e-sim or pocket wifi - Shinjuku Forum - Tripadvisor

e-sim or pocket wifi

Las Vegas, Nevada
1 post
e-sim or pocket wifi

which is better to use when visiting Japan, E-sim or pocket wifi?

32 replies to this topic
Canada
Level Contributor
273 posts
28 reviews
28 helpful votes
21. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

I understand. Better to be safer than sorry. You're right. Some of the public Wi-Fi is were inconsistent but we survived. However the pocket Wi-Fi will be more reliable. Enjoy!

Los Angeles...
Level Contributor
288 posts
46 reviews
40 helpful votes
22. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

I rented 2 hot pocket wifi units for our family of 4 adults. this would allow us to explore on our own, as I knew we would at least be in pairs. This was super helpful when we wanted to shop at different stores. You just need to remember who is carrying the hotspots. Pocket wifi was super super easy to activate & connect. the hotspot lasted about 12-hrs per charge & having an extra battery helps too.

California
Level Contributor
214 posts
93 reviews
73 helpful votes
23. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

So with a pocket wifi, put my iPhone on airplane mode, and connect to wifi just like if I were in a cafe? And then is the pocket wifi always turned on or only turned on when using it?

Canada
Level Contributor
258 posts
3 reviews
11 helpful votes
24. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

@14 Derek

Could you kindly elaborate what was the problem with setting up esim from Airalo?

I am considering Airalo 20 GB.

Have unlocked Samsung S22, but I never used esim before...

Anybody with that phone using Airalo?

Athens, Greece
Level Contributor
379 posts
25. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

All physical SIMs work fine in all smartphones and absolutely nothing will happen to your phone or your regular connection if you add additional APN settings (of course you need an unlocked phone) since all you have to do when you return home is insert your normal local SIM and "tick" the already stored local APN settings.

All this of course if you are under 90 years old :) and actually know how to operate your smartphone .

The instructions that come with Japanese SIMs are very straightforward and easy to follow and will show you how to change your APN settings.

Edited: 2:09 pm, April 12, 2024
Canada
Level Contributor
273 posts
28 reviews
28 helpful votes
26. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

I'm sorry but that's simply not true.

A lot of people have reported that you had to change settings and it made it hard for their phone to work when they returned.

In addition my friend bought a SIM from haneda airport and was not able to program it by following the instructions. She even asked cell phone store staff to help her and they couldn't make it work even though her phone is unlocked and it worked in other countries she has traveled to around the world. Pocket Wi-Fi is a simple n Surefire way to get the Wi-Fi you need.

If you seek to get a sim or a sim, the staff may not be able to help you and you won't get a refund and all your money will be down to drain

Athens, Greece
Level Contributor
379 posts
27. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

* lot of people have reported that you had to change settings and it made it hard for their phone to work when they returned.*

That's because they don't know how their phones work and are to lazy to read the supplied instructions..my 10 year old son managed to do it so it's a no brainer as long as you "read the,you know what, manual :)

28. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

Tripadvisor staff removed this post because it did not meet Tripadvisor's forum guideline with regards to harassment of another user.

What are forum guidelines?
 
Washington DC...
Level Contributor
1,206 posts
182 reviews
70 helpful votes
29. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

If your phone supports it, use an esim and you don’t have to touch your physical SIM card. We used the Ubigi esim card. A big advantage of an esim is that you can set it up right before you leave home and know it works. Ubigi hs a nice app you download and tells you exactly what to do. It verifies the connection. When we were in the air, I switched off my home sim and enabled the esim. Once we landed it connected to the network within a couple of minutes and I was online. Returning home, I did the reverse and had no issues connecting to my home sim.

Pocket WiFi has a couple of advantages - it is a “slightly” easier connection and I think people are more used to switching WiFi networks back home. They never need to touch their sim configuration so it seems more difficult. Pocket WiFi also lets multiple people share a connection. Downsides are charging, carrying, and needing to keep your party together

The eSIM makes it possible to split up. There were multiple times that my wife wanted to shop while I went to look at a temple. There was also a situation where we got split up transferring trains. Since we both had esims - no panic just a WhatsApp message to agree on which station we would reconnect.

Each person need to decide what is important to them before selecting the best option. I see other posts where people use public WiFi and still like paper maps. I prefer the ability to always be connected to wander and use translation, online maps for walking, a quick check of reviews for lunch. Esim was the right option for my trip but pocket WiFi could easily work for someone else.

Croydon, United...
Level Contributor
1,276 posts
75 reviews
138 helpful votes
30. Re: e-sim or pocket wifi

I just returned from Japan yesterday. While out there, I used a physical sim. Had no problems at all using it on hol, and on return to the UK, my UK sim resumed working without me having to change any settings on my phone.

Reply to: e-sim or pocket wifi
Get notified by e-mail when a reply is posted
© 2024 Tripadvisor LLC All rights reserved.

This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.