The Greatest Second Basemen of All Time

Ranker Community
Updated May 2, 2024 108.7K views 111 items
Ranked By
64.7K votes
7.6K voters
85 reranks
Voting Rules
Only players who are known primarily as second basemen and not other infield positions
Latest additions: Marcus Semien, Jeff McNeil
Most divisive: Nellie Fox
Over 7.6K Ranker voters have come together to rank this list of Second Basemen

The greatest 2nd basemen of all time include some of the most iconic names in MLB history. Many of the names on this list are famous players who dominated during the pre-1950s era of Major League Baseball, like Rogers Hornsby and Jackie Robinson, but a few modern-era players like Joe Morgan and Ryne Sandberg are also considered among the best. These guys are the best second basemen in the league and make some of the toughest plays look so incredibly easy, with excellent fielding skills.

Who do you think deserves the honor of the best 2nd baseman of all time? Vote for your favorite second baseman and rerank this list any way you like. The greatest second basemen of all time were slap hitters that got on base and set the table for their team. In recent years, the trend has shifted towards power, and that's changing the face of the 2-bagger dramatically. Like some of the greatest first basemen ever, these 2nd base players were true leaders on their respective teams. From Joe Morgan and Jackie Robinson (arguably two of the greatest baseball players ever) to modern players like Cano and Pedroia, every player listed here played (or plays) a key role for their team and many are power hitters.
  • Rogers Hornsby
    1
    2,649 votes
    Dec. at 66 (1896-1963)

    One of the greatest hitters in baseball history, Rogers Hornsby's prowess at the plate was matched only by his skill as a second baseman. A true master of the game, Hornsby led the league in batting average, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage numerous times throughout his legendary career. Often mentioned alongside the likes of Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb, Hornsby's impact on the sport continues to be felt today as generations of players look to him as the standard for success at the position.

  • Joe Morgan
    2
    2,975 votes
    Age: 80

    Joe Morgan's intelligence, versatility, and all-around excellence made him a true force to be reckoned with in the line-up of any MLB team. An expert at playing the game within the game, Morgan could often be found outsmarting his opponents from his position at second base. A key figure in the Cincinnati Reds' "Big Red Machine" dynasty of the 1970s, Morgan's career is remembered as one marked by sheer dominance and an unrivaled passion for baseball.

  • Jackie Robinson
    3
    2,757 votes
    Dec. at 53 (1919-1972)

    The man who changed baseball forever, Jackie Robinson remains one of the most important figures in American sports history. As the first African-American player in Major League Baseball, Robinson's courage and determination broke down barriers both on and off the field, paving the way for future generations of black athletes. Known for his lightning-quick speed and tenacious defense, Robinson's legacy as a player and humanitarian continues to loom large over the sport.

  • Rod Carew
    4
    2,043 votes
    Age: 78

    In a career defined by consistency, Rod Carew cemented his status as a top-tier second baseman with his exceptional hitting ability and outstanding defensive skills. A student of the game, Carew's approach to hitting was characterized by a meticulous understanding of both the pitcher's arsenal and the situation at hand. His impact on the sport endures, as his contributions to the development of young players and a focus on promoting baseball around the world have left a lasting mark.

  • Roberto Alomar
    5
    2,490 votes

    A master of both the offensive and defensive aspects of the game, Roberto Alomar's style of play was as captivating as it was effective. Known for his incredible range and smooth transitions in the field, Alomar also possessed a strong and accurate arm that made him a feared presence on defense. At the plate, his ability to consistently produce clutch hits earned him the reputation as one of the game's most dangerous players in high-pressure situations.

  • Ryne Sandberg
    6
    2,528 votes

    A well-rounded talent, Ryne Sandberg left an indelible impression on the sport through his work ethic, leadership, and consistently high level of play. As a second baseman, Sandberg exhibited a natural ability to track down seemingly uncatchable balls, earning him a reputation as one of the best defensive players at the position. Offensively, his power-hitting capabilities and disciplined approach at the plate ensured that he remained a threat to opposing pitchers throughout his career.

  • Craig Biggio
    7
    1,887 votes

    One of the hardest working players in baseball during his time, Craig Biggio's relentless pursuit of improvement established him as a model for what a second baseman could be. A true student of the game, Biggio exhibited an exceptional understanding of the nuances of playing the position, as evidenced by his uncanny ability to turn double plays with ease. He coupled this defensive prowess with a knack for getting on base and generating runs, consistently making him a key player in his team's offensive success.

  • Lou Whitaker
    8
    1,544 votes

    Unassuming yet lethal, Lou Whitaker's steady and consistent play at second base made him a cornerstone of the Detroit Tigers' successes in the 1980s. Displaying an innate understanding of the position, Whitaker was known for his quick reflexes and soft hands, deftly scooping up ground balls and making difficult plays look easy. On offense, his skill at the plate ensured that he could be counted on for timely hits and steady production, rounding out his comprehensive impact on the sport.

  • Eddie Collins
    9
    1,786 votes
    Dec. at 63 (1887-1951)

    A true pioneer of the game, Eddie Collins' impact on baseball can still be felt today as his career numbers and achievements continue to inspire awe. Best known for his incredible speed and agility, Collins consistently presented a threat on the basepaths, striking fear into the hearts of opposing pitchers. In the field, his keen instincts and natural athleticism allowed him to play second base with a level of skill that set the standard for generations to come.

  • Charlie Gehringer
    10
    1,592 votes
    Dec. at 89 (1903-1993)

    A remarkably consistent player, Charlie Gehringer's name is often mentioned in conversations about the greatest second basemen in history. Known for his smooth fielding and strong arm, Gehringer was a defensive standout, setting the standard for second basemen of his time. At the plate, his ability to consistently find a way on base and generate runs made him a valuable asset for his team throughout his career.

  • Nap Lajoie
    11
    1,838 votes
    Dec. at 84 (1874-1959)

    A force to be reckoned with in the early days of professional baseball, Nap Lajoie's skill on both sides of the ball earned him a place among the sport's elite. As a hitter, Lajoie was feared for his power and accuracy, frequently driving the ball deep into the outfield with ease. Defensively, his ability to cover ground and make acrobatic plays at second base were a testament to his athleticism and solidified his status as one of the greatest players of his era.

  • Paul Molitor
    12
    337 votes

    An offensive juggernaut, Paul Molitor's prowess at the plate made him one of the all-time greats in baseball history. Displaying an uncanny ability to consistently hit for both power and average, Molitor's name became synonymous with offensive production. Though primarily remembered for his time as a designated hitter, Molitor's time spent playing second base showcased a strong defensive skillset and solidified his status as a versatile and valuable asset to his team.

  • Pete Rose
    13
    715 votes
    Age: 83

    As one of the most polarizing yet undeniably talented players in baseball history, Pete Rose's career is one riddled with controversy, but also marked by undeniable success. Known for his relentless hustle and unmatched competitiveness, Rose's play at second base was characterized by an aggressive style and a never-say-die attitude. At the plate, his ability to consistently make contact and rack up hits earned him the well-deserved nickname "Charlie Hustle" and solidified his place among baseball's all-time greats.

  • José Altuve
    14
    1,289 votes

    Diminutive in stature but colossal in impact, José Altuve's presence in the MLB is a testament to the idea that size doesn't always matter. As a second baseman, Altuve exhibits lightning-quick reflexes, allowing him to cover an immense amount of ground and make seemingly impossible plays. Offensively, his impressive speed, pitch selection, and innate ability to make consistent contact have made him one of the most exciting and productive players in today's game.

  • Jeff Kent
    15
    1,222 votes
    Age: 56

    A powerful and consistent hitter throughout his career, Jeff Kent established himself as one of the premier offensive second basemen in baseball history. Combining his impressive power with an uncanny ability to drive in runs, Kent was often the driving force behind his team's offensive success. Defensively, he displayed solid fundamentals and a strong arm, rounding out his skillset and securing his place among the all-time greats at the position.

  • Willie Randolph
    16
    1,023 votes

    A consummate professional and an exceptional talent, Willie Randolph played the game with a combination of savvy and skill that few could match. Known for his excellent plate discipline and ability to generate walks, Randolph was a constant presence on the basepaths, consistently putting pressure on opposing pitchers. In the field, his smooth defensive play and keen instincts made him a standout at second base, ensuring his status as one of the game's top players for years to come.

  • Robinson Canó
    17
    1,603 votes

    A modern-day star, Robinson Canó's presence in the MLB has been defined by his smooth style of play and undeniable skill at both the plate and in the field. Displaying exceptional range and an uncanny ability to read the ball off the bat, Canó has become one of the best defensive second basemen in the game. On offense, his consistent power and disciplined approach have made him a feared hitter, ensuring that he remains a key figure in the landscape of today's baseball.

  • Dustin Pedroia
    18
    1,311 votes

    A gritty and tenacious player, Dustin Pedroia's heart and determination on the field made him a fan favorite and a key component to his team's successes. With a relentless work ethic and unyielding drive to win, Pedroia embodied the spirit of a true competitor at second base, making every play with a level of intensity that was infectious. At the plate, his scrappy and disciplined approach enabled him to consistently produce and contribute to his team's offensive output.

  • Bobby Grich
    19
    960 votes

    Known for his exceptional defense and power-hitting capabilities, Bobby Grich forged a career as one of the most complete second basemen of his time. With a penchant for making highlight-reel plays and a keen understanding of the position, Grich's contributions in the field were invaluable. Offensively, his ability to hit for both power and average made him a dynamic presence in the lineup, ensuring his mark on the sport would not soon be forgotten.

  • Chase Utley
    20
    1,642 votes

    Considered one of the most intense and hard-nosed players of his generation, Chase Utley's impact on the game extended far beyond the diamond. His relentless hustle and unrivaled work ethic inspired both teammates and fans alike, as his presence in the lineup made his team a force to be reckoned with. Combining his exceptional defense with a consistently productive offensive approach, Utley's career remains a shining example of what it means to play the game the right way.

  • Red Schoendienst
    21
    809 votes

    A versatile and invaluable player, Red Schoendienst's career was marked by his ability to excel at multiple positions, including second base. A consummate professional, Schoendienst played the game with a level of poise and skill that few could match. As a hitter, he was known for his consistency and ability to generate contact, ensuring that he remained a valuable contributor to his team's offensive success throughout his career.

  • Frank White
    22
    649 votes

    One of the greatest defensive second basemen of all time, Frank White's skills in the field were nothing short of extraordinary. With a reputation for making dazzling plays and displaying incredible range, White set the gold standard for defensive excellence at the position. Although primarily known for his work in the field, he also proved to be a capable hitter, providing his team with timely and consistent offense during his time in the league.

  • Nellie Fox
    23
    1,342 votes
    Dec. at 47 (1927-1975)

    A true old-school player, Nellie Fox's career was defined by his gritty play and relentless determination on the field. As a second baseman, Fox exhibited exceptional glove work and a keen understanding of the position, enabling him to make challenging plays look routine. At the plate, his knack for putting the ball in play and generating contact made him a valuable asset to his team's offensive success, solidifying his status as one of the best at the position.

  • Bill Mazeroski
    24
    1,228 votes

    Widely regarded as one of the finest defensive second basemen to ever play the game, Bill Mazeroski's prowess in the field is the stuff of legend. Known for his quick reflexes, smooth glove work, and strong arm, Mazeroski could make even the most difficult plays look effortless. Though primarily remembered for his work in the field, he also provided timely offense throughout his career, ensuring his place among the all-time greats at the position.

  • Bobby Doerr
    25
    1,034 votes
    Age: 106

    A true icon of the sport, Bobby Doerr stood out as a beacon of talent and class during his storied career. Known for his smooth and effortless play at second base, Doerr's defensive skills were matched only by his prowess at the plate. As a hitter, he consistently provided power and run production, ensuring that he would leave a lasting mark on the sport and secure his place among the game's elite.

  • Bobby Richardson
    26
    423 votes

    Bobby Richardson

    Age: 88

    Playing with a level of grace and skill that few could match, Bobby Richardson's career as a second baseman was one marked by consistent excellence. Renowned for his exceptional defensive abilities, Richardson was a key figure in the success of his team's perennial championship runs. At the plate, his disciplined approach and timely hitting made him a valuable contributor, ensuring that his impact on the game would be felt for generations to come.

  • Joe Gordon
    27
    871 votes
    Dec. at 63 (1915-1978)

    An exceptional talent both at the plate and in the field, Joe Gordon's ability to excel in all aspects of the game made him one of the premier second basemen of his time. With a reputation for making difficult defensive plays look routine, Gordon's skillset at second base was virtually unmatched. As a hitter, he combined power with a keen eye, consistently providing his team with offensive production and solidifying his status as an all-time great at the position.

  • Alfonso Soriano
    28
    503 votes

    A dynamic and electrifying talent, Alfonso Soriano's skills at the plate and in the field made him one of the most exciting players of his era. As a second baseman, Soriano exhibited impressive range and quick hands, allowing him to make spectacular plays in the field. Offensively, his power-speed combination made him a force to be reckoned with, as he could change the course of a game with a single swing or stolen base.

  • Billy Herman
    29
    623 votes
    Dec. at 83 (1909-1992)

    Exemplifying the epitome of consistency and reliability throughout his career, Billy Herman's play at second base set the standard for what it meant to be a top-tier player at the position. Known for his steady glove work and solid defense, Herman's contributions in the field were a key factor in his team's success. At the plate, his ability to consistently make contact and get on base ensured that he remained a valuable offensive asset for years to come.

  • Frankie Frisch
    30
    1,229 votes
    Dec. at 74 (1898-1973)

    Known as "The Fordham Flash" for his incredible speed and quickness on the field, Frankie Frisch's impact on the game was felt in every aspect of his play. As a second baseman, Frisch displayed remarkable range and a keen understanding of the position, allowing him to excel defensively. Offensively, his speed and ability to hit for contact made him a constant threat, ensuring that he would remain one of the game's most memorable figures.

  • Davey Lopes
    31
    734 votes

    Combining exceptional speed with a keen understanding of the game, Davey Lopes made a name for himself as one of the most dangerous players on the basepaths during his time in the league. As a second baseman, Lopes displayed smooth fielding skills and quick reflexes, making him a standout presence in the field. At the plate, his disciplined approach and ability to get on base made him a consistent threat, ensuring that his impact on the game would not soon be forgotten.

  • Tony Lazzeri
    32
    996 votes
    Dec. at 42 (1903-1946)

    Renowned for his clutch hitting and steady play in the field, Tony Lazzeri was a cornerstone of the legendary Yankees teams of the 1920s and 1930s. As a second baseman, Lazzeri displayed impeccable instincts and a smooth glove, making him a crucial piece of the team's defensive puzzle. At the plate, his uncanny ability to deliver in high-pressure situations made him a fan favorite and ensured his place among the all-time greats at the position.

  • Julio Franco
    33
    393 votes

    With a remarkably long and storied career, Julio Franco showcased a unique combination of longevity and consistency that few players can match. As a second baseman, Franco demonstrated impressive footwork and quick reflexes, making him a valuable asset in the field. At the plate, his signature batting stance and penchant for timely hits made him a fan favorite and solidified his place among the most memorable players of his generation.

  • Carlos Baerga
    34
    395 votes

    A gifted hitter with a flair for the dramatic, Carlos Baerga was a key figure in the powerful lineups of the Cleveland Indians teams of the 1990s. As a second baseman, Baerga exhibited solid defensive skills, contributing to a well-rounded overall game. Offensively, his switch-hitting prowess and knack for clutch performances endeared him to fans and ensured that his impact on the sport would be remembered for years to come.

  • Davey Johnson
    35
    307 votes

    Known for his steady defense and clutch hitting, Davey Johnson carved out a successful career as a premier second baseman. In the field, Johnson showcased strong defensive fundamentals and a keen understanding of the game, making him a crucial component of his team's success. At the plate, his ability to deliver when it mattered most made him a key figure in the league, ensuring that his impact on the game would not soon be forgotten.

  • Harold Reynolds
    36
    396 votes

    Known for his exceptional speed and top-notch defensive abilities, Harold Reynolds made a lasting impression on the game as a standout second baseman. In the field, his quick reflexes and soft hands allowed him to excel at making difficult plays and turning double plays with ease. Offensively, his blazing speed on the basepaths struck fear into opposing pitchers, adding an exciting dynamic to his team's offensive attack.

  • Tom Herr
    37
    263 votes
    Age: 68

    A steady and dependable presence at second base, Tom Herr maintained a consistently high level of play throughout his career. Defensively, Herr's smooth glove work and quick reactions allowed him to make spectacular plays with apparent ease. As a hitter, his patient approach at the plate and ability to generate contact made him a valuable contributor on offense, rounding out his well-rounded skillset at the position.

  • Ian Kinsler
    38
    556 votes

    Throughout his career, Ian Kinsler has been a consistent and reliable force at second base, excelling in both offensive and defensive aspects of the game. In the field, Kinsler's instincts and quick hands have earned him a reputation as one of the best at the position. At the plate, his disciplined approach and power-hitting capabilities have made him a dangerous presence, ensuring his place among the top second basemen of his generation.

  • Javier Báez
    39
    225 votes

    Javier Báez

    Age: 31

    A human highlight reel with an infectious enthusiasm for the game, Javier Báez has quickly become one of the MLB's most exciting and entertaining players. As a second baseman, Báez dazzles fans with his spectacular defensive plays, lightning-quick reflexes, and fearless approach to the game. Offensively, his combination of power and speed make him a constant threat, ensuring that he remains a key figure in the ever-evolving landscape of modern baseball.

  • Eddie Stanky
    40
    279 votes
    Dec. at 82 (1916-1999)

    A gritty and determined player, Eddie Stanky showcased a relentless work ethic and competitive spirit throughout his career. As a second baseman, Stanky was known for his exceptional defensive skills, frequently making game-changing plays in the field. At the plate, his keen eye and disciplined approach made him a valuable contributor on offense, ensuring his place in the annals of baseball history.

  • Bret Boone
    41
    367 votes
    Age: 55

    A true force at the plate and in the field, Bret Boone's career was marked by his ability to excel in all aspects of the game. As a second baseman, Boone displayed impressive defensive skills, making difficult plays look routine and anchoring the middle infield. Offensively, his power-hitting prowess ensured that he remained a constant threat, forging a legacy as one of the premier second basemen of his time.

  • Brandon Phillips
    42
    605 votes

    Combining dazzling defense with an exciting offensive game, Brandon Phillips has established himself as one of the most electric second basemen in recent memory. With incredible range and a penchant for making highlight-reel plays, Phillips' defensive abilities are truly a sight to behold. Offensively, his power and speed make him a dangerous presence in the lineup, rounding out his impressive skillset and securing his status as a top-tier talent at the position.

  • Johnny Evers
    43
    643 votes
    Dec. at 65 (1881-1947)

    As a crucial component of the legendary "Tinker to Evers to Chance" double-play combination, Johnny Evers' impact on the game cannot be overstated. At second base, Evers showcased extraordinary defensive skills, helping to revolutionize the position with his smooth footwork and quick hands. Offensively, his ability to consistently get on base and generate runs made him a valuable asset, ensuring that his contributions to the game would endure for generations to come.

  • Jim Gilliam
    44
    209 votes
    Dec. at 49 (1928-1978)

    A versatile and skilled player, Jim Gilliam's abilities extended far beyond just his prowess as a second baseman. In the field, Gilliam's exceptional range and quick reflexes allowed him to make difficult plays with ease, inspiring awe among fans and fellow players alike. At the plate, his disciplined approach and ability to generate contact made him a valuable asset on offense, solidifying his place among the game's best at the position.

  • Phil Garner
    45
    245 votes

    Epitomizing the gritty, hard-nosed style of play that defined his era, Phil Garner showcased an unwavering determination and intensity on the field. As a second baseman, Garner exhibited strong defensive skills and an unmatched tenacity, making him a key component of his team's success. Offensively, his determination to battle at the plate and consistently drive in runs ensured that he remained a valuable contributor throughout his career.

  • D. J. LeMahieu
    46
    123 votes

    Setting new standards with his smooth defensive play and consistent hitting, D. J. LeMahieu has quickly emerged as one of the premier second basemen in the game today. With a knack for making difficult plays look easy and an uncanny ability to read the ball off the bat, LeMahieu's presence in the field is nothing short of impressive. At the plate, his disciplined approach and ability to drive the ball have made him a formidable offensive force and an invaluable contributor to his team's success.

  • Plácido Polanco
    47
    241 votes

    With a reputation for consistently steady play and a strong work ethic, Plácido Polanco's career was defined by his ability to excel in all aspects of the game. As a second baseman, Polanco displayed smooth defensive skills and an unwavering focus that made him a reliable presence in the field. Offensively, his contact-driven approach and keen eye at the plate made him a valuable contributor, ensuring that his impact on the game would be lasting.

  • Robby Thompson
    48
    261 votes

    An exceptional talent both offensively and defensively, Robby Thompson's impressive career earned him a place among the top second basemen of his generation. In the field, Thompson's quick reflexes and strong arm made him a standout presence at second base. At the plate, his combination of power and discipline ensured that he remained a consistent threat, solidifying his status as a true force within the sport.

  • Steve Sax
    49
    416 votes
    Age: 64
    Stephen Louis Sax (born January 29, 1960) is an American former second baseman in Major League Baseball. He was a right-handed batter for the Los Angeles Dodgers (1981–88), New York Yankees (1989–91), Chicago White Sox (1992–93), and the Oakland Athletics (1994). Sax currently hosts on SiriusXM's MLB Network Radio.
  • Tony Phillips
    50
    202 votes
    Keith Anthony Phillips (April 25, 1959 – February 17, 2016) was an American professional baseball utility player who had an 18-year Major League Baseball (MLB) career from 1982 to 1999. He played regularly at second base, but also had significant time as a shortstop and third baseman. In addition, Phillips showed his versatility with over 100 game appearances in the outfield corners and as a designated hitter.
  • Jim Gantner
    51
    170 votes
    James Elmer Gantner (born January 5, 1953) is a former Major League Baseball player who spent his entire career with the Milwaukee Brewers (1976–92).
  • Glenn Beckert
    52
    181 votes
    Glenn Alfred Beckert (born October 12, 1940) is an American former professional baseball player. He played in Major League as a second baseman for the Chicago Cubs for nine seasons from 1965 to 1973 before ending his career with the San Diego Padres in 1975.
  • Félix Millán
    53
    151 votes

    A skilled and reliable presence at second base, Félix Millán's career was marked by consistent excellence and a keen understanding of the game. In the field, Millán's smooth glove work and quick reactions allowed him to excel defensively, positioning him as one of the top second basemen of his time. At the plate, his ability to hit for contact and generate timely hits ensured that he remained a valuable offensive asset during his tenure in the league.

  • Pete Runnels
    54
    187 votes
    Dec. at 63 (1928-1991)
    James Edward "Pete" Runnels (January 28, 1928 – May 20, 1991) was an American Major League Baseball infielder who played for the Washington Senators (1951–57), Boston Red Sox (1958–62) and Houston Colt .45s (1963–64). Runnels won two American League batting average championships while a member of the Red Sox.
  • Tommy Helms
    55
    148 votes
    Tommy Vann Helms (born May 5, 1941) is an American former professional baseball player and manager. Over a 14-year Major League Baseball career (1964-1977), Helms played for four teams, including eight seasons with the Cincinnati Reds, four with the Houston Astros, and one each with the Pittsburgh Pirates and Boston Red Sox. He also managed the Reds for part of two seasons (1988-1989). He is the uncle of former Major League player Wes Helms.
  • Dave Cash
    56
    171 votes
    Age: 75
    David Cash Jr. (born June 11, 1948), is an American former professional baseball second baseman, who played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the Pittsburgh Pirates, Philadelphia Phillies, Montreal Expos, and San Diego Padres, from 1969 to 1980.
  • Johnny Ray
    57
    147 votes
    Age: 67
    Johnny Ray may refer to: Johnny Ray (racing driver) (born 1937), former NASCAR driver and team owner Johnny Ray (baseball) (born 1957), former second baseman for the Pittsburgh Pirates and California Angels Johnny Ray Rodríguez, American actor of Puerto Rican descent Johnny Ray (Latin singer), born Johnny Zamot, Puerto Rican Latin singer, see Ray Sepúlveda Johnny Ray (silent film actor), (? - 1927), American actor
  • Dick McAuliffe
    58
    370 votes
    Richard John "Dick" McAuliffe (November 29, 1939 – May 13, 2016) was an American professional baseball player. He played in Major League Baseball as a shortstop and second baseman for the Detroit Tigers from 1960 to 1973 and for the Boston Red Sox from 1974 to 1975. He was a part of the Tigers' 1968 World Series championship, and was known for his unusual batting stance. A left-handed hitter, he held his hands very high with an open stance that faced the pitcher. As the pitcher delivered to home plate, McAuliffe moved his forward (right) foot to a more conventional position for his swing.
  • Ray Durham
    59
    218 votes
    Age: 52
    1971
  • Manny Trillo
    60
    347 votes
    Jesús Manuel Marcano Trillo (born December 25, 1950), also nicknamed "Indio", is a Venezuelan former professional baseball second baseman, who played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the Oakland Athletics (1973–1974), Chicago Cubs (1975–1978, 1986–1988), Philadelphia Phillies ((1979–1982), Cleveland Indians (1983), Montreal Expos (1983), San Francisco Giants (1984–1985), and Cincinnati Reds (1989). A four-time All-Star, he was the Phillies' starting second baseman when the franchise won its first-ever World Series Championship in 1980. He was known as one of the best fielding second basemen of his era, with a strong throwing arm.