

  • Matt Williams
    9
    533 votes

    A veteran leader with prodigious power at the plate, Matt Williams provided stability and guidance during the Diamondbacks' early years, helping to establish a winning culture for the young franchise. Boasting a flair for clutch hits and dramatic moments, Williams made his impact felt both in the batter's box and in the clubhouse. Though his time in Arizona was brief compared to other stops in his career, Williams' contributions to the Diamondbacks' success are not to be underestimated.

  • Craig Counsell
    10
    423 votes

    Though his tenure with the Diamondbacks was short-lived, Craig Counsell left an indelible mark on the franchise's history through his gritty play and vital contributions to the team's 2001 championship run. Renowned for his distinctive batting stance and unrelenting effort on the field, Counsell epitomized determination and clutch performances in the face of adversity. Though he'd go on to enjoy greater individual success elsewhere, Counsell's time in Arizona remains an essential chapter in the annals of Diamondbacks lore.

  • Ketel Marte
    11
    111 votes

    A versatile and dynamic force on the field, Ketel Marte has quickly become a fan favorite in Arizona due to his impressive hitting ability and seemingly endless range. Capable of playing multiple positions, Marte's adaptability adds significant value to the Diamondbacks lineup while his potent switch-hitting prowess makes him a constant threat at the plate. As he continues to grow into one of the game's brightest young stars, Marte's name is sure to be increasingly etched into the annals of Diamondbacks history.

  • Max Scherzer
    12
    260 votes

    Though he would go on to reach dizzying heights of success elsewhere, Max Scherzer's initial emergence as a dominant force in the majors occurred in the desert heat of Arizona. With a live arm and a tenacious approach on the mound, Scherzer showcased the raw talent that would eventually make him one of the game's premier pitchers. Though his stay with the Diamondbacks was brief, Scherzer's time in Arizona laid the groundwork for his remarkable ascent to pitching stardom.

  • Patrick Corbin
    13
    253 votes

    A master of deception and guile on the mound, Patrick Corbin utilized his wide-ranging repertoire of pitches to keep opposing hitters off-balance throughout his tenure with the Diamondbacks. With a strong work ethic and a keen understanding of the game, Corbin emerged as a rock-solid contributor in the Arizona rotation. Though his time in the desert came to an end when he departed via free agency, Corbin's relentless pursuit of excellence remains a hallmark of his Diamondbacks career.

  • Robbie Ray
    14
    157 votes

    Robbie Ray

    Age: 32

    An electric pitcher with a penchant for producing eye-popping strikeout numbers, Robbie Ray's energetic presence on the mound made him a central figure in the Diamondbacks' rotation during his time with the team. With a lively fastball and an array of secondary pitches that kept hitters guessing, Ray was always capable of providing a jolt to the Arizona pitching staff. As he continues to build on his career, Ray's time with the Diamondbacks serves as a foundation for his ongoing success.

  • Tony Womack
    15
    367 votes

    A speedy, dynamic presence at the top of the lineup, Tony Womack was an essential catalyst for the Diamondbacks during their early years, using his quickness and contact skills to set the table for the sluggers who followed. Adept at getting on base and wreaking havoc once there, Womack embodied the term "spark plug" throughout his tenure in Arizona. With a penchant for coming up big in crucial moments, Womack's impact on the Diamondbacks' rapid rise to success remains undeniable.

  • Mark Grace
    16
    503 votes
    Age: 59

    A consummate professional with a smooth swing and an uncanny knack for getting on base, Mark Grace brought a wealth of experience and a winning attitude to the fledgling Diamondbacks franchise. Though his most prolific years came in a different uniform, Grace's contributions to the Diamondbacks' surprise championship run in 2001 cannot be overstated. Revered as much for his leadership and steadying presence as for his on-field exploits, Grace's time with the Diamondbacks stands as a testament to the value of veteran wisdom and poise.

  • A.J. Pollock
    17
    457 votes

    A gifted athlete with a rare combination of power, speed, and defensive acumen, A.J. Pollock consistently provided a spark for the Diamondbacks throughout his tenure in the desert. Capable of impacting games in numerous ways, Pollock's well-rounded skill set made him an invaluable contributor on both sides of the ball. Although injuries occasionally slowed his progress, Pollock's immense talent and relentless determination left an indelible mark on the franchise.

  • Justin Upton
    18
    549 votes

    Blessed with prodigious power and natural athleticism, Justin Upton emerged as a key figure in the Diamondbacks' lineup during his time in Arizona. With a smooth swing that generated tape-measure home runs and a confident demeanor on the field, Upton was a perennial offensive force who kept opposing pitchers on their toes. As one of the team's most electrifying players from his era, Upton's impact on the Diamondbacks remains unmistakable.

  • Gerardo Parra
    19
    247 votes

    The epitome of hustle and heart, Gerardo Parra endeared himself to Diamondbacks fans through his tireless effort and uncanny knack for making impressive plays in the outfield. Known for his cannon-like arm and exceptional range, Parra frustrated opposing hitters by routinely taking away extra-base hits. In addition, his solid contact skills and speed on the basepaths made him a valuable contributor in the lineup, solidifying his status as a beloved figure in Diamondbacks history.

  • Ian Kennedy
    20
    261 votes

    A steady hand in the Diamondbacks rotation, Ian Kennedy brought a fire and determination to the mound that endeared him to both teammates and fans alike. With a diverse arsenal of pitches and an innate ability to mix speeds, Kennedy consistently kept opposing hitters off-balance during his time in Arizona. While not the flashiest player on the team, Kennedy's dependability and calming presence played a key role in the Diamondbacks' success.

  • Byung-hyun Kim
    21
    258 votes

    A unique and unforgettable presence on the mound, Byung-hyun Kim blazed a trail for Korean players in the majors with his unorthodox submarine pitching style. As the Diamondbacks' closer during their 2001 World Series run, Kim generated excitement and intrigue each time he took the mound. Despite some postseason struggles, Kim's raw talent and trailblazing efforts have cemented his place in Arizona baseball lore.

  • Mark Reynolds
    22
    318 votes

    With prodigious power and a flair for the dramatic, Mark Reynolds quickly became a staple of the Diamondbacks' lineup during his time with the team. Capable of launching jaw-dropping home runs with ease, Reynolds was an offensive force who kept opposing pitchers honest. However, his aggressive approach often led to high strikeout totals, making him a polarizing figure whose impact on the Diamondbacks remains a topic of spirited debate.

  • Jay Bell
    23
    372 votes
    Age: 58

    A veteran leader and consummate professional, Jay Bell provided a steady presence in the Diamondbacks' lineup during the team's early years. Known for his impressive contact skills, timely hitting, and smooth defense at second base, Bell proved to be an essential piece of the puzzle as the Diamondbacks vaulted to prominence. Though his tenure in Arizona was relatively brief, Bell's contributions to the young franchise's rapid success are not to be understated.

  • Miguel Montero
    24
    339 votes

    A reliable backstop with a potent bat, Miguel Montero solidified his status as one of the game's best catchers during his tenure with the Diamondbacks. Skilled at handling a pitching staff and providing timely hits, Montero was a vital component of the team's success in the late 2000s and early 2010s. His memorable home run in the 2011 postseason further cemented his legacy as a clutch performer and fan favorite in Arizona.

  • Reggie Sanders
    25
    215 votes

    A versatile and impactful presence on the field, Reggie Sanders made the most of his brief time with the Diamondbacks, playing a pivotal role in their 2001 championship run. With speed, power, and a keen eye at the plate, Sanders was a key cog in the potent Arizona lineup. Though his tenure in the desert was short, Sanders' important contributions to the franchise's crowning achievement remain etched in the hearts of Diamondbacks fans.

  • Chris Young
    26
    370 votes

    With an enticing blend of athleticism and raw power, Chris Young quickly became a fixture in the Diamondbacks' outfield during the late 2000s. Capable of making highlight-reel catches and launching tape-measure home runs, Young's impressive skill set tantalized both teammates and fans alike. As time goes on, Young's name remains synonymous with a dynamic brand of baseball that thrilled supporters throughout his time in Arizona.

  • Stephen Drew
    27
    299 votes

    A smooth-fielding shortstop with a penchant for timely hits, Stephen Drew brought stability and consistency to the Diamondbacks' lineup for much of the late 2000s and early 2010s. With a strong arm and impressive range, Drew consistently flashed the leather while also chipping in offensively with gap-to-gap power and contact skills. Despite injuries hampering his progress at times, Drew's steady presence left a lasting impact on the Diamondbacks franchise.

  • J. J. Putz
    28
    201 votes
    Age: 47

    With a towering presence and a fearsome fastball, J.J. Putz provided a sense of security in the late innings for the Diamondbacks during his tenure as the team's closer. Exuding confidence and poise on the mound, Putz consistently slammed the door on opposing rallies, cementing his status as a key component of Arizona's pitching staff. Though his time with the team was relatively brief, Putz's contributions to the Diamondbacks' success during the early 2010s are not to be forgotten.

  • Bob Brenly
    29
    84 votes
    Age: 70

    As the manager who guided the Arizona Diamondbacks to their first and only World Series title, Bob Brenly holds a special place in the hearts of fans in the desert. A master strategist with a knack for bringing the best out of his players, Brenly steered the ship through adversity and triumph alike during his tenure in the dugout. With a legacy centered around the pinnacle moment of franchise history, Brenly's impact on the Diamondbacks cannot be overstated.

  • Aaron Hill
    30
    237 votes
    Age: 42

    A gritty, hard-nosed player who left it all on the field, Aaron Hill quickly endeared himself to Diamondbacks fans with his passionate play and clutch hitting. Capable of providing both power and contact at the plate, Hill proved to be an essential cog in the Arizona lineup throughout his tenure. With a knack for stepping up in big moments and a tireless work ethic, Hill's time with the Diamondbacks remains a testament to the value of determination and grit.