The Best Broadway Plays of the 70s

Buster McDermott
Updated May 15, 2024 24.6K views 33 items
Ranked By
1.2K votes
310 voters

What are the best Broadway plays of the 1970s? This list has been ranked by theater lovers to determine the most greatest plays on Broadway in the 1970s, a decade of progressive change, rooted in politics and popular culture. The list below has all of the top Broadway plays, performed on Broadway during the 70s. 

Butterflies Are Free was one of the longest running shows of the 1970s with 1,128 total performances. Directed by Milton Katselas, the play opened at the Booth Theatre and told the story of a blind man whose controlling mother disapproves of his relationship with a free-spirited hippie. Set in New York City, the play became a hit and was nominated for two Tony Awards.

Another popular Broadway play of the 1970s, Deathtrap, ran for four years with almost 1,800 performances. Today, the play still currently holds the record for longest-running comedy-thriller on Broadway and was nominated for the Tony Award for Best Play.

Other long-running Broadway plays of the 70s include Gemini, Equus, Plaza Suite, and The Prisoner of Second Avenue, each with strong Broadway runs and critical reception. What were the best Broadway shows of the 1970s? Cast your votes below to rank the absolute best Broadway plays of the 70s.


  • The Sunshine Boys
    1
    41 votes
    The Sunshine Boys is a play by Neil Simon that was produced on Broadway in 1972 and later adapted for film and television.
  • Sleuth
    2

    Sleuth

    Anthony Shaffer
    41 votes
    Sleuth is a 1970 play written by Anthony Shaffer. The Broadway production received the Tony Award for Best Play, and Anthony Quayle and Keith Baxter received the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Performance. The play was adapted for feature films in 1972, 2007 and 2014.
  • That Championship Season
    3

    That Championship Season

    Jason Miller
    28 votes
  • Chapter Two
    4
    Neil Simon
    29 votes
    Chapter Two is a semi-autobiographical play by Neil Simon. The play premiered on Broadway in 1977, where it ran for 857 performances.
  • The Elephant Man
    5

    The Elephant Man

    Bernard Pomerance
    74 votes
  • California Suite
    6
    31 votes
    California Suite is a 1976 play by Neil Simon. Similar in structure to his earlier Plaza Suite, the comedy is composed of four playlets set in Suite 203-04, which consists of a living room and an adjoining bedroom with an ensuite bath, in The Beverly Hills Hotel.
  • Deathtrap
    7
    Ira Levin
    64 votes
    Deathtrap is a play written by Ira Levin in 1978 with many plot twists and which references itself as a play within a play. It is in two acts with one set and five characters. It holds the record for the longest running comedy-thriller on Broadway and was also nominated for the Tony Award for Best Play. Deathtrap was well received by many and has been frequently revived. It was adapted into a film starring Christopher Reeve, Michael Caine, and Dyan Cannon in 1982.
  • The Shadow Box
    8

    The Shadow Box

    Michael Cristofer
    25 votes
    The Shadow Box is a book by Michael Cristofer.
  • Neurotic middle-aged New Yorker Mel Edison (Jack Lemmon) is fired from his advertising job, forcing his loving wife, Edna (Anne Bancroft), to become the couple's sole breadwinner. Feeling emasculated, he begins to fall into a depression. A summer heat wave, unthoughtful neighbors and a robbery only worsen matters. When Mel finally suffers a nervous breakdown, he relies on those closest to him, including Edna and his brother Harry (Gene Saks), to restore his sanity.
  • Butterflies Are Free
    10
    Leonard Gershe
    39 votes
    In early 1970s San Francisco, blind aspiring singer-songwriter Don Baker (Edward Albert) is living away from his overprotective mother (Eileen Heckart) for the first time. Free-spirited actress Jill Tanner (Goldie Hawn) moves into the apartment next door, and they bond over music and literature, but when Don's mother makes an unexpected visit, she clashes with the headstrong Jill, assuming that she'll get bored and leave Don, just as his last girlfriend did.
  • Plaza Suite
    11
    Neil Simon
    41 votes
    Plaza Suite is a comedy play by Neil Simon.
  • The Gin Game
    12

    The Gin Game

    Donald L. Coburn
    24 votes
  • Child's Play
    13

    Child's Play

    Robert Marasco
    26 votes
  • Same Time, Next Year
    14
    39 votes
  • Equus
    15
    Peter Shaffer
    54 votes
    Equus is a play by Peter Shaffer written in 1973, telling the story of a psychiatrist who attempts to treat a young man who has a pathological religious fascination with horses. Shaffer was inspired to write Equus when he heard of a crime involving a 17-year-old who blinded six horses in a small town near Suffolk. He set out to construct a fictional account of what might have caused the incident, without knowing any of the details of the crime. The play's action is something of a detective story, involving the attempts of the child psychiatrist, Dr. Martin Dysart, to understand the cause of the boy's actions while wrestling with his own sense of purpose. The stage show ran in London between 1973 and 1975: later came the Broadway productions that starred Anthony Hopkins as Dysart, and from the London production, Peter Firth as Alan. Tom Hulce replaced Firth during the Broadway run. The Broadway production ran for 1,209 performances. Marian Seldes appeared in every single performance of the Broadway run, first in the role of Hesther and then as Dora. Numerous other issues inform the narrative.
  • Yentl
    16

    Yentl

    Leah Napolin, Isaac Bashevis Singer
    28 votes
    Yentl is a play by Leah Napolin and Isaac Bashevis Singer. Based on Singer's short story "Yentl the Yeshiva Boy," it centers on a young girl who defies tradition by discussing and debating Jewish law and theology with her rabbi father. When he dies, she cuts her hair, dresses as a man, and sets out to find a yeshiva where she can continue to study Talmud and live secretly as a male named Anshel. When her study partner Avigdor discovers the truth, Yentl's assertions that she is "neither one sex nor the other" and has "the soul of a man in the body of a woman" suggest the character is questioning their gender identity, especially when she opts to remain living as Anshel for the rest of her life. After eleven previews, the Broadway production, directed by Robert Kalfin, opened on October 23, 1975 at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre, where it ran for 223 performances. The cast included Tovah Feldshuh, John Shea, and Lynn Ann Leveridge.
  • God's Favorite
    17
    Neil Simon
    17 votes
    God's Favorite is a play by Neil Simon, loosely based on the Biblical Book of Job. It was produced on Broadway in 1974.
  • The Runner Stumbles
    18

    The Runner Stumbles

    Milan Stitt
    22 votes
  • The Ritz
    19
    Terrence McNally
    26 votes
    The Ritz is a comedic farce by Terrence McNally. Rita Moreno won a Tony Award for her performance as Googie Gomez in the 1975 Broadway production, which she and many others of the original cast reprised in a 1976 film version directed by Richard Lester.
  • The Good Doctor
    20
    Neil Simon, Peter Link
    20 votes
    The Good Doctor is a comedy with music written by Neil Simon. It consists in a series of short plays, based on short stories and other works of Russian writer Anton Chekhov, framed by a writer making comments on them.
  • Travesties
    21

    Travesties

    Tom Stoppard
    22 votes
    Travesties is a play by Tom Stoppard. The play centres on the figure of Henry Carr, an elderly man who reminisces about Zürich in 1917 during the First World War, and his interactions with James Joyce when he was writing Ulysses, Tristan Tzara during the rise of Dada, and Lenin leading up to the Russian Revolution, all of whom were living in Zürich at that time.
  • Gemini
    22

    Gemini

    Albert Innaurato
    30 votes
  • The River Niger
    23

    The River Niger

    Joseph A. Walker
    16 votes
  • For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide / When the Rainbow Is Enuf
    24

    For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide / When the Rainbow Is Enuf

    Ntozake Shange
    32 votes
  • Streamers
    25
    David Rabe
    18 votes
  • Sticks and Bones
    26

    Sticks and Bones

    David Rabe
    19 votes
  • Mummenschanz
    27

    Mummenschanz

    24 votes
  • Otherwise Engaged
    28

    Otherwise Engaged

    Simon Gray
    16 votes
  • 6 Rms Riv Vu
    29

    6 Rms Riv Vu

    Bob Randall
    17 votes
  • Absurd Person Singular
    30

    Absurd Person Singular

    Alan Ayckbourn
    24 votes