What do you think?
Rate this book
Calling Sehmat
Calling Sehmat is a thrilling saga of a spy who, in the service of our nation, gave all of herself and that of her family so that we may live in peace. It is a story of a Kashmiri woman who married a Pakistani Army Officer so as to provide the Indian intelligence with invaluable information during the Indo-Pak War of 1971. Sehmat devised unique ways in her quest to get closer to the top brass in Pakistan. She almost single-handedly torpedoed Pakistans war plans through indefinable courage, wit and determination and was responsible for saving lives of scores of Indian soldiers. The story gives rare insight to the humble yet brave people of Kashmir who not only swear by India but also are willing to sacrifice their very being for the service of our nation.
244 pages, Unknown Binding
First published January 1, 2018
About the author
Harinder Sikka
3 books99 followersHarinder Sikka is currently the group director, strategic business, Piramal Group. After graduating from Delhi University, he joined the Indian Navy. He was commissioned in January 1981 and took premature retirement in 1993 as a Lieutenant Commander. He lives in New Delhi with his family.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 407 reviews
November 27, 2022
In a Nutshell: Began well, kept dipping with every subsequent chapter. Based on a true story, so some of the more outlandish events are still based in reality. But the writing is too basic.
Story Synopsis:
Where the book worked for me:
✔ If this were a fictional story, I would have dismissed a lot of the content as exaggerated and impossible. However, the parts that I found toughest to believe are, in fact, true, verifiable through various online sources. The real-life Sehmat sure was a brave lady, and I loved learning about an unknown patriot of my motherland. This is the first time I have read about an Indian woman spy. The choice of topic isn’t a popular one, and my thanks to the author for highlighting her efforts.
✔ The writing is pretty fast-paced and straightforward. It’s easy to complete this 200 pager within a couple of hours.
Where the book could have worked better for me:
❌ This is the debut novel of an established screenplay writer and it shows. Every scene seems to have been written keeping the big screen in mind. The dialogues are pretentious, and the focus is more on establishing the setting than on the characters or their emotions.
❌ The very first page of the story tells us that Sehmat has just passed away. Throughout the book, I waited to know why. Till the end, neither the reason nor her age at the time of death was revealed. What was the point of that emotional opening then?
❌ The writing is utterly basic, almost amateurish. Plenty of lines are repeated after just a few paragraphs, as if the author didn’t trust his readers’ memories.
❌ There are so many interesting characters in the book, but most aren’t explored at all. Except for Sehmat, the rest come and go as per the whims and fancies of the author. There is an underlying assumption that Sehmat is the only one with intelligence, and that the Pakistani military officials have no brains at all, which is a stupid assumption. Quite a few plot holes spring up because of this.
❌ There is a recurring mention of Sehmat’s physical appeal. When sentences such as "She had draped her exquisite body in black crepe" make an appearance in an espionage thriller, it is just too cheesy.
❌ When a book claims to be based on true events, I appreciate an author’s note detailing the actual events and how far the book was factual and to what extent fictional. There’s no author’s note in this book at all, and I was forced to search info online. As the real-life Sehmat is a private individual whose story just happened to come up before the author, there’s not much about her on any site. The author should have therefore made sure we know the real lady well.
❌ The time period in which the story is set isn’t revealed until a long time into the book.
❌ The ending is just meh - too much of philosophy that springs out of nowhere.
The book had tremendous potential, and in the hands of a more experienced writer, it would have worked much better. I can see why this was adapted into a movie (titled ‘Raazi’ for the uninformed), and as I have already seen the movie, I would definitely recommend that you watch the movie because the star cast and the director have done far better justice to Sehmat’s story than the book that inspired the adaptation. This book is an exception to the rule that the book is always better.
In short, this is a melodramatic story based on true events. The average writing doesn’t make me recommend the book to most readers except those who don’t mind beginner-level writing. As I mentioned above, if you want to know more about Sehmat, watch ‘Raazi’ instead.
2 stars.
(If you are wondering why I am not going with 1 star for a book with so many negatives,.. well, let's just say the extra star is for the real-life Sehmat. I relished knowing her story.)
———————————————
Connect with me through:
My Blog | The StoryGraph | Facebook | Twitter
Story Synopsis:
Pre-1971, India. Sehmat is the young daughter of a Kashmiri businessman who runs a secret network of spies between India and neighbouring Pakistan, especially as the climate between the two countries has turned tense. When he is diagnosed with an incurable ailment, his last wish is to see Sehmat take over his intelligence network. She is married off to the son of a high-ranked Pakistani military officer and through her new position, she relays information back to the intelligence officers in India. However, she goes a step too far and someone discovers her secret. What happens next?
Where the book worked for me:
✔ If this were a fictional story, I would have dismissed a lot of the content as exaggerated and impossible. However, the parts that I found toughest to believe are, in fact, true, verifiable through various online sources. The real-life Sehmat sure was a brave lady, and I loved learning about an unknown patriot of my motherland. This is the first time I have read about an Indian woman spy. The choice of topic isn’t a popular one, and my thanks to the author for highlighting her efforts.
✔ The writing is pretty fast-paced and straightforward. It’s easy to complete this 200 pager within a couple of hours.
Where the book could have worked better for me:
❌ This is the debut novel of an established screenplay writer and it shows. Every scene seems to have been written keeping the big screen in mind. The dialogues are pretentious, and the focus is more on establishing the setting than on the characters or their emotions.
❌ The very first page of the story tells us that Sehmat has just passed away. Throughout the book, I waited to know why. Till the end, neither the reason nor her age at the time of death was revealed. What was the point of that emotional opening then?
❌ The writing is utterly basic, almost amateurish. Plenty of lines are repeated after just a few paragraphs, as if the author didn’t trust his readers’ memories.
❌ There are so many interesting characters in the book, but most aren’t explored at all. Except for Sehmat, the rest come and go as per the whims and fancies of the author. There is an underlying assumption that Sehmat is the only one with intelligence, and that the Pakistani military officials have no brains at all, which is a stupid assumption. Quite a few plot holes spring up because of this.
❌ There is a recurring mention of Sehmat’s physical appeal. When sentences such as "She had draped her exquisite body in black crepe" make an appearance in an espionage thriller, it is just too cheesy.
❌ When a book claims to be based on true events, I appreciate an author’s note detailing the actual events and how far the book was factual and to what extent fictional. There’s no author’s note in this book at all, and I was forced to search info online. As the real-life Sehmat is a private individual whose story just happened to come up before the author, there’s not much about her on any site. The author should have therefore made sure we know the real lady well.
❌ The time period in which the story is set isn’t revealed until a long time into the book.
❌ The ending is just meh - too much of philosophy that springs out of nowhere.
The book had tremendous potential, and in the hands of a more experienced writer, it would have worked much better. I can see why this was adapted into a movie (titled ‘Raazi’ for the uninformed), and as I have already seen the movie, I would definitely recommend that you watch the movie because the star cast and the director have done far better justice to Sehmat’s story than the book that inspired the adaptation. This book is an exception to the rule that the book is always better.
In short, this is a melodramatic story based on true events. The average writing doesn’t make me recommend the book to most readers except those who don’t mind beginner-level writing. As I mentioned above, if you want to know more about Sehmat, watch ‘Raazi’ instead.
2 stars.
(If you are wondering why I am not going with 1 star for a book with so many negatives,.. well, let's just say the extra star is for the real-life Sehmat. I relished knowing her story.)
———————————————
Connect with me through:
My Blog | The StoryGraph | Facebook | Twitter
January 17, 2021
This is one of those very few instances where I saw the movie, based on the book, before reading the book. The movie “Raazi” is a very good adaptation of the book.
The story is excellent – and being based on a real story of a young lady who takes huge risks for her country, it is also inspiring. That said – the book slips up in its narrative in many instances – the pace is not tight enough, the characters other than Sehmat do not develop well and some critical portions needed further emphasis.
The story unfolds with the love story of Sehmat’s parents – Tej and Hidayat Khan. Tej visits Kashmir and is charmed by Hidayat. The story then picks up when Sehmat is in college and very gifted. Hidayat as part of his trade connections has contacts in Pakistan, and supplies crucial information to Indian Intelligence. He falls greviously ill, at the time when tensions between India and Pakistan are rising in 1971. The situation in East Pakistan is grim and troublesome for Pakistan, and they are keen to launch a pre-emptive attack on India. Hidayat comes to conclusion that there is no alternative except for Sehmat to take his place.
Sehmat has to sacrifice her love for Abhinav and instead marry Iqbal, son of an influential officer in the Pakistani armed forces. She runs into a number of stressful situations but emerges as a splendid source of information for Indian Intelligence.
The book adds more context to the college life of Sehmat, her love life, her hopes, as also what happens after she completes her assignment, as compared to the movie. If you have watched the movie “Raazi”, the book does not add too much which the movie does not cover.
My rating: 3.5 / 5.
The story is excellent – and being based on a real story of a young lady who takes huge risks for her country, it is also inspiring. That said – the book slips up in its narrative in many instances – the pace is not tight enough, the characters other than Sehmat do not develop well and some critical portions needed further emphasis.
The story unfolds with the love story of Sehmat’s parents – Tej and Hidayat Khan. Tej visits Kashmir and is charmed by Hidayat. The story then picks up when Sehmat is in college and very gifted. Hidayat as part of his trade connections has contacts in Pakistan, and supplies crucial information to Indian Intelligence. He falls greviously ill, at the time when tensions between India and Pakistan are rising in 1971. The situation in East Pakistan is grim and troublesome for Pakistan, and they are keen to launch a pre-emptive attack on India. Hidayat comes to conclusion that there is no alternative except for Sehmat to take his place.
Sehmat has to sacrifice her love for Abhinav and instead marry Iqbal, son of an influential officer in the Pakistani armed forces. She runs into a number of stressful situations but emerges as a splendid source of information for Indian Intelligence.
The book adds more context to the college life of Sehmat, her love life, her hopes, as also what happens after she completes her assignment, as compared to the movie. If you have watched the movie “Raazi”, the book does not add too much which the movie does not cover.
My rating: 3.5 / 5.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 7, 2019
Being a defence kid, I grew up listening to all those stories of patriots who fought for our country. I was really looking forward to reading Calling Sehmat before watching the movie (Raaji is based upon this novel), but I feel cheated after reading this one. It felt like I was reading a summary of a beautiful novel.
Calling Sehmat is about a girl who marries a Pakistani Captain to spy for our country. It's a great plot and has so much potential to turn into a great novel. But unfortunately, it was given to a person who doesn't like storytelling and was simply stating the facts.
The character build up was poor. I didn't get to know about any other characters (even the main character Sehmat). I also wanted to know about the guy Sehmat marries but I got nothing. He is just shown as a sidelined character.
I just wish the movie to be better.
2 stars are just for the great plot.
PS- I bought this book instead of Thinking, fast and slow by Daniel Kahneman. I am totally regretting my decision now.
Calling Sehmat is about a girl who marries a Pakistani Captain to spy for our country. It's a great plot and has so much potential to turn into a great novel. But unfortunately, it was given to a person who doesn't like storytelling and was simply stating the facts.
The character build up was poor. I didn't get to know about any other characters (even the main character Sehmat). I also wanted to know about the guy Sehmat marries but I got nothing. He is just shown as a sidelined character.
I just wish the movie to be better.
2 stars are just for the great plot.
PS- I bought this book instead of Thinking, fast and slow by Daniel Kahneman. I am totally regretting my decision now.
August 6, 2019
A rare book that is based on true spy who played an active role during the period leading to the 1971 Indo-Pakistan war. A panic driven bureaucracy, under the guise of national security, has ensured that the true stories of these heroes never comes out in the light. The fact that the author was a serving officer in Navy helped bring out this story. A true story it brings alive the trials, tribulations, bravery of the girl who even got married to son of second in command of dreaded ISI to serve her country. An inspiring true story of girt, courage and determination.
Shelved as 'the-nope-wagon'
April 20, 2020Read the preview. Lost interest.
November 20, 2017
A friend gave me this for a read. For her, it is a priced possession, not given to anyone before. She commented, that I would love this. I felt privileged.
The book is a fine piece of writing I have read since a while. The story touches one's heart. A perfect infusion of sentiments in a gripping plot. Bet you haven't read a similar one prior. The details are fascinating and they make the reader feel every passage in the book as if he is into the world. This is effortlessly achieved by the author. I simply loved this one. Do give a read. A perfect companion for a weekend. It will open your heart and make you realize the true meaning of sacrifice, determination and love.
The book is a fine piece of writing I have read since a while. The story touches one's heart. A perfect infusion of sentiments in a gripping plot. Bet you haven't read a similar one prior. The details are fascinating and they make the reader feel every passage in the book as if he is into the world. This is effortlessly achieved by the author. I simply loved this one. Do give a read. A perfect companion for a weekend. It will open your heart and make you realize the true meaning of sacrifice, determination and love.
May 27, 2018
This book is a fictionalized true story.Though the book is not even close to be considered as a classic spy thriller,the writing is decent.Other than the chapters describing navy battles,the language is simple and story is fast paced.The author has researched his subject thoroughly which is evident from the minutest details he brings into life.The description of navy battles and military jargon are the only weak points.Its a tribute to an unsung war hero.Just the movie Raazi,I award four stars to the book.
August 26, 2018
Synopsis:
In the city of Malerkotla, in the north Indian state of Punjab, a mother places a call to her grandson to inform him that his mother has passed away. Samar Khan, promoted to the rank of Captain (in the Indian Army), was excited to present himself in front of his mother in his new uniform. Alas, that moment never came. Seeking permission from his Commanding Officer for emergency leave, he then proceeds from Delhi (where he was on short duty) to Malerkotla. While breaking the news about his mother's demise to the nearby villagers, who considered her as their messiah, Samar starts recollecting her past. But why does he say,
Was she not his biological mother?
Born in a house where secularism was taught before the tenets of both the religions of her parents (her father a Muslim, her mother a Hindu), Sehmat Khan was always a mindful child. Their only offspring, she took up her father's mantle, when he is diagnosed with a life-threatening disease. The year is 1969, the place being Srinagar; her father's health would otherwise have jeopardized the intricate cross-border intelligence network which he painstakingly set up over a decade ago, which was also instrumental in the Indo-Pak War of 1965, had the just graduated Sehmat not decided to give up her own life for her watan (country's). After receiving month-long training from the best in the RAW (India's foreign intelligence agency), she gets married to Iqbal Sayeed, whose father was her father's college friend, and whose entire family is serving in/connected to the upper echelons of the Pakistani intelligence. Thus starts her journey as she weasels her way into the folds of the Sayeed family, gaining their confidence and putting her spy school learning to good use. But there is one, who is sceptical of her, not at all misled by her sweet daughter-in-law act.
Who is he? Moreover, what happens there that after her job is done, she decides to settle down for her remaining life in Malerkotla instead of Srinagar – her birthplace, her heart?
Review:
The Hero: Love Story of a Spy was my first brush with the Indo-Pak counter-espionage activities. A much-loved movie, nonetheless a typical Bollywood action flick, while Calling Sehmat is so much more.
This book has some hard-hitting dialogues. The story-line is gripping, the plot tight, keeping you in its thrall.
The story starts with the most spectacular of love stories, between Hidayat Khan and Tejashwari Singh. A classic case of love at first sight, followed by long-distance courting, he of Kashmir and she of Delhi. Overcoming all the odds, they build a life for themselves. They are blessed with a baby girl, Sehmat, who grows up to become someone on whom the country can completely depend upon for its welfare. But that same love escapes Sehmat, as she has to give up Abhinav – her college sweetheart, for the greater love of for her country.
Salute to her father, who brought up a daughter so resilient, salute to her mother, who didn't hold her back from her duties towards the nation, even when it scared her. From children's music concerts to golf sessions, Sehmat leaves no stone unturned in devising newer and innovative ways of information gathering.
Written in the third form of narration, it is no doubt a fictional telling based on the extensive research on the realistic case studies of spies who willingly gave their all, only to pass away unnoticed, unsung, and forgotten.
I cannot even imagine, the toll that it (spying) takes on one's soul. It's chilling, what all she had to do! It must be so tough maintaining a hard heart in betwixt so much love, even if from members of a family who belong to the enemy country.
The author has written a poignant tale of love, loss, guilt, heartbreak, sorrow, bringing out the characters' emotions at their most raw. Such is the finesse of this composition; it made me laugh as well as weep, as did Abhinav's strength and perseverance in the face of seeing the one and only love of his life gradually fade away. I would like to mention here the author's subtlety in showing the blossoming love between Abhinav (Aby) and Sehmat. In spite of not having interacted even once for a long time, there is a spark between them which fans the flames of the love that followed. Subsequently, their first shy meeting, their courtship, everything is so romantic. Though I felt really bad for them both, and for the love that wasn't to be. Except for a few typos, the writing is stellar.
The last part reminded me of the book as well as the TV Series The Last Ship as far as the naval operations are concerned. We need more Indian writers in this genre. The author's experience as a young naval officer works in his favour, in the crisp descriptions of naval warfare and counter espionage during the Indo-Pak War of 1971.
The ending is perfect, drawing everything together, providing closure to all the hurt and grief which Sehmat had to go through.
One inconsistency was, where was Aby after Sehmat's death. Also, there is no mention of Brigadier Sheikh Sayeed's wife, it left me a little confused, especially when it was stated that theirs was a liberal household for women-folk.
*The underlined portions have been taken from the Foreword.
Highly recommended. Set aside the neighbourly tension, and read this book from a humane, emotional perspective.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but the book really reads like a movie script. In fact, Bollywood actress Kirron Kher said long before the movie happened,
And I heard they missed out Aby in the movie, why!?!
Psstt… I wish I could have the Konark Publishers edition (I got it issued from the library), the cover is so beautiful!
P.S. I read this book as a part of the #discoveringindiareadathon (Discovering India Readathon), which was held from 1st to 15th August 2018. In its second year now, this challenge has been curated by three wonderful bookstagrammers:
Padmaja (https://www.instagram.com/thebookisht... )
Aritri (https://www.instagram.com/theliquidsu... ), and
Ankita (https://www.instagram.com/theblue_bal... ).
It is a great way of reading as well as discovering the gems of Indian Literature. Just follow the hashtag on Instagram, and the above three accounts, and you are good to go! (I am hoping it makes a comeback next year!)
Originally posted on:
https://sassyshaina.wordpress.com/201...
In the city of Malerkotla, in the north Indian state of Punjab, a mother places a call to her grandson to inform him that his mother has passed away. Samar Khan, promoted to the rank of Captain (in the Indian Army), was excited to present himself in front of his mother in his new uniform. Alas, that moment never came. Seeking permission from his Commanding Officer for emergency leave, he then proceeds from Delhi (where he was on short duty) to Malerkotla. While breaking the news about his mother's demise to the nearby villagers, who considered her as their messiah, Samar starts recollecting her past. But why does he say,
She was the most enigmatically beautiful woman to come into his life when he was merely seven.
Was she not his biological mother?
Born in a house where secularism was taught before the tenets of both the religions of her parents (her father a Muslim, her mother a Hindu), Sehmat Khan was always a mindful child. Their only offspring, she took up her father's mantle, when he is diagnosed with a life-threatening disease. The year is 1969, the place being Srinagar; her father's health would otherwise have jeopardized the intricate cross-border intelligence network which he painstakingly set up over a decade ago, which was also instrumental in the Indo-Pak War of 1965, had the just graduated Sehmat not decided to give up her own life for her watan (country's). After receiving month-long training from the best in the RAW (India's foreign intelligence agency), she gets married to Iqbal Sayeed, whose father was her father's college friend, and whose entire family is serving in/connected to the upper echelons of the Pakistani intelligence. Thus starts her journey as she weasels her way into the folds of the Sayeed family, gaining their confidence and putting her spy school learning to good use. But there is one, who is sceptical of her, not at all misled by her sweet daughter-in-law act.
Who is he? Moreover, what happens there that after her job is done, she decides to settle down for her remaining life in Malerkotla instead of Srinagar – her birthplace, her heart?
Review:
The Hero: Love Story of a Spy was my first brush with the Indo-Pak counter-espionage activities. A much-loved movie, nonetheless a typical Bollywood action flick, while Calling Sehmat is so much more.
Why can't we all be Indians first? How long will we suffer due to this caste and religious divide and at the hands of our politicians?
This book has some hard-hitting dialogues. The story-line is gripping, the plot tight, keeping you in its thrall.
The story starts with the most spectacular of love stories, between Hidayat Khan and Tejashwari Singh. A classic case of love at first sight, followed by long-distance courting, he of Kashmir and she of Delhi. Overcoming all the odds, they build a life for themselves. They are blessed with a baby girl, Sehmat, who grows up to become someone on whom the country can completely depend upon for its welfare. But that same love escapes Sehmat, as she has to give up Abhinav – her college sweetheart, for the greater love of for her country.
My country comes first.
Salute to her father, who brought up a daughter so resilient, salute to her mother, who didn't hold her back from her duties towards the nation, even when it scared her. From children's music concerts to golf sessions, Sehmat leaves no stone unturned in devising newer and innovative ways of information gathering.
Written in the third form of narration, it is no doubt a fictional telling based on the extensive research on the realistic case studies of spies who willingly gave their all, only to pass away unnoticed, unsung, and forgotten.
Any nation worth its salt cannot afford to forget its heroes.
I cannot even imagine, the toll that it (spying) takes on one's soul. It's chilling, what all she had to do! It must be so tough maintaining a hard heart in betwixt so much love, even if from members of a family who belong to the enemy country.
The author has written a poignant tale of love, loss, guilt, heartbreak, sorrow, bringing out the characters' emotions at their most raw. Such is the finesse of this composition; it made me laugh as well as weep, as did Abhinav's strength and perseverance in the face of seeing the one and only love of his life gradually fade away. I would like to mention here the author's subtlety in showing the blossoming love between Abhinav (Aby) and Sehmat. In spite of not having interacted even once for a long time, there is a spark between them which fans the flames of the love that followed. Subsequently, their first shy meeting, their courtship, everything is so romantic. Though I felt really bad for them both, and for the love that wasn't to be. Except for a few typos, the writing is stellar.
The last part reminded me of the book as well as the TV Series The Last Ship as far as the naval operations are concerned. We need more Indian writers in this genre. The author's experience as a young naval officer works in his favour, in the crisp descriptions of naval warfare and counter espionage during the Indo-Pak War of 1971.
The ending is perfect, drawing everything together, providing closure to all the hurt and grief which Sehmat had to go through.
Humankind has not learned about balance, let alone practiced it. It is guided by greed and ambition, steered by fear. In this way it will eventually destroy itself. But nature will survive; at least the plants will.
One inconsistency was, where was Aby after Sehmat's death. Also, there is no mention of Brigadier Sheikh Sayeed's wife, it left me a little confused, especially when it was stated that theirs was a liberal household for women-folk.
*The underlined portions have been taken from the Foreword.
Highly recommended. Set aside the neighbourly tension, and read this book from a humane, emotional perspective.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but the book really reads like a movie script. In fact, Bollywood actress Kirron Kher said long before the movie happened,
The story bares a chilling truth of the life of an Indian spy and gives rare insight to the people of Kashmir. It provides an ideal platform for a Bollywood film in the future.
And I heard they missed out Aby in the movie, why!?!
Psstt… I wish I could have the Konark Publishers edition (I got it issued from the library), the cover is so beautiful!
P.S. I read this book as a part of the #discoveringindiareadathon (Discovering India Readathon), which was held from 1st to 15th August 2018. In its second year now, this challenge has been curated by three wonderful bookstagrammers:
Padmaja (https://www.instagram.com/thebookisht... )
Aritri (https://www.instagram.com/theliquidsu... ), and
Ankita (https://www.instagram.com/theblue_bal... ).
It is a great way of reading as well as discovering the gems of Indian Literature. Just follow the hashtag on Instagram, and the above three accounts, and you are good to go! (I am hoping it makes a comeback next year!)
Originally posted on:
https://sassyshaina.wordpress.com/201...
November 18, 2022
Love and respect for the plot based on real incidents.
The writing could have been much better in terms of drafting the characters and situations.
Chapters 19 to 21 were carved out into another bollywood film - The Ghazi Attack! One of those books where the films are better than the book. Because in the book, it is just the plot skeleton without even basic development.
Also got irked by few minor plot holes. Beware of major spoilers ahead.
1. Phone call -
2. Chapter 10 Accident -
3. Ending -
4. Ending2 -
Overall:
Recommended for its great plot. Salute to the strong real life heroes, who sacrifice everything to create a major impact on the results of a war - and stay anonymous behind the curtains.
If you're into bollywood, would recommend the films over the book.
The writing could have been much better in terms of drafting the characters and situations.
Chapters 19 to 21 were carved out into another bollywood film - The Ghazi Attack! One of those books where the films are better than the book. Because in the book, it is just the plot skeleton without even basic development.
Also got irked by few minor plot holes. Beware of major spoilers ahead.
1. Phone call -
2. Chapter 10 Accident -
3. Ending -
4. Ending2 -
Overall:
Recommended for its great plot. Salute to the strong real life heroes, who sacrifice everything to create a major impact on the results of a war - and stay anonymous behind the curtains.
If you're into bollywood, would recommend the films over the book.
January 20, 2023
Raazi movie is based on this book. Meghna Gulzar director of Raazi movie. She stole away all his credits, bulldozed him out of Left leaning Jaipur lit fest. Raazi Filmmakers Intentionally Changed The Ending Of Film To Appease Pakistanis. Meghna Gulzar(daughter of Gulzar)took liberty & changed the narrative making it less patriotic & in pro-pakistani sentiment showed their army in good light, protagonist as remorseful after her exploits.
This is why I am not surprised at all why Bollywood is dooming. If you remember Gunjan Saxena movie it was based on The Kargil Girl: An Autobiography by Gunjan Saxena and Kiran Nirvan book. That movie changed entire narrative and made it for their own agenda.
This is also one of the reason why I don't have any expectation from Sam Bahadur movie which is going to release this year in 2023 directed by Meghna Gulzar.
This is why I am not surprised at all why Bollywood is dooming. If you remember Gunjan Saxena movie it was based on The Kargil Girl: An Autobiography by Gunjan Saxena and Kiran Nirvan book. That movie changed entire narrative and made it for their own agenda.
This is also one of the reason why I don't have any expectation from Sam Bahadur movie which is going to release this year in 2023 directed by Meghna Gulzar.
August 27, 2018
Harinder Sikka has watched a lot of Bollywood movies, he loves the over the top patriotism, and Tiranga is probably his favourite movie. He came to know of Shemat's story and thought it to be the prefect plot for a classic tricolour flick, he writes with such Bollywood panache that the 273 page novel even has a dance number. Please understand that I do not wish to undermine the sacrifice and courage of Sehmat Khan but this novel is less of her account than a script for Karan Johar film waiting to happen. She appears for less than 2/3rd of the novel and just like in a Chetan Bhagat novel, it's never really about the girl and eventually becomes about the navy (read The Ghazi Attack).
July 27, 2018
Good story, mediocre writing. Several themes are explored in this book, but the transition between them is too abrupt ("unsmooth"?) for my liking. Also, there are many parts which could've been written with more depth, giving more dimension to the story as well as the characters. The story was pretty good, nevertheless (albeit being written in a very cut-short manner).
December 30, 2020
This is the Book that can discover the hidden patriotism inside You..
All the time when I was holding this book, was the best Time I had in last few days. I couldn't stop my urge of reading it from the time I received the book, afresh & instantly.
There is one thing I liked the most about this book is, its not just the Book, its the world that I entered into. Its pages will let you fly without any effort. That's the magic it creates. Its not just about Sehmat(not the real name though for the purpose of Protagonist's safety), an innocent girl from Kashmir but about the most precious time of her life that she sacrificed in the name of her country, that is also in the time of most cherished period of any girl or boy (being collegiate). This is the story that hooked you till last. However, bit slow in the End.
Its not about winning over the rival country, its about the Patriotism that is required in the form of action from every other citizen of any country, specially in the time of strategic wars and the fear of entering of any other country's unnecessary interference to create big diplomatic issue and to take advantage of the situation.
The situation between India and its officially orphaned child Pakistan were very bad and were on the verge of creating the condition of War; which however, did happen later. At that time, there was a lady (by action and a girl by age) who took this huge responsibility of delivering results in favor of her country by espionage(Clandestine Human Intelligence), an ages old job done for country involving deception and subversion. Call it a military intelligence that the whole mater remain clandestine throughout till its final positive results and thereafter. However, the Pakistan army became well aware of the situation at last but their counterintelligence was a complete failure and there not much left for them to react on. All they can do is to fall in the trap of Indian Intelligentsia and thus we came as victorious. It all goes to the information that was collected over the period of time by Sehmat and bravely passed on to her country's Intelligence on the verge of her not-so-old-life. The girl who saw not so much in her life has become the part of one of the most Glorious Victories of India.
Harinder Sikka cast the words very well and quite precisely understandable to every reader. However, he used few words repetitively which does not seems as the good sign of fine literature. But in end, Hail to story, who cares else, when you have truth in your hands. One thing though I feel lack of, is the mentioning the events' dates, which is highly required when you're writing a biographical non-fiction.
Well, Considering all the Pros and Cons; and the efforts put to give somebody's life; words; which in itself a big thing when there is no previous source available except the protagonist's own real life son and herself (adding more facts from official sources later), prior to the meeting of author and them in an unintentional Incident during their daily chores (in the Indian Army as colleagues) having discussion on war strategies & work of Indian Intelligence. I call it Hilarious.
For me it deserves: 4.9/5.0
All the time when I was holding this book, was the best Time I had in last few days. I couldn't stop my urge of reading it from the time I received the book, afresh & instantly.
There is one thing I liked the most about this book is, its not just the Book, its the world that I entered into. Its pages will let you fly without any effort. That's the magic it creates. Its not just about Sehmat(not the real name though for the purpose of Protagonist's safety), an innocent girl from Kashmir but about the most precious time of her life that she sacrificed in the name of her country, that is also in the time of most cherished period of any girl or boy (being collegiate). This is the story that hooked you till last. However, bit slow in the End.
Its not about winning over the rival country, its about the Patriotism that is required in the form of action from every other citizen of any country, specially in the time of strategic wars and the fear of entering of any other country's unnecessary interference to create big diplomatic issue and to take advantage of the situation.
The situation between India and its officially orphaned child Pakistan were very bad and were on the verge of creating the condition of War; which however, did happen later. At that time, there was a lady (by action and a girl by age) who took this huge responsibility of delivering results in favor of her country by espionage(Clandestine Human Intelligence), an ages old job done for country involving deception and subversion. Call it a military intelligence that the whole mater remain clandestine throughout till its final positive results and thereafter. However, the Pakistan army became well aware of the situation at last but their counterintelligence was a complete failure and there not much left for them to react on. All they can do is to fall in the trap of Indian Intelligentsia and thus we came as victorious. It all goes to the information that was collected over the period of time by Sehmat and bravely passed on to her country's Intelligence on the verge of her not-so-old-life. The girl who saw not so much in her life has become the part of one of the most Glorious Victories of India.
Harinder Sikka cast the words very well and quite precisely understandable to every reader. However, he used few words repetitively which does not seems as the good sign of fine literature. But in end, Hail to story, who cares else, when you have truth in your hands. One thing though I feel lack of, is the mentioning the events' dates, which is highly required when you're writing a biographical non-fiction.
Well, Considering all the Pros and Cons; and the efforts put to give somebody's life; words; which in itself a big thing when there is no previous source available except the protagonist's own real life son and herself (adding more facts from official sources later), prior to the meeting of author and them in an unintentional Incident during their daily chores (in the Indian Army as colleagues) having discussion on war strategies & work of Indian Intelligence. I call it Hilarious.
For me it deserves: 4.9/5.0
July 1, 2018
I read this book in one sitting, and I am not disappointed! What a wonderful book and what an absolute page-turner! You seldom come across such books which keep you hooked until the last page! I can't believe that the story based on a woman who ACTUALLY risked it all to serve her country, her 'watan'. This boks fills me with pride, it brought out the patriot in me and I am so glad I read the book before I saw the movie based on this book. Kudos to Harinder Sikka for bringing out the tale of this unsung heroine, Sehmat Khan, the amazing Kashmiri spy- princess of the war of 1971. A full 5 star for the amazing page turner! I'd recommend it to anyone looking for inspiration; wanting to witness the power of sheer grit and courage. Wonderful book that must be read to realize how much people like Sehmat khan went through to safeguard the pride of our country, our 'watan' during the troubled times of war.
May 16, 2018
Emulations
The heavier tends to settle down and influence from within with no hope of appreciation or rewards.clinging to a cause sacrificing the prime of the life is laudable
The heavier tends to settle down and influence from within with no hope of appreciation or rewards.clinging to a cause sacrificing the prime of the life is laudable
December 19, 2020
5 SHINING 🌟
Could the writing have been better? Yes.
Does it really matter? No
"Respect the uniform, and your soul will respect you"
The book is about the 1971 Indo-Pak war. It's about the Indian Navy's win. It is about how Sehmat Khan's intelligence gathering in Pakistan proved invaluable to India. It is about how she sacrificed everything, suffered insufferably yet did what needed to be done. Most important of all it is about respecting the Watan above everything.
The minor flaws of the book pale in comparison to the theme of the book. I can't recommend this book enough. I'm glad my dad made me read this.
Could the writing have been better? Yes.
Does it really matter? No
"Respect the uniform, and your soul will respect you"
The book is about the 1971 Indo-Pak war. It's about the Indian Navy's win. It is about how Sehmat Khan's intelligence gathering in Pakistan proved invaluable to India. It is about how she sacrificed everything, suffered insufferably yet did what needed to be done. Most important of all it is about respecting the Watan above everything.
The minor flaws of the book pale in comparison to the theme of the book. I can't recommend this book enough. I'm glad my dad made me read this.
October 23, 2020
Having watched the movie based on the book I was really looking forward to reading it but I was very disappointed. Sehmat Khan’s story is the stuff of legends - A Kashmiri girl who opts to become a spy for the Indian intelligence by marrying into a Pakistani army family. But the story has been manhandled by the author.
The book starts off on a very anti-Hindu note. Painting both Kashmiri Pandits & Hindu Brahmins in a bad light. Half the book is spent on a detailed backstory of how Sehmat’s parents met and fell in love and then on how beautiful and wonderful Sehmat was. Sehmat’s decision and motivation to become a spy are hardly dwelt on. Her training is mentioned in passing reference and next thing you know she’s in Pakistan. After that it’s like watching the highlights of high scoring cricket match. It’s page after breathless page of how Sehmat settles in and gains the confidence of the household without even mentioning who are part of the household.
The climax is just a blur of words racing to finish the story. And then there’s a sudden shift to the events of the war between India & Pakistan. These events are narrated without much background and you’re left scrambling to try to piece everything together. After, there’s a cut back into Sehmat’s life which reads like the ending of a terrible Bollywood movie.
All in all a grave injustice to a probably very intelligent and brave woman. I hope someone decides to retell her story and actually does her justice.
Now here’s something I thought I’d never say: Skip the book and watch the movie. At least the movie has good songs.
The book starts off on a very anti-Hindu note. Painting both Kashmiri Pandits & Hindu Brahmins in a bad light. Half the book is spent on a detailed backstory of how Sehmat’s parents met and fell in love and then on how beautiful and wonderful Sehmat was. Sehmat’s decision and motivation to become a spy are hardly dwelt on. Her training is mentioned in passing reference and next thing you know she’s in Pakistan. After that it’s like watching the highlights of high scoring cricket match. It’s page after breathless page of how Sehmat settles in and gains the confidence of the household without even mentioning who are part of the household.
The climax is just a blur of words racing to finish the story. And then there’s a sudden shift to the events of the war between India & Pakistan. These events are narrated without much background and you’re left scrambling to try to piece everything together. After, there’s a cut back into Sehmat’s life which reads like the ending of a terrible Bollywood movie.
All in all a grave injustice to a probably very intelligent and brave woman. I hope someone decides to retell her story and actually does her justice.
Now here’s something I thought I’d never say: Skip the book and watch the movie. At least the movie has good songs.
May 6, 2019
I was planning to be generous with 3 stars but that wouldn't do justice to the other better written books with same rating.
Plot and characters deserved better narration.
I definitely didn't care for the last few chapters on the naval attacks. Though I am definitely watching the movie again!
Plot and characters deserved better narration.
I definitely didn't care for the last few chapters on the naval attacks. Though I am definitely watching the movie again!
July 29, 2020
Some of you have never met Vicky Kaushal as Iqbal Syed and it shows. RTC.
February 6, 2022
A good read. Inspiring. Definitely a to-be-read book.
Writing could have been better. Watched the movie (Raazi), again, halfway through the book.
Writing could have been better. Watched the movie (Raazi), again, halfway through the book.
Shelved as 'gave-up'
May 21, 2018God yes i want to read this
June 12, 2018
Extraordinary story of an Indian spy, writing style is not up to the mark. Still would say, all Indians should read this true account of a heroic Indian. Alia Bhatt starrer Raazi movie is based on this book.
July 20, 2018
The most beautiful way to share this legend.
The most beautiful book i have read after years. So emotional with intense emotions. It had love, sacrifice, lovr for nation, determination towards your nation and selfless love for our nation. Sehmat Khan was truely the most beautiful women in this whole world. Thank you Harinder Sikka for introducing her to us .
The most beautiful book i have read after years. So emotional with intense emotions. It had love, sacrifice, lovr for nation, determination towards your nation and selfless love for our nation. Sehmat Khan was truely the most beautiful women in this whole world. Thank you Harinder Sikka for introducing her to us .
July 22, 2018
I loved the storyline and plot twists. Really a good book. Go for it, even if you've seen Raazi.
October 17, 2018
Majority of times when we watch a movie based on a book (especially these days) they usually fall in between underwhelming to lousy :). Now that I have read the book and loved it as it gave me an in-depth idea on the character of Sehmat Khan as well as how and why she did what she did, I can very well say that the movie is Fantastically made and almost at par with the book if not better. I wanted to read the book before the movie came but the time was so short between the trailer, release and book becoming famous in no time, that I just couldn’t squeeze it in my busy schedule (of reading books of-course). Hence I finally managed to finish it today and I must tell you that I started the book yesterday only. Either the book is too short, or the pace is so nice that it took me only two sittings to finish it and I will very highly recommend it to everyone, especially to those who have seen and loved the movie. It is a totally unbelievable yet true story of Sehmat Khan a Kashmiri girl who goes to impossible heights in fulfilling her father’s last wishes to save the country from an imminent enemy attack.
I don’t think I need to talk much about the plot as the Movie has already made it pretty famous. What I loved about both, the movie and the book is the way they have shown so beautifully as how it was all done that too in the late 60’s to early 70’s. Bravo!! The ease with which Sehmat a girl in 20’s takes up the challenge and on top of that comes out a winner in the end is simply superb. The movie was an edge of the seat thriller yet it leaves so many questions unanswered which book responds in greater details, of-course it is again a fictionalized account of how it all must have happened. It also actually made me wonder if the Syeed’s (Sehmat’s In-laws) were actually so simple, yet were in those high positions in Pakistani Army and ISI, that they were fooled by a simple almost untrained girl, was a little unbelievable. But I will not counter or criticize it as it makes up for a superbly thrilling story in the end. We will never know the reality behind it as the real life Sehmat Khan, who never got her due has already passed away. The way it is done in the book, I really couldn’t believe that a R&AW agent who does something like that will ever get a Red-Carpet Welcome in our country at any point of time and will not be killed by the enemy country’s agent who are roaming around us since last three decades or more. But again, its a work of fiction with some reality in it, so we better take it with a pinch of salt and cherish it.
The philosophical touch in the end was very nice and the great details as what Sehmat does for the country while in Pakistan and how it all pays back heavy dividends was simply mind-blowing. The things that movie lacks in, the book fulfills like I said earlier. Even in the character development department, background story and aftermath is so beautifully done in the book. I totally loved it.
Have you read “Calling Sehmat”? Do let me know how you like it. As per you, which one was better? The Book or the Movie?
I don’t think I need to talk much about the plot as the Movie has already made it pretty famous. What I loved about both, the movie and the book is the way they have shown so beautifully as how it was all done that too in the late 60’s to early 70’s. Bravo!! The ease with which Sehmat a girl in 20’s takes up the challenge and on top of that comes out a winner in the end is simply superb. The movie was an edge of the seat thriller yet it leaves so many questions unanswered which book responds in greater details, of-course it is again a fictionalized account of how it all must have happened. It also actually made me wonder if the Syeed’s (Sehmat’s In-laws) were actually so simple, yet were in those high positions in Pakistani Army and ISI, that they were fooled by a simple almost untrained girl, was a little unbelievable. But I will not counter or criticize it as it makes up for a superbly thrilling story in the end. We will never know the reality behind it as the real life Sehmat Khan, who never got her due has already passed away. The way it is done in the book, I really couldn’t believe that a R&AW agent who does something like that will ever get a Red-Carpet Welcome in our country at any point of time and will not be killed by the enemy country’s agent who are roaming around us since last three decades or more. But again, its a work of fiction with some reality in it, so we better take it with a pinch of salt and cherish it.
The philosophical touch in the end was very nice and the great details as what Sehmat does for the country while in Pakistan and how it all pays back heavy dividends was simply mind-blowing. The things that movie lacks in, the book fulfills like I said earlier. Even in the character development department, background story and aftermath is so beautifully done in the book. I totally loved it.
Have you read “Calling Sehmat”? Do let me know how you like it. As per you, which one was better? The Book or the Movie?
November 28, 2022
Though the writing style of this story ( based on real events ) is simple , it is flowing and engaging . The events which occur through the book had a substantial impact on my mind ..... [ ☆☆Beware Spoilers ☆☆ ]
There are brief mentions of naval warfare .... [ ☆☆Beware Spoilers ☆☆ ] . It is sad that so many young lives were lost ... doesn't matter whether on this side or that . I salute authors like this who endeavor to bring home the brutality of wars .
Finally , a word on an incredible , real human being , Abhinav ( not his real name ) . [ ☆☆Beware Spoilers ☆☆ ]
There are brief mentions of naval warfare .... [ ☆☆Beware Spoilers ☆☆ ] . It is sad that so many young lives were lost ... doesn't matter whether on this side or that . I salute authors like this who endeavor to bring home the brutality of wars .
Finally , a word on an incredible , real human being , Abhinav ( not his real name ) . [ ☆☆Beware Spoilers ☆☆ ]
July 8, 2018
Follow Just A Girl High On Books for more reviews.
I'll be honest here. I only heard about this book when I went to watch Raazi - the Bollywood make of this book. I had loved Raazi. The story of Sehmat Khan made me cry. The hardships she had to face in order to save her nation were well, hard. All that she did for the country was impeccable.
So naturally, I was excited about this one as well. I wanted to know what the book held. Soon after buying it, I read this book and well... i was deeply disappointed.
For one, if anything, I had expected the book to pay more emphasis on Sehmat and all that she did. I understand that the author had to fictionalise a lot of scenarios because she wasn't ready to give him the whole story, but the parts where her life before she got the news of her father's demise, or the parts of her life that she spent in the university (although they helped in determining her character) seemed like a bore to me. I guess I was just expecting a fast paced thriller and this book was slow compared to that.
Well, this is it for now. I'll upload a detailed review later on. :)
I'll be honest here. I only heard about this book when I went to watch Raazi - the Bollywood make of this book. I had loved Raazi. The story of Sehmat Khan made me cry. The hardships she had to face in order to save her nation were well, hard. All that she did for the country was impeccable.
So naturally, I was excited about this one as well. I wanted to know what the book held. Soon after buying it, I read this book and well... i was deeply disappointed.
For one, if anything, I had expected the book to pay more emphasis on Sehmat and all that she did. I understand that the author had to fictionalise a lot of scenarios because she wasn't ready to give him the whole story, but the parts where her life before she got the news of her father's demise, or the parts of her life that she spent in the university (although they helped in determining her character) seemed like a bore to me. I guess I was just expecting a fast paced thriller and this book was slow compared to that.
Well, this is it for now. I'll upload a detailed review later on. :)
May 29, 2021
I had read this book when I was not acquainted with the technicalities about the Indian Intelligence Bureau or the defence for that matter. The book had me intrigued due to the unconventional thriller story and the Character- Sehmat. She is not your ordinary girl. She becomes a spy in Pakistan with her courage, writ and perseverance. The story is extremely gripping and keeps you on your toes.
You’ll be surprised to learn that the author wrote the book after listening to the ordeal of the real life Sehmat. If you loved the movie , Raazi, you’ll like the book. The spoilers don’t ruin it for you. If you haven’t watched the movie, don’t hesitate in grabbing your copy and later your popcorn!
You’ll be surprised to learn that the author wrote the book after listening to the ordeal of the real life Sehmat. If you loved the movie , Raazi, you’ll like the book. The spoilers don’t ruin it for you. If you haven’t watched the movie, don’t hesitate in grabbing your copy and later your popcorn!
May 26, 2018
This one should have been divided into 4 parts - Romance, Suspense, Action and Philosophy. The romance part (first 15% of book) is pathetic, earning - 1/5. The suspense (50% of the book) is wonderful, earning - 4/5. Action (20%) is interesting as it's historical with information that I haven't read before - 4/5. Philosophy(5%) is where I observed most 'highlighted' areas in Kindle. It means that lot of people did like them, but I didn't - 2/5.
One request I have to the author is to avoid experimenting with romance. I wasn't convinced about how Sehmet fell in love with Aby. The stage set for their romance was worse than a Tamil/Telugu mass movie. What's even weird is how Sehmet, reluctantly but easily, agreed to get married to another man. I can't get into details due to spoilers. Some of the writing was sloppy as not well established. Thank God that I skimmed through this part until the spy sequence sets in.
Suspense: This is where the author displayed his brilliance. I felt it was a different person writing this part. The pace, story line, the setting, intrigues are excellent. There were moments my heart was beating fast due to which I stopped reading for a while. May be I'm exaggerating, but this part which is 50% of the book, is an excellent read. The twist and turns are different and not very predictable.
Action: The result of what Sehmat achieved is wonderfully laid out. This part reminds me of a book I read, 'India's most fearless'. They are quick short reads of the Navy attack during 1971 war. It's quite an exciting read especially if you want to know the tactical achievement Indian Navy achieved and the sacrifice Navy officers made during the period.
Philosophy: The author decided the finish the story he started taking a philosophical route. While it's not my favorite part, there were lot of Kindle readers 'highlights'.
What could have been better? While the back story of Sehmet was needed, what was missing is why will a girl decide to take on being a spy? The explanation is not convincing enough for her die hard devotion to her country.
There could have been more time spent on the spying part. I felt other characters weren't as well as developed as was Sehmet. He could have added how her love for her husband kind of confused her loyalty or her father in law was developing suspicion or created another sort of drama in her in-law front. I also wonder how come Iqbal, her husband, didn't suspect of his wife behaviour. That part left me confused.
Overall I recommend reading this one. It brings a fresh voice to Indian thriller fiction genre.
One request I have to the author is to avoid experimenting with romance. I wasn't convinced about how Sehmet fell in love with Aby. The stage set for their romance was worse than a Tamil/Telugu mass movie. What's even weird is how Sehmet, reluctantly but easily, agreed to get married to another man. I can't get into details due to spoilers. Some of the writing was sloppy as not well established. Thank God that I skimmed through this part until the spy sequence sets in.
Suspense: This is where the author displayed his brilliance. I felt it was a different person writing this part. The pace, story line, the setting, intrigues are excellent. There were moments my heart was beating fast due to which I stopped reading for a while. May be I'm exaggerating, but this part which is 50% of the book, is an excellent read. The twist and turns are different and not very predictable.
Action: The result of what Sehmat achieved is wonderfully laid out. This part reminds me of a book I read, 'India's most fearless'. They are quick short reads of the Navy attack during 1971 war. It's quite an exciting read especially if you want to know the tactical achievement Indian Navy achieved and the sacrifice Navy officers made during the period.
Philosophy: The author decided the finish the story he started taking a philosophical route. While it's not my favorite part, there were lot of Kindle readers 'highlights'.
What could have been better? While the back story of Sehmet was needed, what was missing is why will a girl decide to take on being a spy? The explanation is not convincing enough for her die hard devotion to her country.
There could have been more time spent on the spying part. I felt other characters weren't as well as developed as was Sehmet. He could have added how her love for her husband kind of confused her loyalty or her father in law was developing suspicion or created another sort of drama in her in-law front. I also wonder how come Iqbal, her husband, didn't suspect of his wife behaviour. That part left me confused.
Overall I recommend reading this one. It brings a fresh voice to Indian thriller fiction genre.
Displaying 1 - 29 of 407 reviews