What are your top three-five albums? : r/vinyl Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/vinyl icon
r/vinyl icon
Go to vinyl
r/vinyl
A banner for the subreddit

For Everything Record Related. For equipment, setup, or troubleshooting questions, please ask in our stickied Weekly Questions Thread.


Members Online

What are your top three-five albums?

Discussion

I have a small collection of albums (21 records and 3 45’s). Four are brand new and the rest are from the record shop and the thrift store.

My top albums:

  1. Patina - Peter Gregson, 2021 I recently discovered Peter Gregson about two years ago with his album, “Bach: The Cello Suites - Recomposed by Peter Gregson” I love his style of music. Cello with synths, pads, piano, orchestra. Very nice to chill out to and reflect.

  2. Poetzsch: The Soul of Things - Clemens Christian Poetzsch, 2021 I just discovered Poetzsch about a month ago. His music is light and flowing but can get emotional. His style is more like classical crossover.

  3. Double Fantasy - John Lennon & Yoko Ono, 1980 When I saw this album in the newly arrived bin in the used section at the record store, I gasped and grabbed it! Wonderful album! One of my favorite songs from this album is “Give Me Something” by Yoko Ono. I love her avant-guard style! Another favorite is “Woman” by John Lennon.

  4. Wonderland - Erasure, 1986 Erasure’s first album and it still sounds fresh today. I have a work friend and we send songs to each other. The songs he sends me is music from the 80’s and I really enjoy them! Cory Hart, Eurythmics, Berlin, Grace Jones, Duran Duran. Those are just a few artists we send back and forth to each other. He would tell me what songs that certain producers would produce, and the different artists of the same producer, and I’d catch on to the certain style of that producer in that particular song. It’s pretty neat to catch the similarities!

  5. Very Dionne - Dionne Warwick, 1970 Classic Dionne with her light vocals!

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options
u/FVCKDIVMONDS avatar
Edited
  1. The Stooges - The Stooges, literally my favorite album of all time.

2.The Germs - GI, favorite punk band and favorite punk album.

3. Lou Reed - Transformer, one of my favorite albums ever perfect day might be my favorite song ever.

All first pressings.

  • Nirvana - MTV Unplugged

  • Deftones - White pony

  • Alice in chains - Jar of flies

  • Mastodon - Once more 'round the Sun

  • Pink Floyd - The wall

u/Legos_is_Plural avatar

Phenomenal list. Jar of Flies is easily on my top 5 as well!

More replies

Right now? My top five albums constantly change!

Christopher Tin - The Lost Birds

Dire Straits - Love Over Gold

Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here

Richard Hawley - Coles Corner

Wendy Carlos - Switched-On Bach

u/zingo-spleen avatar

Wendy Carlos ❤️

u/backtolurk avatar

Someone recently posted her classics, full albums on YT - Switched-on and Clockwork Orange. I don't know if they're still on, given her stance on this.

More replies
u/Mikkiaveli avatar

Richard Hawley is such a gem. Truly a perfect album.

Yeah! Just a shame that it's so expensive. 50$ on setantabooks + shipping and taxes 💸💸😬

More replies

Love Over Gold is a great album

More replies
u/RomeoGoth avatar

The Cure - Disintegration

The The - Soul Mining

The Chameleons - Script of the Bridge

The Sound - From the Lions Mouth

Radiohead - The Bends

u/MortallGod avatar

From the lions mouth is unreal, I have it on Cd and Lp… however the cd has an additional song like 20 minutes after the last song ends

u/my_thousand_fads avatar

The Chameleons - Manchester's most underrated band!

More replies
u/That_Random_Kiwi avatar

Tool - Fear Inoculum (5 vinyl box set)

Alice In Chains - Jar of Flies/SAP

The Avalanches - Since I Left You

u/duckinspokane avatar

Nirvana - MTV Unplugged

Sturgill Simpson - A Sailor’s Guide to Earth

Fleetwood Mac - Rumours

Johnny Cash - At Folsom Prison

Neil Young - Harvest

Clutch - Blast Tyrant

Tragically Hip - Day for Night

The Crow soundtrack

Tom Waits - Raindogs

New Kingdom - Paradise Don’t come Cheap

Willie Nelson - Stardust
Dire Straits - Love Over Gold
Teskey Brothers - Run Home Slow
Mandolin Orange - Blindfaller
Van Morrison - Poetic Champions Compose

u/guywithfries avatar

Iron Maiden- Somewhere in time

Phil Collins- Face Value

Metallica- ...And Justice For All

Arthur Blythe -Lenox Avenue Breakdown

u/Secret-Asian-Man-76 avatar

From my vinyl collection?

  • Electric Light Orchestra - Time

  • Rob Zombie - The Sinister Urge

  • Babymetal - Metal Galaxy

  • The Knack - Get The Knack

  • Jurassic 5 - Quality Control

Quality Control is super good.

u/thealmightydweller avatar

Time is phenomenal

More replies
u/goshock avatar

Duran Duran - Rio

Depeche Mode - Violator

Pearl Jam - Vitalogy

The Cure - Disintegration

Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon

  1. Temple of the Dog - Temple of the Dog -

  2. Monophonics - Sound of Sinning

  3. Father John Misty - I love you, Honeybear

  4. Led Zeppelin - IV

  5. Nathaniel Ratliff and The Night Sweats - Tearing at the seams

Father John misty, hell ya. Fear Fun is near the top for me but I haven’t been able to find it at a reasonable price.

I think I got my copy of his website

More replies

Upvoting for Tearing At The Seams & Temple Of The Dog

More replies
  1. Hayley Williams - Petals For Armor

  2. Tame Impala - Lonerism

  3. The Cure - Disintegration

  4. Badbadnotgood - Talk Memory

  5. Bloc Party - Silent Alarm

Oh dang it was real hard to decide after the first two, but i think this is my real top 5. From bottom to the top amazing albums!

The Cure! I should find some on my next outing!

More replies
u/Wiskeeee avatar
  1. Alice in Chains/ Unplugged 2.Canned Heat/ live at the Tupenga Coral 3.Rolling Stones / get yer Ya Yas out

  2. Seven Mary Three/ Rock Crown

  3. Dire Straits/ Dire Straits (1st LP)

u/delajoel2020 avatar

Nirvana: unplugged

Meatmen: You still suck

Jane’s Addiction: first album

Descendents: Livage

Portishead: live at Roseland

Lenny Kravitz: unplugged

u/zingo-spleen avatar

Paul Weller - S/T

Led Zeppelin - Houses of the Holy

Getz/Gilberto

Donald Byrd - The Cat Walk

Pernice Brothers - Overcome by Happiness

u/backtolurk avatar

Camel - The Snow Goose

James Brown - The Payback

Michael Brook - Affliction soundtrack

The Headhunters - Survival of the Fittest

Peter Gabriel - Us

Talking Heads - stop making sense

Green Day - dookie

Grateful Dead- American beauty

Goose- relix sessions

The sword - apocryphon

Led Zeppelin- houses of the holy

Nirvana- mtv unplugged

Dire straits- making movies

Going to cheat and choose multiple favorites for some artists:

Kate Bush - The Dreaming/50 Words For Snow

Lana Del Rey - Honeymoon/Norman F’in Rockwell/Tunnel Under Ocean Blvd

Radiohead - A Moon Shaped Pool

Portishead - Dummy

Death Cab For Cutie - Transatlanticism

u/cortezthakillah avatar

You can never choose just one Lana 🔥

FINALLY some love for A Moon Shaped Pool

Awesome choices all the way! I haven't heard much of Lana's music though

More replies

The Butterfly Effect - Imago

Sticky Fingers - Land of Pleasure

The Mark of Cain - Ill At Ease

Nirvana - Unplugged

Placebo - A Place For Us To Dream

My top five changes constantly. But the current line-up includes

Japan - Gentlemen Take Polaroids

The Clash - Black Market Clash

Ultravox - Vienna / Steven Wilson remix

Tangerine Dream - Zeit

OMD - Bauhaus Staircase

This will all change in a week or so.

The Killers - Sam's Town, The Flaming Lips - At War With The Mystics, Yumi Arai - Misslim, Foreigner - Double Vision, Halsey - Manic.

  1. Abba Gold

  2. Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys

  3. Damn-Kendrick Lamar

  4. Rage Against the machine

  5. Ready to Die-Notorious BIG

u/RetardedMetalFemboy avatar

I don't actually have the vinyl releases of any of these, because with the exception of #3, the vinyls are either over $100 or nonexistent.

  1. TOOL - 10,000 Days

Flawless. Every song is absolutely perfect. Rosetta Stoned and the Wings for Marie suite are my two favorite songs ever.

2. Devin Townsend - Ocean Machine

Devy may not be quite as good as TOOL when it comes to raw music, but he's an absolute master when it comes to ambience. While most prefer his later works (and Earth Day from Terria is certainly his best song), Ocean Machine is the most consistent of his albums, only dropping slightly in quality during 3AM and Voices in the Fan. I could listen to Night and Bastard on repeat for hours on end.

3. TOOL - Fear Inoculum

By the time I started listening to "real music" and not just video game OSTs, the thirteen-year-long hiatus between Days and Fear was already over, and I was able to judge the album on its own merits rather than putting it against the expectations of a decade's wait. And I don't know how, but it sounds shiny and premium, like the music itself is made of solid gold. It's beautiful. I'm particularly fond of Descending.

4. Alice in Chains - Alice in Chains

Switching course from sheen to sludge, Alice in Chains's self-titled album is rough, gritty, and grimy and I love it. While Dirt is more popular thanks to being released before the death of Kurt Cobain, being a concept album and generally being more approachable, I prefer Tripod because of its raw sound and seething hatred towards the music industry. (Except for Heaven Beside You, that's a skip track.) My favorite song on the album changes every time I listen to it, and right now that honor goes to So Close.

Speaking of killing the fucking music industry...

5. Cold - Year of the Spider

Yeah, I've got no clue why such a generic, almost Nickelback-esque album managed to surpass Broken and Tormented (#6 and #7, respectfully), but here we are. Not much to say about it. Favorite song...The Day Seattle Died.

American psycho?😆

More replies
u/Patient-Bed6821 avatar

Radiohead-In Rainbows Special Edition

Alice In Chains- Jar of Flies/Sap

Pink Floyd-Wish You Were Here

Simon and Garfunkel-Bridge Over Troubled Water

Frightened Rabbit-Pedestrian Verse 10th Anniversary(The second record is gold to me)

Jeff Rosenstock - Worry

Sleater-Kinney - The Woods

Beastie Boys - Paul’s Boutique

  1. Big Star - #1 Record

  2. Galaxie 500 - On Fire

  3. Arthur Verocai - Arthur Verocai

  4. The Byrds - Sweetheart of the Rodeo

  5. Wire - Pink Flag

In no particular order:

Still Life - Opeth

Damnation - Opeth

The Mantle - Agalloch

Suburbia I’ve Given You All And Now I’m Nothing - The Wonder Years

The Black Parade - MCR

In no order

Linkin Park - Meteora

Audioslave - Audioslave

The Mars Volta - De-Loused in the Comatorium

Wu-Tang Clan - Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)

CAKE - Fashion Nugget

Top 5 that I have on vinyl at least!

I'm curious, does 36 Chambers have all the skits the standard CD version has? I wanted to get it myself

More replies

Darkest hour - undoing ruin

Darkest hour - deliver us

Afi - sing the sorrow

Katy perry - teenage dream

That’s quite the lineup

They are practically the only albums i can listen to without skipping a single song. Masterpieces imho.

Runner ups

Qosta - like clockwork

Marilyn manson - the golden age of grotesque

Darkest hour - darkest hour

I’m an AFI fan myself but I’d put the Art of Drowning #1

Im a fan of their punk era but for me their “hayday” was def december underground and sing the sorrow.

more reply More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies

If you like Erasure, check out Yaz, Vince Clarke's project between leaving Depeche Mode and starting Erasure.

I like it! These are the type of songs my work friend and I share. It still sounds very fresh! I'll have to share some of these with him.

I was a freshman in college when Situation came out. As soon as it came on, the dance floor in any club near my school was packed.

Situation sounded familiar. Great song!

More replies
More replies
More replies

Fleetwood Mac - Rumours, Michael Kiwanuka - Michael Kiwanuka, Arctic Monkeys - The Car, Billy Joel - The Stranger, Neil Young - Harvest

  1. Paranoid - Black Sabbath: parents got me a first press Vertigo for my bday and I’ve been spinning it at least twice a week since.

  2. Vol 4 - Black Sabbath: same as Paranoid, at least twice a week.

  3. My Favorite Things - John Coltrane

  4. Groovin’ at Smalls - Jimmy Smith

  5. Midnight Blue - Kenny Burrell

All first pressings

  1. Lana Del Rey - Norman Fucking Rockwell!

  2. Weyes Blood - Titanic Rising

  3. St. Vincent - Daddy’s Home

  4. Joanna Newsom - Have One on Me

  5. Laura Marling - Song for Our Daughter

i managed to get a vinyl of each of them except have one on me. someday…

u/HB1theHB1 avatar
  1. Bob Marley, Natty Dread

  2. Paul Simon, Rhymin’ Simon

  3. RHCP, Blood Sugar Sex Magic

  4. Pink Floyd, Dark Side of The Moon

  5. Black Crowes, Southern Harmony and Musical Companion

The good rats tasty, Bob Dylan blood on the tracks, crazy horses, second album, Boston’s first LP, and the Bee Gees first album & Miles Davis bitches brew

Alice Coltrane - Journey In Satchidinanda Lyman Woodard - Saturday Night Special Billy Parker - Freedom of Speech Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon Contemporary Jazz Quintet - Location

Albert King With Stevie Ray Vaughan - In Session

Ana Popovic - Trilogy

George Strait - Troubadour

Linda Ronstadt - Different Drum

The Rolling Stones - Sticky Fingers

Sleep- dopesmoker (purp RSD variant) Gwar- America must be destroyed Kiss- destroyer (original pressing) Cannibal corpse- butchered at birth (flesh colored repress) Judas Priest- British steel (2LP pic disc)

This month 1 - hunky dory-David Bowie 2- August and everything after-counting crow 3- Heaven up here - echo and the bunnymen 4- grace - Jeff Buckley 5- on the beach- Neil young. Hunky dory will always make my list

The Beatles - s/t (The White Album): Somehow I've decided that this is my favourite Beatles album. Some people don't like it that much for being too long, and having an unfinished feel to it... but I love it!! all the songs are so great, that you don't even mind that they might seem unfinished. It's like it has that indie, lo-fi quality to it. I own some German reissue from the 70s or 80s.

Fleetwood Mac - Rumours: "Dreams" is the best sounding song I've ever heard. Buckingham is a genius, Stevie Nicks's voice is angelic, John McVie's bass sounds perfectly... and that's not even the best song on the album! (that would be Christine McVie's You Make Loving Fun). A very fun album, with an interesting story to it, and it's quite unique in its softness, I still haven't found anything like that.

Madvillain - Madvillainy: The only hip-hop album I own so far, it's great, you can't really go wrong with Madlib and MF DOOM. Actually not my favourite Madlib album, but still one of the best examples of his style. Really fun to put on.

Dave Brubeck - Time Out/Time Further Out: I wanted to get Time Out on vinyl for some time, then I found out about various strange low-quality jazz labels like DOL, and I was wary... Then I found this CBS pressing in my local record store, and it also came with the lesser known sequel album, Time Further Out! Grabbed it immediately, it wasn't even that much more expensive than the DOL pressings I saw online. I adore the cover art.

Lady Gaga - Chromatica: Quite an underrated record, but I'm mainly putting it on this list because it's the only clear vinyl in my collection lol. I picked it up on sale in my local record store, for some reason they had a bunch of them half priced.

Oddział Zamknięty - s/t: This Polish rock band's debut is quite a great album. 6th entry, because I wanted to include something Polish, and I own a first pressing. I was lucky to find it online, the cover was in a pretty bad state, but the record itself was in excellent condition.

Shout-out to: Prefab Sprout's Steve McQueen, Frank Zappa's Hot Rats, Miles Davis's Bitches Brew, Blondie's Parallel Lines, Kate Bush's The Kick Inside

Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here

Prince & The Revolution - Purple Rain

Nine Inch Nails - The Downward Spiral

Depeche Mode - Violator

Talk Talk - The Colour of Spring

Japan- Quiet Life

Men at Work- Business as Usual

The beatles- Abbey Road

Not an album but Rolling stones- Hot Rocks

Asia- self titled

I am always stunned at just how varied peoples’ musical taste is.

I think that’s the reason why I created this post. I love seeing the different music tastes between one person to the other. I have to say, it’s been pretty interesting to see. And the one thing I love about it too is the love of music from your favorite artists and bands. And hopefully this post will help others discover new artists and bands!

More replies

ZZ Top - Deguello

Fleetwood Mac - Then Play On

Sade - Diamond Life

Freddie Hubbard - Hub Cap

Sly & the Family Stone - There’s a Riot Goin’ On

u/Adventurous-Set5029 avatar
Edited

As of this past month, these have been in pretty heavy rotation

JJ Cale - Naturally

Taj Mahal - Happy to be Just like I Am

Joe McPhee - Nation Time

Todd Rundgren - Runt

& Captain Beefheart - Shiny Beast (Bat Chain Puller)

Dire Straits - Brothers in Arms

The Doobie Brothers - Takin it to the streets

AC/DC - Back in Black

Donald Fagen - The Nightfly

Meat Loaf - Bat Out of Hell

This is so hard... mine changes so often! Here are my current faves vs. all-time faves:

Current faves:
The Last Dinner Party- Prelude to Ecstasy
Chappell Roan- The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess
Melanie Martinez- K-12
Marina & The Diamonds- The Family Jewels
Jon Bellion- The Human Condition

All-time faves:
P!ATD- A Fever You Can't Sweat Out
21 Pilots- Blurryface
Billie Eilish- When We All Fall Asleep Where Do We Go
Daft Punk- Discovery
Fall Out Boy- Infinity On High

Fugazi -13 songs The cure - disintegration The doors- the doors

If you love The Doors first release check out the Rhino Mono release. The original Mono Masters were used for the pressing. It has a much more Blues Rock vibe and worth the $$.

More replies
u/Counting-Trains avatar
  1. recovering the satellites - counting crows

  2. z - my morning jacket

  3. the positions - gang of youths

  4. binaural - pearl jam

  5. summerteeth - wilco

u/NChSh avatar

Dvorak - String Quartets (Complete) Vol 1. / Vox: with my KLM Series 5s it sounds mind-blowing.  I got really stoned with this woman and we just laid on the floor blasting it at 3 am laying on the floor, 5 stars

Can - Tago Mago: Absolute classic, love this record

Young Thug - Barter VI: I feel guilty every time I play it as it's gotten so valuable, but I just love this album

The Congos - Heart of the Congos: Lee Perry's masterpiece 

Alice Coltrane - Reflection on Creation and Space (A Five Year View): As close to a greatest hits album that you can get for a free jazz artist, but it comes together beautifully 

  1. Eric Church - Mr Misunderstood. There's something really cathartic about this album, especially listening to Record Year in this format.

  2. John Mayer - Where The Light Is Live In Los Angeles. I'm a big fan of his and almost have all of his albums but this one is truly a sit down and have a full blown listening experience. I'd recommend it to anyone who is a big fan of people who play the guitar.

  3. Miranda Lambert - Wildcard. This album really set a new tone for her and her music, I probably put this one on the most of all her albums.

  4. Maren Morris - GIRL. I listen to this one less than I did but I had it on cd before vinyl and it was a nightly listen for at least 2 years. I have one copy that unfortunately is pretty scratched on display. The album is just full of really powerful songs about friendship and womanhood and idk showing up as yourself and it'll always crack my top albums.

  1. The Cure - Disintegration

  2. Blur - 13

  3. Radiohead - In Rainbows

  4. Radiohead - Kid A

  5. Interpol - Turn On the Bright Lights

Had to sneak in 2 Radiohead records, because they're just awesome. Also, I've ordered Duster's Stratosphere, so when it comes, it'll definitely be in the top 5!

Upvote for Interpol :)

Edited

I'm planning to buy the sky blue repress of Our Love To Admire!

I haven’t heard that one. I have the first pressing and the tenth anniversary repress. Make sure you take a listen first if the sky blue version is released through Matador.

Yes, it is released through Matador

'Interpol's 2007 classic, "Our Love To Admire" is available on sky blue vinyl for the first time, alongside a standard CD edition' - official Matador website

more replies More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies
More replies

I got over 200 but these are the ones I listen to often.

  1. Delilah bon self titled release. I absolutely love Delilah so much. When I'm feeling beaten down I put it on and sing along.

A. Incredibad lonely island- LIKE A BOSS! And yesterday I was definitely rapping along with Natalie Portman on the fourth. Natalie is a bad ass bitch

@. Flcl soundtrack FOOLY COOLY! also the pillows rock.

🥇Powerman 5000 tonight the stars revolt! I love the whole album and reminds me of my childhood

🩷 Barbie the album - my favorite album to dance around my apartment with my cat on my shoulder, she insists, and yells at me if I dance without her

Aw! My kitty likes shoulder rides when I come home from work. I think she'll freak out if I try to dance with her on my shoulder!

More replies
u/backtolurk avatar

Chuck Berry doesn't approve of everything in your selection!

RAMONES - "MANIA" RANCID- "LIFE WONT WAIT" BONE THUGS - "E99 eternal" Anthrax "spreading the disease" Sublime - 's/t"

Pleasure - special things

Ramsey Lewis - sun goddess

Kitty and the haywoods - love shock

Giant - shifting time

Hiromasa Suzuki - high flying

Get funky.

u/dkernighan avatar
  • Roger Waters: Amused to Death

  • Al Stewart: Year of the Cat

  • Marillion: Clutching at Straws

  • Yusef Lateef: Eastern Sounds

  • RHCP: Stadium Arcadium

pablo honey pablo honey pablo honey