The 30 Best Margaret Rutherford Movies

Ranker Film
Updated March 5, 2024 30 items
Ranked By
596 votes
179 voters
Voting Rules
Vote for your favorite movies, regardless of critic reviews or how big the role was.

Dame Margaret Rutherford, a famed British actress known for her eccentric and distinctive on-screen presence, delivered outstanding performances in numerous classic films throughout her career. It's no wonder that film enthusiasts and critics alike debate the best Rutherford movies, as this remarkable actress left an indelible mark on the cinematic world. With a wide range of memorable roles under her belt, identifying the cream of the crop among Rutherford films is a challenging endeavor. 

This comprehensive collection of Rutherford movies showcases the actor's unique style, and uncovers the depth of her talent by highlighting her most exceptional performances. Each Rutherford film expressed her essence as an actress, while also shedding light on the overall quality of the movie itself. A handful of productions, featuring stellar screenplays, skilled direction, and unforgettable characters, stand out among the prestigious roster of movies with Rutherford. 

Notably, in Murder, She Said, the first of four Miss Marple adaptations, Rutherford brilliantly portrayed the beloved amateur detective, while Murder at the Gallop showcases her undeniable flair for the role. Then, there's the timeless classic Blithe Spirit, where Rutherford's unforgettable performance as the eccentric medium Madame Arcati left audiences enthralled for generations. Each of these movies masterfully captures the essence of what made Rutherford such an influential figure in cinema.

The best Rutherford movies list offer a glimpse into the illustrious career of this actor and serve as a testament to her enduring impact on the world of film. With this selection of outstanding productions, one can fully immerse themselves in the rich legacy left by Dame Margaret Rutherford. 

  • Murder, She Said
    1
    Margaret Rutherford, Arthur Kennedy, Muriel Pavlow
    44 votes

    Margaret Rutherford's exceptional performance as the iconic Miss Marple in Murder, She Said brings Agatha Christie's famous detective to life on the big screen. Released in 1961 and directed by George Pollock, this film showcases Rutherford's innate ability to embody a character with both wit and charm. Suspenseful and entertaining, the movie follows Miss Marple as she investigates a murder she witnesses while traveling on a train. With its intricate plot twists, intriguing characters, and superb acting performances – particularly from Rutherford – Murder, She Said is hailed as one of the best adaptations of an Agatha Christie novel.

  • Murder at the Gallop
    2
    Margaret Rutherford, Robert Morley, Flora Robson
    46 votes

    Continuing her portrayal of Miss Marple in Agatha Christie's whodunit series, Margaret Rutherford stars in Murder at the Gallop, released in 1963. Directed by George Pollock once again, the film takes viewers through another thrilling adventure as Miss Marple seeks to uncover the truth behind a mysterious death at a large estate. Supported by an outstanding cast of actors such as Robert Morley and Flora Robson, Rutherford shines in her role as the sleuthing spinster with exceptional observational skills and determination. Murder at the Gallop remains another exemplary adaptation of Christie’s work that stands testament to Rutherford’s stellar acting abilities.

  • Murder Ahoy!
    3
    Margaret Rutherford, Lionel Jeffries, Bud Tingwell
    30 votes

    In this third installment of Margaret Rutherford's acclaimed portrayal of Miss Marple from Agatha Christie's novels, Murder Ahoy! (1964) offers yet another exhilarating mystery for fans of classic British cinema. Under George Pollock's direction once more, Rutherford delivers an impeccable performance as she stumbles upon foul play aboard a naval ship while investigating maritime thefts. Utilizing her signature wit and resourcefulness, she delves into unmasking the murderer amidst a ship full of suspects. Aided by an accomplished supporting cast, Murder Ahoy! proves itself as another must-watch entry in Rutherford's Miss Marple series.

  • Murder Most Foul
    4
    Margaret Rutherford, Ron Moody, Bud Tingwell
    28 votes

    Concluding her portrayal of Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple, Margaret Rutherford stars in the captivating 1964 film Murder Most Foul. Directed by George Pollock, this murder mystery finds Rutherford's character infiltrating a theatrical company to solve a homicide case. Showcasing her versatility as an actress and adeptness for the genre, she effortlessly captures the essence of Miss Marple with her wit, charm, and keen deductive skills. With its engaging plot, striking performances – most notably from Rutherford herself – and suspenseful atmosphere, Murder Most Foul serves as a fitting finale to Rutherford's remarkable run as the beloved detective.

  • Chimes at Midnight
    5
    Orson Welles, Jeanne Moreau, John Gielgud
    11 votes

    In this 1965 adaptation of William Shakespeare's Henry IV directed by and starring Orson Welles, Margaret Rutherford showcases her formidable acting talent as Mistress Quickly – the tavern keeper who befriends the legendary character Falstaff (Welles). Known for its innovative storytelling and exceptional performances from the entire cast, Chimes at Midnight is hailed as one of Welles' finest works. Rutherford’s captivating turn as Mistress Quickly only adds to the film's overall brilliance, solidifying her reputation as a versatile actress with a flair for both comedy and drama.

  • Passport to Pimlico
    6
    Stanley Holloway, Hermione Baddeley, Margaret Rutherford
    27 votes

    In this delightful 1949 Ealing comedy directed by Henry Cornelius, Margaret Rutherford is part of an ensemble cast that brings to life a fictional London borough that discovers it legally belongs to Burgundy – leading to political chaos and uproarious situations. Displaying her trademark wit and impeccable comic timing alongside fellow actors such as Stanley Holloway and Hermione Baddeley, Rutherford's performance elevates Passport to Pimlico to a beloved classic in British film history. With its clever script, memorable characters, and outstanding performances, this movie is not to be missed.

  • Blithe Spirit
    7
    Rex Harrison, Constance Cummings, Kay Hammond
    37 votes

    Adapted from Noël Coward's famous play, the 1945 British comedy film Blithe Spirit, directed by David Lean, features Margaret Rutherford in an enchanting performance as eccentric medium Madame Arcati. As she inadvertently summons a writer's first wife during a séance gone awry, hilarity ensues when his current spouse becomes increasingly jealous of the ghostly presence. Combining supernatural elements with comedic flair and top-notch acting from Rex Harrison and Constance Cummings alongside Rutherford’s scene-stealing turn as Madame Arcati, Blithe Spirit remains an enduring classic in British cinema history.

  • The Importance of Being Earnest
    8
    Michael Redgrave, Michael Denison, Edith Evans
    17 votes

    Based on Oscar Wilde's timeless play, the 1952 film adaptation of The Importance of Being Earnest, directed by Anthony Asquith, boasts an all-star cast including Michael Redgrave, Edith Evans, and Margaret Rutherford as Miss Prism. In this witty comedy revolving around mistaken identities and love triangles among Victorian high society members, Rutherford delivers an unforgettable performance that perfectly captures the essence of her character. Her effortless portrayal of Miss Prism adds further depth to this tale of romance and deception – making it a quintessential showcase for her undeniable talents as an actress.

  • I'm All Right Jack
    9
    Ian Carmichael, Peter Sellers, Terry-Thomas
    15 votes

    This 1959 satirical British comedy directed by John Boulting stars Peter Sellers alongside Margaret Rutherford in a story centered around labor disputes in a missile factory. As Sellers' character accidentally triggers a nationwide strike, Rutherford shines as his doting aunt who provides comic relief amidst the ensuing chaos. With its biting social commentary and exceptional acting from both leads – particularly Rutherford’s endearing portrayal of Aunt Dolly – I'm All Right Jack remains a hilarious exploration of post-war Britain's industrial challenges.

  • The Happiest Days of Your Life
    10
    Alastair Sim, Margaret Rutherford, Joyce Grenfell
    25 votes

    Featuring Alastair Sim and Margaret Rutherford in top form, The Happiest Days of Your Life (1950) is a charming British comedy directed by Frank Launder that revolves around the accidental merging of two schools – one for boys and one for girls – due to bureaucratic errors during post-WWII England. As rival headteachers forced to cooperate under unusual circumstances, Sim and Rutherford exhibit excellent comedic chemistry that elevates this farcical tale into a must-watch classic for fans of vintage British cinema.

  • The Smallest Show on Earth
    11
    Bill Travers, Virginia McKenna, Peter Sellers
    19 votes

    Starring Peter Sellers, Virginia McKenna, Bill Travers, and Margaret Rutherford, The Smallest Show on Earth (1957) is a heartwarming British comedy directed by Basil Dearden that centers around a young couple inheriting a rundown movie theater. As they try to revive their newly-acquired business, they enlist the help of an eccentric group of employees – including Rutherford's character Mrs. Fazackalee – who inject humor and warmth into each scene. With its engaging plot and memorable performances from all involved – particularly Rutherford’s lovable portrayal – this film remains an endearing piece of vintage British cinema.

  • The V.I.P.s
    12
    Elizabeth Taylor, Maggie Smith, Orson Welles
    18 votes

    Boasting an impressive ensemble cast that includes Richard Burton, Elizabeth Taylor, Louis Jourdan, and Margaret Rutherford in an Oscar-winning supporting role, The V.I.P.s (1963) is a glamorous drama directed by Anthony Asquith centered around the intersecting lives of various characters stranded at London Airport due to fog delays. As the eccentric Duchess of Brighton seeking funds to save her family estate from foreclosure, Rutherford delivers an exceptional performance that captivates audiences while adding depth to an already star-studded film.

  • The Magic Box
    13
    Robert Donat, Maria Schell, Margaret Johnston
    8 votes

    Margaret Rutherford joins an all-star cast, including Robert Donat, Maria Schell, and Richard Attenborough, in The Magic Box (1951), a biographical drama that chronicles the life of British inventor William Friese-Greene – one of the pioneers of early cinema. Directed by John Boulting, this fascinating exploration delves into the trials and tribulations faced by Friese-Greene as he tirelessly works to develop moving pictures. Rutherford's memorable supporting role in this engaging tribute to filmmaking history further showcases her remarkable acting prowess.

  • Miss Robin Hood
    14
    Margaret Rutherford, James Robertson Justice, Richard Hearne
    7 votes

    In this 1952 British comedy directed by John Guillermin, Margaret Rutherford stars as Henrietta Robins – a crime novelist who teams up with a timid insurance clerk to stage daring heists aimed at redistributing wealth among society's less fortunate members. With its amusing premise and brilliant performances from Rutherford and co-star Richard Hearne, Miss Robin Hood offers viewers a delightful twist on the classic Robin Hood tale while also highlighting Rutherford's exceptional comedic skills.

  • Miranda
    15
    Glynis Johns, Googie Withers, Griffith Jones
    7 votes

    A quirky 1948 British comedy directed by Ken Annakin, Miranda revolves around a beautiful mermaid (Glynis Johns) who bewitches a London doctor (Griffith Jones) during a fishing trip off the coast of Cornwall. Margaret Rutherford stars as Nurse Cary – providing comic relief amidst the ensuing romantic entanglements when Miranda is brought back to London for observation. Her lively performance adds much-needed humor to this whimsical fantasy film that has become a cult favorite among fans of vintage British cinema.

  • Trouble in Store
    16
    Norman Wisdom, Margaret Rutherford, Moira Lister
    6 votes

    Starring Norman Wisdom alongside Margaret Rutherford, Trouble in Store (1953) is an entertaining British slapstick comedy directed by John Paddy Carstairs that follows Wisdom's character’s misadventures as he tries to prove himself worthy of a promotion at a department store. As the store's eccentric piano teacher, Rutherford delivers a delightful performance that effortlessly complements Wisdom’s zany antics – making this film an enjoyable romp for audiences who appreciate classic comedy.

  • The Mouse on the Moon
    17
    Margaret Rutherford, Bernard Cribbins, Ron Moody
    6 votes

    A sequel to the popular British comedy The Mouse That RoaredThe Mouse on the Moon (1963) directed by Richard Lester centers around the fictional country of Grand Fenwick attempting to land on the moon using their homemade rocket powered by wine. Margaret Rutherford appears in a supporting role as the Grand Duchess Gloriana XII, bringing her distinct brand of humor and charm to this amusing satire on Cold War politics and space exploration.

  • The Runaway Bus
    18
    Frankie Howerd, Margaret Rutherford, Petula Clark
    11 votes

    In this 1954 British mystery comedy directed by Val Guest, Margaret Rutherford stars alongside Frankie Howerd and Petula Clark when passengers aboard a fog-bound bus become entangled in an intrigue involving stolen gold bullion. Rutherford's portrayal of Augusta Prodworthy – a formidable passenger determined to uncover the truth behind their predicament – is both entertaining and engaging, further demonstrating her unmatched ability to captivate audiences with her diverse range of characters.

  • Aunt Clara
    19
    Margaret Rutherford, Fay Compton, Ronald Shiner
    5 votes

    Margaret Rutherford takes center stage in this 1954 British comedy directed by Anthony Kimmins as Clara Hilton – an elderly woman who inherits a large fortune from her brother-in-law but struggles with maintaining appearances amidst newfound wealth. As she navigates through various comedic situations with help from her loyal butler played by Ronald Shiner, Rutherford's endearing performance elevates Aunt Clara into an enjoyable viewing experience for fans of vintage British cinema.

  • On the Double
    20
    Danny Kaye, Diana Dors, Dana Wynter
    6 votes

    An American war comedy released in 1961 and directed by Melville Shavelson, On the Double sees Danny Kaye taking on dual roles as both an American soldier and a British officer during World War II. With support from Margaret Rutherford as Lady Vivian, this engaging film showcases their comedic talents while also offering an entertaining look at the absurdities of wartime espionage.

  • A Countess from Hong Kong
    21
    Marlon Brando, Sophia Loren, Charlie Chaplin
    5 votes

    In this 1967 romantic comedy written and directed by Charlie Chaplin, Marlon Brando stars as a wealthy diplomat who unwittingly becomes involved with a beautiful stowaway (Sophia Loren) aboard his ship en route to America. Featuring Margaret Rutherford in a smaller role as Miss Gaulswallow – one of the ship's eccentric passengers – A Countess from Hong Kong is notable for being Chaplin's final directorial effort and marks another example of Rutherford's versatility as an actress.

  • Yellow Canary
    22
    Margaret Rutherford, Anna Neagle, Richard Greene
    3 votes

    This 1943 British suspense film directed by Herbert Wilcox stars Anna Neagle as a British spy during World War II posing as a Nazi sympathizer to root out enemy agents in her midst. Margaret Rutherford delivers an outstanding supporting performance as Doris Owen – the protagonist's fellow passenger on board a ship bound for Canada – adding depth and intrigue to this thrilling tale of espionage and deceit.

  • Meet Me at Dawn
    23
    Margaret Rutherford, Hazel Court, Stanley Holloway
    3 votes

    In this 1947 British romantic drama directed by Thornton Freeland, Margaret Rutherford stars as Madame Vernoreux – a Parisian fortune-teller whose elaborate tales lead to a series of misunderstandings and mistaken identities involving an aspiring artist (William Eythe) and his love interest (Hazel Court). With its atmospheric setting, engaging plot, and charming performances from the entire cast – particularly Rutherford's captivating turn as the enigmatic Madame Vernoreux – Meet Me at Dawn provides a delightful viewing experience for fans of vintage cinema.

  • Spring Meeting
    24

    Spring Meeting

    Michael Wilding, Margaret Rutherford, Sarah Churchill
    3 votes

    Margaret Rutherford stars alongside James Mason and Pamela Kellino in this 1941 British comedy-drama directed by Walter C. Mycroft. Adapted from a play by M.J. Farrell and John Perry, Spring Meeting revolves around the eccentric members of an Irish family who become embroiled in various romantic entanglements during their annual gathering at their ancestral home. Rutherford's deft portrayal of Aunt Bijou adds much-needed levity to the film, further showcasing her exceptional comedic abilities amidst a talented ensemble cast.

  • Arabella
    25
    Virna Lisi, Giancarlo Giannini, Margaret Rutherford
    3 votes

    Starring Virna Lisi in the title role alongside Margaret Rutherford as Princess Ilaria, Arabella (1967) is an Italian comedy directed by Mauro Bolognini that takes place against the backdrop of Rome's high society during the late 19th century. As Arabella's scheming aunt who orchestrates various deceptions to ensure her niece marries into wealth, Rutherford delivers yet another memorable performance in this lavish period piece filled with intrigue and humor.

  • The Wacky World of Mother Goose
    26
    3 votes

    This animated feature film released in 1967 showcases Margaret Rutherford's impressive vocal talents as she narrates a series of classic nursery rhymes brought to life through colorful illustrations and whimsical storytelling. Directed by Jules Bass, The Wacky World of Mother Goose offers a delightful and nostalgic trip down memory lane for audiences who grew up with these timeless tales – further demonstrating Rutherford's remarkable versatility as an actress.

  • The Demi-Paradise
    27
    Laurence Olivier, Penelope Dudley-Ward, Marjorie Fielding
    3 votes

    In this 1943 British drama directed by Anthony Asquith, Laurence Olivier stars as a Russian engineer visiting England during World War II who faces discrimination from the locals due to his nationality but eventually forms enduring friendships along the way. Margaret Rutherford delivers a heartfelt performance as Rowena Ventnor – one of the kind-hearted Britons who befriend Olivier's character – providing emotional depth to this poignant tale of cultural differences and understanding.

  • English Without Tears
    28

    English Without Tears

    Michael Wilding, Margaret Rutherford, Lilli Palmer
    2 votes

    English Without Tears (1944), also known as Her Man Gilbey, is a romantic comedy directed by Harold French that centers on a group of women learning English in order to work in war-torn Britain. Bolstered by an ensemble cast featuring Michael Wilding, Penelope Dudley-Ward, and Margaret Rutherford, this engaging film follows their comedic misadventures while offering an intriguing snapshot of wartime life in the UK. Rutherford's performance adds another layer of charm to this heartwarming story about love, friendship, and perseverance.

  • Just My Luck
    29
    Norman Wisdom, Margaret Rutherford, Jill Dixon
    2 votes

    Norman Wisdom takes center stage alongside Margaret Rutherford in Just My Luck, released in 1957 – a British comedy directed by John Paddy Carstairs that revolves around his attempts to win big at the racetrack after developing a formula for predicting winning horses. As Miss Daventry – the owner of a jewelry store beset by thieves – Rutherford delivers an entertaining supporting performance that complements Wisdom's zany antics throughout their misadventures.

  • Mad About Men
    30
    Donald Sinden, Margaret Rutherford, Dora Bryan
    2 votes

    In this 1954 British comedy sequel to Miranda, Glynis Johns reprises her role as the enchanting mermaid who returns ashore to visit her human friend played by Dora Bryan. Margaret Rutherford joins the cast as Nurse Carey, lending her comedic talents to this whimsical tale filled with romance and intrigue. Directed by Ralph Thomas, Mad About Men offers another delightful viewing experience that showcases Rutherford's abilities in light-hearted fare.