The 25 Best Shows Like 'Shadowhunters', Ranked By Fans
  • Photo:
    • Shadowhunters
    • Freeform

The 25 Best Shows Like 'Shadowhunters', Ranked By Fans

Molly Gander
Updated April 25, 2024 25 items
Ranked By
481 votes
65 voters
Voting Rules
Vote on the movies and shows that fans of 'Shadowhunters' are sure to love.

Are you craving more supernatural thrills after diving into the mesmerizing world of Shadowhunters? Look no further! We've curated a list of captivating series that will keep you on the edge of your seat with their blend of action, drama, and fantasy. These series were chosen because they feature similar themes and tones to Shadowhunters, immersing viewers in worlds filled with mystical intrigue and complex character relationships.

Step into the eerie town of Mystic Falls with The Vampire Diaries, where supernatural secrets and romantic entanglements abound amidst the backdrop of vampire lore. Or join the dysfunctional family of adopted siblings in The Umbrella Academy as they navigate their extraordinary abilities and unravel the mysteries surrounding their father's death. These shows, along with others on this list, offer a compelling blend of supernatural elements, intricate storytelling, and standout performances that will leave you craving for more.

The shows on this list have been compiled using votes from Rankers like you, ensuring a diverse selection of series that resonate with fans of Shadowhunters. Plus, with convenient "Where to Watch" buttons below each show for streaming services such as Netflix, Amazon Prime, Max, Apple TV+, Hulu, Paramount+, and Disney+, you can easily embark on your next binge-watching adventure.

So, what are you waiting for? Cast your vote for your favorite series and discover your next obsession. Whether you're in the mood for supernatural drama, dark comedy, or thrilling mysteries, there's something for everyone on this list. Don't miss out on the opportunity to explore new worlds and characters that will captivate your imagination.

  • The Vampire Diaries

    In the supernatural drama The Vampire Diaries, Elena Gilbert becomes entangled in a love triangle with two centuries-old vampire brothers, Stefan and Damon Salvatore, amidst the backdrop of Mystic Falls. As secrets, betrayals, and supernatural threats unfold, the characters navigate complex relationships and grapple with their identities. With its blend of romance, drama, and mystique, the series captivates viewers with its rich narrative and compelling characters portrayed by actors like Nina Dobrev, Paul Wesley, and Ian Somerhalder.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, The Vampire Diaries offers a captivating blend of supernatural elements, intricate character relationships, and a richly developed world. Both series explore themes of identity, destiny, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, captivating audiences with intense action sequences and emotional character development. With a diverse cast of characters and a compelling narrative, The Vampire Diaries delivers a thrilling viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Grimm
    2
    39 VOTES

    In Grimm, homicide detective Nick Burkhardt discovers he is a Grimm, a guardian tasked with keeping the balance between humanity and mythological creatures known as Wesen. As Nick learns to navigate his new role with the help of his Wesen friend Monroe, he investigates supernatural crimes while keeping his identity hidden from normal society. With its blend of police procedural, fantasy, and folklore, the series explores themes of justice, identity, and the coexistence of the mundane and the supernatural.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Grimm follows a protagonist discovering his supernatural heritage and confronting the hidden world of mythical creatures. Both series delve into themes of identity, duty, and the battle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world where the supernatural intersects with everyday life. With its unique concept and engaging storyline, Grimm offers viewers a captivating exploration of the supernatural reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • The Originals
    3
    41 VOTES

    In The Originals, the Mikaelson siblings - Klaus, Elijah, and Rebekah - return to New Orleans, where they once ruled as the city's original vampires. As they navigate the treacherous politics of the supernatural community, including witches, werewolves, and other vampires, the Mikaelsons confront past betrayals and family secrets. With its blend of supernatural intrigue, family drama, and intense action, the series explores themes of loyalty, redemption, and the consequences of one's actions.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, The Originals features a diverse cast of supernatural beings grappling with their identities and relationships while facing external threats. Both series delve into themes of family, loyalty, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, captivating audiences with their richly developed characters and immersive storytelling. With its dark and atmospheric tone, The Originals offers viewers a thrilling and emotionally resonant viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Locke & Key
    • Photo:
      • Locke & Key
    4
    29 VOTES

    In Locke & Key, the Locke siblings - Tyler, Kinsey, and Bode - move into their ancestral home, Keyhouse, after their father's murder. They discover magical keys hidden within the house, each with unique powers and guarded by a sinister entity known as Dodge. As they unlock the secrets of their family's past and the origins of the keys, the siblings must confront their own fears and protect the world from dark forces.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Locke & Key follows a group of young protagonists discovering their supernatural heritage and confronting hidden dangers within their environment. Both series explore themes of family, destiny, and the battle between good and evil, drawing viewers into a world of mystery and adventure. With its imaginative premise and compelling characters, Locke & Key offers viewers a captivating journey into the supernatural reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • True Blood
    5
    40 VOTES

    In True Blood, the small town of Bon Temps, Louisiana, becomes a battleground for supernatural beings, including vampires, werewolves, and shape-shifters, as they navigate a world filled with danger and desire. Centered around waitress Sookie Stackhouse, who can hear people's thoughts, the series explores themes of love, acceptance, and the struggle for equality in a society divided between humans and supernatural creatures. With a diverse ensemble cast featuring Anna Paquin, Stephen Moyer, and Alexander Skarsgård, True Blood offers a provocative and seductive take on the supernatural genre.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, True Blood immerses viewers in a world where supernatural beings coexist with humans, exploring the complexities of their relationships and the eternal battle between good and evil. Both series blend elements of fantasy, romance, and supernatural intrigue, captivating audiences with their richly developed worlds and diverse cast of characters. With its darkly seductive tone and compelling narrative, True Blood delivers a thrilling viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Bitten
    • Photo:
      • Bitten
    6
    33 VOTES

    In Bitten, Elena Michaels, the only known female werewolf, grapples with her dual identity while navigating the complexities of love and loyalty within the Pack. As she confronts power struggles and personal challenges, Elena must balance her supernatural heritage with her human relationships. With its riveting combination of action, romance, and intrigue, the series captivates viewers with its portrayal of the supernatural world and the dynamics within the werewolf Pack.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Bitten explores themes of identity, loyalty, and the eternal struggle between good and evil within a supernatural framework. Both series feature strong female protagonists navigating their supernatural heritage while forging alliances and confronting adversaries. With its compelling storyline and well-developed characters, Bitten offers viewers a thrilling journey into the realm of the supernatural, echoing the themes and tone of Shadowhunters.

  • The Umbrella Academy

    The Umbrella Academy follows a dysfunctional family of adopted siblings with extraordinary abilities who reunite to solve the mystery of their father's death and prevent an impending apocalypse. As they navigate their complex dynamics and confront their traumatic past, the siblings must work together to save the world. With its darkly comedic tone, compelling narrative, and standout performances by actors like Elliot Page and Robert Sheehan, the series offers viewers a unique blend of superhero action, family drama, and mystery.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, The Umbrella Academy presents a diverse cast of characters with extraordinary abilities who must come together to combat dark forces and navigate personal struggles. Both series feature a blend of action, drama, and fantastical elements, immersing viewers in a world of supernatural intrigue and complex character relationships. With its engaging storyline and dynamic characters, The Umbrella Academy offers a thrilling and immersive viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • In Penny Dreadful, Victorian London becomes a backdrop for a dark and chilling tale that intertwines classic literary characters, including Dr. Frankenstein, Dorian Gray, and Dracula, in a web of supernatural intrigue and horror. As they confront their own demons and face external threats, the characters navigate a world filled with darkness, secrets, and forbidden desires. Starring Eva Green, Timothy Dalton, and Josh Hartnett, this Gothic horror series explores themes of morality, redemption, and the nature of evil in a mesmerizing and atmospheric setting.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Penny Dreadful delves into a world where supernatural beings and human characters intersect, grappling with their own inner demons and external adversaries. Both series blend elements of horror, fantasy, and drama, captivating audiences with their richly developed characters and immersive storytelling. With its dark and atmospheric tone, Penny Dreadful offers viewers a hauntingly beautiful journey into the macabre, reminiscent of the mystical intrigue found in Shadowhunters.

  • 9
    22 VOTES

    In Sleepy Hollow, Ichabod Crane finds himself resurrected in modern times, tasked with preventing the apocalypse alongside Lieutenant Abbie Mills. As they unravel mysteries and battle supernatural forces, the duo delves into the rich mythology of Sleepy Hollow, blending historical events with fantasy and horror. With its atmospheric setting, compelling storytelling, and diverse ensemble cast, the series offers a thrilling and immersive exploration of folklore and the supernatural.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Sleepy Hollow combines elements of fantasy, horror, and mystery as characters confront supernatural threats and navigate the complexities of their world. Both series delve into themes of destiny, redemption, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, captivating audiences with their richly developed mythologies and dynamic characters. With its blend of historical references and supernatural elements, Sleepy Hollow delivers a captivating viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Legacies
    • Photo:
      • Legacies
    10
    29 VOTES

    In Legacies, Hope Mikaelson, a tribrid (witch, vampire, and werewolf), attends the Salvatore School for the Young and Gifted, where supernatural beings learn to control their powers. Alongside her friends, including werewolf Rafael and witch Josie, Hope navigates the challenges of being a teenager while dealing with various magical threats. With its blend of supernatural drama, coming-of-age themes, and intricate mythology, the series explores the complexities of identity, family, and the eternal struggle between good and evil.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Legacies follows a group of young protagonists with supernatural abilities as they navigate personal relationships and confront dark forces. Both series delve into themes of identity, destiny, and the battle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world of magic and danger. With its diverse cast of characters and compelling narrative, Legacies offers viewers a captivating journey into the supernatural reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Haven
    11
    44 VOTES

    In Haven, FBI agent Audrey Parker is drawn to the mysterious town of Haven, Maine, where residents possess supernatural abilities linked to the town's enigmatic past. As Audrey investigates the town's mysteries alongside local law enforcement, she uncovers dark secrets and uncanny occurrences that challenge her understanding of reality. With a cast including Emily Rose, Lucas Bryant, and Eric Balfour, this supernatural mystery series explores themes of destiny, redemption, and the consequences of meddling with the supernatural.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Haven follows a protagonist delving into the mysteries of a town filled with supernatural occurrences and hidden truths. Both series explore themes of identity, destiny, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world where the line between the natural and supernatural is blurred. With its atmospheric setting and intriguing mysteries, Haven offers audiences a compelling and immersive viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Lost Girl
    12
    26 VOTES

    In Lost Girl, Bo, a succubus with no knowledge of her origins, navigates the world of the Fae, discovering her own powers and facing various supernatural threats. As she forms alliances with other Fae and humans, Bo delves into her past and uncovers secrets that shape her destiny. With its blend of mystery, romance, and supernatural elements, the series explores themes of identity, loyalty, and the search for belonging.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Lost Girl follows a protagonist discovering her supernatural heritage and forging alliances in a world filled with mystical creatures. Both series delve into themes of identity, destiny, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, captivating audiences with their richly imagined worlds and complex character relationships. With its compelling narrative and diverse cast of characters, Lost Girl offers viewers an enchanting journey into the supernatural.

  • The Secret Circle
    • Photo:
      • The Secret Circle

    The Secret Circle follows Cassie Blake as she discovers her ancestry and becomes entwined with a group of teenage witches, navigating the complexities of life, love, and newfound powers. Set in a small town, the series explores the dynamics of the coven as they face supernatural threats and uncover dark secrets. With its blend of mystery, romance, and magic, The Secret Circle offers a captivating exploration of friendship, betrayal, and the consequences of wielding power.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, The Secret Circle revolves around a group of young protagonists discovering their supernatural abilities and facing the challenges of a world filled with magic and danger. Both series delve into themes of identity, destiny, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world of intrigue and mystique. With its compelling storyline and ensemble cast, The Secret Circle delivers a thrilling and immersive viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
    • Photo:
      • Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

    In Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, a young half-witch, half-mortal named Sabrina Spellman navigates the complexities of her dual identity while battling dark forces threatening her family and the mortal world. Set in the eerie town of Greendale, this supernatural horror series delves into themes of power, destiny, and the consequences of embracing one's true nature. With a cast including Kiernan Shipka, Ross Lynch, and Lucy Davis, the show offers a modern twist on the classic Archie Comics character, blending elements of horror, fantasy, and coming-of-age drama.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina follows a young protagonist discovering her supernatural heritage and facing the challenges of a world filled with dark magic and ancient secrets. Both series explore themes of identity, destiny, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world of mystical intrigue and complex character relationships. With its blend of supernatural elements, romance, and dark fantasy, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina offers audiences a captivating journey into the occult.

  • 15
    20 VOTES

    In Being Human, a vampire, a werewolf, and a ghost share a house, trying to live normal lives despite their supernatural identities. As they navigate the complexities of their relationships and the challenges of their respective conditions, they encounter other supernatural beings and face moral dilemmas. With its blend of drama, humor, and supernatural elements, the series explores themes of friendship, acceptance, and the struggle to maintain humanity.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Being Human follows a group of individuals with extraordinary abilities trying to integrate into society while dealing with the consequences of their powers. Both series delve into themes of identity, morality, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world where the supernatural intersects with everyday life. With its compelling characters and emotionally resonant storytelling, Being Human offers viewers a thought-provoking exploration of the human condition reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Blood Ties
    • Photo:
      • Blood Ties
    16
    34 VOTES

    In Blood Ties, Vicki Nelson, a former cop turned private investigator, teams up with Henry Fitzroy, a 470-year-old vampire, to solve supernatural crimes in Toronto. As they delve into the city's underworld of vampires, ghosts, and demons, they uncover dark secrets and face deadly threats. Starring Christina Cox and Kyle Schmid, this supernatural mystery series explores themes of redemption, mortality, and the blurred lines between good and evil.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Blood Ties follows a strong female protagonist who teams up with supernatural beings to combat dark forces and solve mysteries. Both series explore themes of identity, loyalty, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, captivating audiences with their blend of action, romance, and supernatural intrigue. With its compelling storyline and dynamic characters, Blood Ties offers viewers a thrilling and immersive journey into the world of the supernatural.

  • Witches of East End
    • Photo:
      • Witches of East End
      • Lifetime

    In Witches of East End, the Beauchamp family, comprising witches with unique abilities, navigates a world filled with magic, romance, and dark forces. As they unravel family secrets and confront ancient enemies, they must harness their powers to protect themselves and those they love. Starring Julia Ormond, Jenna Dewan, and Rachel Boston, this supernatural drama explores themes of destiny, sisterhood, and the eternal battle between good and evil.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Witches of East End features a diverse cast of characters with supernatural abilities who must confront dark forces and unravel family secrets. Both series delve into themes of destiny, identity, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, captivating audiences with their mystical intrigue and complex character relationships. With its blend of supernatural elements, romance, and family drama, Witches of East End offers viewers a thrilling and immersive journey into the realm of magic.

  • The Strain
    18
    26 VOTES

    In The Strain, a mysterious viral outbreak spreads across New York City, turning humans into bloodthirsty vampires under the control of an ancient vampire known as The Master. Dr. Ephraim Goodweather, along with a group of survivors, races against time to stop the epidemic and save humanity from extinction. With its blend of horror, thriller, and apocalyptic themes, the series explores the consequences of scientific experimentation gone wrong and the fight for survival in a world overrun by supernatural creatures.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, The Strain follows a group of protagonists fighting against dark forces threatening humanity, albeit in a more horror-oriented setting. Both series delve into themes of good versus evil, the struggle for survival, and the importance of teamwork and sacrifice in combating supernatural threats. With its intense action sequences and intricate mythology, The Strain offers viewers a gripping and suspenseful viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Salem
    19
    25 VOTES

    In Salem, set against the backdrop of the infamous witch trials, dark forces lurk in the shadows of the Massachusetts town. As accusations fly and alliances shift, witches and witch hunters alike navigate treacherous waters in a battle for power and survival. With a cast including Janet Montgomery, Shane West, and Seth Gabel, this supernatural thriller explores themes of betrayal, persecution, and the lengths people will go to protect their secrets.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Salem explores a world where supernatural beings coexist with ordinary humans, navigating treacherous alliances and battling dark forces. Both series delve into themes of power, betrayal, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world of intrigue and danger. With its gripping narrative and complex characters, Salem offers a thrilling and suspenseful viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Hemlock Grove
    • Photo:
      • Hemlock Grove
    20
    24 VOTES

    In Hemlock Grove, the mysterious town of Hemlock Grove becomes the stage for supernatural occurrences and dark secrets. As unlikely friends Roman Godfrey, a wealthy heir with a dark side, and Peter Rumancek, a newcomer with enigmatic abilities, navigate through chilling events, viewers are drawn into a world where nothing is quite as it seems. With its blend of horror, fantasy, and suspense, the series explores the complexities of its characters and the eerie atmosphere of the town.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Hemlock Grove delves into the supernatural realm where characters with extraordinary abilities grapple with their identities and confront dark forces. Both series immerse viewers in a world filled with mystery, intrigue, and danger, exploring themes of identity, destiny, and the eternal struggle between good and evil. With its atmospheric setting and complex characters, Hemlock Grove offers a gripping and immersive viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • The Order
    • Photo:
      • The Order
    21
    23 VOTES

    In The Order, Jack Morton navigates the world of secret societies and dark magic as he uncovers hidden truths within Belgrave University. As secrets unravel and alliances shift, Jack must confront his own demons and navigate the complexities of the supernatural realm. With its blend of mystery, suspense, and supernatural elements, the series offers a gripping and immersive exploration of power, loyalty, and the battle between good and evil.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, The Order immerses viewers in a world where secret societies and dark magic coexist with ordinary life, exploring the complexities of power and identity. Both series delve into themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, captivating audiences with their intriguing plotlines and dynamic characters. With its dark and mysterious tone, The Order offers viewers a thrilling journey into the supernatural reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Teen Wolf
    22
    23 VOTES

    In Teen Wolf, high school student Scott McCall is bitten by a werewolf, leading to a series of supernatural events in his life. Alongside his best friend Stiles and other supernatural allies, Scott navigates the challenges of being a teenager while dealing with werewolf hunters, rival packs, and supernatural threats. With its blend of supernatural drama, coming-of-age themes, and action-packed sequences, the series explores themes of identity, friendship, and the struggle to control one's inner beast.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Teen Wolf follows a young protagonist discovering his supernatural abilities and navigating personal relationships in a world filled with mystical creatures. Both series delve into themes of identity, destiny, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, immersing viewers in a world of danger and intrigue. With its diverse cast of characters and thrilling storyline, Teen Wolf offers viewers an exciting and emotionally resonant viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • In From Dusk till Dawn: The Series, bank robber Seth Gecko and his violent, unpredictable brother Richie escape to Mexico after a heist gone wrong, where they encounter a family of vampires led by the seductive Santánico Pandemonium. As they become embroiled in a deadly game of survival, the Geckos must confront their own demons and form uneasy alliances to stay alive. With its blend of crime thriller, horror, and supernatural elements, the series explores themes of redemption, family, and the blurred lines between good and evil.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, From Dusk till Dawn: The Series features a diverse cast of characters battling against supernatural forces while navigating personal conflicts and moral dilemmas. Both series delve into themes of identity, loyalty, and the eternal struggle between darkness and light, immersing viewers in a world of danger and intrigue. With its intense action sequences and complex character dynamics, From Dusk till Dawn: The Series offers viewers a thrilling and suspenseful viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • Reaper
    24
    18 VOTES

    In Reaper, slacker Sam Oliver discovers he is a bounty hunter for the Devil, tasked with capturing escaped souls and sending them back to Hell. With the help of his friends Sock and Ben, Sam balances his newfound responsibilities with his mundane life, navigating the challenges of being a reluctant hero. With its blend of comedy, supernatural elements, and quirky characters, the series explores themes of redemption, friendship, and the consequences of one's choices.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, Reaper follows a protagonist thrust into a supernatural world and tasked with combating dark forces. Both series blend elements of comedy, drama, and fantasy, captivating audiences with their unique premise and engaging characters. With its witty humor and heartfelt moments, Reaper offers viewers a refreshing take on the supernatural genre reminiscent of Shadowhunters.

  • 25
    14 VOTES

    In 666 Park Avenue, a young couple, Jane and Henry, move into the historic Drake apartment building in New York City, only to discover that its residents have made deals with the devil for their desires. As Jane becomes the new building manager, she uncovers sinister secrets and supernatural forces at play, threatening her and Henry's lives. With its blend of mystery, supernatural thriller, and psychological horror, the series explores themes of temptation, morality, and the consequences of greed.

    Similar to Shadowhunters, 666 Park Avenue delves into the realm of the supernatural and the battle between good and evil, albeit in a more urban and suspenseful setting. Both series feature protagonists confronting dark forces and uncovering hidden truths about their world, immersing viewers in a world of mystery and intrigue. With its atmospheric storytelling and complex characters, 666 Park Avenue offers viewers a thrilling and chilling viewing experience reminiscent of Shadowhunters.