Abe Lincoln is our cousin?

Abraham Linciln

 

 

Abraham Linciln
Abraham Lincoln – 16th President — and our cousin?
Merrill Family
FAMILY FINDER: Merrill
(from Stiehm-Burton Family)
Connects to Stouts

Not sure how big of a bet I’d place on this, but evidence is accumulating that Abe Lincoln, 16th President of the United States, may be our cousin.

A book by James Pindall Stout 1819-1903 and Burthena Shackelford Kemble 1824- 1908: Their Ancestors and Descendants Kemble Stout, 1975, contains (on pages 279-283) a long quotation from Richard Stout Descendants in West Virginia by Russell R. and Olive M. Stout which says:

“The three daughters of Richard and Penelope were married early to men of the same or neighboring communities. Mary, the oldest daughter, married Judge James Bowne of Portland Point. It was their great granddaughter, Hannah Salter, who married Mordecia [sic] Lincoln the great grandfather of Abraham, President of the United States.”

The website, Famous Kin, says:

The genealogy of Nancy Hanks has always been a controversial one with scholars debating the various theories since research began shortly after Lincoln’s death. Even members of the Hanks family and reported cousins of Lincoln could not agree on it.

Of the various theories that have evolved over the past 150 years, only two were believed by Lincoln scholars to have the possibility of being correct. Now DNA evidence has identified which of those theories is correct.

Going on, the site states:

The ancestry of Abraham Lincoln’s mother Nancy Hanks has always been somewhat of a mystery. For over a century, historians and genealogists have repeatedly made claims that they have finally solved the mystery of Lincoln’s mother, and that everyone before them was wrong. They claim to be able to “prove the truth!”

All of these theories regarding Nancy’s ancestry have been “documented” mainly through circumstantial evidence and oral traditions. There are very few primary documents remaining. The one thing that can be proven about Nancy’s origins is that no one can prove the truth, at least not yet.

The Hanks DNA Project at Family Tree DNA just announced the results of their Nancy (Hanks) Lincoln mtDNA Study. The results appear to be conclusive that Nancy Hanks’s mother Lucy was indeed a daughter of Ann “Nancy” (Lee) Hanks, wife of Joseph Hanks. It appears that this issue has finally been put to rest and Abraham Lincoln’s ancestry on this site will be changed to reflect this latest news. You can read more about this at Family Tree DNA.

The lineages of Lincoln and our family would be:

 

Lincoln’s line is:

  1. Richard Stout b 1615 m Penelope Van Prince b 1620
  2. Mary Stout m Capt. James Bowne
  3. John Bowne m Lydia Holmes
  4. Sarah Bowne m Richard Salter
  5. Hannah Salter m Mordecai Lincoln
  6. Abraham Lincoln m Mary Mudd (?), and Barsheba Herring
  7. Thomas Lincoln m Nancy Hanks
  8. Abraham Lincoln b 1809 m Mary Todd of Kentucky

 

 

 

 

 

Our Line is:

  1. Richard Stout b 1615 m Penelope Van Prince b 1620
  2. James Stout m Elisabeth Truax
  3. Penelope Stout m William Merrell Jr
  4. Benjamin Merrell m Jemima Smith
  5. Anna Nancy Merrell m Boyd McCrary
  6. Phebe McCrary m Thomas Burton
  7. William Burton m Elizabeth Saunders
  8. William Burton m Hannah Lloyd
  9. Thomas Burton m Gertrude Whitbeck
  10. Georgia Burton m Oliver Stiehm
  11. Joan Stiehm m Henry Van Der Wal

 

That would make Lincoln our 7th Cousin 3x removed. If I get time, I’ll see if I can confirm elsewhere.

Oh, and if the lineage is correct, we may be related to Tom Hanks.

Other connections from the Kemble Stout book include:

A claim that Daniel Boone may also be a cousin. “Richard and Penelope’s son Jonathan and his wife Anne Bollen were the 2nd greatgrandparents of Daniel Boone.” That would make a second connection to Boone. (See The man behind Dan’l Boone – Great Uncle (6x) Michael Stoner )

 

Finally, the book claims that Zebulon Pike may be related. “The husband of Alice Stout, the second daughter of Richard, was John Throckmorton. Dr. John E. Stillwell, who wrote an early history of the Stouts, was a grandson of Alice. The third daughter of Richard, Sarah, became the wife of John Pike. It was of their line that Zebulon Pike, 1779-1813, American general and explorer was descended. He found in 1806 Pike’s Peak, and then pushed on to California. Tradition says that when General Pike went west to Colorado he had two or three Stout boys with him.”


 

(For more on Penelope Stout Prince, see also: Penelope Kent: “Case of a stranger, remarkably saved among the Indians” )

(For more famous ancestors see: Famous Distant Relatives. There, one of or relatives is assassinated President James Garfield. [I wonder if there is a link to McKinley?])

 

 

17 Replies to “Abe Lincoln is our cousin?”

  1. I’m related to Lincoln by blood my maiden name is salter Hanna salter is related to my grandpa William Henry salter the 2nd just not sure how I have not gotten that far yet

    1. Hello
      My name is nanci malone
      I descend from the hanks and the
      Burtons. I you tell me , which burton line you descend from. The hanks,
      I belong too, william quaker hanks
      Thank you
      Nanci

    2. Your line from 1-4 is also my line as well. Captain Benjamin Merrill and Jemima’s daughter Penelope is my next line. It would be nice to connect with you. Also, my father is a McCrary and I think Phebe is also in my tree (not direct line). Thank you in advance.
      -Amanda McCrary

  2. Stout and James Bowne are a parallel line

    But Mordecai Lincoln married his brother, Captain John Bowne’s granddaughter

  3. My mother told me years ago she’d been told she was related to Mary Todd Lincoln; I have done research that says I’m related to Penelope Stout.

  4. Ancestors
    Mom
    Grandma Iva 1919-2001
    Isaac V Wamsley Jr 1875-1930
    Isaac V Wamsley Sr 1836-1908
    Isaac Wamsley III 1798-1868
    Isaac Harvey Wamsley Jr 1778-1825
    Isaac Harvey Wamsley Sr 1735-1825
    Revolutionary War Veteran
    Leah Stout Wamsley wife 1742-1820
    Daughter of
    Dr Jonathan Stout 1704-1775
    Richard Stout 1678-1749
    John Stout 1645-1724 Middletown NJ
    Son of Richard and Penelope..
    Elizabeth Crawford Stout wife 1650-1730
    Ayshire Scotland
    Daughter of
    John Crawford 1618-1698
    12th Lord Patrick Crawford 1580-1649
    11th Lord William Crawford 1560-1644
    10th Lord Patrick Crawford 1530-1560
    7th Lord Thomas Crawford 1505-1541
    6th Lord James Crawford 1470-?
    5th Lord Robert Crawford 1435-1513
    4th Lord Archibald Crawford 1389-?
    3rd Lord Thomas Crawford 1350-1401
    2nd Lord Reginald Crawford 1317-1358
    1st Laird Reginald Crawford 1283-1358 Fought at Bannockburn 1314 along with Robert the Bruce and received Lordship for his services.
    Hugh Crawford ? -1319
    Sir Reginald Crawford of Loudon 1255-1297
    Sister Margaret married Alan Wallace, mother of Sir William Wallace

    1. Thank you so very much David Bagley! So to confirm, if we are descendants of Richard and Penelope Stout, we are descendants of William Wallace’s Mother?

  5. This so cool I have just started reaching my ancestry and have found so many corrections to some awesome history my 9th great grand father and 9th great grandmother were: Richard Stout b 1615 m Penelope Van Prince b 1620.

  6. I am related to Lincoln via Penelope van princes and Richard.. my line is as follows
    Richard Stout b 1615 m Penelope van prince b1622
    David Stout b1667 m Rebecca Ashton b 1672 or 1673
    Free gift Stout b 1693 m Mary Higgins b 1699 or 1700
    Isaac Stout b 1740 m Mary Quincy b 1745
    Isaiah Stout b 1773 m Catherine Kennedy b 1773
    Elisha Stout b 1803 m Rachael b 1809
    Theodore Stout b 1843 m Delia Conover b 1864
    Harvey Emery b 1883 m Dorothy Stout b 1887
    Harvey Emery b 1905 m Margaret Gallagher Emery b 1903
    Harvey Thomas Emery b 1935 m Shirley Miller Emery b 1936
    Sharon Emery b 1965

  7. My African/Native American/European mixed race grandmother is born a Salter in Southern Ohio. She was born in 1917 in Hamilton Co, Ohio. Her family ancestry ties to Virginia and Kentucky. I have all of the Lincoln’s surnames & birth locations in my DNA results to include Rockingham County, Virginia.

    1. Alexander Herring Sr. and Margaret Hamilton Herring are Abraham Lincoln’s 2nd great grandparents as well as my 7th great grandparents. That makes us the President and I 3rd cousins 5 times removed. My Watkins family lived in Harding County, KY as did his family. Relatives of my Watkins and Gum families would have known him at New Salem, IL. He surveyed for some Gum relatives west of that village.
      I travel his postal route weekly which leads to his survey point on Main Street in my hometown of Athens at the Long Nine Museum (where Lincoln and eight legislators celebrated the vote to move the capital from Vandalia to Springfield). Check for summer openings for this neat museum.

  8. My name is Janet Sue Green Brakenhoff. I am related to Penelope Van Prncis Stout Through Their son David Stout, his son Freegift Stout and Mary Higgins, Their daughter Rachael Stout who married a Rounsavell. Their daughter Mary married a Godown , Their son Evan married a Martindale Their daughter Emmaretta married a Bailey who was my Great grandmother. This makes Penelope my 8th great grandmother Sue Green Brakenhoff

  9. Type in “FamousKin.com” If you can trace your linage to any of the Magna Carta Sureties, then believe it or not your spouse can possibly be your cousin. Though Henry de Bohun, Daniel Boon descends from this linage. I am a descendent of Richard & Penelope stout thru Peter. Started with the stouts, Coomes/Combs, Jarboe’s, Stouts from North Carolina to Indiana, Kentucky, then to Illinois. Also, descending from a Stout Linage is Johnny Depp. It took me 17 Years before finishing the Stout line. Beern into Genealogy by accident since 1998. HI cousins
    .

  10. My great great great grandmother was Ruhama Simmons Hanna and through her linage on Simmons side, John Simmons , her great great grandfather married Mary Hanks, whose great great great grandfather was Thomas Hanks II b. 1570 and through this I found I’m the 7th cousin, 6th removed from Abraham Lincoln, whose 6th great grandfather is Thomas Hanks II as well.

  11. Richard and Penelope are my 9th GG’s.

    Penelope van Princess 1622-1732
    9th great-grandmother
    Benjamin Stout 1669-1734
    Son of Penelope van Princess
    Agnes Bonen Stout * 1711-1793
    Daughter of Benjamin Stout
    Elisha Stout Blackshear 1736-1810
    Son of Agnes Bonen Stout *
    Susannah Blackshear 1769-1834
    Daughter of Elisha Stout Blackshear
    Josiah Bush 1790-1842
    Son of Susannah Blackshear
    Elafaire Bush 1835-1870
    Daughter of Josiah Bush
    Green Malcom McLain 1862-1935
    Son of Elafaire Bush
    Eugene Hudson”Jamie” (Huchison) McLain 1893-1976
    Son of Green Malcom McLain
    Grulie/ Greelie McLain 1921-1995
    Son of Eugene Hudson”Jamie” (Huchison) McLain
    Andrew McLain 1942-
    Son of Grulie/ Greelie McLain
    Brian McLain
    You are the son of Andrew McLain

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.