Stampede: Vol. 1 by Orville Peck (Album, Contemporary Country): Reviews, Ratings, Credits, Song list - Rate Your Music
New Music Genres Charts Lists
Stampede: Vol. 1
........
ArtistOrville Peck
TypeAlbum
Released10 May 2024
RYM Rating 2.84 / 5.00.5 from 265 ratings
Ranked#873 for 2024
Genres
Descriptors
passionate, eclectic, male vocalist, playful, warm, LGBT, love
Languages English, Spanish

Track listing

Rate/Catalog

Saving...
0.0
Catalog
In collection
On wishlist
Used to own
(not cataloged)
Set listening
Tags
Save
Review
Track ratings
To rate, slide your finger across the stars from left to right.
Issues

1 Issue

1 Issue

Credits

Credits

3 Reviews

May 2024 in Review: Stampede: Vol. 1 by Orville Peck
Masked country star Orville Peck has released the first volume of his Stampede duets project. Unfortunately, this new EP contains some of Peck’s weakest material yet. About half of the songs here are covers. He’s a good curator, the songs he chose are good songs to cover (for the most part), but they never really reach the heights of the originals or Peck’s previous material. I was ambivalent, yet a bit appreciative, when Peck released the lead single to this EP. A cover of the Ned Sublette-penned “Cowboys Are Frequently, Secretly Fond of Each Other” with Willie Nelson, whose cover of the song back in 2006 made the song gain prominence. It’s fine. All of the covers on this EP never excel beyond fine. Some fall very flat, like Peck and Elton John’s rendition of “Saturday Night’s Alright for Fighting,” a classic in the latter’s catalog, but here it sounds so much less rough around the edges. It loses so much of the charm the original had. The best cuts here are the non-covers. Like “The Hurtin’ Kind,” a duet with country group Midland, which is a sleek cut with a really solid melody.

Stampede: Vol. 1 is pleasant enough to throw on in the background, but it doesn’t mark a big progression in Peck’s sound or artistry like I think it should. He’s coming off of two really good records and, while I’m sure this project was fun to make, Stampede doesn’t seem like the next best step for him. We’ll see if I’m proven wrong, I hope I am!
6.0
Published
ADVERTISEMENT
Orville Peck and His Little Duets
A collection of duets immediately intrigued me. Peck’s deep slick singing style, in my mind, seemed like a wonderful complement to say a more feminine, lighter voice. His powered up collaboration with Shania Twain, for example, had been a highlight of his previous work. He brings some powerhouse names on here, Noah Cyrus, Nathaniel Rateliff, and the legendary Willie Nelson with a cover of the amusing “Cowboys Are Frequently Secretly Fond Of Each Other.” Nelson still shines at his age of 90, and without question, not only is the gold star to the album for Nelson’s performance, but Peck’s as well. Warm and lucid, it shows his voice work has continued to grow.

But also, the previous pinch to Peck’s upper register that occasionally found a way through his first album returns here at the beginning of the song “Miènteme.” Otherwise, the mariachi-inspired Southwest sound to this is a fun new exploration into country and western music for Peck (and a real wild card of a collaboration choice with Bu Cuaron). “Chemical Sunset” takes us into an almost vaudevillian style, with the track dancing along to a jazzy upright bass and plodding piano— it’s alright, Allison Russel puts a touch of gravel in her singing that gets some rawness to the track, but the song’s inclusion felt more like an experimental excursion rather than cohesive to this collection.

Another disconcerting trait in these tracks are occasional over-glitzed steely guitar sounds that have plagued popular country for 20 years— something Peck often shied away from in his work otherwise. It doesn’t overpower these tracks but I can’t help but roll my eyes when I hear them.

Of course, Elton John’s appearance caught my attention; Peck and him do a cover of his “Saturday Night’s Alright (For Fighting).” The song seems another excellent choice for Peck. I can tell he was having fun in the recording. He belts with a sort of pride suited for a bar fight anthem, and the rebellious undertone with this version, what with two gay men singing it, isn’t lost on me. If anything, that’s cooler.

Though, considering this album is a series of duets, there’s not really much of an “exchange” between Peck and his featured guest. Sure everyone’s voices sound great together, but far too many of the songs feel like they are singing to each other, communicating— the exceptions being the aforementioned Nelson track and “How Far Will We Take It?” with his old friend Noah Cyrus. Though, that latter one also happens to be the least interesting melodically.

Peck has a few kinks to work out, perhaps a vision that will be fully encapsulated with Stampede’s second part, but the quality of his music hasn’t taken any steps backwards. The only other note that wracks my brain is if it’s second part will feel less like a curiosity acted upon or showcase of Peck’s versatility and feel more like a collection of ardent exchanges between artists.
Published
A bit disappointing.
I really loved Bronco and expected something similar, so that's maybe a bit on me. I like the opener very much, tracks 4 and 5 are good as well, but nothing else hits me and I actively dislike Miénteme cause I am allergic to the Dembow rhythm in songs.
Published
ADVERTISEMENT
Votes are used to help determine the most interesting content on RYM.

Vote up content that is on-topic, within the rules/guidelines, and will likely stay relevant long-term.
Vote down content which breaks the rules.

Catalog

Ratings: 265
Cataloged: 40
Track rating sets:Track ratings: 28
Rating distribution
Page 1 2 3 .. 5 .. 7 .. 9 10 .. 12 .. 14 .. 16 .. 18 >>
7 Jun 2024
maxivanov  2.50 stars not my cup of tea
7 Jun 2024
7 Jun 2024
divided  3.00 stars Ok (Would relisten)
  • 3.00 stars 1 Cowboys Are Frequently Secretly Fond of Each Other
  • 3.00 stars 2 The Hurtin' Kind
  • 2.50 stars 3 Saturday Night's Alright (For Fighting)
  • 3.00 stars 4 Chemical Sunset
  • 3.00 stars 5 How Far Will We Take It?
  • 3.00 stars 6 Miénteme
  • 3.00 stars 7 Conquer the Heart
7 Jun 2024
6 Jun 2024
5 Jun 2024
Banter  3.00 stars
4 Jun 2024
guccirayn  2.50 stars inconsistent or lacklustre
3 Jun 2024
3 Jun 2024
GaalMethon Owned1.50 stars dont care
3 Jun 2024
Dif  3.00 stars
2 Jun 2024
ripkoko  2.50 stars has potential
1 Jun 2024
krisis Digital4.00 stars Excellent
1 Jun 2024
bowiestone  3.00 stars Fair
1 Jun 2024
31 May 2024
Uroboros221 Owned1.50 stars
........
ADVERTISEMENT

Track listing

Credits

ADVERTISEMENT

Contributions

Contributors to this release: WithWith, RaulHernandez, iN008, Chenrezig
Log in to submit a correction or upload art for this release
........