The Best Miami Dolphins of All Time

Ranker NFL
Updated April 15, 2024 75.7K views 196 items
Ranked By
51.0K votes
4.1K voters
21 reranks
Voting Rules
Please rank the players based on their time with the Dolphins

List of the best Miami Dolphins of all time. Since their formation in 1966 as part of the AFL, the Miami Dolphins have been one of the most successful teams in AFC history. From the beginning of the 1970s through the early 2000s, Miami was the standard bearer for excellence in the conference. During this nearly 30 year run of success, the Dolphins had many of the best players in its history on its roster. The dominant Dolphins Super Bowl teams of the 1970s had some of the top players in the league on the team. With head coach Don Shula as the constant, the Dolphins fielded what some consider to be the best team of all time in 1972 when they went an unmatched 17-0, the only NFL team to go undefeated during a single season. 

Many of the team's best players were on the 1972 undefeated, Super Bowl winning team. Hall of Fame players like Larry Csonka, Paul Warfield, Bob Griese and Larry Little to name a few are considered some of the best Dolphins ever. While the players on that team are memorable, perhaps the most famous Dolphins player is star quarterback Dan Marino, who is one of the best quarterbacks of all time. Despite not winning a championship, Marino is still considered one of the most popular and greatest Dolphins ever and thousands of Miami fans to this day will wear his jersey to the team's home games. 

This list of the best Miami Dolphins factors in all players from the team's AFL days to the present day. If you see someone missing from this list, feel free to add him if you consider him one of the greatest Miami Dolphins players of all time. Vote and rerank this list so it accurately reflects who is the best Miami Dolphins player of all time, then head over and check out the top Dolphins kickers ever and best Dolphins tight ends.

Most divisive: Ryan Tannehill
Over 4.1K Ranker voters have come together to rank this list of The Greatest Miami Dolphins of All Time
  • Dan Marino
    1
    2,522 votes
    Age: 62

    Dan Marino, an exceptional quarterback who donned the Miami Dolphins jersey for 17 seasons, redefined the passing game during his era with his quick release and precision accuracy. He shattered numerous NFL records, establishing himself as one of the most prolific passers in the history of the league and propelling the Dolphins to consistent playoff appearances. Despite never winning a Super Bowl, Marino's storied career left an indelible mark on the sport, earning him enshrinement in the Pro Football Hall of Fame and solidifying his status as one of the all-time greats.

  • Larry Csonka
    2
    1,783 votes

    An instrumental figure in the Miami Dolphins' early years, Larry Csonka excelled as a bruising fullback, combining power and agility to bulldoze through opposing defenses and leading the team to two Super Bowl victories. As the centerpiece of the Dolphins' potent rushing attack, Csonka's fearless running style embodied the tough-nosed mentality of Miami's iconic "No-Name Defense." Solidifying his legacy in the annals of the NFL, Csonka starred in the Dolphins' legendary undefeated season in 1972, setting the gold standard for football perfection.

  • Zach Thomas
    3
    1,647 votes

    The heart and soul of the Miami Dolphins throughout the late 1990s and early 2000s, Zach Thomas embodied the tenacious spirit of South Florida football. As a downhill middle linebacker with uncanny instincts and unparalleled determination, Thomas anchored the Dolphins defense, displaying an impeccable ability to stop even the most potent offenses in their tracks. Although not yet enshrined in the Hall of Fame, Thomas' contributions to the sport have left a lasting impact that will forever be remembered by Dolphins fans and the entire NFL community.

  • Jason Taylor
    4
    1,809 votes

    A fearsome force on the defensive side of the ball, Jason Taylor made offensive linemen quake in their boots as a relentless pass-rusher for the Miami Dolphins. Known for his explosive athleticism and impeccable timing, Taylor terrorized opposing quarterbacks throughout his 15-year career, tallying multiple sacks and turnovers to keep the Dolphins competitive. A stalwart leader on and off the field, Taylor further cemented his legacy with a well-deserved induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

  • Bob Griese
    5
    1,467 votes
    Age: 79

    A quarterback who transcended the game and guided the Miami Dolphins to two Super Bowl championships, Bob Griese's football IQ and unwavering leadership were unmatched during his era. Known for his ability to strategize and outsmart his opponents, Griese became synonymous with sustained success throughout his 14-year tenure with the team. Enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Griese's unforgettable legacy stretches far beyond South Florida, as he remains a symbol of excellence for the sport.

  • Larry Little
    6
    1,210 votes

    Larry Little

    Age: 78

    As an undrafted free agent, few could have predicted the meteoric rise and profound impact Larry Little would have on the Miami Dolphins' offensive line during the 1970s. Playing the unheralded position of right guard, Little's sheer dominance paved the way for the Dolphins' storied rushing attack, enabling the team to hoist two Lombardi Trophies. A testament to his greatness, Little's remarkable career culminated in a well-deserved induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

  • Mark Gregory Clayton
    7
    1,098 votes

    Mark Gregory Clayton

    Age: 63

    Having formed one of the most dynamic receiving duos in NFL history alongside Mark Duper, Mark Clayton endeared himself to Miami Dolphins fans with his electrifying playmaking abilities. Blessed with soft hands and innate route-running skills, Clayton consistently found ways to get open, becoming a favorite target for Hall of Famer Dan Marino. Responsible for several iconic moments in franchise history, Clayton's impact on the sport resonates with fans and players alike.

  • Paul Warfield
    8
    1,170 votes

    A breathtaking wide receiver who left defenders grasping at air, Paul Warfield provided the Miami Dolphins with a true game-changer throughout his time in South Florida. Equipped with breakaway speed and mesmerizing agility, Warfield complemented the Dolphins' ground-and-pound offense by stretching the field and keeping defenses honest. Another integral member of Miami's undefeated 1972 squad, Warfield's contributions to the sport have been immortalized in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

  • Mark Duper
    9
    1,085 votes

    Mark Duper

    Age: 65

    Mark Duper, one half of the famed “Marks Brothers” tandem, offered a compelling blend of speed, agility, and flair to the Miami Dolphins throughout the 1980s. As the perfect foil for fellow wide receiver Mark Clayton, Duper struck fear into the hearts of defensive backs, using his trademark speed and ability to make acrobatic catches. A gamebreaker in every sense of the word, Duper's exploits on the gridiron have secured him a deserved spot among the pantheon of Miami Dolphins legends.

  • Nick Buoniconti
    10
    956 votes

    A feisty and tenacious linebacker, Nick Buoniconti anchored the Miami Dolphins' “No-Name Defense” during their back-to-back Super Bowl victories in the early 1970s. Known for his cerebral approach to football and nose for the ball, Buoniconti wreaked havoc on opposing offenses, proving size isn't everything in the game of football. Enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Buoniconti's contributions on and off the field will forever be remembered and cherished.

  • Dwight Stephenson
    11
    1,038 votes

    A versatile and technically sound offensive lineman, Dwight Stephenson became the cornerstone of the Miami Dolphins' line throughout the 1980s. As a center excelling at both pass protection and run-blocking, Stephenson provided Dan Marino and the Dolphins' offense with invaluable stability and consistency. A beloved figure within the Miami organization, Stephenson's remarkable career remains an example of excellence for future generations of football players.

  • Ricky Williams
    12
    1,336 votes

    A bruising and powerful running back, Ricky Williams left his mark on the Miami Dolphins throughout the early 2000s, bulldozing through defenses with unmatched determination. Known for his relentless style of play and ability to break tackles, Williams became the focal point of Miami's lethal ground game. Though his career was marked by ups and downs, Williams' impressive on-field performances continue to resonate with football enthusiasts.

  • Mercury Morris
    13
    924 votes

    Mercury Morris

    Age: 77

    A versatile and elusive running back, Eugene "Mercury" Morris dazzled Miami Dolphins fans with his speed and agility during the team's golden era. A vital component of the famed "perfect season," Morris formed a formidable one-two punch alongside the bruising Larry Csonka, leaving defenders grasping at straws. Although not inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Morris' contributions to the sport and the Miami Dolphins organization remain cherished by fans and players alike.

  • Bob Kuechenberg
    14
    782 votes

    Bob Kuechenberg

    Age: 76

    An anchor of the Miami Dolphins' dominant offensive line during the 1970s, Bob Kuechenberg's unwavering work ethic and reliability proved instrumental to the team's success. Playing left guard and left tackle, Kuechenberg's versatility allowed the Dolphins to deploy an unstoppable ground game, highlighted by their undefeated 1972 campaign. While not enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Kuechenberg's impact on the sport and dedication to the Dolphins will not be forgotten.

  • Jake Scott
    15
    804 votes

    Jake Scott

    Age: 78

    A tenacious and instinctual safety, Jake Scott played a pivotal role in shaping the Miami Dolphins' identity during their Super Bowl-winning seasons. Blessed with a knack for disguising coverage and baiting quarterbacks, Scott became a nightmare for opposing offenses and an invaluable asset for Miami's vaunted defense. As a testament to his greatness, Scott was named Super Bowl VII Most Valuable Player, further etching his name among the all-time great Miami Dolphins.

  • Cameron Wake
    16
    1,290 votes

    A defensive standout known for terrorizing opposing quarterbacks, Cameron Wake made a name for himself as a relentless pass-rusher throughout his time with the Miami Dolphins. Undrafted and initially overlooked, Wake's tireless work ethic and determination propelled him into the upper echelon of NFL defensive players. His penchant for game-changing plays and ferocious intensity will forever be remembered by those fortunate enough to witness his illustrious career.

  • Manny Fernandez
    17
    728 votes

    Manny Fernandez

    Age: 77

    A tough and gritty defensive tackle, Manny Fernandez anchored the Miami Dolphins' defensive front during their golden era in the early 1970s. Fernandez's relentless drive and ability to collapse opposing offensive lines proved instrumental in the Dolphins' quest for football perfection, as he held his ground against some of the era's toughest offensive units. Although not enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Fernandez's unwavering commitment to the success of the Dolphins leaves a lasting legacy appreciated by fans and players alike.

  • Richmond Webb
    18
    794 votes

    Renowned for his exceptional ability to protect Dan Marino's blindside, offensive tackle Richmond Webb was a stalwart on the Miami Dolphins' offensive line throughout the 1990s. With an uncanny combination of size, strength, and technique, Webb proved to be an immovable object as he consistently beat out some of the league's most formidable defenders. A constant force and leader during his tenure in Miami, Webb's outstanding career earned him the respect and admiration of fans and fellow players alike.

  • Sam Madison
    19
    803 votes

    Sam Madison

    Age: 50

    A lockdown cornerback with a penchant for big plays, Sam Madison solidified the Miami Dolphins' secondary during the late 1990s and early 2000s. Blessed with a keen football IQ and exceptional athleticism, Madison consistently shadowed the NFL's top wideouts, effectively taking them out of the game. As an integral part of the Dolphins' stingy pass defense, Madison's memorable performances laid the foundation for his enduring legacy in South Florida.

  • Jim Langer
    20
    715 votes
    Age: 76

    Jim Langer's stout presence on the Miami Dolphins' offensive line during the 1970s played a crucial role in the team's success, particularly during their undefeated 1972 season. Equipped with incredible strength and a relentless drive, Langer was the epitome of toughness and grit as he consistently overpowered defenses. His enshrinement in the Pro Football Hall of Fame serves as a testament to Langer's profound impact on the sport and the Dolphins organization.

  • Nat Moore
    21
    622 votes

    Nat Moore

    Age: 72

    A versatile wide receiver who could do it all, Nat Moore dazzled Miami Dolphins fans with his speed, agility, and uncanny ability to make clutch catches. A favorite target for both Bob Griese and Dan Marino, Moore consistently found ways to create separation and haul in game-changing receptions. While not enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Moore's significant contributions to the Miami Dolphins organization on and off the field remain revered by fans and players alike.

  • Dick Anderson
    22
    700 votes

    As an intelligent and instinctual safety, Dick Anderson showcased his ball-hawking skills during the Miami Dolphins' era of dominance in the 1970s. Known for his ability to read and anticipate plays, Anderson was a vital cog in the Dolphins' smothering “No-Name Defense,” making life difficult for opposing signal-callers. A valued member of the team's back-to-back Super Bowl-winning campaigns, Anderson's contributions to the sport continue to resonate with fans and players alike.

  • John Offerdahl
    23
    672 votes

    As a smart and tenacious linebacker, John Offerdahl anchored the Miami Dolphins' defense from the mid-1980s to early 1990s, showcasing his ability to disrupt offenses with ease. Known for his exceptional tackling skills and sideline-to-sideline range, Offerdahl quickly became a fan favorite due to his football IQ and unwavering work ethic. Although not inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Offerdahl's contributions to the Dolphins organization remain indelible in the minds of fans and players alike.

  • Jim Kiick
    24
    691 votes
    Age: 77

    An invaluable component of the Dolphins' potent backfield during their dominant run in the early 1970s, Jim Kiick provided a powerful burst of speed and agility that complemented the bruising style of fellow running back Larry Csonka. As a key contributor in both Super Bowl victories for the franchise, Kiick was an instrumental figure on the field, providing a spark when his team needed it most. His skills and impressive career continue to garner praise from football analysts and fans alike.

  • Reggie Roby
    25
    601 votes

    Reggie Roby

    Dec. at 43 (1961-2005)

    One of the most skilled punters in NFL history, Reggie Roby was a key special teams asset for the Miami Dolphins throughout the 1980s and early 1990s. Possessing a powerful leg and a knack for pinning opposing teams deep in their own territory, Roby consistently provided the Dolphins' defense with favorable field position. Roby's significant contributions to the special teams unit have cemented his place as one of the most respected punters in Dolphins lore.

  • Patrick Surtain
    26
    708 votes

    Patrick Surtain, a ball-hawking cornerback who excelled alongside teammate Sam Madison, provided the Miami Dolphins with one of the most feared cornerback tandems in the NFL during their time together. With exceptional coverage skills and an ability to disrupt an opponent's passing game, Surtain emerged as a reliable and formidable presence in the Dolphins' secondary. Although not enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Surtain's impact on the Dolphins organization is still held in high regard by fans and fellow players.

  • O. J. McDuffie
    27
    663 votes

    O. J. McDuffie

    Age: 54

    A consistent contributor during his tenure with the Miami Dolphins, O. J. McDuffie became a reliable target for Dan Marino throughout the 1990s. As a wide receiver known for his sure hands and dependable route-running skills, McDuffie provided the Dolphins' passing attack with stability and reliability whenever called upon. While not enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, McDuffie's memorable career and dedication to the sport remain celebrated by fans and players alike.

  • A.J. Duhe
    28
    521 votes

    A.J. Duhe

    As an athletic and versatile linebacker, A.J. Duhe provided the Miami Dolphins with a dependable presence on the defensive side of the ball during the late 1970s and early 1980s. Known for his ability to disrupt opposing offenses with his quickness and playmaking abilities, Duhe was an integral part of the Dolphins' success throughout his tenure. Although not enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Duhe's impactful career and contributions to the sport continue to be celebrated by fans and players alike.

  • Troy Vincent
    29
    422 votes

    Troy Vincent

    Age: 53

    A highly skilled cornerback with a penchant for shutting down opposing receivers, Troy Vincent excelled on the gridiron during his time with the Miami Dolphins in the 1990s. Alongside fellow defensive stalwarts Sam Madison and Patrick Surtain, Vincent helped solidify the Dolphins' secondary, making life difficult for opposing signal-callers. Vincent's football IQ, leadership, and stellar on-field performances have left a lasting impression on the Dolphins fanbase.

  • Xavien Howard
    30
    375 votes

    Xavien Howard

    One of the premier cornerbacks currently suiting up for the Miami Dolphins, Xavien Howard has quickly established himself as a lockdown defender with a knack for making game-changing plays. With his exceptional football instincts and athleticism, Howard consistently showcases his ability to blanket opposing receivers, effectively taking them out of the equation. As he continues to make his mark in the NFL, Howard stands as a shining example of the bright future ahead for the Miami Dolphins.