The execution is inarguably impressive, but the Head and the Heart have made much better music with simpler technique, and Signs of Light is the sort of album that confirms a fan's worst fears about an indie act signing with a corporate label.
Signs of Light also sees them beef up their sound with sweeping rock guitars and radio-aware production that can sometimes feel overblown (see the Mumford-size stomp of the title track). Things work better when they balance the impulse to hulk things up with their natural traditionalist intimacy.
Most of the good ideas here have been drowned in arena rock ennui, and there aren’t that many of them to begin with.
Supremely disappointing. Their indie folk charm has been replaced by a clean, typical, and--all around--boring alt sound.
Notable Song: "All We Ever Knew"
Probably the most disappointing release of the year for me -- what happened? Their original sound that was once so compelling has been replaced with superfluous corporate rock -- more American Authors than Fleet Foxes. They're capable of so much better.