Abstract

The Danainae, or milkweed butterflies, are a moderate-sized group of around 150 species that are of considerable ecological, physiological and behavioural interest. There are two currently accepted classifications for the subfamily and the aim of this study was to try to resolve this conflict using characters derived from the eggs, larvae and pupae. The 130 new characters (of which 85 are illustrated) are analysed by both phenetic methods (average linkage cluster analysis and principal coordinate analysis) and by cladistic techniques (Wagner tree, character compatibility analysis and manually derived cladograms). Overall, the results corroborate the more recent classification of the Danainae. However, some points of difference are found and, after component analysis, an alternative classification is presented in accordance with the conventions for constructing annotated Linnaean hierarchies.

REFERENCES

ACKERY
,
P. R.
&
VANE-WRIGHT
,
R. I.
1984
.
Milkweed Butterflies: their Cladistics and Biology
.
London
: British Museum (Natural History).

ADAMS
,
E. N.
1972
.
Consensus techniques and the comparison of taxonomic trees
.
Systematic Zoology
,
21
:
390
397
.

AURIVILLIUS
,
P. O. C.
1911
.
Danaididae
. In
A.
Seitz
(Ed.)
Gross-Schmetterlinge der Erde
, (
2
)
13
:
71
79
.

AUSSEM
,
B.
1980
.
Satyriden-Studie III. Sonderbildung an den Mandibeln der Raupen des Tribus Satyrirsi Boisduval; 1836 (Lepidoptera Satyridae)
.
Entomofauna Zeitschrift für Entomologie
,
1
:
226
233
.

BATES
,
H. W.
1862
.
Contributions to an insect fauna of the Amazon Valley
.
Transactions of the Linnean Society of London
,
23
:
495
566
.

BATES
,
H. W.
1879
.
In Miiller, F., 1879, Ituna und Thyridia. Ein merkwiirdiges Beispiel von Mimicry bei Schmetterlingen
.
Kosmos
,
5
:
100
108
. [Consulted in English translation, in Proceedings of the Entomological Society of London, 1879: xx-xxix].

BAUM
,
B. R.
1978
.
Assessment of cladograms obtained for fourteen species of Avena by two methods of numerical analysis
.
Systematic Botany
,
2
:
141
150
.

BEEBE
,
W.
,
CRANE
,
J.
&
FLEMING
,
H.
1960
.
A comparison of eggs, larvae and pupae in fourteen species of heliconiine butterflies from Trinidad, W. I
.
Zoologica
,
45
:
111
154
.

BOISDUVAL
,
J. B. A. D.
1833
.
In Boisduval, J. B. A. D., 1832–1841, hones historiques des Le'pidopteres
,
ďEurope
,
1
:
251
pp., 47 pis.
Paris
.

CARVER
,
R. A.
1979
.
The relationship between Euploea callithoe Boisduval and E. phaenareta (Schaller) (Lepidoptera; Nymphalidae) in New Britain and New Guinea
.
Australian Entomological Magazine
,
5
:
109
112
.

CHAPMAN
,
T. A.
1893
.
On some neglected points in the structure of the pupae of heteroceran Lepidoptera and their probable value in classification, etc
.
Transactions of the Entomological Society of London, 1893
:
97
119
.

CORBET
,
A. S.
&
PENDLEBURY
,
H.M.
1956
.
The Butterflies of the Malay Peninsula
, 2nd edition.
Edinburgh
:
Harrison & Sons
.

CORBET
,
A. S.
&
PENDLEBURY
,
H.M.
1978
.
The Butterflies of the Malay Peninsula
, 3rd edition, revised by
J. N.
,
Eliot
Kuala Lumpur
:
Malayan Nature Society
.

CRUMB
,
S. E.
1956
.
The larvae of the Phalaenidae
.
Technical Bulletin of the United States Department of Agriculture
,
1135
:
1
365
.

D'ABRERA
,
B.
1971
.
Butterflies of the Australian Region
.
Melbourne
:
Lansdowne Press
.

ďALMEIDA
,
E. N.
1939
.
Revisao das especies americanas superfamilia Danaoidea (Lepid: Pieridae [sic]. Parte 1. Familia Danaidae, subfam. Danainae)
.
Memorias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz
,
34
:
1
113
.

DAVIS
,
J. C.
1973
.
Statistics and Data Analysis in Geology
.
New York
:
J. Wiley & Sons
.

DETHIER
,
V. G.
1941
.
The antennae of lepidopterous larvae
.
Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology
87
:
455
507
.

DEVITT
,
B. D.
&
SMITH
,
J.J.B.
1982
.
Morphology and fine structure of mouthpart sensilla in the dark-sided cutworm Euxoa messaria (Harris) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)
.
International Journal of Insect Morphology & Embryology
,
11
:
255
270
.

DEVRIES
,
P. J.
,
KITCHING
,
I. J.
&
VANE-WRIGHT
,
R. I.
1985
.
The systematic position of Antirrhea and Caerois with comments on the classification of the Nymphalidae (Lepidoptera)
.
Systematic Entomology
,
10
:
11
32
.

DOHERTY
,
W.
1891
.
A list of the butterflies of Engano, with some remarks on the Danaidae
.
Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal
,
60
:
141
197
.

DORING
,
E.
1955
.
Zur Morphologic der Schmetterlingseier
.
Berlin
:
Akademie-Verlag
.

DOWNEY
,
J. C.
&
ALLYN
,
A. C.
1979
.
Morphology and biology of the immature stages of Leptotes cassius theonus (Lucas) (Lepid., Lycaenidae)
.
Bulletin of the Allyn Museum
,
55
:
1
27
.

DOWNEY
,
J. C.
&
ALLYN
,
A. C.
1981
.
Chorionic sculpturing in eggs of Lycaenidae. Part I
.
Bulletin of the Allyn Museum
,
61
:
1
29
.

DUNCAN
,
T.
,
PHILLIPS
,
R. B.
&
WAGNER
,
W. H.
Jr
1981
.
A comparison of branching diagrams derived by various phenetic and cladistic methods
.
Systematic Botany
,
5
:
264
293
.

FARRIS
,
J. S.
1974
.
Formal definitions of paraphyly and polyphyly
.
Systematic Zoology
,
23
:
548
554
.

FARRIS
,
J. S.
1977
.
On the phenetic approach to vertebrate classification
. In
M. K.
Hecht
,
P. C.
Goody
&
B. M.
Hecht
(Eds.),
Major Patterns in Vertebrate Evolution
:
823
850
.
New York
:
Plenum Publishing Corporation
.

FLEMING
,
W. A.
1975
.
Butterflies of West Malaysia and Singapore
.
Faringdon
:
E. W. Classey Ltd
.

FORBES
,
W. T. M.
1939
.
Revisional notes on the Danainae
.
Entomologia Americana
,
19
:
101
140
.

FRACKER
,
S. B.
1915
.
The classification of lepidopterous larvae
.
Illinois Biological Monographs
,
2
:
1
170
.

FRUHSTORFER
,
H.
1910
.
Danaidae
. In
A.
,
Seitz
(Ed.),
Gross-Schmetterlinge der Erde
(
2
)
9
:
191
284
.

FUNK
,
V. A.
&
STUESSY
,
T.F.
1979
.
Cladistics for the practising plant taxonomist
.
Systematic Botany
,
3
:
159
178
.

GODMAN
,
F. D.
&
SALVIN
,
O.
1879
.
Biologia Centrali-Americana, Lepidoptera-Rhopalocera
1
:
1
487
.

HAENSCH
,
R.
1909
.
Family: Danaidae
. In
A.
,
Seitz
(Ed.),
Gross-Schemetterlinge der Erde
(
2
) 5:
113
171
.

HEINRICH
,
C.
1916
.
On the taxonomic value of some larval characters in the Lepidoptera
.
Proceedings of the Entomological Society of Washington
,
18
:
154
164
.

HENNIG
,
W.
1966
.
Phylogenetic Systemalics (translated by D. D. Davis & R. Zangerl)
.
Urbana
:
University of Illinois Press
.

HINTON
,
H. E.
1980
.
Biology of Insect Eggs
.
Oxford
:
Pergamon Press
.

HULL
,
D. L.
1980
.
The limits of cladism
.
Systematic Zoology
,
30
:
416
440
.

HUMPHRIES
,
C. J.
1982
.
Vicariance biogeography in Mesoamerica
.
Annals of Missouri Botanical Garden
,
69
:
444
463
.

IGARASHI
,
S.
1980
.
Papilionidae and their Early Stages
.
Japan
.

KAWAZOÉ
,
A.
&
WAKABAYASHI
,
M.
1976
.
Coloured Illustrations of the Butterflies of Japan
.
Osaka
.

KIRBY
,
W. F.
1871
.
A Synonymic Catalogue of Diurnal Lepidoptera
.
London
:
John van Voorst
.

KITCHING
,
I. J.
1984
.
The use of larval chaetotaxy in butterfly systematics, with special reference to the Danaini (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae)
.
Systematic Entomology
,
9
:
49
61
.

KLUGE
,
A. G.
&
FARRIS
,
J.S.
1969
.
Quantitative phyletics and the evolution of the anurans
.
Systematic Zoology
,
18
:
1
32
.

KLUK
,
K.
1802
.
Zweirzat domowych i dzikich osobliwie Kraiowych
.,
Hist. nat. poczatki i gospodarstwo
.
Warsaw
. [Seen only as an incomplete photocopy.].

KÜHN
,
H.
1887
.
Zur Kenntniss indischer Lepidopterenlarven
.
Deutsche Entomologische Zeitschrift
,
1
:
179
183
.

LAWRENCE
,
D. A.
&
DOWNEY
,
J. C.
1966
.
Morphology of the immature stages oiEveres comyntas Godart (Lycaenidae)
.
Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera
,
5
:
61
96
.

LE QUESNE
,
W. J.
1982
.
Compatibility analysis and its applications
.
Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
,
74
:
267
275
.

LINNAEUS
,
C.
1758
.
Systema Naturae
, 10th edition, vol.
1
,
Regnum Animate
.
Holmiae
.

LUCKOW
,
M.
&
PIMENTEL
,
R.A.
1985
.
An empirical comparison of numerical Wagner computer programs
.
Cladistics
,
1
:
47
66
.

McNEILL
,
J.
1982
.
Phylogenetic reconstruction and phenttic taxonomy
.
Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
,
74
:
337
344
.

MEACHAM
,
C. A.
1980
.
Phylogeny of the Berberidaceae with an evaluation of classifications
.
Systematic Botany
,
5
:
149
172
.

MICKEVITCH
,
M. F.
1978
.
Taxonomic congruence
.
Systematic Zoology
,
27
:
143
158
.

MOORE
,
F.
1883
.
A monograph of Limnainae and Euploeina, two groups of diurnal Lepidoptera belonging to the subfamily Euploeinae, with descriptions of new genera and species
.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London
,
1883
:
201
324
.

MORISHITA
,
K.
1981
.
Danaidae
. In
E.
Tsukuda
(ed.)
Butterflies of the South-East Asian Islands
,
2
:
439
628
.
Japan
.

MOSHER
,
E.
1916
.
A classification of Lepidoptera based on characters of the pupa
.
Bulletin of the Illinois State Laboratory of Natural History
,
12
:
17
159
.

MÜLLER
,
F.
1879
.
Ituna und Thyridia. Ein merkwiirdiges Beispiel von Mimicry bei Schmetterlingen
.
Kosmos
,
5
:
100
108
. [Consulted in English translation in Proceedings of the Entomological Society of London, 1879: xx–xxix].

MÜLLER
,
F.
1886
.
Siidamericanische Nymphalidenraupen: Versuch eines natürlichen Systems der Nymphaliden
.
Zoologische Jahrbücher
,
1
:
417
678
.

NELSON
,
G.
&
PLATNICK
,
N.I.
1981
.
Systematics and Biogeography
.
Cladistics and Vicariance
.
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.

PACKARD
,
A. S.
1895
.
Attempt at a new classification of the Lepidoptera. Monograph of the bombycine moths of America north of Mexico, part I
.
Memoirs of the National Academy of Sciences
,
7
:
56
83
.

PATTERSON
,
C.
1982
.
Morphological characters and homology
. In
K. A.
Joysey
&
A. E.
Friday
, (Eds)
Problems in Phylogenetic Reconstruction: 21–74. Systematics Association Special
Volume
21
.
London
:
Academic Press
.

PETERSEN
,
B.
1964
.
Humidity, darkness and gold spots as possible factors in pupal duration of Monarch butterflies
.
Journal of the Lepidopterists' Society
,
18
:
64
65
.

PIERRE-BALTUS
,
C.
1978
.
Resultats ďelevages de Neptis a facies “melicerta” en Cote dTvoire: description de trois nouvelles especes (Lepidoptera Nymphalidae)
.
Lambillionea
,
78
:
33
44
.

POEY
,
F.
1846–1847
.
Catalogo metodico y descriptivo de las Mariposas de la Isla de Cuba
.
Memorias de la Real Sociedad Economica de la Habana
, (
2
)
2
:
174
177
, 233–236, 297–302, 383–388; (2) 3: 44–50, 121–125, 175–179, 243–246.

RAWSON
,
G. W.
1976
.
Notes on the biology and immature stages of the White Peacock buttterfly, Anartia jatrophae guantanamo (Nymphalidae)
.
Journal of the Lepidopterists' Society
,
30
:
207
210
.

REUTER
,
E.
1896
.
Über die Palpen der Rhopaloceren. Ein Beitrag zur Erkenntnis der verwandtschaftlichen Beziehungen unter den Tagfaltern
.
Acta Societatis Scientarum Fennicae
,
22
:
1
578
.

RILEY
,
C. V.
1880
.
Philosophy of the pupation of butterflies and particularly of the Nymphalidae
.
Proceedings of the American Association for the Advancement of Science
,
28
:
455
463
.

RIPLEY
,
L. B.
1923
.
The external morphology and postembryology of noctuid larvae
.
Illinois Biological Monographs
,
8
:
1
102
.

ROGERS
,
K.
&
VAN SOMEREN
,
V. G. L.
1925
.
The butterflies of Kenya and Uganda. Part 1
.
Journal of the East Africa and Uganda Natural History Society
,
21
:
22
44
.

ROHLF
,
F. J.
,
COLLESS
,
D. H.
&
HART
,
G.
1983
.
Taxonomic congruence re-examined
.
Systematic Zoology
,
32
:
144
158
.

ROSEN
,
D. E.
1978
.
Vicariant patterns and historical explanation in biogeography
.
Systematic Apology
,
27
:
155
188
.

ROTHSCHILD
,
W.
1915
.
On Lepidoptera from the islands of Ceram (Seran), Bum, Bali and Misol
.
Novitates Zoogicae
22
:
105
144
.

RYDON
,
A. H. B.
1971
.
The systematics of the Charaxidae (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae)
.
Entomologist's Record
,
83
:
219
233
, 283–287, 310–316, 336–341, 384–388.

SALKELD
,
E. H.
1975
.
Biosysteraatics of the genus Euxoa (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). IV. Eggs of the subgenus Euxoa Hbn
.
Canadian Entomologist
,
107
:
1137
1152
.

SALKELD
,
E. H.
1976
.
Biosystematics of the genus Euxoa (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). VII. Eggs of the subgenera Chorizagrotis, Crassivesica, Longioesica, Orosagrotis and Pleonectopoda
.
Canadian Entomologist
,
108
:
1371
1385
.

SHIRÖZU
,
T.
&
HARA
,
A.
1960
.
Early Stages of Japanese Butterflies in Colour
, Vol.
I
.
Osaka
:
Hoikusha
.

SHIRÖZU
,
T.
&
HARA
,
A.
1962
.
Early Stages of Japanese Butterflies in Colour
,
Vol. II
.
Osaka
:
Hoikusha
.

SHIROZU
,
T.
&
SETOYA
,
K.
1973
.
Variation of longitudinal ridge number of eggs laid by a female of Hypolimnas bolina Linnaeus
.
Butterflies and Moths
,
23
:
51
53
.

SILBERGLIED
,
R. E.
,
AIELLO
,
A.
&
LAMAS
,
G.
1979
.
Neotropical butterflies of the genus Anartia: systematics, life-histories and general biology (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae)
.
Psyche
,
86
:
219
260
.

SMART
,
P.
1976
.
The Illustrated Encyclopaedia of the Butterfly World
.
London
:
Hamlyn
.

SNEATH
,
P. H. A.
, &
SOKAL
,
R. R.
1973
.
Numerical Taxonomy
.
San Francisco
:
W. H. Freeman
.

STEVENS
,
P. F.
1980
.
Evolutionary polarity of character states
.
Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics
,
11
:
333
358
.

TAYLOR
,
R. L.
1964
.
The metallic gold spots on the pupa of the Monarch butterfly
.
Entomological News
,
75
:
253
256
.

URQUHART
,
F. A.
1960
.
The Monarch Butterfly
.
Toronto
:
University of Toronto Press
.

URQUHART
,
F. A.
1970
.
Mechanism of cremaster withdrawal and attachment in pendant rhopalocerous pupae (Lepidoptera)
.
Canadian Entomologist
,
102
:
1579
1582
.

URQUHART
,
F. A.
1972
.
The effect of cauterising the MNPPM of the pupa of the Monarch butterfly (Danaus p. plexippus) (Danaidae)
.
Journal of the Lepidopterists' Society
,
26
:
137
140
.

URQUHART
,
F. A.
&
TANG
,
A.P.S.
1970
.
The effect of cauterising the PPM (“gold spots” of authors) of the pupa of the Monarch butterfly (D. plexippus)
.
Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera
,
9
:
157
167
.

WATSON
,
J.
1899
.
On Calinaga, a single genus of an aberrant subfamily of butterflies
.
Memoirs and Proceedings of the Manchester Literary and Philosophical Society, Old Series
,
43
,
1
23
.

WILEY
,
E. O.
1979
.
An annotated Linnaean hierarchy, with comments on natural taxa and competing systems
.
Systematic Zoology
,
28
:
308
337
.

WILEY
,
E. O.
1981
.
Phylogenetics. The theory and practice of phylogenetic systematics
.
New York
:
J. Wiley & Sons
.

YATA
,
O.
&
FUKUDA
,
H.
1980
.
Descriptions of the early stages of two pierid butterflies from the Philippines
.
Tyo To Ga
,
31
:
81
96
.

YOUNG
,
A. M.
1973a
.
The life cycle of Dircenna relata (Ithomiidae) in Costa Rica (Lepidoptera)
.
Journal of the Lepidopterists' Society
,
27
:
258
267
.

YOUNG
,
A. M.
1973b
.
Notes on the biology of Phyciodes (Eresia) eutropia (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) in a Costa Rican mountain forest
.
Journal of the New York Entomological Society
,
81
:
87
100
.

This content is only available as a PDF.