Bill Hader Welcomes Daughter Hayley Clementine

David Livingston/Getty

Bill Hader has another little lady in his life!

The actor/writer welcomed his third daughter, Hayley Clementine, with wife Maggie Carey on Saturday, Nov. 15, his rep confirms to PEOPLE.

Hader, 36, and The To Do List director — who kept the pregnancy completely under wraps — are already parents to Harper, 2, and Hannah Kathryn, 5.

But adding a third baby girl to the mix likely didn’t come as much of a a surprise to the former Saturday Night Live star.

“I grew up with my two sisters and my mom, so it’s my lot in life to be surrounded by women,” he told PEOPLE in September of his female-fueled household.

— Anya Leon with reporting by Gillian Telling

[