What To Watch If You Love 'Carnival Row'

watchworthy
Updated May 10, 2024 30 items
Ranked By
636 votes
168 voters
Voting Rules
Vote up the films and television series that you know other fans of 'Carnival Row' will love.

Wondering what to watch after Carnival Row? If the dark fantasy of the series has you hungry for more dramas featuring mythical creatures, you're in luck! Since the public fascination with neo-noir crime dramas is not ceasing any time soon, there are loads of other movies and TV shows like Carnival Row ready for you to start bingeing. 

If you’re on the hunt for movies and TV shows similar to Carnival Row, Penny Dreadful is a great TV series featuring popular Gothic fiction characters, like Dorian Gray, Count Dracula, and Henry Jekyll. True Blood is another great show that explores relationships between humans and mythical creatures.

For fans of Carnival Row looking for good movie recommendations, Pan's Labyrinth is an excellent film that features a twisted fairy tale. Other good movies and shows featured on this list include Grimm, Mortal Engines, and Crimson Peak. 

If you have a favorite movie or TV series like Carnival Row on this list, give the project a thumbs up! 

With more than 40 million people visiting Ranker every month, we are able to offer you data-driven recommendations based on voting across thousands of film & TV polls. 

  • Penny Dreadful
    Photo: Penny Dreadful / Showtime
    1
    48 VOTES

    Penny Dreadful

    This Showtime series is the perfect pick for those that are looking for more grim storytelling after finishing Carnival Row.

    Venturing into the dark recesses of Victorian London, this Gothic horror series masterfully weaves together classic literary figures with a chilling narrative that keeps viewers on edge. With its ensemble cast led by the enigmatic Vanessa Ives (Eva Green), Penny Dreadful delves into the supernatural world, unearthing creatures and legends that lurk in the shadows. The show has garnered acclaim for its superb acting, atmospheric cinematography, and rich storytelling, earning several awards and nominations throughout its three-season run. Seamlessly blending psychological drama with visceral horror, Penny Dreadful offers an immersive experience that lingers long after the credits roll.
    48 votes
    More Penny DreadfulRight Arrow
  • His Dark Materials
    Photo: His Dark Materials / BBC, HBO
    2
    47 VOTES

    His Dark Materials

    If magically inspired storytelling is your jam after finishing Carnival Row, you should absolutely check out His Dark Materials and the multiple-reality narrative it presents.

    His Dark Materials, an enthralling adaptation of Philip Pullman's beloved trilogy, weaves a rich tapestry of fantasy, drama, and adventure. The series has garnered critical acclaim and numerous award nominations, including British Academy Television Awards and Primetime Creative Arts Emmy Awards. Set in a parallel universe, the story follows the courageous Lyra Belacqua (Dafne Keen) and her shape-shifting daemon companion, Pantalaimon, as they embark on a perilous journey to uncover the truth about a mysterious substance called "Dust." Alongside a diverse cast of characters, such as the enigmatic Lord Asriel (James McAvoy) and the cunning Mrs. Coulter (Ruth Wilson), the show expertly explores themes of personal discovery, loyalty, and the battle between good and evil.
    47 votes
    More His Dark MaterialsRight Arrow
  • The Witcher
    Photo: The Witcher / Netflix
    3
    80 VOTES

    The Witcher

    If you're in the mood for a high fantasy series after finishing Carnival Row, this series based on the best selling video game series is a great choice. 

    In a realm of magic and monsters, The Witcher presents a complex tale of destiny, love, and power. As an adaptation of Andrzej Sapkowski's critically acclaimed novels, this fantasy series has garnered immense praise for its intricate storytelling and phenomenal acting. At the heart of the narrative is Geralt of Rivia (Henry Cavill, Liam Hemsworth), a skilled monster-hunter who navigates through political intrigue and supernatural dangers. Alongside him, powerful sorceress Yennefer of Vengerberg (Anya Chalotra) and young princess Ciri (Freya Allan) embark on their own transformative journeys. With its rich character development and immersive world-building, this show has earned multiple award nominations, solidifying itself as a must-watch for fans of the genre.
    80 votes
    More The WitcherRight Arrow
  • Pan's Labyrinth
    Photo: Pan's Labyrinth / Warner Bros. Pictures
    4
    20 VOTES

    Pan's Labyrinth

    In 1944 Spain young Ofelia (Ivana Baquero) and her ailing mother (Ariadna Gil) arrive at the post of her mother's new husband (Sergi López), a sadistic army officer who is trying to quell a guerrilla uprising. While exploring an ancient maze, Ofelia encounters the faun Pan, who tells her that she is a legendary lost princess and must complete three dangerous tasks in order to claim immortality.
    20 votes
    More Pan's LabyrinthRight Arrow
  • The Alienist
    Photo: The Alienist
    5
    24 VOTES

    The Alienist

    This gripping and dark period drama based on the novel of the same name is the perfect pick to binge for fans of Carnival Row.

    A journalist tries to solve a series of murders in New York City in 1896.
    24 votes
    More The AlienistRight Arrow
  • Crimson Peak
    Photo: Universal Pictures
    6
    20 VOTES

    Crimson Peak

    This gothic romance film is the perfect rainy day movie for fans of Carnival Row to curl up to if they're looking for a love story with a bit more depth.

    In the haunting, Gothic movie Crimson Peak, Edith Cushing (Mia Wasikowska), an aspiring author, finds herself torn between love for her childhood friend and the allure of a mysterious outsider. After an unexpected tragedy, she's drawn to the enigmatic Thomas Sharpe (Tom Hiddleston), leading her to his home, a decaying mansion atop a blood-red clay hill. As she explores this eerie place with its ghostly inhabitants, including Sharpe's sister Lucille (Jessica Chastain), Edith begins to uncover dark secrets deeply buried in Crimson Peak. It's a chilling tale of love and betrayal, wrapped in spectral whispers and shadowy dread.
    20 votes
    More Crimson PeakRight Arrow
  • Locke & Key
    Photo: Netflix
    7
    33 VOTES

    Locke & Key

    If you loved the weirdness of Carnival Row, you're going to love this supernatural series based on a comic series of the same name.

    Locke & Key, a supernatural drama series, unravels the tale of the Locke family as they uncover enigmatic keys in their ancestral home. These keys possess extraordinary powers, while also attracting sinister forces. Nina Locke (Darby Stanchfield) and her children, Tyler (Connor Jessup), Kinsey (Emilia Jones), and Bode (Jackson Robert Scott), navigate through this thrilling adventure, balancing their daily lives with the secrets lurking in Keyhouse Manor. Adapted from a popular graphic novel series by Joe Hill and Gabriel Gabriel Rodríguez, the show has garnered critical acclaim for its engaging storytelling and stellar performances, earning it multiple award nominations.
    33 votes
    More Locke & KeyRight Arrow
  • Grimm
    Photo: Grimm / NBC
    8
    29 VOTES

    Grimm

    If you're a fan of Carnival Row's weird vibe, Grimm's twisted take on fairy tales is going to be right up your alley.

    Nick, a warrior known as a Grimm, protects Portland from dangerous creatures known as Wesen.
    29 votes
    More GrimmRight Arrow
  • Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
    Photo: Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
    9
    29 VOTES

    Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

    Dark, twisted and well written, this Netflix iteration of Sabrina goes in deep with her magical roots and is wickedly entertaining.

    Chilling Adventures of Sabrina offers a dark and enchanting twist on the classic teenage witch tale, drawing viewers into its bewitching world. This supernatural drama series has garnered critical acclaim, with numerous award nominations to its name. The story follows Sabrina Spellman (Kiernan Shipka), a half-witch, half-mortal, as she navigates the treacherous realms of magic, high school, and family ties. Alongside her friends and powerful aunts, Sabrina faces sinister forces that threaten both her mortal and magical existence. The show masterfully blends horror elements with coming-of-age themes, making it a must-watch for fans of the genre.
    29 votes
    More Chilling Adventures of SabrinaRight Arrow
  • The Magicians
    Photo: Syfy
    10
    29 VOTES

    The Magicians

    Lev Grossman's sexy magic school comes alive in this darkly funny fantasy series and is a perfect binge after you've finished Carnival Row.

    The Magicians invites viewers into a world where magic is real, and the consequences are often unpredictable. This fantasy series, based on Lev Grossman's novels, follows the journey of Quentin Coldwater (Jason Ralph) and his friends as they navigate the challenges of attending Brakebills University for Magical Pedagogy. With its intricate plotlines, the show explores themes of friendship, power, and the complexities of adulthood. The Magicians has been praised for its diverse ensemble cast and its willingness to tackle dark subject matter, earning it a dedicated fan base and nominations for Saturn Awards throughout its five-season run.
    29 votes
    More The MagiciansRight Arrow
  • American Gods
    Photo: American Gods / Starz
    11
    29 VOTES

    American Gods

    This fantasy drama series based on the novel of the same name by Neil Gaiman is a great pick if you love the storytelling in Carnival Row.

    In a compelling exploration of myth and modernity, American Gods masterfully weaves a tale of old deities struggling to survive in a world that has forgotten them. The critically acclaimed fantasy drama, based on Neil Gaiman's lauded novel, has garnered numerous awards for its unique storytelling and exceptional performances. With an ensemble cast led by the enigmatic Mr. Wednesday (Ian McShane) and his reluctant human companion Shadow Moon (Ricky Whittle), viewers are taken on a cross-country odyssey through the hidden realms of ancient gods and the rising tide of contemporary deities. The show skillfully balances its rich narrative with visually stunning cinematography, captivating audiences without revealing too much of its divine secrets.
    29 votes
    More American GodsRight Arrow
  • The Originals
    Photo: The Originals / The CW
    12
    22 VOTES

    The Originals

    This Vampire Diaries spin-off is a great series to binge after finishing Carnival Row and The Vampire Diaries.

    The remaining members of the original vampire family move to New Orleans to reclaim the city.
    22 votes
    More The OriginalsRight Arrow
  • Castlevania
    Photo: Netflix
    13
    21 VOTES

    Castlevania

    In a harmonious marriage of historical fiction and supernatural fantasy, Castlevania weaves a tale that is both dark and riveting. This animated television series, based on the popular video game franchise, has garnered critical acclaim and several award nominations for its intricate storytelling and visually stunning animation. At the heart of the narrative lies Trevor Belmont (voiced by Richard Armitage), a skilled monster hunter from a disgraced family, who reluctantly joins forces with sorceress Sypha Belnades (Alejandra Reynoso) and Dracula's son Alucard (James Callis). Together, they embark on a perilous journey to confront the malevolent force threatening humanity — the legendary vampire himself, Count Dracula (Graham McTavish). Through its exploration of complex character relationships and meticulously crafted world-building, Castlevania masterfully transports viewers into an enthralling realm where darkness and danger lurk at every turn.
    21 votes
    More CastlevaniaRight Arrow
  • Supernatural
    Photo: The CW
    14
    32 VOTES

    Supernatural

    The fantasy show that seemingly never ends, Supernatural's massive backlog of episodes is the perfect library to lose yourself after finishing Carnival Row.

    Supernatural, a thrilling journey of two brothers combating otherworldly forces, has managed to captivate audiences for over a decade. The engaging storyline follows Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean Winchester (Jensen Ackles) as they confront demons, angels, and creatures that lurk in the shadows. With its seamless blend of drama, horror, and humor, the show has garnered numerous accolades, including multiple People's Choice Awards. Throughout its 15-season run, Supernatural has remained true to its core themes of family, sacrifice, and the battle between good and evil, while continuously evolving to keep viewers on the edge of their seats.
    32 votes
  • Mortal Engines
    Photo: Universal Pictures
    15
    14 VOTES

    Mortal Engines

    Hundreds of years after a cataclysmic event destroyed civilization, mysterious young Hester Shaw emerges as the only one who can stop the city of London -- now a giant predator on wheels -- from devouring everything in its path. Feral and fiercely driven by the memory of her mother, Hester joins forces with Tom Natsworthy, an outcast from London, and Anna Fang, a dangerous outlaw with a bounty on her head.
    14 votes
    More Mortal EnginesRight Arrow
  • True Blood
    Photo: True Blood / HBO
    16
    26 VOTES

    True Blood

    This sexy fantasy drama series was released in the late 2000s vampire crazy and remains one of the only good things to come out of that sparkly, sparkly time. 

    Vampires walk the Earth using synthetic blood.
    26 votes
    More True BloodRight Arrow
  • Sleepy Hollow
    Photo: Fox
    17
    8 VOTES

    Sleepy Hollow

    If you're craving some spooky storytelling after finishing Carnival Row, this modern take on The Legend of Sleepy Hollow is a great choice.

    In a modern-day retelling of Washington Irving's classic tale, Sleepy Hollow delivers an enthralling blend of mystery, horror, and fantasy. This critically acclaimed series has garnered numerous award nominations, showcasing the exceptional talents of its ensemble cast. The plot revolves around the resurrection of Ichabod Crane (Tom Mison), who finds himself in contemporary times, tasked with preventing the apocalypse alongside Lieutenant Abbie Mills (Nicole Beharie). With captivating storytelling and a richly layered mythology, Sleepy Hollow seamlessly weaves historical events and figures into its narrative, providing viewers with a thrilling adventure that keeps them on the edge of their seats.
    8 votes
    More Sleepy HollowRight Arrow
  • The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance
    Photo: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance / Netflix
    18
    10 VOTES

    The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance

    This high fantasy Netflix show is the perfect world to get lost in after finishing Carnival Row and is a great lead in to the 1982 film The Dark Crystal.

    In a realm of mysticism and wonder, The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance transports viewers to the world of Thra. This fantasy television series, prequel to the 1982 film, has garnered critical acclaim, earning a Primetime Emmy Award for its outstanding children's program. Embarking on an epic quest, three Gelflings - Rian (Taron Egerton), Brea (Anya Taylor-Joy), and Deet (Nathalie Emmanuel) - unite to save their world from the sinister Skeksis. With masterful puppetry, a rich narrative, and an ensemble voice cast, this enchanting show weaves tales of heroism, friendship, and the power of unity in the face of adversity.
    10 votes
    More The Dark Crystal: Age of ResistanceRight Arrow
  • The Order
    Photo: Netflix
    19
    20 VOTES

    The Order

    If magic, mythical beasts and secret societies are your jam, this Netflix series is an absolute must-watch after finishing Carnival Row.

    In the realm of supernatural drama, The Order sets itself apart with a compelling narrative that delves into the mystical world of secret societies and dark magic. With a talented ensemble cast led by Jack Morton (Jake Manley), viewers are treated to a gripping journey as he navigates his newfound powers and uncovers hidden truths within Belgrave University. Recognized for its engaging storytelling and strong performances, the series earned a nomination for Best New Fiction at the C21 International Drama Awards. As secrets unravel and alliances shift, The Order maintains a balance of suspense, intrigue, and character development, leaving audiences eager for more.
    20 votes
    More The OrderRight Arrow
  • Midnight, Texas
    Photo: Midnight, Texas
    20
    12 VOTES

    Midnight, Texas

    This shortlived supernatural series featuring a vampire, a witch, a half-demon AND a werecreature is a great choice for fans of Carnival Row that are looking for something easy to watch. 

    Midnight, Texas is a supernatural drama series that premiered on July 24, 2017. The show, based on Charlaine Harris' book series, centers around the remote town of Midnight, Texas where the real world and the supernatural collide in a dangerous, sexy, place full of dark secrets and mysterious people. The ensemble cast includes François Arnaud as psychic Manfred Bernardo and Arielle Kebbel as assassin Olivia Charity. Themes include acceptance, community, and the struggle between good and evil. Despite its short two-season run, Midnight, Texas developed a cult following for its unique blend of horror and romance.
    12 votes
    More Midnight, TexasRight Arrow
  • Dracula
    Photo: Dracula / Netflix
    21
    10 VOTES

    Dracula

    This retelling of the classic horror story is a great choice for fans of Carnival Row. 

    In a dark and atmospheric reinvention of Bram Stoker's classic tale, this gripping series delves into the life of the enigmatic Count Dracula (Claes Bang), as he navigates the Victorian-era London with a sinister charm. Balancing horror and drama, the show masterfully intertwines the iconic vampire's lust for blood with his yearning for human connection. The audience is drawn into the battle of wits between Dracula and the fearless vampire hunter, Van Helsing (Dolly Wells), who is determined to bring an end to his reign of terror. Garnering critical acclaim for its enthralling storytelling and remarkable performances, this adaptation has breathed new life into the legendary character and left viewers thirsty for more.
    10 votes
    More DraculaRight Arrow
  • Good Omens
    Photo: Good Omens / Amazon Video
    22
    13 VOTES

    Good Omens

    This Amazon series based on the novel by Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman is a perfectly contained fantasy drama mini-series that will leave fans of Carnival Row satisfied. 

    In a delightful dance between the forces of good and evil, Good Omens expertly weaves a tale that transcends genres. This six-episode miniseries, an adaptation of Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett's celebrated novel, has garnered critical acclaim and multiple award nominations. With a touch of humor and a dash of wit, the unlikely friendship between Aziraphale (Michael Sheen), an angel, and Crowley (David Tennant), a demon, is brought to life as they join forces to prevent the impending apocalypse. The show's ensemble cast, intricate plotlines, and stunning visuals combine to create a truly memorable viewing experience that resonates with audiences worldwide.
    13 votes
    More Good OmensRight Arrow
  • Bright
    Photo: Bright
    23
    15 VOTES

    Bright

    This weird fantasy-crime Netflix original film is the perfect film to watch when you need to remember exactly how good Carnival Row was. A buddy cop film with fantastical creatures- how bad could that be? (Note: It's pretty bad).

    In an alternate present day, humans, orcs, elves and fairies have been coexisting since the beginning of time. Two police officers, one a human, the other an orc, embark on a routine night patrol that will alter the future of their world as they know it. Battling both their own personal differences as well as an onslaught of enemies, they must work together to protect a young female elf and a thought-to-be-forgotten relic, which, in the wrong hands, could destroy everything.
    15 votes
    More BrightRight Arrow
  • Salem
    Photo: WGN America
    24
    10 VOTES

    Salem

    This period fantasy drama is the perfect catch-all series to wrap your brain around after finishing Carnival Row. 

    Salem, premiering in 2014, is a dark and atmospheric series that delves into the infamous witch trials of the 17th century. The show blends historical drama with supernatural horror, exploring themes of fear, power, and manipulation. Janet Montgomery shines as Mary Sibley, a powerful witch manipulating the town's hysteria for her own ends. Shane West co-stars as John Alden, a war veteran skeptical of the witch panic. Salem's unique take on this notorious period of American history earned the show a dedicated fanbase and critical acclaim for its performances and intricate plotlines.
    10 votes
  • Penny Dreadful: City of Angels
    Photo: Penny Dreadful: City of Angels
    25
    8 VOTES

    Penny Dreadful: City of Angels

    Set against the vibrant and tumultuous backdrop of 1938 Los Angeles, this mesmerizing series explores a time rife with racial and political tensions. Penny Dreadful: City of Angels delves into the supernatural realm, seamlessly weaving together elements of crime, drama, and horror. The talented ensemble cast, including Detective Tiago Vega (Daniel Zovatto) and his enigmatic partner Lewis Michener (Nathan Lane), navigates the city's dark underbelly while confronting age-old Mexican folklore. Nominated for an impressive array of awards, this gripping show masterfully captures the essence of its era, offering viewers an enthralling journey through a world where danger and mysticism intertwine.
    8 votes
    More Penny Dreadful: City of AngelsRight Arrow
  • Wynonna Earp
    Photo: Syfy
    26
    8 VOTES

    Wynonna Earp

    Fans of Carnival Row will love this supernatural western horror series where our hero fights revenants, reincarnated outlaws from ages past, and protects her town from unimaginable horrors. 

    Wynonna Earp, a supernatural western drama, weaves an intriguing tale of family legacy and relentless demons. The series follows the journey of Wynonna Earp (Melanie Scrofano), the great-great-granddaughter of legendary lawman Wyatt Earp, as she returns to her hometown to protect it from malevolent spirits. With a touch of humor and a strong ensemble cast, including Doc Holliday (Tim Rozon) and Waverly Earp (Dominique Provost-Chalkley), the show has garnered a dedicated fanbase and critical acclaim, earning several award nominations for its unique storytelling approach. Viewers can expect a thrilling ride through this mystical world where history and fantasy collide.
    8 votes
    More Wynonna EarpRight Arrow
  • Charmed
    Photo: The WB
    27
    12 VOTES

    Charmed

    The original Charmed series is an easy fantasy series to fall into after finishing Carnival Row that won't require too much investment to get the most out of it. 

    A refreshing take on the supernatural drama genre, Charmed weaves a tale of sisterhood and witchcraft that has garnered critical acclaim and a loyal fan base. The show revolves around three sisters - Prue (Shannen Doherty), Piper (Holly Marie Combs), and Phoebe (Alyssa Milano) - who discover their magical heritage and destiny as the Charmed Ones, powerful witches destined to protect innocents from evil forces. Throughout its eight-season run, the series maintained an engaging balance between enchanting storylines and heartfelt character development. With 54 award wins and nominations under its belt, Charmed has secured its place as a beloved classic in television history.
    12 votes
    More CharmedRight Arrow
  • The Gates
    Photo: ABC
    28
    3 VOTES

    The Gates

    This shortlived supernatural crime drama follows a police officer who is transferred to a gated community that is occupied by a number of fantastical creatures and beings like vampires, werewolves and a succubus.

    The Gates (ABC, 2010) is an American supernatural crime drama television series created by Richard Hatem and Grant Scharbo. A police officer (Frank Grillo) and his family move to a serene, upscale community where vampires, werewolves, witches, and other supernatural entities reside.
    3 votes
    More The GatesRight Arrow
  • Charmed
    Photo: Charmed
    29
    10 VOTES

    Charmed

    A reboot of the classic WB series, this interaction of Charmed follows the same formula as the original series with a Latina leading cast. 

    A refreshing take on the supernatural genre, the show revolves around three sisters, who discover their latent magical powers after a life-altering event. As they navigate through the perils and responsibilities of being witches, the siblings Piper (Holly Marie Combs), Phoebe (Alyssa Milano), and Prue (Shannen Doherty) form an unbreakable bond while protecting innocent lives from demonic threats. The series has garnered critical acclaim, earning numerous accolades for its engaging storytelling, well-rounded characters, and captivating performances. With a touch of humor and a relatable family dynamic, this bewitching drama pulls viewers into a world where love, courage, and sisterhood triumph over evil.
    10 votes
    More CharmedRight Arrow
  • FreakAngels
    Photo: FreakAngels
    30
    1 VOTES

    FreakAngels

    After civilization comes to an end, twelve psychics must rebuild society.
    1 votes
    More FreakAngelsRight Arrow