Gubernatorial elections, 2020

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
StateExecLogo.png
State Executive Officials

State executive elections by position and year:

Eleven states and two U.S. territories held elections for governor in 2020. Of those eleven states, only Montana featured a term-limited incumbent.

Incumbents won nine of the eleven races. Spencer Cox (R) won in Utah, where Republican incumbent Gary Herbert (R) did not run for re-election. Greg Gianforte (R) won in Montana, where incumbent Gov. Steve Bullock (D) was term-limited, making Montana's governorship the only one to change party control in 2020.

Out of all the state executive offices, only the governor is elected in all 50 states. As the chief executive officer, the governor is among the most powerful figures in state government.

Most states impose some form of term limits on governors; of those that do, all but Virginia limit a governor to two four-year terms or to eight years in office. Although most states' term limit laws allow a governor who has served two terms to be elected once again after time has elapsed, some states impose a lifetime term limit like that on the presidency.

Elections covered on this page may have been impacted by the coronavirus pandemic. To read more about those elections and changes to them, click here.

On this page, you will find:

  • An overview of how many governorships each party held before and after the 2020 elections.
  • A list of the eleven gubernatorial elections that took place in 2020.
  • A list of offices that changed party control in 2020.
  • A list of incumbents who did not seek re-election in 2020.
  • A list of offices that flipped in the 2019 elections.
  • A summary of election competitivenes in the 2020 elections.
  • An analysis of margins of victory for winning candidates from 2004 to 2020.
  • An analysis of battleground races in 2020.
  • Outside race ratings from The Cook Political Report, Sabato's Crystal Ball, and Inside Elections.
  • An overview of polls in selected races.
  • A summary of 2020 state government trifecta results.
  • A summary of 2020 state government triplex results.
  • Presidential election results for the 2020 and 2016 elections.
  • A history of gubernatorial partisanship from 1977 to 2020.
  • A summary of election results from 2016 and 2012.
  • A list of states that held both gubernatorial and U.S. Senate elections in 2020.
  • A table of ballot access requirements for gubernatorial candidates.
  • Information about the office of governor.
  • Links to Ballotpedia's analysis of state elections.

While this page includes links to pages on state executive elections in the U.S. Territories, it does not include the territories in its statistics.

2020 Gubernatorial Races
State Incumbent Term-limited (Y/N) Incumbent running?
American Samoa Grey.png Lolo Matalasi Moliga Yes No
Delaware Democratic Party John Carney Jr. No Yes
Indiana Republican Party Eric Holcomb No Yes
Missouri Republican Party Mike Parson No Yes
Montana Democratic Party Steve Bullock Yes No
New Hampshire Republican Party Chris Sununu No Yes
North Carolina Democratic Party Roy Cooper No Yes
North Dakota Republican Party Doug Burgum No Yes
Puerto Rico Grey.png Wanda Vázquez Garced No Yes
Utah Republican Party Gary Herbert No No
Vermont Republican Party Phil Scott No Yes
Washington Democratic Party Jay Inslee No Yes
West Virginia Republican Party Jim Justice No Yes




Partisan breakdown

See also: Election results, 2020: Partisan balance of governors

The following chart displays the number of governors' offices held by each party as of the 2020 elections and immediately after the elections took place.

U.S. governors partisan breakdown
Party As of November 2020 After the 2020 elections
     Democratic Party 24 23
     Republican Party 26 27
Total 50 50

Election results

The table below shows gubernatorial elections that took place in 2020.

State Trifecta status (before) Trifecta status (after) Triplex status (before) Triplex status (after) Incumbent Incumbent ran? Winner Margin of victory
Delaware Democratic trifecta Democratic trifecta Democratic triplex Democratic triplex John C. Carney Jr.jpg
John Carney Jr. Democratic Party
Yes John C. Carney Jr.jpg
John Carney Jr. Democratic Party
D+20.9
Indiana Republican trifecta Republican trifecta Republican triplex Republican triplex Holcomb LG Headshot.jpeg
Eric Holcomb Republican Party
Yes Holcomb LG Headshot.jpeg
Eric Holcomb Republican Party
R+24.4
Missouri Republican trifecta Republican trifecta Republican triplex Republican triplex
Mike Parson Republican Party
Yes
Mike Parson Republican Party
R+16.4
Montana Divided trifecta control Republican trifecta Divided triplex status Republican triplex SteveBullock2015.jpg
Steve Bullock Democratic Party
No
Greg Gianforte Republican Party
R+12.8
New Hampshire Divided trifecta control Republican trifecta Divided triplex status Divided triplex status Chris Sununu.jpg
Chris Sununu Republican Party
Yes Chris Sununu.jpg
Chris Sununu Republican Party
R+31.7
North Carolina Divided trifecta control Divided trifecta control Democratic triplex Democratic triplex
Roy Cooper Democratic Party
Yes
Roy Cooper Democratic Party
D+4.5
North Dakota Republican trifecta Republican trifecta Divided triplex status Divided triplex status
Doug Burgum Republican Party
Yes
Doug Burgum Republican Party
R+40.4
Utah Republican trifecta Republican trifecta Republican triplex Republican triplex
Gary R. Herbert Republican Party
No
Spencer Cox Republican Party
R+32.7
Vermont Divided trifecta control Divided trifecta control Divided triplex status Divided triplex status
Phil Scott Republican Party
Yes
Phil Scott Republican Party
R+41.1
Washington Democratic trifecta Democratic trifecta Divided triplex status Divided triplex status
Jay Inslee Democratic Party
Yes
Jay Inslee Democratic Party
D+13.5
West Virginia Republican trifecta Republican trifecta Republican triplex Republican triplex Jim Justice.jpg
Jim Justice Republican Party
Yes Jim Justice.jpg
Jim Justice Republican Party
R+34.0

Offices that changed party control

See also: Election results, 2020: Partisan balance of governors

Eleven states held elections for governor in 2020. Incumbents won nine of the races. Spencer Cox (R) won in Utah, where Republican incumbent Gary Herbert (R) did not run for re-election. Greg Gianforte (R) won in Montana, where incumbent Gov. Steve Bullock (D) was term-limited, making Montana's governorship the only one to change party control in 2020.

Gubernatorial offices that changed party control, 2020
State Pre-election control Post-election control
Montana Democratic Party Steve Bullock Republican Party Greg Gianforte

Defeated incumbents

No incumbent governors who ran for re-election in 2020 were defeated.

Incumbents who did not seek re-election

Two incumbents did not seek re-election:

Offices that flipped in the 2019 elections

See also: Gubernatorial elections, 2019

Three states held gubernatorial elections in 2019: Kentucky, Louisiana, and Mississippi. Kentucky's governorship was the only one of the three to change party control, flipping from Republican to Democratic.

Gubernatorial offices that changed party control, 2019
State Pre-election control Post-election control
Kentucky Republican Party Matt Bevin Democratic Party Andy Beshear

Competitiveness

See also: Annual State Executive Competitiveness Report, 2020

An election is considered more competitive when there is no incumbent running for re-election. Incumbent advantage is frequently cited in political theory and its importance frequently debated. For example, data compiled by OpenSecrets.org shows the re-election rate for incumbents in the U.S. House of Representatives has been 85% or higher for each of the 27 two-year election cycles between 1964 and 2018. From 2008-2018, the re-election rate averaged 92.1%.

Across the eleven gubernatorial elections that took place in 2020:

  • Nine incumbents filed for re-election. Montana Gov. Steve Bullock (D) was prevented from doing so by term limits.
  • Eight of the nine incumbents running for re-election faced at least one challenger from their party in the primary.
  • All 11 races featured at least one Democrat and one Republican in the general election.

Margin of victory analysis

The following table details the margin of victory for winning candidates in states that held gubernatorial elections in 2004, 2008, 2012, 2016, and 2020.

Margin of victory analysis, 2004-2020
State 2020 margin of victory (%) Party of winning candidate, 2020 2016 margin of victory (%) Party of winning candidate, 2016 2012 margin of victory (%) Party of winning candidate, 2012 2008 margin of victory (%) Party of winning candidate, 2008 2004 margin of victory (%) Party of winning candidate, 2004
Delaware 20.9 Electiondot.png Democratic 19.2 Electiondot.png Democratic 40.7 Electiondot.png Democratic 45.5 Electiondot.png Democratic 5.1 Electiondot.png Democratic
Indiana 24.4 Ends.png Republican 6.0 Ends.png Republican 2.9 Ends.png Republican 17.7 Ends.png Republican 7.8 Ends.png Republican
Missouri 16.4 Ends.png Republican 5.9 Ends.png Republican 12.3 Electiondot.png Democratic 18.9 Electiondot.png Democratic 3.0 Ends.png Republican
Montana 12.8 Ends.png Republican 3.9 Electiondot.png Democratic 1.6 Electiondot.png Democratic 32.9 Electiondot.png Democratic 4.4 Electiondot.png Democratic
New Hampshire 31.7 Ends.png Republican 2.3 Ends.png Republican 12.1 Electiondot.png Democratic 42.6 Electiondot.png Democratic 2.2 Electiondot.png Democratic
North Carolina 4.5 Electiondot.png Democratic 37.4 Electiondot.png Democratic 11.4 Ends.png Republican 3.4 Electiondot.png Democratic 12.7 Electiondot.png Democratic
North Dakota 40.4 Ends.png Republican 57.1 Ends.png Republican 28.8 Ends.png Republican 50.9 Ends.png Republican 43.9 Ends.png Republican
Utah 32.7 Ends.png Republican 38.1 Ends.png Republican 30.7 Ends.png Republican 57.9 Ends.png Republican 16.4 Ends.png Republican
Vermont 41.1 Ends.png Republican 8.8 Ends.png Republican 20.2 Electiondot.png Democratic 31.6 Ends.png Republican 20.8 Ends.png Republican
Washington 13.5 Electiondot.png Democratic 8.8 Electiondot.png Democratic 3.0 Electiondot.png Democratic 6.4 Electiondot.png Democratic 0.1 Electiondot.png Democratic
West Virginia 34.0 Ends.png Republican 11.0 Ends.png Republican 4.7 Electiondot.png Democratic 44.1 Electiondot.png Democratic 29.5 Electiondot.png Democratic

Battlegrounds

See also: Gubernatorial battlegrounds, 2020

Ballotpedia identified six of the 11 gubernatorial elections in 2020 as general election battlegrounds: Indiana, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, North Carolina, and Vermont.

Of the six, four were in states with Republican incumbents and two were in states with Democratic incumbents. All but Indiana and Montana changed partisan control in 2016, while all but Indiana and Missouri were carried by the opposite party's presidential candidate that year. All but Indiana and Missouri were also under divided government, with the party opposite to the governor holding majorities in both state legislative chambers.

These battleground races were selected by examining the results of the 2016 presidential election in each state, whether the incumbent was seeking re-election, and whether the governor's office changed partisan control the last time it was up for election. Outside race ratings from the Cook Political Report, Sabato's Crystal Ball, and Inside Elections with Nathan Gonzales were also considered. For more information on our methodology, click here.

Battleground list

The following map displays all gubernatorial elections taking place in 2020, shaded by the incumbent's political affiliation. Battleground races are highlighted with brighter shades of blue and red. Hover over a state for more information.

Battleground gubernatorial elections, 2020
State Incumbent Open seat? Margin in previous election[1] 2016 presidential Margin
Indiana Republican Party Eric Holcomb No R+6.0 R+19.1
Missouri Republican Party Mike Parson No R+5.9 R+18.7
Montana Democratic Party Steve Bullock Yes D+3.9 R+20.5
New Hampshire Republican Party Chris Sununu No R+7.0 D+0.3
North Carolina Democratic Party Roy Cooper No D+0.2 R+3.6
Vermont Republican Party Phil Scott No R+14.9 D+26.4

Outside race ratings

The following table compared gubernatorial race ratings from The Cook Political Report, Sabato's Crystal Ball, and Inside Elections prior to the November 2020 elections. The following table compared gubernatorial race ratings from The Cook Political Report, Sabato's Crystal Ball, and Inside Elections prior to the November 2020 elections.

Polls

State government trifectas

See also: Election results, 2020: State government trifectas

Updated February 12, 2021

Republicans gained trifecta control in Montana and New Hampshire. Republicans have 23 trifectas (a net gain of two), Democrats have 15 trifectas, and 12 states have divided governments (a net loss of two).

Heading into the 2020 elections, there were 36 state government trifectas—the most since 2013. Republicans had 21 trifectas, and Democrats had 15. The other 14 states had divided government, meaning neither party had a trifecta.

In the November 3, 2020, elections, 44 states held elections for one or more trifecta offices. A state government trifecta occurs when one party holds the governorship and a majority in both chambers of a state's legislature. We identified 16 vulnerable trifectas: eight Democratic and eight Republican. We also identified seven states where one or both parties had the potential to gain a trifecta.

The states under divided government included eight with a Democratic governor and Republican legislature and four with a Republican governor and Democratic legislature. The final two states were Alaska (with a Republican governor and state Senate majority, but a minority coalition in the state House) and Minnesota (with a Democratic governor and state House majority, but a Republican state Senate majority).

Though Republicans won a plurality of seats in the Alaska House, Republicans were unable to organize a majority, resulting in a minority coalition comprised of 16 Democrats, three independents, and two Republicans. Click here to read more.

The Republican flips from divided power to trifecta control in 2020 were in:

  • Montana: Republicans won control of the governorship.
  • New Hampshire: Republicans won control of the state Senate and House.

As a result of the 2020 elections, the country had 23 Republican-held trifectas, 15 Democratic-held trifectas, and 12 divided governments, as illustrated by the table below.

Change in state government trifectas, 2020 elections
Trifecta status Before After Net
Democratic trifectas Democratic Party 15 15 0
Republican trifectas Republican Party 21 23 +2
Divided government 14 12 -2



The map below shows trifecta statuses following the 2020 election.



The map below shows trifecta control in states going into the 2020 election.



State government triplexes

See also: Election results, 2020: State government triplexes

Thirteen states held elections for one or more triplex offices on November 3, 2020. A state government triplex occurs when the governor, attorney general, and secretary of state in a given state are all members of the same political party.

In the November 3 elections, Republicans and Democrats each gained triplex status in one state.

Heading into 2020, there were 36 state government triplexes: 19 Republican triplexes and 17 Democratic triplexes. The remaining 14 states were under divided control, meaning neither party had a triplex. As a result of the November 3 elections, the total number of triplexes increased to 38: 20 Republican triplexes and 18 Democratic triplexes. Twelve states remained under divided control.

Changes in triplex status

Montana


As a result of the 2020 elections, Montana transitioned from divided control to a Republican triplex. Republicans flipped the governor's office and maintained control of the secretary of state and attorney general offices.

Oregon


As a result of the 2020 elections, Oregon transitioned from divided control to a Democratic triplex. Democrats flipped the secretary of state's office and maintained control of the attorney general office. Incumbent Gov. Kate Brown (D) was not up for re-election in 2020.


Changes in triplex status
Democratic triplexes Republican triplexes Divided control
Before 2020 election 17 19 14
After 2020 election 18 20 12



Presidential data

See also: Presidential election, 2020

Historical control

Republicans led in governorships from 1994 until 2006, after which there were 28 Democratic governors to the Republicans' 22. Republicans regained their national majority in the 2010 midterm elections. Between 2010 and 2017, the number of Republican governors continued to increase, reaching a high point of 34 following West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice's switch to the Republican Party in August 2017.[10] From 2017 to 2019, Democrats won Republican-held governorships in Illinois, Kansas, Kentucky, Maine, Michigan, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, and Wisconsin. Republicans, meanwhile, gained a governorship in Alaska previously held by independent Bill Walker. In 2020, Republicans won a Democratic-held governorship in Montana. These changes brought Republicans to 27 governorships and Democrats to 23.

Past election results

2016

See also: Gubernatorial elections, 2016
Beyond the Headlines - Title Banner.png
Staff Writer Kate Carsella gives a quick overview of the 2020 gubernatorial races
View other episodes here.

Twelve states held gubernatorial elections on November 8, 2016, including a special election in Oregon. Republicans won six governorships, flipping control in Missouri, New Hampshire, and Vermont. Democrats won the other six gubernatorial elections, including flipping control in North Carolina. Therefore, Republicans won net control of two governorships.

2012

See also: Gubernatorial elections, 2012

Eleven states held gubernatorial elections on November 6, 2012. Democrats won seven governorships while Republicans won four. In six of the eleven races, incumbents won re-election. Only one governor's office flipped partisan control, as Republican Pat McCrory defeated Democratic lieutenant governor Walter Dalton after incumbent Gov. Beverly Perdue (D) decided in January 2012 not to seek another term.

States that held both gubernatorial and U.S. Senate elections in 2020

See also: States with both gubernatorial and U.S. Senate elections in 2020

There are five states that held elections for both governor and U.S. Senate in 2020: Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, North Carolina, and West Virginia.

States holding both gubernatorial and U.S. Senate elections in 2020
State Incumbent Governor Open Seat? Incumbent Senator Open Seat?
Delaware Democratic Party John Carney Jr. No Democratic Party Chris Coons No
Montana Democratic Party Steve Bullock Yes Republican Party Steve Daines No
New Hampshire Republican Party Chris Sununu No Democratic Party Jeanne Shaheen No
North Carolina Democratic Party Roy Cooper No Republican Party Thom Tillis No
West Virginia Republican Party Jim Justice No Republican Party Shelley Moore Capito No

Ballot access requirements for candidates

The table below details filing requirements for gubernatorial candidates in the 2020 election cycle.

Filing requirements for gubernatorial candidates, 2020
State Office Party Signatures required Signature formula Filing fee Filing fee formula Filing deadline Source
Delaware Governor Democratic N/A N/A $6,840.00 Fixed number 7/14/2020 Source
Delaware Governor Republican N/A N/A Pending Pending 7/14/2020 Source
Delaware Governor Unaffiliated 7,141 1% of all eligible voters as of 12/31 in the year preceding the election N/A N/A 9/1/2020 Source
Indiana Governor Democratic and Republican 4,500 Fixed number N/A N/A 2/7/2020 Source
Indiana Governor Unaffiliated 44,935 2% of votes cast for secretary of state in the last election N/A N/A 7/15/2020 Source
Missouri Governor Qualified party N/A N/A $200.00 Fixed number 3/31/2020 Source
Missouri Governor Unaffiliated 10,000 Fixed number N/A N/A 7/27/2020 Source
Montana Governor Major party N/A N/A $1,183.97 Percentage of annual salary 3/9/2020 Source
Montana Governor Unaffiliated 12,797 5% of total votes received by winner of the last gubernatorial election $1,183.97 Percentage of annual salary 6/1/2020 Source
New Hampshire Governor Democratic and Republican N/A N/A $100.00 Fixed number 6/12/2020 Source
New Hampshire Governor Unaffiliated and political organization 3,000 Fixed number $100.00 Fixed number 9/2/2020 Source
North Carolina Governor Qualified party N/A N/A $1,510.00 1% of annual salary 12/20/2019 Source
North Carolina Governor Unaffiliated 71,545 1.5% of total votes cast for governor in the last election $1,510.00 1% of annual salary 3/3/2020 Source
North Dakota Governor Qualified party 300 Fixed number N/A N/A 4/6/2020 Source
North Dakota Governor Unaffiliated 1,000 Fixed number N/A N/A 8/31/2020 Source
Utah Governor Qualified party 28,000 Fixed number $834.13 Fixed number 3/19/2020 Source
Utah Governor Unaffiliated 1,000 Fixed number $834.13 Fixed number 3/19/2020 Source
Vermont Governor Major party 500 Fixed number N/A N/A 5/28/2020 Source
Vermont Governor Unaffiliated 500 Fixed number N/A N/A 8/6/2020 Source
Washington Governor All candidates N/A N/A $1,821.79 1% of annual salary 5/15/2020 Source
West Virginia Governor Qualified party N/A N/A $1,500.00 1% of annual salary 1/25/2020 Source
West Virginia Governor Unaffiliated 7,139 1% of total votes cast for governor in the last election N/A N/A 7/31/2020 Source

About the office

See also: Governor (state executive office)

In the United States, the title governor refers to the chief executive of each state. The governor is not directly subordinate to the federal authorities but is the political and ceremonial head of the state. The governor may also assume additional roles, such as the commander-in-chief of the National Guard when the role is not federalized. The governor may also have the ability to commute or pardon a criminal sentence.

In all states, the governor is directly elected and, in most cases, has considerable practical powers. Notable exceptions with weak governorships include the office of the governor in Texas, though this may be moderated by the state legislature and, in some cases, by other elected executive officials. Governors can veto state bills. The specific duties and powers vary widely between states.

Compensation


According to compensation figures for 2022 compiled by the Council of State Governments in the Book of the States, the highest salary for a governor was $250,000 in New York while the lowest is $70,000 in Maine. To view the compensation of a particular governor, hover your mouse over the state.[11]

Staff size


According to figures for 2022 compiled by the Council of State Governments in the Book of the States, gubernatorial offices range in size from 9 staffers in Nebraska to 277 staffers in Texas.[11]

Involvement in budget proposals


Although all governors have some involvement in the process of developing a state budget, the specific level of involvement differs from state to state. According to information published in the 2022 Book of the States, 24 governors share responsibility for developing a budget proposal, while 11 governors have full responsibility for developing an initial budget proposal and the remaining 15 have full responsibility for developing a budget.[12]

Term limits

See also: States with gubernatorial term limits


Most states impose some form of term limits on governors; of those that do, all but Virginia limit a governor to two four-year terms or to eight years in office. Although most states' term limit laws allow a governor who has served two terms to be elected once again after time has elapsed, some states impose a lifetime term limit like that on the presidency. Although Vermont and New Hampshire do not have term limit laws, they are the only states whose governors serve two-year terms rather than four-year terms.

Line-item veto powers


The term line-item veto refers to the ability of a governor or other chief executive to veto specific parts of a bill while signing the rest of the bill into law. Currently, 44 states grant their governors line-item veto powers.[12]

Analysis of state elections

See also: Ballotpedia's Election Analysis Hub, 2020


In November 2020, regular elections were held for 86 of 99 state legislative chambers, plus 11 gubernatorial offices, nine lieutenant gubernatorial offices, 10 attorney general offices, and seven secretary of state offices.

Election analysis

All state elections

Trifectas

State executive elections

State legislative elections

State ballot measures


See also


Footnotes

  1. The previous gubernatorial election took place in 2018 in New Hampshire and Vermont and in 2016 in all other states.
  2. This poll used a credibility interval instead of a margin of error.
  3. Bauer: 1%
    Combs: 2%
  4. Bauer: 1%
    Combs: 2%
  5. We Ask America, "Missouri Statewide General Election Survey Results," Sept. 8, 2020
  6. The Trafalgar Group, "Missouri Statewide Presidential August 2020," accessed Sept. 14, 2020
  7. Saint Louis University, "Parson and Galloway in Statistical Dead Heat," accessed Sept. 14, 2020
  8. Missouri Scout, "June 2020 Missouri Statewide 2020 General Election," June 12, 2020
  9. We Ask America, "Missouri Statewide General Election Survey Results," accessed Sept. 14, 2020
  10. Because Justice switched his registration more than halfway through the year, he was counted as a Democrat in 2017 for the purposes of the chart.
  11. 11.0 11.1 Council of State Governments' Book of the States 2022 Table 4.3: The Governors: Compensation, Staff, Travel and Residence provided to Ballotpedia by CSG personnel
  12. 12.0 12.1 Council of State Governments' Book of the States 2022 Table 4.4: The Governors: Powers provided to Ballotpedia by CSG personnel